Megaling A a. Wh wyeuhe seuttary amita GR Nd. SMUT , duly toy Zo corpio, J, ny Man original Bohm fir the mk of cerworari and — po hibition. In [4b/, bong Head pesled ; kA So ottm Orarhing phe having — haselnes op the Philip pines a On Archi pelagic Crk. fai [an ffitend the pramng sf the Bawemtisn fae Tome gota eq md the. = Contignoug one th M69 C UNE I), edifying, among hod, yh€ frere- Tah of Sad over their Fenton cea, the breadth ohith, brvtrer, WAS leet VAdetermined. Hemp oh AN Yai Tat daring pre ar oud neg shahind in btm gq tn tbo Cunthog A) pred petite! tons domeahilly , kA 4946 remained Unchanged for rear) Pie decade, sare fe begin abe pasica hm eR, comeeging type grap ital enerr md ratnirg fhe Aranahy A badctines brung Sabah inno Bren.Ih su, congress menaed.... PA. Ie by rag RA S72, tue change Wad prompted ses by re need fe ride KA 406 corpliant ae een te eb TES phitipytned nt ed 6m. FEMANY 24 “frag: thes, Nae 4 othe, Ye Abe. and rahis 7 leap AA ma ok ths petagll, Sates ke toe Philippe Cen the. drid ne Pte. flog of spplt cnn fe the feted. corppnontal Vhelg- “pa 928- shodmed....fhe... CUE 1 Sprite he (acatron of Shee valeprintr arena) fre Philippine areh'perage ama _olsasi Peal —adjnuerk —_fenTonias 10 regimes of 19 Nrald _ guerak herr Ph appli abe raring vontds stat whether or not RAASAQ VV ame rth tha). Ruling a eno. UNCLO] M nag — nothing h ee Yat sequigifim or a) tribry i : ju oa wodi freq —nirm eat negulatee the oon dug of state. seee ee dente prinds alerng CoAtts senting AL. eda. a charting. pei. RA. arte: able. dnd cms Yaad enferee__owr claims... TRE... Ke, Scarborough hod ana Sabb “tne Fipreme Court. “aamied the PoP.Opora tr. — Fattran, vr. ie Re Nd, [01083 July 3, 19Q3 Phen ocak a ye a Ie ay) taxpayer's lass Suit ay : minors Juan pobnio Opera, et.al, uly reprdenka and joined bY __ their respecte parents, and resenting — hein genera~ unbom preying Yat oraering the defendant ; hic agen’, reprutaitives ard oor pects akg: ia Ail behalf b — : . : (Cancel a Yion and gene rations yet ua ment be Rendered all exesting thn ber lilense «= Agreement ih te Country 3 (2) ceare ard —atesil pom receiving , acct png, : procesting ) renening o opening = new Fin bee ; licensing Ggrement. o and granting — tH puinfty ouch ote relies putt and equitable Undenire ine ep ramie They alleged that ey hay 4 clear and ont tutional dgnt wp a walanced ang hea |/tAfuy ecology ana an enti fe profecttn by vat, chek Cpayly pres pata ard thot the Aefenclant’y ———_Osntihued refwal tonneWe finber Manntikg 4g ren enite Ch he Gonetitchinay ply ot He Sink prt ana ovate we right dhe roe eet ae Se et fed th te nly lh are barmany fate, Under “ aedtin le, Ace T oof He ney Concha. __Twfhemmore, they craim ——tthe tot He aefenaant = ih_—alfoming fre btmber “‘Mensng getienanty bole fe, wt and alerts He —tenahing : pop Dons hides Oe ‘ma syzpnpriatin amd / o impaiment if ee . natal Pepburets prey etal talk in eb At of: the inti. oibers ane “uce ting the poittneny hare legal standing. 16, The Court finds affratty ah rly Kat porhings fr Premselneg , Tr thers — of ofhuih_ gen trartin and pr othe euctcaihg generations ’ the 4 fas cut Their pertnaliy sue th vehalp of he auctediegLigerefos om nly fe te once of ___ nteegeneratonay “retpsre billy infra he okt ba balanced ard baba! ewigy @ eortemed. : _ftrtinafter capinded consi olte. . Nature means uch a ight, a Ye “nny tin and farmny of — natire," jae crea tea worl th its Cobrrety. Sick rythm and harmony __tndicpers ably inchuate Ie i fe suoli eros dilpesition , utilization , management , ren@rial and Cander— farkm the countys Busty mineral, land, water and ofhep = ahi) fiheriet , wildlife , off chore eas a Pein exploration dorelop~ oer mee ubileakin t equi'ta bly accestible t the oe pent a nell as fiw Genera. weedlien ao vay, “ery «generation har a teeponsite ity te the next te prereset Pym and armory fh Ke $id J eisyment oa balance and hea Hkfa/ cuslogy « pt With difectly he mi auterhin of Pit atte differently the mihont’ Hae hE pmvate On cencd akong 1» MMDA Ce ae oR. no. I7/997- 4@ , peember Ie, 209 Vuarw 7 hy J raed On Sanuary 24, 1904, Conctmed Ores af Manilg Bay fed 4 osmplaint — bere. he KI th mas, Cavite agained — Sereral gvemment Agena’ , arorg wen iamoa, pr She Clan up , Nhalnlidatty amd prectiin of Manila Bay. he complain} alleged fat fhe tent quality of the “Oni bay Mal ality = blew the Gab /€ san- dGras SA bg law petifically fd Iix?. The Maporaerty , ay lantnffr, preyed dap Prmen be ordered bh tam he Manila fay 4nd Sim} ty tne RIL 4 Len ee plan of acnen fr Purple . Tre Rit deuded th Taner af ra parderte ang edertd fhe — defendan} - atrernmen} agoneter to tam up an, neha tale pania ar] Te p6hh ners arqued — Lthrt the A D 2° ready op the deani, af Eee far as nop : Aeaming ih foeal. They Alo ad Ataring the’ Mami, Bay W "hot onthierin ard buy, Canns — be np ted bY hongomus., |Sue Whethe, — 6r nob A , pet mere Corn ule, rt ea oe mardamug fp cfean up the RULING Scope = MMbAY Auty bn the aren of“guid raake atepbla) ik SC irk not Ory ho PD Ita ana KA 963, ut th A Ker a wen. = Thi7 ay ann} be Charadfentea «4 AR oes ona for dl oehtn Uppeler fre power & night : given by law G. Ra ophraal aucrding oh their salynent ar havrérer, The ty Ve charter of toned would Weld tr eae frat ok oi ey ate enjoined , 1 4 mw Statury okligahtn fh pedrin— Lertnih qincinl plating” hed by or Indi h the Aran u 4 we manila Bay. Trey are pre~ Olude fom — chetling mt perforin rede audits.De elena herpes oh a OT ue Uns, 444 7 1909 gustite tolmes - Thi Was Qh opplicatisn to the Philippine court of lard resickation hr phe regichatn of certath land. the “application was grank de y the Court on march 4, 106 hn apat Mes tate te he Sted toe ft Infante rower Bagi, th ena ot he erroment 3. dhe. Pilani, ard allo behalt he Unie Jokes «Bote __ pamnents = hava taken posession of the paprty pw ard military purpekes. the mati) fat — ford ave nrg fev. The appli Gita plainteff Ih erm am Igor af te = Prdce of Berquet , her, He lana let Por more han fatty Yeas bere the fheaty Farid, Api’, 18-99, pr tick » Ke fr alitgy Gs thes pA ttf and ancestors NA fd he dead as net «HL Grandfather faq lived pon ib, and : mained fences Mbp nt fe te hol ing of Othe _ aueeding th he aed Asimy 6. at tig Gury , fme Fhe fences pik :ueemy_,_hamihg Pen of muh —earlite dak . thd fit, hah culkvad gna bad wie part for posturing Catt, and had sed it fr path mr hi? fun, “They all had been rio griyeg aa = mete = by he poke, and ke hog py how kd or eeeivted fee lad fom Aa fhe. mh atuardance — ath [goroh tutte. Ki potanene 6 Wie , fevers, ad Glued Tn the JSparith — Comm and Alttragh , in 1993 ~ (944 and aah mh 1097 , pe wade an apphcabon for Mt Mer fe ryal atecreed ten tr free, noibitg ceemy hare come of Th, unkee ~ perhapy, thfomatin —fhak land i penguer — csuld rot cance ta conta] ese be ruupre fr tnayon'um jhe, hed been cleriQhoded — ~ puapote aap haw been cwrited..oat. by he. Mp. grom men ard fee Umied fata . In (49, He plate flaia petam ; Aleying _pmrer eipe nator he nertgage Men aed fhe laote bry if fe him et tithing, ae i: a a Wee Af eheerg Fie, EN Bid. Sue Se ce erage ei eager ce enc eee bhetir om met fheuur Yes, peiti hat, all He ud iv Mige Whaterer pry sae boten the fechaniza of fhe Spah pty nt Pile he ly do he Ub he Nad noth ara wal a wee res palm abhor pratt gre meat citea bio lad. Te Ct eta —_faat arnt ana ought th bt 7 ie greet G Certainty , tn 9 care Me al, (oe fie oo) A dou b} mr ambiguity sh He Spanith ln, the urd seght fy homme pre HE apphing Yes Penekt 4 the au be. AACE jubice fe nahvd ard the Prpor of fe orghrit = act ought nod Carny bed beyod shbt, — examinatn of tn ent tut of u The land hined he fae mi 1 perkins ertn bey md te abi ful spantth lam, humane fhough I> wig, iF urnecediiy p dedde. plant? ad hi Greeting pad htiy Ke Al Senet, Tmey all hog been reg On Wherg by te [Goro ae heel Ketter phen ?eq — ™ receneof | lana hom bil Pathe COP ange | Vp rof astm, (Peano ee ee vt TE ccpeececrearal a - Oar