Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Shubhra Ranjan PSIR Paper 1 Notes Part 4

    Uploaded by

    saikumar adhikari
    43 views222 pages

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    43 views222 pages

    Shubhra Ranjan PSIR Paper 1 Notes Part 4

    Uploaded by

    saikumar adhikari

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 222

    •

    •
    4ft

    *
    % •

    4*
    VAJIMM AND RAVI
    • t

    POLITICAL SCIENCE
    OPTIONAL
    HSIW POLinm mom
    C F A R T- II )
    HANDWRITTEN
    CLASS NOTES
    2017
    \ SHU RAW \

    o
    ss
    *89

    ' 00. ’

    lOS
    ; i
    ' !
    ! ;
    is . ?
    I
    r^ a^ xisro i

    rasci^^ i
    I CL
    i
    l
    ?
    !
    3
    \

    \ QJ1 i
    s

    i
    i
    i 35 i
    *J

    14- 3

    160
    165 •

    18 I

    j
    t
    f
    t

    I
    I

    V
    t :r.

    i
    :
    0

    I
    t
    •=>3

    * *
    %
    f/3

    mi ©
    © FPOLITICAL IDEOLOQIES
    i©
    Im
    *21
    *
    a ^
    1©
    1©
    3
    ^ 0Kp3oPOtSof 3cipQ \ erO
    crates, P to, Art** ,
    -
    T - d Careen -
    ^
    —
    ROOSSGQM , \ 3g <ii
    * * .
    i

    ©Otare .
    for idea i i‘sts Moo '»S SOOQ / K\cnfal bg
    '
    Is ©
    r
    • '
    a- # fcyv idea \ Csls godetj is Rd05r to MOO -
    I

    :
    • 4

    3
    VS
    vs
    © fdr idstnists state VS prior to MaOv
    for ideo iIsts society state '£ KiataxaiyoQooic
    V3
    •

    ©
    ^
    •
    -f ’ >

    -tbS} gVe
    Tcieavists do native \ roportaoce to the R{gbts
    vi
    I©
    n© 1»-opoi+aoce tocdaties -
    t?
    m Xo ideau'sro oe seethe dovelopement of +tOo -schools .
    1©
    I
    (D Mog<3liao school P Rernoao Trad ' ti'oo)
    , -
    Yrsoo idea lists gave pdroacy to ate -
    4 ©
    .
    A

    ^
    (0)( 5) KQOtiQo school
    ^
    it5 f )
    pViroaOj to soa'etc oot state •
    '

    *r
    <D »
    ^
    £hrihsb <Scbooi (fcK btd XdeaifStsj
    ^ _
    '
    .
    o
    I ©
    I
    i© V vOto the
    josh -paotioo op
    VV
    Pbn-Hcoi id to \ iS©Q r-oay
    >v V ,'-
    0 ) oot \ecpvisro « O“0 Tot 1 ’ toiriaofsro •
    .
    • i
    °
    i
    i
    I
    v :
    v
    V
    ’
    Medial Tiroes
    1
    :

    To r edlfe/al tiroes t-bd lhe ©/ of -the Divine Rights op The


    *I .
    %%
    ^
    k' OCJS COOS pnsoro^ot '
    ^
    IheXhGD of oftviae Rights led to th>e josh Rea Woo of
    15 #%

    K
    ©
    ^
    State absoiattsro oo -the basis of TTS IOO -
    ^
    >
    ;
    ;
    i
    1
    i

    1© Sotb jdeaiisro CWide Rights jbeascj josb'Red! gate !


    cthaOtutSro bat: on d i bxeot groaods- XdeaivSf'O oo the
    :

    I»R m -
    < iSDaod of season*/ tqglc
    0
    ^
    CViv-ioe sights on the g^oood
    |
    i

    i
    !’I
    II © of ueligbo *

    ft
    Il © t
    I
    [;
    $
    5
    5
    © :

    ©
    fZ
    V

    \S
    5
    m .
    t
    5
    1
    i
    5

    5
    \

    ^
    5J555 35S£S ¥
    M
    c: i
    $S 03 \ fefs ctsG Ofeo GOu©d
    CB PoUOCQilSfe - - -v
    Vi- c?

    V4Vxi? g. u
    •
    /v?.\?.;. i

    %Qcaos© 4bey bOJ ' ve ItoaF idocx is seal fd^ coo be


    )

    i
    ^
    Understood oovtj idsougb -the US© of 'sectsoo- ©49
    .1
    &:
    v- 3
    i
    cbi
    SS: Mad e^o Tiroes f--C /

    ; Kioboro Age ( o Edsope started as a Tsesci ^T ov oocMe -


    "

    f ^oeot r, ke Reoaisgao <3G, pg bfanoaiian , fciigbteo - ‘

    roeot - ibese f oc,veroaots sstnbiisbed -Vdov wo is


    ?
    ^
    T5atiboa I •
    if mao is ^Hbnal ' • Mao cpo be 0\ven rights ,

    ai LO
    ic:
    S3 and Ube»bj.
    »4
    :?: :!
    %A
    *

    Libera \ is no Stands for © rights of wO y iV cboieogoa!


    m
    .:•]
    the -rights of K-iogS Libera isno ctoausages aatoo>rb) .
    '
    ©
    UbPxOiisTNo bas challenged oudoras T- Tscfdi +icros .
    ' •
    .1

    Lib0 X0 iisro s toot jost a fOnbOal ideolagg , it S or coa.0


    '

    i of Ufe to -Hoe oesh ’ IT i s a d-epoiog culture of oesV •


    .
    :Si
    V egt o Fu-sojpg § NJ OT-HO Aroert co together COOSH-HJ -VH
    ^ ^
    -the liberal cOo rld - Oafside <Oesf jtbdfcx is cooS>f dezred ©
    • •:i
    ^
    Os -be Island of Ube*auspo . ©
    Tii ) 1991 coold bas oottnessed Abe clash op ideologies . t e . , .
    v Ube ^a 1 isno Vs ConoroUOfSro .
    "

    o ^
    y

    '
    .- !
    •
    -1i
    Since SQp\ . QOO! Scholars dns 4a (hoc aboat 4be ,
    dash of dviiisa-Hoo - pdroa clash is bekoeeo coestera
    .
    '
    l

    ^ ^
    . 3
    :• ]
    dvi l iea+-ioo §- Bbooic -faodbcroeo Plisno - ©
    -J
    Do iggi ubeisal scholars da I rood that- libera usnr> bas
    <ooo 4be historic Baffle P ictoolcgleg .
    i
    °
    Francis RU kuycxnoQ pTsadainood Mberaiioro as -endi
    ©
    ©
    •
    T
    of wist© . '
    ntj Hocoever , IF is fco eadg 4o Spggesv- -tba| m
    :9
    •

    Libera 1 ism Is end O-f fl {stofj. /TT


    Si0
    ;1

    ^ & bbeiaiisro is 'O an cis . lbs nocbbr doalierge ©


    230 '

    -
    :V: /

    A& CibevcMisno Games


    fraro Ideologies if be cowrauoite - T r.
    ^ -,
    OiS O , rOUI t - CU lrtQ , iSrr ||Q
    S
    ^ , :

    / C to| ^
    ' 1 4 ' ©
    ©
    ©
    :.l ©

    I C£/

    #
    •Ft:
    S3 #
    - )

    X
    © Schools op Ubesotis^o -
    3
    $

    a© VV> » CooVPrccoravcj
    p 040s 1
    -3
    C
    -
    c0nKX*M
    if ^
    \<3
    ° S 3

    3 ©
    -
    3
    classical / Modern/ 30 s
    3
    .-s
    '
    3 © baiSsez. falsey ioe\ fare stave Mki *
    Social
    .»
    R ybHcaKbroa-o dale Vve libera*" Far»dQm o\aivs<r»
    • -9
    V ' 1
    . 3
    UV><?va
    ©
    3
    3
    •
    ii
    5
    hA o \(beva iic rvo
    ^ . poSV toc -
    ^
    ' ..• 2
    Classical Ub0faivsrO - WasW\ ng too. ^bii
    3
    H
    3 0
    •
    '
    Consensus
    (
    ^
    9 0y Cbnsc v
    >
    *
    3
    t
    I
    a
    ® f /ery ideology bas
    ifs Social loose. !
    ,

    3
    classical UbPYcnSno is coosicJP d as 4te idtoCQy, 0
    :5
    ?
    * C ^ f
    .vl
    i ©> ervoeigioy Bocpyeoise class - At 4tat -binoe Kiddie C\asc
    .{
    e o Utorals defended 4b>e Rights op Kao aycdpsf -the.
    ::5
    I
    Plata . "Tbey claimed liberty op Mao -psoro -the Autbo- .

    1#
    *3
    V

    I
    ' .> - *
    3 © centol value
    n
    •

    of Ubexansro
    ;i © cento1 value of Uberaiisro
    '
    \
    Mfceraj fclassfcai vieco
    ishbesfij
    ;l 3 )
    -

    - 5
    of Mao -
    I* ©
    t
    tadlifeaai isfc by rOofe e •
    •

    Mao is
    wo is PaKooai . Ra-Hooai Viao* > o Ubeioa ! (sm l3 the
    • •
    ?

    .1 <S
    .

    i
    t
    • tcao coho koocos boo -to psotec-t bis aeAf i-otexPst •

    i © r.
    V.
    4t>fy b>eicv© roao is oti i ( -bariao by Klcrto -sp
    C .
    ttacy beneve by hJatoTre -
    \b •

    r\
    MQO fs KOferiaueHc
    ;
    • * i

    ' (J Society s Q osaaHoo of Kao . society is cb oryeolc io


    (
    RoKiire - Ubexol vieco of
    • °
    © society is called cdofeacfacil vied
    I
    • c >>
    :. . C
    ;V "
    |
    tAxa-sdI og to Ube^alg -them is ootoioy c»ued coWecfiva
    •interest - Society \3 agy egate
    of XbdUviauais .
    V
    /-5
    ;!
    •

    I
    ^
    ^ Classical Cbe a I vt-etoop
    *
    .>
    a f; ^ Society JS> also boo^oo css Mtsrfces-
    y
    Madei of Codety - Society is Marl et
    ^ ptatos. cobeirp roanype
    I* c fbc ^satfefee-feo of bis toterests
    l©
    4 - i
    i
    x &
    3 Vv© --
    ‘

    $
    5.
    T
    - i
    i
    .

    *
    :
    ••
    l
    i
    \
    I© "
    i
    i

    i;
    I>:
    © \ v
    1
    t

    I8 ©
    4
    '

    I© t

    3
    1
    -
    1 ._ - ^« -^r<;rC >T 7S?
    x r3
    ' ' '

    ? ' r-:4P7T'- ^y'^<^‘


    yy>4
    Vipco Ak Stove -
    -A %| classical / 5?
    %
    state ts oecessa-iy evi t •

    Why £vi \ ? - — \ ^ * ;
    * { w,
    '
    ;

    3
    BPcaosG \ t Uroih tibpjrU) m
    &
    <?. Accessary ?
    (
    5
    o-
    Because Mao ts set fsb •
    $
    Acco-sbKoa Vo this A ieco -that the Skate is best
    ‘
    i
    1
    m a
    gc^erns^-tbe leasts - Si ore SfcHO is> necessary t-vilv skaVe
    ^
    Should pPv-torro roi oirouro -( iOCKoos - fA ' Oi roq ] p Q-f© ^
    :A What- are r*Vio\ <aai faoGh'oos; ?
    ^ m
    m @
    £3
    Fbi &e faoch'oos roeans secu-irily CgAe^Ql
    S3
    :«1
    Ct;
    v. J
    4:4,
    -;V
    and' onrdtQX
    LQCJO
    ^
    According to AdanoSroitb, State should be aretTery
    ^ Tote&oaiJ]
    ©
    ©
    . .V••I
    '
    - aOVbor 4bao CqpVo i o Jh roeaoS Abe. 'sole Qp etat© (5 •

    ^
    j bat- of a c guiattor -
    c©
    '

    I
    ^
    According Vo da icpi Ubesqis society s f o o u b e ©rgaoi -
    i
    Pc
    - Sod 00 -the ^ ©
    VV

    PMocipteof SurvAvai of ftHesb •


    @
    According to <%abaoQ iSuconer, O^oVavd VO 4bs patter
    \S cC&fQ be @
    outjbfc to be -
    e
    > I Concept of Rights /

    o ©
    3
    Wbicb Ay bis Hberais -talk about P . *?
    n
    1
    Civ / 1 aod political Rights 0
    •

    :vl

    Classical Ubesa ) vieto Ube tu 00 ©


    begaHvG GbeshTu
    -
    *
    jg absence of loter-fhjjeo ce . ©
    °? the state >4h»z>p0 AM m
    hi
    •
    QassiQa ] Utoerat vipco 00 Egogiif- j ©
    hi:!
    1 Liberals talks aboat 2. tgua 1 vty . ©
    0 TtgoaH y bQfoire lacp fcoocept op legal eqoa ity)
    -
    1 ©
    © f oaiitg of oppovtaoH - - roaaos Oqooiity of ^oetfare -
    :-.v
    $«
    .
    •A

    ^
    Mere Egoaiity of uOej irerOQaos Qgocs) oppcnrKsof-hy -\o
    ' c

    p:.
    be happy j Qcpa \ opportunity to earrs
    pYopes h) ^
    ©
    teconoe Jsicb •
    U
    ^ ©
    ©
    ©
    p
    Vi
    Cd
    m
    SSi
    0
    STd
    1

    @
    r::;:

    . /J

    A
    iY « '« -, ^ « •* «> •' * * *
    -
    + bi concept- of -eqooi f -ty r
    ~-M '

    i/JbaV McronSts
    ~
    &oy 5
    11 & aquoiity r
    & i s a PfOceduTsaI -E uoirty a ^
    . is
    '
    S
    :t3
    1© -\be coroe SQ
    gquau'-kj according
    ^
    , seCv^- *-
    MQ *ists
    ,
    * o \ epaait'-fa.j Cs
    ^
    1©
    :ti
    y social aod ecoooroic -
    C
    ©
    *”

    /:*
    iy
    classical Liberal Rnodpie of Jus-Kce -
    4® principle of X 'ce - vst^esit - pecoa-cd should be < o
    :<
    i
    K
    C
    m ^
    accD^daooe to -tbe Merit -
    .i
    ? © UibaL i‘S -Vbe GDocepI- of Merit WlbOf Is +be ciLffe COc ,
    ¥
    bcfoeeo Merit aod talent ?
    "
    - ^ ^ ^
    1^ '

    1© \f
    ^crit , is. a soa'ai <330 oepV •
    cseot inQpodaooQ io d / -ff? eot talent -
    oiff^
    sen V ^sodebes gives cA ( $f-
    1i # *
    ! c ;
    R aVioo bip BeKoneo Ubesb) and fc payibj ?
    ^ ^bore POQSKQS
    : J

    1:i # Ubedy Socfoeoo -


    ^
    ACCCnrdlo 4o 4-bero } £ eFfatfte' c$w£ Toads +0 bri znca
    1i m
    5
    ©
    ^
    eqoavrty in social ftoooroic telcos
    ^
    Liberty . ibMS eqv^aiftuj is ootidbeJH’ax! -te) Liberty .
    uce
    1t ©
    1m
    c According 4o '{-hero ^ Absolute Q oaiif-j is injustice..
    ^ -
    ©
    V

    i LA
    (©.- KJ
    *

    - •

    j ©
    r' - ,
    j
    i
    <<v
    J
    -
    i
    c
    ©
    t ©
    >v;
    5
    5:
    A

    Il f *
    i ?
    l
    \
    l: ©
    S
    i
    I
    5 r

    s
    1
    |© {

    1©§ s
    ti
    % ;
    ? ©
    i
    '£
    ie
    5 -
    m &

    1©
    :
    »
    &

    aI
    © &:
    >

    1© h

    !©
    1
    { % 1 1<
    5
    5
    -
    /
    8
    C
    T;: P
    V- cv:.
    :•:
    1
    /

    dberaifef 'o hove boo types 09 ’•


    , ©
    r.~
    (?) Those cobo racs/desed Liberals qra bdggiog too roach
    V-
    c;.:
    *
    •
    charge They -sesfetedi charge & they raera called as
    •

    a conservatives ) Qigbtfest •

    rtov
    (u) Those echo consider that Obecau'sra is. ° t pxog'Yesshe
    "

    :o °
    Q^oagh - cLT Should roov© Tcnrraasd ~Thc\ eDexe koooo t-;
    )

    •
    fZ'
    j
    . y

    j as le-ftiest ?y later 00 socialists - , .*%•


    *

    #
    J idega-bve Uberau'sra changed ioto positive lib • P
    1 Ubexoiiono developed ioto boo trac ibiao 1 Chiaosicaf ) ©
    © Matasai Rights Tad itfoo Tobn lock ©, Tbonoao poi oe
    •
    ^
    -A © Ob' 1 ita-ua o Trad \h 00 n praotedlcy Boothano 4
    % ^ -
    xc?
    oH 1 i+oviaoisro coas The Tseaaoo that t- jbeScaUsm canoe #
    - under challenge 35- raas XS HIM «Obo tded toraodi
    cT 1
    I -
    ObUtadoois^o - XS - HUM iSQ Star£bic5g oo the crass ty
    @

    1 raacls op Klegaitve aocj Positive U bQiro


    <

    t isro •
    ©
    4
    V - I Ubecaifeno raas -parced tp change becaCBe Crp social (st ©
    . *

    challenge - The P phi locopheir rabo cao be CaosfdesGd Q


    .

    •
    l
    T
    8
    i
    as t\)G liberal is TH cpreen .
    to dehoe Liberty jo ternce op He raas.- the pcssoo ©
    capoertg He ts hooeoo £ >
    . .5
    - s; cis father op positive
    liberty -
    •
    .
    • :i
    i
    . •

    X
    ?
    i.
    0

    —
    HscO dossiers I Ub0ra \ fsra raas changed veto Hod
    :::i£
    '
    '

    J
    era Ub ? C
    •
    PeaSOQ Challenge pYOro SOCiavisro .
    < i .. .
    .J
    *
    •

    1
    pbeg have irepbisTiQed Libe&ai isra by bringing Concept
    "

    ^
    i
    1
    * ideoMsro. xdean'sro actually Sbay
    ;d
    OY < ^ many assuropHoos
    concepts oitb S3da \ fsTa Vibe boporfaoce op .
    @
    -
    CL;

    1
    collectivity .
    ©

    v .i
    -.- f
    *

    f-c
    ©
    T

    :vi5
    -Vi
    ©
    @
    --
    S
    y
    <C -
    y-

    T #
    i s ;-
    @
    -
    y'
    rr
    e* •>:
    ;t

    •••• TraXTXX
    &
    - 53
    1©
    I©
    Care value —- Ubedy .
    Hocoe er tbcy bave rede-popd +be coocept cf Ubertrj
    /
    i

    Negative UbQrty becanoeposlinve - VQ coas bey -


    :? ©
    •2
    ©
    ^beo state i0ten*e oes 1' t does not reduce Ubesr-ty
    'lOtber ( obooce

    v"
    fvp Kbeyals
    Liberty . Ibsoucjh Liberty is CQpacity .
    f: .>
    '1
    c
    Vc
    V
    X
    -
    - © > Progressive vieco of rooo y /
    I>, §)
    tor tbPro t^VDO IS moral /•§- etbiGal
    - ^ eiopet^eolQi vtootMa^
    >
    - i

    i
    •v

    ::s
    © > Ifiefr concept of soo’ etb
    society i -S {mpo*toot , TT3
    i
    1 ©
    61 §~ CQOOOI- be coosfcieKeJ just
    aO aggregate Of £bd iV duo y
    •
    © > TBeV concept of slate
    S ate is> 00 o t'-vo +icso
    #
    ^
    - rcpod Ufe -^ ' -
    of \Jhstue s3afp \s oecessuay
    ::f
    of
    1 • $
    %
    D > ^
    TBehr concept of Justice
    •"V

    ] © Jbcy beiieve -that liberty coo be baiaoce cottb e o.U‘ty .


    1i ©
    I TO og -tfoe baiQocpfbere is o °eed tear QfVnoa^-b' ve
    °
    OOhoo Or positive diSOrinoiOab'OO fO ©IvoU 2
    '

    establish eve! p\ay> iog fteid »o the society of ^


    ?
    1
    i © oeat to
    1-
    n '
    fbsvfvp liberals -laves
    • o

    iospi '?oti’oo fxooo bnoaoaei koto©


    : Co r* toot
    :
    f Co Ftemve ** ° F +k*oai OigOlty
    ° •

    c Hb U bpr- .
    also give importance -y dgoty along
    A
    r .
    VO ° fj
    © j
    !© •

    *
    i
    X5
    t
    . m
    1©
    1
    k
    i
    b
    o
    I*-- ©
    r
    >
    <
    sc
    ?
    - ©
    'C -
    I
    0
    ©
    Fc
    5 ©
    >:

    \
    I ©
    $
    ;.
    ©
    5
    F
    ©I
    |
    s

    :
    f
    lecture. xf *'
    4
    m
    &
    svx.
    m a *
    0
    T- H - £REt>J 0
    © 4 j oi |2ofj
    id
    i
    J
    !
    (free rds v/ ieo op Uberbj - ©
    I

    i
    Si
    ©1 Uberiy (S the capacity of doing sorae-t-biog coartbda / ong% (B
    Ao .individual is fee oog tobeo be bas capacity to ©
    f!
    \ pH flit -tbe lacO Of bis bei .v 0
    ,)
    :)
    I
    °3 S
    I
    T w Gj'seeo cs
    1 * 9
    t * pevSoo to de- liberty uo of foe
    (
    Opacity . io dossil Ubc lsro Uberty been m.
    53
    -
    ipl
    dejpoPd Q ^
    3 absence of votc^DEREINCQ by tbs
    ' ©
    Hotoeuer, 4bis> concept of Ubedy ved to the ooploita Hoo - i

    4be *009063- CJQ&s; QDI ©


    UbOiOijorc? ConoCLModes Cwi -bCfQJvp
    -^
    '
    ! -&r ( ts \o hu'ooao nohj a

    -4 *
    ^
    33- teas t fiU coho Pried \o
    eftffoe utility . Roof d »i| could
    not 9 ® the. ideec of Eve
    *

    - >cy
    r '

    liberty. 3f Hoas afford *

    ft"
    ©
    •* «
    con ce fdcaiids .
    | of tue U testy . tue liberals dm
    >b Ttf freco <cbo gade
    ( i
    /55?
    r.'
    •

    •Crocmu-ei
    tosptwsd by fv,.
    tont ©bo talks about haroctn dignity .
    According to ru .CfrQ©
    Ufcertu is eornetbioo <©}©s4t) doing
    cdn'Ch iS apprtate -for^ buroQoS ©
    . s
    bunoao digoViy. He ate epege s- liberty CdoocAr be-Ogaiost t
    fat cebeo state totesvemss
    i

    ;
    *
    1

    i/
    *
    ^
    opacity Vxii idfoqof
    boas% ff bond net de
    Seated ©
    ^
    05
    c
    /r -
    Ub
    ^
    V£
    isa dlf
    *•

    fCMiag a ^'gbfe bas e to be


    $ .
    ‘

    ^ \ n fights aocf ipnce ©


    J
    < 2
    •

    ooig f a 05 *0
    /
    afversdUu available
    aojcg eights ?a ff vitedge . cf
    i
    . cr
    Q
    r>

    ©
    v
    \

    <v
    ©
    /

    . ) ©
    Vizi

    ©
    :.
    *
    0
    ©
    •. -3
    j
    i ©
    © ! ©
    1 ts
    ~

    u. m
    a;;
    :r<
    i ft
    (
    vi

    i .-
    VV T,
    ^ - Iv.Cy
    ' V ’/ .<
    ...^. uwvoae-aaa*^- 5
    0 s
    <5 II?
    "
    0/
    }o £ c 9 3 ;
    v>
    ft
    M *
    ft
    i•s
    55
    0 v 3
    ?
    S ? io 8c
    n
    tc
    Qy
    3
    ‘>1
    '!•
    &
    i.
    G
    0/
    e ^ rS
    J3 C f QJ &'
    &3
    4
    Q)
    a Stf 0 ---1* GH > *p ^ 1
    JO
    3
    ,
    >• * 5C/) Jig I54
    Ql 2
    S3
    2 Q) v 5: LV > £
    H«0 1
    1 $ C i° *
    .%
    ~
    #H
    *
    p § •
    54
    §
    50 \ e
    QJ 1
    s 2^ 2 Q 5
    ?V i
    P
    8
    8.JO,n_ *.
    • 4T
    •

    £Hi
    S>5
    &5
    V
    50 -£ y
    <0 .CT) tt I5
    *c f
    (f) „
    « ;
    iax< \
    .
    3$
    0 >: 1
    0
    a
    $
    .
    ec s9 4? »
    ;j
    $
    a
    ti
    g - Co 50 Kv
    £3
    ^
    £ jcn
    6 '
    a

    fey
    iV.i
    ;rj
    &
    :‘v<
    $
    15
    '
    &
    ,-
    f .>
    ;>
    *J
    *
    - ..
    TT ; ;•
    & # © © @ © # ® © ® ®
    .
    fii
    H
    0 @ c: © © .
    ^^
    *
    ywwoiiwuew*
    © © 'vwwwwm' ^ ^
    ;
    - J j
    •
    /f ? ,' vi > v V w »•'< < w <y vv^
    ,
    ' ,0’
    A 0-‘
    ^i
    - -‘- - ‘- '' '
    5H
    (
    w © © K , ^' ~ '
    , >W '
    ' '' ' ' ''" v ’w
    basis op -fbe state # >
    e B -the
    kill ) OOf iotCQ
    —
    &

    -
    yj
    ©-
    T - H q meo ©
    r
    ^1 •

    • M4
    Xbcxes\ c*te-n©f> -fsaro T- vk ©tesos besot p*nocipe>
    '
    ©
    © Of poa'-foai oblgart-ioo '. ©
    ©
    citaaf - is fbtf -baai obligaBoo ? #
    I
    . *» '

    ffctaa ' pies op fbl - oblipQ -H oo ten the basis op 4ba


    '

    ©
    autborttcj of Hbt> Slate on T OSOOS oJrfj people sbetabl
    c?

    $
    cte -fbo state ^ ©
    ^ •

    ©
    OTSQ
    _
    slrxo Hbe Htnoeof ptate
    ^ An totte polecat sebobus
    ^
    plvrog tb-e pnoc/ ptes op political obii a-Koo ©
    ^
    •

    | '
    ^3 poops should be obliged focoQ^dls astarte,.
    ' ©
    ©
    V
    AarrccPiog io piato § AiristaHe because , state tS O . • ©
    a
    Soq-isce op vi?rtae §- ^oa caooot tecta cx pexta b-fe
    r.'-
    ©
    tfdtbout a state3•
    V
    41
    V

    -
    O'
    /i

    j?
    f
    9ate
    v ^
    AcaaYdtag Ho j ecBp , r03O ncud obey 4be> sferVe because
    provides security op ^ U-(e . ©
    Aoco-sd leg -to locte Mao boaad obey etate becnasQ
    >:4
    1:*

    -
    ;J
    Sfcfte isQrocs/GS, Hbe lo corjviofspces evrsHog iO itte. ©
    state op nature • Hooever , cocte stooits tee scope op 0
    authoonty of state a
    fOusseciu mo should obey state beerxuss
    (
    .. J
    DtDS of state -sop-ssseots the Q©oexa| < pfl ( * 63
    :i
    '
    \ Wage! State is roQsdb of (qpdl oo Barite 3
    ::»

    V
    1} Hr oos ban Btaax <tebo ebalieoged tee oocateg op ©
    - 1I
    •
    i
    !
    -
    Hte state MQY?C (tDiis He* aevoiutfoo agpiost tee stated e:
    not obhboi-tfQo tecoqrds State - ACCPadCogopta toa?nc state .ts 6) -

    iosbunaeot op Cbesetaq -xf is a sautee ecploitabion


    :: {
    .A
    .-
    TiA pKebo cootrad fds tee vfQoo teat- a state 'crepreseot
    rH
    :-;1 •

    forte ' IIYQ poasseau be believe op teat state 'ceptesaqts m


    m -tee co\ i|op people ibese fe
    , idi ! - he people -por -toe
    {
    Sate Because state pesdaroos voaoy eaepu -ptoGfiHoos - rp
    I ,

    .I
    ‘State Hiadev Hhe tfodteJoGes pr H -Gseeo) abe fact
    -tbat Stfite \ > ooo-ptbuiog
    e Hbe^re bars been no r*evo ~ o
    ;: •
    lufioo aba-vost tee state ghoo tbaf \t te MOM I oat
    1 -faros -that- is tee baste cp - o state
    ^
    s -
    •

    ©
    - •1

    1 ©
    @
    5
    ©
    ?•
    @
    £
    @
    vj

    -v
    J
    ;'
    V i pr 5
    s - 5
    >i
    Si
    © iS
    *
    1 ® ,3
    s
    ';i s
    1! i
    i
    3 © 1* ,
    5 l
    3!
    ©1
    !
    it ©!
    3
    I I
    1
    3 32
    3
    ©I
    I l
    m|
    >
    i
    • sjspo /
    5
    3
    OGJO^O SO - O -}ipo ao-CD
    ov o!
    3 I -«2wXiS :ip !O0 ) ?QSrSfc©Cu Of|AE S ^
    ? pdo n pCV\0\ 0J3o>JJ) dK
    ^ )
    ^ •
    © js
    j ^ easo Sii) CM q-saqo d p do j 6 © < jjeAd3 oq^
    ^ >
    - -pcQ ^qv Aa- t?
    '
    ^ ^ * # I
    aq-O S ~odO \ > \op &< lSOo> J S ^
    ' qScHQ*J o» iqnd Go jSDa«crr I:
    ^ ^3
    '
    ro cojv+ ifol 9qv Jo sisuo do SOo q- CD jpcjp ©|;
    !-
    .
    i
    d /TDDCSU jv- jfen Jo 0)su© Ropo #|
    r
    jS
    }JO ac © JV •
    \ 3
    E ^ °f po r*oa . 5’
    f
    ^ aqo^ asm^ SSf d° ^
    •£ • £ i ^ O f-
    ;
    ,
    J it
    •
    ( /©.
    •
    ooqqpAS . SBiqp SopPOcn P OAO
    * ' '

    _
    pi PCD S0 uqoncD a ^apacp Jd
    Xto? s.pq- Qx &SD0 paBp /ALRJ japori aqp o
    "
    © !.-
    - * .=
    -TTDoB JOTOCB apAOX, Of SoKjTOR- l Q i /7^ot>CM sa. csp\ a}
    '

    ^
    a lacb pc ebpo sauijoncD cua DTP
    ^
    &qo-rco CXRO O^ aqv Oi, paRbeqo aj-t S Jo OSOfCCl
    ^
    ^ ajM
    ^ __ ^
    ^
    J!
    © iE.
    . f
    »
    ^
    -aqv Cvjpj oV© to O) sjspo § - H3 ©
    H iiepos of asuodsax or ^ J- ! - V.
    3
    • * ^ . © I:
    ) f> .
    <a+o\s acqp cooj aoqsbf -paeUs> - jCXXOD
    ^
    S%3?Voi • 35Dp O lOd-Q 'OcQ sqp Jo aofBOu OJQ3 aA
    ^ Rix&xB © v;-
    ^ £
    sqv Q ' xsfru @
    Jo <sp*co? aqv QX - sst>p jai 1 cjjcto
    soxop 501 § seep 1
    Jo qsatXe>fo* aqv of saav^ooo 00 © l
    5) 3fp IV
    qsjiofdto oJo qaaoam so of Rujpaccov '
    .
    *'
    ^ ^ - JVtds aqv oo Ooaisod VXPV4 ^ <
    si 4tDCf
    © KLg : ;"
    > © £ -:
    0\ S3D04 i
    )
    • apJS a lJioC^ J
    •
    ^ ° ©AtJJOCO V
    Qo O<3A\ 6 qdaoooa v> s» vr I
    •
    '

    -^aqcH ^o\ocp -I ASDCM ©!


    - 5 •
    '
    ^ ^ :-:.
    - ^ q- jfen 00
    S svo OOHDCU ^ +<oc^
    ^ 0 !-: ;.
    s
    • aopj Of # r V
    S- -
    qojqp oo.qoou j,'6a~i JP ;
    -TXZQ sj \
    J Im
    t-
    J0o ocps IXACVI - CBH m
    v'©
    '
    cb>ocv aqp oaAiGsoq ^ta^aqoH - S¥K :
    -
    ^ socea J t
    a:
    0 © Jfois aqp HP3 1
    - & ’ '
    • p Qp
    ^ ^ UiCP X gSos peouoAg
    ^- SO po© © S&-..:. K
    ^^si a^ aqv ©foqap. ©di
    osaq j) ooac? jaq t . »c
    0
    foo op sp-j^jui % ^ ^
    Accoidfpg to HabQwaois
    "
    g
    ( j£ \ Vi o
    happenscslq / s #
    is based o>o 2_ Cbotxad rctovcj
    -
    ir
    0

    £3
    boceiose coGl ave state £ -V
    v|
    J
    1
    • •
    !
    psinciptes:
    " ^ : ©
    © .SbCjaiigno \ o
    '
    pOli -h'CS
    @
    v;
    a
    .-. t
    © -
    Cq pi ta ifsnQ VoRDOonoia, -
    to Ovoid osevoiqHoo staves io Oett extended (cpt to
    ©
    ©
    vcte to poovs - ho OK6QY to 9eh‘ MCH©S -£*OOQ t^ -be_ pooag,
    @

    -
    . political parties have to rnate psoroises pa - -
    <dck07ress povev-y .
    70 fail Pal psoooises - .te
    - — ©
    ©
    s Keep on
    oat of eoooovod - TSSe gerqpb of Oepec attoos
    ^ ^ ©
    .sfoese iso. Ucdt do cchJct) etcocovpH
    Cao fvoaoce ndq t a ca vita proararos. 4 tooodo
    ©

    A N ^NbackO of
    ° |
    I P isC toMiog T -foaoae Hence, the on u olpWoO
    • \
    ©

    % . the state .
    tack social spcurt' bj ft is
    cx State soUs
    *

    bmcd b spffer fhoro -the


    uobQo
    @
    I ories of I gittroacy.
    ^ fveo caeitatwe state ts not -the
    osb-Hao dor the cootrad CGHbng ©
    < io capitQifspQ -
    %
    • i
    !
    ©
    i
    1 #
    O ©
    -
    ..
    ..•!'
    Vi
    ; m
    . Ti
    ©
    ©
    :s ©
    ©
    .: i #
    V;
    @
    •
    r -1
    Vi;

    :; i
    : •
    ©
    =1 ©
    n @
    1 -Vi
    \t
    3
    . ©
    m
    .

    •• ;

    : .<
    • 1
    t
    ©
    i ©
    ri
    ©
    *3 " AC>

    • y
    ©
    @
    , i ho clnomce. of
    M "
    A- L/\s k l C o m f i v t ESCOM

    II ©r fotroducfioO -
    • LosM Koo -for fdodft Hebru •

    ^ °F XoSpi^
    .
    1
    !©
    \
    cOas sou Q

    © bask-' coas positive Liberal cottboobaust leaoiogS


    ' -
    3
    &
    \Me attribute -fabiaO soa'aiisra to -VOQ idgos of
    '
    Lasi-ci •

    1©
    KlgWru s'
    Soaiaifst / c pattern of Xodfao Soa eJk) is
    '
    1i:3 ©
    .
    S tftqQnced by Lasld .
    I© IOSWJ has giveo tbe elaborate ©St of soo'ai cxad
    1
    © •ecooonoie ^
    ^sights to be provided by tbe Stats x>
    .
    "

    1 * Pbtft is: Of Xbdi'ao Cbnetitattoo <^Ncb ^omos ocioj


    r\1

    -1 •

    i
    I Soc/a| § Gcoooro'lC3 bights ci itQ i ofMeoced by laski -
    , '

    t1 #
    •

    13 ©
    • v j &vety ^a4e is koodooby the fcjgbts vt MQfotai’ o - v
    ;
    -1 #
    |Pf 3b\s are -those coodP-foos of U{© coi+boat cobfeb oo
    k © j rx3ao 0:10 -Steeh To genera ) to Be at ts© its test *» •

    4 •
    '
    £c
    * ©
    ^ Tbe social crsdpr coWcJb iis ooV based OQ clajnos of
    ’
    i

    44 ©
    3
    persoo (3 based oo ib>e spcod
    i ©
    :. £
    * Bight s a.??©
    claims bat cot erep+y
    ^
    © ;•
    c, r Wtaor eta+e of duties 55
    eh ouid ,' ,
    1 px
    Q)I can +be^ stater01 **
    °" CqF to iste
    5 (xX © Approach op Laski
    T:
    •
    -
    Kieape 'baosi+i'oo is lasbh ideas . XbWaUu lasbi esas
    ©
    ii
    advocate of liberty . HiS -psrooas booth is gTfatroroe r
    1© of (Jberb - Latepoo be got Inspired by tb© arbieve^ -
    y
    1@ roeots of USSR - focoovep be becanoe disappointed
    .

    % because Soviet Sjsteno denied Ubertu . tie oa?noe Vocacetc .

    ; Ufaoattero bat remained Pbercti earth soddiioHc tern -


    logs - Lash toootsd state to tate> up ^the oqpacft
    ;

    ! f y\
    I ©
    building tctsbs , 'iDjtexvQoe. lo ioddSteg oo behalf of cOQf
    > .•

    i© 'ers Tsegavab’oo of cooYkiog ‘boars aDQyps prrvf 'cit'r ^


    '

    i
    #
    © •ers to roar£xg© ro0otr - ^
    ^
    beoef ts like noatproity Tsplfe e, parb'cj'paboo of aooQrh- ^ i

    ©
    © >
    l
    \
    Q I*
    t
    ?
    © \ (•

    t;
    © {,
    ft
    © I
    f
    ©
    gSgS5SBJS35w ®>*
    *
    m
    gs las Id toaol-od -ffoat .eldfp should
    Q StOro
    roa ( o -fa < o tbe.
    of 'taghtS HS Qto
    ^ ' :
    dbaf 00

    -zdgbta^ is -
    Offgbt duf es oxe ttStf 3|ated
    1he^ruj ^
    Ifence ~
    orcj of !
    5
    roiled as fuochboai -
    of mghfe " .

    ^
    -.v~
    ' '

    capitalists hay© - ngbt io r cHce p&o|ft , bo. also @


    bas/e duty ta tQi e^ aw ^
    3w
    , •

    ^ Of fp? oeilbaioG ? ^ ) of a
    ’ '
    :

    1 ©
    M

    Kl:
    ©
    1 @
    C
    r

    ;
    5
    •V
    •//.
    .

    i
    ..
    v
    ©
    •? -:
    ©
    i v
    •*

    .•..v
    . -
    *».

    v
    »
    e
    /
    ©
    r •
    ;
    .•
    ©
    a_
    Vi /

    .. .i
    0
    .!

    0
    ;
    6
    V/
    v.
    -
    ©
    0;
    i-> Xr

    i @
    .-.•To
    '

    c
    :: H
    c
    !
    £§
    .- • !
    -
    0
    Si
    vr
    ©
    >
    '
    • :
    §
    Vi
    -
    v::

    I
    S3
    m
    •

    L
    to t g g o s 3 - *

    ; si
    53
    *
    fg)
    Ub<?rai ISO '
    Cl 9!os
    r
    .
    s
    f>-S'

    •
    ’
    08
    ir © \ srry ?
    .
    id bat i'S dg ” \ rfce O I
    .

    ©I > ° ^ rOcaTtSt
    pS b?^o tA0f ) \ ;b0rOM \£rQ \s>
    ico

    1s ©
    ••

    vS
    5
    : S? XrTS
    Itdeo
    ^
    \^oGt±a \ \srO '
    i

    bercHlsro fo on / toe revival oF taCssGS


    ,
    V

    • •

    :-£
    ii' ^
    roore iobunoao S on'PotQd
    .%
    : i.
    c © -fdi*e state But ft fs
    -
    to^oatots market -taoo class 1 aal Liberals -
    :
    *5:
    .
    .5
    x
    5
    ©
    Market as cx principle.
    7
    t ( • classical Ubesak sasgesfed
    ; .
    * 1 ib scoooroi'cs but- Kieo Uherbs have ttopaoded tbe
    —
    '
    Vi
    '
    4
    :-ri
    # I tcawket principles io ’ ai aspsctsop ' • They pspje

    '
    5
    •

    5.
    :5
    7.
    © 1 cted Mcratet as Qod . '

    I © MQ3 Ub0fdiisro i'S tost d@_


    :d '
    libe aj aod roast -ganda
    •
    5
    •

    *t ©
    I roeotaiisra c*s favds toarhOf is* > oaoeeroecF -
    # > [ Vribi) SigCr I ' bgyQifSrQ caooo ?
    § © lb 1970 J M@o- libooifero -past came \o ©store
    •
    I©
    1•
    caroe do bo Q oa'ated cottb -tb© pottoi<ss of
    MQ-
    >
    ^
    07- *

    ^^^ Y feTbcitber Qr is also


    3
    called as Tbatoberisro .
    •

    i © •
    «
    : ,S
    I© do I980s it coos adopted so OS / under
    5 \ Ronald Pesagan
    Heocp, it is also called as
    ! ©
    i
    < Peagoooroics •
    :

    J
    k /[batcher beiorp to conservative RQ3tt| § pociop
    0 beioo
    V
    V
    -to PfepubliCQo pQdy
    .

    •
    *
    ; .H0OQP Meo u' besQ 1 fero (On ^
    i.

    =
    Vv
    deo- 'dgbtigwo. not- be dteHogufobed ftoro
    r: 1
    i cv Heo - Uberaifsno co^e because roei-fans otaV<9 becanoe
    j
    ..<•
    © uos-i^Q ' cable - lAi© i-[dir© State \o the <-oes&eiro counties
    .‘i '
    v
    Vsas 0iTDcCOtp*tfe» big . Jf caroe to be knota>o
    © f
    cus 4 Kkaoou
    5
    bate aoas expected to tote case op the person
    '

    ^
    '

    1© i p«3rn> o$odle to Grave. -


    !^
    \
    3avs dotted SHTebop -foro fiscal Defat Hence it uoas, ,

    © adviced that state has no option bat to L


    Ron ©act. - s

    P
    I©
    \
    5

    i
    5E

    !: ©
    >
    \

    1© i
    \© i
    |
    l
    tI ©
    -?5:
    !©
    f
    I©
    !
    >

    2 ©
    I

    ^OTS^s^^** * 1
    5
    © gaassssass
    ;
    a-
    toVtfoduced ;lp Bdtolo +teo
    io dsA .
    'STi

    l ib \ qdO-5 (tcoas +byOcJ0bc lt


    exploded
    ^> -

    S
    v
    0

    2, bg \ ggos feo - \ {b©CMfsrO ^


    XT-
    &
    lofxodacpd as shock T ejrqy (p -

    ! -tbe GetobO ' It «-OQS


    COoOfTOcxov’sV CDuoto ' B Xk axis 0
    •

    Russia aod other '


    3 as st^ructU'xa 1 adyustroenV
    irdrxodcJtced pogroms \ o Xbdia - 0
    QfXj obQV -psvri uSctfd touotwes - ffe ffioolustoo of
    "
    0
    do
    O U0 UtOLU _ Tjouoda of la IKS led to tbe
    - esotalteWtneot #
    1
    ••

    *
    Of WTO in 99T
    -

    pHodpGS '
    of tfGO Vb^chfsro conbG understood . ,
    ©
    .
    ieo poiote coasbiogtoo atosonsus proposed toy Jono
    J
    I
    v - 'I
    .1
    :r,i
    •

    ulii \ i arosoo ©
    m •

    #
    m peducWao fo focal OPfcit ' ©
    1!) pro- loduseMj -tax vb amos -
    ^
    \ \ \ vJo lodiscwaake subsidies oo \ y -\axgetod pso gpocotb
    -
    :- 1
    ::r.
    *

    v :- j
    Sohsidi ® -
    Qg Market debar rc&oed vcftevest rvako&
    _, ‘
    m
    ©
    © pac*~oc to exports-
    •

    i;. Ccxcpe-ti kive Bccbarge ro\95 to


    Sr
    0
    Trade IfbexdiiQQfoo - by 'spdcidog Kodffacd OOO
    • v
    • '

    tortfp bartnQirs 5
    @ PtonoQHoo of FDt ©
    •
    •
    ?
    I
    (vpl asIovoStnoeoi: of P00s . i ©
    ® be soguks+tbo
    '
    . ..
    o
    ©
    © ftoteoHooto Pgbt firope .
    to dg '
    .
    •

    I
    '
    5
    ; m- v- y

    »
    p FVoroiOPOI . pbi ICGOpOesS OP pgo fbexci isno - - ' fr ? -

    (a Moyek
    -
    r-;>
    :,y
    (

    © tobptfb Wasick ©
    © rT -fOO Pded-rO>00 %
    Tl

    ) Xso ib
    ' ' O ©
    ?0 bbo sd
    + m
    © Murray 1 “

    %
    \
    m
    <&

    -
    £3
    I
    ©
    - -.
    •
    '
    I
    ©
    ©
    @
    :a
    m
    S' : m
    m
    * ©
    >; :- 1 m
    ©v
    :- •’
    iccRgvg. ££
    i HAVE X
    © L 6lo \ |2Dp
    pi
    © Mis boon CbOSH +U hOO
    - - ' Op btoe5

    pe is considered css Fo
    1* © r of sieo libera \ fsoo QOc a
    ^
    .•
    :;
    secure© of i oftuso ce on Ibafcber • ^
    13 pe coas orib'c
    if-X of certranged planning. He called
    V
    :
    ’

    Co
    .-- pianoirx QS bnS<olot-fan
    According^ fa bsro
    ' -5 -
    N >
    Ooescfse te' touod -to fail .
    J^na-rt
    EVOO -VbG roost
    >
    ^
    ^ based ailOcaKoo i'S bQSV 1

    1© CotelMcjent
    iibo pHon@" cannot Afdob .

    ® tdarkef
    Scp -Pno tOhiCb M<arneb is like CK ceotsa ) nervous
    1@ ^
    froe
    030 intercept -
    roiiiioosop nDessapes afa
    © Op ts9SOu s ,S 001H
    (4TSXPS
    ^ through tocbrfefs ^ 'XGSOUtfcQS ctodl 026

    Il ©>
    : ( .

    ! 1 HayeK opSocial Justice


    i
    Justice is Mirage - 5 - uatyeb
    * Social 1
    © ''

    Xt S unachievable - Justice is a vhftu© cf a person -


    ©
    ^
    '

    ©
    '
    not of a state • rn -the oane of JUSHCJO state
    \ OCW2QS<93 podoe^f - State -ta^os noooeg fVoro tbe
    ~
    I ©
    pBDdaob' ve sec-tos, moo-ey cbe-soof preachVo fcrxgetea
    !^ Qcd-oo - 35
    i © gWe Tsiap to parallel eazooroj os ft ^ pocketed
    b poii-b'cibos §. oivi|
    servants •

    AocoTfdio to Hayelc progressive taxation is a bonded


    ©
    labour.
    ©nstedd
    ^
    of State providing Justice State should p&OnDO
    •
    /
    '

    i te ChaxJhj .
    "

    © If a person is poanr 4be


    fail dbes not life ^Oftb
    b tfe Erbh .
    pov@ T {e, a bod luck
    ^ j
    /

    - Heoas fbrore^ocMai of
    t povedy eoersioo of tech is not Justi R
    - uble •

    :
    P Hcxyeb ctoes not accept concept <afp fve - eedoino /htabe'.
    ^
    .;

    fseedonQ. AoDirdiog to b'*o f oPdOPC) a\ropfe fe^-o fe


    ©
    @ absence of (
    ^
    Sersbo • ^
    ©
    © t
    ;
    © f
    t
    i
    ©
    m
    ©
    q {? 1

    l
    S553533 l
    X5
    ^m1l
    : 6 ”

    ROBERT plos\cb 1-bbbJe lau ^cnfe 0 1


    :
    ^
    !
    — AVQTChtj 3\- p-\ <p and CHop'iQ “ © osiCks Book
    '
    f
    0

    — ; Kios>cE isa CiHficof jbho Roils .


    •

    T- i (§
    S3 V'iQS Cfe do<£3 oof sopporf eoel-Rs fO
    ' ^ EiocHoos .
    r«
    Accosdina fo seasick ,
    ce d
    *
    ^ •

    © -

    Mioirv ai ’«ospi?nog t
    - V
    ^ (3 % Trkjfrt o’ ©
    Vfe
    ^revives 4ibe
    ^
    l ecxf oP diyb+ eaitebmao
    * glatp , "ibe
    ©
    coiy TJOlg’ op 4be sfafo is -fo ibo-t- property is
    @
    ^
    vii
    gbHuiy acquhspd / -fra r>3 rr<pd - SlQfe have oo rojo
    ^
    XT ’
    2.

    ib dfshributivg josHcp ' H0 qlso ooosic ess <S


    '1
    -
    rta*Q+foo ce> bonded bhoar -
    progressive
    .

    ^
    , S/
    iW'tvxjro \ s loSpVr ’i oq beeabse it enoVivafes © v

    X*

    ;
    £
    ?

    \ 'J
    n
    -^
    r
    P^&Soo 'fo uoorT bard. .Ht fe ooe-fblQnl \ F sk -fe iioroe
    ^ QO to onaii
    ^
    ~
    aga'ost

    SPCUTfdxj -services % COND


    bfe icisbes- S
    < sicb Is
    * P* <?ci qg Qp^p v narob isfr - fie brieves tbaT even
    d
    ^ be provided)
    ^
    Olso ©
    ^ • Is

    -
    by -private seefar . ©
    ©
    / ©
    - V . ©
    / ©
    ©
    i
    e
    ©
    V £v>-
    - V

    I pv>
    o:i

    :r .

    I
    I
    ©
    so
    ©
    ’C
    ©
    1
    <&
    \iy'

    P: @
    *JS •

    i r5? ,
    bv^ ‘
    -a
    s
    ©
    ©
    0
    KILTONJ FR ' EDM .
    — * *

    - tdoBe.
    !

    Goof - CapTVcurjjfo §r
    •
    •
    -S
    ¥
    ©
    Me beB dfoaV -fkeedora is oc* Deeded by
    ,
    • :i
    ; r
    2fV^SJ©. < *3 needed -fbg
    ^fCt +foer rOQT
    3 1

    fo e>02f the*e
    S3
    s. - #
    .? • £o eoao i'PS Aob&se CUpHcJltenO dc*?3 o
    ^ 4foaV = «

    1©
    1 DO people Oao «0307 fs^edoro - £|- »S
    I1 *
    e
    - •)

    -
    4biS ?sms^o neo \ 1 foetf a 1 isro fe CO l led as Madcff -
    .
    1
    1
    V -
    -fuodanoeotal » arO - 43- VS roooy -tiroe. VOOYJO ooaateF
    •
    fos @ O reobpd dabao CJassfGai Liberal fer^o of Adacc) SroC-tb -
    si ^
    :M
    ! ~
    jlfSAXM
    ‘
    55
    J1 ©
    :
    !
    ©
    •
    ©
    - -
    X Gen ip HTejeds 4foe coocep
    reaves a. d ^-Ffe)npoce bGfooeeo
    S RU K]
    ^ \
    ^
    of -We nbe*ty . aod
    Xtoeskj % copaa -©) . 0

    4
    4
    : •«
    •*

    •\

    I
    1 ©
    .
    ©

    1I ©
    1
    •
    *

    t
    >
    ^ MURRAY RaTMGARD
    Me coropa sed Pia-t-eC fbrdio'aos -§ ©p spacrais) as gaog
    ’

    of 'HatiS-fs aod osot&al baolcas legi a-tiv© -fPiUcQ


    ]

    ^
    -
    1
    "
    i
    r v:
    ^ Kieo liberate hsa+egy
    1 '©
    I
    \
    td000 -ep(©c-f • ^ povpcK/ a I 1 \/ i6Woo iS TJT iCk:I©.
    '

    cObat- is 4-foe sbbos op hieolibesa 1 isro -today c


    \
    5 t i
    Keo lifoe-satisra fe \r> ccSi .
    3 Tbe cwsfe> smarted uah-bp
    \ • '
    5
    :
    4e>co ysa^s op ocfsfrfoocQ of vdfo • peo liberal ecoeo u
    •

    1© -
    policies loCB osod iote r-sta-be §. ^ -
    © ^ * xbfo^a stfop < £ fepAcf-b'es '
    - =
    1©
    <
    ^opg like RMssfcp Mevfoo ; ybgeof oq Ooaorsies :
    •

    !
    5
    SD^-Vfo Bf e'c Asia. Soffibragd -fo C) ftoanob 1 CfosS'
    ' !

    % ^ '
    \
    \?
    i
    These has fc>een asoob o c -Afotl qlofcoiisQHbo coo/e.w>o
    ofe - <5 bcfi 00a %^
    >
    - - ?
    i
    I^ A * /

    VopaC-foog YGD <oeg«2*v) GouotYes


    -
    ueo lifoesol policies bave sta*«rfe=f ;

    is
    f .
    • 1
    !
    f
    ©
    5
    i
    G
    * i
    1© -i
    8
    1J © li
    t
    ©
    5
    i

    i
    Q
    \

    m t

    0 i
    ?
    r

    ’
    •
    i i

    \
    '
    ^
    Z8!ZSZ2&8888£
    m s
    a
    •I
    mr Sbcio l (JO 1 igrp
    . j (JbgKD| Ecjo ii ton'ooiSro
    ' ' '
    -
    ... i
    :\1 33MS a Tfe/Wo I of fesHive UbCTsaiiSM bu-t dte opp^acb § < )
    cd
    .
    Of soob! ( ibOTQls diffeV -f oro roodew CJ fchorads •
    ^
    1

    :-1
    •

    Modem Liberals Suggested skate lote^eottoo > o -eco- ®


    . vJ
    -'3
    -i
    ' Ootroy - SfatB £*SfclbVvSbioa} fSQs .pTJOVlC OCj OOplOcJ
    mcot - Social © bexa 1 fsoo is based GO d<be Cbrooeph
    ©
    ^ '
    —
    . ..:<
    .
    v:
    •

    >

    Df pa-stoessSbip QnCOQC) p\)f - SfSCtor, stat e § bvt|


    " ©
    soctody. Fvd sector should play do e '^esparto bi i (dy ©
    T "
    : \•d *
    . I

    Of pTOnoo-tto cpocoVb • State sbauld act <o^> facilito- 8


    -
    bd
    S?
    C!
    ^
    to*- £f etopocoemcd aivU scsdeitj eosqz^s Waspe$ r> pg ©
    •

    Sr OCODCxOtobi Lrh/ - Sobol Vibrate Suggests Qq to ^ )


    -
    tovt - ©
    •

    1 o copaci-y
    budding. - s oroe ^
    of 4be joTjOrdcaot stoai ©
    Ubpstte iOClud BV
    &
    !
    J (D 3bbr> RacOb ^ @

    J - P-acols bdogs balance betmeeO MG rfb§•


    Vteed .
    W

    i
    pa
    ^
    bas gWeo aWc. oF
    Justice , esfejfcaufced ova\ (ocA vtouo * s
    .ideas of Inoaoei toot**
    -
    ^
    Of ) . . ©
    ©

    t
    © Amadya Seo ,
    ©
    Arr>orfhp, Sen t p&opases -tbe idea of &
    -M
    pacidy Qu ,
    ^
    f r

    3-
    i A i Q
    2
    ©
    ^^
    ;. 4
    Ibs ad of Idcnrld ttoolc ’ppp«oa.cb
    :
    •
    '

    i
    J

    •
    ^ -to c vesnaocc'
    boused GO jp MDVis ViOO . A' SQO pno OSQS c
    toernance^ based^ on HUfOQO Oevelc r^ ^OGat
    •

    ^
    c 4

    ’• '
    (
    o
    ^
    *

    © JoQgpb Qdqltez ; _- t ,
    ,

    • d Joseph SdgU'to Xo bis hoot ©


    ti giobaM bo -
    Wbo § its dUscoo
    .
    -
    f -i
    -v
    Vd
    tGot have d oon
    •

    lubpisal ^
    ^ -the tooctonoeobab -fecas of - <3
    . T'j
    t

    r
    '
    •'
    -\ Modal op Qtobai tsafbo .
    wicM/ oovVb

    hi
    Xb bis Qnodba Boob
    PC pggeste
    ^
    ^ Jaa dbg - <3tobQ \ fe£aWoo ub
    roOGessify of TJftorrQS fo cSbOrti'todton^s tf
    (T

    2
    . •i
    -! (3f 6
    bbc» \ optoh UfC Udp- IAJT© CP that ddocp beco^us ©
    -."Vi
    bfaospespnt sepTfeseo tafvp ^
    §- csccauLotobus .

    ©
    -
    i hi> .
    :' J
    ' 'A
    V: i
    • - £?>:
    M V,v
    J
    J
    : •:
    w
    ©
    1
    53
    fiS
    •V
    ?
    £ fl
    V..V
    ?
    sh'gn't^ bos 9'iveo +he roooept- op pasf
    ©
    f
    .

    V:

    © ten CDOSPOSUS cowcb <inopba.sts OD ( odosJvie cJ3, '

    °
    V3

    1o
    ^ 'Dfsfeibu-Bve Jasjhce- -
    1- ©
    ::
    - a
    Co you 4biob-
    Ub ^3 ' fenQ bas cooo 4-be baWeoP
    33
    Ideologies ?
    s ©
    3
    '
    •
    •

    £ bberoiisro
    (
    bos been ooe of -VbG laDgGSV 3- vrvi'Ocj
    1© ^
    ;
    3
    .-a ©
    :i
    \deoio y 'to
    9
    -broro d\ Ffereof ( -
    4be LOPS© Ubproifero bag got challenges
    deoiogfes at different d aes -
    ^
    1 <2> ‘ Edri'e - challenge co oe -
    • i;
    -S
    ©
    ^ ^ omo OSOS jSVa fv<ss 7 PgbbG
    Sfoce, octobe IRevotuHoo > 0 Pcissia ^< o ig © t? 11 ^
    3
    -*
    l
    i
    "

    .1 © *
    139 ] ciisiofeg^oKoo of ago Qss £ -
    /
    s
    1 0
    . © beisaifsrQ bas? been
    challenged bg .sno'a feno ^
    J
    i
    I5 0
    • CODomoooiSno . Otrbog icfoor toqy pevfod Uib va i igry,
    ^
    '
    :i foced aoafhev cbQHeoge lo "fa
    i ©
    f-OSQSro is COOSFDQTTPD cos e-cberoe bcse VQ.h' srn ^
    o-f - aso'-sno -
    ^
    i © ^ •

    ib aeuJid xt U
    t
    5
    f
    0 •
    bercMisro defeated Fasafsr-o bed coad
    OOf dG- .Scholars Ift©
    fVaoos ^
    © a CororOOOl'SrO - rO
    1 ^
    )
    (3 3 )

    Protoi-imed ' ubexa usro <as 4be_


    ? '
    © fdku yaroo
    'Cod
    of hKShojry '. be betd Abcff —
    > '
    1:1‘ 0 Q &P ocd jusL ^OPf
    ^
    I0
    •
    nGS3ing dbe end op
    brsdcrag, coe_ cne txzx'Hropssiog d:<be . ?
    blgbest faint of I'^ioos -ideological VOit-Hn - M&o&
    : O bas p-saved dbad 4hese ° ° g
    is no 4 beLte^r dec boo 4bQ|
    - ( -
    I 0 of libera i ISPO Hotaeve - , bbc?»a i i ro bas
    •
    *
    ^r been
    "
    * ^ oeve
    i O f”®^ -Proro dbe chaMerges - U) -
    farms of fk>\ losophy Ube-
    i rbOM(sro is fceeo
    #

    > 0 cballerged by Muifp ca I'fma'aips -),


    -
    t

    > © Corntouoitoxia ofsrn 'Joosf noodes- ofenQ


    ' *
    ^ - Uo besrpQ op
    >
    s © polite Ubsraitoo is ChoIleaded
    bcajtolfeoo , Pc OiSno .,
    fcy Isianota
    ^
    - Puodc, _
    ^
    S
    I 0 <too-fM«slarafsoo . <£» fSHOo
    : 0
    i
    vJw b-
    nr
    0 'beYQ';Sr^
    -vbese vs °Hd
    f
    ° ofde b
    OF PJ3 1 ptoui

    ^-
    Loft - KVeo \ (b WQ » ao»0 odec
    tc
    : 0 ^ ^
    Crisis, g aexlt is on© * fociny I
    i m v. ••

    QJC io <dioaHoo - ^ - '

    0 ^
    i
    © ?
    I
    i
    l
    © l

    © I
    ;

    © t

    \
    © t
    ©
    m
    ^ aHoo-
    UjW-te sbo vf an Liberal GoocSpt of IblQ’vlsro . t

    £
    - <4-
    _
    cv
    i OV '
    Toie^ •
    , \ jQlue Of bbCfcOAfex). ©
    -d Alooc| V) (Jb0rty Fo <?ra 4-ioo fs 4bO
    -. iOrmo
    LO
    ^
    lotevo 44(00 ooro -
    QS Fof >9 -th>S latte ‘
    XOorcd 3
    rr '
    Jhe ay SodMrG GF>G fcfeb -
    2d
    3
    S- a
    ”

    ^ -
    TbleXax<p ’ to cb noFa-ns Vo beao
    loieyottoo is pe^sssa
    -
    far Tfeaiisa+iao °f 4Fe
    ®
    ©.
    :W
    v>
    :'F
    'A
    ^fi
    ;
    of
    libera ) idea of Uibedxf UbCrbj Coo ^ be. -eop
    considered “ OS
    -
    ^^
    1
    v c,v'

    ooly io Iblereot 9Daeiy . ’[ols^ b


    S
    -LL
    :- v.
    Wl
    '
    ^
    '

    -
    |

    Woo is
    ©
    •W
    .•
    '

    VL
    PL
    M
    t
    4Fe ' sobstatoFve UearP of Libera
    a cJeifbevate exerause of self
    tfeho
    Trest
    .
    -xaio
    Lb

    -flogs or bQbavtOuss <Obtab oe steoogVj cdisaprove 50 ©


    fra
    ’ 4fcQ
    © ^
    f&l

    bad oof been aOoatJl HOMO qscd Vfcjrbe IbieraL -


    ,
    Is not a. boat 'fbioos 6QrH> »espQGf -to ^
    Cfcrtcb ° e c*no
    ©
    ^
    :J 4 lodffferPcF ; -\f fsn ©WSl acceptance of divpssSHf Tol
    1 AT

    cc.
    V:
    xatToo i & occepfna ~fo things wtaicb otb@reOise
    bate TotesaWoo IS considered as personal vvrtae, social a
    2A?
    .1!
    • vtaue as toeii os poi (tfco \ vtftue. - ©
    :5
    i
    -
    i
    context of Ibl-eroHoo debate .
    -
    If etoesged io -fbe content of 4be issue of 4be
    _ ©
    ©
    roQOqqirja diversib-j - One Of -fbe BOtet'est pc
    ' ^ O oio
    ^
    t

    f^ Cfcat / bo te -
    UbeofSJ o is aesooiated texts GT - Locte
    f- !

    In bB lefec cooSsroic leraWon ,


    ^^
    • :S
    i
    SO90 GS+ 4bqv-
    v-.?3 ©
    Slate should g\ ve -feedoro oPcoosdeote § • state
    . :!
    Should not dictate routcss of "oGl igloo - e
    . :>
    ©
    J
    fs - OFO g'WFS Uthe ideq of ccheo be
    —
    :i
    ©
    :Vi
    .1
    •
    LI
    •

    -
    l ipsopoaes burro principle 'The only busts for- fobex
    l . Nnebtoo ’>o dbe -fo° cdono of taao cs obeo bis achat ©
    '

    1 £

    •V.
    1 50SuVt IOIP ±be cDocccfo baffno •
    ^ 0
    John PacQ=> ggesbs that 'icie^utoo isa feature °P ©
    I ^
    Li
    LI -
    liberal socle bbs becacee people fo dbeaal sselsbfes ©
    oao coofoue do po ,ess
    :;d
    1 ^ dratcfns^heioGivQ ©
    L4
    LF
    doebnoes Ozfn eHool -h-L 1udate«o u' bexaiisro, xslorois^o) ©
    '

    •
    fi
    fi ©
    4 0
    Li
    •
    •
    ••>
    v:t ©
    n
    '
    :; J
    Ll
    -
    v7
    4
    {

    1 ©
    @

    i ft

    S’

    sL
    8o+ sPM people
    cao CXQCJ&OQ Otr c?Qvebp© ' CMe^rfapptOf
    1©
    vS
    * •- . .?
    ••

    Consensus
    •• •

    >
    00 pot 1-b' cal GDOaepHtOO Op JtlSfrfce.
    •

    I © -
    -> EVoluftoo aT -fbe policies o-p TolsraKoo ’ o aoest ejro
    £•
    \
    : ©
    :4 ©
    coovld r
    c
    ffl Tte Principe. op sieubroirbj § Oob/evoal cMzensfei p -
    !
    : ©
    5
    c
    Cfc>ofe>p
    F
    1 © Hbao aodi hence 4be
    TbPjflP COW GJ \QfyOU )S ^300x9 0
    ^
    . \
    “
    "
    I
    s1
    /
    Q
    Qolu +ioo 4003 +
    ° 030 Poe reJicjbo -Vo -fbe. private
    sphere, Ala to adap; -the policy op orGi fous c^uYx lckj
    ! &

    ^^
    • ?c ©
    cl © 15 ensure 4bqf pcope betao ooj b ' fp
    O OpbUg
    ^
    ^
    *

    ?
    hacbpoaode live (o P®5^ § ba* 1000*0 Ffe idea of
    X

    54 ©
    ^
    "

    S9CU (qf noJriooanfsvvo «003 prao *>0 *sd - NJaKaod lisco OJ.
    |
    =
    •
    ;

    1
    ::«
    ©
    :•
    i m a. Oot -fyir -Bsoe - Idea op pa fitsoo i fero ORS based
    i ©
    j
    ^
    so ooiw i q’fe osbf p f -e -evetfppne
    ^
    Sb4e§ sf coble ste-fc© is hootip
    iar
    3 poll cues sv^+e f- oof
    :' l s
    V
    ::
    * ©
    tetbsp foto ConsHC'VO
    •

    (3 020 Of bjbceo-
    a
    i © ^ ^ *
    Of ) 2ror>sbfp 1eads -te -be oHbx>o QVii QDCSS - l?e_
    ::S
    • $
    >:
    ?
    c
    © °
    Bbopgao idea op tdQffooc* tisino aoos based G> O d&e
    "

    . <
    }
    < ©
    oofpj io ©nipbaewdy . Tbe -koo *ncodels ;
    r.
    c

    ii
    ©
    e
    i
    a French rocdel iS based cp c y
    * sepe^aPoo .
    © OS Mode? is based co 4be caocepb °p MSIPO I pc4-
    i Q
    ©
    <g£ tSP QQSi ro-i Won - ^
    fVcsboF
    i

    !©
    ©
    lb
    Cco
    psPSCOV ^PnoSS
    ^ ©UefeuS BFdorc, bats P*d do dbg
    :x
    4 ©
    Qsooffc of fdeopkJ toasc& uSoessV<a 60«od 4be "
    ! Pvep» \o toes o ouctarces *©be e erQ*3 r

    I© red dbirouap pub ^ ^ sphere


    * ° ’ ° l

    © be toto boenre § 1 GO *
    7 '

    ^ ^ ^
    '

    i© froobneot io public sfW * ' beire ^ brr >


    1. ©
    V ? ©
    ^ fe
    OF «ei ,5foo b poittcs b cjif b sc -Hej - rock 'ag
    *
    ® v
    a ^
    .
    ^
    r

    |©
    I
    c
    :•
    1©
    iOPftCSO SocIOf . ^ ^ j

    I © !

    I © V l
    l
    5 '
    5
    « ©
    / i:
    i‘

    f
    © t:
    > i f
    >:
    S © :::
    !
    ; i
    . !© c
    [

    i ©
    © s'

    i
    b
    f f

    kyroiv^ ^a bas 9 0
    I

    ^
    •

    -
    vCf
    vajl I !
    .-* > 9
    w

    irioe of t
    *£>
    (?) Deroa epf opb c changes ; ciscd Wipes sasle of njov gVo-Hon©
    ^
    '
    r\
    ' ©
    Si
    .3
    @ TaOcOirg coosdoasoess oboalV burOQY T hfe
    (

    roitoo'rl ti'GS
    '
    . & vof 00 Tib PS ' ^
    b 92Drbic ©
    ^
    '
    ( |
    r :i
    '
    :::
    ?:
    -
    ' •
    c\s&&f -bVe •

    :. !
    1
    ascuzrf -b^ HOo of f 4h one mb+ibos
    Q'
    - e
    •
    •
    1
    ::.
    G
    •
    SIHUGH-TOQS Cbaoojfo ~\be OcfeViog nccbeJs of
    ct&g
    vi
    :- :!
    •
    :::M
    •

    I i©l0£}+iorxs
    Uodog-
    ^
    ptsocf cob \ n |?SQOCG § QS a&o C^rolrg
    ©
    © ^
    / .

    I- ^ cbcHleDQO./ coMO sliPs life coooia 'V) IS ^ fOs


    4ustohQ ', 0 3bs Save pJibifcQi ^ ©
    ,
    !jl + <:U 'k ' <,
    4tbe c bopK00 ©
    ^- ^
    n
    &
    ?•
    %
    s
    '
    « »
    '
    ir lu '
    7 7t ^^ ^
    ^ ibo ^
    QDcS '+u 4
    ^
    f

    .
    *
    1 QPP
    lfer0 43 policy , to ct ©o GkJbetrPs

    -
    -
    tubons Qbbpf 0 Me f i r CU ( fcj °P ( '

    ^slSTo -V^ lUSS is


    +o
    <33<nSf/' - ©

    ©
    _
    £ i\

    1
    !
    ?1
    ©
    2
    !i ©
    .]

    • i
    1
    ©
    «
    7
    :5 ( z
    •
    '
    .i
    :i
    ©
    ....;
    c
    .J
    .: i
    . I
    'I

    •' :>
    ©
    ? 3
    G:
    ©
    5? -~
    • v

    i
    ©
    - •;
    ©
    • •

    :P. (Sc
    v i>
    cc ^
    I c.
    r \

    V :i

    !
    !

    ;
    .
    :'i
    ‘

    1 ©
    •' I
    !

    -v: ::31-
    1
    ©
    @

    1 v
    :
    '
    l
    i
    I
    #
    • J
    rb
    I
    3
    *
    ©
    :~5
    .* * •
    h u HcolHAyiQ 11 Sro
    ^ ' - lecPuse 2,
    /
    I -f~ l <3 | 2.0
    ^ o

    5 © Dopin') Og Mu I pi - Cu tMTH 0 1 Sro


    I'
    '
    '

    I©
    3 tAeces&iPy o-f MuIp' -Du i Puiria i iSM) -
    I ©
    :s
    il
    1#
    Sasic a ssarofHo os
    '

    Debate betcooso oo'iteirsbnSls MU (Pi- CUPa'jria ( ists -


    I
    1D
    ©
    Debate to'4bio MIU i -b’ -ca Hada i isra -
    ^ •

    S
    Oribcj'CpQg o-f Mu! Pi DU l +a Q I ISM}-
    !©
    '
    ^'
    4
    © ^
    KMii

    WbaP vs Mul-pi- catKbna i i£rv? p-


    is © :
    • -daiis o ^ °o
    Mtuipi ,cu Htj
    ' , appsoa ch OY
    i

    ideology
    :?
    13
    I © nseF’BDSQDbog Pbe iotCs SP
    '
    ^ of Abe ooo 'ciorovoaoV aedbare
    F AbesodePy.
    -.

    !©
    !
    * ° mcy iobude roioOfcMPes,imrogs^crts
    ppfjgees,cx aoy ooo boro'ioaot cpoap
    :a4
    ^

    #
    i ©
    -> viby Mu 1-Pi - Cu tputea i isr*o f
    Pbe -hsadiPioicol Liberal idea of
    & hoacag,03 divosgjPy
    fe pzsd i0C5 1nadetyoqiQ
    i
    o ^ •

    -}
    *i
    J ©
    -> Why +bis debate is fnsonoioeo-i- debapiop
    1
    ;
    ;
    !

    uio-yid is becoraiocj sroaiier § people o*<9 tGcaooi *


    '
    ?
    4
    '
    t
    .
    C
    ©
    roc e aansdous aboup -PbaiV
    9
    t
    ^ OUT idea. op
    ^rights
    i
    c
    2 © Justice pbiVoess Cs beenvoioy Tocnse ecfiricbe<d •
    :n
    c
    ©
    •

    k
    :! © Vibah fsPfoe basic dK -$es c> OP
    < o bePcoeeo PaajdkH-Tcyea l
    Ubesafe §. M<U it© Ca \ b_a ia 1 isPs
    45 © ?
    iBcbi+ibnal Ubesab 'lobe -the \ jfeco of roQo
    if © oisbicb
    Gao be
    I ©
    x

    be
    called as a torY^isPie noao (Sl'depeodeot n°aoA
    -

    1©
    -<

    -
    ?

    3
    ^ op ^PHo-oteHc is beiog cwiPfa's<p<d as
    * AbsVwa Cp Xb cPividua > fs^o 9 Abspsacf anefilvfduo i fs<m>
    •

    1© A does noP give Abe p>icPorye of fipe nsaa i mao •


    4
    3J © i

    4
    !©
    1
    *% ©
    c
    .£• - .
    ?;
    •
    ©
    <ks
    m
    I© I
    I
    & j

    1I ©
    1© !
    ;

    K
    IR © l
    y
    I :
    ;

    S
    $
    A,
    I
    - ^ SCuu6
    >

    P
    > Kv;'-*" K
    V)cj? l -h' - Cu»(teia i ( ©
    . 33? Vibab is 'seal moo accosting ^
    Me rponov Isolate air ofcevsad; roQo ouvof bis
    Op

    I
    1
    V. oultuins ozr idsnb'ty. 4
    ! a
    ©
    OV
    .
    <4
    ccosdfog to Gbikbu R>rekb ,
    r\

    |
    CS Mao <& CoRnsoily probedcfed rae caonot sepswate roao <f
    c :
    t* ,
    -fe b>is> cultuftP - G- fs iroprsocS-TcJe "to accept tbat roaio
    uD'di -{b&get bis CQl-klwe dCbeo be. ODBC'S io po1.1\TLEPBESE -
    ©
    fe ioot *ae>ai tSHC- it is oofdiiT- 0- is oat possM
    ^
    j
    MCb only <

    1 bfe to Tietpeet ex pe^soo bub Dot Trpsppc&og bis ©


    culture - X-f eoe ocf >od ck Trigbts toq pe^rSoo buLcto OOf- @
    TJFcogo'iboio to 4be culture > oa* csppxoacb) I'S
    «
    #4
    G* ©
    I i»oprisacti'cabls -
    ©
    ( ) Liberals do oct give oeoegsa'ry Tjscogoitiao i© 4be cul-
    JJ ture - OuHMps provide TOSatoiogS 'to OUTT uod'e rskaodbog. © '

    .p
    ' '
    culture acts \ \ lpe cxgpiss -WysocjQt sobicb COP uode^otev- ^ )

    vV - nd -tbe Qli-hJ -
    ^
    © ^
    bve»y ecu-tore is H/brwd § pU»ai j pscioaeKJ or OfOcOr)
    ©
    -
    £
    .V. sciously oatbl?res interact coTtb ocb ctfbera Tfcese lb 00
    <

    ^ ^
    CQ (-tu«e ecbtf cb can be considered c?s eottseiy gtsp .
    ' o
    Liberals to \ fopcoQ curtate o-f rootjefini
    ^ ©
    ^
    . -
    t
    nbinofjnty \ o tbe naroQ o1p Orb ve sa lts«no r^tovoai is . ©
    xi
    n © Tust V te Bicdi^iefty ;sgood -fov 01090 cor SYs ^ ©
    i- * ^
    -
    Si cfiiivsiy co rttwpl divei®n-tu is
    is KJWooal . toe 030 |©atfr>
    also good ‘tracts caltq c©
    ,
    ©
    penra
    ^
    V<
    5

    i
    -
    ici- ccjjr cxitfeprg fey *
    •
    t '
    tfRugnisiog d xfex nt cu i-tu’xes
    :: f ' ^ •

    ©
    :i
    vS
    J
    . A*
    >
    1

    1
    . — S a s i c aasu
    Mu {:< - cu 1 -fcu WQ lists
    ( •
    ropt-
    ioas of pul -ft - cu t -tu crisis
    sSaire assuroptfoos <xoBb
    ©

    >•
    9
    4: Oa»5nnrxioi taTriaof ) aod ca ItxtTra I 's dati v-ists -
    * '
    .

    1 Uke cc nn incMo'ta 'ria ns MU ftI - cu iturYotigts areject .


    it©)

    1 obiversa usra % ia \ k about pa t-i'ca lansisi^o -


    '
    > ©
    ! ^
    U e CDr^-nQuoi tOToanS MU ttf - Cu (ttnrO i fSte coppoat
    !
    ;
    *
    politics op ictcoblt § poirf'es <3>p GDcoroUorbj .
    ©

    ^
    *
    1
    .• ©
    :; ©
    3 Q
    ©
    ©
    ©
    #
    a
    ::a )
    I
    3
    •

    3
    I
    a .

    ;I
    >. #
    >Si

    i -S> _ _j ; :'v':'::
    .'
    CCd -:&©
    3fc4> '
    -©©;v-©©©©>>>©->>>>© >; ©:'';::::':'>
    Xxt© ©r' ©r©©r©::
    ^
    ' " '* ' '
    i © 5
    ptroro^^ot t'lul fcl - Cti ( tu'S lOllg
    '
    ' '

    ^S aod tbsiv
    "
    V 'fGCQS —
    Liberal Mul-b‘ Cciltg-B ionste
    y -
    © ®
    "

    i
    © 3
    :<3
    cr ui ill kyofckq
    I©
    .
    :-3

    M% © Fhs
    ^ agonies| - caltu-riaii^ste-
    i© © 8bI khu
    Parekb
    2
    •

    LJ
    * ©
    i
    i <S) Cogroo Fb>Iltao M jHn ~ CLsItu'TnaI fSM ( )

    iS i m "

    (Tj) Jes errxj hiaidkon'


    .
    *>5
    ©
    i
    i
    v
    ©
    © S y la Se^obdbi b
    > '
    i
    •

    AI ©
    •

    *$r- © CD ul iij Ky ^o JickQ y

    ::«
    •
    -? ©oob - Multi' Cultural Citizenship - A Liberal
    3 ® TBeoty of Mioo
    ^y Pigbts ( 1995)
    ,;1
    *

    v4;
    be
    5
    e
    I
    ©
    ©
    uHil K/ roUckq
    da+u?ral
    3093^5 then Muff - Coitus b the
    ioeMfobie svoiubtoo op Ob aieT^.
    . '

    I © I believes tfoqf On\ y U berate cao feM c dbpf- ^


    I ©
    I
    Cuitu?naiiQro. vdill KyroMckQ Syggesi "thai * gc>\) (-s.
    Shoqid g'lVG Special
    'fights Lo it>e raio^bfh'es
    i
    .3
    >:
    O. '
    *

    5. S category op sights : * :
    5:\ © .
    •

    x‘
    ? © .
    CD Special PepreseotatYoa Rights -
    s G © -SGt-f Governaore PigbiS- Xf 4be elboie Ctorarooofty
    iS CoocGobratpci ^‘n> CK pasticulcfr g©ogzs2 pb1cts l Q?rpQ .
    iG £

    3 * sboyiA be
    ( ) Rd y Ethnic. PlgbtS - JCt means vi » Oo^ ftlos
    .

    I O'
    i
    :A
    • '
    giMop Qppcial cultural nsigbts - MG Suggests po-ots - 4c .
    <:i
    4t
    :
    :.rJ
    v
    4
    *

    i
    © *
    9^°° ^XGroptdos -eg MusiVro g’nfls sboa (d be QUOCQGM
    4o coouir socnrfe io a school , MUSli roS Q3D be i\ r>
    0^
    1O 7 Mondays 00 pbeday , SiKbs 030 be ol\o *oecf to <3jpar <
    !s ©•
    tUvbGr) *
    5
    1
    0 1
    ;
    :3
    3 © !

    1s a
    : !i
    Ia 55.
    © !
    1
    i
    5
    C
    ©
    '5

    JS J
    a
    • t
    v
    5 •

    a © %
    -V V
    ;
    >4
    « 5
    %- C2
    -2
    m >
    i

    1©
    1
    MS I
    ;

    »
    3
    3
    : 55SSES ?SS2SSSS35SSf^
    ^ ^ ^SSSSSSSC«» ^ ^
    ?
    ” SSSS3SSSS KS 5SSS £S<KW
    sf 4 4beae special bQf
    ;
    •
    vJ , kynoli'cWq MOCC&IQY
    -
    £<
    -
    :
    \ tr>oi +0d do Ma -Mooqi -^ [ ndisiUGS oob/ . #
    ' •

    s&
    hQ-bts Sboald (

    ts oo need Ho -eMend db^e bts Ho {pooofcpyQ - ©


    ^
    *

    - i
    ^J
    ots £ isp uyeeb -
    H:1-
    '..t

    5S
    - ^
    Kiby ocA -to Xroro jcpra’Z ts ?
    '
    '

    -V. ornite tOobbocu roioovi'b'es coho d© oof cboose dobefo ©


    rororfhj 0?roop So Hbey Sooutd oof softer -fVore> e
    °disadv
    <

    /aofoge Su-t 't «v>OiOpfaj®tie>0 fs Ov neater or cbc*oe . r;


    *

    -
    wente, CTroi o -Qcis should cxdopl -fbG roQfo r?rGaoo
    SK
    OuHipfe op Hhe Vaod to
    kiby oot -fe ise-fUg es ?
    ^ ^
    toHcb they GtfP ( irrolg^aiiog - ©
    .-
    We CKQ SfHlI Uvf ^In Q cooa d CbGJrC adnbi of - ©
    ©
    ^
    \ J<

    '
    2
    S sabve oo'p fs a-bbo stat© <2XAO\ 5I‘£S 00000P be. •

    -ferced to to teg the bu dpo bPc bev spates jjo


    ^ - oab' -
    ^ ^
    '
    —
    ^
    :b

    .
    ^ 1 cororownity shall puf papssuap 00. c^ootbev Cmobg ©
    dotirpat; -ffoe ro\ no h-Hgs
    r\
    v - pROppJrlg - ©
    ©
    v-: sbi Rbu pbygkb
    ©
    Goo Y- - Re +bfOW oy Mufplb Ctilfuwaifsno -
    G
    Tboagb be
    ' Soroe basic ossorop^h'csos «of +b u
    .

    W . hynoHcUa © boat Hhe (nopoH-aoce opccdtctae 0

    i
    'n&pd 4o ops e specfOl zsight© be_ opposes W© frolictq
    ^
    4©<o .
    ©
    c
    ^ V

    00 ttoo ggoaads -

    >'-
    a caonoV he Ofrxi josh pi sshbo
    ^ roQh£
    ce bel-aoeeo MaWaoai M 'marih'©s , -p^t^ig'Ba.ats ar© (C
    Vv

    pfog ©es toe Ccsooor say Hhop iav ftns3oog^rQ:ots -


    :':i
    *

    W.
    *0

    3
    ’

    0sefa g.es Hbei r cuctaw? does 00H


    ^ - lecO
    noode^r-
    -hbaVdbe
    cP
    ^— • '
    • •*
    *

    ® ou
    t\e doe? nc © cxgi
    ^ee udiHb the \ / .

    i-buma \ (sno te a, ©oabuws op (Jbe^a 1 ooaeKes oovy


    '

    -
    .

    ,
    ' Nw .

    Me bejieves Hbcn Ubexols hove lobeK^olr saose °-P sope y


    '

    Posevh Qoggeste t * c>^oio0oe be P-o'eeo :


    .
    i'.

    dviiigo on’ QO 4boV oeoocnhe at- sc^oe best s '

    ^
    roioATOuro vaiugs ^obicb coil I he. occeptobte Ho QH
    V
    *
    e
    ©
    .:
    ; V:
    a

    0
    Jy .
    .-. c -.
    $ :
    •v >»
    (
    ^
    ©<•
    s-& >:

    :p; rr >,-ftAg-ee
    ^ - J( qu ( r>
    5V>et+£ v~ In ca && ooav
    ^ of
    ' oo>d be
    >i Hc
    '
    -Vbd-V-
    BNbbu fbdasfcb fe QfH ^ 9 ecoerge b rougb dialogue
    .
    ii

    vt ©
    ©
    CQ e corrxoon VQlUPS C£» b
    ^ ^pc^ >|ftP o feve 1 -
    cxAo'Ch echo be applicable QV enema
    . .
    ) ^
    speb p o-
    il
    © He belfeves Hbaf Hqroao Dig-entcj t s one ^ '

    C\ p\G CObpjfe ioe CDo ct Veiope. (Qnoro 0 0 values * •

    © ^
    © 0oM4au fbrei^b proposes be oppifcaHao of 7 Razrro
    J © -
    pdodplp pp -these is no GCrocs ele baeho to anyone '
    -
    I . v -
    ^Hb respect \a oovy cultural sped-pt practfoe.
    .
    I© ^ jcb proGhfcps
    need nap -to be Tresbdctpd Ha^
    S3 ©-r /
    prlndpie OQO achieve -the balance bet '-oeen Aubo
    oemog £ Culture *
    - -
    ,10
    i
    .a
    1i #
    -
    short tUafe oo Value phnrcmsno -
    ** © value pluTso i fsro as. a concept is gVeo by isoib Qe ho
    •
    .
    ;
    .i
    ^
    © context oP vaiue pip
    ^ ivsino
    . "

    m 33- is cooted of 4be debater betaoeeo values •

    i es Eg - Ibe debate bebtoeeo Liberty £ Pgaalf -fcy • •


    *
    I © vaiae PuTraiis »-o\)2> ValU -G MOo isrO
    ? © AcroTsdibcj -to Igalb Berlin , value HOnlavr) roeaos
    f one
    value determining all
    <
    © cbofees bg Oti iltoYians tabs
    • •
    •
    f casibe oltiroa-fce dderroioaot
    • t/ fbv can act'd os • *

    -
    f
    A«mdl ng Ho r Ben 1o peoples
    !© s^nopooe betimes 4RQ hove different VQIUES - Lt
    + bibevtu basQ Pnriofty ave r Qqpa
    i
    $ ©
    'fly r>o ^ -
    t

    .».ty T^ Ugueroecte cc>\\\ coov'


    iYoce tb© person that

    ^
    *
    II © bos a
    i
    c
    ©
    ©1
    S
    1©
    ^ S ‘ '
    * Mec e dhoaid bo+ Otntise
    Ubesai couotaips priopaca is given 4u Irhpv-Kj
    iogfoIT - Patio, Hfoese can fee ooaog such vtnuec,
    coBcb are equally correct Qod yet io cooPlVot *cftb •each
    dbec pig- (Jbeyb| Bgoairty . fVofcAeno increased -farthsev-
    '
    i

    1© because values c*« © «• irxQoomeoSM raVDVe '1 (deo-oot be


    *
    '
    '

    {
    © . meaeoTred ) and pa-iavi -tfeed • - i

    S
    ©
    •

    S
    \#
    - ?

    I< ©
    i
    1!
    ©
    I
    H
    i!

    i
    f
    f;
    © t:
    i
    !

