Professional Documents
Culture Documents
اصدار الاوامر التغييرية من قبل المهندس في عقد المقاولة- دراسة في عقد الفيديك الكتاب الاحمر
اصدار الاوامر التغييرية من قبل المهندس في عقد المقاولة- دراسة في عقد الفيديك الكتاب الاحمر
(! "#)
! .
:
.د
.() +C ", ( 3 ()
)
.! "
(9 F3 :(* D - % ='& +
9
.! /
9 F3 (#
5( * 0. " 0*
I' "( F3 1!
.( 1! ! & )
. ", O : /8 I ='& !
+9 ", B3 ='& ", 1 . P3 6 3
6 J '& ", 9 C 3 + 6
; .L *
C 3 /8 O* ;
PA + ' +Q, "3* % # 3 .3 + +
(1) Michael R Ludlow and J Gordon Rees “Engineer’s Role under FIDIC Standard
Conditions of Contract” International Business Lawyer, November 1992, published
on line.
(2) Nael G. Bunni, “Which Form to Use?” a paper presented at Falconbury Workshop,
London 3-4 March 2005 at p 1
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
% . ' ( + 6 /* *
% /8’ 2 /* ", # 3 +8 "
I9 J +3, ( - S$ , & '3 ."3*9
:<$ T8 2$9 + U. :*$ 6 ( U,
. 3 ", " $ .!
.د
6 IL J /* O .* /8 6 '& :
3 3, "
U( + ,3 J '& %
", B / -! + I* /*
J # %
+, ' /* . UC * L
+3 P3 , & # V
3 , ' + P3 3
: ( 1 V
# ".
I + +3 6
. /
U
* I' :
", 6 '& *3! +, ' /*
. "& , IL 9 =8 ", B
& P + ^ < =' U C U* F " .!
^' ; 3 & , < ='& I' "
^' " B9 & ^
* <
IL 9
&
" +1 +P I 6 /8 6 , ' /*
& =Q S$ S$! IL 9 :
I 6
", B .* , 9 6 .
. 9 ='&
'3 - 3 6 + 9 '& .! IL
0 " , $9 "P 6 . L 9 0.
-3,
-3, _3, 6<P IL ", B
6 / .6P :.
0 .! $ 3
3 #
", "** "( K $ . K1 +
.0
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
", B &! .* IL 9
; 8 ;
/* <
V
O8 U F*. *
9 >??? , :X .
F + "*9
", -
, U *
8 L!9 ", L I " U /* IL
6 :
'& ."! 6P ( 3 F L3 U*
/8 U /* =Q S$ - L!9 &
IL 9 :
/8 -!N +3 .' ! 6P (
= ".
", .! 4 ' B U L " :"
.()"
F 2$ C I
L ", 0
",
L " U IL 9 :
, '3
* * ( " L 9 , 3 " M 3
(5)Peter Marsh, Contracting For Engineering and Construction Projects, 5th ed. at p 185. published
on line
.د
IL ", B .* + /* 3 + X &
c . < ='& U$
", 7 .! <$ + T8 +3
+8 6 B* < ='& P O.8 /* "' (
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
. + '( O # V /* U(3 P "9
+ OL8 ,8 F*. IL 9 +
"C ", L '3 3 ", O *
.() +
'(
(9) Ndihokubwayo R, Haupt TC, Uncovering The Origins of Variation Orders. Published on line.
(10) Mauro Rubino Sammartano, “ The Role of the Engineer- Myth and Reality” International Business
Lawyer, 1986. published on line.
(11) Nael G. Bunni, “ The Role of the Employer and the Engineer” a paper presented at Falconbury Workshop,
London 3-4 March 2005 at p 5
.د
J /8 - -!8 "9 " + + \?Z - ! P
C + 6 V
", '
'( ", I'
L
0. -3' - + /* * -9 #, ",
F
.()U3 U& 6 + IL 9 :
:()* +
, *
@% A: 9 BC % % DE FG 2& " :/
1 / % >') # ( (&;)
/0 J FG 2; . F
H%
1 /0 #C B 3%: I:0 /G 3C
."0HK 38 F$ L"C 3% D 6
9M
38 B H
C 0HG 38
,
" ;<<;/&<)O E
9%/ (&)
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
, F " e 2$ ", C 3 . 3
+ 3 " : ='& ", 6 ,N 9 :3 3
S*$ $ & 3 U 3 &'( " 9 5
O F U O F ' ", U /8
c$ 5 3 +
&C " 9 + +
" + S * O8
= C* U 3 I' d*
.()"...+(
.د
"
IL 9 8 /* 0,
F + P + B
.() A *1. ' + 0 F +
", $ - ", L
O* + . 3
-
$
", , .! ='& P .9 ='
", .$ S I ",<
F 9 ='& 7 .( )
* ", -3, I ,N U.
'3
.(
)'( O
N J!
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
L!9 C ",
* L 9 +3 + 9 +8
" * +, .1 & B ' + /* ():3 ", V($
-1C (*3 F +3 '8 (*3 -C L 9 8 0,
" -! ; (*3 S$ , '3 B , < 3 -!
$ <P -! (*3 + .IL M C
P /* , -! ; :3 U* 0( & -C
.' ; 9 V
-8 (*3
J. :3
C C< +C -C +9 V
", IL 9 .
L 8 ", -L +8 3 J! * $ U K ;
L F*. 3 U* I'
", *$ K
.د
.()
S$ , P3 < O8 '$
+ ,<$ + U ! & L * C + /*
*
3
F
'$ I' 3* < ,<$ ='& +3 ; . L* -.
.()3 :3 + & <.
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
'( O
F O ", L
O V
OL8
B + L 9 8 "' (
A + /* .' /* S ' U . <
.& & < ='& 2 P & 5.
