The Forrester Wave™: Enterprise Fraud
Management, Q3 2021
The Eight Providers That Matter Most And How They Stack Up
Summary
“Th teportahow: how each provider messes Up end help ecu and isk management rl aud
Tonks
- Common 2) (Cenren~+) (ramcomeee +) Cam
Workflow, Ease Of Model Building Differentiate Vendors
‘ich nancial isttutons (Fs) having to respond In eal tine and across channels, to ever faster
hanging patems in payment and nonpayment Fave, sk meceling has tanstoned Fram a9
nn or semiannus campaign to & continuous acy, Date scents labor costs have grown
signieantly fester than general Inbox costs, ané regulatory and compliance requirements are
becoming harser one harder to meet
‘As result of these tenes, enterprise troud management EFM) customers should lok for
rowders hat
+ Provide flexole enc customizase workflow for eizen cate scent to bul a medal
Vendors’ solutions inereasigly offer model governance wih checks for model finess and
cies. Wee seeing giant leaps in vendors’ ably t provde an inEFM-a9p workbench wth 3
woskow that enables clzen date scientists and business users to bul rain, and manage
canned ang custom-built models ang macel ensembles. Workxencnes ineressingly also
Provide the abity te inegrat tn aty modes (fle vis Jupyter notebooks into the Fs
‘raud management risk scoring environment
+ Integrate te custorer's cum ard third pry data fest with quelty checks and workfow Bets
val and quantity of data that crves transaction decisoning fe. payment amaunt, ATM
locaton, mobile device operating system verson, ee) greatly endanes the seeursey of sk
19‘oreo maintain an agile stance against new and emerging Haus paters.
+ Autorrete maintenance of segrrentafin of customers enc erties, Behavorl profiing of
customers sre ents (ATM location, phone numbers, ayia! adetesses, ete) ar thet
segments allows Fs te more acurately predict aud, even for accouns that ae brand new
ané fr which not much transactional data yet ets. EFM sohtions that offer automatically
recommended andr undated customer are ently segments help reduce model building
‘ye times and — because of thelr greater accuracy ane ler false postives — customer
Evaluation Summary
“The Forrester Wave" evaluation highlghts Leaders, Strong Performers, Contenders, and
Challengers. ts en assessment ofthe lop vendors inthe marke: end does at represent he enze
‘vendor lndscape. Youll find mare information about hs market in our repens on EFM,
‘We intend this evaluation tebe 2 starting pet only and encourage eliets to view procuct
evaluations and adopt teria weightings using the Exet based vender competsen tool (see
Figure and see Figure 2}. Clekhe link athe begining of ths repor on Forestercom to
Forester eve Entre Fraud Menepemon 032021
29Wishor trey | > sone stateay
—
“2000
Sane: Fors asexch he Unnuared praaiion, or ara RB
Pee
Forster ave Frere Fret Menegement creer 032091SON
Ccurent offering
Dt ietcoration
EFM adinistator management
fedawrng ne
Modal lng
‘Sipenand and ureupervind ML,
Model expsinabity and
‘ovenance
‘Gueve management
poalya investigation
Chennai
“Tansacton pee
Reporting
Seay rumbor of
investigator.
Swrateny
Execution roadmap
Make approach: EFM
Sevoopere
Maxketapposch: EFM sles
Data tegration plans
‘Aeinceater manager plans
Data sient worktow
Inprovernet pans
Fule-bened ak sory plan
Supeniced machine
issn psn
Unsupervised and deep
framing pers
Modal explinatity plane
Model governance plans
Procuctzed mode pane
‘Queue management pans
ego ad at
Suppor stating
Profesional servos staftng
Parser conten
Market presence
‘SaaS EFM revenue
‘On-pem EFM revenue
EAA revenue gon
PSP FHA 2 HBR BEBE
ea ae39 938
$98sa22 se998 8
282
300
100
300
1.00
300
300
500
192
1.00
1.00
1.00
100
1.00
1.00
100
300
200
ase
88
eee
500
300
gees
324
1.00
500
00
300
500
100
1.00
500
‘At scoms are baredon a sal of wes 05 torah
Vendor Offerings
302
500
300
500
300
1.00
300
200
a6
300
300
500
300
500
200
aa
ae
500
ees
100
300
500
gees
300
500
500
100
300
300
00
ge 888
400
300
1.00
100
190
100
100
1.00
100
300
500
200
300
190
100
300
500
500
300
500
500
200
500
500
ars
500
300
500
00
500
500
00
500
00
% %
220
4100
100
100
100
500
‘500
3.00
120
4.00
4100
00
100
000
000
100
100
300
408
1.00
500
500
500
200
200
1.00
az
1.00
500
00
300
3.00
300
100
400
1.00
49‘lune Vendors nd Frock fermen
Product version Version reaase
Vendor Product evausted ‘oahiied ‘te
ACI Wore Proetv Fisk Manager 20 savunny2029
Featespoce — ARIC lk Hub ane
Fooazal “Wareacton Fraud 23
OO Fcon Frau Manager
1 1B Ser Payments 62
NICE Actmize integrated Fraud Management 10. (FN)
sa SA Adoptive Authentication loud aes anwar 2025
ss ‘SAS Enterprise Fad Soon a
Vendor Profiles
‘Our analysis uncovered the following strengths and weaknesses of incvdual vendors
Leaders
+ NICE Actimize offers strong model bucing Gut lags n partner ecosyelem. The verdlor
Inuoduced ts new secount aud Solution as wellas Xeeed te uncover new aud aatteins.