    1
    i
    i

    i
    U&DCE , be iibesal Ooc>t- fa f o ^ r Hse. ^ - e§

    —
    ;
    ?Si
    a laities JT- Bedio is Qso a optfrpieKc as be heifeviod
    ' fa

    - e-V
    •
    B1
    fba 4- dbes-e QpQ Sonoe sbcrsed vacues b^oo ng civi
    ©
    !
    1 Usa-bbo's - \di+b ^HOOTTP § roo-ye develops noeot roojfp no .
    ere broader ©
    of sucf vaiaes ^oiit e^op e
    :: l
    •
    • • ••
    / i
    ageee noeot e*ist -
    ^ ^ #
    v:j
    bi
    ft
    ri 6bovt MoVe oo Bod of Bistasry §. cb pqre ©
    rod of H feio <o?*b C\ dsb Of OvtUSabbo.
    ^ <

    vj

    ...I
    ''
    ^
    Bod of Histos-y os coeM as clatsb of civt lisa Boo
    ©
    #
    •s 03fb ptcesPof 4fe *pasf Co >d coav oocrsid azrder - m
    rod #
    WtJS -i qbe.sfcs fe ossoaa-ved eaRb «
    ’ ideasc
    ^:
    ^ ^^
    rbd of
    osfs y >
    f
    » 989
    m
    M
    : }

    '•
    -
    • ••i

    :
    a 1* p a b W h
    acd p icrter oo io 139a as o boob *cdb dbe bf ^
    >
    'fbd of HiSitoMj § ibe \asf aof
    vdbav doec, rod of
    ^
    'Vbesb •gvgQeste ?
    ^
    rod of MlSVoyu does Od r^eao <2jod of bbe eveote tp ©
    ^
    ^
    • •
    ©
    ©
    f
    -

    -
    RiSto VTj - fbd Of Ri O
    ^^nsDeoos , 4be °f MQo'sf
    V ]
    ideological evo /ubor) .' ©
    fifat is dbe Vnopucofoo
    : l
    ;
    ,
    -i ^
    UbibrO 1 isro or dbe^QV betoocsactj VS dbe u itijoa f-e foyr ©
    of qo r - ccHdb coeo be coodeved by bOnoaK3 \0ei ^>
    :i

    .5
    <
    ^
    fbd of m ozrn Ob ooe baod
    ^ abTieb
    03
    saperv^cy ©
    <£?
    -
    ‘. •.
    i

    -
    Gf fibe arfsao 3 0^ dbe cMber ^
    e^obiisb -tbe
    . : *

    ^ G
    -
    QDp^roacx) of 4be LOGS • gb Cx C Qfro +fcoV
    ^ j
    Wolqgfes
    ^ ’
    ©
    ;
    tismo bae, IOOT) fbe bisia rfci baM
    ^ - e °F , - f :©
    * C 5

    FSkuv/aroQs ' Cbocepf of Gbd of V 4 iS\cftsxj (s Vfe c j p i i -


    a- •
    •I ^ #
    raWoo of Regels §- Maryd ekplaioaHao of Ebd

    :: j--
    \
    1

    ^
    Cf RiStore; • Rocoe/er, oei’R^ev c eirroao Sfafs oas Bod
    Of Hfetovyoor .Soviet
    n ooiro
    Me psetdaed 4tx»A- biefta y
    ©>obo
    ,
    -
    Ebd of RiSteflry
    '

    -
    irvfeieoced by dbe ideas oB ,\exaodre bqjeve
    ^
    ^
    lead f ^coemreb 4be esta'
    cor ce e. ©

    ^
    ^ - %
    @
    AV

    i>i “
    ^
    b1'sb«aeol of ooWer.scs ( §. Rarooge-oocss,
    < • ©
    ©
    ©
    m
    a #
    1
    •
    ©
    ’ :<.
    ©
    m<:
    '
    <
    #
    -r:- ?cc
    of \ { bpso < idPQ- s b' bprof <00 of
    r'-oC»

    ;i
    - ©
    •55
    >S:‘~sii
    ' 5
    * © life povt9 boGo pifoooaocpd easier also ; o Hde ^
    <

    5! cOOirfS of S- M . Upset • f ;

    •
    ?©
    Poofei 30U ^P^oo 4otk ?cl obou t Ebd op J2j0Oto3y .
    .
    vs .
    '
    .

    8
    tq

    Fod op wr osy IbeSfS bos beeo artfi < iSed


    1# ^-
    Scboiass e. g . Suroael p Huob'oqtoo , Farid
    = ^
    ZLakaviQ
    x/csviotc
    M 8
    *
    18 De^bda -
    3
    Fraocis fu uyaroQ b> Q3 revised bis ideas § bianoed
    1'
    • ••

    3
    •
    0 *

    -HTG ^
    poncies &F Qjpoge Basb la Afghotyoisf -oio X3rac»
    ^ ^
    %
    :2
    - ©
    ‘

    'se9poos
    :2»
    39 »ble for 4be declioe
    1© of os HCgeroacKj.
    1 dte. Triso. of (deoHbj ooosdou-soess - c
    ‘If #
    . .4
    ix © Sa.noM.tg/ p . Huo-biogtop aod HfS COOcepf
    . 1.
    • Op
    10 dash op C\ vi hao \-tbo3
    '

    .J ©
    ;
    Accord i Ocj -Vo S‘ p- Hur ’ o OO, +be eod of bidkmj
    vs
    : < ©
    !
    ••

    • 3 tbesls does oof


    ^ ^
    prsesetoir 4he Tsediffu of paSF
    Gold coq^r aoo'vfd o- deTr - He bas p^rodi fQ , -vfe clash
    y
    ^^
    *
    .. 4» 8
    Of CM Voodoo tbzrou bou-t cold caqr- eo«v|d <UDQS
    K

    ^
    '
    f
    $
    P ,

    .
    V
    - rb
    J¥ w
    divided bei <^Ceeo differpoV ideological oanops I ' P - i

    f
    COrono uofeno Qod CO pi fo lisno - ideological differences
    !8 <23o get Tjeso vedi ba-t curtH'sal §- *2PeJi3?bus differences
    f p- '
    a?sc difficult to wssoVvp - £o bis boo)L clash of PfvYi f» "
    (
    5
    i 0
    .6
    da^Hoo' h>e roeoti'oos g civil isafio ns -
    I
    > ^© © Cbi nes te
    ic @ JO pQYoese.
    1:< ©
    *•
    •
    Hiodu Pi vi i iSQ +i'OY~)
    Ij 8 ;

    |P © Odbodoc PAVI i fscHiOo i-e • fqssiao


    i' .
    © JS1Orofc Ci vi l ISQKoo
    Io (g) voesterp CJVVWSQKOO c

    t8
    I © AfnCOO
    i

    !© (§3 Lapr ) AroedCOO


    ?
    t
    I
    5
    I c
    © ^ i
    i
    s.

    !© i
    P:
    .: I
    E
    iit
    I©
    8
    8
    r:
    It
    k
    i
    G ft
    is
    fp:
    I§ G p
    :
    >
    }.
    © P
    $
    i i
    i £
    E
    !
    J
    i£
    '

    I p£ talk3 atouV * be poSsilDT ti ^y o p


    '
    - Chopped- fcGfcoGb
    ei
    a (T) XstOrO i C C'tvi l iso Woo §- v ps jro - ^ ^ Civi li9aVfcio .
    ©
    @ cbioese civ/ ifsa +iop § v4estejm CtVniSQ-Woo -
    . -3
    :: *i
    •

    i
    •
    ©
    ovj
    He calls pUSSi'Oo §- Xbdtoo/ HVockj o’vi lisal-ioo Q3 <$>
    :>rl
    V3 CStoiocj civi I isctKoo .
    •3

    MQIO (bopid predicted by 5 p - HuoKogdoo - *


    ©
    a t*s belcOeeo § cbiO SG asO f ( iSQb'OO - © •
    •

    23- cow be coopic* befuoeeo care starve


    ^ •
    ©
    IbG -P bt befcQPGo nOGSVesb c)vil £3C>Woo § TsfcsroiC eivf
    ^ -
    \ VSdA-fOO Vs fCrroed Cfe p3Ul -t LioG coop! fc0- -
    )
    &
    0
    I — &
    by

    tetay -faa \ v Ooe CDoPUdr - ^


    •
    .v.i
    :
    .c i- @
    Ibere is bo case Sta+s (o \slanoic. <u3a»te$ -1100 16 (

    -. V
    v-t com be a fdui -t Uoe coopleb Patoewo* , dbeaei's <©
    :o
    •
    a poSs ! bi l
    ,
    ity -4toa-V Sstenoic ^GosHd cOrofcsi nGS \
    1
    b @
    -
    SioiC dv’nisa Hoo agaMOSV -
    ie °^ 5
    < St
    =s
    S3
    coop TGV bekOGGO CslOrofC vJGSVt?3b Civi lisp^oo ? # *

    1
    PAfb anre rOJiSSiaoasy 'WStjgiooS 8afb ctw2 T^iGologfcai d3 ^ • .

    ^ ligioos- Go4b are QqaioSl Mom - be I fevers cose © ,

    ,
    uoisersa iS 3. ©04 beiiWe ib AM or - Ma+feioqJ -
    ^ ^ . 1
    i . © •* v

    Aoroedfbg to IkJof -ipg -Voo, T^G^TC bovo aicco.ys been =CA^S ©


    '

    Coo-Piets bCkoPPo cal-ta&GS ooUj - ds 4tae sbeM- pGdod


    PiStaetj ae b>«vG seeo obopicV <of ideologies-
    0
    ^
    The dasb bekn CM ifso4-ioos bc»S lory boS-Vo-sg S ©
    'OCG
    roo^et-oeov op <bvf i tgoHoo As (
    riQ3WL>o \
    afcaocPbi'oo § com«oy - ©
    *

    ecboology PoiM bCSDnofi oAvoooe |


    «

    oeople cGfl #
    beCDncG roc&e vaoye Coosoous op pooi T CdooVrtu . /
    V
    .

    • :a ^ ^
    ft

    ©r:

    ©
    ©
    :
    •
    ©
    ©
    #
    i5:s
    -
    •V3 ©
    m
    w m
    I
    -- »
    .V.VA' ~<i
    -.-
    vr v:
    noJc faodacofito ^
    ' t rvD

    feceoos W Hse of Isl^


    r-'.i
    ©
    & pDHciGS \ 0 VOaddle
    - east- -
    •

    --
    . i

    tl
    © ff \ C

    @) \ aCV- of ipeiooc^y
    •

    i© •

    t puWoo -
    vcl
    :
    *
    1
    © @> 1fe g cnboF .

    ** ^
    © © ^ oU b •
    *g^ ^V' rO ^
    " CJ

    f tsVTTa^'OO OrOO

    ^
    .- 11 TO
    .3

    1Stressful s^si’sV ooce


    5!
    a
    • ti
    t>
    ©
    (0) *2 toy lyavot f b
    ^ ^ae| S;

    *
    :
    l
    i
    •

    1©
    ; ©ho© sosgeoce of 3S\ ano cx self irQsfeof 4 f conff _
    •
    ?. IdPOCG’ for -

    .
    .,<•
    !
    :& W
    eolro^c fo'oqrds toesv m dtfcnopts -to
    ^
    r
    Y '
    £
    :»
    . :?S
    • © ooivpicscnfseoS oesteifo va \ufs ^ *
    5
    I< #
    i.

    * ©
    ©>| fbd Of GOtowToo -eoehry <
    Drorouoisno ( fh9ro i>
    1 dtepct.;. Cbnfsoo ta+itoio ^oS-to each o4toa ~
    :S *
    i
    -
    ©
    - I ® OrA’-HctSho Of clash of QViiiso-h’oo-
    ..

    i® |
    !1 B AcCov^\ng totoe cin-Hcs 4h^c fs no f o4-© vo ctasb of
    ,
    i
    ‘
    : S
    ©
    *
    cMUsa+foos to£>s!s- S3t ?sotoex psoVdes fcasfs
    2-
    Ic © jcJSboaVion -for OS, OO > 0 ro? ddl(9 6t? Sf £ <

    ofhpJT TS foo - If airos to sfr ogVtoeo t-tege -


    ©
    ^ ^ ^
    '
    #
    s
    ( :» roo<ry ooVy . "ibe^P awe roQ*y 1-eadesS rro *ooarM Ciho
    *
    i
    eroptaasfS on -toe oacessHy of d& volcgpe bQhoepo
    : cr> ’
    Civ 1 1 vfia-h'oos •

    © i

    ii o-
    vV

    f © <

    I©
    I© t

    I ©> .v-
    :
    5

    !
    i
    © /
    >

    5
    j
    1ft \

    £
    © \

    A
    1s. ©
    v
    .

    1: ©
    I
    1© J
    '
    %
    \% ©
    -r f

    1 ©
    ‘1 1,
    4

    I. &
    i

    V l
    Y
    I
    1Q
    y

    1© 2
    I
    i
    l ©
    ~~
    r.'i
    i
    s
    SOCIALISM o §
    <
    ChQr><%$ +«
    .A
    <? Kar* y
    I
    Moto 4o ] o& SCDCJOllSro ? 'wV
    ]
    £t- te dlfpcuip to ctopoe aoci
    m3 attet beaaose acxiaiisro ©
    ^o
    V • \& KLs a Hat -that bas lost its shape becnose
    i •everyone #
    ::>l
    • :1 uoec&s \t - .,

    vi
    i
    \ Ui by everyone ‘oea. ss it ?
    '

    A >'S <pou*+icaUy assftii


    'tor
    :i
    :
    i * 3 hzvge SQdto specially fo -toogo eouotdos
    >

    oo of society to pocar
    1
    m pocrss bav© rlgbft to vote - Xv

    ^ ©
    Why h is said 4bch ft has lost- fbs shape ?
    Reason - godless VcnHeb'es op s c}ai fsro
    ;
    -
    .
    T
    T
    V.
    Thp»e QW9 =
    coaohy specifrc noodels, pe&soo spocf -Pc
    •
    m
    4
    ;•>
    A -
    *
    nDtx ip s > there a®e
    '
    Tsoate to Social fs
    Yoetocds toblcb ooppa&te . pesoa-fai ©
    :’.V
    y .';

    to ^ox same sopp<a?to 'vJoieov ayou-fce C


    social fsto - ’
    '

    /T >

    TStoc V) ft t (te a Mat cobweb has lost f -ts tSbope bci-fc-


    >£&to ^
    tee (Qo ^eco rai'ss -bbe V-tatr - C
    :i
    i

    -i
    ^ % C
    M
    .! ©
    V
    -1 AC
    i
    !

    I 0
    A?
    V> -
    •!
    I
    ‘.
    0
    '
    M A
    0
    £i

    >

    A-\

    0 , - t

    ©
    i
    ©
    . . -J
    *

    -
    v.j
    '

    -.V & ,

    A #
    0
    Sc @
    5553
    i
    - #
    v. .* . -S
    *
    uecJUiie '

    00g \o
    it "
    BOSIC QSSUrop ^
    fj ^m
    *' .

    % : r
    is gpaal ?- Fcooar-oto Eqocufty -
    :

    CCnrQ value of g^ cionsro

    1p ®
    !
    B0CQOSP -\foe cszHajfo op SDCiauSf'o S
    ' ,
    \ o in
    cboVeyf op cw+icisr -
    £ vr - -- Of CqpAa V 'Sro . (V i • •

    »fe<ro tas •tfpsoitpd ioto (oc»Q3se. to


    1© Ua feees.

    - ioeqoo i f -H) V G^plortotVoo-


    .j
    :R
    v . fl
    1
    © Socialists ptopose Hhcrt £foc$ UsV*ial s C a o b e ^=^
    \

    -
    =
    >1
    . § © on betfes pzrfncipes -Hoao +ba-b of cqpTtaJisrO
    © I IBey suggest -to base s&cs -eMj on pdoc/ p\es of soot> i fe^o- 1

    •
    i

    Conception oP Vturoao Kioto CBy Socialists) *


    *©
    1 .v i Accord ioy to 4t>ero , roao Vs sociai by Ma -tobE .
    # ACCO Tsd iog to SoCia i IstS Mo nooo iS oo Island
    •
    3
    x ) Qocb t^OQO is a pQ'Jst op Cootiooot.
    rl
    .534*

    1 g» | .socialist concept op SocJC’bb ., .

    j So oo i|'sts wpjoct- ag 'se atlVG VfPcO op Scvjoiy . ^


    10 ^
    I B'GU 'Gve -foot society \Q, Kia+UTraO , <3 0OQ1CL sotttij
    ^
    s ©
    0 j
    ® Pdoa fst concept o-p Pigtots -
    \ *
    '

    -
    '
    V
    V

    1 1 Socfcni s beiieve. \o social §- Ecoooroto Rights -


    ^
    p o
    f \

    1© Soda i Ist e o o o e p t Q p Libert u


    concept - instead
    ^ ^
    >;

    !: © far socicnfsts , liberty is a P ocpgpois© p


    -; •

    c *
    Of Ubprty \ - foey ose -te -tew p eedono ’ Real ! &?edaoo
    }s -pSPedoco pO<
    D •OgGP it'CEx
    1©
    :»

    Socia \ Sts Concept


    ^
    !l 0
    : ' |o
    i

    :i od if
    3/$ # 0 Social £y Ecooo *^oic Tpoq i i -
    1
    %©
    •

    bj
    :l ©
    1
    ^
    rtbSo U-tg Equaif-ty
    '
    oof CO no&s

    1 ©
    3\
    5
    I©
    1 \

    £
    |©
    I © ;

    I
    i

    i
    t t
    I; Q
    •
    X
    i

    >&
    SJ 0 l
    &
    § © f
    ‘‘ 3
    r
    I« ©
    %
    >

    |©
    1s ‘t
    i
    IE
    M l-
    P.
    8
    &)
    Socialist- yiesp op-he - m
    .
    £ •
    •
    •

    1 1

    Cf - fs 'ia CorjVPkf opa state. -that sacia ' 6te di -ff y.


    I
    Qoroe Soda lists a*e against -the state § SOroe cbP- io -
    ^ s
    -faviour of a starts *

    £
    E ©
    • i
    Sbctaifets Mettods op &nogfoc| sodbub»o v

    •Sxio lists a iso dippy to ] 4h aspect Vo 4he tepvbod . %


    Scroe- prefer psorp-fa i cobespas saroe pKeferVibient
    Toethad .
    -4
    ''

    1
    •
    /Vi
    v
    4
    •:.' J
    •

    .
    i

    E*OlU +iOOQTLJ
    I MARX -I Aftev ' MQYX

    I
    ©

    ^ fobioo
    '
    G£0\OV\OOOYU
    '

    Sodoi ofopfaos
    SOCJO \ iSrd
    SyodiOai ferv) £
    m 4 Qocfchisry)
    1 Quild ©
    Ki goo'ou'sro
    vv
    -VJ
    ~v
    •
    i)
    Sodaiisoos After tvyarA <*>
    © PeviSiooisrv^ / pvoiu -h'QoOry Sbaa e /

    i fero
    Stbolqxs - fduard J rosteio ©

    — ^
    <
    i 4 karl kauiskj
    •• «
    tbrkjrf P^ogifarorog a £>

    -O
    •

    GeroQ be©OIU HOO fs d+b &i- ^ pcs


    • £
    : c
    4
    .>
    ^

    ha ^ tO
    °
    s££2rkj ; Wo no) dosses abound adopt
    '
    v«
    5
    c
    >c fed iQnoQoirQ^y
    cipi 4beo cao
    oof opo9
    ^
    Rot$4 to SodaHsrO Siooe 4b - cf ^e lo roo-p ey -
    G
    ©
    !;
    •
    >
    get toei ?r foterey- pinpined even Vto'tfongb
    -
    , 1
    :
    I iost’4aVoOal ho©Hood's - E c
    i
    i
    ^ oiu h'ooQ- y soa'aits^o popular fo Q°sroaoj .
    fv 4
    "

    3
    S
    3
    © Fabianism ^ CJOOS

    SI
    8ri -Hsb V//

    ponocao VartehJ
    3 of Sbcia lis^o - basod ideas of
    oo toe
    i Qeoesa ) E&bUS Tbe
    fib
    :d*
    .
    ] policy op fabibs coas 4o strike
    •' :1
    uben Y&oo is bat • £b>
    OOotSM sociau\ 3ho (V ^oois, * *
    '

    proposed -hat aOCiaHsno colli oof (2yroe a \Je9rOlgtat


    X

    •
    I to© ba> jp to
    pi©pQT© society -pSer sacia i isto -
    :- j
    ©
    ’ '

    -.- J
    . .i
    ©
    1.

    .
    I

    1 3 #
    !
    :
    .
    -
    -up
    •.

    :id ‘

    Hoi
    >rs -.

    :- V !
    : :A ©
    } ooW coheo 1t tebnoSS
    1 @
    .
    £ociO usro <uo fee~ SoCCQSStu
    or>horaoQS !ose phe ooicpe aspect op Pafc>io
    - .ofero is
    tS
    -3
    '

    • >* •
    '
    15t © 6bcio \ is o thsoagb roidciie Gtatss03 - TBe ©Cocated
    *
    •

    iSedtfoo -fcro -fc& Middle dees com take op 4t>e ^spo


    I© ' .o ~
    *
    i@ sibii iiy -fBr d<*te loping a coarecess Fabians bave
    _ ^'
    •

    &#**&** biao oociQ es - Fabians


    beireve Fo
    #
    basic ^ ^
    |9
    * ^
    >
    23ooepts OF
    i
    +•

    9
    (

    CC class sboqQi-e % RoyaluP’oO ' bioo ^


    SDCiauste fodode 9cbo\a«s I!fee Qeo«ge SQ«m*d 9hQ= ,
    t
    o
    9 *
    I9
    I
    :- -x
    Sydoey acd Beatrice Webb - G.-DH (ble, /note Besaot - y

    i
    ?3
    '
    :&
    if
    z © Fabiansro loots a slate as a foaio cgoncy -fax- bringing
    a
    I#
    *
    saaausoo fo pent ne&sbip Civil society.
    ^<^>0 Soaoifero is fcosGcS o«o Fobjoo te> no
    «
    4
    i
    6
    © Oulld Sacian'sro —
    © teacefitl Baroioeot scholar —
    Gr -DH - Cote.
    •
    .t
    © JC+ is also o British vcnHety op Soabi(sr o, >
    .?

    Ic 9 Accord \Oa to Gr ’D ' H. CQ\e tt>e TTPO | iotete is CCOOoro'c


    Interact - Hence, -beise iso need few ad^
    3
    '
    * © eqooto ^representa i

    op M3 TTioua, Geo • lotetfCStS O po Ii cy Ma


    i
    .t
    <
    © ' troy .
    Ouiid socio i rsVs also sbotf© Ssnoe basic pw’ ocJ pies tonp
    t - © Marxnbra iodad ag ebss toggle Sqt do oof considev
    c
    :
    i

    o 's o / uttao QS Q.
    '
    i. - ^
    0O - H * Cole has
    roecessi-b- . c
    : ©
    psepo sac -
    a Functional
    r
    %
    >

    i © $aeitexraeot Qioocj toT+b fbu'-Hcal


    4
    5 ©
    •

    m
    i-<
    :>
    <
    ©
    © RincHoooi 'vepeeeowHooaioqg
    arxJasmii DenoootQcy or Ce
    Rnticlpavtoo Of - uzotKets^
    coracy
    - +^ ^
    'ttrdiaroeot
    © ’10 01
    ^^00
    (c lodastwj .
    •
    1 :

    ii
    Am in
    1

    19
    .5
    ^aoageroeotr :
    i
    I
    5

    Ii © ;
    i
    f
    0 Jrn 5
    I
    s^ I
    |@ i
    $

    I© i
    v
    i
    t

    I{ a ..
    i
    E
    1'
    f
    6
    1 £
    © F
    i•
    I©
    4.
    S

    I> ©
    I? © 5 !
    i
    1
    ?!
    !S 0
    s i
    \0b I
    p
    i B
    ; ;• '
    • . -'-r-V -'. •-
    f
    @ g nd \ca\\sro
    0.

    ^
    Ci- iSQ p*eocb vatfety of SDcion is^o -
    Syod103 \ «3*v> soppo-irlrs violent - .I* is
    Ao -tb©
    VT:
    ef

    i
    -

    QxPaBs
    faeas of ^ bBesides
    faM YPC* IMQ
    ©
    ?A - '
    influenced . by Geof ) Sowg\ Abe author- of PefTecf IOQS
    . £2
    VS
    •;: . On violence • ^
    lecboqoes proposed - Tbey papoee atetVs poctoets, c-
    Sicxo tOCwfc .
    According -to fbeso the© is oo need of pofviafl ste*fe S
    i
    • i
    . .5
    " ,

    only -eoooroio slate fs enough -


    .3
    j

    I .vj
    Qffepeogg (o Guild § gcjodtoj-te ©

    ^hsadess
    '
    nds TSQPRESENT dt f reov
    ^
    , cooScirog fS ? cooTsfers
    ^
    ©cooonoic g^oopfo life
    ^
    - <JPOG)CS
    &
    fe

    Syndicate cx&o. Just coorf /oy class © §


    <
    w. gcxbisatvoos •
    «?
    - - V
    Society dll te Cbofetettfoc, op eu^dloa-tej .
    Ehtae ipoioer coin be lo
    f.
    r
    i
    *» bonds or coorte
    ?>

    Q- Oo you -tool OK SocictHsro can -enoe


    ^ •

    ^ e fo ' jst
    Ai
    5

    0
    CD
    Century as Aoti - capitolfero -
    frplQiO Soda i tSr-O.
    ^ ^ ©
    ©
    :a
    Rapalavif ) of Sopoiisro
    - e
    d Since -the Pc4og) of CO©OinOMOSr<5 VO fcJSSJO f tbceod op c
    ^
    •

    - sV
    •

    Cold OOCttT Qocionsro 6CQ9 fh>s roqjoY


    icfeolc0iQ3l cbalierrp t& ©
    ribeoiisrvo. divided ioto -foo blocks:
    toas
    —
    >•
    • V,

    . . *>
    :- 5
    3
    ( ) Frsk l
    ^
    o?rld.
    The Cqpftaifgt- dQorb!
    O Secood tOo? jld - Social - 3
    .- . I
    d-. isf Cororouofsh <UCry>Hrl .
    3
    Besides ^
    0,° cocoridl fbQsc
    pT
    ^
    : \i
    <UZ3QS
    !
    of bateos #
    - =r.i
    : coiooioi pasv f olnolog -io pq-vsue 4te
    £1
    Iv
    ••:
    1
    :l -
    tdOh Qi 'iyoroeo\ cobicb canoe -io
    toos biggoc ia-fberxp
    be ^
    o\ icy Gp /Td
    -
    bnotoo Ss yd ccxMd , - .- -
    V4 ’

    r'

    of sodbiif Sb? -ffpo Qqpf i. ferv, &-


    - .4

    :i
    ’ ^ C.

    :l %
    -h3
    •

    ?i
    - :1
    i
    - ©
    ;- .i
    ; ! ©

    **
    ©
    m-
    c :'
    !
    ©
    -r:
    ss @
    i.g
    :
    •;-r

    i !
    -
    •
    *•

    VJ
    t
    3 cacnrid CoMr> frlGS
    ST
    Social is^o big9& P&esencp 1*0
    ; #
    | ATOerto Tbe^ e «09 popedavf hy -

    1a ) of Asia, ^°
    Afbca , La ,

    of soaaifervo b^caose of nooss payt?* ty aolooial past -


    , *

    i1 f-
    :ii
    Y-oilavvb !H bbe value 3jStefO - MOn" tOOSte«Qo vCdaeS
    '

    ©
    g
    a
    ss
    >c ^ '
    ^
    (Tonoe roach o<?Q pr to Soa'Qiis - ttaap cqpf ta i ieoo Xb
    ^
    'M •
    ^
    '

    ij # -these vs
    3«Pab°tr i^portaoce
    •

    * h-bo toPSVQm societies

    3 bo cbUecfvihj. " • '

    i
    : @ -J esP COCK lot of a Ihacb'oo bocoords godansoQ even in
    ^ -
    • *s; p
    ’
    S
    raidedie east cohere ooaoy political Apa*ties i * te
    I0 Bathtest party iO £ 03 §. Syria *
    •

    :d
    1P Mocoever , oof -tb bdoC? di£, \ r c ufOO Op OSSR \Socia liStvo
    1 bos iost HsathracKcso - ^ ^
    -

    I ©
    1t Xb 03Os toe SOP the esvaVn (sh^oer a f -He eroooy
    V

    >
    •
    ?
    s Nteo - libera 1 feirr Ma?rx ^GQS pnoc] ctfroed os a <3pd
    * ^
    i ©
    I. bbqt- bos fat led . .- v
    5* #
    5:
    :v
    •

    15 © Xtfsteue bbof sociaiiervo Cannot da ( Abe 3=?* \evG\


    ^ ^
    1O 5f aocoftaoce as (f
    COQS before \££ps - tAof any country

    ^
    4
    ! © tan 30 entirely pur
    aDOau' politics or Socialist eco
    '

    ^\ed
    oonry - ftocoQ\ 9!f it S> beiie -tba-h SOa'ai is^o sh>oulcd
    10 J ) (

    oof be Q3cs1desp>d Os OuSrHo op j-h'SrVOOj


    ?.
    f)
    %A t&th (3 believed that SocitaMf ro tail ! *rO ’erv e5
    ^ > g£
    <
    c

    -Hoo
    ^.-
    Aot/ - Cqpita ( IQVD io a|d ceotdrry - KO^ y QOb' _ otobaifsq
    t •
    rocxyeroeots a e cbosfciesed as Aob' - c
    * pf trusts
    ^
    V © Socialists § Marxists scho lars do oat ocoopt
    “

    > © sociaifono Oo Mc sno bos lost its OSISVQOC -


    ^
    V

    ^
    "
    I
    V 1S Accord f03 -t Raipb i
    ° MUibaod , bh>G oathor- op &a’ct 1 i

    I? ® b5r sgephcai
    43c - published io \gg MeoHooo that ^
    -
    fh Q
    ^ ^ oosoo -Woat- cqpj o
    4be + fsno toas ’beep -tbarTOuph ly ^ -;
    5
    I
    1
    'brans -psrnoed
    4. repasent & b&(- tOhicb Vxtcoao V-Tod
    ^
    V

    t ©
    O/er
    bapeio achievete Ojreadpdl slar - S Ur- op> baooao
    s
    V

    10
    &
    Trace - cfccfcb t
    I© c
    «
    ;

    l
    l l
    l 0 %
    f I
    c
    ©
    © *c
    i
    Y

    m
    i
    \1
    i m E
    B] !-

    |> .v.y
    Marxist scbofer Emmanuel . VAtaOergtelo m
    Im -
    Aoo -tber
    has ooy -hen aptoos •
    i

    /© }

    -|o b<<r> , noaoWod


    n- •J ! Aarordioa 's O ©
    fHber sneia ] {e«D or QarbpYopx ^
    .
    '

    .
    ©:i

    :oiA 1
    ©
    Eaqietoo - sot < s pasB'poobie ko 2Py -\toaf soda i s^o
    (
    TefTM
    ‘

    5 g eievQot • aod
    ?A
    c-;i ~
    oatda . * «*»e «x*M bos #
    ^*
    ;Y<
    • 33
    ?>•
    :> 3
    changed \bQ xvxwQ it has tecoaioed ea* ©
    •
    $
    ;-.-M
    v.-J
    £1
    y
    Ibeqoa n'Vi'es tct>ab t-coxe present to S ?> 9i
    -
    ass ve eno©0iocj . becaose of capitalists global isatoo -
    ^ ceor ^ k<!

    Hw}qs pi tetty io bS boavc - Capital \0 oft century alto ©


    ;:A
    ©
    sa noco boeo ineqaat ities a?e rtsiog abound 4b© globe. -
    ^Abo/© vietos suggests that Qociausra xeraatos iropovf - f -
    ant bGCacos toQquatt -fetes OS9 vising , - ^
    ooi as ao al-ter-
    nativo to capitalism ., Socxaifeno ‘bill uGnaato yelgbxotctc. ©"
    y

    -.
    •X

    &
    ©
    V

    a -
    of capftoirsro- Soa'aifeno <-olli ’secncdo l^opoyfuof
    4o ensure 4bat cqptfeaiism
    £
    .:
    V ;o burvpnc Soce, gtoba ) &
    '
    • y
    :©
    Poa octal Qn'Sjs -Vb©«o t9 a grocotb of oofean\) rjgbt but
    V
    Qias ‘,n roarg c&uotm'es of ©usoipe. -
    ^
    ©
    ©
    •
    •1
    '

    ©
    l *»
    :
    !
    :: &
    <3
    -
    . ri V
    A ~r
    .. i
    i
    © i
    U:
    r s

    . -*
    ©'
    ii
    i•• u
    Sci

    & y-'-\
    £-
    • •

    :V 3
    ] " ©
    v4 [
    @
    - :c
    *

    1 ©
    ©
    #
    \
    ©
    @
    ::c'

    ©
    •• • ..
    :v -
    i i bl:/
    **
    V
    - 0

    -s
    : oS:
    MdRxtsn
    i3 &
    •
    t

    1a ©
    •
    Scboo\s of © crab'sro
    1« s r arxfsv g - er V^cx-fX
    I
    3
    ;
    ©
    -
    r.

    4 *?:,-:>->
    l
    Cnr -Vbodox bdarbist
    ^ ^
    y
    1
    tdeo - Mcnocists
    V
    :d

    CsoviOi Ma-rvist )
    :
    :-:.B5 ©
    t
    Q a saij
    :!
    a
    s © Bogles MO.O
    ^^
    l
    Leoir) 1 I
    1s- © *> On-Hcd )
    *
    i

    Stofn f ’
    Scboo |
    grzuck»s|
    a -
    ds <P
    be
    •

    Sto )
    >oo
    B
    a fo SQ luye^obu-g
    >

    * © l
    : tf
    •

    :S

    ! ©
    ® Otobodax btotods^o /
    l

    believe -Ytoat teal Ma^visro S -vbe ideas of tda^-ee


    >

    1©
    /e Ircpotffaooe. 4o +h& Loo^rbs HV
    '
    : NX
    *** . Tb’©j gf ^ .

    13 © Agels
    CDnorouoiSt r dao\ festo - P soos Jite,
    - » LOoio
    11 #
    ^
    RrQjOdpd Uqrl poaw as a <5od . and bis pedWoos
    .

    1. ©
    Ot*e boaod to be a
    ^aV
    t
    5
    Icy 0
    OTT-Vbodox-
    NdavtoSb cooside MavxfSi'o Qs a Sci'eooe
    !: © * •

    >
    •:
    t
    ?
    <£? ^ caosider ft as a sdeobfc e bioaWoo
    T&e ^ast- fnopo toot p-doo' pie
    ^ of
    -

    toawisro
    of Mis^a
    is ©
    ^
    - Ca l Matoba i isr-o •

    ; © Coobn'ba+i'oas of Leoto ) Leoi ofe^o -


    U3b)0 Is toe |SV pp& soo Obo cocUd s ccess Uu taplenoeov
    e d
    ^
    Maiocfst ideas Hocae^pir , teolo bas QISO roaefe
    • e lob op
    ^
    © ( o -fee ideas oF tori
    CVA
    Hicypy- QaobibaHoos of io 4be -tbearq of boaodsRo - (£nio
    © 0 (Oocepv of cononpyjoisf- pQytq - fc?rojpcfiBto+
    ©3
    1&S UDQS givep ty Usoio \o ©to f*Wpfetke aedsa -y -tied
    o bcbot is to be diooef Sioce ccoatdog class woese not able
    \
    # to <deMe( ope asoscl outness OO rfe c oo feoto of
    * ;
    bdogio cononoaoist pavt as Vao guard of Tfexo a.ttOo -?
    •
    1 " (
    ©
    ©
    ^ ^ r
    i

    ©
    0 I
    »

    © 1f :
    t;
    ©
    ?
    :i
    © 5
    L
    l
    fc
    :
    £
    I
    r?7Si
    pc\yKj ~ i
    1to ® C -. F QVU -^ 5 of COQrouoiS-f / rev,

    0 0frjoi9f potokj I S
    F !r0oV ftodc oofoos -
    tol
    to
    f

    i
    ^^
    ©I copanouoSl d i|
    ^ '

    - potoy fob^ a seoref soci fj Hr bas te


    ’
    !
    Q

    to
    cGo t s Gn feiCJ .
    & @ 2
    . !1 , it rs
    si ;
    ©.
    tos psoginara-o-e ^
    A
    Si s to b °3 Tetoiu+foo so Oo SVci
    :i
    (
    ^ 6
    ©rad© oofoos system - © '

    ^f of Capita isb un
    1 <
    Qire PQ
    T&ade 00G05 cao de/etope ao , brad © '° 0
    : '51

    \ ood oo|'&©yoicj -HooQ-vy coo9doasb>e3S - ^ ° 030 #


    5

    3
    to
    toS
    £4
    to
    @ Cbnoroctois^ *cfiU differ fvano Bcu«geotee to
    4bo\ r organisation - Oopig©c> i9e. p3.5-W©s Qs£? .Hiefcutondca i .
    © payees
    ) Ifaam pcxoes ts caoceohated ( o toe bards of " . l©ad© sbip . by (Of
    d * '

    1
    1
    © Cononajoisb fpsty fop \ bp boaed 00 to9 principles op @
    Cproacscibc OOfDroaotSV pctvH ) is c* pcparofdfcii )|
    CentiQ \ l'9rO ’
    I |
    OBgarasoboo fcwoad at tos base T)Cfs?oto <o2r fbe top
    Tie QPCQ \ \©V ao't is called as ce\ i O- wepraseo&s -Vbe > 0|D|Q **
    at toe grass Tfoot P -
    0^- »

    gsass . V
    '
    • h
    i decide toe ^ f opietat TSO©

    roab pBogyanoroe of 4be pasta . if eotM he ^


    level of IJ
    ©
    to - ^
    ODrarou ofca ed 4o toe top leadership ' Af toe toh eOlll be . jfr s

    to
    to . -
    toe ceptxal a>ro*ofdee ®ot«3| cpror-oftfee afth decide ©
    peoples cieroaod . to psoct/cle ptog xpra ^oe of acKorv ooce r -
    . {• ^
    : *<
    to:
    t
    decided pgag^aroroe V s to be 'irope.reeotod octal! levels
    ^ ©
    -
    V

    :7•
    in tofs oae My&Q col U be centra tvscdnoo •
    ^
    .’

    • r
    .

    © lemo txroaghb toe T^voiabooapy cbse -


    peasaotsy eoitfoio
    (: '

    cefespas Kqvi MQW COAS against treating pe santey cts ©


    .4
    V

    ^
    Ti JOMftoooog because fcfaey / toay posse oaroe ORooaotaf
    '

    t
    .v‘i
    •
    ;
    l
    ^
    load - Go \y pisoiltotoah Qao be yevoiuboooopj .
    ^
    tot

    toi
    ! leo^o toed to bs'vng cono^oc oisi TP^votuVtoo lo f
    to.- :

    to
    fd-eda 1 30 deig .
    •
    to ;7:

    4
    gj leoios blggasv eooVto bub'oo is bisfbeary of inape^ aHero. ©to ’
    • •
    Cv*

    Sj
    ~. .1 - ©
    i
    ©
    :i
    ;l ©
    .;;;i
    .i ©
    @
    S 1

    to ©
    to-i
    #
    to
    'to.

    ito i
    w
    V •
    '

    -
    ' L
    -
    JI

    I©
    Of leo'so’s book- IIrop
    ^ allSr,Q h>gbes+ slage of Capita ifsn
    ‘ .
    &
    bos coof^ned b'ts c*oQU_ jts 3 o-p oqpi-taifeoo lO
    vG ’
    (;> VO% \ Mar
    ^
    3 •
    *
    *
    ••

    - @
    :s doroesHc cootexi He bas cot- c5 iscussigd.Pbe Octe oa )
    •
    :S
    ^
    •
    ‘
    S
    •

    aspects oF cnpTtaibrv . -it ccas leoio iobo Qoaiyaed


    t»
    ;.c

    ^
    xs
    extcrcal agpecfs § teo'105 Ujeotcj
    -
    beoxraxo -ihe bq.Si'5
    1
    - #
    :. 2
    & h-oarsdst tbeorci op btOfnabooa )
    •:i
    £t
    :s

    »
    © ocy dcboof) . ^ poi1' pcs C 'Cepaoda ~
    .:r »
    s obhUiAvy,
    © (£QiO b>as Ckppcded -Vbe nov 4b -Vbaf frqqpda
    "O
    *
    .s
    s
    F noeo's basdeo - £ is oo-vbirg bai 4foe bfcjbe ^ ifeno 1s ZCbK<e
    *
    r r>

    ,
    v
    X5
    1
    £
    3 © capita HSno. be has gW<?o S stages op ^ toge of
    CtjpfevCano -. ^ '

    1
    H
    S3
    @
    35
    0 Mercbaoti' le cqprtcnfex-o
    © Ibdu&gt&ia\ &?p'Fi 1 rsro.
    ••

    # .:? > '

    1 ©
    i: .
    @j Roootg CapftQi isr
    a -
    - 1
    V

    be bas
    55
    , °
    ^ <»« % ' bad 4F>Q+- -If cocts
    d Is
    i

    # ^ ow \ o3
    52
    ss
    B
    '
    dpOOgbt
    dbe capitalists iOac- erxie
    of sapposbog 4 EYDCLFOOCI1ist? pq be$ '-
    1 | “ b-ho agedQst b ^ ^ >
    :4
    1
    :i
    ©
    n
    © ’w^
    ^ ^ \ 5pe2r1 a it's o - Leoi' o SQS
    | bat-iboa 1 isho fo -tbe espy pcci ^ ^ oot cfcepJQst-
    ccas - trsoia
    ’
    QNiQo
    •

    <•
    *Xe
    © °°
    ghV 'tbqt cot nou oist *seva,(
    '

    04pita 1 !5»>o fig


    ^ M-Hoo can staaf cxgQi
    ^ceb
    © coiootes -
    .
    ^ F
    3
    :

    !
    i Q-
    :*
    *? a
    • :c

    1©
    I* ©:'
    .S

    1©
    I
    I:ii © i

    ! £
    © i
    i
    :

    © 1
    ?
    1
    1 I

    It ® 5

    ©
    P
    K i
    ©
    ©f
    S

    - 5 y
    e :
    ?
    .

    R
    ir ©-
    s
    I© .
    15

    r?
    ! I
    &
    5 SSi5S&S 3?Sr>>Civv i>2 --vwi”-' s
    ^
    V '<
    ^ ^ « »

    £
    <r-
    [MAO becfqte 2-9 m
    -
    :ws
    a
    «

    f£3 pe^soo to app' l


    ^^ y
    coas the -P'Ss
    -vj
    K\ QO
    COmrouO Sf- principles j« pM Kj A
    '
    OtiC ' ^ p
    tqaPoos Sf « o pu^tj fuedai Ood ^ -
    .w
    Pd
    p1 >
    ^ ,

    r,v

    -A V
    Maoism ISO pTQg'rvXrtiC §• flexible pbvnQ Op Cb^Oredo \£rO - t.
    '
    Maoism is not against cqpitQMsro - MQofero I'S also not
    -d
    O GitO5i MobooQlis no Masisro vs acpiaQf — *
    0 ^ ,

    ffl Poedorvsro
    <s XropeTfia t S'OD ©
    m Mao roods soroe ibodanoarta! oborges vO the. theory of
    Cbrorouoisro - i^bo accepted ai| principles of . Mcmfero tv to ©
    %

    Historical MagicsiisTv DOleeHcs , Class Sbuggte, peyoiupion


    ^
    hrtod to r^oodi -fg MQvtSsno to suH Chinese? iSAt-uatioO • ©
    china coos inter national colony colo oia\ possess- have nsta -- <$
    i /

    :• -
    bVisbed thQb \ nfkjanceio different rones - china ecas aPo
    CqecJlal Soa'
    •£1
    lb• Siy toi+b tong bistosy of peasants ^revolts
    Moo biroe>c(f conoe -prora feasant -fanolp . OTOC does oot-
    •
    • 4

    ^
    Consider peaSQOty Qs -hbe n voiuHooavy class bsr>i
    &
    b•'Bought peasants) ,0 the ^ °
    .
    >
    m
    1:5
    :- - o
    Ui 9ob<5 vdioate position revextiHbnawy class, bett- in
    l :1,
    to vdoirldog claves • Mao has gfver)
    •

    centra / poaitioo to
    '
    ©
    the R6vo ( u 4-ioo
    :•
    r- t.
    :
    :?

    <
    V
    to
    Peasant ' «
    rrr

    $ Mao toas inttuenced oot only by tq?r! MQTOC he coasa o ©


    •
    $
    5
    S
    £
    iC -fiuenced
    pcahbns
    -
    ^ '--
    by Mgcbton/dl © Mao bos noade -foliocoina Modi CM
    '

    , i
    . 6 .
    l
    Dialectics
    1
    1 AntagonasHc -
    diaiecHcs roQaos
    V3S?

    Pcraoci tiahoo is
    oof possibiP - /tCfiirdlog to
    -* M Q Q J people have* otogo -
    d oiSdc coot dicHoop coith
    ^
    geense. jrape na ns-fe feiodai ebse aod fd qn Bour - * &
    J
    ^ •
    ^ ^ @
    >too AhtagooiSHe
    -tYaeaos corAYcidteVioo echdido cao be. ©
    isesoived By . \p case
    ebith indegenous of cbtoa MQD held no aon-fsodtre-fen @
    Bcuryoolse ebss-
    ’ *•
    -:
    1
    !
    ©
    :•’ 5
    i
    ©
    . -!
    ©
    •

    @
    i
    ©
    '

    :!
    * y-i
    #
    ri3
    1 .;*X
    \

    r :i
    a -
    :<
    I© MQO's c5ocppir OF PFVOM -
    H OO
    +
    '

    h£*h +0 001( 0;
    - 0

    Jo MQVX - fs only ooe revoiuHoo


    3 ( •
    fe 04
    riC

    Is ©
    ‘
    rcode of rrhdadHoo -
    O3fX0pt of
    05 '
    ° KlQOfero
    ^^
    vr>cao0ot- PF^OiuWoO -$• peya ( J^bas ot
    >

    MS
    :S
    ©
    .

    fcisaiqgi ctji boatovlol


    '
    Sl ^ '^ -
    F
    Htoo has 0ivt?o Hbe Concept- of Qu-FrUlO lAku-fbxp, -'
    & 1
    .
    i
    I$ © kiarfare Should be 4ta? of pocxs •

    * {
    *3
    .
    x '
    ^ aeTn' llQ
    Mao coos also a bscAegjsb Jb bis Rod Ebcf ba discos©
    ^
    1© -tbe Sbsa egy 0f pevoiufoo . Accord i og -fob x people ' );

    3 ^ -ery 4o COpVtnrC +be pp>Hpbe* M \Pe. fc<+-


    Should I9
    ' ^ XJ
    "

    3
    3
    Nibbles • He befd -hbaf people / Masses sboaid aHacc- cohoo
    ^
    3
    Fs
    I ©
    •

    !
    ,

    £
    Gc>e<rxj is T^esPog -Hbey Should XdkbdTfQ to coboo eoenoy
    cum*y a Hacks .
    ^
    ^
    "I % 4cco*cMocj 4o Mao, Rbcoor -Pot £ -H ooc *gH 4hie kcrcneJ cJr oo -
    .5

    I: ©
    5
    (
    ^
    & twbos 0 o<n*y oDoy p0ope coo
    ^
    ° ^ io po^oe ^r -ic, ^ ,

    l
    * © ; ^
    soacjb violence .
    •

    Carppare M ao
    eOi 4b C and b\ -
    -v •

    I©
    •

    !©
    5
    ~
    Ba4b MOO § Faodbi ^ _
    coo\cnoponX»x'GS - ©ato Have beco
    Soccessfal TXQSS leaders • to-f ^ uence of boYb 3«o be/ood
    t
    -
    '

    x
    © fhsiY OcOQ Couotoi'ps • ©Ofb dbogbf - agcuosf CDrowaoo enenoy /
    <2V< I is - JfOpC’ 2ricn S<X> -
    5 ’
    »
    |© '
    Motoe r> Abe Hoo differ to ACinrcQs of Stoat-egy , If c ejodb
    £
    | (;i 5 ^ vioeoce as ag A'd-ide of b!-to> §. spgQCsved
    ^bosvdeirpd ^

    _^
    *c

    oori vioieof MXHbod


    '
    os a '‘Aehbod of shrog e - rr •noasses .
    ?
    s> .
    .•

    I? ©
    <©
    Mao bstf -eved io violence . MQO be(d +hQf
    dbzroogb 4Pe baxirel of oo. if ctfodbi spgQecHsdF pcrOC ^r COno-C^S ^ ^ 1

    oiqae of
    -Vbe feob-
    - a g
    foedHa Saf
    © j ?rainq Mao sc pc d -Vbe fscboiguc Q> f
    i

    5 ©
    ( c*£&T QifQ
    ^
    Yor mosses
    *
    _ ^ ^
    •
    s
    % (f-A
    '
    Iboogh bafb QTSC SacceSSfd I bqf QaodbiS»X) lS'naorallu SopCJrfo;
    f W \o MQoisro viol^oc0 c3o0S nof TS S .I V TO -VO aoy eoiu±-i!30
    * *

    I vToieoce 0\VQ
    *

    vbleoG? AcOD^ ^ iog Ao qoodbi , Vfoi0O<"


    *

    ^
    .

    to ©be Aoirv^a \ gj
    *
    ^
    +be ^oo cf
    I @
    R
    ^
    cO'itl noQ
    ^ ^ 1
    S
    Si
    R
    1
    © A^covdlog Ho <5bodbF Jbere_ LS CX oanrHcaftry b^koeeb -eods
    aod •

    >* © i
    s
    i ?
    !f © G V o eov
    ' ' -
    es - QossiQo
    ^ cbioese JrQVon '
    «

    ©
    j
    1 vj
    -

    S © i
    ;
    ; ©
    ;

    r
    f
    ;

    m i
    r
    © !;
    !
    © /;o
    ©
    V -

    iO enbpocoeirroeni- p
    i Tb^G Revo lu -b'o O s did oot eod @ *

    n op Hasses •
    !

    «o*

    -:1
    ;

    NSEO MARXISM}
    c
    r.'.v;
    '
    v.

    :::i
    i
    i
    To OGO - roav>dst-o +fc>0fe cxsQ schools bolb cire oFlU 1

    s
    | - ?oce?dby Qnszarosci .
    V

    CD CTST -HOOI School // fraOhibid School "" "


    ©
    "‘
    ""

    prootford school coos - otivodcd io roai- io !


    0^OS SuV ©
    :i
    •

    •
    -J

    Ofpr oo
    y ^ ^ '
    .

    shifted to tbc ooWShStty op COucbbia Bpcausp op ©


    • :i
    :
    -i •
    HrhGSS
    '

    1
    •
    poHdpg, -
    pro rofoeoV ScbcAa&S -
    !
    m
    I. .
    ©
    r. © &nc pzororo ' I

    V - '

    © Max Hor betcoev ©


    :-
    © Theodore^ /rdo oo , 't
    ©
    -
    ;y © Marbart MarCUSS ©
    0 Goutco op Jb-Pugoce .
    ’ #
    a
    •T

    Sari Marx
    "

    bi
    © Me3^t ©
    ©! Sproood Phud Q
    ©
    Ulby (t is kootoo as arWcoi school ?
    ’
    1
    Critical school ' 3 lo dialectics cof -tfc>~ ©
    a capita
    •
    l .

    iv i is fa . ©
    © RoHonaiisto £ Eoi i btcoraeat} .
    Orthodox Marxism^.
    ©
    ©
    1fo< y doere asi'+ical of csov^et Markisro - They ^oare also ©
    -
    .. Vi; cd -Hoal of Fasdsro .
    ©.©•
    V©
    y' t.. vibest is 4beir cooearn ?
    :

    :•:!
    “
    Their Vs eroaocipaffoo - They beiOeve -that dbe real
    COOCQVO
    £ ~j.'\
    OhjecfvG of VC MQrV aDaS> f ^COQ o«fi 3EpQ-H'oo Of reaQ glViO 1
    CLf -
    ^
    :•
    (

    ^hro f ^Qechro Bpa \ eaosG • «7 ob)Gdt ihe vyie^o -teat tfce


    ^ m
    15 201 Concern of Mcwx «oas class druggie
    " ( TjoyoiaKoo as
    prppc4ed by Ma*yig4s - ^ %
    m
    1 ©
    ©
    ©
    #
    **
    m
    fey

    1 @
    aoce to Masanc COoc<opf op
    ©
    » d.' They
    Yyysi-e 0\\/ <?n i^po ^
    Acsordfog to tbemo leoaKor oa&
    ) * oafeocN
    -^
    & ( eno^ on •
    ^
    •

    Strepgttoeopdh
    5 ‘

    © ©
    . - O'
    'rqtbGfr QOt roO'tfCt

    © Optical Marxists bove of pxploV-v=M -b


    aoaysecf the oeco - -

    © adopted by oqprfa »lsro- dbey* bod oocMyeed -the oq-vase op


    ©Kpiot’+ah'oo io fbsV capita iisf 30 ci-ebes £b soviet Oobo •
    ©
    Tobt iftain'ao society bos caroe ^ota xbeoc^ fiCxbpre +be ^g Os
    > >
    I /©
    :S .©

    »0 OjpHa ( \0h soaeHes pe«ope


    fl
    :'d

    1
    s
    ©
    no hope for -feedovo S«5‘ i yar •

    ^
    hove bocoroe roore Stages dbao ecttd G "- 'v a>c Hovl ^* 00^ , *
    ^

    '
    I a (
    •
    bas con+feo aboa-t o crtive dialectics ' - *ACCOnrd ( o9 to bepative
    . s
    -S
    3
    i
    © ^
    Dialectics cop Q e OOt roovioy -VocciqYcis pseedono "rather
    *
    novfog tecoavds
    -

    1 © slavey The project op onn'gbleofoeob 's ahoy


    •

    1a ® '°5 Order - Critical school orbelap owe On+foa| op srjerxy


    -
    .

    IC
    i

    ( >
    Science promotes ’ fosta-qmeotal 'yabooQif-ty ’ . science bas and
    errofmpd
    4
    I
    @ ^
    e, \iDpodaoce op values pk y? oq t i { . Accoitdfocj
    ft3 Hetbey t'baTcose
    * * * £
    science bos pakpo cxaaay ont-foal ypqsob' o
    :
    i
    -a ©
    .

    bciroao fceJn33 bpbayo 15 Ve a bend op


    sheeps § goats T>> bis,
    . •

    '
    •
    © book One. Oiroeosiboal Mon be sqggeste -fbat coe a-se tlvVn
    t

    '
    I
    .

    \ © to COosonopriSt
    & sodety cobose ca (4are is coosumebst •

    !© R?rSooQ if kj op toc o bee bpcom>


    -
    na cfepoooQiooQ 1 • The- on y
    ‘ * ° ° -
    (

    dtcoene>;oo is diroensfao op ODosoncrer 2qpff<q u's y) euWives '


    !i © by creating- -false oeedsv Scholars life bbr kbeinoG '
    (

    f
    > Cy] ' ^ ard
    Theodore Adoroo have analysed +be "role ^ Cqf-Rbe iodustay ,
    ;
    4PM~ irdqsfoy io "»pdq-!noy roao foio noa©S § +be 'noie Csp •

    i © MOSQ rrjpdvd vO onpatoo op IMQSS society -Adcncoo bos ana ys d


    • \ G
    i
    the Impact oP capitalis^o 00 phasic • ooy such rouse Cs p-romo
    "
    •
    ^ '
    !

    Ted cObi'cb Id 1 (0 QeosiPvittj - Mqsfo has been y<pducsd to SeiS "


    1 G
    , T

    4v: © roocjYQp>bic fraunoatic


    ' ^
    shocks •
    <

    i ©
    :
    Recordir0 to these scholars s Mov>:tsf o ^boaid oo<r be coos'—>

    desed as a eiospd tblotdog - Mavpisro sboaid be considered


    i© as 00 open school a>f tboogbt As, society ebargio roetbod<
    '
    |
    ^
    t

    i
    ©
    s
    op e oftd+too are a bo cbctogloy . Hence, Mav>cfs rood op
    ^ © ^
    i# Ueoo
    ^ I
    Qoa is need to ‘
    ^ incorporate
    op evplorta-hon - Today "Abe roast
    ideas \o uodetstaod npao to
    effective vjay <op ocp o i-fa+ioo
    !@
    ? tbraogb cuttmp Caltciwe \& Ooao o eco . coro^cndity . CwHxSrrP Cs ' 1
    I b notO SO0 ?T pqndaased • 04 i-tare
    bos bccoroe dbe bat bf basic
    '5

    S^ acture. Qitture % >ts


    iropacp oeedb to fc o om ’ ,
    i
    5
    i ©
    i ©
    *
    ^ 5
    ?

    ! G)
    tv
    i © :
    :
    ©
    m |i / E
    1
    S ? @ Sfyuctohml Sc boo 1 •
    / iSfou # qviai fero - @ » -
    3C4
    -
    stoJCto 'riouS© according +0 Havx , ecooonofc
    r1
    r arx '«oas
    :
    • • •! ^
    Steuct
    ?:\
    ore (S -vb© basic siYackisp . Malis aritousad as '
    ©
    BDOO*-O ?C e+ewoiafs Because acca-rdio to Marx , m
    £3
    S3 ^
    Ecocorofc factor is -toe* aolu
    •

    beb iod^ at events - ' )


    Si factor #
    ^
    (jrarogci bos -fav -Vbpv ~oodippd Q fUCtovicifisro coad bxl2>
    ^
    also g\ ver> i^opo aoce to Qgper &bacfl«T2. > ^ ©
    Vi
    :•:!
    ^
    to>nssQr have -fortoer
    © ••

    ^
    •

    :V1 StetiCkrrfaifsr'O - ©
    Sorest- tocu fcoooroic factor is o er ctoterrofoed < 0 MQWC -
    1 +4e gives toe toocepv- ^ #
    of Mui -tipie stsuctosps- Hieto-yy oao
    '

    ©
    ftoro any rirudK-iif ?9 •
    ^ bad octo gMes toe -©cPropto °P ROSSIQQ
    i

    ©
    ^ yoiat/oo obicb

    - rg
    nrakb r poi fioal SVzfUcto
    & }
    •
    ftoro ecoocroHc stoacHD-ye ,
    ©
    KV
    'X ©
    v~
    .-v
    #
    @
    ©
    4
    ©
    '
    > i

    <3 ©
    <i
    f..''

    ©
    ©
    ©
    a r. .-
    -
    V MV

    V ©
    m
    m
    r -A-
    :
    :?>
    * •

    ©
    ©
    ©
    ©

    -
    Si
    :. .
    •M
    •

    m
    :©
    II
    v
    -
    s
    0

    m
    a © I
    1© O. S pOl rHCtl
    cx |
    .©r
    •

    o
    Csi^ oaMq analyse -tfca na+ave of fascism
    i© V
    Ideology .
    Analyse fbe -fa-ctoxs coblcb gives aise to FQSCISCXD .
    SJ
    "
    '£
    e'3
    S
    - © .

    A’
    op
    • 3.
    ©
    Q. Do you -HDIO^ fascism bos -ended colfb +be -end
    © pe ned abocxf
    2-nd Wo?nd War ? -Shod id ae akoays be con ^
    «

    1?
    .:: c
    j
    ;' : )
    jooasibiHy op arise of fascism •

    n &
    i Fascisro sagcxrded as political ideology . sa id aregoyd-
    is not <

    ed as Prcpngaoda xt i s Ixue -bat oonp op T-be ideology


    •
    ‘

    si © fells tarutb - Hocoaler, -there is no •Vjra+b ataii \o fascism


    • •

    .
    i:

    pasa'sm
    @ Rasa's no is foosidesed as Hodge- Fbdcje of ideas -
    © as ao ideology canoe after fascist slaves, gal- slabilsbed -
    ;
    ;i
    -3
    v- ^
    mv.- m These Bettes appointed Qcboicuss To osHc pbl lasopby ^o-f
    Rtsa'si-o - Fg - Moussbiini Gtppoiatetf Qeb-tile. teavaooi fa torvte
    a # ,
    m'
    j 4He philosophy of fascism - Maussoiioi bVase( f~ !-0'50 to>
    1© -
    -the philosophy of fascism- Rascism vs not- a systerocxHo
    : © school op Tbooght - fascist scholars baye to ten
    ideas -pVoro
    .

    i
    •
    *
    i © cPtfhtfcot philosophers To Jusf -py helr acMoos-
    a
    1 f
    ^
    V

    t
    1 # V

    -
    •
    >:
    v

    i P
    y.
    -- ‘

    \i Q)
    i
    if f -
    •

    3
    *
    * # :
    $
    I@ !

    ;
    © .*
    i
    1£
    m
    |
    !© i
    I
    ?

    i© I
    £
    :J
    •
    v

    1©
    i
    © F
    i:

    1 F
    © t
    6
    »
    Im :
    K

    i t
    i ©
    I
    ©
    1 )1. I
    E

    I K
    &
    t.
    .
    !< © V’
    ~

    -
    T'J SQS IC qssur-opfioos
    ' of fQscisp? - 49ckw 3o|5JJoiyaoTgT] #
    clsoojj by obseruaiioio
    rF
    v.! Basic, CSSOVtopHOOS Of Fascism (qo be
    ' F/

    i
    4
    J
    about -the -type of social poivHaal sys\eoo Abq\ eoas e^Vablf - ©
    ©1 io Hay Qp& taaoy cMirioy iotpr- <ioar pedad .
    ©
    fboa9b Mascisro § Fascism <^>re oof 4be only .

    XJ - e^noplcs - T besie <UDS3T© -exoTNcples cslsa 11Fa 3apa o ©


    ^
    '

    1 DOda*r fy,‘o CG Furo joayo, fbs-kyai t>oder Sotozar , pe^rooi -


    '
    ©
    <Sra io AogGotiOa - All obese Con bp oooeicioirpdi 03 vairiaots © -
    - fa
    Of lb4 ?fa riaoi9 -
    ai ro
    '
    Tbs basic cSt -Ff £ Poae
    * fOscfsoo
    --
    :i . ©
    •
    - Mascisro COQS 4baf fasciOno jgave pti'^aocy te +be state §-
    Nlasds^a taiv^d about 7 f a c& . @
    f -i
    23
    } . Fdscfero cao be
    ‘

    53
    to fascism QDZTQ value coos ooib) % SotfckjTrilt - -
    #
    Cbosideaed as Oliyct- naFrOoa ' vs^o - Hitler rocbe Trace 03 tbe #
    basis of oafonolis^ . f<bce
    ' bpcaroe -the. basis fear Abe Justr - @
    -pcafioo op f i tiecs Iraperrioiist poircies = v as
    nocoo ( jeobeo-
    V: §
    :

    lx OOTTUnQ . . .. <
    vx
    .v
    . Haroao Matclgg ©
    vx
    •
    .. .
    -V
    •

    vx FOsdsro is wpoafoo aap'OSf


    ^
    TsaFioobusoo - Risa’ar^
    -fbaf bxjraoo nafa-Fe is abided
    potions § oaf by b/
    .
    , .sI eeosoo . fascists palates- po / rb es of pa^s Toos - Ibs(g biOOGQ f-
    ’
    ©
    °dtF©passions rafa&x Abao appeal to TSTPQSOO . Klbgo possbos
    • j
    'osybfed 3bey bocoroe - coaFro\ob le §• v-sGo^e politics
    u o ©
    . +*,

    i
    1
    s
    of poesbos. ocoasSQ-aiiy cul^F*ates Toto VOFIDOG "
    . ©
    Fascist ^eode&s believe. < 0 the COoagpV of loeqoa 1 < hj l >Q y
    :Ii
    _ ©
    •

    • -t c00
    ^ biffeaGOc^ befcoeeo tea. roass
    ^
    FaasejQs to fce
    .

    ’ -the ceo-tira ( pasHtoo.


    s "
    .A
    <Dohsoi {<pcf & •
    ©
    tes Loader bos
    ^
    a
    •
    .?
    .V
    ' '

    tasasr^ benooods obsolete abfd fence. -fo oq


    '

    ,•

    ir teadejf & soppy roao * *ds 4fo© (eadlsr ^


    .
    •

    J - @

    I .

    :
    i

    ‘
    •
    i
    Society
    i^ po
    as OreatVe O sHiacti
    ^
    ^ on . Tbe/
    '

    values of eoilybteo ^oeot Fo) gbteo Deraf - p-


    ^
    -
    ce -to souejy .
    "
    MeJ
    004- 3a+fsf ?ed
    soinoofocl lyatK
    ^
    @

    e
    3
    r -.-.i
    O' llstn , lOd'iVick 3 tjSro , o
    * +fooioy op cas3o«as -t sacSi -Hoos
    --.I ^ ^
    fasdsr - ^ ^
    ^ cocote to ctesttroy ssefety § cq tj^ ^ «5 « - , ^
    _
    •

    of ^ fgbteonceot do no+ sfcppo 4 ^ ^


    ?V3
    !

    f aterotetfc coao sepetre? * 2Q


    forobls ca iffse^
    cDocep @
    K3

    oaot -to ireczrea-te dtoe ^sadety. ^O KI


    obe e peop ? ^ ©
    - y

    oof te ^ lQJcedi va +bev bFecov y


    ^ 4be^oseff ;0* cqituvp 4.>qd;+4c ^ 0
    ^©
    PT ,
    e
    :§
    m
    rfV'p

    -> •

    K-:
    <rC*>
    Ss frV:'

    1
    c:
    @
    4o \ K abociV^ oe^o -ooo .
    ^Obo f •peo rQQO :
    oonoroootty oc*KOO Or
    a Organically linVpd 4e> b p b \S

    ^ Pa ' io -GoeHc
    © I a \A*a - oa-b '
    of
    I
    a ©
    & no is kHOiOO as
    FQGCi
    ^
    csiisro. PcM / ogeoebc ropaos ve - b^Ab ^ F os
    ' naKoo.
    a
    a© Cbpcepfr o-T ©QKOO -
    .

    .
    ©X Tbe/ betieve ?o CCJ ibiSQ I oa+i’oca I isro ' CCJliqre is cx besfe
    -
    OP NIQFOOA iisro • caH aUvbfib^ isno W * bos asp
    1» * ,,
    C b
    '
    Pi
    .. K
    ^ t
    $i

    i5 ©
    '
    T O\ § esgaoic eotiy - a Sieves
    ^
    - Aba V noboo
    ^
    ,1 ecjlitr^Ot OafioOO \ \ SirO e>cdusivist .
    I
    •
    S
    ©
    fascists caese also a \bra. 03baoa ' \sbs - -
    £
    ''y :
    ~8
    .
    m Cqscfef
    4
    s8
    "

    :• - 6
    i
    © femk coocepV of Rfobts § ufcesFj
    t'JO Ooocepj- op aabes - ©eai liberty
    •
    - is O04
    5 © pigbtS
    I pgaiogv Abe sfme but uode© -the - cite
    I- © ^ •

    :S
    ••
    ©
    Fascfsf concept °F K1QV
    fqscisro jasbfy 'oar . £o
    Abe coo?rids» op rOauQsoi io i‘ >
    a @ 4
    .

    Mar fs +o r -eSt&\f $t roeo „ is toba V eoaAOsO' -to too roeo7


    ^
    "

    ©
    I ©
    Fascist ECooonojc Fblicq
    Acrtarkcj - rafoos OAf sofpofpocy ba^iog rdofrat possi -
    —
    1? © ble cooAaot ©ofAb ioAerocsAiooat econoroy Fascists ^ -
    A pq sufA
    Hbe policy of CbYpaYaFisco . TBey daK«-o 4bo+- -©LSQOV ^
    •

    I © slate
    is a coyporaAg QtQte • Garpora -te 4aAe
    •
    i
    i
    I & as eqoiiibinaoo rca *- § Aebog core op
    roeaos ^taAe - aofioa
    J
    5
    both lock&stey ^ as - jhe iotesest
    . t
    of
    J Qscoeil taosAeri .
    Fqscfero OH
    •
    > PgrOQCSQCCj ^

    '
    ir-
    ^ Th>OtJ0h fciSCl /SV CQroe +0 pOc^ ir loy <3p<
    :>:

    I OD becuro e *Aoti depooc ^ ff c • Aoxyrdirog


    ^ '
    - ^to M
    rooO^° cr
    ^ ^aisso-
    5
    5

    I #
    4
    '•p°aTniooeots
    f
    ' fs -toe MXrctoy OF
    ' ^ cb ooKo’oa ®od *

    I# « ^otbJrQ but. 4a\ ^og stoops -


    ©
    %3
    '
    1c © !
    i
    A
    l
    |
    s
    © i
    »
    :
    !© 8
    ;

    1
    1
    i©
    5
    I;

    i> ©
    tG
    ?
    5

    i 0
    1
    ;
    l ©
    (

    I
    \
    \

    .
    SjSrv wSSJ
    ^533S3SS?SS5
    :"rt
    m
    %
    %
    Sources of feflueoc
    t
    ^- i
    1
    • M (?:•

    ::•.)
    ^%$b ol-f obidfeooe t©ocsc$rds the state
    . 5 ’

    " 4
    ©L Ktocboygi i j eeperafbo of ethics § poi ifeicg ©
    -
    pcpsuft
    ^
    &
    mSi of pure pocoey politics » o -fbe ooroe op f
    i
    poqssouc - ^
    t ctKbo .
    POTOQob’Ol'^O io POUSSOU'- obo gctve He
    i

    1
    • COocepf of Qeops-oI «05 / 1 § Sqagosted bbaf
    - tioat } CQO
    - ©
    farced to p&ee .
    -
    8
    © HegQl - Hgcjei Held 4dQf state fe r pvcb op QocJ 8
    % ' oo esHb •
    pi
    p-
    ?ss-
    f
    ^OUasoitoi
    osed 4b e>oy that dbesp I© oo +b>\ ocj Outside, ©
    sdafe,
    Vs>

    '
    c
    obovp state . obe should soot pee b'\«o-se (P a+
    © t > e Q iter of -the state • ©
    *
    © vShrel - Au+bor of RePoc-Poos oo violeoce e
    iSjuel fos JsusfPpd the I @
    £ -SP of VYOleooe • oare) bos also
    Si © _
    gostifed the Iropovjooce op Mytbs O pon' Hcs -
    M
    -

    /etzScbe
    - '
    - M ietzscbe gave the concept of ope«- coao -
    @
    ;S
    NK-Gtz cbs? also suggested
    ^ bhab uofll is roare i^porfaot-
    ^
    4bao xeasoo Thewp fs a eo'iH -for 8
    .1
    _ pocoe ^ to noao-
    “

    VS
    1 © J^Sosgsoo Bpsgsoo gave -the epocepf op vnfoiffy. ©
    .- 4
    vi to ftq s a Life -force
    '- /
    odd 9oo* ded easoo•
    life is abac# pussfoo oof afcoc4f ©
    ^ -
    •
    x
    •
    . .3
    V.r

    -^
    -:.l
    . . ii ©
    i o jChorles MQg irass B > \
    He gave +t>Q concept of £0
    staf /poa Us^o C(f
    coo oof be dtevi'dedg 3 «ai ^
    .

    *
    5 Heyber -TbcoY of OjitUra / Nlabooa irsnQ
    * ©
    -
    .

    .-. iv
    •
    i

    .
    r

    s
    3
    robots ^
    ttbe OQkJKe Op pusps^-o
    QO ©
    vs dfff? e<u ( t to understood -the notate
    •

    I
    3
    ^
    because f-Qsa’sr-o is Hodg£> ~ fbcP eop ldcpg, - iffasasro
    of ' V
    /TO

    1 '
    dtfpcqi /k boo o - ^ is also- - &
    T’'i
    / .
    • 3
    C
    / for neutral aoaigsis ^p jP>sja's>~o -
    -fdscj!sw3
    is declared -to ©
    be a Had toord . ^sofetv- j ,'c,
    :

    . -.- j

    -t
    ^
    •
    used ' o po, ?tics 45r
    ,
    opponeots-
    ^ m
    ©

    d
    8
    @

    ©
    life
    f'J @
    b: 1
    - 1
    ©
    •
    V‘ t
    I
    I <r>.
    ,

    «3
    m< B.y
    5 :
    g555SS3?ESSo3SSS ? 5Sr51
    <
    >Zu
    ^
    sproe Foco of .
    Paso's *"0 os ^
    ,

    cgQCia
    '

    capi^'3 ilsro -
    4 © of rq^plfa i&rr) <oheo .?© &
    % ^a ( face
    ^
    in mate - Fasc fete arse psOJPOf^d OQ QOiorol© of
    © SCJcio t
    I
    © oo -fre oHnejr hood tfbe ai scholq&s Hte Ha’d Q^ppe* §
    % .

    *H- ATKSOCH coosidetf pctscfero §


    !
    .: @ i
    scbola^s H
    : Cdtar^ uaiSr-o as Va 'G G of 'lofo Cjtatrfooism
    ^ - •

    ^
    }

    # ^ ^ - ottescp
    1 X aolorS lite Las © b&3 +foQ+- fascism fs -HoQ |c*sf
    '
    3
    4a
    i <
    ^
    ) by cqpfaijs^o i6 ia save itseFf LosM colts fiaecfsno ots
    »

    3 ©
    :3
    1© 1 c CdadbOT Ts^voicjf oO .
    '

    UJbQf l'S COaoft?v Revolt!“Hiao 5!


    *
    1
    ©
    i 33- is spyotaHbo against ^evo«jf fan - If ^as aftenoph by
    vv “

    -
    fcbe eUftes to pwofed captto ' fsm -tonsy -Fbey
    '

    « 11- @
    :
    a | -bbe opocQiog potoe^rs op cooTrying classes - feta'st have
    I©
    -
    j actually pot behind all nsqqjov sodoifsi - <z>«rroooCsf- f

    leaders. bRbiod -ftbe baqf though fasc/sro came 3


    : s
    1
    x
    © t
    *
    pOCO©r cOpitb noQss -Soppovf If COQ be C003fci©s <=d G(S
    -:3
    •
    0~
    "

    ©
    4^>e CboQphfQcy by tbe •a-idg
    •

    .
    '

    ^
    c
    :••
    I--* © Ot a (fosset fo bt's book. Rs^off bp basses '*
    •

    © ^ .
    CorsbeiKpcfi 4bscisro as 4be > > s >queo op of
    cor
    © ^ -
    c enoooracg geH-tog canv r kpaS \okq ronbacso- cy .
    ^s<pdl as -vhp ”»ipacKoo of c&ohs7
    # FoscisrvQ jo, also coosfd@ °
    5 Right >
    !3 © is G9o vp Rght ?.
    C nttrp RigfV* TrepffiSsPOt- IceOe middle Obsess j
    '
    1> ©
    £
    ^ *
    ^sosses poo*s OW teiocj O’agoolgpd by Socfat &i pq +iQs
    - 4f 4hc<k 4-lme
    "

    ‘C : 1
    coere cilTSpady bafcKog pocoecr § paiv? fedggp nofoicfile
    751ch .
    * >
    .J£
    •

    classes coeirp -tee \ir oeavectsd Middle classes


    *
    j Ci)
    f
    ^ ^
    tadog h q-iTtShips becqose a>p Rb tdoorld coq r Fascist
    ^-
    t
    V
    © loaders eroade kbe/r bas<p Qrqoif the lotoe r ootbSte class
    ^
    ^
    i

    .q Qscqss 4be
    <P
    - coodibtoos fbak ^rise +o fdsa 'sro .
    : < tv--
    gWe
    i@ nbe 5t> are -froo schools ~ ~~
    * bf -fboagbt •
    @ Fascism fee product of ci curosVaoces Eg. M A odf
    1 3
    ^ - ^ -
    b d
    ^
    ^- ^ ,
    g^soovh of
    ^
    J: 1

    I ©
    5 cao be a d
    ces
    °© 'n°^ ^oikJ as
    3 oqei i QS
    @ SHxjoho cs id disw
    I©
    ‘ 3

    ^ ;
    -
    i© »

    i1 © :.
    1
    r« © !.

    ‘
    19 ©3
    1©
    !? © !
    i':
    i
    A

    ^r.>?:-r-rcr-r-r-c — 4
    i
    s
    i
    3-

    i
    Mot -H? bos gWen {Sitocotog reasons
    •

    Q xp deroonraccj is ' ohrodoosd . fjf +be rise dp fusds

    iotbe 3Pdpk| - Cftpre ck^ -


    Czracy is oat a pq*4 op caliOsp . dohpYp Society is
    ^fi
    ©
    3
    t
    •teadrtrboQl 5, poif -b’oa ) values ctae safe
    < -
    c#eroo ora He -
    ©
    Si
    .•c“
    0 Cbanb'i'es eDbicb failed 4o develop detoocraKc c*u fiare ©.
    1 coVi0jp de cooro H
    ^ - c gout •, QDCM f -KOQS P iled to CQOHC -
    ^
    £1
    rH
    .•- vl
    a!
    © T3~000-<-~0 C Ctrl'sfs ccb'Ob 3>V0 rise to OoGoop}Oyr^>GOp
    )

    ,
    - , ^
    ©
    ©r
    vv Hardships- usher pascMs^o pvQvat Is &'+uahcso OQO be
    exploited by Deiroogaucp'c leude&S •£ apPeQv to be detocoraHc) ' @
    ® generate roi i ilcm'shc oat/ono t ts^o 'wasppet - jor
    ^
    i

    :• ) \ ©
    1 roil ? tQYTSh‘C VQfUe * ®,
    s- ) pt ulovid wW oof oouj genera fed M 11i 4ansWe \/atue buf
    ©
    -
    Q \so resulted foto beHev- iobevi taoce ©p friusfatted
    J

    1
    ?
    oabooQiisre §. deslTjp HSSY ^revenge -
    i
    ©
    c
    !
    I
    ©
    ""V «
    (S)i ©He finprorv) bas given 4ne concept of * Fear of pmedorb’ ©
    jib v&oUhj dbese is o fjp.ar op hoedorh n rnao - Pireedboo ©
    l gets- - associated
    ^ aoHb insecurity. ifcese iscx -Poeuocj op
    j isola boo fo roao - Hence, bunbao beings loot 4oaoa^ds
    @
    ) 4be sbong leader uxboaao provide tbere> «oMb the oeoao
    < op secuHixj - There is a QthraoKoo fov chemsnoa-Vi'e persona ©
    vl{ -
    .
    •

    \ >t j » o bciroao oaturp - Hence, fee mates -


    •
    • M
    i \I io of fascisno lie ©
    buncoo nature • Historical
    (

    i
    1
    ;
    frfiro - Heoce. toere
    ^+bQf roasses hcxv > T) QV T rnfeant RQCfero. ©
    35- B 4o bp DCMPo
    '

    feSSSZ'*** c

    fascist pooera aaese cAe{bated io^ Ubr^


    ~

    . -.I
    <
    . Viv
    1
    . ' ;
    ,1 pns-eoi- Si'tagHop - ;- ©
    Soce 2.O0& -toon? has beeo the gracOtb op R bbest
    - -1

    ^
    •
    .
    -:
    -_ • fj
    torces as toeif QS tHeo' pdsc©> Vs ttc3 cbsfe op' dbesa /
    "
    /;? :
    •

    :-'- V
    p^pjeut -
    fa-:

    Hde - FotsdseD coo be deftoed fooe by oodersbfnd'ny "


    V>
    v‘
    ,

    ;•
    -
    ,
    cobicb {asdsra coppo&e. Hence, fcisusm fS
    -Hoose dblng5
    rawed as oob’- ideology - fascisra te> against ©be^b/ ,
    - © ’

    . Oecoooraoj ^ Hunctsoitij , ioteiroc>H'd'oai geace.


    . <
    ‘

    ©
    ©
    ©
    ©
    #
    V

    ev -
    m-
    er :

    Pc-

    i !

    Si h;-V
    :di
    . - - .^ ^ ^!cvv vrn vs^ '>:
    ^ ••,•*^-^7^.*'"’^^^ '© * ~ ,
    ' Vnj V
    '

    -^
    © •iVarva’C rV S ar
    - -vag>: v;>::-y:;
    - -- -
    9 COOK31-
    jS. CJ530 CDO >'jd0SPc=
    © p32>C SK>
    (

    'f ~o < jovita


    naoisro •
    2
    o ^ t
    3

    Is ©
    entries OF Mult©
    ?
    _ CultuTiansrO ;
    <g

    —
    >
    B
    s ©
    l -^x MO Her OKCPO
    '03
    3
    ©
    fy \ perO OlSt '
    SUSQO
    -
    Mu t FI CU ltd rid \ fsro is -{or
    03

    .: K
    According to S M • OKOO f - pert Kkprcba I
    1 © cootoeo because olcoost oil OUltUWPS
    *8 .
    t
    0 : 3'ive sobcwdioate status to Utoroeo
    :X
    I © @ liberals - BHOO 8cunry
    _S
    ;•

    Mu f -H* cu Iknnbl isro pTTOroofeS po l rtHcs Op fctecrtffey <


    - c
    •'S

    c# 0
    15 ©
    decides people % ooderroi oos. :tbe poiHHcs of de elopo - 5

    ^ -
    . 6
    voeot - !

    f $). pV-cartyg geo


    S3
    .

    2
    t£
    0
    t 0 -
    Mu Hi‘ Cu itqria \ isro r-PSU its iryto G-betto f sa -h'oo • 3As oot- cpcd
    < -tor oo4iooal ooi-tt).
    ©
    1
    @ Cband'tao Kuku -tbus - eVo&ty
    #i © pjberSis aloofly5 a subjugated iotesocl rofOQ'stfey lo
    t
    1© CUltU-irtS . Pg . WoroosexualS .
    1

    |
    © st (§) COSnoo - po I (too MUltf - CulturjQ 1 fetS "
    A
    !© Jereray UdidYOO §- Seyja Beo Habib «

    Mu tti- cuituvi'ch (s*-o under esHroctle people'^ <x& p** cStu


    J i
    ©
    X
    to adopt dlff spoV co (tpwps tbQs CsCatcS obtoclos 'O ttbe -
    of^ cos -
    >
    \
    |© vsyQ's-gQnos. pOdHao ou * tdS£
    ^ < oO' •

    ::- 0 j
    fbone C\VQ scholars =obo seggest that Multf - CU HtAntM Csro
    <

    oao be pwochopd , ooiy by ObeTQi3-(5sa , k> Bedi'o )


    -
    0 r

    believe -that foiera-Hoo -focoa. rds


    «
    Qinp carriers cobo '

    X ©
    veto lerects is oot ociy appectsoroeot but also Vtore.o.t -to
    £ ©
    treedbro £ security .
    >
    x
    ©
    ;
    4
    fevuce Bacoer io Vote boob surrender Appease feloro
    * .
    © $
    saon-ttce d eedcxc) 5 'Suggest cot +o be toiereot tocoo-»ds
    * ©
    i
    iotoiereobs- ^ i

    .. . ;

    1 ©
    |
    AodMeco Murphy also suppcMs -H^e sii*0' a^ )ocQ I
    I
    $
    i iI
    © I
    S i
    ;
    14 © "
    i

    &
    I ©
    4
    V

    !© y
    .
    £
    IO i
    i
    ie
    :
    i
    •5
    s
    c-
    I
    1<
    5

    *
    •
    E
    i
    {
    K
    3;
    §
    rj 5
    s
    tc
    PS

    & FE h A I M I S M
    •
    ©
    r,
    .v! Fenotofe
    ^ « Q Meta- ideology, or orotoireviQ ideology .
    -\bese cvo roQot| schools op FbroiofSro lihe Libera © ., ©
    -
    • VJ

    SI SodatIsis, Padi' cn\ feroloispo, fbst - colonial and -


    , @
    o;
    VO
    pQS\ fhooi vOfera - dhQ GDoorooO threat CDOCrpCp oCj CU) #
    a
    v v
    *
    .-
    •fitm'
    StiSt \S> -4ho CoOC-9cO to&OQtfcte the Vplc>(tQft'OO Op
    '
    ’ ©
    cooroen QO attempt to end exploitation • Ppholofs o
    ^
    ^
    iS both p A biiosoph g
    l -
    "
    ^
    A noOv/Q'no©Ot- • AS o HOOMP-
    # f

    mpot p noinfero
    ^ ^
    developQd \r ) tbe.vfb*ro op' 3 cOavps • @

    :~i
    %
    © jd^ ~
    cco>JQ — |2>t cQQVg) Stotf
    +pci OV -tfe t-i op theneb
    ©
    vv-
    ''
    w
    v- j
    •

    Pevofotfoo • " l
    }’©
    ©
    fd
    •

    -V» MQmj kiollstoneooft Is caned as Motbfirof F oioVs ? -


    :Vt
    Jhi
    i'lo rp8? she coeots ao essa
    y - * Thoughts oo education
    ** ^ ©
    of daughters . Xb ttgs she ^o'sote P v/ Jodicap
    cV
    -
    •
    •te & < bts op
    9
    ’
    KlOroery to thrts booh she has
    ,
    / oo op <@
    i fhe xc(OSIOO of USOnOPO prono atJC >
    “
    (
    qofetiooGfcl ©
    X-- duties she h>as also presented rosbip frights %>
    the chaafea- op Pfcfbts ©
    jOf cOOropo ioclode
    V! i Meo -
    4he dedctea -Woo op pfcjbts of 0
    Eav t'est posro op Ip
    Vi
    \ '
    DlQt-O - IBs Cfa ll'
    fenoiotsfo is kooeoo as dbeaa ] Fhooi -
    est dt jnoaad pOV coor-ooo nCra.<© f>o ©
    coas f ai Tsrj^ ts por?
    *
    t
    ©ot
    ^ ° gV coan oeo § par tor-fb noOn - The-
    iropOYtdo^t Trfcpd - - <
    - 79
    Q
    CQO$-

    Fd'T 'right to vot© fo-fhaboic-f is


    b fortoioists <LC,QX1? QCtM
    * ° o
    •i
    cOby -fpraho\sV roove ~
    *
    tX 3ef s

    The Seneca
    1' "
    pails CCnv/poWoa
    called as Sutfrogate Ma/enoeot- •
    ©
    ©
    v{
    convention -Vo hox-roaiu desio Os A
    soaod ' ^ AS coos -tbe
    O
    . pt ©
    '. V
    tooroeo h OSA * ^ ites coe^oP^^rbt tos ai -fov
    SoffiragG - ©
    :V;
    geHiog Ri bt to ^ ^ j0 suoj

    ^
    <
    Vote - r daoroeo i
    hr,
    Vvt
    PV
    •\
    i ^ © liberal GOoobries •

    ©
    ©
    V 'i
    .vj
    m53 ©
    sa
    © ©
    V
    :V1
    - ©
    ©
    ©
    ;
    , v
    ©
    •v.
    V

    •v
    5
    <
    ©
    i |.
    ©
    i
    &
    m
    -
    ©
    v
    ccbtbe soroe
    , SOCJ
    ' s o -fbe eoc\
    _
    'Q tfet fprotovsro alSO h deve~
    . YCS. of fospfTfa'
    Hoio '
    .

    -
    >
    S8
    «. loped io \ aoc / au ^
    §*
    *

    •
    T
    © (jOt-aPS , -fom ~vb>e &oetf \<s ©
    :S
    c
    S

    *
    \ °
    o of f ^rohy
    1© pfgeb ID bis boaK O \g
    *°
    i^> erp\ aifc* fye °P

    -
    Q staff , held teat cnpi ^
    1
    ?S ©
    © COOroipO cooroGO sbOUld SOpporf Conorouoisl ct oo.
    * ^
    y f &r e./r - Hhe_ _^_
    £
    s
    4t ©
    • lUtfao toecaase \F *s ° ° . ^ _
    oa \ « y fidr ^c#*000"
    .

    Leoio CJOQ£> cllso ^ecS^pporfer oF


    ^
    : '
    c

    ^» © pe*SJO \ +o give . 4^
    r
    |
    4
    ©
    Li9nio tons +b<o
    sfcHus of Minister of c& bteef ^ 4a tooroeo -
    .
    -

    .
    pcxoev/er, Ste no coas oof
    54 ©
    f^ragressive noao - ft©bad
    I © v©ry -Hrad f-HooaI v/eo colHo Tyespx cf te Oobeo’
    ;
    -—2
    :.S
    : s.
    f
    /'
    ^
    ©
    19603 -Bn 9903 It fe Koocoo as £
    M:P
    ; *
    ©
    Of sctdi' ool
    " ' 'sno -
    FeroiOi * padtcof T^roiovsrr ? kootoo
    wdv/e
    os
    I © fsue Ttem o r pool fproi ovsf 'tfaeorxy
    / Oi -Sno
    ^
    1© wiby Real FeroioiS'a Tbpovy
    . t:-
    5 coos -sadicai fsroio S+ eboa have bufif oeao a o ^epf
    l ©
    9e £oiog fproioi'sro • Liberal § socialist roiofsf^ tacsaj
    - '
    ’
    It ©
    |
    3

    : ©
    * .
    arigloaiftxj If ODQS Jast -tee appiicmi’ao of Liberal §.
    '

    ^ <

    Mcreasi: p^nna'ple io CbotexV of raoroerv Uberaiisira


    4 CD
    4*
    <

    •
    - MCTOrlSr-o ©sp KHOtOO OS MOSCCJ i '1 Of 3t bis CDCi ^ CPs -
    ^ ^
    | (9
    Offers of PQdi
    - 'CQl If ngiOfSrQ -
    ©
    CDI Simone eta Beauvoir - Soot-Dscood sGV * -

    V
    tfOoe is oof boro uxroeo one boraroes
    - tbrjiToer) ?y
    :- © ^

    I ©
    j
    Q Betty fn'edao _ Boob- x ©JysHqoes,
    5
    t

    .•{
    Fero/ oioe
    t> © •
    i
    -t
    if ©
    •
    i - i
    I ©
    »
    ;•
    )
    '{ !
    1. ©
    •/ !
    f
    •

    i;
    |© V
    l
    |
    {
    ^© ?.
    {

    <.
    r.
    5-
    5
    !4 ©
    i ©
    v
    :
    £
    Cv © ;
    a-? 3
    »:
    •
    -
    >
    :
    <
    © r>
    SI t
    !0 V

    z ?
    I
    1
    %LJ J !

