Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00449-018-02064-8
RESEARCH PAPER
Abstract
In the present study, the effects of four different culture media on the growth, astaxanthin production and morphology of
Haematococcus pluvialis LUGU were studied under two-step cultivation. The interactions between astaxanthin synthesis
and secondary messengers, reactive oxygen species (ROS) and mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPK) were also inves-
tigated. In the first green vegetative cell stage, maximal biomass productivity (86.54 mg L−1 day−1) was obtained in BBM
medium. In the induction stage, the highest astaxanthin content (21.5 mg g−1) occurred in BG-11 medium, which was higher
than in any other media. The expressions of MAPK and astaxanthin biosynthetic genes in BG-11 were higher than in any
other media, whereas the ROS content was lower. Biochemical and physiological analyses suggested that the ROS, MAPK
and astaxanthin biosynthetic gene expression was involved in astaxanthin biosynthesis in H. pluvialis under different culture
media conditions. This study proposes a two-step cultivation strategy to efficiently produce astaxanthin using microalgae.
Keywords Haematococcus pluvialis · Astaxanthin · Two-step cultivation · Reactive oxygen species · Mitogen-activated
protein kinases
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
Materials and methods procedure was repeated as necessary until the pellet became
colourless. Total astaxanthin was spectrophotometrically
Microalgae strain and their culture conditions determined by measuring absorbance at 490 nm. All experi-
ments were conducted in triplicate. The astaxanthin content
The Haematococcus pluvialis LUGU for this paper was (mg g−1) was calculated according to the following equation:
obtained from Lugu Lake (27°42′N and 100°47′E) in Liji-
ang, Yunnan, China [25]. The seed cells were cultivated in C mg L−1 = 4.5 × A490 × Va ∕Vb ,
( )
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
its use as astaxanthin feedstock [29]; hence, the species was To study the influence of different media on microalgae
cultivated in four different culture media. during the induction phase, cultures were exposed to high
In order to optimize the alga biomass, H. pluvialis LUGU light intensities (100 µmol m−2 s−1) and incubated in four
was cultivated in CZ-M1, SE, BG-11 and BBM at its growth media without nitrogen for 15 days. The growth curves of
stage (Fig. 2a). The biomass concentration was found to be all cultures were determined (Fig. 3a). All cultures showed
highest in BBM media (1.38 g L−1), whereas the biomass some growth under induction conditions, where the highest
production was lowest in CZ-M1 (0.94 g L−1). The biomass biomass concentration (0.84 g L−1) was found in CZ-M1
production was at approximately the same level in SE and medium on day 13, and it was opposite to the first green
BG-11 media. The absence of Na2EDTA might be a cause stage. Lowest biomass production (0.47 g L−1) was observed
for the low biomass concentration in CZ-M1. Previous stud- in cells induced using SE. Under CZ-M1 medium, Fe3+ may
ies showed that adding EDTA can improve the solubility play a vital role in the cell growth. The growth rate of micro-
of metal ions and enhance their availability to microalgal, algae was stimulated by an increased bio-available iron con-
which evidently promotes biomass and metabolite accumu- centration [33]. Wan et al. [34] also recognized iron as a key
lation [30, 31]. Additionally, the highest biomass productiv- factor in regulating microalgae biomass. Additionally, there
ity was observed at 86.54 mg L−1 day−1 in BBM medium are few nitrogens in CZ-M1 relating to ammonia, and few
(Fig. 2b). This may be due to the presence of vitamins in carbon sources and vitamins in BG-11 and BBM, respec-
BBM medium. Ruangsomboon et al. [32] indicated that tively. However, SE medium has fewer nutrients than do the
the addition of vitamins, particularly vitamin B1, increased other three media. Therefore, a greater decrease in cell dry
the microalgae biomass. Therefore, BBM medium was weight was observed after induction day 11. Similar results
selected as a suitable growth medium for increased biomass were obtained in a previous study, which demonstrated that
production. nitrogen deficiency inhibits chlorophyll biosynthesis and
favours chlorophyll b degradation, chlororespiration and
cyclic electron transport, while cells cultured in high light
Effects of different induction media on growth are characterized by a higher destabilization of PSII [6].
