Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 Playing Pieces
The wooden blocks are the game’s playing pieces. Color iden-
tifies army. Each piece has a face marked with symbols. The Approaches can be narrow or wide.
number of symbols is the piece’s strength. The kind of sym-
bol is the piece’s type: infantry, cavalry, or artillery. See the
examples below:
To fully block an approach, at least two blocking pieces are re-
quired if the approach is wide; just one if it is narrow. A wide
approach blocked by a single piece is said to be partly blocked.
Locale symbols are explained below:
Infantry and cavalry penalties. Assaults across them led
Generally, players can see the faces of their own pieces but con- by the matching piece type are penalized when they are
ceal them from their opponent. In certain situations the rules in the approach occupied by the defender.
require a player to reveal the face of a piece, then conceal it
Artillery penalty. Artillery cannot bombard or conduct
again.
assault defensive artillery fire across it where it is in the
During play, pieces can be reduced in strength as a result of at- approach opposite the artillery.
tacks and retreats. A piece is reduced by removing it and re-
Impassable. Pieces can neither occupy nor cross it.
placing it with another piece of the same type and one-point
lower strength. (For example, a 3-strength infantry is reduced Cavalry-obstructing. When in the defending side’s ap-
by replacing it with a 2-strength infantry.) A piece reduced to 0- proach, cavalry is severely restricted in its ability to at-
strength is removed without replacement. The faces of reduced tack and defend.
pieces and their replacements are briefly revealed during sub- Locale capacity. Pieces may not enter a locale (even to
stitution. pass through it) if doing so would cause the number of
At full strength, an infantry piece represents about 2000 sol- friendly pieces in the locale to exceed its capacity.
diers, a cavalry piece represents about 1200 troopers, and an Main roads (top) and local roads (bottom). Pieces can
artillery piece represents about 40 guns and their crews. move up to three locales a turn by road, and, if the road
is a main road, they can do so at no command cost.
The game’s morale tokens do not represent military forces and
are not considered pieces. They exist solely to track morale (see French set-up. The symbol count is the piece count.
section 18) and have no other effect on play.
Objective line. Used in marginal victory conditions.
3 The Game Map Approach direction. An arrow pointing west to east. The
Austrians can retreat east and the French west only if
The game map is overlaid with polygons. The polygons are lo- there are no other choices.
cales. Locales regulate pieces’ location and movement. All the remaining map artwork (towns, swamps, elevation con-
Within a locale are multiple positions: The locale interior is the tours, etc.) is purely decorative and has no effect on play.
reserve position. Each locale side is an approach position.
3
(2) Put 3 French morale tokens in the uncommitted morale area Once a piece has participated in an action that turn (whether
(Z ONE DE M ORAL NON E NGAG É ) as shown. or not that action has a command cost), it is done for the turn
and cannot participate in a second action that turn (whether or
(3) Put pieces face-up in the three set-up areas along the edges not the second action has a command cost). There is one excep-
of the board (Alessandria, A U D ÉBUT , and R ENFORTS), match- tion to this restriction: the organize action. A piece that partic-
ing the armies, strengths and types. Many pieces will be left ipates in an organize action can participate in a second action
over. Left-over pieces are used as reduction replacements. that turn.
(4) Randomly shuffle the pieces from the French at-start (A U No more than three (3) pieces can ever participate in a single ac-
D ÉBUT ) set-up area face-down. (The top of the game box can be tion. Even lower limits apply to road marches (one piece) and
used for this) The French player blindly draws them and places organize actions (one or two pieces as per section 15).
them in French set-up locales, matching the number of symbols
in each locale. Pieces are placed in reserve. The French player
may look at the faces only after they are been assigned their set- 7 Off-Road Marches
up positions. A piece performing an off-road march action can move within
(5) Randomly shuffle as above, but this time use the pieces from its locale or to an adjacent locale. An off-road march cannot be
the French reinforcement (R ENFORTS) set-up area to fill the made into an enemy-occupied locale.
three French holding areas for 5:00PM, 11:00AM, and 4:00PM To make an off-road march together as a single action, all the
(5 h, 11 h, and 4 h respectively). The French player may look at pieces must move from the same locale and position, to the same
the faces only after they are been assigned their holding areas. locale and position.
