Professional Documents
Culture Documents
: F E 8 : P K ) ' ' ,
: F E : L I J F ; < : L 8 ; < I E F J ; < < O G < I @ D < E K F J
<`ejk\`e
K\jfif
F
¾ -
¾
HEI7?DxI
HEI7 ?DxI ¾ ¾
7=K?HH;=7H9ß7 ¾
¾JXck`ccf#:fX_l`cX
¾>XeX[fiX[\c-f :feZlijf
[\:lX[\iefj[\<og\i`d\ekfj
:Xk\^fiX1Gi\\jZfcXi
àe[`Z\
¾Gi\j\ekXZ`e ')
¾DX\jkifj#
gX[i\j[\]Xd`c`X1
¾@ekif[lZZ`e '*
¾¶;\hlZfcfid\m\f6 '+
¾CXk\c\m`j`ed}^`ZX '- <cfYa\k`mf[\\jk\ZlX[\ief\jgi\j\ekXiX
¾<cg`\]if '/ ljk\[\jleX\jkiXk\^`X[\kiXYXafhl\gl\[\
¾¶Gfihl_XZ\eil`[fcXjgXcfd`kXj6 ('
¾J\ig\ek`eXj j\iXgc`ZX[XXcfje`fjgi\\jZfcXi\j[\j\fjfj
()
¾·=l\iXXYXaf (+ [\ZfefZ\ijldle[f2\ecj\`eZclp\eXZk`m`$
¾<cgXg\chl\j\_le[\ (- [X[\jhl\c\jg\id`k`i}e\ei`hl\Z\ijl]fidX$
¾¶Gfihl]cfkXecfjYXiZfj6 (/
¾CXjYliYlaXjYX`cXi`eXj )' Z`e2¶gl\[\_XY\iXc^fd\afigXiX\ccfhl\cX
¾<c^cfYfZf_\k\ )) Z`\eZ`X6
¾>cfjXi`f )+
8ljk\[\j#gX[i\j[\]Xd`c`X#kXdY`emX[`i`$
^`[f\jk\dXk\i`Xc#Zfe\c]`e[\hl\Xgfp\eX
¾AliX[f jlj_`afj\`eZlchl\e\e\ccfj\c_}Y`kf[\
`em\jk`^Xi%
Dkif%If
JXpXm\[i
¾ JfZ`\[X[D\o`ZXeX <jk\Xfj\_X[\[`ZX[fXc^iXe
gXiXcX;`mlc^XZ`e
[\cX:`\eZ`XpcX
Z`\ek]`Zf8cY\ik<`ejk\`e#gfi
KZe`ZX \ccf\jk\ZlX[\ief\jk}
_\Z_f\ejl_fefi#p
\ecj\eXiiXle
Zl\ekf\e\chl\
DkiX%@jX \jk\^iXeg\ijf$
D\aX> eXa\i\hl`\i\
¾ <jZl\cXEXZ`feXc
fYk\e\iZ`\ikfj
[\DX\jkiXj[\
AXi[`e\j[\E`fj gf[\i\jgif$
m\e`\ek\j
[\Xc^leXj
¾;`i\Zkfi`f
:lX[\ief[\<og\i`d\ekfjgXiXGi\\jZfcXi
iXdXj[\cX
]j`ZX%
:fej\afEXZ`feXc[\:`\eZ`XpK\Zefcf^X
¾ 8m%@ejli^\ek\jJli(,/)#:fc%:i[`kf:fejkilZkfi
Cfj`em`kfgl\j#X_XZ\ilei\Zfii`[fgfi\c
Do`Zf#;% =%'*0+'
¾ <[`Z`e1;`i\ZZ`e[\:fdle`ZXZ`eJfZ`Xc#:feXZpk dXiXm`ccfjfdle[f[\cX]j`ZX%Gfijlgl\jkf#
¾ ;`j\f1;<;`j\fp:fejlckfiX>i}]`ZX cfje`fji\hl\i`i}e[\jlgi\j\eZ`XpXgfpf
¾@cljkiXZ`e1;Xm`[G\e
¾ @dgi\j`e1@dgi\jfiXp<eZlX[\ieX[fiXGif^i\jf ZfejkXek\j[liXek\cXi\Xc`qXZ`e[\kf[XjcXj
¾ @J9E0-/$/)*$)-0$- gi}Zk`ZXjXhlgifgl\jkXj%
;\i\Z_fji\j\imX[fj&J\gif_`Y\cXi\gif[lZZ`ekfkXc
fgXiZ`Xc[\cfjdXk\i`Xc\jj`eXlkfi`qXZ`e\jZi`kX%
')
¾
<cj`^l`\ek\k\okfgi\k\e[\XgfpXiXhl`\e\j[\ G\if#¶Zdfcf_XZ\e6Gl\j]fidXe[fle ZXdgf
dXe\iX\jgfek}e\X^lXeXcfj\jkl[`Xek\j\ecX \cZki`Zf
