OBBHHMTEJIBHOE 3AKIIOUEHHE no yrononuomy zeny No 2013390223 no oSsHHcHMo Kewsipxuk Burana Huxonaeswaa B COBeplleHHH Mpectynems, mpenycmorpenHoro 13,(4) o7.264 w er.266 YK PM Hacrosmiee yronosHoe steno GkUI0 HayAaTO OpraxHoM yronoRHoro mpectexonanna Yasip- JIysrexoro PKII 26.05.2013 rona no ‘mpusakam cocrasa npectynenus, npenyemorpeHHOro (4) 1.264 YK PM. B Xoxe mposenenHoro yronosHoro npecseonanius Osi10 yeranonneHo, ro 26.05.2013 Towa, upuMepHo B 02 vaca 30 MunyT Hou, KumupxnK Burana Huxonaesus, waxoyics B COCTORHHM CU:IBHOTO ANKOTONBHOTO ONBAHEHA, YIPABIIA MOTONMKIOM ¢ KONSCKO! MapKHL «Qluenp 11», purascs » r. Yamsp-Jlyzra mo opore no HapaBieHiio OT aBTONPOMA K YsIMMe Jlenuua, up mpoesne no Mocry uepes pesky Jlysira, p Hapyutenne peSopanuli mur.a) u.14, 1.45 TIpasnst jopoxnoro aBwxeHus, yraepaxueHHEX Tlocranosnennem IIpapmtencrsa PM Ne 713 or 27.07.1999 rona, ne yex nopoxxnyto OGcraHOBKY HM TOpOxuEIe yoroBHH, CROC ToHXomsHONOTH4ecKOe COCTORHMe, KOTOPOe BIMSET Ha BHHMAHHE H PeaKIMMIO, a TaKOKe CBOlL BOAMTEISCKHH OMIT, NOSBOMMOMMi NPOTHOSHPORATS ONacHBIe | cMTyANUM H, MPeBBICHB Gesonacylo CKOPOCTS ABIDKEHHA Ha NAHHOM YHACTKE NOPOTH, He cripaniied © yripanieHHen 1 COBCPHIN ONPOKHABIBAHHe, B pesymbraTe ero HaXomMBUINiicA B KaectHe HaccaxUpa Verparnit JA. nonysun Tmxxne TenecHste TOBpeKeHs HO TIpHIHAKy —oMACHOCTA 7A 2u3HH, OT KOTOpEK ocIeMHM cKoHNancs. Tocne conepmenia Buimeykasanuoro J{TI Keriipanx BH. ckpsuics ¢ mecta npoucmectBua. Ueticrsua —Kswspxux B.H. opravom — yronopuoro —pecuenonanna Guim xpasmunuposanst no 4.(4) c1.264 u cr.266 YK PM. Tonpomenusii » KavecTBe mlogospenaeMoro HM oOpHHseMoro Kemupaxmx Buramnit Huxonaesi BHHY cBOI0 MpH3HAN MONHOCTEIO H TOKaza, "TO MoTONNKI MT ¢ KOMACKOi NepHoro MBeTa OH MpHOGpeN B npouLIM Tony 2a 100 yorIapoR, y napa no HMeHM Tox, amu ne sua. MoronnKr Osim He paGOwHM, rocHOMepHOl sHAK GsLT, H T1aCTHKORD Dacnopr, HO He Mory ero uaiira, BoxHTeNbcKOTO YAOCTOBepeHUS y Hero TaIOKe He uMeeTeH. 25 mas 2013 roa oH 6bul Ha aBroupoMe, Tam noMorast Onery Kyneny oprann30ns1BaTs aBrorouKu. Tam 65110 mHoro pebar Oxo H ero Opar Herp. Morouskn octasnn na pasGopxe Kysiewa ul caMt exai Ha asoMamane Onera Kyzena, Bevepom moexain Ha ceppuc 1 oH 3a6pai MOTONMKA, Gsu10 yare Temo, locale 9Toro Moexalt OH Ha ABTOAPOM, TaM CexTH 3a CTONHK H XOTCIIH 3aKAsaTD no. Tam yannenn KanmanescKmx peGsT, KaK SOBYT HX He 3HACT OHM CTAIH NPHRETCTRORATS ux, Ou TaM THI BHO, Giu1a naTuMETpoBAR KaHHCTpa BHA. 3a cTONOM cHjleno 4 HenoReKa — Twa, Coana, ox a ero Gpar Tera. Tam Gsuo eule mou, Ho on He saMeTun KTO. Juma MpeIOMAT eMy CheSIINTS 3a cHTapeTaMA, B Topo. OH BHAYALIe He XOTeN T.K. OBI B COCTORAHA ANKOTONSHOTO ONBSHCHHA, HO HOTOM Ace Tak Noexa. Ox cen 9a pysis, UMA ce B KONICKY H BuIeXATH Ha Hopory. OHH exann c KaKoii cKOpocTIO HE suaeT, TaM eme ECT NOBOPOT Ha MOCT, 4H Ha NOBOPOTe YBMeH, HTO Ha MOTOWMKNe CTaNA NOAHEMATKCH KONACKA H OH CHPSIHYN Ha seman. TloxHaBmnHcs ¢ 3eMsIH TO Yate Ha MOCTY YBHET TO MOTOUMINI Bepx KonecaMa H Zuma TO MOTOMMIIOM. OH OMEN MOTONHKN H nocMorpen Ha Jumy. Ox 1exKa1 Ha CHHHe H On MSITANCH ero TORHATS, NOCAMTS, HO OH GsIT Ges ABHeHHA. Ha MOCTY OH YBHLIEN KPOBb, 130 Ta TaIOKE BLIXONWIA KPOBB, OH HCNYTAICH TPYTa H OSTOMY BEITONKAN MOTOLKN AATbIC OT ‘apyna B ctopony ya. Jlexmma nossoHH Gpaty Tere. Hera mpexan Ha MamINHe H BEITARY:T MoTONMKH B Mone , TaM rye BHHOrpaqHHKH OOO OKemuyxunar. Tam ocTaBHn MOTOUMIL cpsrai ero B xepeniax. Ox xored cxe4S MoTONMKT, Ho Gpar Tlets ero otrosapanan. Iles 3H 470 Ha MOCTY CTS TPyT,, # eMY Bce paccKasal. Hi B ONMUINO HH B «CKOPyIO OMOMIb» OH He SBOHILI T.K, HeMYTaNes, YO eTO HOCAAST B TIOPEMY, PeINHN CkpsIT MOTOUMKN. OH 3HACT, ¥TO Ansa xeon He Osu Ha MOCTY, T.X. OH ObUT Ges NBIOKCHILA, HO HH HYsbca HH CepmneOHeHHA OF He mposepa. $1 Xouy yTouHHT) TO Kora MoTONMET MepeBepHysIcs, TO [uma ocTanCs BKONACKe, OH Kora nepesepHy MOTONTHKH, To Twa ocrancs Ha seme. Ox pasiee ToBopHn 470 ‘una 6511 3a pynen 1.k. ucnyrancs yros1OBHO! OTBeTeTREHHOCTH 3a eMepr: JImss. On exart co CKopocrst0 MpHNepHO 60 KM. ¥aC H He BIIHCarCa B TIOBOPOT Ha MOCT, Hl TAM HA MOCTY SMKH ects, Boxee raxoro we mostoputses. Bpaty Tlere om mpanay cxasan cpary, Ho oH TaIoKe uenyrancs, Ox Korga traces nous Jay , To B39 ero 3a TONOBY H HO4YBCTBOBAM KPOBB 1a pyKe H Tlousn 470 ToT ymep H ero OxBATHTa NaHHKa, (ux. ) Tonpomennsiii 8 kauectse notepnesuero Hctpatnii Anexcanip AneKceesus 10Kasail, YTO 25 maa 2013 roma ero coin Jama Victparati c Henectkolt Putolt w ero xeHoti noexamm 8 Yazsip- Jiynra Ha aproroukn, B Kayectse Goxexsumkos. Yoxe 26 Max JOmKeH OBUI BHIEXATS HOH T.K. PeMOHTHPYeT CHOPTHBHEIe MAITHHB!, KaK MexaHHK. 25 mas HOsBOHELT coin Jama mpumepHo B 19 "WaCOB Hi CKa3ail, YTO BCe B MOPRIKe yxe JoexaH. Bonbule chin He sBoHHA. Ho B 5 Hacop TosnonHa xeHa H ckasasia, WTO cBiH Juma Meprs. Ox mpuexas 8 Yansip-JIyura, re yaa 40 cro chin nora6 = J{TTL. 3a pysem Motoumksa cm Jama He camuics, TOMKO 3a py ABTOMAIIMHI, Y Mena MamuHa «PeHO-CueHHK», BONATENBCKOE YiOCTOBEpeHMe Y Chia ECTS. Ava paGoran » Tommtexnuyeckom HHCTHTYTe MEDKeHEPOM, H 3AONHO M yuuUICA. CBI He MHoTpyktop no BoxneHMo. Ox celivac ToTopulIca K 3aliUsTe 7MIMIOMG, MB HHCTHTYTe BEIOTHAT YHKNHH HHxeHEpa... [Ma 4yTb- 4yTb Gossica TpaHCHOpTHEIX cpercTB, u OH JyMaeT, ‘ro OH He cext 651 3a pysIb MOTOLKa. Ga. ) Tonpouenusii » xavectse caunerens Kswspxux Terp Haxonaesn noKasai, 40 y nero uneetos Gpar Buranux, ox mpuo6pen MotouuK y CUABHI, KUBET B ero YOM HB ero nomsesne, Motonmr MT wepHoro mBera ¢ KosscKoii. BonHTesEcKOro yilocTouepeHus y Gpara eue wer. Bpar KyMH1 MOTONHKT OM roma ToMy Hasay, HO OsIT HepaGomNM BHaTAT, Aoxywenrst na morouxa y wero Gum, Burak 25 mai 2013 roza buaiane waxonMcs ¢ HUM Ha ABTONPOMe, TAM TOTOBAIHCH K TOTOBKe ets. BTAIMK YexKAN H MpHe3KaN, OHM NOMOTIH Kynesy Onery. Jae mor Grom BMecTe, MOTOWMK Jem BHTaNHK ocraBHa Ha TeppHTopHH asrocepsuca «opcax Kynena O. a G5tT NOCTOSHHO ¢ HM HEM. Besepom OHM NOeKaH Ha asrocepsuc , 4706 pemonTuposaTs ony MammHy. Kora saKOHYHH To MOcxalTH Ha ABTOPOM, TaM Toca u mum BHHO. [loTOM MpHexalIH 3a MOTOUMKLIOM Burana 4 OH 3a6pa MOTONMKA Ha ABTOAPOM, a On NOeXa Ha cBOeH MamIHHE Ha aBTONPON. BBUIO MpHMEpHO OKONO 24 YaCoB HOH, Tas yae nourn Bee oTmsIxaH, On c Buranuxom cHesH NOX TeHTOM 3a cronOM. OH MpHexas Panbine Buramaxa, u Kya OM MpHMTApKOBANI MOTONMK He aHaeT, He BUEN. OH He BUEN, HO BOsMOAHO BUTAINK Heelies B TY MAIATKY, Fe 3a CTONAKAMH CHILE TOME, HO TOUHO He SH1aI0 KTo H moruGurero aps OH He HOMHHT TaM, BOIMOAHO WTO H GxOT, BHTANHK NONOMIeN K HEMY HM Ckasa, YTO OW OTKeNET, HO KYNa He CKASAT H OBUI He OHH, HO C KEM He aHaeT, 6KLIO TEMHO. Capimar ¥70 MotonmK Burana orkesxan ¢ aTonpoma. Yepes munyT 5-6 no3BOHNI Ha MOSWIbUEIH Tenedbou BuraTHK, H TOSIOCOM TPeBOXHBIM TouocoM Hompocust 4706 OH MpHexan Ha aBToctantimo. OH HOH: ¥TO, ¥TO- TO CHYNHIOCE H Toexall B ropos. Tipoesixaa Hepes MocT TO uuvero He BAe, exan OsicTpo, cnemm x Opaty. Yyrs nanbue Mocta B cTopory ya. JIenuna, Burak ero ocranonuz, MoTOMHT Osi psloM. BHTAIHK ckasa eMy YTOG OH He RKIXOMHA C MAIDHBI, WOH HeMIMeT TPOC M HYAHO TOTAHYT MOTONHKT. OH Hes, 4TO MOTONMIN HMeeT TOBpexeHUR, PYNb TepeKOMeH, saee KPKUO TlepeKoMIeHO. OH NOHAI, TO, ¥TO - TO cTy"UbI0c8, HO CHavaTa He cHpaMMBaN sro. BATAMK Osu BoxGyaKNeH, H cKasan 4TO HYAHO MOTONVII OTRESTH NOMATEINe, YTOG MOTOUMIG HE HANILIH, OH HOH 470 BUTAMK UMCET B BILIY noamuelicxux. OH MOAYMAN H peu exar 2a «CoprceMonOm Ha Tome, TAM B 3ApocmaX MACTHHBI OcTaBHLIN MoTONMCT, BHTATHK CHIEN Ha MOTOUMKIe, HO Y Hero O¥eHb Gostena MpaBan PYKa W Mpaag Hora, OM MOH TO OH Yan Ha Mpazyio cropony Tena, OHM BIROEM CEM B Mamany, BUTaIUK MUHYT NAT BOSHACK C MOTONHKIOM, TO JeaI He 9HaIO, OTOM OMEYexanst, Ho jopore oH cupocust y BuramaKa ¥ OH cxasax, #70 OH ONPOKMHY:ICs NaccaxcipoM 1 Raccaikip Yuep. BUTATHK ckasan, TO Macca CHAE B KOMACKE M KOTHA OMPOKURYHCS. BUTaNHK ckasa, wo naccaxHp B xpos H eprouil, H on ySemUICA TO On MeprBEIH, B nommuio H 8 «CKopyio Hoou” He oBpamaics. On Nousut, uro BUTAMMK XO¥eT EXpSITb, TO Copepunin [ITT m ox emy ue Bospasun, Y Buranuxa Osun moK y nero Toxe. Ou ores oMolt Burana a cam noexax na aprocranuio H Tam man xode 20 yrpa. Ha astocrarm or monet OH YemINIAN HTO Ha MOCTY HeTOBeKa COMIH, eXAT TpYN, HO HHKOMY HuYeTO He roRopuT. Ha ABTOAPOM B TY HOW OH He BosEpamanes, C NOTHEMMM OH 3HAKOM He OBIT. Ga. ) Honpomenmiii » xavecrse cauyerenx Jouen Cepreti Ipuropsesa noxasax, sro 25 Maz 2013 rona wa paGore nonysim sapmurary m on © spyrom Ocxpuor:to Hluxontaew ua ero MOTOUHK:e «BHKTAI HOWIO MpHMEpHO B 2 Yaca EXAM B Topo B ap, HO Sapst yrxe Guinn Saxpbirsl. OH eXaul BOXPyr FTaBHOME YHMNE, TK. OBL BITUBLIMM C ya. KOMCOMOMBCKAS BBTexamT 4a MocT, BTAPKe, KOTOpBI BENET Ha TlONe, re HOMIE GBM NPOXOANTS asToroHK. [TpoeswKaK Mo MOcTY, CO cropoH! asToxpoma x ya. JIenma .npumepuo » 2 waca 30 MuHYT How, oF ‘YaHIeH, TemAIETO YenOBeKA, YBHNET Yay KPOBH HOA HM, OH HCHYraiod H NAKe He cra OcTakanmusaTécs # npoexan 1o ya. Jlenuna. TaM a aBTOCTAHLINA OM TOSBOHNN B MOmMTULO it coobuT © NesOReKe, BLU OH HBEIM HIM MepratiM On He aHian BHaNane, TTOTOM ol pepaynes Ba MOcT HO ae © paboTHuKaNH TONHIUM, HoKasaN HM HeTOReKa, TOT wexKAN Kaxe H stexan, Tommiciickye YoueNM 470 OH MepTE, H Yoke XOnOZHBIH. O Tox, TO Ha MOcTY mpomomit0 JITTT OF BHaYame Joke He NousH, AyMaN, YTO MyACHMy nobHUH. IIOTOM yBuAeN eHeHBe ¢ KoNKCKIL wexer0ro MoTonUMKa Tima MT, wacrH oF cTon ‘apér aalvell, KOU cxoMaHHite, cxlemn oF Xorec, OH noHsuI 410 npowsomut0 [{TTI, no tpaxcnopruoro cpestcTea Ha MecTe He Guo, On [PSMIOTOXUT, ATO YenOBeXA TO mH COWNH Ha MOCTY, TO JIM OH BEM ¢ KOMLCKH MOTOLNKTa, Heonexa on ue ysuait, oH Gstn oer B KpacHylo MacTepxy m woprsi, GocuKOM. Ga. ) Zlonpomertias » xauecrse ceurerens Kouxonant Baxenrana Koncranrmnoniia noxasana, ro 25 wax 2013 roza ona c myxew, nevow, Metparalt JIwurpueM, ero warepsi0 Caeraaol, Hesecroli Tues Putoii, mpuexama » Yausp-Jlyura wa astoromms. [pyexam oum na «Curpoenie> cusero upeta x 21 wacy. Ocraxosiict HanpoTHs Teppacst Ha asToowe, Pasbitnn TAIATKY, UPHTOTOBILIN cHaNbuBe MecTa, NOXAPHIH Mico H Toe. Ha Teppace ecTb CTOAHKH Tam coGpamich peGara, ee myx Komxoxax Bayecuas JImwott Mcrparui nou « uust 1 SAXBATHU HATHUUTPORYIO KawMcrpy ¢ BHHOM. [Ima BepHYcR BIG KEIPUANeM u nOMeN x cTomiky o6parHo. Morowuicr wepHoro Beta ¢ KONACKOH