Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Arianna Boja
Intern/Mentor 2021-2022
treatments, including CAR T cell therapy, a type of adoptive T-cell immunotherapy that can be
used to treat cancers. T cells are an important component of our immune system and assist in
targeting and eliminating foreign substances in our bodies, and are used in CAR T cell therapy to
target cancerous cells. Patient’s cells are collected and transformed by introducing a chimeric
antigen receptor (CAR), where the T-cells are reintroduced into the patient’s bloodstream. This
antigen receptor can identify and target a specific structure in the patient’s cells, and then
multiply and attack these cells containing the specific target structure (Mäkelä, 2021).
Conducting further research on CAR T cell therapy and continuing to demonstrate its useful
applications can help significantly advance cancer treatment and how we conduct future
research. Additionally, having scientists and researchers understand the side effects caused by
CAR T cell therapy and modifying the treatment can help increase survival in patients with
blood cancer.
From an analysis of CAR T cell therapy clinical trials, CAR T demonstrates its efficacy
in treating patients with blood cancer in comparison to other methods of traditional cancer
treatments. In analyzing response rates and median overall survival, patients in the CAR T cell
group had overall higher rates compared to patients in the standard of care group. Demonstrating
CAR T cell therapy’s success can help boost its applications in blood cancer treatment as well as
allow for further developments and research to advance CAR T and cancer treatment as a whole.
1
Introduction
With advancements in the science and medical field being made and pushing the
boundaries of how we diagnose and treat diseases, new and innovative methods of treatment are
constantly being explored. Cancer is a complex disease, which can stem from a multitude of
issues such as environmental factors or family history. One relatively new development in the
cancer treatment field focuses on utilizing a patient’s natural immune defenses to fight cancer,
and shifts away from using traditional therapies including chemotherapy and radiation therapy.
Scientists can reengineer a patient’s immune system, and aid them to fight and eliminate cancer.
Immunotherapy is a broad term to describe a method of cancer treatment, involving the use and
boosting of a patient’s own immune system to fight and target cancerous cells. CAR T cell
therapy is a specific subset of immunotherapy involving the extraction of T-cells from a patient’s
bloodstream, where scientists then transform the patient’s T-cells by attaching a synthetic
receptor. This synthetic receptor recognizes and binds to a target antigen on the cancerous cells,
eliminating it. Because of CAR T cell therapy’s promising clinical trial results and its ability to
effectively target cancerous cells, CAR T cell therapy is the most effective prospective method of
treating blood cancers. This paper will examine the mechanisms of CAR T cell therapy, the
effectiveness of CAR T, and why CAR T cell therapy will become the most effective cancer
cancer, how to treat cancer, and how cancer spreads involve many factors which need to be taken
into consideration. Cancer is a general term to describe a condition in which the body’s cells
divide rapidly and grow out of control. Normal cells only grow under certain conditions, and
follow the general cell cycle, involving stages of growth and replication. However, cancerous
2
cells are able to grow and divide rapidly, advancing through the stages of the cell cycle at an
uncontrolled rate (“What is cancer?,” n.d.). These cancerous cells are also able to effectively
“trick” the immune system; where the immune system normally is able to recognize and attack
damaged cells and foreign objects, the cancerous cells are able to evade the immune system’s
natural defenses. To provide a source for oxygen and nutrients for their rapid divisions,
cancerous cells are able to route blood vessels to grow towards the tumor, also allowing for the
removal of waste material (“What is cancer?,” n.d.). Blood cancer is one specific type of cancer,
involving the rapid and uncontrolled growth of blood cells. Blood cells are produced in the bone
marrow, where most blood cancers originate. Fighting off foreign particles and infections is one
of the functions of blood cells which is inhibited by the abnormal growth of cancerous blood
cells. Blood cancers can be divided into three main subgroups: leukemia, lymphoma, and
myeloma. Leukemia originates from the blood and bone marrow and involves the rapid,
abnormal growth of white blood cells, resulting in the interference with the bone marrow’s
ability to create red blood cells and platelets. Lymphoma can then be divided into two categories,
lymphocytes, a type of white blood cell that fights infections (“Blood cancers,” n.d.). Hodgkin
lymphoma also develops from lymphocytes; however, it is different in the sense that the
Reed-Sternberg cell, a type of abnormal lymphocyte, is present in this form of lymphoma and not
in Non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Multiple myeloma involves cancer growth originating in the blood’s
plasma cells, which are a type of white blood cell (“Blood cancers,” n.d.).
