You are on page 1of 12

J Polym Eng 2015; aop

Rong-yuan Chen, Wei Zou, Hai-chen Zhang, Gui-zhen Zhang, Zhi-tao Yang and Jin-ping Qu*

Poly(lactic acid)/polypropylene and compatibilized


poly(lactic acid)/polypropylene blends prepared
by a vane extruder: analysis of the mechanical
properties, morphology and thermal behavior
Abstract: Poly(lactic acid) (PLA)/polypropylene (PP) DOI 10.1515/polyeng-2014-0312
blends with different weight fractions were prepared by a Received October 21, 2014; accepted January 25, 2015
novel vane extruder. The mechanical properties, morphol-
ogy, crystallization behavior and thermal stability of the
blends were investigated. The tensile strength, flexural
strength and elongation at break decreased nonlinearly 1 Introduction
when the PP content was not more than 50 wt% and then
increased with an increase in the PP content. The flexural The excessive consumption of petroleum resources and
modulus decreased with increasing PP weight fraction. the increased environmental awareness have contributed
The PLA/PP 90:10 blend exhibited the optimum impact to the extensive research on the development of biode-
strength. Scanning electron microscopy measurements gradable polymers and composites [1, 2]. Various biode-
revealed that the PLA/PP blends were immiscible. Phase gradable polymers, such as poly(lactic acid) (PLA) [3–5],
separation occurred significantly at a blend ratio of 50:50. poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) [6], poly(butylene succinate)
Regarding the PLA/PP 90:10 blend, the mean diameter (PBS) [7] and poly(butylene adipate-coterephthalate)
of the disperse-phase PP particles was the smallest at (PBAT) [8], were widely investigated and applied in many
1.11 μm. Differential scanning calorimetry measurements fields. Especially, PLA, a linear aliphatic thermoplastic
showed that low content of PP enhanced the crystalliza- polyester with good biocompatibility and excellent tensile
tion of PLA. The PLA component in the blends impeded strength, can be prepared from starch by fermentation and
the crystallization of PP when PP was used as the matrix. is one of the potential biopolymers to replace petroleum-
The thermogravimetric analysis measurement involved based synthetic polymers [9–12]. However, the rather high
a two-step decomposition process of the blends. The price, low crystallization rate, low deformation at break
thermal resistance of the blends was improved by com- and low toughness of PLA in comparison to petroleum-
pounding with PP. As compatibilizers, both the maleic based thermoplastics limit its applications [13–15].
anhydride-grafted PP and the ethylene/n-butyl acrylate/ In order to improve the properties of PLA, several
glycidyl methacrylate terpolymer helped improve the modifications, such as copolymerization, plasticization
mechanical properties, crystallization property and ther- and polymer blending, have been proposed in many
mal resistance of the PLA/PP blends. investigations. Blending PLA with other flexible and
biodegradable polymers, such as PBS, PCL and PBAT,
Keywords: compatibilizer; poly(lactic acid); polypropyl- is a practical method to improve the toughness of PLA.
ene; properties; vane extruder. Shibata et  al. [16] studied PLA/PBS blends and found
that their elongation at break and brittleness improved
with the addition of PBS. Todo et  al. [17] investigated
*Corresponding author: Jin-ping Qu, National Engineering
Research Center of Novel Equipment for Polymer Processing, The PLA/PCL blends and found that their fracture energy was
Key Laboratory of Polymer Processing Engineering of Ministry much greater than that of neat PLA, and they also found
of Education, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou that when increasing the PCL content, a phase separa-
510640, China, e-mail: jpqu@scut.edu.cn tion in the PLA/PCL blend occurred and suppressed the
Rong-yuan Chen, Wei Zou, Hai-chen Zhang, Gui-zhen Zhang and
toughness improvement of the blend. Teamsinsungvon
Zhi-tao Yang: National Engineering Research Center of Novel
Equipment for Polymer Processing, The Key Laboratory of Polymer
et  al. [18] studied PLA/PBAT blends and found that,
Processing Engineering of Ministry of Education, South China with the increase in the PBAT content, the elongation at
University of Technology, Guangzhou 510640, China break and impact strength of the blends increased but

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
2      R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends

the tensile strength and modulus decreased. Besides stability of the blends were investigated. Furthermore,
the biodegradable polymers, thermoplastic polyolefin the compatibilizers, maleic anhydride-grafted PP (MAPP)
has also been extensively used as a toughening agent in and ethylene/n-butyl acrylate/glycidyl methacrylate ter-
numerous polymer blending systems, such as polypro- polymer (PTW), were applied to improve the compatibil-
pylene (PP), polyethylene (PE) and nylon. Reddy et  al. ity between PLA and PP in the blends. The mechanical
[19] studied PLA/PP polyblend fibers and found that the properties, morphologies, crystallization behavior and
two polymers showed partial compatibility and that the thermal stability of the PLA/PP/compatibilizer blends
mechanical properties of the blends were inferior com- were also investigated.
pared to those of pure PLA or PP fibers. The PLA in the
blends, however, had substantially better resistance
to biodegradation and hydrolysis [19]. Anderson and
Hillmyer [20] investigated PLLA/PE blends and found
2 Materials and methods
that the impact properties of the composites were highly
dependent on the dispersed-phase properties. Wang 2.1 Materials
et  al. [21] studied polyamide 6 (PA6)/PLA/maleic anhy-
dride-grafted poly (orthoester) (POE-g-MAH) blends and Poly(lactic acid) pellets (PLA 4032D, specific gravity 1.25
found that they were an effective compatibilizer for PA6/ g/cm3) were supplied by Nature Works LLC (USA). Polypro-
PLA, which improved the impact strength of the blends pylene pellets [PP N-Z30S, specific gravity 0.9 g/cm3, melt
significantly. Except for biocompatibility and biodegra- flow index (MFI) ca. 25 g/10 min (190°C/2.16 kg)] were sup-
dability, thermoplastic polyolefin is more preponderant plied by China Petroleum & Chemical Co. (China). Maleic
in many aspects, such as cost, mechanical properties and anhydride-grafted PP (MAPP Fusabond P353, specific
processibility, compared with many other biodegradable gravity 0.904 g/cm3, ca. 1.8 wt% maleic anhydride) was
polymers in modifying PLA. supplied by DuPont Co. (USA). Ethylene/n-butyl acrylate/
Polypropylene, one of the most successful thermo- glycidyl methacrylate terpolymer pellets [Elvaloy PTW,
plastic polymers with excellent cost-to-performance designated as “EBA-GMA”, MFI ca. 12 g/10 min (190°C/2.16
ratio, has been widely used in many fields, such as kg), E/BA/GMA monomer ratio 66.75:28:5.25 by weight]
packaging, housewares and electronics [22]. Due to the were supplied by DuPont Co.
excellent performance and low cost of PP, and the similar
processing temperature and application fields of PP to
PLA, some investigators began to study PLA/PP blends. 2.2 Preparation of the PLA/PP blends and
Hamad et al. [23] studied the rheological and mechanical PLA/PP/compatibilizer blends
properties of PLA/PP blends prepared by a laboratory-
scale single-screw extruder. Choudhary et al. [24] used a PLA, PP, MAPP and PTW were dried at 50°C in a vacuum
batch mixer for blending PLA with PP; the mechanical, oven for 12  h to remove moisture before use. Blending
thermal and morphological properties of the resulting of PLA and PP at different ratios (PLA/PP, 90:10, 70:30,
blends were then characterized. Some other researchers 50:50, 30:70 and 10:90) was performed using a vane
used intumescent flame retardants [22], bamboo fiber extruder (self-design, see Figure 1) at 170°C, 175°C, 180°C
[25], ethylene-propylene-diene rubber [26] and wood and 180°C from hopper to die; the extrusion speed was
fiber [27] as fillers for PLA/PP blends and prepared for set at 60 rpm. With the same processing method, 2, 5
composites and investigated the properties of the com- and 8 wt% of the compatibilizers (MAPP and PTW) were
posites. However, few researchers studied PLA/PP blends added to the PLA/PP granule blend with a 50:50 ratio to
comprehensively based on the closely related mechani- prepare the PLA/PP/MAPP and PLA/PP/PTW-compati-
cal properties, phase morphology and thermal proper- bilized blends. Then the extruded blends were pelletized
ties. There are still many properties, especially the effect and dried in a vacuum oven at 50° for 8 h. Subsequently,
of compatibility between PLA and PP on the mechanical, the dried blend pellets were compressed into blend
thermal and morphological properties of PLA/PP blends, sheets with thicknesses of 1 and 4 mm using a compres-
that need to be investigated. sion molding machine (QBL-350, Wuxi No. 1 Rubber &
In this study, PLA was blended with PP using a novel Plastics Mechanical Co. Ltd., China). The compression
vane extruder based on an elongation force field with molding temperature and pressure were 190°C and 15
better mixing effect [28, 29] and the mechanical proper- MPa, respectively. Dumbbell-shaped specimens (width 4
ties, morphologies, crystallization behavior and thermal mm × thickness 1 mm × length of parallel part 25 mm × total

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends      3

Hopper Stator Heater Vane Baffle Rotor Die Extrudate


A A-A

A Rotor Vane Stator


VPCU

Figure 1: Schematic diagram of the vane extruder.

