[

Musi
c]

IwonderaboutGodandIam puzzl
edby

consci
ousnessbutwhydoest
hemy
ster
y

ofconsci
ousnessl
eadsomet
othe

exi
stenceofGodandwhydoot
her
stake

consci
ousnesst
obecausedent
ir
elyby

t
hebr
ainmuchl
i
ker
unni
ngi
scaused

ent
ir
elybyt
hel
egsconsci
ousnessi
s

whati
tfeel
sli
ket
oseear
edsunset

orahor
rorf
il
m

t
ohearaBeet
hov
ensy
mphonyora

j
ackhammersuchi
nnerawar
enessi
s

ext
raor
dinar
yinal
lthecosmos

consci
ousnessseemsoutofpl
acespod

buti
sourconsci
ousnesssowi
l
dlyout

ofpl
acesooddt
hati
tpoi
ntst
oa

hi
gherconsci
ousnessI
'
dli
ket
obel
i
eve

i
nGodcanconsci
ousnesshel
pgetme

t
her
e

I
'
m Rober
tLawr
enceKuhnandcl
osert
o

t
rut
hismyj
our
neyt
ofi
ndout

[
Musi
c]

I
'
veal
way
shadmysenseabout

consci
ousnesst
hatonewayort
heot
her

ei
therr
eal
i
tyi
sal
landonl
yphy
sical

ort
her
eissomeki
ndofnon-
phy
sical

exi
stenceper
hapsaGodt
hat

consci
ousnesswoul
dbet
hekeybutIdo
nott
rustmysensesohowt
oexpl
orea

possi
bleconsci
ousnessGodl
i
nki
fther
e

beanyIst
artwi
that
heol
ogi
ant
rai
ned

asaphi
l
osophert
hef
ormerRegi
s

pr
ofessorofdi
vi
nit
yatOxf
ordKei
th

War
dHeat
hcl
aimst
hatconsci
ousness

poi
ntst
oGodwhyIt
hinkt
he

t
radi
ti
onal
placet
obegi
niswi
th

i
ntr
ospect
iont
hati
slooki
ngaty
our

ownexper
ienceandaski
ngwhatal
lthe

knowl
edgei
sbasedonandy
ousayhowdo

Ihav
eanyknowl
edgeatal
lorwhathow

doesi
tst
artandi
tst
art
sfr
om t
he

f
acty
ou'
reconsci
ousofsomer
eal
i
ty

y
ou'
reconsci
ousofsomet
hingokay

cansomet
hingf
oll
owf
rom t
hatIt
hink

qui
teal
otf
oll
owsf
rom i
tbecausei
f

y
ousayconsci
ousnessi
sisa

f
undament
alel
ementofr
eal
i
tyy
ouhav
e

t
oaskt
hequest
ionwel
lhowdoes

consci
ousnessor
igi
nat
orsj
ustj
ust

suddenl
yspr
ingi
ntobei
ngf
ornor
eason

t
hatwhydoesi
tspr
ingt
obei
ngwhen

t
hebr
aini
sasi
twer
ereadyf
ori
t

per
hapsconsci
ousnessi
snotonl
y

f
undament
ali
nthehumancasebut

per
hapsconsci
ousnessi
sfundament
ali
n

t
hecosmi
ccaset
hati
sthemat
terof
f
actt
hewhol
ephy
sical
uni
ver
sei
nsome

sensepr
esupposesanddependsuponand

st
art
sfr
om consci
ousnessnowt
hatwoul
d

assumet
hatt
heconsci
ousnesst
hatour

l
i
ttl
eear
thhaspr
oducedher
easmal
l

mi
crocosm ofal
lreal
i
tysomehowhasa

connect
ionwi
thal
lofr
eal
i
tyy
es

t
hat
'sr
ightImeant
hat
'
snota

sur
pri
seImeanasphy
sical
bei
ngsbut

connect
edwi
thal
lreal
i
tyandour

phy
sical
bit
sar
eint
erconnect
edwi
th

ev
ery
thi
ngphy
sical
int
heuni
ver
seso

i
t'
snotr
eal
l
yabi
gsur
pri
set
osay

humanconsci
ousnessi
spar
tofawi
der

cosmi
cfor
m ofconsci
ousnessi
fwe

assumet
hatourhumanconsci
ousnessi
s

r
eal
isaf
undament
alpar
tofr
eal
i
ty

canwet
henmakeanyi
nfer
encest
o

spi
ri
tual
real
msori
nadi
vi
ne

consci
ousnessIwoul
dn'
tseei
tcari
s

ani
nfer
encel
i
ket
hati
t'
sit
'
smor
ea

quest