IpHexan MpHMepHo B 2 uaca, x70 GEL 38 pyle He sHalo. Tam 68110 MHOTO Mam, mons pasOUBATH NAaNATkH, eaEME MHOTO no Topore. Beuto Muoro GonesbmmKos unoropomuux. Ee Myx custen c [umott 3a cronmxom ¢ MYKsHOH, KAKUM TO, HO KTO oH He 3Haet. Kro eue HaxXomMcs 3a cromKOM He stiaer. On YeustuIata KPHK ¢ Teppacsi- «CaapMK, 8 celiac MpHeny, a 9a cHraperaMt>, Oua suena, «70 Awa Merparait uaer x Moroumeay 1 cex Ha MOTOMMIET c3azmH 3a BonHTexeN. Canoro Bostiiens ova B aunio He Brena. Oua nOMLIa K cTomKy, Kora JIuMa Ha MOTONMKIe Yate OTBexaLt, H o7ta Tonuura Mya sT06 ox mien cmars. Ee Myx cHlen 3a CromKoM © napHeM n Geno dyrGouKe cunel xypTke H onMH napeHb Oopoxarstii, rpssHO oxeruiii. Myx ¢ Heit nomen cars. Mars Zhou Tome commana KaK OTKeDKAT ee CHM Ha MoToWUKNE. Oua ocTaTaCs € Mano Tyne xaars Tasty. Ox mpoxkiam HexoTopoe BpeMa H MOTOM TOLL Ha Teppacy empallitears Kax walima posuurens Morons, 1-x. Jima noexax Ges moOusH0To Tene*poua. Ha teppace yenonex B cunell xyprke cxagai, To mwa Yexau c napueM xpactoli xenxe us Komanitsi Kynesa, Oun ¢ MaNOHi NOWUI x Mamuwe H 22am. poxaam rae To ac M Mate J[mMeK oma no nopore ® Topon, Mauesce Berperims Hwy. Mars nest nospoxmra xu cxasaa ¥To nama Jay 1 om Pech B posit wa nopore. Korza oula mpauina To site paGoraKos nomumn w tpym Test Merparuii na mocty. Ona we moxer ckasars 8 xonscxy cates [Iya ini nosaztn womensHo uM YesxxamH BIBoeM. [[HMa G5UT HEMHOTO B COCTOsHHH aiIkoroubHOTO OMBsHeHBS. Kora MOTOMMICI Yexasl, TO # He CHBIMAIA TO SByKY WTOG MOTOTMKT OcTaHanmHBancs. JIMA He cTaT 6s1 cpenH Homa, B COCTOSHUM OIKAHeHUS CAMHTCH 3a py YyMOFO TpaxcHopra, Tem Gosiee B ‘mom ropore. Moxer cxasars, 70 J[mMa Ha Teppacy Momlest GocHKOM, OsUI B MOprax H B pachoti MactepKe. Gn. ) Honpomennsti s kayecrne coupreresa Komxonan Bavecuan AnexcaHaponi noKazai, 470 25 maa 2013 roma ox c cynpyroti, aersMm, Metparuti JImmrpHem, ero mareps10 CeernaHoi, nesectoit Jjmst Puroii, mpuexant » Yanep-Jlyura wa astoronxy, IIpuexanm onM Ha «Curpoene» cnnero peta x 21 acy. OcraHOBAIHCh HanpoTHB Teppacst Ha abToOMe. PasGmmH TANATKY, IpHTOTOBILIN CHANBHBIe MECTA, HOXapHAH Maco H noes. Ha Teppace ecTb CTONMKH H Tam co6pamcs peGsta, on nomex Ta ¢ Duo Merparaii u saxnaTium nsriuETpoRyio Kanuerpy c BunoM. Juma Osu GOCHKOM, B TIOPTax H MACTepKe KpacHoro UBeTa B OpaNKeBoHt yrGomke. Oxm BHavane cnjemm c peOnran-paboTHMKaMM Teppacsl, BbITUBATH, Jtama He XOTEN ‘106 MaTS BUENA YTO OH KYPHT H OSTOMY OH Home Ha Teppacy. MoTouMKN, IpHeXAN Kora OHM cHslesIH Ha Teppace. OH BEIIeN B TYaIIET, H KOIIIA BEPHYsICH TO 3a CTONHKOM YBHIEN TpeX peGar HesHaKoMen, OHM ToROpHIH c J[uMoli o HeM To. Ox ce 3a CTON H TYT OMMH Hapetth KaK OW NOUS HOTOM, BOMHTeMS MOTOTIHKNA BCTAN H Nomen k MoTOHHMETY. JIuMa enpocH ero KYZa H Mapen ckasaz, ¥To B ropon exer H JlsMa NOMpOcHT 4706 MapeH eFO BIE C COBO! T.-K. xouer KynHTS curaperst. Morommkt yxke Gi sanevlen onATesIeM, Kora Jama emy KpHAL MPO curapersi. Out euje orrosapxean Jlumy, 1706 He exaN, T.K. 4yKoH Topod, H Bast 3a pyKy JlmMy, xo wa orronkHyn ero H ynien x MoToumxary. OxH RqROeM yexar. [[mMa cen 9a ROMMTENIEM Ha MOTOMMKT, OH eme ckasan J[AMe “706 OH Cell B KONICKY MOTOWMK:I2, HO OH CKagaT eMy 4TO He XOWET, B KONACKe KecTKO, On MOsICeN K MYASHHE C KHMMHeBA KAK soByT He sHaI0. Ox ero YFOCTHLI BHHOM. BBUr elle OME rps3HO ONeTHI MY-RIIHA, HO He 38 HAIIHM CTOAIHKOM, OF XOTHT H TonpomatisHaax no cronuxa. CKos1bKo OxUIO BpeMeHH OH He aHAeT, TAK. BINT. TyT MpHUA xena Bais u nossana ero cnars. Ox eli cxasam, «70 Jama celiac IpHeyer, H OHA MHS crazia Pyrats, 4T0 ero OTHYCTHN. 3a pysmb MoToUMKa JIuMa cecTh He Mor, OM BHZAeN To JlwMa cen 3a pomurenem. Hi MOTONMKT peskO TPOHY.ICA ¢ MecTa Ha GombMOH cKopocTu. Juma He Mor cecTs 3a pYib YY2KOrO MOTOWMKTA H exaTs TO YyxHM JoporaM. Ecnn Ont [wa saxoten Ostrb 3a PYzeM MoTONMIOTa, TO OH cpasy HOMpocHT Gxt y BOmHTENE Pym, HO [ama 3a pyneM ESE He esa HMKorNa, OH OBI 3a PYM He cen caM. OHM BAINKIH Ha Teppace 1,5 marpa nua, Tin 1H BUHO ¢ HAMH BOMMTeN_ MOTONMICIA OH He BHIeI. XOyeT 1OGABHTb ¥TO TAM eMle Ha MOBOpoTe OW BANE ¥TO MOTONHKT HAKPeHWLICK M KOIICKA HOALIACK, cKOpocTs Gxu1a Gombunias. Or ‘Teppacsi x0 Mocta metpos 400 M MpeonOueTs Ha MOTONMIMe 9TO paccTosHMe Hc TaKOH eKopocrsio on mor a 1-1,5 ManyrsI, Ga. ) Buna nonospesaemoro KsiBsipxnx BH.” 8 CoBepIeHHH —mpectyrinexus mpenyemorpentoro cr. 264 4.(4) u cr. 266 YK PM nograepaaetes m xpyrHMn MaTepHanaN ‘yronoBHOrO esa, a HMCHHO: = MporoKoxom ocmorpa mecta JITIT (1.1. ) ~ exemolt x JATH (1.1. ). -TIpOTOKOITON OcMOTPA H MpoRePKH Tex#H. cocTosHMs Tpaxicnopra (11.2. ) “IpoToKos1oM OcMoTpa MecTa MpoHCHIeCTBES! (111. » ~saxmoyenuem cye6u0-memHmMAcKoi skeneprHsEt NO76 (1.1. ds -SAaKTIOWEHHEM TOKCHKO-HapKonorMueckoll axcneprassi Ne (a. “TpOTOKO OcMOTPa peAMeTOR H MOTONK. (1.1. ) OGctosremcrsom, cMaTIaIOMHM oTReTeTREHHOCTs OOnHHseMoro KumupxHK B.H., corsacho cr.76 YK PM, spasetes mpusianne BHEBI.OGcrosrescrs, OTATIAIOIINX OTBCTCTBCHHOCTS OOBHBEMO! KerBEIpanK B.H., cormaco ct.77 YK PM, wer. Tio Mecty xurembcrsa oGsunsemEii Kitsipaxux BH. xapaxtepasyeres nocpencrseHHo, O6sunsemstit Kemspxux B.H, wa yuére y Bpaa ncHxHaTpa H BapKo7ora He cocrouT. Ha ocuosanuu usnoxenxoro OBBMHSAETCA: Keepxnx Butaraii Haxosaeus, 01.09.1989 Tona PORNHHA, YPOXeHEM 2KUTeIS ropona Yauup-Jyura, ya. Onunmulicxas Ni 7, rpaxnanna PM, mo HanwowamHocta rarays, xxeHaT, o6paionaHHe — HeMlomHoe cpemttee, BPeMeHHO He Tpy0ycrpoeH, patee He cyHM B TOM, 470 oH 26.05.2013 rona, mpumepuo 2 02 vaca 30 munyr How, Kupepxuk Burammii Huxonaesw4, Haxonscs B COCTOSHHH CHIBHOTO ATKOTOMBHOTO ONBAHEHHS, YMpABIAs MOTONMKIOM ¢ KouicKoll MapkH [emp 11», mpurascs B r. Yansip-—JIyura no zopore 10 HANpaBeHMO OT ABTONPOMA K ysIHHe JleHMHa, NIpH Mpoesme Ho MocTy Hepes pesky Jlysra, B napyinenue tpeSosanmit mut.a) 1.14, 1.45 Tlpapnn 7opoxHoTo ABIEKEHHS, YrBepRNEHHEIX Tlocranonnenuem TIpanutenscraa PM No 713 or 27.07.1999 rona, ne yuex 20porxxyl0 OGcTAHOBKY H OPOKHBIE YCIOBUS, CROe IICUXO}HSHONOTHYeCKOe COCTOSHHE, KOTOPOC BIMKeT Ha BHUMAHHe M PeaKMMIO, a TAKKe cBOH BOTHTeMECKHI OMBIT, MossormOMUAl MPOTHOSHPOBETE OMaCHBIe CHTYaIMM H, MpeBbicHA Ge20NIACHYIO CKOPOCTh ABIKKEHUA Ha JAHHOM YYACTKe JOPOTH, He cTpapMied ¢ YMpABIeHHeM H COBCPITA ONPOKAIBIBAHHE, B PesyssTave wero HaXOMMBUMKiicR B XavecTRe naccaxupa Mcrparuii J|.A. nosysHs OTKpsITy10 MepeHO-MOsTOBYIO TPABMY: KPOBOHAIHAHMe B MATKHE TIOKPOBKI TORO B 1O6HO! oOnaCTH Crrpana H Mpasyio BHCONHYIO MEMIMY, OcKoMbaTHIl Mepenom HeIyH MpaBoH BHCONHOH KOCTH, mmnediueii mepesoM B 3aqHeli YeperIHoli sMKe, IMHHA KOTOpOTO HlepeceKaeT MHpaMHKy TIpaBoli BHCOMHOH KOCTH, TyPeHKoe CeO U TmpaMMzKy seBOl BUcOMO! KocTH, OOpasya lem, cooGmaiomyiocx co cpeNHHM YXOM cHpana, H cieBa; cyOAypaNbHylO TeMaTOMy cmpasa c TMepexoJOM Ha OCHORAHHe MO3Ta HM TIO MO3%KCUKOBBII HAMeT, OTeK-HaGyxanHHe TONOBHOTO Moura € BKJIMHEHHeM Mpoforowaroro Mosra 2 Gombe 3aTKUIONHOe OTBEpCTHE, OCTpyIO MOSTOBYIO HEOCTATOHOCTS, SaKpBITBIM MHOTOOCKONBYATEH MepeTOM Tena H AYTH Mpapoit Cky0BOl KOCTH, KpoBonoOATeK BOKpyr mpanoro Twa3a, ccaqMHBI npaBoli NOsOBHHEI WHA, KPOBONONTEK Ha HIKHEM BeKE JJeBOTO Tula3a, CCAMMHY Ha MPABOM Mulee, MONOCHATyIO CcaNHEY HA CIIMHe Ciena, ccamHHBI B MOSCHMMHO! OGNACTH cIpana, CTYMeHHBHH SMANEPMHC Ha sIeBOM KONeHE H NpaBol FOueHH, YTO OTHOCHTCH K TOKKHM TENECHBIM HOBpeXk/eHHAIM 10 MpHsHaKy OMACHOCTH WWI %KUSHH, OT KOTOPIX NocHemHMH cKOHYaTICH. Taxum o6pasom, cBommn Zelicrsnsmn Kepupxwx Buraanit Huxonaesws conepuit mpectymenne, mpenyemorpenuoe (4) cr.264 YK PM, a umenuo: conepuiua HapymrenHe Mpasnn Ges0TIacHOCTH © ABYPKEHHS © TPAHCTIOPTHBIX CpeyICTB —HTIOM, YMpaRMAOMENM ‘TPAHCHOPTHEIM CPeCTBOM, MOBTeKII¢e —CMEPTs NenOBEKA, COREPIIEHHOe B COCTOSHHH ombsnenus. On xe, nocne copepmreHHs BEMTIeyKasaHHOro NOPOXHO-TpallcrloprHoro MponcHTecTBHs, a MMeHHO: COBepHleHHe ONPOKMIEIBAHHA IPH YUpaBIeHHH MOTONMKIOM ¢ KO/SCKOH MapKH «Inenp 11», B pesymstare KoToporo HaxomMEMIMlich B KayecTBe Naccaxspa Herparait J|.A. TONY THEKHE TENECHEIE HOBPERNEHHS MO MPHSHAKY ONACHOCTH [UIA AHSHH, OT KOTOPSIX CKOHYAIICS, ¢ HeNbIO H3GexKaHMe YTOMOBHOH OTRETCTREHHOCTH OCTABHI MecTO TpaHcHOpTHOrO POHCMIeCTBHS H eKPBILIC. Takum o6pa3om, cowmn zelicTenamm = Koiesipxnk Butanmii Hxonaenws conepumnt Mpecrynenne, mpenyemorpennoe 1.266 YK PM, a mMenHo: octanienHe MecTa ‘TpaCHOprHoro MpOHCUIECTBHA HUOM, YUPABIMOMVIM TPAHCHOPTHEIM cpenCTBOMHOpyMMBLMM MpapMia GesonacHOCTH JUBIOKEHMA TpaHCHOpTHBIX cpeyeT, B pesymbTare KoTOporo HacTynuTa cMepTb YenoBeKa. ‘Yauremas, 110 yronosHoe npecteyoBaHe 8 oTHomeHHM Kemspxux BH. oKonseno, BacTommee yronosHoe yeI0, 8 cooTBeTCTBHH co cr.ct.36, 297 YIIK PM wanpasnsetea Jaa paccmorpenua no cymectsy B cyt Yansp-JlyarcKoro paiiona. OGemmtemsoe sakmouenue cocrasneHo 24 mona 2013 roxa w rYaxtp-Jynra. Wo. samectaresa npoxypopa rYagsp-Jlyara wopuer 1-ro paxra Stax JA,CY], YAIBIP-JIVATA rMaguip-Jlynra, ya.Jlomonocosa, 22 MCTIIbE Hompamui Anexcandp Anexceesws mpox. rKummmay, ynXorme leBy Hompamutt Ceemnana Bacunweena npox. rKumupy, ya. Xorun 1«By OTBETUHK: Kereespocux Bumanuit Huxonaeeus mpox.r.Yansp-Jysira, ya. Onunmaiicxas, 7 MCKOBOE 3AB)1EHHE (© BosMemenuu marepuam.Horo m MopaneHoro yurep6a or conepmienus npecrynienusl) B mpowssoncrse Cyze Yagup-Jlynra naxommrea yronosHoe meno m0 OSsuHeMMo Keruipxnx Buranix Huxowaesma B copepmienmm mpectymensti, mpenycmorperinx 4.4 7.264 u or.266 YK PM. B pesyssrate JITTI, npomomenmero 26.05.2013, smxoBsKoM KoToporo spuseToa oTeeTanK, norMG vam ext — Werparmii [simpult Anexcarmposia, poaMBmutiics 26 sxmaps 1987r. B xoxe caeactsua s, Verpariii Anexcanmp Anexcees, 6511 mpusnan norepnesutell cropoxoit Ten mpectymienmem Ham MeTHaM, OsIN TpHYMHeH MaTepnambnut Yalep6, KoTopstii cocToHT #2 PacxOHOB Ha TIOXOPOHM CMHA B CYMMe 27.342,36 Jeli, KoTopstit vewnensetca 13 cleaylomlero: 1. 3arparet na saxoponenne 10.936 sei: - 1p06 2800 nevi ~ Kpecr 390 eit ~ Hag Ha Kpecte 80 eli ~ Kararbamk 450 edi ~ YouyTH No saxoponenmo Ha xrayGmme 5716 seit ~ ApenMa seMenbHoro ysacrka Ha kraz6ume 1015 nel - Ma JIA Baxoponerna (Komlanne, OANcTKa) 485 steft 2. Sarpare1 no oprannsamuin um nponegenuo norpeGenua (Bk:uo4as Upuobperenne Heo6xoqumerx Beutel): 4756,38 nel, 3. 