[

Musi
c]

[
Musi
c]

whati
sthebi
ggestofal
lquest
ions

doesGodexi
sthowdi
dtheuni
ver
se

begi
nwhati
sconsci
ousnessi
sther
e

l
i
feaf
terdeat
h

bi
gquest
ionssur
elybutnoneoft
hem

t
hebi
ggesther
e'st
hebi
ggestwhyi
s

t
her
eany
thi
ngatal
lrol
lev
ery
thi
ng

t
hatexi
stsi
ntoonewor
dandcal
li
t

al
lsomet
hingwhyi
sther
esomet
hing

r
athert
hannot
hingt
hisquest
ionnev
er

st
opshaunt
ingmet
hisi
sthemy
ster
yof

exi
stence

I
'
m Rober
tLawr
enceKuhnandcl
osert
o

t
rut
hismyj
our
neyt
osol
vet
his

my
ster
ysol
venonotr
eal
l
y

I
'
m notdel
udedI
'
mjustobsessedwhyi
s

t
her
esomet
hingr
athert
hannot
hing

t
hisi
snoor
dinar
yquest
iont
rustme

t
hemor
eyoupondert
hist
hemor
ewobbl
y

y
ouf
eel
IknowITeet
ersot
ost
eady

my
sel
fIst
artwi
tht
hephy
sici
stwho

expl
oresr
adi
cal
quest
ionsbutwho

cent
ershi
sexpl
orat
ionsi
nsci
ence

Mi
chi
oKakuMi
chi
othr
oughoutmyl
i
feI

hav
ebeenobsessedwi
tht
hequest
ionwhy

i
sther
esomet
hingr
athert
hannot
hing
whyi
sther
eany
thi
ngatal
lanyl
awsof

phy
sicsany
thi
ngwhat
soev
eri
nfact

wel
l
-knownphi
l
osophersai
dift
his

quest
iondoesn'
ttot
all
ydr
ivey
ounut
s

y
ouj
ustdon'
tunder
standt
hequest
ion

wel
lIi
saphy
sici
stt
ryt
ofi
nd

meani
ngul
ti
mat
elyt
hroughequat
ions

obser
vat
ionsandt
henaf
tert
he

obser
vat
ionsandequat
ionsar
edonet
hen

wecanl
ookbackandseewher
ear
ewe

goi
ngwi
thal
lthi
sandwhatweseei
sa

pat
ter
nweseeapat
ter
nthatt
hel
aws

ofphy
sicsseem sost
rangeand

di
sconnect
edandnut
tyi
nfactbutt
hey

ar
econv
ergi
ngconv
ergi
ngt
oa

har
moni
ousendsot
het
rendof

uni
fi
cat
iont
het
rendofhar
monyi
s

somet
hingweseet
hroughoutt
hiswhol
e

pr
ocesst
heny
ouaskt
hequest
ionwel
l

what
'sbey
ondt
hati
sther
eanequat
ion

l
i
keeequal
smc-
squar
edt
hatwi
l
lgi
ve

ust
hewhol
eshoot
ingmat
chandIt
end

t
obel
i
evet
heansweri
syest
hatt
her
e

i
sanequat
ionper
hapsnomor
ethanhal
f

ani
nchl
ongwhi
chwi
l
lgi
veust
he

ent
ir
etheor
yofcr
eat
ioni
tsel
fyou

r
eal
i
zet
hatonasheetofpapert
his

bi
gwecanal
readywr
it
edownal
lthe
knownl
awsofphy
sicsext
endi
ngf
rom t
he

hear
tofanat
om al
lthewayoutt
othe

nat
ureoft
heBi
gBangandt
hegal
axi
es

t
hemsel
vest
hent
hequest
ioni
swel
l

wher
edi
dthatsheetofpapercomef
rom

wher
edi
dthatwheni
tsequat
ioncome

butwhenEi
nst
einwoul
dwor
khewoul
d

sayt
ohi
msel
fint
hemor
ningandhe

wr
oteaboutt
hisi
nhi
smemoi
rsi
fI'
m

Godt
odayhowwoul
dIcr
eat
eauni
ver
se

whatwoul
dIst
artwi
thwhatpr
inci
ples

woul
dIneedandy
oucansayt
oyour
sel
f

wel
lfi
rstIneedanar
enaf
ir
stIneed

apl
acewher
ethi
ngst
ohappent
henI

needst
ufft
omaket
hingshappen

sowheny
oust
artwi
thanar
ena

i
mmedi
atel
yyou'
rel
edt
oani
dea

t
hatt
hemi
nimal
uni
ver
sey
oucancr
eat
e

i
sauni
ver
sewi
thsomeki
ndofspace

andt
imef
orst
ufft
ohappenandt
hen

y
ouhav
etohav
est
uffhappeni
ngbuti
t

di
dn'
thav
etobet
hisbi
zar
requant
um

t
heor
ybuti
tdoeshav
etobet
his

bi
