Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PROGRAMME
Department of Geology
University of Dhaka
17-20 April, 2011
Prosun Bhattacharya
Professor
1
Contents
• Geochemical modeling
2
Considerations in Geochemical Modeling
• Hydrological Considerations
• Mineralogical Considerations
• Thermodynamic Considerations
3
Geochemical sampling based on flow
system
Recharge zone
Lake
A D
C B
River
200
100
• chemical equilibrium
• chemical kinetics
4
Approaches for geochemical modeling
• Exceptions are special environments
like mine tailings with the oxidation of
pyrite.
py
Types of Modeling
10
5
Forward and inverse modeling
11
Forward modeling
SI = log(IAP/Ksp)
where IAP is ion activity product and
Ksp is the solubility product for a given temperature.
12
6
Forward modeling
• This means that when IAP = Ksp
13
Forward modeling
14
7
Forward modeling
• Forward (reaction path) models are used for prediction of water
chemistry evolution.
15
Forward modeling
16
8
Forward modeling
17
Forward modeling
18
9
Forward modeling
19
Forward modeling
20
10
Inverse modeling
• Through inverse modeling, it is possible to determine the
possible reactions between 2 or more sampling points.
• One of the pre
pre-requisites
requisites is the knowledge on the solid
phase composition in the aquifers.
• This type of modeling is based on a mass-balance
approach and does not have thermodynamic constraints.
• Inverse modeling in is generally used to verify, if certain
reactions for the release of various contaminant species
of As release and immobilization are possible.
• Mass balance for As and As related species such as SO4
i performed
is f d using
i hydraulically
h d li ll connected
t d samples.
l
• Data on mineralogical composition of the solid phase are
essential because they have to be entered together with
water chemistry.
21
Inverse modeling
• Inverse or mass balance models are based on mass
balance calculations for solid phase and dissolved species
(sometimes also isotopes) in a geochemical system.
• The input comprises water samples from two or more
h d
hydraulically
li ll connected
t d sampling
li points
i t and
d the
th
composition of the solid phase between these points.
• The output has the form of
11
Inverse modeling
• The mineral database in NETPATH (Plummer et
al., 1994) does not include all elements viz. As.
• F
Furthermore,
th uncertainty
t i t in
i analytical
l ti l d
data
t can
be accounted for and a range of concentration
values may be entered instead of fixed
concentration values.
23
Inverse modeling
• Standard flow/transport packages like Visual MODFLOW
which includes transport program MT3D, can simulate
flow and transport p in 3-D,, but their ggeochemical
capabilities are limited.
• They include adsorption isotherms like linear adsorption
isotherm Kd and first order decay.
• The Kd value is generally determined from batch or
column experiments, when ground water in contact with
solid phase from the investigated aquifer is spiked with
the contaminant species in question viz. As.
• The slope of the straight line in a graph of equilibrium
adsorbed concentration S vs. dissolved concentration C is
based on a batch experiment determines the Kd value,
which is used to calculate the retardation coefficient R
(Fetter, 1999).
24
12
Inverse modeling
v w Lw ⎛ρ ⎞
R= = = 1 + ⎜ b ⎟.K d
v c Lc ⎝ n ⎠
25
Forward modeling
26
13
Applications of geochemical modeling
• Another application includes determination of
saturation indexes for minerals, which could be
sinks for dissolved Fe.
• In Bangladesh and West Bengal, India, the
correlation between dissolved Fe and As is poor in
some cases.
• Precipitation of Fe(II) iron minerals like siderite,
FeCO3, and vivianite, Fe3(PO4)2.8H2O, was
suggested to explain the lack of correlation by
S
Sracekk ett al.
l (2000);
(2000) Nickson
Ni k ett al.
l (2000) and d
Bhattacharya et al. (2002b).
• Saturation indices for both Fe(II) minerals were
consistently positive.
