Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Urs Brägger
Weber et al. Consensus Statements and Recommended Clinical Procedures Regarding Loading Protocols
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
4
Agenda
Implant loading Protocols
5
Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially
Edentulous Esthetic Zone
6
Grütter et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Esthetic Zone. 7
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
Grütter et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Esthetic Zone. 8
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
21 studies that reported on 758 implants
• The analysis of the literature on immediately restored or conventionally
loaded implants in the esthetic zone revealed an initial survival rate of 97.3%
after 1 year (10 prospective cohort studies and one case series). For periods
of 1 to 5 years, the survival rate was 96.7%.
• However, for immediately placed implants with immediate restoration and
occlusal loading, the survival rate dropped by approximately 10% (four
studies).
Grütter et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Esthetic Zone. 9
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
Influence of occlusal contacts,immediate
implantation and loading
• 21 studies • 4 studies
Grütter et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Esthetic Zone. 10
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
Implant Loading Protocols for the esthetic zone
ITI Consensus Statements 2008
Conclusion:
• Lack of prospective cohort studies addressing patient-centered
outcomes.
Grütter et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Esthetic Zone.
11
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
Recommendations for Immediate Implant
Restoration and Loading
• The implant is of adequate length (≥8 mm) and diameter (≥4 mm)
• The restoration should be taken out of any functional occlusal
contacts both in centric occlusion and during excursive mandibular
movements
• The restoration should not be removed during the healing period of
approximately 6 weeks
• Screw-retained provisional restorations are recommended
• Patients with parafunctional occlusal habits should be fitted with a
habit appliance
• Immediate restoration and loading can be used when the bone
volume at the site is close to ideal- no bone augmentation needed
• “good”primary stability
12
Grütter et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Esthetic Zone.
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
Primary Implant Stability is dependent on
• bone density
• implant design
• implant surface
• the technique and accuracy of the osteotomy
preparation
Cordaro et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Posterior Mandible
13
Int J Oral Maxillocfacimplants 2009;24(suppl):158–168
Implant Loading Protocols for the Esthetic Zone
ITI Consensus Statements 2013 – Treatment Guidelines
Gallucci GO, Benic GI, Eckert SE, Papaspyridakos P, Schimmel M, Schrott A, Weber HP. Consensus Statements and Clinical
Recommendations for Implant Loading Protocols.
Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants. 2013 Aug 15. doi: 10.11607/jomi.2013.g4. [Epub ahead of print]
14
Implant Loading Protocols for the Esthetic Zone
ITI Consensus Statements 2013 – Treatment Guidelines
Gallucci GO, Benic GI, Eckert SE, Papaspyridakos P, Schimmel M, Schrott A, Weber HP. Consensus Statements and Clinical
Recommendations for Implant Loading Protocols.
Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants. 2013 Aug 15. doi: 10.11607/jomi.2013.g4. [Epub ahead of print]
15
Recommended Clinical Procedures Regarding
Optimizing Esthetic Outcomes in Implant Dentistry
ITI Consensus Statements 2013 – Treatment Guidelines
• Immediate loading or restoration of an implant cannot be recommended as a
routine procedure because risks are elevated and esthetic outcomes are
variable.
=> In agreement with previously published ITI documents, early loading of
dental implants in the esthetic zone is recommended.
Alveolar Socket Healing Period Initial Bone Healing Period Prosthetic Phase
Provisional Phase
0 6 - 8w 6 - 8w 3(-5)mo
17
• Buser, Wittneben, Bornstein, Grütter, Chappuis, Belser: Stability of Contour Augmentation
around Single Tooth Implants in the Maxilla using Early Placement.
3-year Results of a prospective Case Series Study.
J Periodontol 2011 Mar;82(3):342-9
• Prospective study on 20 patients with 20 single tooth replacements post extraction in the
esthetic zone
• Concept of early implant placement was applied
• Average age of 42 years (range 24-60)
• Standardized surgical procedure (only 1 surgeon)
• Extraction without flap elevation, 6-8 weeks of soft tissue healing
• Placement of bone level implants, simultaneous GBR, primary wound closure, and 8-12
weeks of healing
• Following reopening, provisional restorations with crowns were inserted (Dr. C. Hart; = day 0)
18
• Buser, Wittneben, Bornstein, Grütter, Chappuis, Belser: Stability of Contour Augmentation
around Single Tooth Implants in the Maxilla using Early Placement.