ionofwhaty
out
aket
obe

const
it
uti
veofofr
eal
i
tyofwhatt
he

wor
ldi
smadeofandi
fyoumake

consci
ousnessr
eal
l
ypr
imar
ytheny
ou'
re

goi
ngt
oanswert
hequest
ionwhati
sthe

f
undament
alnat
ureofr
eal
i
tyi
tsel
fof

t
hewhol
euni
ver
sey
ou'
regoi
ngt
ogi
ve
t
heansweraconsci
ousnesswel
lsowhat

y
ou'
resay
ingi
nessencei
t'
snotj
ust

t
hatconsci
ousnessi
saf
undament
alpar
t

ofr
eal
i
tyal
ongwi
tht
hest
rongf
orce

andt
heweakf
orceel
ect
romagnet
ism and

gr
avi
tyandal
lthet
hingst
hatphy
sics

f
eel
sli
keaf
if
thf
orcebuty
ou'
re

say
ingt
hati
ndeedamuchmor
eful
lbody

conceptofconsci
ousnesst
hat

consci
ousnessi
sev
enmor
efundament
al

t
hanal
lthesef
orcesi
sthatr
ighty
eah

t
hat
'sr
ightt
hat
'
sabi
gst
atementbut

i
tisast
atementt
hatmostphi
l
osopher
s

hav
emadet
hroughouthi
stor
yandt
o

ov
ert
urnt
hatst
atementj
ustbecausewe

knowahugeamountmor
eaboutt
he

phy
sical
uni
ver
sei
sper
hapsnot

somet
hingwhi
chi
sgoi
ngt
olastImean

It
hinkt
hemat
eri
ali
stv
iewi
sav
ery

shor
t-
li
vedphenomenont
hisv
iewi
snot

necessar
il
yar
eli
giousv
iewy
eaht
hat

y
oucany
oucanar
guef
ort
hepr
ior
it
y

ofconsci
ousnesswi
thouthav
ingany

r
eli
giousi
ncl
i
nat
ionswhat
soev
erI

agr
eewi
tht
hathowi
sGodi
nvol
vedi
n

t
hecr
eat
ionofconsci
ousnesswel
lIdo

t
hinkconsci
ousnessemer
gesbynor
mal

ev
olut
ionar
ypr
ocesses
I
'
mjustsupposi
ngt
hati
fit
'si
ntended

byGodt
henGodi
sact
ual
l
yhav
inga

causal
inputi
ntohowev
ent
sint
he

uni
ver
sear
edev
elopi
ngi
nthatway

t
her
ear
echoi
cesatv
ari
ouspoi
nts

whi
chwayt
het
hinggoescoul
dbe

i
nfl
uencedbyt
hei
ntent
ionsofGodi
t

makessenset
omet
her
ehav
ebeen

t
err
ibl
yskept
ical

r
ightKei
thIam skept
ical
Iwi
shI

wer
en'
tI'
dlov
eGodt
ohav
edoneal
l

t
hei
ntendi
ngbutIst
ruggl
etof
ind

har
dev
idencet
osuppor
tit

asmuchasI
'
dli
ket
obel
i
eveIcannot

suspendcr
it
ical
thi
nki
ngsowhi
l
eat

Oxf
ordIv
isi
tapsy
chol
ogi
stwhogav
e

uphersear
chf
ort
hesuper
nat
ural

becauseassubhl
ackMoor
esay
sthedat
a

di
dn'
tsuppor
titIaskedsuewhatshe

t
hinksofconsci
ousnessasasi
gnpost

f
orGodt
henIduk-
soosomewoul
dcl
aim

t
hatt
hisexi
stenceofconsci
ousnessi
s

oneoft
hebet
terpr
oof
sfort
he

exi
stenceofGodhowdot
heywor
kthat

onepl
easedbyt
hef
actt
hati
t'
sso

uni
queandt
hati
t'
saf
ir
st-
per
son

exper
ienceandt
hatourf
ir
stper
son

exper
iencecan'
tbet
hatexpl
ainedby
j
ustt
hingst
hatar
ehappeni
ngi
nthe

br
aint
hey
'r
esot
otal
l
ydi
ff
erent

cat
egor
iesandt
hatf
ort
hist
ohav
e

ev
olv
edt
her
ehast
obesomef
undament
al

consci
ousnessi
ntheuni
ver
secal
l
edGod

Isaywhatki
ndoft
wist
edwonkyl
i
kei
f

y
oust
artf
rom t
hepr
emi
seofhowi
t

f
eel
sthatseemst
omakeacer
tai
nki
nd

ofasenseweseem t
obeev
olv
edt
o

t
hinkt
hiswayy
ouknowI
'
minher
eah

i
t'
snott
hatIam t
