Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cover page
1 Based on the ILO PRODOC and adapted for the Masters in Management of Development, C.Oehl
1
PRODOC
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This project objective is to empower small farmers in Central-South region of the State of Paraná
in Brazil by enabling them to produce and to sell high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder in
order to increase their profits and improve their livelihood.
10,000 small farmers depend on their yerba mate production in Central-South region and 37,000 in
the whole state of Paraná. Those small farmers sell their yerba mate crop and their other crops as
commodities with little value-added. They try to make more money by increasing the volume of
their sales, but they struggle to compete with the big agribusiness companies. That is why small
farmers are a poor and vulnerable group. However, yerba mate can improve small farmers’
livelihood because it has an enormous unexplored potential to become a product of a high value-
added.
Yerba mate is consumed mostly as a hot or cold beverage and, like tea, coffee or cocoa, it can be
roasted in different ways to produce different kinds of beverages and, therefore, develop a gourmet
market, as coffee and tea markets already did.
In order to achieve its goals, the project will work on three fronts:
1. Raising awareness among small farmers and among yerba mate consumers about high-
quality varieties of yerba mate powder;
2. Training small farmers to produce high-quality varieties; and
3. Training small farmers in finances, business administration and marketing in order to
exploit all the economic potential of high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder.
To realize all the necessary activities, the project needs EUR 1,808,000.00 and two years.
2.1. Introduction
Agribusiness is responsible for 33.9 percent of the GDP of the State of Paraná, Brazil (Ipardes,
2020). Despite its main crops are soybeans, maize, wheat and beans, the State of Paraná is
known by its yerba mate production. Paraná produces 87% of Brazilian yerba mate.
Yerba mate’s supply chain engages more than 100,000 families from Paraná and the livelihood of
37,000 families of small farmers depends directly on yerba mate (Government of the State of
Paraná, 2019).
Not only yerba mate, but most of the food served in Brazilian tables come from small farmers,
however, they receive just 14% of the public investment (Ministry of Agriculture, 2019). One reason
for that is the big agribusiness company being very powerful and well connected, leaving the small
farmers in a very vulnerable and neglected position.
Yerba mate has the potential to improve small farmers income because it has a lot of space to
grow. Instead of being sold just as a commodity, it could be sold as a high value-added product.
Yerba mate is a plant consume mostly as a beverage. It is similar to coffee and tea. This
resemblance to coffee and tea is what make yerba mate so interesting to be exploit. Yerba mate
could follow the same path coffee and tea beverages already followed. From being a standard and
cheap beverage, it can become a gourmet beverage with many kinds of roasting and blends, and a
high value-added.
2
PRODOC
This project, by increasing small farmers profits and by improving their livelihood, will help Brazil to
achieve the following Sustainable Development Goals: SDG 1, no poverty; SDG 8, economic
growth; SDG 9, innovation and infrastructure; and SDG 10, to reduce inequalities.
2.2. Sector analysis
The State of Paraná is located in the southern region of Brazil. It is divided in ten mesoregions and
399 municipalities. This project will take place in the Central-South mesoregion (see map below).
Paraná is the place of the National Park of Iguaçu (Iguazu Falls), considered by UNESCO as a
World Heritage site. Close to the park, is Itaipu Hydroelectric. Itaipu is the second biggest
hydroelectric in the world and it represents 15% of electric power in Brazil.
3
PRODOC
One of the biggest political coalition in Brazil is Bancada Ruralista, which objective is to defend the
interests of big agribusiness companies. This creates a lot of tension between those big
companies and the neglected vulnerable groups, such as, indigenous people and small farmers. In
Paraná is not different. This fact is reflected in the destination of public funds. Only 14% of those
funds are meant to help small farmers, even when most of the food consumed in Brazil come from
small farmers’ crops.
A third of Paraná’s economy is related to agribusiness. The state stands out in the production of
soybeans, maize, wheat, sugarcane, cassava, beans, tomato, orange, yerba mate, oat, barley,
peach, tangerine and strawberry. However, the state is known for its yerba mate production. 87%
of the yerba mate produced in Brazil comes from Paraná.
The yerba mate supply chain employs over 100,000 families in Paraná. 37,000 of those families
are from small farmers producing yerba mate as one of their main crops. In the studied region,
Central-South mesoregion of Paraná, 10,000 families’ livelihood directly depend on yerba mate
production.
Yerba mate is a very important
plant for south Brazil and other
countries, such as, Paraguay,
Uruguay, and Argentina because it
is part of their culture and their
traditions. 96% of yerba mate is
consume as a hot beverage called
chimarrão or just mate. Many of
people in those places drink mate
instead of coffee or tea. They drink
it in their homes, in their jobs and
in social events. It is not only about
drinking yerba mate per se, the
whole ritual of preparing, drinking
and sharing the same cup in a
circle of friends and colleague is Yerba mate plant – José Fernando Ogura, 2019
very important for them.
