Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FLATPICKING GUITAR
by Mark Humphrey
If you had been learning guitar in your grandpa’s time,
you might have bought a method book for ‘plectrum style
guitar.’ The Latin-rooted plectrum (‘to strike’) sounded
high-handed to country guitarists, who preferred to speak
of straight picks or flatpicks (as opposed to the curved
variety worn on the thumb for Carter-style strumming or
Travis-style fingerpicking). Flatpicking came to describe
a genre of guitar playing in the early 1970s, about the
time the four men featured in this video started being
widely noticed. And it is a genre they defined: guitarists
of every ilk from grunge rock to trad jazz play with
flatpicks, but they tend not to be called flatpickers. It is
tribute to the dazzling instrumental skill of Doc Watson,
Tony Rice, Norman Blake and Dan Crary that they not
only defined this relatively recent development in Ameri-
can traditional music; their facility with a simple piece of
plastic (or nylon or tortoise shell) became the adjective
for a school of guitar.
The music played on this video isn’t only about
flatpicking, of course. “Beyond technique are some
deeper essentials of musicianship,” Tony Rice once noted
in a Frets magazine column (Frets, April 1985). “Music
is mainly communication...Doc Watson and Dan Crary
could both play the exact same notes of the same tune,
yet sound totally different.” For demonstration purposes,
check their disparate versions of ‘the flatpickers national
anthem,’ Black Mountain Rag, on this video. Both are
expressions of distinctly individual personalities, as is ev-
ery other note played on this video. Hot licks abound,
but behind them is a focused skill of communication
through music, which, whatever the genre, is the reason
we honor such artists as ‘legends.’
2
Photo by Axel Küstner
3
DOC WATSON
7
TONY RICE
8
he was only five: “I prob-
11
using some of the mandolin technique I’d developed. Like I
used to try to play this rhythm on the mandolin where your
hand actually goes in a figure-eight pattern on the strings...I
got into that and gradually kept bringing it down into single-
string playing on the guitar.”
Norman was too enamored of music to finish high
school. At sixteen he joined the Dixieland Drifters, with whom
he played mandolin and dobro on Knoxville radio station
WNOX’s Tennessee Barndance. The Drifters would earn the
distinction of being the only bluegrass band to record for
Sun Records (their 1957 recordings waited until the 1980s
to be released). Norman’s talents subsequently earned him
stints in Hylo Brown’s traditional bluegrass band, the
Timberliners, as accompanist to countr y singer Walter
Forbes, and as part of June Carter’s road band. Uncle Sam
requested a different performance (U.S. Army radio opera-
tor) in l96l and Norman brought his fiddle and mandolin
skills to the Panama Canal, where his Fort Robbe Moun-
taineers was voted Best Instrumental Group of the Carib-
bean Command!
After his 1963 discharge Norman was back in Nash-
ville, where June Carter had become part of Johnny Cash’s
troupe. Carter’s enthusiastic recommendation got Norman
12
some record dates with Cash (you hear his dobro on “Un-
derstand Your Man”), though he continued to teach guitar
in Sulphur Springs and pick with a local countr y band.
Norman’s low profile heightened considerably in 1968 when
he played on Bob Dylan's influential Nashville Skyline al-
bum. The following year he became par t of the house band
on Cash’s network television show, and his new visibility
brought him session work with Kris Kristofferson, Joan Baez,
and John Hartford (he toured with Hartford's Aeroplane
band). Norman’s role in the Nitty Gritty Dirt Band's Will the
Circle Be Unbroken project and the release of his debut solo
album, Home in Sulphur Springs on the then fledgling
Rounder label, effectively launched his solo career.
In 1972, a young cellist from Independence, Missouri
was performing in a group which opened for Norman at
Nashville’s Exit Inn. “That was the first time I’d ever heard
him,” Nancy Blake told Jon Sievert, “and I thought to my-
self, ‘This guy must be totally nervous to play this fast!’”
Despite coming from different musical worlds (Nancy’s train-
ing was classical, though she was per forming in a progres-
sive rock ensemble), the pair hit it off and were married in
1975. Both the marriage and musical partnership have
matured over the ensuing two decades.
In 1978, fiddler James Bryan joined the B1akes to form the
Rising Fawn String Ensemble, a trio that lasted nearly eight
years. “It gives my guitar music some places to go where it
hasn’t been before,” Norman said of the trio to Art Coats
(Frets, April 1979); “We’re very much into the bass line
concept in our music...Nancy and I play the bass line to-
gether when we back the fiddle with the guitar and cello...It
gives James some decent backup.”
Like any new combination playing old time music, the
Rising Fawn String Ensemble met with mixed notices: “When
people started to label us as ‘chamber music,”’ Blake told
Ronni Lundy, “it was a little offensive to us.” But the point
the Blakes and Bryan hoped to make was that old time coun-
try wasn’t one dimensional. “A lot of people can’t get past
the cornfield,” Norman told Roanoke Times reporter Laura
Alderson. “I’m looking for the source.” Norman’s search for
the source frequently took him musically to the British Isles,
a journey manifest in much of the Rising Fawn String
Ensemble’s performance on this video. “Our music demands
an ancient tone character,” says Norman, who cites old fiddle
13
books as one of the source he looks to for both material
and inspiration. Likewise, he hews close to what he calls
“good old-fashioned country music” as witnessed by such
standards as Jimmy Brown the Newsboy and the Delmore
Brothers’ Nashville Blues.
Norman’s approach to fiddle tunes prompted this com-
mentary from J.D. Kleinke (“Backroad Baroque,” Acoustic
Guitar, November/December l99l): “One of the most dis-
tinctive qualities of his playing is a singular ability to pre-
serve and emulate the spirit and drive of old-time fiddle
music with six strings and a flatpick,” wrote Kleinke. “Blake’s
heavy use of down-up-down-up cross-picking between
melody note and harmony note accomplishes two key things
in the pursuit of the old-time fiddle sound: the square down-
up stroke perfectly replicates the bowing patterns (‘sawing’
and ‘shuffling’) of an old-time fiddler; the two-string har-
mony of the cross picked pattern captures the drone echo
of a fiddler’s double stops, the chordal essence of traditional
fiddling.”
Norman likes to cite an old mandolin book when asked
for tips from aspiring flatpickers: “They said you have to
pick it like you were shaking water off your hand,” he re-
marked. “I simply turn my wrist outward.” Beyond tech-
nique, Norman told Art Coats: “I’m just lost in the tune and
trying to interpret what’s in my head...” Which, despite lim-
ited formal education, is a lot. “I’ve got a ninth grade edu-
cation,” Norman admits. “There isn’t much else that I can
make as much money at as I’ve been able to do with music...I
play for pure survival reasons, as well as, you know, loving
it.”
14
DAN CRARY
Photo by Axel Küstner
D AN C RARY
Country Boy Rock N' Roll
Medley: The Fishing Creek Blues/
The Blackbird/Turkey In The Straw/
Bonaparte's Retreat/Arkansas
Traveller
D OC W ATSON & J ACK L AWRENCE
Bye Bye Blues
Tennessee Stud
T ONY RICE & RICKY S KAGGS
Where The Soul Of Man Never Dies
Dan Crary
More Pretty Girls Then One
N ORMAN B LAKE & T HE R ISING F AWN STRING
E NSEMBLE
Nashville Blues
Medley: The Cuckoo's
Nest/Over The
Waterfall/Opera Reel/
Cherokee Shuffle
T ONY RICE A LL S TAR J AM
Freeborn Man
D OC & M ERLE W ATSON
Medley:Sheeps In The
Meadow/ Stoney Fork
Doc Watson & Jack Lawrence