Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Artigo
Artigo
DOI: 10.1002/jsfa.1107
Abstract: Raw materials for cocoa butter substitutes, replacements or equivalents depend mostly on
the unsteady supply from wild stands of plants, while there is no current supply of Neotropical origin.
Seed fats from Theobroma species (T cacao, T bicolor, T grandi¯orum, T obovatum, T subincanum,
T speciosum, T sylvestre and T microcarpum, plus the closely related species Herrania mariae) were
analysed for fatty acid and triacylglycerol composition by gas and liquid chromatography respectively,
for iodine value, for melting point by open capillary tube and for solid fat content (SFC) by nuclear
magnetic resonance. All Theobroma species had signi®cantly lower palmitate levels than T cacao,
except for T sylvestre and T speciosum, T microcarpum presented highly unsaturated fat (C18:2),
while H mariae had high levels of arachidate. Fats from T sylvestre and T speciosum had a similar
iodine value to T cacao and a higher melting point. No fat from the other species presented a similar
melting pro®le to cocoa butter. T sylvestre and T bicolor were the most similar to T cacao but had a
higher SFC at human body temperature. T sylvestre and T speciosum seed fats had more POP than
cocoa butter. Fats from seeds of T speciosum, T sylvestre and T bicolor could be recommended as
cocoa butter substitutes, while fats from species of the section Glossopetalum could be employed in
products requiring fats with a lower melting point.
# 2002 Society of Chemical Industry
Keywords: Theobroma species; triacylglycerol composition; fatty acid composition; cocoa butter substitutes
* Correspondence to: Lireny AG Gonçalves, FEA-DTA, UNICAMP, CP 6091, Campinas, SP 13083-970, Brazil
E-mail: lireny@fea.unicamp.br
Contract/grant sponsor: FAPESP
Contract/grant sponsor: CNPq
(Received 22 August 2001; revised version received 14 January 2002; accepted 2 February 2002)
estimate the theoretical triacylglycerol composition tion, pod maturity or postharvest conservation. Simi-
based on fatty acid composition. larly, Carpenter et al 14 reported a large discrepancy in
oleic and linoleic acid levels between H mariae and the
Slip melting point other Herrania species, while the data presented here
Of®cial method AOCS Cc 3b-93, method B.19 Fats con®rmed the similarity in composition between H
were totally melted and placed in 10 mm capillary mariae and the other species belong to Herrania. The
tubes with thin walls and 1 mm id. The capillary tubes high level of arachidic acid (C20:0) detected in seed fat
were maintained for 2 h in a freezer and for 24 h at of H mariae is similar to the values reported by
26 °C before measurements. Carpenter et al,14 who identi®ed higher levels of
arachidic acid in Herrania than in fats from Theobroma
Solid fat content species (mainly present in the sections Telmatocarpus
NMR method AOCS Cd 16b-9319 for tempering fats. and Glossopetalum).
There were signi®cant differences (Tukey P < 5%)
Statistics in fatty acid pro®le between species of distinct sections
Signi®cant differences between means were deter- (Table 2), but there was no signi®cant difference in
mined by applying the Tukey test for multiple com- fatty acid composition between species within the
parisons (signi®cance level P < 0.05) same section, except for palmitic acid in the section
Oreanthes. All fats from Theobroma species differed
signi®cantly from T cacao in palmitic acid level, but for
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION all the other fatty acids there was at least one species
Fatty acid composition presenting no signi®cant difference in content from T
The fatty acid compositions of the seed fats from cacao. Species from the section Glossopetalum did not
Theobroma and Herrania species (Table 2) were similar differ from T cacao in stearic acid content, while T
to those described in the literature,11±13 considering sylvestre and T microcarpum did not differ in oleic acid
variations due to genotype, season or environmental content. In general, the fatty acid compositions of T
effects. The only major exceptions were the data for T sylvestre and T speciosum (section Oreanthes) were the
microcarpum and H mariae, both sampled from the most similar to cocoa butter, but both had signi®cantly
same collection as used by Carpenter et al. 14 The data higher palmitate and signi®cantly lower stearate con-
presented here for T microcarpum were similar to the tents. bicolor (section Rhytidocarpus) seed fat was also
fatty acid composition of T gileri reported by Chaisieri similar to cocoa butter but contained signi®cantly
et al,23 another species of the section Telmatocarpus. higher stearate and signi®cantly lower palmitate levels.
