Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Risk Factors and Impacts of Sleep Deprivation on High-School Aged Adolescents in
Kayla Epps
Fall 2021
HPRB 5010
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 2
Table of Contents
Introduction 3
Methods 5
Results 8
Impact Measures 8
Outcome Measures 11
Discussion 13
Limitations 16
Conclusion 17
References 18
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 3
Introduction
Receiving an adequate amount of sleep each night is vital to maintaining one’s overall
health and wellbeing. This is especially important during the time of puberty when an
According to the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, the recommended sleep time for
adolescents aged 13-18 is eight to ten hours per day (Wheaton et al., 2015). However, 72.7% of
high school students in the United States have reported inadequate sleep duration (Wheaton et
al., 2015). When adolescents do not receive enough sleep, it increases their risk of obesity,
diabetes, injuries, poor mental health, attention and behavior problems, and poor academic
Sleep deprivation in high school students can lead to a multitude of negative side effects
automobile accidents as a result of lethargy (Killgore, 2010). The core cause of these issues is
that sleep deprivation has been linked with a slowing of response time, increased variability in
performance, decrease in alertness, and decrease in attention (Killgore, 2010). When adolescents
are not receiving enough sleep to function properly, their academic performance, physical health,
maintaining high grades in school, attending extracurricular activities, working part-time jobs,
and taking care of family members. Another reason that adolescents are chronically sleep-
deprived is that their late sleep times conflict with early school start times (Winnebeck et al.,
2019). Since these lifestyle habits are unique to the developed world, this literature review will
focus on the population of adolescents in developed countries. Countries from which the
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 4
reviewed studies were conducted include the United States, Japan, Turkey, Germany, China,
Norway, and Taiwan. While this selection does not encapsulate all developed countries, it is
intended to assess a wide range of countries. Ideally, this selection will adequately represent all
The original population of this literature review was intended to only include adolescents
from the US, but additional studies found in other countries provided the basis for expanding the
study population. Expanding the population to be worldwide would have required too many
assumptions, as the studies found did not adequately represent all population types. All studies
currently included are from developed countries with the exception of China and Taiwan.
However, these countries are experiencing rapid industrial growth and are anticipated to be
categorized as developed countries in the near future (Benoit et al., 2020). While the definitions
of these two countries are undergoing debate, they will be classified as developed countries for
Throughout the literature, the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) is used to measure
sleep quality. It does this by asking about sleep quality from the preceding month through 19
self-rated questions. It measures sleep quality, sleep latency, sleep duration, sleep efficiency,
sleep disturbances, use of sleep medication, and daytime dysfunction. Regional changes may be
made when translating into other languages. For example, the J-PSQI is used for the Japanese
questionnaire.
This literature review aims to identify what risk factors contribute to sleep deprivation in
high school-aged adolescents (13-18 years) in developed countries along with the negative side
Methods
through PubMed for peer-reviewed journal articles from 2011-2021. An additional stipulation of
an adolescent age range (13-18 years) was included to filter results. After looking through the top
The studies’ selection criteria were that they had to be peer-reviewed, were published in
the last ten years, were conducted on adolescents aged 13-18, and are related to the effects of
developed countries was developed after observing that all selected studies pertained to the
lifestyle habits of developed countries. Two studies were related to academic performance, two
were related to physical health, and three were related to mental health and development.
Specific searches included “sleep AND “high school’”, “delaying school start times”,
“sleep adolescent academic performance.” From these searches, five sources were longitudinal
cohort studies, nine sources were review articles, four sources were cross-sectional non-
The tables below show the process of identifying relevant articles through PubMed. The
first table shows the preliminary searches conducted and the second table shows supplemental
Results
This literature review identified several risk factors for sleep deprivation in high-school-
aged adolescents between the ages of 13-18 in developed countries. These risk factors included
grade year in school, demographics, internet usage, and delayed school start times. The most
commonly identified outcomes associated with chronic sleep deprivation were the negative
impacts on academic performance, physical health, and mental health and development.
Impact Measures
Grade year in school was one risk factor found to have an effect on how much sleep
adolescents received. A study conducted by Mitchel, et al. observed the sleeping patterns of
students from southeast Pennsylvania and southern New Jersey. In eighth grade, sleep duration
averaged 6.72 hours on school nights and 7.50 hours on nonschool nights (Mitchell et al., 2020).
