Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sexual Dimorphism in Human Lipid Metabolism
Sexual Dimorphism in Human Lipid Metabolism
ABSTRACT The existing work demonstrates that striking differences exist between men and women in lipid
kinetics. These differences cannot be explained simply by the presence and action of sex hormones and are not
always due to secondary, phenotypic traits that characterize men and women (e.g., body-composition, regional fat
distribution). In fact, some of these secondary traits may even be the result of sexual dimorphism in metabolism,
Within the past decade, a great deal of effort has been observed differences in lipid metabolism may be secondary to
dedicated to uncovering the relevant physiologic differences those characteristics. The other strives to eliminate as many
between the sexes that may affect the prevention, diagnosis, potential confounding variables as practically feasible to de-
and treatment of disease. For example, there are differences termine whether sex per se represents an underlying factor in
between the sexes in the lipid profile that may have clinical the control of metabolism.
implications. In women, high plasma triglyceride (TG)3 con- A simple view concerning the underlying cause for sexual
centrations are independent and better predictors of cardio- dimorphism in metabolism would be to blame it on the pres-
vascular disease risk than total or LDL cholesterol (1,2). Treat- ence and known action of the sex hormones. However, we are
ment of hypertriglyceridemia may, therefore, be of greater now starting to discover that many genes are actually ex-
importance in women than in men. Also, differences in he- pressed in a sexually dimorphic manner, and there is evidence
patic handling of fatty acids between men and women are for differences in post-translational changes in men and
likely responsible for the greater susceptibility of women to women (although the mechanisms are mostly unknown); this
fatty liver disease and the more severe liver injury as a result of will almost certainly result in different enzyme activities,
it (3). A better understanding of the control of lipid metabo- abundance of cellular signal transduction elements, and con-
lism by a person’s sex will therefore not only increase our sequently, in substrate kinetics. Furthermore, the association
knowledge of human intermediary and macronutrient metab- of many gene polymorphisms [e.g., (4 – 6)], associated with risk
olism, but may also be useful for the development of novel factors for disease and substrate kinetics is also often sex
approaches for the treatment and prevention of disease. specific (Fig. 1).
There are 2 general approaches when evaluating differences The aim of this article is to review the major findings on
in metabolism between the sexes. One (clinically probably the differences of human fatty acid and TG metabolism between
most relevant) is to accept the differences in phenotype be- men and women in the basal, overnight fasted state and during
tween men and women (e.g., body composition, regional fat the major physiologic challenges that affect lipid metabolism,
distribution, aerobic fitness, all of which affect substrate me- i.e., food intake and hyperinsulinemia/hyperglycemia, exer-
tabolism in persons of the same sex) and acknowledge that the cise, and short-term fasting. Reference to women in the fol-
lowing sections refers to premenopausal women unless specif-
ically indicated otherwise.
1
Support was received from the U.S. National Institutes of Health grants HD
01459, AR 49869, DK 56341 (Clinical Nutrition Research Unit at Washington
University), and grants from the Novo Nordisk, the Danish Natural Sciences Fatty acid kinetics
Foundations, and the Danish National Research Foundation (Center for Inflam-
mation and Metabolism grant).
2
Circulating fatty acids, derived from the breakdown of
To whom correspondence should be addressed. endogenous TG that are stored in adipose tissue and muscle,
E-mail: mittendb@wustl.edu.
3
Abbreviations used: LPL, lipoprotein lipase; Ra, rate of appearance; TG, are an important source of fuel. Insulin is the major regulator
triglyceride. of basal and postprandial lipolytic rates (7), whereas cat-
681
682 MITTENDORFER
Food intake/hyperinsulinemia
Insulin stimulates glucose uptake by tissues in response to
food intake and is the major regulator of lipolysis (14 –16). No
study has compared the inhibitory effect of insulin on adipose
tissue lipolytic activity in men and women, but it appears that
doubling of its concentration in plasma, reduced the storage of the adrenal medullary response to exercise and in adipose
dietary fatty acids in visceral and retroperitoneal adipose tissue tissue lipolytic response to epinephrine stimulation in obese
and increased the storage in subcutaneous adipose tissue (23). subjects.