Therefore it is likely that the discrepancy in fatty acid The fatty acid pro®les of species from the section
composition for T microcarpum analysed by Carpenter Glossopetalum (T subincanum, T grandi¯orum and T
et al 14 might have derived from erroneous identi®ca- obovatum) were similar. Stearate levels were not
Composition
Section
C14:0 C16:0 C16:1 C18:0 C18:1 C18:2 C18:3 C20:0 C22:0
Species M P Po S O L Ln A B
Theobroma
T cacao (8) tr 30.6c 0.6 33.9b 31.4c 2.5de tr 0.9d tr
Oreanthes
T sylvestre (12) nd 42.0b 0.6 24.0cd 28.4cd 4.4bcd tr 0.6d tr
T speciosum (3) nd 46.9a 0.8 20.2d 23.3d 7.2b tr 1.3d tr
Rhytidocarpus
T bicolor (6) nd 8.1e 0.2 47.8a 41.0b 1.2e tr 1.6d tr
Glossopetalum
T obovatum (5) tr 8.6e tr 31.7b 42.0ab 6.1bc tr 9.7b 1.4b
T grandi¯orum (4) tr 8.5e 0.2 34.6b 42.0ab 3.4bcde tr 9.9b 1.3b
T subincanum (6) tr 6.8e 0.4 31.8b 45.6a 3.2cde 0.7b 10.3b 1.4b
Telmatocarpus
T microcarpum (3) nd 14.4d 0.8 6.4e 31.4cd 27.1a 3.6a 6.6c 9.8a
Herrania
Herrania sp (5) 0.2 8.9e 0.3 26.7c 15.0e 29.5a 0.6b 17.8a 1.1b
H mariae (1) 0.2 9.3e 0.4 23.7cd 19.7de 28.2a tr 17.3a 1.4b
nd, Not detected.
tr, Fatty acid not detected in all samples.
Values in parentheses are number of samples of each species analysed.
Means within the same column sharing a common letter are not signi®cantly different (P < 0.05).
Table 3. Iodine value and slip melting point of Theobroma and Herrania fats signi®cantly higher in Herrania species and in T
Section microcarpum (section Telmatocarpus), but not in
Species Iodine value Melting point ( °C) Glossopetalum. The signi®cantly higher levels of
behenate in seed fat from T microcarpum show this
Theobroma
species as a potential source of this unusual plant fatty
T cacao 33 28.4
Oreanthes
acid, useful for low-caloric speciality fats.25
T sylvestre 35 38.6
T speciosum 34 43.6 Iodine value
Rhytidocarpus Iodine values of the Theobroma seed fats (Table 3)
T bicolor 38 36.3 were calculated based on the fatty acid composition. T
Glossopetalum cacao, T speciosum, T sylvestre and T bicolor presented
T subincanum 47 32.0 the lowest iodine values. Species from the section
T grandi¯orum 43 32.0 Glossopetalum had iodine values slightly superior to
T obovatum 48 30.8 cocoa butter. T microcarpum and H mariae showed the
Telmatocarpus
highest percentages of unsaturated fatty acids, mainly
T microcarpum 86 Ð
linoleic acid, and presented the highest iodine values.
Herrania
H mariae 65 29.0
Melting point
Fats from T speciosum and T sylvestre presented the
highest melting points (Table 3), and both could be
interesting for application in mixtures with other fats
signi®cantly different from T cacao, but all had with lower melting points, such as T grandi¯orum, T
signi®cantly lower levels of palmitate and signi®cantly obovatum and T subincanum. Cocoa butter with a low
higher levels of arachidate. T obovatum is a yellow fat melting point could be mixed in the case of use in
and could be interesting for production of coloured tropical areas. T bicolor fat has an interesting melting
fats such as margarine. These fats are softer than cocoa point, near body temperature, with potential applica-
butter and less stable owing to the high level of tion in foods. Fats from Herrania spp showed a low
unsaturated acids. The fatty acid compositions of T melting point and could be used in plastic products
microcarpum and H mariae were most divergent, both such as margarine.
