‘1aiz021 Defining the setup of dual-purp control | Hydraulics & Preumatics
Hydraulics &
Pneumatics.
Prnetant arsceues.
TECHNOLOGIES > HYDRAULIC PUMPS & MOTORS,
Defining the setup of dual-pump control
Single-rod cylinders can be actuated efficiently and accurately by using two
synchronized pumps with displacements matching the rod- and cap-end
volumes of the cylinder. The problem with valve control of cylinder motion ...
Jack Johnson
MAY 14, 2007
The problem with valve control of cylinder motion is that it does its work by
converting (consuming) unused power to heat in the hydraulic fluid. The
advantage of valve control is that it accommodates differential rod- and cap-end
flows. Pump control, on the other hand, is efficient because it ean deliver power
only when and where it is needed. The disadvantage is that it works best with
equal area actuators, and works not at all with unequal area actuators.
Attempts have been made to use pump control on single-rod cylinders. However,
they incorporated some form of valving to deal with the unequal flow, thus
hitps:iwwn hydeaulicspneumatic.com/printicontent21885152 16rarz021
Defining he setup of du-pur con | Hydraulics & Phoumatics
introducing an inefficiency. The simplified schematic shown here depicts pump
control without any valves, except those needed to control the displacement of the
two pumps. This system is called the two-pump control method, and it uses a
pump on cach end of a cylinder. Put simply, the two pumps have displacements
that are matched to the respective cylinder areas. To extend the eylinder, pump A
displacement increases to route flow into the cap end of the cylinder. At the same
time, displacement of pump B increases to absorb flow from the rod end of the
cylinder. Obviously, pump B's displacement must increase at a lower rate than
pump A's. This is the function of the block labeled Ratioed stroke synchronizer.
‘Two pumps can be better than one
no phe
fee est
tot
Conta esse /
cogeandpes pump
Single-rod cylinders can be actuated efficiently and accurately by using two
synchronized pumps with displacements matching the rod- and cap-end volumes
of the cylinder.
Suppose the cap-end to rod-end area ratio of the cylinder is 2:1. The synchronizer
is a mechanism (electrical, hydraulic, or mechanical) that causes pump A's
displacement to be twice that of pump B's. If pump A displaces 4 in.3/ rev, pump B
will displace 2 in.4/ rev. Clearly, the pumps must be capable of over-center
operation, The least expensive means for displacement synchronization would be a
simple mechanical linkage between the two pumps. However, the most flexible
solution would occur with computer control.
Setting up the system
It would be impractical to try to set up the displacement synchronizer before the
system is built. The system can be tuned approximately during final assembly and
testing, but the final adjustment has to be done in the system.
hitps:iwwn hydeaulicspneumatic.com/printicontent21885152i202 Defining the setup of dual-pump control | Hydraulics & Pneumatics
‘The tuning of the synchronizer involves a slight misadjustment of one
displacement or the other (it doesn't matter which) to prevent cavitation during,
system operation. The two pumps must work against each other at all times, but
only toa degr
This conflict elevates both pressures, and the adjustment is aimed
at ensuring that neither pressure drops below atmospheric, thereby preventing
cavitation during normal operation.
How the system works
‘The circuit in the illustration has the equipment connected in a closed positional
servo loop. Preliminary adjustments will set the two displacements at zero when
the cylinder is unloaded and not moving. The two cylinder pressures will both be
zero, or nearly so. This results in a lack of stiffness in the servo loop — a condition
that must be corrected. When the cylinder is at rest, adjusting the offset control
causes the displacement of one pump to increase. If this is done to the rod end,
fluid from pump B will tend to retract the rod. However, if the piston rod actually
does retract, the position loop takes over and increases the displacement of pump
Ato push the rod back.
The result is that cylinder position is almost completely maintained. However, the
pressures at both ends of the cylinder are now elevated. In a 2:1 area cylinder, and
with the cylinder at rest with no load, the offset would be adjusted so that the rod-
end pressure would be about 4 of the maximum anticipated pressure, and the
cap-end pressure would be about ¥%. The elevated pressures deliver the desired
stiffness. In fact, it is the same stiffness that contributes to the success of a valve-
controlled servo loop. The next step is to tune the displacement ratio synchronizer.
Tuning the synchronizer
Again, the system is to be adjusted with no external load on the cylinder. A
command signal is generated — either manually or by some automatic means — to
cause the cylinder to extend and retract slowly enough to enable reading and
interpreting of the two cylinder pressures. Once the proportioning mechanism
synchronizes the two pumps' displacements, the two pressures will change very
little as the cylinder extends, retracts, and stops.
hitps:iwwn hydeaulicspneumatic.com/printicontent21885152rarz021
Dafning he set of cu-pump control | Hyeraulics & Preumatios
To visualize this, imagine a command is given to extend the cylinder, and the
displacement of pump B is increasing too rapidly in comparison to that of pump A.