3-year Results of a prospective Case Series Study.
J Periodontol 2011 Mar;82(3):342-9
19
The pink esthetic score – PES
absent incomplete complete
Mesial Papilla 0 1 2
Distal Papilla 0 1 2
- Fürhauser R, Florescu D, Benesch T, Haas R, Mailath G, Watzek G. Evaluation of soft tissue around single-tooth implant crowns: the pink esthetic score.
Clin Oral Impl Res. 2005
- Belser U, Grütter L, Vailati F, Bornstein M, Weber HP, Buser D: Outcome evaluation of maxillary anterior single tooth implants using objective esthetic criteria. A cross-
sectional, retrospective study in 45 patients with a 2-4 year follow-up using pink and white esthetic scores (PES-WES). J Periodontol 2009
20
The white esthetic score – WES
Tooth Form 0 1 2
Outline/Volume 0 1 2
Color (Hue/Value) 0 1 2
Surface texture 0 1 2
Translucency/ Characterisation 0 1 2
- Belser U, Grütter L, Vailati F, Bornstein M, Weber HP, Buser D: Outcome evaluation of maxillary anterior single tooth implants using objective esthetic criteria. A cross-
sectional, retrospective study in 45 patients with a 2-4 year follow-up using pink and white esthetic scores (PES-WES). J Periodontol 2009
21
PES 10 PES 5
WES 9 WES 8
22
Table 5. PES and WES of the 20 implant-supported single crowns after 12 and 36 months
Root
Curvature Level convexity Tooth
Mesial Distal Mean Tooth Surface Trans- Mean Total PES &
Timepoint labial labial Soft tissue Volume/ Colour
Papilla Papilla PES Form Texture lucency WES WES
Mucosa Mucosa colour and Outline
texture
1 year 1.45 1.5 1.75 1.9 1.5 8.1 1.75 1.55 1.4 1.95 2 8.65 16.75
3 years 1.5 1.5 1.7 1.8 1.6 8.1 1.8 1.5 1.4 1.95 2 8.65 16.75
23
Table 5. PES and WES of the 20 implant-supported single crowns after 12 and 36 months
Root
Curvature Level convexity Tooth
Mesial Distal Mean Tooth Surface Trans- Mean Total PES &
Timepoint labial labial Soft tissue Volume/ Colour
Papilla Papilla PES Form Texture lucency WES WES
Mucosa Mucosa colour and Outline
texture
1 year 1.45 1.5 1.75 1.9 1.5 8.1 1.75 1.55 1.4 1.95 2 8.65 16.75
3 years 1.5 1.5 1.7 1.8 1.6 8.1 1.8 1.5 1.4 1.95 2 8.65 16.75
24
1Table
mos 1 yr
4: Cast analysis regarding the length of the implant crown (IC) and the
contralateral tooth crown (TC) in mm (mean ± standard deviation).
3 yrs
Exam IC TC ΔIC-TC
Statistically significant differences between the gingival parameter scores are marked with the same letters
Statistically significant differences between the gingival parameter scores are
IC = implant crown; TC = contralateral tooth;
marked with the same letters
IC = implant crown; TC = contralateral tooth;
25
3-year examination: The crestal bone levels are stable
26
Prospective Radiographic Examination up to 3 Years
Longitudinal DIB measurements (in mm) Frequency Distribution of DIB
>1
0.51 – 1.00
0.26 – 0.50
0.11 – 0.25
0-0.10
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Minimum 0 0 0 0 0
27
• Buser, Wittneben, Bornstein, Grütter, Chappuis, Belser: Stability of Contour Augmentation
around Single Tooth Implants in the Maxilla using Early Placement.
3-year Results of a prospective Case Series Study.
