Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Posveta
Dragima J., F. i M.
1. poglavlje
3UREXGLR P H ]YXN NXFDQMD QD YUDWD VSDYDüH VREH$ GGLVRQ LK MH SRODNR
RWYRULODª-HVLOLEXGQD"©
ª-HVDP ©VODJDODVDP SULGLJQXYãLVH,P DODVDP WHãNXQRü9HüLQRP VDP
VHEDFDNDODLSUHYUWDODUD]P LãOMDMXüLR-DFNX+ HQU\MX1 HP DãDQVHGDVDP
RGVSDYDOD YLãH RG SDU VDWL QR QH åHOLP GD VH$ GGLVRQ JUL]H ]DWR ãWR P H
SUREXGLODªâWRMHELOR"©
6MHODMHQDUXEP RJNUHYHWDª6LQRüQLVDP QLNDNR]DVSDOD©
1 HP DP OHüH X RþLP D SD P L MH VYH P XWQR QR YLGLP GD MH ]DEULQXWD
ª% ULQHãOLVH]ERJDXGLFLMH"©
ª1 LP DOR8 RSüHP LQLMHVWDOR0 XþLP H=DF1 HP RJXSUHVWDWLP LVOLWLQD
QDVLNROLNRP XVHMDNRåHOLP YUDWLWL©
1 HP RJXYMHURYDWL$ NRJDWROLNRYROLQHELWUHEDODELWLRYGMHYLãHQL
WUHQXWNDLULVNLUDWLGDMRMSREMHJQHª2 QGDNUHQL3UHVWDQLELWLMDGQDLNUHQL©
ª6WYDUQRP LVOLãGDELKWUHEDOD"©
-DQHELKRNOLMHYDODª$ SVROXWQR9ROLãJDLWRQHüHQHVWDWL©=QDP L]
LVNXVWYD6WLVQXODP LMHUXNXª1 DSUDYLWüXWRQRåHOLP GDWLRGHãQDDXGLFLMX
XP MHVWRP HQH©
-HOLSROXGMHOD"* OD]EHQDLQGXVWULMDQHWUSLWDNYHLVSDGH1 HP RJXVHMD
VDP RSRMDYLWLXP MHVWRQMHª1 HP RJXRWLüLQDWYRMXDXGLFLMX©
ª0 RåHã8 VWDQLLRGMHQLVH,P DãVDWYUHP HQD©
ª1 H1 H1 HP RJXWR©0 RJXOL"
ª2 þHNXMXSMHYDþLFX7LVLSMHYDþLFD² LWRRGOLþQD1 HüHLKELWLEULJD]D
GHWDOMH NDG WH þXMX NDNR SMHYDã 6LWXDFLMD MH ]DSUDYR VDYUãHQD NDG P DOR
EROMHUD]P LVOLã7UHEDMXSMHYDþLFXNRMD]QDVYLUDWLJLWDUXDWHELWUHEDSRVDR
3UREOHP ULMHãHQ©
1 LVDP SMHYDODQLVYLUDODYHüGYDWMHGQDª1 LVDP VHXYMHåEDOD©
ª2 GDEHULQHãWRSR]QDWRSRSXWª: KDW+ XUWVWKH0 RVW©7RL]YRGLãYHü
GXJRGXOMHQHJRVHSR]QDMHP R7RWLMHMHGQDRGQDMEROMLKLP RåHãMHUDVWXULWL
EH]]DJULMDYDQMD©
8 SUDYXMH7RP LMHRGXYLMHNELODMHGQDRGQDMEROMLKL]YHGEL0 RJOREL
XSDOLWL
Ma daj! Zar ja ovo zbilja razmatram?ª2 EMH]QDP RGDMHRYDMSRGYLJ
þLVWD OXGRVW ý DN L GD LP VH VYLGL P RM JODV RYR MH QHSURIHVLRQDOQR ,
RþDMQLþNL5 HüLüHP LQHNDVHJXELP ©
ª-DüXLüLVWRERP 3RQDãDWüHP RVHNDRGDVDP MDGRãODQDDXGLFLMXDWL
VLP LVDP RSRWSRUD=DP LMHQLWüHP RP MHVWDXSRVOMHGQMLWUHQ©
. DGRQDWRNDåH]YXþLWDNRODNR² LWHãNRMXMHRGELWLª1 DSUDYLWüXWR
âWRVDGDLP DP ]DL]JXELWL"©
ª1 LãWD©
8 SUDYXMH. DGQHP DãQLãWDQHP DããWRL]JXELWLª0 RUDP VHVSUHP LWL©
3R]YDOLVXQDVXVWXGLRLYUDãNLVDP QHUYR]QD2 YRQLMHVLWXDFLMDXNRMRMVH
P RUDP GRND]DWLQHNRP RVUHGQMHP EHQGXNRMLVYLUDSRP DOLP NOXERYLP D2 YL
OLNRYLVXR]ELOMQLLXVSMHãQL
$ GGLVRQ VH SUHGVWDYLOD D MD VDP VWDMDOD X SR]DGLQL NDG LK MH
ERP EDUGLUDOD ª-D GDQDV QHüX L]YRGLWL 2 QD üH SMHYDWL XP MHVWR P HQH©
3RND]DODMHSUHNRVYRJDUDP HQD
1 DVWXSLRMHNUDWDNWUHQXWDNWLãLQHSULMHQHJRMHIUDMHUNRMHJSUHSR]QDMHP
NDRJODYQRJSMHYDþDSURJRYRULRª1 HELKUHNDR² RYGMHWRWDNRQHLGH0 L
RþHNXMHP R$ GGLVRQ ' RQDYRQ$ JHQW QDP MH GRYHR QMX L QHP D L]QLP DND
1 LMHRYRãDOD©
=QDOD VDP GD MH ORãD LGHMD 1 D UXEX VDP RGODVND QR$ GGLVRQ VH QH
SUHGDMHWDNRODNRª0 RMP HQDGåHUMHGRJRYRULRRYXDXGLFLMX]DP HQHSULMH
QHJRMHVD]QDRGDRGOD]LP L]]HP OMH1 LMHOLVXOXGRSRWUDWLWLDXGLFLMXNDGYDP
RQRãWRWUHEDWHVWRMLSUHGQRVRP "©
ª1 HWUDåLP RGUXJRUD]UHGQX]DP MHQX©-DVQRMHWNRMHWXYRÿD* RVSRGLQ
6DYUãHQL3ODYL8 YRMDNV1 DXãQLFDP DL,VWHWRYLUDQLP 3RGODNWLFDP D
ª7RYDP QLVDP QLGRYHOD2 QDMHQHYMHURMDWQDYRNDOLVWLFDLJOD]EHQLFD
6YLUDSRVOXKX² JLWDUXLNODYLU©. ROLNRJRGFLMHQLP $ GGLVRQLQRQDEUDMDQMH
P RMLKYUOLQDRVMHüDP VHNDRGDWUDåLP P LORVWLQMX2 GYUDWQRP LMHWR
ª1 H1 HP DGRJRYRUHQXDXGLFLMXLQHP RåHVYLUDWLQLSMHYDWLGRNQMH]LQ
P HQDGåHUWRQHXUHGLVQDP D©7RVHQHüHGRJRGLWLMHUP H' DYLGRVWDYLR
QDNRQLQFLGHQWDV% ODNHRP
1 DVWDYLOLVXUDVSUDYOMDWLGRNLKMDQLVDP SUHNLQXODª8 UHGXMH$ GGLVRQ
,GHP R©
ª1 H1 LMHXUHGX©2 NUHQXODVHWLSXVNRMLP MHUDVSUDYOMDODª* DGQRüHWH
SRJULMHãLWLDNRMRMGRSXVWLWHGDRGH©
6YHRYRP LMHSRQLåDYDMXüHLRGELMDP VWDMDWLSRSXWQHåHOMHQRJSRNORQD
GRN $ GGLVRQ SUHNOLQMH X P RMH LP H 8 ]HOD VDP VYRMX IXWUROX V JLWDURP L
NUHQXODSUHP DYUDWLP Dª* RVSRGRåDRP LMH]ERJQHXJRGQRVWLNRMHVDP YDP
SULXãWLODLåHOLP YDP VUHüXXSRWUD]L]DVDYUãHQRP YRNDOLVWLFRP ©7RMHP RMD
ãLIUDNRMRP LP åHOLP UHüLGDVHJRQHNYUDJXLGD$ GGLVRQXãXWLLNUHQH]D
P QRP 0 RåGD VDP P DOþLFH RþDMQD QR UDGLMH üX FUNQXWL QHJR SURVMDþLWL
0 RåGDQHP DP SRVDRQLOMXEDYQRMRãXYLMHNLP DP SRQRV2 YLNUHWHQLP LWR
QHP RJXRGX]HWL
ªäHOLP YDP XJRGQRSRVOLMHSRGQH©
5 HNODVDP WRVGR]RP RWURYDLNUHQXODSUHP DYUDWLP D' DERJGDGRELOL
WULSHURGWLVXüHNXUYL
ªý HNDM©
=DVWDODVDP QDYUDWLP DLRNUHQXODVHGDYLGLP NRMLP LVHLGLRWREUDWLR
2 SHWYRÿD² RQDMYLVRNLVIUL]XURP NDRNRG. HLWKD8 UEDQD1 DVORQLRVHL
XSLWDR RVWDOH þODQRYH EHQGD ª+ RüHP R OL GRSXVWLWL RYRM GDP LFL GD QDV
]DEDYL"©
. DNRMHVDP RGRSDGDQª1 HP RUDWHP LþLQLWLXVOXJH©' D]QDP GDVHQH
ELKWUHEDODSUDYLWLSDP HWQDSUHGQMLP DQRQHP RJXVLSRP RüL/MXWHP HMHUVH
SRQDãDMXNDRGDVDP LP SUHSXãWHQDQDP LORVWLQHP LORVW1 HNLWLSNRMLMH
OXSNDRRORYNDP DRVWROVHQDVP LMDRª5 DWRERUQDMH7RELP RJDRELWLGREDU
]QDN©
3ODYRNRVLP LMHP DKQXRGDVHYUDWLP 1 HåHOLP L]JOHGDWLSRSXWRþDMQLFH
SDVDP QDEDFLODVYRMHSRNHUDãNROLFHLODJDQRNUHQXODQDWUDJ* ODVQRVDP
VSXVWLOD IXWUROX V JLWDURP QD NRQIHUHQFLMVNL VWRO L L]YDGLOD P DP LQX VWDUX
JLWDUX3UHEDFLODVDP UHP HQSUHNRJODYHLVMHODQDVORERGDQYLVRNLVWRODF
ª. DNRVH]RYHWH"©
0 LVOLP GD MH QDMEROMH GD QH NRULVWLP VYRMH SUDYR LP H MHU VDP VDG X
NRQWDNWXVDVYRMLP RFHP 1 H]QDP ãWRüHVHGRJRGLWLNDGDVYLVD]QDMX]D
QMHJRYXYH]XVP RMRP P DMNRP ² DVDP RMHSLWDQMHYUHP HQDNDGüHVHWR
GRJRGLWL7DNYHVWYDULQHP RJXRVWDWLWDMQDDMDQHVP LMHP ULVNLUDWLGDP H
RGP DKSRYHåXVQMLP
0 RUDODVDP VHQDEU]LQXVMHWLWLQHNRJLP HQD² EDãNDRRQHQRüLNDGP H
MH-DFN+ HQU\SLWDRWNRVDP 3DORP LMHQDSDP HWGDNDåHP ª3DLJH% HFNHWW©
QRWRLP HELP HRGP DKSRYH]DORVRFHP
ª/DXUHO\Q 3UHVFRWW QR NDR XP MHWQLþNR LP H QDP MHUDYDP NRULVWLWL 3DLJH
0 F/DFKODQ©
9 LGLP GD VH $ GGLVRQ WUJQXOD L SRJOHGDOD P H 6LJXUQR P LVOL GD VDP
SROXGMHOD0 RUDWüXVHVMHWLWLQHNRJREMDãQMHQMD]DQMX. DVQLMH6DGDP RUDP
LP SUHVLRQLUDWLWULWLSDVYRMLP XP LMHüHP
ª-D VDP & KDUOLH© 2 Q MH JODYQL YRNDOLVW RQDM V NRMLP üX MD SMHYDWL
8 ãWLP DYDODVDP JLWDUXDRQP LMHSRND]DRIUDMHUDVD]DOL]DQRP IUL]XURP NRML
MHSUHNULåHQLKUXNXVMHGLRQDVWROFX1 LMHELRRGXãHYOMHQP RMLP SULVXVWYRP
ª2 YRMH5 \DQVYLUDNODYLMDWXUHLP DQGROLQX©3UHãDRMHQDOXSDþDRORYNDP DL
]QDODVDP ãWRüHP LUHüLª2 YRMH3-QDãEXEQMDU©
-RãXYLMHNVHQLVDP RVMHüDODNDR0 LVVVLP SDWLþQRVWLQDNRQRQDNRKODGQRJ
GRþHNDQRRVP MHKQXODVDP VHª' UDJRP LMH©
ªâWRüHWHQDP L]YHVWL"©
=QDP ãWR üX 3MHVP D 5 DVFDO )ODWWVD MH QDMEROML L]ERU MHU SRVMHGXMH
crossoverSRS]YXNEDãNDR6RXWKHUQ2 SKHOLDª: KDW+ XUWVWKH0 RVW©
ª' REDUL]ERU©
3RþHOD VDP VYLUDWL L SMHYDWL ]DWYRUHQLK RþLMX 9HüLQD OMXGL P LVOL GD WR
UDGLP ]ERJWUHP HLQHUYR]HDOLQLMH]DWR,VNRULVWLP YULMHP HGDELKRVMHWLOD
JOD]EXLYL]XDOL]LUDODGRJDÿDM3UHP MHVWLP VHWDP RQHJGMHXJODYLNDNRELK
VWYDUQR RVMHWLOD RQR ãWR SMHYDP 7R P L VDGD QHüH ELWL WHãNR SMHVP D MH
SRSULP LODVDVYLP QRYR]QDþHQMHRWNDGVDP VHUD]LãODV-DFNRP + HQU\MHP
' UåDOD VDP WHP SR OXSNDMXüL SHWRP þL]P H R SUHþNX QD VWROFX VYH GRN
QLVDP GRãOD GR UHIUHQD 7DG VDP RWYRULOD RþL 7URMLFD þODQRYD EHQGD
6RXWKHUQ2 SKHOLDVXP H]DSDQMHQRJOHGDODQR]QDODVDP GDMHVDGNOMXþQL
WUHQXWDNVDGDP RUDP SRYXüLSRVOMHGQMLSRWH]LRGDEUDODVDP & KDUOLHMDNDR
åUWYXMHUVHRQSRND]DRNDRYRGDWURMNH
3RJOHGDODVDP JDXRþLLVDVYLP VHRJROLODNRULVWHüLVHVWLKRYLP DNDR
YODVWLWLP HP RFLMDP D3RND]DODVDP P XVYRMHVUFHLGXãX² XåDVQRL]JOHGDMX
RWNDGDQHP D-DFND+ HQU\MD9 LGLRMHP RMXWDP QXVWUDQX]DWRãWRVDP P XWR
GRSXVWLOD
. DGVDP ]DYUãLODQDVWDRMHWUHQXWDNWLãLQHSULMHQHJRVXP L5\DQL3-
SRþHOLGLMHOLWLNRP SOLP HQWH& KDUOLHMHVDP R]XULR5\DQP XMH]DSXFNHWDR
SUVWLP D LVSUHG RþLMX L QDSRNRQ VH RVYLMHVWLR ª& KDUOLH ý RYMHþH ãWR WL
P LVOLã"©
3RND]DOD VDP SUHP D YUDWLP D ª0 RJX L]LüL YDQ L SXVWLWL YDV GD
SRUD]JRYDUDWHQDVDP R©
ª0 LVOLP GDQHüHELWLSRWUHEQR©UHNDRMHRVP MHKXMXüLVH
7DGVDP VKYDWLODGDMHRGOXNDGRQHVHQD3ULGRELODVDP WULMDGX6RXWKHUQ
2 SKHOLMH
6. poglavlje
7UL 3URNOHWR ' XJD 0 MHVHFD 7ROLNR MH SURãOR RWNDG VDP SRVOMHGQML SXW
YLGLR /DXUHO\Q 0 LVOLP GD QHüX P RüL SRGQLMHWL YLãH QL P LQXWH 3RP DOR
RGXP LUHP VYDNLGDQEH]QMH
% LORMXMHVNRURQHP RJXüHSURQDüL6XGELQDMHELODSURWLYQDVQDJRWRYR
VYDNRP NRUDNX -LP MH P RUDR L]YRGLWL FLUNXVNH WULNRYH GD EL GRãDR L GR
QDMP DQMHLQIRUP DFLMH. RUDNQDSULMHGQDWUDJGYD² XP MHVWRREUQXWR/DNãH
ELVP RSURQDãOLRGEMHJORJNULP LQDOFD
1 RSURQDãOLVP RMX/DXUHO\Q3DLJH3UHVFRWW² MDYQRVWLEROMHSR]QDWD
SRGXP MHWQLþNLP LP HQRP 3DLJH0 F/DFKODQ² WRMHåHQDNRMXüXYHþHUDV
YLGMHWL
8 YLMHNVHQDVP LMHãLP NDGVHVMHWLP GDMHX]HODP RMHLP HQRQHP RJXD
GDVHQHSLWDP ]DãWRMRMXRSüHWUHEDDOLDV1 LNDGDP LQLMHVSRP HQXODGDVH
NRULVWLXP MHWQLþNLP LP HQLP DSDVDP VH]DSLWDRMHOLVHP RåGDQHãWRGRJRGLOR
VDVSHUP RGDYFHP ,OLMRãJRUHV% ODNHRP 3KLOOLSVRP
8 ãDRVDP XSUHGYRUMHGYRUDQHLELORVHWHãNRSURELWLNUR]JRP LOX* LWDUD
0 DUWLQNRMXQRVLP GRGDWQRP LRWHåDYDSUROD]=DELMDP VHXOMXGHLVWDOQRVH
P RUDP LVSULþDYDWL
3URQDãDRVDP VYRMHP MHVWR5 REXMHP QDYLNDP DLELORP LMHGUDJRNDG
VDP VKYDWLRGDMHXWDP QRP NXWNX6MHRVDP LSRORåLR0 DUWLQLFXNUDMQRJX
1 HUYR]DQVDP LDGUHQDOLQP LMXULåLODP DVUFHP LOXÿDþNLOXSD6DGüXYLGMHWL
åHQXNRMXYROLP NDNRL]OD]LQDSR]RUQLFX
3RJOHGDRVDP QDVDWLYLGLRGDMHMHGQDP LQXWDGRRVDP 6UFHP LOXSDNDR
GDüHLVNRþLWL8 VSMHORMHQDGJODVDWLJRP LOX6DGüXMHYLGMHWLSUYLSXWQDNRQ
WUL P MHVHFD 0 RMD /DXUHO\Q 6YD GDOMLQD L VYR YULMHP H NRML VX QDV GLMHOLOL
QHVWDOLVXLVWRJWUHQDþLP VDP MRMYLGLROLFH
,]JOHGDLVWRDRSHWGUXJDþLMH. RVDMRMMHP DOþLFHGXåDLWDP QLMD9 LãH
QHP DSUDP HQRYDERMHP HGDLVP UãDYMHODMH-RãXYLMHNMHSUHNUDVQDP DGD
YLãHQHL]JOHGDNDRRQDVOLNDNRMXQRVLP XUH]DQXXVYRP VMHüDQMX
2 EXODMHVP HÿHþL]P H² RQHNRMHMHQRVLODNDGVDP MHYLGLRSUYLSXW²
L]EOLMHGMHOH WUDSHULFH L ELMHOX P DMLFX EH] UXNDYD 1 MH]LQD JROD UDP HQD P H
L]D]LYDMXGDMRMGRGLUQHP JROXNRåXLSROMXELP MX0 DMLFDMRMVWRMLXVNRQD
JUXGLP D MHU MH VYH]DQD LVSRG QR OHSUãD SUHNR UXED QMH]LQLK WUDSHULFD
=DP LãOMDP NDNRLKQRVLQLVNRQDERNRYLP DWDNRGDMRMP RJXOMXELWLWUEXK
,]YDGLOD MH JLWDUX ² ]ELOMD P LVOLP GD MH WR RQD NRMX MH VSUHP RGDYDF
GDURYDR QMH]LQRM P DMFL WH SUHEDFXMH UHP HQ SUHNR JODYH 7UHEDOD EL LP DWL
VYRMX0 DUWLQLFXXP MHVWRWHJLWDUH
2 NUHQXOD MH OHÿD SXEOLFL L SRQRYQR VDP VH VMHWLR RQH QRüL X : DJJD
: DJJLNDGVDP MHJOHGDRNDNRUDGLWRLVWR=DGLYLODP HNDRQLWNRSULMHLWR
VHQLMHSURP LMHQLOR-RãXYLMHNVDP RþDUDQ
0 RMD P DOD $ P HULNDQND ]DX]LP D VYRMH P MHVWR L]D P LNURIRQD L WDGD
SULP MHüXMHP IUDMHUDSRUHGQMHý LQLVHGDVXåHQHXSXEOLFLOXGH]DQMLP
3ULP LMHWLRVDP LSUHRVWDODGYDþODQDEHQGD-LP P LWRQLMHVSRP HQXR² GD
RQDSMHYDXP XãNRP EHQGX² LP DOR]HOHQRþXGRYLãWHVHEXGLXP HQLL
RGP DKåHOLWXüLLXELMDWL
. DGVXVYLVWDOLQDVYRMDP MHVWDVLQVWUXP HQWLP DXUXNDP DIUDMHUNRML
VWRMLSRUHG/DXUHO\QQDP MHVWLRMHVYRMP LNURIRQ
ª' DOODVNDNRVP RYHþHUDV"©
* RP LODOXÿDþNLQDYLMDL]YLåGLGRNEXEQMDUOXSDSRQDMYHüHP EXEQMXGD
LKGLJQHQDQRJHý LQLVHGDVYLSOMHãüXXULWP Xª-HOLLWNRRYGMHVSUHP DQ]D
WXOXP © YLNQXR MH IUDMHU D JRP LOD MRã MDþH YULãWL ý LQL VH GD LK RYL OMXGL
RERåDYDMX
2 GVYLUDR MH QHNL P HQL QHSUHSR]QDWOMLY ]YXN QD VYRMRM JLWDUL L REMDYLR
ª' DP HXYLMHNLP DMXSUHGQRVWLQDãDSUHNUDVQD3DLJHüH]DSRþHWLVMHGQRP
VWYDULVQDãHJQRYRJDOEXP DQD]YDQRP
/HWLW* R
©
=RYHVH/DXUHO\QDQH3DLJH
0 RMDSUHNUDVQDGMHYRMND]DWYDUDRþLL]QDP GDMHWRQMH]LQ]QDN3ULSUHP D
VH]DSMHVP X7DNRRQDRVWDYOMDVYLMHWQHJGMHYDQLLRGOD]LQDRQRP MHVWR
JGMHMRMJOD]EDLULMHþLSULþDMXSULþX
* OD]EDMH]YXNRVMHüDMD1 LMHOLRQDWRJRYRULOD"
6MHGLRVDP QDUXEXVMHGDOD0 RUDP SUL]QDWLGDVDP RþDMDQLGDYLVLP R
WDQNRMWDQNRMQLWL9HüP MHVHFLP DXJODYLþXMHP VDP RULMHþLNRMHVDP MRM
WUHEDRUHüLDQLVDP 1 RVDGVDP RYGMHVQMRP LLP DP SULOLNXUHüLMRMNROLNR
üHQDP OLMHSRELWL]DMHGQR
-HGQRP P LMHUHNODGDP HYROLLQDGDP VHGDVHWRQLMHSURP LMHQLOR
3ULP DNQXOD VH VNUR] EOL]X P LNURIRQX GRN MH SMHYDOD R VMHüDQMLP D L
RGODVFLP D L ]QDR VDP GD P RMH VUFH SUHSR]QDMH VDP R QMH]LQ JODV 3XãWDP
QMH]LQJODVXQXWUDLGR]YROMDYDP P XGDVHREDYLMHRNRP UWYLK]LGRYDP RJD
VUFDLSRQXNDJDGDSRQRYQRSRåHOLELWLåLYRLNXFDWL
2 WYRULODMHRþLNDGMH]DSMHYDODUHIUHQ. DRLXYLMHN1 HåHOLP MHVOXãDWL
NDNRSMHYDRRGXVWDMDQMX=QDP GDELUDVDP RSMHVP HNRMHP RåHSMHYDWLL]
VUFDLSRP LVDRGDP LVOLRQDP DGRNLKSMHYDP HXELMD0 RåGDWR]QDþLGDMRã
XYLMHNP LVOLQDP HQH0 RåGDP HMRãYROL0 RåGDVHQDGDGDüXGRüLSRQMX
* RP LODMHSROXGMHODRGRGREUDYDQMDLRGXãHYOMHQMDQDNRQQMH]LQHSMHVP H
,P DMXSUDYR)DQWDVWLþQDMH]DEDYOMDþLFD=QDRVDP WRDOLP LVOLP GDVDP WHN
VDGD]DSUDYRVKYDWLRNDNRMHRGOLþQD
2 QDMGUXJLSMHYDþMHVWDRX]VYRMP LNURIRQª& XUD]QDãWRUDGL]DUQH"©
* RP LODRGJRYDUDSRYLFLP Dª1 DãDVOMHGHüDSMHVP DVH]RYH
: LQ< RX
2 YHU
©3RJOHGDRMHP RMXFXUXRVP MHKQXRMRMVHLQDP LJQXR
Koji mu je kurac?
