Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/261949504
CITATIONS READS
0 417
4 authors, including:
Dusan Gordic
University of Kragujevac
47 PUBLICATIONS 257 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Dragan Cvetković on 13 January 2015.
Dragan Cvetkovic1, Vanja Susterstic1, Dusan Gordic1, Milorad Bojic1, Srdjan Stosic2
1
University of Kragujevac, Faculty of Engineering, Serbia
2
Metro Cash&Carry doo, Belgrade, Serbia
Abstract
The aim of this paper was to study the performance of a single-stage rotating biological contactor with supplemental aeration in
terms of removal efficiency of organic and nitrogen content. Research was based on fifteen samples collected during the four
year period. The wastewater was low strength with maximal measured concentration of 362 mg COD/l, 100 mg NH4/l, and 324
mg TSS/L. The maximal measured removal efficiency of COD (chemical oxygen demand) and TSS (total suspend solids) were
71% and 56%, respectively. The high rate of nitrogen removal was achieved using supplemental aeration. The removal efficiency
of NH4, NO2 and NO3 were 83%, 60% and 52%, respectively.
Key words: nitrogen removal, organic removal, single-stage rotating biological contactor, supplemental aeration, wastewater
Received: December, 2011; Revised final: June, 2012; Accepted: July, 2012
Author to whom all correspondence should be addressed: e-mail: dragan_cw8202@yahoo.com, Phone +381641246233
Cvetkovic et al./Environmental Engineering and Management Journal 13 (2014), 3, 681-688
was 92% with ammonia loading of 1.1 g/m2d efficiencies were improved, significantly higher
(Tawfik et al., 2002). Hiras et al. (2004) investigated organic loading rates could be treated and Beggiatoa
characteristics of organic and nitrogen removal in growth were completely eliminated. Consequently,
two-stage RBC. The RBC system consisted of two these would lead to considerable cost saving in
separate RBC units, anoxic and aerobic unit. The design and construction of RBC units (Surampalli
average removal efficiency of BOD5 (biochemical and Bauman, 1997). Saikaly (2001) conducted a
oxygen demand), TSS (total suspend solids) and TN more comprehensive study in which the effect of
were 86%, 63% and 54% respectively, so it can be variable HLRs, OLRs, and influent substrate
concluded that increase of hydraulic loading, concentrations applied to a three-stage RBC system
resulting from higher recirculation, have limited operating in a step-feed mode were evaluated. It was
negative effect on organic removal, but improved concluded that variation in the HLR had insignificant
nitrogen removal (Hiras et al., 2004). Yeh et al. effects on the overall COD and BOD but it was more
(1997) investigated the performance of anaerobic effective on NH3–N removals. It was also concluded
rotating biological contactor (AnRBC) for the that at low OLR (COD of 1200 mg/L), the step-feed
treatment of high-strength synthetic wastewater system was more efficient in terms of NH3–N
under different flow rates and influent organic removal; however, no differences were found in
strengths. The removal efficiency of BOD increased COD and BOD removals. At high OLRs (>1200
as the hydraulic retention time (HRT) increased or mg/l) the step-feed system showed higher
the influent organic strength decreased. The overall efficiencies in the removal of NH3–N and COD and
BOD removal efficiency ranged from 74% to 82% at higher stage DO concentrations were attained
HRT of 32 h, and from 44% to 53% at HRT of 8 h. (Saikaly, 2001).
The organic loading in influent was very strength and The study reported by Neu (1992), showed
ranged from 3248 mg COD/l to 12150 mg COD/l that recycling of secondary sludge to a pilot-scale
(Yeh et al., 1997). Tawfik et al. (2005) conducted a RBC resulted in several advantages, such as:
study about the performance of single-stage RBC increased organic capacity, improved effluent quality
system, two-stage RBC system and UASB reactor and significant reduction of nutrients (N and P)
followed by a segmental two-stage aerobic RBC. without chemical addition, reduction of bacterial film
Influent was treated in UASB reactor. The single weight on the RBC discs. Under non-optimized
stage RBC was operated at the constant HRT of 2.5h process conditions, at least a doubling of the
and temperature of 21oC but with different OLRs phosphorous content of the biomass was noted and
(organic loading rate). better settling and dewatering characteristics for the
The results clearly showed that residual value effluent solids were obtained (Neu, 1992).
of organic load and ammonia in the final effluent was In this study, the performance of the RBC
significantly lower at a lower imposed OLR of 10 g system with supplemental aeration is investigated.
