Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Research Paper - Diorka y Leydi1
Final Research Paper - Diorka y Leydi1
Final Task:
Research
Submitted by:
Leidy De la Cruz
Diorka Linette Mendoza
Date:
Junio, 2021
San Pedro De Macorís, Dom. Rep.
Spanish-speaking English learners´ perception of Explicit
Instructions of Phonetics
Content
1.2.1 General................................................................................................................................3
1.2.2 Specific...............................................................................................................................3
1.3 Justification............................................................................................................................3
3.4 Procedures............................................................................................................................14
Conclusion................................................................................................................................23
Recommendation.....................................................................................................................25
References.................................................................................................................................26
Appendix...................................................................................................................................28
1
The teaching of foreign languages has undergone great changes in recent years.
Didactic renewal, which has been reflected in the development of the communicative
approach, the first to establish learning objectives aimed at oral and written communicative
competence.
Although language teaching has improved, students still have difficulties expressing
themselves and understanding native speakers, especially when their contact with the foreign
language is reduced to three hours of class per week. These difficulties could be related to the
phonetics.
As teachers we are concerned about this contrast in the domain of the various skills;
Improving the results in the domain of oral skills and matching them to the written ones seems
convinced that achieving better results in oral language, seen from both production and
Faced with this, the current trend in the educational field of foreign languages is to
Despite the advances and innovations that have occurred in foreign language teaching, it is
believed that pronunciation continues to be neglected and that it does not receive adequate
treatment (Kirkova-Naskova, 2019). This is partly due to the fact that teachers do not know
how to integrate the teaching of pronunciation into the communicative approach or the most
recent task-based approach, because, on the one hand, they lack materials and there have been
2
no proposals to integrate the pronunciation in these approaches and, on the other hand,
manuals and existing activities do not separate pronunciation from phonetic correction and,
therefore, its integration into the communicative class is impossible and it can only be
presented as an annex or appendix that does not bear any relation to the development, content
and focus of the classes. Consequently, pronunciation remains the pending subject of foreign
language teaching.
The above mentioned raises interest in determining how students perceive the
instruction of phonetics in their english class in order to identify areas of improvement in the
subject.
2- Which strategies does the literature suggest to teach effectively phonetic to Spanish-
speaking students?
speaking students
1.2.1 General
instructions.
1.2.2 Specific
1. Identify factors that students think affect the improvement of pronunciation in their
English lessons.
Spanish-speaking students.
1.3 Justification
In all areas and social spheres, the English language has taken on great importance in
such a way that it has been called the international language par excellence. Regarding your
teaching, the sound of the words is very important if you want to establish good
communication.
pronunciation. English as a second language learners tend to transfer all knowledge of sounds
in their native language to English as a second language. This phenomenon contributes to the
perception of the foreign accent and, as a result, can decrease the intelligibility or
with native-like precision is often a personal choice; What is clear, however, is that certain
4
communication errors can occur due to lack of phonological awareness in second language
learning.
Therefore, knowing the perception that English students have in the explicit
instructions of phonetics is relevant, since the information that phonetics offers to students is
essential for them to understand any conversation or instruction in English and not have the
barrier that supposes a bad pronunciation and they can get to feel insecure when speaking in
this language. The results of this research could serve as input to make pertinent adjustments
in the educational curriculum, which allow the implementation of the teaching of phonetics
second language from the very beginning of their studies. studies, and thus strengthen the
linguistic bases.
5
Population
Specific objectives Techniques Responsible Materials
of studio
Identify factors that Leidy De la Closed
students think affect the Cruz question
improvement of Comments guide
pronunciation in their Diorka Linette 15 studens
English lessons. Mendoza
The extent to which explicit phonetic instruction helps learners improve their L2
(SLA) research has been conducted on L2 speech learning, very little has been applied to
explicit phonetic instructions for L2 adult learners. One of the real challenges is to bridge the
gap between theory and practice, given the disconnection between research in L2 phonetics
With regard to explicitness of L2 learning, many SLA theorists argued that the first
step for effective instruction is to have learners to become consciously aware of formal rules
interlanguage development (Schmidt, 2001). In this respect, (Dekeyser, 2003) emphasised the
treatment is explicit if rule explanation forms part of the instruction (deduction) or if learners
are asked to attend to particular forms and try to find the rules themselves s (induction)”.