)UDMHUJOHGDX/DXUHO\QGRNSMHYDSMHVP XRSULGRELYDQMXQHNHFXUHQDNRQ
ãWRMRMMHVORP OMHQRVUFH* OHGDMHXRþLGRNMRMSMHYDLWDGP LMHVLQXOR² WDM
LGLRWQHSMHYDSXEOLFLQHJRP RMRMGMHYRMFL
. XUYLQVLQ
1 HP RM JD JOHGDWL /DXUHO\Q 1 HP RM SDGDWL QD WDNYD VUDQMD ² QD
]DYRGOMLYRNUHYHOMHQMHJODWNLJODVLMDP LFHQDEUDGL=QDP VYHWHIRUHLVYHMH
WRVUDQMHNRMLP WHSRNXãDYDRGYXüLXNUHYHW
=JUDELRVDP QDVORQH]DUXNHWDNRMDNRGDVDP LKVNRURSRWUJDRâWRDNR
VDP ]DNDVQLRLRQDMHYHüXYH]LVRYLP GUNDURãHP "7RMHP RJXüH1 HP D
UD]ORJDRGELMDWLJD2 QDQHP DSRMP DNROLNRMHYROLP LãWRVDP VYHSRGX]HR
GDELKMHSURQDãDR6LJXUQRP LVOLGDVDP YHüSUHãDRQDVOMHGHüX
7DGVDP VHVMHWLRåHQHNRMDMHVNRURSRVWDODEURMþHWUQDHVW5 DGRMHSRãOD
X KRWHOVNX VREX VD P QRP V SRWSXQLP VWUDQFHP QDNRQ QHNROLNR P LQXWD
UD]JRYRUD1 DP MHUDYDODP LMHGRSXVWLWLGDMXSRãHYLP MHUMRMþRYMHNNRMHJ
YROL QLMH X]YUDüDR OMXEDY 7ROLNR JD MH åDUNR åHOMHOD L]EDFLWL L] JODYH SD
P DNDULQDNUDWNR0 RåGDVDP MDEDãWDMX/DXUHO\QLQRMJODYL² WUHEDP H
L]EDFLWLL]JODYHLGRSXVWLWüHRYRP IUDMHUXGDMHSRãHYL
7 RMHORãH-DNRORãH
5 D]P LãOMDP GDXVWDQHP VDVMHGDODLNUHQHP SUHP DSR]RUQLFLWDNRGDP H
YLGLLVD]QDGDVDP GRãDRSRQMXäHOLP YLGMHWLQMH]LQXUHDNFLMX0 RUDP MRM
SRJOHGDWLXRþLLYLGMHWLMHVDP OLMRãXYLMHNWDMNRMHJYROL,OLMHWRVDGRYDM
IUDMHU
8 VWDRVDP QRQRJHVXP LVNDP HQMHQHQDP MHVWX1 HåHOHVOXãDWLQDUHGEH
NRMHLP ãDOMHP RMP R]DN3DP HWQLMHVXRGP RJVUFDLP R]JD]DMHGQR. ROLNR
JRGåHOLP GDRQDYLGLGDVDP WXQHP RJXVHSRP DNQXWLMHU]QDP GDELP H
RVLJXUDQMHRGP DKVSULMHþLOR
2 YDMNRMLMHMHEHSRJOHGRP XSUDYRMH]DYUãLRVYRMXSMHVP XL/DXUHO\QMH
]DP LMHQLODJLWDUXGUXJLP LQVWUXP HQWRP ² P RåGDP DQGROLQRP
1 LNDGDP LQLMHUHNODGD]QDVYLUDWLLãWDRVLP JLWDUHLNODYLUDSDVDP P DOR
OMXERP RUDQãWRRYLOLNRYL]QDMXVWYDULRQMRMNRMHMDQH]QDP
=DSRþHOL VX VOMHGHüX SMHVP X ]YDQX
7HOO 0 H : KDW , : DQW WR + HDU
)DQWDVWLþQR% DãP LMHWRWUHEDOR² QMLKGYRMHSMHYDMX]DMHGQR1 HP RJX
XþLQLWLQLãWDSDVDP VDP RVMHRLVP LULRVH
' RYUãLOLVXRVWDWDNUHSHUWRDUDLP RUDRVDP JOHGDWLRYRJWLSDNDNRRþLP D
ãHYL/DXUHO\QVNRURGYDVDWD% UXWDOQRMHNDGVHWRGRJDÿDLVSUHGWHEHDWL
QHP RåHãQLãWD/MXWVDP NDRSDVQRLP DP OLSUDYRLãWDUHüL"1 H]QDP DOL
SREULQXWüXVHGDVD]QDP
. DGMHGRãORYULMHP H]DSRVOMHGQMXSMHVP X/DXUHO\QMHVWDODQDVUHGLQX
SR]RUQLFH² JGMHMHWUHEDODELWLFLMHOXYHþHU² LSUHSR]QDRVDP SMHVP XNRMX
MHQMH]LQNROHJDVYLUDRQDNODYLMDWXUDP D
ª2 YX SMHVP X VDP QDSLVDOD NDG VP R QDMEROMD SULMDWHOMLFD L MD SXWRYDOH
L]YDQ]HP OMHQHNROLNRP MHVHFL,P DODVDP P QRJRYUHP HQDLP DOþLFHVDP VH
SRVYHWLODSLVDQMX=DSRþHODVDP GRNVP RMRãELOHWDP RQRGRYUãLODVDP MH
WHNSULMHP MHVHFGDQD=RYHVH
: LWKRXWD* RRGE\H
©
Čekam da se probudiš,
»Ne idi, draga«, da me zamoliš.
Moje srce strepi, zebe,
Spremno je preklinjati.
Ali riječi od tebe ne dolaze,
A tu bol ne nogu podnijeti.
Sad moram otići bez pozdrava,
Ti nikad nećeš znati da sam plakala,
Moram otići bez pozdrava,
Sama sa suzama u očima.
Odlučila sam i otišla,
Daljina nam se ispriječila,
Sad te nema, daleko si,
Lažem samoj sebi,
Jer znam da srce neću moći osloboditi.
Sad moram otići bez pozdrava,
Ti nikad nećeš znati da sam plakala,
Moram otići bez pozdrava Sama,
sa suzama u očima.
Odavno ti nisam dotaknula obraze,
Nedostaješ mi, a dani prolaze,
Gledam tvoje slike i pitam se
Je li bilo pogrešno ostaviti te.
3MHVP DMHSUHNUDVQDQRMDNRWXåQD5 LMHþLQDVVDYUãHQRRSLVXMXL]QDP
GDSMHYDRQDP D1 DGDP VHGDMHWDNRMHUVWLKRYLRSLVXMXSRJUHãNXNRMXMH
åHQDSRþLQLODRVWDYLYãLVYRJP XãNDUFDEH]SR]GUDYD0 RUDELWLGDVHUDGLR
QDP D
. RQFHUWMH]DYUãLRLOMXGLVXNUHQXOLYDQ-DVDP VDP RVMHGLR3RWUDMDORMH
GRNVHGYRUDQDQLMHVDVYLP LVSUD]QLOD,]YDGLRVDP UXåXQDGXJRMVWDEOMLFL
NRMXVDP VNULYDRXIXWUROLVJLWDURP . UHQXRVDP SURQDüLVYRMXYROMHQXV
UXåRP XMHGQRMUXFLLJLWDURP XGUXJRM1 DSHWLMLVDP RGVWUXQH² GLMHORP
]DWRãWRVDP JOHGDRRYRJMHEHQRJ' RQ-XDQDNDNRSRJOHGRP SURåGLUHP RMX
FXUX² DYLãH]ERJWRJDãWRüXQDSRNRQYLGMHWLåHQXNRMXYROLP VYLP VUFHP
. DGVDP VHVSXVWLRGRSUROD]DNRMLYRGLL]DVFHQH]DXVWDYLRP HMHGDQ
]DãWLWDUª1 LWNRQHVP LMHXQXWUDRVLP EHQGDLRVREOMD©
ª,P DP 3DLJHLQXGRGDWQXJLWDUX©SRGLJQXRVDP IXWUROXNDRGRND]
3UHNULåLRMHUXNHLQDSXKDRSUVDªäDRP LMH$ NRWRSULSDGDQHNRP HRG
P X]LþDUDRQGDQHNDNRVUHGLGDRQLWRGRELMX©
9 LGLP GD RYDM VQDJDWRU QH SDGD QD VODWNRUMHþLYRVW SD VDP L]YDGLR
QRYþDQLNLQDVWDYLRUD]JRYRUXGUXJRP VP MHUX,]YDGLRVDP GHVHWQRYþDQLFD
RGVWRWLQXGRODUDLVWDYLRLKLVSUHGQMHJRYHIDFH
ª7LVXüXGRODUDXJRWRYLQLMHWYRMHDNRP HSXVWLãL]DGDSUHGDP JRVSRÿLFL
0 F/DFKODQQMH]LQXJLWDUX©
2 þLVXP XVHUDVNRODþLOHLSRJOHGDRMHRNRVHEH-HGQLP SRNUHWRP MH
X]HRQRYDFL]UXNHª$ NRWHXORYHQHP RMUHüLGDVDP WHMDSXVWLR6KYDüDã"©
% LQJRª$ SVROXWQR©
2 WYRULRMHYUDWDLSRND]DRP LQL]KRGQLNª7UHEDODELELWLXERUDYNXGRN
RYLSDNLUDMXRSUHP X7 UHüDSURVWRULMDOLMHYR©
ª+ YDOD©
=DWYRULRMHYUDWD]DP QRP 0 DOþLFHVDP ]DVWDRLGXERNRXGDKQXR6UFH
P LMHOXSDORNDRGDåHOLSREMHüLLSURQDüLVYRMXGUXåLFX9 XþHP HNQMRMMHU
P XWUHEDGDELVHSRQRYQRRVMHWLORSRWSXQR
. UHQXR VDP QL] KRGQLN 3URãDR VDP SRUHG QHNLK OLNRYD QR YLGMHOL VX
JLWDUXLQLVXP HQLãWDSLWDOL=DVWDRVDP LVSUHGYUDWDMHUVDP VHXVUDRRG
VWUDKD
2 GãNULQXWDVXLYLGLP /DXUHO\QNDNRVMHGLQDNDXþX² DRQDMGUNDURã
SRUHGQMH6WDYLRMRMMHUXNXQDQRJXLSRODNRMHJODGL² EDãNDRãWRVDP MD
þLQLR QHEURMHQR SXWD 3URNOHWVWYR 2 Q MH GLUD L ãWR MH MRã JRUH RQD P X
GR]YROMDYD6ODP DP LVUFH6LJXUDQVDP GDVHVDGDORP LQDWLVXüHNRP DGLüD
GRNWXVWRMLP LJOHGDP RQRþHJDVDP VHQDMYLãHERMDR
=DWYRULR VDP RþL L SRQDGDR VH GD VDP VH SUHYDULR L GD VH P RM XP
SRLJUDYDVDP QRP . DGVDP LKSRQRYQRRWYRULRRQVHSULP LFDREOLåHGDMH
SROMXEL
2 NUHQXRVDP VH% LORP LMH]OR% LRVDP XQLãWHQLVORP OMHQ
ª+ HMâWRYLRYGMHUDGLWH"7 NRVWHYL"©ý XRVDP QHNRJDNDNRYLþH]D
P QRP LYLGLREXEQMDUD
3URJXWDRVDP MDXNHNRMLVXSULMHWLOLGDüHP LL]OHWMHWLL]XVWD-DVDP NULY
]DVYH=DEUOMDRVDP LVDGDWRSODüDP
3RGLJQXRVDP IXWUROXSUHP DQMHP Xª2 YRSULSDGDJRVSRÿLFL0 F/DFKODQ
0 RåHWHOLMRMWRGDWL",UXåXP ROLP YDV©
ª0 DUWLQLFD6XSHU©3ULP LRLKMHL]P RMLKUXNXLXSLWDRª7UHEDP OLMRM
QHãWRSRUXþLWL"©
Da. Recite joj koliko je volim i da mi je žao što sam pustio da ode.
ª6DP RMRMUHFLWHGDVDP XåLYDRXL]YHGELLGDMHELODMHEHQRIDQWDVWLþQD©
ªâWRüXUHüLRGNRJDVX©XSLWDRMHGUåHüLUXåXLIXWUROX
ª=QDWüHRQD©
7. poglavlje
2 YD GYRUDQD MH GUXJDþLMD RG RQH X NRMRM VX QDVWXSLOL SUHWKRGQH YHþHUL
,]JOHGDSRSXWVWDURJND]DOLãWDVDVMHGDOLP DSRVWDYOMHQLP XREOLNXSRWNRYHL
WHNP DORP MHVWD]DVWDMDQMHWLNLVSUHGSR]RUQLFH* RP LODVHEU]RSRYHüDYDOD
SDVDP RGDEUDRVMHGDORXUHGXQDMEOLåHP SR]RUQLFLWDNRGDP RJXJOHGDWL
QDVWXSEH]ERUEHVJRP LORP
9 ULMHP HMH]DSRþHWDNNRQFHUWDL]ELOMDVDP L]QHQDÿHQEURMHP OMXGLNRML
VXGRãOLþXWLEHQG6RXWKHUQ2 SKHOLDý HNDMXGDþXMXP RMXGMHYRMNXLWHNP L
MHWDGDVLQXORNROLNRVHEU]RYLQXODGRYUKD1 LMHGDüHWHNSRVWDWL]YLMH]GD
RQDWRYHüMHVW
1 LVDP VLJXUDQ ãWR WR ]QDþL ]D P HQH 6LJXUDQ VDP GD EL MRM ELOR ODNãH
QDSXVWLWLVYHLYUDWLWLVHVDP QRP X$ XVWUDOLMXNDGMHNRGNXüHQLMHþHNDOR
QLãWDDOLVDGDYLãHQLMHWDNR,P DVYHRYR² EHQGNRMLRYLVLRQMRMLNDULMHUX
VSXQRRERåDYDWHOMD
* OHGDR VDP JRP LOX QD SDUNHWX GRN MH /DXUHO\Q SMHYDOD VD VYRMLP
EHQGRP LQHãWRP LMHSRVWDORNULVWDOQRMDVQRRYRMHVDP RP DOLGLRVODYH
NRMDMHþHNDXEXGXüQRVWLLSUHVWUDYOMHQVDP ]ERJWRJD3UHVWUDYOMHQVDP GD
üHMRMVHVYLGMHWLEOMHãWDYLORLJODP XURYRJåLYRWDLGDüHJDRGDEUDWLXP MHVWR
P HQHäHOLP GD/DXUHO\QGRELMHVDYXVSMHKNRML]DVOXåXMHMHUMHYROLP QRQH
QDXãWUEQDãHJ]DMHGQLþNRJåLYRWD=DWRüXMRMWLMHNRP VOMHGHüLKP MHVHFGDQD
P RUDWLGRND]DWLGDWUHEDRGDEUDWLQDVDQHRYR$ NRVDP ]ERJWRJDVHELþQL
NXUYLQVLQQHNDVDP 0 RJXåLYMHWLVWRP VSR]QDMRP DNRMHRQDX]P HQHDQH
WLVXüDP DNLORP HWDUDGDOHNR
ý LQL VH GD MH & KDUOLH RGXVWDMDR RG /DXUHO\Q MHU MH YHþHUDV QLMH ãHYLR
RþLP DGRNVXSMHYDOL5 HNDRELKGDMHVKYDWLRSRUXNX1 RQHP RJXJDNULYLWL
ãWRMHSRNXãDR/DXUHO\QMHVWYDUQRVMDMQDFXUD
. DGVXRGVYLUDOLSMHVP X]DNRMXVDP P LVOLRGDMHSRVOMHGQMDGHþNLVX
QDSXVWLOL SR]RUQLFX D /DXUHO\Q MH VMHOD QD YLVRNL VWRODF LVSRG VYMHGD
UHIOHNWRUD1 DP LJQXODP LMHGRNMHXãWLP DYDODVYRMX0 DUWLQLFXLQDJQXODVH
QDGP LNURIRQª1 DSLVDODVDP RYXSMHVP XXMHGQRP P UDþQRP UD]GREOMXVYRJ
åLYRWD8 SUDYRVDP VHELODUDVWDODVP XãNDUFHP NRMHJYROLP LERMDODVDP VH
GDVHYLãHQLNDGDQHüHP RYLGMHWL* RYRULRVWYDULP DNRMHELKP XUHNODDNR
P LVHLNDGDYUDWL6UHüRP YUDWLRVHLRYDSMHVP DLGHQMHP X=RYHVH
/RYHG
E\< RX
©
Sudbina nas je spojila,
Nas, dva stranca potpuna
Obrušio si se na mene,
Poput plime, i izvukao me
Iz toplog zagrljaja obale.
Tad nisam znala što hoću,
No željela sam sve.
Sad želim samo tebe,
I da me trebaš ti,
Moje srce se nada samo
Da ćeš ga uvijek voljeti.
U nemirnim sam se vodama
Bez straha s tobom utapala,
Kad je oluja utihnula,
Moja ljubav je narasla.