4
PRODOC
5
PRODOC
6
PRODOC
lives. Every year it is more difficult for them to compete against the big agribusiness companies
and the inequality gets bigger and bigger.
In order to change this situation, NGOs and the government try to help the small farmers through
agriculture projects. However, these projects are focused into expand what the small farmers are
already doing, instead of bringing innovation and adding more value to their crops. This is the main
difference of this project. The foundation to improve the small farmers livelihood will come from
innovation.
2.4. Target group analysis
The target group will be small farmers from the Central-South region of the State of Paraná in
Brazil because this region already has a well-developed standard yerba mate market, more than
10,000 families already produce yerba mate in there, therefore, transforming a standard yerba
mate market into a market of high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder will be easier than doing
it in other places.
This project will help the small farmers to improve their business and to create a network in order
to empower them financially and politically. This project will create networks and will train the small
farmers to produce and to sell high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder. The direct beneficiaries
will be the yerba mate small farmers in the Central-South region of Paraná. They will be more
empowered, but the ultimate beneficiaries will be the whole region inhabitants because, by
transforming the yerba mate market into a high value-added market, it will develop directly other
markets like tourism –by gastronomic routes, for example– and, indirectly, other markets will
benefit from it as well, since the region would become richer. With more money flowing to the
region, more people will spend in supermarkets, in entertainment, in education, in health services,
in beauty salons, among many others services and products.
In this new high added-value market, manual work would not be the only kind of work available.
Marketing, business administration, research and innovation will be necessary as well. This would
give to women the opportunity to work in a field where most of the workers are men. In addition, as
other markets, such as tourism, will benefit from this project indirectly, other people with different
personality traits and skills could get a better job, improve their livelihood and increase their
income.
2.5. Stakeholder analysis
The implementing partner will be Matte N’ Roll. Matte N’ Roll is an organization that works to
engage players from the yerba mate market in order to create a yerba mate network and to bring
value to their members.
Matte N’ Roll has a vast experience in the yerba mate sector and it is always looking to new ways
to add value to the yerba mate producers and consumers. The founding members of Matte N’ Roll
are engineers, cooks and entrepreneurs of the food sector that already succeeded in creating a
network of local farmers and food producers in the State of Paraná. It means, besides having the
know-how, Matte N’ Roll is well-connected with the local authorities, restaurants owners and
tourism agents.
Matte N’ Roll has the management skills and the technical capacity of implementing this project,
however, it is lack of financial resources to implement it.
From the public sector, there are two different government levels that could be engaged to aid in
this project: the municipality level and the state level. The agriculture secretariats from three cities
(Guarapuava, Palmas and Pitanga) and the agriculture secretariat from the State of Paraná have
experience developing and implementing projects for yerba mate production development.
7
PRODOC
However, those projects were not related to innovation, that is why Matte N’ Roll should lead the
implementation of this project.
Chambers of commerce of agribusiness will have an important role to create a network with
political power and would help the small farmers to present their problems and to develop policies
that could lead to solutions.
Using Matte N’ Roll and the public sector to engage restaurants owners will be essential to help
the small farmers to sell their high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder.
A stakeholder that should be considered because it has a lot of political and financial power are the
big agribusiness companies. It is true that in this boutique market a small farmer could compete
against and big agribusiness company, but only in a real free market or in a well-regulated market,
but none of them is the reality in the region. The agribusiness sector is controlled by those big
companies and they have a lot of influence in the creation of laws, rules and regulation policies.
8
PRODOC
9
PRODOC
With this strategy, the small farmers will be well-connected and will have the know-how to produce
and to sell high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder.
4.2. Lessons Learned and synergies
Three years ago, the founding members of Matte N’ Roll created the Locavorista project.
Locavorista is a gourmet lounge where local entrepreneurs from Paraná can display and sell their
products. In Locavorista, local producers of draft beer, granola, honey and also mate sell their
products.
In order to engage people to Locavorista’s project, the staff organize events such as: fashion
shows, sustainability workshops, barista training course, coffee tasting, among others. In addition,
having a restaurant in Locavorista with Paraná’s typical sandwiches and desserts has been
essential to have a constant flow of costumers.
Locavorista succeeded and it could join forces with Matte N’ Roll in order to increase the chances
of success of this project.
Another place where the project could learn from is the coffee and tea markets. Since yerba mate
is similar to those beverages, yerba mate could mirror the paths coffee and tea followed. Both,
coffee and tea, innovated in how the beans or the leaves were roasted and transform their
markets. From commodity beverages they jumped into gourmet beverages with high value-added.
This project can learn not only from the production of new varieties of coffee and tea, but from their
marketing strategies as well.
4.3. The Logical Framework
The ultimate impact this project aims to reach is to empower politically and financially the target
group, small farmers. For achieving this, small farmers should make more money and have an
active voice in chambers of commerce.