In ninth grade, sleep duration decreased to 6.29 hours on school nights and experienced no
change on nonschool nights (Mitchell et al., 2020). As adolescents enter high school, the average
hours of sleep adolescents receive decreases by an average of 25.8 minutes on school nights.
This is largely due to a 22.2-minute delay in sleep onset (Mitchell et al., 2020). The increased
workload and responsibilities given to adolescents once they enter high school are hinted to be
the cause behind this decrease in sleep duration. In China, sleep quality in adolescents was also
found to decrease as students grew older and moved on to higher grade levels (Xu et al., 2011).
Specifically, 18.6% of adolescents aged 16-20 experienced poor sleep quality compared to
15.2% of 10-15-year-olds (Xu et al., 2011). These results show that grade year differences have
an effect across multiple countries. As students get older and receive more stressors and
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 9
responsibilities, their sleep duration and quality decrease. This change is particularly noticeable
Demographic variables were also shown to have an effect on sleeping times. From the
southeast Pennsylvania and southern New Jersey study mentioned previously, males were 59%
less likely to sleep eight hours or more and had more night awakenings when compared to
females (Mitchell et al., 2020). The study also found that Black students were 51% less likely to
sleep eight hours or more when compared to White students (Mitchell et al., 2020). Additionally,
students in households with less than a $40K annual income had both later sleep onset and offset
(Mitchell et al., 2020). Sleep onset refers to the time when participants fall asleep and offset
refers to the time when they wake. Those whose parents had an undergraduate college degree
had a shorter sleep duration than those with graduate degree parents (Mitchell et al., 2020).
Overall, these results suggest that risk factors for decreased sleep include being male, being
Black, living in a low-income family, and having parents with lower levels of education.
However, there is potential for these demographic risk factors to vary between countries due to
disparities are not as prevalent, race and ethnicity are not significant risk factors (Chen & Gau,
Internet addiction was another factor found to have a negative effect on sleep quality. The
definition of Internet addiction may vary across studies with varying measures such as the Chen
Internet Addiction Scale and Internet Use Survey (Chen et al., 2003; Rotunda et al., 2003). A
longitudinal study of Taiwanese students found that Internet usage and sleep problems have a
bidirectional effect on each other (Chen & Gau, 2016). This means that an increase in Internet
usage led to an increase in sleep problems, and the presence of sleep problems led to further
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 10
Internet usage. Participants who exhibited Internet addiction were found to require longer
amounts of sleep but reported shorter sleep durations, resulting in greater sleep deficits (Chen &
Gau, 2016). This cyclical effect is supported by a study of Japanese high school students that
found a significant relationship between Internet addiction and sleep disturbance (Tokiya et al.,
2020). Screen time on television, computers, video games, or mobile devices is adversely
associated with sleep duration (Hale & Guan, 2015). When adolescents spend more time exposed
to electronics, they experience later sleep onset and shorter sleep duration (Hale & Guan, 2015).
Among a population of students from Notre Dame, increased social network usage was found to
have a negative effect on sleep quality (Wang et al., 2021). Students with larger social networks
found difficulties maintaining them through social media, negatively affecting sleep (Wang et
al., 2021). Extended screen time is particularly detrimental to sleep since the blue light emitted
off of screens has been shown to alter circadian rhythms (Tosini, 2016). Blue light is naturally
emitted by the sun during the daytime, but overexposure to it during the night can disrupt
sleep/wake cycles (Tosini, 2016). Ultimately, increased screen time and Internet usage have been
strongly associated with a decrease in sleep quality. These effects appear to be cyclical, with the
presence of sleep problems also resulting in further Internet usage. Differences between study
results can be attributed to the different measures used to define Internet addiction and sleep
disturbance.
Several schools have attempted to alter school start times to see whether this has an effect
on adolescent sleep times. These experiments with delayed school start times have resulted in
positive effects. One such study was conducted with five public high schools in the metropolitan
area of Minneapolis and St. Paul, Minnesota (Wildome et al., 2020). Two high schools delayed
start times by 50 and 65 minutes respectively, while three other high schools served as a
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 11
comparison group. Students with delayed start times had on average an additional 41 minutes of
sleep a night (Wildome et al., 2020). More importantly, delayed start times were not associated
with students falling asleep later on school nights (Wildome et al., 2020). One concern with
delaying school start times is that adolescents will simply sleep later, not necessarily longer.
