Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/309282596
CITATIONS READS
6 240
1 author:
Rebekah Scotney
The University of Queensland
8 PUBLICATIONS 100 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Compassion fatigue in the subtropical dairy industry: What roles do dairy workplace human-animal relationships play in dairy farmer / worker psycho-social health?
View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Rebekah Scotney on 26 October 2021.
Environmental enrichment in
veterinary practice
Abstract The stress factor
Most research on environmental enrichment (EE) for dogs and cats has been con- Research shows that animals undergo physiologi-
ducted in shelters and refuges. It is suggested that certain types of visual, sensory, cal changes, including increased heart rate and
auditory and olfactory enrichment reduce stress. When incorporated into practice cortisol release, that are associated with negative
policy, modifications to everyday husbandry can be used as strategies to create an feelings such as anxiety or fear (Gregory, 2004).
EE programme. The benefits of EE, as shown in rescue shelters, can be extrapo- Furthermore, some dogs and cats do experience
lated for use in hospitalized patients and could prove to be an effective stress extreme stress through being separated from their
management tool. Further empirical research within veterinary practice is neces- owners and kept in a cage (Valsanen et.al, 2005;
sary to evaluate the clinical relevance of EE. Dybdall, 2007; Hewson, 2008). Owners want to see
that their pet is as relaxed and as happy as possible
Key words: environmental enrichment, veterinary practice, stress, welfare when hospitalized and so the traditional primary
concern of veterinarians and veterinary nurses re-
garding the health of clients’ pets must be extend-
F
or many companion animals, a visit to their ed to include how the pet is feeling when in their
veterinary surgeon can be a very stressful and care.
anxious experience. It frequently represents a An adverse mental health state (especially if pro-
novel environment or may be associated with previ- longed) has the potential to exacerbate pain, slow re-
ous adverse experiences. Stress factors for pets can covery and affect an animal’s general health (Hewson,
include an unfamiliar environment, separation from 2008). Secondary to this, a stressed patient (Figure
family, the presence of other animals, noise and nox- 1) can be difficult to manage and as such is at an in-
ious procedures performed by strangers; they cannot creased risk of injuring itself or personnel.
predict or control what happens to them. By being It must be recognized that there is a significant pos-
aware of the signs of stress and anxiety in hospital- sibility that animals can experience positive feelings
ized patients and providing structured, evidence- as well as negative, as acknowledged by those working
based approaches to environmental enrichment in all facets of the animal industry (Hewson, 2008).
(EE), the welfare of patients can be greatly improved. Concern for animal welfare has tended to cause veteri-
The degree to which a patient is stressed by a visit nary practitioners to overlook the possibility of giving
to, or stay at, a veterinary clinic and the degree to pleasure to animals that may not be suffering, but that
which it suffers because of this depends on the ani- would enjoy a better quality of life given some, gener-
mal’s experience, genetics and capacity to avoid or ally very simple, changes to their husbandry (Fraser
control their situation (Bradshaw and Goodwin, 1998; and Duncan, 1998; Duncan, 2006; Hewson, 2008).
BCSPCA, 2004; Hewson, 2008). This article aims to
outline some simple approaches to reducing stress in Figure 1. A typical stance of an anxious dog:
hospitalized dogs and cats using both proven meth- cowering, lip licking and tail between legs
ods and methods with overwhelming anecdotal evi- (Brooks, 2010).
dence. A structured programme of EE has benefits to
not only the patient but also the pet owners and the
veterinary practice team.
Table 1. Some of the more common signs of stress in dogs and cats
Recognizing stress
Cats and dogs exhibit stress in many ways. For this
Dogs Cats reason it is desirable that those working within a vet-
Increased heart rate √ √ erinary clinic learn to recognize the signs of emotion-
Increased respiratory rate √ √ al stress, as being distinct from pain-induced stress,
Dilated pupils √ √ in hospitalized patients. Table 1 lists some of the com-
mon signs of stress in dogs and cats as extrapolated
Tense body posture √
from available research (Flannigan and Dodman,
Hiding in back of cage or box √ √ 2001; Wells, 2002; Graham et al, 2005; Hewson, 2008;
Inappetence (loss of appetite) √ √ Ellis, 2009; Segurson, 2009). These signs can be used
Lack of interest in the environment √ √ as a tool in developing an appropriate EE programme
Lack of interest in people √ √ to suit individual animals’ needs.