0. ,
( $ .! )
F +
/8 % +
L +3 + + U 0 . < ='&
34 3" 4" :A :
1 B4 /F 5 %8 8
" &/& # ( (;))
(S /0 ,
2B...,4 /0 ,
2 :/: : (6
)
@ 61 I% / 41 / B /0 ,
2T 3"1 C C 61 R
1
, U ,
% /0HG 3 6 F 27 3"1 6 @G 2 3"1
, 3
C %:8 " M ,
C " 6 5F /0 C S 3"V
H
"3"1 F ,E 3: /0 ,
2 R
0"4 3 ,
C
.د
B C S$
, % ,<$ I F
", ,X
.()U<
.= F. ", ' 1 ='& 6 '&
!
*
#2
.%8: %0 34
0 B -W 3"M F M , 4 F 8 0H ,
6 3 Q 7 I
A
/ ,:8C % 3% : 8...
I
E F . $
B ,:8 0 : 4 5F 4 :4 .%8C 9:8
(A B ) 3% CX : 2B 6"
C 2 :Q 7
A: I
Q
8 2T $
Y
3 / 3W 6"
M ( C
M F$ 3X 3% ,CX
C8 FS 80 3% ,CX A: Y
3 / 3W A L"C ,:8
."3 DE B Q 7 I
/
A L4 6"
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
= ", U8 9 B /8 .$ P
3 /* B V
I(! 9 8 D + "
. P U* D + " <$ U! *
+ +( ", 1 , 9 & '& +3 '8
I(! 9 /* ,
1P & + /8
,3 . $9 0 + % 3 + UP I'
.9 '( /* " - :
!
" /0 $
G .&'=<
W 8% I: (# 4
" )
0 C H% (;O)
*< ( 9C D
.د
+ <
", F3 IL .!
+3 6
Developers, Inc. v. Safeco Insurance Co. of America and Robertson Contractors,
Inc. (2002)
(29) See http://case law. Lp.findlaw.com. The date of the judgment 11/2/2003
(30) The Entrusty Group “ Can A Contractor Claim For Compensation for Extra Work
When There is No S.O. Instruction?” Master Builders Journal, 2nd Quarter 2007
(31) See http://case law. Lp.findlaw.com. The date of the judgment 5/11/2002
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
.! 3' /* 3 O 9 C 3 3 ",
"' ( "9 " + /8 J +3 3
: 3 ", O
F + ".$ .! S + ", "
- +9 O ", 3' " ,N 9
F +3 + 8 ,N ", .! " + + `/\?Z
+ ,N /*
F , /* * "(3 .,
F + +
:! B +
..$* . &'(
.()"...
-. !
#
5 6
", B .* ( $ .!) +
IL I + /* S
+ ' + IL 9 8
J .
* ; +3 + F B =
- , ' /* ='& P # &
.! /8
. < B* " :/* >??? ( 3 + >/@
+3 '8 .- 3
+ ( *
", U
< U
F , /* + B + *.
. $ .! ", * S F *. ='& P +,
.د
!"#
$% &!'
.* < O.8 9 ", 9 +, ' /* ."$
(
) *
'
= '& U$ ", $ IL 9 8 ", B*
< % < '& + /* B* < + B3
.U * " $ .!*
F; 9 + C + 9 :+A '& ", P
; IL 9 +3 +9 *
&9 + "P I 9
U /* & 6 2 9 A /* N ", .
.!
I F; 3 +3 +
+ .()- *
+ I F;
, U(*$ /* F & I, F; + :*$ I +,
'8 +3 0 U(*$ /* F , F;
(
(33) Laurette Gallagher, “Desirable or Not” Building Journal, Hong Kong- China April
2003. published on line.
(34) Laurette Gallagher
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
& ' ", 5
.
, -C + /8 IA U,8
.- /* . 3 0*
"$!
/* %(
# /* I. I' 9 " U F; 9
", B + 3 , 3 "U + <
.()'
(35) See http://case law. Lp.findlaw.com. The date of the judgment Septempter 1979
(36) Laurette Gallagher
.د
Davis& Co (shopfitters) Ltd v William Old (1969) 67 L.G.R. B + "
8 '& ."
F ' " O L
.(37)IL 9 =8 ", < B +3 + - /* 3A
I' &
F, % % U< B X+8
( + 3' + .U U #, I' & B +X
, + /* B +3 + - /* S +3 >?i\
.(
)": " & $g
>???
"*
+ B U & L ' #, +3
+ -3 + +X >??? I + ", . B
", " U /* +3A B + +
+
.()
F U*
U
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
",
+3 *3 U +3 ='& /* 0*
",
C* B +3 *3 L =8 ", B <
L /8 IA + B /* 7 S +,
.().,
F * : S$! /8 U* + = , ",
. !
(59 )
7!-
8 IL 9 + - : F*. ", 0 X+8
c$ : I . ", U 0 + ",
",
$ & ' ",
&
.2$ ",
( '& '8 . ,N 9 ( + U
+ `a` - S
",
* J F
! .
'( F
> " :, O " "9 " +
C8 /*
` . + U # 0( . U*
+* , UC* + & +3 U,
.":
. :
.د
+ 9 V
OL8 :' + IL 9 0. X+8
V
OL8 /* F 6 * 0 P + & +3
& + . = I' /* B3
:3 V($ 9
$g :*3 9 + F OLQ IL 8 C
'$ . 7 + j # V
' +
L 0*
F9 ' '( 0. ", L - IL 9
*
' . .'( ",
/8 IA :%
%8 F$ G 0HK /H%: : C A0
C 1
C %8 H (=&)
" :8 7F$ .:8 8C !
8 % 4LC 5F /0
A: ] 8
#% C D 5F QE J %8C 3]8 A / 8 1 B
F
C /H% E : "%8 34
.5F /0
38 M %8 /0
7
G 3 A: %8 :4 !
.%8: :
3S D : 9MC : !
1 %8 ,: /0 /H% AC % 6F
F$
C
9 /$ : 3S 7F$ 40 : 3S 5
9M C
C
4
$
(,M) " 9%
2/ % -
"
6
.%8 ,:
.;=<2;' ( ;<<) 0%X
%
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
" 9 F U, + C - 6 9
L B + * +3 +, J! ", &'(
' + ! - # $ 9 ='& + L
.() ,8 ( /
,8 - 7 +
L ,8
3 - ='& L ,8 <
F
( # O.
