2/G

µ7\bVSPSUW\\W\U5]RQ`SObSRbVSVSOdS\aO\RbVSSO`bV2]
g]cPSZWSdSbVOb-BVWacaSRb]PSa][SbVW\UbVOb^S]^ZS
e]cZRbOYST]`U`O\bSRO\RaOg·=TQ]c`aSSdS`gbVW\UeOa
Q`SObSRPg5]RZ]]YObbVSRSaWU\¸0cbeS¸`SU`]eW\Uc^W\
ORWTTS`S\bbW[SO\R\]eeS¸`Sb]ZRbVObbVWa[WUVb\]bPS
O\]^bW]\¶

2/Gj!
>aOZ[!!($
0gbVSe]`R]TbVS:]`RbVSVSOdS\aeS`S[ORS
O\RPgbVSP`SObV]T6Wa[]cbVOZZbVSW`V]ab

ES¸`S]TbS\b]ZReS¸`S]\ZgQ]a[WQOQQWRS\ba)bVS`SacZb]TOPWU
PO\Ua][S"PWZZW]\gSO`aOU]=c`QcZbc`SbSZZacaSdS`gbVW\U
VO^^S\a]\ZgOaOQ]W\QWRS\QSO\RbVObbVS`S¸a\]cZbW[ObS
^c`^]aSb]ZWTS

5]RbSZZaca]bVS`eWaS

2]
2]g]cSdS`ab]^O\RbVW\YOP]cbbVWab`cbV-5]RbSZZaca6SWabVS
1`SOb]`]TSdS`gbVW\UZWbS`OZZgSdS`gbVW\UPcbR]g]cV]\SabZg
PSZWSdSbVOb-=`VOdSg]cP]cUVbW\b]bVSZWSabVOb]c`QcZbc`S
T]`QSTSSRaca-

7aOWOV"( $
:WTbc^g]c`SgSaO\RZ]]Yb]bVSVSOdS\a(EV]Q`SObSROZZbVSaS-
:WTbc^
6SeV]P`W\Ua]cbbVSabO``gV]ab]\SPg]\SO\RQOZZaT]`bVSOQV
]TbVS[Pg\O[S0SQOcaS]T6WaU`SOb^]eS`O\R[WUVbg
ab`S\UbV\]b]\S]TbVS[Wa[WaaW\U

6]e]TbS\R]g]ca^S\RbW[S[O`dSZW\UOb5]R¸aQ`SObW]\-

1][Sc^eWbVOZWab]Ta][S]TbVSU`SObSab[O`dSZa]TQ`SObW]\
bVObg]cVORbVS]^^]`bc\Wbgb]aSS]`e]cZRZWYSb]aSS]\SROg

EVgR]g]cPSZWSdSWbWaW[^]`bO\bb]µZWTbc^g]c`SgSa¶O\Ra^S\R
bW[S`STZSQbW\U]\5]R¸aUZ]`gO\RQ`SObW]\-

BVWadS`aSOZa]bSZZacabVOb5]RY\]eaSOQV]TbVSPWZZW]\a]TabO`a
Pg\O[SO\R\]b]\SWa[WaaW\UBVWaWaO\W\Q`SRWPZSb`cbVEVOb
R]SabVWa[SO\T]`caeVS\eSabO`bb]USbe]``WSR]`aQO`SRbVOb
5]RWa\¸beObQVW\U]cbT]`ca-

2/Gj"
µ5]RaOgag]cQ]cZRZ]]YObQ`SObW]\O\Rg]ce]cZRaSS6W[
A][SV]eg]ce]cZR`SQ]U\WhSbVObbVS`SeOaa][SbVW\U
PSVW\ROZZ]TbVWaa][S]\SPSVW\ROZZ]TWb¶

2/Gj#
@][O\a( 
4]`aW\QSbVSQ`SObW]\]TbVSe]`ZR5]RaW\dWaWPZS_cOZWbWSa6Wa
SbS`\OZ^]eS`O\RRWdW\S\Obc`SVOdSPSS\QZSO`ZgaSS\PSW\U
c\RS`ab]]RT`][eVObVOaPSS\[ORSa]bVOb^S]^ZSO`SeWbV]cb
SfQcaS

ESO`Sb]ZRW\bVWadS`aSbVOb5]R¸a_cOZWbWSaVOdSPSS\QZSO`ZgaSS\
aW\QSbVSPSUW\\W\U]TbVSe]`ZRESVOdS\]SfQcaSb]WU\]`S5]R
]`aOgeSQO\¸baSS6W[5]RWaPSVW\RWbOZZ

A]WTeSVOdS\]SfQcaSeVgR]g]cPSZWSdSeS[OYSSfQcaSa-
6OdSg]cSdS`U]\SbV`]cUVO^S`W]R]TZWTSeVS`Sg]cVOdS
_cSabW]\SRbVSSfWabS\QS]T5]R-

