Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Paediatric Cancer Care in Abakaliki South-East Nigeria: Challenges and Outcome
Paediatric Cancer Care in Abakaliki South-East Nigeria: Challenges and Outcome
doi: 10.17265/2328-2150/2022.03.005
D DAVID PUBLISHING
Udechukwu Ngozi Patricia1, Ukoh Uchechukwu Chukwuebuka1, Nwagha Theresa Ukamaka2 and Nwokoye
Ikenna Chidiebele1
1. Department of Paediatrics, Alex Ekwueme Federal University Teaching Hospital Abakaliki (AEFUTHA), Ebonyi State, Nigeria
2. Department of Internal Medicine, AEFUTHA, Ebonyi State, Nigeria
Abstract: The care of children with malignancy is almost always a feat and is even more difficult in resource-poor settings such as
our country Nigeria where several factors present as challenges as seen in other countries of sub-Saharan Africa. In this study, we
present our experience in AEFUTHA, over a six-year period. This study aimed at finding out the current prevalence, outcomes and
challenging issues leading to poor outcomes. This retrospective study spanned from January 2012 to December 2017. Information
was extracted from the patients’ case notes using a structured data proforma. Children aged 17 years and below who satisfied the
inclusion and exclusion criteria were studied and the sample size was 68. In our study, the prevalence of paediatric malignancy is
2.0%. The outcome was generally poor with a mortality rate of 30.9%, and 60.3% having abandoned treatment at various stages of
management. The top-ranking challenges noted included diagnostic problems and late presentation accounting for 19.8% and 17.3%
respectively and, poverty and lack of effective treatment and drugs representing 16.0% each. We conclude that there is a need to
adopt a multifaceted approach to tackling these challenges to improve outcomes.
2.5 Exclusion Criteria analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences
(SPSS) version 20. Results were presented using tables
Children who had been diagnosed with cancer and
and charts. The Chi-Square test was used to test for
had begun treatment in another facility before being
significance. P values < 0.05 were considered significant.
transferred to this institution were excluded.
2.9
4.4
4.4 7.4 19.1
4.4
5.8 17.1
7.4
10.3 16.2
Rhabdomyosarcoma
Nephroblastoma
Retinoblastoma
Neuroblastoma
Teratoma
Hodgkin Lymphoma
Others: Langerhans Cell Histiocytosis, Yolk Sac Tumor, Basal Cell Carcinoma, Renal Cell Carcinoma, Primary Liver Cell
Carcinoma
resources and manpower. Other major challenges low socio-economic group, which is consistent with
involved were late presentation, poverty and findings from Ife and Kano [20], but differs from Port
non-availability of effective treatment drugs, see table Harcourt [24] where the middle class constituted the
5. The interruption of treatment by workers strikes in majority. The prevalent socio-economic class noted in
two consecutive years and self-medication were the this study reflects the general economic situation in
least. this environment, the majority of residents are peasant
farmers and come from rural settings; in addition,
4. Discussion
most of the upper class would opt-out at the early
The prevalence of 2.0% in this index study is higher stages of diagnosis to more advanced centres for
than 0.14% recorded over 10 years ago by Nnebe and continuation of management. In this study, most
Onwasigwe in this centre [6]. This is probably due to patients belong to the lower class, which is a serious
increased awareness and improvements in diagnostic problem, because it means that in an environment
facilities, yet it is lower than reports from other parts where the cost of treatment is mostly at their own
of Nigeria. [20]. The lower value in this index study expense, these patients may not put forward the
may be likely due to under-diagnosis as the other financial needs of investigation, diagnosis, treatment
centres referred to are more advanced with better and management. Although more of our patients come
diagnostic facilities. The value in this study is from rural settings, it is still below the known level of
however higher than that obtained at Nnewi, Nigeria rural-urban population disposition in Ebonyi state
[21]. This study did not show any annual variation in which is 70-75%: 25-30% (rural: urban ratio) [18].
the incidence of paediatric malignancy as were the This implies that quite a good number of children
cases in Nnewi [21] and Cote d’Ivoire. [16]. The affected with cancer in the rural settings are not able
reduction in incidence in 2014 and 2015 were due to to access care from the tertiary institution available.