zar
requant
um t
heor
yyouseet
he

si
mpl
estst
ufft
haty
oucoul
dhav
eis

Newt
oni
ant
hingsgoi
ngar
oundot
her

t
hingsear
thgoi
ngar
oundst
arst
hat
's

t
hesi
mpl
estst
uffy
oucanhav
ebuti
t'
s
unst
abl
eifIhav
etwosol
arsy
stems

col
l
idewhathappensIgetmushi
fI

hav
esol
arsy
stemsbumpi
ngi
ntoeach

ot
herIhav
epl
anet
sbei
ngf
lungout

st
arscol
l
idi
ngwi
thst
arsi
t'
samess

sot
her
efor
eAdamsmadeoutofgr
avi
ty

ar
enotst
abl
ether
efor
eyouhav
eto

hav
eagl
uet
hatcanhol
dst
ufft
oget
her

t
hingshav
etobeatmor
epl
acesatt
he

samet
imei
nor
dert
omaket
wot
hings

st
ickt
hat
'swhatt
hequant
um t
heor
y

comesi
nsoy
ouy
ouhav
ebot
hoft
hese

maj
orway
soft
hinki
ngy
ouhav
ethe

ar
enaspaceandt
imei
ninwhi
cht
hings

happenandt
heny
ouhav
etheki
ndsof

l
awswhi
chcr
eat
ethemat
tert
hest
uff

ort
heev
ent
stohappenwi
thi
nthat

ar
enaandt
hatal
lcoher
ent
lymakes

sensebutt
hequest
ionpushesusback

onest
epf
urt
herwher
edi
dthosel
aws

comef
rom howdoy
ougett
hem nowso

beaut
if
ull
ythatwor
kedt
oget
hert
he

answerIt
hinki
smat
hemat
ical

sel
f-
consi
stencywheny
oust
artt
o

cr
eat
eat
heor
yofanar
enaandat
heor
y

ofst
ufft
hatst
ickst
oget
heral
most

i
mmedi
atel
yyouf
indt
hatmat
hemat
icsi
s

unst
abl
ethi
ngsf
all
apar
tthi
ngsdon'
t
st
ickt
oget
her

Newt
oni
anat
omsdon'
tst
ickt
oget
her

wheny
oust
artt
oputi
nconsi
stency

mat
hemat
ical
consi
stencyt
heny
ou

r
eal
i
zei
tcoul
dbeuni
quet
her
ecoul
d

beonl
yonet
heor
ywher
est
uffst
icks

t
oget
herandi
sst
abl
eandexi
stsi
n

ar
ena

soi
nsomesenseGodi
samat
hemat
ici
an

Godi
sageomet
rycr
eat
ingonl
y

uni
ver
seswhi
char
emat
hemat
ical
l
ysel
f

consi
stentandoncey
ouhav
eanar
ena

andoncey
ouhav
est
ufft
hatst
abl
eit

coul
dbeuni
quet
her
ecoul
dbeonl
yone

t
heor
yofst
uffi
nanar
enawheny
ou'
re

usi
ngt
het
erm gody
ou'
reusi
ngt
het
erm

i
nanEi
nst
einsenseandi
nthesenseof

under
lyi
ngpr
inci
plesoft
heuni
ver
seas

opposedt
oar
eli
gioussenseofa

per
sonal
GodIassumet
hat
'
sri
ghtt
he

godofSpi
nozai
swhatEi
nst
einbel
i
eved

andhecal
l
edhi
mtheol
dmant
hati
s

t
hel
awgi
vert
hatexi
stedi
nsomesense

bef
oret
heuni
ver
sewascr
eat
edt
heol
d

wat
erorsomet
hingl
i
ket
heol
done

r
ightandandt
heol
donewasnota

per
sonasmuchast
hisubi
qui
tous

pr
inci
pleofhar
monyofor
derof
consi
stencyr
ightandsomat
hemat
ical

consi
stencyi
ssost
ri
ngentsost
ri
ngent

t
hatEi
nst
einsai
dmay
beGoddi
dn'
thav
e

achoi
ceheaskedhi
msel
fthekey

quest
iondi
dGodhav
eachoi
cei
nmaki
ng

t
heuni
ver
seandher
eal
i
zedt
hatmay
be

t
heuni
ver
sewasuni
quei
thadt
obet
he

wayi
tisbecauset
her
e'snoot
her

possi
bil
i
tybutMi
chi
oev
eni
fther
e

coul
dbeonl
yonesel
fconsi
stentand

st
abl
euni
ver
sewhi
chmanyphy
sici
sts

nowr
eluct
ant
lyr
ejectwhyshoul
dthat

uni
ver
seexi
str
athert
hannouni
ver
se

atal
lgr
ant
edsel
fconsi
stencyand

st
abi
l
ityar
eneededf
ort
heuni
ver
set
o

exi
stbutdot
hesequal
i
tieshav