J Periodontol 2011 Mar;82(3):342-9
CONCLUSIONS:
• All 20 implants achieved and maintained successful tissue integration up to 3 years of
follow-up
• At the 3-year follow-up, all 20 implants were successful and fulfilled strict success criteria
• The periimplant bone crest levels around the implants were stable with a mean bone loss
of 0.18 mm at the 3-year examination
• One implant showed bone loss around 1 mm and a gingival recession between 0.5 and
1.0 mm.
• The remaining 19 implants showed no signs of recession at the 3-year follow-up
• Thus, the concept of early implant placement after 6-8 weeks of soft tissue healing offer
predictable esthetic outcomes with a low risk of mucosal recession
28
Agenda
Implant loading Protocols
29
Early loading at 21 days of non-submerged
titanium implants with a chemically modified
sandblasted and acid - etched surface:
3-years results of a prospective study
Bornstein M, Wittneben J, Braegger U, Buser D
J Periodontol 2010; 81:809-818
30
• Bornstein M, Wittneben J, Braegger U, Buser D: Early loading at 21 days of non-submerged
titanium implants with a chemically modified sandblasted and acid - etched surface: 3-year
Results of a prospective Study.
J Periodontol 2010; 81:809-818
Summary:
• 56 implants were inserted in the posterior mandible in 40 patients
• at day 21 the implants were fully loaded with a provisional crown for 6 months then
final restored
• none of the implants failed to integrate. However two implants were spinners and left
unloaded for an extended period
• 3 year success and survival rate of 100 %
• DIB: 1 year 2.67 mm and after 3 year 2.55 mm
• Comparison SLA vs mod SLA Surface („SLA active“): statistically different for PD and AL
(mod SLA surface having lower PD and AL after 3 years)
31
• Bornstein M, Wittneben J, Braegger U, Buser D: Early loading at 21 days of non-submerged
titanium implants with a chemically modified sandblasted and acid - etched surface: 3-year
Results of a prospective Study.
J Periodontol 2010; 81:809-818
Conclusion:
Reduction of the healing period from 6-8 weeks to 3
weeks was primarily possible because of the favorable
ultrahydrophilic properties of the chemically modified
SLA surface
32
33
Evolution in Surface Technology over 35 Years:
from Topography to Chemistry
TPS: 1974 SLA: 1997 SLActive: 2004
Improvement of Improvement of
Macro surface Micro surface chemistry Molecular
topography
34
Immediate and early loading of Straumann
implants with a chemically modified surface
(SLActive) in the posterior mandible and maxilla:
1-year results of a multicenter study
Ganeles J, Zöllner A, Jackowski J, ten Bruggenkate C, Beagle J, Guerra F
Clin Oral Impl Res 2008; 19:1119-1128
35
Immediate vs. early loading with chemically
modified surface implants
• 19 centers in 10 countries
• prospective randomized 3- year study
• 266 patients
• 383 implants
• posterior maxilla & mandible
39
Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially
Edentulous Posterior Mandible
Purpose:
Evaluate the predictability of early and immediate loading protocols of
implants in the posterior mandible
Cordaro et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Posterior Mandible
40
Int J Oral Maxillocfacimplants 2009;24(suppl):158–168
Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially
Edentulous Posterior Mandible
Results:
A total of 19 papers were selected: 8 on early loading, 9 addressing
immediate loading, and 2 comparing immediate and early loading. Of
the 19 studies, 5 were randomized clinical trials and 14 were
prospective studies.
Cordaro et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Posterior Mandible
41
Int J Oral Maxillocfacimplants 2009;24(suppl):158–168
42
=> Early loading in the partially edentulous
posterior mandible at 6 to 8 weeks can be
considered routine in the posterior mandible,
either with single crowns or fixed dental
prostheses.
43
44
Immediate loading in the partially edentulous
posterior mandible proved to be a viable
treatment alternative.
Caution is necessary when interpreting published
outcomes for immediate loading, as the inclusion
exclusion criteria are inconsistent and many
subjective confounding factors are evident.