01P + P I ", S U*
3 ", * -C ,8 <
='( J! :%
8 /8 &'( c ..$* , &'( " M *
(
"IL
8 & 9 + +3 S '& <$ +
/* /* ,3 + U,
+3 + F 6 L
I ,8 < +3 + +3 ' . *. 9
.د
3' +3 , '3
.
", U* S
. U, 3' +3 UC*
<! + = +3
Sharp v San Paulo C* ", P /*
+ 3 +3
'( + 3* +X 6 Railway (1873)
"8 d* B /* +3
", +P + L
+ U + (! ; ) C* 3
I U 0 - 9 + $ L
.()
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
k ( " 9 + (! ; ) C*N 3
0 C + OC %
", 3' /
/*
S O *
3 .",8 V
I
+8 9 U* F + K U " , 9
.()
'& - '
' 3'
,8 <
"(, 9 C 3
:
L C* + /8 -!N "L 6 '& ",
(
.! + >/>@ - S 6 .U* V *
B + O L + /* (9 F3) >???
" - 3 .U, %* 5 + B F*.
."...='( L 3 C* + /* +
F*. + &
I +, L B
.د
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
.د
/* .:. 3 C 0 ( I + <
B C<, -C *
-C I +, '
.! ",
( & -! . + +3
. 3
!
*
=
. FN .
-
F .:.9 + \ F8 /8 c 8
'& .' ; U3 * # ", +P3
.! /*
6 :. /9 &9 ; ", + 7 /8
,
I B B + /
()
F & U,. +
T8 0.
.! Pg +,
Pg ,
,.
+ +, M , .
F & :.9 +
0%X
4 4 % /0 # %8 2/ % -
"
()&)
&' ( ;<<&
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
S$ 0 & 8
0, U, X
+ *
:. ; +3
+
+3 <, # FN "< /8 c
",.
. :.
31 : " 9%
31 @ / % -
" /0 C 6
C ();)
.' ( ;<<; 3S
%8 %8 :31 % %8
0
9 FG BK 3C% 9C 2& " /: : /
1 / % &<< # ( ())
0
M /4 W0 3S 7F$ Q8C : 9M .
: H /
$ 3S 34 :
3SC %8 /0
$ 3S D : 0
9 F 2; .C4C 9M F$ ,CX
C80 3S 7F$ : 9M %8
Z 4 %8
" 8C 0
: % :
:8 8C %C
0 /H% 4 P0
: 9M / 3S : !W E F %8 E %8
"8 !
8 % 41
B4 (/WK A% /0
%
) /
1 / % /0 M
:
()=)
.;=< ** , ;<<; / %
.د
F3/
.!) >??? , + >/>@ - ",
:"& ='& IL 9 + $ /* *P9 V
(9
L ...S1$ ", L ...3 ", L "
", L ...",8 I '( ... L!9 + I OL8...F ",
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
"& 1 ='& + & /9 %< "... L!9 '( *
) L 3 ! + +3 "
S 7,n 6 P /*
%< ./
'& /8 : ; ='& ""* /* (IL
L
0. + L + & S ", #, P
.U'
",
.د
-. !
*
*
i@@ - ,X ( / "& 3
$g $! = 3 " 3 "9 " +
+ <3 B +3 2 I /Q, ."*
C1 : ", U(
" A '& /* N X+8 ^IL 9 =8 2
F
.B
F + <3 . " <
", 6
I' # & 9 :+ + ", B* X+8
'& + /* . '( /* :!N , "P ='(
# B /8
F + /
B C<
+8 V( '& . '( /* :!N $g :*3 P +
* + *
+ U T8 % + 3 +3
+ 3 '( /* :!N # B ' / + J!
8 " . ", # O.$ I9 B 3! '
U,!8 V
", A " 9 + B + IL 9
.J! '( /*
:!N B + +3 33 B ",
# #.
F + U ,
F J! '( /*
$! + P 3 3 B + /9 _+ ", 3
3 +
+ 0( 3 + /* .
", B
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
J!* U
2 B X+ /8 F&' $g 4 X+ /*
:!N U
F + U F U
,
X$ U B /* 3
F # . , '( /*
.(
)
F + - <
.د
F + " 7 $ .! +3
F
& ' /* P C
.
< B*
'8 .()' ",
F + <3
U 6 L B
0. 3 +, L B $ '&
/* ., 3 3 0. 3!
<
/*
.()IL
=2=; ( ( &'O>
4M !
8 #L" % % 4 #
% 0 ()')
3 ,
DH 3X 3 : I
C % / 3M ! 4
38 _: B
E 3% C 3X E R
3 .F : !
"M ,%
3 F 4 % $ 3$ %8 : C JC B 5F : .A4 8C 3%
% % 6
" - C 6
E .4 %8 / X % %8 3M 3M \ DH 5F
.) ( ;<<&
4M !
8 #L"
% 6
D
" /0
;<<O
4M !
8 #L" @H% A% @H /0 % % 4 -
" B " BC (*<)
== (
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
.()-3C
" + % ", B :3 ", ( +, ' /*
/*
8 " I & & : J /*
"9
F # B < ", 3 -3(, . +
0*
+ / " " + % ", -
9 B 8 /* 0 # '& .
F B < +3 + +3 2$ *3 .IL
3! 2$ F ", 3! F V
"(, .*$
. 3
& + Y\ - ", U =X J! B +8 "
+ 6 U F '( :!N ", U*P
F 2 $
", ( 1 +
", 9 # :<$3 F1 # :<$
+
3 / + ", O /8 O* & :<$ '&
.* B ".
+ Y\ - .! ", B U 3 1 ='&
.()"=% ", 3 .* F '3 :<$ ", T3 3
0%X
4 4 % /0 # %8 / % -
"
(*&)
&; ( ;<<;
,
" &'O/)O E
9%/ (*;)
.د
$-
./ !
01
/!0
.!