hisbodyi
t'
sthat

y
ouknowf
indsomet
hingt
hat
'si
nsi
de

her
edr
yI'
mthedr
iveri
fyoul
i
kei
na

v
ehi
clet
hatki
ndoff
eel
i
ngi
fyou

st
artwi
tht
hatv
iewIcanseehowy
ou

mi
ghtbel
uredi
ntoal
lthoseki
ndof

ar
gument
sbutl
et'
snotdot
hatl
et'
s

st
artwi
thwhatweact
ual
l
yknowabout

t
hewayt
hewor
ldwor
kst
hewaybr
ains

wor
koncey
oust
artl
ooki
ngati
tthat

wayandst
art
ingf
rom knownt
hingst
hose

ar
gument
sjustl
ookl
i
key
ouknowy
ou'
ve

l
osti
tatt
hef
ir
stst
epwe'
vegother
e

t
hisabsol
utel
yfundament
almy
ster
ythe

nat
ureofconsci
ousnessbr
ingi
ngGod

doesn'
thel
pint
hel
eastwel
li
tis

sy
ner
gist
icwi
tht
heconceptofGodi
n

Godi
saconsci
ousnessandGodi
fyou
t
akeupt
heper
sonal
expr
essi
oni
n

West
ernr
eli
gionswant
stohav
ea

r
elat
ionshi
pwi
thot
herconsci
ousbei
ngs

i
thasani
nter
nal
consi
stencyi
fyou

t
hinkoft
hewor
ldi
sbei
ngki
ndof

dr
ivenbyt
hesei
nvi
sibl
esuper
nat
ural

power
sist
hatr
eal
l
yasensi
blewayof

t
ryi
ngt
ounder
standt
hewor
lddoesn'
t

seem sot
omeIdon'
tthi
nki
t'
san

i
ssueofsensi
bleornotsensi
blei
t'
sa

quest
ionofwhat
'sr
eal

al
otoft
hingsi
nthewor
ldt
hat
'sr
eal

t
hent
hey
'r
enotsensi
bley
eahI
'
mjust

f
lummoxeddr
ivei
tbybypeopl
ewhowhat

whot
hinkt
haty
ougetany
wher
eby

i
nvoki
ngaGodandar
elat
ionshi
pwi
th

Godi
tdoesn'
thel
pdoesi
t

i
t'
sjustmy
ster
ymonger
ingi
t'
sjust

r
epl
aci
ngonemy
ster
ywi
thanot
her

consci
ousnessi
snowahugemy
ster
yI

don'
tthi
nkwe'
reev
encl
oset
oat
heor
y

t
hatdoest
hej
obbutwewi
l
lbeand

t
hatmy
ster
ywi
l
lgoawayi
nvoki
ngGod

i
snotgoi
ngt
ohel
pint
hel
easther
e's

oneoft
heway
sthatt
hei
stswoul
duse

t
heconsci
ousnessar
gumentt
oinf
ert
he

exi
stenceofGodt
heywoul
dsaywehav
e

consci
ousnessandev
ery
bodyagr
eest
hat
wecan'
texpl
aini
tandunderwhi
chset

ofpr
iorhy
pot
heseswoul
dconsci
ousness

beeasi
ert
oexpl
aint
hegodhy
pot
hesi
s

t
hati
tther
eisaconsci
ousnessi
nthe

uni
ver
set
hatt
hishasemer
gedora

r
andom uncer
tai
ntyoft
heuni
ver
sei
n

whi
chconsci
ousnesshasmagi
cal
l
y

my
sti
cal
l
yandr
andoml
yemer
gedt
hat
's

t
hechoi
cei
t'
sjustsay
ingwegi
veup

weneedt
heki
ndoft
heor
ythatdoes

somewor
kupmaki
ngsenseofhowbr
ains

andexper
iencear
erel
atedt
oeachot
her

t
hatdoesn'
thel
pdoesi
tdoy
out
hink

i
thel
ps

t
hankssuef
orput
ti
ngt
heonusbackon

meokay

f
airquest
ionher
e'smyansweri
t'
sthe

onl
yanswert
hatmi
ghtf
avoragod

hy
pot
hesi
sift
hemani
fest
ati
onof

consci
ousnesswoul
dbemor
eli
kel
ymor
e

expect
edmor
epr
obabl
eift
her
ewer
ea

God

compar
edwi
thi
fther
ewer
enoGod

t
hat
'si
tthat
'sal
lI'
vegott
osuppor
t

Godwi
thconsci
ousness

per
hapsast
rongeranswercomesf
rom a

di
ff
erentdi
rect
ionwhi
l
eChr
ist
iani
ty

Judai
sm andI
slam l
i
nkedconsci
ousness
t
oGodt
hel
i
nkf
rom consci
ousnesst
o