    -
    l AW I
    ’
    i SSSS?SSSfSB5 ^^
    @
    |
    v
    -
    3d
    23
    < (01 2oIf -
    -M BciS ^O-VlOliSno fcos its TSOOiS ' O fvOoCS
    ^
    '

    <s
    -

    T=© cooeqd- of be/ood _ 4be concept of


    Fiseedono iv©o by -B->e LibeaolS teo b'S ( - boocxJS tOofc. ©
    ::
    oi <
    0
    m Being aod teo+bir n©sf sQtore too^foos dbA4- FbisteD-
    a ;

    ^
    O© ( s Pkio to fSSQnSQ Ddsteoce »OQ30S
    ^
    '
    &SOO
    :; :
    ^ •
    .

    no its © ioQ | sense <ohe Pco too 'fesei ge is


    ^
    -
    v
    . .- i
    ! ^ ^ e ;

    fdeof+y ficbich ohb-ess give - Accnxdfog to saH &dsfe- -


    o<& bos a
    pTnCvsity Gvpe essonsQ - essoo should have
    *
    ^
    ~- \

    :o:
    ^- ©

    sotsp, -Hoe toodrWoo


    ^
    edoro -to c)efe«nnoiQo Hs odOD \ dpobty - Accord log -fo
    Efeseofa > is^o das /4s 'tfOots rt <o
    ©
    5
    'as igfons - AH mtigbos cvse leteoiogtcdi . feJigtbos so —
    *
    99<2sf -HDQV I^OO is Cerate! by Gbd • fed coaots noao £
    to fut ! f? i| (Piftoo Qbd \s §r IF tocse goals ocs© not fail- <§
    1 -Fupd Qod
    punishes MOO •
    ,

    appears as if t'Ooo to ©
    1- -:
    i,
    Pobof , TrerrooteJiy controlled by (feed If -fa-eats MQO . ©
    Os 00 objeef 'soffaer 4foo ©object <ofto cooscioasossfs (5
    00 its ocoo - Sat ® beb tocto belief ro (fed to a bod
    ?4
    Vi
    *
    j fafto S- belief fo 00eseS -F (s Good
    e
    ©
    ic
    is Dot bmo toonoao, 008 becoooes<&& oferoao
    ©
    V — Sif-ooo ck Qe.diS/ofr C-> '

    sVateoaeot is basket 00 sate ideas -tool- tec/st - - is

    Soce (s ffioir +o 0S990SG yfeOCTtfdtOCj to Sfrooo c e


    •
    • I
    I BeaVoiY coe five fo a
    iCbot is (feoct©red Qeodered sooeixj-
    ,
    ^ f:

    ©
    sod eto ?.
    1
    lb© SOCifto totoief b g i v e s l e d g e 4o O L b;.;;
    .
    ,
    -
    1 V:
    • «
    09od©r § ccWCb is a. noa-Her of ctieadv patrfoulav @
    ••'•I
    older fender - ardoge to -tte
    r :.?s.
    ccbctt fs Sender ? \

    fadf 031 feminist


    \

    &
    !
    G©od>or . SOK iso.
    teatf a d'iffeireoce fcofcoeeo 6ex
    bfoiogicav 1 -terno ©
    >1
    '•

    - :
    :•
    fender is social tom. ^ 'oatoirQ cobeseas
    ©
    A
    J"
    . e
    V:i
    Vl - ©
    - -1
    ' ©
    ", ©
    -.- - j @
    •r.

    ..
    v.
    o\
    1
    a
    &
    . m-.
    m
    j

    <t;-r:>
    m *
    ^
    -
    --
    ?•v vlKgggr ? ' ^
    ^^ ^ ^ .^
    =gw«wSSSS5S«SS 3 SSSK ^4«£ 325
    Her bcot ' T e - : oocood sex '
    de Beauvoir ^ "
    •

    * ® Si'oooo
    v

    1 suggest -Hoot GC© \>ve i‘o


    cx f te bircfoai css- Mafe
    ^
    :21
    •

    s- ©
    r ' 'the cbbac 2<5X
    $.
    • do»-alcxHecf saatety - tAchoco is oof
    <

    tcoraoo {3 the second sex - ffiWcb dfeD roeoos 0^ 90


    !
    X
    i© ' r, one is oov fccsrr
    i
    ;
    -
    cc ©
    ~
    £
    serooda-su hiatus - According to ^
    m
    because cooroso a %ode)r a deotHg
    i © ci©

    9',veo by socipte Societe does oof gWe oppad-ctoHy to


    : £ '

    I-s © •
    -
    r he gepdey' QocfeKj
    I©
    ~bh
    ° peitsoo -to dleterro'i oe Ws
    ° *
    "

    hspafs ppKsoo as a object ’sotber bfaf ^spbjpdf hite po


    •c f V
    :?
    V ©
    c-
    i. c055 Op bp -oipg OOC5TOOO . Sfrcte S\ Oce hfe -\r <X>& f
    1 §>
    c
    ^ Y
    " ° <

    ns
    •' I ©
    Q detg Ste s di rngofsAirg b©foe©r> Sh) ChildI tMcdte
    ^ ^ ^
    cWfci • ' }b<2. process osodcued childhood to etdhle
    - •
    4
    1© sence x Adulthood (n a\ \ scab stages, cooroeo Es
    x
    fV
    ©
    do letWe ctairQ her S°t)]9OHkvl ijJ*
    . .)-
    • o ^
    Aoo&d og -fo Srooo de Beauvoir Rxbnc by is bod Oof ©
    gs
    •?
    :%
    © '
    oovy for <iocjf-oeo but also gjoy roQo • sde BeaM&vcD'ir .
    i© hav© highlighted rnaoy
    K
    i O One ncytf associated <=oi-fh ccoroeo is
    norths
    ossoda fed oltf coo
    ^ 1
    ‘
    t
    t
    © oQonoeo erypys nDottoerteood but * nocsir
    <
    2 of Abe <ooroe0
    •
    1 ©
    i
    fooncd Hated ^otbprhoad • -She bos arif'aspd
    V

    ? © JbPO ^
    "Q5 Of poocOfec e Itfce Medical Science § PQJCHOIC0VJ
    te<f perpetaating Myths • io Medical so' encc ^co eo is
    © <defosd cOfh ceteveoce to oopo. f cbofogy
    ^
    : © ate myths - she Has ahbased Sgroood Freud
    also pprpC'

    dor pQrpekiaUog Myths - Piground fseud suggested tfcf


    ^
    ) Q
    he roost iropozrtaoV Gibci I cf tootvpo Is to appeqr
    /

    kJ
    -
    ^
    attsacpveto Meo - \
    r
    I Q

    !
    ; ©
    a
    •
    f
    # ^ bc©t?id % SI'rooo de Beauvote
    to pod fbtriav . she spggest ca>oeo to oonoe ouh
    cby
    '

    dhe Gxofdxts op fabriarchg ., fa te -tesir ace


    of
    ( {
    ©
    •
    X § ‘fe HOVQ
    v
    f- good -pd tte) •

    I© ;

    -2 i
    I< ©: *
    2
    I© i
    > '

    I© V
    ; •

    < !
    5:
    c © :
    •

    :
    lI © i
    ?:
    c- i*
    ;
    |© :•

    1:
    scC:
    ?
    - 5 C
    a
    & i
    -
    i: -
    1£ © :
    I;
    I.
    |©
    1 , ::
    t
    1 © P.
    £

    K ??
    /
    * ac®5R3SBS5S»5S55 B55S^^
    §
    <
    o
    4
    *
    -
    eM -
    M;/
    ni *
    :

    vl \
    o
    6)
    •
    - -I
    •Y:l
    •

    Sbs? bos
    • •!
    ©
    si
    log io oOQf ] Of -fcsrofy . io
    '
    ?
    Si ,
    K;! •

    cObGffoer ibpy aogfQ 33f iSiPcd ibGir tiff ? > MCSfOf ©


    -^
    vl. :
    '

    .. ;
    '
    4

    iths azoroeo 'o fXiO odS fhaf - -fbey co > bof Saps fiecJ
    ^4 ^ © -
    '•
    5
    ]
    coBP. -v dss Life
    ^ -feel itoaf aoroe b'og
    Phcopopy fbey d-oOfO oof able bo de prrd* oe H^e soof
    ^
    nolssiog. ©'

    =
    -
    GGHCJ paieJoo s^ggost e pso ©
    ^ -
    mPJJ
    • CQCQQ of 9aob\ero -
    Piero <Os pvobet-o op oooQroe. 2be dePoe- i<bcxf fb^
    “

    ^
    Lv
    -
    1
    pyobiero \S fbf ’CXKCby . A< jOOvc}foq
    ^ +Q beiT, IP Is OCi ©
    ‘ J
    Pooogb bbaV eaoropo Y&SJQ TrjejbV io MoVo VP l s. teo mV ©- °
    :
    .
    1
    VI
    !
    -
    enough PPai bbey eqjpy social ecDoanoic
    ^
    bP baf ec*°~
    #
    Pf
    loaq PCftsiQ'scbcj ObbHoues If is oOf pC
    K>eo coil! be able to oa'o - saPs-fadh'oo ^
    bbeic ©^
    &
    vJ
    -1 Uf &3 - BePU) Pnedcso afo bts«>9s aod2Pj, dor roearcv
    ©
    de/ofopirg rp Vhe, TsSKaPng io =oanoi9n - She Pas csiPa © -
    ^
    vl
    1
    ;: l
    l
    ^
    cOor o roagopdnes poiway career cooroeo leading ©
    - g
    oosa + isfej U fp houseLDi -f © leading a happy UR> •
    she cxlso swggofifed fbaf bbe ’rgyfb , \s pvopo/gaf vs
    ©
    1
    i ifoaH o cooroeo shod id noprscj af 06 porbau|atr pgp. effer ©
    '
    \
    hr aihaoHoo - o

    ^ ^
    ..
    J
    i
    l fraS '
    » S >eo ^ e»^ +**! = * caJppS P© s sf
    Siodies rdoPP *< -<9pforce be SObcnsd ' oafe eta-PP
    \ fYl
    i
    a 4 C .\

    i
    6COrO0O •
    .• 5
    i
    •
    0
    • i

    :5
    5
    :
    '
    1

    :J
    "
    ,

    ••
    !
    •
    ©
    .• 1'
    ©
    •P :i
    i ©
    «3J
    C
    -
    g• ©
    > ::! ©
    ©
    vl
    ©
    @
    1
    ©
    -:
    - -i
    .. ©
    Y:
    n 0
    ~v»
    podicai F© «~Ofcfefcs ° like SbalasroTtb ptegfooe
    • :

    i© !

    •2

    •n
    *?‘
    v

    © Book - Dialectics of sex


    if
    P Kate Millet
    ; r:< -
    : ©
    l
    i ©
    Gook - .
    Sexqa / fb i rti'cs
    5 C5J

    i# Accosdiog -fo fak? ei § sbUlasroi+b p-ceston© 4oda dos


    M;
    ‘
    cS
    :3
    •
    00
    ^
    "
    -to -Volt abouf oof josf +b© politics bel coeeo cla - - ^
    1^ sses toe toesd 4o wscogpise poif-Hcs be$toeeo se>ces -
    AaD-xdiog -to J3ad«'ao\ teroioiste ftono<ro/c_ sf2rtj)Cte^e feooi„
    if
    f
    S:
    (f
    - _
    to© basic 2Vyac6< >?se of1 society ’tf #3© '' R^4^borcby • Rx'rai
    if:
    if #
    d-scby \ S -be
    **
    '
    sbtidpnrp op socieH/ . Peoc©> Vogels
    3 •
    £
    © «DCKS <1070og «0h>©0 vSP006Sp U^af once Cqpf +CJ Ifsno
    "
    : s
    4 © c
    toWI eod cooncen cdll a&toro3>ttoty Liberated-
    coflf oof be Liberated -til / soctal Tf ncct o
    : 5
    • i>
    •:f
    ©
    pctWrlavcfa I. ^ ^
    !
    ss ©
    1 Tbfve (SO VtJYTOfiOO Onooogf Tsad fca1 fftTCHOiStS • 37 Slrooo
    i
    :? © be QOOMNOl If dDint'
    -fbctl- rOQo 3 tocPoQO Ca*} tOO'JrfL O0 >
    5
    10
    '
    •

    'fber , Radical oi'sf Like s^saoe gsecoo Miue


    ^
    ;* ©
    |
    .
    soggeste +foaf MQQ coooof ^
    Jc oocfeboVood t o© .i r s e y
    bav© oof ^gobe tovougb +be tenoe Ocpedeoo
    In ©
    of cODnoeo - decoding to bar t eo ^ life -Fbqf
    conoof be feoiotefs
    4
    . © ^
    di
    }
    - f
    C
    © \ ^ M<2o
    QCfaalUj bate ooor-oen - Weoce, fcdfcoi Fetoofsfe
    oga’iosh HeJHgzOsGKUal Fatei lies §• CQUs | - or S!sl©fbocd
    x
    i'
    y;
    0 SFoaoe 8irocoo Miner has ctocnusoJ toe events of Repes
    1© Pop^ bos octolog +0 4 do toBb toe SP-Wsfacffoo r

    ;
    < ©
    i *
    sexua i desVisp . pope fs oo TcebtePoo of pbfdQaeby
    43~
    i
    1© keep tcoroe^o ojoder ~fbe p rrooreof stettus of
    fear fsowo noeo * ^
    Im '
    2:
    X
    :
    if #
    i
    1

    i© V
    !
    I
    :
    1* ©
    :
    !
    &
    <
    | >
    1© \

    1© i
    I

    I© c
    i<
    c
    O
    C
    r>.
    - 1% Q t
    ?
    Im
    L

    $ ri-
    c
    io
    i
    \
    \5
    £A

    rMSSSSBSSJSSSSSSSSSS^^
    -
    :,
    £ oHTO
    ©
    1 Ibe S ejODM? Q $
    *
    bos started {foo^ ?99Qs -
    *

    / S* s

    jggck SQCO 4bs eroorgeocjo op posy ifenoiofsoo . TBe ©


    . J* ’
    •

    proro'neoV Scbolqr Of posy R?K4iOt 3 tO IS SHSOOB '

    s!
    f a \u d ! - Sbe cod-tes 4b© b^cf lasb CK?QICS4 fos !
    -
    >
    » ©
    ©
    - vl f?ootos\s do nay support 4b© Tfadfctxl FferoioiSte .
    ,

    .-.•'!
    ••
    QTgaetoeoi 4baV ccoroeo ase. S>ba*sdi toaVe S©K -
    '

    :;! Spc esy 4b>aV dooroeo should cicieo'stlVcL aooroeobooci


    ^ ©
    ••

    -
    1fo&f do oof soppo&f 4b© f roiojoe My4bs Concept
    - ^
    Sey) 'Ba Vhex' Oopbasise Ha{ 4be qoa i » -fcfe9 op <-cn a9D
    <‘
    ©

    i
    >j
    ^* §
    Q O socerior 4bao t^eo • 4b oeed -fo be odetnrated
    ^> - . #
    Today Feno oisro has beeo tn+onoatiy dHTi bHafed). ihQvs ®
    ^
    QTSP noaog schools Eg - Blacb FeroiOtSnq - . ©
    Of Fer-oToisro - ‘
    ^
    (l) Biacb feroioi Np ©
    1£ ^ ©
    ::; JScbolav- - Bel 1 Hoots -
    1•4 ^
    A vdiop 4o b©r Hyp p'sablencs op .Black-
    dWTey fSoro -
    c&Yy te eOOnoQO -
    ^eo
    cDor
    ©
    ©

    feV CblOOlQ\ FerdOSW ©


    gtboiap _ ebaod'yo. laipade Mobaofcu
    1
    Vi
    •} O
    I
    :4
    * •

    AccordIopi -fo fbsy coiooiQ) F cfopbiepDs op ©


    ! LD&noen lo ^
    rato’sls 4he^
    posy <23too\ 0| QOCiQb cif -f r -fkxr>°4he
    :
    ;:
    ?
    c G ero coerpd •
    ^ ^
    fbtdcvccb
    IfoGtJ. c&r ©; unde ^
    apd op cbooicniswo * §c>Jolneobusden ^
    . Is - op
    *
    Q
    ©
    - ffl\ oo’ a>iisrv . )
    ©
    . J
    (TQ) ©co fenoiolSrp
    C--">
    C
    1
    : scholar - vaodaoa Sbivcx
    "

    ©
    :
    j ACCOvdfog 4o ttO fdraiOiSts no©- hxxv^o exported b©+4,
    *
    d
    i tconop as coew ots oatuyis -
    • •

    Tbe
    ^
    cxActjre Vo octvare . sr> .
    > CCOKDQO of GleeQr IS '

    Woroeo are +b> > coorst s^ffprers op er^Karoor^oQOto ) -


    Vd
    4
    ;.;j
    degradbi-fc-foio •
    W

    IOCP -toe Li-fe op coroeo 00402?©,^ber^ ©


    ^CDoccy 4>e
    & vfeyg close
    v'tcg
    oog ^ >s4ca * oobie cdove iopQroeo+
    5 or>i4<bC)a4 ©
    -
    :Vi
    p
    •<

    ;
    -
    ’
    !
    ^ ceoVTsa vltp Xooroisn -
    40 ‘ ©

    il
    ©
    ©
    ©
    i
    •

    -*
    m
    ©
    3
    .4-

    -
    :A
    t
    (
    « A
    rmwwww *.v o;**x*x&r''.*'::' •<:*?*•« > * •- :• » ••*"•'.
    .. -
    ^ ® 0 <3 £5 Q D f 0 i
    < # ci? a m # © a a a
    © © © © # ® ftlv a o
    ft
    &

    ;•>ft!
    a
    "
    M
    :IS$.
    $
    >•
    © 0
    :ft•
    £
    :if
    •
    ;.*
    :•

    ft?:5 n
    ft] o
    .ft•' I] O
    1- 3
    I 18
    S
    %ft i

    I GT
    flv
    o
    • ~n
    Iy
    Si
    s
    ft
    ft
    sa•ft
    :» 3
    g> ? ro 0- Q
    ft 0
    v<
    :ft
    <<
    ;-B 3 0)
    a
    $ 9
    <
    :i :
    ft
    a
    : ip
    55
    S
    !55
    SI
    3;
    >
    :Ji< J
    ft
    5 «
    £
    I
    S3
    i£
    .V
    1
    Vij
    ft
    1!
    fti
    1ft t .

    3
    1 S1
    S
    fti

    fi

    rT' ' Xi
    ••'wi wrvV’lJrr. * ! . .“ Mr » i ..
    ^ * .* %• ••
    •
    . ATrr /’
    .-. - . --
    m
    ss
    i
    -- *
    qynVHa raises tee
    tibe*© are fbe • taoroeo ? .
    f
    5
    qoes+too
    Hbip.e - - foo -
    .
    - @

    -
    ft
    •
    V
    '.
    •

    when- *c +te cooseqoeoaas of sep * ^


    ®
    CSp hers . /P'
    tVir
    CD Urn? tfd pate paKoo Of
    ' di 00 *000
    ' S5 fobl ' ,
    Meglecf of KJoweo concerns » o fblrcy coating . Rest 5i &"-

    *og 3tate to pobic s be -§ oof per notft fog lotprvpotioa


    VC

    3
    S3
    SI
    of state \o tee -farot KJ - ^ ^
    BcploitaWoo § SobowdioaKory
    ©
    :.
    V.I © ! <^o -HocjaHoo of ©
    Fetemiss scholars teopbasise teat personal is fbitficaJ
    !
    iccHch roeaos teat coe caooot tate -pjcouiy far granted
    | tBpre I'sadteiecWcs of ee* ate tee leyet op -puniiy . eateiiy
    - ©
    &

    1
    -V
    do® not Tsepreseot
    life Hggei fard \g <00
    te© as suggested by 3ct aia.s3 .vs W
    :•d
    also be exploitative' There CK ?
    V
    -
    teed j ote veoteo
    ^ by skate t tee fai oiuy ter
    ° - p^otec- ©
    S; ] fiOO Op ODOnoGO •
    1 tee donoestic violence def , brought ty
    is ao
    achooaDledgecaeot teat 4he violence . against cOQ -
    &> Qevh opPodia - #
    &
    'r
    1v:
    not Josv Waited outside
    ^Gn is
    pTssseot softero tee fanoby also of fSootiu
    bat- ttd5 s
    -1
    susane eodfv , CJusHop Fdteity' ©
    ‘s:
    «/
    ?k
    Moner oteo io her booh
    i bas given 4- [ oterpte fa -Woos of tea f gooai & FbiHtaat
    | I
    0 | te@se ( S O vfo\eoce against- fflonoeoenrteio tee torohy $. ©
    -
    ^^ c; ^ -
    teate teoqid 4a ke case of tee figbts of iooncen ^nf-tbio 6
    4be faroi I y . V
    •
    d ©
    :: l
    ! © if "Ofans teat there Os no TFQO\ sef era Hoo bel <b2sso 0 -
    P saoaj <§. poirb' Qai . State does > aterve^ne io -fdoo“, ( y. fte
    ^
    '
    ^
    ate mjQte iaceg
    e ^eo Tsefarted -to persona \ apbese

    ©^KS
    ;:
    : .i -
    J f 1cb is apoLOf
    .
    ^
    fioomeo . te> a patrYcpcba ] society slate
    loetita-Woo of fotedrehy § Benue op . of . , ,
    <v*>

    <
    “ V'
    c .S
    :0
    ; j
    • taiCCG fcg setatod is f >eJs60°Gt ( #
    V:!
    0. ace opal osf cCoroeo .
    © Caroiy Itseif fs 00 rostj+ctHoo op pbte'aYchg. j tdarcbai .44
    3
    Valuestesroerge to fbteiQCcho) far^
    yKj . child cobo IS baougbt © ^
    •S' op lO 4 ^fcgQXUa ( tarolil’® SQcO -tee ^Ofcoad)tOcl -Hgo op o
    pf
    COOrvD0n tealde tee fgjno! \ § « beo -
    :':J

    tioo outside fdrbg


    y ^ fod saroe s°boY<d"ioa ~ .

    ^ cb ld Steats coosberto tt^ oarnoal


    ii:-. '< .
    - fteoeP tadtbout defehrayteg He+p&cSetea f - xr p not ©
    possibte Qod pateiQrdra* 1 venues - Q

    C
    ©
    r: i
    ©
    m-
    ::l
    ©
    "

    c -.i
    !
    v
    .!

    *d: •
    # .
    wl
    * '
    V i
    :
    f
    -
    .rfcVVV .’
    V/' ',
    atpcttes - moa <
    v:
    pafstas-ohal sodety <HOctGr cdqo I ^
    I® Women
    -
    '
    dOOroeo '
    t O labou 8" :

    GOO POQD
    bqsdPn • '"Wj OrqaO 0ctH oOs do no4
    • ^
    1© ' -
    (

    k f / seis. ffeoae , f t-
    •xi '
    •
    vj

    1© genesai <Oohoeo baM9 locoer ^ '


    1
    ?i m
    ^ of cooroQO a f <rooWc plac
    YGSwrts foto sob o*d ( Da -Wan fziatchy ^ - ,

    ia #
    dobicb ogQio
    ' sp- tafoeme. pc ?
    ^ _
    Leefiie - 32 04

    0.4 0 l|2Off|
    J©
    £
    ;
    :f
    :s
    1§ © CGooept- of Cf -feensbip god £q ua \ itq
    _
    OO 0SQ CiA-teeoSb' p
    i& ©
    fproiO S 0(?te cgCtiOS- 4tbe CDDOfpV
    ^ Of
    QOW&SQ ) Qfireoslrfp r>rpoos Qqoal WrecttroGoF .{csr all .
    ' ^ '
    33
    R?rofoists live iyis K)QWOO Vouog soppotf -Woe Idea of
    •

    236a ^
    be

    -JB
    © diffpreofiafed citv-ZGOSbi p • 1hey coaov dliff &ejoHat faeaF -
    1
    © roer* ov posff ve dean minai-fen by Fbe state { o favour
    •

    :.2
    . >c

    -
    :
    :*
    •

    c
    4
    S cf wbroeo - - r .

    © @
    :% h
    |
    a 3

    Slrv3p\g QqOOh’ - Qrop G


    QfJOHbjy ' sr s u-
    :
    ;

    1©
    0«:
    5
    2 Sfecta p , ^
    state need o differeoHaVed bg>co?<?o ^oeo n
    4o fpralot S,
    * bos lo Gun «**<*«n Heoce aap 03
    **
    ^oct In
    jr
    - ^ .^
    $
    :< ©
    S
    J

    t
    d'ffkeocgs ^o d’vf YppKafPrg fqoaii-ty «-oe eq ^cJ. ifse fee
    - ^
    “

    1 ( .:
    r
    GSrO' nsoo '
    bOKQQgQ UtxgsQ ) fenoiois^o ftod 'cai pgroi oisn
    ^
    •

    "

    !
    :
    0
    .
    Ffr01nt2 ro is a «v\eio v’deoiogy 4 Hbese o e macy schools c
    fproloSTO • teroi oferO deVG- ^ .
    >£
    :. •
    ^ lcpod VO -4)0 Of e-CCiV/6£
    »- O I® \4ove gtaWi'
    fc 4%
    dorotoafgd txj03UbfVa ! Feminists - Stoce
    Oro puQOcb pQVota -teoo W l tgQCW <uoas
    '
    :
    5
    •

    £ w
    C)

    setaod cjQave knaco as Padical feral ovs1360


    - * <ne <s9e Hoe
    "

    1: ©
    *
    'ta -
    I © fodfea 1 ffrol ois\s cb OOI 'Gfgayd libg al ffoewofeto as a
    Hrae fenbioist: diiscoctY <se
    • ^
    1© because ;ir is oooppiical-o
    V
    of Uberai coocepfe vo corr s f op tooToeo fadfoai Rprxbnoi :
    !5 © Qf a - eroesgc ftor9 -+be SPodpe ^ > s pe-weoce -
    . faced
    £

    ? ©
    iS
    0* 060 b
    ^faose ibey ave to
    ^
    gendered
    , 0q 1 fiS^O ois - Lite groo QDdeK) . p o i
    ) fe _
    ?
    ?
    5 © gGlta
    *
    Qirchq . -5-0 °°
    Qr
    ' ^ n de Seouvofn and
    olbfirs ba^e f -inod to
    ^ ^
    - ^
    ^^
    -
    !
    ;

    :
    ! Q
    Fer°'0'Sr0
    lase- fafV) „
    ^ t
    ! ©
    ©
    1
    nr Ohte
    a uai
    ^
    ,
    - -
    P l f <Q|
    Itero(o 'sr cai O 6d q v e n d f o g p c t'a n-Q v:
    ^
    =
    ^ j
    i
    ©
    1

    © j
    .
    !
    © /

    i 1
    i
    o-pcoc^'oeo § 4o m
    : s
    &
    r<
    GbP'tQ \ fftoofenQ te fto apf fNeov
    ^
    otoe -Qqoon-Hj of Qohis to xs^roQO * POCKQSJ , fr^fecrQ
    ub vaPtoio of cconoeo §. e oaoopo V
    -
    •
    •
    -I
    !
    1
    Stards fSt
    -
    '

    ^ * t3
    ti
    cv
    • • !
    {toy
    ' "t
    •

    tot
    : :i Litoral to«toOvg\c roofoup cdf) ^0 COov/eo^
    >
    * nal
    m © ..
    of rsDQioto 'io'tOQ toe aspe^ a-Koo beko PO
    toi
    &
    •:;
    i :
    :

    P J t -fiCQi cohes^os PaJiQa ) f§toio&ts to99^


    ° ps^s . 0
    ; to not is po I } +i 03 ( . ©
    lib sql fprdois < ophosj[3 oo Xx dhvi duotffp toV^xr^as e
    ^ ^^ ^
    i
    fbdtQa } Ftootoiste alk abotH afeto b od.
    u!b0ra| * ° --
    vbmisto roonagecf pofifcaJ 3bu39\e § toto abcM-f ©-
    to! t ai coogP'tob'ooGH *GOut< Pod' Cai 6btord$ £>
    ©3
    ;;
    .©i ^ (bosaouenese
    ' °
    toisiocp they atsa suggest
    "

    One Uto otofgg betoso ©e ual fatroiu'es -


    SP99esbto *
    ©
    to--''
    *
    5
    1 SboYr t^Ote- fe noi oi sgpQO of f-bverty
    '
    %
    IBe R?roiofeato>0 Op poverty coatsjztved ty Diana
    pi Pierce to fg 8 . R?roiOi'sa’of poverty sqggpst toat- d
    ^
    ? -
    :Vi
    C00>r0©0 -govmo

    *
    -
    toe ?HOOjGinb| op to©- p<t>OY popotob'CSO \ 0
    toe aoo d. toe pbanot-oeoa op obinaaPbo of poverty
    ©
    ©
    ^ ^
    hcxs tocseaeGd fnce oeo- \ < bp«al giotoifeovtoo has
    evpQooled . OoiQs iQOcjggs-f too\ £Neo to COUO GS u ©
    I -,
    . .'
    b)S/\ toe latest oo -
    of foroeiess '
    popcto
    ^
    -Hbo consf -kite
    ©
    Of cGOrooo - 3ro-« larivjy c.b» OQ has nseOPrd <Ofo
    1
    qssopsa to tototoso-boo of
    '
    poor k .

    peroto'sa -Hoo of ©
    fbvptoj is> ocoxe aoAto \o ctevelodbg ©untofe Tbe Tnof
    COUQQ op ( f » 5 pototo^tooi GtouGk | «B ap toe sociokj.
    toor-oen goffer fVoro nocsi-pjoVe depipvQbooS fcx5<ocjse (
    “
    of
    toeiireex - airxe 4b<=y
    >
    -fsato d rivafoo to tosros
    •O -

    iroerb , viIo oncQ. qgatosf ceoroeo toov toey 30


    ^
    of oduQoKooo) etopotoeirnoeof v rvkjLtofbooo.) er«) pocoer - # '

    ::-

    .•
    1 ^
    Pbeooroeoa o f to^oi'niso’ of povetoj bos oespased
    0
    - noorG • i&s
    ^
    >.
    1

    tecaose ^
    of tot > top bade of toe deffe- r \bec eocsf
    ©
    |nr)p(Xbf toHbdt«OCOal Of. ®Dbe\ =U<s© bets. > ©
    oo tcoT^en- @
    -> V
    . ©
    ©

    ©
    ••
    )

    #
    Cwi
    -.
    •* '! ©
    :5;

    »: §
    1
    > 9
    •
    l JOrogO
    NOtS
    Concept of M issieg *
    s bo*t
    ibe coo^eP of
    '
    ' '
    |V1(SS')
    03 6CX>ro@0 coas
    P* givtoo
    A - 'SOO osi *oa+
    d
    iooiy e §P<
    by
    o 193 -
    °
    !
    ^
    rotes ocj .
    -tbov roose 'o
    SSImg toaroOO poirofs 4 = ^
    d-foGd ICO VOt
    ' '< oc cb -foe. o3\f&se s 'c-co-Wo .
    bo cOoroGO anr©
    ^
    ^' fo ASK>o axjobave ^ %Mc~y roQO
    Poblero AS -oo^e psoroioeof
    Y
    of
    < >
    4bo
    Kicvs +bero AfHkoi - Fveo exaoQple-
    p pHosrcbc ) . HQ gWtO£ 4bP
    te associated <so? f> 3
    * , s0c S«=>ct lve
    -
    ~
    Odta fgxnoalG fo fooficj'd ©
    of 4
    oboA'oos , r'°alerOof f rooyfot ifxf pcO’jr fo^aftb
    ; corre %
    oaVl+HOOQl WGSUJfcS »0 SUCb sHoo-v-foos
    sModSoodb
    •
    ' +0
    Ihopad- of ffloboiisabob oo vOoroeo-
    (Jfcfsat .
    The pYpse>crt noodel op Ubexairspfioo iS ViGO '
    KIGO - Ufceya i|s«o ts based oo SUzrv ^a ) Of -tbe> f 44<PS+
    ,
    i various vSkjdfes shoo odvessG iropocd oo <^oo<rooo <a?oao
    1 -tb© accsjid but rooir© odve&SG fnppcicf o cJevelopioc) Norton*
    & -fbvfb'Gx' odverse Vop0 oo 'suWl ^sv-'OG O csiepnriVQ - '.
    ^
    T-bo9 lacsease <acdMoysfk) iocsipases- MN!CS of developed
    cCuot nbs bof^ie established fbeW onits fo 4bc>se
    ^
    < 3b£5©
    *Ocf s soQbeap lOfcoqv iS cvoi|ob /G ebbofS poonr oasros
    ^ .Vba-f f orpt coo fc© ooax'fnof 'aqd Th© © bas bc eo
    dbe. g^rocofh of ^
    oocytfgaoiSGd eGCdos GObe «2_ oo
    * 'oo’rnos - -
    studies shoto dtba+ Ub©2taM > safO hOS GXpOQed
    COCSnoQQ 4o ocoro -evcpo f' +avive =-oc«rbo cocdddbos- Ube^saif °
    sa+bo bove obvevsfvy fnQpcxted /fjpsiQoditJiriP b c V S(opJ
    countings - Q bos
    fo^ ~
    opd oopfaoopd robpoHory
    ^
    Idonoeo obs
    <r j
    * ^ ^ )

    btced -fo I ve fo loseccfp -envfaooroeot , osox ssn fr© forced


    ^ •jo '
    uoo'st To evcpfo / f i ve
    OfstatP
    ^
    apptfQssive ©HaaWbos - hj i -fbdvacoa
    Heoi-W) seofor bos irOpQckd oASttcoeo b©a ( 4h -
    f j

    —* {c +QUG +t^Qt- i - - » i — ~-.. - » * * *


    m
    ——
    «bo>t Mofe FG~>ro5
    '

    v -
    K*
    - ~r 7 HZa Is* ^OCJOVVU fo ferrooilu acrapf
    '"'
    £2

    -V
    •

    5£
    .
    *
    Scood^o
    f 6r0i0
    Millay
    7
    9
    ^
    ^ ^^
    SCU
    foirnoer US
    ' u 1 ; h« c< £o e^ ptosissd <« ^eoocsssi
    of •ftap - ro' ofgr o<re<qo policy . sbP 5
    cfstate

    bQ suggested 4bcA
    p oay
    ^
    ©
    ©
    ©
    Inofooo viqv ts Q?Q ccoroen YgiO+s - ^
    .^
    sa
    3
    te pnotacKOo^ of huno« rights »;
    '

    e ?
    •
    2

    coc^rom » o t ve
    - “J L
    case oF e*ptorto*fc*o ^ ^ 5 .
    -
    So=>&ck?o hasgo
    30ud « A*obia. The foreign ftfoiSter
    ‘ .

    Op fo ) loccjocj Gbj- op -ScoedenS fbY©'go {Ro' icxp


    ^ ©
    #
    £ •
    0 tS,hr<PogVb>'PO OQ ' Hciroao RsbfS Of sonoen .
    <i£ ©
    2CS
    ® t^ gbt OQ o osF (
    Gjndpv teased s^x w a l
    »

    vioiGOoe SppcIat.H/
    IO OOOyf
    ® ©~£
    ^
    ^ sfcipo^ bo
    s posV COQcv 'lHlcJ OO
    ^
    #
    ©
    spasiog pQ' t' bp COO^OQO Vo peace processes „
    V.J -
    © Snrtoroic r oco vnoeo oif <uconoeo, #
    (2) dd tfsrg+toeo ^ Tsrg- ^ ^
    I:<
    >
    ’
    ' oej ^
    prcsciucsh've "sights a P ^OO TOGQ .
    ^ ©
    f ShsQoghbeotog /ofkJieo ce F coorooo fV> oil afflSQs Of 550CJ-
    (e - fb i fWc& eoa
    p aI
    ° '
    ©
    •
    ©
    m
    ©
    ©
    V £S
    !
    i ©
    f 'y
    v>

    1
    ©
    V
    i e
    V. -
    x'.' .x
    A
    .vd

    A
    JK

    £ Q

    ©
    ©
    ;§
    :.&- @
    v
    -
    #
    -
    :V
    *
    •• m
    i
    %v
    >> *

    &
    THeopiES Of - &TAV£
    m
    1©
    I sfaf2
    1 ©
    JjTPpO^tQOCC of -the 4e .
    -Mcal Tfoposy, is <da
    12
    •
    ~ ' :

    3 ©
    I '\ he r-aosJ Wap - concept of Roii ©rxfccoisf
    )

    -Hcof Sa' oce


    fce /os
    ^ ^
    J
    3 ©
    3
    .
    VH
    a is said too *
    - - - poif ^lo pdli+iCOI Sofrice '

    - p • Tber© coos o -J-iro©


    3
    "ib© SHdl
    of sta+o
    CCS

    i ^ eb fKcd -poco
    3
    •
    • S
    :
    1©
    e^taeo 4 bp -
    focus aOas ' sttjdy of poith'cs as a J^YOGPSS
    as iosfrfu +ibo -to +be be
    -for bringing 4
    .
    QO
    ;- S
    oalic ^td
    a © Scholars like TfSedo Qkocopol ceodai;y
    •

    !oiQ < o -Vb©


    .
    I -
    a
    Sfa e bock in . segg g d -to v ac»
    1©
    •
    + ^ ^^
    Of .state (o poif-t-fcu / ooaysis -
    X
    3
    1 <t
    *
    ?
    3
    uibgf t'-s fbe idea of -fee stale ?
    © -
    •
    3
    :: <•
    1
    Stale is ao obarocf cooaepV
    •

    !#
    i
    ,
    ;! ©
    ?
    ccooffesta -
    K oo -
    dovt <s the coocxohs.
    of the sto+o - Sidle p ^present autfxftfaj ^ -

    '

    s / uihovitg is needed so idai people coo lead ootvsoh've


    ^
    .

    %
    .-v
    :
    n
    4
    ~r • 'ifvo u-h’oo of vStafo
    id +be copsVevn c-oovtd aoe see 4de foi locoing
    ic © fan-as
    of b© ohave :
    :
    ‘

    t
    ©
    S ^
    Q> Ta-rn'esV -fenn-o
    £
    ii
    * of ay tafe ^ ^
    : <
    4
    :
    . "•:•
    © (jj) po ^oao propire •
    o
    •

    3
    ?
    :)
    © Mo-hoo elate • v
    -V

    I0 _
    Id r' 006 bove ottso 4de as-ocOb of SopA- oaf -

    \\
    .
    <

    t <0
    >
    m
    oo

    a +y
    ^
    ^ t N^ ii
    °
    rDfe
    foeb+utioos i e - By opeao on ion,. QHH bbe doroinaoi
    ^
    Rjsoppao fOaVi +
    Q
    ^

    foTfro of State ®uod -tde ^od^dd is Mo Woo ste» fe . No-Koy


    oo -Munich etnergsdi 6 Mode
    -
    -

    ^ is QO ' cjM'
    '
    {
    i C - !
    ;
    *° bross buf beenroe -the OnW rsoi Xbsti u-Woo ds resu { Q ( \
    ^ (
    -
    :
    , :
    »
    of Colooia isro § o
    JjTQpen is^
    \ . '
    l ©
    -
    '
    bJbak are -tbe fiei-opots op -tbe K\af <oo vstetfe ?
    :•

    :
    •
    •

    NaHoo .State ®r p» tee


    I1 # ^ of four sseo -HQl -eteroera-ts - ^
    © Terri to 5

    Ik ©.
    © fbpuia-b'Od
    I% c© E © Oovenoroept
    l
    ?
    ?

    !B ©
    18 ©
    a .SD^ennsiycrtdj s
    ir
    i«
    •
    :
    *
    1% ^ il
    £
    8

    I© 6ii
    6
    I
    o 6

    I ©
    i5
    I1 © ;
    r
    U;
    ?5:
    I 9 I
    Si
    s I
    s s
    t.
    \
    i
    35S55SSSSS33533 ^S — y‘
    1
    S!
    -Hi
    '
    -
    Ktodpro t lcH-foo State Ys Q territoVtal -enHH-y , Q ,s based . - 5
    on +be idpa op ao0bvotteed goot - One op tee eqvires+ (i
    philosophers HhPons'ioq tea-h'oo State include teanoos
    ,- ]
    '

    ;•
    1 Hobbes- Hobbes bas ctenHy established 4bm in a paHH &
    cqlav \Q_rtitOYCj ,
    oo tee papulation living \ n tee nrftaxj a
    m
    1 *
    Hoe olbipoate poeoer ^o\ M be. opHbe. slo.-te Ma
    desedbeej state ce ar> iosh'-tu-Woo <5tech ho©- MO wiebev *
    ^
    ’
    .-.i 00poiy
    over tee use op Coevsive pocaer « o a
    •

    paateulq Vesrfto tj-


    i
    V.- t
    v
    v.i
    -\ * *
    (

    ©
    Hi
    : i PsfH previous Cbo pte«S
    l
    •
    cH
    Theories op opygretpoty -
    1 ©
    © MoofsHc Theory of ' QPv/e- gtertep
    ' i

    HT
    '

    HI
    1
    SopFDHgrs - Hobbes , John
    * AusHO C"
    a
    <
    I ^
    MOOiSHc
    ©
    £
    \x
    H tepire is #
    s
    £
    df on©
    place t -e - state -v
    s
    Accotafoy to MOO ( @
    rj
    i •
    i
    o she Theory
    fterr-aaoeot CbQyactevisHc op ^state sovemH o+31 &—
    ^
    te is fooiiecobie 8
    /1
    ;1
    :
    and todivtaibte '
    5
    — > CgiHaSro pH i ootSHc Theory -
    ' ©
    H
    MoofsHc teiary ^ bos- -3
    been e Ka'sed -pr 42 tetooy paopog-
    :
    1
    vl
    Yi
    «
    a fe> a <=gaiisbc v/Veto rotaer -too
    ) '
    ^
    ^
    © poif +Ycai vfetO
    * ^ )
    Hi
    •
    The approach Of latO is tevkjal, tCbpseas *
    '

    1: poi ( -HQa ) analysis


    •• f
    •
    fs cbotextaa 1 There cao be <a b(
    •
    p ap beftoago y exed
    psacKce - Xo realty severe]qoty is9aiccays a corTheor
    H ?
    H
    'il
    k
    •
    t

    roocept MG state cao everaSe sovetejgnly \o (deal


    '
    -
    ^ p rocsnd
    s o n -
    A
    sence •
    .-
    . t
    .s BAemqilu be choice op state
    + CS Urol ted bp tee pocae&s cr
    :•:!
    Of ofber aiGioxs g (is ace© pocOg&S- Ibterocuiy m
    3>
    • • q <l
    ^ be tiro1 ted by other ossoatotens grjfay
    V
    Qnd frcdHoos , . poop es sustef os
    00 State cao tepose <te ‘tail ( 00 -tee
    .v 3
    J
    cateDaf
    ’
    .
    ppe /pfe
    ^
    e
    ^fePf \ HSDO
    ^
    ‘

    t ? soigne
    •
    “
    ^
    •

    @niy is o i
    goi 4<ch'oo
    ^ ©

    i
    «
    :3 -M
    -i
    . .i
    e

    i
    ©

    -. <
    •
    #
    :•!
    HI #
    ; ’
    •
    v
    i
    V:
    •

    vuvvvtrvi
    t
    LQski , -fbe idea of MooJsn'c ifopovy of
    - t /I ordiog fo
    © since tbe -tiix^eof e^-apic
    v•rw *
    55 y
    G
    51

    5
    '
    3

    ,-S G
    •"
    3 '
    ^
    Qave eignHj
    gsoce ^ of
    bpcoi o
    federal
    -
    gs outdated
    |w, o-FaoOt to fo^no Of
    '

    I tv
    s
    •

    ©
    9o0f- ifoew? {£ rOOTP
    ,
    devoeo
    dbao one ceot
    ^ ofpo
    ^?
    3els
    •
    G.
    - :° <P fee tOV0n9St Of
    S
    5

    i ( 3) Mooish’c Ihewu Of sovereignly ) S> oof ( o


    i
    fbe growth of 3o^fnoWooQl f&icp , inDoiStie feposy
    •
    £ '
    IG
    i
    •
    K
    «
    •
    v
    fc
    0
    o Suggests -feat slate rS sopxprop Tbpre 00
    a Ufeavrty beyond State HeoCP,Oil COroroproOOlS ofa
    •
    - ^
    I
    i 9 • £ pe«son a*e jost toawards -fee skate -
    9
    — of Ldsk-l op Maotstic TbgQf-) —
    ^
    t

    G£ © £<
    & aDouici bo of bust toy bene-Rt fo -tbs cd<fscip loc
    •5

    1
    •

    .£

    i
    ?
    © op poiitfcai Qc/eoag . ip -tbs -eoH-jse coo cept op sove - '
    £ G Tfe/goiy of state is ocpUnged out of ft ? discipline
    •
    9
    9 * ’
    3

    covoBOpoty fs coosldeed cts tbe T-QOS { rcpojrtaot coocept


    I@ io Modem Pb rtfcai -
    *
    .
    %

    ’ ibeory - Mcdsm Mottoo state dS +b«a ,


    13 9
    '
    •

    .•I
    ctapoing fb*to of political orvyaoisatfoo in Modbxo
    -
    froGS -
    -
    ^Scvereigoty is -fee roost
    i9
    i*?.
    frop - eievnosof Of Mfcdoro Mat-loo
    sfe
    ^
    i
    - Hobbes is mpgolopd
    G os fee \ st
    s
    V

    f..>
    *V4
    ^
    ClOStO be S Ne VtbQ tS
    ^ .'
    * CDroplete ^b^
    cdSQKUj established
    ~
    -
    O ?rtJ
    Moc
    Of ^ febter
    o

    ^ QjgVoiU of
    QCM K- c
    -c
    V
    •
    - feaf G>oO pQttttPula Vp^ - •
    n' "
    on© scvenseigo - MOO has* crety
    ) <5
    CQ <
    : /

    frrvN ° 010ly
    40 V'vo Moc
    IG
    G
    bss tbeory ,-g Koocoo _ ^ -fee state or anairdxj .
    _ as Monistic Tbcay tObiof (3 “*

    fadbGr devofopebl by jobo >VisUo ^oho ifsstgd fbQ


    I (v
    ii ^- ctpn skc of sov&
    ’ cbarot-
    scjgoiy -fepf ( f fs tadfvfslble ,
    1© Penaaooot oba dprts-He op ffee sfo ve. vnou retoabie
    1v
    .
    d;
    y.
    v: # taski fs cx cvif^ c op Mobst'c
    oationa 1 ist oObo boieyeci - TBsoiy .
    - -
    toski \S OJO lote^c-
    i# g nhj fs fej^eat too. voferno
    <zr<2i' feat Monistic feeovy of sove
    / ~
    II n
    f
    «
    -tt'ooo ) peaap
    cdblcb ioas
    bgoot-oe o.
    :>
    >
    s necessity - He believes -feat 5r,-f®oaUooai
    0
    I1 QQOISATFOOS :
    >• C& ; \acc> focxsA9 to be shfep tbe-oed - a.vo!cJ
    1%t O coagd COQ-VS - 1 ^ fo
    t

    ; ?
    >•
    |@
    >:
    K
    c ©
    t
    > i
    i© !j
    5
    .

    II © %

    !i © !:

    !:
    Im
    f.
    1
    ‘r
    f
    Iri c>
    5-
    r

    s ©
    1 X3 b

    ^© I
    He Qto bQJ <&/Q$ ftbcft Concept
    of &MpYO£}ota h hove - -fceco - i
    >p
    © •

    i forro
    •
    .

    cof+fe' •tag. efoe*9encQ a|


    '
    w
    •noe oci cj aled
    ^7
    -
    ftF
    ft?.

    <3bvF He
    ^
    aoo ?&Q9 taa m-
    4 Mooted Tfceo vy fs nota? cg
    1 oF Vr tas+iog
    ; ::
    tait Q \< al Raf /ao -
    benppt ^
    xp toe aotmdb op t-QsFi . Ptpce so cjgLkf
    - '
    deYcU .
    ^
    ©
    @
    oa
    •

    *
    f.v
    -;!
    fddgyo l . - Qu feovrhi ofoou (d Q
    ^So ^6— ^
    © plqroiiSt TbeoKj gygvetarctij
    '

    : 1
    ’
    .1
    • •• *

    •ft.-!
    .
    ^ of ' © -
    1
    scholars Lasta . i^acXvey^

    H idfra> cs plurals!- -fogop) op govggggg


    ft?
    I- .
    :c -
    “
    ' jp
    Accotafngte pMsotiSte fbese Q*re nouifpte aera^sGs of
    autoovi -tp ioftheY 4hao 4be tr le ceotro of oahbov'ifcj .
    ^^
    ^ #
    ©

    Aorchdito Vtoofsb aM pouopss lo a parHauloa fpraifon


    \S eonceohsavgd
    > ) -toestate whereas acrovdtag to pjusa ~
    iiSte pocQQx i0 cJferhri bated aroong various
    ,

    da-tioos .
    ^ ft-
    >
    0
    '
    SC- RecordUcg jo Ptorenfsfe ste) ta fs Qbo ao coso ciaM' <*o •
    ©
    :S

    —^
    '

    .
    ft
    •. • •
    Wlhq pkjygitst Tbgorq ? -v
    •v . •
    ©
    ::d (?) Moof0Hc iheoru \s OCH acoducjvp for peace ov \otaroq.-
    A
    i
    •Honawsro - 3ft has, become

    0) IcDr bas becor-oe oakda-ted because op j f t f t t o r a i . m


    Qft iGa hoHoo - ©
    1.•
    i -0> sScmrce of ftta-fiagoce. ©
    A
    ft*
    (D ftSbe df&tojbu+foo pFau+bo'vity ro Medi'e^al Trcoope , f -
    vi Xb roedt'e^ ji eu ’vope there mom -ypie oanv$e.£ ©
    . ft
    .?
    of pocoer - Aatbovtoj COOB dev / ded aifoonoi ttoroao e
    EhoperoT , chardr fVioce § Hierarchy of reseda| lords -
    .
    -j
    . »
    ^
    (Tf ) r^ ooisbo xhtTon-j ieo ebaractedeftc of cap!ta i feft sobek/ .
    ©
    d
    •

    @
    :s
    V:1
    eebpreos pqra f &b'c toesrd $s cx cbqraotads-Vic of Pc&t
    ft
    ft
    ::
    CDpttoufot <socj© ty. ^
    tai
    ©
    r -:

    J
    @
    ft
    ©

    r - <
    W
    ©
    o
    vF:
    #
    fC&
    # *
    !

    #
    m
    M (

    fij
    ! © bJbaf fs PtaicggP^at jo^- fioa^ooof piu^ ctusro ^ 1 .

    «3 ' is^o ooWp&se fr


    Accord foq -to -the soppovtess of pMta
    •
    .38
    © > paarf of , UQNE se . ‘
    ’
    A
    ‘
    -N!
    MU IK- dfnoeosVocai . fe> afeo * ,

    V: TOUltf «e
    I KOO fe ofeO MUl + - d « ropoQ OQ \ . T >QtQ 9 £
    :

    I©
    ••
    s
    03
    ^ (
    * S

    op tAao - oop association coonot -ttiM-fliiait hbo oeedsaf


    .
    G .

    \
    s <c©-3 V (ADD - one assodd^ooxanooh ctafr-o Vbe ^oooopoy
    H ncp, '

    M3
    OV<or -tibe obii a+ioo of Mao - Eo o«d£if -to AuU-fli Ws °®ecls
    •
    •
    I0
    ::£*
    ii8 ©>
    hrtxo rx3S QTPC( ^ ^^
    roaoy CLOSpCfcsWOQSr Goy ooe
    -feUi-fit ) th><=
    - -;
    c
    such asGa cfatKoo - QOOQ o+he«- asQocfGM-toos
    © rteeds of MQQ -tee ^sboqtd a I30 bave au-^bo vity % OOOO

    f,i
    >-

    ^ ~> ou (d
    be obliged totacreds vbecoalso -
    . ^
    @
    hibaf i~s ©uva i ist viecD of save -veicjoty .?
    -

    !© f
    c OCMpseigoty sboMicS be devict’d Ocaor*} dffpbtaoV orgaofso.-
    - s © "bbos- vOe coo gve nbe eyopopte of
    . 4 oLbop tno oofoo tanpsig ^ <
    '
    3
    © Sbueceignty fs oof roooopot teed by a< s\a+e Xb
    :-,s
    vS
    &*y
    scvpif gnb) has fcxpeo shifted odt
    ^ ,3
    Gopxa- OOHOOQI bodies - Lite roerobeJ- cou.otarf©s
    '
    rmnj oseq
    of be -state fate A-h©. ^ ^

    :>5
    i © Of
    "zone
    do ook- have sovQtejgoty oo -fboic caxYeoa qod
    ,
    .
    -to » port cup Moo
    :! ©
    i
    3
    peoo central Gaoh - Qecfefoo ^at/op has beeo shifted te
    &u«o- ^ ^
    1f: ©
    C-gVtl'cfeoQ Qf p) uYQ ( fgh. _
    •

    c
    I. © c v (pc£> p£~ Sa/Ql GQOty
    ^ o

    Sh-
    c
    1
    '^
    ^
    it 0 c>f cuex&gnty <& a SO
    ©V ^
    Q o
    ^ © ^nfusoo-
    ph ta I ids Q ae not -
    croq-ircbvsts - Rlusalists do oof- ecaot Vo give
    :•;

    t c ; QU+bovfy to fhQ State 0L|i -tee SQroe


    »
    State - Tfoo
    tiTOO do cot Ocd -ta<s ’
    t:
    C: > \ bjpe of piochbos state . f ’1
    C
    V -the
    soperfo-aibc/ of state ave
    . peir -fprros descute toto
    I5 f >
    •
    Pbta \iids it ^ oteetaosbteteaos -
    :•: is sold -VhO(2 -they
    # © dap pat ft ^ooot ta ^eep tee cate
    5
    t

    c
    too - .

    >:

    5
    5 ;

    ! ©
    i

    :
    i
    si © ;
    :
    !
    :
    i&
    .
    C I
    '

    ©
    ©
    i

    m
    ;
    mm
    MmMmrnmmMmmmmMmmmmwmmmmmmmmmmmm
    ?£ f l v v G » I sWc '

    au+bodHy should
    L p c f e t e. 3 3 m
    if soaski fedPSO )
    I IS
    __ L O S h l
    •
    2s|o i 20 l f £?:
    '
    •

    federal.-
    .cc s .
    ?
    a so be I l

    J «« RooWoo
    C
    :M
    •

    ^ fco/e o4” las


    (pt jdtwon'sWc ifeso* of ficNoeicyoty -
    ^ ^ ©
    --

    ^
    •

    wl
    s- ; pl LffO ' '>sKC JcJgfH ft £ j Uoo
    % d
    :v : --
    - M o d*. fbi."Theory
    :V>
    •

    So
    •

    M
    3cy
    ^Gi0Otu - teistoyica I ©
    Vvl
    bi
    t vpooeots of
    ^nri-KciSfo ood '
    —
    \toootsHc * ptq*o tishc ;

    -i
    •;
    : «ohy -
    -
    • -i

    M are 4be Q-sg Percents f Sar jushpaat-foo of FedesoT AMtbcnity ©


    oDbcto
    lostr a cxrg uenoent \$ slrxe soctfody fe federal ao a.ti-tejo'nty
    §1 ' -
    ©
    should afeo be fedesa i •
    Moco SodekJ is H$ed©?a i ©
    MOO has Vocitepte needs - Cbnoof faf ( £h {
    One organise?^ @
    .v.
    Qif os needs Uence < PO has c yea Fed vaWous associottoos-
    *
    VC 3 1 Such otssoa'oi Wbos lit ?
    ^ -
    jcwoliy, tdosbtpg goup, psn-fessiboa /
    ^ - ©
    £
    r -
    '
    ag - , lot - gypops, 'fqgs+hev CDo^ti +a Ve iFbe sacie & Fate alone - ^ • ?
    -
    cc

    C&omF pexforroatl +be feooKons- These ar aoi'so+toos ghoad ©


    a ho have soroe aroouot of eedora) f oufeoflnhf Only ote. ^ ^
    d^XJld not bcr/e QUrtoarrty Qp obT .ga 0 of 'nQOO oFhioy oqg . ^ ( *
    @
    ©
    \A
    A
    deserve -the obigat-foo -
    ::{ Since Society bos chaooed ; Hence nooovS-te cboceph oppeotrs ©
    ?
    e
    ^

    :: l
    : .i QOQEHRONFSHC • tteocp, pTq a \ teHc -toteory & a> hettes dfoearb
    31
    1

    -1
    :i of the -
    *
    of Qc^roy<pjg yoty . zk is nl£D mo-re tecnfsVCc. ute*0 °P dhe sofe-
    state •
    - ©
    •
    .! ©

    SM
    ;v3
    :!
    @ State is a
    !<& jstone op soctoi
    tash (S a pUTo ist . Last! does oov
    '
    -tedru.
    ^^cboppo \
    —
    4 -toe roaoiSh
    ?
    Ye LQShi
    'c m
    s:J
    T:I of ^Dvereignty of 4he slate
    Spcloty ts -fedora! aa-fco tj oboMld
    - Accord tog to
    Lastf efoce. @
    b:
    •

    ^ 00 oito be -federal . plcpoi s<a


    io ^toe a9(reoad,
    ^5
    ^ ©
    £ bat- - tt e Sla+e '
    doool -p« av atoiiab og
    ^
    ’^ ^ey dodt acooF 9 ve Occess m
    " - 3
    • Vi
    a< c otJ H, /
    009 ; ©
    p'i
    -
    poccejr fo <totp
    “
    « »
    to iSorffS 'P9 pluralist ffc & Qtfd -ttXM the
    P
    Hbe o e ^
    ! ®) .
    ;i - ooact
    I

    ^- -too Jtocno stenoy co rr s ^


    •
    -
    »cs1 P
    op the ooiqoo ^ ^ a^
    bo '
    . ?- ts ^
    tecaose ’
    si
    3 of be 4 ^e
    ^ -hue -teat ^ ooe
    Qg
    2 Qote
    ,
    ©
    I
    ri
    (fee
    assocbHooiJfce other ®QSSOO'a-brOOS .
    But- State ppUyfe ©
    -
    >1
    -I
    •
    •
    ••
    Weof mates' aroor
    i- -i cote 'pehfO
    ^ idlest .
    -the
    ^ #
    -o @

    %
    / -to
    -
    *A
    rr

    i
    m
    -.
    i t
    |C'>
    .
    )spy sp e, a>F SPCJQ \ ? cbHectare
    as ^ 5re *
    neooaiO ,otQ '
    erc?e . $
    ~
    ^
    :v
    H <

    ;
    >x

    1
    :S ©
    2fF >i_rt «tMd > socia A*
    cb
    ' to oaooc*-

    j> ,s twe -tax pM<o lst vtoeoy ef stove sowpse oy te


    ^
    -*
    I
    •
    £
    •
    S

    £• -? © *
    '
    |C oosist ©nf bdV ?t do<PS pafr aodearoioe -the »eievaoceop ^
    ap PWaiisFc nfoeovu <of slete, dot ©O y F fS mmis Tr<9a t tsFc
    '
    ’"
    v

    ^
    | ft CS rocwe c sttrabte a(sO - ^po^faocn ^ loa osfe tr>
    ^
    VS
    •
    i
    S 3K- .

    I© : $• U<bG present age a© a fobo i isaFo-o oobP* 9:


    - ccut -W t XGl
    ^ -
    J* ©
    :
    fe eroe>
    0* .
    "

    :.t:
    :>3S
    S
    0ov<ofmaoae >

    : S
    <S . /\oa0S ’se. tbe f ^opac of Gtobaiisa-Uoo oo ‘
    ^ so^-zrfejgo+tj
    ^
    :K
    V i
    |
    : ¥.
    e
    vt-
    F '
    OF -t-be s4afp
    i© — > j Pepoe Ffc>bo 'iscFoo .
    Qobo iisPtioo is aode* stood cts bosdeaiess tcc&fd Grtobaif -
    v"
    |
    © i
    oboi village .
    i

    4 33+100 capctos ojocyirlcl bPcotoioo)


    |#
    .:S

    K
    ^
    Stoboi’isoWoo 3l<3>fpd to a *coce pso^o’aSOl <£oa.y sioce '
    ,

    * ©
    ii
    :
    the ct < s4 otegrzSa4-ioo of QSS4 or Q»oce> -Woe -eod op cold coar
    .4
    1%
    ""
    ^j SDversseigoUj
    uJbaf is = &tQigota ?
    5 0/i

    I© - IS
    '

    - -^^
    fee esseoHQl e rv ot of to? ncodero naHc
    sfof £5 • i^vod fO NO+ OO aVa+e is a tew? to£iai eob-ty .
    !v
    I! m sfa-te eroaf ^ ed * op the ' Modeto nafia
    out -
    POPOQO Baprae Pxmpof Modesro
    |
    .
    :S
    .
    © - )£
    ^ .

    ^OtfcsO stqfe KiaFoo lopcaroe -toe basis op statehood q^rpato


    Of f^oesfpbaiiQ . op IS'F'B gives |st fhrnoejf ?recogolFoo +o tfee
    -
    i© idsQ op hiaFoo dlate - As descsibed to -toe tFpaFes op scboio; /

    >!
    H e Hobbes oo a sQJt
    ^ of peop <e V«viog IOO po&Hcuta* fpwi-
    lasy , autbo-viy op toe state shall be. sopspnop S^vic^eicioH;of steit
    -
    1 Q>
    •
    s
    <

    ( -A
    Ve. •
    bcsFco cliroeosioas ie eternal ?- tMefoal
    > .
    S\ ooe 1900 coi+oesdo -fbe R^OM FEHTJWOO opFioboi
    i (S)
    Chovpoh'oos , ^
    ^
    T
    ^ ^
    •Hoos - 7foe e are CFoboi cbauscpes 0 is be.yaod -toe cqpoa+
    -
    ioooi . iobpyoaFooa ) SopTfa naKooai 'IQSF+CA-
    * <

    ^
    h
    of o<ry oglenatioo slone to deal -toese cbaiteogesoo its
    © J s
    cxcxo- HEOCQ
    ^ S\QFC OS o»se evpaqod to <acP to CQOCEVF cc?to -eact
    >
    1© otor- Gtoboi'saFoo expects toe shat© to go noose TS spoo
    |#
    S

    pbe - exQrcfee gob . ^ cd^ la-tod


    ^
    I Upocept
    of Q > /eK

    ^ /
    QiobatissFtoo bas dilated ft - bjrfbsr.
    a toays
    ^ '
    ^
    ::\ . i
    •j

    >:
    k nopoct is net been s^roe tovau <Exjot&ies - Tty? SPejse obj o
    I D
    ©
    ;
    ’ *s
    potoebfai couot es js less oyoprt>oo )'s<pd that 4be <uacaic©!r coao -
    ^
    R o^dirg toe fej'pact of Crjobo n'su-Pbo (So aVe cSdvj rei i
    ^ ;

    ^ ^
    ' t
    A
    toerp te ^ ^ ^
    ;
    i
    ^ difference Op cpioions
    V
    5
    © scbol
    «&
    K ^ '
    :

    &
    *s e
    J
    ? i
    !© c
    r

    1©
    '

    I
    .

    :
    •
    f,
    i
    I Q
    < >
    5 ;•

    ©
    5
    !;
    \
    !
    i
    j
    &

    mmzmmmmmm 1
    j
    ^
    fJVV’wVv' v' '
    '
    -
    '
    •
    m F school of Thought -
    &
    TV. Ibey telWe Abaf (rfobad ^
    0© is mi I £ dbe SoKA^eigr&a of S ~:
    ,

    XI
    ? \
    vv -t CH state bos beeo QtJKicay CtsropJfDToi'sPcJ •

    scholars
    i
    m
    vJ
    - h-!
    i 3usoo efcaogey ttenicbi obatae
    tlQ5Sh \ l K|c

    2.n < * school


    Luban ffHoboi vfitajeJ
    ^ of Tboug bt ^GbYdeiriess ukflrld) i
    (

    SXi
    £ 3
    -cvv

    £.V3.
    State CQrtiwC
    ,
    "

    Tbpse tS yOo rOOl


    oonhoiipd 'ey the states - ^ . 0
    obO teOHTOO SdohaHiscx h »
    (

    ^6
    ’

    Scbolq yg - Robert (ri I p>iO


    -. - .i
    v' :
    iJI - ; E-tbao KQ p9+te/« n <§
    rd school
    3 of Thought -
    Accord ioa tei -VbPno, &)oba luSCtflOO i& OOfa 7® Q9orcie ga!o ,
    ule a, *e , f foesSiOg both- £ f ) SOnoe COOte { £toba KOT i’
    :2? "
    g
    sc ?
    r (
    *
    ©
    i
    0,
    00.03
    Qbo iQrs - ^ ^
    DavfcJ Held , Gob Jessup
    + OO is
    % Vn HO0 <&©* *+ States ape *bolding -tte pocQ-er. ©
    .
    ConClqsbQ
    iT to djhaf edeot iobo 1 isa+Too rs taopocfed so^exef ofcy #
    ;
    of
    I
    u ^a+e V^TOQJOS Q moH0® ofdebafp .
    ^ @
    -
    • O'
    I.
    .V
    ©
    SoQA Mofe -
    ^Spoosibhrty
    j 9\ ffcAecf
    •/

    p 4
    ^ /

    gnty • O- ,s ooto dePogd


    '

    V
    So/Pce/ oodO beJ og nnS-depoed '
    ©
    001 os pocoey of tee svo+e baf Abe wss ooeSbh fty o
    ^ ^
    -

    state © .

    -
    Heed ta* iSe-cteFoiog jgcv. 0
    Sovara’go | -
    ty has beeo tae roos* soared 'pviodpie op xo*-©r- O- '
    oaHhnai (Qto since The deavg of uoest phan’ a • Jo pasf Cold V ,/
    • i

    coair coo ldl atecv -fhewp bos been t’obra state ooo-pfcte vatfe* G
    '
    1

    ^
    4boo interstate coo-P 'cts - 00'fed MaWoos chaate^ Ad- - Q-Gf ) o
    C:V
    •; . J
    60m »ooh pp«roit & tote «veoKoo of GNI to tae aloros&bc Ckrfcfa ©
    '

    ° F -the state Such pwo/ istao cheated dilebcroa -py 4foe Coteir-
    - AAV
    •

    ni
    fi toobooai CDnnroonvtL/ tQ'te tfespecir -Vo -tee cid I lOavTa favcxodoi •
    '

    I Hence, (xovV -of Corxd-Q t proposed a oonoroissioo -to cnostder #


    :•: :> 4bs {ssue of iotewenHoo <aod ^ate eevevHi'gotg. nororofssion ft.
    <
    Vv’ »
    )

    bos given -tee concept of 'tfSspoo&bi i rty -to pTOtecf to S2JDOI . a


    w d OtsJ dov)d Qsmroit aoo (Girroaiy acpnc,cO\edged Tn9spo~
    :-i

    —
    ;
    d
    ^ ^
    <

    nS' bi',-bj -vo pnrotecir - Accord tog to -hte carwerMnp


    •S'.
    &
    :CA
    #
    >«
    ©
    .
    N' ©
    ’: G
    a
    a
    I
    \d ©
    i..l
    - -.i
    v
    #
    ifd
    a--!
    •j
    ’
    i #
    S f
    t
    poos ,
    (C -to "
    people
    '
    )
    1© l
    ,
    •

    1. ©
    is
    \ fVicYDQry qpoQpsoS bi i ' bj to p^ 0
    ) o 4tp
    :,V

    .0
    © m £0 cose state -{CM is -to itself bectinops 40
    4 9 ©ecctsity 0p people \ t beconops -the B^spocstbV - li
    ^
    :£)
    / Op
    IS
    ..v
    ) ^ fbe toV0foaKor>ai ^ cb©orooorh ts " '
    -3 ©
    :s
    0
    <s OKI securfty buodl <&o even autbobse*
    ( 1{
    ^
    tavy (ov^weo-woo
    1© (v) T<te Use Op c oUld f )Ck bs dh Is* cpVtOO YatbeiT
    ^ ® "
    X
    X
    I
    .s
    © lasf oph'oo •
    -x
    'Tbs
    a 5 op farce to be used has b ho pTsopoH-fooa-te
    Qnoouot
    i
    •
    •

    33 © sspspoos/ bhi'hj Vo pwofeef osas froptenoeio-he to case c


    ?
    c ©
    Nle
    Gm
    ly S ;o9
    ^ e 2OII bas osuHed ?c4odbe on+rdspos op
    ^ +beaSbcWioe ^
    © v*°t o'f ^8pazJ
    I* pi
    '
    cxcX&o bod vfoloted ai ( %e nomas -
    I
    ^°
    - |
    has proposed (? p pi?aespoosiVDii { ty vOblie
    1©
    :S - ^atecKoo)- -a-
    suggested to ecsfre -the ooraejofobf 1 op
    ^-
    # dbose cDboare l et oen-Ho Jsespaos'/ bulVy to protect -
    -
    ^ ^
    1
    1©
    A
    *

    5 ©
    •

    5
    t
    I©
    it
    *
    S\ -
    sVaT T
    ^
    &3a
    ^ Q &te5 1
    ** topees
    ° ^* - * bte
    ? © .. \

    S o
    I (3
    i &
    (,

    f ©
    I

    V'

    r ©
    I f
    #
    I. #<
    £
    fS
    1© s
    i
    i
    :•

    ©
    \
    l5
    * ©
    I
    !;
    !;

    : 0
    ©
    :
    © s:
    I
    © £
    &
    I?
    ©
    © g

    v: t
    •>

    >
    :
    -.- . --- -.--.-
    >W V « V' S=SP 5w?3 ?-'>i'??>5c-r-:
    ^ ^^r r3S3v«H?o^-?S33M
    >

    ^^ ^^
    S3 r vvo5uwSS;v?d'- I
    . t
    ® Libgfoi Of Slate &}
    X~~

    (T) a>)0^ o of state £


    4t
    @ Rjno-ions of J>f >8 S^G+O ©
    a
    -i © Mata « e of 4be siate
    •

    m ,

    *3
    ,5
    ® Q .qto
    ^ oP 4be vScQte —
    of stave :
    :.3

    -
    I
    •

    .I
    >»
    • Tltoe are HOD -te es of be
    (m Social (Dotsacf Tfoeoty
    4
    ^ ^9
    0 (0 ©

    *s>•

    1
    (g) fMDiufooay 'TfoQoty
    vi
    v
    3
    ©
    ~3
    S3 ti?Pi social (botodf ibo^yq - : 1

    SI
    Sv oif? 03 ocg -Social GoofTsact Theory (rrpHe^ \daf a sftafe to
    :.;j
    1
    I ^tcof CtfPafpd by <3bd TrcHtoer -+to piroduci op -fh° bme con )
    Q

    Of Mao - for liberals. sK34^ M


    qO foSfcida+roo op of i
    ;
    vvl
    ..-\1
    •
    ttcj . %
    H
    '« § .

    © g^OiuPooarg nbgQyv) .-v


    1
    Vv
    -
    ‘O fS 9N0O bu MaclY r
    ’

    soppo ^f 4be ^stoctbl


    ?
    (

    -
    •
    i MiJ
    . 3

    1 does oaf cbob ocf Gfoecwt) WG


    ‘
    i
    Suggest 4bqt Staff I's oof -the paodudf of QjoWd
    ^ &
    <
    -the anffiGlt of evolution - State bas Groevgeo -fsoro various ©
    1
    1
    1 assodofoos itfp |bro> iyv fiosblp cpoops, cbq &cb and other a
    o

    . 1
    * 1
    associations - V
    ( 5
    ::•5
    Ma elver t' sQ QDQ'O log isV . Mac fve>r Isa S0 0 Pt-v*5 0 > ? sf § these. ©
    :l
    '
    epggesf fbat a sSafe coroes dr*0''0 c MFfew?r > f
    *
    }

    :.i
    (SQ seasoot©

    ePU^rcfS to justify -that otbev associations sPotad ateo -enjoy


    : ! Sy-

    _ , :- s
    SDroe Qufbofta . Affxxdtcg to Macrve* tdes© eras Cjaoy ogaof fc; -
    y
    -•
    •
    < >
    1
    -
    ‘

    Sa-Hons coHeb a«re> pstar -to atf % « >»ob do oof 4epeod OQ


    .i

    *
    '

    ^
    •!
    • . yf A'

    '1

    .
    - iii tb> <2 State •
    v

    Zd
    f?y.
    '• ' A
    :o -
    -Mii
    y >'

    \ * .!
    c:

    5?r1
    ©
    •
    M

    •j

    ©
    @

    •
    C

    -!
    1 #
    > -M. '
    4
    - V,
    •yd •

    1 i
    !
    •
    m ©
    <r . RfocHoos of dbe . Skufe
    Class co! (JbpsdJs ‘%s deo - , skive .
    © beabls , -vbs fdqqs QV&
    3 © ©
    ni B
    1
    - '
    t iight tooVdrxoao slave / p
    ( ce
    °
    gsppo&f coel{ax£
    I1 ® © •
    © p si^Ve Liberals , social libel s
    ^
    giaie § cq po cHy build log .
    '
    -1 ©-
    fs.
    of 4f >e
    NlQfUYg gag -
    •

    >:
    %
    ^ r. )

    ACCOrdfog -fo lJb0jra (g 0 +^ rsJeuVYQi , So^c (Q, Q -eqotiibzdqao


    I © foal or To dfog Society . ^ ^
    - 5>
    3
    I f>
    ^
    According -Vo H ei slave vepresenls oovevsai Aiteuis .
    S
    'Si?
    :Vfi
    © ^ ^
    s5
    18
    #
    Mandst Ibcorg of 4be StQt£
    Tbere a*© HOO perspectives /approaches on bbe
    *
    <
    -
    I >
    : S
    1
    1:
    © CD 3b^hairoeota ' fsls %*spec-Vive
    S5
    I# © ffructuriaiists fcvspecfve /pelafve
    si Autonomy Theory]
    4 ©
    Ibsb u.noGota \ fste tbeofU '
    '

    I:1
    © f
    aarorooofsv vaao i feslo •’
    "
    far I Marx \ n bis book
    !2 ©
    M
    Sfaucki'riav , Siy Tbeavg - Q
    t
    '

    - ir> bis
    (

    s?
    m O'dgio of -Vtoe
    ^ ^, \g-H l surooi \-ra
    ‘
    book — .

    : <?
    :s
    s
    © Marasf- -
    theory
    I

    0p s-\a-V -
    ^ of Louts Bonaparte
    \
    52
    © Slave fs oof 4be product
    of 4be (pee «c ti of 4h? aqcio.
    *
    ;
    i
    if ( <3 -vhe product of fExce -
    •

    1: fb
    V.:)
    angioaf 4be. slave is la
    S^bjagafiOO of cOCae kg -tbs
    .
    •
    ?:

    .
    .v
    5 i
    **
    /
    .; sent jpotOG)T-
    strong . neoc©, SVa.bC
    1 ^rGp£
    I© arxid do oof spppmf -VbQ Uberal AvguenoeoV dbaV <as\av© fe
    I©
    ?
    ^
    o neaVra \ axbitov . Slave fs ao To iraoceov of Abe captors!
    dass- dccosdioa Vo Kart Vaqry, fecorolc sfruoloro is 4be
    ^ !

    ;! ©
    eVrucVuve state. fe> a part of sepcrdrudasep ” lbe dass ~
    bpdc :
    b
    •

    °
    h

    I3 # '
    caobrds -foe basic <garudUre also controls 4be toShl-ufoosaf :
    I
    super ShrucbawP . iviguV'rairty of slave is fBiVse raosdoa&ocss • :i

    1© 5

    i#5
    I
    !:
    !© t
    V;

    s
    11 © l

    I©
    >:

    I8 e>
    ?:
    fl
    t»

    K
    p.
    !<
    3. © :
    s

    i © p
    5

    i© 3
    S
    s B
    ;

    i
    I
    i ^ -
    CV’Vv'.
    " '
    -
    &uTO’eo Qiist feyspgcfve -
    1
    ^
    o
    '
    s
    'J
    ?. ^ost
    a' *.
    ® JSfo tsao F&ocutWe Coronofitee op -Abe Gou
    < eopg ctes i?
    § ^
    foVYoducpoo
    —^
    KQYI MQiOf
    0 ©
    a tv\ajrc4'fp OF State FifOnO YdaodgV
    - ^ p?Ci1^Q
    ^ § -
    3
    4
    -«
    •%

    ©
    1'

    Context
    •
    :1
    dogs OOf sobsc ibo -fo the HY>om ! v) te <o 4bat ©
    :d
    .i
    * 3•( ^ .
    ^vate
    •
    i I'S a neutral - ©
    oo +bQ exec^ -k^e cocomltvee op ^ ax^r
    contra
    ^
    :d
    :: ? gate (s 4bg ©
    -$
    !
    :
    •

    . .f
    geoise class -
    ^ ©5
    :h$

    :o: © teeOO Of E pCUHv/p CDmroi-Hee


    '03 * - ©
    0<ecqpvc CbrorO'rHGe ©)QS OO QUtOOOroy 4o roate decisions
    U is to fcopveroejcrt 4be agOndq op gpu*g©3lSG
    o
    ^ \PS6 •
    . *

    .
    5
    I
    1 The basis op +be csT guenoeo't- £ /
    •
    5

    *ia-fx tbco-BO of +H9fcnrfoa 1 MaVe -srte Se -


    r:
    ©
    *cond '

    Usfoo
    @
    @
    ''
    a: -though state ts dbe core cocoGpl Of, FbiitfctM ec-teoco yef .
    ©*
    aH concepts lo politics ase cootgsvpd concepts - Tbe no(+a«2 ©
    opiate •sptoaios a matte " of debate • For ideal ists , dote %
    •
    r
    <
    *
    .
    *
    (sex aoasce- of vidae, -(by deesICQ I abcmts SJete 1- Q
    3
    * © .

    1 occesSOX) gvl | , Foir anarch1 SV state PS a on oecessairt/ <2te l . .

    -p3r ' no'ioistS date Os a. © loSi -ttot?o> o of tbt Wo& ©


    ^ - .
    ^ nhtj . '
    *
    3
    TfoQte tea 0 ?oterna ( debate: bek-oeeo MQ'svisra rtset-f ©
    -
    $ •

    ©
    -f
    V -
    for ‘tnsVxuroexDteMisiS Skate t’S a iostounoeot fcpF tor Other srboo!
    of -thought ffexte does enjpy ^cia-hug aatooenry- -
    . - •:
    . y
    }.
    ©
    4 -
    ft !
    /

    V 'I ? 1
    •'
    •

    .-"d
    ? •«SHB> S a t e JCn pteSSrx
    tv >
    ( ^

    mecoodabUity of doss Aoiayoai-sras


    -.. -r.
    ©
    .-•5{ 0 UrpoducWOo Lenio
    0 Tbrs (s
    *

    :-..
    PI
    < Kaayxi'st
    ^eto of 4fesx3te . IS
    4
    £n\opo accDJcdfog -to leote disto^noal
    orteodex nocirxtet
    V*

    i
    Ce
    ic,
    ^^alfhaiistx) class eteUggie 'sC'yoiO.koo am iGoda.«oeo-ta ) ^ - /p-
    'kv
    ••
    -1
    .

    i fPindple- of r^arxisco -
    (o? tobat lenio says
    ©
    -O
    I f t e Yorl MOOT, tenlo aiso bfiiicves kbctf siiate cs -oov beabrai
    'V>lber
    Y

    is class <oS*rc^ot of ©
    ©-
    kbe dnr<>oant class - ^tukco
    (o -P«r dbe
    t
    •.- I
    ©
    .-:
    ©
    ©
    :V::
    :::
    S5
    •

    0*
    ‘ - Cvv
    :©:1
    sSc!
    :>-
    @
    - 1\ CAI Ka siauSro 3^99
    ^: +bai-
    :$
    ^
    '

    i © »•
    AcCovd < oq to t£nio,
    cki^p .
    *

    1n Go no rote -
    ig, &e basfc

    * •
    ? S+ QV . lSQ
    ^ of *

    es op History 4b ^© hos/e ©opo -too classes " P .


    4 ©
    :?
    JS ©
    :
    '

    ;s
    £
    £b an ra
    ^^
    Owners if rsbo - otoopss- Gtone&S a-sp •© fol -te*- £. -OQO
    ‘f ’
    t

    _
    § m
    '
    '
    x
    * -:>>
    ocOopss QTSP evploitedi .
    1© 1he$& CQO n yer bo a YPCOOCJOI /O OO beKoeeo pbp (o aest-
    ^ ^
    • r*
    \<c

    IO op e*pbiver £ extorted ,
    pfi£&@ooe op Pfeile itePlf oboeo -'"boV ctee oolo oo'sro
    3? •
    -- •

    0 *
    |

    ;4 ©
    :
    5. CQonoV bp vpsoive }
    ^> . ^
    1© Sfate fs Qo in © QRPAVEJ by 'Qou g-Gols® does -
    ?s no ov
    I

    :!S .
    ^
    oses> {brte 00 4toe poovs co -te 1 rfeesi- o -p 4be eeatgeofse ^
    -
    '

    © ?
    e
    Ck39S Pbots Cbnoot e*ppc£ J ^&Hce p^ronQ +foe stedp . Hence ^
    5
    be on\y apHoo iS nfevoiUbbo SO lory classes •o^fe.ts, class,
    1:«
    ;.l
    '
    © ^Sh*cjLa/ g ] Q e tf Sb ?- loocj class “Sbrayyle
    •

    stei-te -ex/b-ts •
    3ri
    © ’ '

    :
    3n cD'rorounnSxo classes
    *i
    © -erx
    Si -
    Sfav-fe cOrhbptts CXe Oa •
    - ^ so class, e ^-0O90>e -ends • Hence
    >
    ;

    i
    1
    ©
    1i ©
    :! •
    ( jbodUsfoo ^
    1 © °rsfci©^ '3 '
    p^O,p^>G^V^ .
    ^
    L &Q\$~5QY £+<3V£ YQiDYpQorv „

    ^ or 00 v os
    . "®2roci?
    o. roottgr
    /

    >
    © :
    £
    f
    ?
    of d e
    <5
    I (©) I V

    !© ?
    !
    :J
    t;
    1
    S
    I
    :•
    < !

    1© A

    J 6$
    Vs
    >:

    I @
    •

    .1
    ©5

    1©
    1
    >:
    © !

    *
    3 m \
    \
    1© i
    ¥

    :
    ;
    |
    I
    © t

    !© t
    f
    © t-

    t
    t
    sI © R
    B»
    :
    !
    (:

    1;K
    !© •

    | 11S / I:
    -
    ^
    5
    !
    i .
    i
    ^ ^ ^ ^ ^SrtSS3W 5^
    SS3 353SS32S SSS 53555SSS25gRK @
    t:
    AU\OOQrO( J \Js j&DShfU roQOtQ I (St lecture 34
    I£
    ib^wrr>en+ ' isv -Vheowj QWGS no aufeoo f- iOb
    -..
    ?|oi 1 A '

    V*
    £v.

    ^
    ?-:
    '
    •i : Q
    :-d
    -d rpQS d<b© ©
    • ^i- to the State state has no Seedo^o of achoo
    ,
    ^eoooe ^ -e ©
    Steri
    sitaapaos QIOS
    a
    V
    r-
    1
    •

    /
    2 hd
    theoy Qpoeesv that
    -
    ( iQ
    ^ ^ai .
    bat state oppeoss nea
    4
    '
    .
    V&T

    n SOrjoe QnaOcJOi
    onr» te liberals
    Of CiU VOOOOO

    rOQi>ds
    ^
    cb °°^ ^ ' e tovfc estate
    eV/, 4 is m
    CDroptetey
    ^ >

    neutral - Or vson j reto+ivey o-eabat


    • m,
    ' ©
    r:
    e:-
    tobaf does TreJafv'ekj oeataat ro©ao < m
    &
    Sate nca <-j appear neutral to /co fooPicfiooj tote*®oh BropQ*r-
    (
    p
    ;

    9
    ,
    +ted cdoes aoct poors bql ultt coatey state coooes for -the- ©
    V

    pz^tecfbo of ancb ir) CTI93 sHaaPoO atette. cSill 0Oppoaf Ate #


    Tjido - . f • ©
    5 If GOG Qppy TseJcJbve Ctateooroj -theory cDHf )
    pxesppcf to state ip osA despite te>e -gy*- -foa-t bi «y QanCs
    I-- A
    ^
    oa<e rtesponsi bis for sobpsfroe crisis afjcb has Otfpated
    @
    @
    .
    %-
    A '
    •V
    hardships for large eocKooof 4be poaplf Qbte canoo ho
    te -pswe Of 4be bootees bailout fte bools - Oo -ihe (% ©
    oood atcdip bos ueed POI ice -(Stie oo the psopie io
    03311 ffsoef ndeveroeot • ' /
    - occupy @

    G
    ‘ :i
    -
    Uibj Sate becotToes 'seiartWey /u ocr^cousC
    ^
    3£ ail depends oo the historical e>odi -H'onS posG ai i 'rOC) . ©
    • ••
    ;
    r ^
    JJO bis booKs Igb Braroaitso of loug Gooa parte ho
    bos
    expbioed 4b e sHaafoo of c Gooa partis . ©
    ;:!
    . 5
    idbat is (boa panKsno t ^ •n
    fd
    A
    ft
    !
    Those Safes are QooapcpHst skates cohere &ecq-tVe is
    :J
    ^Strong . £f noo\<
    oa
    I
    j happen that different social groap
    :'.:T
    Vd
    '•
    M
    egoaiy Shroocj so -that- a particular group \$ ucable to m- .

    f/ i
    ft :
    •:'
    f
    '
    cbooioohs -hhe toosb ahraefti. • Sacb bHaa -Hoos cfoVe beco -
    ^ e
    :;:>

    :>l
    roes rpJabveicj aatonoroous- bovb 3-roope noag ebropehc for
    •
    :i
    '
    d]
    •• •
    :!
    jdbc Oppcyrh of -tbe state.
    ^ - ,. . • - - %

    cd
    ©
    • vi
    1
    m
    ::

    ;-fi
    :!