27
14
Applications of geochemical modeling
29
30
15
Geochemical modeling using PHREEQC: Input data
1 du004 Puntia, Rajshahi 25.5m du004 c5
916. 1033. 9901 .0000 .9000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000 .0000
TEMP = 24.700000
PH = 6.870000
EH(0) = -.153000
DOC = .900000
DOX = .000000
CORALK = 0
FLG = MG/L
DENS = 1.000000
PRNT = 0
PUNCH = 1
EHOPT(1) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate Fe species distribution
EHOPT(2) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate Mn species other than +2
EHOPT(3) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate Cu +1 species
EHOPT(4) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate As species distribution
EHOPT(5) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate Se species distribution
EHOPT(6) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate Ion Activity Products
EHOPT(7) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate atmospheric pO2
EHOPT(8) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate H2S from SO4
EHOPT(9) = 0 Use measured Eh to calculate U species distribution
EMPOX = 0
ITDS = 1033.000000
COND = 916.000000
SIGMDO = .000000
SIGMEH = .000000
SIGMPH = .000000
31
Sato
Input Sigma Fe3/Fe2 Sigma NO3/NO2 Sigma NO3/NH4 Sigma SO4/S= Sigma S/S= Sigma H2O2/O2 Sigma H2O/O2
Sigma
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Eh - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
-.153 .000 -.153 .000 9.900 .000 9.900 .000 9.900 .000 9.900 .000 9.900 .000 9.900
.000
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - pe - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
-2.589 .000 -2.589 .000 100.000 .000 100.000 .000 100.000 .000 100.000 .000 100.000 .000 100.000
.000
As5/As3 Sigma As3/As Sigma Se6/Se4 Sigma Se4/Se Sigma Se/Se= Sigma U6/U4 Sigma Sigma
Sigma
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Eh - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
.003 .000 -.297 .000 9.900 .000 9.900 .000 9.900 .000 9.900
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - pe - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
-
.049 .000 -5.028 .000 100.000 .000 100.000 .000 100.000 .000 100.000
32
16
Geochemical modeling using PHREEQC: Saturation Index
I Species Anal ppm Calc ppm Anal Molal Calc Molal % of Total Activity Act Coeff -Log Act
50 Al 3 .134000
134000 .000024
000024 4
4.969E-06
969E 06 8
8.816E-10
816E 10 .02
02 3
3.459E-10
459E 10 .3924
3924 9
9.461
461
52 Al(OH)2 1 .045 7.448E-07 14.99 6.713E-07 .9013 6.173
181 Al(OH)3 0 .038 4.837E-07 9.73 4.848E-07 1.0023 6.314
53 Al(OH)4 -1 .353 3.715E-06 74.76 3.348E-06 .9013 5.475
261 As3 tot 0 .017 2.324E-07
250 H3AsO3aq 0 .029 2.318E-07 67.52 2.323E-07 1.0023 6.634
262 As5 tot 0 .008300 1.109E-07
257 HAsO4 -2 .007012 5.015E-08 14.61 3.309E-08 .6598 7.480
256 H2AsO4 -1 .008547 6.070E-08 17.68 5.470E-08 .9013 7.262
0 Ca 2 47.400 44.846 1.183E-03 1.120E-03 94.63 7.489E-04 .6687 3.126
29 CaHCO3 1 4.730 4.682E-05 3.96 4.220E-05 .9013 4.375
31 CaSO4 aq 0 1.833 1.347E-05 1.14 1.350E-05 1.0023 4.870