successive industrial actions by health care workers in In this study, the median duration of symptoms
2014 and 2015. before presentation was 14 weeks and up to 79.4% of
The male to female ratio of 1.4:1 obtained in this our patients presented with metastasis, these being
study is similar to reports from various parts of indicators of late presentation are higher than reports
Nigeria [22-24] and other parts of Africa [16]. from Port-Harcourt [24], however, a similar
In this study, the majority of patients were five proportion of patients presented with metastasis in the
years and below. This is similar to the reports from study from Ibadan [8]. The majority of patients come
other centres in the country [20, 24, 25] for the same from remote rural areas that are far from the tertiary
age group, but differed from other reports including centre. Such patients may have to pass through some
Sagamu [7], Cote d’Voire [16] that had higher age bottlenecks including patent medicine dealers, herbal
bracket (5-9 years). It is important to mention that in and traditional healing areas, primary and secondary
this report and in those that had similar peak ages of care centres before reaching the tertiary centre that is
occurrence, the most common tumour types are usually situated in the urban. Most patients belong to
embryonic tumours. There is a high incidence of the lower socio economic class, this group is more
embryonic tumours, which is known to be common in likely to have financial constraints, to be ignorant,
this age group, while lymphomas and leukaemia with poor health seeking behaviours, and to have
occurred more commonly in those with the higher age abnormal beliefs as to the causes of sickness, and
bracket. these would make them present late with subsequent
The majority of patients in this study belong to the poor outcome.
Paediatric Cancer Care in Abakaliki South-East Nigeria: Challenges and Outcome 103
In this study, 48.5% received chemotherapy alone, presentation as major challenges. Abiola et al [28]
while 26.5% had surgery and chemotherapy. Our noted in their study that diagnostic problems ranked
findings are similar to the study by Utuk and Ikpeme highest among other challenges just like in this study.
[22]. Chemotherapy appears to be the commonly The reasons for these challenges are obvious and are
available treatment form and the modality used in all linked to the general problems of the health
stages of the disease. It is often initiated, though the infrastructure in sub-Saharan Africa, manifesting as
courses may not always be completed due to financial scarcity of diagnostic facilities and lack of specialized
constraints. Surgery was also commonly available in manpower; as well as issues bordering on literacy
our centre thus was provided, but the majority of level and economic power of the caregivers. The
patients had metastasis on presentation, negating the consequences of these challenges are obvious.
use of this service. Supportive treatment is protean
5. Conclusions
and was used by all patients at one time or the other.
The high default rate and poor rate of completion of The current prevalence of paediatric malignancies
treatment noted in this study are worrisome. The high in the study centre is 2.0%, which is a several-fold
default rate is similar to the findings from other increase from that obtained 13 years ago. The
studies [22, 24, 25]. This high default rate could be outcome has remained poor as in other centres in the
due to financial constraints obviating continuation of country and reflects the numerous challenges
treatment as funding is mainly out-of-pocket, burn-out encountered in management; abandonment of
syndrome on the part of the caregivers, not perceiving treatment was top on the list.
obvious improvement in condition in the immediate The above underscores the need to adopt a
time despite ongoing treatment, the misconception of multifaceted approach to address this: these include
embarking on massive public awareness campaigns,
the disease as a spiritual affliction thus not amenable
provision of health insurance and making it to cover
to orthodox medication or even not curable. It would
paediatric oncology management, training of staff in
be expected that most will eventually be taken home,
newer modalities for investigation and management as
or to spiritual or traditional healers, eventually, these
well as provision of current diagnostic facilities.
would end in fatalities. The mortality rate (30.9%) is
Exploring other modalities such as the development of
high. This mortality rate compares with the finding
regional cancer centres and twinning programs could
from ABU Zaria [25], but is lower than figures from
be of help.
Ibadan [5] and PH [24], but is higher than finding
from Abuja [2], it is poor. This poor outcome is likely Limitations
due to the numerous challenges we encountered in the
Being a retrospective study, information retrieval
management of these cases including, diagnostic
posed challenges as seen that up to 22 out of 90
difficulties, late presentation, poverty and
(24.4%) of our cases were excluded from the study
inaccessibility of drugs.
due to missing details concerning the patients.
The main challenges to management identified in
this study are as follows: diagnostic problems, late References
presentation, poverty and non-availability of treatment [1] Kingham, T. P., Alatise, O. I., Vanderpuye, V., et al.
drugs. These are not very different from the previous 2013. “Treatment of Cancer in sub-Saharan Africa.”
Lancet 14 (4): 158-67.
report from this centre [6] and is similar to the
[2] Offiong, U. M. 2012. “Childhood Malignancy in
findings by Utuk and Ikpeme [22] who noted University of Abuja Teaching Hospital Gwagwalada,
non-availability of drugs, burn-out syndrome and late Abuja, Nigeria.” Niger J Paed 39 (2): 60-2.
104 Paediatric Cancer Care in Abakaliki South-East Nigeria: Challenges and Outcome
[3] Chirdan, L. B., Ameh, E. A., Abantanga, F. A., et al. “Establishment of a Pediatric Oncology Program and
2010. “Challenges of Training and Delivering of Outcomes of Childhood Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia
Paediatric Surgical Services in Africa.” J Pediatr Surg 45 in a Resource-poor Area.” JAMA 291 (20): 2471-5.
(3): 610-8. [16] Yao, J. J. A., Couitchere, L., Atimere, Y., et al. 2012.
[4] Eke, G. K., and Akani, N. A. 2016. “Outcome of “Childhood Cancer Care in Cote d’Ivoire.” S Afr Med J.