Sad kad me puštaš da odem,
Sve mi je teže sakriti
Ovu bol koja prijeti
Da će kad-tad van prodrijeti.
Dok brojim dane do rastanka
I pitam se kako ću sama,
Srce mi plače i jeca
Jer ti si u svim mojim pjesmama.
/DXUHO\QMH]DYUãLODSMHVP XLXVQLFDP DREOLNRYDODULMHþLª9ROLP WH©SULMH
QRãWRMHSRVODODSXVXXP RP VP MHUX=QDP GDMHGMHWLQMDVWRDOLSRVHJQXR
VDP QDSULMHGNDRGDMHORYLP LSULVORQLRMHQDVYRMDXVWD,]JOHGDP SRSXW
SLþNLFHQRãWRGDNDåHP "6YLþLQHJOXSRVWL]ERJOMXEDYLLKYDWDQMHSROMXSFD
X]UDNXGHILQLWLYQRVSDGDXWXNDWHJRULMX
ªý RYMHþHMHOLWRRQDWHELXSUDYRSRVODODSXVX"©
6MHGLRVDP GRRYRJWLSDFLMHOLNRQFHUWLQLVDP JDQLSRJOHGDRGRVDGD
ª-HVW$ VDGDLGHP SRSUDYX©
9 LGLP GDMHL]QHQDÿHQLWRP LVDP RSRYHüDYDRQDMGRMDP GDMH/DXUHO\Q
]DQMLKYHOLND]YLMH]GD
ª Wow. 3MHYDþLFD L] 6RXWKHUQ 2 SKHOLMH MH WYRMD FXUD" 7R MH VLJXUQR
]DNRQ©
CuraQLMHSUDYDULMHþ]DRQRãWRP LRQDSUHGVWDYOMDª2 QDP LMHP QRJR
YLãHQHJRFXUD©
ª6XSHU5 HFLMRMGDMHNRQFHUWELRRGOLþDQ©
2 WLãDRVDP QDP MHVWRJGMHP LMHUHNODGDüHP RVHSRVOLMHQDüLDRQDP H
WDP RYHüþHNDOD3ULYXNDRVDP MHNVHELLSROMXELRXREUD]ª' XãRVYDNLþDV
P HVYHYLãH]DGLYOMXMHã©
ª-HOLWLVHVYLGMHOR"©
9 MHURMDWQRMHP LVOLODQDSMHVP XNRMXP LMHRWSMHYDODª6YLGMHOR"% LORP L
MHRGOLþQR©
ª=QDãGDVDP MHQDSLVDOD]DWHEH6YDNDULMHþMHLVWLQLWD©
ª=QDP -DMHGQDNRRVMHüDP SUHP DWHEL9 UDWLP RVHVDGDXVREXGDWL
SRNDåHP NROLNR©
9 LGLP QDQMH]LQRP OLFXGDWRQHüHLüLª% HQGVHXYLMHNVDVWDQHQDNRQ
NRQFHUWD GD UDVSUDYLP R R HYHQWXDOQLP SURSXVWLP D 0 RUDP RWLüL X
& KDUOLHMHYXVREX1 LNDGDQHWUDMHGXOMHRGSHWQDHVWP LQXWD+ RüHãOLSRüLVD
P QRP "äHOLP GDXSR]QDãGHþNH©
1 HP DãDQVHQHåHOLP LüLX& KDUOLHMHYXVREXQRQHåHOLP QLGD/DXUHO\Q
LGHEH]P HQHª0 RåHDNRWLWDNRåHOLã©
2 VMHWLRVDP NDNRP LWHVWRVWHURQGLYOMDGRNVP RVHSULEOLåDYDOLVRELX
NRMRMüXXSR]QDWLOLNRYHNRMLVXXSURWHNODWULP MHVHFDELOLQDMEOLåL/DXUHO\Q
6SR]QDMD GD VH MHGDQ RG QMLK ]DQLP D ]D QMX QLP DOR QH SRP DåH P RMLP
QDJRQLP DãSLOMVNRJþRYMHNDGDVHVP LUH0 RUDWüXVHSREULQXWLGDRQ]QDGD
MHP RMDLGDQLMH]DQMHJD
/DXUHO\Q VH ]DXVWDYLOD LVSUHG VREH L SULP LOD P H GODQRYLP D ]D OLFH
ª1 DSHWVLDOLQHELWUHEDRELWL2 YLIUDMHULVXP LSRSXWEUDüH©
0 LVOLP GDMH]DERUDYLODGDLP DP VHVWUXLGDP LQLNDGDQLMHSDORQDSDP HW
SROMXELWLMHRQDNRNDNRMH& KDUOLHVLQRüSROMXELR/DXUHO\Qª1 DSHWVDP VDP R
]ERJMHGQRJRGQMLKLYLGLRVDP NDNRWHOMXEL©
0 D]LODP HSRREUD]LP DLEUDGLª0 RUDWüHãSUHVWDWLP LVOLWLQDWR©
/DNãHMHUHüLQHJRXþLQLWLª1 DVGYRMLFDüHP RVHVDVYLP GREURVODJDWL
VDP RQHNDRGXVWDQHRGWHEH©
ª9 HüMHRGXVWDRSDQHüHELWLSUREOHP D-HOLWDNR"©
5 XNDP DP LMHSRP LFDODJODYXWDP RDP Rª5 HFL
1 H/DXUHO\QQHüHELWL
SUREOHP DV& KDUOLHMHP
©
3RQRYLR VDP NDNR MH UHNOD 6SXVWLOD MH UXNH V P RJ OLFD L GRGDR VDP
ª' RNOHJRGGUåLãDSHSRGDOMHRGWHEH©
3UHYUQXODMHRþLP DLRGP DKQXODJODYRP ª+ DMGH=DYUãLP RYHüMHGQRP V
WLP SDGDYLGLãNDNRSULMHWQMDQHSRVWRML©
ý ODQRYLEHQGDVXVMHGLOLLUD]JRYDUDOLNDGVP RXãOLX& KDUOLHMHYXVREX
QRVYLVXXãXWMHOLNDGVXYLGMHOLGDVDP MDV/DXUHO\Qª+ HMVYLP D2 YRMH
-DFNLGRYHODVDP JDGDYDVXSR]QDMHUüHWHVHGRVWDYLÿDWLQDUHGQLKQHNROLNR
WMHGDQD©
1 MLKRYLP HQDGåHU5 DQG\VHSUYLSUHGVWDYLR=DWLP VXGRãOL3-L5\DQ
& KDUOLHMHRVWDRSRVOMHGQML,VSUYDVDP P LVOLRGDMHWR]DWRãWRP HRGP MHUDYD
QRNDGMHXVWDRLSUXåLRUXNXQLVDP RVMHWLRQLNDNYRNRQIOLNWQRUDVSRORåHQMH
ª/DXUHO\QP LMHSXQRSULþDODRWHELLOLMHSRWHMHQDSRNRQXSR]QDWL©
' DVDP KWLRELWLãXSDNP RJDRVDP GUXJDþLMHSURWXP DþLWLQMHJRYHULMHþL
² NDRGDMHKWLRUHüLGDP XVH/DXUHO\QSRYMHUDYDODLOLGDP HMHnapokon
OLMHSRXSR]QDWLMHUQLVDP ELRX]QMX0 LVOLP GDQLMHWDNR* OHGDP HXRþL
SRVWXSDP XãNLLQLMHQLP DORQDOLNQD% HQD
ª0 HQLMHWDNRÿHUGUDJRVWDUL©
ª1 DãDFXUDVHLVND]DODYHþHUDV]DUQH"©
,]QHQDÿHQMH² QLVDP VHQLP DORXYULMHGLRNDGMH& KDUOLHQD]YDR/DXUHO\Q
našom curom,NDRGDMHGMHORP LþQRLQMHJRYD' DMXMH% HQWDNRQD]YDR
SROXGLRELKª' DSRSULOLþQRMHQHYMHURMDWQD©
9 ULMHP HMHEU]RSURãORLRVWDOLVP RP QRJRGXOMHRGSHWQDHVWP LQXWD1 LMH
P LVP HWDORMHUVXVYLIUDMHULLVSDOLVNUR]cool.0 LVOLRVDP GDüXMHGYDþHNDWL
GD RGHP R QR QDSRVOMHWNX MH /DXUHO\Q P RUDOD SRåXULYDWL P HQH MHU MH ELOR
NDVQRLELODMHXP RUQD
7HNNDGVP RRWLãOLVKYDWLRVDP GDMH/DXUHO\QLQDVREDQDãDVREDRGP DK
SRUHG & KDUOLHMHYH 0 RUDP SUL]QDWL GD P L MH WR LSDN ]DVP HWDOR 3URãOD MH
NDUWLFRP NUR]EUDYXGDQDP RWYRUL
ª2 YRMHSRVOMHGQMLSXWGDP LERUDYLP RXVRELGRQHNRJDRGQMLK©
8 OD]LOLVP RXVREXNDGMHUHNODª8 YLMHNQDVVWDYOMDMX]DMHGQR=DãWRWL
VP HWD"3DQLVP RXLVWRMVREL©
9 UDWDVXVH]DWYRULOD]DQDP DLVNXSLRVDP MHXQDUXþMHGDMHRGQHVHP QD
NUHYHW1 MHåQRVDP MHEDFLRQDP DGUDFNDRLJUDþNLFXª=DWRãWRVHWLLMDQH
MHEHP RWLKRLQMHåQRQHJRMDNRLVQDåQR©
ª,QHåHOLãP HRVUDP RWLWLWDNRãWRüHQDVRQLþXWL"©
1 LVDP EDãP LVOLRQDVUDP RüHQMHª5 HFLP RWRRYDNRQHåHOLP GDLWNRRG
QMLKGUNDQD]YXNRYHQDVGYRMHGRNVHMHEHP RXVRELSRUHG©
1 DP UHãNDODMHQRVª)XM©
ª8 SUDYRWDNR$ NRLNDGDþXMXWYRMH]YXNRYHQHP DãDQVHGDüHWHJOHGDWL
DGDQH]DP LãOMDMXãWRVLUDGLODGRNVLLKLVSXãWDOD9 MHUXMP LNDGWLNDåHP GD
MHEROMHGDQDP VREHQLVXWDNREOL]X©
' RN VDP YDGLR NRãXOMX L] KODþD L SRVH]DR ]D JRUQMLP JXP ERP GD MH
VYXþHP /DXUHO\QMHL]YDGLODP RELWHOL]VYRMHWRUELFHªý HNDMLP DP LGHMX
7UHEDP LSUDYDJOD]ED]DWR©=DSRþHODMHQHNDSMHVP DLRQDVHYUDJRODVWR
QDVP LMHãLODª
$ GGLFWHG
RGEHQGD6DYLQJ$ EHOMHVDYUãHQD]DRQRãWRüHã
VDGDXþLQLWL]DP HQH©
ª$ ãWRüXXþLQLWL"©
1 DVORQLODVHQDX]JODYOMHª,]YHVWüHãVWULSWL]]DP HQH©7RMHQRYRVWª-D
üXL]YHVWLVWULSWL]"©
ª' DEDãWL-DVDP WRXþLQLOD]DWHEHNDGJRGVLWUDåLR² LP QRJRSXWD
NDGDQLVL6DGDMDWUDåLP DWLUDGLã©
3RSULOLþQR VDP VLJXUDQ GD QH VP LMHP RGELWL DNR MX LNDGD YLãH åHOLP
YLGMHWLNDNRSOHãHSDVDP VHSRþHRNUHWDWLXULWP XLRWNRSþDYDWLJXP EHQD
NRãXOMLª% ROMHWLMHGDSULSUHP LãQRYþDQLFH]DP HQHP DOD©
13.poglavlje
1 LVDP P LVOLOD GD üH SULVWDWL SOHVDWL ]D P HQH ² EDUHP QH EH] UDVSUDYH
,]QHQDGLODVDP VHãWRMHWDNRODNRSULVWDR² P RåGDLP DOþLFHSUHODNR² DOL
QLMHP HEULJD7 DNRMHVHNVLGRNSOHãH
2 NUHQXR P L MH OHÿD L JOHGDOD VDP NDNR VH VDYUãHQR NUHüH X] JOD]EX
P LJROML VH YDQ L] NRãXOMH L EDFD MH SUHNR UDP HQD =DYUãLOD MH QD P RMLP
QRJDP DLSULQLMHODVDP MHQRVX0 LULãLVODVQREDãSRSXWQMHJD6WDYLRMHUXNH
L]D YUDWD L L]EDFLYDR NXNRYH X ULWP X 6MHGLP P X L]D OHGD L YLGLP VDP R
SRNUHWHQMHJRYHSUHNUDVQHVWUDåQMLFHL]DP LãOMDP GDVHXSUDYRWDNRNUHüH
GRNVH]DELMDXP HQH
2 NUHQXRVHSUHP DP HQLLVWDYLRGODQRYHQDSUVD. OL]LRMHUXNDP DSUHP D
GROMHLYUWLRERNRYLP DX]JOD]EX. DGMHVSXVWLRGODQRYHQDSUHSRQHSULP LR
MHUXEKODþDLNRULVWLRJDNDR]LGX]NRMHJVHWUOMDR
ª8 KWRP LVHVYLÿD©
1 DVP LMDRVHLUHNDRª6YLÿDWüHWLVHMRãYLãHNDGWREXGHP UDGLRL]P HÿX
WYRMLKQRJX©
1 MHJRYR REHüDQMH MH RGDVODOR YDO X]DYUHOH åXGQMH EDã NUR] P RM
VSRP HQXWL GLR ª* UL]L VH ]D XVQLFX GRN WR UDGLã© 6DP RGRSDGQR VH
RVP MHKQXRQRSRVOXãDRP Hª0 P P MDNRVLVHNVLDOLYULMHP HMHGDP DNQHã
WHKODþH3UHYLãHVLRGMHYHQ]DVWULSHUD©
ª' DJRVSRÿR©UHNDRMHª6YH]DYDV©
6XWQXRMHFLSHOHVDVWRSDODLVYXNDRWUDSHULFHDOLQHLERNVHULFH2 YRMH
YDOMGDSUYLSXWGDJDYLGLP NDNRLKVYODþLMHGQRSRMHGQR1 RVDGDP HVDP R
L]D]LYDLL]OXÿXMHLWRP XMDNRGREURLGH
. DGMHRVWDRVDP RXERNVHULFDP DYLGLP GDMHMDNRQDSDOMHQ3ULP LMHWLRMH
P RMSRJOHGLSRODNRNOL]QXRERNVHULFDP DSUHNRVYRMHHUHNFLMHSULMHQHJRLK
MH ãXWQXR QD SRG 3RQRYQR MH VWDYLR UXNH L]D YUDWD L NUXåLR ERNRYLP D X]
JOD]EXJUL]XüLVH]DXVQLFXª0 LVOLP GDVLVDGDWLSUHYLãHRGMHYHQD©
ª$ MDP LVOLP GDVLXSUDYX©VORåLODVDP VH. OHNQXODVDP QDNROMHQDL
SRYXNOD KDOMLQX SUHNR JODYH 2 VWDOD VDP VDP R X þLSNDVWRP UXåLþDVWRP
JUXGQMDNXLJDüLFDP Dª% ROMH"©
ª8 VNRURüHELWL©
2 WNRSþDOD VDP JUXGQMDN 3XVWLOD VDP QHND P L WUDNLFH SDGQX SUHNR
UDP HQDQRNRãDULFHVDP GUåDODQDP MHVWX9 LGMHODVDP NDNRP XVHRþLåDUH
GRN þHND GD YLGL RVWDWDN 3UDWLR MH VYDNL P RM SRNUHW GRN QDSRNRQ QLVDP
RVORERGLODJUXGLL]NORSNH
ª-HVDP OL WL LNDGD UHNDR GD LP Dã SUHNUDVQH JUXGL"© 2 GP DKQXOD VDP
JODYRP LRWSX]DODQDUXENUHYHWDª1 LVL©
3ULP LRLKMHXUXNHþLP VDP P XVHGRYROMQRSULEOLåLOD3DOþHYLP DP LMH
JODGLREUDGDYLFH
ª6DYUãHQHVXQDVYHP RJXüHQDþLQH7 LVLVDVYLP VDYUãHQD©
3ULYXNDRP HEOLåHLOMXELRL]P HÿXYUDWDLUDP HQDª1 LVDP VDYUãHQD©
6SXVWLRMHXVWDQLåHLWDP DQKWLRSULP LWLP RMXEUDGDYLFXQRSRGLJQXRMH
SRJOHGSUHP DP RP H
ª0 HQLMHVL©
3UROD]LODVDP SUVWLP DNUR]QMHJRYXNRVXLRVMHüDODNDNRP XMH]LNUDGL
NUXJRYH RNR P RMH EUDGDYLFH ' UXJRP UXNRP P L MH JODGLR GUXJX GRMNX L
SDOFHP SUDWLR SRNUHWH MH]LND 1 DJQXOD VDP JODYX XQDWUDJ L ]DVWHQMDOD
SULEOLåDYDMXüLVHQMHJRYLP XVQLFDP D
6SXVWLRMHUXNHVP RMLKJUXGLQDERNRYHLVYXNDRP LJDüLFH3RGLJQXOD
VDP SUYRMHGQRSDRQGDGUXJRNROMHQRLGR]YROLODP XGDLKSRYXþHSUHNR
P RMLKJOHåQMHYDLEDFLQDSRG=DJUOLODVDP JDRNRUDP HQDLSRGLJQXRP HV
NUHYHWD2 EDYLODVDP QRJHRNRQMHJDQRRQP HVSXVWLRQDWUDJQDNUHYHW
VWDYLRP LQRJHQDVYRMDUDP HQDSULP LR]DNXNRYHLSRYXNDRLKQDSULMHGVYH
GRNP XOLFHQLMHGRãORL]P HÿXP RMLKQRJX=QDP ãWRüHP LUDGLWLQRQLNDGD
MRãQLMHRYDNR-HGYDþHNDP GDYLGLP NDNRüHLüL3RORåLRMHGODQQDP RM
WUEXK 2 VMHWLOD VDP QMHJRY WRSOL GDK L]P HÿX QRJX 8 ]GUKWDOD VDP RG
LãþHNLYDQMDª1 HWNR]QDãWRMHþHNDLP LVOLP GDMHP DORQHVWUSOMLYD©
1 HVWUSOMLYDMHSUHVODEDULMHþ% ROMHMHUHüLGDVDP ELODRþDMQDª9 ULãWDWüX
DNRVDGDQHVSXVWLãMH]LNQDP HQH©
ª9 ULãWDWüHãDNRJDQHVSXVWLP NDåHã$ MDNDåHP GDüHãYULãWDWLDNRJD
VSXVWLP ©L]D]LYDRP H1 LMHP HSUHVWDMDRJOHGDWLXRþLGRNMHMH]LNRP SRODNR
SUHOD]LR SUHNR P RJ VUHGLãWD 2 EOL]DR MH XVQLFH L UHNDR ª8 YLMHN VL WDNR
VODWND2 ERåDYDP RNXVãHüHUDLVSRGWYRJDVWUXND©
-RMXKYDWLORJDMHEH]REUD]QRUDVSRORåHQMH7R]QDþLGDüXVYUãLWLMRã
EUåH
ª7 UHEDWLQHãWRGDP DOþLFH]DVODGLãWDVYRMDSUOMDYDXVWD©
ª$ OLWLYROLãP RMDYXOJDUQDXVWD² SRJRWRYRNDGDUDGHRYR©3ULWLVQXRMH
XVQLFHX]P HQHLRVMHWLODVDP SRYODþHQMHEDãRQGMHJGMHP LMHQDMYLãHWUHEDOR
0 DORMHVLVDRP DOROL]DRLRVWDYOMDRP LYDORYHERåDQVNRJXåLWND6YDNRJP H
MHSXWDVNRURGRYHRGRUXEDQRQHNDNRELRVMHWLRGDVDP WXLYUDWLRP H
QDWUDJ2 VMHüDODVDP VHNDRXVUHGHXIRULþQHLJUHSRYODþHQMDNRQRSDLQLNDG
XåLYRWXQLVDP RVMHWLODQHãWRWDNRX]EXGOMLYRDXMHGQRLIUXVWULUDMXüHMHUP L
QLMHGR]YROMDYDRGDVYUãLP
ª$ KKDKKWRP LQDP MHUQRUDGLã©
ªâWR WL QDP MHUQR UDGLP "© 5 HNDR MH WR SRSXW QHYLQDãFD NDR GD QHP D
SRMP DãWRP LUDGL
ª=QDã WL ãWR P L UDGLã 1 H GDã P L GD VYUãLP © 3RJOHGDR P H MH X RþL
ª6SUHP QDVL]DWR"©
ª-HVDP ©SURãDSWDODVDP % LODVDP GRLVWDRþDMQDª2 QGDP LUHFL² NDR
MHGQDSUOMDYDXVWDGUXJLP D² UHFLP LãWRåHOLãGDWLUDGLP LMDüXWRXUDGLWL©
' UåDR MH P RM RUJD]DP X ]DUREOMHQLãWYX WDNR GD EL GRELR RQR ãWR åHOL
ª9ROLã VOXãDWL NDNR JRYRULP EH]REUDãWLQH ]DU QH" 7R WH QDSDOMXMH MH OL
WDNR"©
