Professional Documents
Culture Documents
replication method
Abstract
This paper describes the fabrication of porous Ti 2AlC MAX-phase ceramics using the
foam replication technique. The influence of heat-treatment cycle and sintering time on
indicates that strength is related to defects that are introduced during the foam
macrostructures. Such materials are of interest for use as a high surface area electrode
a
Prof C. R. Bowen, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Bath,
Claverton Down, BA2 7AY, Bath, England. Tel: 01225 383660, Fax: 01225 386928,
Email: c.r.bowen@bath.ac.uk.
1
1. Introduction
properties and microstructure; one reason being the relative ease with which porous
structures can be tailored for specific applications. Porous ceramics have been
graft substitute [2], filtering of high temperature molten metals and high temperature
thermal insulation [3]. The materials are of particular interest where the application
high stiffness, thermal insulation and wear. The manufacturing techniques developed for
creating porous ceramics include (i) foaming of an aqueous ceramic suspension, (ii)
replication of a sacrificial foam template and (iii) the use of synthetic and natural
templates [4, 5]. In this paper the fabrication of macro-porous Ti 2AlC MAX-phase
shape, pore distribution and pore size is impregnated with a Ti2AlC ceramic slip which
is subsequently dried and pyrolysed to remove the polymer foam before it is finally
The final porous structure formed is a replica of the foam template used. The advantage
of the foam replication method is the ability to control the pore distribution and pore
size by simply changing the structure of the template foam used. One disadvantage of
this process is that the porous ceramic can contain defects; these can be (i) on the solid
parts of the foam struts due to shrinkage of the slip during drying or (ii) internal defects
due to the pyrolysis of the polymer foam from the centre of struts. These defects
2
The motivation for the present work is to produce an electrically conductive macro-
environments, at high temperatures or for use in a microbial fuel cell (MFCs). The
(ii) a high level and size of open porosity for high surface area and flow of
microbial fuel cells used an electrically insulating ceramic that required an additional
chemical vapour deposition treatment to deposit a conductive fluorine tin oxide [6] and
material, such as Ti2AlC, the need for the additional conductive coating can be
eliminated.
The MAX-phase ceramics are a class of ductile material group with the general
an element from group 13 or 14 of the periodic table such as B, Al, Ga, C, Si, Ge, Sn
and Pb and X is either a carbon or nitrogen [7]. Depending on the value of n, M2AX,
M3AX2 and M4AX3 phases are referred to as 211, 312 and 413 phases respectively and
recently MAX-phases with higher values of n such as 514 and 615 [7] phases have been
Currently there are approximately sixty known phases [8] and Nowotny et al. [9] carried
out their initial investigation and crystallographic analysis in 1960’s. The materials are
3
of interest since they exhibit both metallic and ceramic properties. Their similarities to
metals include high electrical conductivity, e.g. ~ 3 x 10 6 Ω-1m-1 [10], high thermal
conductivity, good thermal shock resistance, machinability and they exhibit a degree of
and oxidation resistance and they can maintain their strength at high temperatures [11]
with a decomposition temperature of 15000C under vacuum [12]. Sun and Zhou [13]
reported a detailed review of the Ti-Al-C MAX-phase system and Ti2AlC and Ti3AlC2
are the two aluminium containing MAX-phases of interest due to their low density of
4.1 g/cm3 [13] along with high oxidation resistance. In the 211, 312 and 413 MAX-
properties. Ti2AlC has a low density of 4.1 g/cm3 and a high electrical conductivity of
3x106 Ω-1m-1. Due to the nature of the bonding the bulk modulus of Ti 2AlC (186 GPa) is
lower than the bulk modulus of binary TiC (240 GPa) [14] and it has a brittle to ductile
transition temperature of approximately 1050oC [15]. Gilbert et al. [16] found that the
shear modulus of Ti2AlC at 1000oC is 88% of its shear modulus at room temperature. In
addition the 211 Ti2AlC materials can be readily prepared by subjecting the
stochiometrically mixed Ti, Al and C to a combustion synthesis process [17]. This novel
combination of both metallic and ceramic properties, its technical application towards
chemical resistance, high temperature, machinability and load bearing ability are the
MAX-phase ceramics is rather limited [18-20] and the majority of porous MAX-phase
throughout the sample body with a wide distribution of pore sizes [21-23]. One of the
4
disadvantages of the reactive sintering approach is the difficulty in fine control of the
pore size and pore distribution during the exothermic reactions of the elemental
reactants used to form the product, thereby leading to material inhomogeneity. However
in the foam replication technique, the pore distribution directly relates to the structure of
the synthetic template employed and offers a route to produce conductive ceramics with
With regard to the Ti2AlC MAX-phase material, the majority of research conducted to
date is based on dense material [9, 10, 15, 24-28]. Hu et al. [18] and Zhou et al [20]
reported the production of porous Ti2AlC and Ti3SiC2 respectively, prepared using NaCl
as the pore former for controlling the volume fraction of porosity and the pore size. Sun
et al. [19] reported the manufacture of a porous reticulated Ti3AlC2 ceramic that was
used as a substrate to deposit catalytic CeO2 for a gas exhaust catalyst device. This
2. Experimental procedures
Kanthal was used as the ceramic powder with a 90% particle size distribution of 20µm
particles, with the remainder being a mixture of 2µm and 8µm particles.