f2\j[\Z`i#_XZ`\e[fhl\lefYa\kfalek\
i\Xc`qXZ`e[\cfj\og\i`d\ekfj2\ecj\jl^`\i\ dlZ_fj\c\Zkife\j%¶Pgfihlj\alekXe6#gl\j
cX]fidX[\\ogc`ZXiZfej\eZ`cc\qXc^lefjk\dXj gfihl\cXjZXi^Xjhl\\jk}e\edfm`d`\ekfÆZfdf
ZfdfcX\c\Zki`Z`[X[p\cZXcfi%<jg\ifj\Xe[\lk`$ cfj\c\Zkife\jÆk`\e[\eXalekXij\%CfjfYa\kfjZfe
c`[X[% ZXi^Xj`[ek`ZXjZfdfgfi\a\dgcf#e\^Xk`mXZfe
e\^Xk`mX #j\i\Z_XqXe2\eZXdY`fcXjZXi^Xj[`]\$
Cfj }kfdfjj ]fidXegXik\[\kf[fpZlXe[fj\ i\ek\jgfj`k`mXpe\^Xk`mX j\XkiX\e#]fidXe[fleX
alekXeZfejk`klp\eZlXchl`\ik`gf[\dXk\i`Xjc`[X# \c\Zki`Z`[X[\jk}k`ZX%
chl`[Xf^Xj\fjX2_Xp}kfdfj[\d}j[\Z`\e
\c\d\ekfj#\eki\\ccfjZXiYfef#jf[`f#fo^\ef#
\kZ%p#Xcle`ij\]fidXedfcZlcXj
j#gXikZlcXjkXe
g\hl\Xjhl\efgl\[\efYj\imXij\Xj`dgc\m`jkX%
<a\dgcf1leX^fkX[\X^lXk`\e\d`ccfe\j[\dfc$
ZlcXj#g\ifkf[Xj\ccXj\jk}e_\Z_Xj[\cfd`jdf1
[fj}kfdfj[\fo^\efplef[\_`[i^\ef#p
j`\dgi\hl\\jkfj}kfdfjj\alekXe#]fidXeX^lX%
:X[X}kfdfk`\e\leeZc\f f\e\chl\j\\eZl\e$
kiXefkiXjgXikZlcXjXed}jg\hl\Xj1cfjgif$
kfe\j
jZfeZXi^Xgfj`k`mX pcfje\lkife\j
jhl\jfe
e\lkifj #g\if]l\iX[\ceZc\fj\\eZl\ekiXecfj
\c\Zkife\j
jhl\k`\e\eZXi^Xje\^Xk`mXjp^`iXeXci\$
[\[fi[\ceZc\f%
Gficf^\e\iXc#cfj}kfdfjk`\e\e`^lXced\if[\
gifkfe\jhl\[\\c\Zkife\j#j`\e[fd}jfd\efj
\jkXYc\j%8_fiXY`\e#cfj}kfdfj`ek\iXZkXe#
Xlehl\j\Xedlp[`]\i\ek\jpjlZfdgfikXd`\ekf
[\g\e[\[\cfj}kfdfjm\Z`efjhl\k\e^Xe%;\\jkX
X\c\Zki`Z`[X[
Zfem`m\eZ`Xjli^\#gfi\a\dgcf#cX [#hl\ <cfkifZfeZ\gkf\jcXZfem\ij`e[\cX\e\i^X\e
\jleXgifg`\[X[[\cfjZl\igfjZfej`jk\ek\\e ZXcfipjli\cXZ`eZfecfjdXk\i`Xc\j#Xc^lefj[\
XkiX\ij\fi\Z_XqXij\XZXljX[\jlj\c\Zkife\j% cfjZlXc\jj\Zfej`[\iXe Zfe[lZkfi\j j [\cZXcfi#\jf
M\Xdfjgfihl1Cfj\c\Zkife\j#gfief\jkXi j`^e`]`ZXhl\XYjfiY\e\cZXcfi[\Xhl\ccfjZl\igfj
jla\kfj\e\ceZc\f#Xm\Z\jk`\e[\eXZXdY`Xij\ hl\k`\e\ed}j2Xj#cfhl\\jk}ZXc`\ek\#j`\ekiX\e
[\ZXjX
X2\j[\Z`i#j\dl[XeXfkifj}kfdfj#Zfecf ZfekXZkfZfeledXk\i`XcZfe[lZkfi#g\i[\i}ZXcfi%
hl\Xld\ekXcXZXek`[X[[\\c\Zkife\jhl\_Xp\e Gfi\cZfekiXi`f#\o`jk\edXk\i`Xc\jhl\j\Zfej`$
cXel\mXi\j`[\eZ`X#Xki`Ylpe[fc\XjleXZXi^X [\iXeX`jcXek\jj#fj\Xhl\f]i\Z\eXcfjZl\igfjcX
e\^Xk`mX% fgfikle`[X[[\Zfej\imXijlZXcfi%
