You are on page 1of 9

J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684

DOI 10.1007/s10803-011-1293-y

ORIGINAL PAPER

Parental Perspectives of Communication about Sexuality


in Families of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders
Michelle S. Ballan

Published online: 17 June 2011


Ó Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2011

Abstract To explore the content of communication about individuals with ASD are sexually immature or the pres-
sexuality between parents and children with autism spec- ence of socioaffective deficits renders their sexuality
trum disorders, semi-structured interviews were conducted insignificant (Konstantareas and Lunsky 1997). The few
with 18 parents of children ages 6–13. Content analysis and scientific studies on ASD and sexuality (i.e., Hellemans
ethnographic summary were used to interpret the data. et al. 2007, 2010) demonstrate that youth with ASD display
Findings suggest that parent’s perceptions of a child’s sexual interest and engage in sexual behaviors, not unlike
behaviors and comprehension are associated with the their peers. However, young persons with ASD tend to
likelihood that communication occurs. However, parents possess less knowledge about sexuality and display more
recognize the risks their children experience, with the inappropriate sexual behaviors (Ray et al. 2004; Stokes and
greatest fears being sexual victimization and mispercep- Kaur 2005).
tions related to the intent of their child’s behaviors. This Socially unacceptable sexual behaviors in youth with
study provides information on the nature of communication ASD may be related to core features of autism. The
about sexuality in families of children with autism spec- impairments defining individuals with ASD (lack of social
trum disorders and can help tailor interventions aimed at and communication skills, along with behavioral fea-
assisting parents to communicate sexuality information tures), typically necessary for the learning and under-
effectively. standing of appropriate sexual interaction, often leads to
errors in social judgment (Gabriels and Van Bourgondien
Keywords Sexuality  Parent communication  Autism 2007; Ruble 1992). For example, social deficits can
spectrum disorders interfere with differentiation between public and private
behaviors and misperceiving others’ intentions resulting
in unsolicited sexual contact. Due to their social limita-
Introduction tions, individuals with ASD may innocently engage in
inappropriate or intrusive courtship behaviors in an
Youth with autism spectrum disorders (ASD) are vulner- attempt to develop interpersonal relationships (Stokes and
able to a range of sexual behavior outcomes. Among these Newton 2004). The contribution of their social impair-
are sexual abuse and normative sexual behavior associated ments combined with a desire for attachment and rela-
with maturation (Edelstein 2010). Yet, the sexual devel- tionships could lead to committing illegal offenses (Allen
opment, behaviors and outcomes of young persons with et al. 2008; Howlin 1997; Stokes and Kaur 2005), being
ASD have been understudied in the empirical literature. sexually exploited (Tantum 2000) or engaging in risky
This inattention may be due to misconceptions that sexual behavior.
Risky sexual behaviors include multiple sexual partners,
lack of condom use and lack of birth control use (Centers
M. S. Ballan (&)
for Disease Control [CDC] 1998). Sexual risk-taking
School of Social Work, Columbia University, 1255 Amsterdam
Avenue, New York, NY 10027, USA behaviors increase the likelihood of negative sexual health
e-mail: msb2008@columbia.edu outcomes like unintended pregnancy, pre-cancerous