spi
ri
tual
real
i
tiesi
sev
enst
rongeri
n

Hi
ndui
sm IengageHi
nduphy
sici
stsVi
vi

Robi
nwhor
espect
sthedeept
radi
ti
ons

ofhi
sher
it
agewhi
l
epr
ior
it
izi
ngt
he

adv
ancesofsci
encei
nmai
nst
ream

Hi
ndui
sm t
hati
sthev
iewt
hat

under
gir
dingt
heuni
ver
sei
sacosmi
c

awar
enesst
hecosmosi
tsel
ffr
om t
he

v
eryf
ir
stshr
iekoft
heBi
gBangor

ev
enl
ongbef
oret
hatt
her
ehasbeenan

awar
enesswhi
chonecal
l
sacosmi
c

consci
ousnessi
fyouwi
l
landt
hei
n

t
hatsensef
rom at
radi
ti
onal
Hindu

per
spect
ivet
hati
sconsci
ousnessi
n

ev
eryat
om andel
ect
roni
ntheuni
ver
se

spi
ri
tual
enl
i
ght
enmenti
spr
eci
sel
yone

i
nwhi
choner
ecogni
zest
hatt
he

i
ndi
vi
dual
consci
ousnessi
spar
toft
hat

supr
emeunder
gir
dingconsci
ouspr
inci
ple

whi
chi
sthati
ntheuni
ver
secanwe

i
nferf
rom t
hef
actt
hatwehav
e

consci
ousnesst
hatt
her
eissucha

cosmi
cconsci
ousnessoragr
eat
er

consci
ousnessabsol
utel
yifonemayuse

ananal
ogybei
fyouhav
eav
erygr
and

pai
nti
ngt
heni
nthecor
e

y
ouseeal
i
ttl
esi
gnat
urebyt
hear
ti
st
soonemaysayt
hatouri
ndi
vi
dual

consci
ousnessi
sact
ual
l
yal
i
ttl
ebi
t

ofar
emi
nderofwhodi
dthi
sgr
and

pai
nti
nghowi
tsoundsl
i
ket
heni
nthe

Hi
ndut
radi
ti
onconsci
ousnessi
sev
en

mor
eimpor
tanti
nref
lect
ingt
he

ul
ti
mat
ereal
i
tyt
hani
tisi
nthe

West
ernt
radi
ti
onsy
esi
ntheHi
ndu

spi
ri
tual
tradi
ti
ont
hati
swhatal
l

spi
ri
tual
exer
cisesar
esupposedt
obe

t
her
eal
i
zat
ionoft
hei
dent
it
ybet
ween

t
hei
ndi
vi
dual
andt
heul
ti
mat
e

consci
ousnessoft
hecosmi
c

consci
ousnessnowt
hiscosmi
c

consci
ousnessdoesi
thav
eaan

i
ndi
vi
dual
awar
enesst
hatcosmi
c

consci
ousnesswhi
chi
scal
l
edBr
ahmani
n

t
heHi
ndut
radi
ti
oni
sexact
lyonewhi
ch

i
sawar
eofev
ery
thi
ngandi
tisbey
ond

anyoft
hecat
egor
iest
hatwehav
ethat

meanssomet
hingwhi
chhasnoat
tri
but
es

atal
li
tisj
ustt
heul
ti
mat
evoi
das

i
twer
eandatconsci
ousnesspur
ein

East
ernr
eli
gionsconsci
ousnessi
spur
e

andpr
imar
yconsci
ousnessdoesn'
tso

muchaspoi
ntt
oGodasi
trepl
acesGod

wi
thacosmi
cconsci
ousnesski
ndof

ul
ti
mat
ereal
i
tyconsci
ousnessi
tsel
f
pur
econsci
ousnessmor
ethana

monot
hei
sti
cGodbei
ngi
sthehi
ghest

pl
aneofexi
stencebutt
hiswhol
e

edi
fi
ceofconsci
ousnesspoi
nti
ng

i
nfer
iorl
yupwar
dwhet
hert
oGodort
o

cosmi
cconsci
ousnessi
sbui
l
tont
he

assumpt
iont
hatconsci
ousnesst
ranscends

t
hephy
sical

mostsci
ent
ist
srej
ectal
lthi
sas

nonsenset
heyr
idi
cul
etheanci
enti
dea

t
hatconsci
ousnesscoul
dpoi
ntt
oGod

consci
ousnesspoi
ntst
othebr
aint
hey

asser
tnowher
eel
sey
esIwast
rai
nedas

abr
ainsci
ent
istandy
etIcannotshake

myst
rangesenset
hatconsci
ousnessi
s

r
eal
l
yspeci
alcani
reconci
l
ethe

war
ri
ngcampsofbr
ainsci
enceand

consci
ousnessasr
eal
l
yspeci
alIspeak

t
oacosmol
ogi
stswhoseesi
nthe

uni
ver
seapower
ful
rol
efor

consci
ousnessbutPaul
Dav
iesi
sno

r
eli
giousbel
i
everwel
lwher
edoy
ou

f
all
ont
hisbi
modal
appr
oacht
o

consci
ousnessonei
sthatconsci
ousness

i
ssof
undament
alsoi
rr
educi
blet
hati
t

l
eadst
oGodot
her
sconsci
ousnessi
san

i
l
lusi
oni
nter
est
ingbutdoesn'
tl
ead

any
wher
edon'
tbel
i
eveei
theraboutt
he
f
ir
stt
hingi
sthatIt
akeconsci
ousness

