Professional Documents
Culture Documents
protein engineering
Jens Brange, Guy G. Dodson and Bing Xiao
Novo Research Institute, Bagsvaerd, Denmark and University of York, York, UK
[a
,~e£ ~. ,J/o
.o
examer
Dimer Dimer
h
i-
~ ~ ~ _ ~ g l ~ imer
- \
A21 A21 /
Fig. 2. Contacts made between the insulin monomer surfaces
within the dimer of the 2Zn insulin hexamer, viewed along the
Fig. 1. The assembly of insulin from monomer to dimer and to the local twofold axis. (a) The contacts made by ValB12 and TyrB26.
zinc-containing hexamer, viewed along the threefold axis. The in- (b) The contacts made by the main-chain sequence B20-B28. The
sulin molecule A and B chains are shown as a Ca trace. The side close approach of ProB28 to B20-B23 can be seen.
chains making interactions that affect dimer or hexamer forma-
tion are represented in full with their van der Waals radii drawn
as a Connolly (or dotted) surface.
be one that is not important to receptor binding. In this
paper, we shall discuss four selected mutations in detail.
much as the AspB9 mutation [9"']. No loss of potency is studies show that this mutated insulin forms discrete
associated with this mutation, a characteristic of changes and stable hexamers even in the absence of Zn 2 + ions
and deletions at residues B26-B30 [3",8"',9"']. So far, no [15.,16,17"]. The crystal structure of a zinc-free hexamer
crystals of this mutant as a monomer have been grown, has been determined (X Bing, unpublished data). In this
though there are crystals of a hexamer grown in the pres- structure, the six GlnB13 side chains are completely hy-
ence of Zn 2+ and Ca 2+ (B Xiao, unpublished data). drated and make no contacts with protein a t o m s - - i n
contrast with GIuB13 in the 2Zn insulin hexamer [3"]
and with the arrangement of the GInB13 side chains pro-
Design of slow-acting insulins posed by Markussen and colleagues [18]. Figure 6 il-
lustrates the conformation of the glutamic acid and glu-
In order to prolong insulin release and to mimic better tamine residues at the centre of the B13 Gin and B13 Gln
the natural low-level continuous secretion provided by 2Zn insulin hexamers.
the pancreas, mutations have been designed to stabilize
either the insulin hexamer or the crystals. The philosophy
Size exclusion chromatography experiments have con-
behind these experiments is to increase the stabilizing in-
teractions made within the hexamer and/or the tendency firmed that the GlnB13 substitution results in a reduced
to form crystals at neutral pH. The strategy has therefore tendency of the hexamer to dissociate in neutral solution
[19]. However, the effect on insulin absorption rate after
been to develop an experimental basis for designing ei-
ther insulin preparations containing crystals that would injection of a neutral solution of the GInB13 analogue
is not dramatic, the rate being reduced by only ,~ 25 %
dissolve slowly, or insulin solutions in which the absorp-
tion from the subcutaneous layer is delayed, either by de- (U Ribel, personal communication). This small effect is
creased dissociation of the hexamer or by the formation in agreement with absorption experiments using a non-
of insulin microcrystals at the site of injection. dissociable cobalt-insulin hexamer [2%20].
O rl
n °v s
Fig. 6. The six B13 side chains in the insulin hexamer. (a) The orientation 6f GluB13 in 2Zn insulin; hydrogen bonds exist between pairs
of adjacent B13 glutamic acids and glutamates. (b) Glng13 modelled to optimize hydrogen-bond interactions (n, amide; o, oxygen) [15].
(c) GInB13 side chains in the zinc-free insulin hexamer; the glutamyl side chains are solvated and make no mutual hydrogen bonds.
obtained with the analogue combining all three substitu- This paper contains detailed descriptions of the different structures in-
tions, i.e. GInB13, ArgB27 and B30 amide [18]. sulin has in different crystals.
The crystal structure of GInB13/ArgB27/B30 amide re- 5. MOLONEYPJ, APmLEMA, WILSON S: Sulfated Insulin for Treat-
• m e n t of Insulin Resistant Diabetics. J N e w Drugs 1964,
veals that the B30 amide and ArgB27 make contacts in 4:4258-4263.
the lattice that are quite different from those anticipated, This paper describes the successful treatment of insulin resistant dia-
and which do not adequately explain the reduced solu- betes by using 'monomeric' sulphated insulin.
bility of the mutant insulin crystal. The mutated arginyl
6. KERP L, STEINHILBERS, KASEMIRH, HAN J, HEINRICHS HR, GEIGER
side chains make no lattice contacts, and the interactions R: Changes in Immunospecificity and Biologic Activity of
made by B30 amide do not appear to be more favourable Insulin due to Subsequent Removal of t h e Amino Acids B1,
than those of the native carboxytate group (3 Turken- B2 and B3. Diabetes 1974, 23:651-656.
burg, unpublished data).