James Flege’s Speech Learning Model (SLM) claims that target-like perception of the
empirical research linking perception to production in many different language pairs (M.,
2005); (Newman, 2012). The SLM posits that to fully acquire L2 sounds learners must first
discern subtle phonetic differences between L2 sounds and analogous sounds in the L1 as they
occur in a variety of phonetic environments, at which point learners can create new phonetic
categories for L2 sounds and then finally produce the L2 sounds in target-like ways (Flege,
1995) Though there is some evidence inconsistent with the predictions of the SLM, namely
that learners may produce contrasts they cannot perceive and may demonstrate different
acquisitional patterns in the perceptive and productive modes , still the SLM is the model most
7
commonly used in research on adult, instructed L2 speech, and it motivates the methodology
(Munro, 2008) They characterize the nature of the link in different ways, but stated in general
terms, some attentional detection (perception) is thought to be necessary for further processing
and storage in long-term memory which, in turn, contains the phonological knowledge used
for production.
Several investigations of the effect of phonetics instruction in the context of the current
study, adult Spanish FL, report generally positive results. These studies, detailed in Table 1,
find that learners improve their production of some difficult Spanish phones after receiving
phonetics instruction, but none addresses perception. One Spanish FL study to date has
measured changes in perception after phonetics instruction and reports that learners are better
able to detect non-target-like realizations of some Spanish phones, but not of the stops /p, t,
k/ . Clearly much more research is needed to better understand the impact that phonetics
instruction might have on Spanish FL learners’ perception. The present study aimed to do just
that. The research question was: Does instruction in L2 phonetics improve learners’ ability to
perceive the acoustic differences between L2 phones and their analogous L1 phones? Rather
task paired Spanish phones with analogous English phones, because the Speech Learning
Model predicts that a necessary first stage in L2 speech acquisition is being able to discern the
needs to be better integrated into communicative activities (T., 2009).Alternatives for bringing
learners’ attention to the L2 sound system, perhaps through targeted exposure, focused
listening, dictation, transcription, or other means, should be explored and weighed against the
varied strategies. Although there has been a great deal of research on communication
strategies, the studies have not dealt with L2 pronunciation per se, but rather they have
concentrated on speaking in general. However, some of the strategies that appear in most
circumlocution, and word coinage). Not only have these strategies been linked with
communicative success in several studies found that instruction in paraphrase results in the use
of a greater range of paraphrase types, that is, instructed L2 students were able to access
significantly more alternatives than participants in a control group. Despite the attention
devoted to learner strategies in recent years, few commercial pronunciation textbooks include
approaches to EFL pronunciation learning and the concern for building communication skills
are renewing interest in the role that pronunciation plays in EFL learners’ overall
9
communicative competence. These strategies can help learners develop pronunciation goals
and check their progress toward achieving those goals (Gilakjani, 2012):
prosodic training in instruction and They might begin with listening activities.
stress, and pitch. These exercises will help learners recognize the difference between stressed
3. Focus on Unstressed Syllables: Use function words. Introduce weak forms through
the grammatical category of function words, such as articles, pronouns, auxiliary verbs, and
prepositions. Allow learners to practice using weak forms in conversations in order to simulate
competence is the aim of pronunciation teaching and learning, is necessary for meaningful
communicative tasks in the language classroom, including those that focus on pronunciation.
