Peer Evaluation Form for Teamwork

IE457 Case Study Analysis- Spring 2021

Your name: ________________ ID: _______________ Team#: ________________ Date: __________Case study Title: _______________________________________________
- Write the name of each of your team members in a separate column.
- For each category, award each member of your team a score using this scale.

3 – Better than most of the team in this respect

2 – About average of the team in this respect
1 – Not as good as most of the team in this respect
0 – No help at all to the team in this respect
- Total the numbers in each column.
- Write your impression on teamwork experience.
Team Team Team Team Team
member#1 member#2 member #3 member#4 member#5
Evaluation Criteria

Group Participation & Communication Skills

Attends group meetings regularly and on time. Effective in
discussions, good listener, able to present and document work.
Time Management & Responsibility
Accepts fair share of tasks and reliably completes group
assignments on time.
Adaptability & Creativity
Shows ability to originate new ideas and initiates team
decisions. Displays a wide range of skills in service of the
project and accepts constructive criticism.
Positive Attitude & Contribution to all deliverables
Motivates the team, supports team decisions, helps team
reach consensus, and helps resolve conflicts in the group.
Contributes significantly to all deliverables.
TOTAL Score

1
© Dr. Imene Essoussi
Write a brief Feedback on your team dynamics:
a. Briefly describe your impression of the case studied in your group.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
b. Briefly describe how your impression of the case evolved as you shared ideas within your group. What issues emerged after comparing different ideas
with your teammates?
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
c. Outline your final impression of the case study presentation. What might you consider the next time you analyze a case study about a supply chain
management concern?
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
d. What did you learn about working in a team in this course that you will carry into your next team experience?
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Criteria 3 2 1 0
Makes a clear statement of initial impression and explains reasons behind. Meets all criteria; Meets some Meets few Undeveloped
clear and criteria ; some criteria; often criteria
Makes a clear statement of evolving impression & uses examples effectively for
developed lapses in unclear
evidence.
clarity
Makes a clear explanation of how the team presentation affected the audience
and why.
Makes a clear explanation of which type of mistakes should be avoided in case
briefs and why.
The likely future impact of the exercise is discussed and explained.
Notes are well-organized, concise, adequately developed.
Total /3

2
© Dr. Imene Essoussi