(6) The Austrian player hides the faces of his pieces in the Aus- From reserve, a piece can off-road march as follows:
trian set-up area (except the artillery) and shuffles them as per
section 17. • It may march into the reserve position in an adjacent lo-
cale.
• It may march to block an approach of the locale it occu-
pies. The locale opposite the approach must be enemy-
occupied. The march can qualify as a defensive march and
made at no command cost if it does not result in more friendly
pieces in the approach than the minimum needed to fully block
it.
5 Sequence of Play
Rounds. The game is played as a series of 16 rounds. Each From an approach, a piece can off-road march as follows:
represents one hour of historical time. In a round, each player
• It may march into reserve in its own locale.
takes a turn: first the Austrian player, then the French player.
The time marker is then advanced one hour. The game ends • It may march into reserve in the adjacent (opposite) lo-
after the 9:00PM round. cale.
Turns. In a player’s turn, they first perform any scheduled morale
updates (see section 18), then approach clean-up (see section 16),
then actions (see section 6), and finally morale clean-up (see sec-
tion 18).
6 Actions
In a player’s turn, actions are used to march and attack. March 8 Road Marches
actions have two types: off-road march (see section 7) and road
march (see section 8). Attack actions have three types: maneuver A piece performing a road march action can move up to three
attack (see section 9), bombardment (see section 10), and assault locales in a single turn, entering one after another. The start
(see section 11). One additional special action type of is organize locale, the approaches and locales crossed, and the end locale
(see section 14). must be connected by continuous, unbroken road. (A piece
starting or arriving at an intersection can leave it along any of
A player gets a total of three (3) commands per turn. Most ac-
the intersecting roads. An intersection does not break a road.)
tions require that a command be expended to perform the ac-
tion. Exceptions are off-road marches that qualify as defensive To road march, a piece must start its turn in reserve.
marches (see section 7), road marches on main roads, and all
4
A single road march action can move exactly one piece at the 9 Maneuver Attacks
cost of one command. If, however, a piece marches entirely on main
roads, from start to end, the piece can make the march at no command A maneuver attack is a type of attack. It is an attempt to take
cost. an adjacent enemy-occupied locale by crossing an approach in
that locale that is either unblocked or only partly blocked by en-
Historically, road marches were greatly complicated and emy pieces. (A maneuver attack cannot be made if the enemy
slowed by traffic congestion. To simulate this, traffic limits are approach is fully blocked.)
imposed at crossings, and road marches are carried out in steps.
A maneuver attack can be performed as an action in and of it-
• A crossing is where a road passes from one locale to an self, or it can be performed during a cavalry road march, as part
adjacent locale. (If there are multiple roads passing be- of the road march action.
tween a pair of adjacent locales, each road has its own
crossing.) A maneuver attack can be made from reserve or from an ap-
proach. If from an approach, the attack must be into the locale
• A piece marching by road counts off its march in up to
opposite that approach.
three steps. In each step, a piece can either move through
a crossing (into reserve in the next locale), or it can wait A maneuver attack must include infantry if the defense approach
for traffic at that crossing (remain in reserve in the current is marked as cavalry-obstructing. The attacker must reveal the
locale; see below). face of one of his attacking pieces at the end of the attack to
• Each crossing has a traffic limit. Only three pieces can prove it is infantry. (Cavalry-obstructing terrain in the attack
march through a crossing in the same turn, and each must approach is ignored.)
do so at a higher step count in its respective march than The maneuver attack procedure, with examples, is as follows:
those that preceded it. This can force a piece to count off
steps waiting at a crossing, in order to cross at a higher 1. Attack declaration. The attacker names the attacking pieces
step count. for the attack, and indicates the attack direction. (He cannot
name more than three pieces, since the three-piece limit for ac-
The following example shows how pieces can be forced to use tions applies.) All the attacking pieces must occupy the same
steps waiting in order to comply with traffic limits at crossings: position and must all attack in the same direction. The attack
direction specifies the locale being attacked (the defense locale)
and the approach in that locale the attack will cross (the defense
approach). For a road march maneuver attack, the direction also
specifies the road crossing for the attack; a road crossing can
only be used for one road maneuver attack a turn.
