Professional Documents
Culture Documents
+ 2010 Organic Photonics For Communications
+ 2010 Organic Photonics For Communications
Photons as information carriers have the potential to meet the ever-increasing demands on bandwidth and information den-
sity in fields such as information and communication technology, biomedicine and computing. Organic semiconductors may
be well-suited to such applications, thanks to their ability to transmit, modulate and detect light in an architecture that is low
cost, flexible, lightweight and robust. Here we review recent breakthroughs in organic photonics, including ultrafast all-optical
modulation in polymer photonic crystals, silicon/organic hybrid systems, gain switching in polymer amplifiers and lasers, and
new devices such as hybrid organic/inorganic electrically pumped lasers.
I
n the field of optical communications, organic materials will prob- not be further considered here. We only remark on one particular
ably never replace standard inorganic materials and technologies recent breakthrough: the demonstration of fast OLED modulation
such as silica optical fibres (SOFs) and inorganic semiconductor (>60 MHz) using high-mobility polymers and small active areas
lasers and detectors. The combination of design and fabrication (0.018 mm2; ref. 14), which will be important for applications such
expertise, manufacturing infrastructure and strong market posi- as data communication.
tion makes these inorganic technologies unbeatable — not always In contrast with OLEDs, organic LETs are relatively new devices11
in performance, but certainly in price. However, there are applica- that have recently been enhanced by the discovery of ambipolar
tions for which inorganics are not ideally suited; those requiring, for transport in polymer materials15. Many hope that organic LETs hold
example, colour tunability, large active areas, mechanical flexibility the key to achieving electrically pumped organic lasers16,17, owing
or low-cost processing. Organics are a promising candidate for such to their high achievable current densities17 and to the fact that the
applications as they combine the material properties of plastics with recombination zone for light emission is spatially separated from the
high optical cross-sections, large and ultrafast nonlinear responses, electrodes, which is known as quench emission. However, organic
and broad spectral tunability. In terms of fabrication, they can be LETs have been extensively reviewed in refs 10,11 and so will not be
solution-processed at low cost, allowing large-area deposition (roll- discussed here in great detail.
to-roll or contact printing, for example) on non-standard substrates. OSLs, on the other hand, are a resurging field of interest in organic
In addition, because organics allow dipole optical transitions photonics18, and this is partly due to the ability of conjugated poly-
between confined states, they tend to have large optical cross-sec- mers to demonstrate efficient optically pumped lasing in the solid
tions (typically 10−15 cm2 for peak absorption, which provides a state. Ref. 19 gives an excellent summary of the variety of cavity con-
distinct advantage when interacting with light in either emission, figurations in which this has been demonstrated. Lasing has been
absorption or non-resonant modulation processes. achieved in solid, compact, distributed feedback (DFB) resonators,
We believe that the way ahead lies in complementing, rather than a schematic of which is shown in Fig. 1a. Figure 1b shows photolu-
replacing, standard inorganic technologies. Examples include recent minescence, amplified spontaneous emission and laser emission of
hybrid systems that exploit the properties of both organics and inor- a typical conjugated polymer film.
ganics1–4, or the use of plastic optical fibres (POFs) for short-haul The importance of such DFB periodic structures lies in their
data communication networks, in which glass fibres transport the ability to be readily incorporated into planar waveguides or POFs20
signal over long distances, saving the more flexible and robust POFs using simple soft lithography techniques such as imprinting (Fig. 1a).
for ‘last mile’ applications. Owing to the broad gain spectra of organics and also to the wide
This Review focuses on what we regard to be the latest develop- choice of lasing materials, DFB lasers are highly tunable throughout
ments in the use of organic materials in photonic devices, with a the whole visible spectrum21, even during operation22–25.