McCune (1994) proposed that cats behaviourally
Panting √
express their negative emotional states either actively
Vocalizing √ √ or passively. Table 2 gives a summary of passive and
Over grooming √ √ active behaviours commonly exhibited by cats in re-
Lack of self care √ sponse to confinement. It is critical to be able to rec-
Pacing √ √ ognize both types of cats as typically the passive type
cats are thought to be ‘content’ when in fact it is more
Circling √
likely that they are depressed. Riccomini (2007) sug-
Jumping against cage front √ gests that cats who have shown signs of stress when
Salivating √ √ hospitalized can continue on a negative emotional
Coprophagia √ plane for some hours or days after returning home,
(Flannigan and Dodman, 2001; Wells, 2002; Graham et al, 2005; Hewson, 2008; Ellis, 2009; with cats hiding, not eating and showing aggression.
Segurson 2009) These behaviours are of particular concern in sick or
convalescent animals as their health is already com-
Literature relating to the positive impacts and effects promised and additional stress may delay healing.
of EE on the behaviour and health of cats and dogs re- Similarly, exposure to novel environments or previ-
lates mostly to animals in shelters, pounds and rescue ous negative experiences, together with the processes
centres (Wells, 1998, Wells, 2000; Reinhardt and Rein- of restraint and the perceived inability to escape from a
hardt, 2002; Graham, 2005; Tod, 2004; Gourkow and potentially threatening situation, may provide specific
Fraser, 2006). However, little research has looked at the cues for aggression in dogs (Archer, 1976). Fear, anxiety
benefits of reducing stress within the veterinary clinic. and frustration may also result in preparatory arousal
Proven strategies include human handling (outside of and lower aggression thresholds further (Panksepp,
veterinary procedures), grooming, feeding enrichment 1998). As a result, some dogs can be extremely difficult
and play therapy, and incorporation of these into an EE and dangerous to handle at future clinic visits. There-
programme as part of practice policy would be an easy fore, it is imperative to ensure an animal’s initial visit
task. EE can be implemented as a preventative meas- to a veterinary surgeon is as stress free as possible. In-
ure for animals that experience stress associated with corporating EE into clinic policy and procedures may
hospitalization (Ellis, 2009). contribute to providing a stress free experience.
conversation had any obvious effect. It is common in less behavioural signs of distress (lunging, growling,
both shelter environments and veterinary clinics for barking, pacing, salivating and avoidance) in dogs
staff to listen to general radio programmes and this exposed to dog-laughter compared with those who
may contribute to the apparent lack of response to were not exposed. While no known studies have been
this stimulus. Wells (2002) suggests that the reac- carried out to date using dog-laughter in a veterinary
tions to both classical and heavy metal are due to the clinic, it is believed that the same stress-reducing
novelty factor of these types of music. However, the benefits could be achieved in hospitalized dogs as
reactions to each form of novelty music were quite seen in shelter dogs.