ª' D RERåDYDP WR 1 DMYLãH SROXGLP NDG P L JRYRULã ãWR åHOLã GD WL
UDGLP ©
' REUR% LRMHLVNUHQSUHP DP HQLLWUHEDODELKP XXGRYROMLWL2 QWRYROLL
åHOLP GDEXGH]DGRYROMDQ,MDüXELWL]DGRYROMHQDNDGP XNDåHP ãWRåHOLP
SDVDP VSXVWLODUXNXL]P HÿXVYRMLKQRJXLGRWDNQXODVHªäHOLP GDP HVLãHã
EDãRYGMHGRNQHSRþQHP YULãWDWLRGVYUãDYDQMD©
ª7 RMHELORVXSHUGUDJD3ULSUHP LVH]DUDVWXUDQMH©
3ULP LODVDP JD]DNRVXLJXUQXODP XJODYXGROMHª2 QGDP HMHELXVWLP DL
QHP RMSUHVWDWLGRNQHSRþQHP YULãWDWL©
1 HP RJXYMHURYDWLGDVDP WRUHNOD6YHGRNQLMHVSXVWLRXVWDQDP HQHL
]DSRþHRª2 KRKRKWRMHSUHGREURDOLGDMP HLSUVWLP DäHOLP RVMHWLWLL
L]QXWUDLL]YDQD©-HGDQD]DWLP GYDSUVWDSRþHODVXNOL]LWLXQXWUDYDQL]
P HQH 6LãH P H WDNR MDNR GD üH P L QD åHQVNLP GLMHORYLP D RVWDWL OMXEDYQL
XJUL]7DNRVDP EOL]XRUJD]P DLP LVOLP GDVXP LRþL]DãOHXVWUDåQMLGLR
JODYH3ULP LODVDP JD]DNRVXLP DOþLFHSRYXNODª8 KDKSURNOHWVWYR©
YULãWDODVDP GRNP HVLVDRSRSXWXVLVDYDþD
& LMHORWLMHORP LVHQDSHOR2 VMHWLODVDP GUKWDMHL]QXWUD. DNRVXP LVDP R
QHGRVWDMDOLWLGUKWDML1 LãWDVHQHP RåHXVSRUHGLWLVQMLP D9 MHUXMWHLVNXãDOD
VDP LVDP DVDVRERP
2 SXVWLOD VDP VYRMH ]JUþHQH P LãLüH L P DNQXOD QRJH V -DFN + HQU\MHYLK
UDP HQDª0 DODVYLQDRYRP LGRQMHP NDWXVXWHþXOLNDNRVYUãDYDã©
ª3UHYLãHP LMHGREURGDELKVHEULQXOD]ERJWRJD©UHNODVDP LP DNQXODVH
VUXEDNUHYHWD3ULP LODVDP JDRNRYUDWDGDSRÿHVDP QRP QHåHOLP ELWLQL
VHNXQGXEH]QMHJDWLNX]DVHEH
3DRMHSUHNRP HQHNDGDVDP VHQDJQXODQDOHGDª2 SURVWL©LVSULþDRVH
NDGVDP JDSULP LOD]DJX]XLVWLVQXODX]DVHEHªâWRMHXãORXWHEH"©
7UOMDOD VDP VYRMH LQWLP QH åHQVNH GLMHORYH R QMHJRYH QH EDã åHQVNH
ª1 DGDP VHGDüHãWLXüLXP HQH©
ª$ NRQHEXGHãSD]LODSRP LVOLWüXGDVLMHGQDSULNULYHQDEH]REUD]QLFD©
ª0 RåGDLMHVWWDNRDVDGDWLVHVDP RRWNULYDP ©2 EDYLODVDP GODQRNR
QMHJRYHHUHNFLMHLSRYODþLODJDJRUHGROMHNUR]VYRMXYODåQRVWGDJDQDP DP LP
XQXWUDª+ DMGH-DFN+ HQU\-HELP H0 ROLP WH©
-XUQXRMHXP HQHEH]LNDNYRJXSR]RUHQMDLGDKQXODVDP ]ERJL]QHQDGQRJ
XSDGDQMDäHOMHODVDP JDXQXWDUVHEHLXKYDWLODQMHJRYULWDP 2 EDYLODVDP
P XQRJHRNRVWUXNDLRKUDEULYDODJDGDP HQDELMDMRãåHãüHª9HþHUDVVL
QH]DVLWQD© UHNDR MH WU]QXYãL VH YDQ L] P HQH 3ULP LR P H ]D JOHåQMHYH L
SRYXNDRGRP MHVWDJGMHMHVWDMDRQDSRGXª7RQLMHELORGREURQLMHGQRP HRG
QDVGYRMH2 NUHQLVHVDGDGDWHP RJXSRMHEDWLNDNRWUHED©
6LãODVDP VNUHYHWDLVWDODQDYUKRYHSUVWLMX]DELYãLJODYXXMDVWXNMHU
VDP ]QDODGDüXXVNRURSRQRYQRYULãWDWL3ULP LRP H]DERNRYHLVWLVQXRWH
SRYXNDRQDWUDJLQDWDNQXRQDVYRMNXUDF6WDMDODVDP QDVDP LP YUKRYLP D
SUVWLMX]ERJQDãHUD]OLNHXYLVLQLª7 DNREDãWX% DãWDNR©
* UL]OD VDP MDVWXN GRN VH RQ VYH MDþH ]DELMDR X P HQH QR LSDN VDP
SUHSR]QDODNDGMHELREOL]XNUDMD' REURVDP XSR]QDODQMHJRYRWLMHORL]QDOD
VDP GDXYLMHNSULNUDMXXVSRULMHUåHOLSURGXOMLWLXåLWDN1 RRUJD]DP XYLMHN
SRELMHGL² NDRLVDGD² NDGVHVQDåQR]DELMHXP HQHLYLNQHP RMHLP H
2 ERåDYDP ]YXNVYRJLP HQDNUR]QMHJRYHVWLVQXWH]XEH
ª1 HP DãSRMP DNROLNRVLP LVHNVLNDGVLWDNRQDJQXWDDP RMNXUDFMHMRã
XYLMHNXWHEL©
ª2 GOXþLODVDP GDüXVLQDGQXOHÿDLVWHWRYLUDWL
6UHWQLN
©
,]YXNDR JD MH YDQ L QDJQXR VH GD P L SROMXEL OHÿD ª1 HüHã VH RYGMH
WHWRYLUDWL0 HQLELWRVYHSRNYDULOR©
=QDP GDYROLGQRP RMLKOHÿDQR]DUELP XWLQWDGRLVWDVYHSRNYDULOD"
ª6WYDUQR"©
ª2 ]ELOMQRWLNDåHP ©* ODVP XMHVWURJª1 HP RMVHQLEDYLWLWRP LGHMRP
LOLüXVHSUHWYRULWLXãSLOMVNRJþRYMHND©
ª0 LVOLODVDP GDVLWRXSUDYRXþLQLR©
ª* RYRULP WLRGUXJRMYUVWLãSLOMVNRJþRYMHNDGXãR©3URWUOMDRMHUXNRP
SUHNRMDP LFHQDP RMLP OHÿLP DNRMXMHXSUDYRSROMXELRª1 HELWLVHVYLGLR©
ý XMHP R]ELOMQRVWXQMHJRYLP ULMHþLP D' RJRGLORVHMHGQRP LOLGYDSXWGD
P L MH -DFN + HQU\ SRND]DR þXGRYLãWH X VHEL 1 LMH P H VH GRMP LOR L QH
QDP MHUDYDP JDL]D]LYDWL
14.poglavlje
3URãORMHQHNROLNRGDQDRGQDãHJLQFLGHQWQRJEUDþQRJUD]JRYRUDX9 HJDVX
* RYRULP incidentnogMHUWR]DSUDYRQLMHELRUD]JRYRUQHJRP RMHSLMDQH
WODSQMHRåHQLGELLGMHFLV/DXUHO\Q
1 LP DOR JDODQWQR V WYRMH VWUDQH -DFN 1 LMHGQD åHQD QH åHOL SLMDQX
SURVLGEX 0 RUDP VP LVOLWL EROML QDþLQ ² QHãWR URP DQWLþQR ãWR üH MRM ELWL
SUHNUDVQRLãWRüHJRGLQDP DSUHSULþDYDWLQDãRMGMHFL
1 RSURVLGEDMHVXYLãQDDNRMHQHXVSLMHP XYMHULWLGDRVWDYLRYDMåLYRW
NRMLLRQDNRSURYRGLXDXWREXVXVEHQGRP QDVWXSDMXüLVYDNXQRüXGUXJRP H
JUDGX7RQLMHåLYRW]DQMX2 QDELWUHEDODELWLVDP QRP WDNRGDMRMP RJXGDWL
RELWHOMNRMX]DVOXåXMH
' DQDVVDP NXSLR]DUXþQLþNLSUVWHQ]D/DXUHO\Q0 LVOLRVDP GDüHELWL
WHãNR² P RåGDüHP LSRQHVWDWLGDKDLOLüXVHRQHVYLMHVWLWL² QR]DSUDYRMH
ELORODNR9DOMGDMHXYLMHNODNRNDG]QDãGDVLXSUDYX1 LP DORQHVXP QMDP
GDVDP VDYUãHQRRGDEUDR
1 RQHüH]QDþLWLQLãWDDNRQHVP LVOLP SODQ]DVDYUãHQXSURVLGEX' DQDV
QHP DP WDNDYSODQ1 HüXJDLP DWLQLVXWUDQLWMHGDQGDQDNDVQLMH
6DG LP DP R MRã VDP R RVDP ]DMHGQLþNLK GDQD 9 ULMHP H OHWL L P RUDW üX
XEU]RVP LVOLWLQHãWR6XERWDMHQDYHþHULQDP MHUDYDP MHL]YHVWLQDYHþHUXX
MHGDQRGQDMEROMLKUHVWRUDQDX1 DVKYLOOHX² EDUHP VXP LUHNOLGDMHRGOLþDQ
-DSRMP DQHP DP MHURYGMHQLVDP VYRMQDVYRP H1 HELKMHWDNR]DSURVLRGD
VP R NRG NXüH 2 GYHR ELK MH X 1 RYL =HODQG X NXüX QD SODåL XNUDãHQX
FYLMHüHP L VYLMHüDP D 1 DNRQ WRJD ELVP R YRGLOL OMXEDY X QDãRM RP LOMHQRM
VSDYDRQLFLREDYLMHQLEDOGDKLQRP NRMLQDVVDNULYDRGRVWDWNDVYLMHWD
1 LVDP RþHNLYDRGDüXELWLQHUYR]DQQRMHVDP 2 YDMSUVWHQNRMLQRVLP X
GåHSX YHü FLMHOL WMHGDQ P DOþLFH P L MH SROMXOMDR VDP RSRX]GDQMH % RMLP VH
VYHJD² ERMLP VHGDüHP HRGELWLGDüHRGDEUDWLåLYRWVEHQGRP GDQHüH
KWMHWLRVWDYLWLSRUHP HüHQXP DMNXLRFD0 RåGDMHP RMDVXP QMDQHãWRVDVYLP
SULURGQR QHãWR ãWR VYL IUDMHUL SUROD]H NDGD VH VSUHP DMX SRVWDYLWL YHOLNR
SLWDQMH
1 D]YDRVDP LWUDåLRSRVHEDQVWRO]DQDVDRVREOMHVHLWHNDNRSRWUXGLOR
GDP LXJRGL' RELOLVP RVDYUãHQRP MHVWRVDP R]DVHEHXVHSDUHX2 VMHüDR
VDP VHNDRGDVP RVDP LXUHVWRUDQX0 LVOLP GDVXRYDMVWRORVP LVOLOLEDã]D
WDNYHVLWXDFLMH
ªâWRWLMHYHþHUDV"©
-HVDP OLWDNRSUR]LUDQ"ª1 LãWD2 WNXGWHELGDP LMHQHãWR"©
3RVHJQXODMHSUHNRVWRODLGRWDNQXODP LþHOREDãNDRãWRP RMDP DMND
þLQLª1 HL]JOHGDãP LEDãGREUR-HOLWL]OR"©
ª' REURVDP ©ODJDRVDP äHOXGDFP LMHSRVNDNLYDRNDRGDVDP SURJXWDR
MDWRãLãP LãD
ª$ NRVHQHRVMHüDãGREURP RåHP RSRüLNXüL©UHNODMHJODGHüLP LREUD]
ª0 DORVLFUYHQ©
7RQMH]LQP DMþLQVNLLQVWLQNWSUHX]LP DSR]RUQLFX6DGVDP MRãVLJXUQLMLGD
MHRQDVDYUãHQD]DP RMXVXSUXJXLP DMNXP RMHGMHFH3ULP LRVDP MH]DUXNXL
SROMXELRXGODQª' REURVDP 3UHVWDQLVHEULQXWL©
. DGVP R]DYUãLOLVMHORP ]QDRVDP GDMHYULMHP H]DSURVLGEX-DVDP YHü
QDWUHüRMþDãLYLQDQRXSR]RUDYDP VDP VHEHGDXVSRULP MHU/DXUHO\QQHüH
SULKYDWLWLGUXJXSLMDQXSURVLGEX
1 HåHOLP VDP RL]ODQXWLª8 GDMVH]DP HQH©NDRX9HJDVXäHOLP GDP L
SULURGQRGRÿHDQDMEROMLQDþLQMH]DSRþHWLVQDãLP UDVWDQNRP
ª,P DP RMRãVDP RRVDP GDQDGRP RJRGODVND©
ª1 DãH ]DMHGQLþNR YULMHP H MH XYLMHN NDR WHP SLUDQD ERP ED 0 U]LP WR©
QHJRGRYDODMHJXUNDMXüLSRVOMHGQMLNRP DGLüGHVHUWDSRWDQMXUX
ª1 HåHOLP RWLüLEH]WHEH©
6SXVWLODMHåOLFXQDWDQMXULQDJQXODVHEOLåHP HQLª$ MDQHåHOLP GDRGHã
7 RþND©
ª-HVLOLUD]P LãOMDODRWRP HNDNRüHQDP ELWLNDGVHRSHWUDVWDQHP R"©
ª6YDNLGDQ©SUL]QDODP LMH
ª, MD LVWR VWDOQR UD]P LãOMDP R WRP H ,]MHGD P H GDQRQRüQR© ,VWLQD MH
1 LNDGDQHSUHVWDMHP UD]P LãOMDWLRWRP H
ªâWRVLRGOXþLR"©
3ULP LRVDP MH]DUXNXª1 HåHOLP åLYMHWLEH]WHEH©
ª1 LMDEH]WHEHDOLNDNRüHP RXVSMHWL"©1 H]QDP GDOLP HSRNXãDYD
QDYHVWLQDSURVLGEXLOLGRLVWDQHP DSRMP DNDNRüHP R
6WLVNDRVDP NXWLMLFXNRMDP LMHYHüSURJRUMHODUXSXXGåHSX-HOLVDGD
SUDYRYULMHP HGDMRMNDåHP GDüHQDP EUDNSRP RüLXWRP HLGDVYHRVWDOR
WUHEDP RSRVODWLNYUDJX"' DüHP RVYHXþLWLXVSXW"1 HP DP SRMP DãWRüXQR
L]YDGLRVDP NXWLMLFXL]GåHSD' UåDRVDP MHXUXFLLVSRGVWROD
ª1 HãWRP LMHSDORQDSDP HW©
7DP DQ VDP MH KWLR VWDYLWL QD VWRO LVSUHG QMH NDG QDV MH SUHNLQXR QHNL
þRYMHN 3URNOHWVWYR QDP MHUQR VDP þHNDR GD GRQHVX GHVHUW NDNR P L VH
RYDNYRQHãWRQHELGRJRGLOR
ª* RVSRÿLFH3DLJH0 F/DFKODQ"©
2 YRQLMH]DSRVOHQLNUHVWRUDQD1 HELMRM]QDRXP MHWQLþNRLP H/DXUHO\Q
JDMHSRJOHGDODª' D"©
6YMHWORVW MRM MH EOMHVQXOD UDYQR X OLFH NDG MX MH QHNROLNR SXWD VOLNDR
VYRMLP RJURP QLP IRWRJUDIVNLP DSDUDWRP ª0 RåHWH OL GDWL NRP HQWDU ]D
Country NewsRWRP HNDNRMHUDGLWLXJOD]EHQRMLQGXVWULMLNDGYDP MHRWDF
-DNH% HFNHWW"©
âRNLXåDV² WRVH]UFDOLORQD/DXUHO\QLQRP OLFXªâWRVWHWRUHNOL"©
$ SDUDWP XMHYLVLRRNRYUDWDLGRNMRMMHGUåDRXUHÿDM]DVQLP DQMHLVSUHG
XVWD
ª* RVSRÿLFH0 F/DFKODQMHOLYDP RWDFSRP RJDRGDGRELMHWHDQJDåP DQX
EHQGX6RXWKHUQ2 SKHOLD"©
/DXUHO\QMHJOHGDODXP HQHSDXWRJþRYMHNDª3RMP DQHP DP WNRVWHL
QHüXRGJRYDUDWLQDYDãDSLWDQMD©
1 LMHRGXVWDRª0 LVOLWHOLGDMHXVSMHKEHQGDSRYH]DQVWLP HWNRYDP MH
RWDF"©
8 VWDRVDP LVWDRL]P HÿXQMLKQDGYLYãLVHQDGQMHJDLSULSULMHWLYãLª5 HNOD
MHGDQHåHOLRGJRYDUDWLQDYDãDSLWDQMD2 GOD]LWH2 GP DK©
1 RVQLP LRMHMRãQHNROLNRIRWRJUDILMDLSURNRP HQWLUDRª1 HYMHURMDWQRMH
NROLNR VWH P X VOLþQL JRVSRÿLFH 0 F/DFKODQ 2 ERåDYDWHOML üH ELWL
RGXãHYOMHQL©
1 LMHQLãWDUHNOD0 LVOLP GDMRMMHWUHEDORYUHP HQDNDNRELXRSüHVKYDWLOD
RþHP XVHUDGLLGDRVDP MRMWRYULMHP H. DGMHVYHVUHGLODXJODYLSRJOHGDOD
P Hª2 YRP LMHQMDVYH1 LWNRP HYLãHQHüHJOHGDWLNDR3DLJH0 F/DFKODQâWR
VHRVWDWNDVYLMHWDWLþHMDVDP VDP RNüL-DNHD% HFNHWWD
ª6RXWKHUQ2 SKHOLDQLVXSRVWLJOLXVSMHK]ERJWYRJLP HQD3RVWLJOLVWHVYH
EH]QMHJRYHSRP RüL/MXGLüHWRYLGMHWL©
ª1 H ELK UHNOD 0 RUDP QD]YDWL P DP X L WDWX© (WR RGH P L ãDQVD ]D
SURVLGEX
ª+ HM P DP D -HVL OL NRG NXüH"© 1 DNUDWNR MH ]DVWDOD ª' RüL üX ]D
GYDGHVHWP LQXWD©
8 RSüHVHQHYHVHOLP ãWRüXYLGMHWL-ROHQH3UHVFRWWMHUVHQLVP RUDVWDOLX
OMXEDYL9 LGLP GDLRQDRVMHüDLVWRþLP P HXJOHGDODNDNRXOD]LP XQMH]LQ
GQHYQLERUDYDNVNXSDV/DXUHO\Q1 MH]LQSRJOHGQHRVWDYOMDP MHVWDVXP QML
-DNH% HFNHWWMHVGUXJHVWUDQHYUORSULMD]DQLRGP DKP LSUXåDUXNX
ª' UDJRP LMHãWRWHYLGLP -DFN©
/DXUHO\QLQDP DMNDP LMHVDP RãNUWRNLP QXODSULMHQHJRVHRNUHQXODNüHUL
RþHNXMXüLREMDãQMHQMH
ªâWRVHGRJDÿD"©
ª-DFNLMDVP RELOLQDYHþHULNDGMHQRYLQDU² YDOMGDMHQRYLQDU² XSDR
XUHVWRUDQLSLWDRP HGDNRP HQWLUDP NDNRMHUDGLWLXJOD]EHQRMLQGXVWULMLGRN
P LMH-DNH% HFNHWWRWDF©8 VUHGRWRþLODVHQD-DNHDª3LWDRP HMHMHVLOLP LWL
VUHGLRDQJDåP DQVD6RXWKHUQ2 SKHOLMRP ©
-DNHMHSRJOHGDR-ROHQHSDRSHW/DXUHO\Q
ª9DOMGDVDP WLWUHEDRUHüLQRSURãOLWMHGDQVDP SRGQLR]DKWMHY]DUD]YRG
ý LQLVHGDMHNRSDQMHSRP RP åLYRWXYHüSRþHORäDRP LMH=QDP GDQLVL
KWMHODGDWRL]LÿHXMDYQRVW©
ª1 H EL VH WUHEDOD EULQXWL ]ERJ WRJD /DXULH© QDYDOMLYDOD MH -ROHQH
ª8 RSüHWLQHüHQDãNRGLWL0 RåHWLVDP RSRP RüLXNDULMHUL©2 QDQHVKYDüDL
P LVOLP GDQLNDGQHüHVKYDWLWL/DXUHO\QQLMHKWMHODSRVWLüLXVSMHKQDWDNDY
QDþLQ
ª$ OLXWRP HMHVWYDUP DP D1 HåHOLP GDP LSRP RJQHþLQMHQLFDGDVDP
JHQHWVNLSRYH]DQDV-DNHRP % HFNHWWRP ©SRNXãDYDODMH/DXUHO\QREMDVQLWL