123
J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684 677

changes in the cervix, and contracting STDs, including perspectives on knowledge and skills necessary for effec-
HIV/AIDS (Capaldi et al. 2002; Crockett et al. 1996; tive communication, examine the content of communica-
Kaestle et al. 2005; O’Donnell et al. 2001). Increasingly, tion about sexuality, and identify potential barriers to
greater attention has been placed on the prevention of HIV communication about sexuality.
and other STIs among young persons. This has resulted in
the development of a number of efficacious prevention
interventions designed to protect youth from risky sexual Method
behavior and negative health outcomes (Kirby et al. 2004;
O’Donnell et al. 2005; Stanton et al. 2004). Although Design Overview
studies suggest that youth with disabilities are at increased
risk for unintentional pregnancies (Levy et al. 1992), sex- Seeking to uncover and amplify study participant’s per-
ual abuse (Blum et al. 2001; Mandell et al. 2005) and are as spectives, the in-depth interview provides an authentic
likely to be sexually active as their nondisabled peers pathway to understanding diversity and neglected areas of
(Groce 2003), they are not participating in these interven- research, with important implications for practice among
tions. Taken together with the small body of research underserved and oppressed populations (DePoy et al.
specifically focused on youth with ASD, the literature 1999). In-depth interviews have been shown to be highly
supports the development of targeted prevention programs beneficial for exploratory research and for the development
for this vulnerable yet, understudied population. of empirical models and theoretical knowledge (Padgett
One factor increasingly associated with reduced or 1998). Eighteen in-depth interviews using a semi-struc-
delayed sexual behavior is communication between parents tured questioning format were conducted with parents of
and their children about sexual health. A number of studies children with ASD. The interviews focused on two primary
have supported the protective function of parent–child questions: (1) What knowledge and skills are needed for
communication as a mechanism for reducing sexual risk parents to communicate with their children with ASD
among youth. This literature has been reviewed extensively about sexuality? and (2) What types of support are neces-
(see Jaccard and Dittus 1993; Miller et al. 2001 citations). sary for parents to provide sexuality information to their
Surprisingly, while parent–child communication has been children with ASD? Numerous probes requesting exam-
found to be a predictor of decreased sexual risk behaviors, ples, clarification or further information about topics such
studies have yet to explore the role of communication as sexual abuse, modesty, birth control, puberty etc. were
about sexuality among parents of children with ASD. used.
This study’s purpose was to better understand parent–
child communication about sexuality in order to inform the Recruitment Procedures
design and development of a parent-based psychoeduca-
tional intervention for parents of children with ASD. The Interview participants were recruited from elementary and
study reported here is the first component of an interven- middle schools in New Jersey. The largest U.S. study of
tion project, the Growing Up Aware Program, a tailored, childhood autism determined 1 in 94 children in New
parent-based intervention program to teach parents how to Jersey (CDC 2007) have an ASD, a higher rate than the
be effective sexuality educators for their children with national average of approximately 1 in 110 (CDC 2009).
ASD. The study examined different aspects of communi- Three school districts and one region were randomly
cation about sexuality among parents of children with selected from a list of public schools in Bergen county,
ASD. A comprehensive review of the scholarly research on New Jersey. All agreed to participate in the study. Toge-
sexuality and ASD and parent communication about sex- ther, these districts and region serve approximately 350
uality for nondisabled children led to the development of a children with autism spectrum disorders ages 3–21.
semi-structured interview guide with probes. A priori top- Information sessions pertaining to the study were pro-
ics were identified based on the current gaps in the vided to school personnel. Schools then sent study flyers
empirical literature, however, the interviews were struc- and letters supporting the research to parents of children
tured to allow for the emergence of new content and ideas who met the criteria for participation in the study. Inclu-
beyond the theoretical framework that was imposed by the sionary criteria was limited to mothers, fathers and legal
study design. The intent was to focus the study on the most guardians of children who were between the ages of 6–13
pressing shortfalls in the current knowledge base while and had a primary diagnosis of an ASD, as determined by
allowing flexibility in the content of the participant educational classification. The disparate age range for
responses. Specifically, the interview guide was formulated children was designated due to the diverse functional level
to acquire detailed information on the nature of parent– of social, intellectual and life skills children with ASD
child communication about sexuality, explore parental exhibit. There were approximately 190 children in this age