However, these results point towards delayed start times at schools being a viable long-term
option for improving adolescents’ sleep. Another study involved a high school in Alsdorf,
Germany that experimented with a flexible school start system (Winnebeck et al., 2019). This
system allowed them to come into school later on some days if they wished and make up the
missed time at a later date (Winnebeck et al., 2019). Students were highly satisfied with the
flexible school start system, sleeping 1.1 hours longer and having sleep onsets remaining
unchanged (Winnebeck et al., 2019). This study further supports the idea that students will use
delayed school start times to improve their sleeping times and subsequently their health.
Outcome Measures
performance. Poor sleep quality among high school students in Turkey resulted in a decrease in
cognitive function and academic performance (Tekcan et al., 2020). Similar results were found in
Norwegian adolescents, where poor sleep was also related to worsened academic performance
(Hysing et al., 2016). Lower sleep duration was most associated with poor school performance.
Weekday sleep onset was also significantly associated with academic performance, with
adolescents that went to bed between 22:00 and 23:00 having the highest GPA scores (Hysing et
al., 2016). The later students went to bed, the lower their GPA (Hysing et al., 2016). This data
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 12
shows the direct correlation between lower sleep duration, later sleep onset, and worsened
academic performance.
Another outcome of poor sleep quality is the negative effects on physical health. A study
of students from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania found that shorter sleep duration is associated with
increased vulnerability to the common cold (Prather et al., 2015). This is especially dangerous
for students in a public school setting since they are exposed to a multitude of illnesses from
their classmates on a daily basis. A review of data from North Carolina examined the effect of a
75-minute delayed school start time on motor vehicle crashes (Foss et al., 2019). The shift in
school start times suggests a small overall decrease in automobile crashes among 16-17-year-old
adolescents (Foss et al., 2019). However, researchers concede that the lack of a significant
decrease may also mean that the decline was not a result of reduced sleepiness (Foss et al.,
2019). While results are not confirmed, there is the potential for sleepier students to be at a
higher risk for motor vehicle crashes. Poor sleep quality negatively impacts adolescents’ physical
health through decreased immune response and an increased likelihood of motor vehicle crashes.
Adolescents’ mental health and development are also severely impacted by worsened
sleep quality. Poor sleep quality among Turkish high school students led to an increase in
depression, alcohol consumption, and suicide attempts (Tekcan et al., 2020). In China, poor sleep
quality was associated with higher levels of loneliness, depression, and anxiety (Xu et al., 2011).
On the other hand, students in Germany with delayed school start times reported cognitive and
sleep improvements (Winnebeck et al., 2019). These results suggest that sleep is a preventative
factor for adolescents’ mental health and development. Additionally, a lack of sleep can be
Discussion
Through a review of the literature, multiple risk factors and outcomes for sleep
deprivation were found in high school-aged adolescents of developed countries. The identified
risk factors helped to determine what circumstances put adolescents at a greater risk of
developing sleeping problems and experiencing shorter sleep duration. Among impact measures,
risk factors include grade year in school, demographic variables, Internet usage, and delayed
school start times. Outcomes of sleep deprivation were reviewed to identify the negative side
effects an insufficient amount of sleep has on adolescents. Outcomes of lack of sleep include
worsened academic performance, physical health, and mental health and development.
The greatest risk factor among impact measures appeared to be Internet usage, which had
a bidirectional effect. Students that experienced sleeping problems found themselves spending
more time on the Internet, and those who spent more time online had shorter sleep durations. The
recent escalation of adolescent screen time is in part due to the rise in popularity of social media,
streamable media, and video games. With so much online media grappling for the attention of
adolescents, this age group is at risk for Internet addiction. Internet addiction disorder can be
defined in several forms, but generally is characterized by excessive Internet usage and poor
impulse control when limiting screen time. Additionally, screens emit blue light, which is
typically associated with daytime and signals our brains to stay awake. This exposure to blue
light disrupts the body’s natural circadian rhythm, leading to difficulty sleeping.
Grade year in school and demographic variables also had a noticeable effect on sleep
duration. As students progressed from middle to high school, they were found to experience
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 14
decreases in both sleep duration and sleep quality. This effect may be due to students receiving
more responsibilities at school and the added burden of extracurriculars and part-time jobs.