presenting high levels of linoleic acid. Furthermore, T
microcarpum contained signi®cantly higher levels of Triacylglycerol composition
linolenic and behenic acids, while the Herrania species Triacylglycerols were determined by liquid chroma-
had signi®cantly elevated arachidate, as described tography in triplicate (Table 4 and Fig 1). Results were
before.14 In general, species of the sections Glossope- compared with theoretical results obtained with the
talum and Telmatocarpus and of the genus Herrania TRIGLIC software24. The major triglycerides found
tended to have signi®cantly higher levels of long-chain in seeds of Theobroma species differed considerably
fatty acids. Further, the levels of linolate (C18:2), an from cocoa butter (Table 4). POS, SOS and POP
important acid from the nutritional point of view, were represent more than 75% of the triacylglycerols of
Table 4. Triacylglycerol composition (g kg 1) of Theobroma and Herrania fats from seeds by HPLC or theoretically calculated by TRIGLIC
Section
Species PLiP OOO POO PLiS POP SOO SLiS POS OOA SOS SOA
Theobroma
T cacao 21 (0.2) nd 15 (0.8) nd 208 (2.6) 9 (1.1) 8 (1.3) 423 (1.6) 4 (1.2) 264 (3.5) 20 (0.2)
Oreanthes
T sylvestre 57 (1.3) nd nd 36 (1.1) 330 (4.1) 24 (0.5) 22 (0.9) 338 (1.3) 33 (0.6) 116 (1.9) nd
T speciosum 70 (1.6) nd nd 51 (2.0) 281 (1.8) 93 (0.6) 25 (0.5) 262 (2.9) 55 (0.4) 92 (1.2) 11 (0.1)
Rhytidocarpus
T bicolor nd 19 (0.3) 26 (0.4) nd 14 (0.5) 179 (0.8) nd 165 (0.8) 10 (0.3) 522 (1.9) 44 (0.5)
Glossopetalum
T obovatum nd 30 (0.3) 52 (2.7) 21 (1.2) 20 (1.0) 181 (1.5) 26 (0.8) 117 (0.7) 88 (0.6) 270 (1.8) 150 (1.7)
T grandi¯orum 6 (0.4) 20 (0.5) 43 (0.5) 11 (0.1) 11 (0.2) 161 (1.7) 18 (0.5) 120 (1.2) 78 (0.7) 314 (1.2) 181 (2.6)
T subincanum nd 48 (2.0) 51 (1.4) 6 (0.5) 11 (0.4) 210 (3.5) nd 100 (1.7) 114 (2.5) 274 (3.9) 145 (4.1)
Telmatocarpus
T microcarpum a 20 35 20 20 20 20 20
Herrania
H mariae a 10 55 55 25 135 40 40 50 75
Values are reported as mean of triplicate analyses with standard deviation in parentheses.
nd, Not detected.
a
Theoretically calculated based on fatty acid composition by TRIGLIC software.24
cacao, and the fatty acid chain length, degree of to cocoa butter. T subincanum, T grandi¯orum and T
unsaturation and positioning in the glycerol backbone obovatum had similar triacylglycerol compositions. All
determine the melting pro®le of a speci®c cocoa species from the section Glossopetalum presented a
butter.26 SOS seemed to be strongly correlated with similar SOS level to cocoa butter, but lower levels of
rapid nucleating seed crystals during cocoa butter POS and POP, which cause important changes in the
crystallisation, and with ®nal hardness.26 The triacyl- thermal behaviour of the fats. The triacylglyceride
glyceride composition most similar to T cacao (POS composition, theoretically calculated, from T micro-
42.3%, SOS 26.4%, POP 20.8%) was shown by fats of carpum and Herrania spp had a distinct composition,
T sylvestre and T speciosum, but they had lower SOS without the typical major cocoa butter triacylglycer-
when compared to cocoa. T bicolor had lower levels of ides, with signi®cantly higher levels of linolate and
POS and POP but higher levels of SOS and SOA long-chain fatty acids (20:0 for Herrania and 22:0 for T
(4%). A mixture of fats from T sylvestre or T speciosum microcarpum; Table 2), directly affecting triacylglycer-
presenting similar POS to but higher POP than T ide composition (Table 4). A distinct triacylglycerol
bicolor (higher SOS) would have a similar composition and fatty acid composition was evident for fats from
Figure 1. Chomatograms of Theobroma fats by HPLC: 1, PLiO; 2, PLiP; 3, OOO; 4, POO; 5, PLiS; 6, POP; 7, SOO; 8, SLiS; 9, POS; 10, OOA; 11, SOS;
12, PSS; 13, SOA; 14, SSS; 15, OAA.