The outcome that will build the necessary foundation to reach the impact is small farmers making
more money by selling their new varieties of yerba mate powder at a higher price. With more
money, they will have more economic power and, with the right guide and investments, that
economic power could be translated to political power as well.
Enabling small farmers to produce and to sell high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder is the
core strategy of this project. In order to achieve that, four outputs are necessary. Firstly, it is
important to raise the awareness of these new high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder among
the small farmers and among the consumers of yerba mate. Secondly, the small farmers should
have the needed equipment and infrastructure to produce these varieties. Thirdly, small farmers
should know how to produce these varieties. Finally, the small farmers should know how to sell
these new products.
In order to generate those outputs, the project will do activities which objectives are: to train the
small farmers in producing and selling high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder and in acquiring
and building the needed infrastructure; to create networks and events that allow to build
partnerships and business relations; and to disseminate the new high-quality varieties of yerba
mate powder through well-developed marketing strategies.
4.4. Impact / Development Objective and Link to Strategic Plan(s) & programs,
incl SDGs
The desired impact of this project is to empower financially and politically small farmers from the
Central-South region of the State of Paraná in Brazil.
10
PRODOC
In addition, this project will help Brazil to achieve the following Sustainable Development Goals:
SDG1, no poverty; SDG8, economic growth; SDG9, innovation and infrastructure; and SDG10, to
reduce inequalities.
Small farmers will produce yerba mate with high value-added instead of producing just a
commodity. It means, they will make more money with real value attached to it and it will help them
to develop themselves economically without creating a financial bubble or without leading to
inflation. Besides that, it could build the foundation to other markets thrive, resulting into a solid
economic growth in the whole region.
The innovation in producing high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder and making yerba mate
crops more profitable per area unit, will help directly to develop more infrastructure such as
restaurants, tourism services and training facilities. With a more developed tourism, other
infrastructure like roads and supermarkets will be more profitable and less risky to be built.
Since this project focus on a vulnerable group, small farmers, the success of this project will help
to reduce inequalities between a powerful group, big agribusiness companies, and small farmers.
Improving equality will lead to a series of other benefits, for example, there will be less violence
because the tension between big agribusiness companies and neglected groups like indigenous
people and small farmers will be reduced.
4.5. Outcome
The outcome of this project is having small farmers improving their livelihood through selling high-
quality varieties of yerba mate powder at higher prices in comparison with the standard roasted
yerba mate. In order to do that, the project will generate the following outputs: small farmers and
yerba mate costumers are aware of high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder; small farmers
have the equipment to produce high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder; and small farmers
know how to produce and to sell those high-quality varieties.
In addition, with those outputs, small farmers could make more money and be well-connected.
Money and a good network are two useful resources, with them, small farmers could invest in
health insurances, in more education, in their own business or in new businesses; and they could
be heard in the chambers of commerce and in the local and national governments. In other words,
this project’s outputs and outcome could be quite useful tools to empower financially and politically
the current vulnerable group of small farmers.
4.6. Outputs and activities
This project has four expected outputs: to raise the awareness about high-quality varieties of yerba
mate powder among producers and among consumers; small farmers know how to acquire the
equipment and to build the infrastructure to produce those varieties; small farmers know how to
produce those varieties; and small farmers know how to sell high-quality varieties with a high
value-added.
To raise the awareness, Matte N’ Roll will work to enroll small farmers from the Central-South
region of Paraná. It will help to create a network with small farmers and others important players
from the yerba mate market. In addition, Matte N’ Roll will organize a yerba mate fair and will use
ambassadors to promote high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder in restaurants, clubs and
cultural events. It is important to highlight that drinking yerba mate is a very strong cultural habit in
South Brazil, that is why cultural and entertainment environment are essential to raise the desired
awareness.
To equip small farmers with roaster machines and other equipment, Matte N’ Roll will support their
members to apply to funds, to look for manufacturers of roaster machines and to organize their
members in groups to invest as a group and to have bulk discounts. In addition, Matte N’ Roll will
11
PRODOC
support small farmers to build the required infrastructure. Besides the work doing directly with the
small farmers, Matte N’ Roll will work with the authorities to develop economic incentives, like tax
reduction, in order to help small farmers to buy the equipment and to build the infrastructure.
The small farmers will be trained in workshops of just a few days duration and also in an extensive
course of one semester. The workshops will be more diffused in order to reach more families from
more distant areas. The extensive courses will take place in Guarapuava, Palmas and/or Pitanga.
The project will purchase roaster machines and all the necessary equipment to allow the
participants of the extensive courses to learn how to produce high-quality varieties in a practical
way and not only in a theoretical one.
In addition, the workshops and the course will have business administration, personal finances and
marketing lessons in order to allow the small farmers not only to produce, but to sell their
production in the most profitable and sustainable way.
4.7. Indicators
At the output level, there will be five indicators, as following described.