3arparer Ha mpopegeHme nommnasmstoro Meponpnsttun: ~B Zen noxopoH 11.650 nei.XOna cyMMBI PeaNbHMIX SaTpAT Ha TIOXOPOHE! Ha MHOTO MpeBMUiaior BBIMeYKa3aHHYIO CYMMY, K COVKATEHHIO BCe TOLTREPAMAIOMMe JOKYMCHTHI He Guinn COXpaHeHR, Tak KaK B MOMeHT yrpaTsI cBIHa 06 3TOM He Ay Mam. TIpennonaras, ro OTRETWK —OGPOROMBHO Ml —_pyKoBOACTBYacb BEICOKOHPABCTREHHIMM IIPHHUMMTAMH, BOIMECTHT Ge3 cyZeOHOTO BMeMIATeIBCTBA vancceHHEi MaTepHallbHEIi yatep6, MoI Outim xpaline ynMBIeHBI ero aGcoMOTHO GeapasuumHoMy noBeeHIo. A Tak xe, YSHTBIBAK Te OScTORTeTbCTBA, ¥TO B pesysbTaTe CoBepmIeHHOTO MpectymieHna nOTaG Hal eNMHCTREHBI CBIH, HAM OMI HaHeceH Mm cymecrsennuiit Mopansimtit ymep6, BMpasHBliicn B MpapcTseHHBX 1m TOMKHMeCKHR cTpalaHvsx. OMMICATS cTeMeMs crpalaHMa poaneneli (erpecconoe CocTosmme, enpeccnm n GeccoHHBle Hou) H BOCTOMHMTE NOHeCeHHYIO yTpary (TaGems peCenke) mpakTiniecKH HeBOSMOXKHO, NlosTOMY MpH oMpestestenHM pasMepa MopamsHOTO ymlepGa MpOCHM MpHHATb BO BHHMAHHe BEIMeMaIOKeHoe. Toman peaGMIMTALNMA HAMeTO MCMMUMIECKOTO COCTORHMA HeBOSMOXHa, TAK xKaK ToHeceHHaA B pesyzbrate [TTI yrpara GymeT HocuTb 14 Hac noxoRHeNHL XapakTep, WTO COOTBeTCTBeHHO BueyeT Mm yrpary TpygocrocoSHOCTH HEOOXOMMMOCTS TepHOmWHeckoro © mpodwakTMyecKoro HeRpos1OrHYecKoTO seTeHH, Onermmaem pasMep HaHeceHHoro Ham MopambHoro ymtep6a B: 250,000 eit axa erpariit Anexcanmpa Anexceesnua 1 250.000 neii aaa Herparuit pera Bacumenus. B coorsercrsu ¢ mpeammcanmamn cr.ct.61-62, 219-221 YIIK PM, er.ct.1420-1423 TK PM: TIPOCHM: . IIpyanars Hae, Merparnii Anexoayapa Anexceesiia a Victpatnit Cretmany Baciilbesy, paxaancxman neTuaMa. Bonicxars ¢ ovseTanka, Kapeipaux Butanma Huxoraesma, 8 Hay Tom53y MaTepnarbHBtt yulep6 8 cysase 27.342,36 seit Bsbicxars ¢ orseranxa, Ksupaxnx Burana Hukonaeswa, 8 Hamy nom Mopanbuniit ymep6 B cymMe 250.000 eli 8 nomssy Hetpatwit Anexcanmpa Anexceesua 4 250.000 neii » nomssy Merpatuit Ceram Bacumennt. 4. TIpausrs mepst oSecrievenms nactosmero Ka, xv » pasoaenne: 1. Komua nexosoro sasmnenns. 2. Tinceutennbte aokasaremcrna o Mammiui H parmepe Marepuamsoro ymep6a - cveTe, empankat, axrypH. ep) 3. Kona ssinicxa 1 Gommmnoi xaprowxn, 4. Konus conneremcrsa o caepra DC-IV wy ) , > Sf Homme Yepog de? Sueleuen __ oxrs6ps 2013r. / Te IT (eee Aw CERSL te 9 YTexto No 1-128/13 WH 19-1-729-26 07 2013 ONPEAEIEHHE 13 semaps 2014 roma Manip Jyara Cy YanpJlyara Bcocrape: TIPECEMATENIECTBYIOLETO, CY Ibi Tk A. ‘mp cexperape [lnopoii CB. Cysacrem: Mpoxypopa mpokypatypsr Yanbip-JIyxra — Bparan JLH. apoKatos Llasra A., Ynwmoeu BB. pesicTaBHTesii oTepneBtniero Veerparii A.A. miogcyqMMoro Kewsipxux BH. PACCMOTPeB B OTKPSITOM CysIe@OHOM SACeTAIHH SAREE MpeicrasHTerelt roTepnesmieno Vicrpamaii A.A., Metparali C.B. o npissianin mx. 1perctarickma HCTIEMH 110 yrox10BHOMY remy no c6suxeno Kepeipank Butatia Hikoraesi4a p conepiiesm mpectytmenl, npeayevompestsix (4) c1.264, cr.266 YK PM, sosmemenna matepuarsnoro 1 Mopaimsioro yinlep6a or copepiiena npectyruienns ‘YCTAHOBILI: 13 spapa 2014 roma B cya Yampp-JIynra noctymmio sammtenne or npencrasnteneli norepnesumx Viepamait AA, Verparnit CB. 0 npasiarmm ix rpaxianiccmm neTuaM, BOSMEIIEHHH MaTepHANSHOTO H MOpatbHioro yIepOa OF COBEpLLIEHHA MIpeCTyIUIeHLEA. Tipencrasaten niorepnesiuero Vicpariit A.A. B cyseSHOM sacemaHHH TioTHOCTSIO TIOMMepAKGL TONAHHO HM 3AABIIEHHe 1 TIPOCHLT ero YHOBIETBOPHTS. Avpoxar norepesuero - ILasra A. 8 cyneSHOM 3acenaHHH nomepxata samaneHHe npeacrasirereli notepnesinero, Tipoxypop npoxyparypsi YaxsipJIyrra Bparas JLH. 8 cyseSiom sacenanmn re pospankata TPOTAB SAAB 1CHHOTO MPEICTABHTEIAMH TOTEPTeBLIETO 3AmBIEHHAA © TIPHSHAHHM [perk ALCKAM uetuom Merpamaii Anexcarmpa Aneceesuta, Tloacyaeneift Hero aapoxat Unmoeut B.B. B cyqeOHOM 3acenaHHH TaloKe He BOspe@KaNIA TpOTHB MpHBHaHHis rTpaxTancKHM HcTuom etpamaii Aviexcarmpa AnieKceesita Borcnytias noscHens ywacrHHNOB Mpollecca, CyeOHaN VICTAHLIA MPHNOIUIT K BEIBOZY O6 Soaeropenun sasmternid. Tax cormacHo ¢ 4, (1) cr. 219 YEIK PM rpaxnancxuli vex B STOOBHOM cYOTPOUSBOICTBS MOET ObILS NPETBARIEH (HBHYeCKUMH HTH FOpHAMYecKAMA SHLEMH, KOTOPBIM GbUI NPHMHHEH MaTepHATLBI, Moparbuti yLuepO WI, B 3aBHCHMOCTH OF COcTORTeNECTB, YLepS ZeTOBOH perlyTAUMM HeTIOcpeNCTBEHHO 3ANpeLeHHbIM YTOsIOBHBIM3aKOHOM ZemHHeM (neficTaneM wi GeayelicrarieM) 11460 B CERSH ¢ COBepILeHHeM 3T0rO cess. Kpove store, & coomercranu co c1:222 YTTK PM, ect smo He Geto npusHato parca: HCTUOM B XOIe YTOOBHOTO MpecTeTOBAHU! CysIeOHAR HACTANL CBOMM ONPEeIeHHEM MO:keT TIPHBHATE CTO Tpe@KNAHCKHM HCTIOM. Visyun Matepwalls yrosiosioro jena, M3 KOTOpOTO cilemyeT, 4TO Ha TAME yronOBHOTO pecrenosar 651 MprrstatriorepnesumM Tou1sKo Merparnii A.A. (7.128), a Menpamnai CB. we sua Nprotatia NoTepnesiuell, 6 CASH C HeM CYA MpMUNeIT K BEIBOAY O6 YzlOBTeTBOPEHIH SRaRTEHHA O NpHstaHHH rperaancKaMn ueruaMn Merpanaii A.A. u Vicrparii CB, vectra, Ha octonarii pbuienxtoxxeHH0r0 4 pyxopoacTByscs cr-222 YTIK PM cya, ONMPEAEIMSA: Yaonetsopurs vactH4Ho saapnenne Vetparuit A.A. u Merparait CB. 0 IpusHaHMM Wx rparxnancKHMM WeTHAME, Tipusnans Vietpanat Anexcariapa Anexceesia, npoxcisaromiero Br Kaumy, yo.Xomet 1 eB» rpeoxmanickens neon c pasiscenmen ero npas 1 OmanHOCTeH B COOTBETeTENM co cr.62. YIIKPM. Onpemenerne o6;xanopaHiio He nloyyexar, TIpeacegareasersyoumii cyaea A.®, Hens Konus pepua: Cyaba _ eyaa Yagsip-Jynra / A.®, Tenseno Ne 1-128/ 13 Komm. nomep 19-1-729-26 07 2013 uPHrOBOoP Hmenem 3axona 24 mapra 2014 rona r-Mamsip-Jlysra Cya Yansap-Synra B cocrane: Mpencenatenscrayrowero, cyseM Tlens A.®. pu cexperape Uinaosoti CB, Cywactuem: Mpoxypopa Auax A.J, Bparan JLH. aapoxarop Taraysa V.®., Yunnoewt B.B., Llasra A. ogeysmoro Kitespxux BH. notepreamero Hortparui PACCMOTPEB B OTKPEITOM cyseOHOM saceAaHHH, MO ynpomeHHoii npouesype mo cr. 364! VIIK PM a OciopaHHH JoKasaTenscTs, COGpaHHbIX tia CTaqHH YromORHOTO MpecenOBAHHA, yrosoBHoe se10 No o6puHeH KBIBDIPAUK BHTAJMS HUKOJAEBHYA, 01 ceura6pa 1989 rona poxenia, rpaxaanuna PM, ypoxeHua 1 sKuTena Tr. Manup-Jlyura, npoxxupatoutero mo ya.Oausnuiickas 7, raraysa no HAUMOHAALHOCTH, BIANEIOUIeTO PYCCKHM 2KIKOM Ha KOTOPOM BeneTeA cyonpoHsBoxCTBO, MMeIoMIerO HemlomHoe cpesHee obpasouane - 9 KnaccoB, BpemeHHO He tpymoyerpoeHioro, Coctoauero & Opake, Meroulero Ha mxsuBeHMH 1 (onsor0) HeconepuleHHoreTHero — peGenka, ROCHHOOGaSaHHOTO, He SABIAIOULETOCR HHBATHLIOM, CTeNHANBHEIX 3BaHHH, KACCHDIX “HHOB H rocyxapeTBeHHBIX Harpan He MMeIOIero, NO zaRHOMy jeay Guin sagepxxaH Ha tpoe cyToK ¢ 26.05.2013 roaa no 29.05.2013 roza, pauee He cynuMoro B coneputehAu npecryrenuit, npeayemorpentioro 4.(4) cr:264, o7:266 VK PM, eya Sacnyilan TIOKasaHIHA MOAeYAUMOTO, HecTeAOBAB MaTepHANK jena, sacnyuias pew B MpeHuax npokypopa, anBoKaTOR H rloscyMMOTO YCTAHOBHA: TloncyauMesit Ksisuspacn Burrannii Huxonaesus, 26 max 2013 roaa npumepuo 3 02 vaca 30 MuiiyT, HaXonAeb B COCTORHHH anKOrORBHOTO OnbaLeHHA, YIpABneA MOTOLUIKIOM v KONACKOH Mapku «f{enp II», aBurasce 8 r.Yazsip-Jlyxra no opore ro HanpaBneHHio ot aBrogpoma K ynuue Jlennna, np mpoeaze no MocTy Hepes peuxy Jiynra, a HapywesuM TpeSoBanuli mut.a) 4.14 n.45 o27 mona 1999 roja, He y4en xopoxKHy!o oGcTaHOBKy M jOpOxHBIe ycmOBH, cBOe MICHXOGHOAOTHECKOe COCTOAHHe, KOTOpoe BITMAeT Ha BHMMAHMe H PeakUMio, a TaKwKe cBoii BOAHTeNECKHe OMBIT, NosBOAMOMMH NporHOsHpOBATS OT|ACHBIE CHTYAIIHt H, NPeBKICUB GesonacHy1o CKopOCT ABIEKeHHA Ha AAHHOM yuacTKe jOporH, He cMpaBrMiea ¢ ynpaBlleHWem HM copeputiin OMpOKMAbIRAHHe, B pesymbTaTe vero HaXogMBUIMlicR B KaYecTBe naccaxupa Merpatuit [.A. Monyalia OTKPHITYIO NepemTHO-Mo3rOBYIO TPABMY: KPOROMRANAHHC B MATKHE MOKPOBBI ron0BLI B AOGHOK OGrACTH cMpaBa H Mpasylo BYCOMHYIO MEIMUY, OCKOABYaTHIM NepenOM eUlyH MpaBolt BuCOMHOH KOCTH, MHHeHHBIH MepenomM B saqHeH HepenHOH aMKe, AMHUA KOTOporo MpeceKaeT TUpaMHKY Mipawoli BHCOUHO! KocTH, TypeuKoe ceaTO M MIMpaMHAKy sleBOli BHCONHOH KOCTH, OGpasya Went, cooSuIaIoMLyioc CO cpemHHM YXOM crpaBA H cxeRa; cyOaypabHyio reMaTOMy cmpaa ¢ NepexoXOM Ha OCHOBAHHe MO3Ta H M10 MOSKEYKOBEI HaMeT, OTeK-HaGYXaHMe FOOBHOTO ‘MosTa ¢ BKAHHEHHeM NpososIronatoro Mosra B GosIbUlOe 3aTEITONHOe OTREpCTHe, OCTPY!O MO3TORYIO HejoctaTouocTs, 3aKpHITbI MHOTOOCKONBYATHI NepenOM Tea u AYTH MpaBoit CKyNOROM KocTH, KpOBONOATeK BOKPYr Mpaworo rasa, ccaMHs! Npawoli NOAOBHNBI JHA, KPOBOMIOMTEK Ha HIDKHEM Beke seBoro rasa, CcaMHY Ha NpaBoM THIe4e, MloOCHATyIo CCAAMHY Ha CHHHe Ciena, CcAsMH B ToscHMMHOH OGaCTH cnpapa, CHyMeHHEIH IMANepMHE Ha TeBOM KOsIeHe H MpaBoH romeHH, WTO OTHIOCHTER K THOKKUM TeeCHLIM HOBPEXLACHHEM NO NPHSHAKY OTaCHOCTH AAR 2KUSHIH, OT KOTOPLIX nocneHHti ckouvastea. On xe, nocue copepuieniia BuIeyKasaHHOTO AOpoxHO-TpaHcHoprHoro MpoucuecTBHA, HMeHHO: COBepIICHHe ONPOKHABIBAHHA NPM YnPABAEHHM MOTONHKTOM c KOMACKOH MapKH «Hemp Il», » pesyasrare Koroporo HaxomuBuiuiien 8 KavecTe naccaxupa Merparuii JLA. nonysnn ‘TWOKKHE TeslecHBIe NOBPEKACHHIA NO MPHSHAKY ONACHOCTH UIA AKUSHH, OT KOTOPBIX cKOHasICA c UenbIO HsGerKAHHe YrONORHOM OTBETCTREHHOCTH OCTABHA MecTO tpaticnoprHOTO NpOHCUIeCTBHA 1 expsines. Jexo nocrynuao B cya no o6mteli mportenype, a a cyne6HoM sacenanut, np nponesenuH NpeapaprenHoro sacenaHua, MoxcyauMbil Nona cooTBeTeTBYIOIee saRBACHHe, B KOTOPOM ykasa1, #70 MpHsHaeT BHHY B IPeXBABICHHOM OOBHHEHUM u-TpeByer o paccMorpeHHH yrosoBHIONO Zena MO ynpowenHoii mpowerype, B coorsercrsum co cr.364 ' YIIK PM, Ha ocHosaHun RoKasatenbers, COGpaHHBIX Ha CTALHM YTOAOBHOTO MpeCHeLOBAHHA, 3AXBAeHHLIX NPOKypOPOM B CooTBETCTBYIOWNIEM CTHCKe, ¢ KOTOPBIMH OH O3HAKOMEH H He 2KeNaeT NPesICTABeHHA HOBLIX noxasatenscrs, Tlocne Buinonierua Bcex TpeOosaHnli, npenycMOTpenHBIX NoNOxKeHHAMM craTBH cr.364 ! YIIK PM, HeoGxogunsix sui yzonneTsopena xonaralicraa noneysMMoro, H MlocsIe MpoBepKH MaTepHaso8 esa, YA BUsHee ‘onpereseIme 0 npoBeeHNH eyAeGuorO pasGupaTembersa no Ynpomennoit poueaype 8 coorserersun co ct. 364 ' YIIK PM, na ocnosanun AOKAIATEAECTB, COOPAHHKIX Ha CTAAMM yrouJOBHOrO NpecHeAOBAHNE, H sacqyMIAN oKasaHHA HogeyamMoro, Koropuiti 6511 oNPoUeH No MpasHnaM Zonpoca cBHjteresR. Tloacyausenit Kererpauk Buraanii Huxoaaesu4t n cyje6nom saceranmn Buy NpHSHAN B MpexbABIeHHLIX OGBUHeHHSX, H HoKa3aN (1.1.208-210), «To 26 Max 2013 rona Bexepom Herpatuii J|.A. monomer x HeMy ¢ mpocsGol noexaTb c HMM 3a cHraperamu. On emy orkasaz, Ho Herparnii JA. nacroiivnso mpocun ero u cxasas, ¥to paGoraeT MHCTpYKTOPOM no BomnenHio B Kummese won cornacuaca. OHM cen Ha ero MoTouNKA «J{vemp 