Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FRCPC, FAAD hands and duplex ultrasounds investigation of 28 healthy hands. A technique
Vivian W. Bucay, MD, FAAD of injection specifically designed from anatomical findings was then tested on
Carnac and Paris, France; Vista, Calif.; 8 fresh cadaveric hands using magnetic resonance imaging and dissection in
Coconut Grove, Fla.; and San Antonio, comparison with 3 other commonly used techniques of rejuvenating injections.
Tex. Results: Between the dermis and the tendons, the thickness of the fascial plane
was measured from 0.3 to 2.2 mm. Because of numerous fibrous septa, the en-
tire plane was found as a 3-dimensional sponge-like framework. Veins could be
located in all levels of this framework. There was no predefined free space. The
optimal place for the deposition of a filler was found to be the undersurface of
the dermis. The specific technique named Scrape Skin Threading Technique
and using a cannula scraping the deep side of the dermis was checked as the
only technique which could give a perfect placement of product restricted to
the fascial layer.
Conclusion: The Scrape Skin Threading Technique was designed to inject
safely and accurately any kind of injectable in contact with the undersurface
of the dermis, which appeared anatomically as the optimal location of a
filler for enhancing the outer appearance of the dorsum of hands. (Plast.
Reconstr. Surg. 136: 258S, 2015.)
258S www.PRSJournal.com
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
259S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
260S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
Fig. 2. Illustration of the 3D sponge-like fascial framework on the dorsal side of hands.
261S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
Cannula insertion: To avoid friction in the the cannula was pushed into the subcutaneous layers
to-and-fro movements, the entry points are made without any particular wish to follow a well-defined
with a needle slightly larger than the cannula. The plane, notably subdermal); and (4) strictly subdermal
needle’s bevel should be facing down to guide the fine threading retrograde injection (SSTT) of 0.7-mL
cannula in the right plane. The incision is cres- product using a 21-G cannula. In all boluses proce-
cent shaped. When the cannula is later inserted, it dures, the tip of the needle was inserted in the cen-
engages in the weakest part of the incision, that is, ter of the dermofascial triangle created by lifting the
at the top of the convexity, in direct contact with skin (skin tenting), taking care to remain as parallel
the undersurface of the dermis. as possible to the bone plane to minimize the risk of
Injection: The tip of the cannula is introduced injecting into the tendon layer. The second and third
through the entry point with the lateral hole pointed methods are commonly used throughout the world
up, that is, toward the dermis. This orientation of the for rejuvenation of the back of the hand. The only
side hole further helps to keep injection of the prod- real difference between the third and fourth methods
uct subdermal. The cannula is then pushed in with is the emphasis on scraping the underside of the skin
a small angle of its tip toward the dermis to scrap in the to-and-fro cannula movements to ensure sub-
easily the undersurface of the dermis. The product dermal injection (SSTT). In both methods, cannulas
is slowly injected as the cannula is retracted. were inserted through slightly larger holes made with
In this way, tracing injections are progressively a needle. The same fan configuration of injections
carried out in a fan-shaped configuration from a was used starting at 2 different entry points.
single entry point, gradually covering the marked Two hands were injected using each method
out space. The aim is to deposit enough product with the same MRI data acquisition and analysis
on each passage. A touch-up is always possible. protocols used for each hand before and after the
However, it is important to avoid depositing too procedure to make an objective comparison pos-
much product, which would necessitate correc- sible. All the hands were then dissected plane by
tive massaging. Product can always be added, but plane. The same product was injected in all cases,
it can never be taken out. All the marked spaces that is, calcium hydroxylapatite (CaHA) diluted
can be filled in this way. This technique allows 2-fold in colored normal saline. The purpose of
remodeling, “real sculpting,” of the hand by add- diluting it was to make the product easy to inject
ing filler. Gentle massaging can be used to smooth gently and accurately, and the purpose of coloring
over small local defects, but broad massaging to it was to make it easy to follow in its spread through
redistribute the product is contraindicated. the tissues and its location in different layers dur-
ing dissections. Injection methods were allocated
as the hands came available, that is, randomly.
