You are on page 1of 7

Acta Oto-Laryngologica.

2015; 135: 277–282

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Analysis of therapeutic methods for treating vocal process granulomas

LIJING MA, YANG XIAO, JINGYING YE, QINGWEN YANG & JUN WANG

Key Laboratory of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery (Ministry of Education of China), Department of
Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Beijing Tongren Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China

Abstract
Conclusion: The combination of laryngeal microsurgery and local injections of botulinum toxin type A (BTA) can increase the
cure rate of patients with vocal process granulomas (VPGs). Objective: To analyze the therapeutic effects of conservative
treatments, microsurgical resection with suturing and microsurgery in combination with local injections of BTA for the
treatment of VPGs. Methods: A retrospective analysis of 168 cases of VPG was performed. All of the patients initially received a
conservative treatment. Some of the patients who did not respond to the conservative treatments were treated using
microsurgical resection and microsuturing using an 8-0 absorbable filament. Other patients additionally received a four-
point injection of BTA into the thyroarytenoid muscle and the arytenoid muscle on the operated side. Results: The lesions of
41.3% (71/168) of the patients who were given the conservative treatments (including acid suppression, vocal rest, and voice
therapy) disappeared, and the lesions of 10.7% (18/168) of the patients were reduced. The conservative treatments were
unsuccessful for 47% (79/168) of the patients. The cure rate was 78.4% (29/37) for the patients who were treated by
microscope resection using a CO2 laser and microsuturing of the surrounding mucosa. Of the eight patients who experienced a
recurrence, five of them had lesions that disappeared after 3 months of conservative treatment, whereas the other three patients
recovered after a second operation. The cure rate of the 42 patients who were treated using microsurgery combined with local
injections of BTA was 95.2% (40/42), with only 2 cases of recurrence at 2 months post-treatment.

Keywords: Microsurgery, botulinum toxin type A, conservative treatment, microsuturing

Introduction consists primarily of voice therapy to reduce the


collision forces at the affected site and the adminis-
Vocal process granuloma (VPG) is a benign lesion tration of anti-acids, such as proton-pump inhibitors
affecting the vocal process of the arytenoid cartilage. (PPIs), to prevent injury from GER. The other con-
The pathogenesis of this disease is not understood, servative treatments include botulinum toxin injec-
but vocal abuse, intubation trauma, and gastroesoph- tion [2] and intralesional steroid injection [3]. In
ageal reflux (GER)/laryngopharyngeal reflux (LPR) 2009, Wang et al. [4] demonstrated that most
have been proven to be the main inducing factors. In VPGs (81%) spontaneously regressed and disap-
2010, Carroll et al. [1] presented evidence that glottal peared within 9 months. Although these treatment
insufficiency was the possible etiological factor in regimens achieve desirable outcomes, the long course
patients with refractory VPG. Regardless of the eti- of treatment, the persistence of the lesions, and the
ology, VPGs present similar clinical manifestations. side effects of the drugs made the patients anxious.
The most common symptom is hoarseness combined Surgery is not generally selected as the initial treat-
with persistent throat clearing, sore throat, and a ment for VPG due to the high recurrence rate of this
globus sensation. lesion [5]. Surgery may be indicated to remove
The optimal treatment regimen for VPG is still obstructive lesions or lesions refractory to other ther-
controversial. The traditional treatment regimen apies. However, among all of the single treatment

Correspondence: Jun Wang, Department of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Beijing Tongren Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing 100730,
China. Tel: +86 10 58269207. Fax: +86 10 65288441. E-mail: trentxy@163.com

(Received 11 September 2014; accepted 6 November 2014)


ISSN 0001-6489 print/ISSN 1651-2251 online  2015 Informa Healthcare
DOI: 10.3109/00016489.2014.986756
278 L. Ma et al.

strategies, surgical resection is the most rapid method A B


of eliminating granulomas.
Considering the multifactorial etiology of VPGs
and the advantages and disadvantages of different
treatments, some otolaryngologists have begun to
search for a combined therapy for VPG. Song et al.
[6] used surgical resection plus low-dose X-ray radi-
ation to treat refractory VPG. When Hong-Gang et al.
[7] used surgery and the administration of PPIs to
C D
treat VPG, the recurrence rate was 38.7%. In partic-
ular, there was no recurrence among the patients who
had a recent history of intubation.
In this report, we describe the results obtained
when different VPG treatments were applied to deter-
mine which treatment was most efficacious.