COD/m2day. Also, the results showed that the COD The investigated performances were observed
fractions and ammonia content in the final effluent of analyzing biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), total
a two stage RBC system were significantly lower suspend solids (TSS) and nitrogen contents.
than the effluent of the single stage RBC system Supplemental aeration was manually setup and it was
(Tawfik et al., 2005). Surampalli and Bauman (1997) constant during operating cycle.
reported a study conducted for the purpose of
evaluating the effect of supplemental aeration on the 2. Material and methods
performance of a RBC system in which the first and
the second stages were overloaded thus resulting in 2.1. Rotating biological contactor (RBC)
low DO concentrations and heavy Beggiatoa growth.
The performance was evaluated in terms of The investigated RBC system built, by Tehnix
the total organic loading applied and removed. The Company in 2005, is located in Metro Cash&Carry
results of the study, where supplemental aeration was Nis, Serbia (Fig. 1). The main components of RBC
used, showed that soluble COD and NH3–N removal system are shown in Fig. 2.
682
Perfomance of single-stage rotating biological contactor with supplemental aeration
The RBC system is operating since November submerged (based on disc surface) and it rotates at 1
9th, 2006. Wastewater supply system was gravity fed rpm in direction of the flow. The disc material was
with maximal loading rate of 5 l/s. The RBC system made of polypropylene type 2H TKP-312. The
is one-stage system consisted of anaerobic reactor and quantity of supplemental air was manually adjusted at
additional aeration pool (Fig. 3). The working volume 150 l/min and the aeration was performed on every 30
of the covered anaerobic unit is 11 m3. The unit has min. Duration of aeration was 30 min.
four disks (diameter of each disc is 210 cm) and five The operating process of the RBC system is
rectangular blades (20 cm long) that are placed in disk shown in Fig. 4. The process considers three sub-
inter space to enhance mixing. The total biomass processes: mechanical-physical processing, biological
support surface is 26.58 m2 and the disc is 40% breakdown and stabilization.
683
Cvetkovic et al./Environmental Engineering and Management Journal 13 (2014), 3, 681-688
400 80%
Influent Effluent Removal
350 70%
300 60%
Removal, %
250 50%
COD, mg/l
200 40%
150 30%
100 20%
50 10%
0 0%
Dec 2007
Dec 2009
Dec 2010
Oct 2009
Nov 2008
Feb 2007
May 2007
May 2008
Jun 2009
Jun 2010
Jun 2011
Jul 2007
Jul 2008
Mar 2009
Mar 2010
Mar 2011
Day of operation
a)
350 60%
Influent Effluent Removal
300 50%
250
40%
Removal, %
TSS, mg/l
200
30%
150
20%
100
50 10%
0 0%
Dec 2007
Dec 2009
Dec 2010
Oct 2009
Nov 2008
Feb 2007
May 2007
May 2008
Jul 2007
Jul 2008
Jun 2009
Jun 2010
Jun 2011
Mar 2009
Mar 2010
Mar 2011
Day of operation
b)
Fig 5. The variation and removal efficiency in the organic and solid content: a) variation and removal efficiency of COD; b)
variation and removal efficiency of TSS
684
Perfomance of single-stage rotating biological contactor with supplemental aeration
In Fig. 5, the variation and removal efficiency removal efficiency of TSS concentration was 56% on
of organic loading is shown. The removal efficiency May 2008 (at influent concentration of 256 mg
of COD was in range of 23% to 71%. The highest TSS/l). The removal efficiency of TSS concentration
removal efficiency of COD concentration at organic was in the range of 32% and 56%.
loading rate of 16.98 g COD/m2d was 71%, measured The variation of nitrogen content removal
on the July 2007. For the highest organic loading rate efficiency in RBC unit is shown in the Fig. 6. The
of 19.33 g COD/m2d, removal efficiency of COD was content of ammonium ion NH4 varied a lot during
56%, measured on February 2007. The concentration operating period. The lowest concentration of NH4 in
of total suspend solid had the highest value on July influent was 0.93 mg NH4/L, and the highest was 100
2007 of about 324 mg TSS/L, and the highest mg NH4/L.