4 Cl -1 86.161 86.119 2.432E-03 2.431E-03 99.97 2.187E-03 .8997 2.660
6 HCO3 -1 289.500 277.405 4.747E-03 4.550E-03 62.29 4.115E-03 .9045 2.386
85 H2CO3 aq 0 159.537 2.574E-03 35.24 2.580E-03 1.0024 2.588
16 Fe total 2 22.700 4.067E-04
7 Fe 2 16.911 3.030E-04 74.51 2.000E-04 .6598 3.699
309 FeHCO3 1 10.661 9.130E-05 22.45 8.229E-05 .9013 4.085
63 H 1 .000326 3.233E-07 .00 2.951E-07 .9128 6.530
3 K 1 22.400 22.381 5.732E-04 5.728E-04 99.93 5.154E-04 .8997 3.288
1 Mg 2 18.800 17.807 7.738E-04 7.330E-04 94.73 4.934E-04 .6731 3.307
21 MgHCO3 1 2.306 2.705E-05 3.50 2.438E-05 .9013 4.613
22 MgSO4 aq 0 1.364 1.134E-05 1.47 1.137E-05 1.0023 4.944
109 Mn 2 .824 .622 1.501E-05 1.134E-05 75.53 7.479E-06 .6598 5.126
311 MnCO3 aq 0 .049 4.276E-07 2.85 4.285E-07 1.0023 6.368
119 MnHCO3 1 .353 3.044E-06 20.28 2.743E-06 .9013 5.562
2 Na 1 69.000 68.811 3.003E-03 2.996E-03 99.75 2.703E-03 .9023 2.568
26 OH -1 .000938 5.522E-08 .00 4.976E-08 .9013 7.303
44 PO4 -3 3.414000 .000002 3.597E-05 1.720E-11 .00 6.750E-12 .3924 11.171
46 HPO4 -2 .580 6.047E-06 16.81 3.990E-06 .6598 5.399
47 H2PO4 -1 1.982 2.045E-05 56.85 1.843E-05 .9013 4.734
34 SiO2 tot 0 41.500 6.911E-04
23 H4SiO4aq 0 66.330 6.907E-04 99.93 6.922E-04 1.0023 3.160
5 SO4 -2 15.310 12.426 1.595E-04 1.295E-04 81.18 8.617E-05 .6656 4.065
34
17
Geochemical modeling using PHREEQC: Aqueous Species
1 du001 Mokamtala, Bogra 24m du001 a5
Effective
T pH TDS ppm Ionic Str pO2 Atm ppm O2 Atm pCO2 Atm ppm CO2 Atm log pCO2 CO2 Tot Ncrb Alk
aH2O
30.20 6.530 617.2 .00998 6.48E-65 2.07E-60 8.63E-02 3.80E+03 -1.064 7.31E-03 1.03E-05
.9997
I Species Anal ppm Calc ppm Anal Molal Calc Molal % of Total Activity Act Coeff -Log Act
50 Al 3 .134000 .000024 4.969E-06 8.816E-10 .02 3.459E-10 .3924 9.461
52 Al(OH)2 1 .045 7.448E-07 14.99 6.713E-07 .9013 6.173
181 Al(OH)3 0 .038 4.837E-07 9.73 4.848E-07 1.0023 6.314
53 Al(OH)4 -1 .353 3.715E-06 74.76 3.348E-06 .9013 5.475
261 As3 tot 0 .017 2.324E-07
250 H3AsO3aq 0 .029 2.318E-07 67.52 2.323E-07 1.0023 6.634
262 As5 tot 0 .008300 1.109E-07
257 HAsO4 -2 .007012 5.015E-08 14.61 3.309E-08 .6598 7.480
256 H2AsO4 -1 .008547 6.070E-08 17.68 5.470E-08 .9013 7.262
0 Ca 2 47.400 44.846 1.183E-03 1.120E-03 94.63 7.489E-04 .6687 3.126
29 CaHCO3 1 4.730 4.682E-05 3.96 4.220E-05 .9013 4.375
31 CaSO4 aq 0 1.833 1.347E-05 1.14 1.350E-05 1.0023 4.870
4 Cl -1 86.161 86.119 2.432E-03 2.431E-03 99.97 2.187E-03 .8997 2.660
6 HCO3 -1 289.500 277.405 4.747E-03 4.550E-03 62.29 4.115E-03 .9045 2.386
85 H2CO3 aq 0 159.537 2.574E-03 35.24 2.580E-03 1.0024 2.588
16 Fe total 2 22.700 4.067E-04
7 Fe 2 16.911 3.030E-04 74.51 2.000E-04 .6598 3.699
309 FeHCO3 1 10.661 9.130E-05 22.45 8.229E-05 .9013 4.085
63 H 1 .000326 3.233E-07 .00 2.951E-07 .9128 6.530
3 K 1 22.400 22.381 5.732E-04 5.728E-04 99.93 5.154E-04 .8997 3.288
1 Mg 2 18.800 17.807 7.738E-04 7.330E-04 94.73 4.934E-04 .6731 3.307
21 MgHCO33 1 2
2.306
306 2 705 05
2.705E-05 3
3.50
50 2
2.438E-05
438 05 .9013
9013 4
4.613
613
22 MgSO4 aq 0 1.364 1.134E-05 1.47 1.137E-05 1.0023 4.944