P DMFLªäHOMHODVDP XVSMHWLVDP D©
ª, KRüHã 9Hü MHVL 6YLMHW YHü YLGL NROLNR VL WDOHQWLUDQD % HQG MH YHü
SRVWDRVODYDQLSULMHQRãWRMHRYRL]LãORXMDYQRVW©JRYRULRMRMMHWDWDQR
X]DOXG9 LGLP SRQMH]LQRP OLFXª7UHEDODELRGP DKUHüL5 DQG\MX0 LVOLP GD
ELVP R WUHEDOL GRJRYRULWL LQWHUYMX ãWR SULMH ,]JOHGDW üH EROMH DNR ]DMHGQR
NDåHP RVYLMHWXXP MHVWRGDVD]QDMXL]WUDþHUVNLKQRYLQD©
3RþHWüHSODNDWL2 VMHWLRVDP MRMSRJODVXª2 YRQLMHRQRãWRVDP KWMHOD©
ª3DVDGMHP DORNDVQR]DWR©-ROHQHMHWXSULP MHGEXL]UHNODQDWDNDY
QDþLQGDELþRYMHNSRP LVOLRNDNRMHVUHWQD]ERJRYHVLWXDFLMH
/DXUHO\QVHSULP LOD]DNRULMHQQRVDLSUHWSRVWDYLRVDP GDVHSRNXãDYD
GRP LVOLWLQHNRP GUXJRP UMHãHQMX1 RQHXVSLMHYDMHU]QDGDüHVHXMXWURRYD
YLMHVWSURãLULWLSRSXWãXP VNRJSRåDUDªý LQLVHGDQHP DP L]ERUDMHUüHVH
LRQDNRVYHVD]QDWL6DP RP LMDYLNDGDLJGMHGDGRÿHP QDLQWHUYMX©
23. poglavlje
3RVOMHGQMLKQHNROLNRGDQDSURWHNOLVXSRWSXQRL]YDQP RMHNRQWUROH6YHVH
VDGD ]QD ² -DNH % HFNHWW P L MH RWDF ² L OHãLQDUL YHü NUXåH -HGYD VH
XVSLMHYDP SURELWL NUR] JXåYX QRYLQDUD LVSUHG P RMLK XOD]QLK YUDWD SD VH
P RUDP ãXOMDWL YDQ RGRVWUDJD L WUþDWL X VYRM DXWRP RELO SDUNLUDQ XOLFX QLåH
-DFN+ HQU\LQ]LVWLUDGDVYXJGMHLGHVDP QRP 1 LMHUHNDRQRP LVOLP GDVH
EULQH]ERJP RMHVLJXUQRVWL
3HWDN MH QDYHþHU 2 VWDOD VX QDP MRã GYD GDQD . DNR VH WR GRJRGLOR"
2 VMHüDP VHNDRGDVDP JDMXþHUJOHGDODNDNR]DP DORRGOD]LWDNVLMHP XNLãX
/HåDOL VP R QD NDXþX L JOHGDOL VH 3UHEDFLOD VDP QRJX SUHNR QMHJRYH
ª2 GOD]LãXQHGMHOMXDP LMRãQHP DP RSODQ©
8 GDKQXRMHLSRODNRL]GDKQXRª1 HP RJXRVWDWLRYGMH$ DNRVHQHãWR
QLMHSURP LMHQLORWLMRãQLVLVSUHP QDSRüLVDP QRP ©
1 LMHWRUHNDRDOL]QDGDVHMDP RUDP RGUHüLVYHJDNDNRELVP RQDVGYRMH
ELOL]DMHGQRª7 MHUDãP HGDELUDP ©
ª1 H7REL]QDþLORGDWLJRYRULP GDSRÿHãVDP QRP LOLMHJRWRYRP HGX
QDP D=DSUDYRWLJRYRULP GDWHYROLP LGDELKQDMYLãHQDVYLMHWXKWLRLP DWL
WHEHDOLQHP RJXRVWDWLRYGMH©,P DOLLNDNYHUD]OLNH"
0 LVOLP GDQHüHP RSUHåLYMHWLUD]GYRMHQR7DNYHYH]HULMHWNRXVSLMXª1 H
]QDP NDNRüHP RXVSMHWLDNRQLVP R]DMHGQR©
3RJODGLRP HSRUXFL0 LVOLP GDP HåHOLXWMHãLWLQRVDGDMHWRQHP RJXüH
ª2 QGDüHP RYLGMHWLNDNRQDP LGH5 D]JRYDUDWüHP RVYDNLGDQLYLGMHWLVH
NDGJRGP RåHP R0 RåHãL]YHVWLVWULSWL]]DP HQHSUHNRYLGHRSR]LYD©
2 VMHüDP VHNDRGDüXVYDNLþDVSRþHWLSODNDWLª1 LMHVP LMHãQR% LWüX
VDVYLP MDGQDEH]WHEH©
ª2 QGDSRÿLVDP QRP SDQHüHãELWLMDGQD©äHOLP DOLQHP RJX1 HVDGD
ª1 HP RJX©
ª+ RüHãUHüLQHåHOLã©
1 MHJRYD åLYRWQD ]DUDGD RYLVL R QMHJRYRP SR]QDYDQMX EHUEL JURåÿD
3URYHR MH åLYRW XþHüL ãWR SRJRGXMH NRMRM VRUWL 6KYDüDP WR 2 VWDYOMDQMH
SR]QDWRJ]ERJQHSR]QDWRJELJDP RJORXQLãWLWLQRQLMHSRãWHQRSRVWDYOMDWL
VWYDULWDNRGDMDLVSDGDP RQDNRMDVHQHåHOLåUWYRYDWL]DOMXEDYª% DãNDR
ãWRWLQHåHOLãRVWDWL©
0 DNQXR MH UXNX V P RMH L ]DJOHGDR VH X VWURS ª2 QGD MH ULMHãHQR 7L
RVWDMHã RYGMH D MD VH YUDüDP 1 LMH QDP QLãWD EROMH QHJR RQGD NDG VL P L
SREMHJODSULMHþHWLULP MHVHFD6DP RãWRWHMDVDGDWROLNRMHEHQRYROLP LVUFH
üHP LVHUDVSDVWLDNRQHEXGHP R]DMHGQR©
% LMHVDQMHª=DUVLOMXW"©
ª,WHNDNR% LMHVDQVDP ]ERJRYLKRNROQRVWLäHOLP ELWLVWRERP WLåHOLãELWL
VDP QRP =DãWRQHP RåHP RSURQDüLQDþLQGDWRRVWYDULP R"©
1 HNRYULMHP HVP RWLKROHåDOL1 DSHWRVWVHP RJODUH]DWLQRåHP 2 QMXMH
SUHNLQXRª. ROLNRGXJRWUDMHWYRMDVOMHGHüDWXUQHMD"©
1 DP MHUQRVDP L]EMHJDYDODUD]P LãOMDQMHRWRP Hª7ULP MHVHFD3RþLQMHX
NRORYR]XL]DYUãDYDNUDMHP OLVWRSDGD,P DP VDP RGYDVORERGQDWMHGQDSULMH
SRYUDWNDXVWXGLRQDVQLP DQMHQRYRJDOEXP D©
ª0 RåHãOLSURYHVWLEODJGDQHVDP QRP "©
1 HüHLüLª9 HüLP DP RGRJRYRUHQHERåLüQHNRQFHUWH©
ª-D SRNXãDYDP QDSUDYLWL SODQRYH GD VH YLGLP R L WR ãHVW P MHVHFL
XQDSULMHGDWLP HQHP RåHãXNORSLWLXVYRMUDVSRUHG©
. DåHGDP HQHWMHUDGDELUDP 0 HQLWRL]JOHGDNDRGDMHJRWRYRDNRQH
SRÿHP VQMLP 6LJXUQDVDP XWRNDRXP DORãWRXåLYRWX$ OLNDNRQHVKYDüD
GDP LQLãWDQLMHREHüDR"1 LMHP H]DSURVLR² EDUHP QH]DR]ELOMQR1 LVDP
OXGDGDRGHP RGDYGHEH]LNDNYRJMDP VWYD0 RJDRELP HLVWRWDNRRVWDYLWL]D
WULP MHVHFD
1 LVDP ]QDODãWRGDP XNDåHP ª0 RåHP ROLSRNXãDWLQDGDOMLQXLYLGMHWL
NDNRQDP LGH"©
ª,]JOHGDGDQHP DP RL]ERUDDNRQHSRÿHãVDP QRP ©
=DU åHOL GD VH RVMHüDP MRã JRUH" ª1 HP RM WDNR 1 DELMDã P L RVMHüDM
NULYQMH©
ª$ NRWUHEDåHOLP GDRVMHüDãNULYQMX² WROLNRGDVHRGP DKVSDNLUDãL
SRÿHãNXüLVDP QRP ©
5 HNDRMHkućiLMDVDP RGP DKSRP LVOLODQD$ YDORQDQHQDRYDMVWDQLOL
DXWREXV ]D WXUQHMH 9 LGLP VH X $ YDORQX NDGD ]DP LãOMDP QMHJD NDR VYRJ
VXSUXJDLRELWHOMNRMXP LåHOLGDWL
0 R]DN P H YHü EROLR RG UD]P LãOMDQMD L WUDåHQMD UMHãHQMD NRMH UHDOQR
JRYRUHüLQHSRVWRML0 MHVHFGDQDVDP SURYHODEULQXüLVH]ERJQDãHYH]HLYHü
VDP VHXP RULODäHOLP EDUHP P DORSREMHüLRGXåDVDSULUDVWDQNX
ª2 GYHGLP HXNUHYHWGD]DERUDYLP NDNRRGOD]Lã©=YXþDODVDP ]ELOMD
RþDMQLþNLQRQLMHP HELOREULJD
ª$ NRWRXþLQLP WRQHüHELWL]DWRGD]DERUDYLãQHJRGDYLGLãVYHUD]ORJH
]ERJNRMLKELWUHEDODSRüLVDP QRP ©
ªâWRJRG0 HQLRGJRYDUD©
3ULP LRP H]DUXNXLSRYHRXP RMXVSDYDüXVREX=DVWDRMHSRUHGNUHYHWD
LSROMXELRP H² MHGQRVWDYQRVODWNRLURP DQWLþQR' XERNRVDP X]GDKQXOD
NDGVHRGP DNQXR
ª1 LWNRWHQHüHQMHåQROMXELWLXXVWDNDGDMDRGHP ©3ROMXELRP HXYUDW
WRþQRQDRQRP MHVWRLVSRGXKDJGMHVHXYLMHNQDMHåLP ª1 LRYGMH©
6YXNDRP LMHP DMLFXSUHNRJODYH3ULP LRP H]DJUXGLLSRODNRP HOMXELR
SR YUDWX L UDP HQX 2 WNRSþDR P L MH JUXGQMDN OMXEHüL P MHVWR L]P HÿX P RMLK
GRMNL
/MXELRP LMHWUEXKLNOHNQXRQDNROMHQDLVSUHGP HQH2 VMHWLODVDP NDNR
P LMH]LNRP SUHOD]LSUHNRSXSNDGRNP LRWNRSþDYDWUDSHULFHý XODVDP ]YXN
SDWHQWQRJ ]DWYDUDþD GRN JD MH SRODNR SRYODþLR GROMH L FLMHOR WLMHOR P L MH
]DGUKWDOR
2 ELþQRELP LVDP RMHGQLP SRWH]RP VYXNDRLJDüLFHLKODþHQRVDGDQLMH
* XUQXRMHMHGDQSUVWXP RMHJDüLFHLODJDQRP HSRJODGLRSRNOLWRULVXNDRGD
P LQDJRYMHãWDYDãWRP HþHND2 VMHWLODVDP NDNRP LVHJDüLFHYODåH]ERJ
QMHJDLVDP R]ERJQMHJD² ]ERJP XãNDUFDNRMHJYROLP LNRMHJQH]QDP NDNR
üXSXVWLWLRGVHEH
6YXNDR P L MH JDüLFH L KODþH GR JOHåQMHYD L GUåDOD VDP VH ]D QMHJRYD
UDP HQDGRNVDP L]YODþLODQRJHYDQL]QMLK=DWLP P H]DJUOLRRNRNXNRYDL
SROMXELRXWUEXKSULMHQRãWRVHVSXVWLRQLåH
2 YRQLMHQDMEROMDSR]LFLMD]DRQRãWRGROD]LSDVDP ELODVUHWQDNDGP H
SRVMHRQDUXENUHYHWD3UHEDFLRMHP RMHQRJHSUHNRVYRMLKUDP HQDL]DJQMXULR
QRVRP XP HQHª. DGELKEDUHP RYRP RJDR]DURELWLXERþLFX3RVSUHMDRELK
FLMHOLNUHYHWWLP HLYDOMDRVHSRQMHP X©
1 DVP LMDODVDP VHL]DSOHODUXNHXQMHJRYXNRVX1 HGRVWDMDWüHP LQMHJRY
SUOMDYLMH]LN
3RVHJQXOD VDP ]D MDVWXFLP D L QDP MHVWLOD LK L]D VHEH WDNR GD JD P RJX
JOHGDWL ãWR P L UDGL 3UHWYRULR P H X SUDYX QLP IRP DQNX RERåDYDP JOHGDWL
QMHJRYDXVWDL]P HÿXVYRMLKQRJX
% H]REUD]QLNP HVDVYLP SRNYDULR1 HVDP RGDVHYLãHQHåHOLP VHNVDWLQL
V MHGQLP GUXJLP P XãNDUFHP QHJR YLãH QLNDG QHüX RVMHWLWL QL GMHOLü RYH
HNVWD]HNRMXRVMHüDP VQMLP
7UJQXODVDP VHNDGP HQMHJRYMH]LNGRWDNQXR1 H]DWRãWRVDP XSODãHQD
LOLL]QHQDÿHQDQHJR]DWRãWRP LåLYþDQL]DYUãHFLJRUHRGåHOMH]DQMHJRYLP
XVWLP D
5 D]P DNQXRP LMHQRJHUXNDP DGRNP HVYHEUåHOL]DR2 VMHWLODVDP RQDM
SULWLVDNNDNRUDVWHRQHYHOLþDQVWYHQHYDORYHNRMLSRþLQMXGXERNRXQXWUDL
UDVWXGRNQHSURELMXNUR]SRYUãLQXª2 KKGDEDãWX7RMHWDNRGREUR©
8 YLMHNP HGREURVOXãD. DGP XNDåHP GDMHWRSUDYRP MHVWRQHSUHVWDQHGRN
QH]DYULãWLP
-H]LNRP MHSRMDþDYDRSULWLVDNLRVMHWLODVDP RUJD]DP NDNRP LQDGROD]L
SULP LODVDP JD]DNRVXLSRYXNOD7UHQXWDNNDVQLMHP LVHFLMHORWLMHORQDSHOR
LYULVQXODVDP ]QDRMHGDKRüX
. DGVDP P XSXVWLODNRVXMRãXYLMHNVDP RVMHüDODQMHJRYDXVWDQDVHEL
NDGMHUHNDRª,GRãODMHGRFLOMDGDP HLJRVSRGR©
0 DNQXOD VDP MDVWXNH L]D VHEH L SRSHOD VH QD NUHYHW ª8 WUND MRã QLMH
JRWRYD©
/MXELR P L MH JOHåQMHYH L SHQMDR VH XVQLFDP D X] P RMH QRJH ª2 DOL
VOMHGHüLGLRQLMHXWUND3RODJDQRüXVYDP DJRVSRÿLFH0 F/DFKODQ7 NR]QD"
0 RåGDüHSRWUDMDWLFLMHOXQRü©
ª2 EHüDYDã"©
6P LMDRVHOMXEHüLP HSRQRJDP D. DGMHGRãDRGRERNRYDSROMXELRP HX
YUKVWLGQHNRVWL
ª8 YLMHNVLWDNRJODWND3RMP DQHP DãNROLNRP LVHWRVYLÿD©
/MXELRP HSRWUEXKXLSHQMDRVHSUHP DJUXGLP D=DGUåDRMHXVWDL]P HÿX
P RMLKGRMNLLVWLVQXRLKX]VYRMHOLFH² SUDYLRMHVHQGYLþRG-DFND+ HQU\MD
1 DVP LMDODVDP VH
3RGLJQXRP LMHUXNHL]QDGJODYHª2 NUHQLVH©
2 NUHQXODVDP VHQDWUEXKVUXNDP DMRãXYLMHNL]QDGJODYH/MXELRP LMH
YUDW3RODNRVHVSXãWDRGROMHQH]DQHP DUXMXüLQLMHGDQNRP DGLüP RMHNRåH
6DVYLP VDP VHQDMHåLOD² L]OXÿXMHP HLXåLYDXWRP H
6SXVWLR VH QD GQR P RMH NUDOMHåQLFH ² QMHJRYR RP LOMHQR P MHVWR ² L
SRþHR P H OL]DWL 1 H ]QDP ]DãWR WROLNR YROL WR P MHVWR QR QHND P X EXGH
8 ]EXÿXMHP HNDRQLãWDQDVYLMHWX
3RP DNQXRVHSUHP DP RMRMVWUDåQMLFLLWXVXVWYDULSRVWDOHP DORþXGQH
8 JUL]DR P H QR WDG MH VSXVWLR XVWD L]P HÿX P RMLK EHGDUD . ROMHQRP P L MH
UDVWDYLRQRJHLJXUQXRMDVWXNHLVSRGP HQH1 DJQXRP HQDSULMHGLMRM/LåH
P LåHQVNHGLMHORYH2 GRVWUDJD7RQLNDGDQLMHUDGLRLRVMHüDP VHQDVWUDQR
1 RVYLÿDP LVH-DNR
3ULP LRP H]DEHGUDSRGLJQXRLKJRUHLUD]GYRMLRWDNRGDP LMHVWUDåQMLFD
ELODX]UDNX0 LVOLODVDP GDELP HELORXåDVQRVUDP ELWLXRYRMSR]LGDRYR
ãWRUDGLQLMHWDNRVDYUãHQR
8 YLMHNP HL]QHQDGLQRYLP WULNRYLP D2 GMHGQRP MHVWDRLUHNDRª1 HQH
åHOLP GDMRãMHGQRP VYUãLãRYDNRäHOLP ELWLXWHEL©
3RWDSãDRP HSREHGUXGDVHRNUHQHP
. DGVDP VHSRQRYQRQDãODQDOHÿLP DOHJDRMHQDP HQH* OHGDOLVP RVHX
RþL * ODGLR P H SR UXNDP D L QDSRVOMHWNX LK SRGLJQXR L]QDG P RMH JODYH
,VSUHSOHOLVP RSUVWH* OHGDOLVP RVHXRþL² QLMHQLWUHSQXRNDGMHXãDRX
P HQH 1 R YLGLP X QMHJRYRP SRJOHGX GD MDNR YROL ELWL X P HQL 7R
]DGRYROMVWYRMHQH]DP MHQMLYR
2 EDYLODVDP JDQRJDP DWDNRGDJDRVMHWLP GXEOMHXVHEL6QMLP P LEOL]X
QLMHGRYROMQREOL]X8 YLMHNåHOLP MRã
1 DVORQLRVHQDODNWRYHLQMHåQRP HSRGODNWLFDP DSULP LR]DJODYX/MXELR
P HSRFLMHORP OLFX
ª6WUDãQRWHYROLP 7LVLP LVYH©3UVWLVXQDP LGDOMHELOLLVSUHSOHWHQL
L]QDGP RMHJODYHLMDþHP LMHVWLVQXRUXNHGRNVHSRODNRNUHWDRXP HQL
1 DVORQLRMHþHORQDP RMHª3ROMXSFHP VLSUREXGLODP RMHVUFH©
6DGVDP MDQMHJDMDþHVWLVQXODª% RåHP LOLNDNRWHYROLP ©
3RP DNQXRMHNXNRYHWDNRGDP LWUOMDRQRP MHVWRGRNVHNUHüHXQXWDU
P HQH 1 HP D QLãWD EROMH QHJR LP DWL P XãNDUFD NRML WH WMHUD GD VYUãDYDã QD
WROLNR UD]OLþLWLK QDþLQD SD þDN L V ODJDQLP QMHåQLP YRÿHQMHP OMXEDYL
1 DMSRVHEQLMHQDVYLMHWXP LMHNDGDP LSULWRP NDåHGDP HYROL5 HNODELKGD
VDP WXXL]UD]LWRMP DQMLQL9HüLP DåHQDVYUãDYDRGVDP RJVHNVDQRYHüLQD
åHQDQHP D-DFND+ HQU\MD
. DGVP R]DYUãLOLQDVORQLRVHLRSXVWLRQDP HQL6SXVWLODVDP QRJHGROMH
WDNR GD VH P RåH XJQLMH]GLWL L]P HÿX QMLK GRN MH MRã X P HQL 2 ERåDYDP WH
WUHQXWNHNDGVP RMRãXYLMHNVSRMHQLNDRMHGQR
ª2 EHüDMP LGDWLQLWNRQHüHRYRUDGLWLGRNP HQHQHP D©
2 SD7R]YXþLWDNRNRQDþQRNDRGDVHRSUDãWDP RLQLNDGVHYLãHQHüHP R
YLGMHWLª1 LMHGDQP XãNDUDFP HQHüHGRWDNQXWLQLQDNRMLQDþLQ7 LVLMHGLQL©