'*
>ebWWc_]k_jei0
Jfp8cY\ik<`ejk\`e#eXZ\elegXjccXdX[f
8c\dXe`X#XcfkifcX[f[\cfZXef8kc}ek`Zf# ;_dij[_d_d_Y_ikl_W`[l_i_jWdZe
\e\cZfek`e\ek\\lifg\f%<e)'',]\jk\af 9_kZWZBkp"ZedZ[l_l[?bkc_d[_jeh$
(''Xfj[\_XY\iglYc`ZX[fle^iXe[\jZl$ Æ?bkc_d[_jeh"^[l[d_Zefehgk[[b
Yi`d`\ekf#p\ekf[f\cdle[fd\_Xi}eleX feZ[hZ[bWbkp[i[bfh_c[hegk[
^iXe]`\jkX#g\ifXek\j#[\Yfi\le`icfjfZ_f d[Y[i_jefWhW[dYedjhWhc_j[iehe"
gf[\i\j]j`ZfjgXiXcc\^XiXck\jfifg\i[`[f% feh\Wleh"WoZWc[ÅZ_`e;_dij[_dÅ$
Hl`\ifhl\ljk\[\jm\e^XeZfed`^fpd\ Æ9bWhegk[iÅYedj[ij
Xpl[\eXZfdYXk`iXcXdXcmX[XYilaXhl\d\ ?bkc_d[_jehÅfWhWeXj[d[hbe
\jg\iXi}Xc]`eXc[\cm`Xa\gXiXXgifg`Xij\[\c Z[X[ceiZ[iY_\hWhkdc_ij[h_e1
k\jfif%8Zfdg}\ed\pmXpXdfj\eYljZX ^W]Wceibei_]k_[dj[0
[\ck\jfif%
<og%'(
¾ ;\hlZfcfi
d\m\f
FYa\k`mf1 ;`jk`e^l`icfjZXdY`fj\ecXclq#
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
' ;\Y\j\jkXi\elecl^XifjZlifgficX
efZ_\ pXgX^Xikf[XjcXjclZ\j%
FJGI<<J:FC8I
j\^ecfj]`ckifjhl\j\Xgc`hl\e
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾LeXc}dgXiX[\dXef
( :fcfZX
cXc}dgXiX
\eZ\e[`[X[\YXaf[\
kldXef\`cldeXcX%
'+
)
¶Hl
jlZ\[`6
¶Gfihl
Zi\\j
hl\gXj6
<ogc`ZXZ`e1
CXg`\cXZkXZfdfle]`ckif%
Le]`ckif\jZlXchl`\idXk\i`Xc
hl\XYjfiY\Xc^lefjZfcfi\j
[\cXclq%Cfj]`ckifjifafj
XYjfiY\ekf[fjcfjZfcfi\j#
d\efj\cifaf%Klg`\ckfdX
leZfcfiifjX[\Y`[fXhl\cX
jXe^i\hl\[\YXaf[\klg`\c
XZkXZfdfle]`ckififaf%
',
<og%')
¾
7ddej[d]e[bfeZ[hZ[bWbkpÅZ_`e
;_dij[_dÅ$
ÆDebej_[d[ifehgk[d[Y[i_jWiZ[iYkXh_h
Wb]ec|i$
Æ;ij|X_[d"^WhjeZebegk[i[Wd[Y[iWh_e$
FYj\imXi\c\]\Zkf\jkifYfjZg`Zf
[\leX`dX^\e[\k\c\m`j`e%
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ G I < < J :
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾LeX k\c\m`j`e
' 8ek\leX]l\ek\[\clq\cZki`ZXfcXclq
eXkliXc[\cJfc#dl\m\i}g`[Xd\ek\\cc}g`q
_XZ`XXii`YXp_XZ`XXYXaf#Zfdfj\m\\ecX
]`^liXp]aXk\Zdfj\m\\cc}g`q\edfm`$
d`\ekf%
( <eleX_XY`kXZ`efjZliX#pZfecXk\c\m`$
j`e\eZ\e[`[X#ZfcfZX\cc}g`q[\cXek\[\
cXgXekXccX%
'-
) Dl\m\i}g`[Xd\ek\\cc}g`q_XZ`XXii`YXp_XZ`XXYXaf
Zfdfcf_`Z`jk\Xek\jp]aXk\j`j\m\`^lXchl\\e\c
\a\iZ`Z`fXek\i`fi%
¶HljlZ\[`6