CR, race J pertimed Gur and uripg — night il SUH} /Ssug Rurn § 1 NIE No. 135386, Obctmber 6, bo aacaitrg the Se ae 4 Cerfain PM - NL t Republic Aa 23°71, Her mC brain “w ee Ini gen peal spied fight hor 6 (417 (IPRA) aa ik zien9 rules PA wiaiths, The pefitne~ asta Ke aid — fatute) ana Ht tee om pe gua fAal hese. =» amount «= Pn unlawful asprivel as of he ky ownelthip ter a demain as met a) mineral 9A her t waucd herein. th vival, of pe airan aoihine — Urge ae «(RY Const uion, Seaton 2, Atle Xd. wheter pr not She fe IPRA viola the onh Mt iio. The asgiled prubny =o not con traelit The 1467 Gmshitin. —Xamining he IPRA 7, There N noting hn fhe My YAP rant; to the icles / IPS swmerr=p rte fhe Ratna pesBurced fhe —anetstral «= d6mainy — emalht yh Stite aq he righ tanta by PRA merely gia (Clr | Pe he night fh tht. mall seale — ubl atm of = Patse | eturte oh G prty pn their lage Scale dterclopmend emp) citation. \( Adattronaly, —ancertal andi ant domant are nef rt of rhe dandy of he pubic demain. : They are private lara belonging fh 1CC4/ Pr by native title -Pauince of Noth Ctabah vv, bovtenmend A ty fieyolbirt of ne Philippines CK. Nba. LR3TA), 1€37S2, 133893, 1839601 , 12941, 62 odvoer 4, eaog tac the — Pui ppinc fvernment ara fhe More elamit uUbverahm 4 CMILF) Nore Scheduled f sgh a Memsrardum of — Agreement 64 fhe —fincesral pomam = ped 4 fhe ERP - Mile Typpoll Agretin- onl 6n Peace of wr) jr uala Lumpur , Malay- gan Fugue — Se 209, Invoking foe right fp Infortahth on afera public” CRED 7 ef timed seek fo compel ie Kepordonfl P hivelele and funth rem ye np lefe and maa! bier sf the Men ~AD fl re Ww prhi bit Ye ulghing OF he MAh ~ AD and Ye ublic — oomyulpait, —frtresy . Pes pinen ale Stk hare fhe Mh -AD Aedlared unwhi~ +inpnal . Sug e whethor sr pop fhe WH-AD Unten Sh futibna/, UL . Se raid > yo prudling xf yne Mok- Ap, qe Supreme Curt yale frap they Cann} be Qiimsdatd wade the fect ConShtution and [ang NOE hiya STDate provciin but she very “‘opncept Unaerlyiig them . in fre. Maa -AD_ ultablishing fre bee the pid oad An cane ascsdiakive rdatindnp — between Te and yhe Central Sovermnent, Id « Hef, a Viblaon of Tae — Memorandum of Mhatracti ona from Math 1, Url, Added jhe Preident ¢ data fo he goeninent — peace, panel. Moreover, #4 fhe Clamse Dp nrded, 4 lina ean yaad SRE newesevairy Amendrerhe p Cendtituctien land my be pet / pac md theDate “amla rnnce oer v. ash bk, Nd. B2ISb, Feloruary 3, (497 Bellosille J. TACK IStUe Rung avr koverment Sevict Ihsur ance Hem (6519, aim = MD. > detded «Sel Yhrough publie lading fp STI of He ysded amd but ~ stanaing — share SF neuponddeng Mite. ne rnnihg bide?» w fhe Sventual Cap} “Tre Phil'ppthe tiveral Pe Bure - RULIM, Nb, While Shy Gonttimhon = mandaly the Gat PR oerice full conte! anq csupenignn oer whe exploiiatiin of — mineral reso urtey 7 Novhere does it fequie the goverment — tr ala“ al oy plorapiin permit — ad Similar autpprization In fat, Shere if ho prolibitivn at all gga frretgn dr Joa] pean OA tra ort Aéldtig Proton ano Por - TRE rae 2 no} herd ty See.Dirqugds ec SCGs, MA ESRA! M42. 1 a0 enaplor orton peri? merely grant 4 qualified perron the right ft Brault exp lora hw fir a! tncran fh Speifica = areaDate a Reidonp Wlinke | Mamnnle Keyes 6K, Nb, (12677) , Apri) le Zoe (eonardo - pe Cathey U-y scare £02, she philippe bart men 7 weed ah boop hystca Ji fara ge ploratbn — Orbea UAPEX - yn lanbadk prelts yar gerlogita Ya geophysical Spal eh A the win Straif- roy. JUipey and we fiom alll converte, iT i 7 Senice ae fr af See ey - men? = ana Auch of leum Ourced Zz ee nant 4 Limit. opfhore fhe Phan Sait. Pek pimen fed 4 complaint gain? yt eae fe tht sc fa vila 4 fhe Cath 1m. NUE hhesper ar the Mewaras Nare pre Standibg pr repraent amnall: Kuuné Yer. The Supreme Gourd Ih itt ruling hd the (And mart kul of = preedure ernn - neni! Cates whith ally Pr" Gen sult” and pormiftt any PlPiho un file An acim hepa or uur fir Wilahony “ur Sears land he rah nale cnr Je h re she pnruple that humans ame Strains