Raising awareness would be measure with two indicators. One for small farmers and the other for
yerba mate customers. The first one will be the percentage of small farmers knowing more than
one high-quality varieties in the studied region. The second one will be the percentage of cafés,
restaurants and clubs’ customers in Guarapuava, Palmas and Pitanga knowing about high-quality
varieties of yerba mate powder.
The third indicator will be the percentage of small farmers in the studied region equipped with the
necessary equipment to produce high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder.
The fourth indicator will be the percentage of small farmers in the studied region producing high-
quality varieties of yerba mate powder.
The last indicator will be the percentage of small farmers in the studied region selling at least one
high-quality variety at two times the commodity price or higher.
The outcome will be measured with just one indicator: the price of high-quality varieties of yerba
mate powder. It was chosen just an economic indicator to the outcome because, even with raising
awareness as an output, the true purpose of the project is to improve the livelihood of the small
farmers by helping them to make more money. Developing the yerba mate market is just a mean
to achieve that. The current price of an arroba of yerba mate is BRL 18 and the target price for an
arroba of high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder is BRL 100.
The impact of empowering politically and financially the small farmers will be measured with three
indicators. The indicator to measure the political empowerment will be the number of agribusiness
chambers of commerce in the State of Paraná with at least one chair being occupied by a small
farmer. For the financially empowerment will be used the small farmers’ per capita revenue from
their activities and their per capita income as well.
4.8. Assumptions and Risk Analysis
As identified in the frame logic and in the risk register, following are the main assumptions and
risks within the project.
Assumptions:
• Yerba mate small farmers are open to improve and/or change their livelihood;
• Roaster machines are available;
• Yerba mate small farmers' education is enough to allow them to understand the training on
producing high-quality varieties;
12
PRODOC
• Yerba mate small farmers' education is enough to allow them to understand the training on
personal finances, business management and marketing;
• Matterias (like a café for yerba mate) and other restaurants can do the marketing and the
sales of yerba mate powder new varieties;
• Existing yerba mate culture and tradition are open to new yerba mate powder varieties;
• Yerba mate small farmers will make more money by selling high-quality varieties;
• Richer yerba mate small farmers will be more powerful; and
• Yerba mate chambers of commerce and other chambers of commerce would support small
farmers.
Risks:
• The support of the president Bolsonaro is decreasing due to his reaction to covid-19
pandemic and this could lead to political instability in the federal level. In order to decrease
the impact of this risk, only the municipality and state government will be involved in active
roles.
• As result of the pandemic, small farmers could not attend to the trainings and workshops in
order to avoid agglomeration. In order to mitigate this risk, all measures recommended by
the WHO and by the local governments would be applied.
• The devaluation of the Brazilian Real could raise the prices for import equipment. Even with
funds in Euros or American Dollars, the devaluation of the Brazilian Real will increase the
costs of production and it could jeopardize the sales. In order to mitigate this risk, the
project will give priority to purchase from local manufacturers.
• Yerba mate small farmers could not engage with the project because they could see it as
too risky or they could just do not understand the benefits of it. In order to avoid this risk, it
is essential to engage the small farmers at the beginning of the project in a participative
way. Doing that, small farmers will feel the projects as their own.
13
PRODOC
Finally, the marketing unit will be responsible for all marketing affairs, such as, advertising the
trainings, engaging small farmers into Matte N’ Roll and working with the ambassadors.
The target group, small farmers from the studied region that already produce yerba mate powder,
besides attending to the trainings and applying what they learned, they will collaborate to create
the workshops and the courses, they will help to create the networks and they will help to develop
any other unforeseen activity in order to make this project their own and fits their needs. For that,
Matte N’ Roll staff is trained in participatory approach for project development and management.
The secretariats of agriculture from the municipalities’ government will be responsible to give the
permits and to give support to Matte N’ Roll in which programs, if any, this project could fit for
funding or for other kind of help, such as, lending office or events infrastructures.
The role for the State secretariat of agriculture is to be aware of this project. This could allow
synergy with other future projects and could help to scale up this project for the whole State.
Chambers of commerce do not have an active role, but they are important to empower politically
the small farmers. That is why a good communication between small farmers and the chambers of
commerce through Matte N’ Roll in essential.
5.2. Management Arrangements
Following, the organizational chart from Matte N’ Roll for this project:
Besides these people, fifteen assistants will be hired. Six of them for the training unit, one for the
finance unit, and four for the marketing unit. Additionally, four assistants will be needed for
monitoring and evaluation of the project.
6. SUSTAINABILITY
As the project is aimed at improving livelihood of the local small farmers through enabling
them to produce and to sell high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder, ownership by
small farmers is a key element.
14
PRODOC
Project implementation project will have a participatory approach from the beginning until
the end. Matte N’ Roll understands how this is vital for the project to be a success. That is
why in the first phase of the project, Matte N’ Roll will visit the small farmers in their farms
and talk to them about the project. This conversation will be done at a yerba mate circle.