The attack declaration implicitly defines the attack approach (the
approach opposite the defense approach) and the attack locale
(the locale containing the attack approach.) Because they are
First, the cavalry marches: on step 1 it moves through crossing A, on implicit, they do not have to be directly stated.
step 2 crossing B, and on step 3 crossing C.
Second, the artillery marches: on step 1 it waits for traffic, on step 2 it
moves through crossing A, and on step 3 crossing B.
Third, the 2-infantry marches: on step 1 and 2 it waits for traffic, and on
step 3 it moves through crossing A.
Last, the 3-infantry does not road march. It would have to use all three
of its steps waiting for traffic, with none left to move.
12 Cavalry Continuation
Cavalry has the ability of continuation. At the end of a maneu-
ver attack, assault, road march, or off-road march that ends in
reserve in a locale, cavalry can use continuation to advance to
block an approach in that locale. The locale opposite that ap-
proach must be enemy-occupied.
Continuation (as the name suggests) continues an action; it is For each position, the defender chooses the pieces in that po-
not itself an action. Continuation does not expend a command, sition to take the reductions. If there are not enough pieces of
unless it is used to split up pieces (which is permitted) in a the specified types to take take all the reductions, the excess is
multi-piece action between multiple destination positions. In ignored.(Ignored reductions do not affect morale.)
that case, each additional destination expends an additional
command.
8
2. Retreat pieces. All pieces in the locale are retreated into the mediately subject to disorganization restrictions. (A road march
reserve areas of adjacent locales: would end in that locale.)
• The defender chooses which pieces will go where. French reinforcements enter the game already organized with-
• Pieces cannot retreat into a locale from which the attack out the need for expending organize actions on them.
came, nor into an enemy-occupied locale, nor in excess of
locale capacity. 15 Reinforcements
• Of the three types of approach directions (east, west, and
unmarked), the French cannot retreat west nor the Aus- Pieces placed in holding areas during set-up are eligible to en-
trians east unless no other legal alternatives are available. ter the map as reinforcements at the times and entry roads indi-
(The French do not have to prefer east to unmarked, and cated for them on the map. (The Austrian set-up area is also a
the Austrians do not have to prefer west to unmarked.) holding area.)
• Any pieces that have no locale where they can retreat are A piece entering the map as a reinforcement must use road
eliminated. If locale capacity is enough for some retreat- march. Where the road enters the map is considered to be the
ing pieces, but not all, the retreating player chooses which first crossing of the march and traffic limits apply to it. If more
to retreat and which to eliminate. pieces are available to enter than traffic limits allow, the excess
must wait until another turn.
After all pieces are retreated, their faces are again hidden. (The
attacking player does see which pieces retreat into which lo- Eligible reinforcement pieces are never required to enter. (They
cale.) can be voluntarily held off-map.) They can enter in any order
the moving player chooses.
While there are reinforcements in a holding area yet to enter the
map, no enemy piece may enter (or attempt to enter, by assault
or maneuver attack) the locale which these reinforcements have
to enter first.
In the historical battle, the Austrians threw a pontoon bridge
across the Bormida River. To reflect this, in addition to be-
ing able to have three Austrian reinforcement pieces enter per
turn by the main road, one additional piece per turn can enter
by crossing the pontoon bridge. A piece entering by pontoon
bridge must end its move in the entry locale. (There is no road
from the pontoon bridge out of the locale.) Pontoon bridge en-
try does not require the expenditure of a command.
The Austrian artillery cannot enter before the 7:00AM round.
14 French Disorganization Prior that round it stays face-up in the Austrian holding area.
In the historical battle, the Austrian attack surprised the French.
To reflect this, the following rules are in effect: 16 Approach Clean-up
On the 6:00 AM round (only), French pieces cannot block ap- A player performs approach clean-up for his pieces at the start
proaches by any means. of his turn. (Only at the start of his own turn and only for his
own pieces.)