Childhood Malignancies at the University of Port 103 (2): 113-5.
Harcourt Teaching Hospital: A Call for Implimentation of [17] Hardly, L. G. P., Rouma, B. S., and Saad-Eldin, Y. 2012.
Palliative Care.” Afr Health Sci 16 (1): 75-82. “Challenges of Paediatric Oncology in Africa.” Semin
[5] Brown, B. J., Bamgboye, E. A., and Sodeinde, O. 2008. Paediatr Surg 21 (2): 136-41.
“Causes of Death in Childhood Cancer at the Department [18] Ebonyi State Government of Nigeria. Draft report of
of Paediatrics, University College Hospital, Ibadan.” Afr Ebonyi state economic empowerment and development
J Med Sci 37 (1): 7-13. strategy committee. Abakaliki; 2004.
[6] Nnebe-Agumadu, U., and Owasigwe, C. 2005. [19] Olusanya O. An original system of social classification
“Childhood Malignancy in Abakaliki: A Growing for use in Nigeria and other developing countries. In:
Concern.” J Coll Med 10 (1): 21-5. 24th Annual Conference of the West African College of
[7] Agboola, A. O. J., et al. 2009. “Pattern of Childhood Surgeons. Freetown, Sierra Leone; 1984.
Malignant Tumours in a Teaching Hospital in [20] Shehu, U. A., Adegoke, S. A., Abdulsalam, U., et al.
South-Western Nigeria.” Med J 190 (1): 12-14. 2013. “Pattern of Childhood Malignant Tumours in Two
[8] James, B. O., et al. 2009. “Factors Influencing Time to Tertiary Teaching Hospitals in Nigeria : Comparative
Diagnosis of Childhood Cancer in Ibadan, Nigeria.” Afr Study.” Niger J Paed 40 (2): 175-8.
Health Sci 9 (4): 247-53. [21] Okocha, E. C., Aneke, J. C., Ulasi, T. O., et al. 2015.
[9] Buckle, G. C., Collins, J. P., Sumba, P. O., et al. 2013. “Pattern of Childhood and Adolescent Malignancies at a
“Factors Influencing Time to Diagnosis and Initiation of Tertiary Health Institution in South-east Nigeria : A Ten
Treatment of Endemic Burkitt Lymphoma among Year Study.” Niger J Paed 42 (2):111-5.
Children in Uganda and Western Kenya: A [22] Utuk, E-O. E., and Ikpeme, E. E. 2015. “Childhood
Cross-sectional Survey.” Infect Agent Cancer 8 (1): 36. Cancers in a Referral Hospital in South-south Nigeria: A
[10] Kitoni, G. W., et al. 2009. “Clinico-pathologic Review of the Spectrum and Outcome of Treatment.”
Characteristics and Treatment Outcomes in Children with Pan Afr Med J doi: 10.11604/pamj.2015.22.325.6990.
Noeuroblastoma at the Kenyatta National Hospital, [23] Chukwu, B. F., et al. 2015. “A Prospective Study of
Nairobi.” East Afr Med J 86 (12 Suppl): S39-46. Childhood Malignancy in Enugu, Nigeria (2011-2013).”
[11] Jeremy, S. S., Catherine, C., Marta, P., et al. 2014. Niger J Paed 42 (2):116-20.
“Paediatric Malignancies, Treatment, Outcomes and [24] Eke, G. K., and Akani, N. A. 2016. “Outcome of
Abandonement of Pediatric Cancer Treatment in Zambia.” Childhood Malignancies at the University of Port
PLoS One 9 (2): e89102. Harcourt Teaching Hospital: A Call for Implementation
[12] Dand-Tan, T., Trotier, H., Mery, L. S., et al. 2008. of Palliative Care.” Afr Health Sci 16 (1):75-82.
“Delays in Diagnosis and Treatment among Children and [25] Ahmad, H. R., Faruk, J. A., Abdullahi, M., et al. 2016.
Adolescents with Cancer in Canada.” Pediatr Blood “Pattern and Outcomes of Childhood Malignancies at
Cancer 51 (4): 468-74. Ahmadu Bello University Teaching Hospital, Zaria.”
[13] Israels, T., et al. 2015. “Treating Children with Cancer Sub-Saharan African J Med 3 (3):127-31.
Worldwide-Challenges and Intervensions.” Pediatrics [26] Babatunde, A. S., Gobir, A. A., Adeboye, M. A. N., et al.
136 (4): 607-10. 2015. “Pattern of Childhood Malignancies in Ilorin,
[14] Fafokun, O. 2017. “Cancer Control Reform in Ngeria.” Nigeria: Challenges and Strategies for Management in a
Lancet Oncol 18 (1): 19-20. Tertiary Health Institution.” Bangladesh J Med Sci. 14
[15] Howard, S. C., Pedrosa, M., Lins, M., et al. 2004. (3): 241-6.