e

or
igi
nat
ingcr
eat
ingpowert
ocauset
he

uni
ver
set
oexi
stbutmay
bet
heuni
ver
se

doesn'
tneedacausewi
thouti
nvoki
ng

any
thi
ngsuper
nat
ural
nogodsal
l
owed

coul
dauni
ver
seemer
gef
rom not
hing

sci
ent
ist
ssayy
esandt
heyst
artwi
th

t
hel
awsofphy
sicsbutt
hel
awsof

phy
sicsar
enotnot
hingmynot
hingt
hank

y
oui
smor
enot
hingt
hant
hey
'r
enot
hing

t
ocont
inuewi
thmynot
hingIt
urnt
o

phi
l
osophyIgot
oOxf
ordt
omeett
he

aut
horoft
hebookwhyt
her
eis
somet
hingr
athert
hannot
hing

beadRundl
ewhencosmol
ogi
stst
alkabout

t
hebegi
nni
ngsoft
heuni
ver
sest
emmi
ng

or
igi
nat
ingf
rom not
hingt
heynear
ly

al
way
sifnotal
way
sthi
nkofnot
hingi
n

t
henonl
i
ter
alsensewher
eitmeans

empt
yspaceandsot
her
efor
e

cosmol
ogi
stsnot
hingi
sfi
l
ledwi
th

st
uffwel
lthat
'sr
ightal
lthi
squant
um

f
oam andt
hingsgoi
ngonsot
henot
hing

oft
hecosmol
ogi
stsi
stomenotnot

not
hingi
t'
sseasonedwi
thi
fther
e'sa

pr
esupposi
ti
ont
haty
ouhav
eatl
easta

spaceev
eni
fit
'sanempt
yspacet
hen

t
hati
ssomet
hingt
hathast
obe

account
edf
ory
oucansayt
hingsl
i
ke

wel
lnot
hingmi
ghthav
eexi
stedbuti
f

y
ousayt
haty
ou'
rei
naf
atesay
ing

wel
lthi
smi
ghtnothav
eexi
stst
his

mi
ghtnothav
eexi
stedandsoonandy
ou

don'
tmeant
haty
ouwon'
tsaynonot

t
her
e'sat
hingcal
l
ednot
hingt
hat

mi
ghthav
ebeeni
npl
aceofsomet
hing

her
ewehav
eapr
obl
em wi
tht
hinki
ngof

not
hingassor
tofboundi
ngt
heuni
ver
se

i
nanysenseandmyf
eel
i
ngi
sthat

peopl
ewhot
alkconf
ident
lyabout

not
hingdosobecauseoft
heanal
ogy
wi
thanempt
yspacesot
her
e'snot
hing

i
nthecupboar
d

r
ightmakesper
fect
lygoodsensebut

t
her
e'sst
il
lthecompet
entsoi
fthat
's

ourmodel
thenwei
magi
neget
ti
ngr
idof

t
hecupboar
dandanyot
hercont
ainerand

her
ewehav
ejustempt
yspaceasIsay

empt
yspacei
snotgoodenoughnotgood

andi
t'
sver
yhar
dtogi
veanysubst
ance

t
henot
ionoft
her
ebei
ngnot
hingt
hat

wi
l
lgi
vey
ouagenui
neal
ter
nat
ivet
o

ani
nit
ial
placebutt
hent
akeaway

ehal
lthespaceandt
imeandsot
hat

r
eal
l
yisnot
hingt
her
e'snospacewel
l

y
ouj
usthav
etomaket
hest
epassay
s

okayt
hatt
hatonemi
cromi
crov
eryhot

essencet
hatbegant
heBi
gBangnev
er

came

nev
erhappenedandsot
heny
our
eal
l
ydo

hav
enot
hingbecausey
oudon'
thav
e

spaceort
ime

what
'sar
tthat
'sr
ighty
eahbutt
hen

cany
ousayt
haty
ouhav
enot
hingi
nthe

senset
hatt
hat
'sanact
ual
stat
eof

af
fai
rst
hatobt
ainedatt
hispoi
ntand

t
hat
'st
het
hingt
hatIhav
emost

t
roubl
ewi
thmaki
ngsensebecause

not
hingt
hat
'sagoodwayy
ousayt
hings
goi
ngoutofexi
stencesayonebyone

j
ustl
i
keal
lthest
arsgoi
ngouty
ou

metl
i
kel
i
ght
syourmedswegoy
eahand

t
henwe'
rel
eftwi
thnot
hingt
hat
'sj
ust

t
hecul
minat
ionoft
hisbutt
heny
ou

not
icet
hedi
ff
erentt
hingsi
nthose

t
ermsy
oucoul
dbyr
ever
singt
hepr
ocess

r
epopul
atet
hewor
ldy
esandt
hat
's

becauseasIsayhe'
slef
twi
tha

set
ti
ngaf
ramewor
kint
owhi
cht