Also, all French pieces on the map at start are disorganized and
subject to restrictions. They are converted to organized (the nor- During approach clean-up, if a piece is blocking an approach,
mal state for pieces) by organize actions. and the locale opposite that approach is not enemy-occupied,
then the approach is cleaned up by moving the piece back into
A disorganized piece cannot attack. It can march between po-
reserve in its own locale. Where clean-up is not mandatory it
sitions within its locale, and can block maneuver attacks, but it
is forbidden. Approach clean-up is not an action and does not
cannot march out of its locale. A disorganized piece can leave
expend a command. (A piece that is cleaned-up can perform an
its locale by retreat, but this does not end disorganization re-
action afterwards in that same turn.)
strictions; it just changes the locale to which they apply.
If there are fewer than three organized French pieces on the map 17 Shuffling Pieces
at the time of an organize action (not counting eliminated pieces
or pieces the action is about to organize), the action organizes a To conceal the identity of reinforcement pieces or pieces whose
single piece. If there are three or more organized French pieces faces have been revealed and then hidden again, a player can
on the map, it can organize two pieces. The French player pick up his own pieces in the same position, or in the same
chooses the pieces to be organized by an organize action. If holding area, secretly shuffle them together, and then put them
two pieces, they do not have to be in the same locale. back.
In a single turn, it is not permitted to organize just some of the Shuffling can be done at any time (even in an opponent’s turn),
pieces in a locale. Either enough actions must be used to orga- but pieces that are eligible to perform an action later that turn
nize all the pieces in a locale, or none of them can be organized. cannot be shuffled together with pieces that are not eligible to
perform an action later that turn.
A piece can be organized by an organize action and perform an-
other action in the same turn. Any command cost of that other
action is in addition to the command cost of the organize action.
If a retreat or march puts organized and disorganized pieces in
the same locale, all become immediately disorganized and im-
9
into the locale. B. Chicken Marengo. A French dish consisting of a chicken sautéed in oil with
garlic and tomato, garnished with fried eggs and crayfish. According to a pop-
• Morale tokens committed to a locale can accumulate there ular myth, the dish was first made after Bonaparte’s victory at the Battle of
Marengo, created by his chef Dunant using by what the foraging soldiers found.
as the result of multiple actions and over multiple turns.
Losing morale. Through actions, morale can be lost as follows:
• For each reduction an army suffers from an artillery bom- 20 Terrain
bardment, from a retreat, or as the loser in an assault, it
For ease of reference, terrain rules distributed throughout the
loses one morale. (The winner in an assault does not suffer
other rules sections are repeated here, organized by terrain
morale losses for reductions. Loser assault morale losses
type.
for artillery defense and counter-attack reductions are de-
ferred until the assault result is determined.) Infantry and Cavalry Penalties: In an assault, for each such
• Morale losses for reductions are first taken from uncom- penalty in the defense approach matching the type of the attack
mitted morale. If there are not enough uncommitted leading pieces, one is subtracted from the attack strength dur-
tokens, the opposing player makes up the difference by ing result calculation.
choosing from the losing army’s tokens committed to lo- Artillery Penalties: In bombardment, if there is an artillery
cales. penalty in the defense approach, the attack cannot be made. In
Morale clean-up. At the end of each army’s turn, the army per- an assault, if there is an artillery penalty in the attack approach,
forms morale clean-up for its own morale. The clean-up proce- an artillery defense cannot be made.
dure for the army’s morale is as follows: Impassable Approaches: Pieces can never occupy, march, at-
1. For each locale where the army has committed morale to- tack, or retreat across approaches marked impassable, even if it
kens and the locale is enemy-occupied, or where the lo- would cause retreating pieces to be eliminated.
cale is unoccupied and the last piece to enter the locale
Cavalry-obstructing Approaches: A maneuver attack without
was enemy, the tokens in that locale are lost. (Steps 2 and
infantry cannot be made if the defense approach is cavalry-
3 only apply to tokens that were not lost in this step.)
obstructing. In an assault, if the defense approach is cavalry-
2. For each locale where the army has committed morale to- obstructing: cavalry cannot lead the attack, lead the defense, or
kens and where none of the adjacent locales are enemy- counter-attack.