length 75 mm, according to the GB/T 16421-1996 standard 2.3.2 Scanning electron microscopy
for type II dumbbell-shaped specimens) for the tensile
test and rectangular specimens (length 80 mm × width The extruded blends of PLA/PP, PLA/PP/MAPP and PLA/
10 mm × thickness 4 mm) for the flexural and impact tests PP/PTW were fractured in liquid nitrogen to obtain unaf-
were prepared from the blend sheets with thicknesses of fected fractured surfaces. The fractured surfaces of the
1 and 4 mm, respectively. samples were then sprayed with gold powder to prepare
The vane extruder used in this work was a novel for scanning electron microscopy (SEM) observation by a
equipment without a screw, which was invented by Qu SEM equipment (S-3700N, Hitachi, Japan).
[30] for polymer processing. The schematic diagram of
the vane extruder is shown in Figure 1. The vane extruder
is composed of a multi-vane plasticizing and convey- 2.3.3 Differential scanning calorimetry
ing unit (VPCU). In a VPCU, the stator, rotor, four vanes
and baffles make up the chamber with a certain shape. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) measurements
The chamber changes from large to small, which is peri- were performed using the Netzsch DSC204 instrument
odically attributed to a certain eccentricity between the (Germany) in a nitrogen atmosphere. Blend samples of
centers of the stator and rotor. Polymer materials are fed 6–10 mg were subjected to the whole DSC protocols, wherein
into the chamber when the volume is large, then ground the samples were heated to 200°C at a rate of 10°C/min,
and compacted. Subsequently, the polymer materials melt held at that temperature for 5 min and then cooled to 0°C at
and are discharged from the die, completing a plasticiz- a rate of 10°C/min. The crystallization temperature (Tc) was
ing and positive displacement conveying process based obtained from the cooling process. The degree of crystallin-
on elongational rheology in a short thermo-mechanical ity (χc) was calculated using the following equation:
history [31].
ΔH
χc = × 100 (1)
ΔH × wt%
0
c

2.3 Characterization
where ΔH is the enthalpy of crystallization, ΔH c0 is the
theoretical heat of fusion for a fully crystalline PP and
2.3.1 Mechanical properties
“wt%” represents the PP weight fraction in the case of the
PLA/PP blends. From the literature, an enthalpy of fusion
The tensile and flexural properties of the PLA/PP, PLA/
of 209.00  J/g for PP was used for the 100% crystalline
PP/MAPP and PLA/PP/PTW blends were evaluated
material [32].
using an Instron Universal Testing Machine (model
5566, USA). The crosshead speed of the tensile test
was 2 mm/min according to the GB/T 1040.2 standard 2.3.4 Thermogravimetric analysis
(2006), and the crosshead speed of the flexural test was
2 mm/min according to the GB/T 1449 standard (2005). The thermal stability of pure PLA, pure PP, PLA/PP, PLA/
Impact tests were conducted using an Izod impact tester PP/MAPP and PLA/PP/PTW blends was studied by using a
(Zwick5117, Zwick GmbH, Ulmer, Germany) according Netzsch TG209 thermogravimetric analyzer. The weight of
to the GB/T 1843 standard (2008). All of the data were the samples used was approximately 10.0 mg, which were
the average from six determinations. All tests were per- heated from 30°C to 600°C at a rate of 10°C/min. Nitrogen
formed at room temperature. gas was used to protect the samples from being oxidized.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
4      R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends

3 Results and discussion

3.1 Mechanical properties analysis

Figure 2 shows the curves of the tensile strength and


elongation at break during the tensile tests of the PLA/
PP blends with various blend weight ratios. It can be seen
that the tensile strength of the blend decreased sharply
when the PP content was not more than 50 wt% and then
increased with an increase in the PP content. This indicates
that both the addition of PP to PLA and the addition of PLA
to PP reduced the tensile strength of the blends in the given
content range. The result may be attributed to the poor
Figure 3: Flexural strength and modulus curves of the PLA/PP blends.
interfacial interaction between the incompatible blends of
PLA/PP. For the elongation at break of the PLA/PP blends, it
decreased slightly when the PP content was not more than 50 wt% and then increased slightly with an increase in the
50 wt% and then increased obviously with an increase in PP content. Regarding the PLA/PP 30:70–10:90 blends,
the PP content. The result indicates that the influence of the flexural strength was lower than that of pure PP, which
high PP content (more than 50 wt%) on the ductility of PLA is mainly attributed to the poor compatibility between the
was significant. Similar results about the change in tensile two phases of PLA and PP. For the flexural modulus, it
strength and elongation at break of the PLA/PP blends with decreased nonlinearly with an increase in the PP content.
various weight ratios were found by Hamad et  al. [23] in Since the stiffness of PP was much lower than that of PLA
their study of the rheological and mechanical properties of resin, the flexural load would be undertaken by the PLA
PLA/PP blends prepared by a laboratory-scale single-screw phase, leading to a reduction in the flexural modulus of
extruder. They also found that the PLA/PP 50:50 blend the PLA/PP blends. Consequently, the flexural modulus of
almost showed the worst performance over the range of the PLA/PP blends decreased with an increase in the PP
weight ratios. The result indicated that the PLA/PP blend weight fraction.
was the typical immiscible polymer blend, as found in our Figure 4 illustrates the correlation between the
research. impact strength and the PLA/PP weight ratios of the
The dependence of the flexural strength and modulus PLA/PP blends. It can be seen that the impact strength
of the PLA/PP blends on the PLA/PP weight ratios is increased obviously with a PP weight fraction of 10 wt%.
shown in Figure 3. It can be seen that the flexural strength Then the impact strength decreased dramatically when
decreased sharply when the PP content was not more than the PP content was not more than 70 wt% and then