was used (2 wt% of the ceramic powder) as the plasticizer and binder to obtain a high
flow of the slip solution for ease of coating of the polymer foam. Dispex GA40 from
Ciba AG (1.2 wt% of the ceramic powder) was used as an anti-settling agent to suspend
5
the ceramic particles in the solution during the foam replication process. Methyl
cellulose from Sigma Aldrich (2.4 wt% of the ceramic powder) was used as a
thickening agent to increase the viscosity of the slip without affecting the solid loading
chemicals were mixed in distilled water (resistivity18.2Mcm) and ball milled for 36
hours. Polyurethane foam (“Reticulated vitreous carbon foam” from Duocel) of 10 ppi
(pores per inch) was used as the synthetic replica template in this work as applications
of macro porous ceramics, such as microbial fuel cells [29], require a high degree of
To achieve the optimum composition for coating of the Ti 2AlC ceramic slip on to the
polymer foam it was necessary to produce slips with a range of viscosities. Slip
was controlled by using a range of distilled water contents while keeping the amount of
other chemical compositions described in Section 2.1 constant (see Table 1 for
compositions). Viscosity readings were taken using ‘Spindle 63’ which is specific for
the viscometer with a constant 1.5 RPM for all testing. The slip composition was milled
6
2.3 Coating of foam with ceramic slip
The polyurethane foam was initially cut into a large rectangular block of 100 x 50 x
25mm for preliminary coating studies and later cut into small rectangular blocks of 25 x
25 x 25mm for microscopic analysis and mechanical testing. To impregnate the foam
with the ceramic slip, it was fully immersed into the slip to ensure that the entire foam
was coated, as shown in figure 2 (left image). Once the foam was impregnated care was
taken to ensure that excess slip was removed before the slip dried. A manual squeezing
technique, figure 2 (right image) was used to remove this excess slip. Although most of
the excess slip was eliminated at this stage, some pores in the foam remain filled with
the ceramic slip. Compressed air was used to ensure an open porous structure. Prior to
sintering the foams were left to dry for 24 hours at room temperature.
Once dried, the impregnated foams were sintered in a tube furnace using an inert Argon
atmosphere. A heating rate and cooling rate of 150 C/hour was initially employed with
a dwell time at the sintering temperature of 1400C. The sintering temperature was
based on initial sintering study of dense Ti 2AlC cold-pressed pellets with a dwell time
of 5hrs (figure 3a) and then cooling at 150 C/hour to room temperature.
Since burn-out of the polymer has the potential to create defects prior to sintering, a
pyrolysis stage was also introduced in the heat treatment cycle. This involved a 1hr
dwell at 200°C and a slower heating rate of 60°C/hr to 800°C with a 1hr dwell, as seen
7
600oC [30], hence to ensure a complete and controlled decomposition of polyurethane
The basic processing of impregnating foam, drying and sintering is described by Path I
in the flowchart in figure 4. To further reduce the formation of defects and increase the
ceramic strut thickness in the final ceramic foam an additional ceramic coating was
applied. This additional ceramic coating was either applied before sintering (Path II) or
after sintering (Path III). Precise details of the process and its influence on properties are
The microstructure of the porous ceramic samples was analysed using a JEOL 6480LV
SEM equipped with an Oxford instrumentation IMLA X-act X-ray detector with
particular attention being given to the identification of defects either on or within the
individual struts of the porous ceramic using Secondary Electron Imaging (SEI). The
phases formed after sintering were analysed using XRD (Cu target, Kα).