    I s
    1
    S;
    #
    •r:
    £:'
    •

    P
    f
    :T
    :: 1
    © 4
    v.d gxOrOpie oodor -M "rH22T.
    © op vroQpy
    vJp cao 0vtV > -Vd ? 0<r3 ^> pVp
    (

    ^
    '

    —
    £ t

    1©
    '

    £r> Oerroaetj botb Cqp+


    '
    olists QS els
    tO T2
    ^
    -a
    ’
    *
    /

    © bcogd obHe to 30; o oafo oa^ ay Sl-ofe


    * - -
    .3
    3
    * @
    CK QOiS©3 • dbis ^
    0
    opioid pd roaCS
    •
    '
    leadership a- rsalso
    -tba 4- -*4-

    .L
    - cyf
    3
    protected -^be fatesesV op psapee
    ^
    9
    :-a
    i2 © R ^arta'y
    ©
    1a ©
    1 ^PPeo '4ba +hoo one

    T ZTvfor
    I CA
    :$
    s
    g ©
    SH

    1©
    .! ©
    ; fo ig*>
    R^oate - < ^
    oatooofv j
    peo ^roreso
    cer^avu
    .
    to ?
    S'oce
    Raoce • o
    (BoorvDfc sftudure

    ^ - bos also ©veo sVdlar Cbocept


    ^ 4be
    stated os
    Otass terete
    <ela

    . <?a
    s:,'
    o
    s
    ©
    I
    has gveo tbe cooaep - -
    op totepsal SLATPS pse civof
    * ‘Integral
    ^
    ® P og
    ? 1 sodebj o?r poiitical soc/ ^ ° *
    i© @crte . Because op b eKj aw
    4 9 cKiI society
    I© Hocoe/-pr obeo oVii socJeh -pjiis appeals aMteoai-
    ooci<
    I etcne ceroios -pw -tbe 'jsgqe
    ^^
    •
    © op-the opp'foiiSt cbss
    bfackJnrcii r-Hawtete |
    •
    p
    Poaiaoras also © jppofc* TseJca-fivQ aulteaoo/ +busser ,
    I
    © Isjicole
    I AOCOTjdCo -to Ai-tbasapjr y -4*003*3. ^
    H- © , state ‘» 0 a pttcnist soo’et^ possess
    ;;
    . >:

    :1s © ^
    I to -Hype op . opevatess *
    ^
    ^
    nxdeopcjjcot ate ope^ate S (Xh>sv 4
    • ;

    I
    (?) ^
    Cbexsive state operates^ ^C fbifte § ^ ovYoos op Qv;1 soa‘op> j
    R
    i © ^' ifervtp .

    peiabvp i-teooroy
    I
    ^
    '
    .
    C is QISO kootoo QS stTyactchnOM
    : - t:
    d:
    i* ©
    -vbecmj •

    -tbe oeweols op
    ip 9\ uctaiat
    ^ i aocisro tVopoRaoce is gReo
    ^ <?o to
    ^ ^
    «
    sopor sboct-aires . Maw ©as adopted sRuc-kp
    ;! © 'isio .iQ- app SOacb \ o
    :c ' '

    BfUroalire -
    Sr'acJctartatrsro
    I© developed by as Tfoesm .
    ^arosci § -tbaf is <^oOy de fe )caocOo> '

    I •
    HcJai 00 o- Sope^r stxuCkfirp . ©isorasa bas held dbaV sapeT-
    i# j sbuckioe © OCH 30S+ asePiecNao of base Tra-tber eferucJki8®.
    © i
    sx fo rtSGlP ACCcosdfo b'rD , -vbexe CX&2 4tOo laVess fo
    ”

    *&
    I
    Soper.sb uci-a.yGs
    '
    ^ i
    I© 1

    1©
    !© 1

    ;
    ;
    5 i
    :
    © 1
    r
    \
    . 1© 1
    ® 1f
    t
    13 ©
    >**•
    r;
    1© i
    I
    3 I
    S -
    Ted stTOdUVtaUsbo is
    O'J
    /\ ! fbqssev taa&
    -
    frVbe roodi
    ^
    Soo gGsVed -HT>OA 4b@YP CTO
    be
    * ^-roqiffpi
    © Srt2fUCki?re ^
    dod *^5vv
    * ;
    •

    P1
    1
    i

    net ^ Just
    .poo StortlCt ch$VS 5
    ©
    v>
    § dicoie Fbcjiaoros oo ©
    D >ate beicoeeo Ralph tMiiiband
    i
    :
    ,vl
    ^
    4be t-ia+tj?ve op sta-te
    :i
    Ralph Miiibaod - iS xbshsuroeotaiisv

    ^ > CDIG POMIQO QS rs steudkidaiist •


    w
    • 4 ^
    :.}
    •

    They ho>/e aoaysed 4fc>e oakJftB of pees- <t p?- aitev states .
    * *
    oibav is pQSf CQpifcJlisfr state ?
    =Ve
    Si! Onp^taiTsro roe3CG> pftcMf £To os existed c$t +be ©
    arigfoal <
    ^
    SS
    Si
    tfroe op kart r^av at - \tacrv 4W>e cppfta \ \e^o ^oos hbu^oao ©
    *
    , Fbs CQprtohs>o
    ^ vvf Gir Vox I ^TQ-SY 4be natasno o-f CQpftaiisr^ ©
    :
    ••
    -
    ,

    ^
    bas changed f (- bos bpcQnoe noo-ye baroaoe . LaVases 4aure @
    :c
    s? State gcNe cooy -fo toeiPase state .
    :SS4.i
    Their debotp ta on taPf fore states in coestpvo oouotVes .
    -
    $:
    / ' o
    cJairos op liberals -
    m
    dautte op sRa+e bos taaagped ^Ot+b -*be iOt&otaqdKoo op ©
    / - R ht to vofe -pbr a2>oirheo s\ate totes roao/ ^oeipdtfe
    :

    ^ t
    •

    ;!
    :
    Jbocttoos -fbtvoqy of pocra beoce <L£^Q ^cvoov soy 4texV
    <
    t;v
    »

    - bbe State fe The fostw-^aeot of Tbe Yfcb - The raticise op


    Ol
    ©
    Oapitenisto bos ebat ed-
    ^
    )V1
    I
    ©
    i
    Gpooepf of MagogebaI Peyotutoo
    VA
    taaoc eriai Retatutioo as concept bos boeo csdvaOcad -fo
    i
    ^ a
    Sbo <D Tbe chooged oaHue op capitaus o- iMaoc eriQ TsevoLb P
    ' .
    ^
    tbo suggests Tbe bis GDOOPCKOO betuoeso -tae oooness of ^ ©
    p;
    capital §. desd&too roatets • Capitalists
    <
    too roore desa' - ©
    :r - { Stan ooafcetS - Decision mauny has Db fVed kovo cqpton’St
    ^
    i

    :v
    - -
    doss to too-oage rial class - '
    -
    .s> ©
    tCDnagemi class 02 o open doss - Anyone cao pta -^he 'Hvanago^-iai ©
    ^ '
    ^
    class - Cven -the persons <23 0 oy -fYcx^o -the vOcnrvdog bass ^paroiiv^
    "

    - /''V
    -
    -
    A* ’ •
    •x %
    Cdo be -vbo roaopgexs odost y decisions o «e t ateo ty noa-
    negers eoco.
    ab \
    *
    :-5C

    v
    P.
    '
    -
    (
    ^ o
    ^ ^as between
    -beer? bsoteo - -Tbe oon-os O tb© odu.s 'pj has chpwi9®d -
    ' ^ ' ^
    Money taesebn NOQ U03 bA®

    ::*r
    .
    S @

    ©
    ©
    ?•. @
    •V . '

    %* (
    <

    :T:

    5
    --->
    •
    ^ V

    :c- C'
    stctfe -
    J

    "33
    eqpHatists no rvooire cbotaol -toe
    i ®
    fbst capt'-ioMsV s> ta^ -
    3s
    1 © fiatpb Miiibaod Analysis of
    3
    Goof - The Stove to cnpfKnisfr sodQhj pbbllshed lO 0®3
    '

    •
    3
    : «!
    •

    © ,of Sto&he bos


    I paipb iiband bcb ebo«00 That- the
    "
    3S
    © ,
    DOV charged despite the £*cf Ahat oote have Rgbi tovc^
    -
    I© Accordtog H> bt ^o, rnooOgG'nQ ) •sevotobtoo 'S ^ ^
    8
    #=to9d to toe bands
    \ . -
    * ©
    .*:-
    $ CXtOhn'es FOoonoic pocoesr is
    ' (brxeof
    o
    s
    of -the oapita i t c class TTSoosb r^aoQg TnQl (does fe ctO Op£D
    -.2
    01
    ©»
    ^
    Class bat- 'the ctoonces op sons § dao dteas of ^oatobg dass
    ^
    Ic ©
    -
    -di . ^
    jddng -toe i-oajoases-to) class, is e>cteero©iy cma • aevi! l§. cobss
    ^
    . m~ © they she o< socoe\y -to leaded rf is ocf possible fcxr theno -f o
    '•31
    :
    ^S
    i
    m ^
    Jaio toaoc o roerH educa-boa is cooflardaHe •
    ^
    *
    :: 1
    !s ® Pdipb Milibaod bos a^o analysed the V^Mreacvacy Judrcfa^y
    . .3
    i© iOttoeQG (baatrlGS - pueo TBcvseac&acij £ Judiciary Treraaias
    © H-tsi- §- < t t’s hardly osepjteseot-
    ^
    I © V
    ahve tbus accordley to hasp _
    ; 4herQ Vs oo -ypai
    chaogg FcaooroVc po<ut>eer '^rcrvDa;os cooc©o
    :
    •• (

    ©
    ©
    +*ated The Class ^obicb balds ecDoorbc p6coe>ralso bolds tbs
    •

    fawcal poeoe - deoce stcHQ coof ou-es -to be -the foshar-oe^i-


    Tt ©
    *
    V

    : 1© •
    WCb/ CpprtD t St CJlQSS
    "
    -
    ^
    .
    ^
    si
    1S C© rdicDie fbuiaozas
    •

    ©
    j
    Micbie PoWaocas does not-
    ogrea ib+h, -to-e iosVzruaoeioiaiiSte
    ? • s/tpo
    wHb-er- soppost -toe shuGkJrvatist- iselcitw aatohorvyj
    1
    : © tbG3 y • Accordrrg to bro /
    \
    •

    fNnor& Qm be considered qsao


    *
    dvats io ^oesveso ube^ol sodoKeg
    t C
    i r j j t a r o o f a post? calcs.* cJass -
    '
    :
    I PeausHC -
    1
    •

    CEnboduofoo of or>viQrSq) Adolf franchise has charged 4he


    rxstobe of -toe slave , Th -toese
    l © Sy tern 5 . electoral coutatone9 caropeftibs/e. ga.&4g
    I<
    ^ ^
    ysteno ebciste- Hoarder to caroe -to
    ^
    155 ' © pcSrtical pchhes toove +o gep Qjppa&f ?oro -vhe. tosge poeoor
    5
    i
    #
    Cf tbe SQQ'etky . (d hca +he«e ptrogjfaoos Caooot be xdwsio
    to O priffcijla-r class - Ws voq
    ' eecVioo
    ^ ^ ^
    ^cs Stote oeubai • tb order to
    7i rcaio io gocoer pcrtoji has -fe
    «

    © ° care of the tovesesis, '

    ^
    i
    P
    ? of the dlff reot- classy - 1

    I © 1
    -
    :

    \m
    \
    \
    5
    \
    ! m :

    © 5

    © 5
    t\:
    © f;

    Y;
    © 6
    f-
    © t
    !
    © s
    :•

    © I'lk ti2
    © s
    te>af otafe ts only
    ;& ; -a (so a gs-ejg
    f-toe£>0?/
    ^ fbq la o 'zeds ^
    is OOt CocoptQ ty autan&trpas f
    C'.

    acGlatWoy
    ,
    aa-t eooroous ^
    ta tee case of c& iS S. tee state Of II Goroe lo tee 3
    $ te CUe
    fe
    '
    ,1 of zn cb -
    '
    ’
    ©
    # f G not oisis lb cmj Of tee State @
    1
    ©
    According -to (bH^pv-ine ttaacbinooo toe • fs no fftaotst ©
    teeo*y of -fee state - ©
    cobuf
    Fbno \ o)5v -tbP3«y is about pocoeb pender patvtafdotj -
    .
    -
    V

    Im
    '

    Fpnoios&s ave a5Qi S^ pot-Yiaitabat society .


    ° ^ ©
    m
    fPnoioteJs pasHior) *cite TJQspPc -folate \rs orbd*
    vateot •
    ^
    Obey CW9 not ctaq? about state) OO Obe band teey- <orefd©r
    '
    ste+e_ as ao iosv ? tefioo of pat ?na*chy or) tee ota©* hood @
    te -they beitoye teat -tee state cmo ftp tee aroie to i ^op^ovJing @
    .-
    status op toomoen -
    : Ux
    rM
    •*
    * tep .v
    v»
    *

    ©
    m ACCPTfCitOC) to eateetanp taacti' noon teobGn \ \ cob tee State
    siate appears Male -to roe ”
    m
    tabaV (3 tep i 'nopiloaMon ©
    ^ -
    ate <s a \fcsti tattoo of p3tda*cby - States' pesspe tev- &
    roascqiaofSt- Hence , » t fe ypvy difpcait teat ^corcen <£xo
    o
    ©
    .
    GV
    QOt justice texouyV) tee , State OT: tee t3UY0ciu aracy
    • 5

    -
    judidoryt} § other tns-h tattoos of tee state Gbte@tee taacti - cs. .

    onoo is bcayev by pscf ostoo - tee ©as analysed tee ta ^os


    ^
    'related to Looroen - 'Ihocjb teese tacos ate f &r toaroeo yte. ©
    v
    '
    •

    tees \arO se feu \ of loopholes-


    © § cs as if teeycie?
    ^ appeals
    ^
    toadta far to omen but -fov *oQr > - Sbe ba^e aca sed rrape
    ©
    m
    tatCe tee aurobtesooop judidaJ plages te aud, Situatfens ^ ^
    teat- it becomes etteetooj cdifpcu Vt for Loomen to 0£&- justice- m
    sr / »

    There oo deep analysis of tee oata ©f tee teote \r>


    (s «p

    fteb.oisro %i it is beupyed teat - raol^ts teotees "tageoeto )


    ^
    .
    VJ jy

    -% feroioigts need to eoemte toore soptat nuated arxiGv.scto


    dirp of tee nature of state .^ ^G ' —
    vJ
    i
    : «
    l
    e
    VI ©
    ©
    ©
    K
    m
    :'-:
    c:

    #
    :- ©

    I
    ’ :;:i
    '

    ©
    «1 *

    m ftprotm'SV beo arj of-^ -


    , CD*9 also bppn.3

    fidoo bos
    j&aoaoti -toe
    ^ ° <? <os f MQrfoo 701x03 ?

    -.v

    1- ©
    ©
    soggeswd -toe ooocepl of Jiff
    put fSacj3Q^d -ffhe VlStOs Of CcX^
    £«> oHatoc4
    lQ f
    eta'eeoth o
    'tel -
    :*

    t a
    © ^
    V Q
    cCbo
    CQO 0|3O
    boob
    lo b£V
    ' s<2 tba| CDnHaCf ’
    *
    bQ'SfOd -tbe
    '
    OaiO
    ^ '

    .N

    - e
    Social aootsadt scholats dCioo have -tafcpo > Cbossot Of
    33

    I
    4 ©
    3
    “

    2 rot sped £Tcn\ \y t^oenhoocd


    ^
    . SS ©
    •

    .y -
    S3
    /K .
    V
    tco^oeo HOT gtf ^ otedu Hhey ^ ^
    abou-t '{the pQvff -ppaHoo of ^ooroeo to hbe cbatsadt - - ov "

    ii *
    \
    “ bo
    Icebot-bgr ^Oor-oeo tO ? «re aGth/e pcrsftcfpQO <Q ofoscDStcg ^
    (
    I ©
    . a
    ©
    !
    <

    Qy2tD <m> oohex <iObiob -Hoey5 hcwe tospo fasaed to Use ohe, -
    j?
    Qlso bojlevps +bav | f eortoad bad bePO based Of )
    %
    :3
    3
    @ i
    >

    i
    ba ta - ^
    of AooroQJD ttys. i comA baue bee.o I <vrog \ oo
    - -
    ^.
    .3
    I5 ©‘
    ooacb better tao d
    ;i
    © 2

    •1 Tbeovtos
    '
    5
    ©
    3 ©
    f&sV cbboa
    1
    '
    Tboavij of -the Slate -
    i
    OO f sv C&IOO Ql vStohP
    ^
    «*•
    % '
    1
    -',
    te
    •
    m 1
    i ^tbab om post oooo' skxves ?
    - Qi
    S
    '
    •
    I The States adnicb had ooioatai past- 1&? but tQbgxe cobobl
    ;! # tegacg fs sb' M Qt#&k£4& CooHnq ^ioa - former cnfootjulsm & •
    o
    I 0/&T bat f >esa CDlOOlQltero GOOtiOUQS - Staves Ukp C& A ,
    1 i T%JS4TSCM IQ , fJeo SealQod coo not- be considered as pos-v
    .- cdoobi Becaass? kcvue ovesncoroe -W- => 43® colonial
    ^
    :

    *
    ^V
    legacy .
    v-
    1
    ?
    *
    Tfoe 4ecro hJeO CPiooialis*o toQS adoed by fcns-roer |%esidojn^of
    '

    ;
    %aoa iccoame ® M hsuroab •
    1@
    >
    j °^OQ t iS COlOOl'CxIterO § cObcUr is colony ? '
    •

    Coiooicx \ (sx> §- Cbboy VS a tejf ^o of t aYvfsv disfoavse •


    r*

    |w
    ?
    MacMsts afeo -vbe
    ^
    drepeocJeooy D f ren^a >0 ^
    :
    :

    !#
    I
    >
    @
    dependence depeodeoc-fi • IbVordepence ' is
    ^ -
    Of mutual give §. tate • uobe reas
    •

    ° ^i+tua
    ^oo ^
    ;
    •

    porscty gets beoified aA -the cast: depondenyy


    . ooe
    t bsye 1
    V
    S °
    y.

    Ii
    i
    -
    of -tbe other .
    ' ’«

    I
    i
    *5 ©
    ?

    ii
    i
    m i
    l
    <;
    5
    © S
    f

    \
    \ m 5i
    m i

    ©
    :j
    @
    r
    t
    , ©
    r
    0 .
    f

    xv
    [
    to3
    i
    v
    •
    r lep^ o
    CbbnfQi fs^o WQ(site
    bos _ -
    prided toe
    icto
    '
    -
    of £bop«rfa 'ie^S Qilo0 ' te10
    ‘
    Q ' Is
    ©---
    x<

    si
    0 Unequal Bccbaoge Q
    -\
    :• .
    :V5
    I
    *
    @ Do
    ^4n OoveJc
    ^ -
    rDeot m
    scholars ose too -H^ ro CQTP § podpberup rAeJnropoirg,
    /!
    si
    £:
    r
    Ma^clsl-
    w §- satellite to explain toe situation of dependency .
    < ©
    I Tbeovtes of fat coioota \ states
    i
    fb$T colonial states ha^e beeo studied by Ubera ) pesspecfve G
    - --Ji
    -
    : 1
    os toeii os Marxist perspective -
    Ubeal f peCJhvg
    i• *

    — i
    ^
    Bpp^oacb op Liberal Scbolqts - m
    © itej bave> applied potitaGa-1 dev^ebpopoeot <§. p rtfcai raadpiroigce
    ' jy

    -
    - •••I
    •' -ttoo approach .
    CbdtaiibuHoo of pUj - Riqqs Ofatoerof deve> . drooV
    ^ t
    '

    & 5V. Tr> Case of ‘Third hbvld Countries {Siqqs bq p&pfevsrod toe
    <
    ^ m vu>
    to %
    1 -
    tefrt o " pb-fsroa-Hc Societies '
    §

    Pif iSPOQ-h'C 3QClQ!r<j - V aosihoo societies


    C 'MLS*

    PmsirxaHc 60a eh; rocans societies vo


    ' &

    oocviotq -the uod exdeveloped Stage deveJoped


    C> %:

    j e
    «£ > > coo Qa > i ft as develops og societies - - I

    . (tbtdiog 4o bi a
    ^ ^
    ••
    *
    ^ snoaffc SbateHj Vefreo r -
    v
    0 tos’nco ' -o - J> roOoos H3 gap \r> to oiry fctwosvj
    igf
    (2)1Jrblq 00 rnoa ti noiSpO _ - ^
    CO etaStOO c£ of nsqtfooal
    pnraa ^ eacvtutea e
    -iae. •
    fSTrdtooQ 1 ^ e ^ “ V

    • ?
    nomas of policy roataog . G
    031 Rto cororouoa I iSPD - thttoe country is °cf 0r e aanonouho ftu )

    satber toeire -
    dt -ff &sent cora < auo' des Qwouoibes Co - -^
    *3S\S - butare suspicious about ©oCb otoe5T *

    (
    531 Ecooo'ro^c STeo - 8aT:
    '

    ^ ator<tooteeo ?v^odei
    Adm'«r>Sarovive gHStorvp , S IA rrxadbl «r > odtoida ovfoo txe. ^
    see. to© aarotiiooKoo of osnvfooai ascives as^ 03 fdroiu/ <
    kiodato oc ros
    ^
    ^
    ..
    fUodMooa cxe.dappjog These to oo oe
    ' - >
    ^^
    fo maoj axiotvies afroy
    *

    fdoctoos cvejriap
    * *

    :<>;3
    >j
    G
    ; dviroo /rd roi oi'sl^a ticn
    !
    : •:}

    ©
    @
    i
    toe
    !

    V:
    to .
    OS’ '
    to
    -to
    % 1
    5
    totototo
    i
    <&>: :
    ^*r>tt-::i ZZ£^
    ^
    1 * ~L%\ m
    i o
    a
    '
    4 0
    0
    3
    @
    ]
    !
    ;;:i ©
    !
    ‘
    ?; ©
    ;
    1$ 01
    i
    j
    |
    ©i
    • SOJJ
    . SJ© m\ N
    pool OoOZ Goxci 4 OCKJO
    ^ ^CIGOJ -g op ^
    naqaq peiioj
    siapc©\ OC ©I
    e* u ov 6o> pxo v Atxjootj ? .
    .
    *
    .
    ^ ^I D M D J , D P J L
    xtxv coo.- ( ^ i joorvj •
    0
    ! <
    © ;-i ;
    i
    ’

    o ^P - P IIOD 4
    ^ + 1 QjLq | }
    i
    ^ o*
    SaH-oaps ( ,|(j ©ot,o> jQS > Oipoj Oj v
    COH- U J ^
    ^ -§ . JiopoSBOqoay 90 -S 0CuJQ
    ^- > {
    ^ ,7
    ^ / '
    Q? Dt 0<
    44- s oadsQQj OQQ, D
    44 0
    ° -J 5.
    -X (
    cmoy 9qV EqOclxq oqo 9oo = _ ^
    - p> 3cisa s. /SAOOJL *51 Qsdcjpa i
    ,
    cn O!
    ^ - airq.|r)3 ODtpqi
    •
    spoc co qons 3feks spuoo- jcq. tacoq+}fol D 9 j as© © 0
    ^ :
    " ©|;
    arxj©q spo aou qors (i\ c^opdas - 0005 aA0<4 9^0!Pm. • ( uioq-voo ^
    ^
    a V spapcnov B70aj, p! 0B\ p jo QjtfpHro Bty. PH $0q \qpOO
    £
    ^ ^ © }3 -;
    3,
    ^ ^
    © poot) jo booted
    ^ _
    5
    f
    "
    © © £
    It:-
    4» .V ^opHnwco © © *"
    - 03 p o \ puj: sg£- saostv5 |-
    £ © I.
    •
    ^ •
    ;. *
    s9NVpa ° lt»paooack?|3/ssp ^ Ad.qpG 0+ a*Pwca QT) © I .
    5
    ^ -V
    AOITD r>v \s A9pso %- CPO\ SOQ Q © i%
    - 3 •
    jdfcs: aqp J-O 3D oapb suco aqp 9} 4oqcn
    ^
    ^ ©
    ' V
    UOB-O paoaSvjc aj xoodi aS.UOcpife Q O\© jjgg j - *
    ^ ^ © p
    •
    • saojtod poo o= DI -a?Jiq}oa fivpodoa 9oq o p s # QS 3
    - ^^ 0 I
    AJos S\ VDc
    • # I
    / ./
    _ Dipcyr ^
    A
    340*3 - joe I
    c oisaoopox § o pqj paipo 9oq ,\ an
    5*44 - P^°JQT> spq % © fw
    -osa^ ^ •
    DoaQXCi OOISV - j ©I M'
    *
    5©
    io|8Z» D'.
    ’
    7 } . OQ) © «K .-
    \ tiers I \ JTjDplH rXtXJOVtf Jo O0Hnqw| &
    '
    ^s-ovoai ^ ' A
    B &8^*5
    , jo 0ooa-\qx©
    •
    -°© - (qjaabQxa
    '
    Cxafa.’ p7102 i ^ jS- © ft-
    ^ § i^ iojeposa(Sm S© OO.t-vdy fel ^ ^ I
    ^ ^ ojtHiV \W ® W:
    Sv .\) aoooo X& vo^
    ^ lOSOaBNdlPPO
    “C>

    _ .. . v xfs4 -Analysis .
    ^
    Aoql(jg1 C
    lr> t*xa
    *
    HcKxfst *
    -tbcoopt
    i
    V.
    -There ose 2- school at ©
    @1 £og-sgrogota \ iste / pG c-.
    - - p ' ( ©
    scholars - A •G ptfaof Ce> (so FuYtado, Pa Rrebisb
    -
    «o| ,
    V
    --
    i.

    -v
    / ©
    SaroiT /\noiO ^ T^oOnaei VdallQrSteio.
    .

    a
    Si G
    ©: ©
    ^ ° sJnpu
    = l 1'
    f
    ^
    @
    Vay LeO O - Depeodeocy school Theo 2riSt$ Inca'S yQe>
    *
    ' @
    G •
    The poenoroeoa of ©sPo - O3\oodi i9ro - Oep«2odpo<-y school
    '

    has aoaueed -the Klotqr© of state vo At-o0d<£i .


    XCr'4
    \ QDTOQ of the basic concepts actool : t
    S3
    of Ospeodeoy
    --' A
    '
    (?) CblooiQ i i ©ro has ended ooty io fc«rroa \ <3Gose - G
    . •*

    -
    (??)iMeo CtMO'OC} \ isro r ©0 d^DpO rO iSrO is COoVi<Oulo .
    ^
    @

    ;
    - m Chloobiie^o is a fheooroeoa ^ '
    oseodated otvb capHpusro- ^
    £3
    I oqptau's^o has heonoe <«o^d eysteno - 'SKate '& •
    1 » v

    •
    A
    --I
    _

    ^
    ( states cao be divided ioto 03^9 slaves S pori'phe ies
    (v)j Since the adgio of copilot isno cores
    bcwegc interIioved.
    *
    peripheries
    ©
    (B

    <S
    -V fVcspedty QV the coes has its 'soofe, io -the pavedg §. ©
    The. pen pbehi •

    ^ tlh
    @ 9 e IS ao ooepoai 2xcbapgg,
    dQv-eicpe^oert.-
    < tdoicb nroscn-te iovo boeyeo
    /
    ©
    ©
    r- t
    A ropot of uodeydeye| ©
    demlopeoceot of (<S5P § tho d^yetope- - a
    :l
    -. i
    . op roGrsl of peripheries -
    Those countries co'oicb cpr<s. noose ©
    closely associated Abitb
    the coise countries • -<©Vbes-e tuahoo Is coarse • m '

    ^
    UccDTsdio to -theseVscboiaas the #
    fi ^ otetes or citeohist-
    pse puppet
    stave? io these counties
    tsegiroe O-ibe Suudi ©
    ,
    1 ':
    M
    fabnrenj The states ?o -these Cbuotdes o^e. 4be vnevzru
    I roeots of Mebo poiftao Gourgeotbe. -
    :>•

    f
    iV
    a ©
    @

    ©
    •
    ::1
    s
    ?/3
    S©3 •

    ::!
    *
    @
    - .- i
    ;: 1
    '1
    • #
    K !
    m
    i
    !
    '
    \ / of CNG^
    UTqi sctooo
    •

    SJEE® 1 gp ^
    -X-J
    •
    /.
    S © The Tbecy*9 of QN/ * o^
    rove aoped swve « 3'^ °b
    a scholav Ho^nza A ^'
    1o Tbocgb -ibfoxj feaboaV '
    bOQWe of
    iofhws-tao BdV
    ^
    S - A£va SVQ-VPQ Eh
    .
    I© icnble io case of oideif
    M if is afeo Qppi
    1 ©
    .vS
    »o SXodi'Q, Goog\ad9sb
    Accord' Ogto t-fjro zq Aiacoi , The fci-HA^e of 4be state to
    ' .

    fb^tetao needs ooo*e deeper <AcP* yeJs -Uxso + ,© ^


    © b in sofpS '

    I GS&-
    © dtaiisis approachTJt CQ\ \ ] be. ioa\=>p*oprafcrt© f -DeSP33 4fxs
    '
    a
    a^
    © -fbcf 4be State \o RaAisVaovs jaSt 00 XnSVnra'rO'^cf of
    5
    1 ©
    : oqpltaiigis ciaes of ayse couobtes -
    i
    © Harozci- yyacOif bos qppited db£ i^suct-aacu iSts J retafrce
    - p cxuio -
    -
    ; .K
    £
    - ©
    -
    : fc
    autononpy -theory (o case of R» \cfeVao - <evoo wsbi
    ncpy fbecm-j o@eds roodtif oqPoo -
    .
    ^
    ©
    QQiieov- poiots of bis -Vbecny of
    © overdavedoped e\Q-\ e -

    Xk is cjcwoog -to Qppty foe scinoe coooepts


    1© .
    faraoa ysts cf '
    I©
    dbe oatq
    *© of She state <o case of post coiaoiai soa'eti*® ,
    [ ccbicb is applied to cqse of «oesteno couobdgs -
    4 ©
    :C
    copy ? - V
    :l © These is difference is
    diqtcmcqi cqodittoos -
    *i O aate 6 coPStero couches is QO rSV uro -QO -
    : ©
    pi1 slate ' \ ^ ' °f ^bs capita
    &
    :>
    1 © ' ^ to
    class •

    fcst
    cDiooiQ ) coLiofsiics is ocf oo losburjent- of 4fo,
    i o liodegeoous cqptaiiQf class . s\qte adaaily radiates Oroorx
    ^
    t
    O Hfe 3 Gcro Gk^ ' O
    ) dosses -
    i
    ! ©
    t © Metro - ^
    poiftao Bou3fg-goise .
    1© l(S) Ind geoCMs Bourgeois©
    #
    ^
    © Ibdegeoous feudal :
    class - i
    © 1l
    i

    1
    © 5
    t

    j
    1
    © 1
    L
    1 @ t
    i
    1 ©
    ; !

    ©
    I |

    ©
    1
    m I
    s
    55 © s
    l
    is ©
    "

    s5S5^^vA,aw^
    ^^
    4s3gsssgE '
    0
    gHttefOns cs^hicb psevtjfMoo| ooav^ps e
    .
    rc
    Tb©
    " SpPO' pC
    55:
    potegr-fta does -
    State -tee TVJOSV ©
    5
    :1
    T
    Restate to oecte do -Vhe
    fbvTstao cocoes of Booa- idea ) ©
    AtQcOi , fb ki'stao
    pa-tf -H’GSV ©tote To teta teorcb of Ha^o-GO
    id!
    tai
    m
    • © •

    v;
    •

    va
    ;$ 4 MI iftavy -
    GureauGfQHc o aKChcj . |fie . eovfise potoev
    *
    ’
    ^The baods op -tee ^ eaji-
    ©
    1 to fdtesvao negotiated «o
    :1-
    ‘
    :
    . I
    is
    ^ 0
    five doss - ©
    tfie Skjdy of ^o Aiatei belonged ta f£v F^0r° bis
    Ha «no
    ©
    :
    i pesspea-iv© The oolite of -ta© state to Thdia does oov ©
    :.-1
    •

    m *
    I differ rojeb ocoept -teat -tee 7rcAgof tPiiHaisy te -Todfa
    «

    1 I fs not ' te 4tea4- op pbbstao - ©


    r~
    vv
    ta
    -- '
    petes SS'-HJQ WOOS to coiooa ) couo-vuies <d M4£ -po«o
    '

    VbQt of coo voro coaoteies ?


    * ©
    <

    3
    •
    ^ ©
    S
    :?
    •
    te
    :
    ?<: < 3 state ro tespsteso aouoteies Ccopiteiisvstate) (so natesoi
    gYotote - test-te -tee iriseof foasgeaise1 cbes te© / have caev- ©
    ted te>Q SLpteco of state • ’Pules pcos § ^ta-tacta -bes accord- • ©
    hoo) +o Their ooovi oieoeg •
    "
    ^
    ©
    \
    © lap
    -:
    Slate io post coiootai societies is ao l«3p01stec) \ OSVi-kiTtt)C) . 0
    : - l
    i bos oot been ccsooted by -tee todegenoMb Socpgeoiss e
    i Cbss- KOtegy it bog bgetl CtrgqVcd ^
    , .

    « by -tee catadav roasters - 3


    }
    ffeocp Oates »o These coaotaigs
    :
    :I
    V
    /
    Vx2Ms beso areated p5>r e>
    gesv’fog -the lot©nggt
    -;d
    '
    ;
    5
    .
    of po ooeteO poittao Bourgeois© •'
    G
    dM
    m WfoCM s foG MoeaoiOq
    - ( -
    : i
    . -i
    •
    --
    i of Ovierctavg-bffci C 0
    To GrO Co CJObn' gs TbPsevs a pe
    •
    ^ feef coograooe
    !Vi betesoeo ©COOOrose S, pOiitrica !
    sgStero- OOOQ PCOOCK-OI' C
    Gi
    \
    V OYSTERO betQoos> oood ©so Ccppi-toiiStJ eta-ognH
    K
    rt -
    3t5uckxte Qteo changed acco?tatog\
    Of eopor-
    V? y f -e - Mtade^o taa-Vi'on ©
    Slave canoe sob -etasteoce. •
    i O1
    . w

    '
    t ©
    ::
    :c-
    ©
    eo
    ©
    v
    ©
    i •
    V:i
    ©
    '
    #
    ©:i
    ::G ©
    I
    tai ©
    :V:i

    @
    c©.- ----
    s«
    3
    ••
    COlOOlQl O OCidffQJ'
    Xo coso Op ^
    roQKb society - ^ ed -Hradl f -W Ones ) ,CBI OOlQI 0002*0:
    eroQ i O
    *

    1- ©
    -• 3
    ta
    '
    tJO
    ^
    | hciv/e lObotk-togd ftacdesO ftlitfcql SySteoo-
    HGOcp Atese fsc
    1 ©
    \

    rote vcb b/co O0& Op pocyoo^'se developeroeot- oa- deste -


    1
    ;
    »
    M © ^
    \opetoGov op sode 4- -foe. 'sta e °P developsseenV op pb
    :sf
    £
    CC3
    : tS
    *
    .
    © (Vcq ! system
    Xn q^no soo do
    ^
    ^ ^ %pieta state Cs
    .«

    1
    I © csv/ercie/Qbped . cQ! fon ^
    I©
    •

    © AR^r todepeodeoce, ta <? divscot -


    cooteoi op . wete- jportoo
    rI
    :«
    • •

    ^cxx ^
    •topopnce
    orse
    - Ibe State fo
    baq
    eoded buV odtaecpy Abey cboboue/ta
    '
    . .

    "

    a ?• .

    ©
    jaro noav r anoor s becomes am sqoHbW- (

    si
    1 © ^ classes'
    ^
    |tAatave op overdgv/
    I£ © elcpcd Sta-Pp -
    (T\ovev
    e
    1© detebped £\ete cbroes OQOTT -to \ ' taoapa*P sV Plata - ,

    si
    I © pT) catabai Igqa
    -l ©
    ?dI
    r
    '
    ^
    1 psotedKao op
    ^
    i co\obot Mag is bov<o orealed Gvbrer-oek) pocopr-pA \
    •

    state pbr
    o

    © xbeir co\ooiai iotetesv OTfpcia


    ! \cOroUO\ -faJ
    ^s enjoyed (oVo ©
    .:

    1
    f,
    I ©
    i«“ ‘
    -
    ‘ TtaiteOotarteoucd
    A eter> cxflex (ode peodeoce . E~ - Cp
    :‘

    ©
    S
    OpTacO Secrets p Tod ra
    : ?:
    fi
    Ad cooPtnued, f veo©ve
    -
    de-tao-Poo Oav ©
    ^
    •

    ?
    •
    bcqo roode
    $
    . . ©
    a ptfo/islo’o \0 4b©
    i"*
    i

    - v£ ' (§) legacy op toosH -taboo -


    :
    •
    f © NaViooa! !^a/GroeoV
    \
    •
    t
    1 Ibe poitaocrt
    $
    Q pQ*-H} -oWch plcxyed pYotaoeob TSO\G ta Abe.
    :-
    c vJaA-iooa )
    ' ^ ‘
    MoveroerA COPOG -VO aioqulte
    I © \ odepeodGoce
    • d? Gy poite'cni pooer opqr
    r
    'r
    ©> people ,
    ^ eq)oy lot op leyiteoacy To
    |
    :
    •
    5
    bcmJi y Ads byes op
    : r :\ doo ^ PdbG |SG
    i ©
    :s
    jf lead TO - pqoeSbbo roost. oo 4de teteo -
    1I ©
    1s
    I
    ©
    dGVfOiop^ro^r - toh coas adopted 10 ta Os&
    ^ esoa^ . * (

    I s °P
    ^
    ^ YCGs io dte bcvods op Aba .

    4
    %
    5.
    P.
    t-
    G)
    Vb©- state - ibMs
    •

    \o itself
    ^
    ^rtber QVzsGpyVbeoed dbe posl-woQ op
    ^taQrgpd Abe oocsv pocoe&Pq i class ’

    I% ©
    I5 G
    5y
    i
    £
    © i.
    i

    I£ ©
    c
    ’
    5
    t
    © l
    :
    '
    5
    2
    ©
    i
    *
    \
    f

    5
    l ©
    0 toV\CLYe. M
    |3
    ^ -ftei
    %
    q< pcpv\i 5
    ^
    U V
    ^
    I 3 -T-'KSS
    i DEOLOQ-V
    c5S
    i
    1ci iV
    GOMC£ pr of povJe R ,erciEMa ^v Y -
    "- A

    At

    :
    m -
    I m
    cc .

    &
    Vi
    S 4bG C OVttl\ COO c^epv of pon
    Pcol QCSQO' CQ
    pXO0T \

    SAotoQ/ Qr nve ail concepts po^oer wroaVos: <£ oYe&Ve d


    w
    cr~ > >
    ; •

    ©
    CDoCppt Oif rpot SCJH>O\QXS V>CXMQ loot c) aV poco r \ 0 Ok ^
    •

    vj

    1
    *

    different aocw -
    ^ ^ §

    A COQVeOtbOa ) V»QtO Of PocQgr -- /CPS

    Ch conveo-H'ooal sense po ^oe 6


    * ' coosidesetl os doroioaKon . ©
    fcl
    ”3
    Accenting bo PobeA DabcO, fb«oer \S a TrelaPooat Concept
    - •
    ©
    .-‘
    V
    IS 4be ob \ \ (ty to get 4b\ ogs done by toe otbe)re
    Even qyoiosv -vbe T ooisto - POCOQ
    ^ CDosdered as coexsJve
    ' -
    pi natuse ti ^ * ©

    HOP - CQn^eotOnQ ) -Vi'gco of PocQcy- . - •


    '

    ;
    l taooab AiTPncW has igWeo
    *

    -
    r£
    =£ ooo- conventional ) vieo op ©
    £ political pocoer - Acco-sd (
    03 to H . A*endt > poUHcdl pacoer ©
    doea
    , noi toeao aversion it 'sutbev- Deans 5
    LV Iroeot • " **}pOcO
    © <
    -> SVQVQO Lutes give
    .!
    | 3 dvtoensiooai vi
    v / e^o op pocoes
    ''
    • fe
    Of Pc
    ocoeg- fo pgrrocs\ sense -(ofRce)- ( ox - coebeir:s
    *^ \iieo ioeberiag) '

    CD (btoer as
    • i
    ;•
    : < agenda eeltiog Cwatxfet vteo) ©
    VI
    :•
    \
    (m) -
    fbcoer as tooughV cbnVsc! process - ( £eraor>sa'ao vieo) 0
    Vj "

    •- ?
    IbeODriGS Of RjcoOr ©
    I
    (T)IP''ttsV TbpOKj m
    .
    m
    ::
    (5)| pica a 1 isv Tbeoy / V*

    3
    ®>) tbcwxigt Ibeog <y
    cksJ
    • V!
    ;
    <g G
    ^ arosaa . tfoeay 0
    ;
    T:1
    gl ideberiao Theory to
    : ® Atf-eodtiao Tbeay e
    fbs*- Madoro Tftecny (;Michel
    1

    ::c _- fccQUit)
    vv f-OM (toulf
    x »,-,
    ©
    .* ©
    ©
    v '.

    r~:=

    -
    ©
    %

    .•?}
    T
    %

    V;-
    1
    ~ rs.
    0

    • va
    ; ose of dbe TbeoVies
    '

    i©
    beo'Ans of poc£X^ r soggesfe
    locahoo of poeoec •

    1 t)
    i*2

    i8 ©
    '
    3
    .
    '

    ^
    (T) Elitisf Theory of fecogr <

    -4- Oldeg\
    3
    ia © fbeovg .
    Wes eottb 4*^ o\ <fss -
    ;
    According -to
    •

    %3 ©
    v
    eii -tigr foeop) , pocoer
    . Jfi
    :.:S
    © oobo Q179 elites r *
    V?.
    :'d
    © Human po pula Woo coo be divided into -
    ,

    1©
    :"d
    © £ t ?fc?s
    . 35
    ® Masses •

    3 = © t

    VS fitte is a ©psa ai class \ e- McW a cwdioQirg.


    '
    ,

    : ©
    S3
    •

    ! -

    arse spend ) goatf -b’ es Obich OOQte Cl pe sSOO GJ‘te


    5
    1 i:< ^
    ::¥
    :c-
    -c 0
    According fo Pblo § Atffeto+le. , Reason ?- Ou*aqe esse 4he (
    CiS
    quaif -tfes
    of 4be 'sdnog eiqss or Mashers - ^
    s ©
    <
    A'
    According ho Macbiav/ehi» , fVioce bos -to be For %- UoO -
    ©
    -
    I© P^ f^ -
    y of poooer has teeo gweo by r-tatiao scholar
    !
    • Rq -irefo -
    if.1 © Sau'eoh polohs of ptnGbOs hb<sory
    ?!
    -:I
    '
    ©
    ? Boob - Mfod §- society '.
    ?
    1t e According fe Abo History of Mankind is oovbiog
    f
    !: © bnt graveyard of
    c Aristocracy .
    > O 3n every socien
    I
    ©
    f
    \e FOXGS ?- Uoos .
    *

    io oa +arrs %y pocoer -
    ^
    boy© been Hoo Apes

    '
    of QJ AS
    Acco-sd ng ho pareto r Hrshory iS Cyclical

    ^
    5:
    |© fiocos to a. closed loop . 73* \S Do
    ’hrickie docOo effect-
    £
    f --.
    IS. © /C
    of pocoer- Ibis Abeovy is koodoo as
    jdbeo^ g of
    '

    : J'
    I #
    cir cqia ^r-foo of elites - blibsf 4beo*y of pocoer iS ;

    * Hbe basis -far eWtiSh Atoeosy of democracy -


    © According +0 3£AAtSfr TbGorg of Qgrooaracy , pa ^oer uo'Af ;
    =;

    !l © Masses is a Mg -tb Masses do noV have capacity do bold i


    1

    •
    <
    fg. I potoer err exercise pocoeir The oo\y ?toe roaesos coo play
    *
    1
    1© -
    I - -
    IS dbg Gled vOo of GAvtes 13- is safpeionh -fAr do coo ora.eg - ?.
    !
    £
    i
    i
    &
    m <
    V

    1© |
    0

    1 © h
    i:
    I c
    E

    1I © 1:
    |
    5
    ? r.
    8 © I:
    t
    ’

    \
    S
    ?t;
    6
    6 |j
    /pritAbC
    --
    :-0r >v
    si
    --, elites MDi4b # •

    S3 1
    \heor\% s of demnoaray Gfcropatei <
    S
    •
    S
    ? | '

    leadership - 'Dptoocvaccj is not locbropabbie


    fa
    -
    Vv '

    leaders •
    ©
    - 1 rdosca
    m > ? ©
    Boob - Pa Vog cioss
    '
    jbe
    made +be di{Fhreoce be> <-oeeo Vbe 9QV^°' P3
    ©
    ^
    T OSCQ ,
    ©
    :• 1 Class 4fos governed class - According Vo Moscq , only
    %
    -i
    elites enjoy po coeir - There i’sa difference ( o fbreVo \
    ' ©
    MostD. - According +0 'RatfigV©, Qeiog eARe is a ©
    1
    .
    r
    qoaifty us'oQfGas QCCOTdfng Vo Masco io decoocsavic
    ral
    ^ ©
    societies obi ifty -to aigaoise masses rnabs person 91 Re -
    _
    1bM5 4be svo+os oF elRe depends opoo oKganiectboryap,
    JJG
    ©
    ©
    j
    #
    C.‘.
    J to Poborf Mrebels
    ;:i;
    Soot - ^ Fbn -tical pbr -Fes’ ©
    '
    v9
    pobe&V M'’cbe\s basie Weo < r'Troo taco oF 01 ©
    vgaveby .
    .
    rv 3
    ,

    0 ©
    Idbethef a cbcjcJnrt) is doroocra -vic nr eacatoaois* potoec
    -
    cMcoavjs gev concern saved io fbQ bands oF small ©ecHoo
    _ «>
    :© •

    i
    *
    ov eiRes • weocc, a' \ga.rcbq is -the Xroo VQ ©
    :
    • ?

    1
    Fdoert Michels analyse fhe rovare op socialist pof -Kcai ©
    M pavHes - HQ found -Vbav dbese is no diR sooce in The enorh-
    n•

    •
    t
    r
    ( og opsoabto ^
    Bouryeafee / atoo ! partes - ©0
    0
    parties
    ^
    : .}
    ?. J
    ©
    .>
    ©i dcHa pQr-Hes pocOQir gets OaoceoHsaVed A
    •
    :?
    '

    ,-i
    :: i foyroood A’oOto- ©
    Accordiog Vn V»ro , pocoor annoys lies <udi 4to 4OQ e$R<p asbeito m
    .
    • .1
    I
    v. i
    :
    it <s octansV country or Libera ) cauototp 'fet literal COUCH Qy
    ;©1i
    .
    •*'

    r: i
    -pries ^are roore derooaraHc
    vdao ^socialist counties - Pecao- * •/

    i •
    SC io soda to
    <
    countries nooaoiHtafc 9\Re exists £One pavfy •

    : V.i
    Sgsvero) Hence people do oof baqe cboiCO ubbere
    io
    lateral CDUOtries el Re gjtsucf use ie Atotouveci • (to noeaos © ^
    Ocisvenoe oF Muib’pe pa^-b £Q ) Heoce people can noaba ©
    .r-% eboice arocog ei'-tes
    ©
    *

    m
    ©
    ©
    •»
    ’
    * •
    *
    \ @
    w:
    N: /

    yZ <
    ©
    #
    @
    1
    ScbQrO
    !
    - I

    M
    m y\otoooy OQcQns
    Model op Darooaracy ov fe,00 _
    : $

    bavagWer, Mcwtef
    r"

    .2c
    '
    •
    . >i % IT**' ?/
    Theory of Ogroocsaty.
    'C

    I0 roic
    . Xi
    ».
    CeroocSQcy is lit© Matfkef fen +tOiaos cx*Q RsfiHca? )
    :|
    > 5*
    m Entire.pse rxi-ess , Vof©lsS Qr© tooSMfoerS Tbe only aroV©
    > •
    %
    %% ® voters GOO p(a is -toe seiecHoo of eifi<Ps Heoce, p°<
    i©
    i,

    PQS tOfto -to © ©4He.S^ •


    < : i
    •
    ^
    0
    •
    •
    ?. . V» •
    -

    •
    t'

    Kc f' ;
    v
    — > C btopht M1) )s
    ''
    £
    V . M© ho5 given toe coocQpt or po^petf reitftae * 3<~> coo-toxx '

    i-5 io
    •
    .

    cf- USA AccoYciiog +o b’ to), pocosjrio GSA lies ‘-OM-Vx too.


    •
    1© :c
    SPGh'oo of <oK4©s ectooro be cob Cf5 pcxoer GiTtoa
    1

    •
    :c
    «; ©
    .

    3 £o USA PsAesat pO
    c
    ; ®
    r.
    IViCibios, COSpanfate CS1aj) Maases
    '
    •

    v. Officials of MiHfQsy -
    ! t>
    X

    USA a$e laypo by poto>ex


    flYTO potoor optes - /MV decisions :o
    1© _
    eftes »g 4b0 s- otoo ibtoxes-:t
    ::ic AfCOnsd( O0 -tQ o \*hr*gh\
    ;2

    borob coas 4ai<oo fey to©


    Mills, 4b© dpctefoo 4c> cbop Autotone
    \
    . :.
    a poster ejf-tes •
    >
    st 0 10 toae ©of aiociys [Qcxd
    &
    by poco©ir eTf ' 4©S \ 0 -to© lo gi-
    I ©
    ?:
    joni03 os A <:oos rocra© ctotoacxo
    iotpisDQl one' lit © Cjvil He Vfe> to ©yer / b© co. c>Ge ef ^
    I © s y » uoay s, \oas© ©tog we
    5
    c
    .v
    . *4'
    e •O iOfPJfOa -h'OOQ) pot ipcs -toe ito po'ifa apooe of -toese
    of os/\
    classes h>ave toorpaepdl .
    ©
    Mb o QVQ poua x ei tSS ? -

    o ^ '
    to e <5vj Society 4b©»2 to>ay
    ^
    • V
    1
    . ; © be scto)© psy \oS4i4uHoos av
    orgaosawoos Persons boidiog fop
    •
    10 posi+ions 10 tosse
    (OSVrtofioes Or OTr Qoiscifi'
    oos
    : >:
    ^ poc e)^tes
    • ;
    • •

    -. ©
    •
    V
    : >:
    I
    1

    X 0
    :T
    >

    ;,* © 1
    >•
    ;
    0 ;
    A

    \>v
    :
    <Q i
    1 \r
    1© .
    •
    >

    ?
    IQ
    1;
    I
    t t
    ;

    If 8r

    ?r r
    o
    *
    \
    ;-
    v
    >: f.

    "
    *
    4k
    rS
    © i:
    5

    1a
    '
    *
    V

    >;
    6

    1
    B
    s> :

    I© >: ^ ^ ^^ ^
    scggggg gggwwgge :.>>;- SSSS
    • «
    3§
    «
    •
    , Scholar
    (2|
    0.-
    \? r r

    r-
    ^ cn is -duRobP * V Oohai
    +, tod ' *»*> aovp«
    4 S, he has changed toe ©
    obeesva^oo op C vhrtgv* M «5 «*» wapW to hooray >
    qSA ^
    •
    ©5
    A
    •

    bl
    vo
    (O - VS *009 -Vo say AbQV USA Vs ao olicjA*cby
    pt 03 <
    < .

    Oo@ Abe abbey hood , OsA 5


    ' po'ya^rchy - >•

    a
    4 uo’nat is fbjyaTchy ? f £?J

    ?ofc
    ^^
    cnfdtoa
    Cobai has conduct -Reid suwsys o od oavobe
    -sLj people o us A eo)oy pocopjf Ha^-p^
    ( / buod hai- ^ . 4
    ©
    @
    &
    & o*d oa*y peopled epjoy p ae but not os ao tod ividuaI
    < ©
    ©
    •

    but -Vbe - -ober


    t oet ^po*Viculat assoaaHoo - ' ' GV
    ©
    uotespst ajtfoop Tbe e VS
    . ^ & f aQive t'OtO SV ops°ub poi -
    65

    ^pstobby -Vdj^ r *
    b’cs #
    VOOSA Abese ro\ •
    cjsoo of Ahs
    VotexPst op AbeW VvDerobgjfs ideo , tt fs @
    U - 035009 Ho say ^ 0
    dbat Abe dvSVsibcxPfoO p^cp pooCjQr io’uSA is Voo msyoca '

    »;
    -
    50 OS’d Accord ?og Vo b TX Q£ ocdiocpy
    do Gp)oy poioes- io day Vocby
    - ^
    persons \q GSA ©
    ©
    Decisions
    affbixs of Abed* life
    oas auAtno'ic booob & oe>t os uias day -fb - 0
    ^
    day cdeeisioo - Thus USA & c ~. ^
    * ^-
    * . xQ\
    bG Abao 0!y ©
    aYCby. (bcoQK VS oof io Abe baods op - co OCA* \Q Abe '

    I
    Hoods Op call but \o Abe hoods op POQOLJ.
    tefotnoedS feyQTCby
    ^ " ©
    0
    ( P.

    pob@d Pofooi bos rocdi -Oed bis vie^s eo^sife^ He ©


    beUpvpd Aba A an -p » gifocDps \ 0 OsA ap)oy alroa2A <=3siJcd
    ^
    -

    .vt
    '

    >.h
    pocooss but bfsr oo be acboitted Abot on prepays cpoops
    ©
    <v
    A:0
    ©
    do oot bas/e epoai pcx^ooss - Cbrpomto gtroaps bcMo <toOws
    i
    ©
    pecOQr Abac ©Ab©r- ©bug pcAyascby vs de-Acwro©j ovAA \ Va§ - v

    ©A
    AjouDards Abe corporate pproop ©•

    ©
    .*::i #
    --
    m . ©
    m
    n i?
    ©
    ] © •

    \
    m
    i
    • #
    :S
    V:<
    ©
    ©
    KJ
    :o
    iA
    5>

    11
    0
    ->
    ow b -Wx?
    m
    as coei os eSfHfei-
    '

    i ©
    : :ai VKS vf^o ODCO S
    ^
    .< -IT ) tbpob GS op p&eoe ^
    igctave 36
    |3o|oi Y
    .

    1 •

    2.01
    -s ©
    Oi -p '- ^xxs+s
    3 '
    eoce. b/co
    ^ P\TO » ia\s §
    ;o

    ^ t QO'
    '

    a ©
    Accost iog to t ocisls , toose coho C\to -eGOOO^O CDU doroi -
    1 . J>
    *

    :cS

    ^
    \
    •vsi
    1©
    aH ©
    ^
    nool -bbsj torytso) all eletoearts °p scp?tfehrudiuYe -
    ;
    >

    ;
    !
    t
    $
    8 ©
    (
    ' -
    Accord 'eg to tApo p toatisto, fcerpoYCi ^s h>aos?5 hew© voPlu^
    Qdsioo toafcjco) to ? (boorx>tc. sptoire A* -
    « ©

    J3 ©
    ote Vo Abe
    ^ a \ sphere
    do och dvcktto i .
    •
    -3 i
    % ©
    ;
    1
    .
    3
    !3 ©
    .
    ©|I^QXKVSV :
    of feeoer v >

    '

    .-£ '

    ; ¥
    1

    I ©
    V5

    l
    @\
    I
    s toop-stj op PQOQPV
    pocOpY -
    -
    i © -v
    1
    v ©
    '

    ©j
    I A& n6 hQ o ibgcmj
    ••

    pyoe
    c Q
    of
    I1 © j she "xitps di-ffeooce b) <o pooos , vJioieocp, P rer H-
    .
    I ©
    i:
    v > e
    I ^ hasaoayspd pouPoal pocoQS - ffei . pocOQc belongs
    - ^ +o ^
    *t ©
    ; Civil QDciQbj QGpO > 0 Oooce t cQ°rtb CQCbctoPS .
    ^
    ^
    '
    .
    * ©
    I5 Acco-sdiog to b02r, pocoeri s oov ac> 'O2\ 2sooo
    ©
    Hfo© TSVQ\ pOcoejr xQ ibe potoeir e> p
    ^>
    ^- 0p Coete

    o t
    -ibo
    <

    •
    5- ©
    • i ©
    2
    l
    I ©
    I-
    :: ic-
    3
    ©
    In
    *
    ©
    1$x ©
    1©
    *©
    1. x !
    >
    !© S:
    ;
    i

    !K © :

    <.
    % ©
    £
    t
    1e m
    5
    E -L
    £
    5
    S
    $
    i
    © ir
    ;
    c
    r
    |
    ‘

    8
    l-
    i i
    i ! I
    5 A
    5
    -
    «5S3S3SS>£3>:*t : I
    Micbe! Fbcoult '
    • II
    m B2 &ai± yJ
    *r-.
    /
    <r >

    ms Q \S O
    9
    £5
    . vs
    :h3 ft
    I
    XVI
    a D
    23
    •

    1
    :>1
    f
    .
    '
    O J“be
    fbsro of
    • nptaoosf Of Cap'll )oh PS *
    . :i
    l

    •; Ibhoduc-l-ioo m
    •
    •• !
    ,
    RDCJCOUJ VS oons de©das ooeof Jb® gsrcitpst iO © M©ckial
    * of M
    '
    our tiroes - foucoult axis no\- ooy ao be «eos
    i
    -!

    0190 QO activist ftocjcrvuti eCE& tOiVIO'ly associated sOtb ttxs


    '
    ictst eekjal &
    •isy

    v
    v
    ?:
    keft coOTTOOf He
    .

    ,
    f*-w - Rx «jdt & bc ladies LiogjigUcs
    citedpi 1 offs Q \so*
    U9QS ososesscyof Ps/ OlOg

    . fojca H: aDas vofiOGOoed


    '
    , Tfeoo ocs 4
    PbittO- 41

    N iGtsiSche.
    ^
    * ^
    -
    V.
    V. ^ #
    ( es- zechQ caas czrtfic Of eowQbterx-oent enJppveooooof has
    -
    I
    . • * >1
    ^
    pc "erQsu 1 ted fo ^o - %iQ&ckyro of <-oao - Ehtf i'Qf OCGLO
    5 "

    ^ ' ^
    vv

    coot^oi I^C) by TrOii ioo - r0\ OtQ ^oao >’5 obo bred te?c5 ky aefonco . ©
    |0uot sche b0d Jtoav q© <d
    ^ ^ '-Sthedead
    • ACCcndt -
    oj -to KD (eh2£&bp ©
    ;
    r
    i nobody cao cJa ^o Vo -veil - *Vsutb, -vbeoste crae Just
    perceptions KJ© TsepoiK© -to uodeirSJqod 4b©
    •
    ©
    4b$ ogs f^om
    :;
    .l
    ©
    rr-pi-b'pie point of -oiocos -
    :!
    has gWeo tbo concept of -the corn Jo >
    (jOiehcScboJ . idi pocoe^ IQods Jo uzrn foxioer
    " Jo f? S
    •
    vi ,
    4o
    hnncOGdgio
    is pocop;r. -
    ~' .
    eMs

    Foucouxt aoqs fo-ftueoeod by OieWcbeb ©


    >
    ^
    ^
    boot ixleo
    ' eoeOlogy of Morals 5. MiQh^scbe bo aoa yaed 4 Q ©
    “

    ^ ©
    "
    !
    ,V.i
    Vi
    •
    ovlgio of Mora i ?4y . ^ ^ ©
    i
    V .'
    f -letbodaoq,,
    oF _
    -l
    •

    foucaott called his Metbadoicey as ,


    m
    &
    arcbao&QQ/ utod /
    ’- X_ y

    ^
    2oeoto y .
    -4J kJbat is
    0 '
    ©
    Archaeology
    -
    %
    Acccnrdi ng io foucaa If ft # S
    | Speojf' c roetboj study
    '- V
    rVV
    history io -terncs Jh© evoius -b'oo of hno system.
    ?h
    ©
    e&,

    ©
    ivJ ©
    #
    1
    #
    @
    k ':i
    i v<> .
    :vj
    QeneofooH ?
    :c& “ '

    T
    *
    ‘

    ^
    3 © wlbctf
    +be S^cAy op
    •

    2S
    3
    An^-dfOg fo fociCQu > + , ? neaio9|
    ^
    "

    .. e • v
    1 fe)
    1; ^
    :2
    jpgpaeol: MfGtovtj. Oeofaiog */ t's bodgvsAaoc rg oocOeige
    pocopv Connpc
    ^ ^
    is
    3
    3
    -i ©
    PbaCQUltS
    ^ rho .
    Wtoyfc
    1 ^
    © © Kladovs § cK/i « isa+ioo
    1^ © 8' ^fb of Q G) ioi’c
    £
    OiSci pi > Op % fUni O
    i ©
    3
    *53
    :Fc © History opse*$ucn;ty ^ •

    —^
    'X

    ©
    ::
    £
    i ©
    £
    FbaccxaH
    1
    ^ of pocO0r (g 0'ivpr) fevo bis boot. -
    Di’sci pi » oe
    J @CT %
    y op Poofs h ** lb u odgsskiod bvs
    -
    •

    , -
    -t
    $
    if: 0
    i
    ii ^ * pocoey >e have do uod do
    cnrx^pte of fbo ^uit ^sstesod -PiVlo' og
    t
    -
    ^ -
    *

    f ©
    :
    3
    :*
    fse
    si
    w ® Discourse -
    • r

    Discourse iS dbg ^coy of dei iogi Abe reaitSy Yu b


    l- G) ' + -e 4bo.o
    ••

    ? denTo rg-goif +y • *
    >5

    I©
    I0 ^ -
    age
    t? cf -. Xr> M-edr cvai -Hroe f-d
    has Hs o« >o discoavs ©
    ooas Vbe. discourse of -dfo©.
    •

    cbdddiao ty cobcb shaped OUT uode>ssdoobiooj


    '
    1
    '

    !0 -Brogs ft Cs -dbs cisJscourse op of waotirt-u.


    :w
    :
    ^b soTeooe ^ob'cb
    •

    K
    shapes OUY pesrepVfosQ op \ bg . &aeoa& has became
    :P bT besV discourse Accord
    ^ -fog Bo Pacjcauif , S bA oover
    L
    o - GPC dh© a.bsO ude -dsUrdb - If fs 'i poosi bg -VCOQCJO -vba
    ^ '
    U \t' COa -H? drurdb XbQHocid op OV^
    - ^ Voe Toeodfocxs, ^
    c
    ^ -
    y.

    i d!coa h sudh
    * Q

    ^qgirogs of -hs-udb . 3b bi9 boots »{ fc© Mad) r*oSs £ cjv'Hi


    :c
    X
    l 0
    i*. >
    .)
    ’
    Hoo , Ghr+bopa 0\ oic, 0\ 3cJpl \ oQ §
    - Puoi , M steny of . ^
    ^
    /• !*»
    '
    •
    •
    ? Gy
    :
    • Se^ua u +y be. bets
    UppA £d Qrcbogoiogy § Qsuoeo (
    I© Ois acsgs SbQpee, -be t' . CD0g
    £
    I
    t
    ©
    ^'2
    ®ohate b/ u©
    ros
    ^ £ nDora i ?dy . vO o coe
    a ^ad §, IBOSTOQI
    p^ oo tt ts ood dbof ^
    ^
    ^ ^
    i'
    Q c eL £
    bad
    10 rt^e°coay
    !
    5
    ? ^ fe roebopss § . is oarroar padbgv >

    I© M\Qc3 O0S
    ^ e^plcuoed )
    !
    i
    II
    1: © !I

    Iv
    ?

    ;•:
    ?.
    !
    :

    ic e ;
    *
    i

    !e
    I
    l
    v
    ft si
    £t
    -
    !:
    c-
    e [
    I
    i

    S
    -
    ::
    >: t rr
    1

    t. 0
    9 ^
    ?:
    I0 .
    If _ us
    ;

    ;
    (
    __ 3SfPKe«?55 1;
    p coqsses
    ^ dtete5 o^o© 4be ^dode
    . ^PtOaf - . . f
    :m
    ^^^taVOd ?OC|
    Itaoty 'OUV MOci CiiSQ
    i io <syf
    1
    -*

    ^
    fbUCQU bos d ^elOpQ biS s/ eOG OO pQe^SS V> bis book
    ^ ? ^ ^
    ch’sdpifoe aod paofsb p°b isbed \ Q
    be> b) os sbocob kno^O*© © pocOPV oc^npoboo -
    ' DOafc~
    & ^ '
    ^
    c:
    :1
    :d

    poop
    i"d

    ] fbocouit has QWPO -ffoe coocep\s > V© djgcipUoQ&y V


    '
    "
    v*
    7
    v.H
    i
    QovpKnnooQio i -y a -od Biopotopr. Hekos gWpo Vbe.
    ' ' -
    i Ot^ rcplp op +be «fe£ s-teoo op poaibb roeoV
    ^
    < OGS
    ^ -
    1
    •'• ps© VQi )ook io SktfSffeiT -Vicoes - 'pS. SpSfeoQ of pcra'SbrysQDf
    oas asdurous. Q- "©bu 'rocs'o - Accas-cK op do ov©q 4 0. ^
    ^
    '!

    .
    rc
    %
    & pcbpose op pu ofev>>oS?ot
    '
    ©of josi puoisb -Vbe
    ©
    <X3jn3rg ©d SQ -&T . IT Or 4o TrefeiffO +toe toisoo | c o0r . Do -T
    Tb£ purpose op
    pLOOiglnroGoV gWe ^OeS 0 -fo
    DOOy|fp ^^
    So 4foctf Ht?Gy <do oof Cbrrrroik S>°d5 ©^ Cps #
    <5H> QsS
    '

    1.--
    ^' cb ar<° aooside5f d as ba roP i for gpa'eky . ©
    ^-
    :r
    •

    ^^
    •

    & pbucocuf
    ^ ?-
    (£* !
    -
    viva
    folf ' S ofcxxtf ~H5P choo
    '
    • '( S

    ^ '
    -
    0iocj tedonoicgiespocioe - op '
    X '
    '

    ©
    -
    3o Modero -Hrx> es, fe
    Safes Parted adop-K ^
    ysf <?no op
    puoiSbnoeof changed . 3
    ^ ose buroaoe Qpproacb foax-
    f
    Tds -Vbo '
    Coiro iOQls - Ra. "Rnsoos ioese ©
    bpcQrt^e 4be
    drnoqd
    paces cohere crrotaqis gef
    TS
    ^ . pabsoos
    tooepbrpoedt 0
    ! 3b -^is peopid deve toped 0
    ^
    •

    :X •
    V s ca
    -fcrdb© starts - U bos SVtfspgVfoen ^^ ^ u

    ^
    !
    dbe l WooQcy op ©
    State - ifoe perspcBQ op pa eoo bad ©Q
    4b© TrsfosnO op CrtnO' OQl. %© pu spooe rs
    '
    ^ GOOOPQ
    ^ OQ
    1 •
    lC
    ^ ^
    *
    '

    ’
    :
    • l
    !
    S .1

    :V:
    a To iropvovp pbe i <xpysop dbo starts. •
    T5> roav 4-t>Qk Czn' rtoloais badv
    m
    1$
    ^ 4t
    ^ sociefy . m#
    - . -}
    .

    Y©1
    A

    .•• •I
    ^
    ©
    • \
    %

    «5:J
    X:
    i
    #
    ©
    m
    :::
    K:
    i
    V ^0
    ;VJ
    p:-
    ©:•:

    S
    ©:•
    :;:]
    1 .
    !*•
    OviHsa+foo He
    m/
    Xb bisj - book Mo <3oess %
    ' *

    H © eci bd<o@eo rbc^ toai


    bc*D -fhe system ©f 3Q egaVtb° sVas4 no-i
    si
    1
    -Y3
    ;--
    5e fVA

    Mad p<2ssat> ibe persons <-°bD


    ^ bove ose Jl .
    ^
    -
    X

    M S
    §!

    i»31 ©
    ^
    -BY cap|+o » iSM ,oeire ODOs wd 3
    ' «
    ^
    i #
    feucauvi has given special fbcuS aO -£?
    a -rtg o — .—
    He bas c*oalysed -{ be c&tecJph'ocpy joesH -VuWoca
    Hbejr
    ••
    3
    - x<?
    iodide / \ ,
    •
    S;
    ;
    © aod pappose Tbe. iosbkHioos be <§> bas okiJfe
    ,

    a
    .

    toH be
    * ^-
    © / Mro / schools §. pirteoo - Osc/ pli ' ^
    > '
    vg nS
    ' puoishroent:
    ^^
    7 -
    :- S
    If
    \

    ays ro of ^oar^iabHcvo . asecoanfds - %


    *
    :

    I* © ibucauH- bQs sggge&ed -the concept of t ‘Etoncroy of p e-oev 5


    ^
    11 ©
    3
    ©
    ^ 'road&?o -
    -
    fiToes v 'T&ss gpa'ey bas ,ro<“oe j ato e*cfs+<en>oe
    Xb Older- 4o coottoi S cb a \ aoge a pcSHoo
    ^ ^ of saCeig .
    - -
    Ke adopts -fihe befeod
    s
    «
    «3
    ©
    :$
    , ^ of cdtsdpiioe cb>cb Eoucaudf
    cans 03 QoYGSbroQOio \ lty . Qoveroroeo-lQhi'b/ & a c b\
    <

    1© by
    os
    1 ©
    I frotncgenisakoo 4 -ibsougb o isc|p,poa*y fn&sHu+caos -
    -
    »
    \s {or dbe purpose
    1:S ©
    -
    of dbe. aaovioieo ao cf hbe stafe
    '

    ,
    popu\ m 00 fe Ctassi -Pej ;oVO owes §.

    —
    '
    , mwooal.
    '

    1-M 9
    1 9
    .
    Qca “ tpsejgoeo Tb

    control fbsiY-
    -
    rough discipline people v®»o boco -te
    •

    body roiocl § .
    pacoer cookroHiog^buroao bodies
    1 QOUI
    gives 4bs COOCGpV Op .

    Siopocoex - { <?, •
    ?
    •

    1 Q foucauif has applied 4i > concept


    * senei . cftsu ,
    -5.
    © or dcsgr, op pwsoo suggest of ffaoopHroo
    Vy GeoHxaro . Tfe idea of
    ''

    ,
    . -
    T*.

    Ii jT
    poirceroao -£r ev«y t *
    f UKW
    °° ' ^ “ =* bav
    of tepo ^
    x© K
    f

    ^
    ool . mode ro prisons
    swve ltance docoer. Prisoner aote Hcwy discipline ®
    I5 9 iSeise fhioUog -tfcc jp oebodiy ^^ -H rv5
    ^
    1® * ^ s ^ca^birg t eir aoUaoe -^
    ©sI
    *%
    :>
    S^dpsly society \s avso Hfcea fboapHaoo . arse.
    toe oasr body
    -feel 4bcH m-Hoite eves of
    4 discif
    no' ^ci ?0 coo -tYOl
    ^
    \ ? oe
    ecao9e
    I
    II © ^
    society arns beeping ‘eotkb - !
    5

    s % fx
    ;
    x
    :

    i
    ^©
    i 9 t:
    1© P
    if
    ii
    I? t;:
    •

    K
    :
    >
    1®
    ft
    t£

    !6 i
    I
    !sc >
    B 1
    I
    I ii
    < i
    ?y • :
    5
    I
    copy - - f
    s doa' s/s c>
    • sSaiigdl- points of Fbcjcaud
    ^ J •

    0?J
    I &edl as posi- skru -
    0-
    :

    FbocauHls aoa 'ysis of poc£>®f is coosde


    V

    iy-. i
    he DQ^ V accepted ^baf
    \
    (§
    C-k rov vipoo of pocoev 4hoacjV ^ iSV InS of )

    ^ s ahsacMvia t fSA csv Fbs i Q\ aucWsia


    >

    •,
    ©
    yi -
    i

    he i *
    ' ufecdo
    rodro
    -£
    •

    ^ ©
    sy
    •v4 -
    V ^anra sjfpco of po ^oeY fbucaiik "

    pocoev He \ & noi- fcoi -Up +be_ oodp aadfrg poiO0rfe, ^ ©


    7->!

    r:. .~
    ;: A
    - pc^Tsficuicrr < o3b'4^ Jh'ODS ^
    aigGote Vie. dfeo0Tf&es disT-Vb '
    £
    iS
    ^ '
    ffobtees coho giver 'fbe ° '0aO focoer V

    pocOQS UPS co(4b bhe state' h^e ofeo diso -ceeb Hbe
    v:

    3s
    wl r^otocflaft vfeto of po ^oesf ciccEfsrdf 'OG| va -fc&e ^ ©
    •
    i 7 .:
    coahsol dhe <eco . ^hsuoM ^e ho bis \bo, pocO r fo Vfc>e 2Pcie5hp
    ,

    ^ - C-
    Acoo'xdiog vo 4toess Wecbes po«oer fe ^oHfe GHboq i .
    ^dpac , ©
    + vaut vdl >a| CfgoGS
    ^aTOydirg fbacqtfltr poeOGiris 4 ^
    -
    ( 0 #
    ail dbpopens §~ Cocoes -fror-o ao ^obigjre . fb ueeir ,'S -ffocoin
    ^
    —^
    « *
    \
    • -'
    fi
    & 4b*ou0bocU fhe gociGkj - io 4be -ficnrro of capil fairies or neV
    -
    V*
    ^
    S3 tooerb lilqo
    ovgadsp* ViOoS
    ( JnhejrG te Q cocvo^ oVibo do fooO\eJoje £ potOe* koo«Ole 0e
    ^ ^
    "
    *

    ©
    Tep^eseoi -VbP dfecoejTSBV . Tjbe. dc> ro’\ OQoV disco U'BSS Shqpps
    "
    -
    ''
    1

    .5
    •
    Hbe cjdveyse of poeDGC dCP^diog to foW), dioe^e \h> o >
    VcpoOledge tOfvbcx-? V pocCGV. ©iad iQtftj fo ^oe* Caooohbe
    - - = ©
    ©

    e Q'sed cof bouf boocOiedge Cofecoursff m


    \ *

    3
    ->
    •
    ^
    ocda -f does TV ropao 4o soy -fbof
    ^
    is O® VnoOfecIge #
    cof -rtooai pocoejrf
    .

    A>
    :1
    I
    .
    l
    y

    >!
    VoocDledge iso d &coc se- Ibp discourse ^cbdb geis *be, sofp
    ^ -
    Z33V Of roajob y "bejOrodS' Vbi? cksrv 'OaoV ojbCOU 7sS.e csr 4be
    c iroG of 4?« j4b • fse y disoawse sepsegeat dae tpxoev ©-f
    ^ -
    -
    —^ m
    V.v

    ^^
    '
    :J

    IL
    :

    ^ #
    j vc^ooe - . gfce dis:cxj5’5^e_ of tS/0>oUa \ r4H>, Qri'^OIOQ i TV
    1

    11 ^
    bodoess ts de e^roioed b4 4he cbro\ vooi- v(pO • TS Sofryr- ^ ;

    y.7

    ^ ^
    FA
    co oe toba i 5 noirrOQV Qtooynoq ! 7f & kfce po <o>e^ of
    ' ©
    p c.V)iQ-bisV doc OTT , ps dHa-vitfeV -VaaV coorV3 • sfroban
    V
    1

    >

    ^ ^ ytu h> e qeo


    ^
    sp gesf 'Vhav- pocoes coonoi be OcecisQd tO’Hbcxi. V hno -
    :-va
    ga
    ^ .
    •

    :>:•
    >] ©
    - •!
    .1
    ;
    *

    ©
    ©
    . ;> •

    0
    ; :::
    ;
    #
    I • ©
    ;
    ©
    •
    -©

    1 #
    bi
    VTOKCWW?!
    taoiMo creeps -toe
    fjocHoo
    &QS is c* of'
    AocJx ^
    - -toe
    YC!

    m
    '

    © | PGC x -sapped
    ••
    :a
    :<i - /A
    focoor of doctor became
    - dtoc&
    oed cwiy
    .
    vtocte 6 %
    (<abg'e. of r <=ds'cio0 - fbocacjf
    2 t:
    a<
    '

    -
    c

    I:s © ^ be co oSKdpfcS f fO
    \'S fO^O’ T ; at frogs
    »
    ^ . stWa Hoo^ he. -cteR^’
    - S' i

    ° ^ °P Koootedge 4 pcae*
    ©•

    ,sa<-oe + Hoqs Ib wos+ f -


    1^ V^o dZ
    ^ / , < = =» ^
    peoer . RStoeo
    'VT'fTLr
    .

    * *« - 7 P** ' *
    ;c

    *
    •
    1
    f
    •

    I
    ©
    f>
    V

    fod* * of p^ ?
    *
    tOiernfew T
    b

    *
    "op CCwjpOOGOr tr
    (• ? • 000
    s
    coo detftod css 006 ~tbQ
    °
    !
    : ©
    l
    :
    cKsfoqvso GB,
    fooderOisrvr
    ^ ' i

    4 ©
    &
    - -*:
    •
    © @} fcfle do oof <2<PC fse poco^ - -they erobody p^co .
    ^ ^opie
    .£

    1© Os<P v/oblcjes
    (
    of pS^OeXS • Q— f£S - iG rQ rg to -H^Vot-
    *
    •
    •
    t
    A- (f ) Q- i£ tCfcOOg 4o -VWOt dbQ>
    < pocOG% 'S COPBS.! vlp- is (
    I . © uscay \deptity .
    Ctckiat y pwdcJGfvg - Fbcngir
    '
    V
    < 5
    ::5
    2 .
    4« #
    .
    ( j3) fbcOOjf fs -sVBCHP^y . f scjO^v (s Oppliapiblr tObGJT Ve^ \£>QX& fe =*
    :y
    o :
    •

    :i
    M ©
    A
    .'
    ^ ^
    '

    pocoeif A-bGTse \ S a pDSS» bll by Of -KPSi&tooa2. JObr tlte I


    <

    s- © ro{ ~
    OOY^OaJ
    'i QzciQkj devides 7Sg>OSOO § UO seaSor) ^
    ! © larsiy ObgjTQ -fbgrG is a concept of ps<o« v- -these fe o
    •jjroglstetoce b©3D -
    ccoaef * of Tsge aoce • Accord log -to biro
    fi
    1©
    -
    I f:
    V.

    J
    :
    rO0S HbG> basis -f edo fO
    ^ •
    C ^
    :c

    C ) (2> Acceding to FciicauiV drsdpUoe iS> OCt bod OGCQCBP rt b^ F&


    1 jo boaiotafoQooe Of 4be
    ••
    ©
    V

    5< r
    &
    Q. Kbocciec e Ts fecoes
    ^ ” I

    © Tbeanj ofpotoer -
    i
    K
    : •
    Boot- Dtsdplioe § pooiSb -
    -
    • v
    ©
    ©t
    JAftiPocPd by Niigl-s^cbVs (3<soPaiogy of Mo^is -
    < ©
    :-:
    •
    *
    • V •
    toncepv of dlSCOUKCGS
    i #
    1t AcOOtfd ' Og fjirvo » S o. <d 'SCOUYSG .
    MoCO dtscouvcp coroe ( bvo -eAfsdeoc^? so roe
    ' >

    con e^
    tf. f >
    V
    cdo>'fb ae4s soppovf • aob Cb geJr accepted toy rop)OT> ©/ +
    ° '

    bebnoes discaq^e • tbe ry' a0° toasffe ocoo cMscoa>sse - cf


    .
    cf ©
    /
    :

    ^
    1c: ©
    1© :C
    C-
    (do-a-i MooHy

    dfscoqv ^
    ^
    txxxs discou
    Cxf ^OodGiTO 'ttroo • 'OBCpU
    OU«- ucJereAoncJiryj OSOKe .
    '
    ^
    of poodi ^ Mroe HoQQ -
    '
    1 - - adQCee t
    ^
    sse. de4 S'noioe Vbe !<«3 ?4S of
    I

    I
    \
    1e s bte dtec&uv^e. of sscuci f -ty - Vepcesao-t
    I
    t

    -
    8
    ?-
    !© or pocogir op- bets^os'.Q cicj | fry sirr/iito-viy -+toe dfscousse of I
    r- ^ R
    r-

    Tep^eeot -the. pooler of docfoY .


    .
    Co) Scientg ii:
    I
    ;* ©
    >
    - ^
    otetoakxe of pfycboio y nvepyi°seof -to© dfecm'S'Pof psych^W -
    e.
    5

    I©
    k
    pouooY CQOMOFP be
    ^
    ^
    evdeey cOif4he<uf discou^rse . !
    5
    l
    Y.
    v
    St
    Ci
    - fno de%e
    «
    i • I
    1f ©
    1© s
    no S

    II
    ^ ss^SSSiwi35^>>^»i^sh5
    :%
    120^
    tgokiYe 3
    uv. - t pVe:
    ^ i

    31 joi <*

    — ^ PboCQuH HC6 ooechootet'oa


    %

    Of DnV^Ol
    Q00’0\ ( - 'O

    ss (T MigKQ-liChlcbl obsgi ^ol-too


    '

    £c7.. „
    OF r oeaos observing peopte -
    v
    5V
    '

    %
    © fslgstocn iQiog vTuck^gy^oGof r
    U roeaos pLfoieh^'PO^ op oon- CDo Jjr 00
    ..V
    'i ^ '^ t
    ^ ^ ^
    ni] xQ loafioo
    •

    I .
    Vt roeaos +PSn'p3 pesscxo^ poa \ ft<j % abu ,+y c O '% t - %
    &
    S3
    * *»
    •

    S i
    Societies. social OOYTOS values •
    :
    •• £Z
    .v.
    OOP (X .S'
    --
    Pergoo f^eeps c-OQteb eo BnoeQ -p / »• /
    #
    i i
    •

    *§
    I* 1
    v
    •*

    f
    ©
    ;
    . V.?1 .* /
    0
    o
    o
    s
    -<
    , ' • >

    ©;
    i
    !%
    :;

    V- 1
    vi

    1
    m
    :.:M
    ) ]
    n- s~v\

    .VJ
    :Mi
    !
    .0.i
    '

    ©
    ,
    :vi:!
    '
    1
    #
    i3 >
    0
    .
    * .; ' 0
    ©
    ©
    .

    fv&
    v;
    ©S- (

    s- ©
    s*J ©7

    '»V
    raa^ vtebers / bAeton'Qo Concept of ftogr
    -
    :-.-3
    f*i6ie
    1 © gDtiO iSV
    :3
    i:?
    •
    m '
    Vi
    roox vJebei 's o N^odeioiSt - KOX wiebpr is o cdkc of
    * ' -

    kari MQTSX - \4beo V-Qtl MQYX suggest stoop stole Tsapessrp


    •

    -
    :!
    •
    'J3

    : -Sl
    ©
    fSsce . marx- Vv bQjr sqggPSl ^baf stole Tto fnseseoV autookfc
    •
    ;?.
    I5©
    1 f?>
    ^
    JVe Hobbes W (toPbekr a*eo S^gge l Aba-t la o poftkcub
    (
    ^
    ici
    ;
    S
    £
    i

    © Apssi'tay c«oy slate bee ’ oooopoy -


    overate ^seo-p tostou
    L -S
    x-

    © roeois of coe foo slave das toMtocW+t


    £:
    •

    $ ^ •

    -S ©
    | '
    •to
    use -f # ce> •
    vobavi's Aulboviltj ?
    1
    m
    ©
    vk_Hbo>ity ts vegfb rr^ate potoe?r- A po<^e plus leojip-
    :AS
    3
    -
    © * *
    roacy is ^Actocnoty - £a dlf{©sQo : societies 4be cok re of
    V

    MRC
    •
    '
    3:
    -C
    V
    0
    e OU+boily UOy VQ ' ^
    'Jrtj - \v^ax‘ ki(ObpV bos 01^20 s <Ec$QCtL
    , i
    Aypes of /to+to f (eg .
    I
    #
    fibcff is Heal type ?^
    •
    .-v
    ©
    :? •
    -f ideal ype ^eocs nooctels,
    •

    IA 0
    :! © O X5odf+iooai /tovboVrb) -
    xo saroe societies ^fsctdWons
    to
    ? 0
    • $
    £ castors beconoGs Mxs basis
    - :
    cf autooYrty ep- -tee oattady of qoeeo to Baitoia is bcmf
    O
    5. ;
    eo custom - -vtotdrboios.
    c

    1O ^
    © Chadsroate:Ai+bo fy -
    ^
    O Id so e societies Cbcfirfsnocx ov
    <P
    ^ persona ify cao be tbs
    basis of -AuAfoyiny - Ebj- AJtooity of G@oc$t>
    "
    •

    % o Hoimany Cbads^oafc auAbovvty is o.


    i"

    .:
    V : © Societ'fis or socteKes o csisls -
    '
    of Vodfbfonc
    ^
    ::
    3
    .1
    •

    © Lbegai Qofooqi /\ubboyi1y -


    : . tl
    I 0 Autoo'by tobicf, is Abe pzroduoj
    "
    f
    i 0
    of legoI 7000001
    principles Qrr 'rales eg. If ftooderr> societies
    -

    f -toe a.utbariy
    • K.
    of public as oote coo be QDCSidefind c
    '

    ¥
    0 ^ © Usgal pafc tonal . i

    Ii 0 )

    i
    IS £
    t-'
    )
    \
    :

    I0 0 i
    1

    1s ©
    3
    ?
    ;
    •

    I* © C
    • i
    I
    •
    :
    1© b
    "
    i !

    1I ^ k
    r
    ;•
    f

    i© I

    I0 1M I
    c

    u
    ft

    f
    S
    e^la
    & an aodenes Oil W 3 bosfs
    '
    ; '
    --
    .I
    op0"*10ns -
    te

    Guv -they e*tefr to dif &nenv


    te
    '

    ^
    S|
    a t G.
    -•
    ,-d
    ' .V: •
    ,v .l
    teJnqf as® tee noeteods
    - be Abp noeaolog oP te -h rcay ,
    • 1.11
    J
    Q De
    ^ ^
    •

    i
    3
    bAbat Cs a
    &?
    * . eroplcyed by tee state -to gal o leg C;•^ •

    le ltiroat ieo enSLS


    - '
    m
    n A

    ;i
    ^
    -> IQbav & iggi -Hroacq ?
    ..

    .1

    Leglfiroaccj 'effect -tee consent


    op 4-tae governed • Ibat
    exeease of p^0G«- 63b\chte considered ^ngbt by tee.
    ~
    ©
    I
    people oui be cqoefclewpd as legf H ^ocite -
    '

    te -

    t>‘f t gibnQQcy § Laplfbj r

    ^
    • .
    3
    seocG. \ c
    •

    :
    :i

    :
    1
    ^
    USyouiy noeaos 09 pe*r \aco - laco Gao be tee basis of &
    ;v

    :::\~
    i .'..
    • .7 r
    *t * «
    autbofrity but until ] §- unless tease is cx coreeot of tea §
    :V
    m
    .y
    people \QCO cannot be deforced • C

    teopedaoce of leyi -b nogiq , ©


    I ACGsrodtog -fo foussau PMera tee sbsang^v roan s oe^er \

    O^oog eooupb oobll be CDO'fdS bte stssp b lOte ‘Sigbtr %


    ^
    A
    1
    bi9 pocoor
    '
    < oto auteobty . •
    peocf , legifroacy ;s Q
    fte- ©odftfoo ter c3ove otei
    *
    oebate QO ggi-b^rncg
    .!
    ' _ _
    Wse fe a debale oo of 4 3 tegf +itoacy
    ^
    -
    0
    be(
    coeeo JdqrcSt and ubeaals - Ubesqfs cesort teat ^ State C?
    ^
    nrepasosent tee use of u fftiooaAe. ce_ . tee ateer
    ? / *

    ^
    *
    V<5

    tt :
    ’barxi MiQiPc&t
    challenge -tea
    rdqstet CQ \ I state os a.
    ,

    ^
    noauj of tee <dtete i
    v; - class \ost50'n°orte‘ Handst cad
    -lbs- Tfeyoiutioo a QJ ost tee state. Accovd toy do LibesaAs ©
    ^
    -Vbe tact teat tea state te> (ontaoujng cs 00 lod'Catosr tea> <f
    •

    :
    0:
    ::
    •
    dote Tsep-ueseot tee ail of tee people
    /
    - •

    6
    - •
    /
    ©
    ©
    ©
    x/

    i
    I
    Is
    -a-J
    5
    m
    j

    *
    !
    m
    :•.> .
    -V Tryy
    ^i
    or Vc&d 'I Vrsk- the , basis coe*sbo fe
    -*
    ^
    :• - r
    Cp .