different, with heavy metal music resulting in in- Additionally, the significance of odours for psy-
creased barking and more arousal and activity. This chological well being is well recognized in human
is consistent with studies with human subjects where literature and as such has prompted research into the
heavy metal music has an arousing effect (Gowen- value of olfactory stimulation as a means of EE for
smith and Bloom, 1997). animals (Wells et al, 2002; Pageat and Gaultier, 2003;
More recently, a study has been carried out in- Graham et al, 2005). Pheromone enrichment is the
vestigating the effect of ‘dog-laughter’ (pronounced provision of synthetic pheromone products within
breathy forced exhalations from a dog) which had an animal’s environment in order to improve welfare
been recorded and played back to shelter dogs (Si- (Ellis, 2009). There have been a number of empirical
monet et al, 2005). This study revealed significantly studies conducted in this area that suggest the use of
pheromones is successful in reducing anxiety, stress
and associated behaviours as well as facilitating
Table 3. Separation-related behaviours positive interactions both intra and inter specifically
Destructiveness Excessive licking (Pageat and Gaultier, 2003; Graham et al, 2005; Tod et
(scratching or chewing bars to escape) al, 2004; Mills et al, 2006; Kim et al, 2010).
Vocalization Anorexia Dog appeasing pheromone (DAP) (CEVA Santé
(frequent whining, barking and howling) Animale) is designed to imitate the secretions of
Elimination Gastrointestinal problems (vomiting sebaceous glands in the intermammary sulcus of
(frequent urination and defecation) and diarrhoea) bitches shortly after parturition. DAP is a synthet-
Vigilance Hyper-salivation ic mixture of fatty acids formulated as a spray or a
Trembling Pacing diffuser. It has been reported that DAP has calm-
(Adapted from Kim et.al, 2010) ing effects in dogs in a range of stressful situations
including separation from their owner (Pageat and
Sensory
— visual Other animals, TV, window, visual Other animals, TV, window,
access to staff, blocking visual blocking visual stimulus may also
stimulus may also be enriching be enriching
— auditory Classical music, running water, Classical music, dog-laughter
— olfactory Catnip, essential oils Essential oils, prey odours
— pheromone F3 and F4 facial pheromones Dog appeasing pheromone
(Adapted from Ellis, 2009)
References
Archer J (1976) The organiza- Brooks M, Earning the Trust Duncan I (2006) The changing Risk factors and behaviours Gowensmith W, Bloom L
tion of aggression and fear of a Fearful Dog. On: Ro- concept of animal science. associated with separation (1997) The effects of heavy
in vertebrates. In: Bateson P, chester Canine Academy: Appl Animal Behav Sci 100: anxiety in dogs. J Am Vet metal music on arousal and
Klopfer P eds. Perspectives Facebook http://www.face- 11–19 Med Assoc 219(4): 460–6 anger. J Music Therapy 34:
in Ethology. Plenum Press, book.com/note.php?note_ Dyball K, Strasser R, Katz T Fraser D, Duncan I (1998) 33–45
New York, 2; 231–89 id=413010045814 (accessed; (2007). Behavioral differ- ‘Pleasures’, ‘pains’ and ani- Graham L, Wells D, Hepper P
BCSPCA (2004) The Emotional 18 September, 2010) ences between owner sur- mal welfare: toward a natu- (2005) The influence of ol-
Life of Cats. British Colum- Connor T, Leonard B (1998). render and stray domestic ral history of effect. Animal factory stimulation on the
bia Society for the Preven- Depression, stress and im- cats after entering an animal Welfare 7; 383–96 behaviour of dogs housed
tion of Cruelty to Animals, munological activation: The shelter. Appl Animal Behav Gourkow N, Fraser D (2006). in a rescue shelter. Appl Ani-
Vancouver role of cytokines in depres- Sci 100: 85–94 The effect of housing and mal Behav Sci 91: 143–53
Bradshaw J, Goodwin D (1998) sive disorders. Life Sci 62: Ellis S (2009) Environmental handling practices on the Gregory N (2004) Physiology