123
678 J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684

range with a primary diagnosis of ASD in public schools finish their thoughts and/or discontinue the interview and
within the districts and region. still be afforded financial compensation. Also, in the event
Approval for this study was obtained from the Columbia that a parent became upset during the interview, the
University Institutional Review Board (IRB). Twenty-two interviewer was trained to guide him or her with empathic
parents contacted the researcher by telephone to participate listening and reflection. If the interviewer was unable to
in the study. Potential participants received additional fully ameliorate discomfort, she was to refer participants to
information about the study and were further assessed for The Arc of Bergen and Passaic Counties for education and
eligibility via a screening script. All eligible participants counseling. However, no problems arose during the inter-
received an informational packet by mail. The packet views dictating the implementation of these procedures.
included an introductory cover letter, two consent forms, All participants were assured of their confidentiality.
supplemental materials about the project, information Children were not present during interviews nor were they
about the funder and a stamped envelope to return one interviewed. All interviews were audio-taped and notes
consent form. The first nineteen eligible parents (parents of were taken with the parent’s permission. Audio-tapes
approximately 10% of eligible children ages 6–13), who remained in a locked filing cabinet until transcribed ver-
signed consent forms for their participation and mailed a batim and checked for both accuracy and adherence to IRB
signed copy to the researcher were included in the study. protocol by the research assistant who did not conduct the
The other three eligible parents requested to be included interview. Thereafter, the audio-tape was destroyed. The
when the intervention was delivered. Study participants average approximate duration of the interviews was 1.5 h
retained an unsigned consent form and received a copy of (range 59 min to 2 h and 12 min).
the signed original during the time of the interview. Interview transcripts were coded for themes identified
Compensation to offset child care, transportation or other through content analysis (see Patton 2002). Two indepen-
expenses incurred by parents was provided at a rate of $25 dent coders analyzed and coded the transcripts. A fre-
per interview. quency count strategy was then used to compute the
number of times a participant mentioned each identified
Data Collection theme. Frequency counts serve as a guard against both
respondent and investigator bias (Miles and Huberman
Interviews were scheduled to accommodate parents’ child 1994). They can also provide a measure with which to
care requests and work calendars. Interviews occurred at calculate interrater reliability. Reliability checks and fre-
participant’s homes, work locations and their child’s quency counts across the two independent coders revealed
school. All parental requests for location and times of an overall agreement rate of approximately 94%. The
interviews were honored. Data were gathered using a semi- remaining differences were resolved through discussion
structured face-to face interview carried out by one of two among the independent coders.
research assistants. Examples of interview questions
include: ‘‘What are some concerns about sexuality and
autism spectrum disorders parents may have about their Results
children?’’ ‘‘What would help improve parents’ ability to
communicate with their children with autism spectrum Sixteen mothers and three fathers participated in the
disorders about sexuality?’’ and ‘‘What information or interviews. Eighty-four percent of participants were mar-
skills might parents of a child with an autism spectrum ried, including one couple who was interviewed separately.
disorder need to help their child develop into a sexually To correct for potential error variance in the parental
healthy and responsible adult?’’ responses of the one couple interviewed, only the interview
Research assistants were formally trained interviewers for the primary caregiver, the mother, was reported in the
with a minimum of 3 years of professional employment in results below. Thus, results are presented for eighteen
the area of sexuality education or sexual health counseling. interviews and represent independent perspectives from
One held a graduate degree in social work, the other was in only the individual parent deemed as the ‘‘primary
the final stage of obtaining her graduate degree in public caregiver’’.
health, with a specialization in sexuality. Prior to the The participants had a total of twenty children with ASD
interviews, research assistants reviewed the consent form between the ages of 6 and 13. Two participants had two
with parents which acknowledged that due to the sensitive children with ASD within this age range. Twelve of the
nature of the topic, embarrassment or anxiety may occur. children were between the ages of 6–9 and eight children
They discussed approved IRB protocol regarding proce- were between the ages of 10–13. All but one child was
dures in the event of such discomfort. If any question male. Sixteen of the twenty children were fully mains-
caused concern, participants could change the topic, not treamed, many with classroom aides, while the other four