The effects of female sex hormones (or lack thereof) on Information regarding the metabolic response to exercise
regional fatty acid storage have not been studied to date. training in men and women is controversial. In one study,
exercise training caused a greater increase in fat oxidation
Exercise during exercise in women than in men (39 – 41). However,
these findings were confounded by the fact that the increase in
Evaluating lipid kinetics in men and women during exercise aerobic fitness was also greater in women (25%) than in men
is particularly difficult because it is affected by body composi- (9%). In another study, 12 wk of endurance training in women
tion, aerobic fitness, and training status, age, menstrual cycle increased total fat oxidation by ⬃25% during exercise per-
phase (during high-intensity exercise), and possible other less formed at the same absolute intensity (15). This response is
explored factors such as muscle fiber-type composition (24,25). the same as that reported in men after a similar training-
This may explain in part the often controversial results in the induced increase in fitness (42,43). When plasma free fatty
literature. For example, several studies found that the rate of acid oxidation was assessed by isotope tracer methods, and
fat oxidation was higher in both untrained and trained women whole-body fat oxidation was assessed simultaneously by indi-
sex hormones can affect substrate kinetics during extreme are inconsistent. Sex differences appear to also exist in the rate
physiologic conditions such as high-intensity exercise (49); of secretion of VLDL-apolipoprotein B; in this case, however,
however, fatty acid kinetics were the same during the follicular the secretion rate is higher in men than women (67), which
and luteal phases of the menstrual cycle during basal and many suggests that the VLDL particles secreted in men are smaller
other conditions (49 –53). Interestingly, administration of es- than those in women, consistent with data that measured
trogen to postmenopausal women increased basal fatty acid Ra concentrations of different size VLDL particles in the blood-
(54); however, this was only a ⬃10 –20% increase, probably stream (68). Differences in the particle size may contribute to
too small a difference to be detected during normal fluctua- the differences in risk for the development of cardiovascular
tions of the menstrual cycle. It is also possible that progester- disease (69) between men and women.
one may counteract the effects of estrogen, but the effects of
progesterone on the control of human lipid metabolism have VLDL-TG kinetics during hyperglycemia-hyperinsulinemia/
not been systematically studied. Also, at odds with the findings meal intake
that basal lipolytic rates are higher in women than men (see
above), are the results from studies in which testosterone Decreasing endogenous VLDL-TG production during post-
administered to obese men for 2 mo increased abdominal prandial conditions is important for regulating whole-body TG
adipose tissue turnover (23). In adipocytes cultured in vitro flux when dietary TG are entering the systemic circulation via
VLDL-TG concentration was blunted in the obese compared 12. Horowitz, J. F., Coppack, S. W. & Klein, S. (2001) Whole-body and
adipose tissue glucose metabolism in response to short-term fasting in lean and
with the lean. obese women. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 73: 517–522.
13. Nielsen, S., Guo, Z., Albu, J. B., Klein, S., O’Brien, P. C. & Jensen, M. D.
Postprandial lipemia (2003) Energy expenditure, sex, and endogenous fuel availability in humans.
J. Clin. Investig. 111: 981–988.
14. Horowitz, J. F. & Klein, S. (2000) Whole body and abdominal lipolytic
The postprandial lipemic response, which is characterized sensitivity to epinephrine is suppressed in upper body obese women. Am. J.
by the change in total TG and TG-rich lipoprotein concen- Physiol. 278: E1144 –E1152.
trations in plasma in response to dietary fat intake, is deter- 15. Horowitz, J. F., Leone, T. C., Feng, W., Kelly, D. P. & Klein, S. (2000)
mined predominately by the fat content of a meal. However, Effect of endurance training on lipid metabolism in women: a potential role for
PPARalpha in the metabolic response to training. Am. J. Physiol. 279: E348 –
other factors, such as meal fatty acid composition, body-com- E355.
position (i.e., total body fat, visceral fat accumulation), insu- 16. Groop, L. C., Bonadonna, R. C., Simonson, D. C., Petrides, A. S., Shank,
lin-sensitivity, and physical activity, also play a role in the M. & DeFronzo, R. A. (1992) Effect of insulin on oxidative and nonoxidative
pathways of free fatty acid metabolism in human obesity. Am. J. Physiol. 263:
postprandial lipemic response (74 –77). Postprandial plasma E79 –E84.