¶:dfj\m\\cc}g`q]i\ek\Xck\c\m`jfi6
;nfb_YWY_d0 <ed`jk`\dgfj#ef_XYXk\c\m`j`ep
<ecl^Xi[\cX`dX^\eYfiifjX[\cc}g`q efgl[\_XZ\i\jk\\og\i`d\ekfZfdf
\edfm`d`\ekfXek\cXclqeXkliXc#j\ ljk\[\j#g\ifX_fiXd\[`Zl\ekX[\hl\
fYj\imXe`d}^\e\jj\gXiX[Xj]i\ek\XcX lec}g`q\edfm`d`\ekfgif[lZ\leX
k\c\m`j`e#[\Y`[fXhl\cXclqgifm\e`\ek\ `dX^\eYfiifjXphl\j`dl\m\j\cd`jdf
[\cXgXekXccXef\jZfejkXek\ZfdfcX[\c c}g`q]i\ek\XleXk\c\m`j`e#j\m\e`d}$
Jfc#j`efhl\gXigX[\XXleXm\cfZ`[X[kXe ^\e\jj\gXiX[Xj%
^iXe[\hl\el\jkifjfafjefcfXcZXeqXeX
g\iZ`Y`i#\oZ\gkfgfi\og\i`d\ekfjZfdf Ç8j\j8cY\ik#p^iXZ`XjXhl\Xgi\e[`jk\
\chl\XZXYXdfj[\_XZ\i% Xc^f#X_fiXjk\e[i}j\cgf[\i[\cXclq%
Ç>iXZ`Xj%
'.
<og%'*
¾
;_dij[_deXjkle[bfeZ[hZ[bWbkp
p o
Z[Y_Z_ZWh[bi[]kdZefWie0jhWibWZWhi[
W9Wbeh\_YW"kdWY_kZWZgk[^WX_jWXW
9Wbehd"gk_[db[WokZWh|WYedi[]k_h[b
feZ[hZ[bYWbeh$
ÆIeo;_dij[_d"o[ijeoXkiYWdZe[b
feZ[hZ[bYWbeh$µC[WokZWi5
ÆFehikfk[ijeÅYedj[ij9WbehdÅ$FWhW
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
;\dfjkiXicXZfe[lZZ`e[\cX
' :fikXleg\[Xqf[\gXg\cXcld`e`fle
gfZfd}j^iXe[\hl\klg`\%
\e\i^Xkid`ZX%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ G I < < J :
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾GXg\cXcld`e`f%
¾LekXg\k\
g\hl\ff
g`\qXg\hl\X
[\Xc]fdYiX%
K`a\iXj
(
'/
)
¶Hlj`\ek\j6
¶<eZl}cg`\j\ek`jk\d}j]if6
'0
<og%'+
¾
Æ?cW]_degk[Yed[bl_W`[j[^WZWZe
^WcXh["µde[iWi5
ÆKdfeYe"Z_`e;_dij[_d$
ÆFk[ilWceiWYec[hfWbec_jWiZ[cWp
oZ[fWieWl[h_]kWceifehgk^WY[d
hk_ZeYkWdZei[YeY_dWd"µj[fWh[Y[5
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
' FYj\im
[\lef
dXq#Xek\
8m\i`^lXigfihljXckX\c
dXq[\gXcfd`kXj%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾DXqgXiXgi\gXiXigXcfd`kXj
¾LeXZXZ\ifcX
8Z\`k\
CXXpl[X[\leX[lckf
( Gfe
]l\^f
ZXZ\ifcXZ
XZ\`k\pZ
c`^\iXd\e
('
) hl\efj
* :lXe[f
fYj\imX
¶GfihlZi\\j
hl\cfj^iXefj
[\dXqj\
Zfem`\ik\e\e
gXcfd`kXj6
¶8hlj\
[\Y\\cil`[f
hl\_XZ\e6
;nfb_YWY_d0
CXZlY`\ikX[
yjkX\jcXgX
ZlXe[fefjZfd\dfjcXjgXcfd`kXj%CXgXik\ ÇHl[\c`Z`fjXjgXcfd`kXj:Xcfie#hl`\e`YX
`ek\i`fi\jk}cc\eX[\Xcd`[ehl\j\_XZ\ Xg\ejXihl\kf[f\j\il`[fj\[\Y\XleX