In order to fight and treat cancer, the cancer treatment method must effectively target and
eliminate ideally all of the cancerous cells. If one cancerous cell is left behind, the cycle may
repeat itself. Some cancer treatment methods include surgery, radiation, chemotherapy, and
3
immunotherapy; based on certain factors such as the type of cancer a patient has or how far the
cancer has progressed in the patient, a doctor may make different recommendations for a
treatment plan, which can involve the use of several different treatment methods.
Review of Literature
Examining the biological mechanisms behind CAR T cell therapy and immunotherapy as
a whole provides insight into why it is the most effective cancer treatment method.
Immunotherapy involves reengineering the patient's immune system to eliminate cancerous cells,
and enables it to recognize and eliminate foreign objects, and/such as damaged or abnormal cells
(“What is cancer?,” n.d.). However, since cancerous cells are able to evade the immune system’s
natural defenses and essentially “hide,” scientists are able to administer various treatments to
boost or reengineer the immune system to effectively fight and eliminate target cancerous
tumors. Based on the type of cancer a patient has, different immunotherapies may be more or
less effective in targeting the cancer cells. For instance, CAR T cell therapy is most effective in
areas with high perfusion and generally is administered to blood cancer patients. CAR (chimeric
antigen receptor) T cell therapy is a type of immunotherapy utilizing the patient’s T cells to
attack cancerous cells. T cells are a type of white blood cell that assists in fighting foreign
particles in the body and are activated once they find their specific antigen and bind to the target
antigen (Ryding, 2021). “T cells express a receptor with the potential to recognize diverse
antigens from pathogens, tumors, and the environment, and also maintain immunological
memory and self-tolerance” (Kumar et al., 2018). T cells are the key component in CAR T cell
therapy, involving several steps, the first of which is T cell collection. T cells are first collected
from a patient through an IV (Barrel, 2021), where white blood cells are removed, and the rest of
4
the blood is returned to the patient (“CAR T-cell therapy and its side effects,” n.d.). T cells are
then transformed by introducing a CAR to the T cell via retroviral or lentiviral vectors (Fesnak &
O'Doherty, 2017). CARs are synthetic receptors attached to the T cells that assist and redirect
lymphocytes, usually T cells, to recognize and eliminate cells that contain the specific target
antigen. CAR structure consists of four general components, “(1) an extracellular target
antigen-binding domain, (2) a hinge region, (3) a transmembrane domain, and (4) one or more
intracellular signaling domains” (Sterner & Sterner, 2021). The antigen binding domain allows
for the CAR to target specific antigens, crucial to recognizing and eliminating cancerous cells,
minimizing the damage done to normal and healthy cells. Affinity is an important aspect of the
antigen domain, as it determines the function of the CAR; a CAR has to be able to recognize
antigens on tumor cells, induce CAR signaling, and activate T cells. Because of this, the binding
affinity has to be high, but not too high. The hinge region is a region of the CAR that allows
flexibility and allows the antigen binding domain to target the target antigens. The
transmembrane domain anchors the CAR to the membrane of the T cell, however, research may
indicate that this region can also assist in the function of the CAR T cell (Sterner & Sterner,
2021). After the CAR is attached to the T cell, the cells are allowed to multiply until the desired
concentration is reached, and they are then reintroduced into the patient’s bloodstream. This
antigen receptor can identify and target a specific structure in the patient’s cells, and attack these
cells containing the specific target structure (Mäkelä, 2021). The mechanisms behind CAR T cell
therapy suggest why CAR T therapy is effective in theory, and real-world data can further
is a relatively new method of treatment in the clinical treatment field, however, shows great
5
promise with further clinical trials. Examining the processes and procedures behind CAR-T's
success provides insight into the effectiveness CAR T cell therapy demonstrates. From Michael
Bishop of the University of Chicago School of Medicine “The CAR T-cell therapy success rate is
about 30% to 40% for lasting remission, with no additional treatment…” (Bartosch, 2019). Using
methods of immunotherapy such as CAR T cell therapy effectively boosts the immune system
while providing targeted treatment of cancer. During the CAR T cell manufacturing process, a
CAR is added to T cells, allowing for a targeted attack on cancer cells containing the specific
target antigen. T cells contain receptors for foreign substances that “match” with a specific
antigen on the foreign cell’s surface, and these fit together in a “lock and key” manner, however,
if T cells do not contain the receptor expressed on the cancer cells’ surface, T cells will not
recognize and eliminate the tumor. Adding a synthetic receptor to match and target antigens
expressed on the cancer cells allows for a more accurate and targeted approach to eliminating
tumors. For instance, in certain leukemias and lymphomas, the cancer cells express an antigen
called CD19. T cells with a receptor to target CD19 will be able to bind to cells expressing this
antigen; however, these T cells would remain ineffective in eliminating cancer cells without the
CD19 antigen (“CAR T-cell therapy and its side effects,” n.d.). This approach to targeting cells
expressing a certain antigen decreases the overall side effects seen in patients in comparison to
other traditional cancer treatment methods such as radiation or chemotherapy. Radiation to treat
cancer can be effective, but may prove difficult in treating cancer if the cancer has metastasized.