120 90%
Influent Effluent Removal 80%
Ammonium ion NH4, mg/l
100
70%
80 60%
Removal, %
50%
60
40%
40 30%
20%
20
10%
0 0%
Dec 2007
Dec 2009
Dec 2010
Oct 2009
Nov 2008
Feb 2007
May 2007
May 2008
Jul 2007
Jul 2008
Jun 2009
Jun 2010
Jun 2011
Mar 2009
Mar 2010
Mar 2011
Day of operation
a)
0.18 70%
Influent Effluent Removall
0.16 60%
0.14
50%
Nitrite NO 2 , mg/l
0.12
Removal, %
0.1 40%
0.08 30%
0.06
20%
0.04
0.02 10%
0 0%
Dec 2007
Dec 2009
Dec 2010
Oct 2009
Nov 2008
Feb 2007
May 2007
May 2008
Jul 2007
Jul 2008
Jun 2009
Jun 2010
Jun 2011
Mar 2009
Mar 2010
Mar 2011
Day of operation
b)
40 60%
Influent Effluent Removall
35
50%
30
Nitrate NO3 , mg/l
40%
Removal, %
25
20 30%
15
20%
10
10%
5
0 0%
Dec 2007
Dec 2009
Dec 2010
Oct 2009
Feb 2007
Nov 2008
May 2007
May 2008
Jul 2007
Jul 2008
Jun 2009
Jun 2010
Jun 2011
Mar 2009
Mar 2010
Mar 2011
Day of operation
c)
Fig. 6. The variation of nitrogen content and removal efficiency: a) variation and removal of ammonium ion; b) variation and
removal of nitrite; c) variation and removal of nitrate
685
Cvetkovic et al./Environmental Engineering and Management Journal 13 (2014), 3, 681-688
The RBC unit was working with removal However, using supplemental aeration, the
efficiency of NH4 in the range from 22% to 83%. The greater efficiency of organic and nitrogen content
effluent NO2 and NO3 concentration varied between removal can be achieved. In addition, the analysis of
0.015-0.1 mg/l and 0.1-24.2 mg/L, respectively. wastewater shows that influent in RBC system is low
Nitrification efficiency was in the range between 18- strength. During 2007, concentration of COD was
60% and denitrification was in the range 13-52%. The slightly higher probably because of the fact that
effect of the loading rate (in terms of COD or NH4) technological process was not monitored in trade
on the RBC system performance (as indicated by the center (increased quantity of detergent, oils, synthetic
corresponding removal rates) is presented in Fig. 7. material etc.). In the next three years, the
The values were calculated based on feed wastewater concentration of COD was significantly lower as
characteristics and removal rate. consequence of technological process monitoring.
The relationships between organic and From literature review, it can be concluded that
nitrogen loading and removal were statistically removal efficiency of COD in RBC can be very high.
significant and those relationships can be used to Gupta and Gupta (2001) achieved COD removal of
design the RBC systems. Fig. 8 shows the influence 90% in strength wastewater (1000 mgCOD/L).
of temperature on removal process of nitrogen and Tawfik et al. (2002) achieved the removal efficiency
organic content. A measurement results show that the of 75% after first stage and 80 % after second stage.
higher rate of removal efficiency of organic and In this paper, the investigated RBC system is
nitrogen content were at the higher temperature (May achieved removal efficiency of 84% in May 2007.
2007, Jul 2007, and Jun 2011). The higher COD removal rates with
supplemental air could be attributed to higher
4. Discussion dissolved oxygen levels. The TSS removal efficiency
of 56% was achieved which is slightly lower in
RBC systems are usually used for pretreatment comparison with the data from (Hiras et al., 2004)
process or for treatment of lower strength wastewater. where the TSS removal efficiency was 63%.
14 5
5
12
4
NH4 removal rate, g/m2d
COD removal rate, g/m2 d
10 4
3
8
y = 0.785x ‐ 4.269 y = 0.801x ‐ 0.446
3
R² = 0.633 R² = 0.925
6 2
4 2
1
2
1
0 0
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 0 1 2 3 4 5
COD loading rate, g/m2 d NH4 loading rate, g/m2d
a) b)
Fig. 7. COD and NH4 removal rates vs. corresponding loadings: a) COD removal rates vs corresponding loadings;
b) NH4 removal rates vs corresponding loadings
20
Removal, %
60%
15 50%
40%
10
30%
20%
5
10%
0 0%
Dec 2007
Dec 2009
Dec 2010
Oct 2009
Nov 2008
Feb 2007
May 2007
May 2008
Jul 2007
Jul 2008
Mar 2009
Jun 2009
Mar 2010
Jun 2010
Mar 2011
Jun 2011
Jul 2011
Day of operation
686
Perfomance of single-stage rotating biological contactor with supplemental aeration
Slightly lower removal efficiency of TSS may correlation dependence of the total nitrogen content
be the consequence of higher loading rate or low of 0.4608, and slope of the linear relationships of
recirculation of sludge. 0.5633. For the three-stage RBC system, Surampalli
In conventional single stage RBC systems and Baumann (1997), obtained slopes of 0.909 when
(without additional aeration) very small nitrification used supplemental aeration and 0.707 for RBC
is present. This is due to an insufficient NH4-N system without supplemental aeration. Several
oxidiser population at high COD loading rate, as they authors (Chesner and Iannone, 1978; USEPA, 1984)
cannot compete with heterotrophs for space and have suggested the use of total organic loading
oxygen. This deficiency is usually eliminated by concepts to determine the required surface area for
introducing one more RBC unit. The examples in RBC design and to predict process performance.
