Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Arguement Essay Final Version
Arguement Essay Final Version
Allie Herrmann
English 1101
Prof. Dunham
27 July, 2021
Have you ever thought about how your own diet can impact the world? If you’re
like me you have probably never had too many second thoughts about eating the
hamburger your parents made for dinner. However, I recently had a friend of mine
decide to become a vegetarian. Admittingly I thought she was out of her mind because I
love eating meat, but I decided to put in some research on why someone would want to
be vegetarian. Beyond making the decision based on morals I discovered that the meat
we all consume makes a huge difference in our health and the environment. Meat
through the chopping down of trees for more pasture space, releasing carbon dioxide.
Only 8% of the world’s population say they are vegetarian while the other 92% of us are
contributing to problems like global warming and deforestation. Due to the fact that plant
based diets are proven to be efficient and healthy for most people it is necessary that
It is important to start out by understanding where the meat we eat comes from.
In her article “People Must Eat Less Meat” Laurie Tuffrey explains the problems with
animal farming. She says that, “One major problem with animal farming is the
production of their feed. The crops are grown on a vast scale and combined with the
Herrmann 2
space needed for cattle ranching, it accounts for the majority of the 14,826,322 acres of
forest felled a year, according to Friends of the Earth.” Tuffrey goes on to explain how
this process is not only harmful because of trees' emission of carbon dioxide, but also
inefficient because many crops such as soya that we can eat are instead grown for
animal feed (Tuffrey par 4). It’s easy to forget about the process that unfolds in order to
get meat from the farm to your kitchen table, but it’s important that more people are
aware of it. Like this author mentioned, when these animal farms cut down millions of
acres of forest they release all the carbon dioxide from the trees which contributes
largely to global warming. And, when we have such a high demand for meat people
often do not put consideration into how the process of getting people the product is
Another thing to consider is how eating less meat could make a positive
difference in people’s health. Co-authors Winston J. Craig and Ann Reed Mangels
wrote about health benefits vegetarians have to gain in their essay titled “Vegetarian
Diets Help Prevent Disease”. In this essay they explained how being a vegetarian has
shown to not only be healthy and efficient but even possibly be healthier than a non
vegetarian diet. Craig and Mangels said that people who follow vegetarian diets more
typically have lower blood pressure, cancer rates than those who don’t. They went on to
say this observation is a result of beneficial compounds found in plant based foods such
as potassium, magnesium, antioxidants, dietary fat, and fiber (Craig, Mangel par 6).
Plants provide people with a more direct energy source that includes all the things
people need to be healthy. In accordance with the studies mentioned in this essay
people who are vegetarians experience better health in many places than do people
Herrmann 3
who regularly eat meat. So, if the environment wasn’t enough reason to quit eating meat
products, it’s possible the biggest motive for people would be to naturally improve their
own health. Beyond personal health, a world shift to vegetarianism would improve the
health of people around the world by providing them with food. In another article
“Vegetarianism is the Right Moral Choice for Many Reasons” written by Brian Solomon,
he says, “There are estimates that the world currently produces enough vegetarian
food to feed 15 billion people. 1.4 billion people could be fed with the grain and
soybeans we feed US cattle alone. 40,000 children die of hunger every day.” It is made
very clear here that the world can live on plants, the only thing stopping us is our own
selfishness. Becoming a vegetarian would ensure your own health and the health of
On the other hand, there are without a doubt many people who would not want to
sacrifice eating meat for anything. A lot of those people would like to use the argument
that a plant based diet cannot be healthy for a person, in Kris Gunnars article
“Vegetarian Diets are Not Healthy” she explains that humans are healthiest when eating
both plants and animals. She also adds that we can only derive certain vitamins from
animal products and should not eliminate them from our diets (Gunnars par 9). While
you can certainly make this argument it would be more fitting to say that people can
function eating both meat and plants just as they can eat solely plants. The University of
Chicago News Office has a differing opinion on the subject in their article “A Vegetarian
Diet is More Energy Efficient Than a Meat Diet”. In a conducted study referenced in
their article comparing the energy efficiency of 5 different diets (average American, red
meat, fish, poultry and vegetarian (including eggs and dairy). As it turned out the
Herrmann 4
vegetarian diet proved to be more energy efficient than all the others. As long as your
diet is fueling your body to the maximum potential your health will follow is really good
shape. Therefore, you do not need to eat meat to be the healthiest version of yourself.
they may want to consider making the small sacrifice of switching. Eating more plants
can make a big difference in lowering the greenhouse gas emissions that contribute
directly to global warming, and it can drastically reduce deforestation from animal
farming. Contrary to many beliefs, being a vegetarian is far from a bad thing, you can
benefit from it and so can thousands of people and animals. Moving forward, more
people need to adopt vegetarianism for the preservation of our environment, and the
Works Cited
Craig, Winston J., and Ann Reed Mangels. "Vegetarian Diets Help Prevent Disease." Can Diets
Gunnars, Kris. "Vegetarian Diets Are Not Healthy." Vegetarianism, edited by Amy Francis,
link.gale.com/apps/doc/EJ3010705258/OVIC?u=dayt30401&sid=bookmark-
Reasons Why Vegan Diets Are a Terrible Idea," authoritynutrition.com, 26 Aug. 2013.
Solomon, Brian. "Vegetarianism Is the Right Moral Choice for Many Reasons." Vegetarianism,
Tuffrey, Laurie. "People Must Eat Less Meat." Factory Farming, edited by Debra A. Miller,
link.gale.com/apps/doc/EJ3010701252/OVIC?u=dayt30401&sid=bookmark-
Herrmann 6
University of Chicago News Office. "A Vegetarian Diet Is More Energy Efficient Than a Meat
link.gale.com/apps/doc/EJ3010705220/OVIC?u=dayt30401&sid=bookmark-