LOS ANGELES COUNTY MUSEUM OF ART
ABDEVILLE PRESS : PUBLISHERS: NEW YORK.
‘ 1486
\
COrgorzed by MAURICE TUCHMAN wi sh asstane of
JUDI FREEMAN
insertion wth
CAREL BLOTKAMP
Fup BOL,
JONN £, BOMLT
CHARLOTTE DOUGLAS
CHARLES. ELDREDGE
ROBERT GALDREATH
LINDA DALRYMPLE HENDERSON
OSE-CAROL WASHTCN LONG
SIXTEN RINGHOM
W JACKSON RUSHING
HARRIETT WATTS
ROBERT P. WELSH
THE
SPIRITUAL
IN ART:
ABSTRACT
PAINTING
1890-1985MYSTICISM,
LINDA DALRYMPLE HENDERSON
In 1904 the American architect and occult author Cau
ROMANTICISM, AND THE FOURTH D
agdon (pl. 1) wrote an article onthe Belgian Symbol~
‘he Mauece Maeterinck that brought together
overall spiritual cneeens ofthe ew cen=
tury, Of Mactetinek, Biagdon wrote, "Acta
igor have walue to himtonly as they image
hae spiritual workdin which souls meet
nd dell and he communicates to ov inner
Consciousness his tere in this itmmanent,
tpuiavinible universe much 252 mathemati
fan i able co make plan the nature of foar
“Timensional space intangible co the senses,
{etvacedinch’s esas sem “strange and
tneflabl," it only beense "the infinite
fetuses to be expressed in terms ofthe finite.
Macterlinck i "the mystic of che modecn
World," and "the onenes of the individual
Weinabe absote ie te ecureen cefiain of his
{very song,” Moreoves, is "widening inh
ee and his increasing popularity” establ
thar aficr centuries of parey objective com=
lowsness 2 speivual epoch is at ast upon
Shieh the soul dra neat the surface of
ie"
Beagdon’s text contains one of bis first pub
lished references to the fourth dimension, 2
fubjet that he wold ake his own ina series
Stbocks publithed from 1912 onward. fin
tyoaiehad not yet developed the connections
‘erween a fourth dimension and mysticism,
te he would do Ite his ext nevertheless set
IMENSION
forth certain mystical themes that became
fencal to early wentieth-century discussions
fof fourth dimension: the infinite, the woh
tion of consciousness, and the philosophical
toniam implied by Maetstnck's bein
he oneness ofthe indvidal with the abso
tue" Transcending national Boundaies
these three themes weave «thread reaching,
bck to Romanticism and forward to Surreal
{bm, evo movements which the mystical
tradition played an importanc rok
[Although interest in a fourth dimension of
Space was an ourgeomrth of te development
ole dimensional geomeries during dic frst
fal of the nineteenth century. the nocion of
fourth dimension had become highly popular~
jae by te urn ofthe century. By that time
the term ie accumolted a variery of
‘nowmathematial associations he primary
fone being an ideals philosophical nterpeet2~
lon ofits higher rest Beyond chee
‘mensional, visual perception. fc, the
toncepe enjoyed symbiotic reaionship with
the mystical tradition. Early weners onthe
fourth dimension often drew upon the se
sminology of mysticism, and convessly weit-
rs of mystial bent soch 2s Brgdon found
inthe idea of fourth dimension 3 means 0
sake the inelable more concrete
neNDeRsoine Brad. 8p.
otogrph. Bragéon Paty
Papers Unvery of
chor rang, New York
‘hotogaph
uspesty Colleton,
‘ner. New
Hoven Counce
“This essay examines the three eatiest and
rosin uel ewentieth-century statemens
‘on arc and the fourth dimension, Two ofthese
feoxs were written by figuees within the art
‘world: Max Weber's Camere ork article
“The Fourth Dimension fom a Plastic Point
of View" (1910), and Guillaume Apolinaice’s
iscasion of lepine dimesion he fourth
imension), printed frst ns 1912 article and
Tater in his Les Pevares Cites (1913). The
‘hicd text, Tern Ongena, published in
Saint Poceesbrg nyt), was writen By the
‘rye philosopher PD. Ouspensky an was
ead by arts from te Russian Futurists and
Malevich through the Sueeasts and beyond
Althowgh published in widely separated
few York, Pars, Sane Pversburg),
the hee statements share sours inthe ys
tial and occult tradition. Considered rel
tion to the sues of infinity, mons, and the
ewolaion of conscious he text have Far
‘ore in common than has ben noted
previously
Variations within the mystical wadiion belp
plain the differing aresie ramifications of
tach cent, respecively, for Weber's painting,
for Coie painters i Apolliaie’s cele, and
for Karimi Malevich andthe Surrealist who
ead Ouspensky,* Indeed, 2 soholy or partly
‘mystical iterpretation of the fourth dimen
sion underlies seyesanging from Symbalist
and Cubiscevocations of higher space, which
‘tlized some degre of recognizable form, t0
the foal sbetracion: of Malevich's geometric
Supeematisn and che organi inner world oF
‘he Srrealists Matt and Gordon
Onslow-Ford.>
Deore considering the statements of Weber,
Apollinsre, and Ouspensky in chit indivi
tal contexts, is helpful o provide some
bistorial background for these wre" con
cepts of infinity as well as monismn and che
fvolution oF consciousness. Because infinity
hhsea more complex altral history than
either ofthe other two issues, it serves pattce
blarly wel to demonstate the remarkable
Similrtes in the larguage of mysticism,
Romanticism, and erature onthe fourth
slimension, Thus we begin with the words of
‘Weber, Apollinste, and Ouspensky onthe
subject of infinity.