Material and methods Figure 1. Female, 48 years. (A) Image of the granulation-like
neoplasm on the vocal process of the right arytenoid, before the
For this study, 168 patients with VPG who were resection was performed (arrow); (B) image of the same site after
the resection (arrow); (C) image of the incision site after closure
treated in the Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery using an 8-0 absorbable suture filament (arrow); (D) diagram of the
Center of the affiliated Beijing Tongren Hospital of sites of injection of botulinum toxin type A (red dots).
Capital Medical University between January 2005
and January 2013 were enrolled. The diagnosis was Since 2009, the VGA patients have been treated
reached using rigid video-strobolaryngoscopy on an using microsurgery combined with local injections of
outpatient basis. The medical records were reviewed botulinum toxin type A (BTA). After the granuloma
and data were collected, including the age, gender, was removed, injections of BTA were given. The BTA
occupation, intubation history, history of GER or was diluted to 10 U/ml using a sterile saline solution.
LPR, symptoms or signs, previous treatment methods A total of 8–15 U of BTA was injected into four points
applied, course of the treatments, and whether a of the thyroarytenoid and arytenoid muscles near the
recurrence had presented. The granulomas were arytenoid cartilage of the affected side. The BTA
graded using Farwell’s grading system according to injection sites are shown in Figure 1D (red dots).
the laryngoscopic findings [8]. For the thyroarytenoid injections, the injection needle
All the patients were given a conservative treatment was aimed toward the side of the vocal ligament of the
of omeprazole or esomeprazole (20 mg bid) admin- mid-membranous vocal fold at the floor of the laryn-
istration for 3 months. The patients were told to geal ventricle. If lesions were found on both sides, the
control their speaking, improve bad speaking habits, left thyroarytenoid muscle was injected.
and avoid unconsciously clearing the throat and A budesonide inhalant was administered for 2 weeks
coughing during this period. after the surgery and omeprazole or esomeprazole was
The patients for whom the conservative treatment administered for 3 consecutive months after the surgery.
failed were treated with surgery. The patients treated The patients who were injected with BTA under-
before 2009 were subjected to microsurgical resection went stroboscopic laryngoscopy to observe the move-
and microsuturing. These patients were subjected to ments of the arytenoid before surgery and at 3 days,
tracheal intubation under general anesthesia, using 1 month, 2 months, and 3 months after surgery.
1-2 gauze tracheal tubes that were smaller than those A voice assessment was conducted, which consisted
used for general anesthesia. A self-retaining laryngo- of a perceptual evaluation of HRB (the grade of
scope was usedto expose the lesion in the posterior of the hoarseness, roughness, and breathiness) and deter-
vocal cords (Figure 1A). Under a microscope, a radical mination of the maximum phonation time (MPT).
resection of the lesion and the surrounding neoplastic The perceptual evaluation was performed using a
tissue was conducted using micro-scissors and a 1.0 W four-point assessment scale, as follows: 0, normal;
CO2 laser (Figure 1B). The cartilaginous membrane 1, mild; 2, moderate; and 3, severe. The voice assess-
surrounding the vocal process and the normal mucosa ment was performed at 3 days, 1 month, and 3 months
surrounding the neoplasm were protected. The incision after surgery. The mean follow-up period was
was closed using 8-0 absorbable suture material 28 months, with a range of 12–58 months. The other
(Vicryl), using the interrupted apposition suturing patients underwent stroboscopic laryngoscopy at
method to apply two to three stitches (Figure 1C). 1 month and 3 months after treatment.
Treatment methods for vocal process granulomas 279