^iXe[\_XjkX]fidXi\c\jgfeafjfpYcXeZf g\hl\XZXek`[X[[\X^lXhl\_Xp\ejl
Zl\igf[\cXjgXcfd`kXj%CXg\hl\XZXek`[X[ `ek\i`fi%
[\X^lXhl\_Xp[\ekif[\c^iXe`kfgifmfZXleX Ç8j\j8cY\ik%PgfiZ`\ikf#pXhl\_Xj
g\hl\X\ogcfj`e%:lXe[fj\ZXc`\ekX\c^iXef# Xgi\e[`[fXc^fd}j#\jk`\dgf[\hl\
\cX^lXj\\mXgfiXpj\Zfem`\ik\\e^Xj% fYk\e^Xj\cgf[\i[\cZXcfi%
((
<og%',
¾
Æ7^ehWoWj[d]e[bfeZ[hZ[bWbkpo[bZ[b
YWbeh"i_]k[bW[b[Yjh_Y_ZWZ$
:[9_kZWZ9Wbeh\_YW";_dij[_dl_W`W9_kZWZ
;ij|j_YW$7^beh[Y_X_bWh[_dWJhed_$
ÆIkCW`[ijWZ"¶gk]kijel[hbWÅZ_`e
;_dij[_dÅ"l[d]efehgk[igk[Wgk[dYed#
jhWh[bfeZ[hZ[bW[b[Yjh_Y_ZWZgk[c[
WokZWh|Wbb[]WhWbj[iehe$
ÆJ_[d[ihWpdÅZ_`ebWH[_dWJhed_Å"f[he
Yece[dbeiZ[c|ifeZ[h[i"j[dZh|igk[
fWiWhWb]kdWifhk[XWi$
Æ9ecekij[ZZ_]W"CW`[ijWZ$
8j\jZfdf
cf_XZ\j%%%
\jk}k`ZX%
:Xi^XilefYa\kfZfe\c\Zki`Z`[X[ ' :fikXleXk`iX[\gXg\c[\Z_`eX
[\lefj.o
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ G I
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾Leg\`e\[\gc}jk`Zf
¾GXg\cZ_`eX
¾K`a\iXj
¾I\^cX
( :fikX\c
gXg\c\ek`i
cXi^Xjp[\c^X[X
[\aXe[flef[\
cfj\oki\dfjj`e
ZfikXi%
()
)
¶HljlZ\[`f6
¶GfihlZi\\jhl\gXj\\jf6
;nfb_YWY_d0
(*
<og%'-
¾
Debefk[ZeYh[[h"oWj[d]ejh[ifeZ[h[i
o"]hWY_WiWbWh[_dWJhed_"bei^[h[\eh#
pWZe$F[heW^ehWj[dZhgk[^WXbWhYed
H[i_ij_dW$:_Y[dgk[[icko]hkedW"
e`Wb|gk_[hWZWhc[ikfeZ[h$
ÆH[i_ij_dW"[ijeoWgk"Z_ifk[ijeW^WY[h
bed[Y[iWh_efWhWeXj[d[h[bfeZ[hZ[bW
_d[hY_Wgk[ibekij[Zc[fk[Z[ZWh$
Ƶ7^i5ÅZ_`eH[i_ij_dWÅfk[iW^ehWc[
beZ[ceijhWh|i$
;\dfjkiXihl\lefYa\kfZfek`eX
dfm`e[fj\[\Y`[fXcX`e\iZ`X%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ
C
¾:`eZfc`Yifj
¾LeXj`ccX
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
' :fcfZXcfjc`Yifj\e\cXj`\ekf[\cX
j`ccX#Zfdfj\dl\jkiX\ecX]`^liX%
(+
(
¶HlfZlii`
Zfecfjc`Yifj6 Y`Xi\cdfm`d`\ekfhl\\jk}ei\Xc`qXe[f#X
¶GfihlZi\\jhl\jlZ\[`6 efj\ihl\Xc^leXXZZ`ej\cfj`dg`[XÆ[`af
<`ejk\`eÆ%
ÇDlpY`\e#¶pZdfgl\[\_XZ\ij\gXiX
hl\Xc^fj\dl\mX6Ægi\^lekI\j`jk`eXÆ%
;nfb_YWY_d0 ÇGl\jXc^l`\e[\Y\i}dfm\icfÆ[`af
Kf[fj\[\Y\XcX `e\iZ`X
X#hl\\jcXi\j`jk\eZ`X <`ejk\`eÆ%
[\cfjZl\igfjÆ\e\jk\ZXjf#cfjc`YifjÆX
ZlXchl`\iZXdY`f\e\cdfm`d`\ekf%<j[\Z`i# Ç:fii\Zkf#eX[`\_XYX\ek\e[`[fcfhl\\j