ª=DNXQLVH©
ª. XQHP VH©
=DJUOLRP HLMDQMHJD6WLVNDOLVP RMHGQRGUXJRGREROLª8 P LUHP RG
VWUDKDGDWHJXELP ©
ª,MDLVWR©
1 DVORQLRMHþHORQDP RMHª1 HP RJXWRSRGQLMHWL5 HNDRVDP GDQHüXELWL
WDNDYDOLQHP RJXVLSRP RüL0 ROLP WHSRÿLNXüLVDP QRP =QDP GDQH
P RåHãLP DWLNDULMHUXX$ XVWUDOLMLDOL]QDãGDVHMDP RJXEULQXWL]DWHEH,P DW
üHãVYHãWRWLVUFHSRåHOLLQLNDGDQHüHãP RUDWLUDGLWL©
1 D WUHQXWDN VDP VH SRNROHEDOD QR MRã XYLMHN P H QLMH ]DSURVLR ª1 H
P RJX1 H]QDP NDNRüHP RXVSMHWLDOLSURQDüLüHP RQDþLQ0 RUDP RMHUQLãWD
GUXJRQLMHRSFLMD©
24. poglavlje
âHVWWMHGDQDSURãORMRããHVWRVWDOR* UR]QRMH)XM
äLYRWQDSXWXQLMHRQDNDYNDNYRJDVDP ]DP LãOMDOD1 LVDP ELODQDLYQD
]QDODVDP GDVWDOQDSXWRYDQMDP RJXELWLEUXWDOQDQRQDGDODVDP VHGDüH
OMXEDYRERåDYDWHOMDQDGRNQDGLWLVYHQHJDWLYQRVWL1 HP RMWHP HNULYRVKYDWLWL
RQLVX]ELOMDGLYQLDOLDXWREXVLKRWHOLP LQLNDNRQHP RJXSRVWDWLGRP 2 YDM
åLYRW]ELOMDQLMH]DP HQH
0 RåGDVHQHELKRVMHüDODWDNRGDQH]QDP NDNRP HOMXEDYP RJåLYRWD
þHNDGDP XVHYUDWLP 1 R]QDP LMDGQDVDP ]ERJWRJD6YDNLGDQP LMHVYH
JRUHLRVMHüDP VHNDRGDSDGDP XQHNXYUVWXGHSUHVLMH
5 D]JRYDUDP RVYDNLGDQEH]L]QLP NH² LSRQHNDGVHP DOþLFH]DIUNDYDP R
SUHNR YLGHR SR]LYD ² QR WR QH RODNãDYD QDãX UD]GYRMHQRVW 8 åDVDYD P H
SRP LVDRGDüHP XVYHWRGRVDGLWLLGDQHüHKWMHWLQDVWDYLWLYH]XQDGDOMLQXMHU
WUHEDQHãWRRSLSOMLYRDMDWRQHP RJXELWLý LQLVHGDVDGDVYHSUROD]LXUHGX
² ]DVDGD=QDP GDWRQHüHSRWUDMDWL]DXYLMHNDOLLQHWUHED6DP RMRããHVW
WMHGDQD² MRãþHWUGHVHWLGYDGDQD² LELWüHP RVNXSD]DXYLMHN
6HGDP WMHGDQDSURãORMRãSHWRVWDOR-RãXYLMHNMHJUR]QRLIXM
3HWNRQFHUDWDWMHGQRVYDNXQRüXGUXJRP JUDGX,VFUSOMHQDVDP LP U]LP
VYRMSRVDRQRSULKYDWLODVDP REDYH]XLLVSXQLWüXMHäHOLP ELWLL]GDMLFDL
QDSXVWLWLEHQGDOLMDQLVDP WDNYD9ROLP RYHGHþNHLåHOLP GDXVSLMX$ NR
VDGDRGHP XQLãWLWüXLKMHUQHP DMX]DP MHQX1 HüXLP WRXþLQLWLGRNOHJRGP H
-DFN+ HQU\VWUSOMLYRþHND$ NRRQRGXVWDQHSULMHNUDMDWXUQHMHRGXVWDWüXL
MD 1 HüX åUWYRYDWL QDãX OMXEDY ]ERJ 6RXWKHUQ 2 SKHOLMH QL ]ERJ ELOR NRJD
GUXJRJD
/DXUHO\QLQD WXUQHMD ]DYUãDYD VOMHGHüL WMHGDQ L MD VH QDGDP GD üH WR ELWL
SRþHWDNQDãH]DMHGQLþNHEXGXüQRVWL& LMHORYULMHP HMHELODWDMDQVWYHQDJOHGH
VYRMLKSODQRYDLQLMHP LREHüDODQLMHGQRQLGUXJR0 DOþLFHVDP ]DEULQXWDOL
QLVDP KWLRQDYDOMLYDWLGDQHELKVYHSRNYDULR
=DSUDYRMHWUHEDODLP DWLGYDVORERGQDWMHGQDNDG]DYUãLWXUQHMDLQDNRQ
WRJD VH YUDWLWL X VWXGLR ]ERJ QRYRJ DOEXP D QR þLQL VH GD VX VH VWYDUL
SURP LMHQLOH' DRVDP MRMSUVWHQLUHNDRMRMGDMHåHOLP RåHQLWL
3URãODVXWULP MHVHFDLQLMHP LMRãGDODNRQDþDQRGJRYRU=QDP GDVDP
MRMVDP WDNRUHNDRQRQH]QDQMHP HSRODNRL]OXÿXMH* OXP LP GDVDP VWUSOMLY
DOLQLVDP äHOLP GDEXGHRYGMHLVYDNLGDQVDP RJDVHEHVSUMHþDYDP GDMRM
QHQDUHGLP GDRGP DKGRÿH
,VNUHQRP DORP HGHSULP LUDãWRQLMHVYHRVWDYLODRQRJDWUHQDNDGVDP MRM
VWDYLRSUVWHQQDSUVW1 HNDNRVDP VHQDGDRGDKRüHQR]QDP GDVXQMH]LQD
VQDåQDYROMDLQHRYLVQRVWUD]OR]L]DãWRMHWROLNRYROLP 6YLÿDP LVHþLQMHQLFD
ãWRLP DYODVWLWLåLYRWLãWRMRMMDQLVDP VYUKDSRVWRMDQMD1 RVHELþQLGLRP HQH
MHUD]MDUHQLP U]LWR
,P DRVDP GXJGDQL]ELOMDVDP ELRLVFUSOMHQNDGVDP QDSRNRQVWLJDRNXüL
QDYHþHU % LOR MH NDVQR QR JRVSRGD 3RUFHOOL MH MRã XYLMHN ELOD X NXKLQML
ª' RãOL VWH EDã QD YULMHP H JRVSRGLQH 0 F/DFKODQ 8 SUDYR VDP L]YDGLOD
YHþHUXL]SHüQLFH©
3R]QDW P L MH WDM P LULV QR QH SRYH]XMHP JD VD JRVSRÿRP 3RUFHOOL L
QMH]LQLP NXKDQMHP 0 LULãLEDãNDROD]DQMHP RMHFXUHª. DRGDMH/DXUHO\Q
NXKDOD©
ª7 DNRLWUHED7 RVXQMH]LQHOD]DQMH©
1 HGRVWDMDORP LMHQMH]LQRNXKDQMHLRYRMHEDãOLMHSLSRGVMHWQLNª+ YDOD
YDP 6LJXUDQVDP GDüHELWLRGOLþQH©
* RVSRGD3RUFHOOLVHVSUHP LODLNUHQXODYDQª' DQDVYDP MHVWLJDRQHNL
SDNHW6WDYLODVDP JDXVSDYDüXVREX©
1 LVDP QLãWDQDUXþLRLQHRþHNXMHP QLNDNYHSRãLOMNHª. DNDYSDNHW"©
1 DVP LMHãLOD VH ªý LQL P L VH GD MH QHãWR RG /DXUHO\Q 8 JRGQX YHþHU
åHOLP ©2 WLãODMHSULMHQRãWRVDP VWLJDRRGJRYRULWL
3RSXWGMHWHWDQDERåLüQRMXWURMHGYDVDP þHNDRGDVWLJQHP XVSDYDüX
VREXLYLGLP ãWRP LMH/DXUHO\QSRVODOD,P DRVDP VYDNDNYDRþHNLYDQMDGRN
VDP KRGDR² LOLMXULR² SUHP DVSDYDüRMVREL
9 UDWDVXELOD]DWYRUHQDLEU]RVDP LKRWYRULRGDELKãWRSULMHXJOHGDR
NXWLMXQDVYRP HNUHYHWX1 RRQRãWRMHOHåDORQDSODKWDP DQDGLãORMHVYD
P RMDRþHNLYDQMD
% LODMHWRP RMDSUHNUDVQD/DXUHO\Q
/HåDODMHQDERNXLJOHGDODP HNDGVDP XãDR* ODYXMHQDVORQLODQDUXNXL
ODJDQR VDYLOD QRJH 5 DVSXVWLOD MH VP HÿH NRYUþH SUHNR UDP HQD L RGMHQXOD
P RMXNRãXOMX5 DVNRSþDQX1 DJRORWLMHOR8 NUXWLRVDP VHLVWRJWUHQD
0 R]DNP LVHSUHWYRULRXNDãXMHUP LMHVYDNUYSRMXULODXQDGRP LQDQWQLML
RUJDQ WRJ WUHQXWND ² P RM NXUDF 3RJOXSLR VDP 1 LVDP P RJDR QLãWD UHüL
6DP RVDP ]XULRXQMX
ª% RN-DFN+ HQU\©UHNODMHLVDP RGRSDGQRVHRVP MHKQXODª-HVLOLVH
L]QHQDGLR"©
3UHNLQXODP LVHYH]DL]P HÿXP R]JDLXVWDQRVUHüRP QRJHVXP LMRã
XYLMHN IXQNFLRQLUDOH 3ULWUþDR VDP N QMRM D RQD VH SURSHOD QD NROMHQD L
GRþHNDODP H
6UFHP LMHOXSDORGRNVDP MHGUåDR]DREUD]HLOMXELRXXVWDNDRGDMH
SUYLSXW1 DSDGDQVDP MHUQHP DP L]ERUD1 LVDP MHRNXVLRP MHVHFLP DLSDWLP
RGQHGRVWDWNDLXVNUDüLYDQMD
-RãXYLMHNVDP MHGUåDR]DREUD]HNDGVDP MHSUHVWDROMXELWLLQDVORQLR
VYRMHþHORQDQMH]LQR
ª-DNRVLP LQHGRVWDMDOD0 LVOLRVDP QDWHEHVYDNLGDQLVYDNLWUHQ©
ª=QDP , WL VL P HQL QHGRVWDMDR + WMHOD VDP GRüL MRã SULMH QHNROLNR
P MHVHFLDOLQLVDP P RJODRVWDYLWL& KDUOLHMDLGHþNHNDGVXP HYHüWDNROLMHSR
SULP LOL©
1 HP DP SRMP DRþHP XSULþDDOLQHüXRNROLãDWLª-HOLRYRVDP RNUDWNL
SRVMHWLOLVLGRãODGDELVP R]DSRþHOL]DMHGQLþNLåLYRW"©
ª2 YRMHSRþHWDNQDãHJD]DXYLMHN©
ª2 QGDQHãWRP RUDP XþLQLWLSULMHWRJD©
3ULP LRVDP MH]DUXNHLSRYXNDRSUHP DVHELGRNVDP VLOD]LRVNUHYHWD
6WDMDODMHLVSUHGP HQHNDGVDP VHVSXVWLRQDNROMHQRNDRãWRVHRþHNXMHRG
P XãNDUFDNRMLSURVLåHQX3ULP LRVDP MH]DOLMHYXUXNXQDNRMRMMHQRVLODP RM
SUVWHQLSROMXELRJDª9ROLP WHFLMHOLP VYRMLP ELüHP ©2 ]DULODVHLVLJXUDQ
VDP GD]QDãWRVOLMHGLª1 HåHOLP QLNDGDYLãHELWLUD]GYRMHQRGWHEH-HGLQD
åHOMDVUFDP RJDMHVWGDP LWLEXGHãVXSUXJDLP DMNDP RMHGMHFH+ RüHãOLVH
XGDWL]DP HQH"©
ª+ RüX©-HGQDULMHþ-HGQRVWDYQR7 RMHVYHãWRP LWUHED
0 DNQXR VDP NRãXOMX V QMH]LQRJ WUEXKD L SULOMXELR OLFH X] QMH]LQX JROX
NRåXª. XQHP WLVHGDüXWHXVUHüLWL©
ª1 LP DORQHVXP QMDP XWR©UHNODMHLSURãODP LSUVWLP DNUR]NRVXª1 H
åHOLP þHNDWLäHOLP SRVWDWLWYRMDVXSUXJDãWRMHEUåHP RJXüH©
3ROMXELRVDP MHXWUEXKLSRJOHGDRMHVSRGDª% RåHNDNRVDP VUHWDQãWR
VLWRUHNOD1 LMDQHåHOLP þHNDWL©-RãXYLMHNP LMHP UVLODNRVXLVP MHãNDOD
P LVHNDGVDP MH]DJUOLRRNRVWUDåQMLFH
ª3RVWRMLMRãMHGQDVWYDUNRMXMHGYDþHNDP ©
ª. ODGLP VHGDP LVOLP RQDLVWR©
ª1 HP DSRWUHEH]DNODÿHQMHP ©3ULP LODP HMH]DUXNXLSRGLJQXODVSRGD
ª2 ERMH]QDP RGDP HQHXYLMHNP RåHãLP DWL² NDNRJRGP HåHOLã©
% U]RP LMHRWNRSþDODKODþHLJXUQXODUXNXXQXWUD2 EDYLODMXMHRNRP HQH
LSRþHODNOL]LWLJRUHGROMHª,RYRP LMHQHGRVWDMDOR©
3URãORMHSUHYLãHYUHP HQDRWNDGVDP SRVOMHGQMLSXWDELRXQMRMLRVMHüDP
VHNDRGDüXVYUãLWLRGQMH]LQRJGRGLUDª' XãRVYUãLWüXWLXUXNXDNRWDNR
QDVWDYLã©
ª$ WLELUDGLMHVYUãLRXP HQH]DUQH"©
ª$ SVROXWQR©
2 NUHQXODVHLSXVWLODNRãXOMXGDSDGQHQDSRG2 NUHQXODP LMHOHÿDL
WUOMDODVHVWUDåQMLFRP RP RMHSUHSRQHª=QDP NDNRWLåHOLã©
6NRURVDP HNVSORGLUDRDQLVDP åHOLRGDQDãH]DXYLMHN]DSRþQHQDWDM
QDþLQäHOLRVDP YRGLWLOMXEDYVQMRP LJOHGDWLMRMOLFHNRGWRþLQLP ª2 YRJD
SXWD QH© UHNDR VDP SULP LR MH ]D NXNRYH L RNUHQXR SUHP D VHEL ªäHOLP
YLGMHWLOLFHVYRMHEXGXüHVXSUXJHGRNYRGLP OMXEDYVQMRP ©
ª' DLP DP JDüLFHVDP HELVHVYXNOHQDWHULMHþL©6MHODMHQDNUHYHW
QDVORQLOD VH XQDWUDJ L VWDYLOD UDãLUHQH QRJH QD RJUDGX ª' RÿL L XþLQL GD
YULãWLP WDNRGDVYLXRYRP NUDMXJUDGDVD]QDMXWYRMHLP H©
ª5 HþHQR ² XþLQMHQR© 3RGLJQXR VDP MRM VWRSDOD L VWDYLR LK QD VYRMD
UDP HQD1 DP MHVWLRVDP MRMNXNRYHXVDYUãHQXSR]LFLMX8 ]HRVDP VLQHNROLNR
WUHQXWDNDP LULVDQMDSULMHNXãDQMDª1 HP RJXWLUHüLNROLNRVDP SXWDRP LULVDR
WYRMHJDüLFHGRNVP RELOLUD]GYRMHQLQRQLãWDP LRYRQHP RåHQDGRP MHVWLWL©
=DULRVDP QRVXQMXLXGDKQXRGRNP LSOXüDQLVXELODVDVYLP SXQDª2 YR
QHP DGRVWRMQX]DP MHQX©
9 LãH QLVDP P RJDR L]GUåDWL RVMHüDR VDP VH L]JODGQMHOR . DG VDP MH
QDSRNRQNXãDRELORMHLEROMHQHJRSULMH=DQHNROLNRVHNXQGLVHYUSROMLODX
P RMLP XVWLP DLVWHQMDODª1 LWRQHP D]DP MHQX©
1 HüHGXJRL]GUåDWLDMDVDP VUHWDQãWRMHMRãXYLMHNP RJXGRYHVWLGRWDNR
EU]RJRUJD]P DªäHOLãOLGDP DORXVSRULP GDGXåHWUDMH"©
3ULP LODP H]DNRVXLSULYXNODQDVHEHª1 H1 HP RMQLVOXþDMQRVWDWLLOL
]DVWDWL1 DUXEXVDP LXP ULMHWüXDNRXEU]RQHVYUãLP ©
3RGLJQXRVDP SDODFX]UDNMHUQLVDP KWLRSRNXãDWLJRYRULWL. DNRVDP L
VXP QMDRSRþHODMHSRGUKWDYDWLXURNXRGSHWQDHVWVHNXQGLý XRVDP NDNRMRM
VHGLVDQMHSRMDþDYDGRNMHVWHQMDODLELRVDP SRSULOLþQRVLJXUDQGDVXVYLQD
LVWRþQRMVWUDQLYHüGREURQDXþLOLP RMHLP H
1 LVDP VHXVXGLRVWDWLGRNQLVDP RVMHWLRGDVHSRþHODRSXãWDWLX]P HQH
7DGVDP ]QDRGDRVMHüDHXIRULMXQRQLVDP VLP RJDRSRP RüLäLYRWLQMVNLVDP
åHOLRELWLXQMRMäHOLRVDP YRGLWLOMXEDYVQMRP QRQLVDP P RJDRMHUMHSURãOR
SUHYLãHYUHP HQD0 RUDWüXSULþHNDWLQR]QDP GDQHüHELWLGXJR
0 RNUD MH L V ODNRüRP VDP SURGUR X QMX % U]R VDP MH QDELMDR ²
YMHURMDWQRSUHEU]R² QRQLVDP VLP RJDRSRP RüL. DRGDMHLP RMNXUDFåHOLR
QDGRNQDGLWLL]JXEOMHQRYULMHP H
2 VMHWLRVDP NDNRP HWDSãHSRUDP HQXª-DFN+ HQU\6WDQLP DORP RUDP
WLQHãWRUHüL©6WDQL"2 QDVHãDOL6DGVDP SRSXWYODNDEH]NRþQLFDªâWR
MH"©XSLWDRVDP EH]VWDMDQMD
ª1 LVDP KWMHODRYGMHWUDåLWLOLMHþQLNDNRMLELP LL]YDGLRGLMDIUDJP XSDVDP
MHL]YDGLODNRGNXüHSULMHQRãWRVDP GRãOD©
ª' REUR©UHNDRVDP MHUQLVDP ELRVLJXUDQRþHP XJRYRULQLWLP LMHXWRP
WUHQXWNXELORVWDOR3ROMXELODP HMHXUDP Hª7R]QDþLGDVHVDGDVHNVDP R
EH]]DãWLWH©
ªäHOLãOLP LUHüLGDP RUDP SUHVWDWL"©7 DP RJXüQRVWP HVDP RXEU]DOD
ª1 HDOLåHOLP WLUHüLGDQHP DP QLNDNYXNRQWUDFHSFLMX+ WMHODVDP WLUHüL
GDVDP SRQLMHODNRQGRP HQRNUHQXRVLWDNREU]RGDQLVDP VWLJOD©
ª0 LVOLP GDQHP RJXSUHVWDWL0 LVOLP YDOMGDELKP RJDRNDGELKP RUDR
DOLNYUDJXQHåHOLP ©7ROLNRVDP EOL]XRUJD]P DLP RMNXUDFQLMHQLP DOR
]DEULQXW ]D SRVOMHGLFH VYRMLK SRVWXSDND 0 R]DN P L VH ERULR V NXUFHP ]D
GRP LQDFLMXDRYDMSRVOMHGQMLQLNDNRQLMHKWLRSUHSXVWLWLNRUP LOR
ª' XãRSUHVWDWüXDNRåHOLãDOLEROMHWLMHGDEU]RRGOXþLãMHUüHP RML
SOLYDþLXVNRURSOLYDWLSRWYRP NRNSLWX©
ª3UYRP DODDVDGDNRNSLW"©
ª5 HFL P L ãWR GD UDGLP © SURP UVLR VDP NUR] ]XEH 3RNXãDYDR VDP VH
VX]GUåDWLDOLELORP LMHVNRURQHP RJXüHQDNRQWROLNRYUHP HQDEH]QMHª6YUãLW
üX©
ª,]YDGLJDLVYUãLP LSRWUEXKX©1 LMHELODGRYROMQREU]DMHUþLP VDP JD
L]YDGLRHVNSORGLUDRVDP SRQMRMª2 /DXUHO\QWRMHELORWDNRMHEHQR
GREUR©
2 NUHQXODVHQDERNLSUHEDFLODQRJXSUHNRP HQHª=QDP LP HQLLVWR
/LMHSRMHELWLNRGNXüH©
ª2 ERåDYDP NDGWRNDåHã©3ULP LRVDP MH]DOLFHLSROMXELRª. UHQLP R