Compression testing was carried out to determine mechanical strength of the sintered
uniform, uniaxial compressive load with a cross-head speed of 2mm/min. Rubber pads
were used on the upper and lower surfaces to distribute the load uniformly and the
maximum load at failure was recorded to determine the compressive strength. Six
8
3. Results
Initial investigations examined the development of the slip to coat the polymer foam.
The criteria used to establish an optimum composition of the ceramic slip were:
ii. easy removal of excess slip from the foam while coating,
Each trial was conducted for 5 minutes and the maximum viscosity was recorded in
mPa.s (milliPascal-second). Table 1 below provides the complete set of data of the
measured viscosity for different quantities of distilled water. The quantity of other
For the slips made with the lowest quantity of distilled water (48wt%) the slip was
highly viscous, as seen in Table 1. As a result of the high viscosity and low degree of
flow of the slip, it was difficult to achieve a uniform coating of the slurry over the
polymer foam and it tended to be of high thickness (approx. 1.13mm thick analysed
using ImageJ 1.48t), resulting in a long drying period. A number of internal pores were
blocked, as excess slip could not be squeezed out by mechanical deformation of the
9
For the slips made with 52wt% of distilled water it was possible to achieve a uniform
coating (approx. 0.77mm thick analysed using ImageJ 1.48t) over the foam and the
excess slip could be easily squeezed out during mechanical deformation since the flow
of the slip improved considerably. The slip coating on the polymer substrate dried
For the slip made with 56wt% of distilled water, due to the increase in water content,
the viscosity was lower than the slips with 52 and 48wt%. A uniform thin layer of
coating was achieved (approx. 0.57mm thick analysed using ImageJ 1.48t), but this led
to a thin coating and the ceramic body after sintering was fragile and difficult to handle
without fracture. The slip coating dried quickly and no clogging of pores was observed.
The slip made with 60wt% of distilled water had the lowest viscosity and as a result
From the above observations made in Table 1 the slip with 52wt% of distilled water was
XRD of the sintered porous material using the 5hr dwell at 1400 oC is shown in Figure 5
showing the presence of Ti2AlC and TiC as a secondary phase. Wang et al. [31]
indicated that TiC and TiAl are common secondary phases since they have a lower
(1300 oC) or a shorter time (3hr) led to XRD larger TiC peaks in the final material; this
observation is in agreement with work of Mei et al. [32] who noted higher TiC contents
TiC and TiAl to Ti2AlC takes place by a solution precipitation process, as reported by
10
Ge et al. [33] and Mei et al. [32] also observed that TiC reacted with Ti 2AlC to form
colour within the porous ceramic product. Four-point probe measurement on the surface
104 Ω-1m-1).
Figure 6a shows a SEM image of the struts in the sample prepared using 52wt% of
distilled water using the profile of figure 3a. It can be observed that the struts contain a
number of defects in the form of cracks. The formation of cracks has been previously
reported on research related to the foam replication method [3, 34-36]. These cracks are
formed as a result of the burn-out of gases produced during the decomposition of the
polyurethane foam at elevated temperature. In addition, since the foam is burnt out it
leaves behind hollow struts throughout the material as seen in the SEM image in figure
6b, especially at the triple points. Therefore it is important that the decomposition of the
polymer replica takes place in a controlled manner that was achieved using the
temperature profile in figure 3b. The dwell and slower heating rate at lower temperature
aids in controlling the decomposition rate of the foam so there is a gradual outgassing of
Figure 6c shows an SEM image of the struts in the sample prepared with 52wt% of
water with a pyrolysis stage in the heat treatment process (figure 3b). Although there
were defects in the region, the struts had comparatively less defects compared to the
11
3.4 Coating of foams prior to sintering
Clearly the reduction in size and number of defects in a ceramic is necessary to achieve
Ti2AlC to the foam before it was sintered was considered to further reduce the number
of defects on the struts followed by subjecting the coated foam to a heat-treatment using
Samples were prepared according to the processing route on Path II in figure 4, using a
slip of lower viscosity (51589 mPa.s as in Table 1) for the second stage of coating. A
lower viscosity slip was preferred since the excess slip could not be squeezed out of the
foam by mechanical deformation at the second stage, as it would damage the initial
ceramic coating of the PU foam. After the second coating there was a relatively thick
coating (approx. 2.08mm thick analysed using ImageJ 1.48t) on the pre-coated samples;
the high thickness of the struts leads to some pores filled with ceramic, even when
compressed air was applied, but this has the potential to increase strength. Efforts to use
a lower slip viscosity at the second stage resulted in poor adhesion of the ceramic slip
Figure 6e is an SEM of the struts of the sintered porous ceramic where the foam was
coated prior to sintering. The frequency of the defects are reduced compared to those
manufactured using Path I, and the thickness of the struts are increased (approx.