hings

comeandgowhatI
'
m suggest
ingi
swe

onl
ythi
nkwecanmakesenseofempt
y

spacet
hat
'sunf
ort
unat
elynotnot
hing

andt
her
e'snosucht
hingast
her
ebei
ng

not
hingt
obeadi
tisi
mpossi
blef
or

t
her
etohav
ebeennot
hingt
her
emust

al
way
shav
ebeensomet
hingorot
her

Idonotagr
eemyi
ntui
ti
oncr
iesout

t
hatt
her
ecoul
dhav
ebeennot
hingt
hat

not
hingwoul
dhav
ebeeneasi
ersi
mpl
er

t
hanany
thi
ngbutnot
hingdoesnot

obt
ainwhyIgot
oaphi
l
osopherwhof
or

hi
sent
ir
ecar
eerhaswr
est
ledwi
thwel
l

not
hingt
heco-
edi
toroft
hebookt
he

my
ster
yofexi
stencewhyi
sther
e

any
thi
ngatal
lJohnLesl
i
eJohnt
he

quest
ionwhyi
sther
esomet
hingr
ather

t
hannot
hingi
sn'
tthi
satt
heendof
ev
ery
thi
ngt
hemostf
undament
alquest
ion

t
hathumanbei
ngscanaskhowev
erf
ar

backy
ouwantt
ogoi
nthecr
eat
ionof

t
heuni
ver
set
othecosmi
cfoam er
upt
ing

i
nthei
nuni
ver
sest
hatsomet
hingcomes

outoft
hatnot
hingwel
lthat
'
snota

not
hingt
hatcosmi
cfoam hasl
awsi
thas

par
ti
clesant
ipar
ti
clesl
awf
orcesal
l

di
ff
erentki
ndsoft
hingsandt
hatki
nd

ofnot
hingy
ouhav
etoaskwhyt
her
ewas

t
hatsomet
hingsoatt
heendoft
heday

west
il
lhav
ethatquest
ionwhyi
sther
e

somet
hingexi
sti
ngr
athert
hannot
hingI

t
hinkt
hat
'sr
ightIdon'
tthi
nki
t

woul
dbepossi
blet
osayf
orexampl
e

quant
um phy
sicst
ell
sust
hati
t'
s

l
i
kel
ythatabl
ankwoul
dfl
uct
uat
eint
o

ar
eal
wor
ldandt
hat
'sy
ourf
inal

answerbecauset
hequest
ionwoul
dbewhy

doest
hisquant
um phy
sicsappl
yto

r
eal
i
tybecauset
hebasi
cquest
ioni
s

whywoul
dthatsetofquant
um phy
sical

l
awsber
ighti
twoul
dseem t
hatnot
hing

i
sissi
mpl
erandandandshoul
dhav
e

beent
her
erat
hert
hansomet
hing

somet
hingy
ouhav
etoexpl
aini
n

di
ff
erentway
snot
hingi
nessencey
ou

don'
thav
etoexpl
ainwel
lIt
hink
t
hat
'scor
rectbutev
eni
nabl
ankt
her
e

woul
dbeal
lsor
tsoff
act
ssoi
fyou

t
ryt
oimagi
neoutofexi
stenceal
l

act
ual
thi
ngsandsayt
hat
'
snot
hingi
n

asenset
hat
'sr
ightbutal
soy
ou'
ve

ov
erl
ookedt
hef
actt
hatt
her
e'san

i
nfi
nit
eri
chnessoft
rut
hsabout

possi
bil
i
tieswhi
ch

i
sboundt
oexi
stev
eni
fnoact
ual

t
hingsexi
stsoi
t'
simpossi
blet
hey

hav
epur
elynot
hingbecausey
oual
way
s

hav
epossi
bil
i
tiesy
oual
way
shav
e

possi
bil
i
tiesy
ouhav
efact
sabout

r
elat
ionshi
psbet
weenpossi
bil
i
tiesand

y
ouhav
ethef
actt
hati
mpossi
blei
sa

goodandot
herpossi
bil
i
tiesar
ebad

t
hesear
efact
swhi
chy
oucan'
tgetaway

f
rom sonowi
nournot
hingwhi
chmay
be

nai
vel
yIt
houghtwaswasv
erysi
mpl
ewe

nowhav
etr
uthst
hatexi
stmat
hemat
ical

t
rut
hsl
ogi
cal
trut
hsandnowan

i
nfi
nit
eser
iesofpossi
bil
i
tieswhi
ch

ev
ent
hought
heyar
enotact
ual
i
zedt
he

possi
bil
i
tiesexi
stsomynot
hing

suddenl
ybecomesav
eryr
ichcombi
nat
ion

i
tbecomesev
enr
icheri
fyouacceptt
he

v
iewwhi
chhasbeenpr
essedbyoneor

t
wophi
l
osopher
sthatt
hedi
sti
nct
ion
bet
weensomet
hingbei
ngmer
elypossi
ble