Building off of the issue of Internet addiction, there is also the possibility of intersectionality
between the two. As adolescents enter high school, they may be exposed to more social media,
streamable media, and video games, leading to increased Internet usage. Demographic studies
conducted in the United States found that being male, being Black, living in a low-income
family, and having parents with lower levels of education were the greatest risks for sleep
deprivation. In the US, these characteristics are often associated with lower standards of living.
This may lead to students having to spend more time working part-time jobs as they enter
adolescence. These differences held true across reviewed studies from other developed countries
with the exception of race. In countries with more homogenous populations or where racial
disparities are not as prevalent, race and ethnicity were not seen as notable risk factors for shorter
A protective factor for adolescents getting proper amounts of sleep was delaying school
start times. A common critique of this approach is the belief that adolescents will simply sleep
later, not necessarily longer. However, the two experimental studies reviewed both observed a
longer sleep duration among adolescents without the side effect of delayed sleep onset times.
This may be due to adolescents having naturally later circadian rhythms that are interrupted by
early school start times. The results of these studies point towards delayed school start times
being a sustainable solution for increasing adolescent sleep duration. A potential barrier to
implementation is that altering school times may result in scheduling conflicts within school
districts. Districts may not have the resources available to reschedule buses, teacher work hours,
and mealtimes. Additionally, moving school times back means that students’ extracurriculars
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 15
will need to be delayed as well. Ultimately, it is a well-founded solution but will need more
Among outcome measures, the most widespread was worsened academic performance.
Students who got fewer hours of sleep performed poorly on exams and assignments. This
phenomenon has been observed across several developed countries and in a variety of
populations. However, the most worrying outcomes of poor sleep were the negative effects on
physical and mental health. Adolescence is a time in which the brain is undergoing development,
meaning that sleep is vital for health. Poor sleep was associated with weakened immune
response, which is particularly dangerous in a public school setting where adolescents are
exposed to a wide variety of illnesses on a daily basis. Additionally, some studies have found
links between sleep deprivation and automobile crashes among adolescents. In the Foss et al.
study previously reviewed, the relationship between delayed school start times and automobile
crashes was analyzed. While the rate of automobile crashes did decrease, it was undetermined
whether this was a result of increased sleep times or other confounding factors such as having
fewer cars on the road during commute times. Regardless, it is a possibility worth considering
In terms of mental health, sleep deprivation and poor sleep quality resulted in negative
effects. Adolescents across several developed countries who experience poor sleep report an
increase in depression, alcohol consumption, and suicide attempts. They also report a decrease in
cognitive function and academic performance. The positive effect of increased sleep duration is
supported by students from high schools with delayed start times, who reported cognitive and
sleep improvements. It is vital for adolescents to get an adequate amount of sleep each night to
Limitations
Although this literature review has identified several impact and outcome measures of
sleep deprivation in adolescents of developing countries, some important findings may have been
overlooked. Only two of the studies reviewed were experimental, making it difficult to determine
causality. Additionally, many of the studies used self-reported data or asked participants to
describe their prior sleep experience, putting results at risk of recall bias. The reviewed studies
looked at high schools from seven different countries: the United States, Japan, Turkey,
Germany, China, Norway, and Taiwan. However, these results may overlook themes present in
Additionally, the search process may have resulted in selection bias. Only the first page
of results was viewed for each search before moving on to another search term. In many cases,
articles were identified from the references section of other articles included in this literature
review. While this helps to strengthen the background of this topic, it may overlook other views
in this field. Since it is impossible to assess every research article on the topic, articles were
Finally, some of the measure indexes involving Internet usage and sleep quality were
inconsistent. Some studies experienced differing results and were difficult to compare since they
used differing measures. By using a more standardized measurement index such as the PSQI for
Conclusion
Sleep deprivation among high school students is influenced by a variety of factors such as
being in a higher school grade, increased Internet usage, and being in a school that starts earlier.
Males, Black students, and students with a household income <$40,000 were also found to have
disproportionately less sleep on school nights. Sleep deprivation among high school students can
result in worsened academic performance, weaken immune systems, the likelihood of increased
There are several opportunities for future research. The specific effects of
extracurriculars, part-time jobs, and taking care of family members on sleep duration needs to be
observed. Current research does not separate these factors, making it difficult to determine what
events are most contributing to decreased sleep duration in this age group. More research can be
research has not come to a consensus, and if there is a connection it should be identified.