Validation Study of the Scrape
Skin Threading Technique Results
Once this new specific technique for hand fill- One Single Bolus with No Massage.
ing was tested and accurately designed on 3 cadav- The first injection was made on an unusually
eric hands, we decided to check and validate its fat hand, due to both the fatness of the cadaver
reliability in positioning the injected product, com- and probably localized premortem edema. The
pared with others already published techniques. analysis of MRI images after injection showed that
the entire product was above the tendon layer,
Materials and Methods inside the fascial plane as confirmed by the dissec-
Eight fresh cadaveric hands were obtained tion. But such a hand would never be a candidate
from the Body Donation Centre of Paris Des- for augmentation. Nevertheless, this experiment
cartes University. They were injected using dif- confirmed that injection confined to the fas-
ferent methods and then examined by magnetic cial plane is possible as long as the layer is thick
resonance imaging (MRI) to locate the injected enough to “accommodate” the product injected.
product prior to dissection. The second hand injected with a single bolus
Four different injection methods were studied: alone was more compatible with the demand for
(1) one single bolus (1 mL injected using a 21-G rejuvenation. MRI and dissection showed that
needle) with no massage; (2) one single bolus (1 mL the product was in contact with the deep fascia,
injected using a 21-G needle) followed by massag- between and below the tendons (Fig. 4).
ing to spread the product out; (3) blind retrograde One Single Bolus Followed by a Massage.
threading injection of 0.8 mL into the subcutaneous Examination of colored tissue through the
plane, using a 27-G cannula (blind in the sense that skin showed that vigorous massage had not been
262S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
DISCUSSION
Fig. 4. Dissection of the fascial layer after a bolus without mas- Our anatomical findings and conclusions
sage: the colored injected product is found in and below the diverge from the ones by Bidic et al.9 We did
tendon layer. not find a milfoil cake-like fascial system as they
described, but a 3D sponge-like fascial framework
as in many other parts of the body. The much
higher quality of our imaging due to our high-
definition ultrasounds probes is certainly a major
explanation of such a divergence.
As already described,2–4 the main features of
dorsal hand aging are a progressive loss of volume
linked to fat atrophy; a skin laxity and dermal
atrophy giving too much visible bones, tendons,
and veins; and a superficial aspect of crumpled
skin. The immediate idea is to use already known
injection techniques, intradermal to improve the
skin and/or deeper to correct the volume loss.
Ultrasound investigations with high-definition
Fig. 5. Dissection of the fascial layer after SSTT: the colored probes were the most exciting and fruitful part of
injected product “humidifies” the undersurface of the dermis our research, as they gave us many key findings as
and infiltrates the fascial layer. There is no product in the tendon the thickness of the layers and the multipartitions
plane. system inside the fascial plane. The 0.2- to 0.9-mm
thickness of the dorsal skin must be compared
with the 2.56 mm on the check or 2.25 mm on the
successful in spreading the product out evenly. alar of the nose.14 It seems impossible to reliably
Injecting boluses into each intermetacarpal space inject any filler intradermally.15 A better approach
would almost certainly be more effective than a could be to voluntarily use the immediate sub-
single bolus. However, again in both hands, the dermal space with SSTT or change for alternative
product was found in contact with the deep fascia, methods such as percutaneous collagen induction
or all “lights” devices.
between and below the tendons.
It is surprising that in our time when all the
Blind Retrograde Threading Injection. techniques for the face tend to become more and
In both treated areas in both hands, the prod- more meticulous and scientifically controlled,
uct was still found in and under the tendons layer. the injection techniques in the hands remain as
rough and blind.16 We have not found published
Strictly Subdermal Linear Retrograde Injection. investigations of the position of the injected prod-
On all the MRI images (both transverse and uct after bolus and massage or after blind thread-
axial) of the 2 such injected hands, the product ing. Physicians who insert a needle in the center
was only found above the tendon layer. Dissec- of a skin tenting believe that they inject in the fas-
tion showed that all the injected product stayed cial layer. We showed they are wrong. The product
in contact with the dermis or in the fascial plane, is deeper around the tendons and during a blind
without any leakage in the underlying space threading as well. Because of the multilayered
(Fig. 5). venous network (with 2 main levels17) inside the
263S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
Conclusions
The SSTT, a strictly subdermal linear retro-
grade injection, became our preferred treatment
approach. It is simple and reliable because it is
always easy to follow the undersurface of the der-
mis with a soft-tipped cannula. It is safe because
the cannula is kept far away from the veins and
Fig. 6. A 51-year-old woman. Result at day 21 after injection of the injected product remains distant from the ten-
1 mL of diluted CaHA, using the SSTT. dons. Because of the extreme thinness of the der-
mis and the fascial layer at the time of a request for
hand rejuvenation, it appears as the optimal tech-
nique for correcting both skin textural changes
and subdermal volume depletion.
Nevertheless even if the technique refer to
a solid anatomical basis, it must be confirmed by
studies of clinical outcomes on patients using sys-
tematic high-definition ultrasounds controls, easier
to manage, and probably more reliable than MRI.
REGIONAL APPROACHES
Amir Moradi, MD; Vista, Calif.