and astaxanthin accumulation Moreover, the astaxanthin accumulation is often accompa-
nied by a reduction in cell density due to the influence of
The availability of nutrients is one of the main factors photooxidative stress [14, 35].
mediating the cell growth and metabolites accumulation in Astaxanthin accumulation was associated with algal cell
microalgae. The maximal astaxanthin content may not initi- morphology, and the colour in all cultures gradually changed
ate from the microalgae biomass with the maximal astaxan- (Fig. 4). Morphological observation showed that the green
thin concentration. Biomass production plays a key role in cell colour in all cultures began to diminish after inocu-
estimating microalgae astaxanthin production. Accordingly, lation. After 3 days of culturing, most cells became non-
it is vital to optimize medium composition appropriately to motile. On day 7, the cellular colour in the BG-11 medium
obtain the best astaxanthin content in microalgae species. became more visible and redder than in the others. On day
Fig. 2 Effect of different growth media on the cell growth (a), maximum biomass concentration (BC) and biomass productivity (BP) (b) of H.
pluvialis LUGU under autotrophic culture conditions. The error bars indicate the standard deviations from three independent samples. d days
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
Fig. 3 Effect of different induction media on the cell growth (a), astaxanthin production (b) and astaxanthin content (c) of H. pluvialis LUGU
under induction period. The error bars indicate the standard deviations from three independent samples. d days
13, the percentage of red cells was approximately 70%, also evident relating to morphological observations (Figs. 3b,
100%, almost 90%, and 80% in CZ-M1, BG-11, BBM and c, 4). The lowest content of astaxanthin was occurred in cells
SE cultures, respectively. Furthermore, some cultures, par- grown in CZ-M1 (8.17 mg g−1), and there was no significant
ticularly for BG-11, exhibited a larger cell size (10–25 µm) difference in the content of astaxanthin in alga cells cultured
and contained more large-size red aplanospores than others, in BBM and SE (17.4 mg g−1 and 16.86 mg g−1, respectively).
of which the cell size was ca. 10–20 µm. Meanwhile, all the Moreover, the media composition of BG-11 was practical,
cultures began to die and disintegrate. Zhang et al. [13] also simple and economic. Thus, the BG-11 medium was chosen
showed such algal cell formation in Haematococcus pluvia- as an appropriate induction medium for promoting astaxanthin
lis under stress conditions, which demonstrated that the cells accumulation. In particular, multiple light-mediated stresses
size acclimated under moderate light and nitrogen repletion can trigger excess ROS accumulation, such as the heat stress-
conditions is larger than that under nitrogen depletion and driven Haber–Weiss reaction that can simultaneously increase
high light. In addition, during the induction phase, massive the production of biomass and astaxanthin in H. pluvialis [7].
astaxanthin accumulation is largely accompanied by a mor-
phological change in motile cells to a cyst cell formation in ROS association with the astaxanthin synthesis
H. pluvialis, thereby increasing the mass per unit cell [36]. process
In the present study, the highest astaxanthin production
and total astaxanthin content were reported in cells grown in The endogenous ROS ( O2− and H
2O2) overgenerated during
BG-11 (12.8 mg L−1 and 21.5 mg g−1, respectively), which was photoinduction were measured under growth with four ND
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
Fig. 4 Effect of different induction media on the cell morphology of H. pluvialis LUGU under induction period. a–d Correspond to the algal
cells in CZ-M1, BG-11, BBM and SE. Bars 20 µm. d days
media with the cell-permeable fluorescent dye H2DCFDA, astaxanthin accumulation. The highest DCF content
which is mainly oxidized by H
2O2 among other ROS to form occurred in CZ-M1 medium, and the lowest was observed
DCF [37]. Figure 5a depicts the ROS levels during photoin- in cells grown in BG-11 medium. This phenomenon may
duction in the four culture media. The results showed that be relevant to higher astaxanthin production; most antioxi-
the ROS content increased in cells exposed to high light dants are the metabolites and can considerably decrease
and nitrogen deficiency stresses. DCF content increased excess ROS. Such antioxidants are existing in H. pluvialis,
rapidly in cells exposed to high light and decreased with which can produce triacylglycerol and astaxanthin under
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
photooxidative stress conditions [38]. These results were (ptox2, psy, bkt and chy) were examined by qRT-PCR using
similar to those observed in algal cells under heat stress CZ-M1 as the standard. The results showed that the tran-
[7]. Additionally, O2− and H2O2 may affect the expression script patterns and induction ratios of these four genes were
of carotenogenic genes via negative association with oxi- different between CZ-M1 and algae grown in the other three
dative stress protection and carotenoids accumulation [21, media (Fig. 6). Plastid terminal oxidase (PTOX) functions
35]. H2O2 may directly inactivate sensitive enzymes at a low as a stress protein by inhibiting the over-reduction of the
concentration, thereby depressing the expression of astaxan- plastoquinone (PQ) pool and provides a safety regulator for
thin biosynthesis-related genes [39]. However, the specific excess electrons under abiotic stress conditions [35, 43, 44].