Radiation can be given in three ways, external radiation, internal radiation, and systemic
radiation, but generally works to treat cancer by damaging the DNA inside cells which causes
cell deaths and prevents them from growing and potentially spreading (“How radiation therapy is
used to treat cancer,” n.d.). Chemotherapy is another method of treating cancer, but has harmful
6
side effects. Cancer cells grow and divide rapidly and out of control, and chemotherapy drugs
work by attacking any fast-growing cells. However, chemotherapy presents issues since our
bodies naturally contain healthy cells that divide fast, including cells in our heart, kidneys, and
intestine. Attacking and killing these healthy cells can result in side effects such as fatigue, hair
loss, nausea, and infection. Healthy cells that are most likely to be damaged by chemotherapy
include blood-forming cells in the bone marrow, hair follicles, and cells in the mouth and
digestive system (“Chemotherapy side effects,” n.d.). By administering CAR T cell therapy,
these harsh side effects are able to be avoided and can effectively target cancer cells that may
Administering CAR T cell therapy over other traditional methods of treatment renders
successful results while also mitigating some of the harmful side effects from other traditional
treatments described earlier. CAR T cell infusions are administered through an IV and travel
directly into the bloodstream, where blood cancers would already be present. The CAR T cells
are injected directly to where the site of the tumors would be, allowing for the T cells to quickly
recognize and attack target cancer cells. Since CAR T is most effective in places with high
Currently, no cancer treatment boasts a 100% success rate with no side effects, however,
with more research and clinical trials underway, scientists can hope to improve the success rates
of various immunotherapies, specifically CAR T cell therapy in patients with blood cancer, and
mitigate the side effects of CAR T. The biological mechanisms behind CAR T provide insight
into its efficacy, with a targeted attacking approach to eliminate cancerous cells containing a
specific target antigen. The effectiveness of CAR T in blood cancers can also be attributed to
CAR-T's success in high perfusion areas, and its proximity to the site of cancerous cells.
7
Comparing CAR T cell therapy to other traditional methods of treatment, therapies such as
radiation and chemotherapy come with severe drawbacks and harmful side effects. With new
research, CAR T cell therapy will become the most effective prospective method of treating
blood cancers.
In cancer treatment, having a method of treatment that not only is effective in targeting
and eliminating cancer but also with minimal side effects is crucial, and CAR T cell therapy can
provide both. Based on the methodology and mechanisms behind CAR T cell therapy, it becomes
evident why it is effective in treating blood cancer; by being able to effectively target and
eliminate cancerous cells with fewer side effects than traditional therapies, CAR T proves its use
For this research, meta-analysis was used to answer the research question, will CAR T
cell therapy become the most effective method of treating blood cancers? After completing
background research, data collection, and data analysis, the concluded hypothesis is CAR T cell
therapy is more effective than standard of care treatments in treating blood cancers and through
overcoming associated limitations, will become the most effective method of treating blood
cancers. To test this hypothesis, evaluation research was used. Evaluation research was the best
design model for this research because the end goal is to evaluate and demonstrate how CAR T
cell therapy is not only useful for cancer treatment, but the most effective method of treating
blood cancers. This type of research is a mixed-method research, as it can include qualitative and
quantitative data. In this research study, the independent variable evaluates patients treated with
8
CAR T vs. other methods of treatment, and the dependent variable is the outcome with each
method of treatment.