Radiesse is made of CaHA particles suspended
in a gel. Approved for facial injections since 2006,
physicians have been using Radiesse off-label to
Fig. 7. A 51-year-old woman. Result at day 21 after injection of correct volume loss in the hands. In February 2015,
1 mL of diluted CaHA, using the SSTT. an FDA Advisory Panel voted favorably to expand
the indication to include hand augmentation.
fascial plane, this area itself is not the safest one Radiesse is a safe and effective product when
for a needle. A soft-tipped cannula is certainly a injected in the subcutaneous layer of the dorsum
better tool in hands. Compared with a small cali- of the hand.
ber cannula, 23-G or 21-G cannula has thicker The technique demonstrated in this video
heads that readily slide against the dermis with- slightly differs from the protocol used in the FDA
out snagging inside it. Experience of teaching the Clinical Radiesse Hand Studies and illustrates the
technique has consistently shown that the stiffer author’s technique in his practice.
the cannula, the easier it is to advance it in con- Thorough knowledge of the anatomy and
tact with the skin. However, such a large lumen function of the hand is essential with this proce-
means learning how to control injection pressure dure. One needs to be aware of the neurovascular
for regular product deposition, particularly since location, but also different layers and compart-
a relatively fluid filler product seems the best as ments that exist within the hand (Fig. 8).
it precludes the need for strong pressure. The Evaluation of the hand includes the visibil-
underface of the dermis appears to be the optimal ity of the veins, tendons, and loss of fatty tissue.
location whatever the filler (Figs. 6 and 7). Although the process of aging includes changes
Already in 2004, Coleman18 stated in his tech- in all structures of the hand, including muscles,
nical book on surgical fat grafting that “the key tendons, and bone, the injection mainly corrects
to structural fat grafting of the dorsum of the the loss of tissue and fat in the subcutaneous layer
hand is purposeful placement of a smooth layer (Fig. 9).
264S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
265S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
Fig. 10. Illustration of hand. Mariano Busso, MD; Coconut Grove, Fla.
There has been an increased interest in hand
the full-text article on PRSJournal.com or, for Ovid augmentation over the past years.19–28 After the
users, at http://links.lww.com/PRS/B436). face and neck, hands are the most visible area
of skin, with a surface area similar to that of the
In our experience, there is a significant
face. In fact, a person’s age can be estimated by
improvement in the appearance of the hands.
looking at the hands alone.29 Potential patients
become interested in hand rejuvenation when
there is a discrepancy between the appearance
of facial age and hand age. In general, volume
replacement of the hands occurs in an older
population.30
Youthful hands have fullness and a lack of
visible veins and wrinkles. Volume disguises
underlying structures (eg, veins, extensor ten-
dons, and bones) and makes the skin tighter.
Veins in older hands often appear or are, in fact,
dilated because the emptying of dorsal veins dur-
ing finger flexion decreases with aging. Like in
the face, chronological hand aging is a 3D pro-
cess, but in contrast with the face, gravity does
not play an important role in hand aging. Hand
wrinkles are a tissue reservoir of motion and not
the consequence of gesturing. Other factors that
Fig. 11. Illustration depicting the tenting of hand for injecting. influence volumetric changes of the hands are
266S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
Fig. 12. A 67-year-old African-American woman; Fitzpatrick type VI (before and after).
Fig. 13. A 51-year-old white woman; Fitzpatrick type IV (before and after).
rheumatologic diseases, hand injuries, weight months.31 This article describes a technique to
changes, and hand dominance. use dermal fillers for hand voluminization.
Although the benefits of fat transfer for hand Quantification of Volume Loss
revolumization have been documented,31 pre- A visual grading scale was developed by Busso
packaged, ready-to-use fillers provide a cost-effec- to measure volume loss on the dorsum of the
tive alternative, particularly for those patients hands. This validated scale is based on the extent
who do not tolerate significant down time. By to which the 3 central tendons are visible, which is
contrast, fat grafting requires about 10 mL to proportional to the degree of dorsal hand volume
produce a slight improvement, whereas 20 mL is loss. This is a 5-point scale, where 0 denotes no
necessary for significant improvement, and the tendon seen and 4 indicates that all 3 central ten-
latter can be associated with edema that lasts 4 dons are seen in their full length (Table 1).
267S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
Fig. 14. A 57-year-old white woman; Fitzpatrick type III (before and after).
Fig. 15. A 50-year-old white woman; Fitzpatrick type II (before and after).
268S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
Fig. 17. Anatomy of the hand. Adapted from Bidic et al. Reproduced with permission from Bidic
SM, Hatef AD, Rohrich RJ. Dorsal hand anatomy relevant to volumetric rejuvenation. Plast Reconstr
Surg. 2010;126:163–168. Figure 7 from this article. Illustration demonstrating the different fascial
layers and fatty laminae, with injection cannula placed within the dorsal superficial lamina.