Statistical analysis suppression, vocal rest, and vocal therapy) disap-


peared and the lesions of 10.7% (18/168) of the
The paired-samples t test and the Wilcoxon signed- patients were reduced. The conservative treatment
rank test were performed to assess whether there were was unsuccessful for 47% (79/168) of the patients.
significant differences in the MPTs and the HRB The cure rate was 78.4% (29/37) in the patients who
grades before and at the last follow-up following were treated by microscope resection using a CO2
surgery. A value of p < 0.05 was considered to be laser and microsuturing of the surrounding mucosa.
significant. In the eight patients who experienced a recurrence,
five of the lesions disappeared after 3 months of
Results conservative treatment and another three patients
recovered after a second operation. The cure rate
There were 143 (85.1%) male and 25 (14.9%) female of the other 42 patients who were treated using the
patients with refractory VPG enrolled in this study. microsurgical operation combined with local injec-
Their ages ranged from 25 to 81 years, with an average tions of BTA was 95.2% (40/42). The two patients
of 49 years. In 100 (59.5%) of the patients, the who had a recurrence 2 months after the operation
granuloma originated on the left vocal process, refused a repeat surgery. At 1 year of follow-up, their
whereas 55 (32.8%) of the patients had a right-sided lesions were still present (Farwell class I) and the
granuloma. The other 13 (7.7%) patients had bilateral patients did not have obvious symptoms.
VPG. The patients who were treated using BTA injec-
According to Farwell’s grading system, there were tions experienced hoarseness and breathiness for
12 (7.2%) cases of grade I granuloma, in which a 2–3 days after the surgery. Using an electronic laryn-
sessile, non-ulcerative granuloma was limited to the goscope, we observed that the movements of the
vocal process; 36 (21.4%) cases of grade II granu- arytenoid on the injected side were weaker than those
loma, in which a pedunculated or ulcerated granu- on the contralateral side. At 1 month after surgery, the
loma was limited to the vocal process; and arytenoid on the injected side was fixed and the vocal
104 (61.9%) cases of grade III granuloma, in which cord was arched. Therefore, there was a gap when the
the granuloma extended past the vocal process but did glottis was closed (Figure 2). The arytenoid on
not cross the midline of the airway when the process the injected side could move in 34 (80.95%) of the
was in the fully abducted position. The other patients at 2 months after the surgery, but the move-
16 (9.5%) patients were diagnosed with grade IV ments were weaker than those on the opposite side.
granulomas, which extended past the vocal process The activity of the arytenoid was normal in eight
and past the midline of the airway when the process (19.05%) of the patients at this point. At 3 months
was in the fully abducted position. after surgery, the activity of the arytenoid on the
There were 57 (33.9%) patients with a history of injected side was normal in all of the patients.
GER, 41 (24.4%) patients with a history of laryngeal Compared with the preoperative values, the mean
intubation for general anesthesia, 39 (23.2%) patients MPT at 1 month after operation was significantly
who had used their voices excessively, 33 (19.6%) decreased (p < 0.0001), by an average of 3.9 s, but
patients with a history of smoking, and 19 (11.3%) at 3 months after the operation, the mean MPT was
patients with no obvious etiology. Among the patients increased by 5.3 s. Compared with the value at
with a history of laryngeal intubation for general anes- 1 month after operation, the mean MPT at 3 months
thesia, there were 23 (16.1%) males and 18 (72%) after operation was increased by 9.2 s (Table I). There
females. was no significant difference in the roughness of the
A total of 148 (88.1%) of the patients had different voice at 1 month after operation and preoperatively,
degrees of hoarseness, 111 (66.1%) patients had the but there was a significant difference between the
sensation of having a foreign body in the throat and a other scores at these points. In general, the postop-
cough, 29 (17.3%) patients had throat pain, and erative HRB scores were better than the preoperative
16 (9.5%) patients had mild to moderate apnea. scores (Table II).
Only five (3%) patients, who had no obvious symp-
toms, had VPG that was found upon physical exam- Discussion
ination. The symptoms of patients had lasted from
1 to 108 months (average of 12 months). The diag- In 1935, Jackson and Jackson first described vocal
noses of the patients were confirmed by pathology of process contact granulomas, which are non-
specimens taken during the operations. tumorous granulation-like, proliferative tissue,
The lesions of 41.3% (71/168) of the patients who chronic inflammatory lesions located over the tip
were given the conservative treatment (including acid of the cartilaginous region of the vocal processes
280 L. Ma et al.