relevant literature showed how authors tried to solve However, the high value of correlation coefficient
problem of nitrogen removal efficiency at a single- and slope of the linear relationships for NH4 indicates
stage RBC system using the multi-stage RBC system. a high efficiency of the RBC system. Lower values
Using a 3-stage RBC 60% nitrification in strength for COD may be due to downtime of the system, i.e.
wastewater was achieved (500-700 mg/l of nitrate) the influence of the sludge in the reactor.
(Gupta and Gupta, 2001). Tawfik et al. (2002) Figure 8 shows the influence of temperature
presented high nitrification rate of 0.97 g NH4/m2d on removal process of nitrogen and organic content.
(92%) for the two-stage RBC at an imposed However, due to variations of load of organic and
ammonia loading rate of 1.07 g NH4/m2d and COD nitrogen content at the different measurement results,
loading rate of 6.45 g COD /m2d. This nitrification and lack of measurements at a lower temperature
efficiency is slightly higher than one obtained by (around 0 degrees) it is not possible to conduct an
Cheung (1981), for an RBC system treating diluted accurate analysis of the influence of temperature on
domestic wastewater at an organic loading rate of 8.0 removal process. Also, because of the time that
g COD/m2d. passed between two measurements, significant
The results of the present study showed that variations of the condition of bacteria growth can
when the OLR increased from 13.7 g COD/m2d to occur.
21.0 g COD/m2d the nitrification rate decreased from
1.45 g NH4/m2d to 0.6 g NH4/m2d for ammonia 5. Conclusions
loading rates of 1.98 g NH4 /m2d and 3.1 g NH4 /m2d.
According to the observations of Boongorsrang et al. The single-stage rotating biological contactor
(1982) the COD loading rate should not exceed 2.54 with supplemental aeration obtained a successful
g/m2d in order to enable nitrification occur in single- result in wastewater treatment. The RBC system
stage RBC contactor without supplemental aeration. worked with low strength wastewater in the range
In an investigation conducted by Tawfik et al. (2005) from 38 mg COD/l to 362 mg COD/L, with the
at influent concentration of 42 mg NH4/L nitrification exception that after the first year of operation, the
rate of 14% was achieved with single-stage RBC and concentration stabilized at around 250 mg COD/l. A
30% with two-stage RBC system. In the present 71% COD removal efficiency was achieved, for
investigation, in July 2007, a higher nitrification rate significantly higher OLR of 16.98 g COD/m2d. Also,
of 4.43 g NH4/m2d (83%) was found for the single- removal rate of NH4 had exceeded expectations in
stage RBC with additional aeration at an imposed relation to the recommendations for system without
ammonia loading rate of 5.34 g NH4/m2d and COD supplemental aeration. For high nitrogen loading of
loading rate of 16.98 g COD/m2d. The high 5.34 g NH4/m2d, the high nitrification rate of 60%
nitrification rate at a significantly higher load of and denitrification rate of 52% for single-stage RBC
COD and NH4 can be attributed to additional were achieved. The relationships between organic
aeration. loading and removal were statistically significant and
RBC performance was evaluated based on those relationships can be used to design the RBC
total initial organic loading and removed organic systems.
loading, since there is a strong relationship between Finally, this research shows that using the
the variables. It was observed that removal rates and single-stage RBC with additional aeration nitrogen
process efficiency were indeed dependent on the total removal efficiency can be achieved as a two-stage
organics load applied to the RBCs rather than on its RBC system. Also, at a higher OLR, single-stage
concentration or wastewater flow rate. The NH4 data RBC with additional aeration achieved similar
show a high degree of dependence (correlation organic removal efficiency as a classical RBC system
coefficient of 0.925). However, the COD data do not (without additional aeration) at significantly lower
exhibit similar behavior (correlation coefficient of OLR.
0.633). However, there is a non significant difference
in the slopes of the linear relationships obtained for Acknowledgements
nitrogen and organic removal rate. The authors would like to acknowledge Metro Cash&Carry
The calculated slopes were 0.785 and 0.801 doo in Serbia and Tehnix Company for their full
cooperation. Also this paper is a result of the TR33015
for COD and NH4, respectively. For the two-stage project of Tehnological Development of Republic of
RBC, Hiras et al. (2004), obtained series of Serbia.
687
Cvetkovic et al./Environmental Engineering and Management Journal 13 (2014), 3, 681-688
688