2.21mm). An optical image of the structure of the sintered material is also shown in
figure 6f.
12
3.5 Coating of foams after sintering
Since it was evident that defects are formed in the centre of the ceramic struts during the
decomposition of the polyurethane foam, another approach to reduce the size and
frequency of defects was to re-coat the sintered ceramic foam after the polymer foam
had been burnt out and the ceramic has been sintered. In this method the Ti 2AlC foam
Samples were prepared according to the processing route on Path III in figure 4. Once
the Ti2AlC foams are sintered using the thermal cycle of figure 3b, it was recoated with
a low viscosity slip (60wt% distilled water) of 51589 mPa.s viscosity. After recoating
the ceramic and using compressed air to remove any slip filling the pores, the samples
were subjected to vacuum of 1 bar pressure for 5 minutes to ensure that the slip was
absorbed into the cracks of the ceramic foam. The samples were subsequently dried and
In this case the ceramic struts are thinner and the majority of the pores remain open (see
figure 6g and 6h) unlike the foam coated prior to sintering in figure 6d and 6e, which is
one advantage of re-coating the sample after sintering. As a result, depending on the
percentage of open pore channel needed it is possible to adopt the coating technique
accordingly.
Compression testing was carried out the Ti 2AlC foam blocks to measure any change in
the mechanical strength due to the introduction of a pyrolysis stage. The samples with
dimensions of 25 x 25 x 25mm were prepared using a slip made with 52wt% of distilled
13
water for the two different sintering conditions (figure 3b and 3c). From figure 7 it can
be seen that there was an increase in the compressive strength due to the introduction of
a pyrolysis stage in the heat treatment cycle, however the defects were still present
within the centre of the struts due to the burnout of the PU foam (figure 6c). Therefore
there was a need to further minimise the defects if an increase in the compressive
strength is desired.
Coating of the foam prior to sintering was found to reduce the defects to some extent,
e.g. due to shrinkage/drying of the slip, the existence of remaining cracks resulted from
the burn out of the polyurethane foam. Nevertheless, the compressive strength has
sintering (Path II, figure 7) compared to the 0.32N/mm 2 for the Ti2AlC foams (Path I).
This high strength is also due to the higher thickness of the ceramic struts and the
From the compressive test results in figure 7, the foams coated after sintering (Path III)
had an average maximum compressive strength at failure of 2.95 N/mm 2. The ceramic
prepared with this technique exhibits a higher compressive strength compared to the
Ti2AlC foams due to a reduction in defects. The reason for the lower compressive
strength compared to the foam that was coated prior to sintering, is that the majority of
the open pore channels are filled with material when the foam is coated prior to
sintering which offers a greater resistance to mechanical load. Nevertheless the foams
coated after sintering were structurally stable, could be readily handled and is a
14
candidate for a porous electrode or a microbial fuel cell substrate due to the electrical
4. Conclusions
This paper has demonstrated that Ti2AlC ceramic could be used to fabricate macro-
Optimisation of the sintering conditions has been undertaken to form the Ti 2AlC phase
and reduce defect production during the pyrolysis of the polymer foam. A variety of
fabrication techniques were examined to improve the compressive strength and number
and size of defect within the porous ceramic. This included an additional coating that
can be applied before or after sintering the initial foam. Both the advantages and
disadvantages of each method were examined in the study and approaches to minimise
the formation of defects due to polymer burnout was developed. Such open porous
conductive ceramic materials have potential applications in electrodes for use in harsh
manufacture a range of MAX-phase ceramics and tailor their strength and degree of
Acknowledgement
Bowen would like to acknowledge the research time provided by the Bath Aqua Sulis
Club.
15
References
[1] A. Imhof, D.J. Pine, Preparation of titania foams, Advanced Materials, 11 (1999)
311-314.
[3] A.R. Studart, U.T. Gonzenbach, E. Tervoort, L.J. Gauckler, Processing routes to
1771-1789.
[4] S. Karl, A.V. Somers, Method of making porous ceramic articles, Patent No.
US3090094, 1963.
from preceramic precursors, Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 84 (2001) 2252-
2255.