7. GLAUBERHS, RIVERS RR, HENRY R, SCHMEISER R, WALLACE P,
KOTrERMANN 0(3, COHEN RM, RUBENSTEIN AH, GALLOWAYJA,
Conclusion FRANK BH ET AL: In ViVO Deactivation of Proinsulin Action
on Glucose Disposal and Hepatic Glucose Production in
Normal Man. D/abetes 1986, 35:311-317.
The alteration of insulin's properties of self-association
but not its metabolic effects by informed mutagenesis is 8. MIRM1RARA, NAKAGAWASH, TAGER H: Importance of the
•• Character and Configurations of Residues B24, B25 and
an important first step in the application of protein en- B26 in Insulin Receptor Interactions. J Biol Chem 1991,
gineering to medicine. Surprises and difficulties still re- 266:1428-1436.
main however. For example, the unexpected formation These experiments were carried out using trypsin-catalysed semi-
of the hexamer by the AspB9/GIuB27 mutant insulin and .synthesis, first exploited by Inouye et al. [21], in which synthetic frag-
the dodecamer by the AspB10 mutant insulin are strik- ments are combined with desoctapepUde (B23-B30) insulin. Using this
approach, non-natural amino acids can be incorporated into an inves-
ing examples of how the complexity of protein surfaces
tigation of the hormone's structural and biological behaviour. These
presents formidable problems in predicting the chemical studies have identified that the PheB24 side chain, criUcal in dimer for-
and structural consequences of residue mutation. In addi- mation, is not critical for receptor binding and that conformational con-
tion, the very complex environment in the tissues where straints in the sequence B23-B26 affect binding potency.
the hormone is absorbed means great care has to be 9. STUMPOLF, HARTMANNH, BRANDENBURGD, CRU'VZFELDW: In
taken with clinical characterization of any new insulins. •• vivo Metabolic Activity of Des(B26-B30)-Insulin B25 Amide
and Related Analogues in the Rat. Diabetes Res Clin Pract
Nonetheless, the progress made so far encourages opU- 1990, 9:257-264.
mism and, despite the uncertainties, it is likely that pro- The effects that different modificaUons at the B-chain carboxyl terminus
tein engineering will play a vital role in the future devel- have on insulin's biological behaviour are analyzed. The results high-
opments of pharmaceutical preparations. In addition, we light the importance of residues B24 and B25 and the unimportance of
can expect to see insulins available with a wide spectrum the sequence B26-B30 in receptor binding. This is an excellent exam
pie of the kind of information needed if the protein engineering is to
of properties whose exploitation will lead to better man- be successful.
agement of the disease.
10. BURKE GP, HU SQ, OHTA N, SCHWARTZ GP, ZONG L,
** KAT,~YANNIS PG: Superactive Insulins. Biochem Biophys Res
References and recommended reading Comm 1991, 173:982-987.
This paper describes the synthesis of a series of mutated and modi-
fied insulins with elevated potency. The study reveals that the elevation
Papers of special interest, published within the annual period of review,
of potency and binding is not strictly additive the mutation AspB10,
have been highlighted as:
however, always increases these properties significantly.
• of interest
oo of outstanding interest 11. BRANGEJ, PdBELU, HANSENJ, DODSON G, HANSENM, HAVELUND
1. KAHNCR: The Molecular Mechanism of Insulin Action. A n n u •• S, MELBERGS, NORRIS F, NORRIS K, SNEL L, ET AL.: Monomeric
Rev Med 1985, 36:429-451. Insulins Obtained by Protein Engineering and their Medical
Implications. Nature 1988, 333:679-682.
2. BRANGEJ, OWENS DR, KANGS, VOLUNDPc Monomeric Insulins The authors discuss the design and preparation of a series of h u m a n
• and Their Experimental and Clinical Implications. Diabetes insulin mutations and describe their solution and absorption behaviour.
Care 1990, 13:923-954.