Figure 2: Tensile strength and elongation at break curves of the


PLA/PP blends. Figure 4: Impact strength curve of the PLA/PP blends.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends      5

increased slightly with an increase in the PP content. The results were consistent with the results in this work.
Regarding the blend PLA/PP 90:10, the improved impact Regarding the PLA/PP/PTW blends, the elongation at break
strength may be attributed to the approximately uniform increased and the flexural strength and flexural modulus
distribution of PP particles in the PLA continuous phase. decreased compared with those of the blend PLA/PP 50:50.
However, the reduction of the impact strength may due Similar to the influence of MAPP on the impact strength of
to the immiscible characteristics between the component the PLA/PP 50:50 blend, the PTW had a slight influence on
polymers (PLA and PP), with a big difference in solubility the impact strength of the blend. The results indicate that
parameters [24], such that the blends could not absorb both the MAPP and the PTW can improve the compatibility
and transfer the impact energy efficiently. As a result, the between PLA and PP, which helps improve some facets of
toughening effect of the PP particles on the PLA blends the mechanical properties of the PLA/PP blend.
was significant in the case of low concentration of the PP
particles.
The PLA/PP 50:50 blend shows poor comprehensive 3.2 Morphology analysis
mechanical properties as a result of the poor compatibility
between PLA and PP. Two kinds of compatibilizers (MAPP Figure 5 shows SEM micrographs of PLA/PP blends with
and PTW) were used in this work to improve the mechanical different weight fractions. It can be observed clearly that
properties of the blend. Table 1 shows the effect of the com- there was a phase separation between the PLA phase and
patibilizers (MAPP and PTW) on the mechanical properties the PP phase. The micrographs reveal a distinct two-phase
of the PLA/PP 50:50 blend. It can be seen from Table 1 that morphology, with the PP phase dispersed evenly within
the addition of both MAPP and PTW can improve the tensile the PLA matrix when the PP content was not more than
strength of the blend significantly. Regarding the PLA/PP/ 50 wt% and the PLA phase dispersed evenly within the
MAPP blends, the elongation at break decreased and the PP matrix when the PP content exceeded 50 wt%. With
flexural strength increased compared with those of the an increase in the PP weight fraction, the phenomenon of
blend PLA/PP 50:50. However, the compounding of MAPP droplet coalescence and phase inversion can be observed.
to the PLA/PP 50:50 blend had a slight influence on the flex- Figure 5F shows the change in mean diameter of the dis-
ural modulus and impact strength of the blend. The effect perse phase particles in the PLA/PP blends vs. the various
of MAPP on the mechanical properties of the PLA/PP blend PLA/PP weight ratios. When the PP content is 10 wt% in
was also investigated by Yoo et  al. [33] in their research. the blend, the mean diameter of the disperse-phase PP
They added MAPP (1, 3, 5, 7 and 10 phr) to the blend PLA/PP particles is 1.11 μm, which is the lowest in the given PP
80:20 to improve the compatibility of the blend and studied content range. The morphology of the blend PLA/PP 90:10
the properties of the PLA/PP/MAPP blend. They found that was also investigated by Choudhary et  al. [24] in their
the tensile strength of the blend showed the maximum at a research. They prepared the PLA/PP blends using a batch
content of 3 phr. The excess MAPP did not provide a distinct mixer. The mean diameter of the disperse-phase PP par-
improvement to the tensile strength of the blend. They also ticles in their research was much larger than that in this
found that the impact strength of the PP/PLA blends did not work. Moreover, the dispersion of the PP particles in this
change significantly with the increase in the MAPP content. work was also much better. The reason for this maybe that

Table 1: Effect of the compatibilizers (MAPP and PTW) on the mechanical properties of the PLA/PP 50/50 blend.

Composition   Tensile  Elongation  Flexural  Flexural  Impact


(wt/wt/wt) strength at break strength modulus strength
(MPa) (%) (MPa) (MPa) (KJ/m2)

PLA/PP (50:50)  12.9±0.4  6.8±1.0  30.9±1.5  2413±136  1.09±0.20


PLA/PP/MAPP          
50:50:2   14.9±0.9  5.4±0.1  36.2±0.4  2126±135  1.15±0.19
50:50:5   15.1±0.5  4.7±0.3  38.1±1.1  2497±48  1.04±0.13
50:50:8   14.4±0.9  5.1±0.2  36.5±1.1  2260±96  0.82±0.03
PLA/PP/PTW          
50:50:2   17.9±0.8  6.6±0.2  30.6±1.2  1810±38  1.57±0.07
50:50:5   17.3±0.5  6.5±0.5  26.9±1.0  1516±61  1.07±0.08
50:50:8   15.9±0.6  6.8±0.3  28.9±0.5  1488±54  1.50±0.11