andsomet
hingbei
ngact
ual
isj
ustl
i
ke

t
hedi
sti
nct
ionbet
weenbei
ngov
ert
her
e

andbei
ngher
ethatal
lthe

possi
bil
i
tiesar
eact
ual
somewher
ethat

sai
disasmet
aphororasnosomepeopl
e

hav
etakent
hatcompl
etel
yser
iousl
y

t
hey
'vesai
dforexampl
ethatal
lthe

Gr
eekgodssol
ongast
heydon'
tcommi
t

cont
radi
cti
onsi
nthei
rexi
stencet
hey

ar
esomewher
ethi
shasbeenhel
dit
'sa

bi
tofanoddv
iew

IknowJohnandhehasoddv
iewsofhi
s

ownIsayt
hatwi
thr
espectandawe

Johnf
amousl
ycl
aimst
hatv
alue

i
ntr
insi
cet
hical
val
uei
sthe

f
oundat
ionofexi
stencecant
hismake

senseIt
hinky
oucan'
thav
eint
ri
nsi
c

v
alueact
ual
l
ybr
oughti
ntot
hewor
ldI

t
hinky
oucanhav
efact
sabouti
n

t
ri
nsi
cval
uewhi
chwoul
dbet
her
ein

t
heabsenceofanyconsci
ousnessf
or

exampl
eIt
hinki
fyouhadacompl
ete

bl
anknot
hingatal
lexi
sti
ngno

consci
ousnesst
heni
twoul
dbet
ruei
n

t
hatbl
ankt
hati
twasav
eryf
ort
unat
e

t
hingt
hatawor
ldt
err
ibl
ewor
ldof

suf
fer
ingi
nwhi
chabsol
utel
yev
ery
body
wasi
nagoni
zi
ngpai
nal
lthet
ime

wasn'
ti
nexi
stencenowt
hatf
actwoul
d

beaf
actabouti
ntr
insi
cval
uet
hat
's

t
osayt
hatawor
ldoft
hissor
twoul
d

hav
eter
ri
blenegat
ivev
alueandt
hat

sor
toff
actdoesn'
tdependonany
one'
s

consci
ousnesssur
ebutt
het
ypi
cal

sci
enceappr
oacht
odayi
sthatt
he

subst
anceofr
eal
i
tyhasnoi
sneut
ral

onv
aluei
t'
snotposi
ti
vei
t'
snot

negat
ivei
tjusti
sandi
t'
shuman

bei
ngswhoi
mposet
hei
rownsenseof

whatv
aluei
sisnot
hingi
ntr
insi
c

t
hat
'sr
idi
cul
ousIt
hinkt
hat
'
swr
ong

v
iewIt
hinki
t'
sapi
ti
abl
evi
ewbutI

hav
etobeari
nmi
ndt
hatsomeofmy

f
ri
endsacceptt
hisbutIt
hinkt
hey

j
usthav
en'
tthoughtt
hingsoutpr
oper
ly

ar
etheyr
eal
l
ythi
nki
ngt
hati
t

woul
dn'
tbet
rueunt
ilwe'
vet
hought

abouti
tthatani
mal
ssuf
fer
ingi
nfor

asf
arasbef
oret
heev
olut
ionofhuman

bei
ngswer
ehav
ingat
err
ibl
eti
met
hat

t
hei
rli
vescoul
datt
hosemoment
sat

anyr
atehav
enegat
ivei
ntr
insi
cval
ue

butt
hatt
hathasnot
hingt
odowi
tht
he

st
ruct
ureofr
eal
i
tyt
hat
'
sjustt
he

f
ort
uneorunf
ort
unat
eci
rcumst
ances
t
hatbei
ngsar
einnot
hingf