molecular mechanism of ROS and astaxanthin biosynthesis The expression level of ptox2 in BG-11 medium was shown
in H. pluvialis LUGU requires further investigate. to exhibit transient upregulation, where the highest transcript
level of ptox2 occurred in BG-11 and was 3.16-fold higher
MAPK levels in different induction media than its levels in CZ-M1 on day 13 (Fig. 6a). Furthermore,
the highest levels of ptox2 in BBM and SE media were 1.98-
The MAPK cascade is a key conserved signalling pathway and 1.39-fold higher than those in CZ-M1. Ding et al. [44]
used to transduce extracellular induces into intracellular indicated that ptox2 upregulation ensures a safe level of elec-
responses in eukaryotes [40] and plays crucial roles in plant trons involved in the photosynthetic electron transport chain
developmental and physiological control under biotic and to reduce the redox-potential-dependent generation of ROS
abiotic stresses [20]. The MAPK content under the four under stress. Li et al. [43] showed that astaxanthin overpro-
media during the induction period is shown in Fig. 5b. In duction in H. pluvialis can occur by overexpression of ptox2.
contrast to ROS, the highest level of MAPK was obtained The results agreed with the results relating to ROS levels and
in BG-11 medium, followed by BBM and SE. The CZ-M1 astaxanthin in our study (Fig. 5a).
medium showed the lowest MAPK level. This result was Compared to CZ-M1, psy and bkt gene expression showed
associated with astaxanthin accumulation and ROS levels transient increases and then decreases (Fig. 6b, c). The maxi-
(Figs. 3b, 5a). Asai et al. [40] indicated that MAPK can mal expression level of chy occurred on day 13 (Fig. 6d).
regulate the radical burst in Nicotiana benthamiana. MAPK psy and bkt expression also increased in the first 24 h and
can promote glycerol production in Dunaliella tertiolecta then decreased under high light stress [25]. Ding et al. [44]
under osmotic stress [41]. Previous study revealed that showed that bkt has a sharp increase at induction day 1,
enhancement of the MAPK level increased the production and the chy gene was not upregulated in the early induc-
of astaxanthin in H. pluvialis, and vice versa [28]. On the tion phase. Those results demonstrated that psy and bkt may
other hand, MAPK play an important role in abiotic stress increase astaxanthin accumulation at post-transcriptional
responses in microalgae [40, 41]. Signal transmission com- levels and that chy may upregulate it at the transcript level.
plexity via MAP kinases is further layered by the fact that The maximal transcript levels of psy, bkt and chy under
MAP kinases are multitiered gene families recruited for mul- BG-11 were 7.41-, 3.18- and 4.4-fold higher than those
tiple functions such as development, immune defense sys- under CZ-M1 on days 13, 1 and 13, respectively (Fig. 6).
tem, hormones signalling and responses to biotic and abiotic The expressions levels of these genes under BG-11 were also
environmental stresses [20]. Additionally, Ding et al. (2018) higher than those under BBM and SE, which were closely
indicated that MAPK is a target of NO action in physiologi- linked to astaxanthin accumulation (Figs. 3b, 6). Under high
cal processes in H. pluvialis. MAPK also can modulate ROS light and nitrogen deficiency conditions, different genes have
and ABA signallings in plant responses to various stresses variable transcription levels under different induction media.