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
6      R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends

Figure 5: Scanning electron micrographs of the PLA/PP blends with different weight fractions (A, 90:10; B, 70:30; C, 50:50; D, 30:70; E,
10:90); (F) mean diameter of the disperse-phase particles in the PLA/PP blends.

the processing device in this work, i.e., the vane extruder, matrix, that the mean diameter of the PP particles is much
has a good dispersion mixing effect on the polymer blends, smaller at low PP content (at 10 wt%) than that at high
which, as a result, improved the dispersion of the disperse PP content (at 30 wt%), and the distribution of the parti-
phase in the PLA/PP blends and reduced the diameter of cles in the blends was much more uniform with a low PP
the disperse-phase particles. When the PP content was content. For the blends with PP as the matrix, the distri-
50 wt% in the blend, a distinct phase separation occurred bution of the PLA particles in the blends was much more
as the disperse-phase particles became aspheric and some uniform with a low PLA content (see Figure 5D and E).
of them merged to create bigger droplets. This was mainly From Figure 5, it can also be seen that the dispersibility of
attributed to the poor compatibility between PLA and PP. the PP droplets in the PLA/PP blends (90:10 and 70:30) is
When the PP content exceeded 50 wt%, it appears that, better than that of the PLA droplets in the PLA/PP blends
when it was used as the matrix for the blends, phase inver- (10:90 and 30:70); this may be attributed to the viscosity
sion occurred at the same time. The mean diameter of the ratio of the PLA/PP blend components as well as to the
disperse-phase PLA particles in the PP matrix decreased flexibility of the polymer chains.
with an increase in the PP content. Moreover, it can be Figure 6 shows scanning electron micrographs of
seen from Figure 5A and B, when PLA was used as the the PLA/PP 50:50 blend, MAPP-compatibilized PLA/

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends      7

Figure 6: Scanning electron micrographs of the PLA/PP, PLA/PP/MAPP and PLA/PP/PTW blends (A, PLA/PP 50:50; B–D, PLA/PP/MAPP
50:50:2, 5, 8; E–G, PLA/PP/PTW 50:50:2, 5, 8).

PP/MAPP blends and PTW-compatibilized PLA/PP/ separation phenomenon can also be observed in Figure
PTW blends. It can be observed from Figure 6B–D that 6B–D. The addition of 2 wt% MAPP to the blend allowed
the compatibility between PLA and PP improved signifi- many smaller particles to be formed and covered by the
cantly with an increase in the MAPP content. Compared matrix pillar (PLA) in the blend (see Figure 6B). With
with the PLA/PP 50:50 blend (Figure 6A), the phase an increase in the MAPP content, many more particles

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
8      R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends

were formed in the blend and the dimension of the parti-


cles became smaller and the distribution of the particles
became more uniform (see Figure 6C and D). For the PLA/
PP 50:50 blend compounded with PTW, the phase sepa-
ration phenomenon was also observed, as can be seen in
Figure 6E–G. When 2 wt% PTW was added to the blend,
many particles merged to create bigger irregular parti-
cles. The phase morphology looks like the co-continuous
phase structure in Figure 6E. When 5 wt% PTW was added
to the blend, the phase morphology is similar to that in
Figure 6E, but the amount of the particles is significantly
increased in Figure 6F. When 8 wt% PTW was added to the
blend, the big irregular particles formed in Figure 6E and
F were broken into many small particles in Figure 6G. This
indicates that the compatibility between PLA and PP was
improved. The results show that the addition of 8 wt% Figure 8: DSC crystallization thermograms of the PLA/PP/MAPP
MAPP or PTW allowed the particles in the PLA/PP 50:50 blends with different MAPP contents.
blend to break into smaller particles and the distribu-
tion of the particles became more uniform, which helped
improve the compatibility between PLA and PP.

3.3 Crystallization behavior analysis

DSC cooling thermograms, illustrating the crystallization


behaviors of PLA, PP, PLA/PP and compatibilized PLA/PP
blends, are depicted in Figures 7–9. The DSC data obtained
from the thermograms are collected in Table 2. It can be
seen from Figure 7 that the thermogram of pure PLA shows
no crystallization peak under the cooling rate of 10°C/min.
This indicates that the crystallization rate of PLA is very
low; it was too fast for PLA to crystallize at a cooling rate

Figure 9: DSC crystallization thermograms of the PLA/PP/PTW


blends with different PTW contents.

of 10°C/min. When PLA was compounded with 10 wt%


PP, two weak crystallization peaks around 78 and 94°C
emerged, with the low temperature peak corresponding to
the crystallization peak of PLA and the high temperature
peak corresponding to the crystallization peak of PP. This
illustrates that the addition of PP enhanced the crystal-
lization of PLA. With more PP compounded in the blend,
regarding the PLA/PP 70:30 blend, the crystallization
peak corresponding to PLA became weaker and shifted
to a higher temperature around 80°C and the crystalliza-
tion peak corresponding to PP became stronger and also
Figure 7: DSC crystallization thermograms of the pure PLA, PP and shifted to a higher temperature around 99°C. The result
PLA/PP blends. indicates that too much PP in the blend will impede the