[6] R. Thorne, H. Hu, K. Schneider, P. Bombelli, A. Fisher, L.M. Peter, A. Dent, P.J.
Cameron, Porous ceramic anode materials for photo-microbial fuel cells, J. Mater.
[7] M.W. Barsoum, T. El-Raghy, The MAX Phases: Unique New Carbide and Nitride
Materials Ternary ceramics turn out to be surprisingly soft and machinable, yet also
[9] V.H. Nowotny, Strukturchemie einiger verbindungen der übergangsmetalle mit den
elementen C, Si, Ge, Sn, Progress in Solid State Chemistry, 5 (1971) 27-70.
16
[10] M.W. Barsoum, D. Brodkin, T. El-Raghy, Layered machinable ceramics for high
[11] M.W. Barsoum, The Mn+ 1AXn phases: A new class of solids: thermodynamically
[13] Y. Zhou, Z. Sun, Electronic structure and bonding properties of layered machinable
[14] Z. Sun, Progress in research and development on MAX phases: a family of layered
1865.
crack growth and fracture properties of coarse and fine-grained Ti 3SiC2, Scripta
characterization of porous Ti2AlC with controlled porosity and pore size, Acta
17
[19] Z. Sun, Y. Liang, M. Li, Y. Zhou, Preparation of reticulated MAX‐phase support
[20] C. Zhou, T. Ngai, L. Lu, Y. Li, Fabrication and characterization of pure porous
Ti3SiC2 with controlled porosity and pore features, Materials Letters, 131 (2014) 280-
283.
[22] É.P. Pechkovskii, S.A. Firstov, Structure and mechanical properties of porous
titanosilicon carbide Ti3SiC2, Powder Metallurgy and Metal Ceramics, 42 (2003) 424-
432.
[24] Y. Bai, X. He, Y. Li, C. Zhu, S. Zhang, Rapid synthesis of bulk Ti 2AlC by self-
[27] N.V. Tzenov, M.W. Barsoum, Synthesis and characterization of Ti 3AlC2, Journal
18
[28] X. Wang, Y. Zhou, Solid–liquid reaction synthesis of layered machinable Ti3AlC
of rigid polyurethane foams under laboratory conditions, Fire Research Notes 1039,
1975.
[31] P. Wang, B.-C. Mei, X.-L. Hong, W.-B. Zhou, Synthesis of Ti 2AlC by hot pressing
and its mechanical and electrical properties, Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society
(2004) 1471-1472.
[33] Z. Ge, K. Chen, J. Guo, H. Zhou, J.M. Ferreira, Combustion synthesis of ternary
(2003) 567-574.
reticulated porous ceramics, Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 84 (2001) 1654-
1656.
19
Figure 1. Schematic of foam replica technique.
Figure 2. (Left) Foam immersed into the slip (Right) slip excess removed prior to treatment with
compressed air.
Figure 3. Sintering condition for Ti2AlC sintering (a) 5hr dwell (b) introduction of pyrolysis stage.
Figure 4. Processing steps for the manufacture of porous foam, coated foams prior to sintering and coated
Figure. 5 XRD data of the porous ceramic prepared using 1400oC for 5hrs
Figure 6 (a) SEM of cracks formed along struts for sintered material prepared with 52wt% distilled water
(Path I), (b) optical micrograph of hollow region in struts of sintered porous ceramic prepared with 52wt
% of distilled water due to the decomposition of the foam during sintering (Path I), (c) SEM image of the
hollow strut in sintered porous Ti2AlC with 52wt% distilled water using thermal profile in figure 3b (Path
I), (d) optical micrograph showing the surface coat quality after introducing thermal profile in figure 3b
(Path I), (e) SEM image of defects formed on struts of sintered ceramic coated prior to sintering (Path II)
(f) optical micrograph of surface coating quality of sintered ceramic coated prior to sintering (Path II), (g)
SEM image of coated foam after sintering showing individual strut surface (Path III), (h) optical
micrograph showing the surface coat quality of sample coated after sintering (Path III)
Figure 7. Summary of compression test data conducted. Six samples at minimum were tested for each
batch.
20
Table 1 Viscosity coefficient of slip measured at different distilled water content with constant spindle
speed of 1.5 RPM. The slip composition was milled for 24hrs prior to the viscosity measurement.
60 48 82.9 332000
65 52 35 146000
70 56 20.8 75184
75 60 12.9 51589
21