    1-a ©
    •
    -for r H • Q- jreeo UU l ooh -fame is dbe basis of
    '
    1

    I8 © people -gur tee sate


    teo state - lh&6Q is Q tofK op
    '

    I
    ©
    a
    '

    :f:.
    ; vc
    o35
    3 •,
    ©
    Beca osa estate pp& --ptens noa ^y . use dt
    Hotoe v -for
    ^
    .
    ockoos -
    coil } is nrjGO OCX 0a GtliStelC
    /
    ^ ^ •

    -13, 50
    '

    % rocb oue te bettee teab Soutetecfee skate


    :2
    ;$
    •
    © fe> boaod te su^pr -pom csise* o© teacy -
    ti
    :©
    £
    legitiroa-HoO Cdsis
    i ©
    %
    — Mob^rnoos v
    Jb
    3
    •
    ©
    ©
    « —
    Peter pT bus aqes notes
    ^
    <5 Baroibp -tbe ffSJQHoosbfp b/O pocopr , Autectety °to
    ^ ^
    ‘
    - d
    < '
    3
    *S ©
    V
    ;
    0
    Ls ib'roacep
    v
    £
    *
    J # fotoeste -tbe cebhrai concept of poetics . BetookfcM^a 1 estr
    ii bate Vpla ; o2t5 -hbe ,;tic as 9 °f P o? §
    .-v3
    3
    of f >ooe5r . TFouqK PCsco ,* |sq £eotarcu J“ 91 te ^ '
    caoceoi- upt *>
    !
    3
    "

    1$ ©
    :
    * >'

    W . ^ ~
    ^ OS Contes pcocen !fe> «9 ocJ+tevl 4l f-HOQQ 0
    OQ a - r ^ *
    , J
    ‘

    ^ *
    I0
    evp)Qr0 ^ - ^ ^
    op pocoezr
    9
    focoe r - ibesg
    •

    1V m ate -ftoo fc>5oac5 c-Oa e? i n tebicb pocoer C3


    UodejfSbod i G io
    corveotiooai sense
    * ^
    coeWs CoosfdPted
    £
    lx XW ,

    as Co-roroa b‘oo te >^\bi ttty -tocfet dings ne


    '
    t
    © ty others -
    v V. )
    Maboab BOndt bos 2>ite<n
    pbcoer tobob ^
    •
    000 - c^aveabonal vtp=o op
    4 <: respites pxoervaot in te os Coe sfoo
    '
    tyl etspnooerroeot netting io ODOCP p - ^ *
    i•
    k:
    r-
    *
    lb ponbcai ScJQDcp
    1 tee itea ysb exp
    oer te Vted-
    1^ ^ po < 'J > 'Piorxili

    ^
    3cioteJ lo;
    |@
    >:

    4t #
    (

    H*
    * to^
    Aterdt iaits cxboctt -the
    boca
    Xescfeed
    ogj
    r
    ty -He state
    by tfee
    taite a.bp u^
    . dpi! sxiGbjp © bh )
    ! ° tbaoactt
    -terms of civSCDa*rscs - T e rv?aio debate .Vis po ^oear- io )
    |©
    t
    1 ( and MateSfe obe«s Ubesctis^ cbVo -vbat aba b) co dbe Ub0rq(<
    by -\pe sttte is i itinoate Cbeteas Mazpoist use of pstae
    .
    ^
    -
    10
    II ©
    ‘
    ^ cbvrn teal-
    ^
    00s op pcxoer bj tee stete is Uiegrtwcart© It rs cx £ o&Q(an .
    ba
    .
    5 by tee state to -te Interest pb? cbroioaot- lasa .
    A

    I©
    ?
    ° ° I
    i
    i
    t

    I0
    t
    -\ \

    1
    I3: © »
    ii
    <
    fc 1
    ?: ©
    V

    C
    sc
    i5
    t
    £-
    0
    I
    I$
    c E-
    5
    K.
    ®
    :r'H
    •
    May dtsHneKciD h? ® tvnbod poaQer
    voebor ?t?o o. -T h e
    (

    I aod Aa+borVbj . uhe cseo-f poezsB


    ' bxj ffc>t? -{3 £
    •
    Hence, be.
    considered 1- 'h noqve by -Tba people
    Vci

    v3
    • ;

    ^
    Suggests Ibat steHe -sHpvGseDV ' / pkboinbj . Re
    has &H°O
    S3
    a 3 ideal -types of ^Aa-tboViTy . Tfce dbrbtoQot hjpe of
    ! -
    -Au fbcmtg LCH! I vo fcro &>dQty -Vo Society - $

    ^
    • vO >
    :: :••

    d&e Cbooepf of lo W roacy {3 dcseig associated vrcSfb c


    v v4

    :. !
    '
    :: 1
    !
    •
    i

    -
    • be concept of acMternkj) . Secqose

    '
    ^^
    kho^ifj 3
    ^-Hroq+e. potoes . sates cooRoue becoiose etete enjay
    1-
    ^ §
    : 3
    .'•M

    I le HTcoacy to kbe -eyes of -Vfce people -


    Accensbtey bo §
    1 ^
    "lax Viebpr 4be tseja-bbreHp Can bp -expbnood tbsoc b a
    -jV
    V
    ^ /-
    4be
    ^
    oakon '.
    • A
    &

    ^AuThoriTy - Paecgr 4- l tiroacy .


    I?
    A; - '

    -v
    ^
    P 4odlcqiOXS of leqffiroQca •

    <*
    - •
    •

    ;:v

    © LacO Ob'dUPoaQ anooocj bbe cifzjsas -


    ©
    Rpgpec oy nahboQ) SjnobolSi, Aotbeno, Flay etc -
    ^ ^ d
    ©
    Q poynoeot of Taxes
    © Soda\ Discipiifi>e - \
    ..a
    @ lesser no of Gncoes , pwoteste
    0
    1
    •
    »
    T

    *
    I ci-Hrecs ofcee vtcy Nla-Kooa) festivals
    *
    ©
    w

    ©
    .©

    M-efeods of BoMdiOp
    ^
    l fiQQQcy
    i

    ;• S
    i
    ©
    '
    1
    ;! ©| I'TqioVQioaoce. of laco g osder
    . 1
    S:i
    0 MafotaioaocQ Qp poie of Laos
    ©| feeecSoro of press
    © Todepeodeoag of cfaHicJosy
    'kv

    ©
    '

    ^ 11 Social coei - ace. 3^0©roes


    -1
    f dbr 0lecHoos
    ^
    pVcpagjaodQ .
    ^ §
    m
    m ©
    asetf 'e n
    VCOr epa cep> of y-teea
    ropog
    ^
    ( arosci
    •u
    :- :
    • ••

    io previous classes %
    m
    .: . 1

    :V;
    m
    i
    >>1
    ".
    j
    '
    - •'!
    V:•• #
    H:3.
    b*

    •
    -1
    h
    S3 tv
    :h;
    :
    _ , - j j ..
    'L ; -
    rr'rgr” — >
    ,
    ^ ~'* WXWSJJ CC
    ~

    ^
    »’
    0>

    :& t © Co°cepf of Jdeoiogy


    •
    rs&
    .3 op Xdpolo9y 1
    %3
    <S\ (T) Discuss toe debate oo toe Mature
    •

    ;'
    S
    to
    1© -tivp . HacO
    posi Mode&ofets
    i Q (D dbat ate Me4q KiQtYa
    '
    i©
    - .$
    i
    r cS
    ’

    *
    ii
    Q. (3)
    I06V1 at KiarsQtives
    j sbato state oo &xl '
    of 3Heo \c>3 y toeisis -
    <
    •

    to
    © to
    1 Shod Motedo Pod of HisVOJTL/ Ifoeisis -
    3 ©
    3
    to XbpOiOQy 030 be UcdOSiOod yr> tooo a3Qs ;
    ’
    3 ?
    : -
    f2 f
    ^
    ; 2C
    )
    S ?
    © A tool to understood w cDnopte^bpod fbedseaivto .
    i : <©
    |
    .:
    :S
    3
    *x CD) A prcppa rorae of QGHOO . 3deo\ony is a set of ideas oo ^
    toe baefs op tobicb pessoo cao have a> o access to perne*
    .

    !to ©
    <££ is a basis to ojgaoae people
    to

    :5
    s
    ;
    •

    3 & @ I HiStosy of -tbe terra ideology


    ::3
    c
    © 3?
    '

    I Tb - ideology
    9 learo coos cotoed by psseocb sabola >r
    I9
    5
    I Cooot d Ttacy. -
    Uibai coas its put pose©
    ;
    3
    ©
    ! © He COQS coofenopcrca
    of Ac p ' lao Qooapato: -
    °
    ^
    1
    v

    *5 r. TblS toas dtoe toroe op eoii SVee <noooV § sa'eof -f e


    .
    C

    setoutioo 0
    t© 'Tiraaj coooted
    to -estat>\ fed a school pto dbe so'
    1 eoti Qc toadly
    °f 5Beas - toe purpose coas aodesstoobl \
    Q \ \ tdece
    i ®
    .1 ©
    V scientific boss i tooap be coined toe 09 ideology
    ^ "
    1 <
    > on

    .
    S fdeoioQys denoted s ste^oa -tic /sa©rtofc study op
    :
    I: II
    si
    6 y
    -
    Hocoevp- ideology ^
    ot poiT-Hcisedi •
    edeas •

    *
    I©
    -1
    -
    f
    •
    coaid
    caroe
    oat ^
    to be toocOo as Republicans -
    op
    CO'roe iioto Odeteooe Tracy § bte
    -
    science
    Suppoatenrs -
    ideas
    I
    &
    < ©
    to
    fi >

    I®
    £
    5 © /
    to
    £
    2
    £’ ©
    t
    |
    • 3
    x
    1to ©
    ^
    yf

    1 ©
    1
    •
    v
    %
    S3
    m a ”
    m rv *
    cia'it-oed as
    !
    b/ to Ideology SCfpoCfi.
    as
    •

    - ^j2aie^srx
    i '
    lo3es -
    )

    Science % c+bev schools of taagbte


    \ 1 3
    r-ic.

    avt
    He held -foal- ideas 2, ideologies nesu *
    :t!
    Consa oueopss
    ' •

    Q- coats bsoio echo held tba + cjOoddQo classes also


    oeod -their ideology . 4-4e held 4toq + cononcuofaro asao
    • i

    i -
    ideology of vbe cCo?rti og Oass -
    ! Aoo+bpr Ma ^iSh scholar cDba bQ3 aoavusof ) tbe 'OaVUse
    '

    ^ -
    of tcleolocjfes is cra noso’ . Qsanosa' op^e the aoocepvof
    :h
    -I
    i
    •••

    ^
    hi
    T:V ftege coonj. Q^arosd held 4tai- ubestufero 13 ^ b e- IS
    noory CbnoroPOfe^o ( S> a CoaoVe* Vte ejpcDoy .
    ^
    Ubesa ) scholar \ ibe -
    ka H fbpper atonstgd coinog Moupc
    ^ #
    )

    03 ao energy of apeo society . ye caned Har ao as) ©


    Wi
    ?:v
    S ?
    ao Ideology (JbQrairsoD 03
    ^ “ ^
    school of -Vhoa- £?
    -- fir -
    * Arepdt hcdd Vba -
    • *

    tTJ:

    Manoab \ .
    deology § af »P dhe -HCQ 6
    iaebaroeote op istaiftafriao State has pat
    ©
    hash'sho aod ok* i ; ofev-o asao 0<a «splps of ToVa c, teha ofer-o.
    o

    Above dteo^jasfcyQ -shoco 4hp c o,-te (pobvary to the opi obr)


    Of Tracy top hprro ideology hQs got- ^
    jcoiib cls ecfi.
    Scholars 'ncod © cSKet? ncdHoo bp( aDe o ideology § odeoce .
    ^ .

    >

    <
    SVJ>

    fa
    vv
    ° cv
    -
    \jbQ< f called -their otoo Th ohra as gtieohtb 2 the Ahintc --
    •

    • -.
    : *

    > ©f ;
    (o
    0 of cppooQOl^ as Ideological.' Letter ao pea c0c>d ©sois,f
    ^- -
    .v
    - scholar UV£> foUcauip gave tbe Vemr> discourse djor hootD
    .
    ?

    Vd
    (eJge oyste)
    i :i
    T:1
    ' ,
    - cxcaccif even eaggeste tfca \ Qcieio ee \s>
    ^ . #
    oiso a discourse *

    ^ v:

    O
    : :!
    i
    •
    i

    ©
    w
    ©
    s
    :V:
    #
    m m
    m
    JK
    pp
    like CXiV^ssbutt * Sogg^S'V Woof O tbe f cdd
    ; '• ( - ~ { "
    .vs
    i^ © Qutadq
    *s
    Cv
    toe ^oove < a boHorotess
    aod bosbevt'Qss sea. .
    m% m
    r
    poises ° t
    •• C5
    boot Ideology § utop'o Qives
    I
    3 f
    s
    , '

    -
    3 kOrj Monnbejoo iO bis
    n «os
    coocepfof C 5OQOIO9Y of Kooco dge’ &
    •

    °
    il

    s2 m ^
    >cb • Nb ideo -
    fJXDcOlpdgg bos itS SOdbfc> £> v-( OT SpDO coote
    81 -
    0 P
    x
    *
    ;J2
    ;-a
    •
    © bgv te coitbout -fbe Ttoots to the class -
    t3
    ::.«
    fx/psy ideology tfepspseot -Vbe iofoxesv op pqz cctvayClqgB
    -:J
    •

    f1
    ;« ©
    © •& !

    Vte bas also 'roadie dtt'srViodhtbo b/ to ideology § otep'a . ^


    m3 % ideology vs the set op <Gdaae tsc pseseo -H03 dfoe fotes t
    V.
    3 Of dtoe. do^oi oa ot ciqgc, pg . Ubeycuisoo- otopia. ao ^
    (1. # Ideology •sep^sseetiry 4 0 xbtesest
    1 4 *2 ^s^ploTted
    ;-3>
    :« ©
    . dqss Eg - Qanonocjoisro . pvgr ^
    ) utopia \ S dpslsabe . utopia
    ^
    v
    *c #)
    X
    ; *
    \ S SQqoispd by -tfc>e Exploited class -
    «
    •'

    ©
    .4 Ebd or Ideology -
    1I ©^ ETod of Ideology i s a aoocepV 0W©o by saroe coestesTO
    d. Scholars to i06os aod ip?Os . Ibe period Coloc/des -uoHb
    © fbe period of fbe
    .2

    IO
    2: ' Qateote *
    Create syroboiised
    Hoo <saper pqeogss ^
    s-. avaBoo of tensions bGtoe oVbs
    I1 L- - J •
    Q roe UD
    ^
    &SO sdboiass ck tc»ec9 'ba}
    ^ V
    •

    f ^ *
    ( be age of Ideology is over - Jdoaic ffQi
    •
    !s
    kopostaoce - ore of -fbe psoroiopot^ expoOOQV ^
    Qapg 00
    ¥ 0 fod of
    Ideology) tbeisfs LQOS Oooiei ©ell . He bas Of
    (
    k
    ?: o cadtfeo a boop
    -tf -dedc Ebd
    of Jd«D \ o0y ' tDoese a© te bos da vnoe Pbat <^e ctse
    '
    t 0
    IViog to ao OQP cchQze pa 'itics rs crir -tbe teoebett^ 'S’ODnooa’cs P'
    i O
    is lo -tbe
    .

    Qot 1 0 pnroe goesh'00 of our -t?POS£> te de^e lope^o ^


    ; 0 ^ *
    ^
    ot - to tocAt) ca tds Bust lOeSfc ffast-OsSR) sirdi ar- -type op ^
    # BMtfeaaorabc
    ^ ^
    fcat© Q tocbrxxtrabcs0
    '
    05 baste 03000 ir3b>
    £ ^ _
    esfebpoce • Heocp tdeoto ' cat ^^do oot have rbucb i

    © ^
    TretoVaoce -lb case aP cae oeno coaotslGs coetfu^e. ate bas
    ^
    >

    IrQSOV^sd tbe corvpict blco ^


    t
    0 labour §• captal -
    1s
    I
    sg
    t-
    © 8.
    t;
    1;
    © Ir
    i;

    © I
    ©
    R
    © -i
    t:>

    IIK
    l
    IS
    F- 'a V.
    %
    p
    ^^ ^ ^
    gjj w OTgS
    ^gSSSS^SSSSSSSSS^
    gSSSoSSSSSSSS
    ^S^SSSSSS&w
    Pagtoeo i
    c be/ scholar ato dQKj
    & ^ fecOS
    3 * epocepV of of Tear a «|oc , e.-
    ?•.

    pos-too bos 3ivoo toe


    o , tsfraH socJeA-tes pass toxoc V*
    Q
    Sf-1
    '

    cpsouMb - Accoxdirg H* ^
    7so « b- M©oce '
    ideology ^ a
    S «r) Qr s\qges of cconorofc g
    ' ^ ^ Vv- j

    *vix
    ;
    does ocf roaHe 'r •

    c
    Voas cs \so assented -that asouod toe oaVd
    4bQee
    S - M . Lfps f
    &
    v.
    ?3 ^
    fS 0.0 adtoocO ( © genoeoV- topA topse ts oo belttetf LOaj/ of
    &
    7?J
    £]
    A; life -eccept
    ^
    liberal
    •

    dernoefracy -
    ©
    d

    m- On' HdsoD of Fod of Ideology ©


    a
    e
    to
    End of ideology Tbae \s coukS oo-v <ade acceptance ,
    p
    ^v
    V

    goc/aifcy- scbolaiss accepted toe end of tdQoVoojy


    '
    ©
    ibefsis - to@y coossdpjrpd toPendtof tdentqoy -fs ©ctoio3
    :i

    0
    vto. bto toe cooceated defence of toe ccesAPso of
    to
    &
    otoc9 ofeodof Edtoapy todude -
    ^fDoog
    •

    *ttoo Hi Ctotoflht ^- f l \s <oes& ©ro oocie- f-


    A-ccotoiog to Vito tv- fs cesrong to tont 4bat 4be
    -VtQo, bav/ e etobisbe© toe e ouibriuto befeaeeo ©
    Qcd pe fC£>Y - ^ 0
    to QB C- 6 - KiQqDbe soo o
    ^
    Me bfB toaV COQ
    .

    O soct’ett'es ore baoHdy fQaMtctgriao - ©


    •
    <
    i
    o
    ^
    pence tfo-e {^foatooao of politics baa not tost - ©
    •

    •
    \
    it
    1 © Aiosdair MacIntyre C
    ."i!i
    :• Me held bai end of ideotogy
    -

    Ttsetf ao \decte&t - ©
    .'• 4:
    m
    ii
    .;:i
    - -1
    :TJ

    /
    ®
    -
    00
    ' ^°
    P MiStoYM
    - pef?r Oi bcvoitsrv
    ^ 0
    - - C- fqVcqyarOQ .
    .
    yr
    -~'

    Q.,
    to

    t.«;s
    ©
    • <

    \
    ©
    -
    Vi
    •
    • •
    ‘i

    4
    i
    bi
    ©
    d
    &
    Ax
    ». <&
    A
    •

    • 1
    ©

    «3 I

    .r’.'.4
    -l *
    ?5 c
    ^x;-C:r <rvXv>:r- -
    ; : ?:
    1 ${ bl $&KQr>OQ lO End
    7-
    op jagoiogn ? EB 4 of n stov 4 . ^
    i

    r pod of Hi'Stob} fS to > s^vivdl of T^od of ^yeoloojy ^>0isis,


    ecus; •
    sxcTx'S

    O Bofb of 4bes& concept afro -to josKf ) bexal tovcyof


    ^ ^
    O nQ02n9 CX‘ES02rfiV£? f «r>
    ;
    MS Ufe - Bod of v-Ks 5 ^ ^^
    \
    WUsSf '
    '

    -XSc
    T ," - cicntoiog -Hie soppdo'jntx) of LIBERAICSOQ ^ 00 , o, toto
    *
    -
    par isoo to end of fdootogq .
    i% © _|A<rcbsdlog 4o tod of sdooto9 4bQ3s xded ao cal
    s
    II f
    Ca«y no roeQo03 . 6a} Qao2$di
    ' ‘
    # ^2303910
    .>
    '
    ^
    4 tod of VT og Ubem -
    *
    f 3
    09 o
    UQfO is. 0odPof MQCS fdeologfctU p yota-
    tfoo -
    .

    ^
    I©
    1 ^
    If Pas} Modpvois} Oritie of ideotc0 vj

    s Wha } fg Fbsh Madpuoist-o 2


    I
    If fbs} ModpjrOferO <200 t5P uodessiood OS'
    1© (3 WOJIQrOQXDt
    1© © A SCboo\ of IfooUgft .“ V

    0 As a Mo/e-'ro^oL post ^oode& ofero is aopbogt toe o ato/e


    *I f
    •
    I
    QDOSSqoenoes of Moderorf )
    .

    ^
    Ix f ) ^ ^ec\ scbod of toougbf posL toodQfnisrn dcaiieoge QO
    1'

    •
    IC ( :! base ossainoptions of Madesoftti • V
    *
    4 ©
    - C
    posv Modp^rnfebQ -fast enO'Psgpd) to top -
    ¥
    , l K: feld of /*f ,
    v
    ? UiezrahtoP 4 later 00 fo otopr disciplines toetogebe •
    I © is knocoo 05 foto r
    ^ of pc&\ ModtoOiSto.
    V
    •>
    '
    r. r.
    \dby ?
    •

    ! c
    I© l to tosebe bos
    ^ chahPbg ^d •eo ii ryteo ro oL clatooed
    \

    I#
    1#
    7C
    •then
    eo 1 ighten rogr)} das roadie exjo
    Pee •
    '

    ,
    ^ ^ >
    ;

    I
    ;•
    y. X
    !¥ © '

    •5 I <;
    5
    •

    £ © v
    4
    S-
    0 •
    .
    5
    «
    -o y
    5
    !© l
    1 '
    r

    1L t!
    £
    E
    11 © sf
    I
    fc
    1© l
    1 w
    !:
    1© E
    E
    1I ©
    a 1s
    £
    y.

    :i
    1
    •

    ^© w£ fe

    li
    <

    i?«
    • 5
    e (
    '
    -
    "17'7*:*-7 “ ~.RJ CTW
    - WW»!mw!!!,
    rv
    »
    W W
    ^55KV?^- 3W
    VWW
    # m © & ® © % # © i
    HUP oY'iA'i ® © G> Q ©
    ^ > ® # © © ^ >
    JJlpPP * 3
    01 c *
    . * f
    I
    8 g
    1
    I2
    i
    > 3 ? 9 £— Qfl
    I |§! ‘oP 1 £*
    . $¥
    ft '
    sS 7> 1 c H %; so
    CQ . i
    l.
    O
    ft
    OJ
    0 \ | Cb? < i R?
    1
    s?8
    I
    ^tl_ °
    H* F l
    *
    > 9
    o2
    it
    0 Ja ;
    fU £ - r
    y o, a 8 - i
    .
    iS
    m
    o ;
    ) O
    o S
    \J Q
    8 S 0
    ii
    » «- >
    C -6 <n w > :-;
    Q)
    u, c
    C S* » 1
    $ 4- -dB o W a
    ' ;r io i© 9s , <. o iK
    I p!-!?
    • i*
    • \
    5 c J)
    $ crt <* <Q
    W a
    fe
    --
    •• ^
    o <»
    ft V 24 IBMi
    *> 5 f l o C : 4
    Q $ Q
    /
    v
    QJ “-F
    > K
    1:
    ! j£
    *
    *
    0
    a “
    i f '
    iS » «| 6
    *•
    cn »o ”
    -
    0
    _ f S- Sf I i B «
    ’
    u &
    £ 5rng I? £
    * j) nc
    „ ‘
    c
    AL § -3
    $ §£- $0 0
    C •
    ;
    n
    co T) 75 r
    ~ -' "
    ,> o<h <n
    o t> c «0^ a mS
    n op, # c 8
    9
    r -e
    I ® 2. r I* 2 I n ?^ !s 7I
    £
    Q> >
    I I I S -c
    C4 ft
    0 ?i
    l
    c
    ^ i
    «:•
    _ ¥ 9 2 . -o J J 3 ? ffI
    ) ; ) ) Qa c SJ 3 Si
    us
    ^ sy S
    c
    5 c 2 -o $ g
    a 0 w
    Jo ^
    .
    C D P QJ » f i
    tS ;5 £
    QJ c
    £ in n 115
    =?
    0
    C
    J2
    ^ ?§
    rrN O Q
    fi
    >P
    '

    Is
    « lf I ?* Ss s= ^=8 ^
    C i&s
    8 }3 5 Q $0
    c
    c Q;
    Ki
    K
    1 J. C5 S .
    F ia > OJ
    1
    i
    © ) © ©® I5S
    1
    *
    $
    . -.
    -.•. .WiWf © : -
    •
    'T »
    *
    ;al®Si:4 :?:SS4r : ojiW ; V
    -SK
    '
    :.cs
    © . m \ Tfroroas kubn
    •

    1
    . >:
    ©• Book - jh>e sVsucfcnrp of sapo-Kpc Pevo'ctboo
    - V
    i: © op pasa <d fgros (f f%aroecooto)
    «v GWeo toe coocept
    5;
    : xs ©
    .
    5
    fcco-tolog 'to Itor-oas puho -even scdendfc 'toeorles
    • •

    S3
    1
    :.
    ©:c
    I os? ffrisadi’qnQs . fb^sodf ro iaa fOooe pHial -paaropuOosrk *
    ^ .
    ^

    I £ 9
    xyodignQ . toad 03 Qbo
    •
    r:
    SciQDUsa- also aoozrt coHbex
    ^ ^
    .

    x
    . 9. >
    -
    :$
    . v;
    1© Choose - fba- QOro > fraa <2*1©bog patTddiqro rOO/ be
    . v
    to oc6cD0T <TT>C0^ of -toe portion - MocOQ^ v
    I9 ^ r ov
    1c m tvDcrny qoe&tbos aoWcb edsPqg pa?rodi3ro ^ be
    • :E
    £
    9
    : ?;
    c
    able toaoscoer Lobeo 00 • of -s^ch qoes-Vtoos doasoase
    '

    eMstir g pa-jsckdibf ^o T3«>cc, Ioto cxtfte'is -


    -
    c
    e*tobqg
    I
    - * © ^ ' (

    pcnrodrgro unable do aoscoqy- rnoipvfaj pue-s old pa^a • fe


    S -
    ” ^
    ‘

    :l 9
    x
    % QOCO pa tf&cSip«^o O3>roes vote eblsHpoce . fastis toe coo< ep
    •

    '
    -V
    I© ^
    of pasoto qno SOQ0 S tool- toese lb OO qpoaiito/ » 0 toa
    ^
    V?

    !© i
    If.
    ©
    VtoxDiedge -
    .
    '
    1

    *? © — M Rsfr ecderoisiro cbaiepges b9 basic pwe<X3tees op "

    5
    5:
    © © fbaoctoKoocu (sno
    © [ ° obi^xsa 1 isro . \
    <
    ( •

    (T) j fouodcHi' ooO io >x> 13 bQ3<?ci 00 toe pbiloso pfy afscieoce?


    • C; A

    '• C' '


    toov toese ave cosiolo -fodo poectol pto copies <^cto cb coo
    © I be understood also- '
    toese ctoe teonoe bodcsoocotals of
    .
    t © InuoDoo ocrtase . v\ ^
    © | ooWe^soifero ^cggeSS toaV
    (jT) "
    toe^e d
    ^ to09s ^bicb
    <
    :

    9 I axe octoessaiij appncoBe one ^obtoo sbouid) be °cn e ^ /

    J Cbuotoos
    t

    : fvb
    a- soU
    ^ applicable •
    Eg- fso«x> -toe.
    -
    i

    ©
    I
    dbpse QTre ‘SOf’oe *igbto ooVvesscu ;

    9 Should be dvoltoblo tool! buoooO bei^eg- i

    © j Is 'csptspd h-j © Opcatons odlve sa ) (0 = of c


    ^ ° ^raN'fJ
    ^
    I

    0 i
    i
    © V
    •1
    i

    © l
    i3
    i
    9 \K
    >:
    ©
    © t
    :
    rt-;
    ® IH fc> 1 '
    fro-rdiog tSrio ovd &ir ,
    •;• :
    jo rioci&nrty ; oov se
    ' '

    c
    (s ? p*
    Cr,;
    m- I
    /
    gi GGVu'ye
    ^
    to on\ verse. Acooudfog to fts\ Modernist , (i-
    • '

    ^ ft'

    OfjlV Se i £ uO ChQQS - -ffoOce IS 0 SteUOff <n? f OOtveaSe


    vV
    ^
    -Gxpoodioq • Heocf ece coo not aVe ^
    -fxed roeoo'i ogp- - ^ 5 £•£
    - y

    :>£
    -:
    -
    *

    m
    I Difference In Modp&oisrv g. p sv f^cd oCs ' <§
    -. *
    t
    ^ ^ ^ ^
    © /ircox ding -t o Mod ernis ts -tbpse te qn o'qjec& jvQ
    tobichcoo bG )=OOQO objectively . oepirttj
    -
    droordrog to f &St Pbdooisls KOCKDedge »s ,O
    e )0cfi" . C
    :c-:
    if
    l e foosb of BOOCD ledge )& oot ofcepxvoHon v^
    ^
    Q pPsYeoce
    ^ •
    - 9 ^ ^
    £ ©
    .> ?
    1

    © >^ode?rOfhJ bos COoShsuCktl MeiQ - OPJDQ-HVIW


    --

    -
    rr

    ^^ b apos post - T nodPir


    'Multi
    ple jQTnrotweg .
    oiSro goppods local oowobves or C
    &"
    £
    ^
    ulbat- fs r eto PouoPve ? f
    v>
    V . ^
    ibe 4^TM> bieta DoTaative coos <oioep by i
    Ujota-sd
    if
    V" •
    /\ <xoffdioy tobptersd , Mefq oQaTsafiv f;
    - /efe a -
    fbeoay 4tat- bips to
    pive a totalising oor^opjpbeosive £
    '?

    vernoys events
    erplaioa -Hoo +b«ougb
    % various h&os op u-£e P
    (JMV Modesofty be1feves ^
    fo +te oo+boai g op science
    •

    3
    f &st Modeiroisro does not b0 ip/e +Jo - *
    (
    '

    Hoe autbo'Kftg of QOj C


    1
    roode of toocOiedge ,
    f
    :

    (2) Ho emi tL) stands - ar ooH &ssaWero . o


    ^
    '

    !
    I
    ^
    tonoscas P)g+ roodemisfo brieves t'o divessiby &, -fpcjcSa I ’ty . <:
    ( s\ Kiode&oitu coesnribes biesasetaj, d <9K C
    o-* % oeotesa 1 isn .
    m4 •
    fbst Kiodesofsro prescribes aoaacby , dispersal op pooep
    m
    ' 1 locolisotbo §• radical decooesapj - 0
    §
    (2 I vlodes nftg tbi n ts 4dat ofyjecfvj tg is Tseg
    :i
    '
    dised , so fcjed-i\/\ hj ©
    4
    •
    p is bod - 4a IOKS sobjeciriv ©
    M
    v Ti *
    : fbsf roo de Oi
    objectivity
    < &' 9r'o
    i s o o t p QSibe •
    ^
    ^-y bus 4o be inspected

    ©
    ©
    "
    :J
    "
    ]
    @
    ..VJ
    4. -
    :-:-N
    i:4
    •

    ©
    i:i • ; &
    1
    . Vi
    '

    c•-xi
    cl
    S3
    a Me o rvJ^vva fUf -
    C va^«->4 4hpoYie
    ^sJ ra rgfo'o
    a
    .-
    *.v *
    '1;V
    !

    ^ t
    © shodPxoity S\esods -{or O> ofc*0l -
    'r^od-e^ote^o Stands -0 * -ftsespbro
    :c "
    - •

    .:.jy
    ©
    | pi
    va1 ^
    W) dp©ewe 4BQY -tbe s te son°e
    ^
    tet -hjtrtb . and W one should -fay to
    ^aososodeo
    Wb -
    -

    I ©
    ;i
    ta ^
    post r*xxkxois-o oQi'e^e that eestjooe has l 4S ScOO
    -M
    3 m '
    H&u+b % e/Qjcpoe should l We acrovdiog to his
    CKOO
    Vsbth
    -

    J
    .3
    a
    IS ©
    •
    c
    PrcrhoeoV Thinker Of fbst Mad©rofer>o -
    is © 0 Foucault
    . • «
    .:.S
    # : concept of Ofsco < jn>se
    i ©
    •
    •

    ©
    Fbuoouit
    Lgotarc)
    ^ i

    '
    3
    I:*fc5 ©
    i m
    #
    He fs -p5Sf
    '
    pessoo -to e^pi i aidy OQPOHOO the ^
    W odectoily » o bis boot * he $5St Wtodpso Coodr -Hoo .
    He desrcdbed posi twcde&aiQro ^ as locxedu i ?Hj tooazrds ^
    ocrsra -Hves lyotend soppn s IOCOI ocmabves .
    !m ^ fo Qo age cohere rosto -
    I •

    :U
    I- ©
    C -' K
    Acccnsdiog to h*ro toe owe V \ Y» OCJ
    7
    ? . hcwattves bos/e iosi t-beto p o e o e r- e a o v i o c e - He sagged
    !
    . . ©
    c r
    \
    *
    te -(ecus on dVp&Si bj , loco \ cootptts § rout-Hpio P°iote op
    Ie
    •
    '

    <
    vi(QcQ3.
    ij. © (s)j Pgnnpd Q o
    :e
    t
    ©
    ’

    :«

    k
    V i*dq
    9^0 the concept op &?- co ostsu epoo .
    >

    I
    1: De- conshnjoh'oo COO be considered cis do A pp jroacf to '

    I
    >
    understood toeaorogs - AcoscKcg to Denrida , a
    <
    i f n ay have rooHtpip
    farfvcauv
    Ia ° rsooaoiogs Hu <oao taoguQqe 9 vs oct
    •

    5
    f
    f - c.
    Vrd
    490
    ** ' ^
    * Q {
    bat a plsoo
    ^aod poesCO nO'nn^O b
    c A cate ^ he coo enronouoicnie . j 6 al9o
    I © * ob3t rs ba'oa e
    dte otbsr ppxsoo ffpcieMcs evaoHu ^
    I © -
    Oi ted Hence the® can be ccxronou -
    {

    s
    1©
    ?
    I ©
    I
    ^ vocutfpie ihfcerp ta +bns oTtbe
    text - He suggests double tfQodipg ^
    SI © I

    I ©
    * r

    !5 ©
    I© i;
    m i

    i
    ; Q
    k

    m
    ©
    V,

    W'KWWs
    ^.'WW
    --I Qri -b' cte
    1 p v Modpyoiefcs ^ of o4-eoiQ9 V -
    ^
    . •

    Si @

    tear pc&r roodOsofsJs ecology te Qiao a discourse Or M-eki -


    : <.1

    ©aireo ttee , teoogb tote t isi


    'I’deolqgt'gS' I f Ve MQste3M>
    r, :
    '•d

    03 ©
    ClqirrjSto tel -foe oi-proarte ?n?m ?
    -'V
    .'I
    ) ty j Mvqrt: danned bt‘Sto- ©
    m
    ^ coi ^o-tena isivD as science.
    '
    point of vXeuo 50‘enoe te
    f &ora -tee post noodproisis m
    . i'i
    also a dferocisset tcooto edge. is
    .
    ; I
    !OOt ftee ffcoro its -fjoefeyo
    O f pOcOgte Dp MO.ftteSrO CfnQS
    '
    -lo estetaish tee pocoer of coord og classes ptbio&ts /?*

    -
    d»s(Da?sse e is to estetoi (sb tee poeosr
    of doo-roeo ter ^ •
    ©
    PS
    ,
    test Modern ids oV eCtivity s nfetep^r possible Ooir
    ^
    '

    1
    '

    i
    dPSbobip . ©
    ••
    • .
    -
    ,i

    -!
    } -
    l iove OO fbSrV - CDoo’O
    ' iSro - ©
    1 | test coiooio \ feM rs influenced by post ftedesnfsro • test
    fs
    CoiorHcniS’f'o epest-oos tee He eroony of tee unest citetob
    m
    te
    •
    •.v
    •
    .
    »v
    1

    is notjost Urovted fedo -tee ecooottec ^


    fte01' 03* -sphere ^ C
    '
    s nvbpr ‘Obicf is a Go pccval loot > n cu 'tasal sphere? focJu - £
    -t ding Qoodsnoics. test co\oniav is o eba j

    / t ^ Heogp ‘£bbc> GectefSM> £


    •• I lo /cadstecs - R>s+ Coloniolists
    coaot teal tee
    dftfoe praps living ;0 pst colonial societiespersp ective
    -dnould
    ©
    a-lso be beasd fbd- ooioobtisns is loteueoced ©
    by
    Tbeasy of koocDiedye & Pxcer- According 4o fbsp teacamfs
    *

    Qslooiaibii
    c
    te? coay 4bc soestexn coo id O
    pn? 'fbTsro tee pbeooroeoa
    '
    * described ‘tee Past fe not
    ©daocmd Sod Is Coo too as of
    pocoer 4#
    pother of Pbsv Chioo / 0
    :;:{;• TdtOo^d Sat d has cjiveo tee
    ' cnrsro -
    V:; *
    conce pt of oaten ten ©
    bbav rs ccn'eota Ws m^
    ?
    CRjIeokoiisrv -explains bo <o
    ^
    s
    te:
    uoest bos desnrided !
    Cor oteeo t tch>ao coesv desari bes tee east
    ,
    ^
    iS to -estabiisb te© begenoo-oy
    Past 4b© objective
    coast- ©o post
    Pdcoccrd sold bas gWGo tee evanopie te of boto Loesie ^ •
    @
    0

    bos ^givPo -the lote Hotioo of (slaro . *Ef fae ^


    o - ©
    KS ^ ^
    4PILOG tee ttrute o-bodt Islaro r2 athQx const
    (e COA

    jsadhog the ^
    '

    -broth ©
    ©

    :v S
    .<
    «
    ©
    @

    m
    Sv:
    '
    d
    £7i
    j
    :•

    I© Apoto&y
    ’ p32V schdcnr H© »o»’ GbQbbQ ^ gUPSHop khe
    CD|oo)Q1
    Mod©rHf ©S tCD-f of jootfb +h qgs lO of Binaries -
    1©
    $ m
    * ^
    be gives -the concept of Wy bddi'fj l O bis boot * IOQQWOO
    %
    :Ti
    dfl
    K " opaiitowes ’ bobopeb
    yfpwp is a pospose
    '
    \ o sgggpsHog -the
    ctesori
    m di Pfbseoces fast g <-oa s
    m© &i
    -
    Wes© fad Os al
    ted ag fProioioP, cb idi'sh, and Qoarboteao . * f>£V destehe
    '
    ~
    ^
    .
    "

    1I © l-<39
    St as ^sou ( "OP, Mato&p § Ovi n'sed - £bdh>e -damp of
    Ateteopological ^9300 -Vboy have, hded
    1©
    -»
    ^
    dorolooKoo of east by Oest ©dkooscj Said also saggea-
    *
    to jasbfy -the
    ©
    ci

    -that Knocotoc) fbe odPoh ^cas never -fspe ftor<o 'SGlan,or>


    I@ Of pocop^r - Woocoledge is ")ost -0moidab|© Qi| f<° of
    S ’ m capita 1 fs’oo- The cooy co\ooia\ biStcteans bcwe pleated
    ©
    -i ©
    -the east
    is -(as- fsaro top -sea 1 itcjt fbe basic poopose
    ODQS> 'to
    v
    @
    Jasb fcj CJV 111 si09 noisSiOO •

    ^In b
    »p

    QyqtTri Sp) Va |< V

    $$

    1 cv-
    ^ \
    /
    boot 1 QDO Subaltern QpPCt bf ’ £b© ScggGJf +ba+
    ©r

    1 © ffPId of acode rots is Riso Oeoftric Heo^e fbe pe fpecfiv«e


    ! : *
    Of be> people vVibg fo peri pbp ies fs notes? 09 . She also
    1T
    S
    :~
    © * be qaesHoo t
    ’sais s 4
    ^
    ;*

    f ^ -Obetoea
    4b©-) ba^e capacity -to speatte
    Sobajteso car spPflt <? ofl©
    '

    .
    - •
    /
    S.
    1r
    t o

    i©

    :v
    - v
    '
    <
    c
    4;
    *c £9
    I
    i c -?
    \

    |©
    1
    I1 ©
    1© .4
    1t © •>

    S
    © i
    !@ §
    £
    < -
    i
    I
    r
    ;

    O i
    f

    s© i
    r
    £
    B !
    ©
    1
    @

    I©
    E
    S:*
    I5 © t'

    ©
    IMS t,

    ^CCS35SSHP5XS55SSJSX- .
    ;C!3C®OBQTOei!> j9W *
    '
    •
    9
    "

    DEMOCRACY
    ft

    &
    O, Vo,
    m •

    6 &l )abU5 ©
    CDDiPnqpoymy
    ClQSSifOl h Theories . ©
    &
    (2) QffeSPDt Models Op Op'rOOC&CtUj ©
    1
    tv
    •
    & @ PepW8QotaEve c
    ©
    © fadiCipCitonnj
    AVI (c) Denbe&afcWe - ©

    Ulbg-Hs QsnQoasmq ?
    1 co>atjs ; ©
    § bpnoonpay be uode ood Co Con
    ^ ©-
    (Tj Mawouo Q&oseI letTo - P
    E.y
    DPnoor rcf '\s Gocsi'desed as bzrro op 6 0rcrrc> Qot -
    I
    ^
    © 33>Tfoadey sense/ Taro -
    3b Btoades soose Oerjooarac & togy of
    ^ ^
    •
    (
    <§
    ©
    i
    Qoroocsay is a feed© op cai+asi2 - ^ ©
    ©
    ® idbaf a*e +be co^ppopois op OgroocyaEc
    fuHugg ?
    ©
    £T) {Aspect (ps Huroao Oig'^ty '

    ©
    pesp©cE'og lodlviducutty
    (g) ©
    @ Culture op R biS. Tolesafoo , RaEaoaHsno
    . V

    v{
    -

    Vi
    i
    Accord 1
    ^
    oq io fa-dd ©a to Wa , caosh’+qHooa 1 fs^o QVXXJ d
    \
    £
    ©
    J
    precede Democracy . Cbostf+oHood 1 isip ®<®e Sboq ij
    -\ XJ\ \
    •
    i
    C:
    W

    1
    ?5SV §- -toeo dproocoacy sboUid be fot oduoed
    &
    CO nog?
    f -
    «
    ©

    i.
    What- £> CoosviHJiViOoaiis^o
    t
    fooetiHiWOCQ ismo \S ?njio
    ^Op laoo e» + o p
    . i Q< • 'SQP cxdo -
    @
    v

    ;V
    p >d CDOS« taWDOOM-Sro . ' Ef wca~e pa of
    , ©
    vj-
    . •
    '

    *
    cuUme % -Vbeo aoVe*2> \ *
    a Adait psoochise
    ' 9 ©
    duced - to ©Q^nd zav^a da abaoces op ' '
    9
    , ©
    -I
    Success op detoonracu Boreas© cobew cooevituViopQ" V ® 5

    .-
    V
    •
    /:.! canopy jpcSA Tbe ©osoo - v f» ilu*e bp ©
    -^
    3
    -
    * •

    gV
    :V|
    - -the -Third
    QATsf O
    ,
    Qtoseoce FcpnsE HjviOO
    Lotnd (fcejo fcrfes te
    0
    ^ - ©
    ^ - ©

    :
    •v

    @
    :V: *vSx4
    5

    ; j
    • ,W

    i*
    •i

    i
    a ; f :
    *
    •
    '

    v>
    T:
    gl f
    V9

    ro
    p.
    ^ e of PenoocarQ cy QQ
    t Vfrg 'iO «-OO<3{-
    i '
    ' >

    ©> WG Qin?
    '
    >

    •
    .ii © Huotiocjtoo , bas explained -foe -pypQosfoo of . Demanrd-
    lob© fo the pisro of Q oa s
    ,- S
    ©
    PJ asotuod the
    Cerocnraccf ^
    -

    ^ of
    @
    -|St Uiofy/e
    ©
    !
    ; ^ Is* wttve s\o^s4©d fo oGOtUsig . £b 4be Is* vJa\/ e roc®-
    '

    | © of +be (DUOt^'es of vOesterO coo d become derooss-abc


    . i:S
    ;
    3
    © -
    > Pf R^/QTSg VJgv/e
    ^
    : \2
    '
    3 f lb -tibe lsV bo ( f of ebb
    . J8•

    : •-«
    ©
    cecMfzy these bas been 0 xseyefcse
    -:«s
    v-Jave. of denoocsacc cobeo many Hno peoo n2 J.>oblos
    5
    »
    # ' "I tie Permonu Xfovq Postage) Spa > ^ * ' Qki
    0 come uodes
    :.' C
    S
    •JS

    «
    £
    © to?rsbip-
    ^ '
    °'
    x
    * © 2Td Kia\ e
    '
    ( nd ujote
    2 stalled apes~ Rladd uiQs- iJ
    tost f
    I#
    V.
    counties of dbe colonial ^ °
    c Do d beaSooe O oocrab'c -
    i
    -
    ri
    :4s ^ ^ ^
    ©J; nd
    -> 2 pev sse vJpye
    (

    ^
    X
    x
    t
    I ©
    1 •

    e
    2 nd Pevesse vOave sfvatpd v/e»y QOOO % uoT+b -vbe
    . ©
    QcciepHoo of fPO cou otsies \ ilqp Ibd ,-q fzn’
    .7
    laotqetc .
    i
    :<
    E
    *
    ( V-
    •
    • D©nooarQOj cb\\aps>ed . <3
    r
    ^
    '

    \. t• 3 UJavjCT
    5
    vH
    : P i 3' ixJave sfa'dod <m>*+h 4bs. Gotlopse of comnoun Vsro io
    ? c-
    t

    :-
    ?
    fhsteso fb»opp - Denocoracy became p/oba ) pbeooooecc
    © cQ4 4be e<cepHoo of Asab aoo d. /
    ;5

    I%
    s
    ©
    ^
    sd-ota ® a Je -the -tbeosy -
    Voedoao pontfaai ^
    3 of RcepKoocMis^V '^aab ’
    !
    !

    j@ cowcb noeoos a oc-ooy G OOV COropaf b\ . oCU-U ) - I


    |.
    I© JLSQnQ- ^
    A'sab BcqgpHoochu
    bs a discos me to P ^sKff
    ! © 4be ,
    °
    c

    ' . ,*4« « Monarchies 5 Ofofato-v 5 (

    oPfyp L ii?p -
    Soipc f Vn

    ^^ ^
    8
    5
    ©

    -w -
    *?
    ^wV * < 5

    1
    3-

    f
    ©
    ZTZJt
    _ . &ZL ^
    4ll
    JrefipfcooiG
    ^ve^ A sob
    oj
    pnm Cbave - HocO
    •
    r ' <3 6
    I
    i
    ?
    e?) of l:
    '2
    i© 1
    c
    \ K-l UJ — Juy >314.—
    5
    5
    : )
    )| KJov t 9 fg I
    5
    od I
    5
    j 2. WU1 - l 4
    »9 39 - a” sepi- 13 45
    -I © \
    :
    i

    i; ©
    1
    f) =
    !

    V11 i

    9 fi
    -f (roboiiSQtiOo ood DptoOOraty _ -gcfqre 3g j
    $
    '
    a *

    "
    rfl 02, 02.|W f @
    (dobcnisaf'cm bos inWoePd -toe no - of deroo-
    " J
    •
    I
    ;:J
    '\
    •

    J5
    CXO O'-05 MocOeveV if dcfS oof TOPQO -fhav GdoboMsaHao fe ©
    vl
    • -3
    •

    #j
    rti Deroora tic Ds - of Denooc odes hcsMP ioosP&sed bd.V
    • ©
    3 *
    Dcdd b' xdQtr bc!3 00+ beconoe Ppi-oocrabc -
    i

    -! ©
    Jbsepb <StiC|ht2: bos poiotpd VotOasds fbe “ 'Denraoc^aHc
    ©
    - 1
    DePcTts’ op -fbe lostftufions op Global govpjroaooe .
    ©
    Accordiog fo bfroy -Vo roqfe QVobQleaboo <Moe>te- LOQ
    "
    @
    V: have fo QdcWpos -fbe denoocvabc dePtcit •
    i
    ©
    David Mold boa given caS oPourArd rxx©de1 o p
    Oevooc^acy .
    — f OobtDcf of fhp ibeo - sij
    '
    ^ ©
    o
    #
    v.
    Globa i {safioo bos onopx noinod fba autbodty op naft'oq
    :- f ©
    Cfte - So far fbe goxjt - «o fbe rxafibo state is fbe
    ^bgbcef \v>
    level op oeoao csaHoaiiy elected aoof - wM+b
    fbe evcepKoo op pcJ uoHch has established deroacsq - ©
    -bcttllL elected
    .
    e
    / Rivopeoo f h&taroeot, o© offset cre bo
    -
    boa 3ocb ioQViHaft'oo - Hence, fbe
    policies cpre 4ofeo bu ^ o
    ©
    fhe SuWcTOCti § people do rx>f
    .. have Qcy 'o fbe f

    fWoulafior) op policies - CD

    -f to/d Meld bo
    e ?"S
    y
    © poposed ® gp
    • i cosroopoiT-tao rocxkd - tf '
    A:
    : '1
    have to have deroactfa aj of fbo Global ve ej .
    ;:.
    '
    1 Me has proposed ^ fpo
    Vlv
    lorg tew ood -sbaal few roeagj
    ^
    ,
    &3 -;-
    - lb
    f fbe long few doe hove 4o fbtet about ^
    Globa! aaob
    , p
    «;v

    ^ °d Global fbdioroeof •

    — r S ©
    ©:t
    ^ ° ^°
    © fPfdiroo^ of .securit^y
    "
    °e<s da op -fcx doHoUdro ^-epd^QS -
    fo taate ^
    - :i
    •

    f ©
    osJ cDUodl TP naare /O

    Deraoctfabc - I
    /3
    ff!
    !
    .i
    '•
    Ci
    '
    1 ©
    -.1
    :>d m
    •• 1
    -:d •
    j
    :f>-

    •
    r .f: ^5

    1
    y?c% m
    .
    r ~:

    m
    -.VS
    m
    ^^^vv;:r^crrvr^'^'V
    pqsrl \ Oroeof I 1=0
    I ^ ^
    CCfed WOgtQOOl (
    ® 0 DPooooo+i'ociUc
    that op European Fhd taro^o t •
    -^
    •

    £*
    ©
    Beedoro o -p fkess -
    S?

    :$
    s
    £ © (TTj)
    (2) GbpotY lodepPod^eoce op judicial
    V /4 •
    iM @
    $
    I © © 3^0rQVb0O » Oc( ncsDt X rooctfctc
    •
    •
    :-:ti

    \S
    I0
    5:
    qTfqas
    ^ ^
    t>>
    • Pencoc^
    ,

    ^0^
    •
    3f
    r:
    accj god D^elopg0
    •

    . ;:•*
    f© v*

    Q . Explaio Loi -Vb Trefeeocc to the deuetoperoeot lo •Ebdi'a


    •

    :' fc;
    .3
    re
    33
    @
    ?S
    13 ©
    •

    and CbtOQ - the Ptdahoosb p befcoeeio Qsroocpct cy


    /

    |0
    • fe
    aod Oevelopernenboo gca tbioh dpococ acy is a
    ^
    -
    •;
    :

    Ie pW? Cbbdf HoO -{piT d elOpprv OiT obsiocle fo clever


    $

    V
    @ lopenoeot
    *

    •
    ^ ^^
    I3
    Th© freidHoosbl p
    bppOppo ttoe T)ec©aGrCiO/ §. Oove (openoPo
    ^
    *

    Y
    ^ bae been a poctt-ee op do bate . ttewQ ( 3 inoo]ov debate
    ^
    ©
    WMD Lee kviao YPCO aod ApOCirshjC( SOD - ^
    .4
    v6

    f ©0
    •
    V
    5
    5 & —> [ Lee fbQsiS
    '

    —
    Accord fog to > PP UQO YPeO Xodfcx wenQctOS ,
    ^ CA Yo+Oo
    of Ooftte -filed <5YPatoess; tee Ttoasoo is Jbdfa has
    VJ
    \
    o
    \ © cbooQoo tee
    0 .
    V :i
    c.O'jfOOg
    Actmdiog
    vs oot conducive tp devef opotetoot
    pa+b - b^o, ^rag to Dencpc

    i < ioto locVfQdptfo© sbeo^ DenocCtfacg •

    © deefetoo 'noa og process


    •

    ^ •
    I
    .
    •r

    \ Deroocsacg is topstpxo obsesstop • OenDoaraoj cbeso .


    j
    \ Suit
    ' to AsPao societies . Aseq ^
    ^societes
    -
    f
    venues’. Aseqo \Jaiues ke BdPlt
    :
    Asear;
    ;
    4

    '
    ^
    ^e / da , ^esps c# to
    :•

    10V
    <
    0
    Au+bovi-tu I, 50CJQ,
    d , n9
    ^
    ^
    *~e > 00 Veto abdia toot -tee toroog ecau)
    J. i
    I
    f , \
    ! O 1J
    e sodatfste sDoy. Cbma also toot -tee <sociatisv cooy i ;;
    I< © but china coaid
    change Hs app
    i

    ^cb -
    5

    I5 © !i
    i:

    f © f
    C
    r

    1 © ( *
    _ t:
    i f:
    !©
    , :* 1 ©
    j
    t
    i
    m f
    Et:
    ! 5 r

    © to I:
    !'

    o
    todioo fkt^auorais do oot ha ^e dbe TdgbH "QfodseJ-
    ©? V

    m
    ior f b d Htoting ecoooroic cteJetoperceob He onsdos
    -b ®
    Meb^q as a Ooroogaacpc loader• ^Mi'ao 1tadas dooov ®
    © 1
    •* •
    •• t

    Y:-i
    ©
    "kite right policies , Hbey mtfogtf go -fox poputist
    ©
    £.V
    £
    '

    poifdes •
    ©
    % o
    tarty -
    Di'a ^oo nd , though oof c a?f £V derocoa but y
    I Vj
    tiors about- - 4be paradoxes of Ogrocaracg. Ibqse. ^ o
    ©
    pqxadoxes of Dqroocsapj estate psoblenos for stab irhy ©
    .-
    -
    V 3
    X'* ood edeyob pero -epf
    @
    Opnoocrcicy is abou_t roropql- i-foo, di'sagTree ro^)t9
    :c

    ® y

    Hocoe^x aoropeHtoo § Osogpoe fronts ?s Mt-ts lafe


    tb© cooftfets , CDofsoOtQtiOO,
    ' ^ c?
    Goof ids ibDpQCdS stei -
    «
    &
    bt !Hu . ©
    ©
    v
    1
    <9> •In
    nooaraccj scoiff aeftoo gets pRsq \feedl . @ -

    ©; © PQmccKay is $u \e by coosgof bot consent itsejf '


    * C-
    d©P3 not result into pPfrfbrroaooe leade&s QTSO ppqr >
    <

    -ftil -to boring such r©-f rr*o5 eObiCb c®e OCoeSScpg - ©x _


    •

    as -the -fgtr<r tbq -t 4byy LOU \ loose -He cnosQOb - ©


    ^
    ftencp, it ftaqoises lot of e$b ts -to achieve
    roeot in a denooc o-bc gpatee* onrk - Dspcocrcicy'
    develop©
    a
    -

    ^ ^
    exte©roe\g coropinx § dnnccc&aeg 75©g} o \ ts2s e>CpTQ
    > Q *

    effb^rp, rQ4bQ!r Hhao 3°St pu+ti gg Qoooe p?foa2dbr©3 f C


    to
    . vJ
    pbeg - ab QDtopQ isoo
    to I noocsrxaj ©
    '
    !
    ^ ^ ?
    ^ sAcHoGfocfes
    :'-•:
    b
    '•
    vH
    ••
    d
    *
    t

    ^
    PPS Xrro better .
    '

    ox
    :>X- r
    ©
    r:\
    (£>

    >:< m
    v..
    ©
    ©
    @
    ©
    I @
    i c*
    :- Cb>
    /£;h
    i©c
    m
    %

    1
    ^>^StSSwS ^
    ; 2 ^-
    5?K2««*SsSSS55! ^ .V'r5!3v5
    wjv*Aw: %

    —
    .- .w^^-vw. -•-v-".
    * ' '
    rsf
    /V ^cnrHjq 92o t
    1© /pCototog -fo 3 9so , Denoocfro <y 2 a pjrp-cood '+iot' .
    1
    ^ ^ ' 0 030OQt r0
    00 7 >
    $

    JOf - TcooonoiC
    •
    0
    *{
    1
    -
    :S ©
    3
    - or d MG5CDp9 no QtoO
    ^ 3

    3> S OOf toe ?o


    ..3
    @ 4be po«a roeter -fb de^e. •
    :3
    m ^
    ncHove of go H * o chioa to- toe ^OQ; O -facto bebod
    < (

    i© \ ‘
    '
    J© beta wpcoto Op cb> OQ fo pbueaty ^odi' cad'oo, Moot
    ;i ( .
    I* t
    '

    - § EducaHpo
    '
    '
    ^ been toe coasa'ous cbot' ce
    •

    etftos to lodesf
    '
    io HeaWb §- 15dara n • .so tbaf - cbtoQ
    C
    %
    :S
    © ^00 tof © cp -vb& Oppo uotops c eoGSQ'tod bxj Q oba
    ^
    to
    cxe
    a
    -
    :
    vS
    4 © \'cSQbbo • <Df cao be a ^
    onfoadeoce toQf derooosades ^ ^
    ?,
    do no have
    - 4; © ood : zreooto op dto^ lapp^osot As such
    .S
    ;l
    VS
    ©
    '
    ^ ^
    •

    ctonoacaa.aj (5 attoayg e oductae -for dove laperoeot -


    i: S © He- ofi' t&s 4bQ exarople op
    : kesata . 'toe CtoA - of tealc
    ir ® has invested fo Heol-fb § &
    Heof +h -§ pdaco - toooHob - toveetoeot fv- )

    to3!
    i .
    s
    V c
    X

    ©
    •
    •

    bQ5
    •

    bone better io pWPdty


    .
    hOo bas Gseaifed capob'nfHes to Qla
    ^ -
    I 9enderoq|oavi4y . Woaoevep TreducKoo § - - achie\/ ir
    to
    ^
    Vt

    v*

    >- P
    (Vv iovesfnoQot has oof be atWto toed enocbb
    to>
    been roacto ( o bic rno to* ua
    ^
    4

    Trbougb oppcftfuotttos have oaf fceeo^ crea +ec


    >•
    < (: ; • I
    CQfiOO •
    \
    X

    :
    r::
    v
    -
    ' '
    °
    1 Coofptt
    of too coroe § uoeaifb - Hd bos ateo ^
    ©
    i
    <
    Qoq u -^
    ed <3ojVaV to>def £-j Modei bos o
    sootji p? ^ ©3i h oessp
    • ! C, roof - mobile cpj bos
    c
    .

    actor*© bat Orel does ecTsafed pbysfcai fop


    = Q
    "
    «

    qppo^foov'Hes , <3to have not batoe bond edaccM-tOoaf


    >.
    «
    :< #
    >c.
    (oequau ' bcoer ttofb xpeGfoocsj^ Qendg
    *
    fi
    @ ’ bes § poor tosQito
    ca^e s ste^ Q.
    ^
    c
    ©
    X
    9s.-
    ;-:
    ^
    II © i
    :•
    f

    |© i
    t

    !m
    :
    ?
    6 i

    ti © i
    \
    I- ©
    ; »
    i !t
    i © r
    -

    ?
    © s
    I
    m
    © i
    t
    Is;
    r?? . ii

    1
    -W.if
    V‘ - . Record iog -Vo fe^vtya SSQ OOt
    . ;cfeac a<y &
    *
    @
    <&.?'
    de
    ueepised {or d^obpp^oPot buV ^siope^^
    - eov a bo V.v:

    ;
    ;

    1 needs to feederoocojo Vised ts otfessaty


    •

    ::!
    •

    Qtorxyoic t7i <oM> veroQ » ns feclaisipp - / ®


    i
    v5:

    Accord ioC| ^+ D 4rr)QvHjO«? <g££) these \*2> oo need 4o


    @
    rs
    'roare people -fr $btr d *oocaaty rotbev
    VS£7

    :
    • -
    tbeg G
    Sboy id OQ
    Toads -fM: dh^oa h OSTOOCSCL^J
    1:

    !
    ^ "

    Above discussion Qbc o fhat D


    toocaag aod dev/e? -
    :: :
    rAi
    . ' ^ * ®
    Voppmeot bave coropl iodteJ
    XO Ji

    ^ QM^zsosTaip
    v;4
    -M

    1
    1
    ^
    Oerooaracy el ftseif do^s oof fed HrO dQVQtape —
    <§
    p
    coeoi- r Democracy may
    Oswts trts fellengek . @
    s? roegt kopostoot daokom'
    fV 5 -
    s po » fticni d3M \. @
    ?: •

    Sr: toosfdevipg diversity f 0 Obdi'a 'tee fs oo


    :
    .-..
    r .
    <s
    V
    oRHbo Vboo JPenooczracy . HocoevP ft iSQfSo
    4bat Ibd/tx bas too rouob ^
    of democracy ,
    a
    toa Vtle Qf -sight bind of derooaracu . Democm ©
    'I .

    tbs sbfeogtbeofng of g-srtss Tjoat:


    cy
    •
    - ©
    <3 6
    e. .
    VA V

    -
    v‘'
    .

    /!«
    :;'d

    i
    /T .’

    :• •

    .i

    vs.
    .
    V'
    M
    W'

    t
    .V
    '
    e
    SV
    tv -
    £:1 i
    .<
    *::. m*
    «
    K -
    3
    *
    K»

    £
    ;tv •S' -
    .-vv ’*, ib.
    b
    too pos&vte Cj U0SHOVO
    PS Op 02 noGCYOC
    © ITxPO ^MacPbeysoobas given ao GvbaosVive
    '
    aoa sfe
    ^
    1®
    >2
    3 or ) vavi'ous models op Dpmoctro a Gs
    '

    Types of Qsnoocsa aes


    a
    >-oj ' '

    -3
    >3
    •

    :«l
    ©
    1a © (D Classi oat Model
    *-3 ©
    :M

    -§
    ;
    I
    .

    Jciaseicai Model describes oof deroac&aaj as Q p^jod-ji:


    but derooaraccj as a- philosophy . %e »9 Qse •too TOO —
    1
    I©
    If
    S :'
    <
    cdeb < o cbesfcn \ tbeotfL) •
    i

    @
    £:3
    a @ protective Model
    @
    :: e

    1i © Srbolccss - Johb tocktef Beotbomo


    Cenocanacy tSTteqohs ed pr 4be protec-Hoa o f ^3^5
    ^
    3 '
    S
    5
    I @
    :v
    i
    #
    <3) Pevteiapgnoeotoi Model -
    :1 Scholar- :rs Min - • v

    i-3 #
    fProoca CxcL) ie oecesscr&cj for envelope <^neot ofo p9
    '
    »5o
    1a ©
    :
    : t
    ?
    I1 c
    •

    I- S
    — d Classi cai '
    Modeb do od 0\ ve -tte &popedcai idea op
    1 f- i
    v
    5:
    vr, >*
    | 'Derooosocy toe c^roe +o Vnoe-o -Uoe values of De'roo -
    •
    .
    '

    !I. © Qracy -
    }
    I
    '•
    © (ft) '^AsdPiro theories
    $
    V
    S
    cr -<
    v fbese ocirQ. faDo ibeovt es
    I t•
    •:
    |^
    (g) f r-hsis ifoedstp
    ; f: '

    I Accord I eg to Hlf-hsfr scbobfss O asobcj V3 the. Tsoo


    ^
    *

    PM<
    '
    r. (
    *5
    4

    x Cy
    C '
    ! lotO- Masses oevens h>o\d pocoer . pocoer qtooays i res
    '

    :l

    1S I CV G\ rtes ©Ttfef 4b>eo y is also UootOo as


    •
    *
    14 #
    v
    I MadeI Mavtet Model of 'Doroocifag is proposed by
    '

    I©
    I sebuoepete^- Mavl f Model canoes D©« To dbe fenomic
    ^ !

    jdbeojry of denoooracg gweo by Aotbony Datoo -


    X
    $ i

    I:
    v
    t
    i
    2
    1
    5 !

    !©
    i5 ©
    £
    O I
    X f
    SQ
    s
    J
    f
    t

    i©
    5

    !©
    5
    J SS
    ?i
    ; ES
    i i 559353WS
    &
    /fca^d oy To scholar tbg tvxxv POUSO -role. m
    cob eb '
    I
    *
    •JCS’

    ' oao piay


    noasaQs 10 deKX> GJO.cy \S Tbe Q:foQ
    -.
    •
    V
    Of Elites +be©y is 0 iso Koodoos
    •
    ^ eS
    -Vi

    8
    '

    "©
    1 aoay of deboooroicy . £ ondPiretetods df> voocsci(y . @
    f: '

    vC - Qs a proceed MTST©
    i

    fra ajedfoo of ^pnseool-Q Vves - ©


    - v i tisfr -tbeo&y ©uestaote 4te oc oaf aspecfe of 8
    ^ ^
    Oenoooracy y oco jrdiry 'to Ktosrocsftvjo Qapgof 4be 9 8
    •

    ^
    Of Denooar a cej \s ens>pocO0rooeo+ of voasses -
    ’
    ocJi
    * < «

    AoD«drog Vo scholars> ccQStexO OJUoterieS aure ©


    1 '

    s
    '

    •
    ©:
    oove
    ^cob_ ? denoocsratfc fbao soda i ts{ (Oaotsles.
    ) ©
    3n soaansv rouotaies 6 MO
    ' '
    no i Hbi'c/ rte efids
    :>
    :£
    *
    --
    35 ' - ooe
    p
    A

    t
    ,
    pasfy. TD coedero countries Site <
    ^ .

    8
    m fTrack4xGd (g . Mu i tf pie
    m tfriGs fdsfes . . in coas^eso couo- 8
    "
    +be?re ? a a
    '
    Gfirco offoo
    of . e|fves. I NW

    OP Ptovalise Ibipo Cl
    S holq -r- poi p - f- fob|
    ^ ^ ^
    Typg of Theory -
    ^ (?:

    8
    (§) 8ropOn'Ca| ©
    fbeoxy
    '

    a
    •
    •• • } fVocedu&a i Theory 8
    ; :1

    lypes of Theories 8
    8
    :: £
    ;
    Ky I
    *3 KOYrro -HvG 1
    i fropodcal
    & *
    :p 1 ;

    Wbof you value w


    klbat you Uke fiha+- you observe
    8
    i fbilOSopbeirS i
    v /.
    CTdeaj scieotists
    * a
    Cpecnity) i
    f: 6
    :-
    a
    • 8
    :s;
    •\ y
    i
    i
    m
    1
    SS
    o©
    M
    :- : 55®S - .v.v.v-’.v.-
    V/ v

    ^
    SSEwSS
    ^^ ^ or'wS?Sv5vvvv5v':i??” :vv :5??i:s
    *
    5i v
    ^
    '
    i •
    !

    Types of IbeoviQs -
    i1- ®©
    - • yi

    <r
    •

    *Si-
    >
    V
    1
    © •suhsfaobve
    ;a

    3 procedural t '
    I ©
    Ts
    GI CHOO HVopOcOPynQQOf
    1
    33
    © •
    ^
    s ©
    3
    toca^rds
    •

    According -to pobQft Dabl , Oeroo&cxy potote


    cJ
    ISJ © '

    ft
    lotos03f qraops poffCS If -0* scholars _
    , „Careba -
    55
    5- ! © •

    > « SetetoS , Oe^P


    >
    . 5!

    ©
    1S ©
    >22
    :VrS
    -*Z
    :-33
    O ocqcy . (S c
    ^ is poya tohy - {Sr ** *
    C&acy ^
    |©
    :i*P ©
    -2
    • felt
    8borf Mate - PoVyqvcbcj \

    * V
    •
    © ) qtoby is a oaooepV glMgo by a fbbesf Qabl. fbyarchy
    VS
    :3 © IS a nocesG DM'SKC \ ji G> tO of Ub&ral 'DenooafQ cies
    '

    '

    V'j
    ><•1
    *

    © S
    y
    ^
    Liberal ttotroerodes are oov o\ igQrcbtos ©or My& j
    c

    1i © ideal dercqcracies Fb
    Csaccj ?£. /
    | yq*cbL/ is Approdroa ^-e OGPDC>-
    •
    -
    !>: ©
    :c
    Accord i og +o fobed Cobl , pailovdrtfes ba e folio
    1
    .> ©
    Z
    ;
    -r.
    K -(©a +qrps
    ^
    I o •

    ©. © Pu ^e of iQto
    t?
    V G ® PuodoroQotai Rights
    * > fffl
    ( prQeaod Fair elechoo '

    x
    s-
    i
    •

    5; 0 @i fteedotv> of fpsa
    *
    4
    :=e
    © (v ) freed or*} -fo fbreo asso addon
    •*v

    (S f
    <

    1* © do deepen
    1:l © IcxtependeobJ^d rad*y
    3
    5
    £
    %
    © V

    Jc 9 I

    Ie
    1a a *
    i

    i£ © *

    * ©
    I
    at
    © ?)
    t
    £ l
    I% © i
    *
    I44
    :s
    5$
    © i
    1
    !
    [

    * v
    3 '

    £
    c
    3 :
    5 ?
    7?7?
    3
    @
    ar& &Oropi& of poiy -
    •
    ’
    m
    Si
    mMi
    o •I o& A , Japan, rod to Canada \- ..r
    • M
    '

    CKdntiSS •
    ©
    Q coocfracej
    0 Mac pb^sODS Thecuy of ^
    15
    I
    ©
    Mac Pbesson bas skidted QU philosophical ? Q^opfeiCG
    ^
    ?
    •
    A )
    ;fe
    Ml fed ©
    v3
    rood els - If or) p$ai(D| rood&b oveulaalc fee OGsroafe/e ©
    :i
    aspecf Of _
    DpnOO cso Cc j, dd 9SlG3 rood tiate fee ©} Gv
    eropfeioai diroeoaiocs- ' ^
    Mqcpbe&gao bo© cDrobfeed feope-
    ©
    ©
    :i
    •
    ;
    dcai % Momabv© Oinogosiors -
    ! ©
    ; .4
    •

    301lent- feaferes of MDC pbe&sobs Tte>*y ©


    1
    © Libpsat i9ro ca^oov dqiro roooopcy
    denoocsaMy OVQX ,
    ©

    © The*© coo b© otb©r roodeig of CerCDC&apJ ©

    1
    ' •'
    :i
    I
    ua Those cao be S o c i a l r o o d e J af dQTooc p ) solgecf
    { p the coodi'bbo, single pafey basjot - ^
    ^
    ^
    pdfck/ ci&oo -
    ©
    ©
    Ki
    Gsaoj .
    (S) we e eo \ ©
    A ^ ociudes one party doroloaof roodsi os H&huod
    . I
    fo Many Tfoisd LOovld Countries - Solved- to fee ©
    aandftioo
    ?:]c
    •
    Thai pQrty ©ojops reaprife soppafe - ©
    ^«
    ::t . $
    (v) Aocordfog to rdac pb©©00' feeae avQ 'noaocj coeaK peases ©
    V,
    io fee. model
    -
    -5
    M
    i

    <
    ^
    of LOQ oyo democracies - feefeerr) deroo -
    Cisaci© i0 feek p ^eseov ffeno GF$2 not ideal -
    ^
    ©
    ©
    M
    t eop a
    ° lifeMao -
    © A°©OOCJI og
    •
    f
    M
    M
    to Macfb©590 Qy vMerooc ciCt/ feouid froaufe © i

    \ oto fee ^
    -r- :\\ enopoeoejrrceot • fees© G S© feoQ dl 'noejosi'ooc, m \
    \

    i
    .

    pocoer. * ©
    £i
    -::
    @) fxtyoefive ffcOigy ~

    — Mr fs CDe ^ve & (o oQfer


    ^ , tv )

    : Rrdrxg Someone ' do


    ( do tObrfcb ft be cooatd oot ©
    'Vy

    OMoQfcOfiSS d0 • a
    v
    :i
    (£) Peyeiopero©Qtol - U- roeans de ^(OPENOEOH ©
    s °P capadbes - MM
    5

    f) pv)OOp^ 6 4£>a4 d! | p^op^ Qre viy

    itQ'TtOn ~ i \

    ' oppoofcinfft CS • ©
    Vi
    ^ ©
    - :•;
    •
    -
    4
    ©
    '
    i
    M:
    Me
    5
    ©
    -i
    t
    ' "

    &
    S: i
    i -.
    •a
    «%

    © ax ) cOStero CouOiSfi'CS COpHEM i’s s bov© rtfyzixi <T )Us


    ^
    V w

    *
    '

    :1 © developsnQGOtert pOe-QCr as *^6IIQS Mcotf noq 9 QCHSQ-


    , '
    3
    I
    -
    3 © cfive pocoer - 5

    2
    i ©
    hove mother dsveloperoc
    &. © C>o( xacitvs obal Oor
    potO0o - d90cs, 4<bei «~
    '
    '

    s
    I © Dot <3£P i?tarsi or ) . dsroexr^ oe^gc, (KTO '
    C _
    1
    © pajpsi- cienriocxoa'Qs should
    O

    '
    I © )
    'noove +q ct
    . X
    Xi

    10
    :o
    cohesp OO
    body bos echoed VS si +aa Wor) .

    -'JS
    m 0 0) 031 deijeio p' >c><O0ir CV
    ^ryooe
    J3 peroentai po ber.
    : :S
    s8 © ^
    ^"oqzrtyq sen MQc Pdc 30r> de-
    •
    -
    •

    1s 0 C5Ba «ve Poes d)ov4o|c3pew>Go+-


    !
    :i ©
    Q9
    -freecbnQ . ^
    3

    in: «
    •

    © &bodHve
    : Ocv f-©> to x
    :
    !
    :
    © ^
    +
    Opp/ Ot |
    ‘
    :c
    X
    10
    . f;
    ^£
    93 "
    loo ya 9g
    - ioc%
    Otop '

    e
    I 0 o < y„ ! oo
    I
    :?. or
    ^
    0- i % a - "°A
    1
    I- c
    & 0
    ' °X !00
    I f -1
    -r-
    0 ,, ^
    v.
    Fvjpewa 0
    !
    . C
    1
    ^ <oei ! a,s
    t
    l e>%
    \
    •
    ?
    «
    :c
    ; 0
    %
    2:
    c-
    X. 0
    B
    %
    II ©
    I©
    1 [

    |0
    ft
    ;
    \

    .
    O
    I
    i©
    ye 5
    S
    I s
    1r
    IR 0
    c

    I0 ?!
    !
    f
    i:
    It >
    I © t
    l
    <
    >:
    x i.
    & I
    =
    S 6
    <

    e l:
    ?
    5
    © K
    ! ©
    c
    !v
    ?
    . tr..
    X-rra'i'
    E:
    I
    0

    n
    0
    \
    Models op OenoocKxccj f <v- -
    £

    © Re p^eseo+a ti ve Cb*t3oCXXcy DEXOOC^y


    -
    ©
    S ' bizsecb ©
    Origfna! -fbrno of DonocXiray
    +ioo § Hte dse of Toodero
    ft?
    .V

    #
    $ W. f+b fb© 0*otGb o-f popci loi
    i. \
    roplOX SOC/Gti'(p5 2floptfQ9QOfratb
    <2 cleroocaixce) bpConoGS ©
    V
    •'' 1

    ©
    ^loOyrbobl© •
    >
    ©

    -^
    A'
    ©
    JTS - Mtn bQS CBOSld ^sJ
    0!S +be OS'* besv -fcsro of go^t
    v , “f ?
    ® '

    ^otDfJP
    @

    tooeesW a'coai Wf eaeD e


    03
    v1
    & ©
    r*o\ pg ty ao-ny of rOajOSl ty Heat-P
    XV

    r ©
    0 fW © dQ00D-
    £ ' '

    ^
    ohcsMooge of ^p^ ^
    5 090 rr«.
    's^fox-nos °°£ °b
    .
    o oeoess
    by
    •

    Gsocy \Q bouD -Vo -eosoaO U*>


    gested rocdels of aeptfpseo4a.~

    ^
    <
    :
    -. peace, scholars baye. S<
    *i
    w
    £
    Gto^aLQ steoos Tbo*
    e Q®e
    SI-
    ^ ^
    •
    ;-
    w
    fon % inopTsoveboeote » o
    ft
    -\cco r*oajoY ~ noodels o-f Tfspse^GoVaVtoo *
    0
    @ Pei (qcHe Model - C-
    Scholar - Beo+tbQ ^ , dobo Locke - ©
    9Seo-KO-Uve S boa d OOP
    \ bOvjo ’
    According fo |
    ©v>oaic
    > ©
    Peedono -to 4okp odqpepdeov adhTsDSr Ibb *
    '
    C">
    • . f©
    ;A
    ^ct do db© noaoda -te gWeo by
    - s/otexs
    ©
    i
    :1<
    (E)|&^ii0hb2nod Modoj - ©
    : :
    •
    i
    .:Pi
    :i
    - ScboiQ'r - T- s- M ; i j i ©
    sseortakWes .stoou S \yx J & ao ooci roy 1o©c^ose
    ; #
    Ref ^
    bay © rsDomp evpedeooe of politics 4bao o 'ioccayj
    \
    ^ >

    &
    persons
    ^ #
    m-
    XJL 1

    ©
    m
    2r.
    :4 ^ fdroood
    fepveseotafves
    Qa-cke
    zreipssseo^ oo to aacsP +uo-
    db oob •
    ^ (Jr\

    # ; ;
    oay . pKiiarogoP is oot a plaae cdUsoceroeoV @

    of toco ot£*e<st i3r is oo < tse-etok on oaboo


    =
    ssV-. i
    : ‘

    i
    ''
    SQW 0OO peyspeGfv^e ^dooub .ebo? p« Pba cbovcfis -
    ' ^ ^ ©

    .-.• j

    :M
    ":J
    -
    >•: i *
    © •

    *
    -i
    ;;i
    •
    A?
    !
    •
    m
    :-fv ©
    ?-P
    !

    ••'• i
    kZ <

    i ©
    1! ::
    ’

    J
    •*
    TypSS 6p Electoral 0jSfeno
    •V .jj •

    "
    I
    ::
    ©...

    a1i
    •
    $
    © purpose of SedowaS Sysie^-o t

    i © 6^2pKGSeOtattV<
    o '

    I In ’<~oate <2)PCft’OOS
    •••
    res @5 •

    i
    JV
    ©
    '
    F'afe tw -KOO ncojor bjpfS Df electoral sjsfttgoo;
    •

    --
    .. *
    v
    ft1

    ie> Types
    Ii © v

    -s I
    1© ^QjOTltQn'QO
    T
    Rropor-hooa | '

    I
    m
    ©
    ~ plMTaiiHjSy^
    o
    1
    M2
    © fSlrope wajoyrtetriary) Single transferable
    v.3
    System sy csrvj
    I© voie
    ^ iprx>

    :«
    is
    •
    •
    — SGcbod Ballot * \
    I tost stern
    i
    .
    r
    © L Atteoative Vole Systeno
    1 m \
    • 'V

    3
    $ 0 -0
    :

    -I% ©
    * Single Menober Cbosh+uenc
    3
    (T) Major ) tar/ao
    | Repyesgoteitoo
    I©
    4;
    .
    i © ® piMYaiTk) gyStgrp - o
    >:
    Is Ekaropie - frlectiO05
    s
    c
    '

    c;
    )
    \
    .) robp \o
    ~

    ibdfa . ^ OV' S^bhjQ


    ^ Legis la -fve Asse-
    (
    /

    1 purai f-tg sysiero is loa


    © ^ Ts
    ^ TQoeo
    ^ve ft
    ^
    i
    •
    -.• *
    info LOQstOge op i
    M 1 votes -
    ®
    cs
    S

    1$ ©
    .

    ^ COOd Rallnl
    fvQnopie - Rnpsi'deo-h'a i SleoHoo
    I© ' fo France .
    i
    Oinofog Candidate eGgo'ises cfosoiote noayo?f\
    '
    I © Absolute KiqjoYitg oo-eans 50 4 MS ty •

    P p op -toko i v/ofes -
    I &
    ©
    cobg called as second ^ '
    (T) In sc case no caocKdateBaiiof
    9 -
    © senates absolute noqjcrbtg 'o <
    ig dbe ft ijouod of electrons
    It- © Tselaiopd .
    ooig top too cooct < dates aye "

    ! 5
    ©
    5
    \1 ©
    r

    i ©
    !
    j
    ©
    -
    © ?

    © t
    V
    i

    © !
    t
    f.
    K

    fc J ^ ^ ^^ ^
    Z SS S SSS
    ^^
    SlSSSSi S I
    «S5SS
    *
    1 . Q BecKoos as© cooducted fer The '2Td 4te>e bOKoeeo . ©

    Top Q. cood'da-tes -fois co’iil ati-to^' to- cat results


    !
    41g
    v.
    :: &
    ~*3
    .i
    2
    •

    ' Oto or candidate 9Glfoc| absolute fac ) orfiy .


    ^
    ' ^^ ©
    ©
    •

    »
    3
    91
    ,'d
    4 © Tfi isao irapwatefaeot ove# plqiratity sLpeer*) bud- p
    «31
    Trescjtte 'ioto eiectojrai {Stigoe - , oo@ neoe9se.ag -ey eo -
    •
    Vl
    :;
    vl

    .v 4
    .i
    d
    * 1
    ditu e % oo OPC QSQ rr&j ba&'cics o oo ateoJKoo raacbirtefc} -
    ^ ^ ©
    © /\ ITPY oaf ve 'vote Qgstero - ©
    Ekarop \ e - AJSMU'Q #
    _ --
    '

    To avoid balding eteGfong


    4

    tbe ogcDod t?noe *


    I
    ©
    Mooing candidate needs absolute nogjodty ©
    b \s round of elea-foos if TO candidate gets absolute
    ^ *
    nogjo -ntj -Vben The coodidates gevHog lease no -
    (§

    3
    -
    •

    ;
    :. J of votes #
    f; cOfl! be eliroioateJ -
    I te) aitecne-Kve. Vote system voteSte <u5rirf-te -these
    '

    p* fl9 b
    _ ©
    &
    'A
    >
    Tsaocos Votes ans© 'sedrstd bated acco
    •

    ^rog -to ^ i)
    oteor of p5© faience.. ©
    ©
    " J J
    ( ) Bropo vtibDO I Bepores© o+a-Ho o
    RlrposP - d°to Co roau© electoral SyStero ’ rOOirC roo?r©
    o
    ©
    1
    weptes&oba S v © - v ©
    © Qogte TsoosfeQbfe
    '
    1
    . i

    -
    T
    (
    Vote ©
    . :i
    Wba+ is tbe Ooi'goGi -ten+c? te? -
    ter geHiog -elected aaoaUdtate needls to gef fdotq
    : f

    "
    ©
    •
    i
    i
    \4
    of sates • %-*
    rVC
    A

    tc
    \V

    ©
    © USt Sgstev
    Tb ivst sgstero -env-ise
    couov cot! be seated as a ©
    ^ efnaie
    oooQHtueocy . Each party tail 1 03 -tte i,Sfop csodidat s
    1 •
    3
    i
    ^ .
    TV rs Q noose Tr^prebeoba-tius systero
    ^ ©
    ©
    HiodM - fds ~ by deerq ebaodote
    £|
    .i Tfie
    ^ On Represeotatee OeroccKxy
    <$
    .••4-
    .*
    ,
    @
    .: *
    is
    : .!
    :1 G
    @
    M < >,
    f
    j

    W
    © Cri fiasco of : P^psea r> toWe OprooQsacif
    '
    '
    * ' .
    - Ledu tp 40
    1a #
    •

    •
    foUSSSQU - os 02) 20 Pf
    1
    :v -n © A ( COYd ' Dc|
    "
    fQ Poussebu P’GS
    foghsb'^ooD oo' j cnfp
    “ '
    3

    c.
    l ©
    *
    once to Q fK/e Ljecrf . r^G oy ENDIOO veodeKS \ lYe (Sbodhf
    '

    1© M - KJ nRo , Joyp&akasb siaveyao toe ifo critics of Qeps s o -


    ^^
    aa9
    ©
    :«•1
    • <
    ^
    latfe Oetooeso cy §- Qjppad etfs of less derooc^o cej
    '

    1. ©
    fg
    5 te - OVeeb Deroorraccj .
    -s
    ;
    ;
    s © .
    i

    vsIS
    * %

    1.is *

    1-s 0
    J1 6
    §>
    ;;
    x
    3
    :3 •
    »
    11; 0
    I5 ©
    *

    I
    :S

    :£
    ? ff
    Vi>
    i
    •

    t
    ?
    x
    > V
    :>
    ? t)
    >
    c

    *I C
    •
    ;

    1I ©
    A

    1©
    IE
    ©
    I :

    I5 ©
    I
    I
    1c ©
    ^ !
    i

    |* © !
    5 !
    1
    [ :© <
    1
    1
    © /

    © t
    '

    © J*

    15
    ©
    ©
    ©
    --
    . -.
    r :.* •* c** v •cs^r
    m
    V*

    >
    rl

    £
    c (g) finr-bcipQtonj ' Pggooc5UUj - '
    1 r o
    *

    •S i"
    V » '«

    noOTos Direct Opnoocraty . lo


    '•
    Ai'

    --
    :,'d
    • O afeO ro£ODS , Ihwosioj
    '

    p^-sh dpOH oO of pdSpt®


    ’ ' ©
    iV:
    tex&CXtncjQ . Fh dpQto Denoorxoy q 'SO toeaos DQOOO -
    (
    W:
    •v! ^
    CBO fic C ceo oiisQbdn .
    ’

    ^ ©
    — ^ ^
    • •'
    i

    :j
    J •

    Why (drfldpQtovy penoocvacy ?


    ,- 1
    “V
    v
    y. t
    1 ©
    © Good ovpsDQoce i’s oof possible «bHhoa f pcpH dpa+fciio ©
    ^
    of people© fb^bteipoboo fos 05©s fjons eoaj § accouo- - ©
    1
    * r

    tabi i Hy . fhxb cipoh'oo has etcjaafve \iaue . ccbeo y


    ' ^ ©
    _
    ccr
    people
    I
    paTf+ici pate ; o UenooCBay Understand pc^Gsoaoce #
    &
    d yebp wspoos b\ tifes , 4bec/ Goo q so understand
    ^ ' ' #
    Hbe probieros to c esnaoce .
    ^
    •V
    £ Cecnaaracy a
    d- should be fbe oexf logical step o-fter -
    ep^eserotaiffve
    fv b&iOOGsCLty .
    £
    ^ v
    Mrdous sboco f / eodq Rv

    adopted ? o 1992- tdYibus studOIJ


    b?«Q Steteacsexcy §- Sos-tei
    I'SS sboto ^
    adopted Qf - R fo Qj^ordi G
    4P*p ,seb+ ions.\ 3, p <?£> '

    'eabie Dgye lopgr>o-eoi- •


    i'hd
    "
    /{
    1
    Qc Trepod- Etecororoeof ‘GVteeo CeobnC Qae&-r>aoce ’ ©
    V f©
    1:•
    Methods of Parfapatoty Oe oc&accj -
    .
    i
    i pe femodaro ^ OvU
    ’
    :i

    ft\ i
    VJJ/ initiative
    ©
    \

    © peca \ 1 to * '

    d® Rgbt to In ovTOOHn'OO
    -
    ^
    >•'•••«
    > •>
    S '

    ft
    © Citizens chapiters Sociol AudiijO #

    ^ ^ y- - i

    ©|idatcbdop bodies l i fc<° Hurooo R ipbts OroroiQSiOOS lOfcpQ / . '

    ^
    © Denoo era be QoQoD\^ ij^-tbo ( OevoiaKoo of pocoess.
    ^
    , .

    ^
    y .i

    to local (5cR woroeote)


    ::
    • ••

    5«.
    -
    -
    •
    ^ 4
    ;s
    rr:
    p<? bi ,cfV )

    ^
    -J
    -
    '

    opoio^ of pmpie
    4
    /
    pPfc erJcjrY)
    ^
    4/
    opo too of people
    e
    As <1
    2
    >*oV brndiog fomoQVC5 \oto
    _ 0od 'Og to
    "
    rOOke |QID

    :CJ
    m
    ;- ‘>
    s
    <
    V -
    PI i
    ;

    -
    • V 1

    i
    Fxpooeofs of fb**Hcipato*y De^ooCKacy -
    m i’ #
    s$
    1© (T) Rousseau ^dy cd-tb 4be pcpt-i cipQ-HOO op people . fba-i
    can be -pltespd .
    \
    :I
    rSQ
    © Qeoe
    ^o ) vO \ H
    I
    rs
    -
    @
    (fN fouodioQ fo4h *s Op os Oonsvikjboo
    '
    ^*9^
    eOQsOiogtoo coos csvHc o-f pae?y pOhtiGS
    $S
    t£

    1 c> .
    •
    1
    l
    ; s.- ©
    • *
    @ Qp-odb , M - tO . Poy 3ay pjfQMQsb i0a*OyQO .
    *
    (

    3S ©
    ( jy) CT-S - M i l l fas Hro Ofapcf Deroacaacy Sao
    •

    1© ' bxOSfe
    .1
    -4 fyjp? oepr^eseotobve
    § fs> <25?Cood i

    ss %
    a
    © Geojo ro\ o Ba-sWr pQtffcipato&y
    rSZ
    aft

    I ©
    derooCBOCcj (s oerossq
    H ©
    og -fb^ ng +be podblaVzQs oP aysSUptiOO -
    I-*-
    • V

    -C

    *those
    “ 99 soppo s of fp Ha*pQte'ay Cpoocx saeu
    ^
    •

    C
    ?
    ' pm ta ga> oo - ^ ^
    * of Qcboiq ^s <=oHb .le-fPfasV o iQrioViP
    VS
    3
    ibis r oc of * ^
    i
    c*.
    a
    ©
    ° ^
    fds+ia’pQ-Vo&y dehoDoracg (s knooo o.s>
    fad < cai Osnnocscicg •

    l
    ¥ :y
    © ftadtol Devooasctcy eoopbqsfe , ,
    * of *- e«ofa do1
    ,

    1 !
    1£ © ^A /enoeote §. cMl
    ^ society protests VfoC psoroi -
    '

    • "
    : scboiQ^s toe
    *
    | o, O ' hCQl school
    ,
    cSo Trefpr -to Pabecpoos befocgiog in
    I ] ^ \
    s © pQ t)0irroQs -
    -? •

    I: © Hobprnoas
    ;

    C
    bee <$NQO +fo? asocept of public spb©re .
    V
    t
    -;
    bos Qfeogweo -toe Concept | speech sttuaHao
    £
    Y
    0 Ood cprOrjQaof ve dCpOO
    ^^
    I

    ^
    Wbof is fjbl ic SpbpcG ?
    •

    !© ' A

    i® Q ' noeoos people coroio iqgethxpr enrtezbog tebo -Vbe.