A1 B1 C1

A2 B2 C2

Figure 2. Female, 48 years, with a granulation-like neoplasm on the vocal process of the right arytenoid. (A1, A2) Images showing the
movement of the bilateral arytenoid before the resection was performed; (B1, B2) images taken 3 days after the operation, showing that the right
vocal cord was arched and in a fixed position; (C1, C2) images taken 3 months after the operation, showing that the bilateral movements of the
arytenoid were normal.

Table I. Maximum phonation times (x ± s) of the patients (n = 42) [9]. In subsequent studies, the clinical manifestations
who were given botulinum toxin type A injections at different time and syndromes of VPG were found to be similar. The
points. main related syndromes are hoarseness, a sore throat,
Before 1 month after 3 months after and the sensation that a foreign body is present. Men
operation operation operation have a relatively higher incidence of this lesion than
women [10]; however, VPG caused by endotracheal
17.3 ± 6.3 13.5 ± 5.4* 22.6 ± 5.2*
intubation occurs more often in women. In the
*p < 0.01, paired-sample t test. present study, 148 (88.1%) patients experienced
various degrees of hoarseness, 111 (66.1%) patients
had the sensation of having a foreign body in the
throat and coughed, 29 (17.3%) patients experienced
Table II. HRB grades of the patients who were given botulinum throat pain, and 16 (9.5%) patients had mild to
toxin type A injections before the operation and 1 month and moderate apnea. Only five (3%) of the patients
3 months after the operation. with VPG exhibited no obvious symptoms upon
Before the 1 month after 3 months after physical examination. There were 23 (16.1%) males
Factor operation (%) operation (%) operation (%) and 18 (72%) females among the patients who had a
history of laryngeal intubation for general anesthesia,
Hoarseness
which was consistent with the results of previous
0 9 (21.4)* 2 (4.8)* 34 (80.95)* reports. The hypothesis of McFerran et al. was
1 16 (38.1)* 6 (14.3)* 8 (19.05)* that because women have a relatively narrow laryn-
2 11 (26.2)* 18 (42.9)* geal cavity and thin mucosa compared with those of
3 6 (14.3)* 16 (38.0)* men, women are more vulnerable to intubation-
Roughness
related injuries, which leads to the formation of a
vocal process ulcer that develops into granuloma
0 18 (42.9)* 15 (35.7) 35 (83.3)*
[11,12].
1 18 (42.9)* 24 (57.1) 7 (16.7)* Most studies have shown that phonation-based
2 5 (11.9)* 3 (7.1) injuries, injuries caused by laryngeal intubation,
3 1 (2.3)* and GER are the primary causes of VPG [13,14].
Breathiness In the present study, 6 patients had a history of
0 16 (38.1)* 1 (2.3)* 39 (92.9)*
laryngeal intubation, 8 patients had definitive GER
confirmed by 24 h pH monitoring or gastroscopy,
1 23 (54.8)* 6 (14.3)* 3 (7.1)*
4 patients had used their voices excessively, and
2 3 (7.1)* 18 (42.9)* 10 patients had no obvious etiology. The incidence
3 17 (40.5)* rate of VPG is low, and the three specific causes
HRB, grade of hoarseness, roughness, and breathiness. mentioned above are responsible for most of the
*p < 0.01, Wilcoxon signed-rank test. reported cases, which indicates that the main
Treatment methods for vocal process granulomas 281