oll
ow

f
rom i
tint
ermsofwhatr
eal
i
tyi
sal
l

aboutokay

It
hinki
tinonewayt
hat
'
squi
ter
ight

i
tcoul
dwel
lbet
hatr
eal
i
tywast
he

pr
oductofchancet
hatt
heuni
ver
sej
ust

happenst
oexi
stt
hatt
heuni
ver
sei
s

noti
nter
est
edi
npr
oduci
ngv
alues

t
hat
'sonet
hingIt
endt
othi
nkt
hati
f

t
hey
'r
edecentpeopl
etheni
nthei
r

hear
tofhear
tst
heywi
l
lthi
nkt
hati
t

r
eal
l
ywasunf
ort
unat
eini
tsel
fthat

t
heani
mal
swer
esuf
fer
ingi
nthef
orest

I
IIt
hinkt
heywoul
dsayt
hatbutatt
he

endoft
hedaywhatdoy
oubel
i
eveat

t
heendoft
hedayIbel
i
evesomet
hings

ar
ebet
tert
hanot
hert
hingsIbel
i
eve

al
sot
hati
fyouwantt
ounder
standwhy

t
heuni
ver
seexi
stsy
ououghtt
otake

ser
iousl
yPl
ato'
snot
iont
hati
texi
sts

becausei
t'
sbet
tert
hati
texi
stst
hem

nott
hatt
her
ewasanet
hical

r
equi
rementt
hatagoodwor
ldexi
stsand

t
hatourwor
ldf
oral
li
t'
sbadsi
desi
s

somet
hinggoodt
hesuper
inggoodwoul
d

i
tsel
fbet
heexi
stenceofsomet
hing

whi
chwasi
nfi
nit
elywi
de-
rangi
ngi
nit
s

consci
ousnesswhi
chwoul
dknowamong
ot
hert
hingst
hest
ruct
ureofourwor
ld

buti
nthatcosmol
ogyi
fyouwi
l
lis

whi
chi
sthemor
efundament
alt
hepur
e

consci
ousnessort
hei
nyourt
erm

et
hical
requi
rementoft
hesupr
emegood

nei
thercomesf
ir
stbecausei
t'
sli
ke

t
hist
hatwhat
'set
hical
l
yrequi
redi
sa

goodsi
tuat
ionandt
hegoodsi
tuat
ioni
s

asi
tuat
ionwhi
chi
sgoi
ngt
obe

consci
ousnessi
fyout
akemypoi
ntt
hat

consci
ousnessi
stheonl
ythi
ngwhi
chi
n

t
heendhasanyv
alueei
therposi
ti
veor

negat
ivesoi
t'
sthef
actt
hatt
her
e's

t
hispossi
bil
i
tyofhav
ingagood

si
tuat
ionofconsci
ousnesswhi
chl
eads

t
other
equi
rementt
hati
tshoul
d

act
ual
l
yexi
standt
her
equi
rementj
ust

woul
dn'
tbet
her
eunl
esssai
dwhet
her

unl
essi
twer
etr
uet
hatt
her
e'st
he

possi
bil
i
tyoft
hegoodoft
he

consci
ousnessexi
sti
ng

[
Musi
c]

t
oJohnt
her
easont
her
eissomet
hing

r
athert
hannot
hingi
sthati
tisgood

somet
hingexi
stst
hat
'
scl
everIt
hink

butsor
ryJohn

t
hat
'sal
soabsur
dhowcoul
dval
ueand

et
hical
requi
rementbeacr
eat
ingf
orce
whi
chengender
ssomet
hingf
rom not
hing