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends      9

Table 2: DSC data of the PLA/PP, PLA/PP/MAPP and PLA/PP/PTW but it increased the ΔHc and χc of the PP component in the
blends. blends. This result shows that the addition of PTW also
improved the crystallization properties of the PLA/PP
Composition   Tc (°C)  ΔHc (J/g)  χc (%)
50:50 blend. But the effect of PTW is weaker than that of
PLA/PP       MAPP on improving the crystallization properties of the
 100:0   –  0  0 blends. The reason for this may be that the MAPP com-
 90:10   93.8  –  –
patibilizer with the PP component is better than PTW
 70:30   99.4  –  –
 50:50   116.1  21.3  20.4 in improving the compatibility of PLA and PP. In addi-
 30:70   118.0  68.3  46.7 tion, it can be seen from Table 2 that, in the given PTW
 10:90   119.5  88.5  47.1 content range, the χc of the PP component in the PLA/PP/
 0:100   120.1  113.0  54.1 PTW blends obtained the optimum value when the PTW
PLA/PP/MAPP     
content was 5 wt%.
 50:50:2   120.7  47.3  46.2
 50:50:5   120.3  48.3  48.6
 50:50:8   119.5  53.6  55.4
PLA/PP/PTW      
 50:50:2   115.5  45.8  44.7
3.4 Thermal stability analysis
 50:50:5   115.5  47.7  48.0
 50:50:8   116.2  38.7  40.0 The thermal stability of the PLA/PP blends with dif-
ferent weight fractions and the compatibilized PLA/
PP 50:50 blends with different compatibilizer contents
were studied by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA).
crystallization of PLA. Regarding the PLA/PP 50:50, 30:70
Figures  10–12 show the curves of the blends. TG data
and 10:90 blends, the thermograms showed only one crys-
obtained from the thermograms of the blends such as the
tallization peak of PP. In these blends, PLA did not crystal-
temperature at 5 wt% loss (T5%), temperature at 50 wt%
lize during the cooling process. Moreover, it can be seen
loss (T50%), temperature at maximum decomposition rate
from Table 2 that the Tc, ΔHc and χc of PP component in
(Tmax) and ending decomposition temperature (Te) are
the PLA/PP blends increased with an increase in the PP
collected in Table 3. As evident from Table 3, PP is ther-
weight fraction when the PP content exceeded 50 wt%.
mally more stable than PLA. The T5% of PLA was 334.3°C,
The result indicates that the PLA component in the blends
whereas that of PP started to degrade at 418.8°C. The
impedes the crystallization of PP when PP is used as the
incorporation of 10 wt% of PP resulted in the increase in
matrix.
the T5%, T50%, Tmax and Te of the PLA/PP 90:10 blend. The
Figure 8 shows the cooling thermograms of the PLA/
T5% of the PLA/PP blends increased with an increase in the
PP/MAPP blends. It can be seen that the crystallization
PP content except for the PLA/PP 50:50 blend. This may
behavior of the PLA/PP 50:50 blend has a distinct change
due to the PLA/PP 50:50 blend having a poor distribution
when compounded with MAPP. The DSC data are shown
in Table 2. Compared with the blend without MAPP, the
Tc, ΔHc and χc of the PP component in the PLA/PP/MAPP
blends increased obviously, which indicates that the crys-
tallization properties of the blends improved. This result
may due to the influence of MAPP in improving the com-
patibility of PLA and PP. In the given MAPP content range,
the χc of the PP component in the blends increased with an
increase in the MAPP content. However, the MAPP content
has an insignificant influence on the crystallization tem-
perature in the given MAPP content range.
The cooling thermograms of the PLA/PP/PTW blends
are shown in Figure 9. Similar to the influence of MAPP
on the χc of the PP component in the PLA/PP 50:50 blend,
adding PTW to the blend also increased the χc of the PP
component in the blend significantly. The DSC data are
shown in Table 2. It can be seen that the addition of PTW
had an insignificant effect on the Tc of the PP component, Figure 10: Thermogravimetric (TG) curves of the PLA/PP blends.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
10      R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends

Table 3: TG data of the PLA/PP, PLA/PP/MAPP and PLA/PP/PTW


blends.