[42]. Thus, we deduced that MAPK regulate astaxanthin This result may be connected to different binding sites in the
production and the possible involvement of the four media promoters of genes related to astaxanthin biosynthesis in
in mediating different MAPK-signalling pathways of H. plu- response to exposure to different media [25].
vialis in response to the high light and nitrogen starvation
stresses. However, the MAPK-signalling pathway and the
correction between MAPK and ROS should be investigated Conclusion
in further studies.
In H. pluvialis LUGU, high and efficient astaxanthin content
The expression levels of astaxanthin biosynthetic was significantly achieved with the two-stage induction strat-
genes egy. The maximum biomass productivity and astaxanthin
content were obtained in algal cells under complete medium
To gain insight into the molecular mechanisms underlying (BBM) and nitrogen starvation medium (BG-11), respec-
astaxanthin accumulation under four different media, the tively. The endogenous ROS levels, MAPK and astaxanthin
transcript levels of four key astaxanthin biosynthetic genes biosynthetic genes expressions were related to increased
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
Fig. 6 Effect of different induction media on the expressions levels of plastid terminal oxidase (PTOX), ptox2 (a); phytoene synthase, psy (b);
β-carotene ketolase, bkt (c) and β-carotene oxygenase, chy (d) of H. pluvialis LUGU under induction period. d days
astaxanthin accumulation. The crosstalk between ROS and 3. Markou G, Nerantzis E (2013) Microalgae for high-value com-
MAPK-signalling transduction and astaxanthin production pounds and biofuels production: a review with focus on cultiva-
tion under stress conditions. Biotechnol Adv 31(8):1532–1542
is uncharacterized and requires further experimental studies. 4. Li J, Zhu D, Niu J, Shen S, Wang G (2011) An economic assess-
ment of astaxanthin production by large scale cultivation of
Acknowledgements The National Natural Science Foundation of Haematococcus pluvialis. Biotechnol Adv 29(6):568–574
China (no. 21766012 to X. Yu), the Key Science and Technology 5. Shah MMR, Liang Y, Cheng JJ, Daroch M (2016) Astaxanthin-
Project of Yunnan Province, China (2018ZG003 to X. Yu), and the producing green microalga Haematococcus pluvialis: from single
National Natural Science Foundation of China (no. 21666012 to P. cell to high value commercial products. Front Plant Sci 7:531
Zhao) supported this study. 6. Scibilia L, Girolomoni L, Berteotti S, Alboresi A, Ballottari M
(2015) Photosynthetic response to nitrogen starvation and high
light in Haematococcus pluvialis. Algal Res 12:170–181
7. Hong ME, Hwang SK, Chang WS, Kim BW, Lee J, Sim SJ (2015)
Enhanced autotrophic astaxanthin production from Haematococ-
References cus pluvialis under high temperature via heat stress-driven Haber–
Weiss reaction. Appl Microbiol Biot 99(12):5203–5215
1. Guerin M, Huntley ME, Olaizola M (2003) Haematococcus asta- 8. Sharma KK, Ahmed F, Schenk PM, Li Y (2015) UV-C medi-
xanthin: applications for human health and nutrition. Trends Bio- ated rapid carotenoid induction and settling performance of
technol 21(5):210–216 Dunaliella salina and Haematococcus pluvialis. Biotechnol Bio-
2. Higuera-Ciapara I, Felix-Valenzuela L, Goycoolea FM (2006) eng 112(10):2106–2114
Astaxanthin: a review of its chemistry and applications. Crit Rev 9. Park JC, Choi SP, Hong ME, Sim SJ (2014) Enhanced asta-
Food Sci 46(2):185–196 xanthin production from microalga, Haematococcus pluvialis
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
by two-stage perfusion culture with stepwise light irradiation. 26. Boussiba S, Vonshak A (1991) Astaxanthin accumulation in