ser
iousl
yIt
hinkt
hatmi
ndi
snotj
ust

somesomear
bit
rar
yli
tt
leembel
l
ishment

i
nsomecor
neroft
hecosmosIt
hinki
t

i
sfundament
alt
othewhol
eandt
hati
s

becauseev
ent
ual
l
ymi
ndhast
he

capabi
l
ityoft
ransf
ormi
ngt
heuni
ver
se

i
t'
sreal
l
yofcosmi
csi
gni
fi
cancenow

att
hemomentwe'
vet
ransf
ormedour

pl
anetwecani
magi
net
hati
nmi
l
li
ons

ofy
ear
sti
meourdescendant
smay

t
ransf
ormt
hesol
arsy
stem whoknows

ev
ent
ual
l
ythegal
axyper
hapst
heent
ir
e

uni
ver
sesoi
thast
hatabi
l
ityso

t
hat
'soner
easonIt
akei
tser
iousl
y

t
heot
heri
sbecauset
hroughsci
enceand

mat
hemat
icshumanbei
ngshav
edev
eloped

t
heabi
l
ityt
ounder
standnat
ureandt
he

r
ulesonwhi
chnat
urer
unst
hisi
snot

somet
hingt
hati
sappar
enti
ndai
l
yli
fe

whenNewt
onsawt
heAppl
efal
lhedi
dn'
t

j
ustseeaf
all
i
ngAppl
e

hesawasetofdi
ff
erent
ial
equat
ions

connect
ingt
hemot
ionoft
heAppl
eto

t
hemot
ionoft
hemoont
hat
'st
hesor
t

ofi
nfor
mat
iony
ouwoul
dnev
erev
erget

i
nthemi
l
li
ony
ear
sjustbyl
ooki
ngand

know
ar
enotunder
standi
ngoft
hisdeeper

mat
hemat
ical
theor
eti
cal
lev
elsoher
e

i
sauni
ver
sewhi
chhasengi
neer
edi
ts

owncompr
ehensi
oni
t'
sengi
neer
edl
i
ving

bei
ngswhocancomet
ounder
standt
he

uni
ver
senowdoest
hatl
eadt
oGodwel
l

may
benott
het
radi
ti
onal
GodbutI

t
hinki
tleadsust
osomet
hingI
'
m

meani
ngandpur
posei
ntheuni
ver
seso

t
hati
smypat
hbuti
t'
snotan

ar
bit
rar
ytr
ivi
all
i
ttl
ethi
ngbuti
t'
s

notbest
owedbyGodconsci
ousnessmi
nd

emer
gesoutofnat
urebuti
tli
nkst
o

t
hedeepestpr
ocessesofnat
uresot
his

i
sal
lpar
tofmyphi
l
osophyt
hatt
he

uni
ver
sei
sfr
om sor
tofsel
fconsi
stent

sel
fexpl
anat
orypr
inci
pleorl
oopso

t
hisi
sar
adi
cal
ideaal
thoughi
t'
snot

sor
adi
cal
ify
ou'
rest
eepedi
nquant
um

phy
sicswher
etheobser
verpl
aysav
ery

si
gni
fi
cantr
olei
nthepopul
armi
nd

t
her
e'st
hisnot
iont
hatt
her
e'sa

uni
quehi
stor
ythatconnect
ssayt
heBi
g

Bangt
heor
igi
noft
heuni
ver
sewi
tht
he

pr
esentst
ateoft
heuni
ver
sequant
um

phy
sicsi
sthat
'sj
ustal
oadofbal
oney

t
hatt
her
e'saani
nfi
nit
enumberof

hi
stor
iest
heywi
l
lfol
diti
ntoget
her
andi
fyouknownot
hingatal
laboutt
he

pastoft
heuni
ver
sey
oumustt
akeal
l

oft
hesehi
stor
iesnowwhent
heymake

obser
vat
ionswhatwe'
redoi
ngi