269S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
270S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
Fig. 18. Step-by-step illustration of the technique. Top left, mark entry points placing hand below level of heart; top right, elevate
hand above level of the heart; bottom left, tent skin of the dorsum of the hand; bottom center, inject bolus; and bottom right,
massage.
hand elevation above the level of the heart, com- the dorsal hands are characterized by lentigines,
pression, and diuretics (eg, triamterene 37.5 mg/ actinic keratosis, rhytids, skin laxity, atrophy of
hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg [Dyazide; GlaxoSmith- the dermis and subcutaneous fat, prominence of
Kline, Research Triangle Park, N.C.). bones and tendons, large intermetacarpal spaces,
and bulging veins.
Allison B. Sutton, MD, and Vivian W. Bucay, MD; After the face, the hands are the most con-
San Antonio, Tex. spicuous part of the human body.38 With facial
An aged appearance to the hands is a result of rejuvenation procedures so commonplace, peo-
both intrinsic aging and extrinsic forces, especially ple have begun to notice the discrepancy between
ultraviolet light exposure. Age-related changes in the hands and the face thus driving requests for
Fig. 19. Before and after injecting 2 mL of SGP-HA derivative in the dorsum of the right hand.
271S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
272S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
273S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • November Supplement 2015
274S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Volume 136, Number 5S • Hand: Clinical Anatomy and Injectable Fillers
26. Rendon MI, Cardona LM, Pinzon-Plazas M. Treatment of 34. Brandt FS, Cazzaniga A, Strangman N, et al. Long-term effec-
the aged hand with injectable poly-l-lactic acid. J Cosmet Laser tiveness and safety of small gel particle hyaluronic acid for hand
Ther. 2010;12:284–287. rejuvenation. Dermatol Surg. 2012;38(7 Part 2):1128–1135.
27. Sadick NS. A 52-week study of safety and efficacy of calcium 35. Dallara JM. A prospective, noninterventional study of the
hydroxylapatite for rejuvenation of the aging hand. J Drugs treatment of the aging hand with Juvéderm Ultra® 3 and
Dermatol. 2011;10:47–51. Juvéderm ® Hydrate. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2012;36:949–954.
28. Sadick NS, Anderson D, Werschler WP. Addressing volume 36. Cohen JL. Utilizing blunt-tipped cannulas in specific regions
loss in hand rejuvenation: a report of clinical experience. for soft-tissue augmentation. J Drugs Dermatol. 2012;11:s40–s41.
J Cosmet Laser Ther. 2008;10:237–241. 37. Sundaram H, Weinkle S, Pozner J, et al. Blunt-tipped micro-
29. Bains RD, Thorpe H, Southern S. Hand aging: patients’ cannulas for the injection of soft tissue fillers: a consensus
opinions. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2006;117:2212–2218. panel assessment and recommendations. J Drugs Dermatol.
30. Redaelli A. Cosmetic use of polylactic acid for hand 2012;11:s33–s39.
rejuvenation: report on 27 patients. J Cosmet Dermatol. 38. Fabi SG, Goldman MP. Hand rejuvenation: a review and our
2006;5:233–238. experience. Dermatol Surg. 2012;38(7 Part 2):1112–1127.
31. Coleman SR. Hand rejuvenation with structural fat grafting. 39. Waldorf HA, Fernandes NF, Patel RV. Hands and feet.
Plast Reconstr Surg. 2002;110:1731–1744; discussion 1745. In: Carruthers J, Carruthers A, eds. Procedures in Cosmetic
32. Bidic SM, Hatef DA, Rohrich RJ. Dorsal hand anatomy Dermatology; Soft Tissue Augmentation. 3rd ed. New York, N.Y.:
relevant to volumetric rejuvenation. Plast Reconstr Surg. Elsevier Saunders; 2013:155–159.
2010;126:163–168. 40. Bidic SM, Hatef DA, Rohrich RJ. Dorsal hand anatomy
33. Busso M, Moers-Carpi M, Storck R, et al. Multicenter, ran- relevant to volumetric rejuvenation. Plast Reconstr Surg.
domized trial assessing the effectiveness and safety of cal- 2010;126:163–168.
cium hydroxylapatite for hand rejuvenation. Dermatol Surg. 41. Edelson KL. Hand recontouring with calcium hydroxylapa-
2010;36:790–797. tite (Radiesse). J Cosmet Dermatol. 2009;8:44–51.
275S
Copyright © 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.