For this meta-analysis, three documents were annotated and analyzed to compile a chart
hypothesis. Data were collected by analyzing and researching various journals and locating key
details. These pieces of information were then added to a table under their respective row,
depending on how each piece is relevant to CAR T cell therapy, and how it supports the
hypothesis that CAR T cell therapy is more effective than standard of care treatments in treating
blood cancers and through overcoming associated limitations, will become the most effective
Primarily, the journals used to collect data were clinical trials comparing two different
groups of patients with blood cancer, a group of patients administered CAR T cell therapy, and a
Second-Line Therapy for Large B-Cell Lymphoma,” by Locke et al.,) evaluated the effectiveness
of CAR T therapy through a phase 3 clinical trial where 180 patients received axi-cel (CAR T
cell therapy) while 179 patients received standard care, while source 2 (“Outcomes in patients
with DLBCL treated with commercial CAR T cells compared with alternate therapies,” by
Sermer et al.,) also evaluated the effectiveness of CAR T cell therapy in comparison with
alternate therapies. Results were also collected through a phase 3 clinical trial where 184 patients
and Young Adults With B-ALL,” by Shah et al.,) was a study involving a long-term follow-up of
CD-19 CAR T cell therapy in children and young adults with B-cell acute lymphoblastic
leukemia.
9
Results and Data Analysis
treating blood cancer in addition to its effectiveness over standard of care treatments. Extracted
information from source 1 focuses on the effectiveness of CAR T therapy through a phase 3
clinical trial where 180 patients received axi-cel (CAR T cell therapy) while 179 patients
received standard care. This article found that at 2 years, the OS (overall survival) in the axi-cel
group was higher than the OS in the standard care group, at 61% and 52% respectively. At the
median follow-up of 24.9 months, the median event-free survival was 8.3 months in the axi-cel
group and 2.0 months in the standard-care group. “A response occurred in 83% of the patients in
the axi-cel group and in 50% of those in the standard-care group (with a complete response in
65% and 32%, respectively)” (Locke et al., 2022). Additionally, during this trial, “no deaths
related to cytokine release syndrome or neurologic events occurred” (Locke et al., 2022). The
comparison between CAR T cell therapy and traditional therapies highlights CAR T cell
therapy’s effectiveness and proves why CAR T cell therapy is not only effective in treating blood
cancer, but also demonstrates its superior ability in targeting cancer over standard care
treatments.
In corroborating source 1’s findings, source 2 also evaluated and demonstrated CAR T
cell therapy’s effectiveness over standard of care treatments. This trial found that patients treated
with CAR T cell vs alternate therapies demonstrated a complete response (CR) rate of 52% vs
22% (P < .001), and the median progression-free survival (PFS) of 5.2 vs 2.3 months (P = .01)
The median overall survival (OS) of 19.3 vs 6.5 months (Sermer et al., 2020). Articles 1 and 2
both share results from clinical trials providing similar results; in both clinical trials, it was found
10
that patients who received CAR T cell therapy had higher OS, CR, and median event-free
survival rates in comparison to patients in the SOC (standard of care) group. These results
support the assertion that CAR T cell therapy is i) effective in treating blood cancer, and ii) more
Source 3 examines the long term effects of CAR T cell therapy in children and young
adults and found that thirty-one (62.0%) patients achieved a complete remission (CR), “28
(90.3%) of whom were minimal residual disease−negative by flow cytometry,” (Shah et al.,
2021) and at a median follow-up of 4.8 years, the median overall survival was 10.5 months (95%
CI, 6.3 to 29.2 months), (Shah et al., 2021), highlighting CAR T cell therapy’s high response
rates.
CAR T cell therapy proves useful in treating patients with blood cancer and demonstrates
its effectiveness through real-world data in clinical trials. With new research in CAR T cell
therapy and cancer treatment overall, researchers hope to advance science as a whole and
discover new and innovative cancer treatment methods that have greater success in treating and
curing patients. However, there are certain limitations associated with this research and data
analysis, along with CAR T cell therapy’s applications in the real world. This meta-analysis only
analyzed three documents, which is a limited sample size. To build a stronger argument for CAR
T cell therapy, many more documents and clinical trials need to be conducted and analyzed
before scientists shift to CAR T cell therapy as a first-line of blood cancer treatment.