/
... "
.()"2
!3
#
4 5 63$ 7
"9 " + + \ia - + /8 -
< IA 1! # + = U,.
" U /* U,
*
+ 0. :
'& ."$h :. U
O
+ '8 '( ", O B U I' /*
# U8 3
B
F . + +3
-3, X+8 . U3 + c$ '& . '( /* :!N
( #) I
+ :
", -
O
.(*
O.8 :!N) "&'
'3
$ 8
.
!05
$ 4
1
9
::"
;
% "
/$ 2 -< 4
=!$ >
8
/
'
$
(
(ADECABA)
$
$(
8
$ ?
$
8
!0
'
.
!05
$ 8
)<$ $
( ( 2
$ G
4
!5
(
7 6 $ G
$
(
(HAJCHAI)
$(
.()"...9
25
G7 3 !K $ ?
/!0 $
!
9
%
'
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
U
.
F 2 < B +3 + + 3
0( .'( /* :!N # "& U*
F
< ",
I +
-
F U &
( 7 +3 .
F J L B <, B /* :!
# ",
F .* + & < I # <,
.()B /* OC
-
# !
7 67 O
4
/ M!
.()"...6
,
F B + <
+ + 0 <$ +
<3 B +3 , V, + P3 IL 9 8 S$
8 ", U.* , +3 :3, .< +3 +3
+ 3 ", B + C X+8 ^ ='& + 3 ", IL
.د
>/@ - , ='& + "' ( : +
U O B " /* 9 F3*
.! +
( 3
", * S O U<
c +3 S '& * "
F + U U, U
& F1 ( U +3 8 IL M =8 2 B +
.
F + 3 ( U B + /
(
B
F + <
, #. *
.! /8 J + X '8 >??? "' ( /8 %
='$ 2 B < + # 0 " / $
/ ", +3 $ .! ='& .L
-C + - $ .! ", P /* . $
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
:"* /* >/@ - S ( 1!N #!* ) L!9
$'
$# (
G7
6 :$
9
!
"
(7
$ $
6 $ M!$!<
/
< (
."!R
!
$?
!
CE :
!$?
G7 (1
2 3 B ( "( 8 $ .! ", S '&
.* ='$ ", < I # 6 IL 9 ='$
"(
'& +, " $ " & / ; S$
+ "& -$9 ( % .
3 B ( "( =
F
F ,
L I' B '&
= I' 3 ( U +3 8 & $ / S$
+ X & .IL 9 /* U, '$ - 3
B = IL I + & = U '& X+ %<
.
F * C
U* F
. !
. %&< 7 !
<
+
", ,8 O8 IL 9 8 + K ;
.IL + F ' ; U, $ - U 6
6 + 3
$ / ! 0
+3 + +3
+ /* 3
:. " 0, .!
4,. I B IL M B .
:. ; +
.د
0 9 * B I U ='& /* F
.
<
B + IL +, ' + ;
/ ' ", O* F + U*
.+ +
*
", .! c
:. 0 + U 6
.! -3,
F + +3 2 I /, . U C OC +3
+ ^B & 6P S$! +
=( .! c
^ U
:"* /* " " + + >[Y - S ' /*
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
:" ( /* ' IL ", B*
(
)L* +
9 #( U, .! , .! + 6P J
", B* IL .* .! ", , '&
& $ .
F
( * /* .! '& I. 6
/* 0. '& = + B +3 +8
O< I' .!
O< =', L B* 0 .!
:$ k9 F .! '& +, 3 ", .&'(
. L ", ' *
Fh
%
.د
:!0
? $# %
4$3 S1'
G
4
$(
G7"
('
7
(' G
M
T!R $# 61' !
"
T $# (
G7
".!
(:
- G<
( 4
3 M
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
:!0
" B /* IL 9 8 ", B .* B +8
2 B ( ", 6 O + (
, U I' "U
"
.د
======&
B .* J ", 6 <$ + ='& *$
", & /* ", L 9 8 ", I!N
K1 + * /8 >??? "' ( +
.!
:"&
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
?===>==-
IL 9 ", .! + * , + .٣
+ C U /* "' ( S 6 3 .! &
IL 9 + C1 + U /* . &(! IL 9
/8 6 '& ! . 3 + UP P &(! O
O IL 9 "
1 V
/* O 3 .! + C -3, /8 ' + I(! F*. /*
. (
:.9 *
.د
B,
*
P L 9 8
.٦
/
.
,. B
< + B U /* 6 ' /* 3A (
P IL 9 +3 + " "(
B
.
*
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
.د
+===#=
-C +
L!9 + + - .١
(3 / + ! 9 3* ", +3N
L!9
.! L 9 =8 V
", B
.
."9 " % # :3 '& P +
U "
. ) >??? (
7 P* % .٢
6 + ., B (Common Law) o j IC*N + ('3
+ ' + & (Force Majour, Liquated Damages) *.
+ ='& <, (Fitness for Purpose, Fairness & Risk) &( 6
+9 ", . '
/*
O8
F / ' ' ( + %
", -
-1 + '
='& + +3N
.
",
"9 + ", ,
"
! S O ", "9 O #*. + .٤
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
3 #
* 3 # =< PP -( ", U8 !
( 7 "1 N + -(N +3 6 L 9
; "9 O + /8 & ! *
.9 ='& 0.
+ ",
. " C #
(<P (
3) ' + 1! C %
.3 /8
.د
@A
#
@A
3 :
-! 3 - ,
.>?i\
I #! ", I! 5( I
.`aa> 3 :
-! +
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
-
1 +
.`aa@ 3
U( O ", 3 5! F! F
. `aai 3 :
-! O
.د
English References
- Brian W. Totterdill, FIDIC User’s Guide, a practical to 1999 red
book. Published on line. http://www.books.google.jo PDF file last
time seen 18-1-2010.
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
+
<
.>?\[
(Y@) " " +
.د
.>?i[
(\>) 3 L! %
-
* +
,
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
(! "#)
! .