A yerba mate circle creates a light, however serious environment. In the region, a yerba
mate circle is an intimate and solemn rite. It is ideal to have a truthful talk with the small
farmers. They will feel comfortable to speak their minds honestly and they will listen with
an open mind as well. Moreover, talking about improving yerba mate when consuming
yerba mate is an additional benefit.
Matte N’ Roll will create a set of questions to generate a debate, however, the conversation
cannot be conducted as a survey because it could jeopardize the intimate and honest
atmosphere.
▪ Policy support
Brazil is committed with 2030 Agenda and its SDGs. Since this project helps directly to
achieve four of the SDGs, it will receive support from the Federal government.
In the state level, there are many efforts to boost small agribusiness. That is why the State
government through its agriculture secretariat constantly works with agribusiness
cooperatives.
In the municipality level, there is a great support to agriculture because it is the main
economic activity in the region.
Even with this great support from all the government levels, we cannot forget this project
will be implemented by the private sector and, when succeeded, it will be economically
independent, actually, it could be one of the main economic engines of the region, and,
probably, it will not need furthers funds.
The main support this project will need from the authorities after the two years will be
getting the permits to make events and trainings and to endorse them.
▪ Appropriate technology
The main hard technology used in the project are the roaster machines. These machines
are easy to do maintenance and are easy to find spares. They are like an oven, it means,
they do not have state of the art technology. It will be easy to find qualified people to repair
them.
Besides the hardware, this project relies on marketing tools and strategies to communicate
effectively and to reach a greater share of the target group.
▪ Socio-cultural aspects
Drinking yerba mate beverage is a very important cultural thing in the region. It is not only
drinking a beverage, but it is a whole rite. With a good marketing strategy, this fact could
be very beneficial for the project. It could improve the tradition by giving more flavors of
beverages and by giving a gourmet approach that allows people to have fun by tasting
new varieties of yerba mate powder. Also, the Gaucho tradition from South Brazil, Uruguay
and Argentina could be disseminate to other countries.
▪ Gender equality
Rural environment in Brazil could improve its gender equality. Now, the work doing in the
farms are mostly done by man. However, with this project more skills will be necessary,
15
PRODOC
such as, creativity, marketing, business administration, tourism, among others. That will
create more jobs in areas more willing to give space to women.
▪ Environment protection
Yerba mate is a plant original from South Brazil. That fact is important for the
environment because using autochthonous flora is safer for the environment. In addition,
the idea of the project is to decouple the increasing of profits to the increasing of volume.
In order to make more money, the farmers will not need to increase their crops and all
the environmental impact attached to it.
This project will create a network and will strengthen current institution in order to make
them able to continue the trainings and to face any management challenge. Besides
helping those institutions and creating a network, this project will help the target group to
develop their own management capacities. In the trainings, business administration
lectures will be taught to the small farmers, allowing them to manage their own business
and future projects. In addition, through connecting small farmers to other small farmers
and to other important players from the yerba mate market, they will have more tools and
help to overcome further challenges.
▪ Financial and economic viability
After the two years of this project, funded by the European Union, the trainings given by
Matte N’ Roll will continue in order to reach more small farmers within the studied region
and abroad. The necessary amount to continue the activities will be less than the required
to implement this project because many of the investment will be reused, for example, the
roaster machines.
The continuation of the services will be funded by the members of Matte N’ Roll and, if
necessary, funding from local government and strategic partners from the private, such as
restaurants owner, will be consider. In addition, if any small farmer would like to displays
his or her products in Matte N’ Roll facilities, he or she will be charged and the money
would be used to fund the trainings. This kind of business is already happening in Matte
N’ Roll facilities with other products, such as, honey, granola and draft beer.
This project is highly profitable and will benefit the whole region. The same boom the coffee
and the tea markets have, could happen with the yerba mate market as well. From being
just a commodity sold at BRL 18 an arroba (15 kg), a cup of gourmet mate using less than
100 gr of yerba mate could be sold in a Matteria for the same BRL 18. It means, 150 times
the commodity price in value added only in the yerba mate market. Besides that, other
markets will benefit from it, for example, the tourism sector.
There are strategies that will make the tourism sector benefit from this project. Some of
them are creating routes of mate’s product tasting where the tourists can visit the different
shops and town. Also, creating a certificate of origin in order to create a brand is an
interesting strategy. An idea that could work well is to give the tourist a passport with some
suggested shops and when they spend a specific amount of money, they stamp their
passport. If they have a minimum number of stamps, they can exchange their passport for
a nice gift from the route. Those are example of how the mate market and the tourism
market could thrive together in synergy.
This project acknowledges that the value-added could not reach the small farmers’ hands.
That is why the project will work to add value at the beginning of the yerba mate supply
16
PRODOC
chain and will train the small farmers in sales and marketing in order to see that value-
added reflected in the price of the small farmers’ products.