Bioprocess Biosyst Eng 37(10):2039–2047 the green alga Haematococcus pluvialis. Plant Cell Physiol
10. Choi YE, Yun YS, Park JM, Yang JW (2011) Determination of 32(7):1077–1082
the time transferring cells for astaxanthin production consider- 27. Li D, Zhao Y, Ding W, Zhao P, Xu JW, Li T, Ma H, Yu X (2017)
ing two-stage process of Haematococcus pluvialis cultivation. A strategy for promoting lipid production in green microalgae
Bioresour Technol 102(24):11249–11253 Monoraphidium sp. QLY-1 by combined melatonin and photoin-
11. Zhao Y, Li D, Ding K, Che R, Xu JW, Zhao P, Li T, Ma H, Yu duction. Bioresour Technol 235:104–112
X (2016) Production of biomass and lipids by the oleaginous 28. Ding W, Zhao Y, Xu JW, Zhao P, Li T, Ma H, Reiter RJ, Yu X
microalgae Monoraphidium sp. QLY-1 through heterotrophic (2018) Melatonin: a multifunctional molecule that triggers defense
cultivation and photo-chemical modulator induction. Bioresour responses against high light and nitrogen starvation stress in
Technol 211:669–676 Haematococcus pluvialis. J Agric Food Chem 66(29):7701–7711
12. Fábregas J, Otero A, Maseda A, Dominguez A (2001) Two-stage 29. Kaewpintong K, Shotipruk A, Powtongsook S, Pavasant P (2007)
cultures for the production of astaxanthin from Haematococcus Photoautotrophic high-density cultivation of vegetative cells of
pluvialis. J Biotechnol 89(1):65–71 Haematococcus pluvialis in airlift bioreactor. Bioresour Technol
13. Zhang Z, Wang B, Hu Q, Sommerfeld M, Li Y (2016) A 98(2):288–295
new paradigm for producing astaxanthin from the unicellu- 30. Singh P, Guldhe A, Kumari S, Rawat I, Bux F (2016) Com-
lar green alga Haematococcus pluvialis. Biotechnol Bioeng bined metals and EDTA control: an integrated and scalable lipid
113(10):2088–2099 enhancement strategy to alleviate biomass constraints in micro-
14. Shang M, Ding W, Zhao Y, Xu JW, Zhao P, Li T, Ma H, Yu algae under nitrogen limited conditions. Energy Convers Manag
X (2016) Enhanced astaxanthin production from Haemato- 114:100–109
coccus pluvialis using butylated hydroxyanisole. J Biotechnol 31. Kona R, Hemalatha M, Srivastav KV, Mohan SV (2017) Regula-
236:199–207 tory effect of Fe-EDTA on mixotrophic cultivation of Chlorella
15. Aflalo C, Meshulam Y, Zarka A, Boussiba S (2007) On the rela- sp. towards biomass growth and metabolite production. Bioresour
tive efficiency of two-vs. one-stage production of astaxanthin Technol 244:1227–1234
by the green alga Haematococcus pluvialis. Biotechnol Bioeng 32. Ruangsomboon S, Sornchai P, Prachom N (2018) Enhanced
98(1):300–305 hydrocarbon production and improved biodiesel qualities of Bot-
16. George B, Pancha I, Desai C, Chokshi K, Paliwal C, Ghosh T, ryococcus braunii KMITL 5 by vitamins thiamine, biotin and
Mishra S (2014) Effects of different media composition, light cobalamin supplementation. Algal Res 29:159–169
intensity and photoperiod on morphology and physiology of 33. Che R, Huang L, Yu X (2015) Enhanced biomass production, lipid
freshwater microalgae Ankistrodesmus falcatus—a potential yield and sedimentation efficiency by iron ion. Bioresour Technol
strain for bio-fuel production. Bioresour Technol 171:367–374 192:795–798
17. Rai MP, Gupta S (2017) Effect of media composition and light 34. Wan M, Jin X, Xia J, Rosenberg JN, Yu G, Nie Z, Oyler GA,
supply on biomass, lipid content and FAME profile for quality Betenbaugh MJ (2014) The effect of iron on growth, lipid
biofuel production from Scenedesmus abundans. Energy Con- accumulation, and gene expression profile of the freshwater
vers Manag 141:85–92 microalga Chlorella sorokiniana. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol
18. Zhao Y, Li D, Xu JW, Zhao P, Ma H, Yu X (2018) Melatonin 98(22):9473–9481