123
J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684 679

children participated in partial mainstream and special Other parents expressed a desire to acquire such skills
education/resource room settings. Nineteen of the children using techniques already familiar to their child’s learning
used spoken language to communicate. style (for example, using applied behavioral analysis).
Employing the analytic strategy depicted earlier, four Parents also recognized their children’s normative sex-
content-related themes about sexuality were identified. They ual behaviors to be both stigmatized and feared. One
include: misperceptions of children’s non-sexual and sexual mother said, ‘‘I have had an issue with my son who didn’t
behavior, challenges discussing sexuality with children and understand, he was masturbating. I talked to the school
professionals, sexuality information communicated to chil- nurse who was no help. She was embarrassed that a kid
dren, and perceptions of children’s future influencing com- with a disability was doing this and told us to speak with
munication topics. A section on ‘‘differences among parents’ his psychiatrist or behavior person, basically anyone who
perceptions’’ concludes the results section. dealt with problem behaviors for autism kids.’’ Moreover,
parents shared that the maturational behaviors their non-
Content-Related Themes disabled children displayed were viewed as sexually
problematic or inappropriate when exhibited by children
Misperceptions of Children’s Behaviors with ASD. Such behaviors included ‘‘playing doctor’’,
undressing with others present, touching one’s genitals and
A primary theme that emerged from the interviews was masturbation. Parents also emphasized that their children’s
concern that the non-sexual and sexual behaviors of chil- sexual behavior was not viewed as a sign of ‘‘normalcy’’
dren with ASD were misunderstood and stigmatized by rather an aspect of development to further separate their
others. The majority of parents (n = 16) were fearful that child from nondisabled peers. In the words of one mother,
their children’s non-sexual behaviors would be miscon- ‘‘Even when he grew hair under his arm, got muscles,
strued as having sexual content. Parents perceived their instead of rejoicing that he is on track with his develop-
children’s psychological and behavioral functioning asso- ment, another mom said to me this must be a nightmare. He
ciated with ASD leading to non-sexual behaviors resulting would be better not to hit puberty because he might get too
from a lack of understanding regarding personal space, aroused and not know what to do with himself.’’ Parents
problems with sensory processing and misperceived social were clearly troubled by misperceptions of their children’s
cues. As one mother noted, ‘‘If you have a pattern on your sexual and non-sexual behaviors.
shirt and he [her son] likes it, he is going to touch it, not
because he wants to touch your breasts but because he Challenges Discussing Sexuality with Children
wants to feel the shirt.’’ Parents perceived that others’ and Professionals
limited knowledge of autism may cause their children’s
benign actions to be viewed as sexual expression and Parents expressed a strong desire to communicate with
possibly mistaken as deviant. The mother of a mainstrea- both their children and professionals about sexuality but
med first grader stated, ‘‘The teacher was very concerned expressed apprehension and concerns regarding such dis-
about my son because he wants to approach children but is cussions. The majority of parents (n = 16) stated they
not sure how to, girls in particular. He’ll go over and touch would be comfortable communicating about sexuality with
their hair and want to hug them. It seemed like this teacher their children with ASD but questioned their child’s ability
thought he was a sexual offender instead of a kid struggling to comprehend the information as a barrier to discussions.
with autism.’’ Although parents perceived these and similar As one father shared, ‘‘My biggest concern-is he getting it
actions as normative developmental behaviors for children in the right way? I mean he’s never asked any questions,
with ASD, they discussed socially acceptable mechanisms not even about his erections.’’ Parents explained the
to minimize children’s sensory-related behaviors and to problem of discernment with their children similarly. As
foster social and emotional reciprocity. ‘‘We work on one mother proffered, ‘‘The stakes are much higher with
social cuing every day through role play and opportunities this population because they can very easily invent an
with siblings. He doesn’t know social cues and stands too event. They understand things so differently and not nec-
close to people. He is our little space invader,’’ stated the essarily verbalize how they understand it so that things can
mother of an 11 year old. A few parents (n = 5) employed get really off track.’’ The dynamic of parent initiated one-
a range of visual and behavioral techniques to curtail way communication also caused parents to question their
conduct that might be misinterpreted as sexualized. Among child’s ability to apply the socio-sexual knowledge and
these included the use of red and green paper (red to skills learned. Parents wanted to acquire skills to help teach
demonstrate stop-private, green, okay-public) for places in their children with ASD information about sexuality and to
the home to be dressed or undressed in front of others and appropriately apply this knowledge to their everyday
gestures for visual cuing to signal inappropriate touching. environments.