:
.د
.() +C ", ( 3 ()
)
.! "
(9 F3 :(* D - % ='& +
9
.! /
9 F3 (#
5( * 0. " 0*
I' "( F3 1!
.( 1! ! & )
. ", O : /8 I ='& !
+9 ", B3 ='& ", 1 . P3 6 3
6 J '& ", 9 C 3 + 6
; .L *
C 3 /8 O* ;
PA + ' +Q, "3* % # 3 .3 + +
(1) Michael R Ludlow and J Gordon Rees “Engineer’s Role under FIDIC Standard
Conditions of Contract” International Business Lawyer, November 1992, published
on line.
(2) Nael G. Bunni, “Which Form to Use?” a paper presented at Falconbury Workshop,
London 3-4 March 2005 at p 1
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
% . ' ( + 6 /* *
% /8’ 2 /* ", # 3 +8 "
I9 J +3, ( - S$ , & '3 ."3*9
:<$ T8 2$9 + U. :*$ 6 ( U,
. 3 ", " $ .!
.د
6 IL J /* O .* /8 6 '& :
3 3, "
U( + ,3 J '& %
", B / -! + I* /*
J # %
+, ' /* . UC * L
+3 P3 , & # V
3 , ' + P3 3
: ( 1 V
# ".
I + +3 6
. /
U
* I' :
", 6 '& *3! +, ' /*
. "& , IL 9 =8 ", B
& P + ^ < =' U C U* F " .!
^' ; 3 & , < ='& I' "
^' " B9 & ^
* <
IL 9
&
" +1 +P I 6 /8 6 , ' /*
& =Q S$ S$! IL 9 :
I 6
", B .* , 9 6 .
. 9 ='&
'3 - 3 6 + 9 '& .! IL
0 " , $9 "P 6 . L 9 0.
-3,
-3, _3, 6<P IL ", B
6 / .6P :.
0 .! $ 3
3 #
", "** "( K $ . K1 +
.0
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
", B &! .* IL 9
; 8 ;
/* <
V
O8 U F*. *
9 >??? , :X .
F + "*9
", -
, U *
8 L!9 ", L I " U /* IL
6 :
'& ."! 6P ( 3 F L3 U*
/8 U /* =Q S$ - L!9 &
IL 9 :
/8 -!N +3 .' ! 6P (
= ".
", .! 4 ' B U L " :"
.()"
F 2$ C I
L ", 0
",
L " U IL 9 :
, '3
* * ( " L 9 , 3 " M 3
(5)Peter Marsh, Contracting For Engineering and Construction Projects, 5th ed. at p 185. published
on line
.د
IL ", B .* + /* 3 + X &
c . < ='& U$
", 7 .! <$ + T8 +3
+8 6 B* < ='& P O.8 /* "' (
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
. + '( O # V /* U(3 P "9
+ OL8 ,8 F*. IL 9 +
"C ", L '3 3 ", O *
.() +
'(
(9) Ndihokubwayo R, Haupt TC, Uncovering The Origins of Variation Orders. Published on line.
(10) Mauro Rubino Sammartano, “ The Role of the Engineer- Myth and Reality” International Business
Lawyer, 1986. published on line.
(11) Nael G. Bunni, “ The Role of the Employer and the Engineer” a paper presented at Falconbury Workshop,
London 3-4 March 2005 at p 5
.د
@% A: 9 BC % % DE FG 2& " :/
1 / % >') # ( (&;)
/0 J FG 2; . F
H%
1 /0 #C B 3%: I:0 /G 3C
."0HK 38 F$ L"C 3% D 6
9M
38 B H
C 0HG 38
,
" ;<<;/&<)O E
9%/ (&)
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
:()* +
, *
, F " e 2$ ", C 3 . 3
+ 3 " : ='& ", 6 ,N 9 :3 3
S*$ $ & 3 U 3 &'( " 9 5
O F U O F ' ", U /8
c$ 5 3 +
&C " 9 + +
" + S * O8
= C* U 3 I' d*
.()"...+(
.د
, /8 c + 5 I + /* ."U, %* +
. U J! B +
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
-. !
+/
01
", $ - ", L
O* + . 3
-
$
", , .! ='& P .9 ='
", .$ S I ",<
F 9 ='& 7 .( )
* ", -3, I ,N U.
'3
.(
)'( O
N J!
(17)Michael O’Relly, Civil Engineering Construction Contracts, 2nd ed. at p 254. Published on
.د
L!9 C ",
* L 9 +3 + 9 +8
" * +, .1 & B ' + /* ():3 ", V($
-1C (*3 F +3 '8 (*3 -C L 9 8 0,
" -! ; (*3 S$ , '3 B , < 3 -!
$ <P -! (*3 + .IL M C
P /* , -! ; :3 U* 0( & -C
.' ; 9 V
-8 (*3
J. :3
C C< +C -C +9 V
", IL 9 .
L 8 ", -L +8 3 J! * $ U K ;
L F*. 3 U* I'
", *$ K
.()
S$ , P3 < O8 '$
+ ,<$ + U ! & L * C + /*
*
3
F
'$ I' 3* < ,<$ ='& +3 ; . L* -.
.()3 :3 + & <.
G % ,E 6 /0 3%: 4 " : ( / &''' 5 % ;/& #
(;<)
3"1 G /0 38 2& :A P0 7 G 6F A
Q
8
E I
B R
8 9% 2=...3"1 E :0 2...3"1 E Q 2;
"...38
(21) Ndihokubwayo R, Haupt TC
22 Monty Sutrisna and others, RICS Research Paper Series, “ A decision support tool for
the valuation of variations on civil engineering projects” Volume 5, Number 7 May 2005.
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
'( O
F O ", L
O V
OL8
.د
B + L 9 8 "' (
A + /* .' /* S ' U . <
.& & < ='& 2 P & 5.