Composition   T5% (°C)  T50% (°C)  Tmax (°C)  Te (°C)

PLA/PP        
 100:0   334.3  370.7  376.7  389.0
 90:10   343.8  374.3  378.4  489.7
 70:30   345.4  378.0  376.1  484.0
 50:50   343.6  386.6  374.7  483.0
 30:70   345.8  453.7  467.7  479.3
 10:90   355.6  461.5  468.8  481.5
 0:100   418.8  465.0  473.1  481.9
PLA/PP/MAPP       
 50:50:2   350.4  386.8  373.0  475.1
 50:50:5   349.4  383.9  373.6  474.9
 50:50:8   350.0  389.2  372.4  481.1
PLA/PP/PTW        
Figure 11: Thermogravimetric (TG) curves of the PLA/PP/MAPP  50:50:2   331.3  392.7  370.1  477.6
blends.  50:50:5   336.7  418.9  370.8  472.9
 50:50:8   339.4  431.1  370.9  478.5

to the decomposition process of PLA and the second


decomposition step corresponded to the decomposition
of PP. The result indicates that the compatibility between
PLA and PP is poor, which is consistent with the results
of morphological observation. Furthermore, the addition
of PP to PLA may have also improved the resistance to
degradation of the blends in the natural environment.
The reason for this is that PP is a polyolefin material,
which has higher resistance to microorganisms than PLA
in the natural environment; as a result, the PP phase in
the PLA matrix can protect PLA from degradation [19].
The thermal stability of the compatibilized PLA/PP/
Figure 12: Thermogravimetric (TG) curves of the PLA/PP/PTW
MAPP and PLA/PP/PTW blends with different contents
blends. of MAPP and PTW was also investigated. It can be seen
from Figures 11 and 12 that the two-step decomposition
process occurred in all the compatibilized PLA/PP 50:50
blends. The incorporation of MAPP obviously increased
of the particles and an obvious phase separation mor- the T5% of the compatibilized blends. The T50% of the com-
phology. The T50% and Tmax of the blends increased signifi- patibilized blends changed insignificantly; the Tmax and
cantly when the PP content exceeded 50 wt%. This may Te decreased compared with those of the PLA/PP 50:50
due to the phase inversion of the blends, wherein PP was blend. This indicates that the addition of MAPP to the
used increasingly as the matrix. More interestingly, the blend can improve the onset temperature of thermal deg-
Te of the PLA/PP 90:10 blend had the maximum value, radation, which can improve the temperature of the blend
which was higher than those of other PLA/PP blends and in actual use. Regarding the PLA/PP/PTW blends, it can
pure PP. This result may be due to the good dispersion of be seen from Figure 12 and Table 3 that the incorporation
the PP particles in the PLA/PP 90:10 blend, which can of PTW increased the T50% of the blend significantly. The
be observed from the SEM photo (see Figure 5A). More- T5%, Tmax and Te of the blends decreased compared with
over, regarding the PLA/PP 90:10 –10:90 blends, a two- those of the PLA/PP 50:50 blend. The results indicate
step decomposition process occurred due to the different that the PTW-compatibilized PLA/PP blends degraded at
thermal resistance of PLA and PP, where the first decom- a lower temperature compared with the PLA/PP blend,
position step, between 300°C and 390°C, corresponded but after a 50% weight loss, the degrade temperature

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends      11

had a distinct improvement. The TGA results show that Joint Foundation Project (U1201242), the National Research
the MAPP and PTW helped improve the thermal stabil- Foundation for the Doctoral Program of Higher Education
ity of the PLA/PP 50:50 blend at different degradation of China (20120172130004), the New Century Excellent
periods. Talents in University (NCET-11-0152), the Pearl River Tal-
ent Fund for Young Sci-Tech Researchers of Guangzhou
City (2011J2200058) and the Young Scientists Fund of the
National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant no.
4 Conclusions 51403068).