VDG LVSRþHWND V UD]JRYRURP R NRQWUDFHSFLML 1 LVDP VLJXUDQ GD VDP LãWD
VKYDWLR©
ª-HVL OL þXR RQDM GLR GD QHP D NRQWUDFHSFLMH"© -HVDP DOL YDOMGD VDP
VKYDWLRWHNNDVQLMHª9 DOMGD©
ª+ WMHODVDP GDP LL]YDGHGLMDIUDJP XMHUQLVDP ELODVLJXUQDKRüXOLRYGMH
LP DWLSUREOHP DVSURQDODVNRP OLMHþQLND©
1 H ]QDP QLãWD R WRP H ª0 L RYGMH WDNRÿHU LP DP R REXþHQH L VWUXþQH
OLMHþQLNH1 LVP REDUEDUL©
ª=QDP WRDOLQLNDGDQLVP RUD]JRYDUDOLNROLNRüHP REU]RSRþHWLUDGLWLQD
RELWHOML1 H]QDP NROLNRWUHED]D]DþHüHQDNRQYDÿHQMDGLMDIUDJP HSDP LVH
WRþLQLORNDRGREUDLGHMDäDRP LMH+ WMHODVDP UD]JRYDUDWLVWRERP RWRP H
QRVYHMHLãORWDNREU]R' RNVLP HSURVLRQLMHELRGREDUWUHQXWDN]DWDNDY
UD]JRYRUQRQDNRQWRJDMHVYHNUHQXORQHYMHURMDWQRP EU]LQRP 8 VWDVXWLYHü
ELOD L]P HÿX P RMLK QRJX D WR VLJXUQR QHüX SUHNLQXWL GD ELK UD]JRYDUDOD R
GLMDIUDJP L6OMHGHüHJWUHQXWNDVLYHüELRXP HQL©
ª' XãRVYHMHXUHGX$ NRVHGRJRGLORMHGQRVWDYQRüHP RLP DWLGLMHWH
,RQDNRüHP RVHXEU]RYMHQþDWL1 HEULQLVH]ERJWRJD©
ª1 LVLOMXW"©
ª1 LVDP 5 HNDRVDP WLãWRP LVOLP RQDP DLGMHFL% LRELKVUHWDQGDVHWR
GRJRGLVDGD$ NRVHQHGRJRGLWR]QDþLGDLP DP RMRãYUHP HQD]DYMHåEX
SULMHRGOXNH©
ª0 LVOLP GDQHüHQLãWDELWLMHUWUHEDP GRELWLP MHVHþQLFX]DSDUGDQD,MD
ELK ELOD VUHWQD GD VH GRJRGL QR UDGLMH ELK ELOD XGDQD QHNR YULMHP H SULMH
WUXGQRüHDNRYHüLP DP L]ERUD©
ª0 RåH©3UHYUQXRVDP MHQDOHGDLSRGLJQXRMRMUXNHL]QDGJODYHSDVDP
MH RSNRUDþLR OHJDR QD QMX ªäHOLP YDP UDGLWL VYDNRMDNH VWYDUL JRVSRÿR
0 F/DFKODQ©6SXVWLRVDP XVWDQDQMH]LQHJUXGLLSROL]DRMRMEUDGDYLFXGRNVH
QLMHXNUXWLODª=QDãGDELQDP EHEDVP HWDODVYDNLKQHNROLNRVDWLNDGELKWL
KWLRUDGLWLRYR©
ª2 ERåDYDãWXSRP LVDR]DUQH"©
2 ERåDYDP XVSUNRVVYHP XãWRP LMH(YDQUHNDRª=DãWRWRNDåHã"©
ª2 YRQLMHSUYLSXWGDVSRP LQMHãGRMHQMH©
0 ROLP "ª1 HVMHüDP VHGDVDP WRLNDGDVSRP HQXR©
ª1 DUDYQRMHUVLELRSLMDQNDRP DMND]HP OMD² LDNRVHQHNDNRVMHüDã
SLMDQHSURVLGEH©
ª' DNOH]DSURVLRVDP WHX/DV9HJDVXGRNVDP ELRSLMDQLSULþDRVDP R
GMHFL² NRMXüHãWLGRMLWL"©ý XGQRYDOMGDVDP ELRMRãSLMDQLMLQHJRãWRVDP
P LVOLR
ª' D UHNDR VL GD P H MHGYD þHNDã JOHGDWL NDNR GRMLP QDãX GMHFX©
9 MHURMDWQRüHLRYR]DYUãLWLQDQMH]LQRP SRSLVXP RMLKþXGQLKSRQDãDQMD
ª1 HVMHüDP VHGDVDP WRUHNDRDOLLVWLQDMH3UREXGLODVLQHãWRXP HQLãWR
VDP VP DWUDRGDQHSRVWRMLLGDQLNDGDQHüXRVMHWLWL0 LVOLP VDP RQDWRNDNR
åHOLP GDEXGHãP RMDLGDRVQXMHP RRELWHOM©
ª7R MH ]DWR ãWR VL ãSLOMVNL þRYMHN© QDVP LMDOD VH ª,P Dã SRULY ]D
UD]P QRåDYDQMHP LMDWLVHVYLÿDP 1 RP RUDãP HSUYRRåHQLWL©
0 RUDP VHVORåLWLVWLP ª6DP RP LUHFLNDGDLELWüXWDP R0 DP DüHELWL
OXGD RG åHOMH GD WL SRP RJQH X SODQLUDQMX 2 QD & KORH L (P P D üH VYH
LVSODQLUDWLDNRLP GR]YROLã©
ª0 RMDRELWHOMQHüHGRüLSDP LQHWUHEDYHOLNRYMHQþDQMHRVLP DNRJDWL
QHåHOLã©
5 DåDORVWLP VHVYDNLSXWNDGP LNDåHGDQMH]LQDRELWHOMQHüHGRüLª-D
åHOLP VDP R WHEH L QLãWD GUXJR P L QH WUHED 1 R ]DãWR QH ELVP R NUHQXOL X
6\GQH\L]DSRþHOLVSODQRYLP DNDGYHüQHåHOLP RþHNDWL"2 GJRYDUDOLWLX
þHWYUWDN"3URYHVWüHP RSURGXåHQLYLNHQGWDP R©
ª0 RåH-HGYDþHNDP GDLKVYHYLGLP ©
ª% LOLWLVP HWDORGDLP QHNDåHP GDVLGRãOD"+ WLRELKLKL]QHQDGLWL$ NR
P DP DVD]QDGDVLVDP QRP NUHQXWüHDP RXURNXRGVDWYUHP HQDDMDELK
KWLRGDEXGHP RP DORVDP LSULMHQRãWRVHVMDWHOHãLQDUL©
ª% LWüHP LMDNRGUDJRGDEXGHP RP DORVDP L©
2 NUHQXRVDP MHQDOHÿDª0 RJXOLYMHåEDWLELWLWYRMP Xå"©
ª8 SURWLYQRP ELKELODMDNRUD]RþDUDQD9 MHåEDQMHYRGLVDYUãHQVWYX]DUWR
QLVLþXR"©
29. poglavlje
3ODNDODVDP QDNUDMXSUYHUHþHQLFHLYHüULGDODGRWUHüH=QDP GDP H
QLNDGDQLMHåHOLRSRYULMHGLWLQRWRQHP RåHRGDJQDWLEROQLVOLNHNRMHYLGLP X
VYRMRMJODYL² RQOHåLJROXNUHYHWXVQHNRP GUXJRP åHQRP . DGELEDUHP
VYHSUHVWDORQRQH]QDP NDNR]DXVWDYLWLEXMLFX7DNRVDP SURYHODVOMHGHüLK
QHNROLNRVDWLþHNDMXüL$ GGLVRQ² VMHGLODVDP QDNDXþXLSUHELUDODSRåLFDP D
JLWDUHQDGDMXüLVHGDüHP LVYHVDP RLVSDULWLL]JODYH
ª1 LVLP HSR]YDODQDGUXåHQMH]DFXULFHâWRVHGRJRGLOR"©
1 LVDP åHOMHODL]JRYRULWLULMHþLMHUVXP LELOHSUHEROQHQRQHNDNRVDP LK
LVSOMXYDODNUR]MHFDMH
ª,P DRMHGUXJXåHQXQDNRQãWRVDP RWLãOD©
ª' UXJXdružicu?«1 DSUDYLODMH]EXQMHQXIDFXQDNRQWHULMHþL
ª1 H1 LMHELORWDNR% LRMHSLMDQLSR]YDRQHNXåHQXXKRWHOVNXVREXL
VYXNDRVHVQMRP + WLRMXMHMHEDWLMHUMHUHNDRGDüHWDNRP HQHL]ELWLL]
JODYH©
$ GGLVRQMHNUDWNRSRUD]P LVOLODRRQRP HãWRMHþXODªý HNDMUHNODVLhtio
MXMHMHEDWL=QDþLOLWRGDQLMH"©
ª5 HNDRMHGDQLMHP RJDR=ERJP HQH©
ª9 MHUXMHãOLP X"©
1 HP DP UD]ORJDQHYMHURYDWLª9 MHUXMHP DOLLSDNMHQDP MHUDYDRLDNRWR
QLMHXþLQLR©
ª7 RVHGRJRGLORQDNRQãWRVLJDQDSXVWLODEH]SR]GUDYD"©
3RQHNDG SULNODGQR ]DERUDYLP QD WDM GLR ª' D DOL VDP R WMHGDQ GDQD
SRVOLMH5 HNDRMHGDMH]DOMXEOMHQXP HQHDOLQHVKYDüDP NDNRRQGDP RåHã
VDP RRWLüLLSURQDüLSDUWQHULFX]DãHYX©
9HüYLGLP GDP LVHQHüHVYLGMHWLRQRãWRRQDLP D]DUHüL7ROLNRGREUR
SR]QDMHP $ GGLVRQªäDRP LMH/DXULH=QDãGDWHYROLP LGDWLXYLMHNþXYDP
OHÿDDOLVDGDQHP RJXELWLQDWYRMRMVWUDQL2 VWDYLODVL-DFNDEH]SR]GUDYD
EH]VYRJDLP HQDLSUH]LP HQDWDNRGDMHYMHURMDWQRP LVOLRNDNRWHYLãHQLNDGD
QHüHYLGMHWL1 HELWHQLQDãDRGDQLMHXQDMP LRSULYDWQRJGHWHNWLYD=QDãGDMD
XYLMHNNDåHP NDNRüHãQDMXþLQNRYLWLMHSULMHüLSUHNRQHNRJDDNROHJQHãLVSRG
GUXJRJD1 LMHWHELORLP LVOLP GDRQGLMHOLWXLGHMXVDP QRP QRQLMHMXP RJDR
SURYHVWLXGMHOR0 HQLWR]QDþLP QRJRYLãHQHJRþLQMHQLFDGDMHELRVQHNRP
GUXJRP . DG MH QDSRNRQ SULãDR QHNRM SLFL QLMH MX P RJDR SRYDOLWL MHU WH
SUHYLãHYROL©
ý DNLGDQHNDNRSUHEROLP WDMGLRRVWDMHRQDMGDP LQLMHSUL]QDRNDGVDP
JDSLWDODª$ OLODJDRP LMH6D]QDODVDP VDP R]DWRãWRVP RQDOHWMHOLQDWX
åHQX =DVNRþLOD P H X NXSDRQLFL GD P H XSR]RUL QD QMHJD % LOR MH GRLVWD
SRQLåDYDMXüHVWDMDWLWDP RVQMHJRYLP SUVWHQRP QDUXFLLVOXãDWLNDNRP LRQD
JRYRULGDMXMHSR]YDRXVYRMXKRWHOVNXVREX©
ª7DNDYMHELRQHNDGD² YLãHQLMH² LþLQLVHGDVHWLQHP RåHãSRP LULWLV
RQLP ãWRMHELORSULMH©
1 HUD]XP LMHãWRP HP XþLª0 RJXVHQRVLWLVGUXJLP DDOLRYDMHGUXJDþLMD
MHUMHGRãODQDNRQP HQH' MHOXMHP LNDRGDMHWLP HEDFLROMDJXQDQDãXYH]X©
ª5 D]P LVOLRRYRP H=QDP GDWLMHQHãWRNUHQXORV& KDUOLHMHP NDGWH-DFN
SURQDãDR% LOLKWMHODGDWLRQ]DP MHUL]ERJWRJD"©
7RQLNDNRQLMHLVWRª$ OLWRMHELORVNRURWULP MHVHFDQDNRQãWRVP RVH
UDVWDOL1 HVDP RWMHGDQGDQD©
ª,P DãSURWXDUJXP HQW]DVYHãWRMDNDåHP WDNRGDQH]QDP ãWR]DSUDYR
åHOLãþXWLäHOLãOLGDWLNDåHP NDNRWUHEDãRGEDFLWLVYHRYRãWRLP Dã]DWRãWR
MH RQskoro SRãHYLR QHNX GUXJX" 5 D]P LVOL /DXULH =DU EL GRLVWD P RJOD
QDSXVWLWLQHãWRãWRP RåHWUDMDWL]DXYLMHN]ERJQHþHJDãWRVHskoroGRJRGLOR"©
1 LVDP RþHNLYDODGDüH]DX]HWLQMHJRYXVWUDQXQRUD]XP QRJDEUDQL
ª-HGQRVWDYQR P H SUHYLãH EROL . DNR JD P RJX YROMHWL VYLP VUFHP L
LVWRYUHP HQRåHOMHWLãXWQXWLXMDMD"©
ª=DWR ãWR X åLYRWX VYDNH GMHYRMNH SRVWRMH WUL P XãNDUFD MHGQRJD YROL
GUXJRJDP U]LDWUHüHJDVHQHP RåH]DVLWLWL7DWURMLFDLP DMXQHãWR]DMHGQLþNR
DWRMHGDVXVYL]DSUDYRMHGDQWHLVWLWLS6DGMH-DFNRQDMNRMHJDP U]LãäHOLã
JDXGDULWLQRWUHEDãVHVMHWLWLGDMHRQXMHGQRLWDMNRMHJYROLãLNRMHJVHQH
P RåHã]DVLWLWL©
6P DWUDODVDP GDMH$ GGLVRQGRLVWDSOLWND² L]QDELWL² DOLGDQDVQLMH
ª8 SUDYXVL=QDP GDELKELODMDGQDEH]QMHJD©
ª=QDãGDELKWLUHNODGDMHOMLJDYDFDNRELKWRGRLVWDP LVOLODDOLQLMH' D
ELRMHSUDYDP XãNDNXUYDXVYRMRMSURãORVWLQRNRMLP XãNDUDFQLMH"3UDYR
SLWDQMHMHP RåHãOLWLWR]DERUDYLWLLQDVWDYLWLVDåLYRWRP + RüHãOLP XP RüL
RSURVWLWLLQH]DP MHUDWLP X"+ RüHãOLP XWRVSRP LQMDWLSULVYDNRMUD]P LULFL"©
7RJWUHQDVDP QHãWRVKYDWLOD0 RåGDP HMHQHQDP MHUQRSRYULMHGLRDWR
GRLVWD QLMH KWLR ,]RVWDQDN QDP MHUH þLQL YHOLNX UD]OLNX ª' D 0 RJX P X
RSURVWLWLLSULMHüLSUHNRWRJDMHUJDWROLNRYROLP ©
ª2 QMRãQHP RUD]QDWLGDVLWDNRRGOXþLOD1 HNDVHMRãP DORNXKDWDNRGD
QH]DERUDYLOHNFLMXNRMXMHQDXþLR©
,EROMHP XMHª1 HüHRQRYXOHNFLMXQLNDGD]DERUDYLWL©
ª2 QGDQHNDVHEULQHMRãSDUGDQD0 LüHP RVHGUXåLWLLSODQLUDWLYMHQþDQMH
GRNRQX$ YDORQXNRUDþDJRUHGROMHSRGQHYQRP ERUDYNX1 DQMHJRYRMVDP
VWUDQLDOL]DVOXåXMHGDP DORSDWL©
7 RP XQLNDNRQHüHQDãNRGLWLª6ODåHP VH1 HP RåHVHL]YXüLQDNRQVDP R
MHGQRJGDQD©
ª1 H1 HNDRVWDQHWDP REDUHP WULGDQDWDNRGDWLQHLVSDGQHãP HNXãDF
1 HP RMQLNDGD]DERUDYLWLGDVHP RUDQDXþLWLSRQDãDWLSUHP DWHELRQDNRNDNR
]DVOXåXMHã©
-DFN+ HQU\MHWULGDQDELRXND]QL1 LVP RUD]JRYDUDOLRGMXWUDNDGDMH
RWLãDR 6WR SXWD VDP VH P RUDOD VSULMHþLWL GD JD QH QD]RYHP 8 åDVQR P L
QHGRVWDMH0 LVOLP GDELKELODSRVXVWDODGD$ GGLVRQQLMHELODWXGDP HRVQDåL
3URYHOHVP RSRVOMHGQMDGYDGDQDV0 F/DFKODQLFDP DKDUDMXüLVYHWUJRYLQH]D
P ODGHQNH X JUDGX âWR VDP YLãH V QMLP D WR VX P L GUDåH . DR GD LP DP
QRUP DOQXEULåQXP DP XLVHVWUH' LYQRMH
-DFN+ HQU\QHELELRMHGLQLNRMLELP LQHGRVWDMDRGDJDRVWDYLP 1 RRQWR
MRãQH]QD6KYDüDP GDMHP DOþLFHRNUXWQRWDMLWLWRRGQMHJDLYHüP LMHNULYR
QRVUHWQDVDP ãWRVDP NRGNXüHLãWRRYRP RåHP RRVWDYLWLL]DVHEH
äHOLP GDVHMDYLþLP WHOHIRQ]D]YRQL1 LMHUHNDRQLhaloNDGVHMDYLRL
VUFH P L MH SRVNRþLOR NDG P L MH L]JRYRULR LP H ª/© 2 ERåDYDP VYRM QRYL
QDGLP DN0 QRJRMHLQWLP QLMHNDGP HQH]RYH/DXULHNDRVYLGUXJL
ª1 D]YDODVDP GDYLGLP P RåHãOLSRVODWL' DQLHODSR$ GGLVRQ6SUHP QDMH
YUDWLWLVH=DFX©A ja
ª1 DUDYQR. DGD"©
ª% LOLP RJDRVWLüLVXWUDGRUXþND"©=QDP GDP RåH-DFN+ HQU\ELJD
SRVODRRGP DKGDMDWR]DWUDåLP
ª$ SVROXWQR 5 HFL MRM QHND JD RþHNXMH RNR GYDQDHVW© =QDP ' DQLHOD
GRYROMQR GREUR L SUHWSRVWDYOMDP GD üH YHü ELWL QD SULOD]X NDG RWNXFD
GYDQDHVW
ª5 HüLüXMRM©
1 DVWXSLODMHQDSHWDVWDQNDSULMHQHJRP HXSLWDRª. DNRVL"©
6ODEDVDP LVSUHP QDVDP VHVORP LWLäHOLP UHüLGDGROD]LP NXüLMHUP L
VWUDãQRQHGRVWDMHQRQLVDP 6X]GUåDODVDP VHª' REURVDP 7 L"©
ª8 RSüHQLVDP GREUR1 HGRVWDMHãP LLOXGVDP EH]WHEH©
$ NRQDVWDYLP VRYLP UD]JRYRURP JRWRYDVDP ª1 HåHOLP RWRP HSUHNR
WHOHIRQD©
ª2 QGDGRÿLNXüLGDP RåHP RUD]JRYDUDWLNDROMXGL0 ROLP WH©
ª5 D]P LVOLWüXRWRP H©1 LVDP VODJDODMHUüXP QRJRUD]P LãOMDWLRWRP HãWR
üX P X UHüL NDG VH YUDWLP % RMLP VH GD üX VH L]ODQXWL DNR QDVWDYLP R
UD]JRYDUDWLSDVDP SRNORSLODEH]LNDNYHQD]QDNHRWRP HGDP XVHYUDüDP
YHüQDUHGQXYHþHU
9HüMHSURãORSHWSRSRGQHNDGVDP VWLJODX$ YDORQL]QDODVDP GDMH
JRVSRGD 3RUFHOOL YHü RWLãOD 9HþHUD MH QD ãWHGQMDNX QR QHWDNQXWD MH 6YD
VYMHWODVXSRJDãHQDRVLP RQRJDXGQHYQRP ERUDYNX6OLMHGLODVDP VODEDãQL
VMDMMHUVDP ]QDODGDMH-DFN+ HQU\WDP RDNRMHNRGNXüH
7DGVDP VHSRþHODEULQXWL0 RåGDQLMHRYGMH0 RåGDMHNUHQXRXORYQD
GUXJXåHQXMHUP LVOLGDJDRVWDYOMDP ,OLQHãWRMRãJRUHP RJODELKJDSURQDüL
VQHNLP MHUQH]QDGDVHYUDüDP 7 NR]QDãWRVDGDUDGL
6UDQMH7 RVWUDKJRYRULL]P HQH-DFN+ HQU\QLMHWDNDY2 QP HYROL
6WDOD VDP QD YUDWLP D L YLGMHOD JD NDNR VMHGL X QDVORQMDþX 6DP MH
/DNQXORP LMH' UåDRMHSLüHXUXFLL]XULRXXJDãHQLWHOHYL]RU,VNDSLRMH
þDãXGRGQDLVWDYLRMHQDVWROLüSRUHGVHEH1 MHJRYãHãLUXVWLOX,QGLDQH