The authors describe the biological behaviour of a large selection of 12. ROY M, LEE W-K, KAAP,SHOLM NC, THOGERSEN tt, BRANGE J,
insulin mutants and report on animal and human trials. DUNN MF: Sequence Specific 1H NMR Assignments for the
Aromatic Region of a Biologically Active Monomeric Insulin
3. BAKEREN, BLUNDELLTL, CtrFFIELD JF, CUTFIELD SM, DODSON Mutant. Biochim Biopbys Acta 1990, 1053:63-73.
• EJ, DODSON GG, HODGKIN DC, HUBBARD RE, ISAACS NWI,
REYNOLDS CO, SAKABE K, SAKABE N, VIJAYAN NM: T h e Struc- 13. KRISTENSENSM, JORGENSEN AMM, LED JJ, BAL~CHMIDTP, HANSEN
ture of 2Zn Pig Insulin Crystals at 1.5 A. Phil T r a m R Soc • FB: Proton Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Study of the
Lond [B] 1988, 319:369-456. B9 (Asp) Mutant of H u m a n Insulin. J Mol Biol 1991,
This paper contains a very comprehensive descripUon of the 2Zn in- 218:221-231.
sulin crystal structure and its pattern of assembly into dimers and (in This study was carried out at low pH where the insulin was dimeric
the presence of zinc ions) hexamers. The hormone's active surface is and where the monomerizing properties of AspB9 would be negated.
identified and the evidence for its involvement in receptor binding re- NonetheLess, this mutant insulin gave a sharper and more interpretable
viewed. NMR spectrum than native insulin, indicating ?
4. DEREWENDAU, DEREWENDAZ, DODSON GG, HUBBARD RE: In- 14. I)ODSON GG: Realistic Protein Engineering In Proceedings
. sulin Structure. In Handbook of Expenmental Pharmacol- of the Society of General Microbiology Symposium, Vol 44
ogy, Vol 92 edited by Cuatracasas P, Jacobs S [book]. Berlin: edited by Baumberg S, Hunter IS and Rhodes PM [book].
Springer Verlag, 1990, pp 23-39. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989, pp 293-307.
940 Proteins
15. HANSENJF: T h e Self Association of ZInc Free H u m a n Insulin 19. BRANGEJ, DREJER K, HANSENJF, HAVELUNDS, KAARSHOLMNK,
• and Insulin Analogue G13-Glutamine. Biophys Chem 1991, MEmERG SG, SORENSON A_R: Design of Novel Insulins with
39:107-110. Changed Self-association and Ligand Binding Properties. In
In this paper, it is established by osmometric and spectroscopic meth- Advances in Protein Design, International Workshop 1988
ods that~GInB13 assembles to a specific hexamer in the absence of edited by Blooker H, Collins J, Schmid RD, Schomburg D
Zn 2 +. [book]. Weinheim: VCH Publishers, 1989, pp 139-144.
16. RoY M, BRADER ML, LEE RW-K, KAARSHOLMNC, HANSEN JF, 20. HILL CP, DAUTERZ, DODSON EJ, DODSON GG, DUNN MF: The
DUNN MF: Spectroscopic Signatures of t h e T to R Confor- X-ray Structure of an Unusual Ca 2+ Site and t h e Roles
mational Transition in t h e Insulin Hexamer. J Biol Chem of Zn 2+ and Ca 2+ in Assembly, Stability and Storage. B/~
1989, 264:19081-19085. chem/stry 1991, 304:917-924.
17. KRUGERP, GILGE G, CABUKY, WotJdVmR A: Cooperativity and
• Intermediate States in t h e T ~ R Structural Transition of 21. INOUYEK, WATANABEK, MORIHAR IC, TOCHINO Y, KANAYAT,
Insulin. Biol Chem HoppeSeyler 1990, 371:669-673. EMURA J, SAKIKABARAS: Enzyme Assisted Semi-Synthesis of
This paper describes circular dichroism studies on native and GlnB13 H u m a n Insulin. J A m Chem Soc 1979, 101:751-752.
insulin hexamers.
18. MARKUSSENJ, HOUGAARDP, RIBEL U, SORRENSONA, SORENSON J Brange, Novo Research Institute, Novo Alle, DK-2880 Bagsvaerd, Den-
E: Soluble, Prolonged-acting Insulin Derivatives (2) Degree
mark.
of Protraction and Crystallisability o f Insulins Substituted
in Positions A17, BS, B13, B27 and B30. Protein Eng 1987, GG Dodson and B Xiao, The Chemistry Department, University of York,
1:215-223. York YO1 5DD, UK.