strong relevance to applications in communications. In doing this Breakthroughs in material26–28 and device29–33 design have led to
we leave out particular application areas such as organic light-emit- large increases in the efficiency of OSLs over the past decade. When
ting diodes (OLEDs) for displays, sensors, solar cells and nonlinear pumped with nanosecond pulses, for example, state-of-the-art DFB
optical materials (typically for second-harmonic generation), which polymer lasers operate with lasing thresholds as low as 3.6 W cm−2
are the subject of dedicated reviews and books5–12. We also exclude (36 nJ cm−2; ref. 29), allowing pumping with cheap inorganic diode
established materials such as organic dyes for lasing or photoconduc- lasers34,35 or even commercially available LEDs36 (Fig. 2). Recent
tors for printing, whose extensive application is well-established. work has exploited the large two-photon absorption cross-section of
polymers to demonstrate nonlinear pumping of a blue-wavelength
Organics as light sources laser 37. This opens the way to the pumping of blue lasers with low-
Organic light sources generally take two forms: electrical injection cost red diode lasers, creating hybrid electrically pumped polymer
OLEDs, or light-emitting transistors (LETs) and optically pumped lasers. The replacement of expensive bulky laser pump sources with
organic semiconductor lasers (OSLs). OLEDs are now commercially small solid-state diode lasers, which are commercially available and
available in displays13 and their science and technology are exten- extremely cheap, is a real breakthrough for potential applications
sively discussed in many reviews and books7–9; they will therefore because it promises compact, cheap organic sources operating at
1
Centre for Nanoscience and Technology, Dipartmento di Fisica, Italian Institute for Technology at Politecnico di Milano, Piazza L. da Vinci, 32, 20133
Milano, Italy. 2Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, J.J. Thomson Avenue, Cambridge CB3 OHE, United Kingdom. *e-mail: jc414@cam.ac.uk.
InGaN LED 3
CYTOP
2
Polymer ADS233YE 568 nm
m=0 m=2
Silica 1
Pump filter 555 nm
Laser output 0
Substrate 0 50 100 150
Peak drive current (A)
60
40 polymer, ADS233YE) laser. b, Light emission at 568 nm (blue circles) and
20
555 nm (orange squares) as a function of peak drive current from the laser
1
in a. Figure reproduced with permission from ref. 36, © 2008 AIP.
μm
2
3
0 1 2 3
μm combined with the first 16, is to use device configurations in which
Energy (eV) the emitting, recombination and transport zones are separated to
b 3.0 2.8 2.6 2.4 2.2 2.0 1.8 avoid charge quenching and quenching from the electrodes20. These
typically take the form of LETs, which have the added benefit of
1.0 higher achievable current densities than OLEDs16,17. Direct elec-
trical OSL pumping has not yet been achieved because of device
0.8 constraints, loss mechanisms (Box 1), and the fact that organic elec-
trical devices cannot operate fast enough to produce the nanosec-
Intensity output (a.u.)
Nonlinear responses S0
Intensity
the optical Kerr effect 110,111.
Gain
Stimulated emission occurs from the S1 level, and for las- Stimulated
emission
ing to occur we require amplification to be greater than loss.
Amplification depends on the stimulated emission cross-section
400 500 600 700 800 900
(typically 10−16 cm2), as well as the population inversion den- Wavelength (nm)
sity. A reduction in amplification through the depopulation
of singlets (a reduction in the population inversion density) Figure B1 | The optical properties of organics. a, Energy level structure
results mainly from annihilation processes and exciton disso- of organic semiconductors, showing charges, singlet excitons and triplet
ciation. Losses include ground-state ‘self ’ absorption, scatter- excitons. Vertical arrows are optical transitions, whereas wavy arrows
ing in the cavity and absorption from triplet and charge excited are non-radiative transitions, indicating vibrational relaxation (black),
states, whose absorption overlaps with the stimulated emission intersystem crossing (blue, with rate constant kISC), charge generation
(Fig. B1b) and whose long lifetimes allow significant population (red, rate constant kCT) or charge recombination (green, rate constant
build-up. krec). b, Idealized spectra of a common conjugated polymer. Note that
charge absorption overlaps spectrally with stimulated emission.
Optical gain modulation
Gain in conjugated polymers, if achieved, can be optically con-
trolled by re-exciting the material to the Sn level (typically using emission band (Fig. B1b). Recovery of the emission depends on
infrared or near-infrared light), causing charge generation at a the lifetime of the charges, which can be sub-picosecond owing
rate kCT. These charges quench the stimulated emission and gain to quantum confinement 85,86. This paves the way to all-optical
because their absorption spectrum overlaps with the stimulated logic in plastic media88.
measuring wavelength changes53,57. For example, if the laser is operat- However, over shorter distances, POFs made mainly from
ing at lasing threshold, small changes in the environment may switch poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) or perfluorinated (PF) poly-
off lasing, thus giving a large response to a small stimulus. mers such as poly(perfluorobutenyl vinyl ether) (CYTOP) are
Commercialization of organic semiconductor lasers for appli- taking over from copper cables as the demand for high-speed,
cations other than as short-lived disposable parts requires the life- low-cost connections increases58, for example in industrial auto-
times of organic materials to be significantly improved. This was the mation networks (PROFINET) and multimedia communication
case for OLEDs; the lifetimes were successfully improved and they in cars (MOST)59–62. In these applications, POFs are used instead
are now deployed in numerous commercial applications. In addi- of SOFs despite their higher attenuation (typically of the order
tion, the efficiency and threshold energy of these devices must be of 100 dB km–1) because they are more flexible61 (with a smaller
improved by reducing losses, with the aim of enabling CW lasing bending radius of 5 mm), have better tolerance to tensile load and
and possibly electrical injection lasers. stress63, are cheaper to produce and to install, and become less frag-
ile as their core radius is increased.
