Professional Documents
Culture Documents
for IBA
Season 2
Cost Behavior
Cost-Volume-Profit-Analysis
© by C. Hörner
Introduction to Management Accountin g
© by C. Hörner
Introduction to Management Accountin g
Two Roles of
Management
Accounting
Decision- Decision-
Facilitating Influencing
© by C. Hörner
Introduction to Management Accountin g
• 36% of businesses fail within the first • Management accountants can play a vital
two years of operation. role to bridge gap between strategy and
• Among most common reasons: financial control.
• Poorly thought-out business plan • Scenario planning, strategic options, and
• Running out of cash evidence-based decision-making are
• Pricing or cost issues among the areas where management
accountants can provide expertise.
© by C. Hörner
Introduction to Management Accountin g
© by C. Hörner
Season 2
Cost Behavior
Cost-Volume-Profit-Analysis
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Decentralization 9
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Responsibility Accounting 10
Responsibility
Centers
Responsible for revenues,
Profit Center
costs, and profits
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
12
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Pursuing a Strategy 13
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Learning
(Employee
Training)
Internal
(On-time)
Customer
(Customer
Satisfaction)
Financial
(Revenue/
Profit)
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Performance Measures 15
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Goal Congruence 16
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Goal Congruence 17
What will GE
think about that?
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
19
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Principle of Controllability 20
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Responsibility Accounting 21
Responsibility
Centers
Responsible for revenues,
Profit Center
costs, and profits
© by C. Hörner
Responsibilities & Performance Measures
Principle of Controllability 22
• However…
• Decision-facilitating vs. decision-influencing role: compromises might be necessary to force
the managers to make certain actions
• Controllability vs. information/knowledge of a certain subject: managers of certain
responsibility centers can explain variances the best (even though they cannot control
them).
• Focus and bigger-picture-thinking: production manager with profit instead of cost despite
lack of control over revenue: broader focus might facilitate bigger-picture-thinking
© by C. Hörner
Season 2
Cost Behavior
Cost-Volume-Profit-Analysis
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
24
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
• Cost
• “Resource sacrificed or foregone to achieve a given objective”
• Usually expressed in monetary terms ($, €, £, etc.)
• Goal: Find out the “true” costs (e.g. of producing a car)
Examples:
- Management
- Support staff
- Rent and Energy
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Overhead
Profit
Revenue
Costs
Costs
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Opportunity Costs 27
• Cost
• “Resource sacrificed or foregone to achieve a given objective”
• Not all relevant, economic costs are recorded and based on factual transactions
• Opportunity Costs
• “Loss of potential gain from (the best of) the other alternatives when one alternative is
chosen.”
• Examples for opportunity costs
• Should you buy or rent a house (alternative: invest in stocks)?
• Should you invest $1m in Project A or Project B?
• Should you accept an extra order (Product X) if this means reducing your regular output of
Product A because both products use the same machine?
• Should you accept an extra order (Product X) if the machine needed for this is idle?
• Should you work extra hours in a bar?
• Should you stop to pick up $1 from the road?
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Service
Activity/Process
Customers
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Cost
Assignment
Direct
Costs
Cost Tracing • Related to particular object
Accumulated Costs
or
Indirect
Costs
Cost Allocation
to Cost Object • Tracing economically not feasible/too costly
• Allocation based on (arbitrary?) criteria
determined by the company.
Available information
gathering technology
(“easiness” to trace)
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Cost Driver 31
• Cost driver = factor, such as the level of activity or the quantity, that causally affects total
costs over a given time span.
• Change in in the level of cost driver → change in total costs of cost object
• Other terms: cost determinant, cost generator
• Examples:
R&D: # of labor hours on a project, price of test materials
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Cause-and-Effect Criterion 32
Example
Where do babies come from?
- Old tales suggest storks (theory)
- In fact: statistically significant positive correlation
Birth Rate
- Convinced?
- But:
- Urbanization affects both
- If you include urbanization as control, the
correlation above is not significant any more
Storks
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
• Do costs vary proportionally with quantity or are they independent of the quantity?
Total Total Total
Costs Costs Costs
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Quantity
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Unit/Average Costs 35
Quantity Quantity
Variable Costs Fix Costs
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Cost Driver
Direct/indirect vs. variable/fixed are different approaches.
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Direct Direct
Cost Cost
$500K $550K Direct: +$50K Implications
vs. = Indirect: -$100K for liquidity,
Indirect Indirect Net: -$50K goals, bonus?
Cost Cost
Overhead Overhead
$800K $700K
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Sunk Costs 39
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
Sunk Costs 40
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
© by C. Hörner
Cost Accounting Concepts
© by C. Hörner
Season 2
Cost Behavior
Cost-Volume-Profit-Analysis
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
44
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
What are your fixed costs? What are your variable costs?
