Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- He sees the concept of childhood as a newly discovered idea, something, at least according to
him, that didn't exist in and before medieval times.
- He felt the families back then didn't really appreciate children and the value and importance
they brought into society.
- According to him, childhood was seen as just a normal phase in life that carried the same
level of importance as any other (as opposed to how its seen now)
3. What are some changes in the concept of childhood that the author describes?
- Culture of childhood : this new culture made people take more of an interest in the words
children said. There were some things that adults and children used to do together, like they
were enjoyed by both of them. Because people didn't see a difference in children and adults,
this is why. Now, things like fairytales and trick-or-treating are now only for children, as the
difference becomes more distinct.
- Children and sex : People's attitudes toward child sexuality was much more relaxed before the
17th century. After that the idea of coddling a child came into light to protect their sexual
innocence
5. How has the conception of the child changed over time? (describe at least 3 aspects)
- People used to see children as just miniature versions of adults. They were no different and
could be treated as such. They could do the same things and were expected to. Now they are
seen as their own people. They aren’t expected to do what adults do.
- Societies back then placed a lot more importance on the collective rather than the individual.
Once people started distancing themselves from others and living their own private lives, the
child became the center of attention
- Children were seen as people who wouldn't live past a certain age. It was normal for them to
die at a young age, and people wouldn't get too attached to them. But now child mortality is
rare and people put their children first in most aspects of life.
6. What are some of the criticisms other authors have made to Ariès? Why
- Critics argued that medieval societies did have an understanding of childhood, although it was
not great and fully accepted, they understood it nonetheless. The only reason we are able to
say they didn't not have an understanding of childhood, is because we do. If we didn't know
anything about it, then we would not have the knowledge, nor the credibility to argue
medieval societies did not understand childhood.
- A criticism is that he used aesthetic artifacts like artworks as evidence. Although he does
sometimes use schools and laws to prove his reasoning, most of his paintings and poems.
They criticise this because the problem lies in thinking that the artwork of that time was an
accurate representation and reflection of life.