11> H noexann. Mertpetuii JLA. cen ® Kosscke, a on sa pysem. Kora oH rloexani 3a curaperamn Ha arocranuMio, TO OHM OnpoKHAyAMch Wa Mocty. Ero BsIKHHYNO Ha nonauy, a Vicrpatuli JA. cranes nox MoTouMKnoM. Tepeseprys MoToUMKs, oH yBuxen notepnesiero Merpatuit JLA.. KoTopsiii He MoNABAN MPH3HAKOB HSHH, NexAN HeNOABIOKHO, HY Hero IIa KPoBs H30 pra. OH, Menyrapuiucs, To NoTepneBunHT yMep, cxpsica ¢ mecra npectymieHHA.Ha Bonpocsi apokara noscHust, 4ro Kora oH cen 3a pymb, crpatuii JA. Gein oueHE npsHsiM. OH pres B TOT BeNep, To Metpatuit JLA. 1M BHHO H NlOoTOMy He paspeWiHn eMy CecTs aa pymp. Kora MOTOUMKN MepenepHysICS, OH yA B NONE H MOTepAN cosHAHHe, a KOTAA MpHUIEN B ceOs He NOMHUT. TakoKe OH OCH, YTO He CormaceH ¢ pasMepoM rpaxjaHcKOTO HcKa. Ha Bonpocsi npokypopa noscHHl, YTO Mepe TeM KaK cect 3a pyab OH ynoTpeOman CHMpTabie HAMHTKH, TO ECTS B TeMeHHe HA THA mMBO. KpoMe Toro OH He NPOXOAHN KypCH BOAICHUA HM HE HMeeT BOJMTEALCKHX mpaB, [locse coepulenHoro JITII y nero Guu Tenecusie Tospexjienua, a UMCHHO NpoGIeMa C TLIeYOM M OMlyxiia Hora. OH oGpalanca 3a MemMIUHCKOH TOMOMIsIO B GonBHHNY. J[elicTBHTeNbHO OH HeCKONEKO AHei OfpuLMaMsHO paboTaet aBTocsIecapem a apropasGopke HII «Kyztes Outer. Ha sonpocsr cya nocHn, To B TOT seHb OH BrepBLIe BHeN oTeprieputero Metparuit. Ox NoyoweN ¢ BEIMMBKOH 3a HX CTONHK H HovAN C HHMH OOuarées. TloTepnenUIHi nozomIen TOSHAKOMHTSCA C HMM, TAK KAK OHH OBiM B yTGonKAX HpMes «Popcar. Iocae caynsuseroes OW He CTA 387 Ha MOMOUIS, TAK KAK Heryranes. OH OTHee MOTOLUMKT HA Tone B cTOpOHY o.Bemrnos, a cam yuien JoMoli. Tose on e3qua 8 Kummues x pomutensam motepnesilero MpocHTs Npoulenve, oTBe3 MM MIpORYKTs mM Aan HM MpHMepHo 200 gosapon CILIA. Posurenn Notepnesurero s3an y Hero AeHErM M Nponykrsl. PosWTesIM MoTepneBUIeTO NpeMIOKHIH eMy onzaruT yenyru m0 nMposezeHMIO nOxopoH Ha cymmy 30 000 (rpHsUaTs THIeH) sea, Ox cornacnsica, HO CKa3as1, YTO CMOKET JaBaTb CHB MO YactaM. OgHaKo Ha cerogHaAHM JeHb xpome tex 200 (aBecTH) AOsU1apoB On HAYerO He Aa POAMTesAM HloTeprenero, Ha sonpoc ampoxata Lllasra A, nokasan, #To Ha cileneTaHn oH AelicTRHTeAsHO TOBOpHLA, 4TO sa pysiem cuen Hetparuii Jl, 10 ects gazan 1OxHBIe NOKazaHWA, TAK KAK HCTYraics, HO MOTOM NOMeHAN CBOM NoKasaHHa Han Mpapquesie. locne cnyunameroca OH NOSBORH Gpaty, YTOGBI OH pHeXan Ha NOMOMIB, H OHM BMECTe OTHEITH MOTOUMKI Ha Tone, OH pemlMsl, YTO NoTepreBUAtt mA BHHO, KOTAa OH K HeMY NOROUIeN, TAK KAK Y HeTO B pYKAX Onula naTHHTpORAR GaKIOKKA BUNA, ‘Tatoxe no coctosimio norepriesmiero 6s110 BHUAHO, TO OH BBINHBMIMi, C MaTepHasIbHEIM yuLepGOM 8 27 000 on cornacex, a MopansHstit yulep6 OH CMOKET BOSMECTHTH TONGKO HACTHYHO, TAK KaK CTOmBKO JeHer OH He cMOxer sapaGoTaT. C MOMeHTA HOXOpOH OH He NaaTH MarepHansHii ylep6, Tax Kax emy Gsi0 TpyaHO ¢ paGoToli. Tlorepnesunit Herparuit Anekeauap Asexceenu4 p cyge6uom aaceaamum noKasas (@.n211), 470 On nosTHOCTHIO NlomMEPAHBACT TPAAAANCKHI HCK H TIpOCHT ero yaoRNETROPHTS. Ha nonpocss ageoxara Ularsa A. noxcHun, To Marepuabubiii sarparst x cymme 27 342 ees OH nosreepaun HeKamu. Kpome Toro emy GbiT HaHeceH CHABHEIM MOpaNbHBIH yulep6, TAK KAK Of NeMHICA H NPHHHMAT ycrloKaNBaIoMINe JeKapcTea, K HCKY OH MPHIOKHN HOKASETENKCTBA TOTO, TO OH JeUHNICS, TO ECTS OSpaulasics B NONMKTNHHKY To MecTy 2kHTeIbeTBA, Tawoxe Ha sonpocst atgoxara Lllarsa A. TlOsCHHJ, 4TO HM OBLIM NOHeCeHEI MaTepHANBHBIE sarparsi, HanpHMep B Mopre on sanmatit 1700 sell, Ho Mex eMy He Am, a TONBKO 2aMHCAmH B axypHane. On He MOxeT zOKasaTs nloTpaveHHyIo cyMMY Kpome 27 000, Tak Kak Ha NloxopoHax O10 Mioro Hapony H GsiT0 Gomme MoTpaseHo never. Ha NOXOpoHaX ero MOKOMHOTO CBIHa GBiI0 OKOIO 280 NesIOBeK, ¢ KOTOPBIMK OH paGoTan, H TaKXe GLUT PONCTREHHUKH H coceaH, CHIH OKOHIHLL MYSBIKANBHYI0 LIKOMY, MYSBIKATbHYIO AKAEMHIO H NOHTEXHMYeCKHi yHMBepCHTET, TO ecTS y Hero sino MHoro zpy3eii H OHH OBLT Ha OXOpoHaX cBIHa. Ha ponpoost ansoxara Uusmoeur B.B. noseHiut, 470 jelicraHTenbHo noneysMMENi npHeDKaT gavan um 200 gonmapos, 40 sutpor euia u ogvoro Gapauka, TIpu ykasaHun cyMmsi MarepuansHoro yutep6a B paamepe 27 000 sei on He ykasa 200 aonnapos, TAK Kak 9aGb11. OH He MOXET CKASATS TOUHO, NloveMy OHH C KeHO! OMEMHLIN MaTepHANEHBIH yulep6 Ha 250 000 sei, Ha Bonpoc cya NOscHH, ¥TO MopalbHbIli Bpey 3aksOYAeTeA ATA Hero B TOM, YTO OH ToTepast pomHOro YemIOBeKa, TO ECT CHita, KOTOPEII AOIKeH ObLA IKEHATHCA Hepes TPH MecaLLa.Wccnezonan Marepnasts eda, W BHICTYIAB NOKaxAHNA NOgeysMMOrO, cya, cuHTaeT, HT ero Buia TlomTBepxKnacTeR MPeICTABNeHHBIMM MIPOKYPOPOM M MIpHHATSIMM nOstCyAMMBIM AOKasaTENLCTBAMH, & UMCHHO, IIPHSHATETBHBIMH MOKAGAHHAMH OJCYAMMOTO B CY, NPOTOKO:IAMHL ero fompoca Ha crajHH yroxoBHOTO npecieOBAHMK B KAYECTBe HOLOspeBaeMOrO H OGBHHEMOTO (2.2.37, 110), mporoxonom aonpoca norepnesuiero Metpatuii A.A. (11.21.29), mpoToKosaMH xonpoca ceuzereneit Ksipnipxux ILH., JJones C.U., Kourxogan B.K., Koukoaan B.A. (11.1,31, 32, 65, 87). Tak, norepnesunii Herparait A.A. wa cal yronoBHoro npecsieqosaHua noKasan (2.2.29), uo 25 max 2013 rona ero cin Juma Vetpatnii c Hesectkoli Puroii u ero 2xKeHol noexalH 8 r-Haguip-JIynra Ha asToroHKH, B kaYectse GonembuNHKOB. Yaxe 26 Man NODKEH GBia BIEXATE Ht OH, Tak Kak PeMOHTHPyeT CTOPTHBHBIe ManIHBI, KaK MexaHUK. 25 Mas nosBoHMN cbIH Juma TMpumepHo p 19 wacos n ckasam, 470 Bee B TlopsIKe M yake WoexaTH. Bonbunle cuIH He SOHN. B 5 acon TosBOHIIA ero 2KeHa M cKasana, TO cbIH [uM MepTB. On npiiexan B Yagup-JIyary, rae yaliaal, 470 ero CHIH TlorH6 B JUTTT. 3a pyss com Juma He caNMsICA, TOBKO 3a pynb aBTOMAIIMHEL, Y Hero MaulniiadPeHo-C4eHnk», BosMTeNbCKOe ynocTORepeHHe y cua ects. Juma paGoran B Tlomurexnmeckom nricturyte MivKeHtepom, a 3a0/1HO M ysnsica. CuiH He HIETPYKTOp Mo BOXACHHIO. On celiac rorosnsicn K saulute qunTOMHOM paGoTsI, MR HHCTHTYTe BEITORHAN YHKLMM mokevepa. Zyewta HeMHoro Gossies TPaHCTOPTHBIX cpenCTR, H OH JYMaeT, HTO OH He ceMl bi 3a Py. Motoumka, Congetenb Kiiperspanx ILH. xa craaun yronosioro npecaegosanua noxasan (11,0.65), ‘ro y Hero umeetes Gpat BriTanuk, on NpHOGper MOTOMMKA y CnaRbl, 2KHBET B ETO OMe HB ero nlonpeaue. Morouuest MT yepuioro tseta c KosltcKoll. BosTensckoro ysiocrosepeHia y Gpara eue net. OH KynM1 MoTOUMKA monrona Hasal, HO OH GBI B HepaboueM cocTosHMM BHavane. Aoxymenrsi ia morounen y Hero Gs1aH, 25 was 2013 roga Buranuk BHavae HaxoAMoR ¢ HMM Ha ABTOAPOME, TAM OHH TOTOBMACE B roTOBKe esi. BUTANHK yewkan H MmpHesKan, OM NOMOTIM Kyaeny Onery. Hem onm Gain BMecte, MoTONNKA gem BuTamHK octasHi Ha TeppuTopHn aprocepsica «Popcax» Kynesa Oxera H 6s11 NOCTOsIIHO ¢ HIM AHEM. Beepom OHM noexaNH Ha aprocepaic, ¥ToGbI OTPeMOHTHpoBaTS OnHY MauMHY. Kora 3aKOHMMJIM, TO MoexaTH Ha aBTORpOM, TaM enn H TMH BHHO. TloToM npHexan 3a MoToUMKTOM BuTamuKa, HOH 3a6pan MOTOLMKA Ha ABTONPOM, @ OH TloexaN Ha cBOeHi MaMIMHe Ha aBTOAPOM. BBO npuMepHo 24 vaca HOUN. TaM yrKe TO4TH Ace OTABIXAIH, OHM C BuTAANKOM cHIeMH No TeHTOM 3a cronoM. Ox npwexan paxbue Buranuxa w kya Burak npunapkosan motouMKs, oH He sHaeT. Ol He BHIeA, HO, BOSMORHO Buranwk nepewien 8 Ty nalaTky, THe 34 CTOAHKOM CHEM MoAH, HO TOYHO He sHaeT, KTO H ToruOuero napa He NOMHNT TaM, BOSMOXHO, TO H Obi. BUTANHK MOAOUed K HeMY H cKasaA, YTO OW OTbenET, HO Kysa He cKasA H Gui He O/H, HO C KeM He SHaeT, Gio TeMHO, Casilla, 40 Moroukn Burannka orbesxan ¢ astonpoma. Yepes 5-6 miityT nosBonua Ha MoGHAbHBIT TeneboH Buranuk H TpeBOXHLIM roOCOM NOpOCHL, YTOGKI OH MpHeXAT Ha aBTocTaNUNO. OH Nona, 470 caysiut0ce TO-To, u noexan B ropor, TIpoesxas epes MocT OH HHIETO He BUEH, TAK KAK exalt Gsetpo, cneuma K Gpaty. Uyrs aambuue Mocta B cTopory yaJIenMHa Buranvx ocraHoBua ero, MorowHka 6511 payloM. BuTarHK ckasas eMy, YTOOBI OH HE BBIXOAMI H3 MaLLMHI, OH WerseT Tpoc 4 HYAHO NoTAHYTE MOTONWK OH BILeN, NTO MOTONHKN HMeeT NORPEXNeHHA, PyAb NepeKoUIeH, sage Kpsi0 Mepexouleno. OH NORA, YTO cAySHIOCe NTO-TO, HO cHlavana He cnpautupan 40 unenHo, Buranuk Gbin Bos6yxKilel H CKaval, YTO HYHO OTBEITH MOTOUWEN Mowlambute, HTOBEI ero ke Haman, Out nouan, «70 Byraamx Hen 8 Biy NomMuelicKHX. OH MoyMam H peuIMn exath Ha «CoptceMosoup Ha Nose, TaM B 3apocmAX MACHMHBI OCTABHIM MoTOUMKA. BuTanHk culen Ha MoToMKse, y Hero O¥eHS Gonlena NpaBad pyka H Mpabas Hora, OH HlOHAL, TO ON Yrlan Ha MpaByro cTopony Tena. OHH BABOeM ceNH B MaMHy, BHTaIMK MHHYT MTs BOSHICA ¢ MOTOLUKTOM, ITO Aenan, OH He sHaeT, 3aTeM OHH yexann. Ilo popore on cnpocun y BurasuKa, H OH cKasam, ¥TO OH OnpOKMHysIca ¢ MaccaxHpoM, a HaccwKup yMep. BUTAHK ckaxaT, ¥TO NACcaKHp CHEN B KONACKE HKora OnpokuHy.iuce, Burak ckasa.t, 470 naccaxup Gin B KPOBH Hl MeprBuii # OM YOennuIeA, ¥To ou Mepreaili, B rlonHuHio H eKopyto oH He O6pamaes, Ox non, wo BHTasuk Xouer cKpLITE, HTO coseputnia JITTT, won emy He Boapasin. Y Buranka 6st WOK H y Hero Toxe. Ox orses Burrartike Aomoli, a cam Noexasl Ha aBTOCTaHUWo HTM ‘Tam kode 70 ytpa. Ha aptocranunn or monet on CzBUIIa, STO HA MOCTY COW eHOBeKa H JIEKUT TpYN, HO OH HHKOMY HHYero He ronopun, Ha ABTORPOM 8 TY HOUS OH He BosBpamasICS. C NOTHOUHM OH BHAKOM He GEIT, Aonpowennbili 8 kayectse eenaerens ones C.P. wa craaun yronontoro mpecnezonanua oxasar (1187), tro 25 Max 2013 roma Ha paGore noaysun sapnaary H © zpyrom OcrpHorno HiuxonaeM wa ero morownkne «Bukran) Hounio npuwepto 8 2 uaca noeXAIM ropod B Gap, oM Sapki ye Osim saxpsrrsi. On exe HOKpyr raaBHol yaMUM, Tak Kak Gein BBINMBILUM yKoMcomonsckas BbIexaT Ha MOCT B mapKe, KoTOpsIi BemeT Ha nome, re AOmKHBI OBL SpoxowUIT» aBToroHKH. [Ipoeska no MocTy co eropowst aBToapoMa yaJlenHMHa npuMepiio & 2 daca 30 Munyr HOW, OH YBune: JeKaMIerO HeHOBEKA, YBHIeM AYAY KPOBH Toa HUM, OM enyradtes Awke He OcTaHOBHICA H npoexan 10 yaJleHMHa. Ha aBTOCTAHLMH OH OAROHNA B TOAMUINO 1 cooGutun o HenOReKe. Bout OW AHBKIM HATH MepTBLIM OH He ata BHYaNt, ITOTOM OH BepHy.nea Ha MOcT, HO YaKe © paGOTHHKANH MomMUMH, NOKASAM HM enoBeKa. Tor nexan, Kak it ewan, omnuelickHe yBHUteAH, ¥TO OH MepTA H Y2ke XOsOAHI. O TOM, UTO Ha MocTY npoHsoUlAO ITT, om BHANaTe Rake He MOHAN, AYMAN, TO MyxHHY noGwIN. TloTOM ypuIen cHmeHBe © KonIcK ‘TuKeaoro MoTouUKaa THNa MT, vactH oF cTon saaHel dapti, KOH CHoMaHBIe, cilesb OT KoAee. Ox nouss, sro npowsomo ATI, Ho tparicnoprioro epecraa wa MecTe we Ouno. On TPCANOTORHA, WTO YeNOBeKA OHH AGO Ha MocTy, sIM60 OM BEITIAN 12 KONACKH MOTOMUAKIa, ‘estoseka on He