Pronunciation exercises that relate to daily use of English include role-plays of requests that
Improving the students’ English pronunciation highly depends on the chosen teaching
strategies, i.e. the teaching plan adopted by the instructor in order to achieve his/ her goal. The
strategies employed for teaching are: topic introduction; brainstorming; presentation and
discussion of the topic, both deductively and inductively; controlled practice: listening to
recordings of native speakers in order to get the meaning, the correct pronunciation of sounds,
the stress, rhythm and intonation; repetition; drills; reading aloud; role-plays; recording
students’ PowerPoint presentations on certain topics in which the taught information is used;
The followings are the techniques that are used in the research-based approach for
pronunciation instruction. I would like to put them in a table format for illustration purposes.
Techniques used for pronunciation instruction in (Robin C.Scarcella, 1994); (Wei, 2006).
Techniques Contents
Tutorial Sessions and Self-Study These begin with a diagnostic analysis of each
student’s spoken English and an individualized
program is designed for each student.
Modeling and Individual Correction Report the results of analyses of student speech
sample individually.
Written Versions of Oral Presentations In the more advanced levels, students can be
given strategies for analyzing the written
versions of their oral presentations.
Incorporation of Novel Elements Using novel elements with the use of directions.
is not totally dependent, but reciprocal. Even highly experienced L2 learners may produce
training in the perception in production segmental and suprasegmental aspects of L2, that is,
phonetic training is one of the factors that affects L2 learners' pronunciation. Positive impact
outcome seems to support the interaction hypothesis, which proposed that target use in
accuracy is often a personal choice; what is clear, however, is that certain miscommunications
may occur due to lack of phonological awareness in the second language. Language learners
must develop concern and awareness for pronunciation because unintelligible speech resulting
from inadequate phonological accuracy causes mutual frustration and unpleasantness for both
listeners and speakers. In related studies, (Gravois, 2005) pointed out instances of
nonnative English-speaking instructors. To avoid such instances, the second language learner
must be able to identify and use the linguistically significant phonemes of the language
language learners pronunciation are not anonymous with respect to age being a crucial factor
in second language acquisition, acquiring a second language in early childhood can result in
native-like second language pronunciation, this study showing that late starters cannot achieve
This is an exploratory work based on a mixed approach that seeks to collect data to
demonstrate the reality of college students with regard to the instruction of phonetics in their
13
English Class. By a quantitative approach, data about the strategies used to expose learners to
phonemic features will be recorded. Moreover, this method will serve as a means to identify
The group targeted to carry out this research is the group enrolled in English
Immersion Program in the period 2021. Two out of the four centers that carry out the program
in San Pedro will participate in the survey, which gives us a group of 300 students and 8
teachers across the two centers. A representative sample will be chosen based on Laura
Fischer’s formula which determines that the right number of students participating in this
project should be 170. This was obtained after doing the operation with a 95% of feasibility, a
5% margin of error, and probability divided in 50%. All the teachers active in the program will
Due to conditions of the health emergency due to Covid-19, social distancing has to be
order to learn their thoughts on how phonetics is approached in their study centers and their
feelings toward the activities listed. The answers will be recorded in a google form that had
3.4 Procedures
Once the data has been collected, it will be processed in a spreadsheet in order to
classify answers based on similarities and discrepancies among participants with regard to the
Below are the results of the applied survey, for Determine the perception of Spanish-
Answers Fr. %
a) Male 11 70 %
b) Female 4 30 %
Total 15 100
According to the analysis of the data obtained, 30% of the interviewees are female and
70% are male. These results indicate that the students of the polytechnics surveyed are mostly
male.
The table shows that half of the people interviewed are 16 and 18 years old and the
other half 12 to 16 years old, which represents a segmentation of very different ages, therefore
these ages understand if they have difficulties in learning the English language and be able to
say what the needs are to improve this situation and thus young people learn this second
language faster.