mechanisms underlying the pathogenesis of VPG are among the patients who had a recent history of
still not clear. In addition, these three causes fail to intubation. Microsurgical scissors and a CO2 laser
account for the formation of idiopathic and recalci- were used to perform a radical resection of the lesions
trant granulomas. under a microscope. An 8-0 absorbable suture
The treatments offered to patients with VPG are filament was used to suture the mucosal edge of
driven by the etiology of the lesions. Because the the incision. Then, a four-point injection of 8–15 U
pathogenic mechanisms are unclear, the results of of BTA into the thyroarytenoid muscle of the
treatments – particularly single therapies – are not affected side was conducted. In the present study,
ideal. Conservative therapies, including correcting we applied a microsurgical suturing method using an
bad phonation habits, voice rest, precautions against 8-0 absorbable suture filament to close the wound,
reflux and/or medication using an H2-blocker, and promote healing, and reduce the probability of
medication using a proton-pump inhibitor (PPI), are recurrence. We also injected BTA into the concave
the first-line treatments for VPG. The results of these side of the muscle to limit the movement of the
therapies are not satisfactory because the long-term arytenoid.
nature of the treatment and the occurrence of com- As a chemical denervation agent, BTA was first
plications and adverse reactions typically cause non- used to treat spasmodic dysphonia [18]. In 1995,
compliance. Hanson et al. [15] reported 12 cases of Nasri et al. [2] were the first group to report treating
laryngeal granulomas treated with omeprazole, with VPG by injecting BTA into the thyroarytenoid muscle
an average treatment time of 5 months. Wani and (LTA) and obtained a desirable level of efficacy. The
Woodson [16] used omeprazole or ranitidine to treat success of this therapy was confirmed by the subse-
18 patients, among whom 14 cases had complete quent serial studies. Treatment through BTA injec-
remission after drug administration for 1–20 months, tion was the basis of the theory of the hammer and the
with an average time of 10.4 months. In this study, the anvil as a cause of VGA [19]. Due to the force of
efficiency of 3 months conservative treatment was the collision of the bilateral arytenoid cartilage, the
53%, which is lower than found in other studies. mucosa of the vocal process is damaged, resulting in
This outcome may be due to our short observation the formation of a granuloma. Therefore, inhibiting
time, which was because the patients were eager to the movement of the arytenoid cartilage can facilitate
improve their symptoms as soon as possible. the repair of the mucosal injury and reduce the rate of
Surgery is always controversial. Physicians argue recurrence of VGA. BTA causes temporary paresis of
that surgery should be used only in the patients for the vocal folds, allowing the mucosa of the vocal
whom conservative treatments have failed or in process to regenerate. The total doses used ranged
patients with a large granuloma in the airway. The from 5 U to 20 U. In the present study, the total dose
reason for surgical excision being unacceptable is the of BTA used was 8–15 U, which was divided into four
high recurrence rate; some studies have reported a doses that were injected into the thyroidarytenoid
recurrence rate of up to 90%. The diagnosis of VPG is muscle. Our results showed that the activity of the
performed using video laryngoscopy, but not biopsy. arytenoid on the injected side was limited for 2–3 days
Some of the patients who saw the mass in a video after the injections were performed. The activity of the
recording were afraid of surgery, regardless of what arytenoid was generally normal at 2 months after
diagnosis we gave them. However, because the symp- the injections were performed. The main side effect
toms of VGA, such as hoarseness and a globus of the BTA injections was a breathy voice. Voice
sensation, are persistent, the patients are eager to assessment revealed that the chemical denervation
eliminate them by whatever means possible. Among of the ipsilateral thyroarytenoid muscle was apparent
the single therapies, surgery is the most rapid method 12–72 h after the injection was performed, inhibiting
for removing the granuloma and eliminating the the adduction movement of the arytenoid muscle and
hoarseness and the sensation of the presence of a reducing the strength of the collision of the bilateral
pharyngeal foreign body. Physicians have been vocal process. This state could persist for approxi-
searching for options that would lower the high recur- mately 3 months, after which the denervated neuro-
rence rate of surgery. Hirano et al. [17] proposed muscular junction was fully recovered.
fiberoptic laryngeal surgery as a procedure that facil- First, we removed the granuloma and closed the
itated repeated surgical removal of these lesions. We incision through the surface of the arytenoid cartilage
applied a CO2 laser to resect the lesion and closed the using microsurgery. Then, we took advantage of the
incision using 8-0 absorbable suture filaments and the denervating effect of BTA to inhibit the movement of
interrupted apposition method, along the mucosal the arytenoid cartilage to reduce the force of collision.
edge in 23 patients with VPG, among whom the Moreover, anti-acid medication was given to elimi-
recurrence rate was 21.6%. There was no recurrence nate the pathogenic factors of VPG.
282 L. Ma et al.