Transmission media Current data transmission rates in standard step-index POFs
Information can be transmitted over various distances. For exam- are typically hundreds of megabits per second over distances of
ple, SOFs are commonly used in telecommunications for long- ~100 m, but recent work has demonstrated that the goal of trans-
distance connections over hundreds of kilometres. They have ferring data at rates of gigabits per second is now becoming a
excellent characteristics for this, including low attenuation (typi- reality. This is due to the development of improved modulation
cally ∼0.2 dB km−1), high bandwidth and high transmission rates schemes (discrete multitone modulation), which have allowed
(up to 25 Tb s−1), thereby discouraging direct competition. transmission rates of 1.25 Gb s−1 over distances of ~100 m (ref. 62).
S1
Output intensity
60 3.2 eV 2.9 eV
LES LES S0
40
20
GS GS
‘Off’ state Polystyrene Dye
0
–2 –1 0 1 2 3 420 440 460 480 500
Time delay (ps) Wavelength (nm)
c d
π
Strip
0
Slot
OFF –π
–1 0 1 2 3 4 –2 0 2 4
Time (ps) Time (ps)
Figure 3 | Devices demonstrating ultrafast all-optical switching. a, Transmittance changes of a dye-doped polystyrene microcavity as a function of
pump–probe time delay, with an exponential fit (red line). Inset: schematic of energy levels, showing the locally excited state (LES) and ground state
(GS). b, Laser emission spectrum (red line) and emission when gate pulse is incident (green circles). Left inset: experimental set-up. Right inset: energy
level diagram. D± represent positive and negative charge states. c, Dynamics of stimulated emission in 2 mm of fluorene-doped POF (0.02% by weight).
Red circles denote only pump–probe measurements, and green circles denote pump–gate–probe measurements113. d, Nonlinear phase dynamics of a
silicon organic hybrid slot (green) and strip (red) waveguides. Dots represent measured values; thin solid lines are fits to the data. Figure reproduced with
permission from: a, ref. 83, © 2008 NPG; b, ref. 27, © 2009 AIP; d, ref. 1, © 2009 NPG.
Following pioneering work by Koike et al.64, further improvements Passive components. Organics are directly competing with silicon
have been made using graded-index (GI) POFs, in which the in this field, and although their transmission and optical confine-
refractive index between the core and cladding varies gradually to ment are generally lower than in silicon, organics offer the advan-
reduce modal dispersion58. Transfer rates of >40 Gb s−1 over dis- tages of temperature-independent operation, easy integration with
tances of ~100 m have now been demonstrated in GI-PF-POFs65, other components, non-planar devices and the possibility of creat-
which use expensive PF polymers such as CYTOP to reduce losses ing low-cost 3D structures. Three main techniques have emerged
from C–H vibrations. for the creation of polymer waveguides and other passive compo-
POFs are therefore becoming a tool not only for short-distance nents: direct writing 66,67, self-organization68 and soft-lithography 69,70.
data communication, but also for longer-distance applications, as Direct writing and self-organization offer the possibility of creating
well as for sensing and lighting. Step-index POFs are already used 3D structures simply and at low cost; for example, direct writing
in various technologies, and current research into co-extrusion uses nonlinear processes to ‘modify’ the polymer at the laser focus
offers the possibility of mass-producing GI-POFs in the not-too- to create a region of higher refractive index 66. Similarly, two-photon
distant future58. However, there are several problems that must be polymerization selectively polymerizes a material by exploiting the
addressed, including the increased cost associated with producing fact that two-photon absorption occurs only at the laser focus67. This
high-bandwidth GI-PF-POFs, and also the increase in attenuation allows the creation of high-resolution (micrometre-scale) 2D or 3D
over time as the polymer degrades. structures for use as on-chip waveguides, wavelength-division mul-
tiplexers, splitters and other passive devices. Lower-resolution 3D
Signal processing components structures such as polymer photonic crystals can also be achieved
Optical networks aim not only to transmit data using light, but also using the extremely low-cost self-organization technique68 or
to organize and process the signals all-optically (that is, without through one-photon polymerization71.
resorting to electrical processing), which complicates network lay- Another innovative application of organics is their use in large-
outs and creates bandwidth limitations. In such a role, both active area 3D displays, such as those demonstrated by Savaş et al.72, who
(amplifiers and modulators) and passive components are required. use a photorefractive polymer composite to create an updatable 3D
Normalized photovoltage
array 0.8 Grating
0.4
0.2
Focusing
Hemispherical lens
focal plane 1 cm 0.0
0 10 20 30 40
Pixel number
c 2.0 d 4.5
1.8
4.0
1.6
τ
Spectral responsivity (a.u.)