45
Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially
Edentulous Posterior Mandible
Conclusion:
Additional studies with longer follow-ups, specifically randomized clinical trials,
are needed to consolidate the data for immediate loading. Priority should be
given to trials testing immediate loading.
Cordaro et al. Implant Loading Protocols for the Partially Edentulous Posterior Mandible
46
Int J Oral Maxillocfacimplants 2009;24(suppl):158–168
Loading Protocols:
partially edentulous posterior mandible
Implant/prosthetic design
Immediate loading CD CD
48
Implant Loading Protocols for Partially Edentulous
Maxillary Posterior Sites
Purpose:
Evaluate the predictability of early and immediate loading protocols of
implants in the posterior maxilla
Roccuzzo et al. Implant Loading Protocols for Partially Edentulous Maxillary Posterior Sites
49
Int J Oralmaxillofacimplants 2009;24(suppl):147–157
50
Results Early Loading:
• 12 papers: 2 randomized controlled clinical trials
[RCTs], 10 prospective case series studies
51
52
Results Immediate Loading:
• Six papers: 1 RCT, 4 prospective case series, 1
retrospective study
53
Loading Protocols:
partially edentulous posterior maxilla
Implant/prosthetic design
55
Conventional Loading
procedure of choice for partially edentulous sites
(maxilla and mandible) when:
Weber et al. Consensus Statements and Recommended Clinical Procedures Regarding Loading Protocols 56
IJOMI Vol 24, Supp 2009
Agenda
Implant loading Protocols
57
Fully Edentulous
58
Fully Edentulous
Removable Options
‣ Immediate Denture
‣ Overdenture
59
Loading Protocols for Mandibular Overdentures
Implant/prosthetic design
Adequate/reduced interarch
Clinics space
Adequate interarch space Adequate/reduced interarch space Reduced interarch space
60
Loading Protocols for Overdentures in the Maxilla
Implant/prosthetic design
Bar design (with or without Four free-standing implants with Six free-standing implants with
Bar design over six splinted
Retention cantilevers) over four splinted
implants
Locator or telescopic crown Locator or telescopic crown
implants attachments attachments
Interarch relation Adequate interarch space Adequate interarch space Reduced interarch space Reduced interarch space
61
Fully Edentulous
Fixed Options
‣ Immediate Loading
‣ Staged Approach
62
Loading Protocols for Maxillary Fixed Rehabilitation
Implant/prosthetic design
Implant number and Four anterior Six anterior Six anterior-posterior Eight anterior-posterior
distribution
Full-arch with distal Full-arch with distal Segmented in four three-unit
Prosthesis cantilevers cantilevers
Full-arch
FPDs*
Increased interarch space, Increased interarch space, Increased interarch space, adequate Increased interarch space,
Clinics adequate bone volume in adequate bone volume in bone volume in the anterior/posterior adequate bone volume in
the anterior maxilla the anterior maxilla maxilla the anterior/posterior maxilla
SCV: scientifically and clinically validated - dark green * The segmentation design represents the final prosthesis. For fixed transitional prosthesis a full-arch one-piece is indicated.
CWD: clinically well documented - light green
CD: clinically documented - yellow ITI Treatment Guide Vol 4
CID: clinically insufficiently documented - red
63
Loading Protocols for Mandibular Fixed Rehabilitation
Implant/prosthetic design
Early loading CD CD CD CD
Implant number and Four anterior Six anterior Six anterior-posterior Eight anterior-posterior
distribution
Full-arch with distal Full-arch with distal
Prosthesis cantilevers cantilevers
Full-arch in one piece Segmented into three FPDs*
Increased interarch space, Increased interarch space, Increased interarch space, adequate Increased interarch space,
Clinics adequate bone volume in adequate bone volume in bone volume in the anterior/posterior adequate bone volume in
the anterior maxilla the anterior maxilla maxilla the anterior/posterior maxilla
SCV: scientifically and clinically validated - dark green * The segmentation design represents the final prosthesis. For fixed transitional prosthesis a full-arch one-piece is indicated.
CWD: clinically well documented - light green
CD: clinically documented - yellow ITI Treatment Guide Vol 4
64