The treatment regimen for VPG should be targeted [4] Wang CP, Ko JY, Wang YH, Hu YL, Hsiao TY. Vocal
and comprehensive due to the complexity and diver- process granuloma – a result of long-term observation in
53 patients. Oral Oncol 2009;45:821–5.
sity of the inducing factors. Only a comprehensive [5] Ylitalo R, Lindestad PA. A retrospective study of contact
treatment approach can shorten the treatment period, granuloma. Laryngoscope 1999;109:433–6.
improve the response rate, and reduce the rate of [6] Song Y, Shi L, Zhao Y, Zhao D, Shi M, Deng Z. Surgical
complications and adverse reactions. Combined removal followed by radiotherapy for refractory vocal process
therapy is considered to be the preferred choice for granuloma. J Voice 2012;26:666; e1–5.
[7] Hong-Gang D, He-Juan J, Chun-Quan Z, Guo-Kang F.
treating refractory VPG. Surgery and proton pump inhibitors for treatment of vocal
Although VPG is a benign lesion, it affects patients’ process granulomas. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 2013;270:
quality of life due to its persistence and the long-term 2921–6.
nature of its treatment. An otolaryngologist should be [8] Farwell DG, Belafsky PC, Rees CJ. An endoscopic grading
system for vocal process granuloma. J Laryngol Otol 2008;
concerned about how to shorten the treatment pro-
122:1092–5.
cess and reduce the relapse rate. Surgical removal is a [9] Jackson C, Jackson CL. Contact ulcer of the larynx. Arch
rapid treatment method with a high recurrence rate. Otolaryngol 1935;22:1–15.
Surgical resection combined with the use of other [10] Lemos EM, Sennes LU, Imamura R, Tsuji DH. Vocal
conservative treatment methods may provide a bright process granuloma: clinical characterization, treatment and
future for patients with this disease. evolution. Braz J Otorhinolaryngol 2005;71:494–8.
[11] Pontes P, De Biase N, Kyrillos L, Pontes A. Importance of
glottic configuration in the development of posterior laryn-
geal granuloma. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2001;110:765–9.
Acknowledgment [12] McFerran DJ, Abdullah V, Gallimore AP, Pringle MB,
Croft CB. Vocal process granuloma. J Laryngol Otol 1994;
This study was supported by a grant from the 108:216–20.
[13] Orloff LA, Goldman SN. Vocal fold granuloma: successful
National Natural Science Foundation of China (no.
treatment with botulinum toxin. Otolaryngol Head Neck
81170900). Surg 1999;121:410–13.
[14] Spector JE, Werkhaven JA, Spector NC, Huang S, Page RN,
Declaration of interest: The authors report no Baranowski B, et al. Preservation of function and histologic
conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible appearance in the injured glottis with topical mitomycin-C.
Laryngoscope 1999;109:1125–9.
for the content and writing of the paper. [15] Hanson DG, Jiang JJ. Diagnosis and management of
chronic laryngitis associated with reflux. Am J Med 2000;
108:112S–9S.
References [16] Wani MK, Woodson GE. Laryngeal contact granuloma.
Laryngoscope 1999;109:1589–93.
[1] Carroll TL, Gartner-Schmidt J, Statham MM, Rosen CA. [17] Hirano S, Kojima H, Tateya I, Ito J. Fiberoptic laryngeal
Vocal process granuloma and glottal insufficiency: surgery for vocal process granuloma. Ann Otol Rhinol
an overlooked etiology? Laryngoscope 2010;120:114–20. Laryngol 2002;111:789–93.
[2] Nasri S, Sercarz JA, McAlpin T, Berke GS. Treatment of [18] Blitzer A, Brin MF, Fahn S, Lange D, Lovelace RE. Botu-
vocal fold granuloma using botulinum toxin type A. Laryn- linum toxin (BOTOX) for the treatment of “spastic dys-
goscope 1995;105:585–8. phonia” as part of a trial of toxin injections for the treatment
[3] Wang CT, Lai MS, Lo WC, Liao LJ, Cheng PW. Intrale- of other cranial dystonias. Laryngoscope 1986;96:1300–1.
sional steroid injection: an alternative treatment option for [19] Roh HJ, Goh EK, Chon KM, Wang SG. Topical inhalant
vocal process granuloma in ten patients. Clin Otolaryngol steroid (budesonide, Pulmicort nasal) therapy in intubation
2013;38:77–81. granuloma. J Laryngol Otol 1999;113:427–32.
Copyright of Acta Oto-Laryngologica is the property of Taylor & Francis Ltd and its content
may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright
holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.

You might also like