Theobroma species of the sections Telmatocarpus and incanum, T obovatum and T grandi¯orum) had a similar
Glossopetalum. fat melting pro®le. Some of these samples, plus H
mariae, exhibited a large percentage of liquid fat
Solid fat content by NMR present at 10 °C, probably owing to the large amounts
The fat melting behaviour of the eight Theobroma of unsaturated triacylglycerol that hamper total
species was analysed by nuclear magnetic resonance. crystallisation at this temperature. Fats from species
Fat hardness was expressed as percentage solid fat of the section Glossopetalum have more unsaturated
content (SFC) at a given temperature (Fig 2). Fat fatty acids than cocoa butter and are susceptible to
tempering should be speci®c for polymorphic fats, oxidation. Carpenter et al 14 detected only g- and
maintaining them for 40 h at 26 °C before measure- d-tocols in Theobroma fats, with the total level of tocols
ments. The value of percentage solid fat up to 25 °C (a b g d) described as between 86 and 290 mg g 1
represents the hardness of a speci®c fat, while values fat. This amount of tocols is not enough to naturally
between 25 and 33 °C demonstrate the potential protect the fat against oxidation, which would need to
region for ¯avour release during fat melting. The solid be protected by antioxidants for use in food products.
fat content above 35 °C indicates the waxiness of the
fat. Small changes in solid fat content between 15 and
25 °C, such as observed for T cacao (cocoa butter), CONCLUSION
indicate a plastic behaviour of fat. Differences in SFC Fats from T speciosum, T sylvestre and T bicolor are
between 25 and 35 °C indicate larger heat tolerance, potential cocoa butter substitutes, alone or applied in
an important trait for tropical products.3 Fat from T mixtures, while T microcarpum might be an excellent
sylvestre had a similar melting behaviour to cocoa source for behenic acid. Fats from the section
butter up to 15 °C, decreasing in percentage solid fat Glossopetalum are softer than cocoa butter, but they
afterwards, but with the largest SFC above 35 °C. On have an interesting melting point, below body tem-
the other hand, fat from T bicolor had lower a SFC than perature, and a satisfactory melting curve for use in
T cacao at temperatures below 25 °C and presented a foods such as bread, cake, ice cream or chocolate
higher percentage of solid fat from 30 to 35 °C. These ®lling.
two species had higher levels of saturated fatty acids
and monounsaturated symmetrical triacylglycerols. T
sylvestre and T bicolor fats may be waxy owing to their ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
high solid fat content above 35 °C. All the samples, The authors are grateful to FAPESP for ®nancial
except for cocoa butter, should have little heat resis- support, CEPLAC and EMBRAPA for supplying
tance because of the rapid decrease in SFC between 25 Theobroma and Herrania samples, and CNPq for a
and 35 °C. An important attribute of cocoa butter is fellowship to AF.
the rapid decrease in percentage solid fat content
above 25 °C, which was not observed for any other fat
from the other Theobroma species. These differences REFERENCES
arise from the distinct fatty acid and triacylglycerol 1 Harwood JL, Recent advances in the biosynthesis of plant fatty
composition. acids. Biochim Biophys Acta 56:1301 (1996).
2 Dimick PS, Principles of cocoa butter crystallization. Manufact
T microcarpum had a low solid fat content at all Confect 71(5):109±114 (1991).
temperatures, showing a plastic behaviour. Samples 3 Leissner R, Hogenbirk G, Nilsson J, Petersson B, Alander J,
from species of the section Glossopetalum (T sub- Helmbring G, Stenmyr C, Linghede M and Gunnerdal J, in
Cocoa Butter Alternatives. Ed by Karlshamns, Oils and Fats WM, Lipid composition of Herrania and Theobroma seeds. J
Academy (1991). Am Oil Chem Soc 71:845±851 (1994).
4 Shukla VKS and Kragballe K, Exotic butters as cosmetic lipids. 15 Da Silva WG, Gordura de cupuacËuÂ. SucedaÃneo de manteiga de
INFORM 9:512±516 (1998). cacau. PhD Thesis, Universidade de SaÄo Paulo (1988).