s

chi
ppi
ngawayoft
hesehi
stor
iesand

r
emov
ingsomeoft
hem wer
ecul
l
ingt
hem

andi
npr
inci
plei
fwecoul
dfi
l
lthe

ent
ir
euni
ver
sewi
thobser
vat
ionswe

woul
dthenhomedi
nonsomet
hingl
i
kea

uni
quehi
stor
yandsot
heactof

obser
vat
ioni
mpar
tresol
vessomet
hing

aboutt
hehi
stor
iesoft
heuni
ver
seso

t
hisi
swher
ethef
eedbackl
oopcomesi
n

t
hatt
hel
aws

st
artoutunf
ocusedandf
uzzyt
hat

ev
ent
ual
l
yther
e'sl
i
feandobser
ver
s

t
hatl
i
nkbackt
hroughj
ustl
i
kei
n

quant
um mechani
csbacki
nti
met
hrough

maki
ngt
hei
robser
vat
ionsandhel
p

shar
pent
hosel
awsi
nawayt
hat
'ssel
f

consi
stentwi
tht
hei
rownexi
stenceso

her
ewehav
eauni
ver
set
hathasan

expl
anat
ionwi
thi
nit
sel
fthatt
he

obser
ver
sthatar
isepl
ayapar
tin

sel
ect
ingt
hev
eryl
awst
hatl
eadt
othe

emer
genceoft
hemsel
vesanddosome

i
nter
est
ingwor
dssel
ect
ing

sel
f-
consi
stent
buti
sthatnotbackwar
dcausat
ionwhi
ch

seemst
ofl
yint
hef
aceofev
ery
thi
ng

t
hat

seemst
owor
kint
hemacr
oscopi
cri
ght

i
t'
snotcausat
ioni
nthef
ami
l
iarsense

t
haty
oucandosomet
hingandmakea

changey
ou'
renotchangi
ngt
hepat
hs

i
t'
sjustt
hatt
her
ear
emanypast
sthe

pasti
sfuzzyandunr
esol
vedandsowhat

happensl
ateroni
thel
psbr
ingabouta

r
esol
uti
onofi
tandt
hat
'st
hat
'sa

subt
ledi
sti
nct
ionsbutcer
tai
nly

consci
ousnesspl
aysacr
it
ical
rol
ein

i
nthi
spr
ocessandy
ouar
eusi
ng

consci
ousnesst
osel
ectamongt
hesel
aws

t
ocal
lthatbackhi
stor
ybutt
houghbut

t
hatt
henpat
hthatbackhi
stor
ypat
h

hast
obeonet
hatwoul
dcr
eat
ethe

consci
ousnesst
ogi
vey
our
sel
f

consi
stencyandofcour
sey
ouhav
eto

hav
ethi
sifwe'
ret
ryi
ngt
oexpl
ainwhy

doest
heuni
ver
seexi
sti
nit
spr
esent

f
orm andi
npar
ti
cul
arwhydoesi
t

cont
ainl
i
feandobser
ver
sobv
iousl
y

t
her
e'sl
i
feandobser
ver
shav
etobe

r
elev
antsot
hel
awst
hatgi
ver
iset
o

t
hem becauset
her
e'snoot
herwayy
ou

canhav
eanexpl
anat
ionf
ort
heuni
ver
se
f
rom ent
ir
elywi
thi
nitsot
heonl
y

al
ter
nat
ivei
stoappeal
tosomet
hing

out
sidei
tli
keanunexpl
ainedGodoran

unexpl
ainedsetofphy
sical
lawssoi
f

whatI
'
m say
ingsoundsr
idi
cul
oust
hey

soundr
idi
cul
oust
oobecausewhenwe'
re

t
angl
i
ngwi
tht
hesear
esomequest
ions

ofexi
stencei
t'
swer
eboundt
ogo

bey
ondi
ntui
ti
onwe'
reboundt
ogo

bey
