Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
2
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
Description of Proficiency Levels Associated with the APPEL Model for Systems Engineers
To determine how best to proceed after entering the NASA workforce and progress through the technical professional development model,
it is helpful to understand the definition of each level. The following table is intended as a guide for use with the technical development
model for systems engineers.
SE Proficiency Level I SE Proficiency Level II SE Proficiency Level III SE Proficiency Level IV
Engineering Technical Engineer / Project Subsystem Lead Project Systems Engineer Program Systems Engineer or
Leadership Team Member Center/Agency
Performs fundamental and Performs SE activities for a Performs as a systems Oversees SE activities for a
Description of routine SE activities while subsystem or simple project engineer for a complex project program with several systems
Role/ supporting a Level II-IV (e.g. no more than two simple (e.g. several distinct and/or establishes SE policies
Responsibility systems engineer as a internal/external interfaces, subsystems or other defined at the Agency or Center level.
member of a project team simpler contracting processes, services, capabilities, or
smaller team/budget, shorter products and their associated
duration) interfaces)
Practitioners have obtained a Practitioners participated in or Practitioners have taken a Practitioners will have
working knowledge of technical led SE activities (e.g. significant leadership role in contributed to Agency goals
integration, systems requirements development, multiple phases of a project life and be effective in managing
engineering (SE) and project budget and schedule cycle managing both programmatic, technical, and
management (PM) concepts development, risk programmatic and technical strategic interfaces both
and tools and performed tasks management). They aspects and/or managing all internal and external to the
Level of and activities to support and demonstrated the application technical integration and SE Agency. They demonstrated
Expertise contribute to a project. They of SE/PM tools, techniques, functions for a subsystem or superior competencies in all
(LEO)/ demonstrated an awareness and lexicon at the project small project. They Systems Engineering
Competency and understanding of NASA's subsystem level, including use demonstrated the integration of formulation and
to Attain SE and PM tools, techniques, of SE/PM best practices. They SE/PM tools, techniques, and implementation activities.
Proficiency and lexicon. They have have sufficient experience and best practices across They have sufficient
Level sufficient experience and responsibility and are prepared subsystems at the project experience and responsibility
responsibility and are prepared to lead SE and technical level. They have sufficient and are prepared for a
to contribute to fundamental integration activities for a experience and responsibility technical leadership role at the
and routine SE activities. subsystem or simple project. and are prepared for a program, center, or agency
technical leadership role in level.
support of a major system or
project
Validation of Practitioner’s immediate Center Peer Group and EDP Center Peer Group and EDP Center Peer Group, EDP and
Levels supervisor panel panel Agency-wide panels
The emphasis at Level I is The emphasis at Level II is The emphasis at Level III is the The emphasis at Level IV is on
Learning and knowledge and understanding leadership application and directing, structuring, and the strategy for SE of large
Development of technical integration, SE and participation in SE. integration activities of SE. complex initiatives and the
emphasis basic project management. strategy and management of
Agency initiatives.
3
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
1) Competency Areas: These describe, in broad terms, what is expected of Systems Engineer personnel in terms of
particular components or functions of the job.
2) Competencies: These express the overall knowledge, skills, behaviors that SEs are expected to posses and/or perform
as a part of their job.
3) Competency Elements: Each Competency Area and Competency consists of Competency Elements that describe the
specific knowledge, skills, behaviors, which can be measured against established standards, can be improved via
training and development activities, and correlate to performance on the job.
4) Proficiency Level Descriptions: These specify the knowledge/performance to be achieved in order to demonstrate
successful mastery of the competency and are expressed in terms of levels.
5) HQ courses, Center courses, OJL activities, Other learning activities, Assessment Guidelines: These outline the
required/suggested courses and activities to obtain proficiency in the competencies by level. The Assessment
Guidelines indicate the evaluation and/or assessment of the competencies by level and are used as entry/exit criteria
for each level of development.