123
680 J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684

Reluctance to discuss sexuality was also coupled sexuality is going to be delayed. Because no one ever, I
with the belief that the topic was simply not relevant mean I go to all of the pediatricians, I go to the
for their child. As a father said of his 12 year old son, developmentalist, and no one said to me this will hap-
‘‘My hands are so full with other things that I’m not pen.’’ Parents desired information from professionals
going to anticipate how I am going to handle something regarding their children’s normative sexual growth and
that doesn’t exist just yet.’’ Parents acknowledged their development, a noted gap in knowledge for many parents
children’s chronological age being widely disparate (n = 11). One father stated, ‘‘Knowing from a doctor or
from their child’s emotional maturity. Parents desired educator that he was possibly on the same developmental
guidance as to when it was appropriate to provide calendar as many 12 year olds would have helped. Just
sexuality education and what topics should be taught, as because he has autism spectrum, doesn’t mean that
some parents (n = 6) found it challenging to address anything else physiologically is going to be off, we have
certain sexuality topics when their child still has learned the hard way on our own.’’
‘‘accidents at night in bed’’ or plays with age-inappro- Parents portrayed professionals as lacking initiative or
priate games. Parents who perceived their children with receptivity to addressing children’s sexual maturation
ASD as behaviorally immature struggled with commu- unless an aspect of sexuality presents as a behavioral
nication about sexuality. problem. One mother mentioned, ‘‘The psychologist
Parents were also anxious that their children may never discussed my child’s changing behavior could be
overgeneralize when information about sexuality is com- due to raging hormones or not understanding the changes
municated. As one mother explained, ‘‘My son tries to in his body, even when I asked if that was possible. She
generalize everything. For example, I was telling him that only wanted to talk about it when he got in trouble for
if he doesn’t brush his teeth they are going to turn yellow kissing his piano teacher and trying to touch her breast.’’
and he associated that with a witch. Then I found him in the Training in sexuality was viewed as a primary need for
bathroom for over a half hour and I was like have you been professionals serving parents of children with ASD. As
brushing your teeth the whole time. He’s yeah I don’t want one mother said, ‘‘The experts have an answer for every
to be a witch. With sexuality I have to be really careful situation with my child except the one that could land
exactly how each word is stated or who knows what he will him in jail if he handles it wrong. I just wish they would
think or do.’’ Some parents shared their unease that sex be trained to ask us the important questions since we
education could lead to perseveration or fixation on a topic. don’t know what questions to ask or to who. Why would
The validity of this concern should not be understated as I think my son would get erections or try to kiss girls at
stereotyped and repetitive use of language, mannerisms and 9 when he wasn’t even toilet trained until 6?’’ Parents
behaviors are defining features of ASD. One mother repeatedly referenced other parents of children with ASD
questioned, ‘‘What if I tell my son it is a penis and for the as their main source of sexuality information. As one
next 10 months, his fascination is with his penis instead of mother said, ‘‘Teachers and therapists know a lot but
a computer game or train. What if he talks about his penis they don’t share information about sex or birth control. It
all day and to everyone he meets?’’ Other parents worried would be great to get the information they learned in
about their child’s behavioral reactions to learning about school, the book knowledge. But it’s even nicer to talk
sexuality. For the seven parents of children with self- to moms that have gone through it already.’’ Some
stimulation behaviors, they feared that masturbation may parents (n = 5), however expressed concern about the
become a substitute for current behaviors like hand-flap- accuracy of this information and the applicability of
ping or rocking. interventions suggested by ‘‘parent experts.’’
Such apprehensions have led parents to seek guidance
to acquire additional knowledge about their child’s sex- Sexuality Information Communicated to Children
ual development and the skills needed to accurately and
appropriately communicate this information to their In general, parents reported communication about sexu-
children. However, despite the myriad professionals ality with their child. Parent–child communication was
active in their children’s lives, including special educa- focused on limited themes, their child’s safety and social
tors, developmental pediatricians and psychiatrists among acceptance. Among a range of topics two emerged more
others, parents reported feeling isolated in regards to frequently, sexual abuse prevention and personal hygiene
receiving information or preparation to address their issues. All parents interviewed discussed sexual abuse
child’s sexuality. As one mother said, ‘‘I was in this prevention with their child. Parents repeated that their
little ignorant cocoon and it kinda crept up. Parents need primary fear is for their child to be sexually abused.
to know that just because their child does have a sig- ‘‘Someone is going to take advantage because they don’t
nificant developmental delay doesn’t mean that their fully understand sexuality like a child their age,’’