109 Mn 2 .824 .622 1.501E-05 1.134E-05 75.53 7.479E-06 .6598 5.126
311 MnCO3 aq 0 .049 4.276E-07 2.85 4.285E-07 1.0023 6.368
119 MnHCO3 1 .353 3.044E-06 20.28 2.743E-06 .9013 5.562
2 Na 1 69.000 68.811 3.003E-03 2.996E-03 99.75 2.703E-03 .9023 2.568
26 OH -1 .000938 5.522E-08 .00 4.976E-08 .9013 7.303
44 PO4 -3 3.414000 .000002 3.597E-05 1.720E-11 .00 6.750E-12 .3924 11.171
46 HPO4 -2 .580 6.047E-06 16.81 3.990E-06 .6598 5.399
47 H2PO4 -1 1.982 2.045E-05 56.85 1.843E-05 .9013 4.734
34 SiO2 tot 0 41.500 6.911E-04
23 H4SiO4aq 0 66.330 6.907E-04 99.93 6.922E-04 1.0023 3.160
5 SO4 -2 15.310 12.426 1.595E-04 1.295E-04 81.18 8.617E-05 .6656 4.065
35
I Species Anal ppm Calc ppm Anal Molal Calc Molal % of Total Activity Act Coeff -Log Act
50 All 3 .134000
134000 .000024
000024 4
4.969E-06
969 06 8
8.816E-10
816 10 .02
02 3
3.459E-10
459 10 .3924
3924 9
9.461
461
52 Al(OH)2 1 .045 7.448E-07 14.99 6.713E-07 .9013 6.173
181 Al(OH)3 0 .038 4.837E-07 9.73 4.848E-07 1.0023 6.314
53 Al(OH)4 -1 .353 3.715E-06 74.76 3.348E-06 .9013 5.475
261 As3 tot 0 .017 2.324E-07
250 H3AsO3aq 0 .029 2.318E-07 67.52 2.323E-07 1.0023 6.634
262 As5 tot 0 .008300 1.109E-07
257 HAsO4 -2 .007012 5.015E-08 14.61 3.309E-08 .6598 7.480
256 H2AsO4 -1 .008547 6.070E-08 17.68 5.470E-08 .9013 7.262
0 Ca 2 47.400 44.846 1.183E-03 1.120E-03 94.63 7.489E-04 .6687 3.126
29 CaHCO3 1 4.730 4.682E-05 3.96 4.220E-05 .9013 4.375
31 CaSO4 aq 0 1.833 1.347E-05 1.14 1.350E-05 1.0023 4.870
4 Cl -1 86.161 86.119 2.432E-03 2.431E-03 99.97 2.187E-03 .8997 2.660
6 HCO3 -1 289.500 277.405 4.747E-03 4.550E-03 62.29 4.115E-03 .9045 2.386
85 H2CO3 aq 0 159.537 2.574E-03 35.24 2.580E-03 1.0024 2.588
16 Fe total 2 22.700 4.067E-04
7 Fe 2 16.911 3.030E-04 74.51 2.000E-04 .6598 3.699
309 FeHCO3 1 10.661 9.130E-05 22.45 8.229E-05 .9013 4.085
63 H 1 .000326 3.233E-07 .00 2.951E-07 .9128 6.530
3 K 1 22.400 22.381 5.732E-04
5.732E 04 5.728E-04
5.728E 04 99.93 5.154E-04
5.154E 04 .8997 3.288
1 Mg 2 18.800 17.807 7.738E-04 7.330E-04 94.73 4.934E-04 .6731 3.307
21 MgHCO3 1 2.306 2.705E-05 3.50 2.438E-05 .9013 4.613
22 MgSO4 aq 0 1.364 1.134E-05 1.47 1.137E-05 1.0023 4.944
109 Mn 2 .824 .622 1.501E-05 1.134E-05 75.53 7.479E-06 .6598 5.126
311 MnCO3 aq 0 .049 4.276E-07 2.85 4.285E-07 1.0023 6.368
119 MnHCO3 1 .353 3.044E-06 20.28 2.743E-06 .9013 5.562
2 Na 1 69.000 68.811 3.003E-03 2.996E-03 99.75 2.703E-03 .9023 2.568
26 OH -1 .000938 5.522E-08 .00 4.976E-08 .9013 7.303
44 PO4 -3 3.414000 .000002 3.597E-05 1.720E-11 .00 6.750E-12 .3924 11.171
46 HPO4 -2 .580 6.047E-06 16.81 3.990E-06 .6598 5.399
47 H2PO4 -1 1.982 2.045E-05 56.85 1.843E-05 .9013 4.734
34 SiO2 tot 0 41.500 6.911E-04
23 H4SiO4aq 0 66.330 6.907E-04 99.93 6.922E-04 1.0023 3.160
5 SO4 -2 15.310 12.426 1.595E-04 1.295E-04 81.18 8.617E-05 .6656 4.065
36
18
Geochemical modelling using Visual MINTEQ
(current ver 3.0)
http://www2.lwr.kth.se/English/OurSoftware/vminteq/
37
19
Visual MINTEQ (current ver 3.0): Salient uses
http://www2.lwr.kth.se/English/OurSoftware/vminteq/
20