yatian, oH 6x11 omer B KpacHylo MacTepKy H mloprsl, GocHKOM. Cennerea Kounconan B.K. p xoze yronosuoro npecaenopastus moxasara (3.1.31), 70 25 Max 2013 rona on ¢ MyxeM, xersmu, Herparuti J[wirrpiem, ero marepsio Caetnavoil, sesector Aust Prroii, npuexann a r.anup-JIynra Ha astoronku. [IpHexann on Ha «Curpoene» cunero peta «21 wacy. Octaosuznes Hanpotue Teppacs! Ha abTonpoMe. PasGunu nasarky, npurotosiin cnavibHble MeCTa, NoxkapHiTH Maco H noes. Ha Teppace ecTh CTOAMKH H TaM coOpamtce peGara, ee wy Kouona Bavecnas ¢ Herparuit uot noma x HM m saxeaTHnH naTunuposyio KaUHeTpY € BuHoM. [uma wepHysien, RBA KBIpHaLeM H MoMIeN K cTOMHKY ObparHo. Motown MepHoro luwera ¢ KoACKOHt MpHexar npuMepHO B 2 Haca, KTO Gui 3a pysieM, OHA He siaeT, Tant Guu Moro MaLINH, sOAM paGuBAMH NanaTKH, ea MHOO MO jopore. Beto Horo Gorembuykon unoroponsix. Ee myx cHten ¢ JJAMOlt 3a CTORHKOM € KAKUM-T0 HesHaKoMunt ch Myxcunnol, Kro elle Haxoanes 3a cToMKOM, o#a He aHaeT, Ona yenemaa xpHK c Teppacti: «Chasnk, celiac npueny, 2a curapetamu>. Ona suena, sro Juma Motparai wien MOTOUMKAY H Cel Ha MOTOWMKI 34H 3a BomMTenem, Camoro BOAHTeIA OHA B AMUO He BHZeNna. One Toxouuia K cromKy, Kora TuMa Ha MoTOWMKHIE Y2ke OTHeXAN, H TlOMHAIA MAA, UTOGH OH Lie: cna, Ee Myr Cle 3a CTOIMKOM ¢ Naptiem B Oca0H dytGonke i cue Kyprke H oH GopostaTeat napeHs, rpssHo ovetsiit, Myx nowien ¢ Heli chars, Mark JIvMbt ToxKe cabimaita, Kak oTBesiKalt ce Ch Ha MoTOUHKse, Ovia ocranacs © MaMoii JJuMar xaars ero. OHM MOxOXAAM HEKOTOPOE BpeMA, & TOTOM NOWIM Ha Teppacy cnpocHTs, Kak HaltrH BomHTeNA MoTO\MKTA, Tax KaK J[uMa noexan Ges MoGuutbHOrO Tesespoua. Ha Teppace vesoReK B cuelt KyprKe ckanan, ¥O J[wMa Yexan ¢ naptient Spacholi kenke wa KoManigs: Kyaepa. Oru ¢ MaMofi Just noua K MawuNe H 2eaamH, Tpoxann Fae-TO wae, H Mars JtaMb Houta No Aopore B ropost, Haesch nowperHTs Jumy. Mars JTustst TOsBOHWIa H CKadavta, YO Hata JJMMY H OH BECK B KPOBH Ha Jopore, Korga ona Mpuusto, To yenaeia paSorHnkos noamuun 4 tpyn Jambi Metpatuii na Mocty. Oua He Moxer cxasare. Tuma Callies B KONACKY WIM Mo3AqH ROMMTENA, HO OHH yeakann BjBoeM. JluMa Goin HeMvoro B SocrOmMMH axKOrombHOrO OnbaKeHUA. Kora MOTOMNKA Yexas, TO OF He CHBILIATA TIO aByKy, ‘T0Gs! MoTOWK: OcTanaBTHBalca. JJaMa He Cras GbI cpemH Nona B cocTosHuH anKoronsHoroONBANEHHA CARHTECR 98 PysIb YY>KOTO Tpaxicnopra, TeM Gostee B uyAKOM roposte. Moxker ckasatb, ‘#70 wa Teppacy [ua nomen Gocuxom, Gsut B Woprax u B KpacHOH MacrepKe. Conzete» Komoaan B.A. » xoze yronostioro npecienoasia noxasana (1.2.32), 470 25 was 2013 rona ox ¢ cynpyroii, ners, Hctparuit Jbaurpuest, ero matepiio Cnetnarioh, seoecrol Avoia Pioii, npvexant & r-Magup-Jlynra Ha avroronxn, Tipvexan onn na «Curpoene» canero upeta x 21 wacy, OcraHoBnmucs Hanpotas teppacet Ha aprompoMe. PasGuH nanarky, npHroTosHim cnauibibie MecTa, NO‘apHuIH Maco M Nem. Ha Teppace ECT CTOMKH Ht TaM cOGpazlice peOaTa, oF nomen tyaa ¢ Tjamoli Hetpatui, saxsatue natwutponyto Kanuctpy c BuHiom, JluMa Opi Gocnkom, B mlopTax, oparnxenolt dbyTOosIKe H MacTepKe KpacHoro upeTa. OHH Bratiane CHARM c peGaTamu- PaGoriukaMi Teppacs), buunnBam. ZuMa He xoTen, ¥TOOS MATH BUENA, 0 OH KYpIt, NOSTOMy ox owe wa Teppacy. Moroumk npuiexar, Korna OHM cHiteaM Ha Teppace. OH BEEN B TyANeT, Korma BepHy.Ics, TO 3a CrOsHKOM YBHNEN TPex HesHaKOMBX peGaT, OHM roBOPHH ¢ JAMOl o HEM. To. On Cen 3a CTO H TYT OHH NapeHs, KAK OH NOHAN TIOTOM, BOAUTe:T MOTOMNK:Ia BcraN 4 Hotlen x Morouuialy. Tusa cnpocis ero, KyMla M napeHb ckasan, Yo exert 8 Topo M Honpocitn, wToGst NapeHb Baan ero c coGoii, Tak Kak xoveT KynuTs cHrapeTs. MoTouMKT G5Ln ye 3apenen bomuTesiew, xoraa Jtuwa eMy kpivait npo curaperss. Ou eute oTrosapusaa JlmMy, sT06 He exan, Tak kak syxoll ropon H saat Hunty sa pyky, Ho Jana orromkiya ero M yillen K MOTOLUNKY 1 on Bupoem yexann, Juma cen sa BosuTenem Ha MOTOWHKA Heute ckasan JuMe, uTOGu om con a KOMACKY MOTOUIMKUIA, HO OH CKasaT eM, YTO He XONET, TAK KAK B KOMICKE 2xeCTKO. Ox TONE K Mycune w3 Kiumtiena, Kak 3onyr, He sHaet. On yrocraa ero auHoM. Bsin elle oxHH TpasHO OneTuiit MYAHHHa, HO He 3a HX CTOTHKOM, ON XOAHI M NONPoWAliHMNAT NO cTonMKaM. CKoAEKO GuuIO EpeMen, on He sHaer, Tak Kax BKInHA. TyT npuuina xeHa Bana u nosmata ero cnare. On eff cxmsaa, uro Tuna celivac npuzer u ona Havama ero pyrars, 470 on oTnyeTaa Jlumy. 3a pyaw Norountaa Twa cecrs we Mor. Ou suze, To nwa ceN 32 BoAITeMeM H MOTOLKN pesKo CHsiyTes € Mecra Ha GombioH ckopocTH, Ma He MOF CecTb 3a Pym 4YxKOTO MoroLicna HM exatte no uy?kiiM AoporaM.. Eoan Husa saxoten OxiTb sa py.tem MOTOLINKA, TO O cpasy nonpocan 661 y BomurTeaa py.tt, Ho T[vMa sa pyneM MAEM He eS HHKOTAB, OH GI CaM He cen 3a pyzs. Ox BeIMIUIK Ha Teppace 1,5 mHrpa sHHa. ITM 2M BAHO ¢ HUMH BONMTER MOTOWMKNA ON He payen. Xower AOGaBiTs, TO TAM, Ha MlopopoTe OH BUCH, YTO MOTOILHKN HaKpeHMCH, 1 Konnexe TOAHAACS, ckopocTs Stina Gonsmas. Or Teppactt 0 Mocta merpos 400 m npeojomeTe. Ha MoTouMKae sto paceToste ¢ TaKofl cKopocTBio O11 Mor 3a 1-,15 MUTE. Kpome toro suta noncyauMoro noxTeepayiaeren caexyloMINMH AOKASATeTBETRAMH: = NPOTOKOOM OcMOTPa Mecra jopoxtoro npoucmectsHA oT 26 Maa 2013 roma m orora6mmuant x Hemy (2.0.4-11), ~ oxemoit x JITTT (2.0.12), < RPOTOKOOM OEMOTPa Hl NPOBEPKH TEXKUYECKOTO COCTOSFIHK MoTOLKAA MapKH «btenp Ib xonsexoii u dorota6mnuamn K HeMy (1.0.45-50), ~ MPOTOKONIOM OcMoTpa Mecra MponcuiecTBHA H doToTAbAMUAMH K HeMy oT 26 mas 2013 roma (1.0.51-57), sakiowenent Cyne6Ho-MeamuMHCKOK oxcnepruset Ne 76 oT 31 waa 2013 roa, wa KoTOpOtt cueayer, TO cepts rpaaanuna Herparait JA. 26 apapa 1987 roma poxenua Hactyniia or OTKPBITOH YepeMHO-MosTOBOli TpaBMBI: KPOBOHSAUSHHe B MarKHE MOKPOBBI TOBE B AO6HOM oGnactH cnpasa H npaBylo BUCOYHYIO MBILY, OckKombUATBIH mlepenom YeutyH npazoii BucowHoi KoctH, JHHeHHBH nepenom B saqtieli NepenHOl aMKe, sIMHHA KOTOPOTO Apecekaet nupamuaky Upapolt BicouHol! KOCTH, TypeUKOE ceATO H MHpaMtUAKY ERO! EUCOMHOH KOCTH, Obpasya ier, CooOulaioutyiocs co epeauua yxoM cnpana H exexa; cyGayparbiyio FeMaToMy cripaa ¢ nepexonoN Ha OcHOBAHHE MOSTa H TIO] MOKeYKOBBIli HAMET, OTCK-HADYXAHHe TONOBHOTO MOSra ¢ BTMHEHHEM MPOXONTOBATOTO Mosra B GosblllOe 3aTELNONHOe OTBEPCTHe, OCTPAA MosrOBAN HeOCTATONHOCTS.Tipn vccneqosanun tpyna OOHApyxKeHEI TAKE: SAKpEITBIH MHOTOOCKOALYATHI MepetOM Tena 1 AYrH Mpapoli ckyn0BoH KOCTH, KPOBONIOATeK BOKPyF NpaBoro rasa, ccanMHB! MpaBoil NONOBHHBI SIMUa, KPoBoMOgTeK Ha HIPKHEM Beke JIeBOTO TWla3a, CcanMHY Ha MpaBoM mieYe, MoTOCuATYIO ccamwHy Ha CNHHe cieBa, CCAMMHbI B HOACHHYHOM OGnACTH CHpaBa, cayUleHHbIH oMMepMHc Ha seBoM KoreHe M npapoli ronen. Bee BbIIeOMMcaHHBIe TeNecHBIe MOBpeXKIeHHA NpHYMHEHEL uelicrsvem TBepgoro TYNOTO MpesMeTa BOSMOXKHO B CPOK H MIpH OGCTOATENILCTBAX, YKASAHHEIX B HaNpaBneHHn; ¥ 2HBLIX IHL TAKHE TeNecHBIe MOBpERAeHHA MOraH GbITb OTHECeHEI K KateropHH ‘DOKKHX [lO MPHBHAKY ONACHOCTH ALIA HGH. YUNTBIBAR XaPAKTep, AOKATHSANMO NOBpeX eH H o6ctontenscrea jena cunTato. 4TO BeposTHee Bcero B MomenT J{TTI Mcrparuii JLA. xaxonuaca B Kolacke MOTOUMKIa, YUMTEIBaX THKECTH YeperlNO-MO3rOBOli TPaBMBI, CUMTACT, 4TO CMepTh Vitpatuit JLA. nactynwia Gsicrpo 4, axe mp OKasaHMM eMY BDICOKOKBANMDULMPOBAHHOH M CHeuManMsMpoBaHHOl MeAMUMHCKO! MOMOMM, BPA JM yslaNOch Obi W3GexKaTb cMepTeNbHOrO uexoga (11.181), = MPOTOKOsIOM OeMOTpA MpeAMETOB, MOTOUMKTA H GoToTAGAHHANH K HeMY (1.1,96-103), = sakmoueHnem cyaeOHo-MeAMUMHCKOlt axcnepTHast Ne 362 oT 15 mous 2013 roma (s1.-111)- WG auasivaa netmenpHnerenHnix soxasaTembeTs yemMaTpunaeres etestyromtee. Cygom ycraHosneHo, vro sua noncyammoro Keipsipxnk B.H. 5 npembannennux OGBHHeNMAX MOMMOCTHIO NORTREPKARETCA HE TOsBKO NPHIMATENBHBIMI OKASAHHIMH NONCYAEMOrO Ha cyse6HOM 3aceaHiH, HO H MOKASAHHAIMH BBIMIeYKASAHHEIX CBHLIeTENeH, KOTOPKIC ABLIAOTCR TlocnevORATeNbHEIMH, COOTHOCHTCA C /IPYTHMH OKAsaTeABeTBAMM jHeHa, a TAKE BUIILICTIepesHICHEHHGIMUL NMCEMEHHBIME 1OKA3ATEECTBAMH N10 Jest. Tax, Tor aKr, 470 nostcyzMMetH Ketpsrpxuk BH, 26 maa 2013 roaa npamepHo 8 02 vaca 30 MHHYT, HaXOJACb B COCTOAHMM A/IKOTONBHOTO OIBAHEHHS, YNPABIAA MOTONMKOM ¢ KORACKOH Mapkn «J{uenp 11», apurasics B r-Maguip-Jlyxra nto qopore no HanpaBaeHwio oT aBrojpoma k yauue Tlewnsa, npn npoesze no Mocry epes pesky Jlynra, 8 HapyureHHH TpeSonasuit mwT.a) v.14 1.45 oT 27 uiona 1999 oma, He yHen nopoxuyio OGcraHoBKy HM JOPOXHBIE YyonOBHs, cBOe NCHXOGHONOrHYeCKOe COCTOSHMe, KOTOPOe BIHAeT Ha BHUMAHHe W peaKiyilo, a TaKKe cBOii ROMMTEAIBCKHE OMT, NOBRONALOLUHH NPOTHOSHpOBATS OTIACHBIe CHTYALIMH H, TIPEBLICHB Gesonactyto CKOpOCTS ABMKEHHA Ha HAHHOM YHACTKe JOpOrH, He CHpaBMAcA C yrpaBNeHWeM H cOBepUIKA OnpoxubiBaHMe, B pesyqbTaTe Hero HaXOMMBUIMticn B KaNecTBe naccaxnpa Merpatuit JA. TOAYSUA THKKHE TECHIE MOBPEXKACHIIM TO MpHSHAKY OMACHOCTH ANA -KMSHH, OT KOTOPBIX TOcHenHHi CKOHMaNIC, a TOCH® COBEpUICHHA BBILIeyKasaHHOrO jJopoxXHO-rpaHeniopTHoro MPOMCUIeCTBHA, C HebIO W36exaHHe yronOBHO!