TG concentrations are lower in women than men (77). The 17. McKeigue, P. M., Laws, A., Chen, Y. D., Marmot, M. G. & Reaven, G. M.
differences can be attributed largely to differences in body-fat (1993) Relation of plasma triglyceride and apoB levels to insulin-mediated
suppression of nonesterified fatty acids. Possible explanation for sex differences
distribution (and differences in insulin sensitivity associated in lipoprotein pattern. Arterioscler. Thromb. 13: 1187–1192.
cova, H., Langin, D., Lafontan, M. & Berlan, M. (2002) Hypocaloric diet re- 58. Leibel, R. L. & Hirsch, J. (1987) Site- and sex-related differences in
duces exercise-induced alpha 2-adrenergic antilipolytic effect and alpha 2-ad- adrenoreceptor status of human adipose tissue. J. Clin. Endocrinol. Metab. 64:
renergic receptor mRNA levels in adipose tissue of obese women. J. Clin. 1205–1210.
Endocrinol. Metab. 87: 1274 –1281. 59. Mauriege, P., Imbeault, P., Langin, D., Lacaille, M., Almeras, N., Trem-
39. Friedlander, A. L., Casazza, A., Horning, M. A., Buddinger, T. F. & Brooks, blay, A. & Despres, J. P. (1999) Regional and gender variations in adipose
G. A. (1998) Effects of exercise intensity and training on lipid metabolism in tissue lipolysis in response to weight loss. J. Lipid Res. 40: 1559 –1571.
young women. Am. J. Physiol. 275: E853–E863. 60. Wahrenberg, H., Bolinder, J. & Arner, P. (1991) Adrenergic regulation
40. Friedlander, A. L., Casazza, G. A., Horning, M. A., Huie, M. J., Piacentini, of lipolysis in human fat cells during exercise. Eur. J. Clin. Investig. 21: 534 –541.
M. F., Trimmer, J. K. & Brooks, G. A. (1998) Training-induced alterations of 61. Millet, L., Barbe, P., Lafontan, M., Berlan, M. & Galitzky, J. (1998)
carbohydrate metabolism in women: women respond differently from men. Catecholamine effects on lipolysis and blood flow in human abdominal and
J. Appl. Physiol. 85: 1175–1186. femoral adipose tissue. J. Appl. Physiol. 85: 181–188.
41. Friedlander, A. L., Casazza, G. A., Horning, M. A., Usaj, A. & Brooks, G. A. 62. Cryer, A. (1981) Tissue lipoprotein lipase activity and its action in
(1999) Endurance training increases fatty acid turnover, but not fat oxidation, in lipoprotein metabolism. Int. J. Biochem. 13: 525–541.
young men. J. Appl. Physiol. 86: 2097–2105.
63. Karpe, F., Steiner, G., Uffelman, K., Olivecrona, T. & Hamsten, A. (1994)
42. Martin, W. H., 3rd, Dalsky, G. P., Hurley, B. F., Matthews, D. E., Bier,
Postprandial lipoproteins and progression of coronary atherosclerosis. Athero-
D. M., Hagberg, J. M., Rogers, M. A., King, D. S. & Holloszy, J. O. (1993) Effect
sclerosis 106: 83–97.
of endurance training on plasma free fatty acid turnover and oxidation during
64. Boquist, S., Ruotolo, G., Tang, R., Bjorkegren, J., Bond, M. G., de Faire,
exercise. Am. J. Physiol. 265: E708 –E714.
43. Phillips, S. M., Green, H. J., Tarnopolsky, M. A., Heigenhauser, G. F., Hill, U., Karpe, F. & Hamsten, A. (1999) Alimentary lipemia, postprandial triglycer-
R. E. & Grant, S. M. (1996) Effects of training duration on substrate turnover ide-rich lipoproteins, and common carotid intima-media thickness in healthy,
and oxidation during exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 81: 2182–2191. middle-aged men. Circulation 100: 723–728.