1.4 3.5
Photocurrent (pA)
1.2
3.0
1.0 19 fs
2.5
0.8
0.6 2.0
0.4
1.5
0.2
0.0 1.0
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 –60 –40 –20 0 20 40 60
Wavelength (nm) Delay (fs)
Figure 4 | Organic photodetectors. a, Top: schematic of the hemispherical organic photodetector focal plane array and its incorporation into a simple
imaging system. Bottom: photograph of such a set-up. b, Spectrum of an on-chip organic spectrometer as a function of pixel number. Inset shows the device
schematic, with photoluminescence waveguided to a grating and detected using an organic diode array49. OPD, organic photodiode. c, Organic colourimeter.
Photocurrent action spectra of the three organic photodiodes (dashed lines) in comparison with standard CIE 1931 colour-matching functions (solid lines).
d, Organic photodiode measures pulse duration with sub-20 fs resolution using an autocorrelation technique. Figure shows photocurrent vs time-delay
between two pulses (τ). Inset shows the schematic of such a set-up. Figure reproduced with permission from: a, ref. 98, © 2008 Elsevier; b, ref. 49, © 2009
EDP Sciences; c, ref. 104, © 2007 AIP; d, ref. 106, © 2009 RSC.
range. The use of hybrid systems offers significant advantages over on responsivity, which is relatively low (0.1–0.3 A W–1; refs 93,94)
systems that are completely inorganic. However, the losses intro- compared with silicon (0.6 A W–1).
duced by the organic materials must be further reduced before such Detectivity, dynamic range, spectral range and responsivity are
systems are commercially viable. all important figures of merit, and organic photodetectors fare well
here compared with common inorganic photodetectors. However,
Light detection lifetime, cost, speed and applicability are also important considera-
Owing to their large linear and nonlinear absorption cross-sections, tions. Component lifetime, an issue that once plagued the organic
and also to their semiconductor and mechanical properties, organ- display industry, is a significant problem that must be seriously
ics are well-suited to provide potentially low-cost, large area and tackled before organic photodetectors can be commercialized95.
flexible photodetectors for a wide variety of applications. Organic Nevertheless, organic photodetectors can operate well into the
solar cells, for example, are having much success at the moment. megahertz regime96, and are well-suited to applications requiring
However, they are covered in many reviews90–92 and so will not be large-area and non-planar devices. Such applications include the
further discussed here. Instead we concentrate on photodetectors, use of flat-panel polymer photodetector matrices in X-ray imagers
which have a greater relevance for applications in communication. for biomedical applications97, human eye mimicking vision sys-
Recent work93 has demonstrated a photodetector with tems98,99 (Fig. 4a) and also the placement of an organic photodetec-
a large spectral response (300–1,450 nm), high detectivity tor directly on the cantilever of a near-field scanning microscope100.
(1012−1013 cm Hz0.5 W–1) and a linear dynamic range (>100 dB), The low-cost nature of organics also allows them to be used for dis-
thus directly competing with silicon and InGaAs photodetectors. posable on-chip sensors7,49,101–103 (Fig. 4b) or data communications96,
This organic photodetector uses a bulk heterojunction structure and their chemical tunability allows tunable photo-action spectra to
of (6,6)-phenyl-C61-butyric acid methylester (PC60M) with a low- be obtained, which may be useful in colourimetry 104 (Fig. 4c).
bandgap polymer poly(5,7-bis(4-decanyl-2-thienyl)-thieno(3,4-b) In addition, multiphoton and multistep absorption transitions
diathiazole-thiophene-2,5) (PDDTT) as the active layer. The key to can lead to a nonlinear response in photocurrent. The most evident
obtaining such high detectivity was to significantly reduce the dark application of such nonlinear photodetectors, which rely on meas-
current using electron and hole blocking layers, rather than to rely urements of intensity and not energy, is for pulse autocorrelation,