PLA/PP blends with various weight fractions, PLA/PP/


MAPP blends with different MAPP contents and PLA/
PP/PTW blends with different PTW contents were suc- References
cessfully prepared with the melt-blending technique
using a novel vane extruder. The mechanical proper- [1] Gross RA, Kalra B. Science 2002, 297, 803–807.
[2] Vieira AC, Guedes RM, Tita V. J. Polym. Eng. 2013, 33, 293–302.
ties, morphology, crystallization behavior and thermal
[3] Mosanenzadeh SG, Naguib HE, Park CB, Atalla N. Polym. Eng.
stability of the blends were investigated. It was found Sci. 2013, 53, 1979–1989.
that the tensile strength, flexural strength and elonga- [4] Chen BK, Shen CH, Chen SC, Chen AF. Polymer 2010, 5,
tion at break decreased nonlinearly when the PP content 4667–4672.
was not more than 50 wt% and then increased with [5] Hung CY, Wang CC, Chen CY. Polymer 2013, 54, 1860–1866.
an increase in the PP content. The flexural modulus [6] Liang JZ, Zhou L, Tang CY, Tsui CP. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 2013,
128, 2940–2944.
decreased with increasing PP weight fraction. The PLA/
[7] Lu X, Huang J, He G, Yang L, Zhang N, Zhao Y, Qu J. Ind. Eng.
PP 90:10 blend exhibited the optimum impact strength Chem. Res. 2013, 52, 13677–13684.
compared with the other PLA/PP blends. The addition of [8] Chen F, Zhang J. Polymer 2010, 51, 1812–1819.
MAPP and PTW to the PLA/PP 50:50 blend improved the [9] Neppalli R, Causin V, Marigo A, Meincken M, Hartmann P,
tensile strength of the blends significantly. The elonga- Reenen A. Polymer 2013, 54, 5909–5919.
[10] Delpouve N, Delbreilh L, Stoclet G, Saiter A, Dargent E.
tion at break and impact strength of the compatibilized
Macromolecules 2014, 47, 5186–5197.
blends changed slightly. [11] Othman N, Xu C, Mehrkhodavandi P, Hatzikiriakos SG. Polymer
SEM measurements revealed that the PLA/PP blends 2012, 53, 2443–2452.
were immiscible. Phase separation occurred significantly [12] Wang HT, Chan YH, Feng SW, Lo YJ, Teng NC, Huang HM.
at the blend ratio of 50:50. Regarding the PLA/PP 90:10 J. Polym. Eng. 2014, 34, 241–245.
blend, the mean diameter of the disperse-phase PP parti- [13] Sun Y, He C. Macromolecules 2013, 46, 9625–9633.
[14] Najafi N, Heuzey MC, Carreau PJ. Polym. Eng. Sci. 2013, 53,
cles was the smallest at 1.11 μm. The dispersibility of the
1053–1064.
PP droplets in the PLA/PP blends (90:10 and 70:30) was [15] Chen RY, Zou W, Wu CR, Jia SK, Huang Z, Zhang GZ, Yang ZT,
better than that of the PLA droplets in the PLA/PP blends Qu JP. Polym. Test. 2014, 34, 1–9.
(10:90 and 30:70). The addition of MAPP and PTW to the [16] Shibata M, Inoue Y, Miyoshi M. Polymer 2006, 47, 3557–3564.
PLA/PP 50:50 blend improved the compatibility between [17] Todo M, Park SD, Takayama T, Arakawa K. Eng. Frac. Mech.
2007, 74, 1872–1883.
the PLA and the PP. The particles in the compatibilized
[18] Teamsinsungvon A, Ruksakulpiwat Y, Jarukumjorn K. Polym.
blends became smaller, and the distribution of the parti- Plast. Technol. Eng. 2013, 52, 1362–1367.
cles became more uniform. [19] Reddy N, Nama D, Yang Y. Polym. Degrad. Stabil. 2008, 93,
The DSC measurement showed that a low content of 233–241.
PP enhanced the crystallization of PLA. The PLA com- [20] Anderson KS, Hillmyer MA. Polymer 2004, 45, 8809–8823.
ponent in the blends, however, impeded the crystalli- [21] Wang YL, Hu X, Li H, Ji X, Li ZM. Polym. Plast. Technol. Eng.
2010, 49, 1241–1246.
zation of PP when PP was used as the matrix. The TGA
[22] Lin Z, Chen C, Guan Z, Xu B, Li X, Huang Z. Polym. Plast.
measurement involved a two-step decomposition process Technol. Eng. 2012, 51, 991–997.
of the blends. The thermal resistance of the blends was [23] Hamad K, Kaseem M, Deri F. J. Polym. Res. 2011, 18,
improved by compounding with PP. Both the MAPP and 1799–1806.
the PTW helped improve the crystallization property and [24] Choudhary P, Mohanty S, Nayak SK, Unnikrishnan L. J. Appl.
Polym. Sci. 2011, 121, 3223–3237.
the thermal resistance of the PLA/PP blends.
[25] Zhang YC, Wu HY, Qiu YP. Bioresource Technol. 2010, 101,
7944–7950.
Acknowledgments: The authors wish to acknowledge the [26] Park DH, Kim MS, Yang JH, Lee DJ, Kim KN, Hong BK, Kim WN.
National Natural Science Foundation of China-Guangdong Macromol. Res. 2011, 19, 105–112.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM
12      R. Chen et al.: Mechanical properties, morphology and thermal behavior of PLA/PP blends

[27] Almgren KM, Gamstedt EK, Berthold F, Lindström M. Polym. [30] Qu JP. C.N. Patent 200,810,026,054.X (2008).
Compos. 2009, 30, 1809–1816. [31] Qu JP, Zhang GZ, Chen HZ, Yin XC, He HZ. Polym. Eng. Sci. 2012,
[28] Qu JP, Chen HZ, Liu SR, Tan B, Liu LM, Yin XC, Liu QJ, Guo RB. J. 52, 2147–2156.
Appl. Polym. Sci. 2013, 128, 3576–3585. [32] Martuscelli E, Silvestre C, Abate G. Polymer 1982, 23, 229–237.
[29] Jia S, Qu J, Liu W, Wu C, Chen R, Zhai S, Huang Z. Polym. Eng. [33] Yoo TW, Yoon HG, Choi SJ, Kim MS, Kim YH, Kim WN. Macromol.
Sci. 2014, 54, 716–724. Res. 2010, 18, 583–588.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 6/22/15 10:05 AM

You might also like