Pump B's displacement is moving too much fluid. We would expect pump B's
pressure to fall, but so would pump A's. When the cylinder motion is reversed, an
excessively high pump B displacement would cause both pressures to increase.
Just the opposite pressure changes will occur if pump B's displacement changes
too slowly, or if pump A changes too rapidly. So now the tuning strategy is simple:
Adjust the ratio for synchronization until the changes in cylinder pressures
between extension, retraction, and stopped are minimized. This will require some
judgment because the pressures will not be constant.
The cylinder pressures are determined by a slight mis-adjustment of the offset
control — a process made possible by the pumps’ internal leakage. The amount of
internal leakage resistance determines how much mis-adjustment is needed to
reach a given operating pressure. The higher the internal leakage resistance, the
less the mis-adjustment.
Because the internal leakage resistance is affected by the internal sealing and
clearances within the pump, it is dependent upon manufacturing tolerances. This
means one pump pair will require a different offset than another because the
tolerances will be different in each pump specimen. This is the reason why final
tuning has to be done as a system. Pump ratioing also must be matched to the
cylinders.
Assessin
ternal leakage
The amount of internal leakage can be assessed beforehand by copying the
procedures developed for servovalves, namely, by conducting a pressure gain test
on each pump. The pressure gain test is conducted by driving the pump from a
suitable prime mover, with pump displacement set at zero, and with the pump
output port blocked. Then, the displacement of the pump is slowly — but only
slightly — increased while the deadhead pressure is measured. A graph of
command signal into the stroke controller vs. pump deadhead pressure is the
graph of importance.
hitps:iwwn hydeaulicspneumatic.com/printicontent21885152svwza21 Detning the stip of duahpump contol | Hydraulics & Preumatin
The test can be repeated individually on each outlet port. The slope of the
deadhead pressure as a function of command signal input is the pressure gain.
When gain is very high — indicating very high volumetric efficiency — it may be
necessary to add an external leakage path from the outlet port. This external
leakage path also contributes to system damping, which helps improve the
stability of the servo loop. This is also done regularly with servovalve control.
‘A flow gain test can also be conducted — again, as is done with servo and
proportional valves. The pump is operated at nominal shaft speed while the output
flow is routed directly to a low-resistance flow meter. The slope of the output flow
under zero pressure versus input signal is the flow gain of the pump. The internal
leakage resistance is simply the ratio of the pressure gain to the flow gain,
provided both tests are conducted at the same shaft speed.
A key parameter is the internal leakage resistance, and, most importantly, how it
varies. Pump tests reveal that leakage resistance varies with displacement and
somewhat with pressures. This is because clearances can change. For this reason,
we can expect the no-load pressures during extension, retraction, and stopping not
to remain constant but, rather, to change. The degree of change will depend on the
degree to which the internal leakage resistance is not constant. At any rate, the
closed-loop pressure testing just discussed will result in a map of the internal
leakage resistance of the two pumps as a set.
Clearly, a disadvantage of this system is that two pumps are required for each
actuator. Plus, a pair of pumps must be provided for each axis to be controlled.
However, as fuel costs approach $4/gal, and perhaps higher, a pair of pumps could
become a bargain. This point begs the question, "Will this method work on mobile
machinery as well as industrial?" We'll explore that topic — and other viable
configurations — in next month's "Motion Control."
Handbook details Electrohydraulic Systems
The Designer's Handbook for Electrohydraulic Servo and Proportional Systems
covers electrohydraulic system design, control, and analysis by teaching
principles and reviewing practical problems from the real world instead of
endlessly discussing complicated theories.
hitps:iwwn hydeaulicspneumatic.com/printicontent21885152‘1aiz021 Defining the setup of dual-purp control | Hydraulics & Preumatics
Pret
Pare
ran
Tyna
SELVO AND
TMA
Sia
Much of the information updates and expands on important concepts and
calculations from such groundbreaking works as George Keller's Hydraulic
System Analysis and Jean ‘Thoma's Hydrostatic Power Transmission. The book
sells for $99.95, plus shipping and handling. The textbook:
+ covers everything from fundamental hydraulic circuit analysis to
dynamic testing of motion control systems,
+ is packed with more than 500 pages of useful formulas and dozens of
fully worked examples, and
+ contains 20 chapters covering hundreds of topics, including
components, systems, circuit analysis, modeling, servomechanism and
control, simulation, and testing.
For more information, including a detailed table of contents describing all
topics discussed, visit the H&P Bookstore.
Source URL: https://wwwhydraulicspneumatics.com/technologies/hydraulic-
pumps-motors/article/21885152/defining-the-setup-of-dualpump-control
hitps:iwwn hydeaulicspneumatic.com/printicontent21885152