‘Compared with Ouspensky's kngthy book
con the fourth dimension, the essays of Weber
dnd Apollinate offer suecinc statements on
‘he relation of the fourth dimension 0 infin-
ity tn is tgioarile, Weber explained that
th fourth dinension i "he emmensity fall
tinge” ad the dimension f ny
Apoliaie in hi agra arte deseribed the
fourch dimension 35 "the aac of space
cteraising sel nll dvecoons at any ven
‘omen and srrtd that" space ell
{he dimension ofthe nfnite"» The dosenss
ofthe so texts maybe explained in part by
Weber's having met Apolinaie in Pare b>
{908 and Apolinairessubreyoen eransoion
of Weber's ey Before he wrote his own
‘Ouspensky's Ten Organon presents his
_mysical philosophy based on ee evolution of
consciousness co comprehend higher-dimet=
‘Sonal space. For Quspnsky (pl 2) “art
Finciuding poetry and msic}is 2 path 0.65
‘ic consciousness," and 9 "sensation of init
ity” characterizes the fst mornents ofthe
transition tothe new consccasness of Fou
dimensionality: "The sense of the infinite
‘he fis and most treble wea before ini
ation, Nothing exists. A litle miserable soul
feos tslf suspended in an infiite void. Then
‘even the void disappear. Tare is only itin~
ityea constant and continuous division and
isolation of everything.”According co Ovspensky che “sensation of
infinity" and che attendant recognition of "sn
abyss everywher2" willbe secompanied by 0
impression of unter and never-ending
ilogiaiy-"™ With the ansiton to four-
imensional consciousness comes radical
reversal of what had ben seen in the three
‘imensional world as rel and unreal 0 logi=
‘al and illogieal. Ouspensky proponed h
‘ew alogial logic of “Tertiom Organum” 3s
‘means for an individual to prepare forthe
tevtltion of four-dimensional reality. Once
achieved, "cormie consciousness” brings fur-
{er reversals In the fourth dimension, the
| snitorioned sense of up-down and left-right
fadesaway, and objects canbe viewed from al
sides at once. Even more sailing isthe
‘discovery that time and motion, as under
‘00d nthree dimensions, ad been mere lu
sions produced by inadequate perception of
four-dimensional extension. Not ony 3 new
Togie but anew language i needed forthe
world of higher consciousness. "New parts of
seeds are necessary, a infinite number of
‘words," Ouspensky argued.*
In addition to infinity, these Last re issues
(Geeedom feom up-down and left-right ort
entation and the adequacy of present n=
guage) aso indicate che debc of Ouspensky
and others to mysticism and Romanticism.
For example, Wiliam jomesin The Vareer of
Religious Experionc (1903) lite 38 the st
uricteristc of mystical experience"
{abity” or “incommunicableness
fon the fourth dimension in the early ewe
cencury Feequendly pointed ox the nad
"ere the similarity to Apollinaite'sdescrip-
tion of the fourth dimensions particulary
serking: "Ici space sel, the dimension of
the infinite
“Throughout the fist vohime ofl Unveiled,
Bhhvatsky gave a series of definitions ofthe
anima mandi ths establish ts connections co
the Western mystical tradition af infinity as
swell 25 to the ancient wisdom of India and to
modern sconce. She described the anima
‘mundi vaioudly as the "Chaos" of the
ancients; “the Soul ofthe World” of Plato nd
te Pythagoreans; the Deity in the shape of
‘Aether pervading] al things” of the Hindus:
the Astal Light ofthe Kabaiste"; "the mod
ern Ether, not sch 2 recogaized by ours
«entsts: but such a twas known to the ancient
philosophers”; "the grea univers, magnetic
gent, which [Newton] called the divine
semsorbon”: and the “Nirvana” of Budd.
The ether (the mysterious ight carrying
media believed by scientists before Albert
Einstein to 6 all spac) is the explanation of
theanime mundi to which Blavatsky tured
again nd again. Her primary source for these
Aiseusions was the remarkable text The Ue
seen Universe; or, PhyialSpraatons ona
utr Stat, published anonymously in 1875
Ins authors, British scientist Balfour Stewart,
and Peter Guthrie Tat, speclated thatthe
cher might function 25a “bridge nto the
invisible universe," a5 Blwsteky quoted them
in her book.»