{ OTBETCTBCHHOCTH OCTABHN MecTO TpalicnopTHOrO MPONCUIeCTBHA H CKPBUICH, NOATBEPIKMACTER KAK MOKASAHMAIMH NOJCYAMMOTO, TAK H HOKAsAHHAMH notepnenmero u caugereseti. V3 mporoKona ocmorpa MecTa jopoxHoro MpoxculecTaus, a MMeHHO KaHasa Haxogupuieroct 3a A3C Ha Mocty, Beaymem Ha aprogpom r.Yajbip-JIyHra yemarpunaerca: Hanmune pasGUTbix 4acTell ABTOTPAHCTOPTa - CH/IEHEE OT KONACKH THDKEsTOTO MOTOLMK:IA YepHOTO UuBera, TpaHICHOpT HeHSBECTeH, MpeMMONOKUTENEHO MOTOUMK:T; TPYN MYAYHHBL, HAXORMBIMHHCA Ha Mpoesxeli ¥acTM Mocta ronopoli B cropony yaJleHuHa Ha cnuHe (Tpyn oner B dyTGoMKy c PYKABAMH KpacHoro URETa, MaCTepKy KPACHYIO, WIOPTHI TeMHO CHHero BETA, Ges OGyBH. TaIOKe Ha MOCTY psJIOM ¢ TpynOM rpaxksanuna erparuii JIA. MMeloTea AMKH CO CieAOM 103a OT KOsIeC tpauicnoprnoro epenctaa. Kiioux oT TpaHcnoprHoro cpejicrBa narialoTes Ha MOCTY HemaIeKO OT ‘pyna. Creda 3axkHraHHa OT TpalicHlopTHoro cpeycTBA HaXO,HTCA BO3Ne NpaBoll HOrM TpyNa. Kpome toro, #3 mpoToKona OcMOTpa HM MIpoBePKH TeXHHYeCKOTO COCTOSHHA MOTOUMKIA Mapku «J{nenp 11» ¢ KONACKOii YeaTpHBaeTes jebopMupoBaHHAR YacTs MoTOUWKHA, NepenHHii Gouaps, nepegan BMKA BOrHyTa BHYTPS, KONscKa Aeopmuponana. Ha navienM npHGopos OGnapykeHst cr1ens1 Kpactio-Syporo uBeTa, NOXorKHe Ha KpoBb. Ha KOIACKE MOTOLWKTa HMeIOTCACHEB CKONDKEHIA KONACKH (HANPUMEp, NH ONPOKHALRAHNN Ha accanst). SagHHii ra6apHTHi cbouaps Kpactoro wsera pas6ur (nosperkzen). He ucrpasHa Jocka mpu6opos, pacnomoxKeHHad Ha nepesieli puke MoTouMK:a. TIpHGopHas zocKa 7eopmuponata, OrcyTcTayeT oaeMeHT cHeHHA Konacku (1 urr.). Taroxe 13 saxmoyenme cyreGHo-meMuMHCKOH 9koneprHast Ne 76 or 31 mas 2013 rome, yomarpusaetes, To cmepTs rpaxqanuHa Hetpataii JA. 26 annaps 1987 rona poxnenns HaCTYTIMAa OT OTKPBITOH NepenHO-MOsTORO!i TPABMBI: KPOBOMSHAHHe B MAPKHe MOKPOBEI TOsIOBBI B AOGHOH OGNACTH CMpABa H MpaBy!O BHCOHYIO MBIMILY, OCKOMbYATEIH TIepeTOM eUIyH npaRoi BHCOYHOH KOCTH, sIMHeliuBIH nepesIOM B samuel YepenHol AMKe, AMHHA KOTOporo mpeceKaeT MMpaMHAKy Mpagoii BUCOUHOH KOCTH, TypeUKOe ce;IO M TMpaMMAKY seBOH BHCOUHOM KOCTH, oGpasys ules, cooGua1oMlyIocs CO cpemHM YxOM cMpaba M cileBa; cyOAypansHyio reMaToMy cmpana ¢ Tepexo/loM Ha OCHOBAHHe MO3Ta H 110 MOsxKe“KOBBIHi HaMeT, OTeK-HaOyxaHMe TOnOBHOTO MOSra C BK/INHEHHeM NpOAOsITOBATOTO Mosra B GombiliOe 3aTsIMONHOe OTBEpCTHe, OCTPAX MosTORAR HegoctarouHocts. TIpH HccHesoBaHHH Tpyna O6HAapyXeHEI TAKE: 3AKPBITBIM MHOTOOCKONBYATHIA mepeniom Tesa M JyrH MmpaBoi CKyTOBO! KOCTH, KPOBONOATEK BOKPYT MpaRoro riasa, ccayMHbl Npapoli NonoBHHBI AMA, KPORONO;TEK Ha HIKHEM BeKe JeBOTO TIasa, CcaMHY Ha TIpaBOM MIe4e, Nosocwaryio CcamHHy Ha CMHHe CHeBa, CCARMHBI B TlOSCHMUHOM OGNACTH cHpapa, cayWeHHEA OMMJepMHC Ha NeBOM KOseHe H MIpaBoii roneHH. Bee BEINICOTCAHHBIe TeIeCHLIe MOBPEXxICHUA MpWuHHeHBI JelicTBHEM TRePLOTO TYTIOTO NMpe Mera BOSMOXKHO B CpOK H Mp oGcToRTeMBCTBAX, Yyka3aHHBIX B HAmpaB/leHH; y XKHBBIX JMU TAKHe TenecHBle MOBPeXK/eHMA MOTH OBIT OTHECEHEI K KQTerOpHH TAKKHX MO MPHSHAKY OMlAcHOCTH WIA HSH. YSHTEIBAL XapakTep, JOKAMHIALWMIO Tospexksenuii H OGcTOsTesIsCTBA esa CHHTAIO. ¥TO ReposTHee Bcero B MomeHT J{TTI Vetpatuii ILA. waxoquies 8 Konsicxe MoTouMKa. YaurTsiBaa THKECTS “eperlHo-MOsTOBOH TPABMBI, CHLITACT, uro cmeprs orparwii JLA. actynuaa Gsictpo H, ake TIpH OKasaHMM ey. BEICOKOKBAIIHCpHIUNPOBANHOH H CHIeLWAIHSHpORAHHOK MEAUUWECKO! HOMOML, BPAA J yslaTOC OBI waGexaTs eMepremsHoro exon. Tawxe cyoM yoraHosneHo, Yo noxcyauMbit KepsipxuK B.H. 01 centaGps 1989 roma PoxeHH, Ho cTostiio Ha 12 mona 2013 roma BomMTeNBcKOe YOcTOBepeHME He NOAy¥aN, TO TlogTaepxnaeres enpapKoli Havanbunka P3O r.Yansp-JIynra P.Kansin, Takum —o6pai0M, —BBIILIEYKasaHHBIMH = JOKARETENKCTRAMM =—-M_—_-yoTAHORNEHHBIMH OGcrosrenscrsaMH NO jeNy B NOTHOM OGBEME TOATBEPAACTCA BHHA MOACYAHMOTO —B TPebABTEHHBIX eMy OGBHHEHHAX. OGcyaaas Bonpoc o KBAMM>UKaNHH CONeMHHOrO, Cys MPHULEN K BBIBOAY, TO AeHiCTBHA nogcyaumoro Knasipaux Buranuit Huxonaesw cneayer keannpuuuposath no 4.(4) er.264 YK PM, kak napymieume mpania Gesonacnocru gBuaxeuna TpanenoprHbIx cpexeTR ANUOM, YMpABASHOMUM TPAHCHOPTAKIM cpeTeTROM, MORJeKUIeC CMCpTh “eIOReKA, CORepUIEHHOE B CocrostiMl OnbsneHms, HocKonsKy oH, 10 seKaGpa 2013 rosa ripumepHo B 17 acon 50 MunyT, ynpasaan asrowammoit Fiat Uno p.x. CG AE 863 no ya.JIenua ¢ Kuper-JIyxra, a vapyuteniit na) ¥.2) n.10 # na) 1.14 Tpapua JopoxHoro aBwxeHia, GyayHN AMMIeHHBIM Mpaza ynpaaneHHs ‘TpaHCTOPTHKIMM CpexeTBAMH H HAXO/AC B COCTOSHMM CHABHOTO ATKOTOABHOTO OMbAHeHHA, a MMeHHO ¢ KoHLeHTpauHeli apoB ANKOTONH B BEULEIXAeMOM BO3YxXe B KONMYeCTBE 0,95 mr/.I. Tanke retictens rloneyauMoro Kupuipknk B.H. cneayer Keanuduyuponars no 1.266 YK PM, kak ocrapaenue Mecra Tpanenoprioro mponecitecraus sHyoM, ympanasiomum TpAHCHOpTHBIM cpeNCTROM HM HApyIIMBMHM = mMpaRita GeaonacHoeTH ARIEL ‘TPAHCHOPTBIX CpeACTB, B PesyabTAaTE KOTOPOTO HACTYMMAA CMEPTh HeMOBEKA, MOCKONDKY OF MOCHe cOnepIIEHHA BEILIeyKASAHHOTO jOpOXkHO-TpaxcOpTHOTO NPOHCIICCTBHA, a MeHHO: COBepILEHHE ONPOKHABIBAHHA IPH YnPABMeHHH MOTOUMKIOM ¢ KOsICKOH MapKH «]Iuenp 11>, B pesysrare KoToporo Haxoquammniics B KayecTBe accexkHpa Merparuit J[.A. nonysin TsoKKHE‘renecBle MoBpexiLeHHA TO NPHSHAKY ONIACHOCTH ANH KUSH, OT KOTOPLIX CKOHUANEH ¢ KETO usGexaHMe YyroiOBHOl OTBETCTBEHHOCTH, OCTABHT MecTO TpaHcHopTHOrO MpouculecrBua u expeuca. Pemias ponpoc o HasHAYeHHM HaKkasaHna BHHOBHOMY Keresipaxnk BH., cya yuntoipacr ‘XT COBepIIEHHBIX MpecTyreHHi, WX MOTHBEI, cTereHb OOtlecTBeHHOM onacHocTH cofesmHoro, OGcTosTenscrwa lena, ANWHOCTS BHHOBHOTO, cNaryaloMMe M oTaryaromHe oGcrosresscrBa. OGutectuenian onacHocts sakmouaeres B Tom, YT noscyauMelt Kepsipanx BH. copepunnt oKOHeHHbIe NPeCTyHIeHHs, MpecmeayeMBIe YFOOBHLIM 38KOHOM. Kpone Toro cyst YUNTBIBAeT AHHBIe O sINYHOCTH TloneyANMOrO, TO OH paliee He CyaHM (1.4.89), no MecTy 2KHTeNDCTBA XapaKTepHayeTeA MOcpeNCTBEHHO, CIMPTHRIMH HaNHTKAMH He gnoynotpeGaser, OStlaeToa ¢ JINIAMH pallee CYAUMBIMH, BeslyWIMM aHTHOSMeCTREHHEI O6pas 2kIGHH, CKTOHEM K COBEpLIEHAIO npecTyneNHt (3.2,94), oO MecTy pa6orsI XapaxTepusyeTca TOAOKUTENBHO: LOOpsIH, OTSLIBYNABIH, Acerta NPHXOAUT B TpyAHyIO Munyty. Huxorsa ne 6x11 gaMeueH B TVIOXHX JEAHMAX WIM NOXOIKACHHAX, He HME BEIrOBOpOB. MMen xopourii noTeHUMAA H paspupanca B cBoeli JerrenbHocrn (1.1.164), Ha yeTe y rlcwxHaTpa W HapKosora He cocTOHT (4.2.90, 91). B xavectse cMar4arouiux orRererneuHocTs OGeTosTesbeTs, corsiacho cr.76 YK PM, cy YUNTIBaer, 4TO TOCYAMMEI BHHY NPH3HAT, YHCTOCEPeYHO PACKARICR B CO/CAHHOM M xogataiictaosa| 0 nposeyleHMH cyseGHoro pasGupareubcTea Ha OCHOBAHHM joKasaTeNbCTB, coBpannbix Ha craqHH yrooBHOro MipecrenoBall. ‘Taloxe mpH Ha3HayeHMH HakasaHHa Cys yYMTBIBAcT HANMHHe y NoAcyAMMOTO KiBEIPAHK B.H. | (oauoro) Heconeputentontetuero peGerca. Orarsaiomnx oGcrosTenbers cyjJOM He ycTaHoBeHO. B coomeememeuu c wacmoio (8) cmameu 364 ' YIIK PM noxcyammomy, KoTopsiii MpwsHarca 8 COBEpUIeHHH jesHMi, YKASAHHBIX B OGBHNHTENDHOM saKmOYeHHH, M notpeGoRAN mponenenua cyneOHoro pasOupaTeascTea Ha OCHOBAHHM OKa3aTeLCTB, COGpaHHBIX Ha CranHH YronoBHOTO MpecHe7ORAHA, HA TPeTb COKPAMaloTeH pee MPeAYeMOTPEHHOTO SaKOHOM HaKAZAHUGL B cya NPHTOBOPA K AMUEHIO CHOCO! WAM HeOTWIAHMBAeMOMY TpyAY B TONEY oSulectea H Ha YeTBEPT COKPAMLAIOTeH Mpesesthl MpeAYCMOTPCHHOTO 3aKOHOM HAKAgAHHA B cayaae HasHayenna urrpada. EcaH saKoHoM mpeayeMOTpeHo HakasaHHe B BH NOXHsHeHHOTO aKHOUeHHA, NPHMEHACTCA HAKASAHHE B BHLIE AIUeHHA cBOoGOREI Ha cpoK 30 eT. Ha ocnonanu waoxenHoro, cy mpauiéa K BEIBORY, 4TO ¢ yHéTOM cTeNeNH oSmectnenHoli omacHocTH AelicTBHit oslcyAUMOTO, ¥TO OH Patlee He CyANM, JaHHEIX o sINIHOCTH HoxcyAMMOrO, HAMICINA CMATUALONUNX H OTCYTCTHHA OTATHALOWWHX OGCTOATENKCTB, TO MOBENCHHA bo BPEMA H NOCHE COBEpULeHHA MpECTyMMIeHHs, OTCYTCTBHIA HCKIOMMTENbIAIX OGCTONTEMLCTE NO ery, AaOuWX ocHOBAHMe JIA MpuMenennA cr.79 YK PM, u orcyretas ocHosanuit sa pmnenenna cr55 YK PM, To 8 gailHom cayyae, cro uenpannenHe M jlocTIOKeHMe Ueneli Hakasalma, mpenyemorpeHuBix 4.(2) cr.61 YK PM, 34 copepuicue mpectynmenHs, BOsMoxHO TIpH HasHANeHHM TIONCYANMOMY HakAsaHA B BULIe THINEHHS cBOGORK, ¢ yueTOM monoxeHHs sacra (8) crarbu cr. 364! YIIK PM. B To oke pens, ¢ YYETOM BBIMeYKAZAHHBIX CMsTUBIOUNHX OGcrORTEMTLCTB, Cyst MpHMIEN K BbIBORY 0 HetleecoOSpasHocTH OTGsIBAHHA BHHOBHEM KerBuIpxHK B.H. vasiaveHHoro HakasaHHA B BIN TMUIeHHA CROOK, HOCKOLKY HETpABNeHHE H MepeBocrHTANHe MosICyAHMOTO BOSMOAKHO Gea ws0sKUIMH ero OT OGUIECTBA, H MOITOMY BOIMOXKHO NpHMeHHTS K Hemy er. 90 YK PM, B COOTRETCTRHH © KOTOpOH, HAsHAveHHOe HaKASAHHE B BAe AMICK CBOGOAM He MIPHBOAHTS B UcrlonHeHne, ECT 8 TeHeHHe HeriuITaTeNbHOTO CpOKA OH HE COBepUIMT HOROTO MpecTynaeHHA H pHMepHiM oBesleHHeM H YECTHBIM TpyzOM OnpaBAaeT OKAsAHHOe EMy {OBEpHe.Paccmorpes ck notepnesmero Herparuii A.A., cya cuntaer, wr on noanexur yaonneTaopeniio B nanan. B coorsereraun c 4(1) c1.1398 TK PM sul, KoTopoe BHHOBHO coBepmHo Hempanomepnite jleicTaHA To OTHOMIEHMIO K APYFOMY AMUY, OGH3AHO BOIMeCTUTE UMYULeCTREHHBIT BPes, @ B MpeAYCMOTPeHHEIX 3aKOHOM cHy'YaIX — TAKE HM MOpAMbHBI Bpes, NPHYHHeHHBIE aeiictsvem WH Gesgelicranem, Kak vcxoquT 13 mpouMTHporaHHoli BEIe HOpMbI 3aKOHa, OOULMMH ocHOBAHHAMH JeAMKTHOK OTBeTTREHHOCTH (TO ECTS BCNeNCTEKe NpHuMHeHHA Bpega) sBAsOTCA: yulep6, HenpaboMepHoe jlesHHe, TIPHMIMHHAA CBS MeKIy HenpanoMepHEIM eae M TpHUMHEHHEIN yillep6oM 1 BHHOBHOCTS Hla, CoRepLIMBIerO HerIpaBoMepHBIe feVicTBHA. OriiocutembHO HenpanOMepHOCTH JeaHHA =H -BHHOBHOCTH TlogeynHMoro ero coBepUIMBMcro, cyfe6Hax MHCTAHIMA BbICKASATACS BEIIe, OTHOCHTENBHO NPHYHHHOM cBAH Mek HEpABOMepHEIM AeRHHEM H TIPHNMHeHHIEIM yulepGOM, cyseGHAK HHCTAHLMA ycraHoBHa, ro yulep6, TpeGyemstli © rpaxnaHcKUM CTUOM, ABISeTCA pesyiIbTaTOM COBepUICHHA HerlocpencTBetiHo sanpeuleHHOro YronOBHbIM 38KOHOM jleRHHS. OruocurembHo pasMepa yutep6a, notepnesmmm Verparuii A.A. sapien vcK Ha BUBICKAHME MaTepHauIbHOTO Bpena, KOTOPBIH OH OUeHHBaeT B 27.342 (ABARUATS CEMB THICRY TpHCTA copox ipa) nes 36 Cau u MopaibHoro Bpena B cymMe 250 (quecTH naTHAecaT THICAY) seeR, TOsTOMY HCXOJA 3 MIPHHUHTIOB PasyMHOCTH, mponopuHoHaMsHOCTH mM HeOGXOgMMOcTH BOCCTAHOBEHHA COUMAMBHOM crIpaBesLIMBOCTH, CyseOHAX HHCTAHUMA B COOTBETCTBHH co cr.225 YIIK PM cunraer HeoOxoqMMBIM YqOBNeTBOPHTE ero B MpHHUANe ¢ MocmeAyIOULUM peMeHHeM Bompoca 0 pasMepe omaraioulerocs BOSMeILIEHHS B IIOpSsIKe FPAKNAHCKOTO CyLONPOHSBONCTRA. B cBA3H C STAM Cys PASBACHAeT MpaBo MloTepHeBUero NPeLABHT HCK K TlOeyAHMOMY B Mlopsike rpaxxraHicKoro cysAonpousBoACTEa. Mepy npecevenust 8 orxouenHn Kepbipxux BH. 8 sage nognuck 0 HeBBIese HS ‘MecTHOCTH (11.11.73), OCTABHTb MPexXHIOIO J10 BCTYTUICHHA NPHTOBOpA B 3aKOHHY!O CHITy. Bemectsennpie 1oKasaTenberea 110 Jeu1y B Bue: = MoTOUHKNa MapkH «J{wenp Il» 6e3 r.w.3., Haxogsiuulica Ha xpanenum B Uanbip- Jlynrexom HIT, cya npailien K BsBOAy BepHyTs mo npuHagnexnoctu Byrkyc Bayecsapy Tasnosuuy; ~ cHeHKe MepHOrO UBeTa, CBeYY 3AKUTAHA, HAXOMAMIMeCR B KaMepe xpaHeHua BeUleCTBCHHBIX OKAsATeNBCTB uHCMeKTopaTa nonauAH Yassip-Jyxra (1.1112), cya npHuien K BEIBOAY BepHyTS lo npHHaIexHOCTH Byrkye Bavecnaby Tasos ~ CHOMAHHBI KIO, MOcKoryGusl, MaYKy cHrapeT ¢ 3aKHTANKOH, macTHKOByto Gyrbinky wo-r0 BogBI, YacTH cTON-hapél, HaXOgAMIeCA B KaMepe XpaHeHHIA BeUleCTBeHHDIX Hokasatensers wucnexropara nosmunn Yagpip-~Jynra (a.9.112) cya npmmen x BbIBoy HUSTON, Ha octosannn wanoxeHHoro, B coorsercrsHH co cr.ct. 70, 76, 78, 90 YK PM, pykonogeraysice cr.c.338, c1.364 ', 382, 384-385, 389, 392-395, 397, 400 n 402 YITK PM, cya, PEWS: KBIBBIPIKHK BATAJIMA HUKOJIAEBHYA npyaiars sunonHsim 8 conepuleHiit npectyrmennti, npenyemorpersrx ¥.