Sight Cloud analytes allows customers to use ther own madi for fae cetection The
‘vendor plas to: ease and speed up deta acgulsiton ene processing 2} execute ants A
{st strategy using Incremental earring ane model governance improvements and 3) use
consortium data or improved rau risk searing. The vender hes robust plans fo improve eta
Invegraton and admin strator management buts behing compareete ether vendors ints
Plans for model expinaity ad oreseth of pat
scosytem The sokilon provides exible
data ntegation an rtes-basee risk scoring and alerting with sept and guided ule
authoring and rule impact analysis and visual rule tuning feeeback, Model buleing also shines:
Comperson of cham and challenger mocels is expt availabe, Anatyst Investigation
screens are very easy to customize For some capabilites, aminsaters ang data selentsts
rust ute multiple, ané often thiek cent, nemwelb management interfaces, The venéar's EFM
‘olution developer bench cepth i aller than tat of most competitors and— compares to
ie marke presence — the vendor's molementationparnerseasystem is smal The sokon it
«great or ergenizations looking for an ende-ené‘raud management solution with bult-in
channel and transseionspeci loge
‘SAS spers a strong menegement fr rs scorira but legs in ete tegration workew The
‘yencor has been emphasizing inegraton of ts EFM porvolo with ts AML porvole tough
the Data Orchestation and Visual Ivestigatar components underpinning both the EFM ane
AML solution. Par ofthe ‘raud management ane AML [FRM strategy sinvestment int the
‘case management funetonslty The vender plan 09) nvest in its clouetnatvedeclioning
sfehtecture: 2} expand ts outot-ne-box (COTE) transaction monkorng strategies for dgtal
poyments and ienty fraud and 3) use thie paty datasources wa a standardized connector
‘Homework The vendors aéminstater management and mocel explainabity ane
‘nnaneement pins reall shine, but the veneorsexseilon strategy reacmap and plans forconrgurable, The solvton lags in data integraton worklow capabties and oferng
productzed, OOTE macels or peer-to-peer payments. The solutions «great for
organizations wth exstng SAS programming skl sets running large anaytes and data
‘Strong Petformers
+ Feeturespace has strong medelaulng but fll behind in squeue maregemert Featurespace
In developing automated deep behaviorslnetworcs (ADBN} to achleve better pretecion
outemate feature extraction using Its new-generation ADBNS; 2) develop rskcbased
authentication for 3D Secure payment authorization; ane!3) enable its strategy stu toolto
make new or amended analytes eontiguations. The venders execution roadmap end
supenased machine learning plans are strong; however, procuctzed model plans and
professions serves slang Ing Benin other venders. lens reper that— everthing being
equal —the solutions susenptions usualy las expensive than tose of ater compettors
FM seminstrater management eluding mulitenoney management ne deep lesinng
basee decisoning ate ahead ofthe competion. Supsert for mule urencles and ule
performance dashboards are easy use. The venéor i behing competitors when itcomes to
I Noth Aivercan ane APAC istlled base, Queue management and OOTR models for
supporting various channels eb, mobile, phone, and in-person} as wellas support forthe
150 20022 message format are behind those of competitors the vendor plans enhancements
Intis ate). The soluson sa great ft for fms wit enstng EFM operational processes
FICC provides sora data itecraticn but lags ln segrrentation managemert ICO hes been
Investing nits eloue-based arabes platform ane, acearcng o data an statist collected,
publishes FeleonIteligence Network Insight ous benchmas os cents. The vendor
plans to: futher ntegrate the Falcon Avthensicatin Suite (E2MCOM aequiston) wth ts EFM,
ein 2) provide benchmarks a8 to how the lent individu model performance compares
to tat other consortium members and 3) expand behavioral prafing cepadlies FICO has
5 deep bene in developers working on is EFM sokitan ane has convinlng ests scents
\wortow improvement plans, but ag nthe areas of administctor management procuet
‘enhancements and syperised machine leaning pln. The solition provides nice etn
Integration ad atcbute mepping capasies and oes greeter ule setiarary fr detecting
‘raue on various enannel (onine web, mobile app elc} and provides outstanding, O08,
Prodetzed supper for modeling rk or eiferent Lansacton types fespecally card
payments). The oluton lagen administrator management, segrientstion ard benaviorl
rest for card issuers with no or ite data science -house siete In need ofa manages
endto-end EFM solution
Feeczal cers strorg data intesraticn werefow but ecks In cuete management. As the
‘vendors EFM solution's enterpse-