Perhaps 2 fourth dimension wae not men
‘iomed in Blavatsky ss Evel beexose
Stewart and Tait dd not incorporate he idea
ln The Unseen Univerre unt the revised ec
tion oF 1876. Yer the mysterious ether came to
De associated fequently seth che Fourth
dimension in subsequent decades, Aleady in
1076 Stewart and Tas found it wef 10
answer certain extcisms of hei book by
Suggesting that “our (essensllythee-dimen=
sional) matter is] the mere skin or boundary
of an Unseen whose mater his fur dimen
ions." Similarly Hinton in a New Eva of
Thowghe would propose thatthe ether wie
perhaps the boundary or sutfce of contact
bexween two four-dimensicnal existence.
With such an ideitication etablished a
carly ewonticth-centory rede of ss Unviled
‘might well have fle hat Blavatsky's equation,
anima mundi equate infinity equal ether, also
implied “equals the fourth dimension.”
MONISM AND THE EVOLUTION OF
CONSCIOUSNESS
Unlike infinity, with ts long and inde
Itong, nonin ind tenon afte
sciousness were often closely sesociated with
cone another Philosophical mani posite the
unity ofall things, bth spiitaal and materia,
Incrpreted from 2 mystial viswpoint,
_monism ao implies an abeolute One with
‘which the individual self may ulimately
achieve union os, 2s in Neopltonic emanation
theories ike that of Plotinds, reunion Inthe 2
indo Upaaishads emphasis is placed on
overcoming dscinctions Between the pecete
ing subject andthe objects ofthe world, ata
step toward zehieving the union of self and
Brahma. The phrase Tat tom al (hat are
‘hou from the Upanishads appear repeatedly
ineary twenteth-centurysourees,inloding =<
James's The Varees of Religious Experiowe
and the writings of Edward Carpenter 9
Rudolf Sines, Ouspensky, snd Bragdon.® sd
And sucha monise and at tines panteistic 27014
view undeties much of German and Bagh:
Romantic thought and Emerson's transcen- 5
deneatis, ee
Jatt font meson ame ike
‘wih infinity, the concept of higher fourth 3
dimension was an ideal menise tol to expla
the blending oF pit and mater. For the 38
Theosophists Blavatsky and Staines, develop
‘ments in nneteenth-century sence, pacts)
[arly atom theory, supported the dermaterah
ization of matter and interpretations ranging.
from sprit a “tines matte to matter 3
‘condensed spc ™ Yet a fouth dimension
of space offered an even more graphic demon
‘uration ofthe way in which three imen-
sional mater might be subsumed within
ghee spiritual realm. Charles W. Leadbeater
se the deat explain “astral vision." And
(Guspensky, who based his ene philosophy
upon the “"monism ofthe universe,”
-xplined in Tetum Orga: “Nobody ve
save mater, nor will he ever — itis possible
‘oly to tink rater. From another paint of
view its an lusion accepted for reality. Even
tore tly its the incorrecly peeved Fost
ofthat which exis in veaiys Mater i 5°
tion of tomething 4 nonexistent, imaginary
section, Bot that of which matter is a 362600,
sist This is the real, ourdimesional
sword"
For Ouspesky, ourdimenonsty,
‘mony anny were eked 1 BE
Sroinman of ger Il of eosciousnes
Moreau ofevlition.Ouspenty's Paaey
In paintin
berwees spi
Weber achieved a sense of fluidity
and matter only in works from
1913 onward, such as Interior of the Fourth
Dimension, 1913 (pl. 4). His primary stylistic
source in such works was the analytical Cub-
ism of Picasso and Georges Braque, which
had achieved a suggestion of higher dimen-
sions by denying 3 clear reading of three
dimensional space and objects. Like the
‘writings of Macterlinck and the pictorial pho
tography of his friends Coburn and Clarence
‘White, Weber’s painting functions as a Sym-
bolist evocation of mystery, an attempt in
Cubist language to express the infinite by
‘means of the Bnite
‘The difference between the styles of Weber
and a totaly abstract painter like Malevich
derived in part from the type of mystical
source upon which each artis drew. Although
the evolution of consciousness was a central
clement in the philosophies of Carpenter,
Bragdon, and Ouspensky, for Carpenter the
‘object of cosmic consciousness, the “great
Self,” was only incidentally four-dimen-
sional. Carpenter used the analogy of a fourth
dimension primarily to clarify his argument,
and his major emphasis remained upon a
‘monistic empathy with objects in chis world.
By contrast, both Bragdon and Ouspensky
ly believed in the reality of four-dimen-
sional existence and considered the world of
three dimensions an dlusion,
Weber's object-oriented Cubism is the coun-
texpart of the “extrovertive” mysticism of
Carpenter, and Malevich’s abstract Suprema-
tism parallels Ouspensky’s more
“introvertive” views. 6 Weber, like Carpenter,
sought union with and a spiritual trans-
formation of nature: his fourth dimension is
“brought into existence through the three
known measurements.” Malevich and
‘Ouspensky rejected the theee-dimensional
world and sought to achieve the mystical
experience of infinity and four-disnensional
consciousness. Ouspensky's "abyss every-
where” finds its equivalent in Malevich's
starement, “I have transformed myself into a
zero of form,” and in the negation repre-
228