ondcommonsensesor
tofev
ery
day

not
ionsandsoany
thi
ngwecomeupwi
th

i
sgoi
ngt
ost
ri
key
ouatf
ir
stsi
zes

j
ustbi
zar
rer
idi
cul
ousev
enanswer
ed

butIt
hinkwhatI
'
m say
ingi
snomor
e

r
idi
cul
ousorabsur
dthant
aki
ngon

f
ait
htheexi
stenceofanunexpl
ained

Godordesi
gneroranunexpl
ainedsetof

phy
sical
lawst
hatj
usthappenedt
obe

r
ightandgi
ver
iset
oobser
ver
sli
ke

our
sel
vesr
ightPaul
ever
yexpl
anat
ion

ofexi
stencei
sri
dicul
ous

Paul
'
ski
ndofbackwar
dscausat
ionwher
e

consci
ousnesst
odayandsomehowsel
ect

t
hel
awsofphy
sicst
hatenabl
edi
tsown

ear
li
eremer
gencei
scer
tai
nly

r
idi
cul
ousbuti
sPaul
'
stheor
ymor
e

r
idi
cul
oust
hanasel
f-
exi
sti
nggodor

t
hant
hel
awsofphy
sicsmagi
cal
l
y
appear
ingoutofnot
hingandbei
ng

per
fect
lyt
unedt
ohumanexi
stencemor
e

t
hanv
astnumber
sofuni
ver
seseachwi
th

i
tsownl
awswhysuchext
remesol
uti
ons

t
ocosmosconsci
ousnessGodmaybe

ext
remei
swhat
'
sneededt
oexpl
ain

ul
ti
mat
ereal
i
tyany
onewhot
hinkst
hat

Paul
off
erst
hemostext
remeul
ti
mat
e

expl
anat
ionhasnotencount
ered

phi
l
osopherJohnLesl
i
e

Johni
sco-
edi
toroft
hemy
ster
yof

exi
stencewhyi
sther
eany
thi
ngatal
l

i
tcoul
dbet
hatt
hewor
ldhasbeen

const
ruct
edar
oundconsci
ousnessf
or

exampl
eyoucoul
dbeabel
i
everi
nGod

whot
houghtt
hatt
hewor
ldwoul
dnotbe

i
ncr
eat
edatal
lhadi
tnotbeenf
or

consci
ousnessandIt
hinky
oucanev
en

def
endt
het
heor
ythatnot
hingcoul
d

act
ual
l
yber
eal
unl
esst
her
ewas

consci
ousnessi
nvol
vedhowwoul
dthatbe

t
hei
deaIIt
hinki
sbasi
cal
l
ythi
s

t
hati
t'
sessent
ial
tot
henat
ureof

r
eal
i
tyt
her
eal
i
tybesomet
hing

compl
i
cat
edbutal
lthecompl
exi
ti
esar
e

al
li
nasi
ngl
ethi
ngbutt
hisdemands

consci
ousnessonl
yconsci
ousnessi
sabl
e

t
otakeaent
ir
ecompl
i
cat
edpat
ter
nand
makei
tbel
ongt
oasi
ngl
ethi
ngand

unl
essy
ouhadconsci
ousnesst
her
ewoul
d

benocompl
exi
tyi
nthewor
ldIt
hink

t
hati
tcoul
dbet
hatf
orexampl
ethe

ent
ir
est
ruct
ureoft
hewor
ldi
sa

st
ruct
uret
houghtbyani
nfi
nit
emi
ndor

i
tcoul
dsi
mpl
ybet
haty
oucoul
ddef
end

t
hev
iewt
hatev
enatt
hel
evel
ofv
ery

si
mpl
esy
stemsl
i
keat
omst
her
eisa

v
eryobscur
esor
tofconsci
ousnesswhi
ch

i
sneededi
nor
dert
ogett
he

busi
nessofcompl
exi
tyi
ntot
hewor
ld

howdoy
ougetacompl
exuni