Determination of behavio- 583–606 Enrichment: Practical strat- welfare, behaviour and se- and Behaviour of Animal
ral traits of pure-bred dogs Dobson H, Tebble JE, Smith egies for improving feline lection of domestic cats Suffering. Blackwell, Oxford
using factor analysis and RF, Ward WR (2001) Is welfare. J Feline Med Surg (Felis sylvestris catus) by Griffith C, Steigerwals E, Buff-
cluster analysis; a compari- stress really that important? 11: 901–12 adoptors in an animal shel- ington C (1999). Effects of a
son of studies in the USA Theriogenology 55: 65–73 Flannigan G, Dodman N (2001) ter. Animal Welfare 15: 371–7 synthetic facial pheromone
and UK. Res Vet Sci 66: 73–6
on behaviour and food in- ings of the North American Pageat P, Gaultier E (2003) calizations of domestic dogs dogs. Appl Animal Behav-
take of caged cats. In: Pro- Veterinary Conference, Or- Current research in canine during play encounters. iour Science 93: 295–308
ceedings of the 3rd ESVCN lando: 52 and feline pheromones. Animal Behavior Society Valsanen A, Valros A, Hakaoja
Congress, Lyon McCune S (1994) Caged cats: Veterinary Clinics of North Conference E, Raekallio M, Vainio O
Hewson C (2008) Stress in avoiding problems and pro- America. Small Animal Simonet P, Versteeg D, Storie (2005) Preoperative stress
small animal patients: why viding solutions. Newsletter Pract 33(2): 187–211 D (2005) Dog Laughter: in dogs – a preliminary in-
it matters and what to do of the Companion Animal Panksepp J (1998) Affective recorded playback reduces vestigation of behaviour
about it. Irish Vet J 61(4): Behaviour Therapy Study neuroscience. In: The Foun- stress related aggression in and heart rate variability
249–54 Group 7: 33–40 dations of Human and Ani- shelter dogs. Proceedings of in healthy hospitalized pa-
Kessler M, Turner D (1997) Mills D, Ramos D, Estelles M, mal Emotions. Oxford Uni- the 7th International Con- tients. Vet Anaesthes Anal-
Stress and adaptation of Hargrave C (2006) A triple versity Press, Oxford ference on Environmental ges 32: 158–67
cats (Felis sylvestris catus) blind placebo-controlled Reinhardt V, Reinhardt A Enrichment Wells D, Egli J (2004) The in-
housed singly, in pairs and investigation into the as- (2002) Comfortable Quar- Segurson S (2009) Impor- fluence of olfactory enrich-
in groups in boarding cat- sessment of the effect of ters for Laboratory Animals. tance of behavioural health: ment on the behaviour of
teries. Animal Welfare 6: Dog Appeasing Pheromone Animal Welfare Institute recognizing and reducing black-footed cats, Felis ni-
243–54 (DAP) on anxiety related Riccomini E (2007) How to stress in shelter animals. gripes. Appl Animal Behav
Kim YM, Lee JK, Abd el-aty A, behaviour of problem dogs recognize feline stress in North American Veterinary Sci 85: 107–19
Hwang SH, Lee JH, Lee SM in the veterinary clinic. Appl veterinary practice. VN Conference Wells D, Graham L, Hepper P
(2010) Efficacy of dog-ap- Animal Behav Sci 98: 114–26 Times 7(8): 10–11 Stanford T (1981) Behaviour (2002) The influence of au-
peasing pheromone (DAP) Moberg G (2000) Biological Shaffran N (2005) Pain man- of dogs entering a veteri- ditory stimulation on the
for ameliorating separation- response to stress: implica- agement in critical care: nary clinic. Applied Animal behaviour of dogs housed
related behavioral signs in tions for animal welfare. the veterinary nurse/tech- Ethology 7: 271–9 in a rescue shelter. Animal
hospitalized dogs. Canadian In: The Biology of Animal nician’s perspective. J Vet Tod E, Brander D, Waran N Welfare 11: 385–93
Vet J 51(4): 380–4 Stress: Basic Principles and Emergency Crit Care 15: (2004) Efficacy of Dog Ap-
Martens P (2001) Sniffing Implications for Welfare. 240–7 peasing Pheromone in
around for information on CABI Publishing, Walling- reducing stress and fear re-
ford Simonet P, Murphy M, Lance
feline olfaction. In: Proceed- A (2001) Laughing dog: Vo- lated behaviour in shelter