At the end of the project, a whole training and marketing infrastructure will be fully operating in
Matte N’ Roll facilities. Due to this project, Matte N’ Roll will be able to continue with the trainings,
raising awareness and expanding the networks.
The project manager will lead the Matte N’ Roll’s Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) team. The
team, made of four people, will be responsible to collect and to analyze the data.
The outputs will be measured through five indicators. The M&E team will conduct surveys to collect
the data for the indicators. The team will disaggregate the outputs’ indicators by target group,
gender, and education level. For the raising awareness output, there will be an extra
disaggregation level: tool or activity used to raise awareness.
One indicator, selling price of high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder, will be used to evaluate
the outcome. The M&E team will collect this indicator through research. The source of verification
will be Esalq website and report. Esalq is a research institute from Brazil specialized in
agribusinesses. They publish the price of yerba mate (BRL 18 per arroba) and other relevant data.
Since the desired impact is to empower small farmers by increasing their income, is not enough
just to produce high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder. They have to sell those varieties with
more value-added. The target for this indicator is to sell high-quality varieties at BRL 100 per
arroba or higher. This indicator will be disaggregated by varieties (kind of roasting). This will be
important to understand which varieties are more profitable and this could help the small farmers to
leverage even more their businesses.
Finally, the impact will be measure through three indicators. The first indicator will measure the
political empowerment by showing how many agribusinesses chambers of commerce have at least
one chair being occupied by a small farmer. This indicator will be disaggregated by target zone
and the whole state of Paraná. Also, it will be disaggregated by gender to understand better the
impact of this project in gender equality. The target is that 50% of agribusiness chambers of
commerce have at least one small farmer in their board.
To measure the financial empowerment of the small farmers, the M&E team will research from
IBGE and Ipardes reports and websites the per capita revenue and the per capita income of small
farmers in the studied region. Even when IBGE and Ipardes are both reliable institutions, a survey
will be conducted at the beginning of the project asking revenue and income data of the
participants. This will help to isolated factors that could affect revenue and income that are not
related to the project, therefore, understanding the real impact of the project will be easier and
clearer.
The first report from the project manager to the project responsible will be at the end of the first
semester. Afterwards, the project manager will report monthly the progress of the project to the
responsible.
It is important to highlight that in the first semester the objective is to engage the target group and
to raise awareness of the project and of high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder. That is why
this first phase will be crucial to discover the baseline for the indicators and update the targets.
17
PRODOC
Matte N’ Roll will reach the small farmers personally. There is a specialized unit to talk and to
engage the target group. They will go to the farms and explain to the small farmers about this
project and its benefits. In addition, this unit will use their participatory approach knowledge to
make the small farmers to share their thought about the project and to help the unit to create the
trainings. This first approach will be at a mate circle because this kind of event is intimate and
serious for the small farmers, enabling an honest and straightforward conversation.
Reaching the target group personally will have the advantage that the chances of the reached
farmers talking to their neighbors about the project will increase. The communication among small
farmers about the project is very valuable because the referrals among equals have a lot of power.
Besides the personal approach, there will be others. In order to widely advertise this project’s
trainings, they will be announced in the websites of the following institutions: Matte N’ Roll,
Guarapuava government, Palmas government and Pitanga government. Also, they will be
announced in the local radio stations, local newspapers and local agribusiness magazines. Finally,
there will be banners in strategical point in Guarapuava, Palmas and Pitanga cities.
8.3. Knowledge sharing
Monitoring and Evaluation unit from Matte N’ Roll will collect success stories regularly. The
marketing unit will use those stories to disseminate the results of the project and to engage even
more small farmers into the project’s courses and workshops and into further trainings and events
after the project reaches and end. In addition, this dissemination and communication plan could
leverage the project to the whole State of Paraná and even to the whole South Brazil Region.
Moreover, the reports will be published by the Monitoring and Evaluation team in agribusiness
magazines (online and physical issues), in Matte N’ Roll’s website and in the governments’ website
as well.
18
PRODOC
With those platforms, the results and the project per se will reach people from the agribusiness
market of the region and the consumers of yerba mate beverages too creating a foundation for
other projects.
The last job of M&E unit will be to create a report with the lessons learnt from this project in order
to collaborate to future projects. This report will be published in Matte N’ Roll website and will be
available to everyone. Also, the lessons will be share in further events organized by Matte N’ Roll.
20
PRODOC
10. ANNEXES
Yerba mate small farmers They are from the rural area They know their soil and their Low education level They are the target group and
from the Central-South of the Central-South region crops. the direct beneficiaries. They
Not political power
region of the State of of the State of Paraná, should be very engaged in the
They have some valuable
Paraná, Brazil. Brazil. Not economic power project and should participate
connections that could help to
actively. Could be a resistance to
engage other stakeholders
change because the project
They are a vulnerable group could be seen as too risky for
because they are low- some of them.
income and because they
do not have fair political
representation.
They have little resilience to
climate change or any
climate hazard.