    8
    f:
    discussions § ^ -bfynog -tbeic p-»ob loros
    - -debatesdeo
    4b> ptfop about SOM-HOOS. ftccb*dfoo 4o bbbesroas bbe
    .
    \ O
    TfPOl sb Gpgvb of Paroccaa.cc) to
    ' ;
    ocestesn couobdes ronoes
    .
    b
    !\ ©
    Public Spbeae - Xt ta not I pq l aroeot or Cbsngrcse,
    -
    ^ i:
    5 O
    i •
    5
    Webber io coffee bouses 4bQf DeooocPaKc cattpre
    s # iotp -evi’stcooc -
    Cor i;

    e ;h;

    I
    t
    ‘

    r
    © Ij:
    !
    © !
    C

    m I
    © i
    ;
    Ll
    k

    ©
    isv (i
    K

    t -r-rccco^-
    I
    ©
    3,
    7
    — > j MooCy l-7>G5Q§f
    rhoncg FxosGr Soggpst bov roa^gi no used sccboos. of
    j

    Vc- s,
    V
    • 1

    1
    \
    gbodid -
    ^
    4foeiir oooo public spb0s© ,-p> x
    tri _
    ©
    ':l

    jSodeby fosro -

    ©
    3
    5
    sbc bas> Co \ oo3 \bQ -terro counter pot* 'c ' .!

    I
    CO -»| Jacques Raoa'gre
    4

    . ©
    p]
    Me 'irecooopptudiisos -vbe concept oT p^n-ticnl <
    »
    fe
    c::-i I-#XBQ t-DbG VjQNiP 'OQQO aJ7 4bo rAdsyfos-
    ~
    , .
    cipcthoo (s Jfbttfti
    °J ,
    t

    :
    •4
    |4be ooy COCKJ Vo end do^boaMoo §- expoita1 00' - ^ ©
    7:1
    :!
    .71
    ,
    r :.\
    jOVbpr padfcot SchoiqsS Include Judt’+b Butler / cbacrta ®! ©
    /e / EVogt laclau - CP
    mb
    -~
    ^oufp
    • .. .
    •
    \ •
    J •

    >
    -5 Accord f Oy 4o Area fy SOo , fbd-icJpatosy Penooara y ,
    '

    *
    ,

    poises aapac/ty baiidip


    . CO

    £ conducive. environcoenl •

    7
    I£ i -> 3b case of India, ^
    -FbQf J3 C A • AC7
    coe can
    #

    i
    77 Bficd +0 acWw ite ob) ecf«ve because 'goob basrDOf Mateo ®
    ernoyb ^ steps $>r capacity buidioy a>f ffeptp . ©
    Acoeodmeot AO psovfdes -{pY Rsse^ct boo -pdr ©
    coeat oedMoo - pescs\Jatioo alone does ooV ecsutre ©
    M
    !

    ^
    • i

    \ pa« tic pabbo -


    = ) <s
    G
    a
    • 1
    '
    :

    J
    o
    !

    m
    :.VJ•

    773
    #
    P;.i W7
    V

    .• .. *
    G
    ©
    VS
    f:->.
    '7-7
    vO • ©

    *&
    ;
    ••

    %
    1
    Tbj.
    O]
    *S5>
    m
    m-2
    s:
    75
    >*-•!
    & :i
    1
    - O. . m
    •

    : 'Z
    ' I
    ;i DiSSct
    i* ©>
    sc .
    > OV) ^ ideq - G?Mbexovibo ^ons Dialogue, Oebab? O,sscc(ss?oo
    I>- © 1

    'fep (s no need
    • C
    •
    add 4<be 4ptrto dei'ibesatbye. 4n
    |© pbbjSCj' Pt?
    1
    t<
    '
    .
    6pjoten of
    TSQtNG
    - 09 of
    -Bsgo
    0 00 ( De
    ^^roc^
    Dejfbe - .

    ^
    ^
    .5
    ,
    VP ' to
    Hoe essense o p oenoocsau -
    - .
    1© 4
    wo bWIns In » «n
    P rn
    Ono
    Vtnoe QOOOOCYQO
    1

    *
    4* rvvaH consider as Q acae of ) S
    ( -

    ^ ^ u3

    ^
    1- © t b©s or ro
    ^ of cr S - Mill r
    . •
    •x - aonj
    Z
    Of
    ^
    '

    i5 © jo^nt
    ; jk
    i~s © ^
    'Dpmooaacy fs Dot chops toupcihou

    « ««
    about
    <» »»
    ou ;

    1©
    t
    X
    £

    0 pW
    P33f oF • ^ aPIO ,0
    °
    ’ ' r+ " * **
    QOUId R» hs> !rgbt 00 *
    -fehe
    *^00sit/ -to siieDcip +bat single Nofce
    nC
    *>.
    •
    t

    © , ^ wpceo f •

    ZT
    <

    ^ ^ fke Mobwroas Oovfd Held Josbua


    5
    (bbpr
    I ©
    ^oan, &fy \a ’ ,

    I© boraHve Cbrooc QCL) . Qeob abib q se +be exponent of Pe\r-


    oop o© -©be ^ btfpsv
    ^ e pooeo+ °f Osi <
    * © :5l ioG^atnvp Opnoocr
    acy {S fend£5 +h ^? A+beofan* SHstenoaO-
    1© Accord!09 +0 hfiro QpUbperQfi
    1? & ?fc is iodfepeo ^ oo & Oe/ex cx. OborobViry 'SOC© ,
    '

    siblp , prp 11mi OCt y Or


    I ©:> Ads-toHIe * any oG^Se Q G©or> •

    ?
    <•
    ©-
    f- o-rdioa -) people
    f

    !O
    •
    sqiber tbao
    Pbusspqq
    ^ do-tibeea -Hog DO
    expends f pbvosopb
    1
    f
    cwnvQ art beH jr
    decCefcn
    e v fcJOg) aotiog c^100
    (

    1 l. * ^-
    Only by
    v;
    l (,
    J' S deliberation
    ^feopoi can bp can be bnooo-
    I? © mu *

    1 >e yspp- esV


    1©
    >*

    * ^ cjdvooq op Fseecboo
    John pjcais ^
    of speech ^cp ^ressbn !
    i #
    I% © ib bis boot piftioa1 ifbesoifsrn Pa <Qs
    people borioy d Soggesv t-tbav sa©ooa \
    ^ <
    5

    I© Qt ra/0s-lqppioy ' tferoo t ^ dodbi oe cao^ active


    co rop»P-hersi\ G y

    t
    1 ©
    Consensus 5 i
    !
    I

    I t
    t
    I#
    •T
    S
    Ir
    f:
    | © s
    i
    b
    I© §
    It
    s
    I< © li
    i;
    < R
    lc
    !c © r-;
    r

    I© $
    rt
    •

    i p
    .
    ;;

    ! c
    1
    J II
    -
    : I
    I5!

    ^035^SS3sS^«^aSSS^^ -SS F ^ ' ? 5S 2vi35K?KS:3f 3S5?


    s '

    i
    4 m
    1 ArfXXi
    ^ja
    QQO
    '

    -u v
    - m pubic 'reason * ‘ .*.

    n
    A
    :• i

    3
    •

    .]
    •• ^
    :•V1
    Ar*xXf
    tdffboaf
    ^ Ooppotfs foe idea of
    * public TKpasonicx) sound policies oaona ’e«>ege-
    iSQn

    pjbiic wosodna soggfSb, pobhc debate. l- b big boob


    ^ ©
    i
    owj be SogQ^sV that coteoat public debase,
    > \y
    Uncertain
    ^
    3
    •yv

    Vi coe GQOOOV bosh QcvJerOnoeofcS to take ad-ioos- ACCoTsdfnq C


    1
    • - J:
    •to W\ OQ 4bp •ypasDn
    for tee necked- of public UeaHb fe (
    ?;
    teat Heate bas been roi o om pofcdc debate -
    ^^^ ©
    ©
    ai :
    fbtiic Reasootrxj is a rocde of de iberahtorv Q- is
    ) Q coy ©
    r.
    ofddsh' fyio particular position Hj U&Q of amsooinsp
    ^
    >w

    Vp
    public 'siposoolng provides Q°f °f asguerosots Obcl-y enters
    Gao accept - public 'reasoning \s a coodCtiao -for coeil order-
    B

    ed aodehj- Accord fog b> Anoatft q Qoo , following conditions <®


    - --
    .v ,
    roqoted;
    O?SG
    (T The Idea of fbbiic Reasoning roast exi
    ^ &
    %
    :c '

    (2) Pubic sphere should e ist -


    '

    ^c • £
    (P
    * X?

    © fk)pb dnomd have cppaerty . £

    a
    •
    Hob&aij#
    .- I babemoas has given tee tecorj op public SpbecP, carranou.- C
    i
    bcattve a cho<o & idea I‘
    speech Q'taat-ioo -
    -. J•

    . Klbat is deal Speech Situation ? 0


    (J) A situation a3be«e oo other -{diroe exists
    except -tte -fdrce
    ••
    :l
    ,. 1 &

    i
    _ of aisgucnoeot - £3
    ‘
    :Vl
    .ViI (ID) Ad have equal argfbt to speech-
    : ir DI A\\ - have -equal chances fo present Vbeir -thoughts .
    '

    : v
    :
    •d

    --
    © Whatever ideas Q^s being presented should be booest §
    r n t w i.
    -

    -
    ry
    VW•
    . :!
    ;- - d
    .

    (2
    -. 7 !

    I
    rm+ m
    m
    %
    m
    . V

    t
    v. -

    %
    m
    m§ $
    ^
    : :o
    5

    -
    ii r; p_ /«‘
    ^-
    vCv 7
    2yrrou ofcofve ad-bO pEOpfe to XcJsai speech sh-uaHoo
    :)
    !
    :
    '

    *
    -
    '
    ©
    , S
    o
    (
    ^ '
    TOO
    CbrorounfCUK'QCj ondGrstaodi 03 63Ch otbeh
    .coBao rabie
    ' ^
    to 3!
    (

    -1>2M

    :
    £Ocb other.
    1
    Hannah /\tfer>dl
    .4
    :*is ©
    l
    a
    ;
    #• Hannah A*eodt is Qlso S^ ppoAer of Defbpsafve Deooo -
    4 '
    c <5aaj QS she enopba-stee 00 -Action 5.
    f
    .. / . •.

    io
    ‘
    a
    • ; i •

    Joshua Qsfoen
    c. \ I

    I © Jo nua Cbhen peitbe aHve


    ^ has given S of ^
    '
    ejenooots
    vts
    I r Denoocsacg ;
    J © 3> i3 ao independent §- ongoing association of pGopte
    ?S
    : --SZ
    » C2 ca'4b expected cootiouftg -
    - tf @ f op\e accept - that- psi{ be«a -Hoo is the hsdd t eg fa <ao
    ^
    •

    Ix.
    *
    -C ^© (o fotfoouiciKoo of locQg §
    poi fetes
    m -the
    2 •
    *
    V « NiO*v ctterstVe eevi roocoooV obeo each p0sSDr7
    -a ©:5
    nrecDgots©
    •

    1©
    C£|pacfty of toe
    other -ha speaVo V V

    : 2<
    is a respect
    ‘
    8
    •e
    © / rv ^ for p\uaau' G«D of va tues .
    :S
    &
    I
    © © -
    OSJibosa Woo (3a aausce of tegiti oocxcg .
    ff
    •
    $
    - CbhPo has alsogWipo
    3
    £
    '
    r/ foiioeOng advantages,rb*
    !-s O CD Best coog to dOql tOf +h dteogTSQeroeofrS -
    <
    5
    -5 ( 2
    © Bad- coay to secure toe fsgif ^oay of <DI leefve QLCKOO .
    c © Encourage fbblic perspective oofbb\ ic rssues -
    V (hMSeHer policies
    c © fhbiic QducaHon .
    *
    t e © DevoJoperoeot of hust i
    l v
    K
    CJ
    « @1 A tocy to Vooco oar genuine -fexeo ces
    g
    er fre
    ' ^ ftbooiog d-enooctojuj .
    S
    A 0

    ^
    :
    :>
    •r
    -
    © Vc enlarge OUJ unbexS-bodtog cf tbsae. .
    i
    >
    «<
    n #
    (S

    fi Ci © It: ^oQhes denoocra-cy ccmso cia-btonal t


    <
    ©<V
    '

    © Deliberative doco© is centered 00 Harcao dCg^tg - XitS^^


    • 1
    t
    l
    ;
    :
    ©
    prfahhj -todebate ever choices-, discussion ever vchog. i j

    !
    S# V
    '

    i © l
    5
    li
    0
    0
    o j

    © p
    :
    :
    L1’.
    0
    .

    c
    Co oa'aV;00 ai - actio < co\+n roo - .*.
    0 ^ 5 ^pnsMS 2SS5JASS?SS555. B
    (S?.

    t;
    V -
    RIG- HTS
    SI
    a
    :l
    r.i 0 HPaoirg
    © ^ Theoies
    f

    l 1
    !

    m
    m
    •
    «1 @ Cbncept Of Human fights
    : VX>
    :!
    i
    -Jbtraduction
    Rights of MOO a concept of modem times. Xh medieval
    \S s*r?

    roes -toe \- heo-xy of device ^rights of toe t gg ccas


    •• t- \y

    ^ ^
    prevalent - P btS bQbrg to the liberal disaDU*Sto PB^ts
    ^
    v3
    23 ©
    a&Q coosbecred as da f nos of GCSOOS Accord fog t©
    ^
    .y •
    . .
    <:
    DoOOTfkio , Rights a?e bumps - roeocs Rights osse dai*ns
    V

    £
    cobdb cot l have priority ove* a I! other dal ros- fh-ssor)
    '
    I
    '
    -
    enjoy sight eobeo ether perform duties - #
    ©
    “V tt'
    St
    J- Theories of PfobtS
    l (T; Tbeoxj of Maternal Rights
    &
    if is a oldest tbeovy op eights •

    qnQb-ls acre
    \
    .I
    j According +0 the Theory of fda +urai %
    given to roan by oQhjrP - MQO \s , - , bo?ro <G>fffo the Yjghte \ (5
    - 1
    they c^e integral pq^ f of the pes -son a i <ty of toe
    •

    C< :

    -
    Tteovy of Matobai PQbt Ur oT-f the scope of Staves action -
    ere of the earliest exponent of Tbecny of tia +usa ! Justice.
    <&
    S

    <h
    ~Z

    S Tohn Locte - Ute oon also weoHoo the TQ« e ah


    '
    t
    : ^ \\y

    ;
    :l
    Thomas pQ loe . >
    ,
    ft!
    tti
    •i
    According to the tbeoa-y of na+aaol hrigbl-s, into!Hon ov ©
    J
    .-V.
    ! - reason Totbex than ir&H -VaHoo is 01 source of r?jgbt • n
    «v
    .
    If CS a Bo She SVroogeef 4feeo«-) of dgbto - 2> IS Obo -the basic
    * :

    Of hurcOO BjgbtS - ,v .

    f
    t£
    ft
    ©

    c :, /

    Pa
    xS.-
    •

    x- @
    sy

    -:
    “ XV

    ::::::
    s

    :i
    B-53
    n Oritidbro of Natural P&bis
    v
    0
    ~ *
    i
    *93
    •3 »
    ©
    :•« (H Theory of legal Rgbts - !
    5

    :
    *©
    $
    -v
    <gtits oHlftQYiao Theory -
    '

    i©
    S :
    <SOpp6 v|: Scholar - Pen-tharo .
    o»S

    1-.
    • :r
    According to Beatbaoo , fights p*opeidJ/ the csoa toons
    £r\ of laco- /recording to hfnr) Natural P > bts are coo sense >
    I
    .£ y

    S nonspose opoo shits


    /
    0
    :

    i
    -X ©
    ••
    3C
    £!
    -
    -: r
    . According to bi«D, Ktataral
    i i

    Mataral Tights Tesu ts into


    TQWS is a tf *roriSt language - 4
    Anarchy . .
    '
    ;- A
    23
    ©
    t
    m
    :-s0
    Bentharo sopporte Hobbes IOO TrnadtaHbo • According to
    X
    Hobbes moan cannet enjou Tjmbts io ttoe state of MaVuve
    i m 3b -the ato +e of Mature noi u
    -
    •

    bV fe P'0bt - pn£j coheo state.


    0

    I©
    ; ©
    i
    :
    '
    (jomoes toto

    real source of spgbts fe slate MQO


    -
    ^
    existence , ^OQO CUO eo)oy T bts - H60
    ^ ^
    bas r> > liberty ootj

    .
    i? ©
    •
    :
    cCbese \QO VS> sheet - si^o'i aciy , Ge otherc ; *
    "I ©
    2
    • 4
    '
    Aoa-rcbi ca ) foilaq'es QrvWcised the toeo
    ’
    © o bis boot
    -stj of oaHiva) ai bts
    !3 ©
    J

    ~
    ASSS^Hng t Abte egaioa the s t«?
    io tt>e society - fhv Becrtto, the* ^ «Bsa > t w 6 chaos ^
    : ©
    !
    :>•

    *:: ^ real aog^rce of tri,§btsis


    Slate . Rights against a stert<?, right a ios
    *
    * Q & &
    of state carrc| o
    3°- * * **
    1 © ° roeaoigg - ,

    o ® Cooggyvafve Theory
    V

    c Scholar - bbrooocl Qu |c
    According to fdroond Qu* l
    A £
    I f :-
    <
    •

    physical QbStTsaGh’o ^^ / rviatarai rights qr© roeta. -


    a ©

    4rAS* “S5£r «tsr


    1 of Natural
    I ©
    . 2
    Source of
    1s m
    K Mo on© cao
    C
    o* © QCOOiOioQ to tb© Hbey Ore noV
    >
    custonos §. f adftbos -
    1 m ^
    1©
    Sr.
    :
    J
    1^ ;
    :
    :
    1O
    i
    ©
    6 -
    IV i
    i t
    i © ?
    V
    c
    8
    I
    I© i
    5 f

    ©
    ( bf
    ©
    5K5S??-?3¥-??vv-5?
    'G31 theory
    MO Ol Theory of Rights / Teteo!cg\
    fee;
    'vS
    *3
    1 * /.V :

    Scholars - Icoanuet Rant , T- A - CiVeen


    IV '.
    i
    i
    -

    1
    5

    -
    Atcord '\ 03 to T- H Qreen . fhp argio of rights » Q « 0 -the
    -
    i
    1
    Sense of gbt £ covoog - Afcordifg to bito, Human
    ^
    consciousness postulates I' bestcf Ubeda involves
    @

    .:- •!
    v i ^rights - M
    ( jv) FuncHonai ThepYL) Of Rights - C:
    J
    A
    !
    Scholar - ioski
    ys
    s?. According to b\ no, Rights § duties ass interdependent •
    . ©

    «t Tgpes of Rights
    m
    Qj CWH fbufcal Rgbis -
    1 (H) Sbdoi §- Brononoic Rgbfs - >

    i
    W:

    £
    4 Right to~ £duy food, - .v
    i
    <2
    % ’
    *
    - part Tv
    ••
    •
    @ _ Huroao_Rgbte_2 e
    l
    5
    Q_.| Discuss Wous debates <otfb Wspecf - to human Rights
    r .
    Xv

    ( .! cultural perspebhVeof Rgbts - .


    <

    : -!
    ^df Value - piqraiisro - V .
    .
    V V

    A
    (•:•
    *'

    Q . GeneTO Wons of Human Rights ( taraf vasef) v>


    -

    —
    •
    i
    • •
    ’< W 3 QeoeraWons I
    tv
    (T) avi| fbiftical Rights - to- -
    • ! W-
    CD Social §> Hcooonoic Rights
    ••
    1
    1
    S
    'L ©
    f.-:
    • i
    ' •'
    @) QsOup Rights
    - Outural Rights
    ;
    •;

    ,
    - bevetopenoeota Rgh+s
    •
    i

    V '.|
    W: i
    vd fig
    -vJ

    m r
    ©
    0
    0:
    3 ©
    V:1
    ? a $
    i Wv

    ;3 - ft)
    g§
    **i
    y .-.

    J
    C553???S55SSJ! *33S
    trevr m55SSS55S3S3KS^^
    ::> -V-vv '
    % *

    v:a

    Mm \ dhat are HUPQQQ


    sed os -tose tfgbts cobicb an Vxi -
    0

    (Dos!dg>
    Uarroo f h-is
    ^
    Y3
    :r. 1

    .-':3
    ©•

    noaoS Should posses issesppcfue of


    ttaele casve coioar, /*
    a
    a ©
    sac© csp d , oo+i'ooa i T+y , Hunoan Q/0bls should bo posoe -
    -
    . a
    '-
    -a '
    •• id
    £v>
    • ^/

    3
    52 seed eqoauy ioy an bunoaos tp coe ta ^e oat 4be duooeo -
    m
    sbn of ©qoauty toe ctest-so 4bQ Bed of bawao dgfete
    m # -
    :u

    IO
    :VS
    3
    tf ro©aos $coe cvs© ti ©avieg ^
    ^
    epoo on© css tess tbao bcJLnOOOS
    I
    :r
    © $ Huonoo R.{0bts have 5 faodanoeotatI feafeJf*©-3
    "

    I© fqoa i rHj
    5
    c;i

    c5
    (UJ uoivgnrsonty
    43 © 53 Idaiienabi life/
    (S fbrnoonaooe
    1© Lecture 41
    © rbjdiv
    ^ duaiit
    --
    •

    re
    5 ©
    £
    •
    •

    0 ^
    Higfortj of Huroop fights
    04-102- 1 2-Oiq

    ©
    It© idea of Poraon Rights onoesaGd afe*'
    exposeace.
    1m ^ t 'Se
    1©
    :! •

    ::>:
    :5c
    •
    A

    £
    ©
    ©
    OF Hftieis AtocJKes oc Tecs - a
    oopd +o dilute -4b© concept of S3/©se\gbtL/
    state -tales Qcoau 4b© siabts > t decodes
    ! io\o« Cx3
    '
    u a , orfrtKLc ,
    ’Hboal QDrooouoity -Vo protect bu>noar> pgot
    ^^^ . .^
    ’v »
    poo dr ty o{ ^
    nas l© j
    ^ o

    :r- ©
    1
    | c.
    "io 4he obiV
    0rSQ\ dpclasafoo of V-feJtOOn ( btS or>
    ^0 9
    ^
    .4
    V
    • )
    Htbcoo RvgbiS 'GOf-os faced
    oppeej-fbo -fbo«4)
    1© COuaLdPS - COrorouoieV ODU>OW£S bQ \ e^e 4-bcu Hooo^O fgbts &c
    I

    1& fidpdeso pBopoQQodo fee fotesveo-Hoo of paaoestic a -fjefas.


    2:
    oF couabtj -
    I ©
    I©
    i

    *
    -X

    ©
    dodcra-Q HDr> of Harooo
    HT-tie^s
    •
    4'oo - set
    ^ of
    of
    ^ ^
    bte 10010404 i© or>M4ssoi
    PQhfts c^e based GO exp©o\'©oces o f
    Q.1^0 » O OOHQ also
    rs< basad GO fbiiosopby of Ubeira \ ?sta - u bGSaifac g<2 s
    '
    K
    v.
    t
    #
    pssocjoted csfd) coes oisatdo • Hpoop. goce ) ©od©ssof
    ^ *
    2
    1 ©
    4be deveiopir
    ^
    cOGdd paued if as cu Hra^a > XOQPSDAIMGC'o. -
    ^^ aseao va u
    i
    x
    1$ © i
    dBfd called - jr < ©S -
    5
    i< m :

    i
    l
    J 5
    1© !
    ;.
    j
    :
    i 0 !:

    | & I
    !,
    t
    )
    c
    © i
    i

    V
    6
    ?A TKy b&d 4ba4 COPSIOJO values a$Q oo{- su M bi© ^ .
    -gr
    > y
    A
    >A OQO- coestoo sotieM &s
    0:

    1
    i
    A\
    0Ot-{ R. aod +^0 eovoDQ rfcs
    0 CoMPnaoks oo cJVi | poi ’rtiral Rgbte
    (B)OKpoaots oo Social §.&)acaf?oooi
    - R
    m
    @
    ©
    TBis +bspe
    410001 , ,1
    (
    ciocciropoks 4oQ e+b
    ^^
    yrocoo as ®b+©roa -
    s s cxse
    bsts - Qosiaos Q bcve- cSoca 'nooote -fbe?soQ«&
    conv o+iors wgso logons ao 4the wb-bte op roioQTl®
    ^ bte

    C
    -i-r i
    '
    ^
    3, oefa ps , cooroon , cb'ild’Qeo Gfo
    I ^ ^' - COnoPS <-> odar
    4he QsooiOg otPKOChfenoJ 'sppiVoe of Haoaao Pgbts.
    @

    PCJHbooi pbofs - KQVQ 4b2 nog}or 'BSspoosiVdi 'Htj ersuPa £


    for
    ^
    '

    ::.d 14U«X!O RQhis "to doroesbfo- Sphere Ibo #


    I UiO bodife prsonoineofr beipg UkJ Huoroo RQbts COCJOC| ) i
    •

    ^
    :> odsos a cOoicbdcg bedy a v©s/ tV of otsj ef £*rte skte
    ^
    •

    s
    VXVG Qbvfebod NJQROOQ! MUrvxx)
    ^- cOr^ciro’OSiOOS-

    XokPrno HooQi osirovna) axKf esta biibbod cjodex focoe e


    ertate fs a6o dbe -essooHoi
    ^ .
    rorerp^oeob Op CrtofcQ| WcJorQri
    pgbte fbgjooo . Artovdicg -to A'^oQvfrja s&o, 4be_ aoocepvop
    C
    <5
    +4uroao Tr’gvqtsr)s> ambiguous oocep’r - , w U
    QS6- Jclsk ^*00X3 ua1ao1:0ps • WCJ^ ^ OO Rgbts r
    '0 ''

    rOQO P gb$ S Qgi no© SG-ffjb


    ( S * "

    '
    £
    ^ or° cbaUemps, C3OQC£ 4IJOI QS toeu os
    :!
    i

    CbCtlfenQGS
    Cbooepfuai
    - I
    cboligo P5
    ^ tosbtobooat
    L* '

    5.V - ^
    ctb+Pir>o b'or» Q ) f cOror^o u o ty bqs
    ' ag 'segrosoV on ao pSce -
    /53 ’

    '‘
    ::j

    •*.•
    4baw 46Gy | ac
    |
    -
    SS.ibj op 4be profscPoo oP Hu r»o P )Ab4s txiW fc oyooc3
    *
    c cooseosos• itoe feoo Gaooaos«3 eveo
    '
    Li ,

    ( ^- '

    \i - Cn 4be cdG44 o\ 4ibo of parados - for Scsnoe. ol \ sfccuid be g


    A

    ,>!
    CQo&i dared
    as, Huroaos tbbs.xecs
    pevegore Co'^orof
    o4b rs fsv^ow'
    ^
    osiroes o osk buraarovtp
    —
    \. ^fYg
    nudde do oov dGsGro© 4o be 4»Sa.4Qd ae. bmroaos-
    ;

    ^ t
    P? !
    «}
    i
    ^ 0
    V
    i

    e.:
    -
    1
    i e
    *-33
    : i
    ::i

    i t
    ]
    --
    ,i':
    A;
    4:
    s 'bssp oo dePoiHoo of
    '
    -SS
    V£J
    £S
    0 i
    •jkpre f' CN&T
    1
    -
    I
    3 ronsts - ' JbQxQ Is 06 CQnSPn&QQ as to cCbeo fKlroO'O
    '

    0
    :.r3

    vi£ ^ shbtS - !tCbP*0 it -slosfe »o the coo«t of -the /sxHb0


    I©
    I Dr a-ffor fc>hdb - tbfsf is a disa se© roeol bepoeeo hbos <
    ~

    .1 ©
    -?S
    tOho de>coaod pight to r\bovHon §• dbase coho c^re ^
    r
    : i
    -. *2 # ogaiast - ibPfp ie> no »3 tree noeot 00 Basic atgbts cOhJef -
    ; «
    0 ODo be caoSidP^rd as Huroan fights ©30 toostero rociO-
    : £;•

    *f J
    tdes P>gbb -to U £>, libedy § ptoperty ,s -He rocg
    £
    10
    1 -fqodanoPotal ik© CHOQ
    .
    these.
    •
    v
    *
    1
    « © but ip otiOhrvPS \
    •

    *
    Tsigbts are Qougoovse Q0bte § social - BDoooofe xigb-te ^
    I
    SB
    .-:»
    :S
    •
    c
    ^© have o period -ty . At pssasect asuovsnes n‘Ve cbsoa fran,
    0
    5
    .
    *2.
    • Puss‘6, Mo ) ,ia look
    dve Wunoao R£gbts as afenDpte for
    I
    -
    -
    'tfQzj roo, cbarx
    ^
    C

    I 0 Q
    %
    Tfi9fe ore problems 0 the Gbooeph of Haorpu-) Pigbbs os.
    1©
    1
    '
    ©
    tbQ* bode to tee Qvofiableto Hurogos C es ObpJividvjQfe . =
    I
    is
    5b roa «^y socueKiQs ^ ad'ivicduct 1 fero fe bo( c qing SlnQl
    1
    I© ^ ^^ icfTfy
    3?
    10 rOQ <ry socJQhes eoororo do oeh eryey eqocu Tty
    <
    ¥
    0 of
    e
    s dtatos - If cano&v Happen f & odeod sbeae a-fcjhts FO 'IXDSO
    <

    ©
    5
    SFDEOY
    ' +0 oorceo . furoon dgbV-S Boue 4obe avab -
    I / abl fo Q \ l OhbpjrtuOfse f-t <u6) t ) ’lOQf y -HSQ4 600 Cpsf OO
    ^ ^ *r .
    c
    © tapah '
    cg pp 40CP *SOr) bunoao
    ^ cohort <100 Oye 004
    :a giviog these eights - Hu roan ffabts cnre hosed 00' -
    ; 0 V ,
    0if33 lisrv . cobrtbrr gosor ) i5 '
    -
    if> Bets llo or Baghdad 1
    00
    *

    be sboqid bavp equal 's-


    jabfcs -
    6
    06 fbv Hurooo Rights acf visro
    m bqs.
    been sbosaq by the
    0QO s be < x>is . of fthe «^oes rO =vDov|d .
    %> ^
    bq^ oot bepq^ ^
    AffOctch of
    m cpesf oeu'ta6M* -tbey ba^e beso •selecfva- \
    OSA talkingQbout Vtocoo Rgbfe
    0 violahfc>«o by the ,

    8°* Sy r10 §- o/erioopi AiioiahooS by c bof - bp


    0
    0
    Ooudf AYabiq a
    ^ ^aeJ •
    ^ ^ ;

    s>
    i

    I
    0 I-
    l
    i
    r.
    0 5
    f
    ©
    l
    i>
    -

    © FK
    : .

    -
    t
    © li

    m ifci \

    i
    i
    ;

    S555g S¥5SSc
    ^ ^S^i^e55SSSS 553S5S?55^^^5S^^
    §
    to
    4~n ctoroeSf'c SpbPsr © buncoa Bj0bVs Oreatp dbe pafcbtePQ
    to
    to
    &
    . S
    to
    -d
    y§V steMG By de-flot -Boo Havvxjo pQbb Q&Qafe pcwoess of tto-: /
    ••

    »1
    S+QfP • 84b Ckpsofod to -OD ov Cp HM>POOO Rfeyld ( -
    ^ s- rs

    -
    '

    - So osf Of dfoe TbitsicJ coo’bid CDUo


    1
    to
    ^ taies -ftoese is. 0' ©
    lacO §• Ovd r psob\ptr) - tAqiny 'tfofald
    ',Zi
    • vj ^
    -face successioo ( s-t Cballprgps - The
    ktozrld (toqotoies
    .. 1
    •
    use of pocoe^f by.
    -toe Qtoh? against insurgents bpcbnoej
    4 e;
    v. boo Qccaeod op H noPo Rjgbts vbla
    - ^-
    basis -far
    ^
    •

    - -!
    ^ -
    Hoo ©
    to
    ^ bove di'0>cc4ssfoo sboco 4<be <§
    £2
    «c POOOEPHUCIL «§, fQsffq -bona (
    p^otol^nas •to^ooTircfs The enfdvap
    ~f coeol of Hut-coo Rfebte ©
    zr
    • 'r
    ^
    to

    ^ tive PesSpgGbVPS
    Alterna
    09 •
    /a

    I Scholars fro to 'Ttotald torrid CfiXJoWtSS 'Suggest 4bq


    >v
    "i
    I
    £
    ^esf Should not fay to iroposG uOGSteW * #
    ©
    Mfsoo other sode -Hes - 'the leaders fo 4he rooo - coest-
    coovid e paof 4-bav coes+ should adopt cq ( torsa m
    * I
    ‘TS eJa-bv/ fS'no Muto - oq (tozai . approach docoajsds zr/gbis ©
    '

    ^
    l^he OoocppVtoo of p hto aaooof toe detached jp
    •

    ©
    -te cqtozrvof 4he
    appocfi fbqf
    ^
    9obety • -^a 'zreterto -p rxxss -thejsa^
    cOGst should adopt ouf - ‘- cq(
    -
    Q

    fa Q.O
    o
    b oJ
    ta* appoDpch - ©
    /\ccotoieg to BbIKhu ffcpj
    ,

    .!V
    .J
    © vtb , These iso OOPal
    •!
    bSRoeen c) w 1 isa -Hoo to ' of dialogue
    evolve -toa Ctoo'seosos asoaod to "
    Q^roe toqoic \OlU6S - Vto

    !
    -to bVo Huroao di oito governing harcoo osfU-tos - AOctysdio
    ^
    •!
    (
    eao 'be. such va IUG •
    ^
    .N

    ;
    ©
    .1 *

    &

    ©
    •:
    to!
    fe1
    1

    &
    m
    to

    0
    V
    -v

    :::
    ©
    ;

    *
    Ji

    to 5
    ©i
    :.:J Qd, ct>boo-f 3^0JP | v
    S'5?# -K 5-
    ’
    OO GDO+eropOJTQtty
    .l i
    *
    fOronoPDf OO ( SOUPS Of
    Oe ooc a-Hc Tb©o uj .
    • ~
    3
    ::l ©
    i ^ ^
    > tdpq i'o bohb fos-i- § wksf • £o east-
    :s!
    i!
    •
    C
    Dfroocvacu is an ancJfot
    tOGsee -vbe cDocep of N/ titage yopobi ics • \ o coesf
    3
    :•
    :C
    § -
    3
    ©
    *^
    '
    fc
    Scholars h’ £e A 'Stofs. -j-atkio aboci - -Vbe P 1' ^
    "

    ^
    '
    33
    an © ^
    cipoHoo of p cJ-Hzoos < o 4he affairs of -vbe dhj s t+e - ^

    .
    JS
    . ©
    xs
    +ho roost- aocepobio -pJroo of
    V

    Iv ©
    Lfss
    ^
    .
    ««»««>
    : ?s

    ^
    f I
    'O
    of forei *reverse
    '
    ¥
    £
    . fteeot ge a
    •

    :&
    il #
    §8 fbe -fcnrroS g- •
    'S
    °
    ©3
    :-: @ Oat ftbowo mai-tiptepoodefe
    I*
    r.

    « «0 **«» c

    ^ of
    : St

    #© (

    :*l k
    Modpfcs of DewacraOj debab Vo coo ^opo * fnoes
    1; i ® oce do Moc ftosoob ^ ^ ^
    !©
    :'•
    raobGoodPistood -W) tse
    ^ ^
    e^bQuefve voosk oo Dproocjraci) - i-^dc pbe po © b\s took
    :I
    a- ©
    •

    f
    I>
    ’

    ©
    " Donooosatie
    Tbpopf § io bis ovbf^r dcob ®Qt
    •

    of dproocsoLcj » has aoa spd -fouocfl g roodeis '


    ^
    ^*
    - 3«S
    •:
    .:

    :<
    <

    *:.•
    ; *
    >
    © C\assicr) (
    ^odel
    t ^
    ?i
    1 f Classical Model has fuse? vajriaots i -e -
    DpveIcpe^opcfQ *
    :
    X
    *? ( fVofeofve - R asdio vdassiQqi 4bpo y fbe cdficisTvD <s>
    -
    ^
    ^ ^
    )
    *
    ^
    .

    d
    v- -ft tacks '(ODpeenCOl pgsspeofv© •

    |Moc pbpssoo
    .c
    v
    ->-
    r
    V
    -
    Aoaujsps +0210 raodeJs of Modp&a "Tfoeo'sy
    fbp
    £if tfet vipco rep-ijoseofed
    /

    «•
    C scholar© nks Rjseto,Michels
    c tenri bf MfMs , Scbcjro pehdr -ffxQse sebota
    ^ -as ^3 9® 4be-f I

    dGnooasQCcj os o. ?ruie b doa os- is c> rr j+b d- oli ^ ^


    &
    •

    I15 © 1

    1©
    1-- # -
    dbe too IQCO . ^ ^ axoby k
    pu jra < ists soboiaTS pdgsfoo -fthe el -tlSt \/ 0 Qbou-t
    \ >
    ^ ^
    ie ’
    COOShpiO
    deroGasoaos SU99OS+ Ir es dbe' cooaepf of
    f <
    $
    1g ©
    6
    fe
    r
    t-'
    dofarro ^
    pOUjQYCbifs
    Q^
    •
    i o«?Hf>s 4 :
    ;•
    l

    ? ;
    I©
    ;•
    i
    t
    s ?
    © !
    z
    I © i

    u
    i ©
    f

    I
    i;
    ?
    .
    I
    :•
    © I
    -• :
    * © I
    v

    i©
    \
    1
    \
    : ^ ;
    ;
    5

    -SSBBRSBSSSSSS^^ ;
    $
    m; •

    m
    , 5^deb
    ^^
    l V r
    ^frg b KbfpH ^
    ’' ° «? !.

    J
    of ib > deb doss - Acco *
    !
    •
    loeifive ©bite
    ^noatos -foe lOSb 'oeb of ^ 3
    - -
    44 Class *
    *

    I f CpV^0tfSO O oV^O \oi'°O09tf is Q C&1+i(£>| ( Tb(?SQ| Qoc}Op$\s


    <CJ
    :
    &
    »A ^
    4xbQ+- edesH&D d rooorctdGS Q««2 po Qittodao
    m vy /

    ^ ^
    •
    si
    M
    d
    •
    •

    Tfreire te QGO Q deba-ie bekoeeo scholars like Lee kuan y ?to ©


    seo aJ£*f 4be 'zselaffoosbip bef- coggo cL?ooo —*
    1
    1 § Aroaa o ,
    ^
    .
    :' ]
    \;: m- •* v
    Gracy % deveiope rosoV <§• ^obe-vbpr d 9r>
    r-M
    g: * rccvacy fs-vfoqv
    Be fiv j sioo soaet/pj - Cee hot?? ypcosqgg
    .
    solia © ^

    ^
    •

    c5
    •

    1
    t pr-oecsacL) fs Q UDOS O abseasbo § does oo ^- noq-vcb
    ^ ^ f-
    .
    * / :
    v:

    4o Asian values - A oqtftya S©o Sqggeste 4thc4 'OPHOQOSQO


    *
    ^
    •:

    IS OnWeisgai vqtup ’. He \ves . <3 Unities of denooGsacc . #


    ^ /
    c~
    •V
    ::-4
    $ © Irytefo e- 'Value - ro Ons dencoc ^saa/ gfives sense op
    ^
    6
    rJi © DOcoex ooeo - - ©
    11
    © ^ ^
    JIn-S-WkJ4-10OQ\ VJQIUP - TfGJfc d -to A'?

    © _
    EdMoa-tive Vqtqe . jp roaees cM-t ^ g.oOol cpN/0r-oa00s
    ^eos G^ OGC/QUC, trespo -
    •
    ©
    nsibie •
    IS
    0
    4+ p>Y<PS0O+- 4b>0Jsre (Sex cdebal-e oJe* 4be. bQQa.tr>os3es ©p
    t -
    pSpxGSSo -FQVA/Q Mode] • K)© qve cO'4opssi
    •V

    -fbS 'sna© op
    - <
    : - .1
    I

    p'Opf k? riQOfevo §- decline qf cdeE bsohv© <dercx3C2sa ©


    :i
    1 r-
    f©y ScbolQ^ ifte Hab^ifnCcts 4b?ire fSCXroeed -^oy
    . i i+

    \
    ©
    gk
    ^rgEbeoirO pobb’c sphere SinoiiqtfiL/ A©- 0Qd-yc( cgp ;i
    <

    i ©oppoT^is pobHc seasonlog.- ft b beifeved UxzifdD©


    w -w
    .Vi
    '

    :d - hove -to ^OQ (<u9 denqcCtfaccj pqtfPcj patde 4- del I beaQtWe ^ v

    b: cQHtbcxit aohteb aoe ettm© Qcbfei/e 4be goals op Q^s-la io- / v


    ^ . tA ?‘
    .

    abte che^elope.noeof - -ybeirQ a«e scholars <=oh>o ofeo uosoffon


    abccjf 'tbe. paxociov ss op oleK ip xro TXOnobod .
    ^ oOracg . )
    v .- ^ '

    1
    i ©
    i

    m
    m
    1 ©
    ©v:

    1 cb c;,v
    ©4
    g aS5S ?IS«S«> -' -©S
    ^ *
    i »3S!S®52
    !S25
    ^a^^^
    , '3
    }

    it c^ooaay no“ y *becD< oeF


    ©JK bO roQy
    COirOp + -
    &
    * 10 0 0
    ^" "
    3
    cbnQidc -
    1© STprOQfoS COOtPS+ed
    © Tfeus ti v^o Q !| fDOCeptS denXDCSGLCCJ
    lb C|oote cburcbt / i oe^ooc -racsj I'S
    r
    (ToncepVS -
    .:c«

    «S
    a
    5 m tCOrvSf -fbx>0 o -p 0OOf“ txf ft- is b£bf -HU COG do Oot
    rS
    1 # Invent. -fbe Ipetfc r-
    s
    ••

    i
    0 f:
    i
    ^
    i © Q. DISCUSS +be ERolutioo ° f TbeoVVes Of Hurcoo R igbls -
    pro *s> Niakjural Pfgbte to ooitecfNe % Ebvtooroeoteu Rgbfe
    '

    -
    0
    |0 >
    - Hurooo Rights -
    I © Huroao P-igbt is fbe rocst poe-aRs -ful idea of our -tinoes -
    '

    HocOQ </eir HM«oao R \0 bte TJCTOQlOS \ CDOtesbPcj COOcepf-


    0 °
    It is oov omy cooVP Kd but also coopfctaa | .
    >
    i
    •
    ^
    !
    : Huroao RtgbfS VoQS beCOro 4
    <° be f ufcnre. of JoVSrOa+iOOQ 1
    i
    . © Uto offer -fbe second
    uocr&id ^
    Based oo -toe e*pe*te_-
    i© •Vi
    of de^TTOPiOvj. hfirOQ+ibrjq) Cbrorour>i+q VxiS adotofed
    0 UoWejfSai DgtJQKaHoo
    op H 0 TKe H
    1 Qoo be ffcQOPd to tuoo
    : 0 + ScbotQss v\*<2 - John locfc. cobogave -Vf^e_
    :§ ©
    “Vb
    ^ovy of R(ghte $ ccfoaoqe) kaoi
    4be' concept op V4 cdoo bos gtiVfOO
    uroQo O oi-ty
    1
    J. tb>
    :<
    ^
    r
    HBE sef of Tfj tote
    ^ cObteb eui ^ Huroctn R bts t'e defend CLS
    vberacse fbey qro buroQos- Huroa)-os obouid possess, jost
    beoka of HUPOQO
    ^
    1C cieoiai of Hunooo Qx& is
    -I '
    .
    veoce . Tbe idgq
    of Vi^roav) r bfefe
    1f
    1O
    •
    h
    also lion to fhe
    bos glven
    - -toe (
    concept of Huroao
    dgovty . RQ I vaseb
    Docepfof 3 geoerc Moos of? ^ ^ \

    :$. ©
    l
    < Ovi 1 poi 1 ti ca i (i|)
    social ecoooooi c (« cwBqwo |* I

    -I 5
    ?
    •

    1a
    A
    © .
    ^ viTTOOrOSOtal Rjflbfs •
    |(3oe of fbe eosif f
    ^
    col lecf v0 %

    fbGDty of Huroao Rights is 40 0} Rghts


    1 According to Joho \ ocbe tbe basic .
    of Huroao R is.
    * ^
    'veasoo
    -
    i
    1© io OQO ' It is fbe Soiai-Hoo - bts
    ^ i
    •k

    jicfber io9f t-uHoo


    I© oCHci? f^oaf cs -
    ^
    r
    i
    !
    ;

    !© {
    i
    \
    \
    i# f
    s
    !i
    ii

    r1;

    9
    s m ib
    t m
    B 1
    Im
    I s

    li
    i
    i;
    e it
    8-
    h

    :x:r<r-
    f
    8
    t.3S
    ^
    vpQWeo <®
    Scholars 1lteP TToroas Rjfne- -^koanuej
    SoppoH +ba Q'*guenoeo* of JAwroao Cgoit=j 347
    <
    ^ .

    t £
    ©oteropovasy -b roei Jack- Cbnetlj ^soppo c eoo Met*
    ^ ^^
    '

    4
    '- -
    and Men Qe’ea WP ^soppoal 4be a fguenoonf op Huroao
    O orbj- pMv'oQif ) pj bls c sf 5seo4-ia i|y based or> Hhe
    ^ ^ ^ *

    ideas oP Ubera 1 isw> H^oce fbe choi &o caoop -Qoro


    •
    .1
    1
    -
    ;!
    4be cbro^oucfev block is
    noroic ^ ^
    ^
    do +tae vreco O / HOLOO-F socUa / c
    ©
    H bts
    AS Q 'resoit- op decoiaoi saww process
    s
    many Tb~'sld
    couobries becaooe +be roeoobos P OrO Qgnexcxi
    ~> d
    £3
    coortd aouobpes dleroofoded cbitecppe ° y m
    HgbsVs HVe
    to deveiopepoeob PkoteGpoo ap poui
    Third coortd aouobbS some \eoA s
    tson men>v i%Ot~o
    & dencoodkd to recb
    - ©
    <

    £
    &
    nfee caiPtfrqi cliveKSifiejs
    Ppea Rc Tri hrfcS.
    '
    £
    t b ocbpt / '25?°cognise act ipjso ^ #

    ^
    V:
    P
    •

    i -
    .v

    © .
    •!
    c
    i
    ©
    / cVV.

    ©
    •
    ?•" . *
    @
    A-''

    %
    v©
    i P -"
    >
    .S #
    •.
    %

    ©
    .. l
    ' '

    >V:- ©
    i

    - yy\
    •
    m
    i @
    sS
    #
    :#
    Vp m
    £K
    OvJ
    Svl9
    a
    •
    .!

    I &
    .
    P 3jtlQbUS
    (

    g© . cjof+h sppcta i ; -Vo


    •

    I
    a ConcepHons of Justice
    . -.a © Covrjrouol-lavlao OnWcpRS -
    :«
    .

    .V
    rs
    33
    ©
    pacCfe Tbeovy op 3US-HCS
    ^ t{S
    m ©
    * JofYOduc-Hoo -
    ~

    . iropojrVoo^- <oo>ooeffn of poiifcal


    '

    ;S
    •• § j0sH09 fS 'ttxp fOOSV
    "

    ..s ©
    :SJ

    philosophy 4b© -ffroe af ptofo - £o poUfiCPi pbilo


    •
    a
    ••
    • *ri

    -*$ © SDpb Jogvice fe oof \ tfxMed -to fbe \ g)4 l sysfero


    - &' '
    : -5l

    I©
    -
    C‘
    '
    ^
    fbii+foai pbilcscpbess -failed
    abouf JosKc© as pafoc/pi
    bavtg
    *
    |
    ; © :
    op Q-bks lf >e roosV f '^opovj-oof idea ;o JJS+!CG
    •

    .'S5
    j -idoa of o»shri bu+ive Jusfic© *
    _
    -^
    :; -5£i
    . @
    :
    . *
    „poccte
    £

    Tob asis fflosid


    ^ ^ ,
    .
    $
    15 CS a^aHs , Fhilosopb
    Of so ceowsu . 'Pods posi'Hoo In
    : s coc ets pora
    .

    3 © * ^^
    ;£

    1©
    4 H
    ’

    ,
    bl Shed
    »X'
    be9iooL
    - ~
    <" r»
    f JUSKte
    i

    •
    x
    y
    i

    £y
    f
    s
    ©
    e
    ©
    ^
    WorKs of John parols -
    W
    ^ rts -H
    *
    C pW i opwp
    ^ ^ P ^
    °
    ^
    ;
    V,M31

    I ( ;

    t
    O
    ® bis AaHcle - £ Jassos as paboess > eoas published.
    I { © r° 19^ coroe bis Tb<=ovy of TusWae ’ •
    |
    V
    ?v r
    V. © So 1993 pQcolaboot - ‘FbMtfcai UberanW ospobiisbed.
    •

    1©
    A
    ^
    © Tbe Locos of +fee p^opig’ published io / 933 cdbe e RQcOs
    >:I
    : ©
    4
    *
    bas respondad to 4b© aTgu£ ro©o ts § pfoes+fons *sniGed bd
    - •
    :;
    *e
    Cosnoopowtan scholar iif © Tborv^Qg f gee Charles
    .1
    1©
    >
    ©
    fe
    ^ i
    -
    fe i
    IO {
    !
    I. y i
    l
    k
    «- §5 \
    :5
    '
    *
    I
    I
    I©
    f..
    V

    1
    © J

    1R
    .
    p. ©
    W*

    -V
    e
    &
    1® v
    t

    1©
    %
    i
    c{ : \
    *:
    4i 1
    S2SS2S I
    I
    >:
    f
    pa cols School af TboL hij
    %
    «3
    ?3
    V. V
    #
    ^ of posHW© Ubesan'sm or
    UV
    '

    1
    Utooifera - !
    '
    ••

    3odol

    — ©
    V.'

    ig 9QC0|S is a cfrWcof oP/ ) Havianis«r? . ©


    ;

    - In bs toeog of JUSPCP he has ariKdsed ohiftajao


    '
    ©
    v.i
    :M
    Ideo of dos-negy ©
    '

    J- -
    J pocOls coos in-puenced by John Loofe Uke 3bho Loch© ©
    V
    ••>

    pacols bos 0Weo bb to©o *y aen social coot s-


    aef -fssa - -
    y
    &
    >}J
    •• !

    diboo- ^
    - pacds teas also io-fluenced by EroanueJ Kant - -He beiies/es- &
    I •
    JA
    fhcM- Huroao D oity bas to be one
    •
    -
    1
    •

    -i "
    ^
    pmodple op Theory op Justice. .
    of toe fbuodabomi
    .
    ,

    v> *

    ©
    IV
    -VV §
    ccordirg to John Rncols , JOshoe to©
    Vv
    V .
    ^
    Soa'oi
    fosti + +i oos 11 te T u +b as toe vitr+ae
    cj ’
    ^
    ^
    Vflrtoeof
    op sysvero - m% .
    *w

    Of tooygbt Ofce plQkD^ pocOls cUso +btot -that TasHce


    sbouia be to© foundational psindpiG op toe society - C
    society nooy posses ctoer Wurtoes also £-$ • effc/enty P
    but justice is toe , \0 MtStoe - justice. is toe t®*:» \ tae to
    toe rohar usay Ttruto ts toe vitfkie ©p -vhe syster© of V ^ 0
    ^
    Jboc bt -
    "

    a
    : :l
    --
    (

    ^ ,
    AC(DrdiO0 to pauSls, Kjafarai DiS buHoo 'S oiehberjOSt OOr I '
    ©
    ^
    unjust - toeve ,:C r ~ sdoproe op i Justice IQ fOcrHisc? ] - aefe
    ©
    \/ v
    o J K^ J

    < { rs -toe society tobfeb mates Justice 2, injustice. - fesse- ^ ©

    v; -
    ssfoo of so roe cjoaifbes or esoMwues become advantage -
    ^ ^ ©
    bus ?- SO noe QVQ diSadvaotogQOULS - #
    V
    rVj
    hi bat does it imply ?.
    :V
    Snce if is G human Creation , Huroao ayonuy Can charge )
    j toe yystoro % <^oe. can areate Q jstero obch isd st -
    Vi
    -
    .
    :
    •i

    J
    ^ ° ©
    M
    i
    W
    $S&:
    m ©
    ftv

    /•
    .. -
    E) *

    y
    w. ©
    i
    6

    l c55:
    V - Q
    *"
    3
    >I what t's Justice ?
    vS
    :' rk

    ,6
    .*
    G Vo
    •
    -Justice
    ^e '
    fs feiroess - XusWce
    open
    rrypans
    •

    5
    -
    x
    Ix D
    P
    fair -to ai | those coho ba
    io disadvaotcxge The Throb es
    •

    tbe fo\boi pg pd o clpl0


    advaotc

    •
    Jostico^
    ^ ^ Abase are
    based
    of
    p -

    or)

    i &
    @
    © Desert - means cobQf OHQ deserves oo -the basis of
    I© v bis qoQiify
    tx O
    c
    :¥
    © r^ea't - from the -perspective of society he .
    cnbcy-
    £
    £.
    oocjety vaiues -
    -x
    ;
    x3
    Meed -
    I
    1©
    :
    •
    RacOte CD^OVDVOG an the 3 psiodptos 'io bis
    -
    ^ JbQory of jus-vica
    c
    3
    C -- © Cootexf Op Tbeonj-
    -

    !m I (MHcJsm of ofi 1 tfariao tbeortj op justice -


    C,
    i @ Dacb person possess
    iouaiabilfiy -founded oo the
    s« © fbodpies of Justice that even" -the
    3
    - *> coeifareop coboi©
    ’7
    -C
    t
    . r, Society cannot cvewlgbt +hS loss Of
    c
    •t:
    -£x tbQ greater of SDroe
    © good of racing - 5>
    focojs beweve 4-bqt -the
    Patois - —
    . d
    1 •

    Digoitv of evert) person basto


    ^
    f.
    1

    Sx C be •respected - Ufe Ttaaou-el part


    U3bo held 4bof no one
    l
    i ( Ought to be 4-be means -{or -the other person - Q (SO
    O ^ ' -Ojest -
    that - jhQ dj ofty of o. person coo not be conopro—
    <
    number -
    * ^
    noised fo -tbe aote of areatest happiness f greotesr
    ® °
    I©
    G
    .-.c
    £
    . C-
    V
    # ..

    A
    <:
    F m
    IS ©
    * ©
    fca :•
    ii
    © i

    i {

    1© Sr
    •

    i
    I© 5

    I
    t©
    K

    ia © e
    't

    I© !f
    I© ,

    g i
    ?
    8 a
    I - SJSS^SSSV^JWSB'^*
    •Si j
    ^
    '
    «)
    , -
    if cJkiYp 4 2- #1
    c:
    <~&
    • ;- •
    Q. Sop e^
    '° p e0^ op na «ao' Rlabte *SOWS - ^&
    «30
    W ««GQt '
    joeloxUoig eg
    4fce coodudr Of
    OS noa+VPY o- changing
    cf

    Huroor> RgWs is a \ yocoei prycs tiroesfaI of oust


    *^ ^1
    1
    ?
    '
    @ . •

    -:.!•

    'o lot- of change i o -toe quaif


    *Wl1
    sea
    'T'

    •5
    1
    gpcausp Marvin Rgbts too
    0$ tjf ? . d provides us ^oope tfo* ffpedone -fk? <ro expoi-ta ,

    5 coaots 4 bup0?2 GF toe adbe^ +oH* a better teoaicl fs


    0
    <®
    ^
    : ;;•

    -- ^
    •

    possible - nboug 4h2ve Iso 7reoi &oH oo of 4foe potentate


    m- ^ ^
    Rights has reduce3 to another discourse
    rV

    ptOTOvses yeJt MUPOQO ‘

    toooeptaa) issues UD- 's t - +be -


    i
    f
    7he«e core roang practiced
    InopveroeotaMbo of
    i
    ^
    pQbte - Any AtteropV to i no pie-
    efcjcoao
    m (

    Qny deroaod fcrt Vtonra'hRg-bts becocoes


    '
    ?!
    roeof fWmq o Rgpbs .
    >
    e
    polibtol % (Sn-f tuaai Psobero s*6 because -fceseka
    M
    ^ •

    lacb- of consensus csf roeoofirg of Murmoo 3 '-ohQV basic


    @
    S'. " %
    I
    tfgbte Should cbnePdate tog uduei^af rhinos - TheJfe to a (f
    m • o^ te -
    ss r> eed 4bat Q \ l those echo are +be SlqVp boicM® 0 .

    developed couches, Civil society CHR- /MQo4 ) uf deYeto -


    ^
    @

    : .1
    fed cooof &'ss , states is Tbiftid Wo?rld CbuoVaies p v* i t
    -
    •

    I
    should take honest ^flbiits -fo depoi ?tfe© Wu <noaa ©
    1
    4
    Rights - Oo \g cobeo -Ibtesoa h’ooai Gomsouoikj obi OQfcfptorg
    -
    4 ptboTi-V - fey Trlgbf ooe/ Abel* c opcr / itfCQl fotespst coe cuo 0
    ^
    hoi id 4be of (fiobai Mu«oan 'RgbiS <s s »nne
    SinoilOtfig Huroqn R bis ^tsa3da fions ( bocq
    ^- ^ *
    Q:

    G.

    ^ =
    V

    •ihe
    LOCKED coaoU'es ^oo d < la ocvo oe
    > ops
    af ^ ^
    g
    Wive to adopt: 00 ? neabaa I o ppifoaoh ^oncspo ^
    & so csxiioV ej ^ - ^ ^ /?> *

    :d
    .1
    |-f OK) noo Loes irt)
    ^^ 0 stete
    ^- •

    ^^
    .
    v
    *>

    -i ^ '

    ^
    cfruohnSS itmgeno'es ^ ;
    Succesgioo v tbssaf . Humor) R
    ! ^
    R dt>£ T btS Of IQCO
    hf gpotips
    ^ opbcsfos.
    ^ ooy
    A
    ^
    ' aa roe \evel of
    Orjirdiep
    Is oof <5OOGO
    Yioo - 'StQ.te QGfeiVS '
    ^
    - -
    -: i1 stQ-fB
    ’
    ••

    :S-i
    m au+bovi -be . Jd- does oof -
    ' c
    :’i
    -
    ^
    P;°g eouohsies oeed oof do c?
    4 hof slates rio cdeveb
    IS
    dop 4 re*o doie oce
    ^
    :- {
    • •
    . J
    ' apP ~toczcb bcy- crzla, fthe vlobf{0o
    ^ -
    of H
    c
    ^raoo Rgbfs r
    • :; ©
    - d- 1
    '

    m
    3?

    4-®?,
    N ,V

    o
    • 0\ :

    -d
    -
    v:: >
    a '
    §3 ^
    Xh&j CK*uaVgineecJ 3 hnrg ••HutoaV) PghU |De*S 3Ve / O
    «
    •
    •

    ^
    3 '
    . 3
    ^ !

    rs
    boe< -b eofa . isUp n^ citoofQQ*- ^ ^
    ^ ^ ^^
    .‘Si1©
    !
    pcbUc poi \ t - Tb ^
    s ( QCD eMo <& TO<9r>V a
    anuf . 3f?te - Q\3o tre
    {

    s
    •'
    I3 ©
    :E
    *
    SDppO’vf O-p 3^04 0^VfOOq ( (b K)U^f
    ^ S~scb ^
    .w£
    1©
    *9

    .:fi
    I
    ©

    ©
    fr> tonopifK < 4uo44onS '

    $x*s opt3 i oo\99


    ^
    ^ |o

    coesfeo as «ooef [ os 000"


    ^ .3 ;x ;. '
    -
    > !

    ^ s
    •

    t* ctfr
    t
    :sS& Q . b&ifg obaruj© * o -H>ejr opp-tfoatobes ace
    ••

    !©
    cOS
    ^ ^ ^+
    canrop
    >im aoo d
    Kl\ j
    .

    13 ©
    ^ O iOtoo|{go Huroao
    \
    '

    V
    3 @ (

    :l
    1
    .
    "
    £
    • ©
    *ts ©
    :\>5s
    •
    © :

    :‘S
    :Z&
    v3
    -
    m -
    •V

    1© 5
    . / •
    •

    I
    R
    Q

    1m C

    *S
    I <
    i.
    I
    \ .
    V - « \
    A: C
    i

    •
    _ * ••"
    . V
    •
    i
    ©
    ? <: .; <

    - fI £
    4
    i CVi
    I© r
    £ =
    .
    ^
    I£ © >
    •. 5

    Ic
    -1
    \
    * ©
    Ic ©
    *
    ;
    •
    j

    I
    © i
    i©K
    i
    i
    \
    !
    I ©
    ft !
    t
    E {

    1i
    !© l;
    ’t
    \$ m i
    \ © i

    :
    <
    ;
    m
    i
    ! \
    I
    ©
    0 m i

    .'co-xo--><•sr^vvv
    '
    -
    eg)
    m 6ooMoU d ©Justice •••

    ss*
    .
    ©3 IHQY'IOO tbeovy Of jQSHoe is -toe
    { jW \ -n
    :v« ©
    nOC& of 4te coestovo axootoies - PQ <O!S altos to bullet
    ®
    4

    * o toe f^adtotoo of ubeset-


    :t •

    >1
    ©
    \ \ S 0;
    *
    cy.
    ©
    Historical ci sca'rosfDoo pTsevoi 'ir df to©
    .
    Wbaf ’
    ^ CJOQVS

    ^
    ”1

    :-:1
    fnoe pa «d d ©
    4 • 0f
    :
    - :i ©
    Otory His fto>e -toes© toew nca social roo^roeote
    to
    ! ^
    psolesY <05» rg Oo \r ) os Sodety Heoee b<? f«H dfoqf toe ^ &
    (tov

    .rvJ
    • . -vhpcfr-j Of CJUsHce is nov sofPc/eni- fi^ag need
    ©
    1
    Si
    to build npo 4bsow of Justice - ©
    utoav -type of neo - of jeto'ce F m
    theory
    The toeovy ccHcb is acceptable to oil the theory edbeb
    ay G Oioos ©f fbe t
    I ^ society -f? od ceasooabto - Thus Pacds,
    Qnobtfioo is to bui Id such Vbso'y of jUsfTce <cb»ch> is 'safb- ?-
    1 V .
    •

    bQl % uJo\Ch COO bp COOSid 55lcd as an olttooorbe


    theory of
    justice %
    uddcb Cao be (bodudve tor <90Cia ( stobi ii°to/ .
    • ©
    £?>
    to Hoo Pacols ctosnfbe bis 4tfbisu ? vCv

    :. i
    pacOfe desoribe bis 4bso os ‘Deootolcgicoi lb©
    5
    0
    UJbat tsv Dsootoipojicol sbeoyf
    ^ .-ev
    «
    OH I iiain'oinis'ro is QQ (Exor-opi© of oo-
    >
    tolcyfcpi Cns toIso1031(0 / ,-c \
    f-
    Theory . Heoce , of I 'itavicxoiS O !fS ©
    01190 c_$s ©rvi
    ' (

    - ©
    ccovdioy to tob itoriooisro ; ach'oo to bush -fed) SO
    '
    .
    IM
    Xa
    ^sesuitsvotp to©
    .
    roaxiroiSQbooof '
    tlappioeas- p30(c, -faecMj :
    t5 Jusfce to ©©ootoipyoai t&xose everyone accept jjusHc
    f C
    tong ^ .-
    c "?

    ©
    to:
    >
    : V:
    as fetooess as a fdodpte - IbGy adhexe to Tf atncHereh
    <
    -
    ^
    »
    •>
    rocy be toe (ton9spoenaQ/ ©
    •

    ..
    ©Vi
    •' V
    .*

    » /

    @
    rS
    t:|L to

    wit

    •p]

    rnmMmmmmmmm
    <y
    9
    *
    ftathte MgVbodolo°p/ ~
    &
    ?3
    ©
    3
    fools 'ffQvVes 4be -todd-too of sodai + < Cbo SDd • social ooY»a
    <
    1c ©
    tc& ii er ose 4f o a B n o d p^e s of cs^sffce ase 4b© oofcoroes
    •
    .
    ;: ©
    ! - jtao ifxopceed
    « \

    of 'so-Ho-oa l dlo ogoe o* deilbesadoo


    '
    S
    2
    v.
    os ©

    fcsHe - dodo * coobsocf <& \ ) ateo ^ffisuM: icta te enoege


    :
    -
    *
    :cts

    i ' -from oa-


    I ©
    r>ae of (Doseceos on dfo© -{puxdatiooal palodp ^O ga/e^o -
    i
    I©
    <
    cg society -
    '
    £
    &
    © & CDocgpV Of Paginal fhsibor)-
    :. ?
    ft

    ©
    Ominot Pos {+ioo 15 l ? £e +be concept- of sfate offra-bi^S , <r
    3
    & C\OSQ\CU \ So dal cactaracf 4f eo&i©£ isa situaHoo befas©
    m%
    I
    1
    -S
    •
    •

    ^
    1
    ( Oofsacf -
    3 © ’

    ; ( figoUAygs of ffoe ncn


    *
    f

    @
    t
    crfr
    ^
    Peysoos bave Cdnoe -foae-tbey -to e>otey
    posf-boo -
    }pto -fbe caa+iracf .
    baf -type of poysons P
    i© '^
    Pools does oof loovcat peirsoos as Mobbesfaq Eodlviduals
    •*\ •

    © Me vcHber sg
    I gesfs rocnrai 'individuals - io tanHoo sense -
    !©
    :i
    -
    -V S
    a

    4be pe&soos tfobo


    ^
    f&sons bos/e Iobeiroo^ sense of- TPjgbi § «OSOr> -
    0 crae i

    1t uodossfaod Vbqf- ©opeyofi on ,fe benefr _


    - '

    dot -
    ( ace ^ooa ) , 4b bave ap 4ain
    ^
    :f
    .c
    . 4
    t -fes cbicf) 4beg coo oof * goals fr 4bdv
    ‘ :s
    © ’ •
    pursue r f ~\b&s<& fe oo ponce
    - ,
    io
    -v
    - ? e Society • 3n 4be eoo^ds of <1- RacOls ev£2gj pe&soo bos q
    .. -
    V
    ?:
    -f > Wiooal ploo lo b'e U-(© - l
    x-
    5 ©
    V
    © cnsQ assembled far
    - 4be cdiSf ribu-fpo of
    &
    goods- ^ pd^oacg
    i ©
    Kihaf are pvnoapj
    .
    x ?s
    goods?
    i i4e. roeowaos five pzriroayg goods -
    1A © © Ubeyy
    !4 © IW
    Income
    iiy
    6 >
    !

    1© >
    s
    ii s
    3 dgor
    ^
    .
    1© :r '

    5 |;
    i: a <
    1r
    I
    .

    !© \
    i

    1
    r!
    '

    - 1&s © t:

    1 ®
    I I
    ©
    i*3 © lfc“8
    f
    !-
    f
    E
    !© I «.*.
    ^ ^
    5 f5?5 r-.W5?:<-
    ^S5-'
    i
    -
    OYPOOS in
    ^cSecoodQjg goods
    ^^
    V' •
    J
    CC:
    ;
    SSJ
    Tbs &t-L Q

    p&imaiy goods a*£ recessa- to ocb'^e escooctoy goods


    ^
    "

    - * *

    bihort or* © becoodasg goods / Po-hona! plans £


    '

    -r:
    O

    ^ § * Sf cSorvosbody UDQOVS to beoorcea docto* it , tout be


    Seated as sscoodo goods tr> cnrdex -fefe© to pursue 4bG.
    %

    ^
    •
    •
    0
    Q-HDOOI
    ;:i
    ^ pbo psisoos ’deqoi&G toe p^tooatfg goods -
    Veil of 3 OQRANEE to .
    ^
    33- \'S a -too<-Kjbf exp© Gnc^ ^
    ^ ° ©
    -
    ;

    Purpose of ibourfhV f JoHerceot


    •d
    s
    S3
    ^
    1b br’ rg people , <n a ertuafi’oo &o*o cohere 4h y ®o look
    ©
    :: bi
    ;
    Si
    : -M
    at -toe ton ngs -f%oro 4toe conopteteuj optional perspective ^#
    1
    •
    ,

    MotO to oecD’oos Pa+iooal T


    vi
    ' -

    EF 4bose 4adots edbich ^oate roao non- '^atonal am eii-


    @
    &_
    v

    •V -. irdoatodl. @
    .-
    V

    an ovi xnai post Woo persons ase bebibcf ^ ©ilop *gooraoc e 6


    V
    ;

    ^
    S!f

    <cb? cb toeoos -
    Vbeg, do oof tootO pqi&fica lar oac, aboqf
    ,,1 -! dfcepogeUjQS' tor do 4b j tooo -the Wjpe. op eociQhj ^ 6
    ^
    • • •'
    • i

    ^ tob to gp
    ' * to ecoege
    - gf 4be do not tncx-o ©blcs

    i
    ^ ootrhj coni be viQiued or <ctoto|) sbiH ciMiV be valued - ^
    If meare toey do not kmo cobqt P 01f -tiGS qwg go? ry ©
    «

    to be advootegeous $ aobaf c\oa ©-ties


    ° ©
    goi to be
    d 3«tov/
    ' antojPou$ . Pcy-ctworr -Hols pQsSons toove peoesas fd<tos,
    © ^
    ©
    tosto uodgjtS- of feoorocs S, ffey ebotog
    vqodlogs
    \
    V §:
    ;
    5 Ouvcot-oes of -toe contract
    Theory of 3bsbce as Fatness .
    •
    /©
    fei
    ^ >

    S3
    -.
    .*-. •• ©
    ©

    I m
    w

    e
    ©
    ©
    ;
    V
    @
    vy
    *v .
    :
    •i - !
    ©
    f
    i
    : -y
    -r-r :
    i
    -•-• 's.
    %

    Vivrf
    3 piindpps of Theo ) of JUSHCXJ as
    ..-r
    •a

    ,3rs
    3
    e
    ©
    >
    What
    faWnc»6 ? ^
    i
    '
    5
    3
    ©
    --3w
    CE liberty pdociple
    J . © © Iqoa i ?{tj of oppotfu.bHij.
    pVindpte - —
    ©rvS
    ma © $ O -ffGrQnce - idLe^eSt of t<8as4
    •
    .
    ^Mrg to hh£
    tO
    * ©
    . 48
    adjortogedi 6ip <3i‘on op - e sociekj -
    ^
    I
    I© Lexical order
    c
    i? 9 o, defiott-eorder or sepoenc-e •
    J .

    *# Bdndpies <3F Janice Q°e Vo a pa ' ojiar ^ oe °F


    1
    ^
    i5 # psbznt - bbe has ipzrfo'zdty ove* fquaifbj of oppazrUcby ^^
    I
    i£ ©
    -
    •

    • ^ ^ pviacJpie ^
    of oppotfuoity coUl have p*b*ry over d'«{fereo^e
    o
    I
    /
    ©
    @ p&foc/ple.-
    @ uibai is -fo© basis op ue fcoi order ?>
    aA * .

    © RacOls give MQV\ «>oio priodpie - since persons awe


    ^Vion
    •

    M
    c

    :
    5:

    *«-. ©
    at
    they coouid prefer Q sysfepro <cHcb coin give ^ax^ouno
    i
    **<: ©
    Oppo'tfuoitu ojf fkecbre to de
    ^siope 'H-eur taieds off ddvao-
    I& tapes - Ttay cow qlso ensuse that ~tae
    :£
    System)
    r
    \ ^
    ?
    * £ngu*e 4hek°co *l being io case -they bappao
    ? Qdk/aofcaoed - SUsieo doouid be <3Jcb fidmcb f'dionnoise.
    >
    <

    :l
    c
    R
    < dVsadvaotMes - Pa«3nal pe^o coUl choose 4he steoatfve
    ‘

    Ie o COhoSQ cCOffSl CXjtCOrrOQ. IS betfeff bbo.Q the cCC 2£ OOpCO X e


    «
    I e of onj o+beff aiterative
    ^ "
    ' ^ ) '

    if
    ¥
    If posoo cbcoses bfcedy as 4be
    1t 0 §- he Vbppeos to be -the least
    ontg principle advantage! tb*
    )
    oocn& outcome. cdM be Goorse -tbao -the outco^oe If be bed .
    1
    0 Cboass d oTt ciS -tb>0 \& principle -
    I
    I
    t
    e
    ©
    ^ ^ ,

    i
    a j

    \m
    £
    i©
    1© li :
    ;

    ©
    1;
    ! © 6
    l
    F
    © |
    >

    ;
    i

    © i:
    1'
    \
    m s
    f 5
    -
    .
    ^ -
    u 03 the |S* Option
    s

    w
    II
    m
    SWlOtfU iS t
    he happens to be -the roost advantageous iVadi ) be toe
    i!}
    ^ » •

    £*>
    © .

    <ocnSt option - 8pcaese be <x5ih cot fce


    a position -to
    . ©
    advantage of bis ta fonts ©
    "
    date
    -
    V..
    @
    I ReftexTtoe &)Qf < i bri ute> -
    cfinnvpdl at arsis ©
    The Principles op <JCSHc© dOblcb roe bav©
    r>o\- ODteirg Obo ^accuro but -tbey am corofrjg -frOrv,
    ©
    ^
    ionadbc sense of Justice mbs root »0 On* rO' Od .
    ©
    p9f \ vWe bih'Wurvn IS o process by ob'Cb oe stteaoo- ©
    ^ ^
    I toe veri -fij ourjoc gooeoto Jbls hoppers <=obeo toe ©
    1

    ^
    qoeohoo our halves- f'roso l jadgenoents have dteia
    - ©
    origlo to tog Qc> cJ &aj . justice as fatacyoss irefte^f fefexfv^ ©
    ,
    v\

    B O ! i ) b?nuro- @
    ©
    ;x
    ©'
    -
    to ^
    Justice fan ness
    QS
    ©
    Ito -A

    \ * .* Hoco Tfoeols 3 p&\ocip)es Of Jos-tce cpse. -fair ?


    ©
    ftjcolebos -vaiteo \otoConsid0o-Hor> an 4foe Q psAodiptes of
    f:
    Justice te - Deseirt/ to lent , teeint , toeed . drs principle
    of justice ,‘s fair ^fboee eobo bQppeo ro be 4fce. nocs - G
    i

    * 6
    ;.
    1 o
    ocbaofcypd ^3 .eel! as least advantaged foots does not
    ( ,

    ::{
    tokP Utpiriy -
    tpoQ utoj aoti tbotfoai ( joppototto) to Octch
    '
    £
    other - m rathe*- tofetoot Ube toj £ oaif ce cotapieme- ©
    * j
    ^ ^
    :! •

    .to
    va
    1
    tot
    .
    H
    ° rof no pie of Justice ensures ©
    - tot
    >
    ACCOTTOII Haroao Qfcpite r
    :' -!
    tori

    v /i
    to
    .- ;
    Hence LooJXn
    to pS ‘
    so**^ to diFfevpo). '
    TTOInic )
    ’
    S
    W 0
    differ Vo **
    S^' tat> le HocOever*
    .
    , e toeqoai ,
    V<B
    ©

    -
    a
    toi opK)Vtun lt(PS
    fled only coben Obey Ts suit foto -
    f J.
    v to -

    ^ toe £|»r 'tesoarces ccbich £


    '.• ••

    Con be. otiised


    •• :•!
    e CIG JSY- -toe feast odvtxotGged sod- ton of -the ©
    -to!
    tor
    tot? ^ ^
    °oor > ; $ T**® robo qre roost fqlooted should have
    *

    -
    •

    incoiae, coin get ooore coeqitb .


    ,

    Bat -fhei -rpoceessibn ©


    ©
    .
    •
    to©

    e
    &
    to©
    c:-:
    -. -v .

    v: i .-
    iT .V

    it
    ton
    V
    greatev mcoroe aoeartb is J°5^ fed
    iS
    © OF
    ^
    used -for too^er SPGHOO of soci &^ j . £f> Q
    OOt <Qben Hr is

    :l ©
    -C
    -Ci

    I© )
    fnsoQxeo e taxation
    ^ *

    bihy ppope should QSOVyfbcjle for -he teas*


    ^ocVaotagfo
    coo bp supports

    *
    .
    I@ ^
    CD -found > t ratboai cdben tb y behind -&G veil of
    f-s ©
    i
    It # ignorance *
    ^
    0 ,9 ocfjos^ because of’ oner -faieot , it \ s>
    '

    I'atS < «» a peosate


    k
    1 ©
    •

    ctaoce • Hence,
    £
    ?•.
    Y,
    X
    X
    m
    fbose COVXD hove
    ^ a;re
    oaf been os exchaoFasjeous as cce
    **
    I# peace &ste-bury
    &

    1 © © V? i to\ H opt
    OQroe -Vbese oof be
    CO111

    f . in tbe sodQty c -cb icb


    '
    t require -to pursue fbe 'znafiooai
    -? ©
    2
    .

    M'-fe -
    •

    goals Of rqy
    (
    :?
    x
    U> ckiY 43
    I5 *
    Of |02.| 2 Olf
    •

    •
    4 ©
    -?
    • woco Ratals loot at Ous-HceP
    3 # © JusHce as 4be
    .entiot 'lOSW -KAtiOOSi of social fbstt ^abioro-
    % vteHje
    © tOH ’
    ct ) 3
    I
    :?

    © 1 Fbiltioai JLOSHFQTF ooSj "Eco ooroi'c §- otter


    f
    <OHcb p odpleof
    sooaf i - ^nG^-HJ-Hons
    ^
    c
    i©
    * jostice as
    3 asHce ?
    •’
    x<:
    C
    (VDo
    „> Paiifoess
    vJo
    ^ cororouoftortaos iffce Michael UJQI
    i
    f f -d VO bis bcot ;spbc«
    y- \ -
    Of TusKce ajgg Fba tor different
    ^
    > Kr\
    ^t- - -t ( -
    spheres -theseaboutJ fc>Q
    e
    \:r
    - different prioctples of Xush'ce
    - paOls toaoj- to o' ie ao absolute xqfoocp ('

    ^
    f
    u Q^ deQ of oustae
    eObbb fQo be accepted
    k fS’. \
    by Ql \ if th j loohctt these pjnodplps
    >
    I©
    ^i
    • VDJ‘

    V
    vV pfOro hei purely faWooQl
    ^
    cooornuo'taboos ss gesv
    point o£ vie><a> . ^
    i m
    %
    x

    l
    people beion i
    &^
    cf justice . '°fl ^’ Pbeot ^
    tfat t- te oof po ibte -bx -the
    ' -
    cuitq ceto fg'ree -the ohe dec,
    ‘ ^
    ^
    sf ©
    l
    PacofQ iblnt tbaf jo
    ^ insviHiHor
    -
    1C 1
    coo create
    <

    t
    c
    © o ^ bust eo osette
    © e

    0
    :
    : ©
    ••
    k
    •

    <
    |©
    I> # i

    tu
    if
    ! © l
    i.

    . <I © B

    \ t D
    ^
    \®
    m - , Qpco ose Po^Ots
    cfegd QQOOQ
    m.
    •
    &
    Atoortya Sen bee
    -tfd'Ots -that 7 oSK &s f3 the OQtCDrrje Of 3 as^ ibst-P^tioo
    «
    *5?5 " '

    :•- i
    id93 of eot-iooo i ty
    '
    .

    booed oo esnog •

    ©
    -
    ;d

    RaCfe is CTsUnc/spd txj | ro^ 0*3 , * Wcis s > b0ffQ vfctos, ^ ^ ^


    y
    *t-33- .
    &
    :
    C 13

    -,-:i
    .-
    V V
    I Qjmorouof avi'ans o& aeii QS vaocial Gbe*aAs
    ^ ©
    ^ ^ •
    ke;

    ©
    % 5tat£roeoSS Of pooOls ^ Q
    ©
    m
    Qcc Justice is -the Ist op social jos+ykJH'oos, as -featf,
    \/ fekte
    fs Of /Qfef>0 of thought fl Thecng bocoe^ejr Ghgaot
    la -
    ss-V
    ^
    <

    Qod ecoooroi <xd rou


    -

    be "sejectod or Tseyfeed if itts


    ^
    •

    0 '
    ,
    UOfoue Ute t-oiSQ \ acOs § ioShtu-h'ons on noa-Her baco bet

    SiFcieot P cGeil arraeged *oast be obo\ TSbeJ • \ f they


    ' 'V-

    i
    -
    ; ;-j
    :;i

    Ji
    -3
    Qi
    •
    nojogt . Bach pe ssoo possess ov'iofoH 1 / fouoded 00

    93ctefy
    <
    ®
    ^
    H^g paring pies of dosKce ubnt even the coei -fig-set of g
    cobo\e cannot gviginridg - tor the
    QS
    ^ soo jt ice
    ^ ^ ^
    ©
    ©

    i
    *
    c i

    -. •
    -
    i
    ^
    ^ T
    loss Op faeedcro - br SDfOe
    bt bej greater gcod
    noode
    by others - a d o c s oot
    Qitoco -fbot -the soon -pees ’iroposed OO -4 0 a e o<ut -
    ^ ©
    fS
    'QP

    ^
    pi
    .Gi * .

    ©
    1
    coegbed by -the. iqrger ©oro op advootexyes <e>qj0y by
    i
    fbpKQfbts o adjust society Jhe liberties of &jucti . ©
    r,CQcy . '

    & ^ ©
    Gtcrposbip Quo 4qppo Qs sett ted , 4he Tffee Gpea ^pd bej .
    • .- 1.
    Justice Ore oot ©ub)pcf to potfto’ oal bargaining . or to ©
    CQtc© UQ
    of Social lObPrest , • Being ViTstaes Of barcQn V©>
    V*
    * »
    £ * •

    Qrtiyf -b’eg
    f ^uH) §. joshes cne 00 cotop^ oe G

    At
    © “ Right ? e» prior to good -
    5? &
    1 •

    @ ‘ fag datura distribution uojost ^ oov ©


    :.\ •

    ' jc,
    it is oot onjoe -that cx pQsSoo b-oro into society ctfc
    oiefbero°S*
    ©
    iSoroe- pQYtiou ar posi-s'oo - Ot>eae oire sir py ca+axai
    ' ^
    4GQ- kibat is just £ on) oot is the ^OQy iosVitui-Hoos
    ©

    ris
    -;:
    f
    I deal coi-th -the o fjcfe ^
    ^ G
    ©
    ©
    ©
    ®
    ©
    - vs
    ft:
    ®
    Ir7! +
    ski
    •
    w*
    ©3
    7?

    v' ©
    £
    tS prior to QOQ(X
    bjRctOfe as a CSHiClSrO Op O^ h'fQtiOO

    -
    /e Siatproeov is ajtveo
    :1
    © Abov roimo^
    S
    •
    a
    Thpcmj of Jogtice • bfi ftQriQ 'ni s*o has feeeo 4be
    ' ^
    i ©
    ~
    roosi of -vha ioesVe*o sodetieS <
    ' ? ot

    :.s3
    i3 #
    '
    3

    I <>
    H
    ©
    51*
    Convinced dbere
    -that
    os-foe - ccotepHoo op josvfcp
    ^ i
    »«

    * rxZ*
    te eocb "CWcb ap
    Vote he
    2, Meote be
    Wroe

    **. - fe

    ^
    x
    :S* © cnceiderod OB feavf
    s©
    **-
    c
    pair do cm - ooy usheo principle of Jos ^
    -there ecW be peaces stability vo d-be society
    «Obfc<b fs necessary

    l3 © pcs dhe puysoft of nrahfonal piaos -


    -NS
    v2
    tdi+bio Liberaiisr>o fbe«<2 Qre -Kb +'r adrt-forh> of ethics . First fs
    .

    s -
    f
    * ©
    OHiifariQo 'Yepreseo +ed by Geo+bero- Second Is koo+tar) tVina'p'e
    •
    *£
    e 5 cabicb is based oo -the Weal of Hucoao Ojgofty £ SWMduaiigr,
    :.l
    1 © paOte supports kaob' ao -rcidf-
    :
    f Hoo . Accord(og to ^^oeouet fca«o4 ,
    E&cb person is end io \dsetf . NSO persoo
    3S oucpt do bs brea -Vrd QS
    ^
    .
    ’

    -?
    :
    i. © • " eeoos do ao end . J>>
    sSroiiqardoay RaOls Qfeo Soggesb dbet -eacK
    X
    S person possess an iOv iohbiI ?ty
    /
    dbe principle ofjoatfee
    !
    :
    S © Abat eveo -the toetfc e op edhVe society aaonoL override - Parolscpu
    5
    J
    1:
    © big theory as **
    Oeootoloo\ <»i . Tbshce as o faltroess bos> ids » otvfr>sic
    ( vaiue 33- caonov V>e .
    COTOpronois J -frrr be sq. of (cs ^ges SOro of
    *

    i
    QcivQ ryo
    ^ / od by roany .
    ^ ' ^
    Qor>ooV be coropsor-oisoci -Vo f©/ i -
    f
    5
    t
    © )
    bargaloioq ov cgicalos of q>, orN > ?rd<gsgQb - 3> < s ^ settled bated
    -@ £ - t3ei +be vtehie it caryooV
    -
    |
    t

    V
    ?. (..V
    CO .
    ^ o p*o<T> feec) -
    ^
    .^
    RacOisibo idea te s3p Hcv do ovn ’taviao ;di >a of Jos+ice •
    ^
    ••'
    0 ^ £ ub-
    *?I
    . f: ’: Each peirsoo has an inv / olabi ifhy
    U
    V
    founded OQ p^siOCJpIps
    JosHcp . »
    ©
    f-
    © © roiroducWon of f^cOls -
    S
    i
    i ©
    :1

    ©
    RacCte is considered os dhe greatest political pbiicscspbcr of 2
    Gprdbr
    f We bos revived -the paioopie. of Nbjr^QVivp pbUosapby.
    ^ :

    i©
    WiS db^ nooSterptece A lbeor|
    of device ,s ooosidefrQd CISOt i
    >

    ^FAerrenco point gbr aM caoteropacay pbiiHcai phiio &opbGLs i

    m
    © ^
    4 °*^ Ndasib -do Afoqrtt|Qt3eo -
    ©
    ©
    s
    E
    i
    f
    © sc
    E
    &

    i
    r
    i
    1;
    :X 0
    »3
    © MG
    bvpose '•
    toos , disewfis-p pd cOf+b> - ' be Ofi-UkaviaO ftrindp es of ' frr

    Cl
    * O'i

    Jcfitfce eDtorcb ha e OQQOa


    \ +toe donofoaoV p op
    ^odfes e.-
    .V;
    dbe ! ‘
    ^ .
    societies He believe toat
    " yr - .
    r:=:l
    JogVice rro ^
    Ube aiv3i~o bos Q beHpv idea
    of Justice bcacd on <§
    v£
    *
    ideas op scbo\ avs dV^e atocteouel toot
    •
    •
    1 jr.c
    f
    V £»

    -
    '
    vr
    (nj) Xopfueoaea . :
    PQCOIS >S io-pupnced by -the eooeepf of’ Hurooo t aoi-bi
    ^
    ••

    f
    •
    •

    VJ>

    dVen by J aoaei toot • Thus Pdoo sogge


    Uberaiisno -fbews
    ^ .
    * **«
    -pradftfoo
    tv?
    we
    ,
    op Klo^o Xbdividua v 'Sro -
    {3 sopevfor
    , adi-tbo
    ^ " *
    -toaf fe
    @ •

    .it (S) Oescvibe pools Ideas :


    Accovdto do Pools jos+ice is -to? Is* vb-vac- of social Vrsb-
    *
    -
    ' -- •
    £
    4U44oos os toe-
    is toe i * v&ke’ v «+ae
    - 6 op Qdsvptos op
    •dbooybfc- .cf
    pv
    v£
    society je, not- based oo -toe pJsVobpes opjos^os
    mV ?t coil nePber bade peace rxr stebi Hy . "toe, -toeo y op jos- ce
    I
    ::
    bus -to be teased on -toe idea op Justice os palvopss- 'toe
    ' ^ ^
    idea of justice as -ta'iimess * s a deoo-totoyi'cai pe^ speawe •
    It \S> baaed oo toe beifeP -Hnat human cifjorty bos to
    "
    be
    dbe 4«rctenoerdqi ideal beHnd any 4hy& op jos-nce.
    ,
    r 10
    xtj
    9 fecad; eaob person das trvbtalburty Quoded oo (Vinci- <£
    Accoidli ®

    pies of josvice - Vbropo pfc)n


    ty ts -toe oHtoa^ ve [toirtofie 4Cb'Cih
    * .
    e )

    caonof b-e dodtod . £voy \ dad op Jastioe has to oeftpbaa o


    -toe dea ^
    oP Huroao 'Dgptoy - Huroao o ofty isa settled ^ C
    p&iocJpip cQmnot be sobi-ected -to apy
    ,

    Oaicqios . Hence be
    f^ qaio ox social ^ e
    rtf' - **

    QOQQQ&S -*&&& -toon 4be 103s op ftoecW,


    tor soroe oaooot- be ;Jo©P pod -pto -toe gfreateJr a ood ol
    ^ otoe^s -
    ^
    -
    poie ms -
    toeovy is cJeootolqgiea ) . £ 4boD> © n MVS
    %

    .:•.
    •
    Murooo Ofcpihj 09 CK principle cao oof-
    ever footed • The idea is -to e><plQio toe oanop^roroisecio^
    Hurooo canity is esseo-
    ^ fjoSHc©
    (S;

    tdai coropon&m Qp apy

    .«:• :
    XT .
    idea usHce -
    ^ i
    I
    -O
    v.