Additionally, CAR T cell therapy is still relatively new; the long-term effects of CAR T cell
therapy may not be evident quite yet. With more time and new research, more evidence may be
11
collected to prove CAR T cell therapy’s superior ability to treat and eliminate cancer, and
12
References
Barrell, A. (2021, March). Everything to know about CAR T cell therapy (A. Cattamanchi, Ed.).
Bartosch, J. (2019, October 17). Three years after CAR T-cell therapy for lymphoma, patient still
https://www.uchicagomedicine.org/forefront/cancer-articles/a-walking-miracle-car-t-cell-
therapy
https://www.cancercenter.com/blood-cancers
CAR T-cell therapy and its side effects. (n.d.). American Cancer Society.
https://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects/treatment-types/immunothe
rapy/car-t-cell1.html
https://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects/treatment-types/chemothera
py/chemotherapy-side-effects.html
Fesnak, A., & O'Doherty, U. (2017). Clinical development and manufacture of chimeric antigen
receptor T cells and the role of leukapheresis. European Oncology & Haematology,
https://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects/treatment-types/immunothe
rapy/what-is-immunotherapy.html
How radiation therapy is used to treat cancer. (n.d.). American Cancer Society.
13
https://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects/treatment-types/radiation/ba
sics.html
Kumar, B. V., Connors, T. J., & Farber, D. L. (2018). Human T cell development, localization,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.immuni.2018.01.007
Locke, F. L., Miklos, D. B., Jacobson, C. A., Perales, M.-A., Kersten, M.-J., Oluwole, O. O.,
Ghobadi, A., Rapoport, A. P., Mcguirk, J., Pagel, J. M., Muñoz, J., Farooq, U., Van
meerten, T., Reagan, P. M., Sureda, A., Flinn, I. W., Vandenberghe, P., Song, K. W.,
https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2116133
https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/726823
https://www.news-medical.net/health/What-are-T-Cells.aspx
Sermer, D., Batlevi, C., Palomba, M. L., Shah, G., Lin, R. J., Perales, M.-A., Scordo, M., Dahi,
P., Pennisi, M., Afuye, A., Silverberg, M. L., Ho, C., Flynn, J., Devlin, S., Caron, P.,
Hamilton, A., Hamlin, P., Horwitz, S., Joffe, E., . . . Zelenetz, A. (2020). Outcomes in
patients with DLBCL treated with commercial CAR T cells compared with alternate
https://doi.org/10.1182/bloodadvances.2020002118
Shah, N. N., Lee, D. W., Yates, B., Yuan, C. M., Shalabi, H., Martin, S., Wolters, P. L., Steinberg,
14
S. M., Baker, E. H., Delbrook, C. P., Stetler-stevenson, M., Fry, T. J., Stroncek, D. F., &
https://doi.org/10.1200/JCO.20.02262
Sterner, R. C., & Sterner, R. M. (2021). CAR-T cell therapy: Current limitations and potential
https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/understanding/what-is-cancer
15
Appendix A
Methods (how was A clinical trial (phase Results were Phase I trial of
the study conducted; 3) was conducted collected from a autologous
who were the where clinical trial (phase 3) CD19.28ζ-CAR T
participants/subjects, 180 patients received where 184 patients cells in CAYAs with
etc.) axi-cel (CAR T cell were randomized relapsed or refractory
therapy) while 179 B-ALL
patients received
standard care
16
What aspect of my The comparison The comparison Analyzing the
research does this between CAR T cell between CAR T cell effectivity of CAR T
help me answer? therapy and therapy and cell therapy in blood
traditional therapies, traditional therapies cancer, but also the
this source helps and proving why long term effects
prove why CAR T is CAR T is the most
the most effective for effective for blood
blood cancer cancers
Are there trends Yes, another clinical Article 1, another In this study, the
across different study (article #2) also clinical trial, also median overall
sources? demonstrated the backs the efficacy of survival (OS) was
benefit of CAR T CAR T in 10.5 months, whereas
over standard administration to in the study in article
therapies patients with blood 2, the median OS was
cancer 19.3 months
Conclusions/limitatio Patients treated with Patients treated with CAR T cell therapy
ns CAR T cell therapy CAR T cell therapy can prove to have
have a better have an increased CR long-lasting results in
prognosis than rate, an increased complete remission
patients receiving median PFS, and an and median overall
standard care or increased median OS. survival.
traditional therapies
17