123
J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684 681

asserted one mother. Parents identified numerous reasons Perceptions of Children’s Future
for their children’s vulnerability to sexual abuse includ-
ing an inability to judge other’s negative intentions, Parents’ discussions of sexuality tended to be void of topics
limited communication skills and dependence on multi- focused on forthcoming social and sexual behaviors such as
ple caregivers. Four parents noted suspicions about dating, sexual intercourse, and birth control. Foregoing
friend’s or relative’s children with ASD having been such discussions was due partly to the child’s age but most
sexually abused by caregivers during the early childhood notably, to an inability to envision their children’s future
years. These parents questioned if children with ASD are including a partner. Collectively, parents expressed the
able to provide accurate abuse reports due to their lim- reflection, ‘‘It’s hard for me to imagine my son ever having
ited communication skills and underdeveloped vocabu- a girlfriend.’’ Several reasons for this belief were identified.
lary about body parts. More than half of parents (n = 10) remarked their child
Many parents (n = 11) were concerned that they have didn’t have a friend, so a date or partner seemed implau-
inadvertently communicated contradictory messages about sible. Based on common experiences with failed attempts
sexual abuse prevention to their children. One mother at socialization with peers, parents now focused on their
affirmed, ‘‘For many years we’re teaching our children to fear of rejection by children’s potential ‘‘crushes.’’ One
go with everyone and hold everyone’s hand for safety father described, ‘‘He gets crushes; so far he is ultimately
issues and it’s ok to have someone help you get dressed and rejected and devastated. The thing is preparing him for
go to the bathroom, to shower you. Now they are older, and rejection so it doesn’t destroy his self-esteem. Why talk
still need personal assistance. I try to tell him when it’s not about sex with him when it will most likely never happen.
ok to pull down your pants and it’s ok for this and not ok It is cruel to get his hopes up.’’ One mother stated, ‘‘Is my
for that but there are too many rules.’’ Parents also worried child ever going to get married and have kids-no. That
that they may not provide the information in a logical way opportunity was taken away from her the day she was
to their child. As one father concluded, ‘‘I want my child diagnosed with autism, without her having a choice. She
knowing he has the right if someone were to approach him, has discovered [her area] but a partner, nope it is just not in
to say no. I have never had a discussion with my son like her future.’’ Despite accounts of their children’s expressed
this but I have told him generally to stay away from sexual interest and a wide array of age-appropriate sexual
strangers and not let them touch your private parts. I behaviors, parents believed without an appropriate level of
wonder if this helped him to understand or confused him social functioning, their children would be unable to
further.’’ Parents desired additional knowledge on sexual achieve romantic or intimate functioning. Other reasons
abuse prevention and wanted to enhance their skills for parents were unable to foresee a partner in their child’s
detecting abuse and their children’s skills for recognizing future included children’s hypersensitivity to smells and
and reporting abuse. tastes interfering with intimacy and an inability to ‘‘han-
Parents also discussed hygiene and grooming with their dle’’ social and emotional reciprocal interaction. Percep-
children with ASD. Most parents (n = 14) reported chil- tions of their child’s futures greatly impacted topics
dren’s continuing struggles with personal hygiene due to addressed during parent–child communication about
sensory processing dysfunction, especially tactile activities sexuality.
such as wiping, bathing and teeth brushing. As one mother
shared, ‘‘I finally got him to wipe himself thoroughly after Differences Among Parents’ Perceptions
years. I still have to beg him to change his underwear each
day and take a shower. I help him in the shower and wash While parents overwhelmingly agreed on the importance of
his hair. He’s going to be 11 years old.’’ In general, parents and desire for communication about sexuality with youth
were anxious about aspects of sexuality linked to hygiene with ASD, they disagreed on two particular points. Parents
such as menstruation and cleaning after masturbation or suggested varying time frames for educating children with
nocturnal emissions. However, some parents (n = 6) dis- ASD about sexuality and regarded the communication as
cussed the use of activities related to hygiene to commu- either their primary role or a shared role. The majority of
nicate about sexuality. One mother stated, ‘‘Bath time was the parents (n = 8) of younger children between the ages
the perfect opportunity to teach the correct names of body of 6–9 expressed a need for communication to begin during
parts and about personal boundaries since I bathed my son the later elementary school years, suggesting a focus on
and daughter together.’’ Attention to hygiene enabled areas such as modesty and body part awareness to be
parents to discuss self-esteem, attraction to others and conveyed to children. However, most parents (n = 6) of
pursuits towards social acceptance. In general, parents children ages 10–13 believed sexuality education should
perceived hygiene as a means to foster children’s self- begin in the early elementary school years focusing on the
awareness and socialization. need for sexual health information, puberty and