16
Answers Fr. %
a) Dominican 15 100%
b) Haitian 0 00%
c) Other 0 0%
Total 15 100
The nationality of the students surveyed is 100% Dominican. This question was
important to ask, since in our country currently many nationalities of people who emigrate
looking for new ways of experiencing themselves and thus verify if nationality influences the
a) Ascending 12 80%
b) Descendant 3 20%
c) Not responding 0 0%
Total 15 100
The level of motivation for learning the English language of the students surveyed is
80% upward and 20% descendant. Here it is indicated that the factors that most affect the lack
of motivation to learn of the students surveyed are, in the first place, the lack of understanding
of this language, as well as influencing place is the teaching method of the teacher, indicated
Total 15 100
Among the factors are with a 10% lack of understanding of the language and 90%
teaching method of the teacher. The teacher must offer the students the didactic scientific
organization of the process of conscious knowledge explaining the purposes and tasks of the
work to be carried out, the ways to carry it out and, thus, to arouse the interest and attention of
The opinion that respondents have of the teaching materials used by teachers, is with
90% little and 10% say that they are not used. The use of resources incorporated into good
teaching practices can have good potential to improve the understanding of concepts; to
The consideration that the students according to the data thrown are with a 20% says
yes, the 60% a little and the remaining 20% says no. It is necessary that the teacher can create
in the classroom an atmosphere that invites everyone to investigate, to learn, to build their
learning, and not just to follow what he does or says. The role of the teacher is not only to
provide information and control discipline, but to be a mediator between the student and the
environment.
The importance of the environment according to the data is with 30% consider it
important and 70% say that it does not. As for the environment that is reflected with its
students are the recovery of knowledge, play, as well as debates, socialization, group work
among others. However, the strategies that give them the most results are the innovative ones,
solving complications, the game among others. Also sharing knowledge, problem solving,
cognitive strategies
19
Students surveyed consider the techniques the teacher uses for classroom assessment to
be excellent, 17% say it is excellent, 32% say it is very good, 17% say they accept them and
the remaining 32% say they are deficient. Educational evaluation is a central element within
the field of English teaching, it can focus on a technical conception of educational processes,
within which are the verification of the achievement of the objectives of the contents offered,
as well as the verification of the acquisition of the theoretical approaches granted by the
teacher.
Within multimedia resources students say that teachers use it only a little with 45%,
40% say no and 20% do not respond. The integration of technological resources into the
school curriculum is a gradual process that is linked to several factors the technological
resources themselves; the availability and correct use of appropriate digital content; the
The use of devices in the classroom is with 80% affirmative and 20% say no. The use
of mobile devices in the classroom is becoming more widespread. These elements offer great
advantages from the didactics in the different areas, in the particular case of learning a second
language expands the vocabulary and allows the teacher to generate new strategies to
In encouraging class participation, 40% say frequently, 20% say sometimes and the
remaining 40% say never. Student participation in class is critical and has multiple benefits.
21
Answers Fr. %
a) Yess 8 50%
b) Maybe 8 50%
c) Not 0 0%
Total 15 100
The students surveyed consider that the extension of class hours is with 50% if and the
remaining 50% with 50%. Learning a language is something that really requires a lot of
Answers Fr. %
a) Yess 11 70%
b) Not 5 30%
Total 15 100
The consideration on the levels of English available is with 70% yes and 30% say no.
Some English level systems are integrated into a particular English exam, while others consist
Answers Fr. %
a) Professional quality 0 0%
Total 15 100
As for the factors that prevent the learning of the English language in the students
surveyed is with 40% the way to evaluate, 40% the state of the structure of the classrooms and
Conclusion
the individual, this implies that he will be able to communicate in any circumstance of daily
life. It will also contribute to forming a critical, autonomous and respectful subject of plurality,
capable of appreciating other cultures while strengthening one's own; it should also assess the
The teaching and learning process of English has undergone enormous modifications
in the last twenty years, especially in the early nineties due to the inclusion of Information and
Communication Technologies (ICT's) for its teaching, possibly it will be necessary to design a
special didactics for its use and application to the teaching of English.