(4) cr.264, o1.266 VK PM nt HasHawHTs eMy HaKasaHHe: = no (4) 1.264 YK PM ¢ npumenennem +4(8) 1.364) YIIK PM nage ammenna cro6osst cpoKom Ha 4 (veTsIpe) rosa ¢ THIeHHeM MpaBa yrpaBseHna TpaHCnOpTHBIMH cpesicTRAMH epoxom na 5 (nsrk) ner. = no 1.266 YK PM ¢ npumenenmem 4.(8) e7.364' YTIK PM suze numenns cpoGonst cpoxom Ha I (oqaH) roa.ul B coorsercrauu ¢ 4.(1) er.84 YK PM nytem yactuunoro cnoxenua HasHayeHHerx HaKa3saHuli OKOHYATEIbHO HA3HaYHT NOUCyLMMOMY HakaxaHHe B BUC AMMICHHA cBOGoAEI cpokom Ha 4 (4ersipe) roga 8 (Bocemp) MecayeR c JIMUIeHMeM mpapa yripaBsenust ‘TpaticnoprHbiMH cpexcTBaMH cpoKoM Ha 5 (1istTB) ster. B coorsercrsun co cr. 90 YK PM wasiaventioe HakazaHve 8 BHZe AMUIeHA ¢BO6O,IBI B ormouenn KetBsipxnk B.H. He mpHooa¥Ts B ucronHenHe, eca B TeveHHe 5 (nsTb) ser HeNBITATeTBHOTO CpokA OH He COBepILMT HOBOTO MpeCTyTIeHHA M MpUMEpHbIM NoBeNeHHeM HM eCTHBIM Tpys{OM ompabslaet OKasaHHOE eMy AOBEpHE. OGssars nogcyaumoro Ketssipxnk B.H. He MeHsaT Ges paspemienua KomnereHTHoro opratia mecro 2xuTenscrBa. Bosnoxurs Ha Biopo MpoGaumm r.YanbipJlyxra oGssaniocrs Ha6monenis 3a ocyxcqenHEIM Kerpsipanx B.H. x ycaoBHOMY ocyrKsIeHHIO. B coorserersun c 4.(4) c1.65 YK PM cpok yononnerensoro HaKasanus 8 anne JMuleHWa Mpaga ynpasieHHa TpaHCMOpTHSIMH cpejleTRAMH HCHHCHATS cO AHA BCTYNACHHA pHronopa B 2aKoHHYIO CHIY. Tpaxnacknii Hck, saapnenHeti notepresmum Wctpatuii A.A. 0 B3bICKaHHH MarepanbHoro yulep6a B cyMMe 27.342 (aBanaTs CeME TsICsY TPHCTA COpOK s1Ba) ses 36 GaN H Mopaimuoro yutepGa B cymMe 250.000 (aBecTH naTéjecsT THICs') sleeB B COoTRETCTBHK co cr.225 YIIK PM yzossersopurs & mpuHunne +c MocKenyIoUM peuleHMeM Bonpoca o pasmepe Honaraoulerocn BOSMeMLeHHA B opasIKe rpaxxstaHcKoro cy AOMpoUsBOACTBA. Mepy npecevenus 8 oTHomeHn nogcyaMMoro Keissipxux B.H. 20 scrynnenna pHroBopa 8 3aKOHHYIO CHAY OCTABHTb NPEKHIOIO B BHLLe NO;NHCKH O HeBBIesTe Ha MeCTHOCTH. BeulectseHHble JOKasaTesIbeTBA TIO Jey NOCHE BCTYNeHHA NpHrOBOPA B 3aKOHHYIO cuny, a nMeHo: = MoTOUMKA MapKH «Hemp Il» 6e3 1H.3., Haxogauniicn Ha xpanenwH B Yagbip- Jiyurekom HI, nepuyrs no npunaqrenuoctn Byrkyc Bavecaapy Tapopiy; = CHJeHBe YepHoro UBeTa, cBeYa SAKUTAHHA, HAXONAUIMECH B KaMepe xpaHeHHa BEULECTBEHHEIX lOKASATENBCTB HHcHekTopata nomMuHH Yasep-Jlynra (0.2.112), BepuyTs 10 putiagtexxtocra Byrkyc Baecstany Masnoanyy; ~ CHOMAHHEAM KINO, TLIOCKOryGu, NaYKa cHraper ¢ s@KUTANKOH, TuIaeTHKOBAA GyTbIIKA W3-nOM{ BOB, YaCTH cTON-*apsl, HAXO;ALMLHECA B KAMepe XPAHCHHA BCULECTBCHHBIX HOKAsATEMECTE neichekropara noanuaH Yausip-Jlyura (1.2112) yunsroxurs, Konmo npurosopa Hanpasirs Ha nerionHenne B cryx6y npoSaynn ofc Yasup-JIyHra no Mecry 2«uTemBcTBa OCyAeHHOTO. Tipurosop Mower GsiTh OGxasOBAH B ANeMAALMOHHOM nopasKe 8 AneananHoHHyIO nasary Kospar vepes cys Yanbip-Jlynra 8 tevenue 15-rH quel co sua npoposrnainenna Mpnrowopa LenoM. Tipeqceaarensereyroumuit, cyanst A.®, Tens Konus nepa: Cyava cyaa Yagpip-Jyura rem A®, TensAnexasumonnas Taaara Kompar yn.Kompar, ya.Jlenuua, 177 G-€0/f5G3 of OF Awe or Herparnii Cueraans Bacuavepini npox, r-Knmmmnoy, ya. Xorun 1B» ‘Kaccanmonuas a106a (ua Onpeaeaenne Cyaa Yagexp-lynra or 13.01.2014r.) 13 ausaps 2014r. Cyaom Yaaup-JIynra (Cyasa Tews A.®,) 6sin0 paccmorperio HONaHHOS NHOI 3AsBIeHMe O NPHSHANMM TpAXTAHCKHM HCTHOM B XONe paccmorpeHua yrowopHoro ena Mo obsuNcHHIO KeweipxuK Byram Hixonaesnia B cosepucHnn mpecrynennii mperyemorpenusrx 4.4 7.264 cr.266 YK PM u suiecexo Onpenenesue or 13.01.2014r., Ha ocHoRaHuH KoToporo MHe GBLIO OTKAZAHO B yZOBNETBOpeHHN Moero saspienna. Aannoe Onpexenenne cysa 6110 oGocHoBAHO TeM, WTO Ha cram yronoBHoro Npecievonanus # He Gbu1a MpHsHatla noTepneBuuell, M CoOTRETCTREHHO He Mory GuITS NpHSHaHa TpaxkitaHicKHM HCTHOM. Cauraro janHoe Onpeyenene cyaa HeoGocHoBaHHBIM H HesaKOHHBIM, BbIHeceHHOTO TpyGeiiimm HapyuleHNem HOpM MaTepHaNBHOTO M mpoueccyanbHoro xapaxtepa, a COOTBETCTBEHHO, MOWeKAMeMy OTMeHe B HaCTH OTK#a npHsHaHHA Mena — VcrpaTui (CrersaHl, rpaxktaHicKHM HeTHOM M0 CHeMyIOLINM OCHOBANHAM: 1, B mponsponerse Cyna Yansp-JIyura pacemarpupatocs yronosioe e010 oSsnreHMo §=—Kupsipxuk Burana Huxonaesiia 8 copeptenun — npectynennit, mpenyemotpenuix 4.4 1.264 u cr.266 YK PM. B pesyasrare J{TTI, npousomeautero 26.05.2013r., BHROBHHKOM KoToporo aBnseTca nocymMMBIH KeiBBIpKHK B.H., 1lorH6 Moll CbIH — Horparaii Hwrpnii Anexcaxaposny, poampumtica 26 ssieaps 1987r. 2. Ha ochonannn npennucanmi er.61 YK PM, xoropaa ycranannusaer to: «I pancdanexun uemyom npusnaemea duswieckoe uxu wpuduiecroe myo, 6 omnowenuu Komopozo usmelomcn Oocmamownsie ocHoeaxux noxazame, umo exy 6 pesynomame npecmynnenua npuiunen mamepuaronorii wiu mopanoueii yyep6, u Komopoe npedvacuno 6 epean yeonoenoz0 npectedoeanun wi 6 cydeGxyIo uncmanyuo epaxcdancruit ucK x nodospesaemomy, obsuniemomy, nodcyOUMOMY UHU K JJUYAM, Komopele Hecym wHyuyecmEenKyTO omeemcmsennocms 2a dexnua nodospecaeoz0, oGauixemozo, nodcyounozo. Tpa:xcdancKuit ek pacemampueaemca cyde6uoii uncmanyueli @ xode npouscodcmea no yeoroenomy dey, ecru Pasmep yuepGa Geccnopen», i Nogaa COBMECTHO ¢ MOHM cynpyrom — icrparuii Anexcanmpomt TPAKAAHCKH HeK 0 BOSMeUIeHHM MaTepHANEHOTO H MopanbHOrO yulepGa NPHHNKEHHOTO HaM coneputenssins npectynenviem. Hecmorpa na tor dak, "70 B xone cienCTBHs npercTaBHTeNeM MorepneBuel CTOPOHLL 6811 npmsHas mH Moll cynpyr - Herpatui Anexcaiiap Anexceesi, nanibim npectynaenuen iam - OGoHM posurenam noruuero - Osi MpHAMHeH KaK MaTepuanbuBili, TaK W MopanbuBiii ymep6.Caenyer orMeTHTs, TO MPHSHAHHE TpwKAMHCKHM HETHOM He BBAHMOCBASAHO C HeoGxomMMocTHIo ony¥eHMs, PaHee, CTaTYca - npedcranuTena noTepnemmieH CTOpOH, @ HL, axrom Hannya MatepuaasHoro, aMGo MoparsHoro ymlep6a B pesyaurare cosepmenHoro mpecrynaenus, B To xxe Bpems, Ha OcHOBaNuM npemnucannit er. 225 YIIK PM cyde6nax uncmanyus 6 pase mau» ¢ uckwouumeroneix cxyyaxx yOosIemeopUMb & npunyune epaoKcdancKuUil UCK, eciU pu pacewompenuu zpaacdanexozo ueka sosHuc1a HeoBxoOuNoCM mxooKuMe deno Ora c6opa Oonomumeasieix Ooxasamersems 6 yerax onpederenua cysster, nodreacayell eoaMewjentio epancdancxomy uemyy. B paccmarpuzaemom ete Taxol HeoOXOAMMOcTH He GbUI0, TAK KaK NpHUMHeHHbiit MarepHabubi ymtep6 ObL1 NOATBEPACIEH NMChMEHHBINE AOKE2GTEMBCTBAMH B rlonHOM OGweMe, 4 OTHOCHTENBHO MopamsHOTO YulepGa, cyAeGHAR HHCTAHLIMA, PYKOBONCTBYSCH NpenTHcaHWaMH AelicTeyiomero SakoHogaTenbCTBa H OOCTOATeTECTBAMM COBepUleHHOrO NpectynacHua, Osa KOMMeTeHTHa aT OUeHKY NCHXHVECKMM CTpagaHMEM pogMTeneli noTepABLINX china H onpegemmts pasmep ymep6a. B coorsercreun c npeanucanuamn ct.cr.61-62, 225, 400 ¥.2, 401, 405, 415 4.2 YIIK PM, cr.ct.1420-1423 TK PM: mPoury: OrMennrs sactuunio Onpenenenne Cyza Yanbip-JIynra or 13.01.2014r. B wacrn orkasa npm3nanua mena —Herparali Coetnanet Bacnnseniii rpaxianickHM HCTHOM. 2. Ormennrs mpurosop Cyza Yaxsp-JIynra or 24,03.2014r. 8 acta ysopersopenus TpaxtaHckoro HicKa B npHEIATe, 3. ButHecth Hopoe peuienme 8 opanke, mpezyeMorpeHHiom sua cyaa nepsolt wHicTaRUH, Ha ocHoranmu xKotoporo mpusHars mens - Herparai Crewiany Bacuavesny, TPRANACKHM UCTHOM HM YOBIETBOPHTS MOM MCKOBMe TpeGoRaHHA B eOM OtHocHTenbHo BOSMeMeHHs MaTepHambHOrO H MopanbHoro yulep6a. 4, Bosickats ¢ orserwnxa, Kusiipaux Butanus Hukonaesa, B Hay nonssy ~ Merpataii Anexcanapa u Hetpatuii Cneviaiet matepuanbubil yutep6 B cyMMe 27.342,36 seit. 5. Babickats ¢ orseranka, Kewssipauk Burana Huxoiaesia, B Molo rlonb3y Mopambui -yutep6 B cysmce 250.000 eli. 6. “Tipunats mepst oGecriesenns Hacrosuero ucKa. Moms §— Vreyps VEL CQ ia He 07 anpeas 2014r.Koaaterns no yroaontuim xenam Aneaasnonnoi Manat: Kompar Ano nr.1-12813 19-1-729-26072013 &-66/ 124 Anreaaaunonnas xa1068 saspueHHas norepnesmmHM, Vectparait Anexcaniapom, Tlporus npurosopa Cyna Yansip-Jlynra or 24.03.2014 r. puinlecenvoro 0 yronosHoy sleny no oOnnnentio rp.: Kerspipank Brrasna Huxonaesnya 01.08.1989 roga poxxaenns, ypoxxenna r. Yaxuap-JIyxra, rpakqannua Pecny6amxu Mosjopa, raray3a, HMeloUlero HenOmHOe cpeanee oOpasonanne, HeTpyz0yeTpoeHHoro, *eHaTOTO, pane He cynumoro, npoxunaiouero ro anpecy: 1, Yamup-Jlynra ya. Oamwmaticxas, 7 Ocnopanus anenasnonnott aa106u1 (Markocrs mpuronopa 1 yaonnersopee rpaxknaHcKoro Heka B npHue) B coorserereun ¢ mpurosopom Cyna Uansp-JIyura or 24.03.2014r. noneymuneitt Kowhipaux Buran Hukonaesu4 6817 MpusHal BMHORHBIM B CoBepuIeHHM NpectyneHHit npeayemorpenusix cr. 264 4. (4), ct. 266 Yronosnoro Kojiexca PM, 6yaysn npurovopes K 4 roam 4 8 Mecalam ToppMbl, ¢ JMUIeHHeM npasa YpaBAATs TpAHCHOpTHBIMM CpesicTBaMH CpOKOM Ha 5 ner. Ha ocHosanm ct. 90 YK PM xchosenne npnrosopa Gbu10 HasHaeHo yenoBHo c YoranoBaeHveM HenssraTembHOTO cpoKa 5 sieT. Tpaxtalickuii vex 61in yaosiersopent B punuune, ¢ nocmeayIoMNM pemieHHeM Bonpoca o PasMepe rlosaraioujerocs K ROSMeUIeHMIO MaTepHaNbHOrO M MopabHOrO ymepGa, B nopsKe Tp@kaaHcKoro cynonpousponcrea. [lo noBoly Mep OGecreveHHA saaBHeHHOTO HcKA cymeSHaN HCTMs He BBICKAIAACS, 28.03.2014 r. aaMusiii npuroBop noctynus nocpenCTBOM nlo¥roBoro oTHeNeHUA nO Anpecy Mecra 2kHTenbcTBa NoTepneaulero,B xoze cyneSuoro pacemorpeniis G:i1 nomHocTnio noKazan Tor dhakr, ro Kumpupavie Buranuit Huxonaesu4 piiosen 8 cOBepLleHNM XopoxHO-rpaHenopTHorO Mpocmecrsua Np oGcrostemscrsax YCTAHOBNeHHBIX OpraHOM yron0BHOTO MpecmevOBAHHA M_ TIOACYsIMMBII XogaTaiicTBOBAall O paCCMOTPeHHH YrONOBHOTO ena B COOTRETCTBHH C NpeyMHcaHHAMH cr. 364 (1) YIIK PM, na ocHoBaHNM 2oKasaTesscTS cOGpaHHEIX Ha CTANHH YTONOBHOTO MpecHeNOBAHA H YkasaHHBIX POKYpOpoM B crucke 2oKasaTezECTS, OyayH ¢ HHMH cormaceH. Cyne6nax wnctanuus, wsy"MB M mpoBepHB BCe mpegocTapneHHbe qoKasarenbeTBa OGBeKTHBHO H NOAHOCTSIO, B COBOKYNHOCTH JPYFHMM JOKAsaTeTECTEAMH, YCTAHOBHa, YTO BAH nogcyaumoro Kesipxwk Butanma Huxonaeswya 8 copepileHua —mpecrynenuit mpeayemorpenHbix cr. 264 u. (4), cr. 266 Yroaosxoro Koziexca PM Gsuta oKasaHa, Ho MpHHUMAs BO BHHMaHVe HeKoTOpse cMaruaiomue OGcTosTesscTBa MYHOTO xapaKrepa MOCTaHOBHATA npuMenums ct. 90 YK PM u mepesocrmtars ero rlocpecTaoM MpHMeHeHus Apyroii, vest TIOpeMHOe saKmovenne, Mepoii Hakasanns, B Morueauyn npumenenus cr. 90 YK PM cya ykasan, 470 nosey quMbil: © Tipusnan BHHY H YHCTOCepne4Ho packaMBaeTCs B COjeAHHOM; ‘© Bnepsuie conepuiua npectynmenne; © Vimeer na copep»xanmu HecopepulennoneTHero peGeHKa; © Xapaxrepusyeres nonoxuresHo no Mecty paGorsi. ConoxynHocrs jaHiLx OGcTORTeNECTS, NPHSHANHBIX cyNOM CMsTYBIONIIMH, NoCKyRHIA ocuosanviem 1K MpyMexennia cr. 90 YronosHoro Konexca