6) The Competency framework is hierarchal and the numbering scheme is as follows:
Competency Area – #.0
Competency – #.# – the first number indicates the Competency Area the competency falls into, the second is the
Competency number
Competency Element - #.#.# - the first and second numbers indicate the Competency Area and
Competency, respectively, that the Element is related to, the third is the particular Element number
4
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
5
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
6
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
7
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
8
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
9
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
Other learning activities
Assessment
10
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
11
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
2.2.4 Requirements Contribute to: Able to (for a subsystem or Direct (for a system): Direct (for a program):
Documentation • Validation of requirements simple project) validate • Validation of requirements • Validation of requirements
a. Validate the technical • Development of specification requirements • Development of specification • Development of specification
doc. doc. doc.
requirements Contribute to (for a subsystem
b. Baseline technical or simple project) development Define Agency/Center
requirements of specification doc. technical requirements
definition policies
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
12
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
13
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
14
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
15
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
b. Fabricate product • Support documentation • Monitor product fabrication fabrication fabrication
c. Prepare support preparation • Preparing support • Preparing support
documentation Contribute to (for a subsystem documentation documentation
or simple project) preparation
of support documentation
3.1.4 Product Reuse Contribute to acquiring the Able to (for a subsystem or Direct (for a system) SE Direct (for a program) SE
a. Review product technical product for reuse by: simple project) provide SE participation in acquiring the participation in acquiring the
information • Reviewing product technical participation in acquiring the product for reuse by: product for reuse by:
information product for reuse by: • Review of product technical • Review of product technical
b. Assess supporting
• Assessing status of • Review of product technical information information
documentation status supporting documentation information • Assessment of supporting • Assessment of supporting
c. Assess enabling product and user manuals • Assessment of supporting documentation and user documentation and user
status • Assessing enabling products documentation and user manuals status manuals status
d. Assist in requests to status manuals status • Assessment of enabling • Assessment of enabling
acquire the product from • Assisting in requests to • Assessment of enabling products status products status
Government source acquire the product from products status • Assisting in requests to • Assisting in requests to
e. Assist in product Government sources • Assisting in requests to acquire the product from acquire the product from
inspection • Assisting product inspection acquire the product from Government sources Government sources
Government sources • Product inspection • Assisting product inspection
• Product inspection
3.1.5 Product Contribute to capture of work Participate in capture of work Direct (for a system) capture of Direct (for a program) capture
Implementation products from product products from product work products from product of work products from product
implementation activities implementation activities implementation activities implementation activities
Documentation
a. Capture product Define Agency/Center product
implementation work implementation policies
products
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
16
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
17
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
products
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
18
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
19
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
20
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
21
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
22
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
23
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
Assessment
24
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
25
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
26
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
27
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
28
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
4.2.5 Requirement Contribute to capture of work Participate in capture of work Direct (for a system) capture Direct (for a program) capture
Management products from requirements products from requirements of work products from of work products from
management activities management activities requirements management requirements management
Documentation activities activities
a. Capture requirement
management work Define Agency/Center
products requirements management
policies
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
29
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
30
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
completed on all physical
interfaces
d. Evaluate assembled
products for interface
compatibility
e. Confirm product V/V plans
include confirming
interfaces
f. Prepare and interface
evaluation report
4.3.4 Interface Control Contribute to interface control Participate in interface control Direct (for a system) interface Direct (for a program) interface
Execution activities activities control activities control activities
a. Manage interface changes
with the system structure
b. Identify and track changes
to interface documentation
c. Confirm interface issues
are analyzed and resolved
when a change affects
products on both sides of
the interface
d. Control traceability of
interface changes
e. Disseminate approved
interface change
information
4.3.5 Interface Contribute to capture of work Participate capture of work Direct (for a system) capture of Direct (for a program) capture
Management products from interface products from interface work products from interface of work products from interface
management activities management activities management activities management activities
Documentation
a. Capture interface Define Agency/Center
management work products interface management policies
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
31
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
32
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
33
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
34
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
Management products from configuration products from configuration work products from of work products from
Documentation management activities management activities configuration management configuration management
activities activities
a. Capture configuration
management work Define Agency/Center
products configuration management
policies
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
35
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
36
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
37
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
38
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
presentation materials technical review boards (e.g. boards for other projects (e.g.