123
682 J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684

masturbation as essential topics for younger children to normative social or romantic relationships and sexual
learn. They noted disadvantages children face (i.e., exhib- behavior. This may be in part due to the fact that the
iting inappropriate sexual behavior, inattention to issues of majority of families sampled for this study had a younger
privacy and modesty) when sexuality education and social child with an ASD. However, when parents were probed
interaction with same age peers are delayed. about future romantic relationship orientations for their
All expressed the belief that parents should be sexuality children with ASD, the majority did not foresee a future
educators for children, however, some parents (n = 7) where their child might be appropriately sexually active.
noted shared responsibility of both medical professionals This result was most pronounced in families where there
and educators to provide sexuality education to children was more than one child and not all were children with
with ASD. Other parents (n = 6) explicitly expressed ASD. In these instances, parents reported differential
disinterest in their children being educated by professionals expectations regarding the formation of romantic rela-
on sexuality. Instead, they highlighted the need for pro- tionships and sexual behavior. For nondisabled children,
fessionals to foster gaps in parental knowledge and skills to parents envisioned a future where the child was expected to
enhance communication about sexuality between parents form developmentally appropriate romantic relationships.
and their children with ASD. As a parent shared, ‘‘I don’t The tendency for parents to perceive romantic relationships
want someone on the child life study team educating my as foreclosed to their children with ASD results in limited
son about masturbation. I have no idea of that person’s attention to addressing the reproductive and sexual health
morals, values or skills. I often don’t even agree with what needs of this population. This is troublesome in that youths
she wants for my child academically. But, I would like for with ASD may be unprepared to protect themselves from
them to help me to figure out how to best provide the unintended pregnancies, HIV and other sexually transmit-
information to my son, so he learns it and I know he gets ted infections.
it.’’ Parenting behaviors reflect insufficient effective strate-
gies to foster the sexual and reproductive health and well-
being of their children with ASD. Parent-based sexuality
Discussion training programs that rely on evidence-based interventions
such as applied behavioral analysis and social stories
The results of the current study highlight the importance of should be developed to enhance parents’ self-efficacy with
developing targeted sexual risk reduction programs for communication. Such programs enable parents to imple-
youth with ASD and their families. Similar to the existing ment skill-based techniques commonly used in educational
extant empirical literature, the data reported here suggest settings familiar to their children’s academic and life skills
children with ASD are at great risk for involvement in risky learning style. Such programs further assist parents to
sexual behavior and/or sexual victimization. The current accurately assess their child’s understanding of sexuality-
study addresses a gap in the scientific literature in that it related topics communicated. Given parents repeatedly
seeks to further understand the sexual risk reduction needs questioned their child’s level of comprehension regarding
of ASD youth from a family-based perspective. Limited sexuality information imparted, the development of effi-
attention has been placed on the role of families in cacious parent sexuality training programs is a particularly
reducing sexual risk behavior and sexual abuse among salient recommendation.
children with ASD. In this regard, the study is innovative With the proper supports and knowledge, many children
and has important public health implications for an with ASD develop into adolescence and adulthood with the
understudied and vulnerable population. ability to form and maintain mature and healthy sexual
Despite an increasingly large body of literature that relationships. All individuals with disabilities have a right
suggests parents can influence important sexual behavior to education about sexuality, sexual and reproductive
decisions and outcomes in their children’s lives, scant health care, and opportunities for socializing and sexual
research has addressed the potential protective role of expression (SIECUS 2011). Many of these rights are
parents for youth with ASD. This is worrisome in that the addressed by the ratification of the Convention on the
findings reported here indicate that parents perceive their Rights of Persons with Disabilities in 99 countries (United
children with ASD as vulnerable to involvement in sexual Nations Enable 2011), in particular Articles 23 and 25
risk taking and negative sexual behavior outcomes. Parents explicitly discuss sexual and reproductive health and
primarily report concerns related to their children with reproductive rights. Important to note is the global trends
ASD being sexually abused or demonstrating behaviors towards increased research and scholarship related to the
that can be misconstrued as sexually inviting or provoca- sexual and reproductive health needs of individuals with
tive. Striking to note is the fact that almost no parental data disabilities. Internationally, there is a growing body of
discussed youth with ASD as potentially being engaged in literature (i.e., Grieveo et al. 2007; Löfgren-Mårtenson