10
Wide and Narrow Approaches: It takes at least one piece to The game map has been redone. There are many subtle changes
fully block a narrow approach; two for a wide approach. A to the layout of the locales.
wide approach blocked by one piece is partly blocked. A ma-
Randomization now applies to French reinforcements as well
neuver attack succeeds against an unblocked approach, fails
as those French pieces that start the game on the map.
against a fully blocked approach, and may or may not succeed
against a partly blocked approach. (See section 9 for details.) French activation has been replaced by French organization,
An assault across a narrow approach is limited to one attack which works differently in almost every detail.
leading, defense leading, and counter-attacking piece. An as- Marches, bombardments and assaults, and organize (the latter
sault across a wide approach can have up to two attack leading, replacing activate) are all classed as "actions" and can be per-
defense leading, and counter-attacking pieces. formed in any order. A maximum of three pieces can partici-
Locale Capacity: Pieces may not enter (even to pass through it) pate in an action.
a locale by march, maneuver attack, assault, or by retreat if do- A march to block an approach can now be at no command cost
ing so would cause the number of friendly pieces in the locale if it qualifies as a defensive march.
to exceed its capacity.
A maneuver attack across a wide approach occupied by a sin-
Main and Local Roads: Used for road marches. Marches en- gle enemy piece is now permitted; it takes two pieces to block
tirely on main roads do not expend commands. Cavalry can a wide approach against multiple attacking pieces. The num-
perform maneuver attacks during road marches. Cavalry con- ber of defending pieces that can advance from reserve to block
tinuation at the end of a road march must be on the road. Rein- a maneuver attack now cannot exceed the number of attacking
forcements enter by road march. pieces.
Artillery can no longer march and declare a bombardment in
21 Piece Types the same turn.
For ease of reference, piece type rules distributed throughout The steps in the assault procedure have been reorganized. The
the other rules sections are repeated here, organized by piece defender must now name the defense leading pieces before the
type. attacker names which of his pieces will be making the assault
Infantry: A maneuver attack across a cavalry-obstructing de- and identifies his leading pieces. Artillery defense cannot be
fense approach has to include infantry. In an assault: (1) one made if there is an artillery penalty in the attack approach.
is subtracted from the strength of an infantry-led attack for Cavalry pursuit has been removed. Counter-attack has been
each infantry penalty in the defense approach, and (2) infantry added. Reduction calculation is now based on a combination of
counter-attacks do not increase attacker reductions. For retreat enemy leading pieces, counter-attacking pieces, and the result.
reductions: (1) from reserve, two infantry reductions are as- A losing attacker no longer withdraws into reserve on losing
sessed if the attack approach was wide and the attack advance an assault. After a successful assault, the attacker is no longer
is by multiple attacking pieces, or one reduction otherwise, and barred from entering the defense locale with other pieces later
(2) from each approach, one reduction of infantry or cavalry is that same turn, but is barred from entering by road march.
applied if the approach is narrow, or two if wide. The rule preventing cavalry continuation being used to make
Cavalry: During road marches, cavalry can carry out maneu- an approach-reserve-approach move within a single locale has
ver attacks. Without infantry, cavalry cannot make a maneuver been dropped.
attack across a cavalry-obstructing defense approach. In an as- In a retreat, two infantry reductions from reserve instead of one
sault: (1) one is subtracted from the strength of a cavalry-led are suffered if the attack advance is by multiple pieces across
attack for each cavalry penalty in the defense approach, (2) cav- a wide approach, and two reductions instead of one are suf-
alry counter-attacks increase attacker reductions, and (3) if the fered from wide approaches. The retreat reduction exemption
defense approach is cavalry-obstructing, cavalry pieces cannot for pieces in the defense approach in an assault has been re-
lead an attack or defense, and cannot counter-attack. Continua- moved. Retreating now takes into account east-west directions
tion moves can be made only by cavalry. For retreat reductions: as printed on the map.
(1) cavalry in reserve does not take reductions, and (2) from
each approach one infantry or cavalry reduction is applied if Pontoon bridge entry no longer requires a command. Austrian
the approach is narrow, or two if wide, artillery cannot enter before the 7:00AM round.