21
PRODOC
Matte N’ Roll A cooperative of the yerba They are high educated, with good They could be seen as too risky They are important in the
mate market. connections, they are creative and for those more conservative designing phase and in the
good communicators, therefore, stakeholders. implementation phase because
they could be very good at engaging they know better the
It is made up of high- stakeholders. stakeholders: how to reach
educated entrepreneurs They have no experience of them, how to engage them and
businesspersons. implementing projects of this how to manage their
They have experience dealing with size. expectations.
local producers from rural areas.
They have worked with honey and
granola producers in Paraná. They will have the important
task of continuing the training
after the project comes to an
They have experience creating end.
networks and to develop good
relations and partnerships.
They will be in charge of
monitoring and evaluation of
the project.
Municipalities’ Rural municipality from the They have political power inside Could be hard to engage them They would be helpful in the
secretariats of Central-South region of the the municipality. implementation phase and they
Bureaucracy is high and could be
agriculture. State of Paraná. could give some important
too slow in order to have an
insights in the designing phase
Since agribusiness have an active role.
They know the small farmers. as well.
important role in the
economy of the
municipality, the They do not have enough
They have connections with They could fund following
secretariats already have political power to engage other
important stakeholders. projects and could disseminate
experience in funding and municipalities or politicians from
the results from this project in
implementing agriculture higher levels (state level and
order to expand the impact to
projects. They could be a funding partner for federal level).
other municipalities.
Yerba mate is already an next projects.
important crop in the
municipality, that is why the
secretariats know which
22
PRODOC
Big agribusiness They have a lot of political If they can see the project as not They could shut down the It is important to keep them
companies power and a lot of money. harmful to their business due to its project even before it starts if satisfy about this project. Giving
small size, they will not be a they decided to do it. They are them an active role would be
Agribusiness is the main
menace. Actually, if a good lobby is enormous and they are that kind risky, but if succeed, they could
business in Brazil.
made, they could fund this project of organization that measure not be the biggest ally and help to
Those companies are huge as a social aid. This kind of aid has effort to accomplish what they scale up.
and very well connected. tax benefits. want.
Entrepreneurs’ hub They are people with They could be quite helpful for If the project partner up with a They could be very useful in
diverse background and fundraising, for developing technical hub, they must follow some rules developing a solution and
know how. Mostly people solutions, to do the marketing, to and compromise, for example, creating partnership between
under 40s. They are do the implementation and they the project must withdrawal in a several synergic projects that
creative, resourceful, well have many useful connections. specific fundraising because it could give access to more funds
connected and know about could be competing against and bigger funds. In addition, it
Many projects from those hubs
fundraising. another project of the hub. could give some political power.
could benefit from this project.
They are many solutions for
agribusiness that start-ups from
those hubs are developing.
23
PRODOC
Low education level Difficult access to health care Big agribusiness and small
services farmers unequal political
representation
Low-income livelihood
Not aware about high-quality Do not know how to produce Do not have the equipment to Do not know how to sell a
varieties high-quality varieties produce high-quality varieties high value-added product
24
PRODOC
High education level Easy access to health care Big agribusiness and small
services farmers more equal political
representation
Aware about high-quality Know how to produce high- Have the equipment to Know how to sell a high
varieties quality varieties produce high-quality value-added product
varieties
25
PRODOC
26
PRODOC
Outputs:
1. Small farmers and
yerba mate
consumers are aware
about high-quality
varieties of yerba
mate powder - Percentage of equipped yerba mate small
farmers.
2. Small farmers have
the equipment to - Percentage of yerba mate small farmers
produce high-quality knowing more than one high-quality variety - yerba mate small farmers are open to improve