-RQHVDELRMHSRUHGQMHJDLSUHWSRVWDYLODVDP GDVHQLMHGDYQRYUDWLRVSRVOD
% LRMHRGMHYHQXWUDSHULFHLP DVOLQDVWXNRãXOMXLLVNRULVWLODVDP SULOLNX
GDVHGLYLP QMHJRYRMþLVWRMP XãNRMOMHSRWL' DEDUHP P RJXYLGMHWLQMHJRYH
NULVWDOQRSODYHRþL2 ERåDYDP NRQWUDVWL]P HÿXQMLKLQMHJRYHVNRURVDVYLP
FUQHNRVH7RP LMHRGXYLMHNELODRP LOMHQDNRP ELQDFLMDLQDGDP VHGDüH
QDãDGMHFDWRQDVOLMHGLWLRGQMHJDäHOLP GDL]JOHGDMXEDãSRSXWVYRJRFD
9 MHURMDWQR MH RVMHWLR GD JD JOHGDP MHU VH RNUHQXR L YLGLR P H % LOR MH
QHP RJXüH]DQHP DULWLL]QHQDÿHQMHXQMHJRYLP RþLP DNDRLVWUDK² EDUHP VH
P HQLþLQLGDMHWRVWUDK
1 LMH XVWDR L SULãDR P L 8 SODãLOD VDP VH GD VDP P RåGD SUHWMHUDOD V
þHNDQMHP
ª/]DãWRP LQLVLUHNODGDGROD]LãNXüL"©1 LVDP P XKWMHODUHüLGDVDP
åHOMHODGDVHEULQHMRãMHGDQGDQQRXãWHGLRP LMHWUXGª' DVLP HEDUHP
QD]YDOD1 HELKELRSRSLRVDP RYDMYLVNLGDVDP ]QDR©
ª8 UHGX MH -Rã XYLMHN P RåHP R UD]JRYDUDWL 0 DOR YLVNLMD QDV QHüH
VSULMHþLWL©
ª1 H ]QDP P RåH OL VH NROLþLQD NRMX VDP SRSLR VP DWUDWL P DORP ² ]D
DONRKROLþDUDP RåGDLMHVW©-H]LNP XVHP DOþLFHSOHRª-HVLOLVNUR]SLMDQ"©
ª0 RJXüHMHQRP RJXUHüLXVYRMXREUDQXGDVDP LP DRUD]ORJDELWLäDR
P LMH/6DGDYMHURMDWQRQLMHQDMEROMHYULMHP H]DUD]JRYRU² DNRVLGRãOD
]ERJWRJD$ NRVLP LGRãODUHüLGDP HRVWDYOMDãRQGDVDP VUHWDQãWRLP DP
-DFND' DQLHOVD©
ª5 D]P LãOMDOD VDP R WRP H GD WH RVWDYLP QR $ GGLVRQ P H QDWMHUDOD GD
REUDWLP SR]RUQRVWQDVWYDULNRMHQLVDP UD]P RWULOD©
ª,ãWRVLVP LVOLOD"©
3ULãODVDP P XLVWDODLVSUHGQMHJDª2 YRMHJRWRYR©
-HGYDVDP VWLJODL]JRYRULWLULMHþLNDGMHSRVHJQXR]DP QRP =DJUOLRP H
RNRVWUXNDLSULYXNDRNVHELý YUVWRP HVWLVQXRª0 ROLP WHQHJRYRULGDMH
JRWRYR3UHNOLQMHP WHQDNROMHQLP DQHP RMQDVXQLãWLWL©
ª1 LVL P L GR]YROLR GD ]DYUãLP © 3RJOHGDR P H ª2 EMDVQLR VL P L ãWR VH
GRJRGLORVRQRP åHQRP ' DELORP LMHEROQRþXWLDOLQLVLP LXþLQLRQLãWD
QDåDRMHUVP RVHELOLGRJRYRULOLGDVHYLãHQLNDGDQHüHP RYLGMHWL1 HP RJXWL
WR]DP MHULWLLSUHP DWRP HJRWRYRMH1 HP DUD]ORJD]DGDOMQMLUD]JRYRU©
ª+ YDODNXUFX% LRVDP OXGSURWHNOLKQHNROLNRGDQD©8 VWDRMHLSULP LR
P H]DOLFHª. ROLNRüXWHSXWDVNRURL]JXELWL"©
ª1 H]QDP ©3RGLJQXODVDP OLMHYXUXNXª% ROMHWLMHGDVHSRåXULãLVWDYLã
P LLRQDMGUXJLSUVWHQ©
ª=DERUDYLP RQDVLOQDSODQLUDQMDLYMHQþDMP RVHVXWUD©
0 RåGDMHVWSLMDQQRRYRJDSXWDP LVOLR]ELOMQRª1 HP RåHP RWRXþLQLWL
0 DUJDUHW6WUDãQRELVHUD]RþDUDOD©
ª3UHEROMHODEL©
. ROLNRJRGVHåHOLP XGDWLQHP RJXSRYULMHGLWL0 DUJDUHWª9 MHQþDQMHMH]D
P DQMHRGWULWMHGQD0 RåHP RþHNDWL©
3ULYLRP HNVHELª-HVLOLVLJXUQDGDWHQHP RJXQDJRYRULWL"©
ª-HVDP VWRSRVWR©
ª' REUR ý HNDW üX GR þHWUQDHVWRJD GD WH XþLQLP VYRMRP VXSUXJRP DOL
QHüXþHNDWLGRWDGDGDWHLP DP ©
=JUDELRP H]DUXNXLSRYHRSUHP DVSDYDüRMVREL% U]RVDP X]HODQMHJRY
ãHãLUVDVWRODªâWRüHWLP RMãHãLU"©
ª-HU åHOLP GD JD QRVLã GRN P H MHEHã© QDVP LMDOD VDP VH ª3LMDQ VL L
SUHWSRVWDYOMDP GDüHãVHVDGDGDWLQDJRYRULWLQDVYH©
ª' XãRQHP RUDP ELWLSLMDQGDELP HQDJRYRULODQDQHãWRãWRåHOLã8 YLMHN
üXWLGDYDWLVYHãWR]DWUDåLã©3ROMXELRP HSULMHQRãWRVP RXãOLXVREXª1 H
VP HWDWLãWRVDP P DORSLMDQ"©
ª1 H% LWüH]DQLP OMLYR9ROLP VWYDULNRMHP LJRYRULãNDGVLSLMDQ2 VLP
WRJDYROLP LRNXVYLVNLMD3DOLP H©
ª3XQRVDP SRSLR©SUL]QDRMHª1 DSLWüHãVHRGSROMXEDFD©
ªâSLOMVNLþRYMHþHQHP RUDãSLWLGDELP HRSLR7UHEDP WHVDP RSRJOHGDWL
LSLMDQDVDP RGOMXEDYL©
34. poglavlje
/HWMHOL VP R SULYDWQLP P ODåQMDNRP NRML VDP XQDMP LR ]D SXW QD + DYDMH
/DXUHO\Q QHP D SRMP D NDP R LGHP R QR YRGLP MH QD QDã SULYDWQL SRVMHG X
0 DXLMXNRMLVDP QHGDYQRNXSLR7RMHMHGDQRGP RMLKYMHQþDQLKGDURYD]D
QMXL]QDP GDüHVHRGXãHYLWL$ WHNNDGYLGLJOD]EHQLVWXGLRNRMLMRMDUKLWHNW
SURMHNWLUD* OD]EDMHRGXYLMHNELODGLRQMH]LQRJåLYRWDLQHåHOLP GDP LVOL
NDNRMHVHP RUDRGUHüLGDELVP RELOL]DMHGQR
ª+ YDODWLMRãMHGQRP ãWRVLGRYHRGHþNHGDVYLUDMXQDYMHQþDQMX7 RP LMH
ELOR SUHNUDVQR L]QHQDÿHQMH VNRUR NDR NDG P H 0 DUJDUHW L]QHQDGLOD
GRYRÿHQMHP P RMHRELWHOML©
ª1 HP DQDþHP XOMXEDYL©3ROMXELRVDP MRMUXNX1 HP RJXMHSUHVWDWL
OMXELWLRWNDNRVP RSRVWDOLP XåLåHQDª1 LVDP ]QDRGDGROD]HWYRMLURGLWHOMLL
EDNDLGMHGLKWLRVDP GDWXEXGHQHWNRNRJDVP DWUDãVYRMRP RELWHOML©
3ULQLMHOD MH QDãH LVSUHSOHWHQH UXNH XVQLFDP D ª7L VL QDMEROML 1 H ELK
P RJODWUDåLWLQLãWDYLãH² RVLP DNRP LQHQDP MHUDYDãUHüLNDP RLGHP R©
ª1 H² VP LMHã]QDWLVDP RGDQDVRþHNXMHMHGDQDHVWVDWLOHWD©-RãXYLMHN
VP RELOL]DNRSþDQLVLJXUQRVQLP SRMDVHYLP DQRVWDYLRVDP UXNXQDQMH]LQR
NROMHQR L SRþHR NOL]LWL SUHP D JRUH ªâWR üHP R QDSUDYLWL V WLP VLOQLP
YUHP HQRP "©
2 GJXUQXODP LMHUXNXª-DFN+ HQU\7 L]ELOMDQHP DãVUDP D
ª=DUVLP LVOLODGDLP DP JRVSRGR0 F/DFKODQ"©
ª-HGYDGDVP RVHGLJQXOLVWOD6WMXDUGHVHELP RJOHXüLVYDNLWUHQ©
. DSHWDQMHREMDYLRGDVHVP LMHP RNUHWDWLXQXWDUP ODåQMDND3RGLJQXRVDP
REUYX SUHP D VYRMRM VXSUX]L ª=QDþL GD VH P RåHP R SUHP MHVWLWL X VSDYDüX
VREX©
6WMXDUGHVHVXXãOHXQDãSURVWRUQRRGP DKVDP LK]DXVWDYLRª0 RåHWH
RVWDYLWLKUDQXLãDP SDQMDF6DP LüHP RVHSRVOXåLWLLSR]YDWLYDVDNRQDP ãWR
EXGHWUHEDOR©
ª' DJRVSRGLQH©MHGQRJODVQRüHRQHªý LQLVHGDüHLP RYRELWLQDMODNãL
SRVDRXåLYRWX©0 HQLQHELVP HWDORGDVHYLãHQLNDGDQHSRMDYHª0 HQLWR
RGJRYDUD©
8 VWDR VDP VD VMHGDOD L SRYXNDR QMX L] QMH]LQRJD ª+ DMGH / LGHP R
NRQ]XP LUDWLRYDMEUDNX]UDNXLXþLQLWLJDQH]DERUDYQLP ©
8 VWDODMHVDVMHGDODª7 L]ELOMDQLVLQRUP DODQ©
ª0 LVOLP GDVLWRYHü]QDOD©
=DVWDODMHSRUHGYUDWDL]DERODP LSUVWXSUVDª0 RJXOLEDUHP GRELWL
P LQXWXGDVHSULSUHP LP "©
ª' DRGMHQHãQHãWRSRVHEQR]DP HQH"©
ª' D L GD ULMHãLP NRQWUDFHSFLMX MHU VL WL YHü QHNROLNR SXWD SUHNUãLR
SUDYLOD© 1 DJQXR VDP VH QDSULMHG L SROMXELR MH X YUDW ª7DNR P H GREUR
SR]QDMHãVXSUXJR©2 GJXUQXODP HLRWYRULODYUDWDª,WHNDNRVXSUXåH(WRP H
EU]R©
ª' ROD]LP ]DWRERP ]DGYLMHP LQXWH©
ª' RWDGüXVWLüLVDP RVYXüLRYXKDOMLQX©
ª0 HQLWREDãRGJRYDUD©2 ERåDYDP MH]DIUNDYDWLª1 H8 üLüHãNDGWL
NDåHP GDVDP VSUHP QDLQLP LQXWHSULMH©1 DVP LMDODVHLEU]RP HSROMXELOD
ª6ODGDNVLNDGVHGXULã©
3RYLULRVDP XQXWUDSULMHQRãWRMH]DWYRULODYUDWDª3RåXUL-HGYDþHNDP
GDWHQDVYHQDþLQHXþLQLP VYRMRP ©
6WDYLODP LMHUXNXQDSUVDLRGJXUQXODP Hª6WUSLVHP DOR©
ª1 HP DWXSRP RüL. RQMP LMHSREMHJDRL]VWDMHLåHOLVHLJUDWLVWYRMRP
NRELORP ©3UHãODP LMHUXNRP SUHNRSUHSRQDª' ROMHGHþNR©1 LMHVHQLP DOR
RSXVWLR
=DNRUDþLRVDP XQXWUDLSOMHVQXRMHSRGXSHWXª2 QQLMHEDãSRVOXãDQ
0 RUDãSRåXULWL©
ª' REURGREUR©
6NRURMH]DWYRULODYUDWDNDGVDP VHVMHWLRGDQHP DP SRMP DNDNRüX]QDWL
NDGMHVSUHP QDª+ HM. DNRüX]QDWLNDGVP LMHP XüL"©
ª3R]YDWüXWH©
7 DMSODQMHSXQUXSDªâWRDNRWHQHþXMHP "©
ª0 LVOLãGDWLWUHEDSODQ% "=ELOMD"©
ª' D1 HP RJXVDP RP LUQRVMHGLWLDNRQH]QDP NDGVP LMHP XüL©
2 GP DKQXODMHJODYRP ª0 DMNRP LOD2 WYRULWüXYUDWDDNRP HQHEXGHã
þXR1 HüHãRVWDWLVDP GHVHWVDWLDNRP HQHþXMHã2 EHüDYDP WL©
8 GDULRVDP GODQRP RSRGL]DUHåDRª3RåXUL0 ROLP WH©
=DWYRULODMHYUDWDDMDQLNDGDQLVDP ELRVSUHP QLMLQDWRGDMHX]P HP
3URãOD MH P LQXWD D NDR GD MH ELOD YMHþQRVW 3UDWLR VDP YULMHP H QD
P RELWHOXLNXQHP VHGDVHEURMHYLQLNDGDQLVXRNUHWDOLWDNRVSRUR' RVHJQXOL
VP RGYDQDHVWP LQXWDLYHüVDP ELRQHP LUDQ+ RGDRVDP NDELQRP MHUVDP
RþHNLYDRGDüHP HSR]YDWLVYDNRJWUHQD
ý HWUQDHVW P LQXWD ]DWLP SHWQDHVW L QDSRNRQ QMH]LQ JODV ª* RVSRGLQH
0 F/DFKODQGRÿLWHLX]P LWHP H©
. YUDJX' RVWDVDP þHNDRQR]QDP GDüHELWLYULMHGQRVYDNHP LQXWH
2 WYRULRVDP YUDWDLYLGLRMHLVSUXåHQXQDNUHYHWX1 RVLODMHELMHORYMHQþDQR
UXEOMH² VDWHQLþLSNDVXMRMSRNULYDOLJUXGLDSUR]LUQDWNDQLQDWUEXK-HGYD
SULP MHWQH JDüLFH SRNULYDOH VX MRM RQR GROMH 3RGLJQXOD VH QD NROMHQD L
RNUHQXODGDP LSRNDåHOHÿD² WDQJHVYHOLNRP VDWHQVNRP P DãQRP LVSRG
OHÿD=DWUHVODMHVWUDåQMLFRP LSRJOHGDODP HSUHNRUDP HQD
ª6YLÿDWLVH"©
ª1 HP DãDQVH2 GXãHYOMHQVDP ©]DNOMXþDRVDP YUDWDL]DVHEHLNUHQXR
SUHP DNUHYHWX3ULP LRVDP MH]DOLFHLQMHåQRMHSROMXELRMHUüXVDGDXþLQLWL
QHãWRãWRMRãQLNDGDQLVDP ² YRGLWüXOMXEDYVDVYRMRP VXSUXJRP ª7LVL
QDMOMHSãDåHQDNRMXVDP LNDGDYLGLR1 H]QDP þLP HVDP ]DVOXåLRVUHüXGDWH
QD]RYHP VYRMRP JRVSRÿR0 F/DFKODQ©
ª2 ERåDYDP NDGP HWDNR]RYHã©
ª' REURMHUüHãWRþHVWRþXWL©3ROMXELRVDP MHXREUD]ª6YDNLGDQüXWL
WRJRYRULWL©3ROMXELRVDP MRMYUDWª,VYDNXQRü©
ª2 EHüDYDã"©
ª. XQHP VH©
* OHGDR VDP YUSFX L]P HÿX QMH]LQLK JUXGL ªâWR üH ELWL DNR RYR
SRYXþHP "©
ª1 H]QDP 3RNXãDM©
3ULP LRVDP VDWHQLRGYH]DRYUSFX3UHGQMLGLRQMH]LQRJUXEOMDVHVDVYLP
RWYRULRª8 SVäHQLP LMHSDODRGMHüD©
ª' DDWLVLP LVOLRGDüHWL]DWRWUHEDWLWHNLOD©
ª1 H JRVSRÿR 0 F/DFKODQ 1 LNDGD QLVDP P LVOLR GD MH ]D WR SRWUHEQD
WHNLOD©6WDYLODMHUXNHQDERNRYHLVP LMDODVHªäHOLãUHüLGDVDP ODND"©
ª1 HäHOLP UHüLGDVL]DP HQHXYLMHNVLJXUQD©
0 DNQXRVDP MRMEUHWHOLFHVUDP HQDLSDXþLQDVWRUXEOMHMHSDORQDNUHYHW
3ULP LRVDP QMH]LQHJUXGLXUXNHLSDOþHYLP DMRMJODGLREUDGDYLFHª2 YRåHOLP
RWNDNRVDP WHYLGLRXYMHQþDQLFL% LORMHSUDYRP XþHQMHQHGRGLULYDWLWH$
]DWLP YHþHUDXYLQVNRP SRGUXP XP LVOLRVDP VDP RNDNRüXWLVHXYXüLSRG
KDOMLQX©
3RJODGLODP HSRGRQMRMXVQLFLª7 LLWYRMDSUOMDYDXVWD©
ª2 ERåDYDãVYHãWRL]OD]LL]QMLK©
3ULP LRVDP QMH]LQXEUDGDYLFXL]P HÿX]XEDLSUHãDRMH]LNRP SUHNRYUKD
ª' DYROLP VYHãWRWYRMDXVWDUDGH©
ý YUVWRVDP MHSRYXNDRLSXVWLRX]JODVDQ]YXNª* RVSRÿR0 F/DFKODQ
YHþHUDVVWHYDWUHQL©
3RþHODMHVJRUQMLP JXP ERP QDP RMRMNRãXOMLLNUHQXODGROMHª-RãQLVL
YLGLRYDWUHQRDOLXEU]RKRüHã©
ª0 P P NROLNRJRGYROLRWYRMXYDWUHQXVWUDQXQDGDRVDP VHGDüHQDã
SUYLSXWNDRVXSUXåQLFLELWLQHãWRVSRULMLLVODÿL1 DSUDYLOLVP RVNRURVYHãWR
SRVWRMLLMDåHOLP GDYHþHUDVEXGHGUXJDþLMHäHOLP YRGLWLOMXEDYVDVYRMRP
VXSUXJRP ©
8 VSRULODMHSUVWHQDP RMLP JXP ELP DªâWRJRGWLåHOLã©. DGMHRWNRSþDOD
LSRVOMHGQMLJXP EP DNQXODP LMHNRãXOMXVUDP HQDLEDFLODMHQDSRG6WDYLOD
P LMHGODQRYHQDSUVDLSRJODGLODSREUDGDYLFDP DNRMHVXVHRGP DKXNUXWLOH
ª3UHNUDVDQVL1 DGDP VHGDüHQDãDGMHFDL]JOHGDWLNDRWL©
ª$ MDVHQDGDP GDüHLP DWLP DMþLQH]ODWQRVP HÿHRþL©3ULYXNDRVDP MHN
VHELLSULWLVQXRþHORQDQMH]LQRª0 LVOLRVDP VYDNXULMHþNRMXVDP L]JRYRULRX
]DYMHWLP D6YHãWRVDP ELRãWRMHVDP ãWRüXLNDGDELWLVYHWRMHVDGDWYRMH©
ª' DMHã P L VYH ãWR LP Dã D MD QH P RJX ]DP LVOLWL QLãWD OMHSãH RG WRJD
1 HNDGDVDP WHVP DWUDODOMHSRWRP VYRMHEROL² RQGDNDGVDP P LVOLODGDWH
YLãH QLNDG QHüX YLGMHWL ² DOL WL VL QHãWR VDVYLP GUXJDþLMH 7L VL OMHSRWD
SUHGDMH² MHUSUHGDMHãP LVHLRGULþHãVHRVREHNDNYDVLELRGDELP LP RJDR
GDWLFLMHORVYRMHVUFH2 ERåDYDP WH]ERJWRJD7RMHQDMOMHSãLSRNORQNRML
P ODGHQNDP RåHSRåHOMHWL©
3RODNR VDP MH SROMXELR X XVWD ,VWLQD MH MD VDP GUXJDþLML ]ERJ VYRMH
OMXEDYLSUHP DRYRMåHQL2 QDMHP RMHVYHLWRMRMQDP MHUDYDP GDWL² VYHãWR
QMH]LQRVUFHåHOL2 QDVDP RWUHED]DåHOMHWL² LSRVWDWüHQMH]LQR,VSODQLUDR
VDP QDP P QRJRGLYQLKVWYDULDRYRMHWHNSRþHWDN² GDQDVMHSUYLGDQ
QDãHJDVUHWQRJåLYRWD]DYLMHNHYMHNRYD