Artillery: Without infantry, artillery cannot make a maneuver Approach clean-up is now distinct from march movement and
attack across a cavalry-obstructing defense approach. Bombard- occurs at the start of the turn.
ment actions can be made only by artillery. In an assault, qual- The rules for shuffling pieces are more liberal.
ifying artillery can carry out artillery defense (see section 11,
step 4 for details). If forced to retreat, artillery is eliminated. Morale now uses morale tokens, which can be in the uncommit-
Austrian artillery cannot enter before the 7:00AM round. ted morale area or on the map as morale committed to specific
locales, and which can be transferred back and forth between
them. Morale can be gained over time. The winner in an as-
22 Differences from Bonaparte at Marengo sault no longer takes morale losses. Demoralization ends the
This section is to highlight differences between TRIOMPHE À game immediately.
M ARENGO and Bonaparte at Marengo for players familiar Marginal victory is now awarded based on Austrian pieces east
with the older game. This summary is not a substitute for a of the objective line at the end of the game.
thorough reading of the rules.
The rules organization has changed. There are terminology
changes: piece for unit, reduction for step loss, position for place,
holding area for display area, main and local road for primary and
secondary road, march for movement.
11
23 Game Play Example attack into locale 5. This is an economical French solution in
that it solves two problems with a single move. Another French
This section is to give some insight in the mechanics of T RI - defensive response might be to accept that the pieces in locale
OMPHE À M ARENGO by looking at a possible first turn move
5 will get attacked and forced to retreat, and instead block the
by Austria (red) and some possible responses by France (blue). northern road with the pieces from either locale 8 or 24 (C1 and
The discussion is neither complete, nor are the moves shown C2, respectively). Each move would cost two commands. Note
optimum. The types of the pieces are hidden. For ease of ref- that this is true even for the move of the locale 24 piece, since it
erence, all pieces are face-down, the locales are given numbers, is moving on a local road; by doing that, however, the piece can
and the discussion is from the Austrian point of view. defend the bottleneck between locales 4 and 7. Alternatively,
the piece could move on the main road without command cost,
but only to locale 13 (C3). This is not the perfect blocking po-
sition, but would leave the French two commands to be used
somewhere else (instead of only 1).
After having completed our move, we realize another attrac-
tive opening: we could have moved our first piece to locale 4,
instead of locale 3. If it were not for French disorganization,
we shouldn’t do this, as the French pieces in locales 5 and 8
could deliver a 1-2 punch maneuver attack sequence and force
our piece in locale 4 to retreat. However, due to the fact that
they would need to spend commands organizing pieces before
they could move them, they don’t have enough commands to
do that.
Looking ahead, regardless of the French response, we need to
think about where we intend to apply pressure in later turns.
One option would be to focus on the French pieces guarding
the northern road and try to drive north. Another option would
be to attack the French center: locale 8 and 9 (Marengo). Still
another would be to work around the French left at locale 10,
and extend the fight in that direction. As we build up strength
In our first turn we can bring a maximum of four pieces onto we will eventually allow us to do all of these at once, if we
the board (three on the main road, one by the pontoon bridge). choose, but in the short term we don’t have enough commands
But how? Should we simply move all four pieces to locale 1? or pieces on the map to do that. Instead, we must prioritize and
Maybe this is too slow? Or, should we split them in two groups, make choices.
two pieces in locale 1 and two pieces in locale 2? Or, should we Other considerations
enter with maximum speed?