5 Sengupta A and Roy SK, Triglyceride composition of Maduca 16 Venturieri GA, Ronchi-Teles B, Ferraz IDK, Lourde M and
butyraceae seed fat. J Am Oil Chem Soc 55:621±624 (1978). Hamada N, CupuacËuÂ: a EspeÂcie, Sua Cultura, Usos e Processa-
6 Moharram YG and Moustafa AM, Utilisation of mango seed mento. Clube do Cupu, BeleÂm (1993).
kernel (Mangifera indica) as a source of oil. Food Chem 8:269± 17 Berbert PRF, DeterminacËaÄo do teor, aÂcidos graxos e caracter-
276 (1982). Âõsticas fõÂsicas das gorduras das sementes do Theobroma grand-
7 Szpiz RR, Jablonka FH and Pereira DA, Mango seed fat. I. i¯ora, I. e do Theobroma bicolor, L. e comparacËaÄo com a gordura
Physicochemical properties and fatty acid composition, in do Theobroma cacao, L. Rev Theobroma 11:91±98 (1981).
Proceedings of International Meeting on Fats and Oils Technology. 18 Cabral Velho C, Whipkey A and Janick J, Cupuassu: a new
Ed by Barrera-Arellano, Daniel and GoncËalves, Lireny beverage crop for Brazil, in Advances in New Crops. Ed by
Aparecida Guaraldo. UNICAMP, Campinas, pp 150±151 Janick J and Simon JE, Timber Press, Portland, OR, pp 372±
(1991). 375 (1990).
19 AOCS, Of®cial Methods and Recommended Practices of the
8 Cuatrecasas J, Cocoa and Its Allies. A Taxonomic Revision of
American Oil Chemists' Society, 3rd edn. AOCS, Champaign,
the Genus Theobroma (Contribution National Herbarium US
IL (1993).
National Museum 35). Washington, DC, Part 6, pp 1±1235
20 Hartman L and Lago R, Rapid preparation of fatty acid methyl
(1964).
esters from lipids. Lab Pract 22:475±476 (1973).
9 Ducke A, As espeÂcies brasileiras do geÃnero Theobroma. Bol Tec
21 Facioli NL and GoncËalves LAG, Modi®cacËaÄo por via enzimaÂtica
Inst Agron Norte 28:1±89 (1953).
da composicËaÄo triglicerõÂdica do oÂleo de piquõÂ (Cariocar
10 Martini MH, Lenci CG, Santos LZF, Tavares DQ and Figueira brasiliense Camb.). QuõÂm Nova 21:16±19 (1998).
A, CaracterizacËaÄo estrutural de seis espeÂcies do geÃnero 22 Deffense E, Fractionation of palm oil. J Am Oil Chem Soc
Theobroma e uma espeÂcie do geÃnero Herrania para estudo da 62:376±385 (1985).
®logenia. Livro de Resumos 2, XVII Congr Brasileiro de CieÃncia e 23 Chaisieri S, Arruda DH, Dimick PS and Enriquez GA, Thermal
Tecnologia de Alimentos, Fortaleza, Resumo 5.180 (2000). characteristics and composition of fats from Theobroma
11 Sotelo A and Alvarez RG, Chemical composition of wild species. Turrialba 39:468±472 (1989).
Theobroma species and their comparison to the cacao bean. J 24 Ferrari RA, Estudo comparativo da composicËaÄo lipõÂdica do milho
Agric Food Chem 39:1940±1943 (1991). hõÂbrido nutrimaiz com as cultivares genitoras. Master Thesis,
12 Sotelo A, Lucas B, Garza L and Giral F, Characteristics and fatty Universidade Estadual de Campinas (1992).
acid content of the fat of seeds of nine wild Mexican plants. J 25 Cooper C, Reduced calorie cocoa butter substitutes. US Patent
Agric Food Chem 38:1503±1505 (1990). EPO 571218 A2 (1998).
13 Hammerstone JF, Romanczyk LJ and Aitken WM, Purine 26 Chaisieri S and Dimick PS, Dynamic crystallization of cocoa
alkaloid distribution within Herrania and Theobroma. Phyto- butter. 1. Characterization of simple lipids in rapid- and slow-
chemistry 35:1237±1240 (1994). nucleating cocoa butters and their seed crystals. J Am Oil Chem
14 Carpenter DR, Hammerstone JF, Romanczyk LJ and Aitken Soc 72:1491±1496 (1995).