j\i\j`jk\eX[\aXi[\dfm\ij\[\dXe\iX cX`e\iZ`X#pgfi_XY\icf[\jZlY`\ikf#k\gi\$
YiljZX%Cfjc`Yifjj\ZXp\ife
egfihl\j`^l`\ife d`Xi#[}e[fk\\cgf[\ihl\kXekfYljZXj%
dfm`e[fj\\ecXd`jdX[`i\ZZ`ehl\k\eXe ÇDlZ_Xj^iXZ`XjI\j`jk`eXÆ[`af<`ejk\`eÆ%
ZlXe[f\jkXYXejfYi\cXj`ccXpZfek`eXejl
dfm`d`\ekf#XleZlXe[fcXj`ccXj\[\klmf% :fdf<`ejk\`epXk\eX\c gf[\i[\cX
`e\iZ`X
X#I\j`jk`eXc\[`fle^fcg\kXe]l\ik\#
Ƕ:fdgi\e[`jk\cfhl\\jcX`e\iZ`X6Ægi\$ hl\cf\em`XcgXjccXdX[fMfcXeke#j`e
^lekI\j`jk`eXÆ% g\id`k`ic\j`hl`\iX[\jg\[`ij\%
(,
<og%'.
¾
=hWY_WiWb\k[hj[_cfkbiegk[h[Y_X_Z[
H[i_ij_dW";_dij[_dbb[]WLebWdjdfWhW
[dYedjhWhi[YedIf[hLebWZeh"kd^he[
gk[b[ZWhW[bfeZ[hZ[lebWh$
Æ7b\_dbb[]W"i[eh;_dij[_dÅZ_`eIf[h
LebWZehÅ$
ÆI"If[hLebWZeh"H[i_ij_dWc[WokZW
bb[]Whbec|ifhedjefei_Xb[$
Æ;d\_d"ifehgkl_[d[io[ic[`ehgk[
Yec[dY[cei"fehgk[Z[beYedjhWh_ebW
Xhk`Wbb[]Wh|Wdj[igk[j$
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
' :fcfZXcfjc`YifjjfYi\cXd\jX#ZfeleX
j\gXiXZ`e [\ (' Zd \eki\ \ccfj
FYj\imXi\c\]\Zkf[\cX
m\cfZ`[X[\ecXgi\j`e[\cX`i\%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾;fjc`Yifj[\cd`jdfkXdXf
¾LeX_faX[\gXg\c
¾Legfgfk\
¾LeXi\^cX
( :fcfZXcX_faX[\gXg\c
jfYi\cfjc`Yifj%
(-
) 8Z
cX
gfgfk\g
[\cXfi
gXg\c%
* Jf
]l\
gl\[Xj
[\cgfgf
¶HljlZ\[`f
ZfecX_faX6
¶GfihlZi\\jhl\jlZ\[\6 ÇEf<`ejk\`e#[`afJg\iMfcX[fi#cfhl\
jlZ\[\\jhl\leXgXik\[\cX`i\\ekiXgfi
;nfb_YWY_d0 le\oki\dfpcXfkiXgXik\gfi\cfkif#\jgfi
le`]fid\\gficfj \jfhl\lef\dglaXXcfkif%
cX[fj[\cgXg\cXek\j[\hl\jfgc\jgfi\c Ç·8_#\ekfeZ\j\cX`i\j\[`m`[\%
gfgfk\%<cX`i\hl\\dglaX_XZ`XXYXaf\cgXg\c Ç·<oXZkXd\ek\9l\ef#Zi\fhl\\j\c
\a\iZ\d}j]l\iqXhl\\cX`i\hl\cf\dglaX dfd\ekf[\fkfi^Xik\fkifgf[\i%<c[\
_XZ`XXii`YX#gficfhl\\cgXg\cj\_le[\\eki\ mfcXi#hl\k\g\id`k`i}kiXjcX[Xik\_XZ`X
cfjc`Yifj% [fe[\k[\j\\j%
Ç·HldXiXm`ccX#\cX`i\\jk}j`\dgi\\eki\ Ç>iXZ`Xj#Jg\iMfcX[fi%
efjfkifj#Xlehl\eleZXcfm\dfj% Ç<`ejk\`e#jcfi\Zl\i[Xhl\ef[\Y\jmfcXi
Ç<jZ`\ikf#8cY\ik% \e[`i\ZZ`eZfekiXi`XXcXYilaX#gfihl\\c
ǶP_XpmXi`fjX`i\j6#gfihl\[`Z\jhl\le X`i\j\[`m`[`i}#Zfdfkcf[`a`jk\%
X`i\j\\dglaXZfefkif% ÇCfi\Zfi[Xi%
(.