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
50.000
40.000
30.000
20.000
10.000
-
- 1.000 2.000 3.000 4.000 5.000
Cost Driver: # of meals
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
Regression Method 50
© by C. Hörner
Cost Behavior
Statistically The line (red) with the least distances to the observations is estimated and described as: Y = a + b*Q
This estimate is better as it relies less on the two extreme observations (blue line from Low-High)
Careful again with the interpretation of the intercept.
© by C. Hörner
Season 2
Cost Behavior
Cost-Volume-Profit-Analysis
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
53
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
Cost-Volume-Profit-Analysis 54
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
Examples 55
• What-If questions
• Examples:
How many tickets do you need to sell if you want to organize a profitable festival?
How many tickets does Lufthansa need to sell for flights from FRA to NY if they want to
break even?
If DHL lowers price by 10%, how much express parcels should they handle to earn an
operating profit of 100’000?
How is Nintendo’s profit affected if they are able to reduce variable costs by 10%?
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
CVP-Analysis 56
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
CVP-Analysis: Assumptions 57
• Assumptions
• Revenues/costs change due to the same driver (= quantity of output)
• Linear behavior of cost and revenue functions
• Unit variable cost, fixed cost and selling prices are known and are assumed to be constant
• No inventory-levels assumed, all cost and revenues are added without taking into account
time value for money
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
4500000
4000000 COST
REVENUE
3500000
3000000
2500000
2000000
1500000
1000000
500000
Q = 10’000 units
0
0 4000 8000 12000 16000 20000
Output
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
Assume that LG wants to realize a Target Profit of 350’000: FC = 1’000’000, UVC = 100, USP = 200.
Q: How many units does it have to sell?
Contribution method:
Q = (FC+OP) / (USP – UVC)
Target = OP = 350’000
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
Assume a 30% tax-rate: Does the break-even point for the LG example changes?
o YES
NO: Taxes only relevant if OP > 0 (by definition not the case for break even point)
o NO
What happens with the number of units that LG needs to sell if it still wants to earn an profit of
350’000, but after taxes
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
OPTION 1: An outside subcontractor asks a fixed fee of 2’000’000 per period to meet
up the demand of LG (fully fixed fee structure)
What does this mean for the demand risk (volatility) of LG?
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
Assume that LG has outside contracting options of a fully variable cost structure of 130 $ per unit
or fully fixed cost structure of 2’000’000$ and selling price for LG = 200 $ per unit.
Q: Which contractor should it choose knowing that market for low budget LED TV’s is
a) 9’000 units (30% probability) or b) 19’000 units (70% probability) ?
E(OP) = 0,3 * (-200’000) + 0,7 * 1’800’000 E(OP) = 0,3 * 630’000 + 0,7 * 1’330’000
= 1’200’000 = 1’120’000
GM has gone from losing billions of dollars to making money, $7 billion so far this year. Thanks to
its reorganization and government bailout, North America’s largest car company is largely debt-
free. Granted, Europe is a problem. Apparently the company is not doing so well in South America
either, a big car market. And the stock price is not where it should be. But in distinction to life in
pre-bankruptcy days, GM’s new executive management team now has the luxury of actually
running the business (as opposed to lurching from crisis to crisis), Amman told The Wall Street
Journal Senior Editor Darren McDermott during a session at the recent MIT Sloan CFO Summit in
Boston.
What was GM’s strategy for lowering its risk profile? One big step was to dramatically reduce the
company’s break-even point, Ammann said. “We had a huge fixed-cost base, so we had to build a
certain number of vehicles to cover the fixed cost. We had a supply-push business model: You built
the vehicles and then figured out how to sell them.”
“Getting the break-even point down allowed us to have a business model where we are building to
demand, as opposed to building a particular level of volume to allow the business to break even,”
he added.
Outside contracting can be a way to reduce (inside) fixed costs.
© by C. Hörner
Cost-Volume-Prof it-Analysis
CVP-Analysis in Government/Non-Profit 66
• Governance agencies, hospitals, social institutions, etc. often receive a fixed budget to
run their operations
• They can have the goal to maximize the number of people profiting instead of company
profits
• Example 1:
The city Genève has a (lump sum) budget of 400’000 to treat drug addicts. This budget is given
to an agency to conduct a counseling program. Fixed cost of the agency are 150’000; the variable
costs per patient are 400.
Q: How many patients can receive a treatment?
CVP-Analysis in Government/Non-Profit 67
• Example 2:
Assume that the budget of the agency is reduced by 10%.
Q: How many patients can receive a treatment?
© by C. Hörner