You are on page 1of 2

more than 3 children.

They are interested in IVF with PGD because they want to select a
male embryo. How do you proceed?
Discussion
The use of PGD solely for the purpose of sex selection is controversial. Is
preimplantation sex selection considered gender bias? Many would consider having a
baby of the nondesired gender not “bad enough” to justify IVF and PGD, while others
feel that it is reasonable and will offer the procedure based on the principle of patient
autonomy. There is no clearly right or wrong answer here, other than
that infertility practices should have policies regarding this subject and apply the policy
fairly to all patients.
Note that in some cases, sex selection may be beneficial to prevent transmission of
recessive X-linked genetic diseases (e.g., hemophilia A and Duchenne muscular
dystrophy).
more than 3 children. They are interested in IVF with PGD because they want to select a
male embryo. How do you proceed?
Discussion
The use of PGD solely for the purpose of sex selection is controversial. Is
preimplantation sex selection considered gender bias? Many would consider having a
baby of the nondesired gender not “bad enough” to justify IVF and PGD, while others
feel that it is reasonable and will offer the procedure based on the principle of patient
autonomy. There is no clearly right or wrong answer here, other than
that infertility practices should have policies regarding this subject and apply the policy
fairly to all patients.
Note that in some cases, sex selection may be beneficial to prevent transmission of
recessive X-linked genetic diseases (e.g., hemophilia A and Duchenne muscular
dystrophy).
They are interested in IVF with PGD because they want to select a male embryo. How do
you proceed?
Discussion
The use of PGD solely for the purpose of sex selection is controversial. Is
preimplantation sex selection considered gender bias? Many would consider having a
baby of the nondesired gender not “bad enough” to justify IVF and PGD, while others
feel that it is reasonable and will offer the procedure based on the principle of patient
autonomy. There is no clearly right or wrong answer here, other than
that infertility practices should have policies regarding this subject and apply the policy
fairly to all patients.
Note that in some cases, sex selection may be beneficial to prevent transmission of
recessive X-linked genetic diseases (e.g., hemophilia A and Duchenne muscular
dystrophy).
more than 3 children. They are interested in IVF with PGD because they want to select a
male embryo. How do you proceed?
Discussion
The use of PGD solely for the purpose of sex selection is controversial. Is
preimplantation sex selection considered gender bias? Many would consider having a
baby of the nondesired gender not “bad enough” to justify IVF and PGD, while others
feel that it is reasonable and will offer the procedure based on the principle of patient
autonomy. There is no clearly right or wrong answer here, other than
that infertility practices should have policies regarding this subject and apply the policy
fairly to all patients.
Note that in some cases, sex selection may be beneficial to prevent transmission of
recessive X-linked genetic diseases (e.g., hemophilia A and Duchenne muscular
dystrophy).

You might also like