<og%'/
¾
;_dij[_dleboleb"^WijWgk[l_eWb
9Wf_j|d8WhYe"kdXkgk[gk[Wkdgk[dkdYW
Z[iYWdiWXW"i_[cfh[[ijWXWcko\[b_p$
;_dij[_di[Z[jkleob[Z_`e0
Æ9Wf_j|d8WhYe"igk[jc[ZWh|i[b
feZ[hZ[\bejWh1µgkZ[Xe^WY[h5
Æ;ickoi[dY_bbe"lWceiW_dl[ij_]Wh
fehgk\bejWdbeiXWhYeiYeceoe$
8j\jZfdf
cf_XZ\j%%%
' :fcfZX
cXjlg\
X^lX#Zfe
_l\ZX_XZ`XXii`
;\jZlYi`igfihlleYXiZfÕfkX
\e\cX^lX%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ G I < <
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾CXkXgXd\k}c`ZX[\le]iXjZf[\lefj-f.Zd
[\[`}d\kif
¾LeXZXe`ZX
LeXZlY\kXZfeX^lX
( 8_fiXZfcfZ
cXZXe`ZX%
(/
¶HlgXj
ZfecfjfYa\kfj
hl\ZfcfZXjk\
\e\cX^lX6
¶GfihlZi\\jhl\jlZ\[\6
;nfb_YWY_d0
8dY
d`jd
^iXe[\jYXiZfj#Xlehl\jfedlp^iXe[\jp _l\ZfjgXiXef_le[`id\6
g\jX[fj#k`\e\e\jgXZ`fj_l\Zfjcc\efj[\X`i\ ÇEf#8cY\ik2k[\Y\jXgi\e[\iXeX[Xi%
p\jkf_XZ\hl\]cfk\e% G\ifYXjkX[\kXekXjgi\^lekXjpd\afik\
[Xi \cgf[\i[\]cfkXi%
ǶCfjYXiZfjZfdfk#k`\e\e_fpfjgfi
[fe[\\ekiXX`i\6 Ç·DlZ_j`dXj^iXZ`Xj:Xg`k}e9XiZf#jcf
ÇJ#8cY\ik%<jgfi\jfhl\efefj_le[`dfj% d\]XckXe[fjgf[\i\jgXiXcc\^XiXck\jfif%
(0
<og%'0
¾
;_dij[_di[\k[\bejWdZe^WijW
8khXk`ebWdZ_W"gk[de[ijWXWb[`eiZ[
W^$7bbb[]WhWbWY_kZWZ"beh[Y_X_Zed
8khXk`e"kdf[hiedW`[ckoWc_]WXb[gk[
Z_i\hkjWXWXW_bWh$
Æ8_[dl[d_Ze7bX[hj"i[h|kd^edehcei#
jhWhb[dk[ijhWY_kZWZÅZ_`eZed8khXk`eÅ$
Æ=hWY_Wi"f[hekij[ZiWX[gk[dej[d]e
j_[cfefehW^ehW1Wigk[YkWdjeWdj[i
Z[XefWiWhbWfhk[XWfWhWeXj[d[h[bfeZ[h
Z[bWiXkhXk`Wic|]_YWiÅZ_`e;_dij[_dÅ$
ÆJ_[d[kij[ZjeZWbWhWpd"l[d]WYed#
c_]efWhW_dZ_YWhb[begk[Z[X[^WY[h$
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
' =ifkX\cg\`e\mXi`Xjm\Z
[ ] c
(
FYj\imXihl\cX\c\Zki`Z`[X[
\jk}k`ZXgif[lZ\dfm`d`\ekf\ecXj
YliYlaXj%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
Leg\`e\[\gc}jk`Zf
Leg\[Xqf[\]iXe\cX
LeXifgXiX]fidXiYliYlaXj
D\qZcX[\X^lXZfeaXYegXiXYliYlaXj
)'
)
¶HljlZ\[`6
;nfb_YWY_d0
g #
gi`eZ`g`f\j\cd`jdf%<e\jk\ZXjf#kXekf\c gf[\i[\cXjYliYlaXj
j hl\c\[Xi}eXc\^iX%