    %
    '
    pi
    m—
    iC~

    1
    %
    H
    •V.l
    V*
    0
    riraocigstoo ’
    v;3
    a ©
    ;3
    © •

    uJ £ Co o o\yprc Ci CH Q PocOls idea of


    ' jbStfce eoWcb is opouodpd
    1
    •'

    15
    i - © to +he concept o-f Fturooo Ctfgoihj- Only i O socb sbcteKes -
    §
    1© pur-oao DfgoiH/ 'IS Q \>Q \ U '9 System T-bpre_ CQO be e
    I
    H vroooy . . ACCDvdfog To Bb'ikhq R -yiS\^bf bumci 'O sor> ,
    m* © ^ ^
    3 OF Fbe_ sFsoo eSV value t be be If eves dbqf . Wuroao t>'opi ,
    13
    ^© OQO be , ^
    fouodt* Fiona ) viaiue op ("OsroopDiiFob tec^ffd
    •
    -S .
    p
    : Q
    © Sbon Nioi-e - orvl ioal
    S
    : S
    •

    a
    ©
    v $
    1Conoep) osed bj Ra «©ls (o
    bis ^seoiy of T sTice •
    ^ fbsiboo
    "

    * - bos a.dbptecfi ^
    ,,s
    S3
    si
    si ©
    D~.as
    Ra ni,

    wrsi '« Hs Thaat


    1
    I ©
    V

    ^
    - *
    oi jusKco . • -©
    30 dQ| TxdnrOCfr Fyod f -HOO

    Feb+<JYT°S of crrQ'ioQi
    ,
    ftsaiWoo •
    *
    ( 4o give

    -1
    * FdovQi Individuals Vo4b©r - nan
    ,1
    > -8
    :
    ©
    Tf% are de lnfapxipgved
    bobbesian
    . ^ ivxitvfckials :
    •
    •

    persons .
    ^i* ©m
    i
    Tbe q e assembled for
    ^^
    mutually
    deFe-mplofag 4h
    ^ paiocipies
    ^ }
    & of Qoods - fe Ubeitxp ^quatrty, irvo<ae , toeatfb . >

    5 © Dignity .
    © we proposes, ex -tboM bt expevi'eroeov
    •
    noocon as veil of Xgooraoq;
    • i
    - - — -r ^JgooYaocG
    —
    —___
    *
    : | U > Pbn w ivr^e ^ r' » > >• ~s .
    .>
    Tbey do oof
    •

    c
    kooo pqyUcqiqjr® -{acf £> about 4
    II ©
    .
    aa aoaefcg . benose\ves eta aoetl
    < G Tbeg have 95«DS c
    eoexai
    1% © - Tbecj qw ive ' ^ icFprxof canornfes
    af +ba 3 pti -ocJp^ea of
    © # psychology .

    —
    .
    - justice
    $
    :• © - Uberg
    ?

    _ Igodubj af oppoisFuoi U - Difference p?nod pfes


    ^
    '

    - I
    i
    © (v) Cbodusto o -
    To conclude ooe can Sa y 4
    •

    |© baF 4be area I pospose of 4be


    cyp original posWoo IS^ To Spggesf conoepF
    $
    1¥ © VbQV dOS- doO noape TsqWooa )
    pO|ici<S. or>\y udr>Qr> ood Cno etirnl o erte.
    -
    I © aui Oioo pexG.o oai
    vence^- Si »roltcrf \ L) toe should evatuote \cu£§ i
    1I ©
    !v
    C

    ©
    cnncjioa ) pcelbcto o e voiQe OUT ^
    ^^
    C Ororajn rVavioioS have on heused TQds
    pcs\ fcA*es -paarr) db«
    ndevstaodr e G\ ii be ics'a.osJ •
    ,

    ^ >
    {
    2:
    :
    © absbracf b'raseIf J yr^o bts bacpg jrouo<=k - JDb £a £b oaonosen
    ‘necoLase coon -F <

    I
    5
    <
    > dbe ccocepV of Alc
    ,
    ^ - !
    \ © ^ois f'OQo dyna^eas 4hn reqt roan fs
    5
    ;•
    *
    ©
    5'taQ \ec{ s^e.\-f. ^ ?

    i ©
    © t
    l
    1
    ©
    © i
    l;

    0
    m 5
    Y ^
    f ?
    «1 °f SlggggC
    Mde -

    _
    SI
    la
    *3 Xblvodu Ghoo '
    opplf ^d by
    £
    3 • \

    veil of oovono© is. a ^ot6h s '


    ' ©
    ~i
    .
    ••*• i

    :©4
    Vi
    1
    Pac^ b ^
    mobile giving 4 te pwoclples o£ jostfce - ©
    ©
    (IT) Jhy xpggiero^nl ?
    Si
    s?.
    '
    4
    •'
    i*
    ^
    ©pcaose. be uoaoiS to derivp 4be Tbqovtj
    ofjosVic ciohtcb © 5
    ©!
    -V.1 Q process -
    RoVics oa* § fair by c*11 • ©
    v ;i
    - >. fft|Conditions
    ( ©
    ;;1

    '^fittef - VQii of Ignorance* coocepV osod fo oin0xoa \ position .


    j

    '3
    iSa #
    ::
    fin original posi-Hoo persons bo^e cooe •fqgeib'©3 4a deterrooe i> '

    n
    l
    ©i

    i
    the p^ocjpies TreiaVed to 4h>e dUetai bu+too of fVmfipy 8°°
    cuiqv ac S they 1=00 =0 ony Qen %al
    9
    m ^ '

    They cboV tooco toajfh'

    ^
    r;*

    -1
    * ®
    2
    Qeb' Od 4bp Mell of Ignorance persons ow'fe 0.1- Afce > principles
    "

    >
    ©
    |of sjosHce eob'Cb fames dfc&. bosic principles f po «cs ® TJ>ep>
    y
    n: ° ©
    S?.'
    •?S?
    of vJbsVice as -(plainese - ©
    -
    r> * -o
    ©M (fN Sgni -ffcQoce
    i
    -
    OeJI of inncjraoc-© ninsore goal 4he decisions =
    qs e p3
    ^ rational . ©
    ® CrVtidsoo
    ^ ©
    - "

    DuDO rbo SpggPSte tba there fs no


    * potting people behind
    fomf ©
    the veil op ignorance because c e caonof iroposs -Urose.
    .
    !
    5
    °
    principles of Justice cobicb dbey 'ho.o ^ aereed behind <®
    ©
    Cii
    (/i:
    veil of Ignorance -
    \
    7.1
    c ©
    Ocoovbn in bis boot s ese n s/ iifae* s ggeste -Hre aoocepi
    :. 4

    : ^
    ^
    of 4ton veil of gnoraoce - ra +ber 4han +bict ^ \ieii © p Ignorance
    proposed 'ey pQtD'lS
    I
    ^ V;-'

    ©
    According -fo (Dcornooi+oytans, it is difficult 4o consider at ©
    :wj
    noon can ever be ioo opgioaK position . ©
    .•. .•-
    *
    *
    dde - OrHidsro op original foS'tioo by feroiofStts - ©
    -
    ::i
    sdnolav Carole Fbteroao in bey bexot ®
    sexiaa ) Gnofyacj- >
    ©
    -
    suggests vbo\ -Vbe pcarVicJpanb? \e> PeOll -\beqvg Of social
    M
    :
    ! ons
    fnenticjn
    -
    ^
    -
    contract q re bead of the farobies- m majem' by op si-HfqW
    --
    of 4bs orol l s ave > roeo 6aCls doQs oof expli crfceiy
    *
    ^ - — ©

    ^
    iobe+ber <ooirv>eo coese pq rfof -4>e dsirbevafi'on'Sbe
    e}'0^es- -Vbof ?f <cOt co had
    ^ bteo -4e pqsbcJparA beb-ev
    ^©
    of dug-hce doould bave
    "J
    emerged . @
    ;-J
    "

    ©I ©
    1
    .

    •' !
    •
    i

    :©i
    '
    • • •J

    w>.
    n
    •

    RQCCSS FVioC/p I0S


    Of iTos-Hce -
    ! © A -ta to>0 Meostyte
    4 (Jj pacb pp -sSOO \ S +o hosJQ an •G ucs l >
    ^ ^
    © Lit>pa +y 1 0Y o+b<5SS
    ^
    4 •

    I liberty roropat bie octoto SITO'IO* ^


    1 © {StoGxfroUr'O -GqoQi Lib>0Vk|•).
    © © SodaI § COOOTOIC fn UQh' -Hes Qy& ta be Q^ra oged So ttoa.4- -they
    ss
    -To:
    ..v.o! © QTHO botb -
    ^ ^
    •

    «•*4* © (3) Reasonably -expected to be -eyevyoneto ac$.vjao+age ^


    1 ©
    ;:H
    -3
    © /VHacbed -to positions § cafpoes open -to an -
    :i
    •

    lexical ovder - — ot psi -odpiPS op Justice ©


    I ©
    y

    I 0> Liberty
    Mae
    £
    :
    , -.*o © m 2.b - &joau' y of
    opportunity .
    © d( 2. a -
    ^
    otp YPoce p ndpte
    -
    3 ,

    © ^
    *< © gyploioafi'oo op principles op TasHce.-
    1 V$ © fVvnctpe soggbSl -that possoot
    ' .
    tobsie. -f't^GQ or -o to [M«we-
    ^
    1 ® rtbelr osoffooa \ plans Ubb*iy| cdU w3sult into m- oaifto'es -
    - . *

    )
    •« s

    Xneqoatf -Hes gyre r^i --


    •

    - vt Tx-ai Vvor ^~»H eroeige. Voebctose people o\ i| ^


    ©i
    i
    ?
    !
    ? © -
    ctoffto <o tcirt'osbf toaleot - ttotOOVeY, NJQHJVOI fc*Q|s> cpse. not Jocp
    * - 3> s t-y co p je ioSVi -kxHonS, cdteai aoi-to +hcs& ba.H4.-ira|
    1L >
    or unjust
    ^ + ,-
    -facte - coe ca -o create s°cb tosP+avioos - ,*L^Hcb n i °dse -lbs.
    •

    -2
    ^
    '

    I ©
    ^ocixf ^ise 4he c^cKx^o ac es.- SUSo oaif-Wes
    <

    o
    cMSQdvaO toges ’

    ^ — ^
    ^ ^ ^
    ic © jO i ffed ool aDbeo
    ^
    (§)In oqi|-ti' > c\«rp 4 ) ^ - ^
    : «i
    J
    > ^
    ^3
    p<9 500
    ^ ^ 0uVcoro0s o P -Q oaf f -b op < ppo uo ? 4t .
    ^
    ^^ ^ ^
    5 © CM P p* ncjpi j
    ^ '
    ^
    sV^oU \ Yyy \)Q appcf qoHd. 4-0 pQ UQ- loisiQleoV -
    ^
    i;
    •r-
    < • ^
    u bi es onfQ Jasti-
    ^
    £ ' Poo/ ooy obeo » oq. 1 ( b* s OL<S _ x cidle
    Q Lisefai - or -+be teas* advantaged ^^ ^ ^
    *
    £
    i-
    •
    JJ
    y.

    1
    © Abav/e. ps- ^ todpter
    Pb taecaose
    dtAor}
    opse.
    pvovrif
    ^ • A

    *- C ese J) ^ Z: 7 ce oppo -
    I
    1I- ©
    W
    © tty to pursue oo©!s -talent
    b‘
    toe toe roost
    .

    od- JoSt
    odvaotoged
    >
    ^
    orta -
    e a- ^
    totana
    „c r -. adbo happens
    ^
    -feat n ^ ^
    .. y nnen s
    +0
    ave.
    %

    beca.oe,e of Hs tootanls- He bos cejrkxSn aflvaWogey ^OA/'&T


    ^
    ^ ^
    ^
    © 4be others-
    y. Those o.ve in -toe. least cx6. vctn ~te Q)Qocj $, posto« av-> '

    ——-
    i

    I© coiU qbo
    _ 4foc| ,-t ?nt !r bQCaoge * j

    Ss

    >
    0v©vy cwpje, Vyaci Ubevty .
    - 1

    i
    -fheiv l-OteYGsi- ^fS to4 ten
    I
    -
    c. -evpvyooe. bod e oOw'tij o|T
    «

    Im
    I »
    OppCfYto'ottj .
    care np
    1
    i-
    fc
    > x :;
    hg
    1 -
    t

    IB © 8
    !
    | Ie
    |
    5 ^© t

    \P ©
    %
    i 1 2

    9
    i‘
    i'
    *
    5
    K

    f
    ?
    b
    i
    V
    £:
    W3K
    »>*
    justice - Lgdurg 44-
    ’
    @
    ROODIs B-ioopes of
    ,

    Crifclsros of [oSTo if
    i
    ^ 20 ©'
    *
    *

    i ( to Gil •
    m MCX>rf«?cjro Uherfcj ©
    COtnnOUOlfoYl QQ CYl -b CS- &> © <
    ' v

    Xi
    '
    ' '
    n&
    ^ ^
    (
    RQOIS has
    -
    a /pcoidioc, to Cow^ooiHsian
    s ,
    a
    ’
    cionot soppo>£ £ # '

    1 ropoifaoce -Vo 4te


    ctyrorauafty - They
    +
    ° irxite choice should^
    ’ e- ftfeedoro 0 ©
    agueroeot Aba \ ehbesh ^
    CO
    • .
    **
    - t
    t B noV oecessoay +bah 4he life
    .
    'V
    be qbove alt dR> r values- ) ©
    choice is
    Qf a pevsoo -ex^irdsirg his fseedoroof
    £%
    '

    ©
    bis -fseGdtaro c> tf choice..
    •

    ep exeYciofr #

    :'c
    *Cl•
    '

    x<
    Abe tffe pevsoo 'cob
    Qappos© Q p©5300 •exercise. a ^
    fspedovso op choice Ao roqwj
    voeQo Afoqh- h life ope pe^soo £ho
    ©
    -- multiple At roe, ih dees ndr ? .
    0
    roamra ©cAU Ac* orxe is 00V as sohspj
    W COrorouOlfQvianS OISO SpjQQSV Abqh CCyQ- ave
    00 b f *ee Ao choose
    ,.
    ^ ©
    #

    1v:
    1 OW ends - 00 « >.
    ou «r ends
    band , end Vs araPadi 8 *
    * oter
    ) - dB 0>
    " ° ^ ®
    VQT 'frat-be* - ao cboosipg Ahem;
    • .
    ^
    pa this pAoo'Hy Vo Ubes+t \S based oo 4foe coocepHo'o of Aho-
    ©
    ?.£
    r' j
    ^
    rotShfc rr>ar) coheaeos mean Is QituQ-hod ec?lf
    ' •

    -
    ,

    of ©
    Rousts Wmset-f couth oof be fsee Axono hhe
    his otoo sodGfcq - VAiS pYefcyeoce - r Ufoehy B ° °t ©
    i

    his society ie Os coKUte -


    ^ ©
    ©
    .1
    \ ©@ Social tiberals CrftftS
    ©
    /.{
    dioQYt a son
    ^bacots
    •

    a, sen appre- © 5
    i
    Co biS essacj y ‘Ibeqoaif -y
    Re-examine© Ama
    cot -thou -h Capacity @ ^
    Chive buV h© SOc esV +hflh
    ^ fsefidtaTo
    ‘

    ..• I -
    cq frej no foeah
    j- pveo f^iart-ha Nlussbauro a \e,o Orlhicised ©
    -
    :1

    ^
    '
    ,
    ''
    • .:•
    vM Raote OJT tsvetflootirg -the cqpacfA app ^ooeb -
    :V.i
    £5
    -1
    ^
    © femiotSV scholars ^ ©
    #
    ISI
    © ccnole. Crtngan
    <- £4toiCS OpCCSYG ' ©
    she scg0psh Aha ir lostcadiop Uhcxh)
    :Y
    S3
    aooth -top hhe p?Ac5Mhy .
    a
    ^ ©
    W. ©
    m--r-
    ©
    ©
    ©
    ©
    cS
    - I

    33
    .vl
    '

    4C-~
    : .JI
    *

    ::h
    tc ii
    is
    - m
    -W

    1
    iSl
    - 5USQO
    (Ry 1 MQlQY ORiO o

    m
    '
    •

    ~
    Xb bev boot c C-ceobef 3 ush ce.
    & '
    1©
    '

    J I ^ fc coose Pools has oe eofed Abe fssoe of jasfce


    |©
    ‘

    : «
    «
    3

    3 c£>{4h> l o A-foe ^ ^ --
    Me. oos j balks afc>oUb josAce \ o Public
    > * 3
    x
    © Sphere csf social vosf
    .
    '!
    asbte'
    '

    1©
    (2) 2,fc© Fair Eqochtt of Oppo rVu o<tcj . ^ MO CYV CiSrvO — ^
    .3

    8
    -?
    ©
    JOSH -fed i f +b | are
    ^
    ACCDvdlOg -tc> pacDls, Sbdd \ § pcomoroih ,’oequdiities a^s
    Guto'coes of fexir
    ^
    •
    .c
    2 ©
    *
    :>
    :$ ©
    %•
    Of opporfuort) . & roecms ^toqf 4hew2. should be SOTOS.
    •3 leve 1 i og process lO
    .
    soaeiy •

    ©
    S
    ©
    - SCA3s (§) 2A ~ Social §- Fcooorolc £b <?quaif -Hes as© josAped 00
    - ^^
    ?

    - c-
    :
    ( P 1+ 'yesoltB 10 I0 fbe bene-pts
    * ©
    • V*

    A of +b© leash otdvao bagc


    vi © opGhi’oo of 4he socfebj
    -
    3
    :»

    M ©
    :«
    •

    :«
    :<
    •
    5

    ©
    '
    Above p odpie te kno =cr> as < Kf{ isgpce pwobpie - Q
    ^
    Aabps foto ODosidpacyKoO toe. fropcrrhaoce.
    <
    = ^
    F •

    3
    C
    ^ of Muroao O\ gott
    I M spnce fb'ociple «dll Neo. fafv ck?a>| Ho fbose oha
    r
    ¥
    ic
    ’
    ©
    ©
    ^
    ^boppoo -

    ^
    in be ioa poster) of dtlsabvoo-teiQpJ ? IQ p e roaor-
    F.
    V

    £
    <•
    fc
    £
    :
    © , j^ ootofS-Won . Disadvantage fe not- beccxose of Ah&fr ^
    choice bat- becaoso of r*aodono bocbooseo 1act-
    I
    A
    © J

    Cvi'bi Clsro of
    .

    t o Difference fbocipie -
    f © U bPC +CmQO Aj
    ^ aerpooV •
    1

    ,
    !© c
    © MQZ-ICF- - 1

    c
    ©
    Niozj’ckhas gNeo c PoH-tleroeot Theory of cfosHae * fsjo fcb
    ji
    do , oof ooppoyv- coel -faxe slate Accord log ^ -
    ^ ' kio ce
    -^
    ^
    C
    |© (

    <
    I © Rogress ive TavcaAoo is a. bonded la boar 33- is ao qgse-
    i sstoo or Qy&rcxon Jf goes agavosi Abe. p ociple of “D o itj . '

    ^ ^
    '

    5
    i 0
    0
    O doeicks Abeyvy ca ooh be coosdeeA superfcr -fo pa CMs,
    Ibeo -
    ^
    Xf is af Abe bes+ just dte C Hci&vy of Pa <as Xbpavc;
    ^ :
    I
    i
    i

    ^ ^ 5.
    1
    i©
    fiso^ Abe f >e^specfveof ube*laovao \Sro.
    f

    i ©
    © I
    1'
    !
    © 1
    V
    t
    !
    © :
    I1
    ;- v

    © I:
    i:

    L<
    1:
    © c
    t
    ( u )|~ C9DCJQ 1 / Mgrxfftte
    i<wl
    *1 ^
    Pools beoy of Josffe
    '
    a d fooce of foeqmu -
    ^
    Z:-y

    ^ IS
    3
    -Wes found coestefo csocie-fgs «
    •
    i
    fo
    m
    Afcovdirxj fo 'tvtirxlSlS Pa ^lS Tb !0*j of Justice , is net -tfoe
    i
    a >
    ix - ©
    i ^
    4 >eouj of
    Justice rotber a \- beoy josf fjipg ?oeq oatitn £5- .
    ©
    Raoofe bos + ed do .2bo?o 4hof foeqooiF-y ifathp* fbao Sqoai
    ^
    :.y

    ^
    •

    I
    (So psQfQrQOCjP ttG tbiGS do Shoo ?+ QSo 'yOtfona / choice • ©
    o
    -
    «
    i
    Difference Principe- shojr OHS- ^
    (T) facois is a greatest -t-binter of so*5 century -
    #
    i ©.
    © S dbeowj of JosHce is ao ho porta ov dbeoirj Justice
    of
    '
    ^
    '
    Hi oof OD
    AJ .
    but also <01veo Credit fbr wpAivQ| of oorrootWe. pou-bru tpnioeopy
    *

    Cv
    ^
    © fools is a UbeffQl aobo doG3 not soppoa-t fbe Of lifaJriao J&eoin ©
    U'
    V;
    Of Justice -
    ©» facas has tofvnessed socbi nocveroenb , promts f be\ fQMed that
    ^
    54 db©se caoact be Qfij stability ootf l caoAess people ( hnsk -ev 5
    f
    .u
    xiS-tirg ocioj systero ;s Josv •
    ' ^
    ^ ^ O
    3> JuS ce is a -the f ^ vfetqe op do dai system
    ::1

    < ^ ©
    •

    © 8y using dhe roethodoiogy of CDOV*-QC£ be has glveo 3 pobcifies ©


    -
    of justice cobo' o he called Qs Justice QS fkivoess - ©
    u -
    bis ffoeoy op jygpce he bn'es do ocbfe^e Q ol n bdccx t/co
    ^ -^ ©
    :' i
    desert / 'oort t oeed •
    J
    ^
    @ de bos given bis psiodptas of jastice io dbe 'lexical asde ^. ©
    c
    P&indple tS bbesrhj, sr- C3 fair ecf >airfcy of .

    ^ Deference Principles -
    is
    According ta Difference Rnandple Social ifConoravc 'loe oarffe
    CQO be jostifed ^ ~tbe_ ^
    ( >

    ©
    s
    '

    .
    ong_ if ft ^GSuits into -the beae -p-fop #
    .;M
    A iGasl advootoged . Q & natural that -,n a '

    i3@ffree noavkef oapitaufero com etoe»ge as -fte (eas-f- ^ #

    1 - .
    adN Qotpged ihei r posibbo is oof josf out of choice
    ^
    'taodoro aod bfuif luct • pence -those <Cbo
    bub
    ©
    ©
    =
    Qjdyao1< g© i

    ^ ^
    ,
    »
    •

    Should CDoWibuVe -far dbe uoell bei o-f aOorSf o p .

    l\
    ^ ©
    ©
    -o
    ©
    • :0
    ©1 ©
    , -;- 3

    @
    ©
    %•
    f.cj
    :•
    ->:
    -
    ©
    :u

    •
    r
    neatest not fe i
    Soday ( s a chain - Bteo
    :&
    4be
    @ as fol ryPSs
    is gges^ wd jusffos ^
    © ' Thus, PcscOB
    ^
    1
    fovfoiabf ; Hy o-f Hurvxao D n'
    ^^
    '
    /
    '
    4
    s£
    IS based GO
    0
    it< ©
    (x) HooOeyQr pacOte tfoeoS; is •sotsjleGfod 4o c&i +iasro
    SoTa l sfs •
    '
    s
    f &oro Ub
    ^^-
    16 #
    : •
    tavioos l ft© MO CT-
    ^ ^
    ^dccordiog - -
    Vo SociaifSte, Difference ptndpb is defence
    '
    - >v
    r
    -
    8t ©
    3 -f inequality -
    :.k
    £
    0 N

    t
    •

    I 0 pQcQlS 2nd Tb-eo j Of Jus-Vice -


    •

    :
    :<A
    I;
    «
    * ©
    T- >;
    : MS
    0
    ^
    boot - cPoiifcical Ubesaifero’ published fo tgge.
    xo Cbirtcal Liberalism patois Was MPO 4 fbifffcao cbncep
    T:
    .
    £
    ifc
    <:
    I ©
    ©
    tboof TbsKceT ib political Liberal isr^ Palate has respon-
    ded to bis tfo^otouaitq r >a o c&t'tics -
    ^
    © Qa<? •
    •
    #w 0 Kito rs COnOrOUOl'ta ria Oisro ?. . -
    #ss .®
    A
    «*

    (2) bat are op


    3 ©
    P< •
    •
    ^+0*100$ 4- U bGrtcnrioas ?
    the major poiots debate be-tuaeeo cbno^aop
    t O (5) Gft
    *
    I© ’
    ^ COrorouOitCfJfiQO CDOCeptiQo -
    ©0 ToS ticG •
    -
    It
    r.
    @ SboH Mote - Mfchael Saodels Idea op aush'ce -
    v
    i ©V
    i,
    d) shoH Kioto -- KtQteors Concept of Spheres Of cjbsW< e = •

    I O (T) htbQl <s COrQriOuoitQriooiSro ?


    *
    .
    vtcvproe
    ?: Q
    Ccn~> t-ouo WanootSr o- eroded to ©taeSt both as Q

    V
    O as coet t as a pb IOSO pv y

    I0
    x
    c - Q
    ^
    cobav ,'s tbe idea beblod commaoitaviaois«o
    To coestero cooVid because of The p^e^alenoe c> f Libesauhno
    . V
    as dbro'ioaot cui-fctiY© 4be*e bos been a o © -excessive
    !
    i 0 \odividualisro . FvreseWe Isota Ken lo the oanoe
    of f adomo
    I- 0
    c. .
    Tjesu teiato foang oe a -Hve consequences oa- oog
    ' ^
    T.
    I0 ©roao but Qbo ^
    society £ state ' £b coesteso <oavid there -
    !
    t-.
    0
    S'

    C>

    655 ©
    ^ is a decline of l suat capital as suggested
    ^ ’
    /
    pobevv Ritxifa .
    i
    }

    £ i

    I£e- ©
    .
    \
    X

    I .
    i

    Ib © i
    l
    iK ©
    |
    c
    © :
    ::
    sK ©
    6 !
    -
    c
    IJ
    © i
    l
    l

    fiK ;
    s i
    i .

    ? £
    f
    .VSW
    Heooe, rotorouov -fa'fiaois^ a '' ^ ^evi 0G
    ' v<3 D '3
    ° ^ av bn ~
    ' ©
    I rJ
    1
    CQlis ISi
    1
    .

    vi
    gb \ p «Oi +b HiS COmroUOih-J- CbrorodOfffJViQ-O'SM) '

    . .i
    * Socles! oeJt toovbi rg . I B
    -
    'j
    Vr >
    i

    / js a philosophy rornrrunitQ'rfootsro Ltoevgctl as unbejoe


    Q
    v;.j
    .Vi
    ©
    Vi
    '

    v; Of bberbi'bQoiS^oC UbfVOli'smJ - SornLof +«e p-sonolopryf


    ' ©
    i eoronouni+Qriars ape. Alas Dcsir MQcXo jr v M Vhael Qacdaf

    vi
    "
    '
    d

    :1
    )
    cbQvies Tc jbr Mfcbaei vJairjur:
    ^ Ccrnmu .
    ^
    ^ '
    ©
    •
    •
    .1
    :i
    -
    •
    '!
    :-Y :i
    *

    ’
    # Dpbofe bGttoeen
    q Concept of
    oi+an’QOS
    Sgj-f ( HUOOQQ MqHJrg ) ^- U bPvfOriQ rS1sco ©
    t
    §§
    '
    -
    Si
    I According to ^rouoitabans^ +be liberal d <sc f ^ooo£ btao
    Cor '
    ^
    m as a Atorotebc vooo is oato reoii j- tdao fe neve* ao uneo-
    i
    #
    )is

    ? rj
    ^
    Curobored self - MANI'S embedded self or situated seif -
    According to liberals, soif is prior to end . But accosdipg to
    '
    ©
    #
    CDrorOUOitariQOS QGlf I S OOt paiOS to end TfCHber CDoeti +oH-ed
    "
    ©
    .0-;

    by end - -
    Seif 6 ptoor to end -> i Sa Ubeeai ague noeov •
    *
    •

    -
    suggest thai-
    ©
    ©
    ^ao should bone fspedoro to dea'de bis end or <goat - or concep -
    +ton Of good j'sight QI90 • On the other band cornroaoitAsiaoS ^
    ©
    S gg£Q\ 4bav Mur> Os situated seif - toe canoot caiftoch ourself
    i °
    ;l

    fom our community - Qoad OS Common - <5ocd is abased ale. - ©


    v:
    i
    K
    ©3nnov Vooco good atoop - ble d [Scene* Tsotbpr -vf >ao cboose •
    ©
    i<
    fokle. \ ive io ttnof , spaced cuftase . It csd iff cult for Ma «0 fo e>
    G>oe out of bis Q3nOTOC» oit - corn nod O'tortQoS talk Qbocit pa - e
    rr8 ’
    ^-
    cAcle o sodogor self dts ODvesy scHberfhan obstruct 'season -
    ^ ©
    © Cboceptof GbrorounTt j - @
    ’ {r
    ^
    Ubetaifsm/ Liberals do not gVe impoboooe +o conofouof .

    A
    ’

    1
    for liberals
    Qocoroaopy fs ootb’> og £<oepl Abe Os egof ©
    Of Individuals - Liberals beneve Abat person cao leave ^ ^ #
    ©
    VAs ctxorountb-j- liberals QISQ believe -that- t-bev^ fis notb '<
    •

    OQlied OOronQOO
    good - Lbrorooo ood fS QUro Of tod'VtdUQ| ^ ©
    :-f
    ;

    *!
    ss
    ©
    3
    ; ^ @

    ©
    - i ©
    r

    :* ©
    ::i
    ©
    ..i
    '

    >34
    ©
    fi ©
    -
    o'; j #
    ->:-
    •

    s^ '

    assises
    ©
    I t)
    I
    .v
    ©
    » ©
    •
    *
    1©
    1
    bob co
    ^ . ro
    unihj ^ouoife
    , '
    te ,
    Accoxdiooto coromuoHarians, 't S not possible
    ** *
    .
    «
    b« 0 gev toao ijr >d « viduai. individuals ood ^
    deot of the (p rov^oon good .
    (if ?) Concept of jushoe ,
    -
    .
    ^
    to p r -
    ^
    r
    ^ -
    |©
    #
    . According to Ub^YQis +F>0fP Ct>o b Q d cjoh/erQQl f oaple ^
    •
    T
    >
    £
    $ ©
    *

    -
    of jQ9H oe Justice is a pYodud of 'season io ^an . Liberal
    toooepv of Justic£ is bQ8fd on toe concept of Atoroisbc
    £

    ' -
    I © mao - cp Libia s tai^e covptsaiish’c VIEGO ofjustice / cororeu-
    r:
    :£
    1
    >1 oHaritetfans tote pQ'*HculQY (s*ic ui<?o of Justice - the sense "
    >
    1 5 Qf Jos+ice to’iii VQ -frora - .
    society to sociiejjf idea* op
    ^
    1
    T ;
    t
    I£ # justice cannot be iodepaocteov of pros space 4 Cuitotoe •
    :l ©

    &
    :c
    (jy) l CboQgpv of stale
    io ©
    According ^ Uberctis oeutwatrtoj -
    :

    I-i © etaVe should adopt value ,

    :•«
    Sbate. -should be tod iffbireni totoa*ds different
    < op iIft? .
    |^ >
    1©
    i
    Xi
    c
    Itap bomd be sppemtfoo between peasonai 5 p i -Hoa / -
    ^
    Uberais propose oo'vprsqi citizenship - Ubeva is crsiive on
    ^'-
    % 0
    dbe idea of toa -wooout'si-o to achieve solidary .
    ¥
    Accord ir to Cornr-ou ofK) YiQrs , Sto-ip need not be npuhtolov- o
    x
    5
    £
    -
    ; ra
    ©
    \-
    ^ ^
    indifferent - Stoto should praroofe such values obicb stsen-
    »

    v Qtoeos aoaai GoiidQTfto - Jtute should not- expect -toatperaoo


    ? C
    codl becorv <30 YQ-h'Ooq I to foYget bs CfarorOuoHf @S . CU9toro 3
    i o 1
    ^
    brad toons - shale should adopt cultural aeia-tivist perspsa-iv ^
    ^
    •
    !:

    I• O
    5 ©
    •

    V
    to+e
    ^Jocjqishould net oHter o pt -
    to achieve
    sot f da Tito - Justice ia> oof
    bonoc eoisa
    oobeeaiislcg
    -
    ^
    V ioo -fov
    . Justice isao
    -
    ,

    < © Ottk Of diffpreota -b'csn - According to 4hero, 4beve e no need to


    : P keep -religion out oP pob\{c spber® becaiuge -vhcsV fg, oot !
    i
    ; © passible - n- & better If toe recap o\Sg it %
    give space in
    ;
    i

    © public poll Lies- COroroucitotoaos soppcfrts 00030 ci a bona l 1

    -
    . \ ^ \

    deroocracd ratbeir toao t^ajo-dtabao oeroocra


    ©
    ^
    •

    G ’
    i
    \
    0
    o i
    E

    @ ;
    E
    ii
    > i

    0 |JCD

    f
    .
    V
    5?5K????IMMM :>
    mmmmmmmssmsm
    <®
    Saodal 5 Tbgoftl Of JusKce
    Book - ubesaiis^o if uroits of Juswce.!
    * '

    ‘ . £

    . Vi
    •'•
    ;
    Soodoi has Ontscisai TOtols tbecng’ of jush c£ 00
    g&ouods (T) Racote conceptfooop self -
    •
    ^ no
    ,
    ^ r
    m
    ($ pools conceptoo of society -
    conception op se \ f.
    © Ratals -
    VJ
    According -topod
    Saodai ,
    Hon -
    MQO JS etnbedld0j . s£lf . MQO CS nQsJQr
    ®

    posiWoo isan doswaO ^idea -


    ©
    io Original Ordinal m
    People are DOV- abstract individuals* ’TjQhpcj choices, tbcg #
    a*e moral agents froecobQJs of society J located to vinoe 4 (

    ©
    ssi spa ce , embedded io apftooncop Yeia+tons. hoy tsuds seif
    \6 panor -to end . SuV according saodq ) self is eoosPk -
    *
    ^ m
    «1

    -
    -hed tg -God Rople toto dpdeface Co *ecH it ftp coo the basfe, '
    @
    ~. v.. OF cohah -tbeg oars Id eras rgb-t - Hccoever, ( Hsoevas a f %ee
    -
    .V
    Choice - Hence, +be concept of justice coo b«> understood ong a
    coH-hio doe Btacopcoovp of conotnuo'vy not independent of U ^
    f cV;
    £?

    ^
    %
    •

    ©
    ;
    •

    © pqcQlS Conception of Soaeg.


    pocds Should haye to pen bucb e
    duiieir \rieco of cow^ unl .
    V.

    : i
    •
    A
    )
    5

    1
    <
    QOocept Of pgbiS cannot- be defiocbed faa D (bro um -ties

    i t£ j - J> os not urdciStacdab © oe to


    *
    ^
    <
    ^
    cut -tun? % Hadf fion - lb t's not passible +n adopt vQiueneuba'
    ^ §

    &
    1 ' ' ^chg coe should oof - atft'irrv?
    ourr fdeopties, io poblic sphQrp .
    <

    ‘
    1
    @ Michael klalzer
    vf :-
    •

    Boot - The spheres of juahce - >

    in -the coords of ida (rfr , Different goods ©45 M


    ‘ ^^^
    diSt buded different . accordl og o -the different roean -
    ^
    :’:1

    ^
    ^
    •'

    attached to -toeno bg diffe-ceoV , foacovdao ^ to # groups


    i -the different procedures leg different egents an the diff- -
    erences Ore derived fforo -the ol ffereot understand tog toh/ cb
    ;
    Ore inevitable product
    of difference in bieteft j culture - ^
    ^
    ^^
    • dl
    tvi
    m ©

    %
    m
    :Vfl

    %v:l
    *Vi
    • • ••
    * .
    .f .-L,
    :1
    /
    _ _
    -- -
    c

    -^ ^ ---
    '. v vj

    of .
    •
    .
    CC'. r»‘’v%'V%r c
    ' ^

    >Kv. ri TtJr vr'vrT


    V* ^

    one aocW 0 equals - W e a v e piroducQss of


    1-C-
    # V4G )
    ^
    BodOl roeaorrg. We should *599? & each © be s osocep
    4 ?-
    @
    *
    ;
    ."-S
    : S
    ©
    : £!
    We should ooi- ir-opcee cm roeooirg ov values oo
    5
    0U ^
    4foose toba caooor \ ctaoH j 'hberose.lv s <crf +b 'Vhese vaiop

    ^
    / •$
    .j
    rl:
    © ^
    >§§
    1
    : -S
    # TusHce fs DOST oo hQVsod- conoepv -
    :S

    I© ^ Jdshce ts ObcU people


    d>obsadbp - -tD. He has \veo
    1:
    0 xonop!e of caste sg&te<© ;o
    abdiQ. x> coohoues toecQOse people <sob9dnbe Vo -fbc toncep
    :c
    ‘1
    1© ;s

    .0 :
    i of castp - He GUQO o vps he fvaropfe op Aoa’ec ireec© *£b©re
    ^
    ^ ^ ^
    •

    :• R
    »
    %
    >a % people prefer to donate tooney -
    •

    for bal d!pa Q rr^aseur^o


    '
    Ji
    5f
    13 © •
    l
    -
    ipa tber -VtoQohGlpJ
    rg poovs-
    .
    igdme 4-5 ^
    |© p9 jo^l 2- ] 00
    «
    i
    :
    S
    O • 2? 6ook of fiacots - ^Po ih'cai UbevotisoW
    ’
    Ulby Pacds cxosote Pon-tfCQl Ub0Sc*| ferr^‘/
    1#
    I •To response +o ODroroucSVcivVio aribfc
    I ©
    tonrioO& vieco ?
    1
    1 © ‘
    u3 hcK cOQS <2)ir>rouo
    ^
    I
    S
    1 JbaKce tls, '
    -
    poa+iCo \orbhc
    ft O
    M sober be -Vo -toot rdea of jusVice tob cb is a&u pev -Vbelx
    I
    I© *
    firodfHons or (brorouolb) voiue -
    '
    ^
    Ie idhoi- coos -Vhe toafo qoes-Hoo fiaofe has -
    tacUsd i0 bis book
    *
    *
    V
    C> «
    ’
    rbllhcal bbexoijsro ?
    Xb u bera| societies, #3afe people \-yosje
    -
    c

    '
    >:
    f.
    f basic vlbeshps like
    p eedorv of .speech
    S 0 ^ ^ if cp^ess ioo Hweedoro of felpgloo .
    ^
    '

    f
    !f (: -
    Ueoop, It is oqfu Traj
    fbat people aO’tU be boldloo d\ £f ?n20f
    <e
    va\ups os pbiiosopbies or
    -
    '

    I©
    H&
    corTprebeneive cJadhrioeg,.
    ’

    ^ * fe +be challenge ?
    \ ba

    1© UocO -to GneuirP - bac ppvsoos


    Ik © ’ ^ baN'iog dffeseof coropwebcosi ve
    docfs ioe stay -Vcpeiber $ Hbeve. fs a
    -
    II ©
    1©
    .
    Moto SAabl r Kj is eosused
    hoto -tbey 'tsesofe -vbe
    -
    fr j »
    lolfbevai detyj^Kabc sodeues ^society .
    °
    ^
    !

    i
    fsso'OS ddoich
    evoer e because of CcoofiioHrg
    "K

    S©
    5

    *
    ^ .SQsooable plu«3Us»o?

    i
    r
    C
    ? i -

    ; •
    0 ii

    © I -

    ©
    P
    ;
    p

    r
    |;
    plq Qiisro £
    %
    UlbQl' - . fS PasoOG'bl ^
    si
    1 ^
    ps . ppffSOOS jpiiOcOs
    -
    ^ Vaw’oUS CoKjprQ -
    A ~:
    2-
    :c x
    S

    .:M
    '
    So \\\yQZG | CDUO
    beos'iv-© dochrtoe^
    ^ •
    Cv.
    t-v ;

    E>carop\ ? of CoropbpbPoSNi© dodixioe &


    _
    •

    . UbpsCHisro QS pbiiceop oP life , cbnr&Haottc) , Xsla.rO ,


    ^
    v:-i
    S3
    3 ©
    »3
    >3
    FJ
    teoo oP sabi \\ty to -4toese.S3cte s ‘
    ^
    «3
    '
    • --!
    '
    ^
    -:::
    ::
    •

    CU ltU*
    )
    -
    AcCDtd'ting -to PACD|9 ©he ffpcsoo b denpoOfO -bic poutfcQ |
    ©
    ©
    ':V
    :-g _^ Wha-v feAuYGS op OSrooc^a+^C RDUATCQ| CulFqsp ?
    QY<9 4be - ©
    CD Voiue of Gqoai_ dtteeoeMp -
    •«

    ©
    i @1 P<=op1e ctvG 6GS » r» Oq
    g Ao a-ffes- paitr 4ooos Ao -e^ncb oAbeir .
    C '

    (@ people 3o/ -k otoes ^ -VihCoo


    Tr bV ^ioqsoo

    ^
    '
    I1 m
    .;4
    ;
    •

    ;' d
    i

    !
    ’
    (DrOpOVs'OO
    o r bQ./ OiO',rg. ^
    PacOfe cess -kbe + Vto OY r lappSo
    0 rcaoserxsos •
    #
    ^
    ^
    !

    1
    I Acco^ di-no so
    tocois, CM?*1QPP>' cooseoaqs iS OCdfe
    ©

    I • v’ |
    <
    Modas VI'VPDCPl •
    uibaf is Modus vuQodi f
    ^ %
    ©
    ,< A
    /

    » .•
    Modus viv-oodr sboco baga'O uld© by eel4f . ©

    ^ ^
    - 1

    ovpriapptoa (poseoo s fs ©
    - based co ^OOTSQ! CBPVODTOT>
    . .:1
    '
    | of fahr oees • <3
    r.p
    \ f,v
    j '

    :' !
    1 .
    ! Wbav rs oYosiappi consensQs P
    d!
    Poasooobp %
    McfKJl psop-e Viv'tot ; o cbrocorovic peni ticp ) ©
    ^
    -
    1
    .! PUlttjBQ QSO Qble Ao ciG /
    : i '
    ' GAop OYe^Oppf OQ COfogdbSOs op # '

    V.i pD! HnCQl CbOCgpnoo Op ©OSHcgp - CST

    1 wbaHs ffoiVHcoi coocepHoo op JbgHce


    pCppi'CU )Q> JTlfpaSC) OS -
    ^
    fts
    <13

    .
    sse?
    '

    •
    A
    •5
    i pbtit-fcQi COO cept- iovoop
    Ju£©c,£fS bQSPd on -vbe
    JiSHce as .fhWoesscOHto so« e es teisoi TCOCJL CQMOO
    ncipie exp V^ ©
    I
    sa
    AdDTidiog Ao QatCAs > , Pb \ rtf cat
    ^
    °cooeep foo Cf cjosbee >& "
    ^ '
    ©
    #
    Free
    ^ -
    3 {QOOHIO idpa
    ^
    b
    ^ ©

    •o
    : ©
    ©
    ©
    ©
    ©
    I
    .
    vr
    #
    :: £s )

    1
    gs i
    #
    :!
    • b”

    »:
    -Tv
    » *

    e Stood 1*0 C
    W.

    -7
    t ulhav ' (s> 'f
    ©t
    ^
    rofQns tool- basi
    ^ on Q try pc^rb Cu \Q v COtTYpnre b Pr>3' Vt
    ’

    t Is jbsl- a ^otoaBeOCG ‘
    '
    '

    11 ©©
    •

    ft TSPSPmfol-PS doy
    f
    doef ^ OGif
    A-ba^ people feesipve
    fbl ^rtCOI ccncpptfeo of •OasKce suggest
    i ® $ e l te^Qes is
    .
    'V
    i Abat 4be best aDoy to -resolve Abo doo cfua
    1si ©•

    tbsopab the ygbt procedures <rcf $ cb toc'ude DeU be^J Hoo -


    $ v-
    :i Cb tsro . sss
    -:S
    i©
    to l-eg is)a+ um?s os toeuc*s access •to -the j clal
    Tbus . (3QCOJS Krv> t Liberal
    .

    Ao tbe po/ itica ) apHeve -


    V H e (s ^
    m > >

    .
    -
    1& 9
    not- ad on liberal ism ae> a ctroprevoeo ve c\cxJ ryS. txJ^
    as
    i©
    AS "

    paittoi ,ftoevorsro Thus Pocofe adroit +txw oceU prfocipl ^ oV


    ^ ^
    MG

    © justice COnocA- X oppKed to 0.1 epbe


    * -
    OF | * °^e p*ooP
    ^
    Ube.
    .
    of JUSKOQ cd« u oof appeal reasonable t o a i l .
    •
    I
    .;J
    •

    *I8 ©
    . S'
    ''

    AS © TSOtfero is CL ebaraotejrfebc of sode^ es u*tf > deooocraWo fob


    |
    i © b'cai culture •

    1©
    X
    Ccronouoitartao On' b'cs - o •

    ©
    Boob ^- Co^orouovtcm'ao LiberalfsnQ.
    CCS 4o cohy
    people
    I AtfOvdig AO soodai -+tbere fs oo inPQQoo rGo -
    !
    *
    i
    ©
    :s
    4
    ©
    Should ^
    accept Liberalfsro as (
    political cepfoo opj'U9Vr'ce

    i © vd
    - cp< g -
    1*
    X
    £
    O
    '
    3 8oob of pgcQfe gbe Lacos
    this boob racDls bas responded 4o +be qoesVtoos
    ^
    of A-foe
    ^
    1 TTOispd by CO ooa po i \ tQ Q .
    )
    scholars i ; te 'tboroas fegee, ,
    >
    ? © '

    -
    • i'

    x
    cba > tes - Bertz
    II /

    b
    « [ WbQf Qve 4bdiv qO'esUoos ?
    [) Sioce> people in , <r*>Hb are -SOffeYirg toeooose of Or ost
    4©
    I1 © fagKtat/oos. 'moposed oo Abero Vy -Vbe •jticb people of Nfcndb
    . ^
    1© Since toe are Uvta lo o global tOorid sboUid <d i-ffpirODce.
    |©
    9
    -
    4be oor Vb - dv Abe ibe'i
    ^
    pfioopte be applied be-Uoeeo societies ie to fa-yadcb io
    of poo,Y \ 0 SCXJftb
    - -
    -
    I©
    ^ ^ ^
    :

    i
    #
    * \
    a© -:
    i

    ie *
    %
    s
    10 |

    I© i.
    r
    .
    t

    •** . I
    e> 1f
    t
    i
    Ig ®
    S
    5
    i •
    I
    I
    %
    - #
    .
    -n1 PQeds declines OUfe^pncg P&SocSples ruooot applied
    »

    behaeeo aocte t«s HOtoc-vpv be ge ce^aro norms


    ^^ -
    ^ eS -xxocmig
    rl
    A *
    feloaded
    * £3

    S <cbvcb should be
    - by | jbg ai Ccuc
    ^
    *© hoo - 101- fb ocp « o
    nfc
    ?
    *
    ’
    ;1
    y;- i noo-Ubevai deceof people * ^ ^ . &
    donoesVi'c apfahrs, obsesviog fireab'es / Pssppcf
    f]
    s.i
    ' (6
    Observing code of cooducf col^b p^'sonors of cocps,
    • :-

    $
    -
    t > ei- p 'no bVoes of culanoifes -

    -! Ar-
    ^
    pqybfq pa cols Tbeonj
    geo 010
    ©
    0

    £1
    & Me appreciafes Pools - for Abe cA -bolero of uHiifca - #
    .
    Yiooisro HQ appreciates because Pools rxjte - t
    V!
    ' fatness as
    4be basis op Jbs-Hcp He also appreciates
    - because evesupoe • 0
    sbaqld
    :a,-1
    ;
    equal -fseedoro - Hoeoijyetf '
    be cdisagpee «-CS4b ©
    A:
    •T

    ST. -
    1
    (D
    pQcOfe on fb\locO'» •
    He does oot soppcpf Hbe
    g #
    «
    v

    -
    : y.
    -
    ?:
    necessity of any poWersai \ deo. #
    i TasKce. cog <330 never cnd at c o idea of droaHce
    ^
    dOblcb can ea-bsfv} c ||. He Ocpfoias * #>
    '- ./
    if fb^ops b Hbe Qovcj
    ’ H

    of S ebUdtaeo •
    * ^ 0
    (3) He also 60s; not- better
    fbaft jc&Hce ea pTsodecu- of pro
    cedures - /Accord!ng fo A^oan jcx Sen, -
    - ©
    ©

    .1
    ^ OpeaiOv-
    © He eras
    fe> Mf -h* . ’
    fospmed by Qoddba . 0oddba
    \ ^*4yaya fe
    o

    cOds -Ipy',pg fo
    ,

    0
    1
    <r

    no>'<X3 p3 hUTOOO
    -bo . | - Ke po'jrpose of
    '
    i
    —
    • !
    'Sof
    ^
    “Should be fo 'OfrvoSodfe be?nooj© spfr rln
    ^ policy ©

    y \
    i
    calls QS, s®3 tt'aafoo -
    (£He calls bts
    ^
    focased approach ^
    toWcb be
    ^ ©
    j
    ^eftbodoiogy qs gpo'Ql choice. aoto'Cb ( £> S pC-
    Si OriCnr ftaoo ra+taoai cbofcp
    - foHooa1 choice «'s booed op ° #
    ©I
    v.

    '
    .:i
    Qbsfrocf persons ns .
    tiog deobbos To > decH feed oon-
    dTboos- social Choice ^( Q cgal persons noatanc fc ;
    choices
    :'
    •
    :S
    y
    < }
    I
    io p-^aoHcle sffuaffoos .
    ^ !
    fA)

    ©
    M
    •

    *
    • 3
    iX!
    Z'-t
    -A
    :
    - : r=
    :>]
    •

    • j

    r.
    - vi
    n

    © @
    ©
    1
    '•
    J

    • vv
    X'
    vv2
    l %
    1 ©
    V.V i
    m
    m
    $
    51
    # © Tboc^ fya Q'Qn calls . bis tbeovy of Jus-Wee as . coropa «aH\p
    Co pavo bve Tbpoy ctass 00V -focus on achieving
    :3i
    •

    :•

    ^
    '

    si PeiffecHys j(_S SOCi ©tj but noqfcing S& ci &


    if ^ ’
    txJ QS JOsH
    :
    !
    b* QS possS bfe •
    cf
    tefc
    ms.
    ?S£
    §
    © Nozickg TfrQQYLj op JUSWo& -
    S
    £
    Mo-zjck. calls it as Ebt/ tleroeol- Tbeovu o (2 JbsHce -
    :. f

    -
    Ci Motlcli gives i < bestaYiQo \ /tipco op jus+fce He. c ®s 1

    ^° °°^
    ^a psogr Mighv
    ii QPppo &ssWe fctxaHoo - He soppovf- ocxxich
    : -' X
    .
    CCS
    X'
    3S r o o s e sboutd bop cMtenop *'
    t a t
    >5
    -2
    St
    fQjosfi' oe nisto-bca | Jpjos-Hce c°onot- be sb* e ~
    •
    $
    :;i 'Kbed 4oo POY to 4be preseot -tiroes - state bas oo ^y
    ' '

    #
    ^bilocoirg f 'PQbh +o
    :X

    I
    •
    © pocopcs Pyopexfj
    a ^-{late should
    S
    * see
    ?3 © -Hbqf property fs ^Qbt -fcjiy
    > ooned,
    *
    * Cl
    c<5
    Mosfe^ecJ
    - cry to hen'-Hcoi .
    eft
    rtg
    ® There is one sJ+aa-h oo \r> cOo ob etote wo tjoteweoe -t^ .
    ’

    •o PgbP +o pgopeslg ^cbeo '


    r
    :«
    « ©
    ^ Bopetfb/ <3ao pu f
    '

    £
    '
    -
    i© +be life %>p noaOy to dlopg . -He gWes <s escQsop ^ aj~
    •
    )
    4e
    v
    village tobese ^
    dbpee cs c* oeii * voeii is 4tbeoo
    I- - ^
    >4
    -

    I > x
    ;
    -4c .
    •
    Source of -fbe
    the UDq-ter -psoro the oell.
    -
    coa t -
    ^ -
    Ufo of
    4-be ocooer of
    v?l lagers q
    ^ =^epeod
    <

    4beVcoe\1
    £

    ^ ^-
    .o
    ctepdcies oitbe&s -
    c
    fsoso -k? b( rg GOQ T e a t-e Cbo ose
    !f torce roQte ^Oqfpir cNOilobfe -fE?y others
    tc
    £

    I0
    ^ •
    .:

    £
    IV
    V
    vV
    cc
    M
    55
    54
    v..
    s
    Jt
    o
    54
    K
    «5;
    f; -
    !
    !

    IL
    :
    ' <

    1© I
    i
    K

    !© !
    :
    ;
    f
    £ ©
    c-
    ?
    s*
    I
    ©
    s
    K
    •
    •

    !©
    i
    (

    I& m
    V.
    "
    i
    !5 © r-
    S
    8
    5 I:

    k
    ?
    .c t
    l•A
    -
    CVW«1V W
    *8 WHa* © Concept of JUS-HCG in r odeeQ
    ^ - igckjVe 46 '
    * *•

    -
    :;i
    jgjoapgft t.bv

    © Xropovtooce Of ThPOT^ j of Jus-Vice •


    m
    of!
    VX
    Xf
    ©
    Stooe 4he> -Hrr^ of pXdo - piato called h <s
    •

    3
    of !
    '
    o vbeay QS
    <£>

    a ^cdQii- Viroes - ocSVOiO tooMd- TOQTVL XhPox"gs of JosVice 0ds\ . . #


    '

    @> UVi uHariarXgt'o based on vdeq o-f^ Qeov ano-


    fd
    :X
    ' . O
    ^ ^
    :y}
    Opi fhXJTiQDtSro
    —
    based oo gstsaiest good of gyPaAesV <000 . w
    ico:
    ;1

    ^
    ©
    0hv ?
    Marxt
    °
    g \
    cod 1 be ePcvf-Pced
    vh mj
    '
    op =
    -fbv 0^0 good Op QOClQkj. #
    dusdee ~ ' poes+ioro i P) m ^
    InhoooQo Oord vioos -
    "
    ifAy 4
    :V
    s
    ' found to coeSVetrf ) toorb ^obese -Vbe #
    cbrotOooV V5Qdf -Hoo 9 Op l HoviQO s o
    ' ' ^ < x;v
    Cb’nrrvYXjinSero {c. Q pevfhq idea op Jog-bee Zb C& rotmaois
    fd
    snervo obJ ePce ecM \ be c
    ,

    ^ #
    v

    & ^
    © 'Social
    ^
    > e!faje ppp'foacb or>eof
    ^
    based on
    -
    roost- \ VToptsessivQ
    ^eed !
    - - ©
    -
    coo&b f & Oro 33 0 a ! bbeKJ ) pptjspeG ve VS -tbDtv pou3b
    coho dePfoGg jusbee as -paboess dbese oyQ 3 pfhodf «S/
    ^ ^
    ©
    ©
    in 'lexAooi
    PacOfe vbsm bos
    — ojrdec
    ied fo - ^v'cvaj Gp ncr^ ofive poi, pb'dO"
    ©
    •}

    j - G ©
    GOpWj bas jben 'stee do ma j oVb8T h^ones
    ^
    - •

    - her
    eg - femWsf F pes Ne- (Susan t^OlQV
    ^ ^
    boob Qende* > Josh cp 4 P^a' b/ XX33e dbe need do
    " 1 *)

    ! UO£&?vSlaod 4hf > 'noiaSb'cje cd-tbio -the facoby -


    ^ re
    v;y

    © '
    x*'
    X Mosicb- avto Ubep-oviao eznfie. io k \s epVibouoecw dbeox
    bailees^
    ©
    ': f ( the 'dee op aDelfa^ e shale , jyddfy -dbe / ^
    - 0p
    A
    e:-v
    N fffv

    _^ ighlcOQVchrOQb S teHrP •

    ncazdya <3so Qpp^o’ates RQO dbeoxj tuV sj eSVs do -^


    m
    -. ^
    baue Y<9O ' isckdoo Reused dppsoach , bvs dbecr j as
    ^ --:
    ,
    •
    ef
    bV

    d
    •i
    t
    <bo9pQV >-
    £ bye
    dbosgoj <obcb is based oov 0» ^Viooa (
    bef social choice - be e ablfebos dhe sup-senoacy op
    ^ ©0
    - -
    o c>*

    si
    yaya - ^
    o

    ^ o\Je?r bib
    3
    Sffj
    - - ":

    ©
    .:]'
    • --]
    •! © .:
    c
    :X
    :
    ©
    : :>1;
    : >/>

    ;
    f‘J
    %
    gi
    :X; S
    ^-
    : y
    '

    I
    V

    f;::
    ?¥ . .. r
    \
    m
    tik
    ^a5 © **
    fhougb fsatQp 8h3oq M > bto SbggOSV fbav froa/vftp SQo<
    *
    ' . /
    :3
    voptetv i
    dhPOKj rocty cveate- pxaohco issues
    ' )
    )•
    ^
    {a-b'oo oe ssx oe is ei of ag-seeMoeob ox procedure Os
    .*:; ?
    A
    ?:
    •
    © ^ '

    dens beci of rapacity buWdkg setrap


    ft f ;
    ;.$
    3
    <
    £3 zroqbtxod
    ‘ yel A '
    3
    S
    3
    I* # ever otoer toeoyies -
    :> •
    3. ©
    .
    *
    =?
    ® COrorou oiHavtoos Otl°o gi'v/po d 9 -fbeosy eQbiCf ) fjto lS OO b<2 K:
    * - ^
    ord &l f s k a o d ( O f a P l-f , rOrOrOCJOfty odop oo op pViob'jl
    ^
    &)
    *5e -
    of d \ yenb'aft'oo - ^
    3
    •

    :*
    c-

    : xc
    3
    i
    fK ?.)l

    ©
    '

    T) uibaf ©c
    ^ '
    s^ggesJ- sfbeses op fuswce,
    i

    3
    ^
    endi does fbootsiao oat
    Godoi Joshos depgods oo o of
    aebiQ^oj &mm&
    3
    9
    5
    5:
    ©
    ^e^nancb' Cboeeosos ^
    ^
    •

    I © Ooorg CCJ i h-iTrcr )


    t
    2
    i ©
    3
    -A
    ' §
    © PatOls 4 3lgoiPcooce of bis < ooA
    serous
    ideological gsoaps -
    i # ^ •
    RoOs coaoV -t© cdetfivg 5ucb> -Vbecrry of Jusfrcp £>toicb
    3
    - appeq s afi'ocoI to a | (
    • 2i
    ^ so -
    ^ to be. tfodtf
    3
    peace stobtoto). ^ese OoO

    in bis^boot
    Ift ©
    1
    .3
    >,
    © © '
    ' ATbecm-jof JbsHae1 pobb^be ^ (O
    c
    -
    v v. he gpv > 4be 3 p siocjpi s -
    ^
    > > '
    « t 3
    .¥ V

    & VfS 4to?o>y has been Sobjeofed A csiftcisras psoro


    >V:
    .
    >:
    ft
    ¥
    ft
    ft
    ft
    2
    t

    (to

    «5- i
    va^ioqs ocbools of fbouqbt © apof fbe pyooofoeo^
    ©toe of facOfe toovt te» fsaro caroTouO'fabaOS -
    '

    -
    v
    CD Cbro rouoHaba e> viao - l
    1© bos to be pqpH cutq sKc ^ey \too.of Jos ce
    ^
    _
    C: • A

    E f @1 Mictog SQ<r-
    dats ^ •

    1® © RotOle. in bfe Q.nd bcot oo jusb'aa pobirsbed '*) 19 3


    M
    * ^
    I © G Poi iPCDl (JJBOXENTE.ro 4Q\ G fbftb'cQ ! to'oaEP^PO Of
    'OPSfcic* .
    ‘
    -
    ?
    5 pocDte qoestoo
    •
    0
    io boto sbb Ufj
    .
    cao be -ensose^ fa
    v f

    ?i ©
    G socisiq people to ctrff wsoV tonopxe . '-
    -- Q
    !
    3 bens- ve docf^oes Uve' Qbcb p biQ-pQ
    ^ acrWesfoa
    i © UbpxQi 30a efj) becaose oo obeso) 5cxJieK| p'&ovdes -piree ^ i

    !&
    Q <m
    boros ^ fo p§TC>ec$Crnr) op SpQecb , *150)
    paoZ>ls> b ;0MQ -A+3CM-
    ^ t
    0100 -
    posple vfg o Qobebto <-Cf V>
    (
    ^. -
    •

    detOooroiHc caitore Ceo c e\ OMerloppVoo OfOoef * I


    i
    ©
    a^ . ^ cp *£
    & cbirg
    _ ccoGeosos ovtor
    pob'tJoai cooceppoo
    !c
    op TosHce -
    ,
    ::
    i

    Q 1
    !;
    © ?
    r
    1

    ;•

    © L
    V

    ©
    1®
    p p
    a
    1 0
    fb ) ;-b' G3 ? oso^epno^o of Jb^'ce '3 {%ee Staocflfrg. ftte . /r..
    -
    ad ©! biased oo ° y Qorop^e bernWe cfocfsrioe -
    c-r- tv --
    ;V

    S3
    .
    ^
    •;

    people 1' V'^g 1o such Socte-Wes sense op


    JQgVice 4ihrGy cpsG e ditiog fo - <2S*d OJfjQ -ir -feu# ) ’" ©
    8vv* #
    fgwos , ~VbKy beti'evo fbQt fb e b© ^oo-'f 4o tresoKJ ©
    < '

    dvsagtfeeToebfcs oo 4be issues op Inoo -sat Ganptcts is a


    •

    >.!
    Pbwspgh Li benrol cSenooofab'C psoce bu se 'Ifceycon&de^r
    • *

    v *

    each oVfos eq^Q l • dbey Qo foir pobiid ^asoolrg •


    m
    *
    qbi p opte pbibco -og di-ffPseof btTope beoo^ doc ne
    '
    <§
    .d
    :o\
    :P-
    ^
    coo^ doue/op Overarch! ng co'D On ps CVe&a'scbifg Coo —
    ( {
    ^ ©
    &
    ^
    Sens s fs di -f veoF fsoto Mtdus ^\>n/eooL‘.
    ° ^
    paOlsi'Qn goal of acHedrg Social
    -

    te
    J
    *
    w

    qbcjtrtow lead -to peace


    p;
    ©
    .v:
    c-:-
    overchrcb °g oooseasos
    '
    foae- to puesfoo Pools Q9 -to oW- j people
    ^
    SNbiuttj adH depend or)
    conrjrt- of dQos
    ^ ^ Coo-
    #
    a
    V/
    "
    sboad cp o^
    4o fbe politico ) (Deception
    of jos-Wcc f Jtoey c^se sjc^pVi ^ @

    QbOdl: 4tbe pQ3g,1bi Lrty of <fk/ecQSCb'


    tsg CboSSJOSos, . . ^ Led

    £
    1

    vl
    GJ , Ipcoroioe fOcOle,
    dygoGrosot -far dereaorafe eqoo \ fkj . ©
    -
    (D Ib vodcjGf on- Patois %. bis
    .::-
    1 ^ grr^atoess -
    0 pacOls 'Vbeo'Hj of Just-tee
    1
    -. 1
    . .!

    © °bgf Beccxose 4de&e coas vv -


    p )j / COd 'Cg to pQtOlQ pboWciG (S -tbC lP^ VVdt\G . ~

    s
    ^ ^
    ® Lext CQ \ ow ir if 2> p'vf -ocj pies .
    ^
    ;

    ©
    1
    a
    t (§J ( OViMUOi+ -fanS Cdf cigrvo.
    ' Q S::--
    :!
    •V

    © fbtrb'COI Liberalise #
    \ Steibl
    r- d
    v•-:l
    -: 3
    < fbiibca \ (bncepHoo of JLsfee . <v
    ^Vf

    is possible ots people lo a desosoa-bc po \ ,'fcdi fsl


    .s
    ii
    V
    CuHorP 'hrea - each o \bee as e uqj d-W-^ens- y areedy 4o
    ^ ^
    ©I
    r.
    LqP Y )
    Ferros coH\ develop ovesiopp'i 'TQ <ronsB^°s
    m political crmsepttao of Tustfce pbpq agsQQ that derro „ >

    CVoti' c coag fs a «oa


    —
    ©
    —
    ^ -\be «
    (B) 'ibis Vn bis boot, COG> to, ff
    Qeb , ^
    tde =? of denoco^otfc,
    epo« it y ashief) s oeces>sayy -fov shad t { ty io -+be scDcgdy ©
    -
    dibeve people adbe 4o di ff. corop bendve
    aocVMnes. ^
    .

    ^
    A

    s* ^ t'-'T?

    &
    . >-- V

    dy

    J
    '
    m
    m
    a
    L
    EQUALITY
    © Syllabus -
    *
    to
    to,
    Ci
    © o6 ba'o ( ; Poii -b’ cai §- FCOOO^
    ' JC Eqaatibj .
    © Relafioo sbip befcoeeo equai f -y §- Ereedoro
    MS * <@ft ^

    i
    S
    :' © Aff is^a-five Adioo •
    7$
    ©>
    According to DOQXMO , Fcjoaity ‘c/Savewe o v toae ’ , ; -
    ::

    I© :
    i
    * ©>
    O- roaaos equaiftu cam "Wurap over an otoer vetoes .
    Eqoan'+y (s toe Idea of ^cdorp toroes as our coosa'ous -
    ^
    vl
    1
    VS
    K3

    ;
    S
    ness 13 g^ocoiog ociir aodpFstoodUrg of aqoa \ f y !s
    1© evpaodlog becotoirg deepen isqoan' y is cteejy qsse>-
    to

    to
    i ©
    £
    ©
    da tod to HUPGQO
    de-fnecj as Gxpaosfoo -of Fffeedbro § ©goau' toes -
    •
    Haroao FkgTf^sS . CQa be

    # Fqoouy 3 ) to tad to +be Gooogpf op Dfgotty . Gdoauty


    I *
    gives toe seose of OOGW be/ o -

    ^
    >
    1
    to
    -?
    :>: D Typos of S uaiHd s -
    I
    I© a Uberal abaci - ^ ^
    $g
    •
    rsj
    %:.
    &(uo 1 f-kj before laco •
    •
    ?

    l
    :
    x
    V V
    Bquaiitg of oppotojoftop
    3
    “C
    v
    © ® Marxt'sA Vieoo -
    t? 1' for Marxes -toe above -to idoos 5-© os-roa 1 procp-
    ,
    )

    Il
    Ci duTTOl ViPaO of Gqoai; . xk
    . -y
    Psoi equa> nty 13 poss bto ODU IO ooropo -) of oobeSj .
    \s oof Qobs aofve tdeq /.
    *
    ^
    to ^ 3v (

    1
    :

    © v? ^
    Vafe ocooejrsbip
    does oof -edsto classes dlooot ;

    KTTJ *s Fleoce
    ^
    J****MQ' *^te 'bs 3** bis Qb1
    1s
    e>,*oocotoqoauUj o f
    .. . S e9c i

    l1
    v

    'o ,, ’
    £ OOV Sa>b<sfad

    ^
    i

    1© S
    ^
    $
    BV
    te ® Socio \ Liberal abea - l
    SacjO )
    I© UbFfaiS e^abiisb eqoii ibsiuro beluDeeo bdeidg i> Fquo.-
    Ig bfb) Patois Sfggesi- dfai loeqoau'tfes are boaod to ewa >\ge i
    ;
    i-
    ^ ©r -5
    K
    bat foeqooiitfes bs jo Hp'ed ao j uoder SL coodi-tfoos* .
    ^ ^
    f
    JC

    I
    ©5:

    £ E
    6
    5*.
    £
    © -.
    •

    £•
    ss ©
    < i:
    iS
    6 S
    cfc 5
    '

    S ’©
    j » £
    !: © 1
    r.
    •
    >
    l
    l
    5 :
    s

    &
    !
    f

    ^5gE525*SRK55S?^S HS^JS53S »? S^^


    « SSw?SK5S
    5 !
    ^^
    m
    iilJ
    vx i
    XX - .
    '

    (7) f £H of fo\ r eqcaiffj of opportunity. o

    2
    * (Tj) fbeo ( f Cs bene fetesi for ke (eo
    iv-i advaotc ed ,
    ^ -

    ^
    </
    »5 -

    I
    -;i
    a
    Ibus pQcOls givesyocoer 4o fbe least advaobged .
    \tek
    keqoaufies c«e justified ©
    I
    3S
    ooy cobeo ^e cntmtest of .
    -

    #
    lOecfWar SPd-6o te beirg 4Q If GO CQXP OF- Aaotdirg Vo
    O',
    '

    W'ro , Trices should aqre© BEECXOBQ key understand


    Abelr possess ioo fe because key bays certain adva+o-
    x.. tav
    .

    :
    •
    if vicb tom gWe a pen titular p oerKige offhe
    ^_ c\
    f CDroe -fit -the peers tt COlU pot- rcPCf-Q
    tr
    I os big diffg^oeg - /fr.
    XX Geosoae ke ^oqsglnal ability of Abe coblQbk t
    *•

    X~:
    gjYQO »8 hof 90 big SinoijQvtj poors cof)| { accept kef
    - -

    iooquajrKes awe be ou-tcot oes


    ' of -fdVpeaceduos At- &
    ke eoro© biroe Ahey <p?r© a^so jekrg ©soiurces k>
    r

    Qd'oess keif SO -ff0nOQS - TFsp Onoouot ^


    .
    £
    §5 #
    of T*ooo y poavg
    «cfi| be ge-fog *oill hose byye roa-
    ir .
    gioaf oVdig jp poor.
    2v
    v:::
    *
    dhgQyfgS Of EquQuk
    .
    :v.
    •

    Aroabtja sen 'm bis abide r


    Equate-ty of ulbqr aoa yees 0
    of sqoair - , % <4/es bis acQo -'\beoy
    ,

    diffdvem -theories
    g £
    of Rjoau' ty . Adhere is Q consensus -that
    QqoatNy eg
    essential but -tbenS is cx tact of clasn -b as -to —
    )
    tde have -to roc a
    • Ml
    *^ people eyuai fo cobat s©oQ© - 6
    ;
    j
    © £quaitty of l/Jej-fayg a:
    Vo
    ;A
    £t * s a Oti i ihonrion appsoaoh .
    ‘
    to
    Acco-odlyg AD L>H iH QPO OS COG aboqiJ 4&y do aeebie e
    r' .
    -i ^ &o
    equality of xoet -fdire le - Q oaiiy of piaasove ov
    ^
    bapboess -
    Person
    aoo A Soo 8 -
    i ex
    •

    vH

    I F><peoSive Tbgts i
    a :
    Taete
    i
    !
    Bro IAJ
    1/ a
    -.1 ALTO

    v
    *
    -l
    M ov
    ^ r -OcyOQsf fatbOr \ j£s& yA& ry&
    j £
    ::
    *i
    fei
    • Cfu6ti'c^ frjustice ©
    Si
    :‘
    -
    T-c rJ
    ”1 i
    -
    : •- i
    Xl
    i
    ixS
    SV
    i:
    V'

    ' ?

    4rccr^' -fo Duoorbo


    JV-S

    II$ % DooviJ 'o

    ^- art of us -to teep


    9
    ' }$
    a
    a rV:-A'
    iSCOObl IrbsVQ)
    ^ pqooutu Op
    ideipavt? ^
    UXKIH ) TSqu
    b>S UJto
    •
    fl OG - coho roeSSPS op cOf4b
    :&
    rorvQpeosQ H0 SDrOPO ' qs eve> vy -
    *

    i
    I©
    @
    eve/ <§- O/<P/ t too =
    or>e etees * but o
    ^ J eep b S levs
    *
    ] oP coei -fare <
    '

    '
    sensible egaiftaviaosnQ
    coouicf
    .8
    m
    £
    •

    §
    # .5 9
    °
    :
    B
    8 ©
    '
    ..8
    © EqoQyfHj gf pp ogfces -
    ;
    :. H
    -
    - ©
    8
    Scbpigr- Do3
    ^
    ork ? o
    VS] ©
    -
    us
    DcoovUo Spyppgts to pvp eqoqi TjeaDuvces . Acccordfn
    1©
    :S
    %
    Dtoo^rbo Josh Society is cobese initial diSniba4n'or) of ^^
    WSOtXrCQs (SoOSt •
    ©
    ?
    Gcofe. - Sovereign V i-cbe .
    m
    :- £
    &
    *:
    ? t
    Terras .
    -Horn SPOSf -HV© AuCtolOp . v ’
    % .
    '

    ©
    !
    VS
    © EbdotOnoPot sensitive Auction;.-
    ? S
    (3) Bovy tesf
    i© '

    © JEOSUYO oce
    :s © 1 © Op+ioo luct Vs Scute luch
    1© T

    I© f opk? Q -iQ- bctv^ liny oo 4-tie slop buf 4bcA sbisp bos of
    *©'
    »

    k © ^ '
    dtooDO od - PeopbcQOodr QO bact- -Vo +p>ei« bo^es - qise ^
    i
    i:
    V- i
    ^
    beach +o ao istood ccbicb is oo o babi+ed islooci bqs
    ;
    >
    ^
    f
    |6'
    1
    !
    bPSoc.rjfgc psopte cJpclde 4o 'S ta -d 4beir
    ' -
    soa'oiy OQ - h©.
    ^
    :•
    .;i ^• (Stood . People decide Auction Qsa noeib - odl -h> <dofev'roin<
    ‘
    Il ©
    j

    j tCbo sbopld toSir <Qbcct


    - - i

    : v
    ; Auction ©
    Auction is ^be fcpsv roetbod 4o uode^jStot -od 4tie
    ;

    real va /ge
    *,

    j# !
    i
    Op Qoy TTSSoaroe/ cororood ^h) •
    i

    © j people dedde ioctiStirida-te c\ aropsbeiis


    ;

    &
    equally ,
    ciorop - 1

    © she is are used dor A^dl+ioo aerslbve AUCKOOV


    -
    l
    !
    I
    © [
    l
    \
    l
    \
    ;
    i
    © l

    ©
    © r.
    © I(
    »
    t
    © ;

    >>555
    ^3=535558353^^
    *
    to
    people e- behind 'Tbicd tOtii op jgG O -
    /
    s-j <?55
    Sin QAOOIS 4fc> eo C
    '
    M , ,
    •V
    ' -
    ^ ^
    TOOCjQ buv lO De-OOrt O toeu (S. S© beb ivod TbtO c-OiH op
    ' A :—
    - -T '•

    -I I
    ' 4taeW toieo+s,
    - .v»
    J
    i
    ,
    Hgnoroooe - Tfee
    ^ boocD
    vantages / but do oof kno <Q --toe QQuaf venue op toeir
    < sad - %
    ©
    advances
    ^
    S3
    o
    g:
    :/:i
    to
    •
    :i - to leois if coo be decided by Audh'on . vot(Je (Etoook #
    be dpa'dcd by toe pesoo - aiue depends or> bodo touch #
    ••

    :!
    •

    .1
    •
    i
    1 ^
    •/. ?
    5 • coQrfcet *S cOfinrg 'fo pQy . io toe end op 4be VhicHtoo it ©
    !
    -> coay h>Qpp@o Ahoe persons toieo^ bos toe - detoaod £§
    : - -I
    Jo toe ooQvkef: - Hence , people dail 00 -for eeplpy SO^oe ©
    ^
    -

    a
    :- •
    Clorop sbe 1 as Q Josu'ccroce . Her>ae_ a crsnooooo pool Qjto @
    > )

    be Czroated - Decode Proposes Envy Ted to>ab dU aibu-


    +tor> is PQW Oto' Cb does oof 7seSJi-t /odo -toe -fbsJto ^
    op ©
    «3
    >
    -1
    Bovj . tobQoa
    p0rsoo is eabsp<pd tQfto bis oaoo bund ©
    4ber> - eetidg jea lous Jpf toe buodi© op 4b© oHbevs
    .
    # ^ •
    ' :
    tB
    SI DuDovvdno wes toe Concept op opHoo JucJc as coei \ cts
    -v
    re

    ^
    BtnJt © Vucfc • Ebsu-jance cao enropeoaat-e looto AacHoo
    Ood BBUte luct - DaOCfrtoO ^pcjggsf 4b)QV COmrOoG pOQj
    cao be used -tpv to© beoe -Rt of toose <-ck-*o e.o g
    :
    pbr-o B*U+ \ucE- Soppose CL person -SeffesS ptoor) aooe. £
    ppysfcql disab / liEj he coilt bade to beep soc^e
    ^
    8
    ^ -

    Ctonopsbel -Jo comrjpeoscbe ©-« Ah© d iSOdv/QO+Ogps .


    ^ -

    Hence be caanoj eoleir \ dt) Abe Auction ca-Hb toe setnoe ©


    ipyef oF eqoQutoj • Qocb
    pc&soo About! be Wen etona
    C<

    .
    -
    claropshell to co^n eoscHe -tor B«JA© luck - Accord! -fo
    ^
    r-
    ^
    ^
    . i
    . d
    Otoovbo ubedavian ar ue-nogot -toot m vl
    peop e cne ‘res -
    - d.
    ^
    ponsible % sboqid be b© jd a pooeible
    ^
    0

    ^A
    ^
    '
    ouV -
    Z'

    apply .
    (bnQoaop
    : ctootoes does oot aoydlno
    VJ

    DcDodoo pespe q«e OOI


    ^ espoasbiB ^ to
    oouid nob be
    b©d -ce poostbie ^
    toe uoeboogeo dreuno aoces, fo
    ,

    .•.. •
    ^
    coHeb 4b©j roake ( > <
    ^
    cbo ce£ - Hen © be soggesv Fodo o -
    > «
    v
    •

    cS
    -- -
    vv.- toed seosi -tiN/© aacfioo ie- O e.drQ clarcpebeils .
    v

    1
    to:
    - -- •'
    -lo
    corop^sa-le dtsadtvaofcpjes-
    QIV '
    ^ ©
    a
    o
    :•
    m
    £>i
    • to
    to: -
    dc- -
    fes-/
    •to

    to
    to
    s<-; @
    i
    to
    »1 *

    f
    Aroavkp setis Theory B|oaiifcj -
    ©
    equal oe jcs \ ry ^fQ$ OUirCj£ 5 '
    s®
    i 0 Me suggest Ho roate people *
    ves -
    ^ bocopYs \
    .9
    a
    © but io capabh\b es AvxxrUfQ
    '

    i Capatof » "4ty - Cqpabu ?


    seo • H co
    ^
    fs 4£>e
    ^
    bt i rfy ho do
    o?
    :V3

    :7s!
    ©
    70

    J #
    One doooVs - ^.
    Cdpabj i 'Hj is abseote o -f cfeprWctbbo -
    ? •

    ^
    ( ) fuoGbooln 5 -
    FhoeHooi ogfb fe being doing *, ncboolmC
    ^
    ^ ^
    '

    -
    iS doing ucbqt ore c-OooVs Ho do, i-bi's ck.
    .9

    ! :- s source o£
    1
    : -t 9$
    *® j

    toQi beioQ .
    o '

    JvS
    . :-y & xf
    •
    gWe -bo0 dNlteo Vbe bt cycteo one boocs
    toe
    ©
    aod +be OHtber does OOH £ooco,4be caooa e bQ
    cycling ,
    1® ' i

    ie^e} op Punch'ooi q -
    - ^G qoa l
    1 ^g '

    : #
    |
    He compares bugger\
    . . '7

    © fedog Margcv sGpreseoH


    1
    : depu-wo-Hoo QS bungee cooob be
    choice cdoereas
    fbsVirg ^ao \ e choice ctseif
    ^ mdopV
    3 Q
    1m .
    q ^eocHce f fboebom ,
    Q'
    i : peoce be St
    i © $80SV cqpabn 't -pj approach •
    £
    Po/0rky is nof just Hbe absence of income \ff \'s pe pcpnc
    l© Op dep ivQ4i'oo PesoqTrce Qgoat r-
    '

    ty ,‘s epuaip-ty of means


    &

    !
    f
    © * ' •

    V
    ccbereas equQirHc) of capab
    iiy i $ a Q ua \ ity oPends
    1: ©
    x
    5'
    f
    The Gods being fuoQ^'oni .
    og ^
    ,
    <

    lo
    .£v
    c. ? Capabl i’iy beHe* because
    approach is Hate tote
    i
    .
    5’

    £ C: account -the dwscs - o pereof people


    \ *^ roay pcxwe *
    i c cbfferpo! kjpes op deps) va4-ioa - bg . £b Xbdrao Sac/
    i':
    < efy
    i:

    ?s © +he oa-Vqreof dep vpM'on ccbiCpa. poor gvrj child '


    ^
    may Soffec a«t£ OI
    0 eg
    y
    Ho bp fbe difpvaoY f oro 4be
    1# dfep^baHoo ccb'^ Ch poav' noate chMd < 0111 SGlbe'C. Q pabip S ^ -
    approach -feus dp vAqrnao deN/
    ^ ^
    1 Copa i bHp

    ^
    -
    eiopernreof Xb
    I5 © dpprcacb
    people cqsp oot- mogoas of economic g*ocofb ' !

    im -
    Tra thor Gods op GCona rote oxocefrb' jbas
    be depm£
    \
    r
    i
    l
    de/efpe rood as -
    freedom ^ i
    !
    !

    ;
    I
    '

    w i

    ; ©
    -3
    q

    9 1

    © \
    A

    ©
    1

    PI

    xr:
    heokire 47 %
    SiS3
    S! Cor'Ople^ GfcpN f£j -
    11 (02J 2.01
    '

    SIb
    '

    :
    •
    • ••
    I
    • •}
    vOiO^ roatiVe
    PbMo^opby
    scholar - -Michael Maizer
    Book. - spheres of Jashce
    ^ .
    V; C :’

    A::.

    {eveni oods crghV io be 3 s ^buied


    ? b
    -
    *

    i o Mo : Di -f
    ^
    : vi
    According ire
    '

    iv:l ,
    £3]
    v
    V-!
    •
    •

    diffeYpntjg ©
    EquQii j roeans Mo CiVt ^GOS
    rd
    .Vi .

    :\:J
    .vi
    '

    -1
    '

    Record ioa -fo Malzer . Cb^plpx


    3andigg
    <

    gxd Q3o
    io
    be
    one sphere ©r calk TS

    undercut bg bs staodlog \o
    '
    ^^
    avd to one social
    Sonoe other
    m
    i
    Sphere coHh regard .
    {p SonoG other good •

    be cbooseo over persooY


    or poM-hcai
    Eg - fbvsoo x rocy '
    o sphere o-f po \ \ bres -
    bp

    © ^
    office, +he boo become unepoqis ' - fP <De xa|
    oov be tocpoaif tg Qe
    ^
    '
    1
    l
    etouopepr, 4tofe loeqoaictg
    tQi
    '
    •
    (

    advoc'lgge op bis
    so long pgvsoo X does oof tav^e -the " <£ >

    i Off ice over person Y io aeg other -


    sphere it VQ soperfov ©
    Medical care, beHer schools -£>r bis cbMteo £eJccbao p -Hea a
    oppontuof
    to felocb
    \ (O BonOroic Sphere - UCHDPT ‘Suggest
    (foods obtained «'o one sphere aboatd oof be used -ho obhq ;0
    ^ r:
    ^ :, ,
    i

    / r>
    :

    good ?o other sphere- Eg - Money - person


    eQms io eCOOO "
    ©
    sbocjid be used -i o bpd poco ©r § ( offence
    roic sphere not
    ©
    to poi{fa'cai sphere •
    ©
    . i Thus (Oroplex Sqoailpj eOiM lead to r»Dore Fa,a i ; taviQn
    dfshributioo op social good - 5b -each sphere disPocj
    ’

    • ;i
    loosen i ftg com p»evQ i i but given The piq acnrig of spheres ©
    ^ F-.
    -
    e/pobua i is ^ verg person oUi acquire to ooe
    a good
    s
    *

    Sphere or -the other- 13 6 core argue coeoV fe that


    ioeqca -
    ,
    )

    trh’ESare* . mQCCDYdaocQ to the ocAa © bp sphere op U


    - „
    ^
    *
    1 *
    but COG coonov peano'rV uhese 'loo oct v I -HGS do becoroe
    m CUrou loti ve , Overlapping
    TsecofbrCfog one. aooVtber- ^
    :- A
    :1

    :1
    ^ ©
    'd ©
    VVJ
    ' A
    NS

    ©
    - C -»
    (id

    y.
    V
    m
    u
    ©
    m !A .
    &
    • :>
    i

    :;- i
    vd &
    S3
    wS
    &<
    7- v
    m % pptaHoos!o>p bol co eeo Liberty ‘gquChrtu g
    (
    CJUs-Hce '
    :,:i? ©
    •
    •
    Uber -kJ , equallit § CfotsKce +bc p*arofoeo+ Vamps
    c»re> oV
    ^VQppi (
    .•>£ -nj

    ^
    2
    jiVbOal qbe0
    a
    « 0 lo -vbeHofraabfka
    ^^ip Fqua , f

    a3 «
    «
    $

    f#
    values The telaH-oo
    Justice
    •

    Q30 be uoc Kstcod


    parttoutar school op +Ooqght -
    ^
    b& ooeen Uto«
    GO1
    ^ ~
    acHools © p tbo -
    d ^ ,
    wpfereoce 4o
    ^rfb ' ^$
    Q

    1 MQbV nol- on cii'aa '^os oo +beir Trela+ioosh>i p , tbey also


    I- ©
    ifl
    I©
    s
    •
    ^ ^ '^
    disagree oo -vte roetio * s oP Phe^e cooaspts .
    i #
    •

    © Classfca l Ubprals NIGO liberals ) LiterLagans -


    /
    -3
    I# classical Liberals loot at hbedy as absence f iotor - °
    18 O
    :
    e
    fprcnce |qy 4bG state § society • Accovdipy to Hayefp -
    Ie Liber j I'S absence op cbercjoo - Tfoic vlpcooF Liberty
    1- # :•
    ^
    ooto Koodoo
    ^ ahVts
    i$

    Liberty- Liberals soppod -Vbe


    as tb
    idea of equauify before iao § §qua \lty of opposl-uoi .
    ^
    1
    '
    & fj
    I
    8 ' Hocoever -fo* Vibpvals cHteropt to estotbKsb e> oct'au 4. cce> -
    s
    •
    ©
    oo«~ofc eqoaiity by the state reduces ibertcj . Hence .
    Ubedy te Aotetbetoqi +0 -the idoq op ' social -econorot
    4c eqoaif dcoo-rd 1 og - o Motj'cfcs Tbeouj of EbH-Pe eoV , tt °
    *2 (;
    I I coould e injustice if ^ elate ioterforps in ^
    person 's ' b (-
    ^
    1

    tc (
    K

    f
    'to
    psopedy for Pbg sa g of Justice - ^
    f O
    l-
    I C.
    © LSanogts
    rAOrvivsts oaM liberal fdeq of Lfbgdy as false coosa'ous^
    1 (. apss - The so called
    liberjy ;r> toesvero capitalist soad j is,
    ^
    c
    If. > 00+ Ubgrty but AUeoaKoo. The Liberal idea
    l of eqoatf&
    lt # I
    iS fovroai % paocedOyai <§. fay froco bolcy. substantive
    l

    © .
    ^bstoad of Libgd j % social Etonor-ofc pqoo 1My loej'n8 \
    \
    1
    }
    f
    rOQpo
    ^^
    Anti' -thefcai -+he are ctropVeroeo -tojy - Housever-, ^IQVXIS
    Q, dtFfergpce beVoeeo ^
    i
    1

    if aberty § fveedo^ - Accord - I


    5

    ;o ing -to Marxist, PVeedoro ,e, p eedo^n fsoro oecesa« +ies.