t
hencal
mlyIf
oll
owJohn'
sar
gument

t
hatev
eni
fther
ewer
enot
hingt
her
e

woul
dal
way
sbepossi
bil
i
tiest
rut
hsof

l
ogi
cmat
hemat
icsandv
aluebywai
ver

John'
sinsi
ghti
snotabsur
d

butnoIsnapbackv
aluej
ustcannot

causeexi
stenceIr
ecal
lwhatRi
char
d

Swi
nbur
net
heemi
nentphi
l
osopherof

r
eli
giont
oldmeIt
hinkal
otof

phi
l
osopher
spar
ti
cul
arandI
'
m ar
ecent

phi
l
osopher
shav
egi
venast
atust
o

t
heset
hingst
hatt
heydon'
treal
l
yhav
e

asi
twer
eandaphi
l
osopher
swho'
ve

sai
dwel
laswel
lasourwor
ldt
her
e's

r
eal
l
yapossi
blewor
ldwhi
chi
sal
most

ar
eal
wor
ldsomewher
eel
sei
nwhi
ch

t
hingshappen

notsopr
inci
plesofl
ogi
car
einmy

v
iewr
ulesf
orwhi
chhumansent
ences

makesenset
heyar
enotet
ernal
trut
hs

andt
her
efor
etal
kofpossi
blewor
ldsi
s

j
ustt
alkaboutwhi
chcombi
nat
ionsof

sent
encesar
econsi
stentwi
theachot
her

sot
hey
'r
eal
ltr
uthsabouthuman

l
anguaget
heydon'
texi
stapar
tfr
om

humansasf
ornot
hingsomecl
aimt
hat

t
hei
deai
tsel
fisnotl
egi
ti
mat
ethat
ev
ent
oaskt
hequest
ioni
sal
readya

mi
stakeandal
thoughIsenseIwi
l
l

r
ejectt
hisconcl
usi
onIknowImust

consi
dert
hear
gument
ssoIgot
o

Ber
kel
eyt
omeetHuber
tDr
eyf
usa

schol
aroft
heGer
manphi
l
osopherMar
ti
n

Hei
deggerbi
rdi
fwehadt
ocomeupwi
th

t
heul
ti
mat
equest
ioni
t'
sthat

f
undament
alconceptwhyi
sther
e

any
thi
ngatal
lwhyi
sther
esomet
hing

r
athert
hannot
hing

Hei
deggert
houghtt
hatwast
he

f
undament
alquest
ion-buthet
hought

t
hatt
hatt
hatwayofput
ti
ngt
he

quest
ionwaswr
ongIj
ustgotawhol
e

bookaboutt
hepr
inci
pleofsuf
fi
ci
ent

r
easonwhi
chi
saboutwhyt
her
emustbe

r
easonwhyt
her
e'ssomet
hingr
athert
han

not
hingandheconsi
derandhesay
sit
's

i
t'
spar
tofmet
aphy
sicsi
t'
sa

wr
ongheadedquest
iony
oucan'
taskt
hat

quest
ionexpect
ingaki
ndofr
ati
onal

answert
oitwhatHei
degger
'st
hinki
ng

i
sthatwe'
real
way
sal
readyi
nit

t
he

t
houghuni
ver
set
hewor
ldt
hingst
hat

ar
eandi
t'
sonl
yfr
om wi
thi
nitt
hatwe

candeal
wit
hitandsof
ort
hinst
eadof
get
ti
ngananswery
ousor
tofswi
tcht
he

posi
ti
onandi
nst
eadofl
ooki
ngl
i
kea

phi
l
osopherandamet
aphy
sici
anst
andi