EVOb[ORSg]cbVW\YbVOb5]ReOa\¸bbVS`S]`RWR\¸bQO`S-

EVS\
EVS\eSPSUW\b]\SUZSQb]c``SZObW]\aVW^eWbV5]R]`_cSabW]\
VWaSfWabS\QSO\RQ`SObW]\eSO`SSaaS\bWOZZgaOgW\UbVObeS¸`SbVS
QS\bS`)eS¸`SbVSQ`SOb]`aO\RRW`SQb]`a]T]c`]e\ZWdSa

6]eVOabVWae]`YSR]cbT]`g]cPST]`S-6OdSg]cSdS`b`WSRb]
T]ZZ]eg]c`]e\^ObVO\R^caVSR5]R]TTb]bVSaWRS-3f^ZOW\

>aOZ['(
BVSVSOdS\aRSQZO`SbVSUZ]`g]T5]R)bVSaYWSa^`]QZOW[bVS
BVSVS
e]`Y]T6WaVO\Ra

5]RWaW\QVO`US]TWbOZZO\R6SRSaWU\SRO\R[ORSSdS`gbVW\U
BVS`SWa\]SfQcaSb]aOgµBVS`SWa\]5]R7¸[UZOROZZ]TbVWa
`O\R][ZgVO^^S\SR¶<]eSZ]]Yc^O\RQO\¸bVSZ^PcbaOgµBVS
VSOdS\ab`cZgR]RSQZO`SbVSUZ]`g]T5]R¶

2/Gj$
µEVS\bVS0WPZSe]cZRRSaQ`WPSbVWa0SW\UWbeOa\¸bXcab
O\]bVS`dS`aW]\]TcaO\ROPWUUS`dS`aW]\]Tca0cbbVS
^S]^ZSeV]W\bS`OQbSReWbV6W[aOWR·<]\]6SQOZZa
VW[aSZT6]Zg¸6]Zg[SO\W\UaSbO^O`b)Q][^ZSbSZgRWTTS`S\b
T`][ca¶

2/Gj%
7BW[]bVg$($
6SOZ]\SWaW[[]`bOZO\RReSZZaW\c\O^^`]OQVOPZSZWUVb<]]\S
VOaSdS`aSS\6W[\]`QO\O\g]\SaSS6W[B]6W[PSV]\]`O\R
SbS`\OZR][W\W]\

EVS\eSbVW\YOP]cb5]ReS]TbS\^ZOQS]c`Vc[O\ZW[WbObW]\a
O\RWRSOa]\6W[

4]`SfO[^ZS[OgPSg]cVOdSOab`OW\SR`SZObW]\aVW^eWbVg]c`
TObVS`eV]b`SObag]cZWYSg]cO`S\¸bSdS`U]]RS\]cUVT]`VWaZ]dS
O\ROTTSQbW]\BVS\eSW\bc`\^ZOQSbVSS[]bW]\a]T]c`SO`bVZg
TObVS`]\b]]c`^S`QSWdSRS[]bW]\a]T]c`VSOdS\Zg4ObVS`O\R
acRRS\ZgeSPSZWSdSeSQO\\SdS`PSU]]RS\]cUVSdS\T]`5]R¸a
Z]dS

6OdSg]cR]\SbVWa-EVObSO`bVgZW[WbObW]\aO\RS[]bW]\aVOdS
g]c^ZOQSR]\5]R-

0cbbVS0WPZSbSZZacabVOb6SWaV]ZgW[[]`bOZO\RPSg]\ReVOb
eSQO\SdS`Q][^`SVS\R

/Qba%( " #
BVS5]ReV][ORSbVSe]`ZRO\RSdS`gbVW\UW\WbWabVS:]`R]T
BVS5]ReV][ORSbVS
VSOdS\O\RSO`bVO\RR]Sa\]bZWdSW\bS[^ZSaPcWZbPgVc[O\
VO\Ra/\R6SWa\]baS`dSRPgVc[O\VO\RaOaWT6S\SSRSR
O\gbVW\U@ObVS`6SVW[aSZTUWdSaSdS`g]\SZWTSO\RP`SObVO\R
SdS`gbVW\USZaS

BVWaWabVS5]ReSaS`dS6SWaO5]RPSg]\R]c`Q][^`SVS\aW]\
O\R6SOZ]\SWabVS]\SeV]UWdSacaZWTSO\RP`SObVO\R
SdS`gbVW\UeSaSS

6]eR]SabVWaY\]eZSRUSQVO\USV]eg]caSS5]R-7a5]R
O^^`]OQVOPZSb]aW\TcZ[]`bOZaZWYSca-EVg]`eVg\]b-

7aOWOV"( &
2]g]c\]bY\]e-6OdSg]c\]bVSO`R-BVS:]`RWabVS
2]
SdS`ZOabW\U5]RbVS1`SOb]`]TbVSS\Ra]TbVSSO`bV6SeWZZ\]b
U`]ebW`SR]`eSO`gO\R6Wac\RS`abO\RW\U\]]\SQO\TObV][

2/Gj&
µ6SRSbS`[W\SRSfOQbZgeVS\O\ReVS`SeSe]cZRPSP]`\
6S]`QVSab`ObSabVSaWbcObW]\aO\RQW`Qc[abO\QSaW\]c`ZWdSa
a]bVObeS[OgTSSZ]c`eOgb]eO`Ra6W[O\RTW\R6W[¶