0. ,
( $ .! )
F +
/8 % +
L +3 + + U 0 . < ='&
B C S$
, % ,<$ I F
", ,X
.()U<
34 3" 4" :A :
1 B4 /F 5 %8 8
" &/& # ( (;))
(S /0 ,
2B...,4 /0 ,
2 :/: : (6
)
@ 61 I% / 41 / B /0 ,
2T 3"1 C C 61 R
1
, U ,
% /0HG 3 6 F 27 3"1 6 @G 2 3"1
, 3
C %:8 " M ,
C " 6 5F /0 C S 3"V
H
"3"1 F ,E 3: /0 ,
2 R
0"4 3 ,
C
(26)Peter Marsh “op. cit.”
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
.
* ; +3 + F IL 9 +Q, 2$
/* V U & L ", ( K
'3
.='( & 9
.= F. ", ' 1 ='& 6 '&
!
*
#2
.د
-3 ", + J $ " + . ", " U* O
+ "(! /* O '
", U* 0( J + /* U(*3 .1
( .! (* #$
+ 6 L
B
.(
) 3 IL 9 +
+ +( ", 1 , 9 & '& +3 '8
I(! 9 /* ,
1P & + /8
,3 . $9 0 + % 3 + UP I'
.9 '( /* " - :
!
" /0 $
G .&'=<
W 8% I: (# 4
" )
0 C H% (;O)
*< ( 9C D
(29) See http://case law. Lp.findlaw.com. The date of the judgment 11/2/2003
(30) The Entrusty Group “ Can A Contractor Claim For Compensation for Extra Work
When There is No S.O. Instruction?” Master Builders Journal, 2nd Quarter 2007
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
+ <
", F3 IL .!
+3 6
Developers, Inc. v. Safeco Insurance Co. of America and Robertson Contractors,
Inc. (2002)
.! 3' /* 3 O 9 C 3 3 ",
"' ( "9 " + /8 J +3 3
: 3 ", O
F + ".$ .! S + ", "
- +9 O ", 3' " ,N 9
F +3 + 8 ,N ", .! " + + `/\?Z
+ ,N /*
F , /* * "(3 .,
(31) See http://case law. Lp.findlaw.com. The date of the judgment 5/11/2002
.د
F + +
:! B +
..$* . &'(
.()"...
-. !
#
5 6
", B .* ( $ .!) +
IL I + /* S
+ ' + IL 9 8
J .
* ; +3 + F B =
- , ' /* ='& P # &
.! /8
. < B* " :/* >??? ( 3 + >/@
+3 '8 .- 3
+ ( *
", U
< U
F , /* + B + *.
. $ .! ", * S F *. ='& P +,
!"#
$% &!'
.* < O.8 9 ", 9 +, ' /* ."$
(
) *
'
= '& U$ ", $ IL 9 8 ", B*
< % < '& + /* B* < + B3
.U * " $ .!*
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
F; 9 + C + 9 :+A '& ", P
; IL 9 +3 +9 *
&9 + "P I 9
U /* & 6 2 9 A /* N ", .
.!
I F; 3 +3 +
+ .()- *
+ I F;
, U(*$ /* F & I, F; + :*$ I +,
'8 +3 0 U(*$ /* F , F;
(
& ' ", 5
.
, -C + /8 IA U,8
.- /* . 3 0*
"$!
(33) Laurette Gallagher, “Desirable or Not” Building Journal, Hong Kong- China April
2003. published on line.
(34) Laurette Gallagher
.د
/* %(
# /* I. I' 9 " U F; 9
", B + 3 , 3 "U + <
.()'
(35) See http://case law. Lp.findlaw.com. The date of the judgment Septempter 1979
(36) Laurette Gallagher
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
.(37)IL 9 =8 ", < B +3 + - /* 3A
I' &
F, % % U< B X+8
( + 3' + .U U #, I' & B +X
, + /* B +3 + - /* S +3 >?i\
.(
)": " & $g
>???
"*
+ B U & L ' #, +3
+ -3 + +X >??? I + ", . B
", " U /* +3A B + +
+
.()
F U*
U
.د
",
+3 *3 U +3 ='& /* 0*
",
C* B +3 *3 L =8 ", B <
L /8 IA + B /* 7 S +,
.().,
F * : S$! /8 U* + = , ",
. !
(59 )
7!-
8 IL 9 + - : F*. ", 0 X+8
c$ : I . ", U 0 + ",
",
$ & ' ",
&
.2$ ",
( '& '8 . ,N 9 ( + U
+ `a` - S
",
* J F
! .
'( F
> " :, O " "9 " +
C8 /*
` . + U # 0( . U*
+* , UC* + & +3 U,
.":
. :
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
+ 9 V
OL8 :' + IL 9 0. X+8
V
OL8 /* F 6 * 0 P + & +3
& + . = I' /* B3
:3 V($ 9
$g :*3 9 + F OLQ IL 8 C
'$ . 7 + j # V
' +
L 0*
F9 ' '( 0. ", L - IL 9
*
' . .'( ",
/8 IA :%
%8 F$ G 0HK /H%: : C A0
C 1
C %8 H (=&)
" :8 7F$ .:8 8C !
8 % 4LC 5F /0
A: ] 8
#% C D 5F QE J %8C 3]8 A / 8 1 B
F
C /H% E : "%8 34
.5F /0
38 M %8 /0
7
G 3 A: %8 :4 !
.%8: :
3S D : 9MC : !
1 %8 ,: /0 /H% AC % 6F
F$
C
9 /$ : 3S 7F$ 40 : 3S 5
9M C
C
4
$
(,M) " 9%
2/ % -
"
6
.%8 ,:
.;=<2;' ( ;<<) 0%X
%
.د
" 9 F U, + C - 6 9
L B + * +3 +, J! ", &'(
' + ! - # $ 9 ='& + L
.() ,8 ( /
,8 - 7 +
L ,8
3 - ='& L ,8 <
F
( # O.
01P + P I ", S U*
3 ", * -C ,8 <
='( J! :%
8 /8 &'( c ..$* , &'( " M *
(
"IL
8 & 9 + +3 S '& <$ +
/* /* ,3 + U,
+3 + F 6 L
I ,8 < +3 + +3 ' . *. 9
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
3' +3 , '3
.