ng

out
sideandl
ooki
ngatbei
ngandsay
ing

whatwhyi
sther
ebei
ngr
athert
han

not
hingy
ouseet
haty
oucoul
dnev
erbe

i
nthatposi
ti
onandt
heny
oucanhav
ea

ki
ndofmy
sti
cal
ori
nther
ebei
ng

somet
hingr
athert
hannot
hing

f
eel
i
ngsomehowabouti
tthatHei
degger

seemst
ohav
ebuty
oucan'
taskt
his

ki
ndoft
radi
ti
onal
phi
l
osophi
cal
Ifeel

If
eel
thatemot
ionaboutt
hatquest
ion

wel
li
nhi
ghdegr
eedoes-het
hinks

t
hatt
hat
'ssot
hat
'
slegi
ti
mat
eyeah

wel
li
tpoet
sandpai
nter
sgosi
ncet
his

quest
ionandt
hecor
ereasonwecan'
t

makepr
ogr
essi
sbecausewe'
rei
nitand

wecan'
tgetoutofi
ttol
ookati
tas

at
hir
dper
sonsr
ightt
hatwoul
dbet
he

phi
l
osophi
cal
mist
akephi
l
osopher
shav
e

al
way
sthoughtt
hatt
heycoul
dbeas

Pl
atoputi
tfr
iendsofGodst
andi
ngon

t
heout
sidel
ooki
ngi
nbuti
fyoudon'
t

dot
hatt
heny
ouhav
eHei
deggerwhyi
s

t
her
esomet
hingr
athert
hannot
hingt
he

answermustbeont
hisl
i
stonea

not
hingi
sabsur
d-noexpl
anat
ioni
s
neededt
hreechancef
ort
hev
alueor

per
fect
ioni
sul
ti
mat
efi
vemi
ndor

consci
ousnessi
sul
ti
mat
e

Imy
sel
frej
ectoneandt
wonot
hingi
s

notabsur
dandanexpl
anat
ioni
sneeded

chancet
hreecanexpl
ainwhywear
eher
e

butnotwhyt
her
eisany
thi
ngatal
l

v
alueorper
fect
ionf
ouri
sint
ri
gui
ng

butwher
epr
etoi
sit
'scr
eat
ingpower

asf
ormi
ndorconsci
ousnessf
ivewhy

shoul
danet
her
eal
Godorcosmi
c

consci
ousnesshav
esel
fexi
stenceher
e's

myt
akebecausesomet
hingdoesexi
st

t
her
emustbesomet
hingt
hati
ssel
f

exi
sti
ngi
nthati
tsessencei
sit
s

exi
stencet
hishasbeenat
radi
ti
onal

descr
ipt
ionofGodbuti
tcoul
dal
so

appl
ytoul
ti
mat
elawsofphy
sicsort
o

consci
ousnessi
fitwer
epossi
blet
o

knowt
hissel
fexi
sti
ngsubst
anceasi
t

r
eal
l
yisourast
oni
shmentIsuspect

woul
dnotbet
hati
tissel
fexi
sti
ng

butr
athert
hati
tcoul
dgener
atest
uff

ust
hati
snotsel
fexi
sti
ngoht
hat

bookonwhyany
thi
ngatal
lthemy
ster
y

ofexi
stencewhi
chJohnLesl
i
eis

co-
edi
torIam t
heot
herco-
edi
t

whi
chdoesnotmeant
hatIam anycl
oser
t
otr
uth

[
Musi
c]

f
orcompl
etei
nter
viewsandf
orf
urt
her

i
nfor
mat
ionpl
easev
isi
tcl
osert
otr
uth

cal
m

[
Musi
c]