Additionally, the impact of Internet usage is a great opportunity for future research. Internet
addiction is a relatively new concept and online platforms have only gotten more popular the last
few years. More research can also be done into the application of delayed school start times and
their impacts on students with extracurriculars. Future intervention programs may tackle Internet
Researchers in this field have not come to a consensus as to how detrimental a lack of
sleep is for adolescents. While the studies reviewed have found supporting evidence, they often
reference previous articles that have had contradicting results. More research into the topic will
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 18
help to identify gaps in how we support adolescents and what needs to be done to improve
References
Benoit, P. & Tu, K. (2020). Is China still a developing country? And why it matters for
www.energypolicy.columbia.edu/research/report/china-still-developing-country-and-
why-it-matters-energy-and-climate.
Chen, Y. & Gau, S. (2016). Sleep problems and internet addiction among children and
doi:10.1111/jsr.12388.
Chen, S-H.., Weng, L-J., Su, Y-J., Wu, H-M., & Yang, P-F. (2003). Development of a
Chinese internet addiction scale and its psychometric study. Chinese Journal of
Foss, R., Smith, R., & O'Brien, N. (2019). School start times and teenage driver motor
doi:10.1016/j.aap.2018.03.031.
Hale, L. & Guan, S. (2015). Screen time and sleep among school-aged children and
doi:10.1016/j.smrv.2014.07.007.
Hysing, M., Harvey, A., Linton, S., Askeland, K., & Sivertsen, B. (2016). Sleep and
Mitchell, J., Morales, K., Williamson, A., Huffnagle, N, Ludwick, A., Grant, S., Dinges, D., &
Zemel, B. (2020). Changes in sleep duration and timing during the middle-to-high school
doi:10.1016/j.jadohealth.2020.04.024.
Rotunda, R., Kass, S., Sutton, M., & Leon, D. (2003). Internet use and misuse. Preliminary
doi:10.1177/0145445503255600.
Tokiya, M., Itani, O., Otsuka, Y., & Kaneita, Y. (2020). Relationship between internet addiction
and sleep disturbance in high school students: A cross-sectional study. BMC Pediatrics,
20(379). doi:10.1186/s12887-020-02275-7.
Tosini, G., Ferguson, I., & Tsubota, K. (2016). Effects of blue light on the circadian system and
Tekcan, P., Caliskan, Z., & Kocaoz, S. (2020). Sleep quality and related factors in Turkish high
doi:10.1016/j.pedn.2020.07.020.
Wang, C., Mattingly, S., Payne, J., Lizardo, O., & Hachen, D. (2021). The impact of social
networks on sleep among a cohort of college students. Social Science & Medicine -
Wheaton, A., Chapman, D., & Croft, J. (2017). School start times, sleep, behavioral, health, and
academic outcomes: A review of the literature. Journal of School Health, 86(5), 363-381.
doi:10.1111/josh.12388.
Sleep Deprivation In Adolescents of Developed Countries 20
Wheaton, A., Jones, S., Cooper, A., & Croft, J. (2015). Short sleep duration among
middle school and high school students — United States. Morbidity and Mortality
doi:10.1111/josh.12388.
Wildome, R., Berger, A., Iber, C., Wahlstrom, K., Laska, M., Kilian, G., Redline, S., &
Erickson, D. (2020). Association of delaying school start time with sleep duration,
timing, and quality among adolescents. Journal of the American Medical Association
Winnebeck, E., Vuori-Brodowski, M., Biller, A., Molenda, C., Fischer, D., Zerbini, G., &
Roenneberg, T. (2019). Later school start times in a flexible system improve teenage
Prather, A, Janicki-Deverts, D., Hall, M., & Cohen, S. (2015). Behaviorally assessed sleep and
Vijayakumar, N., Macks, Z., Shirtcliff, E., & Pfeifer, J. (2018). Puberty and the human
brain: Insights into adolescent development. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Review, 92,
417-436. doi:10.1016/j.neubiorev.2018.06.004.
Xu, Z., Su, H., Zou, Y., Chen, J., Wu, J., & Change, W. (2011). Sleep quality of Chinese
adolescents: Distribution and its associated factors. Journal of Paediatrics and Child