The above has only been an introduction. Its focus on the first
We decide for the speed, and so we advance one piece into lo- turn means that the differences between pieces, and how bom-
cale 3, a second into locale 2, and leave two pieces back in locale bardments and assaults work barely get mentioned, and so, a
1. Every piece has advanced its maximum distance. Note that quick discussion here of those subjects is therefore merited. Re-
none of these moves required any commands, as they are either garding the differences between the types of pieces, probably
by main road or by the pontoon bridge. Finally, one particular the most important thing to be aware of is the ability of cav-
audacity is to lead with cavalry, so that we can use continuation alry to make maneuver attacks by road and retreat from reserve
to block the approach from locale 3 into locale 5. Because in without taking reductions. This makes cavalry the dominant
their 6AM turn the French cannot block approaches, they can- arm in mobile situations in open terrain; it is able to both screen
not respond in their turn by blocking the opposite approach. withdrawals and pursue beaten enemies in ways that the other
The result is that we are threatening a maneuver attack at 7AM two arms cannot. Regarding bombardments and assaults, these
into locale 5 that can’t be blocked. (A maneuver attack from an two generally work together. The main thing to understand
approach where there are no defending pieces in the opposite is that taking positions by assault generally takes time. Multi-
approach always succeeds.) This threat will stress the French, ple assaults against the same position over multiple turns will
for sure. typically be required. The attacker ideally will want to have
If we think of possible French attack responses, we can see that artillery to help, as bombardments can help break a position
they could target locale 3. If we block the approach to locale 5 down faster and at lower cost to the attacker than is possible by
there, and if the French have cavalry in locale 10, they can or- assault alone.
ganize the two pieces in locale 10 (they can’t organize just one) While players may pick up the basics pretty quickly, they will
and make a cavalry road maneuver attack into locale 3 (arrow find the game rewards extended thought and study. The armies
A). This would force our piece there to retreat, take a reduction; have few pieces and few commands: every one of them counts.
and we would lose one morale and would have to commit one Games often come down to having a single piece of the right
morale into locale 3. The problem for the French here is that type in the right place at the right time to make the right move.
it requires all three French commands and leaves the northern It is by being far sighted, by anticipating how situations can de-
road wide open, a highly dangerous thing for the French to do velop, and getting their pieces in place so as to be able to seize
on their first turn. moments of opportunity, that players can win in T RIOMPHE À
Now, let’s consider what the French might do defensively. One M ARENGO.
response might be to move both locale 5 pieces together into lo-
cale 4, at a total cost of three commands (B). This would cover
the northern road and avoid retreat losses from a 7AM Austrian
Design Notes
Starting in 2005, I created a series of 19th cen- are simple, so the game system was scaled to T RIOMPHE À M ARENGO is the fourth of the
tury battle games whose design was inspired keep that number small. games built around “The Look” as described
by the appearance of battle maps from that above, and, by me at least, will be the last. It
More than that, the game needed to not waste
period. Their most distinctive aspect was the had its origins as a new edition of the first of
the players’ time. The game needed to enable
way the armies were rendered as strikingly ge- these games, Bonaparte at Marengo, but over
players to translate their decisions into moves
ometrical long straight lines, one army in red its design grew into becoming its own game in
quickly and efficiently. (Consider Chess: once
and the other in blue. This appearance is what its own right. The order of battle is largely the
a player has decided what to do, it only takes
I came to call “The Look”. same, but the map has been heavily reworked
a moment to move a piece: players don’t sort
to both improve it graphically and to improve
I had played many conventional hex-and- stacks of tiny counters, consult tables, do te-
the accuracy of its terrain model.
cardboard wargames over the years, but knew dious distance counting through hex grids, do
that they could never capture The Look – they long division to calculate ratios, roll dice, none There are many small rules differences be-
had plenty of geometry but it was the geome- of that. Chess play is think, move, think, tween this game and its predecessors, but the
try of hexagons, dominated by grid direction, move: that’s the game.) pride of the design is the morale system, but
not at all the geometry of linear warfare. which oddly came very late in the design pro-
But not wasting the players’ time isn’t only
cess. None of the earlier games I did had any-
Ironically, early wargames, the nineteenth cen- about mechanical efficiency: it is about not
thing like it. Its particular strength is the way
tury German Kriegspiel, physically were quite having unimportant decisions that have to
that terrain features can take on morale im-
close to The Look: they used rectangular be made. If a decision isn’t important, it
portance, not because the design gives them
wooden blocks on a gridless map. Really, what shouldn’t be part of the game. Players should
importance, but because the players, through
I was trying to do was not to give wargames always feel like every choice they make mat-
their choices, give them importance: armies
something they had never had, but return to ters.
don’t fight over this or that position because
something they’d had but lost.