ver
sehow

di
dthev
ari
ouspar
tsofi
tknowt
hat

t
heot
herpar
tsar
ether
esot
heycan

r
eactt
otheot
herpar
tsIt
hinki
t

coul
dmakesenset
osayconsci
ousnessi
s

r
equi
redf
ort
hisandsowhatt
hatmeans

i
sthatconsci
ousnessi
samor
e

f
undament
alpar
tofr
eal
i
tyt
hatcoul
d

bet
hecasey
esIdon'
tthi
nki
tshoul
d

si
mpl
ybedi
smi
ssedoutofhand

wel
li
t'
ssomet
hingt
hatmostsci
ent
ist
s

wor
kingt
odaywoul
ddi
smi
ssoutofhand

y
eahIt
hinkbecauset
heyhav
en'
t

t
houghtt
hemat
tert
hroughIt
hinkt
hey

hav
en'
treal
i
zedt
hatwhatt
heyar
e

const
ant
lyi
nvest
igat
ingi
sthe
st
ruct
ureoft
hewor
ldsuchascoul
dbe

descr
ibedbymat
hemat
ics

t
her
efor
etheyar
en'
ti
nthebusi
nessof

deci
dingwhatcar
ri
est
hatst
ruct
ure

whet
herf
orexampl
eit
scar
ri
edbya

di
vi
nemi
ndi
fyouwer
eapant
hei
st

y
oucoul
dthi
nkt
hatabsol
utel
y

ev
ery
thi
ngexi
stsi
nsi
det
hedi
vi
nemi
nd

t
hatt
hest
ruct
ureoft
hephy
sical
wor
ld

i
sthest
ruct
ureoft
het
hought
sina

di
vi
nemi
ndt
her
e'sanet
hical

r
equi
rementwhi
chi
ssat
isf
iedbyt
he

f
actt
hatauni
ver
seexi
stsnowImy
sel
f

can'
tthi
nkt
hatt
heuni
ver
sewoul
dhav
e

anyv
alueatal
lei
therposi
ti
veor

negat
ivei
fconsci
ousnesswer
eabsent

f
rom i
t

It
hinkt
hiswe'
ret
hinki
ngi
sn'
ti
sn'
t

cr
azy

t
ogetatul
ti
mat
ereal
i
tycr
azy

t
hinki
ngmay
bej
ustwhat
'
sneededher
e's

myt
akeonconsci
ousnessandul
ti
mat
e

r
eal
i
tyasequenceofquest
ionsquest
ion

onei
sconsci
ousnessr
eal
orani
l
lusi
on

i
fani
l
lusi
onst
oppedonl
ythephy
sical

exi
stsandt
her
eisnoGod

i
freal
goont
oquest
iont
woquest
ion

t
woi
sconsci
ousnessent
ir
elyt
he
acci
dent
alout
putoft
hephy
sical
brai
n

i
fyesst
opi
fnogoont
oquest
ion

t
hreequest
iont
hree

i
fconsci
ousnessgoesbey
ondt
he

phy
sical
brai
nwhi
choff
ourcauses

woul
dithav
eanewf
undament
alf
orcebe

r
efl
ect
ionofpr
imor
dial
cosmi
c

consci
ousnessseet
hecr
eat
ionofa

consci
ousGodt
hepr
oductofa

f
undament
alv
alueImy
sel
fcangett
o

quest
iont
hreeofal
lthatweknowabout

ul
ti
mat
ereal
i
tyconsci
ousnesspr
ovi
des

t
hebestcl
uesbutt
henwhi
chwoul
d

causeconsci
ousnessf
undament
alf
orce

cosmi
cconsci
ousnessGodv
aluewhi
ch

woul
dbecl
osert
otr
uth

[
Musi
c]

f
orcompl
etei
nter
viewsandf
orf
urt
her

i
nfor
mat
ionpl
easev
isi
tcl
osert
otr
uth

cal
m

[
Musi
c]