", U* S
. U, 3' +3 UC*
<! + = +3
Sharp v San Paulo C* ", P /*
+ 3 +3
'( + 3* +X 6 Railway (1873)
"8 d* B /* +3
", +P + L
+ U + (! ; ) C* 3
I U 0 - 9 + $ L
.()
.د
,8 <
"(, 9 C 3
:
L C* + /8 -!N "L 6 '& ",
(
.! + >/>@ - S 6 .U* V *
B + O L + /* (9 F3) >???
" - 3 .U, %* 5 + B F*.
."...='( L 3 C* + /* +
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
F*. + &
I +, L B
'& /* F P9 ( + V
+ B
,N (*3 '3
C C< ",
6 + 9
", ( ='& V, B* .L /*
.( )" /8 * B + V( I V,
.د
L & UT$ C3 ", B +, .IL
+ /* .
", * 0( ( .! F
"
F. U3 L '(
",
* .
+ B /* = BA 9 '( U " 9 + V
.()
F B S$ 0. c$ 1.$ +3 L
-.
()
;
;
1 "
#2 - 3- -- -4
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
!
*
=
. FN .
-
F .:.9 + \ F8 /8 c 8
'& .' ; U3 * # ", +P3
.! /*
6 :. /9 &9 ; ", + 7 /8
,
I B B + /
()
F & U,. +
0%X
4 4 % /0 # %8 2/ % -
"
()&)
&' ( ;<<&
.د
T8 0.
.! Pg +,
Pg ,
,.
+ +, M , .
F & :.9 +
S$ 0 & 8
0, U, X
+ *
:. ; +3
+
+3 <, # FN "< /8 c
",.
. :.
31 : " 9%
31 @ / % -
" /0 C 6
C ();)
.' ( ;<<; 3S
%8 %8 :31 % %8
0
9 FG BK 3C% 9C 2& " /: : /
1 / % &<< # ( ())
0
M /4 W0 3S 7F$ Q8C : 9M .
: H /
$ 3S 34 :
3SC %8 /0
$ 3S D : 0
9 F 2; .C4C 9M F$ ,CX
C80 3S 7F$ : 9M %8
Z 4 %8
" 8C 0
: % :
:8 8C %C
0 /H% 4 P0
: 9M / 3S : !W E F %8 E %8
"8 !
8 % 41
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
X+8 C & + .()' :.9 <, $h :.
U
. I B U3 .! /* F 8
", +P OL8 &
J +3 '8 P /*
, ." :3
ON & < , 7 8 <
'&
#
1 /* F
, ' /* . # "L* =
. & 1 *(
.د
F3/
.!) >??? , + >/>@ - ",
:"& ='& IL 9 + $ /* *P9 V
(9
L ...S1$ ", L ...3 ", L "
", L ...",8 I '( ... L!9 + I OL8...F ",
"& 1 ='& + & /9 %< "... L!9 '( *
) L 3 ! + +3 "
S 7,n 6 P /*
%< ./
'& /8 : ; ='& ""* /* (IL
L
0. + L + & S ", #, P
.U'
",
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
i@@ - ,X ( / "& 3
$g $! = 3 " 3 "9 " +
+ <3 B +3 2 I /Q, ."*
C1 : ", U(
" A '& /* N X+8 ^IL 9 =8 2
F
.B
F + <3 . " <
", 6
I' # & 9 :+ + ", B* X+8
'& + /* . '( /* :!N , "P ='(
# B /8
F + /
B C<
+8 V( '& . '( /* :!N $g :*3 P +
* + *
+ U T8 % + 3 +3
+ 3 '( /* :!N # B ' / + J!
8 " . ", # O.$ I9 B 3! '
U,!8 V
", A " 9 + B + IL 9
.J! '( /*
.د
:!N B + +3 33 B ",
# #.
F + U ,
F J! '( /*
$! + P 3 3 B + /9 _+ ", 3
3 +
+ 0( 3 + /* .
", B
(B) , ( + ",
F B +
+ ' /8 : U( + 8
F U*
< 3 ", 9 1 & !
.( )
J!* U
2 B X+ /8 F&' $g 4 X+ /*
:!N U
F + U F U
,
X$ U B /* 3
F # . , '( /*
.(
)
F + - <
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
=2=; ( ( &'O>
4M !
8 #L" % % 4 #
% 0 ()')
3 ,
DH 3X 3 : I
C % / 3M ! 4
38 _: B
E 3% C 3X E R
3 .F : !
"M ,%
3 F 4 % $ 3$ %8 : C JC B 5F : .A4 8C 3%
% % 6
" - C 6
E .4 %8 / X % %8 3M 3M \ DH 5F
.) ( ;<<&
4M !
8 #L"
% 6
D
" /0
;<<O
4M !
8 #L" @H% A% @H /0 % % 4 -
" B " BC (*<)
== (
.د
" + % ", B :3 ", ( +, ' /*
/*
8 " I & & : J /*
"9
F # B < ", 3 -3(, . +
0*
+ / " " + % ", -
9 B 8 /* 0 # '& .
F B < +3 + +3 2$ *3 .IL
3! 2$ F ", 3! F V
"(, .*$
. 3
& + Y\ - ", U =X J! B +8 "
+ 6 U F '( :!N ", U*P
F 2 $
", ( 1 +
", 9 # :<$3 F1 # :<$
+
3 / + ", O /8 O* & :<$ '&
.* B ".
+ Y\ - .! ", B U 3 1 ='&
0%X
4 4 % /0 # %8 / % -
"
(*&)
&; ( ;<<;
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
$-
./ !
01
/!0
.!
/
... "
.()"2
!3
#
4 5 63$ 7
"9 " + + \ia - + /8 -
< IA 1! # + = U,.
" U /* U,
*
+ 0. :
'& ."$h :. U
O
+ '8 '( ", O B U I' /*
# U8 3
B
F . + +3
-3, X+8 . U3 + c$ '& . '( /* :!N
( #) I
+ :
", -
O
.(*
O.8 :!N) "&'
'3
$ 8
.