Part of the solution was to not only keep the the position is intrinsically important, but be-
Of course, it can be asked why a fuss is being number of pieces small, but to keep the num- cause the very act of fighting for it gives it im-
made about The Look anyway – isn’t what re- ber of areas small as well. With few pieces and portance. I do think that players will find that
ally matters is how fun a game is to play, or few areas, even a move of a single piece by a it gives T RIOMPHE À M ARENGO a character
how accurate it is, and not how it looks? single area mattered. Another aspect fell into of its own, that really sets it apart from its pre-
my lap quite by accident. Early versions fea- decessors – in a good way.
I think, however, that these things are bound
tured movement that was far too fluid, that
together. How much fun a game is, how ac- Bonaparte at Marengo is a good game. I was
felt more like modern armor combat than 19th
curate it is, and how it looks are all grounded proud of it in 2005 and am proud of it now.
century tactical warfare. I needed to slow the
in the game as time machine. And we are vi- But I do feel that really only with this game,
speed down, to bring it into line with what
sual creatures. We respond and understand T RIOMPHE À M ARENGO, was I really able to
could be done by couriers carrying messages
first and foremost according to what we see. achieve all that I was going for with the older
across the battlefield. And that was done by
game. As it is, time and age have caught up
But the strictly gridless representation of the limiting the number of moves per turn. With
with me, and I believe it will be the last game
Kriegspiel had shortcomings of its own: in few moves, every move also mattered. A thing
I ever design. I do feel that it is a good way to
such systems, measurement is used and typ- once done, could not be easily and cheaply un-
go out, and I do hope you will feel the same.
ically there are huge differences between al- done.
most identical distances like 15/16 of an inch
And the above got me to where I wanted: Ev- Rachel Simmons
and 17/16 of an inch, resulting in a fussiness
ery piece mattered. Every area mattered. Ev- aka Bowen Simmons
that is very dislocating to the sense of pe-
ery move mattered. Sunnyvale, November 2021
riod – no Napoleonic commander ever wor-
ried about whether the enemy was 99 yards From a simulation point of view, the main
away or 101 yards away. thing I wanted was to strongly differentiate
the arms, so that cavalry, infantry, and artillery
So some regulatory mechanism for quantizing
felt very different in play. (This was a lesson I
position and distance had to exist: but what
learned from Frank Davis’s game on the battle
kind? My first thought was a point-to-point
of Waterloo, Wellington’s Victory. Differenti-
system, but soon switched to using an area-
ating the arms is everything.)
based system. Area-based systems had been
used for many years, but with far more suc- The baseline arm is infantry. And one of the
cess in strategic than tactical games. most distinctive things about infantry in my
Napoleonic games is the intense violence of in-
The key decision that transformed areas into a
fantry combat. Casualties are inevitable when
tactical model that worked the way I needed it
infantry clashes, and often heavy. Players used
to work was to allow pieces to be positioned
to wargames where “retreat” is a fairly harm-
not just in the centers of areas, but on the bor-
less result can be shocked by how destruc-
ders between the areas. And it was this choice
tive it is in this game. The closed formations
that really locked in the basic physical design
used historically to keep men under command
I would be working with.
could disintegrate when a unit was forced to
Sadly, I had no game rules or mechanisms to retreat, rendering a unit useless for the rest of
go with them. I knew how the game would the battle even if most of the men survived.
look, but how would it play?
By contrast, cavalry is flexible and maneuver-
My main game play objective was fast play. able. Closed situations with little room for ma-
The goal was to make a game playable from neuver tend to be dominated by infantry, but
start to finish in a single afternoon or evening in the open, with the armies on the move, cav-
session, and not to stick players with the sit- alry rules the battlefield, excelling at both pur-
uation of running out of time but still having suing an enemy and screening a withdrawal.
only an incomplete game on their hands.
Artillery is the opposite pole from cavalry: of
The first consequence of the quest for fast play no use at all in a fluid situation, and even
was that the number of pieces would have to slower to get into position than infantry, but
be kept small. It is very hard to have a game brutal once in place, because of its ability to
can be played in a reasonable time if it has a inflict harm without suffering it. It is the ulti-
large number of pieces, even if the mechanics mate positional arm.