e. Identify and resolve PDR, CDR, TRR) PNAR, NAR)
action items
4.7.5 Technical Contribute to capture of work Participate in capture of work Direct (for a system) capture of Direct (for a program) capture
Assessment products from technical products from technical work products from technical of work products from technical
assessment activities assessment activities assessment activities assessment activities
Documentation
a. Capture technical Define Agency/Center
assessment work technical assessment policies
products
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
39
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
40
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
41
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
42
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
43
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
44
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
45
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
Other learning activities
Assessment
46
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
47
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
48
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
49
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
50
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
facilitates collaboration,
communication, and individual
empowerment to insure
mission success
7.2.3 Team Meetings Contribute to the outcomes of Plan, lead and facilitate (for a Establish a system’s technical Establish a program’s
a. Plan effective technical technical team meetings to subsystem or simple project) team meeting’s requirements technical team meeting’s
team meetings enhance success effective technical team that align with the program’s requirements to ensure mission
meetings requirements success
b. Facilitate effective
technical team meetings Plan, lead and facilitate (for a Plan, lead and facilitate (for a
system) effective technical program) effective technical
team meetings leadership team meetings
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
51
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
52
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
53
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
including system quality, • Plan for the subsystem, reliability and maintainability, Assurance policy and
reliability and Able to follow Safety and including system quality, that complies with NASA procedures (for a program
maintainability Mission Assurance plan as it reliability and maintainability, safety and mission and/or Agency)
c. Develop Safety and relates to technical activities for that complies with NASA assurance strategies,
a subsystem safety and mission policies, and standards
Mission assurance
assurance strategies, • Implementation strategies
implementation policies, and standards
strategies • Implementation strategies Review system safety and
mission assurance activities for
subsystems
8.2.4 Safety and Mission Contribute to: Contribute to preparing for Lead (for a system) the Chair engineering and safety
Assurance Reviews • Safety and Mission and participating in: activities to prepare the system review boards:
Assurance Readiness • Safety and Mission for and participate in: • Safety and Mission
a. Prepare for and
Review Assurance Readiness • Safety and Mission Assurance Readiness
participate in Safety and • Program Audit and Review Reviews Assurance Readiness Reviews
Mission Assurance process • Program Audit and Review Reviews • Program Audit and Review
Readiness Review • Certificate of Flight process • Program Audit and Review process
(SMARR) Readiness process • Certificate of Flight process • Certificate of Flight
b. Prepare for and Readiness process • Certificate of Flight Readiness process
participate in Program Readiness process
Audit and Review
(PA&R) process Participate in review boards
c. Prepare for and for other projects and programs
participate in Certificate
of Flight Readiness
(CoFR) process
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
54
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
55
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
56
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
subsystem leads to insure
quality and accurate reporting
of technical information
Communicate technical
information from a variety of
data sources that is targeted to
a particular audience and
provides an evidence-based,
comprehensive account of a
phenomenon concerning
systems engineering issues
related to a system
9.2.3 Interpersonal Demonstrate skills in: Apply appropriate skills for Apply appropriate skills for Create an environment that
Communication • Speaking and writing (both using a variety of media to using a variety of media to facilitates positive
formally and informally) for effectively communicate effectively communicate communication approaches
a. Demonstrate skills in technical information about a technical information about a within the technical workforce
understanding
speaking and writing • Demonstrate skills in subsystem system of a program
(both formally and listening for understanding
informally) for Promote communication Promote communication Communicate and advocate
understanding approaches that establish an approaches that establish an information regarding technical
b. Demonstrate skills in open and positive environment open and positive environment information to high levels of
listening for within a subsystem’s technical within a system’s technical Government and pubic media
understanding team team
57
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
58
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
system) a collaborative and positive recognition, and
open work environment within collaboration
the system’s technical team
9.3.3 Decision-Making Participate in a technical Manage a subsystem’s Manage a system’s technical Establish the technical
and Solving Problems team’s decision-making and technical team’s decision- team’s decision-making and workforce decision-making and
problem solving activities making and problem solving problem solving processes problem solving processes for
a. Define problem processes technical activities for a
b. Establish solution criteria Understand and follow the Lead (for a system) the program
c. Evaluate alternatives technical team’s decision- Lead a subsystem’s technical system’s technical team in
d. Determine solution(s) making and problem-solving team in decision-making and decision-making and problem Create an environment that
based on facts, processes problem solving activities solving activities encourages consensus
evidence, criteria and building, as well as minority
risk Employ team decision-making opinions, and results in
Evaluate and select among techniques that foster decisions that are based on
alternative approaches, consensus building, while sound evidence
concepts, architectures, etc. allowing for minority opinions,
and resulting in evidence- Employ analytical decision-
based decisions making tools and knowledge
within a systematic framework
to make effective evidence-
based decision
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
59
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
60
ACADEMY OF PROGRAM/PROJECT & ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP
appropriate users appropriate users processes for the Agency
concerning the capture of and
access to work products
HQ courses
Center courses
OJL activities
Other learning activities
Assessment
61