Teachers of foreign languages must have a good command of the language they will
use as a vehicle for instruction. On the other hand, it is very advantageous that the teacher also
has a good command of the first language of the students, since he will have to assess the
The English language has become a necessity for those who do not master it, as it
becomes more important every day in the world of work and in daily life. In the country for
decades this language has been given a lot of value, so much so that there are companies that
require its management to fill their vacancies and the centers or training programs is quite
what can be said, since methods are constantly created and spaces are enabled so that
The socio-economic reality of the students is very humble since the sources of work
are very limited, the students who attend this center are from families of scarce economic
resources, approximately seven percent of the population does not have any academic degree,
not even primary studies which makes education more difficult in the students.
24
The teacher must assume a role of facilitator and guide but must also feed back and
encourage their students and see that their thinking is evolving, always trying to stimulate and
develop logical reasoning. It should encourage exploration and research, arouse curiosity,
expose them to different points of view by encouraging them to make their own decisions. In
short, you should try to create habits of thought, predisposing them to research and discovery.
As far as English is concerned, the fundamental problem in our province is the lack of
teacher training in some areas. It would be convenient for the applicability of this educational
project, to make a survey and study the feasibility of teaching English throughout the territory,
Recommendation
To students
1. Take advantage of the time, paying attention to their classes, clarifying aspects that they do
not understand about the tasks, practicing the languages under study with their teachers and
peers.
2. Take time out, be it at work the home to study, focusing more on the quality of time than on
the quantity.
To teachers
1. Propose didactic methodologies aligned to the characteristics of the current student body,
which entails more work in the classroom and the complementary use of Information and
motivation in classes with means that the young student body likes.
1. Ensure the quality of teaching in the classroom, having a better control of the fulfillment of
References
Chen, H.-Y. (2009). The impact of phonetic instruction on the oral proficiency of english
Flege, J. E. (1995). Second language speech learning Theory, findings and problems. New
York.
Learning and the Strategies for Instruction. International Journal of Humanities and
Social Science.
Gravois, J. (2005). Teach impediment: when the student can´t understand the instructor.
Virginia, USA.
M., A. (2005). Auditory perception as a factor for the acquisition of sounds L2. México, D.F.
Munro, M. N. (2008). Aptitude for novel speech and sound sequency: implications for second
instruction. Elsevier.
Şimon, S. (2014). Strategies for Improving The English Pronunciation of The 1st Year
strategies. Canada.
Wei, M. (2006). A Literature Review on Strategies for Teaching Pronunciation. Non- Journal.
28
Appendix
explicit phonetics instruction during the lesson. Data collected by this means will exclusively
be used for educational purposes, guaranteeing that respondents’ information will not be
Mark with an x (equis) the answer that best suits your opinion.
1. Sex:
(a) Male
(b) Female
2. Age range:
(a) 12-18 years
(b) 18 to 20 years
(c) 20 or more
3. Nationality
(a) Dominican Republic
(b) Haitian
(c) Other Which one? _________________
5. Which of these factors do you consider to affect the lack of motivation in learning the
English language of students?
(a) Lack of understanding of the language
(b) Method of teaching the teacher
6. Do you believe that the teaching materials used for teaching the English language are
suitable for the learning needs of the student?
(a) Yes
b) A little
(c) No
(d) Not responding
29
7. Do you consider that the learning techniques and strategies used by the teacher
promote motivation to study the English language?
(a) Yes
b) A little
(c) No
(d) Not responding
8. Do you think that the environment in which English is taught is appropriate to your
needs?
a) Yes Why?____________________________________________
b) No Why? ____________________________________________________
9. Consider that the assessment techniques used by your current teacher are:
a) Excellent
b) Very good
c) Good
(d) Acceptable
(e) Deficient
12. What could you say about the evaluation techniques your teacher uses are?:
(a) Easy to understand
b) Not so easy
c) Enrich your knowledge
d) They do not help the development of your knowledge
(e) Other
13. Does your teacher encourage participation in technology class to support your
learning in the language?
(a) Always
(b) Frequently
(c) Sometimes
(d) Never
30
14. Do you think that the hours and days of classes of English language teaching should
be extended further?
(a) Yes
(b) Perhaps
(c) No