!05
$ 4
1
9
::"
;
% "
/$ 2 -< 4
=!$ >
8
/
'
$
(
(ADECABA)
$
$(
8
$ ?
$
8
!0
'
.
!05
$ 8
)<$ $
( ( 2
$ G
4
!5
(
7 6 $ G
$
(
(HAJCHAI)
$(
.د
.()"...9
25
G7 3 !K $ ?
/!0 $
!
9
%
'
U
.
F 2 < B +3 + + 3
0( .'( /* :!N # "& U*
F
< ",
I +
-
F U &
( 7 +3 .
F J L B <, B /* :!
# ",
F .* + & < I # <,
.()B /* OC
.()"...6
,
F B + <
+ + 0 <$ +
<3 B +3 , V, + P3 IL 9 8 S$
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
8 ", U.* , +3 :3, .< +3 +3
+ 3 ", B + C X+8 ^ ='& + 3 ", IL
8 ", B < .* /*
8 &3' :
U /
< /* # 3 B, .IL 9
.
F /8 J + S$ = 0, IL 9
/8 1C # + F 6 < #, 33 B
! / J C* U
!*
F
U - U* F 9 3 ", . U
V(
C* ='& + c$ I L Q *
",
I
B .1 $! & C* O"!
F
U< U.*
',
F #
. :%
.
F 2A 0, IL 9 Q C*
F # &
>/@ - , ='& + "' ( : +
U O B " /* 9 F3*
.! +
( 3
", * S O U<
c +3 S '& * "
F + U U, U
& F1 ( U +3 8 IL M =8 2 B +
.
F + 3 ( U B + /
(
B
F + <
, #. *
.! /8 J + X '8 >??? "' ( /8 %
='$ 2 B < + # 0 " / $
.د
/ ", +3 $ .! ='& .L
-C + - $ .! ", P /* . $
:"* /* >/@ - S ( 1!N #!* ) L!9
$'
$# (
G7
6 :$
9
!
"
(7
$ $
6 $ M!$!<
/
< (
."!R
!
$?
!
CE :
!$?
G7 (1
2 3 B ( "( 8 $ .! ", S '&
.* ='$ ", < I # 6 IL 9 ='$
"(
'& +, " $ " & / ; S$
+ "& -$9 ( % .
3 B ( "( =
F
F ,
L I' B '&
= I' 3 ( U +3 8 & $ / S$
+ X & .IL 9 /* U, '$ - 3
B = IL I + & = U '& X+ %<
.
F * C
U* F
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
. !
. %&< 7 !
<
+
", ,8 O8 IL 9 8 + K ;
.IL + F ' ; U, $ - U 6
6 + 3
$ / ! 0
+3 + +3
+ /* 3
:. " 0, .!
4,. I B IL M B .
:. ; +
0 9 * B I U ='& /* F
.
<
B + IL +, ' + ;
/ ' ", O* F + U*
.+ +
*
", .! c
:. 0 + U 6
.! -3,
F + +3 2 I /, . U C OC +3
+ ^B & 6P S$! +
=( .! c
^ U
.د
:"* /* " " + + >[Y - S ' /*
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
(
)L* +
9 #( U, .! , .! + 6P J
", B* IL .* .! ", , '&
& $ .
F
( * /* .! '& I. 6
/* 0. '& = + B +3 +8
O< I' .!
O< =', L B* 0 .!
:$ k9 F .! '& +, 3 ", .&'(
. L ", ' *
Fh
%
.د
:!0
? $# %
4$3 S1'
G
4
$(
G7"
('
7
(' G
M
T!R $# 61' !
"
T $# (
G7
".!
(:
- G<
( 4
3 M
:!0
" B /* IL 9 8 ", B .* B +8
2 B ( ", 6 O + (
, U I' "U
"
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
======&
B .* J ", 6 <$ + ='& *$
", & /* ", L 9 8 ", I!N
K1 + * /8 >??? "' ( +
.!
:"&
.د
?===>==-
IL 9 ", .! + * , + .٣
U /* "' ( S 6 3 .! &
+ C1 + U /* . &(! IL 9 + C
+ UP P &(! O IL 9
1 V
/8 6 '& ! . 3
F*. /* O IL 9 "
/* O 3 .! + C -3, /8 ' + I(!
. (
:.9 *
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
.
", 7 S +8 <! C*
<
. :
* J
C*
.
:%
B,
*
P L 9 8
.٦
/
.
,. B
/* 6 ' /* 3A (
+ " "(
B < + B U
.
*
P IL 9 +3
.د
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
+===#=
-C +
L!9 + + - .١
+ ! 9 3* ", +3N
L!9
=8 V
", B
. (3 /
% # :3 '& P + .! L 9
."9 "
U "
. ) >??? (
7 P* % .٢
B (Common Law) o j IC*N + ('3
(Force Majour, Liquated Damages) *. 6 + .,
Fitness for Purpose, ) &( 6 + ' + &
O8 + ='& <, (Fairness & Risk
.د
"
! S O ", "9 O #*. + .٤
#
* 3 # =< PP -( ", U8 !
N + -(N +3 6 L 9 3
& ! *
.9 ='& 0. ( 7 "1
. " C #
; "9 O + /8
1! C %
+ ",
.3 /8 (<P (
3) ' +
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
@A
#
@A
3 :
-! 3 - ,
.>?i\
I #! ", I! 5( I
.`aa> 3 :
-! +
.د
-
1 +
.`aa@ 3
U( O ", 3 5! F! F
. `aai 3 :
-! O
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
English References
- Brian W. Totterdill, FIDIC User’s Guide, a practical to 1999 red
book. Published on line. http://www.books.google.jo PDF file last
time seen 18-1-2010.
.د
< <íÖæ^Ϲ]<‚ÏÂ<»<Œ‚ßã¹]<ØfÎ<àÚ<íèÇjÖ]<†Ú]æù]<…]‚‘c
+
<
.>?\[
(Y@) " " +
.>?i[
(\>) 3 L! %
-
* +
,