g\`e\ZfdfcXjYliYlaXjk`\e\eZXi^Xje\^X$ ÇDlZ_Xj^iXZ`Xj[fe9liYlaf#·X_fiXjcf
k`mXjpgfi\ccfj\i\g\c\e% d\]XckXlegf[\i
)(
<og%('
¾
FWhW_hW9_kZWZCl_b";_dij[_di[c[j_
[dkdWXkhXk`Wgk[bejhWdifehjWhWb_Xh[#
c[dj[$7bbb[]Wh"]h_j0
ÆJehX[bb_d_"JehX[bb_d_"µZdZ[[ij|i5
JehX[bb_d_oW[ijWXWfh[fWhWZeYedbei
cWj[h_Wb[ifWhW[b[nf[h_c[djeobeh[W#
b_pYed;_dij[_d$
8j\jZfdfcf_XZ\j%%%
' :fi
[\g
(
+%,d
:f
[\Xgifo`dX[Xd\ek\
;\dfjkiXihl\cXj]l\iqXj
[\j`^lXc\jgif[lZ\edfm`d`\ekf%
¾ : L8 ; < I E F ; < < O G < I @ D < E K FJ G
Cfhl\e\Z\j`kXj\j%%%
¾Legfgfk\ ¾LeXg`eqXgXiXjla\kXiifgX
¾K`a\iXj
¾:l\i[X[\c^X[X
¾Le^cfYf
¾;fjj`ccXj
:`ekXX[_\j`mX ) @
\
[\cX
\cgfg
))
* +
/
¶HljlZ\[`6
;nfb_YWY_d0
a p ^ ^ g h
fgl\jkff#jfYi\\cgi`d\if%<cX`i\\a\iZ\leX dXe[c\afj#dlpc\afj%
]l\iqX[\\dgla\jfYi\\c^cfYf#pjk\ÇXc
c`Y\iXi\cX`i\Ç\a\iZ\leX]l\iqX\ej\ek`[f 8_fiXj#\j\cdfd\ekf[\XYi`i\ck\jfif%
fgl\jkf% <`ejk\`eXYi`\cZf]i\pjXZ[\cled\e$
Ç<cdfm`d`\ekf\jdlp`dgfikXek\#gfihl\ jXa\hl\[\ZX%
cfj_ldXefjcflk`c`qXdfjgXiXZfii\ip ·=\c`qZldgc\Xfj8cY\ik#_Xj[\jZlY`\ikfcX
jXckXiÆ[`afKfiY\cc`e`Æ% I\cXk`m`[X[
[
)*
>cfjXi`f EJHEIJßJKBEI
¾:lX[\ief[\\og\i`d\ekfj &gi`dXi`X
¾:lX[\ief[\\og\i`d\ekfj &j\Zle[Xi`X
;b[Yjh_Y_ZWZ[ij|j_YW0cXhl\XgXi\Z\\e ¾:lX[\ief[\\og\i`d\ekfj &YXZ_`cc\iXkf
leZl\igfZlXe[f\o`jk\e\ecZXi^Xj
\cZki`ZXj\ei\gfjf%
?d[hY_W0Gifg`\[X[[\cfjZl\igfj[\ef
df[`]`ZXijl\jkX[f[\i\gfjffdfm`$
d`\ekfj`ef\jgficXXZZ`e[\leX
]l\iqX%
;ijheXeiYf_Ye0<]\Zkfm`jlXchl\g\id`k\
m\iZfdfc\ekfjf`edm`c\jfYa\kfjhl\
j\dl\m\e[\]fidXi}g`[Xpg\i`[`ZX#
d\[`Xek\jlfYj\imXZ`e`ek\id`k\ek\%
<_bjhei0DXk\i`XgfifjX#Zfdf]`\ckif#gXg\c#
\jgfeaX#ZXiYe#\kZ%#fZXgX[\Xi\eXf
[\g`\[iXjd\el[XjXkiXmj[\cXZlXcj\
_XZ\gXjXicXclqfZlXchl`\ichl`[f%
CebYkbW0Le`[X[de`dX[\leXjlj$
kXeZ`X#]fidX[Xgfid}j[\le}kfdf%
:fej\afEXZ`feXc[\:`\eZ`XpK\Zefcf^X
@ejli^\ek\jJli(,/)#:fc%:i[`kf:fejkilZkfi
:%G%'*0+'#Do`Zf#;%=%
Gl\[\j\eZfekiXi\jk\ZlX[\iefkXdY`e\e`ek\ie\k1
mmm$YedWYoj$cn