enhances lipid production in Monoraphidium sp. QLY-1 under 35. Han D, Wang J, Sommerfeld M, Hu Q (2012) Susceptibility and
nitrogen deficiency conditions via a multi-level mechanism. protective mechanisms of motile and non motile cells of Haema-
Bioresour Technol 259:46–53 tococcus pluvialis (chlorophyceae) to photooxidative stress1. J
19. Ding W, Zhao P, Peng J, Zhao Y, Xu JW, Li T, Reiter RJ, Ma Phycol 48(3):693–705
H, Yu X (2018) Melatonin enhances astaxanthin accumulation 36. Sun Z, Cunningham FX, Gantt E (1998) Differential expression
in the green microalga Haematococcus pluvialis by mecha- of two isopentenyl pyrophosphate isomerases and enhanced carot-
nisms possibly related to abiotic stress tolerance. Algal Res enoid accumulation in a unicellular chlorophyte. Proc Natl Acad
33:256–265 Sci USA 95(19):11482–11488
20. Moustafa K, AbuQamar S, Jarrar M, Al-Rajab AJ, Trémouillaux- 37. Scherz-Shouval R, Elazar Z (2009) Monitoring starvation-induced
Guiller J (2014) MAPK cascades and major abiotic stresses. Plant reactive oxygen species formation. Method Enzymol 452:119–130
Cell Rep 33(8):1217–1225 38. Gwak Y, Hwang Y, Wang B, Kim M, Jeong J, Lee CG, Hu Q
21. Li Y, Sommerfeld M, Chen F, Hu Q (2008) Consumption of oxy- (2014) Comparative analyses of lipidomes and transcriptomes
gen by astaxanthin biosynthesis: a protective mechanism against reveal a concerted action of multiple defensive systems against
oxidative stress in Haematococcus pluvialis (Chlorophyceae). J photooxidative stress in Haematococcus pluvialis. J Exp Bot
Plant Physiol 165(17):1783–1797 65(15):4317–4334
22. Steinbrenner J, Linden H (2001) Regulation of two carotenoid 39. Inzé D, Montagu M Van (1995) Oxidative stress in plants. Curr
biosynthesis genes coding for phytoene synthase and carot- Opin Biotechnol 6(2):153–158
enoid hydroxylase during stress-induced astaxanthin forma- 40. Asai S, Ohta K, Yoshioka H (2008) MAPK signaling regulates
tion in the green alga Haematococcus pluvialis. Plant Physiol nitric oxide and NADPH oxidase-dependent oxidative bursts in
125(2):810–817 Nicotiana benthamiana. Plant Cell 20(5):1390–1406
23. Grünewald K, Hirschberg J, Hagen C (2001) Ketocarotenoid bio- 41. Zhao R, Ng DHP, Fang L, Chow YYS, Lee YK (2016) MAPK in
synthesis outside of plastids in the unicellular green alga Haema- Dunaliella tertiolecta regulates glycerol production in response
tococcus pluvialis. J Biol Chem 276(8):6023–6029 to osmotic shock. Eur J Phycol 51(2):119–128
24. Kathiresan S, Chandrashekar A, Ravishankar GA, Sarada R 42. Raja V, Majeed U, Kang H, Andrabi KI, John R (2017) Abiotic
(2015) Regulation of astaxanthin and its intermediates through stress: interplay between ROS, hormones and MAPKs. Environ
cloning and genetic transformation of β-carotene ketolase in Exp Bot 137:142–157
Haematococcus pluvialis. J Biotechnol 196:33–41 43. Li Y, Sommerfeld M, Chen F, Hu Q (2010) Effect of photon
25. Zhao Y, Shang M, Xu JW, Zhao P, Li T, Yu X (2015) Enhanced flux densities on regulation of carotenogenesis and cell viabil-
astaxanthin production from a novel strain of Haematococcus plu- ity of Haematococcus pluvialis (Chlorophyceae). J Appl Phycol
vialis using fulvic acid. Process Biochem 50(12):2072–2077 22(3):253–263
13
Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering
44. Ding W, Peng J, Zhao Y, Zhao P, Xu JW, Li T, Yu X (2018) A Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
strategy for boosting astaxanthin accumulation in green microalga jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Haematococcus pluvialis by using combined diethyl aminoethyl
hexanoate and high light. J Appl Phycol. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s10811-018-1561-8
13