PM m otcpouky ncnomienua mparopopa. Tlorepnesimuii 8 jaHHOM cay¥ae cuHTaer, WTO pH BBIHeCeHMH mpHroBopa cyneHAR HHCTAHUHA HeOGOCHOBANHO MPHMEHNAA B OTHOMIEHAH MOAcYAMMOTO Mepy HaKasanHs Gosee MSrkylo, eM Ta KOTOpy!0 OH 3aCiy:MBAeT mM KOTOpat Moraa GbI peamH30BaTb WeTb YFOuOBHOrO HaKazaHNsl — nepenocnuTanne m HempansieHNe mogeyAUMorO, a TAKE Mpeaynpeajcnue H Mpeyorspamlenne conepmeHNs NOAOOHLIX NpoTHBOsAKONHBIX JelicTBHI (wax HenocpercTReHHO nojcyAMMLIM, TAK HM APYTHMM 4eHaMH OGmecTRA), HcXo_a 13 cenyiomnx coobpaxentt = pH yeraosnenHn Mepst H cpOoKa HakasaHA pykonostcTayscs ct. 75 YK PM, cyne6xiaa wucTaHUMA AOMKHA OBI NPHHSTS BO BHUMAHMe THKECTs COBepLIeNHOTO MpecTyreHHs, a MMeHHO TO, TO B JAHHOM ciy4ae nogcyqUMEIli YMBIMUIeHHO mpoxrHopHpoBaB OGssaTenEHOCTS COOMOACHUA MpABHA OPOXHOTO BIKKEHHA COBEpUIHA THKKOE mpecrynutenve noptexmee emepTs noctpazabuiero; = SaKOHOATENS YeTAHOBHT, TO OGKEKTOM HpectynteHHa MpexycmoTpeHHoTo cr, 264, 266 Yroxosoro Konexca PM spnsiores He TOmbKO OOMIeCTRCHHBIC OTHOMICHHA KacaIoULHeK GesonacHOCTH ABWHKCHA, HO M YeToBeYeckas KUSH, B 9TOM KOHTeKCTe, XOYY NOBECTH 10 CBEREHHA aNesAAUMOHHOK MHCTAHUMH, YTO TlONCyAMMBI NOKAHyN MecTO coBepmIcHUA MPCCTYMNCHHA He MSBECTHB HH MPABOOXpAHHTNbHAe OpraHkl, HH MEmHUUHCKHE Y'PexUeHHA O NOCTpARABINEM, OCTABICHHOM Ha MeCTe MpoHICMICcTANA, a ICKONA WS Baxmoyenua cyneSuo-menmmpnckoro uccnegonanna N02001 or 15.08.2013r. noctpayasumii Hictpatuii Jsurpult yep cnycta 2-3 aca nocne conepileHus opoxKHo- ‘TpavcrloprHoro npovcutecrsus. COoTBeTCTReHHO, B cayuae OKazalNA asjlexameli oneparusHoli MeAHIMMHCKOH NOMOMLH ero >RHSHG Mora ObITS criacenia;+ Xora NlogcyAMMBII MpHsHaT CBOIO BHHY H TOACHHN cysly, YTO packaHBaeTca B COseAHHOM, ero 3aaBeHHA HocaT AeKxapaTusHEili M opMailbHbill Xapakrep, 470 NOATBEpAuAeTCA TEM, ‘yo ¢ MoMeHta noxopox Verpatuii JIMutpHa H 0 MoMeHTa orsaleHua npuroBopa OH HH pasy ne oGulanca c poaMTersMH norHOulero, He NonbiTaica BosMecTHTb npwanntiHEst yulep6, sake He pasroBapusa c OTUOM OFHOUlero, ¢ KOTOPEIM HEOAHOKPATHO BCTPENAAICA 1B cyneGunix sacenannsx; = moncymynniii He BosMectHa mpHunHeHHBiit ymlep6, jwKe pacxonM cEAIaHHEIe © noxopoliaMu noctpaxasulero 8 pesy;IbTaTe CoBepILEHUA AAHHOTO NpectynteHHs, Cunrao, yo npvrosopom or 24.03.2014 r. He Osia gOcTHrHyTa Wen’ yror0BHOro Hakasanna mpenyemotpenuoro cr. 264, 266 YrososHoro Konexca PM. Takum o6pasom, ogcyaumani Kussipxnk Buraruii cBowMn JelieTBHAMM NOCArHys Ha OOMLeCTREHHKIe OTHOLIEHHA Kacaloutiecn GesonacHocTH JOPOACHOTO ABIKEHHA, NOCATHYsI Ha AUGHb YENOBEKa, a NpUMeHEHHO cyoM nakasanne opMupyeT B OGUIeCTBe MHEHHe, B TOM HMCKE H cpenM ZPyTHX BomHTeeH He OOMAMAIOMINX TOTHBIMM SHAHHAMH MPABM AOPOXHOTO ABWAEHUA, WTO jleliCTBHA NOAOOHOTO pona (ynpasenne tpacnoprHoro cpeseTsa Ge3 BOAHTeMsCKOTO YAOCTOREpeHHA, B COCTOSHHH ANKOTOMbHOTO OTAHEHHA, HeOKasaHHe MeMUAHCKOMt NOMOMIM NOCTpAABIeMY, OCTABIeHHe MeCTA MpovculecTaHa) He HaKasbIBaIOTCA cOOTBeTCTAYMIMM O6paz0M, YTO MpHBOIHT K HemOBepHIO Haceneua B mpasocyaue. Tipynuwas 80 srmmarne, sro Goxee crporan Mepa HakasaHHA M3 JIPYCHX aNbTepHaTHBHBIX pexycMoTpeHHLIX 3a COBEPINEHHe MPECTYNACHHA YCTAHABIMBACTER TONGKO B cily4ae eca1H Gone MarKoe HaKasaiive, W3 BBIMIeNepesMCTEHHEIX He OGECIeMHT AOCTIDKCHHE HOM HaKAIAHN, CHHTAIO ‘NTO B JJaHHOM cay4ae 9TO MpABIAsIO He Moker GuiTb MpHMeHeHO, Bonpexu npeaycmorpenHomy 4. 2 cr. 75 YK PM, mp npuMenenun Goce markolt Mepst HAKasaHHa, eM Ta KOTOpad ObL1a SacayAKeHA HS AIBTEPHATHBHENK CTPOTHX Mep, He OBI MpHHAT BO BHHMAHHe TOT MOKasaTeNs HCTHHHOM TMIHOH XApAKTePHCTHKH NlonCyAUMOTO, WTO OH He OcosHAN ‘DHKECTU M OM1ACHOCTH COBEPUIEHHOTO HM eAHIMS, He COXANEET O MPECTYNHBIX NOCHERCTRNAK, H HE Tibrraetes HX KaKHM-sH60 o6pa3soM HcnpaBurs. B aanHoM KoureKcte, cHHTalo, ¥TO ANeNASLMOHHOM HHCTAHUBH HeOGXOAUMO KPHTHHECKH ‘OleHHTE NOsOXUTeNbHY!O XapakTepHCTKY NOeyAMMOTO ¢ Mecra paGOTEL, BIFTYIO BO BHUMAHHE TIpH BbiKeceHMM npuroBopa. Tak, HECMOTPs Ha TO, 4TO B CymeOHOM 3acenaHMM TOACyAMMEI H4HO 3aaBHA1, ¥TO Tpynoycrpowes Hesaqonro (3a 2-3 gH) JO 9TOTO, cy MpHsHAeT B KayeCTBE BoKasatenscra Tak HASbIBAEMYIO XapakrepwcrHKy pBIqaHHyIo OOO «Zona Auto Piesey haruposannyio 27.05.2013r., 6e3 ykasaHua HOMepa pervicTpaumM, He cosepxKaMlylo aHHBIX Kacalouuixca HoMepa mpyikasa 06 yctpolicrse Ha paGOTy M APYTWX KOHKPETHBIX JaHHEIX, KOTOPBIC Moran 611 nloxTmepaHTS Hakr Tpyqoycrpoiicrsa H NONOAHTE:IBHYIO XApaKTepHCTHKY AAHHOTO JHA. Taxym o6pasom, B Xoue Honpoca & KAYECTHE CBHUeTENA Ha CTANMM yronoBHOTO mpecnesoBaHHA aupextop OOO «Zona Auto Piese» - Kysies Oner noscuma, 470 noacyauMBlli HenaBHO BepHy.ica 3-3a npeaienos PM rae ow paGoTas, a B BEIAAHHOH HM XapakTepHCTHKe YKASbIBAeT, 4TO paGoTaeT BMeCTe C HUM NPOROMDKHTEsIBHOe BpeMs. Bonee Toro, mpl wasHa¥eHHH Mepbl HaKasaHHA, cyqeOHan MHCTAHUMA He MpHHaTa BO BHUMAHHe XapAKTepHCTHKY AMSHOCTH MOACY,IMMOTO, AAHHY!O MpaBOOXpaHMTeHBIMM OpraHaMt 110 Mecty 2kuTenKeTBa mlocHeAHeTo, KOTOpse XapakrepHsyioT rlofeysMMOTO MocpescTBeHHO, YoraHOBHB 4TO OH OGulaeTCA C AMLIAMM KOTOPHe ReAYT ANTHCONMAMbHBIM OOpas 2iSHH MpenpacnosoxeH K ConepuleHHIo npectynieHuii.Takum o6pa30M, MpHMecHeHHe ycTOBHOTO Haka3aHus, ycTaHopneHHoro cyqe6HOi wHoTaHNHell NORCyAMMOMY B AAHHOM cAyYe He BOCTaHOBHT conMaTLHOK cnpaseMIMBOCTH, WCMpaBHeHHe H NepeBOCHHTAHHe MOCKeAHETO, NpeqoTEpaueHVe C ero CTOPOHHI, @ TAK IKE HCO CTOpONBL APyrHX sIH dara HecoGMOReHAA MpaBHA jopoxHOTO ABHAeHHA HM He Gyaer MpegeTaBaTs coGoH rapaHTHO H OGsSATENBHOCTS MpABHIGHOTO GyHKNHOHMPOBAHHA B YeIOM npanopoli cHcremsl, a pasa H cpoGons rapaxruponanusie Koncraryuuei PM a apyrumu 3aKoHaMM nloTepreneMy HUY He Gyayr sammueH. Uro KacaeTea yAOBIETBOPEHHA TPAKNAHCKOTO HeKA B MpHHUNME, cHHTAIO 4TO cyneGHOI MHCTANUKH GHIA MPeNOCTaBIeHS! BCe HEOGXOAMMBIe JOKYMEHTSI, NlOATBEPANaOMIHe OGEEM MpHuunenworo yulep6a (pacxorsl cARIaHHbIe © MPORENeHHEM MOXOPOH H TIOMHHOK B cyMME 27342,36 neli, Tpavicnoprusie pacxoasi CRAAHHMIe ¢ Mpoesgom H3 MyH. Kunmroy Br. Yamsip- Ilynra wa cyeGuure sacenanus — 1050 eli, KcepoKonun atepuavion yrosioBHoro sexa — 26 nel, onaata 1opmanyecoii nomomu — 5000 self), a pasMep 3assneHHoro MopambHoro ymlep6a JomKeH Gsin Gui OUeHEH B COOTBETCTBHH C COGCTBCHHEIMH yOeKNeHHAMH cygeGHOl MHCTAHLMH, CopaSMepHO HPABCTBEHHEIM TepexHBAHHAM, OMHCAHBIX TpaKnaHcKHM HeTuoM — Herparuti ‘Asiekcaniipom B xone pacemoTpeHis esa cyzeOHoll Huicranuuel. Tipaso mma, xoTopomy Gui HaHeceH MaTepnanbuBtii, m60 Mopabutili yuyep6 B CRASH C COBEpIIEHHEM MIPECTYMACHHA, 3ARBHTh MCKOBHIE TpeOonaHHA B PaMKAX yroxOBHOTO sea, OGBACHACTCR PANHOHATBHOCTSIO MIPHBIEHEHHA TOMBKO ORHOH cyneOHOH MNCTAHUMH WIA PACCMOTPEHHA YrosIOBHOH CTOPOHK! Jena H BEITEKAIOMLUX H3 COBEPLLHHOTO yronOBHOTO jeAHUA TpaxmaHcKHX TpeGopawnil, a TakcKe ANA KOMMeKCHOTO M BCeCTOpoHHeTo paccMoTpeHHa oGcrosTesscTs jena. Caenonatensio, cya neppoli uucranunn Bonpexs cr. 61 YIIK PM orxtonna saspieune ucrua Herparuli Caetsausi — Marep noru6uiero, 0 OnyWleHHH ee B KavecTBe TpaxaaHCKOrO CTUa, HECMOTPs Ha To WTO CTaTYc rpakaaWCKOrO MUA He 3ABMCHT OT CraTyca MOTepnesuero, KaK ykasaHo B onpestenenun Cyza Yaxsip-JIynra or 13.01.2014 r. B 70 2ke mpems, Ha ocHonaHun npeanucanuii er. 225 YEIK PM cydeGuan uncmanyun 6 pase muy ¢ uckmouumeasierx cayuasx ydoanemeopume @ npunytne 2pancdanexuil ucK, ecmu npu PaceMompenuu zpaatedanckoz0 ucka eosnuKra neoBxodUMOCM> OMmnoIUMe deo d1x copa Oonontumensnocx Ooxasamerocms 6 yenax onpedenenua cynuts, nodreacawyeli sosweweniio apaorcoancxomy uemyy. icxoys 13 neimensnoxextoro, zelicrays 8 cooreercranu co cr. cr. 400 4. (1), 401 4. (1) m. 3-4), 402, 405 415 u. (2) Yronosno-Tlpoueceyaasuoro Kogexca PM, Tpomy: 1. Pacemorpers u yaoniersopiTs aneaasunonnyro xas106y. 2. Ormenurb & uetom mpurosop Cyza Yamup-JIyara or 24.03.2014 1, xa » actu YETAHOB.TeNHA Mepst HAKAGANNS M MpHMeHenns cr. 90 YK PM, TaK 5 wacru Kacaroueiton YAOBuLeTROpeHNS FpaLKAAHEKOTO HeKA B NPMNHNE, 3. Buinecrn Honoe peuienve ® mopsiike mpexyemorpeniom fat cyza mneppoit HHCTAHUMM H HASHAYHTE HAKASAHMe B BHAe TIOPbMEL CpOKOM Ha 5 ster, a Ta1cKe TOAHOCTSIO YAOBACTBOPHT rpwKIANCKHiL HCK C BOSMeMIeHKeM H_ cy/eOHEIx PAacxoson (OpHANYecKast TOMOMIE M TPAHCHOpTHMe pacxoabI cEsGAHHBIE ¢ mpoesiom).4. Tpumenrre mepsi o6ecneienua rpaxqanekoro HcKa B BIUIe HALOxeHHS apecta Ha umyuteeTBo npimaztexamiee ocyamennomy Kumupank Buraano Huxoresisy. Tomepneewuuit > Hempamuii AnexeanopTeno Ne 1a-34/2013 Cyabs neppoit muctannan Kut. 06-1a-33-16012013 Tem A.0. Cya Yamsnp-JIyara ONPEAEJEHHE MMEHEM 3AKOHA 03 moa 2014 roa yu. Kompar Kosueraa no yrososisim zenam Anentauuonnoit nanarst Kompar B cocraze: mpegcezatemscrayiomero, cynbu Kypaoza A. H., cymett Uinax A.K. n [anunioit E.V., pH cexperape Kpuctuorao O, c ysaerHem: mpoxypopa Ipoxyparypst ATO Taraysua Angpouu H.B., agpoxaros Uawnoent B.B., Hlasra A., niorepnesumx Vetpatuit A.A., Herparuit C.B. noxeyaumoro Kerpsipxuk B. H. Pacemorpena B OTKPSITOM cyjeSHOM sacenaHNH B anensaNMoHHOM HOpaNKe yros1oBHi0€ en0 10 OOBUHEHITO KBIBBIPKUK BUTAJIMUA HAKOJIAEBHYA, 01.09.1989 Tora poxyeHHs, rpaxkianuna PM, ypoxenta n xKHTens r. Yaqtp- Jlyxra, npoxusaromero no ys. Onumnuiicxas Ne 7, raraysa 10 HANWOHATBHOCTH, BIAZeIOM\eTO PYCCKUM A3BIKOM Ha KOTOPOM ocytlectBnseTes cynonpoHsBOMCTEO, HMeIOMIero HerIomHOe cpentice oGpasopanne 9 kraccon, Bpemerno He ‘TpyHoycrpoennoro, cocrosmero B Gpake, uMeromero Ha wxauBenua | (ogHoro) HeconepmrenHonerHero pebenKa, BOCHHOOSs3aHHOTO, He ABILMOMeTOCA HHBATHAOM, CEMMATUBIX SRaHHil, KIACCHEIX HOR H TocynapCTBEHHBIX Harpam He HMEIOMIero, 10 NaHHOMY Jleny OBL 3allepxaH Ha Tpoe cyTOK C 26.05.2013 rogta no 29.05.2013 rona, pariee He cyuMoro, B coBepieHHH npectynuienuit, mpenycmorpentEIx 4. (4) or. 264, cr. 266 YK PM, Ho anesnanmonmeim 2at0GaM poxypopa npoxyparypst Yammp-Jlynra Bparan JLH., norepneutero Merparuit A.A. a Vetparait C.B., va npurosop cyna Yarerp-JIystra or 24 mapra 2014 rona, KoropsnM Kepnipxu Brrarait Hikomaenns ipisitan puHOBHEIM 8 CoBepmIeHHH npectynaennit, npenyemorpentmtx 4.(4) cr. 264, ct. 266 YK PM u Haswayeno ey waKasanne: = 10 4. (4) er. 264 YK PM c mpumentenue 4. (8) or. 364 ' YIIK PM b nae AuMIeHUA cBoGONEI CpoKOM Ha 4 (eTSIpe) roa ¢ MHMLeHeM npava yrpasienus ‘TpaHCHOpTHBIMH cpeseTRAMM CpOKOM Ha 5 (mMaTS) eT; - 0 cr. 266 YK PM c mpumenermem 4. (8) ct. 364 ' YIIK PM » nune simmers cBoConBt cpoKoM Ha 1 (OHH) TON;