    ^
    oo g oodeY cbtovxxjojsb noode of pxada lop «530 Can
    -
    i
    V

    ©
    ©
    ^
    o.cb<pve pev -feef pfeedoro - nbos socrQl BcbOoroCc
    ^ I
    f

    I;
    eqoaufcfes are tbe.
    . - coodibons
    fne f eGdoro 4 ^
    ^

    © i

    © Jasfae \
    t
    1
    I
    i © t
    t
    0 t:
    5
    » IR
    t

    i
    V
    l
    © .Social
    v
    £
    ib
    Liberals / ROSi+Wp UbWlS '
    S:

    .
    socioi Uberats I te T- H. Qfeet , Lost; M;<?CO uber §
    ^
    v.
    ’

    B oaii-hj qs cbropiGroeoi-qg - TH. Qmseo takes +be v/ (eto a


    a.
    ^
    of pOSitWo bbe io fevros of capocfbj - ©
    ^
    Sx
    £5;
    T H- %0 >o and Lostci soppovt toV veoboo of State -foK #
    *.
    r;
    '

    fbp I UtOKoo ^
    of MChrfc-Qf . /asb JtjQLt'Jf es soc/ai '? ©

    :.
    Jo
    ^
    econonoic Jrglots
    / 4 ^OSlfdve 9tCtVP . <

    cooterapovcpy b' foes scholars i « te fhccfe has locovpo- w


    ©

    «
    xx
    «•
    ^o4©ol -\be % period pies of uberg K Bpatdy io bis #
    4beog o-p a us+tcp as Rfsopss
    i noatftyc, aeo also deP- @
    , <
    g
    oes d-ove/ope rooof io -tecnos op ^beeoc § fbcpdforv? #
    OnQ
    te i©f«
    BOf expaosioo of CdpGbi t it)'(SS - (:$

    £ iLce co.-tti^o of TflQjQKao&bip se.«oa. Qs a <xau oop


    I£ ?
    £ debate ou-oorg -foe pYoroioeoi schoo' ls ^ •
    #
    ©
    Xbdfan GDrS te +ioo bpftGds foe. Qpp-zfocxcb
    Lberdb - ^ oP tosivWe v ©
    ©
    IO CDPClqde ^oe CUO roeOfOQ
    value pbtfsQtfero Q \
    ] &O
    bn ©
    issaib Garbo obo bad -foot
    tee e
    values t Vo lues QYS iOQoror»3eoSUTOb (e * - CQO be no i-t /pg
    •
    ^ 0
    \
    0 ©
    Q. UocO 16 I : ber-Kj cx Pvecoodi' Woo -fOY H oan - .
    kj a
    explicate -foe Tteia po osbi p b/ <o 1 i bes4
    y ppoa v i -Uj
    '
    ^
    :
    U. bPrVa QS fgp- COodiKoa THPJUCN rjy . ^ ©
    e
    ©
    A
    @
    UbPir -V Tpoo i r- f -VbefY
    .v •

    ^ cktoatsio^
    *'

    TteldVibOSbi P i2> Q ooojov eg


    .'.-1
    r 1 . Qtoa of oorroahve political dbeo*g - ;
    i]
    Ubfirig coo be cjodevslocd ?o t ? jrncs o f eropocoev roeo-i . a
    »
    •
    fgoaw'ig cao be yodorsVocd te -ten^s of cdeveiepemaeo-t • a
    t
    1 Clascal UbQralS loot at LJbpcbj> $ Ejocaifty Q3
    •
    AotV -
    I-.
    •
    a
    •y-:i
    .
    :* 'J a
    1
    ©
    & @

    b
    .d:
    .
    !
    \V

    yv
    a
    V L .
    t
    $ny crttemop’f - by 4fe£? staff fro ecfoa uhj
    to
    mto brivy
    classical liberals y
    '
    •••

    S
    :
    to
    :5i
    3
    J
    - '
    into 4-he mJucKoo of Ubeirlg . Hence,
    libertarians cocfofe to l\ roq +he state fro too vote op
    1 to
    -'
    Mo m
    :
    •
    , .' X

    :
    V
    ^
    Ktfgbf toafr ehrna o .
    I to MlQrasV scholars believe fhqi subsVqoh've Gqoai Tta \*9 .
    I '

    Social §- Pconoro c Bcjoavf'Hj is a pre - oondM-ron -for


    .
    *
    1 to- /
    <
    '
    :i
    -
    .;
    V
    *
    t:
    *
    3
    C
    tooedono . They dePoe fedora as Fnenctoro fro^o pecassi -
    ^es - Soaal liberals Ulce Pools Coosbar Utaev hasinQ
    1
    J^
    •

    to
    to
    to
    3S
    is
    a
    prioi j over -eqoaiT
    ^ We passcA bes a lexica) arctoir
    ^
    *

    bis principles of? JUsh’cG - Me WMcs tiboiy as a. coodi-Ho


    ^
    5. ta Qctaess a concerns of Wtoe leas cta-vao -tesapd season
    1* to *
    to
    :

    1 to
    '
    X
    S

    to
    of 4bc society . Arnor
    ja
    betcaopo e opo to 8no9f §
    ^
    8CD Gpggesfr 4he fr

    ^
    > cta^alopecoeot Acco fca -fo •

    A - Sen Eh>poto0rraQoi op people &asaifrs » ote> -+bQ dfeva -


    ^^ ^
    ctapeodpoc ^

    I to -
    lopero0Qf . q^qc, poupCQ ^ CJb\e Py - de Oarooc^ac caohs
    10
    tado recognise reta
    ^
    dbe noeaos -for de fopenoeD+ - Fv/ea -fr foe cors+i +uvoo 0 p
    '

    ^-Hooshv p IO) CQ paf t tfca I § S CAQ t -


    -
    ^
    I* ^to
    £ ° < •

    • C
    J?
    G ECDOonoTc DepooorQc . -lo Rqd HT toehave ao-fbvcoab
    ^
    £ (
    $
    -
    s
    •C

    & Fuodanoeolqf Rgbfrs £ to pqtrt sT oa'a H§ -eca


    ^
    2?
    $
    t
    X
    Tho b bts So Phoh JIT qrQ nor aaiooaciWcqiui enforce
    ^^
    C
    v (

    '
    T
    •

    XX l
    bt yev +hey
    ^ sappose -to be fAoctaooeovai tro ~ £ ° ^
    govGroqoca op -tae cduofrg. ife o^to as op Cbbsta-frae
    2.

    I. l1
    A
    ^ , pbanco ^
    .

    ISi to asserob /y recpgoised t a e V o t a e o p aberh \he.

    ^ ^
    bta baS/e fro be aufe
    to S . ^c eo roerqeo+ •

    |. #
    K
    Accord i pg to , Qxeeovi i le At-isHo , Pb I rtiQaI pp/ol qWor ) COqs
    «•
    os Means +o acbiev/e socia §
    to \ * ecooonQfe ^eyoa-tioo .
    <

    i © sicHe- W3rd!<
    g -to A - sen. tobeo people a-^e eropoaDeirfd
    ;
    !© K>Q|26> cieroacd -for pobi fc aGhcoo -
    i: to :

    i
    !
    ! ©
    •
    •

    © r

    1
    to i-
    j-

    to i

    j
    to t;

    to 5
    k

    ::
    !

    P i
    s
    40
    SW ®SC2SJ8®5eSS!S53»5
    ^^
    i
    S3
    -
    ft 1 A ff i •moQ-hV'9 AcWo o o i m
    wibctf » s Affpcoabve AcKoo ?
    !

    ! #
    *»

    m APPS^OQPVQ AcHoo is fbsi+ive O /sobmioaHoo »b favour


    ' ©
    -
    Of fbP cOGcd v SPCpfOO of SDae . pfffS ooQf -Wp AcHpr) m
    ^
    AI
    S3
    i> ^ '

    Should CSV bQ -boated Qs ^vQstQsSe d&inr-pf oa +ioa - 13: •

    #;
    d!
    ;:Vi
    y, :\
    '
    sbouid oov be considered Qs discvi roioa-Pon agcd ’oS -
    . <

    M ' ©
    Soro£ooe. Qvber l tSQ disczdnD'OQ+ibo lo -favour of
    * V ^
    tSoroe pop .
    ^ <
    - ©.
    ©
    V l

    m p^>Q idop of B-
    Cft 's roaVivp AcHoo fs booed oo -f<he <a9S<jnop- @
    1. 4fc> o -Hoot io society -Hoes© COO be Qedraio setKors
    r~ #
    33
    Uoto bo/e been bigrabcaiy diQQdvaoVcgpd ti'be
    ho USA Slacks #
    .'.P or Dads JO XbdiQ . 3A fs asscjroed 4baf 4bey
    ©
    I
    rpoooi ctonce of par aoi+ib Abase S
    -
    GGKOOS of ©be SOCUQ
    m
    K>j cobo QV© osicderpd as ftoe -fortocxrd eecfiOo op ' -
    ^
    1 I
    Hbejr ocsOo - Hence,
    external cQVaiists - Q&G ' .
    mzreqoisred
    CbuoMes frpy CollotD d Aferenf m
    I poifci’es Besofvowoo or '9 ok s fs type of AfftemapvpAd-ro
    I apHoo for Q.ffbroa -Bve QGfoo -° ^ o ne of -vbe
    sttrorygsj. ^
    • (
    •

    ©
    i Policies lit ® Peserva-Hon pveraa / os c oso es+ ©
    * + ed issue -
    lAase cobo oppose -H~>ey beucv-e -Hoop IV oorsp orvjises m
    \ , if fs a K&JGXSe- disari robftrpKoo ^
    S ccw)peosa cr*.
    Poy
    r:
    5
    JusKce l^ese policies bcxsie c'oofped ?sa
    -
    ( •
    K0OQ
    fij becpose
    •
    '!

    r .\ <£.- >
    do oof achieve 4beia ends 'sa
    +ber -fbeu "bvCo noe
    V'

    ecd io dbenosewes- AGfb


    ^
    i
    A
    roafWe AcMoo poifa'es have fo
    be eoabiiv poiio'es - ACfbm &
    'V
    :?j
    i
    id
    .
    *
    A
    00 f be on Cl ^
    pQ^rnaoenf basis for 4toe
    alive Acpoo pot ides con
    pQimOQioQoi’ b»Qc,l 3- £f
    -
    poi fci Gs eva ded o >o
    — bi
    'i
    /

    same g^oap if <dGfmfs fbe %


    ( •

    iV porpose , Theg asrp e?;-

    loie -\he noerobpvs


    Onablicg poiia'es <ob' Ob ^bauid ©OQ - _

    of bachbooed CJOGG , -to Ooe otf (do


    &
    fQY cOitb “
    fbe AotLOovd OGhb ^
    oep > 0 O gb/Gb -Pnof A^VanoP , , <c>
    . 0
    m
    V'

    -y. '
    m
    j
    '

    :
    -i
    •{
    ©
    vi
    - -' i
    %
    ii ©
    *;j
    b: @
    ••
    i

    ho
    iv
    m 42
    rr*
    ^
    ti;
    »

    d:1
    -
    vi
    svu :
    »3

    '
    ^
    1B ©
    •
    53
    .

    {
    ^
    btxoe* if i£icb pOUam arp coovinuyd
    ,
    neot basis u deBai +he potrpose -
    ona p-esrf'oci --
    i
    -
    :
    : :c
    •
    1^ l
    :£B
    ;ow
    ©
    :Vsi
    g #
    -. 1 >
    .
    x s,-
    m © :
    -r
    1©
    : -.Cs '
    <-; v.

    i1-S- o
    •

    I©
    &S }

    1
    J ©
    :::'S

    1J ©
    S
    :£
    © •

    -
    ;•

    %
    © >

    1& .
    *

    i:*fe © '
    •
    r.-
    Hi
    ; © •
    •
    *
    x
    % C
    £
    f ©
    i '

    .5 - eZu
    V
    o

    f 1.
    -t
    I C
    ! i
    $ 0 C «
    H

    -?

    1©
    S:
    ?;: ©
    ©
    5
    £ :

    I © i
    *5 ©J£
    t S ;•
    f #• .
    "« .
    X ; < 1
    sS : ‘

    t©
    i
    5
    ;

    \
    I©
    |
    4 O
    >
    ?
    i
    -•;
    IP ©
    K
    :
    :
    : •

    I© C" I-
    •

    !s- © I
    ii
    £
    1? © fir
    c r:.
    6
    !©
    \; F
    j f>
    1:
    , &
    r
    !m E
    I’g. fc
    I

    3;
    !
    ©
    % r
    •
    £ 5
    gg -
    f POLITICAL TlHEORYl
    a
    x ?: - <
    I /TT*- -
    fee
    I lab MS
    Mgani
    ny and approaches
    .rS
    i ©
    lb - ft Lvcnufao cf fbifHcai Science as diSCApioe
    -. I
    . ’
    '
    *
    t
    O+iiiKj of 93! i -h'coi sa eoce
    os diso' pi ' ^ P .
    ’

    Nlav re of poh' tfctn StienoP .


    ^ m
    Hpvhodotodies § A-ppxoaCfoeS
    c
    m '
    m
    TTJO6 i-Ko no } Kod pan Cbote
    cf!

    v --
    i
    , nopora
    ^ ry ,
    Cvatufioo Qp pbl (' pcja \ science
    as discipline -
    R}u Mca\ Science ts one of The olck?s+ dCScipHoies Oaf
    ' n »?. ;v

    c:
    o doe sarzoe Hroe one of dn£> noce><- dyoonoic Mi bran - §-
    l
    cr dOCipMop . m
    - -
    •O

    fLu -Kcoi ^a'poce o rpyocrted i


    o Ana'eo+ (fr-eece Abe. >
    % '
    pOh ticol scienc
    e comes -fro*o -fbs (frcek.. ccoad
    tbliS
    coHcb roeqos C-
    tty QtqH> - The S-Vcjdy.
    §
    v of Ahe a-ty state ?ts tosH
    s -
    Va-hans , processes bpcarv
    •
    C -
    4be area of
    Sludy Awstope obo is feobo Qs 4be
    .
    ^ c
    pO-kber of
    Fbiib Ctji Science coned fbn-b' ca ) ^
    '
    6
    vsastpr science ^ Spence
    ^ f
    ^ to GqrtQ'A f b u H c a j
    ACCOrd ( na
    •M Sa' ence (So. L
    science • A^cbiVectooic < o its ebaroctey Psat <£oVAcb
    - ^
    Q v ©they
    ' -
    p saGfeai sciences 4a £e cue m-eons directions -
    if•v
    C ;: -
    StcQe x %
    X 9ta vied in Aoacor ( jyoece . \f Oar fed as -vbe Brooch ( ' ''
    •
    .

    ;: - 1
    of £4bics or Philosophy - .Scholars liVe plaVo bekd fhat C;

    tdhics & fh' i tics cpooov be sepera-bed • T e cjoesffoo o -


    To
    -
    ood U -fe (?3mov be sopGradpci psom The paes-Hoo op ^ ^
    ^
    QOod peni -H co I U-(s -

    :.v .-i
    L
    M
    i i:V
    :
    §
    eh
    vs:
    1
    *>js
    •,..
    :

    g:
    0

    & Skye H
    ?; i © ro -HVoes fblt' beqf 3d once beca roe d-be
    -3
    I
    3
    3 ©
    QJo d ifeci pi ; OG of Q91 jg I OUS skid res ov scb o !ask' cs
    .::«
    «
    ;*S
    a© Skye Hr
    da
    # XI coos t^acboveiti tobo ‘~oade potittcs independent
    '

    :V
    1- © i religions aod efbi’cs- Me =oas tbe Is* persoo -+0 setab 1 r-
    "

    1s © Sb Qatonorng of politics QS a discipline - He beld +bqi-


    •
    ©
    vfl
    ^oy pot iff cs <use hovo -to go for ccoper CQ! observci-ho o
    '
    QoS understood log of History TSOttaer ffoao EMm'cs %
    -
    mS ©
    T,
    POll0.|*OO -
    l

    M ©
    ..* PSsodUQiy fbii -b'calScience been roe a specia t feed dfsciphY
    1 ©
    cobPffG -jibe study of ska +e (k?oc> t - 4 CboSW ta +COosJ beccunr
    1© d<be xyyre cm&x of sfrudg - £t has been beM* -ftoci* fbii -hra
    ^
    A

    £
    ;
    sci eoce by ins $ ends usrtb -the sta te .
    i -
    '

    @
    .3 Qfage J\T After 2.nd Ulo d IAIQV
    I1 ©
    '

    Opki \ vdui fqrope


    ^
    place -for -He? oprootb
    coas t-be
    I© of dtbe foiib ' cni
    xdeos, philosophy a 0ev and iMM db-e
    i 8 ©
    '
    -
    g socatb of discipline bos been to OSA - Afoedoao fhiftf
    :: ©
    cal sa'eoHest under APSA CAropvfCa 1 fbl vb'cq| ° Sa nc&
    ! •

    :&
    :V
    £
    o ^
    : f
    e; ^ AOSoo aKoo) slaved cte^/ oca -Hog tdqv- fbir -trCa | Sc/eooe
    '

    S
    <
    $
    © Should be soode pu«e Science. xb OSA a fOONGrooot
    1e tobidrj is qiso toocoo QS Revo|M4 'oo developed -+Vxa 4-
    )
    i
    £ Sebav^iOuTy ou
    £e- £
    s
    S f .
    I£;
    '
    - ^ . 'grvo .
    (SQbQ iourricurshs
    ^
    fechbiqacs 0 Raiftfcai Science
    '

    Pfse ^o’ence
    lOhfodace. sc/ooHfc
    Ibi / Hcq ) sa© oce
    '
    -
    i© •

    SodQ 27 060 6 oocoards .


    E
    &
    '
    '
    Pt se of post 0Q ba viour fa 1 isro-
    ’
    |©
    # toas rea used -that if QHeropl: ( 3 rocdle 1
    l
    I© to rv3QVe poftl - }
    i
    <231 science q science £t to|ii oot on
    © : ,
    s>b)ed roarer ^oui Ql30 COrof Dinoi 19 Cofopvo’notee t-be. :
    i
    J
    i ©
    f
    J
    ^ the ^ ^ VSfevaO^ .
    ;
    ;
    =
    :

    i © '
    ••

    ;
    f
    \ ii;'
    ©
    1:
    © !;
    !
    f:
    :

    © rf::
    1

    i
    • t;
    ©
    I
    ©
    -
    # \SV
    1
    i
    b
    p0 Gehaviouviste bed tfeaf i:ws niotb©** possible
    3
    ^
    nor deshrabiQ -tbch Po'itfcai science becomes cx
    .

    vvv;

    pure science- ibougb fbiit/ cal scieocp CQOibe a ©


    £
    Applied Science 5. ©
    8 ..
    • s' |
    Xb
    in Pen ope 33roe op
    -
    caotehaparag. hVnes o -he austere ^o*)d special m
    I

    ^ perspective idm post noodpsoisro


    @
    @
    r

    On' -ti cal school developed - fae scholars Third Wash)


    5
    0
    of
    '
    • 1
    xjovTi’ es have develop
    ^
    Qi Ism •
    ed tb-e school of PbST colon © ©
    . ©
    r ': *

    Today fiblv-hcal science iso vihrooT discipline aoWb


    ©
    expanding 3 00 bees - It’s scope § hoe+tooalo lo 'es
    r..'.
    Qzre ^
    beiog expanded Today pbliticof Sa'eoce ^notony #
    includes 4be ©
    - X bhidy
    of state it cpso fodades staejy
    § OF fdroig C SO no I IS lib'OQiJ ft QV30 fOCLudes Povd ©
    ©
    vx

    lc
    ^ ^
    aororoem . Mary tyawd decisions ji be piitfcq / soefo
    •

    - @
    88' pot Woo ) pcono > Qfo poiitirC9 have QISO CD nop
    rpu
    a
    VsV

    toto QKfsieoce •

    hlatqyig op 4be Discipline- ©


    MafqYe of pe> irHcol odeoce mrocUoa r-oati
    ©
    Q
    Accord fry 4o ooe school of Tbopyi b F 4be nature^^ o f debate . ©
    -

    op
    :- . .)
    fbi FTICDI Science fs pbtiosopbi 031 . They shyest 4hp+
    brcoi Abeovi' es are oorpoath /e theovi'es -
    ibcy s°bppsf
    ir
    ©
    Q —
    !

    - po 11Tea i scboiQffS boo md to bo o p norroe 4 v© \bsu d y


    vfl
    JL
    M "l .

    tfe tsgitFV method to V© l Is the pbHas p+ - fe Vbeorg


    '
    ©
    ^ j
    ^
    • '

    Jvl
    hi
    r!
    is pdiosopbboi approach - ©
    0*0 the other barri these bavP been T Sdno /ass ^bo
    C' /J
    :.:rT.
    "

    :V.i
    i tsoohd -that- pbiitiCQi science sbouM be dTstaoagd ft /

    - :i -
    bono pbbosopbg. fbnbcca Sfcj'Qnce cjoouM Ice aoqd?e <g:
    Fbre Science - These scboicp
    -•»

    -
    "

    X,f H ^ fiD.eba.viou dlSm ^Tantmot


    44
    tC :

    :V:I
    ^ ' passible to ;-oho=Mce sa'eo+tfh -
    ^
    S te produce non- \DorooQ-Bvn Pheovlp - HTcboiaoes
    s .

    ©
    e
    © -
    i
    i ® -
    -V.!
    V
    v- ;
    ,
    v
    #
    AT
    •

    . vi• v<4
    .M ]
    Hotoe^er , Ah&e bos oiicDcys beeo
    Q b
    |g gues-Hoo ooqjrh
    '

    1* -
    oo tee m re or fbiib'cai Theories os gc/eo wpc te
    ^
    "?
    i
    J--C
    ©
    Quote Maftlaod ~ e abeo V seeq quoshbo poppr cOifb
    •

    1s © -
    /£
    •
    tee title, poi (tiCDt 9oi'poce.9 r a ro ^oavie FjroubteJ cO +F tee *
    )

    t2 ©
    5s ’
    •
    btie +boo -bhG cpesPovog -
    1© ij

    -re
    © Si
    Tt iS to fce> noted that -today < t (S> actoo.<o fedjed tbat
    1Si ©
    X?
    even scfeo+iffc tev'es are
    1© sioa? 4he eroe ence of pcsf oaodesoS"? it- tos beeo
    t^ot - -
    C:

    Oil foeo viPS <W© cfocouvces - /KrCovdirg


    a /T \ . actootOledaed -
    to Rwcauit Hifiesa bxToiOle e pocoe*- coooeoHoo - Even
    ^^
    -VS
    ©
    •
    . 5
    -F ga&Aitfc -v-beovtes «»e «* ee +** vheoorvie’oa
    |#
    $ r.
    V
    l

    , -
    = ^ - Pistt ptffeii=-'
    of pocoeir- ftst rood©rote«o has e3«b ;shed +fca 4 tbe >-
    , ®oto«op rc
    £•

    I© stesore sote ekpwt> o5 Virgoes

    S
    © ;
    l-
    *
    ^
    Hen science is <Dos(d«<redl «a . fop

    Ob itej of RiW-HCDl Sateooe QS Discipline -


    •

    * O
    |
    •

    &
    t-
    i©
    qf
    -
    fbn’ bco! -vbeoru is quite si^opty > Mao's attempt ^_
    * _
    | •
    “ V.
    'v
    -
    tonedouslM uocteKSfaod aod solve tee ptobtero& af
    STa pr i -fe aod o Qoisaboos - 3> is a dtsd.pitoed
    ^
    "
    £
    .

    I
    ;
    ¥
    4
    t
    ©
    (
    ^
    iovesHaaHoO of pon*t»'CDl problems - coot or> y slnoco
    I Cbaf political pyoGh'ce tebqtalgo
    V
    c lb te>ocC>i og
    cobQf Q practice dir cjpbqf ' _b ocjgbb
    -Xs
    - (-
    jo rpgQO . pOlrb'CQl tePOrtJ CQO Olter <iQbQj:
    ' ©IS •
    1'

    I© cvpr e °e+teV Iife.


    ' savtne
    ^
    "
    V-
    *I © Coosciousy - diSCJf pIiO-ed / formal stedy
    probienos of group i ? fo % orQ - Scope
    of Fb\ . science •
    S

    I© •

    cobaf a po i f H Ca I pra ch’ce - Kplato; Pol SCd oce.


    ^
    '
    £
    eK
    @ aObaV ({ noGaqS iOVP2rpr© V
    '
    ^
    *

    £
    if
    >:
    L
    °*r3Qf b ought -to noeao - Morooabve ;

    I? © politico * -te>eo*y can alter cobat ff i

    ctooogp better \ t f e -
    ^ /

    I©
    C ;
    5 © S
    £ i
    l
    5

    I© r
    !
    i;
    \
    \
    I © t
    \r.
    i
    l
    ? © \

    i<
    :
    © s

    © l
    i

    © \
    V?s
    t

    0 ,

    !
    .
    "WWWi'K'XTO':
    I
    6
    R
    ?A
    ? i- approaches of f &iiHGDl scfen ce ~
    lYoditionol /ippvoaches -
    .•. * •
    (g)| phi 1030 phico Approach - m
    ^
    © hiSiovicai Approach ©
    V^V

    i
    S

    . i
    © £nopPricai approach ©
    V*H

    ;. :
    i ® egal IhsH'Hi-h'ona ] Approach -
    ^
    '
    I •••
    S''
    '
    /

    ©
    .i!
    f:
    PbtiCH3pbiQal AppraQdv m
    •C X1

    i
    -. % Bcplaiofbe SaWPOV - fboMfrOS of fb' bgophtCD ) App^ach /
    rAorroahlvQ Approach dobaf Q e Ahp roajor tf rota -bons f
    x-ri
    * - #
    ngta of phi icsopbtenV Approach •
    @
    ; ’
    ©
    ! ' *
    * •

    «?
    • ' ; ' *:• I >

    &
    (£> naparP 4h© ory cof 4h tnopprf Qoi ThCO'y -
    ©
    ... . • " '
    - A 5 ' "

    h' ;
    &
    ^ io B4tbetaediSdpiioe
    ' •
    , • •

    :Vx
    ?.x3 oidcsv Approach - poiitiOQl Qbepce has fLs avQfrj
    T. - o-p pbhoQophy - i *
    I
    c
    Hbat iS phhosophu ? :
    ©
    ©I
    ptotvo is kooepo as fata
    PiT Of po ' ft Gal phi losoppvu plQ+O bOL9
    t
    © :

    poe
    de- d phi '.osQpv aQ 4to9
    ^ ^ ^^
    j
    . Of
    '
    -a- .5 ecis TOo. bascusof
    e abiished 4be S3p&© «3a eg : off phi i ©soph a ajeXcOL fl ohher ©
    A: ^
    booch of eboco ibdudio SCIEOOQ - s APpPWof
    ^ ©
    ^
    :5
    - £$r
    ! /'
    * .: f
    > ( >
    /0->
    s+tic j of hoaHpr-
    •

    hoo
    ^ kJ
    " J •
    j
    1

    i lac-klrp 4§ e
    •
    -4 •

    Exponeo-hs of philosophical Approach - 1p oo j o . Ij x d o r f


    l t i <?> *
    ©
    M

    ^
    (J Puerto
    3 ©
    Ifc © Leo Sbaqss .
    •
    A

    ©
    (fjj) planoaoatzL
    p;:-
    ? •s i

    m
    L
    ;
    t3 -
    -
    pQOl<P Gevr ry -OO
    ».

    A
    .1
    Q Pools - ( -; • •

    -
    • • f
    v
    ;J

    i c ,

    -3
    :
    -

    !
    ©

    (5

    &
    @
    ,•1

    M m
    S3

    ©I i ©
    „,,,
    .
    L ,
    *" 0
    W
    £8
    © fgqtmes OF fibncsopb'ical
    5

    -
    •

    Sir deals dDi+b nO^roaV ve fesaes ifke Tbsbcp&pai,'4y;ubP*Aj


    •
    - $
    . tC
    - . Cs ©
    PbUosophSCTfl OppTTCJDCb (DSPS' -toP or tod Of IcgiCO ]
    *St>;

    • 4
    ©
    'S Pasooi
    '

    - pbilosopWco i Approach - deem coi+H


    ®steqv
    ^
    ;3
    : ii
    -.%
    •

    -
    ©
    Ou hv 4oBe ^ -fhao <=oba4 is - pb'tiosopbvoa) /Wpp'aoacb
    ^
    C5

    1e
    •

    * S fresOHpfivP, S gGSbVPApp
    .• cs

    ^ ^
    VS •

    . *# ©
    3
    I )
    MoaDQvpr , PW 030pH CO /
    ' ^PQOh "pay SPffe fso ^ - -
    C0rf aIo It roj -to 4i'oC3 \ . Xo +H& absence of vod-f <a-
    '
    •

    *s:
    •.
    S ©
    1 dale* pbt' toeapbi cal 4BPO bQCorOPP A^no chq'nf Xb@0-
    :
    *
    5
    W 1b£y QTf<9 oof cooQ’deKe as, qbeodes asirqfbe^
    • ••
    CXs
    .*»
    38
    3
    QT0U >(09OfB
    S © -
    •K 0'tVPO by Abe pb \OSOphrO^f -
    1x ® vStoce, pb\ !osopb) col Appvoc cb deals cai4h) 'incenv fve.
    ^ ^
    I -
    Cs3u >s, foese 4toeo <3ies 4b2rose\ \p becorce. biased .
    :f
    ©
    IS2 # •
    ^
    PtrPSor>V sfai-05 -
    ^
    I
    : 5 'Tbesp
    coas o 4inoe «dbeo pbiiosapfdcqi nbeo oos, tV> ^

    :J
    ©
    I ©
    '
    Abo da+e of deOiop . pWiosqpb-ioq / coe s
    Ofced bj bebav / oq^ Q ) foirhcoi gq'eoVig4s as /W cba
    '
    ^ *
    I2 © ^
    Ibeorf
    I© ^ -
    MocoevpTT, o pTSpseoV fi es
    I
    £
    c (o
    ’
    ryyfxxx iWG ’COI
    ^
    dbes-p ?S QSL SspVf'voi of tToVP
    KPol '

    pOirb pOi lOscDph


    .2
    s
    &;
    ^
    '
    -
    f especiQ » e!ioce -f
    pubHca+1'00 «0? faois -fbeo j of jusKce A-qer aeOte +e
    > y .

    ^
    ^^
    l

    ^ foscn ^ .
    < *
    '
    <
    - -
    Of jasHce iq e 00 of aDcttks bq d 00
    1c
    e
    :e
    '•

    ^
    QCb bave Ctonoe < Ote) OaSrhpooe 0bb'cq (
    hove Qn-Hcispd science ACCO'B diOg'fo fbOnQ
    ph [> lcecpb1 CO )

    school srbokrxg
    -
    Af>psc
    •

    £ ©
    5
    dps V science
    '

    , - p2rooryz
    ?. losasq nDoo- bi Rab'aoat school p -feW
    ^
    1
    oH+ ' cni
    zrtj
    $ V,v i
    c

    I© ootfroofive puPshons . Fbsf ModeroiSbo ^


    bas qBo cbo)ie-
    K
    :
    i
    fQ^d d<b0 cnu-fiboAbj of BdoocP \ ed -fc Abe 'ypvivat' / of
    1©
    t \o-borcgv ro pbbosDpVj - ^
    I©
    *z
    I©
    %
    ©
    -
    ^
    ~ I
    s ;
    I © {

    15> e *

    1
    g :
    K

    © !

    )
    1 i
    •
    1©
    ?M !
    I
    !
    I© r
    i

    18 ©
    °
    \2 i
    I1 ©dii:
    I
    i 0
    m
    fy
    ;v
    e £ xpOrX?ofS. Viv-

    -
    : 1

    ® ^Qchiaveiii
    f ©
    si Qo
    \ i OS ° ©
    i U! Losk- i ©
    r
    ]\) Ooooi OQ - ©
    Tbpip> bos alcoayg beso -+b© pOOOSpboO 4baf po tificS is ©
    y? Cbspbf TSSla4sd +O WiSKig - u- is bQl6 tbcH pD / ib' cs fe ©
    psespov th’Sto*y § Mister is pas* pot i b‘cs b/ r-oi la -ci it is
    ^ ^
    •
    : AP.>
    :-X
    Wfetog tba VOcAr y pO / it>CS »5 cs. fsu .
    '

    ;P QDid Pbqf
    yd
    P:: ©
    4-bin We*- is 4be cbid op bis Tiroes
    t
    r. . -
    it- ACca'idicg To lasWfe ©
    and mo poiitfop} Idea i£ ever intelligible - save lo the
    : :•
    :d-
    '

    ©
    Coofsvtof Pnoe - .

    i:S-
    c
    Accent 5 oq -to MacbVovei I i , MtS\avy> is T-be beST 0ai <de -fo ardor- ©
    -- 9ard pow'tfcs. Me did ooh oaot -4haV philosophy sbc> md be , ©
    C'
    P >
    -
    Abe basis Vo Modpxsteod politics - Tbs SkJpy op 4-iiSkvp) has p
    9tetdoro' nated Fblitr' caj SVodias -for |or> . £r* OcH-IOCA ) ,
    ^
    Ts laHoos -fo> loo bos bopn Studied as Cs pi OrocPti C VI 3
    iskpef -
    ©

    ^
    Accord lag -fo Sovioe, bfshe d CQ Approach salves o \ t
    HbsSS conditions <3p cgpod oppTfOaCt' '

    -) . . Is t CDncSiboO is
    ©
    ©
    i

    factual , cP** >pbioaiepp Evaluative - ©


    ^ ^
    C^ batpqpped , (Obaf sbooid happen iObctt- cooutd bovebqpp-. ®
    ^
    ©
    Though Historical Approach bos been pop
    ^ ? o(2 ^
    -T. i
    >;
    Strop! ia pf '
    Cftts soroc Unopa4ioOS OC^*VTtb^-
    odiCOi 4 -
    e
    Sv

    acb - T
    ^ > ppisb @
    :1
    - q troy isBttece vast
    ^
    j
    - ai > 4b< pit
    ^ iStog
    •

    * bgs happed (0 btstovu


    oot be Use ,
    ..-.-ii
    ,AAJ
    C

    v
    :

    pfy
    -
    Tjeievaof daiQ,
    £j . U bxoross a cbaiterw,,
    0 tost- fo ^ - 3
    @
    © I
    © there a-tre reap/ b^pozstooh pou -fjco eas
    PI
    odvor odSfed io -iSio
    ^ . Li
    pj et tropodoo ^-i -fo-r cobicbShftdeOT
    i '^
    KCLV
    \
    ^
    )
    « ©
    of poiibcbi sdence ( t bs -fbeervy asp pbi \ ogpbQir CD V~
    tdeep op GO<-OrO UO uS r 3•'
    i * >

    &

    £>
    Pi ©
    fejJ .fer?

    I- .; i
    to *

    d:
    © .

    m
    i
    p ;j
    I £SS3S&3?
    5;
    I5 d
    !
    3
    3
    g
    * 5
    3
    3
    3
    •3
    3
    5
    '
    i m 4y.
    o
    >
    A
    .1 fta
    ’
    I
    y .
    s
    ^1
    r<
    ! ^s »a
    5 £ >/
    i A
    3
    j -
    i I
    i aZ
    !
    • 0 Ia
    \ <~pt>C cJdV ICn gHOCD (?)
    * s
    :
    '
    ^
    icnvxdi, (T)
    0|
    i
    • ac >

    ‘-poojiclcly
    OOR- 9>o - optDOAddto 0 I¥
    ah
    ^ *3 ^ ^ cA ©!
    OP*® so e,ssa »,,, 31*94- owjflra JO :c
    d Pfe> «n o, stosa edo ^ aonoteadsstoi 0I
    a p , :
    ^ ODC
    ^
    )
    ^ Qq psooaojjy , s JJ |
    . . s
    - SS qoR SJD 3 aI
    ^ROlAd st ! 1 ia/ooicpt> - / 3
    :
    '
    G\Xd+
    ^ ^ 03
    OiApcrxjS ^ XcJ CpoaacicJfc) oS! 5I 3
    ^P^CLRC/dV iDD-fxd -iQOI) ;f
    ) \
    1 , + 4
    ^PtlQjLcidV / Q0 xa OQ) S.f iD4 M i
    ^ >
    H paooPdt lOn cV -VOCO o ( j&
    3 .5
    •
    , sc£ . D< CpDOAddV
    ^ ^ 5
    •
    c*i & ts O} j DA
    ^
    Ad» o <s,» suiacfp .:
    -
    ^ Jo aou jaasd Q1
    1
    -^ ^ ^a 0 I3-
    " ‘
    S3;OJ.OOQH 3sGb|OpoS Sopcp /ej 04 >-t>ScJ 0 f
    v
    30 Sldpsip Qoup CH% 4Sa 6PoS ' qdic39o c|ci
    ^ I
    ODDl ^S ^ 0 I
    c^ %i kxxyo'O hso& jL
    ° ( CDpJfqj ss CJ ov -f8dB0oS Sp / qL&nojAoef g ^
    '
    ^ ^ 0 i£
    Gcaqv |COR < IQCJ aajosp scqv **£ aiGUSUodsaa OOOQ R m
    poo CJOIAOS ,
    ^ St
    :
    ^ H s sp^5? H pa^p/q .uo oofsta pACQ ar .
    @ *
    stShpa B ICOR / JR K- 3
    ^ fo hojAoqaa aoeaua^cw lojynoiAoqaa
    ^ ^
    0D o^^50.0P3C| 30,' Qc3p Op) aoo@ SDCJ| H^Addy i cojxopiH 0| -
    »*
    • qoDOAcldy ICD 3 *ft, -:
    ^^OPH do srno^ ^ctssay 3:
    doaso '
    1 DJ 0 Ia-
    K
    - 0|C©p> |CD >t! l od -ojsjoixofS\ H io . ' n© eW BOrtvJcw^oj
    J 3 5fei:
    '
    fr -
    ; pao IBQSH- ^ <3
    cx\
    - d> <3clclqcJ p,q>{ Lg) # f:
    ^AfcUi W A
    S1C4 Jopo? -
    Od } . Jo -P >od .. 0!
    p^MocldoS
    1 3 :
    CJO 3p|00| XO|SH I 0 fa . : '
    l:
    G ) axjoiso ) aSoqy AO - Jct K
    ^ . •
    01
    /POO&J ^ Pa •
    doaso PHv a cp tp ! ) la/pM w
    ^ ^ ^ oicqp 1DOR I iqj / v
    ^ 0 s--.-
    pasop ~ DOJR o c> /wP iH fdsn w S^OH S^ . ^ # I
    ' f oRH do sa-doc , ox
    ^ ^ aoacoaj ac^ HPqj
    yoo@ -Tf
    ^ 0 *
    >©dcbq pi ^oqS' 4 ) 4K3 AepeiR paoisxapon ov © r
    • OJ 0 sl?
    /upSiR- & o,> p > n!9wlGO ' .
    ..- •
    5 ^°
    ' )
    Oo RCX Cs8SO|
    i
    SBGuR iD'aoOdH / aouco) f ©SDq t3 CA 5
    ‘ 0
    @
    v
    <3 QS H SoH^-H209 <3D
    DJ DJ-RCJdpS - OodR 400 SDR
    ^ >i
    ^
    m
    £ Tee-ta ) Approach - (M
    ©
    a t'so Ufgvo ) ( n p^eiQ^'oo of text - SIOCG ft
    -
    ^ * trteoi £2
    QVpcpcpj- a via o M 0oni
    { does oof charge ©
    ^
    <

    K
    CV
    *
    © bo^ xkia! Approach -
    ( ©
    a is \ GKnoi 4£
    ofpvp>* vf QCCOrdt'gcj > 4he CooffAt
    ©
    ^
    •
    /
    54 io dudQ5|
    g
    avx! ioto coosid<?rt>h'c>o df >e CDobQxt ©
    ••
    •

    Of 4be Qu -fhc>r and 4he cnotexb of 4be. \eader- Since TVH3 ©


    ;'.:.j
    i ^
    Cbo xHjctl roeao' xaepoovrgs charging ©
    :*j
    -
    :«
    According Fo CbO^e x j R j a I c o e C O O O O V- oodpl aod 44 o m
    '.'A
    \
    roeoo' ng op Few £OF4hocjf ejodpY-Stoodi pg 4foe fQXf > ^ •
    ©
    '
    .“
    .•:!
    .i
    i
    E Vvie caoooV Understood <toby Pobfcpc, jus+
    0 >

    ify ctoso' u-fe


    m
    :;VJ.-!
    •
    •
    i
    -
    aufbox jg of Abe stoto uu-toop undergoodi eg 44 2 sitoq.
    ' ©
    •
    :
    * ^

    VA
    3
    .vv*
    •Boos
    of bis bnoe •
    AGOvdlna T vkJai Approach l<f £oe G >qpf 4o understood
    ^ .
    _ @
    Ahe 4eS 4bPto fa no need do understood 4foe raov xf @
    .
    :v
    * coe. 'mA <i§£df >cv -
    again § pgofo coe CQO ppaap Aha,
    ^ ©
    : •!
    nO03oi
    g- m
    •
    ,* \ ACtovd i Oa 4o OboH? x4uci i fgto no
    QPOOUOf op
    be So-ppcieof da understood - tI m
    ' toe -Veto •
    :j
    Accord i °cj V -AO (Tao+ eKtooi ©
    i fS+s <cba+- IS understood es . -toe
    '

    OtAroafe Qkptofoa+ioo I'9 QBOQ (ove2sp +aJn oo- fa


    ^ '

    v
    Accotolg Vo 4be soppoad-ers
    no point 0 cid / in tetos <- of toxtooi Appsoadb -H^QXQ "is
    to

    - ^
    0 f ooeooi pcjs CXSQ Oaorex+ua i (
    U

    ©
    -
    Sadaroa-n oggQSis 4baV ooa live io eff &ofive ft
    ^
    db&Q Should be -fusion
    Of VtoTrf zoos -
    ,
    iatop aod
    / ’ - ©
    <?»
    Tully spgcjQSf 4hav if Osn <?c<?ss <ag 4o understood 4 _ ©
    Q2>oto f - be togb+-
    * tea - 4f © T bV
    dnnd Atoa-v Hs odvocopj of ^ of locfce cao hSip usdo under
    ffctocfoo of rgej o o, toBsenfPKS- pro
    Ao exA =003,
    - C "

    fda Hbe ^ ^ i
    '

    iic
    fe•
    •
    ^ ^ G

    ©
    I

    M
    1 ..
    / v'
    toy
    ) \ v© Fb.COCk % Ski oner
    Ca ^othiclge school scholars -
    1
    £S
    ©
    - o undPvSh od HnQuiSb'c coovexH
    )
    •

    © SgggGSt \
    C
    cObaF is 1 KpguisVic. cooFeb O f dccabs
    U:i

    r>« ©
    © Lio uisVi'c cooFeA
    ^
    surges* ^ ockg s ges*
    ^
    beefs oo cbcwg,Yg. % ^Have 3^^ VihQ4 ^oho44r^©r ^^0
    heo
    >
    roPani

    ~
    ^^ < >

    S3 #
    0a° b is a ttfusi 4bck exad-Jy OVX3 V Locte ^CI 4o COQO

    © QVQ Qble -to uodeYeVaod


    V .-1

    4© convey
    s 0 OePf 'da also sappoMs 4taQ OOOVGVHJQI approach - Deals Ida
    i © Q-ggPSF +be deroosbuc-Koo, cJoode r&Zidt -r > § Q aive
    <9
    )
    Sj
    %
    - ©
    V

    M © © Legal £osFjFa -Kona 1 } Lgqgi coogFiFaWaog t Approach -


    2
    0 fvpoioQots - '

    I © © /p V. Dicey
    flb K - C - Wheats
    :- i .* .
    8®
    i© Ivor Jennf 6
    - ’
    C F - scroop .
    a
    i ©
    1© oonSH' +u +baai Approach Has been applied by hhe
    Legal
    V?

    A&
    > '

    poWWcoi scholQTrs (a a big « oay


    cobeo poirHQQ ) science
    *- -
    •
    V
    tOQS OodOKSVood Qc, 4be dLody of -Sta Kk The opporoachaocis
    '
    IC 0 ' ’

    employed priroq -ZTiy I O 4hQ fcnraocb of ooropay^hve


    "

    -0 V
    '

    I
    :V
    :t c go-t- aod pOh hcs - These scholars bave sVodhed -Lbe px©v,'
    '
    -
    ¥
    ¥ Sbns of 4be cDngpFuWoo. Legal consK +ahooa ) Approach
    I0
    £* is Meg close Vo Legal ihguhjwooai AppYcach - rQ Lego )
    G
    i£ ©
    I1 ©
    XbSKHJWoocil Appoocb Tp^S has beeO OD +b£ Ki
    te0vH4 Fioos 1 f ks. ftnrl ( arOGOf jl-d (Ooi'sy , fes °^0IO
    cbaiienges ebc -
    <
    of
    , voiu 4 bo ^ /

    I1 © . Present sWavos
    i

    l .

    !© legal IhSWWu Fiona \ Approach Has b&eo HWe dcWoaot-


    © r8 hce _ i

    ^^ ^
    r
    appsoacb tni a1^ j^rrdd vOcnr- HO^OON*!
    ? 1

    !©K Of iSebaviouvoi Approach , leye) appbQCb


    I m deb'^oe - G Haviot-biaiisVs s^ggo^ed HO ^ i

    I® ^
    pe \ ibca \ beHavr'o CS J poiiti’cs
    \
    \
    i

    I
    I5
    m
    ©
    ^^
    p^<oce9S HTQ4h^ -fkoo|^ HP Sk
    ^ ^
    v of ro5H4cfK3 >o^
    ^
    \
    l
    I

    l
    !;
    r>.
    5
    : ©
    t

    I© r: .

    i
    l
    &
    IV \ .
    >

    3 3®
    sSs
    m
    P
    * K:
    -
    ='
    r

    k v

    :$i
    i ;£
    :
    ;§r
    5

    a
    a--
    r' ^ ;?

    a
    a
    ~v »

    do

    i
    a C-pcQ
    '

    ^ctciy’ OAQ -
    a
    Cn JO OpoQAdcjV' \ CO <J5ocic g;^
    astodcusto oea 307 cpocuuldTo Icopsaouj i o ^
    w
    i
    §
    -
    ^
    tbOcep p^ e ssepun o apoq
    ^k
    s; ao3H»
    lnoSl
    ' - *
    '-
    .,
    !- SC OTOO i
    ^ ^
    *
    poc o
    * ^,
    P "10® P010^1^
    .
    0 ai
    0J

    -J VTO
    M «0 'a
    oo p=40!-ad<S7 i s
    ^ ix
    -
    :: .v.
    -
    a SODSOU tr CfKOoq / og, i.

    or ov g ^ ^^^asq OSD lD|h /


    MDT POlOq !
    $}

    ^ P<0
    <
    a sp©§, -0 ^J Q-
    OifPOXA/ O.0j-Hz>\ "

    ^
    pr s Scfi- oo SnocJ Cpoosuddy icouRadGLrj
    -
    0 Jo pQCff ou
    •• •
    < ~y
    -} ^
    a •
    cptoojzddv ICOpLcHS ' H Cf c>7 g \

    a OQH-oA
    ^asqo ico .^ddcsui
    ^oib
    spoacsoioa O& ID : I a/\o,iqoov4
    ^
    ^
    GcdC f % 0Q*il> H9UO) J© OO CD
    ^^
    UOJhlOAdAjo
    •
    3 ^
    Sfq ojqotoO^ddy ico acbcgr pejddo Soq ^ isq
    ^iQVp
    3
    l s^°Morqs $Q
    ^ 3|qo

    3 ° soajfV

    -3
    ^o/+dA- >a£q(0 Jiaj-o R|0?o Rj.q IcojqdosQVS d° COJL
    j

    ^ ^^
    c>SH- ; GeA P £txq 64D(SJ - B - qocojzddv ICO,LR<3CJGJ
    «r -

    § ' Jo gap ^
    ©
    -
    OddapO) RWia
    -tckiJoa aq -JOOOOD cpt?QjzddV'
    ^ S- DOULXDH •: v.

    ODOjtdciy dAHcGaxapt 50 p\Q 5D St* CpcjQjiddV lc»}3adGqjj


    ^
    •

    3
    3A jcOLAOtH d+io? cpocL«ddy | co \xa6oaj a>odcuo
    B ^
    s jODOddcdV ICD rJ

    © • cpoQdddy ^ DoojaopJf
    W osun ns ©
    cj asp. oa q SDCI cpDaedcV loao npHsaj;
    [
    ^ ^ /

    . ci
    ^
    aq
    - sso.tcxo
    O oqSOCD 5 930
    *4-
    QjUnp J SO uGo ^ -
    # rduovHaj.48qj aajJ
    <
    do SAQpP’ - dioj-^oqaq !. .
    1 '
    -
    > td:
    © *- oj-tr

    -^ ^
    tfQ <st - ji ttqf pe Sd ' ' dr* ] Gds ^ aCfj- ^ ^
    ta

    rn ^ pcj .
    ^ ,

    .
    pd/1 CDSlp ciS), polo C lSji oG ©Hrntl l
    ^°
    i sojr
    QQ
    fro
    te-
    \r
    ~

    ^ ^
    I .:
    fo
    t'.--'
    s oo? do SJ oo sq-s- do oopvcD
    - ijqpci
    •
    oosjc? P^o *
    o jSdj VSjJ ov
    ?
    i::;
    -
    "

    qipios qooojiddv i ou o i+ + oi ^ ^
    © . Jo IQV/\dud to Pi SJOip -fOaaaa - . Of ' j&l\dCPQh
    Foi
    «•
    Si
    I---
    op STICKS
    *
    • ,s
    'r
    -
    |
    6x
    m ©
    | g*\
    (Ti t4o^vootWe
    Appwcb noeaos
    *
    ** ©
    i JoSb'cf, .ffcjoairtjJ /

    bso^va bip PoGp


    ^ ^^
    Ct^ppHODl App^ aCh roeaos ocA
    :;y ©
    ° ^
    M
    *5353 © © f O’VTOQtive Xpp^oc*0 QaiOgp, p^eso5 iprHs/© iobe^Pos
    ^ ^^
    '
    -
    GDI 4pp»mcb iG QfSon pbvip
    • ‘
    is ©
    vJ ,a oc b-v be
    . © CD) Ovvoabv'e Approach doci S 0
    ^ '
    ;*/

    1© e ~
    Q3 k5 ADfkb ^obaP s -
    1
    G
    ^
    ftroos XnoperfCQ ! App^'O0^ 0 * °
    1 © gi
    ( MOinnco+ivp Approach a&teohgc# £choo e cnriQrM
    .3
    3
    m ©
    £5
    .3 ©
    £-
    t< b ©fQ
    ^
    33 Xhr ppjricQi Approach
    )

    ^
    Sita+os p[uoisbO bc )
    '
    ^^^
    1
    x
    (v) The. Qsi'
    ^ ricx Op McnnnoabMP Approach IS or hf 4 cr0 f
    ^
    :$
    ;s
    Vi
    ft

    I
    X’

    1 ©
    © tobpjnQot -
    op -0
    ^ VPe cetera Of 1 OppsiQa > CDpp-YOacp s 4?rue
    " , ^
    : lsp •
    3
    •

    *
    3 ©
    :
    :$

    I© ^nDpebooi Approach bos led


    i
    4o Abe" WoiuKoo
    of Sa©ohpc
    :
    2$ approach . ' Though Xbopp^coi
    Approach 10 fteJsm sPeob'c.
    * ©
    1
    5
    1©
    I Approach foracy 4beog Ao be cjapi ?-ped! QS soQoHf>c
    ,
    .

    I5 SAbPO'g ff has *to pose Abroe p +be *0 0Q ous, voeVtod0 _


    .

    1
    :S
    ?

    A
    $
    .
    ©
    ©
    adopted -
    cSCj eooQ
    o
    t
    ^
    ^ ^
    !? © Behavioural
    Wbaf I'S bebqvioural qpptfoacb <"
    V

    !K- c
    ©
    £
    ;-.
    © Mcxreroer I' O PblfpCQl 6tl'0Oce bo lOh>educe SCfeCH-fpc
    '
    V.
    I ^
    dbl 03 S C>CVDO QS tSObavi'OpBOfl HOvQnQ | ^oe-lfd
    I7 ©
    © beo
    ° '^ Q focOevQV .

    \
    © ^ roeffodalo C(ba o cs bOeVbool qs c£ 2) ! QS Sc
    ^po
    © of 's pltoe q!9o char p . peoce Gebs < ^ v ocon' liiVQ e^eo
    * ;

    ^
    ;

    bo c. QSCor pforiS accuk urooo


    ©
    ^ ^*
    1
    :
    i

    ©
    ^
    LA 'S ipv dfcfe_ xQqgoo
    ' ,
    ncAqrs K |ce ? ' Vo -
    >
    5
    i
    G >avlGQvfo \ s a Ss cuso VDC
    O
    ^
    '
    qc ^LOO
    :
    s
    1
    ?
    1
    !
    \
    ©
    © '
    h

    © s
    I J

    0 J

    © 1
    B
    l
    © F
    r
    .
    ©
    i

    \ elV i

    0 v
    «B»iWi<nsww*^

    f ;Vi
    '

    S5 X- *S-
    ^ 0vvwS£5
    ^ w35
    ^^
    I hq S
    ^bavlOUVi'O®I iSnO <?
    8
    « 3
    Si
    :..1
    a
    k ^ af ;0urian
    ^ ^
    °QOyidBtfr & **»
    * =
    « »*- @
    v QJ^
    ^aS ptforoa-VCy
    ^SeiAnoe
    ^ dcal^
    ica ucxxnf 3$-
    i
    £
    !
    ©
    U Asspcfatfan . tbeire ase
    pbt .i-b' ca ! 5 oveoce
    «1
    r‘:i
    :: i
    i
    •

    eroeg
    teofqa as ! coehass Historical 'Sisasoos Wb' nd 4be
    - ©
    ©
    Vi &Dce Of Bebavfoq Q )|srO-
    ^
    ' -
    :Vi Q
    fi H(Ston <jQI Reasons"
    l ©
    Cilso’pHnG Op Pbli -Hoo / Science oa o -^be. s-fe?4-eop
    ^
    ::

    ^ )
    drecHo© . David EasVon Q O0Q§he4 SeCi (OG of poiMQai
    S3
    ©4
    VbcoYLj cebesQas pobp& fe>aboi cdedqy d 4b© deehb of
    ^
    ^ #
    ^
    4.5
    I
    •
    ££>
    •• i
    poii-b'Qp) 4txOirU- have btaroeJ W iSterrfciste 4 od; -
    4oooii 5 life sov ioe § Oaoni ^ dor -vbe. dearoe o ^
    V- f
    ©

    j
    ^
    '
    °
    bic^i -VDeD . 1foe$ b id fbav \
    g
    foosio. scboiarss Vo^e
    - jppoif - ©
    .X!
    4©-1
    i

    ^j
    AbeoosGivQs sVtqc$ c o|3 idkjaSj Tb© ose oof - pocd
    .

    ^
    -x:
    0 j ^ ucin
    :V©
    4.
    -
    cprQ jtbGovj cobicb Coo deal toj+b C^o rofooso pjobig .
    W bJ 4bis fiCQiiSQ h'on
    * '
    ^ ^
    ^- ^
    ©
    ©

    ^
    Abfer oJ uoovid toqv omderoi'c con ceo c
    ( ©
    »90 -U5QV xSCVp
    coere called
    ^5 qve ^
    - ^
    rS OQO Q Q. Spg SKOOS or> HfcMt ©
    . :i
    :!i
    nsuGKoo b dev< ^ *yeCons-
    ^
    atopQosof 5b 4bQse Goo seo c o 3to,q?rs
    1

    ©
    ^
    •

    ^
    /

    bebr 'ing -to <dt


    ^
    boq \ .Qcfent-
    sphxpr<96 .
    Vsts cc no oc Vovi'-kocf
    ^
    CinQ fo v! ted bq-
    f pO |
    ©
    ©
    Uibu / * ©
    oVb V diScjpl JoQg bavp p
    ^
    '

    75 -Poed Vibef S ,
    ' ^?>c44 ocloiey /e3
    4be bas/e adop
    ted ec/eob -Pc moe-toad pbey^ could © •

    ^
    uce 'Diablo £ ^ P*C - ©
    **
    •• *

    Qr )
    NJQtfi
    POKPCQI sdence nie&
    Be bcn^lec -
    xv bad Nairobi > 4beovl ©s nor ^ ^ m
    3 dbODWes azb'Cb Could ©CMT SSS coo
    ©1 ]
    !'X
    >4
    ©
    ^ etopoTy Cdnseose^•- ^ 4
    * -
    Con s.^nsoj ©
    .v e
    ©
    5K
    5f: ©
    ©
    C
    ©
    •
    r

    S-i ©
    Cx
    ©
    1 .:
    .J
    © ‘
    :;!
    cV
    m
    eg
    :e,
    :©
    *_ r
    -© V - M'
    ’
    A
    Reasons - 609>|
    I © Ca - Wo aod Cas
    Chicago s^bool scholars
    Ifce
    '
    p i ftfcs ascr process
    * <

    ©
    haue- bcao eropbasis) m 4o °
    ttaf U3G 'SOqai'Se cCaa
    ©
    S £bolq \
    *S |
    { YQ JanoPs 8 3/ ce. called
    ^ ^
    2 ©
    §
    . '
    facte aoc faGted .' *?

    a ©
    FcaKf -hjres op BohaviOUva 1 Approach
    a 4o / noO ' CGf poW-Hcai Science
    J ©
    •V OcMd Ehsteo ( o bis ipoMso
    ^ ^
    3
    en> &
    c
    fotei kpcfuQk ^(e odqKoo
    -
    ^
    ©
    1
    1
    ©
    dS33dat’oo has
    SOUPS of BPbavfou* ia 11s»o .
    " ^ .
    ’
    Bbat QYQ these features 9
    m ©
    5
    n © (T)
    I
    M
    '•

    : '
    Regularities - ft roPQOs jQSf there ara obspcvalde
    I © la-sities ;Q 4 0 natural aeo d rollazriy these ara
    ? - ^ 'es fo haroao tapbavfouh Mence ^ce
    ^ ^
    1& © observable Tj^gjlcbvb
    a © cao noa G so'eop* -fc
    ^ tbecg *
    5t
    a

    1c 0
    >
    © © PystenoaKsaKoo- r,iqg ^research^ ,o Kaf
    *
    -qroiscience
    there should be S\ J tisa4-fc>o fo social scieotuos^
    i

    - <

    1I ©
    ^
    ^ - a f
    raeaos tpere teoouidi bo coooedhoo befooeo -the bQfo-
    4besis aod data ColieGb’on -
    •
    ~

    I©
    tU . M0b P co-Kao - Our l pa+beefe ehouM bo copobte
    i0
    1 rQ,)
    k
    *
    o
    V
    vedpcaKoo
    tbrouyb fadb
    ®) Techniques - ibcg deggested -Vo locospcrsuvo sc/
    ^
    \
    V

    © feoboi'ques te' JdQfOO noa-Kcp ( steH-igWcpI OoKf',


    tecboiqoes -
    -
    I£ © © Mcasa-fTGrocct - PesqIts boaid bo erprpsoed ip
    V
    b © bis rcaoo£0 .
    ^ •
    p^aoppQ„
    5:
    g
    - Jot g-TSOtOO - Adcpb IbVehdisopllnasg approach
    ^
    i V,
    |© HcbeoG— •

    toe should net \abo OUv " te31l


    '
    \

    9 3 ^_^'
    s © Sterol
    3
    ,
    ^^
    s
    pHltoSo Vlu
    tosop ^4 fQCC
    ^
    I u

    ^ ^neshomj
    &
    ^^
    ?
    ? © Oq5 4beo > I
    to doen+i pc cd«'scipl { o 5 iifce. P cbOlOQtj
    <

    ^
    ^
    i
    I 0 5cOo| - ; Q 1

    I © ! Qg
    % ©(Doatofcs • ' I

    ©I
    :
    '

    VtJiue vteubd \i
    ©
    s,s b<s NQiue
    Q '
    - PoUBcai Scholar SbcufcP 'oot ' ^^e - 1
    5
    p'
    ©
    0 © j) Puie Scteoae - taboo coP ^ rooc s
    ^
    1 6&OYUG qboul rootex^ds
    <OH O ^
    £
    E
    :
    !•
    r
    i>
    0 *

    t^b) f-tfca | science colli bccooon po^ acleoc© .


    E
    * '
    IK
    © I;’

    m \
    i h
    # i
    0
    0 "”TTC~C'
    -
    SS ^SSSoSSSSSSS^^S^SSS^^ ^ ^ -TCCCAT
    > v

    ^
    ©
    » *
    o
    ©
    £ ACH
    based oo biPbausourcH approach
    Ume no. of
    a..
    *

    P!
    ©
    ' eo« - WotO&W, Mosf -oP +h? stod
    V -rl
    fes Opse
    .1

    rnS- jp into x iS
    \+
    on electa® ) behaviour- W * ** ^ *©
    ( *
    **
    ^
    p: - i
    fd
    &
    -a
    P
    (Do produce cjuooHtP K°e - ,
    do ta - ©
    '’ l

    gs Post 8ehQvfounri a \ \S«r> -


    pnoe_ \960s
    ©
    ©
    fbsl SdnaviouriQ' fero ? ©
    - PsVg
    ^ of cfelioP. ©
    ..
    *

    c©
    <*
    4

    .
    ftoilHoal science coos ooce «2P

    ^
    > (O
    ^ * * =*
    00 2 «

    ^ J
    1
    iSi
    .-"
    Ifos <cas -u* Vnoe ^cbeo ^ m
    •' :1 Uacopvpr. 0 ¥ cg ] sctotts ©
    *3 !
    i @
    .)
    -
    p^ yjpeal Scboms nPfllsd Ptl ocprr9otiy&
    V,

    1a Tb g
    ^ - ^
    '
    *

    V;
    pasefloie. te ©
    I dealt uDi +pooAy sacb t'S&u^ ^ ©

    -
    \v
    ©rop^ou scfeoh fc, Aecbntaue H©0 , paH'H o^ i -00'!fr£’ c£>Gre
    '

    ^ •

    ©
    i

    loVbP Peid of ecNsrai v t o L - Tfcimc& r


    1

    lsteta© Po aroiee -tt* s aoce of ^ ^ttespge . © ^ *


    •
    4
    :j
    ^
    Oovld fo oo tobo has gWeo 2 ta
    ^ <
    ^
    veupCtaaf ^^ ©
    tau o MHov? ©'

    S
    Stones Vas °Ureo aoab \©GkK£LcH Aopdcao R / rfca?/ ©
    ;

    i crgpoe ^ ^
    SsodaH? oo totooduciog post PiSboo / OM I jv p
    ^
    nsbG
    4
    VitiP- of '\ PGMYG OOUS 4 Gredo of feievqoc© - He ^ ^
    •

    •
    J
    -!
    •
    -Hcised poiifcol scholar SQa +fg /n
    ©
    totoe*s pe*r-p ® f ^ ^
    Cbog -fhehr +PCbni‘
    ojUfS bal- concprro
    •

    bl
    Pbe Subject #
    -
    •

    (U
    *3 rOO Hpr\ dbe TrCJpvao ’ He cp|( 9 - y Create Ate>
    I v^bat ^
    S cyeaHve
    ^
    Ibeovg ?
    ©
    ^ ^
    .

    ij aoHon
    ( 35 guided bg - ©
    (T:

    ©
    i
    rS: t
    in peie^an ce. . v*>-
    Pi
    ;>:

    :•>.
    :©
    ’
    ,
    ©
    ©
    @
    ;.p

    m
    ?&
    #
    :i
    ;
    ©
    P #
    m
    ••a
    •

    I
    v -

    —
    ooi - - Sui -the pq* poae
    :

    JI © Me bed 4b> t&hOic ' Q (s f po


    ^ ^
    -
    m
    v-?t cy <£ jnxCb *eebot u<2 ^^ i '
    Q erof ^^V
    ^ exf v'S f ^OpeM- -
    3

    s
    0
    ao\ 4EF 4foe ^ SQMf
    /
    . v. ^•ues
    •

    x;
    •
    1©
    I
    ^ , .
    •
    v

    1©
    I5c © oop CooncM-
    ,
    MhqV poi '-b' ca; SciPote te *** **5 .
    **P’" _
    3 be ao pppli’e scfeo^e . He hffo* M >e4 fhe &o&por>sjbh
    1
    - x» ©
    5
    ^ ^
    ^^ ^ of gbcJoi edeoHste is *Vbb<o +he ^re poo -
    ;
    ( '

    1©
    - ^
    ^
    %
    iicrt i\ j of siahn' oi Scieops fS ' Mtftr** 1 st+enHs+s
    I~ © ^
    £
    r ?d mof V> cprxe&r) Qtou f cc>ha© b -
    - © X t cso
    ^ T9 4 '

    ^
    -
    $
    fl © 92G'6 \ 3deoHs4s v>oi 4r> guide foe soo'
    --
    IS Lecfure 4g
    £ © ~ o|
    \ feDkiveS of fbs> Qdr»V»OMv id » «sro I
    I ©
    'X

    (H fe>rho’iq\je '3 h*DpOYVocd -t-bat afro S


    © '
    -fcs cobicb +echo>qoe & used . ..
    1©
    11s © ^ -
    ( u) l e lash of ptsi Social SciePhsis ,-c, noo^e chauer ;°
    ^
    b' a
    I © ^
    4hoo -ihav of t akjYQ Sb’ebh's-te -
    ^ .
    * ® fos* GekavbuTri l > sr^> does no* vejecf values vcubsr iovik?
    ©
    I
    5y:. venues Mocoe^er pc^\ sp 0<ss+ vb tv hoea 3 - = -
    |r
    '}

    I©
    Cv
    /

    sbcaid not be 'oiQ e’d .


    © IheoFig ^>oqid have ^ > Ao solve -Hoe oisi'
    o ^
    V

    c
    Q ^ ijjj s
    © Should proT>oafo socb
    I<

    5
    5-.
    4
    c

    ©
    '
    ®
    ^
    Rjliboqi
    - . >!
    he -f ?o u vfeh
    Sq'ence
    #
    values aoh> lcb oh ^iba +o 4oaCqxfe
    3°f Huroao OvilisQ-Woo.
    *

    l is applied sc?eoce> r*a*-be* -MDQO pa


    1 o
    © Qdeoce ^
    X.
    @ biihcai Scieoce Ts a. osefjl
    1© ^
    Soppcfs pd
    disclplloe <Obcb r>eod= ho hfe >

    I®
    K o
    9.
    ;
    5
    oo’ ( ^ pscraahed by Treseascb - octedcs't-toos Q d
    ft OYs\be6 . ° ^ i

    i
    5
    I
    ;•
    © I
    i•
    :
    i
    © i
    i

    © i
    5

    ©
    © !
    i;
    t
    o ;

    > 1
    t
    £i
    ©
    0 ft
    5
    K.

    li

    &
    ; xc
    c: sJCrirUYe of ffef fipbav ioa* <a lisb) •
    el
    IS pog- Qebov,‘0aT O V isro OPQ -SPY to -hsadi+fanoi App-amof (bv
    ?
    ;

    Qehavioura !
    '
    ppxoacb
    QT
    ^
    *
    : -.!
    ©
    Y
    * fbs\ P£>hov ?oavibriSrD is, noV CiosPr 4o VwadWobcri isor> m
    I;}
    j
    Br &hcnf£5 bOS'fC QSSu^pfroos cQrfb QebabCU bOiis^O - 33
    ^
    S is OOV- Q cmn4pr Trevoiofo acplosf befoavbcoria i fsno - ®
    ©
    (tmlgs foe hav r“OCJ Via t jsro {attOord
    .v:
    :!
    .
    if ftfudifboaiieco fs> ©
    Si ~+beis\
    s , BefoavioLnrbi fs^ is Aotb -fbe'sfs K fbs - - E’shaoiv
    '

    1.::
    oa^oilsTyD is
    * ©
    jcrtoesis.
    1
    ^
    @
    & ©
    - -J
    ::
    ?S\
    CoieUeefual rofapoeOs on Post SpbaviousfQii'sro -
    ©
    © Karl Fbpppy bos given -toe cnnoepl- of RJtei £ (b+foo . ©
    Wha+ rs fbfei -pca-
    •x
    •
    re: . stoo P «
    #
    •X , - faiSift'caVioods -foe C&i +era of sdeovifc dbeo-g io social
    5?:' @
    -
    CV
    Sdeoces - Ib soo'a \ sdeoces vfe v's oof -.pass'b'<? 4o produce
    such 4fopovA’es tobicJb coo be vprifed Absorb expe iroeo+ ©
    *
    >o \oboiatoy - ib SDddi oa'eoces ft s <5no pp «‘f -foeog fe ©
    * ^
    OpPO f >5T cbfiGai (bvpg aVton - fYoro +be> pe sp0Gfo/p Qf c 7>

    ^
    fais'i -fcaWbo KOzo oo f3 deVer ro'Oisno -
    * •J

    :!
    © Tboooag, Vnoo SojgPy-
    ^ hsd -foctf .

    -Abes© ts ^00 foou“ jy to


    *
    ©
    k
    ^rncoipckje PVQO scieoVfeb, tcods coifb asocepbal
    ftfQr*oe dCyXsrt or pa-sad ggno vie Q(£G suc esfpd Vbqf
    '

    ^ c.
    0
    v'
    C:'

    -4be VnpovVaoce. ap 4foso j Is oof 'io bota precise ff -e ^ ©


    • ;1
    ^
    bcH footo ( jspfjl A is ro roaoagp <oenf of Crisis or ©
    1 psabipco GDWifXj .
    A
    ©
    3
    '
    :V: #
    y.. ©
    •
    ©
    ©
    I
    V
    .
    H

    ’•'* V' •
    A
    , £
    e
    p -

    ©
    r?
    <§
    <f
    Sj
    :ci
    @

    II dsievro,’nf 5v o _ > LPu .


    @
    V; SrJSS?55S553cS
    ^ of a vo^5
    ^
    "
    ^ S?!SS}5i!S|i
    !
    ^^<S2^S55SoSS^^SSwS5^3^5?S!?v^^
    55SSSvi35?5 ; ?\??:>2rSS55
    ‘vvwi r:C?5Sv?3i
    ^ ’ ^555c
    ! od i+| fete 'OOQi
    V3
    © CrfHcfero of BehOviOOVOM'SrO ^ !
    •

    -.
    '

    .•S 9 ' sadWood \ &s believe -voa v 4b <?«? is no


    I ' Ho -
    i
    , © pOiVHcal science a science - Qoleoce CPO

    ideoo? ortuak «* cmv- of ewopwo


    v2

    '
    •
    -
    f-:3
    SJ
    ©
    ©
    >
    aod Tsetsvaoce eebovKXAvaiiste Have (ottsoducerf uoosce ^
    ssqxo ja aofe or onmyp >«© ved 4e* roi’r'>cdG0y (taWtk ti v>e£ Y a^o» TCJ .
    ^
    •
    :;iS
    -
    M ( « <

    *
    5
    11 ©
    I--fi
    ^
    WLfoiScrt rocve «s ro 5 *g
    ,
    a «
    ^ - ^ ^
    ,
    tchal Mes
    ^<k* xM - ^
    •
    .::i§
    •

    choree - Behavibu-ra ) wpsea ath is cosbjy ^


    ©
    ?
    Sfoo afcoa+ poi iebs have been QKtfved a-f Bs a .-
    lOeWxbcf,^
    vS
    n
    m©
    CcM

    vy
    M

    ©
    vtoU7sbife4s Hb*ocQb oocalfpd

    aiiste -fbsoc r) lexical


    OH^ OUS
    Siro'i icrc cooc\ cc,i<f > o bave Voeeo Qnrdved ted-
    season"
    ^- fwcscP * 4-for
    Macbip ett r >ev o
    ^
    )-

    ©
    ^'e ^ poii- - ^ ^
    '

    - © toi+bouef foi occiiOQ Tdfyoutfous Sa' piOhRc


    ' COMIJ
    VSS
    l'

    *Vi ©
    1©
    ©
    •
    ^
    3
    Ve q* 46
    cooc\as
    Qnoe

    ^0C USOUS ^9£ecqcb


    5
    ^ +bo\
    clustop
    'Or> Bptoavfou ^d W&is
    HeS is
    onci c
    '^ cwsNip
    °f P°^
    offsv
    1
    S
    :-of, ©
    '
    1-S fd
    V^
    Arccwdi -to l^ChxiSIS
    -
    Crmcfeno kg lAa odste (of B avtou a » iSro)
    * ^i .A

    ^
    ;

    0 boviourq ifero
    ^roOige +o couolor
    ?
    ^
    :
    2
    ’t
    © Mqrxfe+s
    anayc , )'s .

    Ij © ^ co+ 5'r ^ bQsfs p


    ba ( 4 bo
    A ^ sdt f q rvisls
    ^
    '

    I© ^ ©pbavibpr a i isvs advocate


    Value
    1© npuHoif m 4be naroe op sdoo+i-fe beo -
    9*t aneoHDo fSo <o Morcoq ^ Q Bebovioa -gQi , '

    l
    ©
    £QaOr 4o ctfNJ

    TSebcvioqYiqi ISND >S iite ^ ^


    -bve Q ufswocxs - .

    f? © ioood o-f ids©ip y a-Hero p ©M


    SdcoHg Ho ju&W -fa 4 ^
    i
    I AfbCVicqb poifb' CQN
    0
    ^ . !

    I5 # IV is ^
    -1 based on assuncp+ioo 4bQ+ all cOoPi cte Sbrtos
    ^ bcwe been Cj* OO
    1

    !© wsoived io 4ta©
    '
    «cea »ro ccutowes acd
    :

    0 & M
    siorroatiVe 4bcog - 1
    ehovibcjjra i i ’3is
    © ^Tbe se> rcocieb. qre
    Pave pncxHuced roadefe. u be s s-vefos appnrood- *
    |
    ©
    -syetet -
    o as
    produced tassjdpa
    an ideal Wpe. U
    coes^ira oou-b'oa ;
    *
    ^ ' f
    f
    1
    t
    V
    i

    e ?
    h
    i
    © <
    fc
    •

    6
    © £
    :
    /

    B r--
    !.

    0 M
    i

    «
    ^^* 5535 533355^^
    *
    ? r Abeh •yseavch tocoQrcis ©
    x;
    to
    s?
    * * TSpb q, vfa ux c* t f$te ^ '

    Sociotfsfr counties £uh$s Abea j A © fty&Q x ao -


    ^ top£w fctete ©
    v-

    ^ ^
    '
    *
    :l
    to! ©
    :•' i !
    Tbpovtj of !Peroo(VQ ©j s^ esi Abq-V o ycKtby is ) - Xxoo
    tod
    bi
    rcS
    •
    :1
    -
    ?

    :
    !aeo f tdnokbes coaoV*y B SoabfssH or Cfberal p©topr
    ' ^^ ©
    ra
    oolU b<o on to 4be hoods of -eK tos - - ©
    •J

    :I
    4
    t

    •
    | -. ^ re Abe
    t cL h toqcxtBto 4b\ o'c Abq + Abe Qiboof Behaviouru'sro
    0
    ©
    ©
    :.;
    £003
    aoaygtoof cemwm coaovafe
    to couQ< * toqsxiQte
    ©
    8u\ eo Caonol- say bctf ccas Abe oojy afro O’o ^v^o
    to
    -X
    ^
    FOOSA hopotftoot- afro - toe ct»o eee Abe geouto>e demise ,
    #

    Qnoorg po \ -hvcq| scholars to b^ ng GdeoW -fc ecboiyogs ©


    i

    ;
    to
    -a i

    Ocd toooq ]49 pon -Kcoi Sct'pDce scxeoffh *Ob cb 4b j Aboq- ' ^ ©

    ^
    \

    i gbh LOOS reopgsAg ^o +ba-i disc/ pUoe /<4beomNes gQ ' OS ' » ©


    . .!

    C*ea ibbt j. #

    ^ —
    K
    r.
    ©
    Motor© of Crisis > 0 fbiWcoi Tbeo'g ©
    Pb ' iAcai Iheovj has soared fk>o Ate c^rteto of oeievaoce .
    ©
    \ UD\ CQ\ ° m
    1 After a toaHd cQox pouAoaj schoiQoS * oo+ i' Ov .4ed
    ©
    -\OY QCQdproi'c conAtoreoces because f -vcoas -felb AhqV 4b© j
    bcwe novb' Yg to off r ©
    •
    -!
    !

    ?
    V

    David "Easton bos tola road fgaJfAi'ooottSte - fS-x Abe dhcJloe ^ ©

    °
    f poh’ woai -Abeo'pj , •
    ©

    ^
    •
    I

    ) AcCDfdiC to dbvid togloo 4<b£ noogf - AtorA?10 AtooSs e.


    0 Op
    CV

    -T
    4 faiHicai fdeqs have* been Atop ctoste pbctaps/ tT«o Q .
    We aoas sairp n'sod -toqv eyeo oper Crteis i < be^ aqoyfcto
    - <£a
    ©
    >'

    .
    '

    m
    •

    £OQ >- If . gM
    coo d OQir pailffoql scbolqss COCAM oov- pzoduce
    ^ to deal dOf +b CboAenopoYA ssaes
    Ojoco 4btotooq
    ©

    ^
    / '
    • ©
    -
    vv

    aespea -fcqlly btoroed b"Sto)Via!9 likeeavtoeA Ooonto


    tObodOor© basu fn ^» 3 t
    ©
    ;
    ;•

    ^to y old ideas . He also


    . •Cy\bof ses
    Jnsh'-tov vto ro \ t’ste oJbo Cod id cot- V2>csb b oncJ
    rc
    :.: toSHto +iooS - ^ r:-a
    V©

    ©
    6
    © {

    x>:
    ;

    l
    a
    :: . _ ._^^^v^ ^5«!?eegg gg^C^TO? ^?-- ^S!?^ - ^'-^
    ^Jv vc - ^
    •• * f
    , v ^rx *,
    ’ » *l 2Vir « CTvggi!g»j | | CTy ,
    r 8 ?
    »
    IL ' ' <v
    tyatir*
    ’‘
    Wof )a i isAs
    - arcticise faac » +tona t t§F Venose
    •

    *
    J

    © §j - Vte
    ’vfGS , Cached aog
    bas/e podaoed A'tfrO Cbjqhr feneo
    •

    =--:f3l ©
    • ?t

    veritable oocole e.
    ^ ^^
    «N

    I3 ©
    M^nce David Pbsfoo OQHec* -fos d£>e { O^OckiX' ^
    'OO
    -3
    3
    m M © saeoVipc .Vecbo o So fbaf foiitfcaf -4bGOY) as ga to
    V®
    #
    ^
    1 1 Os dib' \ ibi .
    :¥
    : SJ
    '
    i

    @ FblWCDi - ^ tfe fjfOrO oisis> opp' D bcff


    1#
    1I e .
    fipp ved
    ^
    I ftovs, 4i «^oe b«9G30g <o Q£ g h>ov^ 'oa'ira5''' s s - 93nCfeV'OUYa |,S
    -
    fecus rootns Of ) fbe puvi - ^CQWoo C>T feCboicpQs >0(4
    '
    ^
    '

    ^
    1-«
    •
    •

    -~
    i ©
    S
    ©
    (
    - ^
    CfcOQGh’ V9 to TOQte pO / }fi‘Ct}!I SQ'0OC£> <q SC/e^Cjo <
    ^
    0©
    M

    ooce b aio fbibKq ) -fhpogi ^oqa, io csi's,ls> b©caos<o


    1©
    -- . # ^
    igebavioqvon te- cbo \0av19 no ec cJ
    ^£ fo issqes

    ^ ^
    .
    4
    .*
    bed 00 4bQe> i 4-?
    ^^
    -

    nS^e^^
    «
    Mg 63
    36S-.
    ;
    :c
    4S
    '
    ©
    ve sociqi
    t'
    **
    ote -
    eteo oaUe {- Sr David
    %fl © fbst Bebavi oujOifsro . We hefd \bQ4 fbit -Hcqi Sa'eoMsfs
    - ' *
    ^
    i © peaf )
    ^
    *

    |ha*e Overlooked -VbejV ’BPSpoO&Woi; l


    -
    , n i^°g tooess perRaKcy -tae/ tf A-eohogo
    ^ ^
    10 50 -
    ©
    1©
    {0
    j
    V
    C\eAsj - ffeoce He Called pr Oegqpye
    aod wSlevoocg? .
    1 dbpog based Op, aCA-nCvc ^ V

    f # l OK irtjj
    Of Qetavfoufanisro
    ly ©
    1
    Bcbavt'ouyo 1 (5KD led +0 +be TOcOrb Of iorjpp COl Ts S©3Xtf )
    ^
    c
    t
    c

    ! 0
    :
    j
    <
    Cy:
    TOtild produce Skidies
    (
    .
    eobavibuvtnis+S HNQ con<PC4cd bi edta-k} - 0ebcxvioqyq \ tsfe ^ ^
    % electoral tebavioqzr lOWdh bay©
    i

    i-

    ':
    '

    ; ( { '
    -
    beeo bsefai - o> poti b' octJ pcprb’Gs ( o debe*°e’•Oi * fbeir
    9
    .
    \
    V!;
    elccHoo sbsat £ j,Gs • r
    ! @«
    Bebovioq o 1 isAs hove enveloped ceste' o CbocepVua ) - onoe. .
    m uve^ supteros qpp*o>Qcb rtradkAKa I {- SocKooo ) oppro=f
    *

    -
    ^ ^ -
    \
    :
    i

    #
    0

    0
    e
    Cb cobiCb cao b » O9od for- 4be ^2tud op cAev lop'iO
    Tbe rocsf {nopovfcab acb<Ov©nOeC op pshav O
    oacb (9 \Odbe Of
    ^ . povi -
    I qppir
    HCQ - ^ ^QOUK
    ^
    ^
    ^. — ;
    !

    !
    i

    [
    i
    ;
    V

    i: :
    © !

    t
    s
    ©
    t
    # .:
    fe

    # I
    I
    :i
    0 t
    r9

    is
    ©
    #
    ©
    0
    V
    -M
    ?
    aod -to cohdf e*4en+
    :
    23* faob l/a t ue Dccbofo
    •

    ©
    * Di cVx Ortv3
    |
    1 4/ O
    '

    ^
    sspOrcuha
    n 2- p s
    ^^
    pos4 bebaviOavdi isro T go|v/e ft
    ffobfri' CQ| Science! isfcofpd d£> O pQ l of - )
    v~v

    >
    ^ ^ "
    fb ^ y Qq | ©

    1
    CO
    philosophy ftifyoaii sdente bas been closes 4o
    . '
    ,
    ©
    foti-HCd! phi lasophLj . Tsodv'Hooal po / iHcal 4bCodes deaf ©
    f

    tJorcoa-tiVe ikues
    » < v* F Jbte, tibes , ©

    JuSKce ^ ^
    %
    cc
    3» .
    fsadvWooai Theories tome uod@s 4b0 ansi' beca
    r^ad 'KooQi fceortes ^oeire norafveoccs) Awro ose’
    '

    cha
    m
    ^toil bodies Me ' lord B^njCe tolled ©inp^n - ©©
    Theo
    .v\-

    :-r. -
    ries - Sobo lays » fce
    - called Tao*s, 4ct <fts ao< facte - ^
    j hoviodrai McMeooeov for * a
    a;

    -
    Vi

    K
    ^p*odud\Vg such AbeortPsaf«ned av fd < =**> o
    <£ fo\cfo d'zre vavj© neuf &at*fo *
    $$ <

    1 roa ^o poi ,t (Q \ science pu e


    , ,
    ©
    * saeooe .- -
    7
    «*

    I9$r Qebavfou^cmsno -ended ffsdt- value dicboVom j ©


    ^
    •

    3 held 4foq+ 4be»e rs 00 need do roov=e fbnKCbi


    .

    ^ Qcfeoce
    ©
    a putre sconce
    applied so enep .
    . fbit'Aioai Sb'ence P°1, c4j scienceo ©

    ^ geoved do locn^po^ Hs \qlucj ©


    '
    Q o

    <J
    Qcd nof ^
    4o ftctft techniques asao end <0 ftseift- a
    Behavioural j fbSf Behavioural scbolqrs f
    ;
    i
    bpld 4bav , Fdcf aod \to Ues dre Pobe&f Bahai, ©
    ' oof OC»rop1efe eTi

    ^
    Oicb o - V

    roofs / sepeaaV© • £b fpd- j .


    Vo
    ! -
    ft era fso coofiouffy befuoeeo ©
    :
    jfbeno- pads become values via lues becomes a •

    #
    ac.
    :o
    #
    4© a©

    ©
    r. .-.
    .•*
    ©
    m
    m
    ©>
    :’! Cs-*
    /•
    -
    --
    •

    v
    !
    ©
    ;:
    • •

    1 M
    W: ii
    ;v .

    .*
    v
    a:
    5®
    -.
    tv

    >Cv>: a
    Arffrtfm-’
    •

    —
    v »
    1

    Pofi'HCol Ibeo -g vs oob escape roechoofs^D bm


    - ©
    re
    » • 0

    i
    a ©
    i
    v
    ©
    •
    ra

    :
    ’
    ^
    a .tdoas (jdi -Ffi ccMt} CaHio^j - ^ 5 Ff * cu f+ coovt)
    '
    .

    ;. a
    4 53
    33 ©
    -32
    : •
    «
    a ©
    i
    ©
    1§ ©
    0

    aS ©
    '

    •x»
    X
    a-
    ©
    ©
    .i
    «
    i ©
    ©
    II 5
    • -v
    I ©
    l
    I
    3
    ©
    !c y.
    k
    I4 ©
    ‘
    #

    4 V
    I>: 0
    k
    ic ©
    V
    S
    :•
    c
    i isV © v I
    -
    I
    $
    2
    ©
    ©
    5
    r#
    ;
    •

    I5 # ;
    :

    1©
    <

    *
    :i C
    I © f
    i
    j f? r
    ©
    !
    i
    ii
    m ;
    i
    f
    :
    e

    j
    ?
    £
    wxv^w: [
    T.-' -

    o
    *- :: r
    V
    !

    ©
    s--sl
    v ©
    Id #
    r
    v> 5)
    ©
    m
    13 *
    #
    i
    ©
    ©
    ©
    !
    g #
    %
    ©
    ©
    ©
    ©
    G

    :
    • 4
    i
    ©
    ©
    •
    •
    1J ©
    1 O
    ©
    :V:
    m
    p
    - im -
    m
    ©
    ©
    :;->:r
    ©
    :V*

    ’’

    ::;1
    •
    ©
    :di ©
    i .J
    *

    -•r.i '
    ©
    •

    id
    vl
    m
    #© tf 5i
    $3
    }•

    v©

    & ' * *•
    /
    6
    m
    fjJvjv5J?vv5i
    - -
    ^^^J^.*A’l*0£J9lJW*2>S?5l!®SS?S?KSS53?K5 5
    o>t w>iV.-.9(.

    You might also like