change these difficulties. Some aspects—such as larger, more
complex antennas—may actually add to the difficulties.
There are problems here that deserve to be solved, but they
do not need a new generation of mobile technology.
Massive Internet of Things
The new 5G technology is seen as meeting the needs of an
expected massive number of devices (sensors, actuators,
cameras) that will be deployed to monitor or measure a wide
range of different attributes. These specific use cases are
identified in Table 7.3.
Table 7.3: Internet of Things Connectivity Requirements
Use Cases Description Challenges
Smart wearables _ For integrated sensors that can be Management of the
used to measure environmental and devices and data
health attributes, such as blood
pressure, temperature, and heart rate
Sensor networks To be used for metering; Device costs, battery
environmental management (e.g., life, high density, wide
pollution, noise measurements); range of devices,
traffic control (e.g., traffic light transmission distances
management)
Mobile video To be used for surveillance on moving Need for reliable and
surveillance transport (aircraft, cars, drones); by _secure networks
security personnel to monitor events,
buildings, etc.Source: NGMN Alliance 2015.
The concept of the IoT was introduced in Chapter 3. IoT was
shown that to be a highly valuable service, but one with
relatively minimal data requirements. The question now is
whether 5G is needed for IoT to materialize.
There are many proposed solutions for IoT connectivity.
They divide into cellular-based solutions and into noncellular
solutions running in unlicensed frequency bands (and hence
often termed “unlicensed solutions”). Within 4G there are two
main solutions—LTE-Machine (LTE-M) and narrowband IoT
(NB-IoT). In 2017, both of these were in trials in multiple
countries, and many MNOs had committed to roll them out
across their network. Unlicensed solutions include Sigfox, LoRa,
Weightless, and Ingenu and are being deployed to varying
extents around the world.
It is hard to see a role for 5G. Solutions such as NB-IoT are
well specified and should meet the foreseeable needs of IoT. LTE
and 4G offer sufficient capacity and coverage. Deploying
another IoT solution within 5G would add further expense for
MNOs, requiring them to run multiple networks in parallel and
threatening to confuse the marketplace. There are no unmet
needs currently identified nor any new technology that would
allow SG to offer a superior solution to 4G. In a major 5G debate
(Cambridge Wireless 2016a,b), the knowledgeable audience
were unanimous in their view that 5G would not introduce a
new IoT solution but that it would encapsulate the existing 4G
solutions. This was also the view that the 5G standards bodies
appeared to be reaching in 2017. Of course, if 5G becomes just