varieties of yerba of yerba mate. and/or change their livelihood
mate powder
- Percentage of consumers knowing at least - Roaster machines are available
3. Small Farmers one high-quality variety of yerba mate.
know how to - yerba mate small farmers' education is enough
produce high-quality - Percentage yerba mate small farmers to allow them to understand the training on
varieties of yerba producing more than one high-quality producing high-quality varieties
mate powder variety
4. Small farmers - yerba mate small farmers' education is enough
know how to sell a - Percentage yerba mate small farmers to allow them to understand the training on
high value-added selling at least one variety at two times (or - Matte N’ Roll survey's personal finances, business management and
product more) than raw yerba mate's price reports marketing
27
PRODOC
28
PRODOC
Output Activity required to produce Matte N’ Roll Matte N’ Roll Matte N’ Roll Matte N’ Roll
Number Output Name the outputs administration training finances marketing
1 Small farmers being 1.1 Engage small farmers into
aware about high-quality Matte N’ Roll x
varieties of yerba mate
powder
1.2 Create a yerba mate fair x
1.3 Use yerba mate
x
ambassadors
2 Small farmers have the 2.1 Assist small farmers to
equipment to produce procure the equipment and
high-quality varieties of to build the necessary x
yerba mate powder infrastructure
0.2 Reporting x
0.3 Steering committee
x
meetings
29
PRODOC
Number of agribusiness
chambers of commerce
Once at Matte N’ Matte N’
in the studied region State of Paraná, Chambers'
the end of Roll Roll
with at least one chair Individuals sector and Research reports and 0 25%
the project Monitoring Monitoring
being occupied by a gender website
(endline) unit unit
yerba mate small
farmer
Ipardes and
IBGE reports
Once at Matte N’ Matte N’
and website;
Small farmers' per Target zone and Research and the end of Roll Roll
BRL/YR and Matte N’ - +50%
capita revenues gender surveys the project Monitoring Monitoring
Roll's
(endline) unit unit
monitoring
unit
Ipardes and
IBGE reports
Once at Matte N’ Matte N’
and website;
Small farmers' per Target zone and Research and the end of Roll Roll
BRL/YR Matte N’ - +50%
capita income gender surveys the project Monitoring Monitoring
Roll's
(endline) unit unit
monitoring
unit
OUTCOME: Small farmers are selling high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder
Monthly
from the
Matte N’ Matte N’
Price of high-quality Esalq beginning
BRL/ Target zone and Roll Roll
varieties of yerba mate Research reports and of the 18 100
ARROBA type of roasting Monitoring Monitoring
powder website second
unit unit
year
30
PRODOC
OUTPUT 1: Small farmers and yerba mate consumers are aware about high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder
Target zone,
Monthly
Percentage of small gender,
Matte N’ from the Matte N’ Matte N’
farmers being aware education level
Roll's beginning Roll Roll
about more than one Individuals and type of Survey 0 10%
monitoring of the Monitoring Monitoring
high-quality variety of awareness
unit second unit unit
yerba mate raising
year
tool/activity
Target zone,
Monthly
Percentage of yerba gender,
Matte N’ from the Matte N’ Matte N’
mate consumers being education level
Roll's beginning Roll Roll
aware about high- Individuals and type of Survey 0 20%
monitoring of the Monitoring Monitoring
quality variety of yerba awareness
unit second unit unit
mate raising
year
tool/activity
OUTPUT 2: Small farmers having the equipment to produce high-quality varieties of yerba mate powder
Once at
the mid
Percentage of small time of the
farmers with the Matte N’ second Matte N’ Matte N’
Target zone,
necessary equipment to Roll's year and Roll Roll
Individuals education level Survey 0 8%
produce high-quality monitoring once at the Monitoring Monitoring
and gender
varieties of yerba mate unit end of the unit unit
powder project
(endline)
31
PRODOC
Once at
the mid
time of the
Percentage of small Matte N’ Matte N’ Matte N’
Target zone, second
farmers producing high- Roll's Roll Roll
Individuals education level Survey year and 0 8%
quality varities of yerba monitoring Monitoring Monitoring
and gender once at the
mate unit unit unit
end of the
project
(endline)
Once at
the mid
Percentage of small
time of the
farmers selling at least Matte N’ Matte N’ Matte N’
Target zone, second
one high-quality variety Roll's Roll Roll
Individuals education level Survey year and 0 5%
at two times the monitoring Monitoring Monitoring
and gender once at the
commodity price or unit unit unit
end of the
higher
project
(endline)
32
PRODOC
Output Activity required to produce the RESOURCES Unit # of units Unit rate Cost Subtotal
Number Output Name outputs
1 Small farmers being aware 1.1 Engage small farmers into Matte
about high-quality varieties of N’ Roll
yerba mate powder
Field assistants per month 12 2000 24.000,00 $
33
PRODOC
0.2 Reporting
Project Management
0.3 Steering committee meetings
staff and office supply per month 24 15000 360.000,00 $ 360.000,00 $
Total budget 1.808.000,00 $
34
PRODOC
RISK MATRIX
RISKS Likelihood (1-3) Impact (1-3) Risk Importance (color) Mitigation action
Political instability in the 1 2 Avoiding to involve the federal government as an active partner
federal government
Fear from pandemic 1 2 Following the recommendations of the WHO and of the local government
Devaluation of the Brazilian 2 1 Giving priority to purchase from national manufacturers
Real
Lack of engagement from the 1 3 Engage the small farmers at the beginning and use their help to develop the
small farmers project
Likelihood
3-High
2-Medium
1-Low
1-Low 2-Medium 3-Low
Impact
35
PRODOC
Arroba 15 kilograms
BRL Brazilian Real
Esalq Luiz de Queiroz College of Agriculture
EUR Euro
GDP Gross Domestic Product
HDI Human Development Index
IBGE Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics
Ipardes Paraná’s Institute of economic and social development
Matteria Gourmet restaurant of yerba mate beverages
M&E Monitoring and Evaluation
PPP Purchasing Power Parity
SDG Sustainable Development Goal
UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
USD United States Dollar
UoM Unit of Measure
WHO World Health Organization
36