Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The fact it's come back down so far so quickly suggests investors still have very little appetite to protect their
positions and portfolios via the options market.
"Have people given up hedging? Hedging seems to be a bad idea because you just end up losing money even on the
outcomes you're hedging against, such as Brexit or Donald Trump getting elected," says Citi's Matt King. "Up until
now, markets have always bounced straight back."
It's a similar picture, although not quite as stark, in currencies and bonds.
Deutsche Bank's currency volatility index is currently at 7.6, below the average over the last five years of 9.3, and the
one-month Mermove index of implied volatility in U.S. Treasuries 59.6, compared with the five-year average of 68.3.
HERD MENTALITY
Central banks' quantitative easing has shaped this mentality as investors have come to assume that central banks
will step in at the first sign of market turbulence or economic fragility, the so-called 'central bank put'.
The S&P 500 reached an all-time high of 2,872 points on Jan. 26 then lost more than 10 pct in the following two
weeks as the "volmageddon" shock ripped through world markets. But recovery has been steady, and it closed within
100 points of that peak on Friday. The booming tech sector boom lifted the Nasdaq to fresh highs on Friday too.
Trouble is, the herd mentality it has fostered means the entire market has the same volatility trade on. Selling and
being short volatility has been such a money-spinner, few are willing to go the other way. At least not yet.
There's no shortage of risks to hedge against, but that may be part of the problem. Hedging against every potential
risk is impossible, and prohibitively expensive. So if you think the central banks have your back, why bother?
That's been the story of the first half of the year, even as the Fed has continued raising rates and the 10-year
Treasury yield finally broke above 3 pct for the first time since 2011. Will it continue to be so in the second half of the
year?
Citi's King is sceptical, as are analysts at Morgan Stanley. They reckon implied volatility is too low and the return (or
carry) from selling vol offers an insufficient cushion for when volatility does turn higher. They advise going long
volatility.
A major variable will be the length of the economic cycle. Many analysts think the U.S. economy, with the labour
market its tightest in 50 years, by some measures, will soon roll over. But others, like those at Blackrock, believe the
growth cycle can continue for years to come.
"Bottom line, selling vol on equity, credit and rates looks quite challenging despite positive carry, unless one is very
optimistic on the longevity of the cycle," Morgan Stanley wrote in a report last month.
nL5N1TA4ED Copy to clipboard
© Thomson Reuters 2018. All rights reserved. Show more