2/Gj'
8S`S[WOV(#
0ST]`S7T]`[SRg]cW\bVSe][P7Y\Seg]cPST]`Sg]ceS`S
P]`\7aSbg]cO^O`b

7T5]RVOaRSbS`[W\SRSfOQbZgeVS`SO\ReVS\eSe]cZRPSP]`\
bVS\bVOb[SO\abVS`SWaOdS`ga^SQWTWQ`SOa]\bVObg]c¸`SOZWdS
b]ROg

A]e
A]eVgO`Sg]cVS`S-/`Sg]cZWdW\UOaWTg]c`^c`^]aSWab][OYS
g]c`aSZTY\]e\]`O`Sg]cZWdW\Ub][OYS5]RY\]e\-

/`Sg]cOQbWdSZgTSSZW\Ug]c`eOgb]eO`Ra5]RPg^c`acW\UO
`SZObW]\aVW^eWbV6W[-

6]eO`Sg]c^c`acW\UbVWa`SZObW]\aVW^-2]g]ca^S\RbW[SW\6Wa
e]`R-2]g]c^`Og-E]`aVW^6W[-A^S\RbW[SW\_cWSbe]\RS`O\R
OeS]T6WaQ`SObW]\-


>SbS` ('
0cbg]cO`SOQV]aS\^S]^ZSO`]gOZ^`WSabV]]ROV]Zg\ObW]\
5]R¸aa^SQWOZ^]aaSaaW]\bVObg]c[OgRSQZO`SbVS^`OWaSa]T6W[
eV]QOZZSRg]c]cb]TRO`Y\SaaW\b]6Wae]\RS`TcZZWUVb

=c`QcZbc
=c`QcZbc`S[OgbSZZcabVObbVS`SWa\]`Vg[S]``SOa]\b]ZWTS
]bVS`bVO\b]VOdSTc\O\RUSbOVSORW\ZWTS0cbeSY\]eeSO`S
VS`ST]`a][cQV[]`SESVOdSPSS\QOZZSR]cb]TRO`Y\SaaO\R
W\b]6WaZWUVb0cbO`Sg]cabWZZZWdW\UW\RO`Y\Saa-

EVObO`Sa][SO`SOa]TµRO`Y\Saa¶bVObg]c[OgabWZZPSZWdW\UW\-
/aSQ`SbaW\-BVSeOgg]cb`SOb]bVS`a-BVSeOgg]cb`SOb
g]c`aSZT-

2/Gj
2/Gj
/Qba%( $ %
4`][]\S[O\6S[ORSOZZbVS\ObW]\abVObbVSgaV]cZRW\VOPWb
bVSeV]ZSSO`bV)O\R6S[O`YSR]cbbVSW`O^^]W\bSRbW[SaW\
VWab]`gO\RbVSP]c\RO`WSa]TbVSW`ZO\Ra5]RRWRbVWaa]bVOb
bVSge]cZRaSSY6W[O\R^S`VO^a`SOQV]cbT]`6W[O\RTW\R6W[
bV]cUV6SWa\]bTO`T`][O\g]\S]Tca

5]RWa\¸ba][Sc\O^^
5]RWa\¸ba][Sc\O^^`]OQVOPZSPSW\UbVOb¸aaWbbW\Uc^W\VSOdS\
Z]]YW\UT]`eOgab]a[WbS]`WU\]`Sca5]ReO\bacab]TW\R6W[
6SeO\bab]VOdSO^S`a]\OZ`SZObW]\aVW^eWbVg]c

6SVOa^cbRWTTS`S\b^S]^ZSW\b]g]c`ZWTSObdO`W]cabW[SaO\RVOa
QOcaSRbVW\Uab]VO^^S\OZZa]bVObg]c[OgTW\Rg]c`eOgb]6W[
/\R]\QSg]cTW\Rg]c`eOgb]6W[eVObPSQ][Sa]Tg]c`
^`SdW]caZWTS-G]cacRRS\ZgVOdSO\Se^c`^]aS

A]eV
A]eVObWag]c`^c`^]aS-6]eQO\g]cPSUW\SdS\W\a[OZZeOga
b]ZWdS]cbbVOb^c`^]aS-

5]RQO\O\ReWZZ`SdSOZeVOb6SVOa]`QVSab`ObSRT]`g]c`ZWTSG]c
]\Zg\SSRb]bOYSbVSbW[Sb]OaYO\RZWabS\

3f]Rca'($
0cb7VOdS`OWaSRg]cc^T]`bVWadS`g^c`^]aSbVOb7[WUVbaV]e
0cb7V
g]c;g^]eS`O\RbVOb;g\O[S[WUVbPS^`]QZOW[SRW\OZZbVS
SO`bV

G]cO`SOZWdSbVWa[W\cbS]\bVWaROgW\bVWagSO`b]RSQZO`SO\R
`STZSQbbVSUZ]`g]T5]REVObQ]cZRPSOPSbbS`^c`^]aSbVO\
bVOb-

2/Gj