123
J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684 683

2004) that has examined various aspects of sexuality and programs that support their efforts regarding the prevention
disability. This scholarship has contributed to an increased of sexual abuse and the incorrect classification of behavior
understanding of sexuality-related issues and service needs as sexual. Parental efforts in addressing the sexual and
for adults with disabilities. Despite greater attention to this reproductive health needs of their children with ASD also
area, much remains unaddressed and warrants further need to consider normative sexual behavior resulting from
investigation. In this regard, the current study incremen- maturation. The sexual decision making of individuals with
tally advances the knowledge base of the field. ASD warrants further attention both in regards to research
Despite the exploratory nature of these data and the and to the development of applied prevention programs.
limited sample size, the findings of this paper provide Family-based programs that target children with ASD with
important implications for future research and applied appropriate knowledge and skills for navigating normative
interventions designed to improve the sexual and repro- sexual behavior associated with maturation and transition
ductive health of youth with ASD. Several important to adulthood are feasible and sorely needed.
applied implications are worthy of further discussion and
reinforcement. Among these is the fact that the majority of Acknowledgments This research was supported by a grant from the
Silberman Fund awarded to Michelle S. Ballan.
parents participating in the current study indicate a strong
interest and need in hearing from myriad professionals
about how to better communicate with their children with
References
ASD about issues related to sexual and reproductive health.
Despite this, a review of available materials from numerous Allen, D., Evans, C., Hider, A., Hawkins, S., Peckett, H., & Morgan,
social service and health providers reveals insufficient H. (2008). Offending behaviour in adults with Asperger
availability of materials developed for either parents or syndrome. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders,
providers to best support greater levels of communication 38, 748–758.
Blum, R. W., Kelly, A., & Ireland, M. (2001). Health-risk behaviors
about the sexual and reproductive health needs of children and protective factors among adolescents with mobility impair-
with ASD. The demand for resources and individuals with ments and learning and emotional disabilities. Journal of
expertise to address the socio-emotional needs of youth Adolescent Health, 28, 481–490.
with ASD, including sexuality, outstrips the supply (Pre- Capaldi, D. M., Stoolmiller, M., Clark, S., & Owen, L. D. (2002).
Heterosexual risk behaviors in at-risk young men from early
lock and Vargas 2004). Many providers who work with adolescence to young adulthood: Prevalence, prediction, and
children and adolescents with ASD do not have the association with STD contraction. Developmental Psychology,
knowledge and skills to address the natural changes and 38, 394–406.
concerns that come with emerging sexual maturity. Too Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (1998). Youth risk
behavior surveillance-United States, 1997. Morbidity and Mor-
often, the discussion when it does occur with providers, is tality Weekly Report, 47(SS-3), 1–31.
restricted to problematic sexual behaviors exhibited by a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2007). Prevalence of
child. Such discussions are reactive versus proactive and autism spectrum disorders- Autism and developmental disabil-
fail to contextualize the normative developmental sexual ities monitoring network, 14 sites, United States, 2002. Morbid-
ity and Mortality Weekly Report, 56(SS-1), 12–28.
needs of children with ASD. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2009). Prevalence of
When parents communicate with children with ASD, autism spectrum disorders- Autism and developmental disabil-
often their conversations focus on sexual abuse and ities monitoring network, 14 sites, United States, 2006. Morbid-
hygiene issues versus the full spectrum of sexual health and ity and Mortality Weekly Report, 58(SS-10), 1–20.
Crockett, L. J., Bingham, C. R., Chopak, J. S., & Vicary, J. R. (1996).
reproductive issues. This is not to say that an important Timing of first sexual intercourse: The role of social control,
facet of the dialogue should not include the prevention of social learning, and problem behavior. Journal of Youth and
sexual abuse and development of personal hygiene. How- Adolescence, 25, 89–111.
ever, the conversation cannot conclude here. When physi- DePoy, D. J., Hartman, A., & Haslett, D. (1999). Critical action
research: A model of social knowing. Social Work, 44, 560–570.
cal maturation occurs at a greater rate than growth of Edelson, M. G. (2010). Sexual abuse of children with autism: Factors that
emotional or cognitive skills, as it does in youth with ASD, increase risk and interfere with recognition of abuse. Disability
how well adolescents are able to adjust to this change Studies Quarterly, 30(1). Retrieved from http://www.dsq-sds.org/.
depends largely on the support and education they receive Gabriels, R. L., & Van Bourgondien, M. E. (2007). Sexuality and
autism. In R. L. Gabriels & D. E. Hill (Eds.), Growing up with
from families and providers (Wallis 2000). Both parents autism: Working with school-age children and adolescents (pp.
and providers need training to better attend to the unmet 58–72). New York, NY: Guilford Press.
sexual health needs and the dearth of sexuality education Grieveo, A., McLaren, S., & Lindsay, W. (2007). An evaluation of
programs for youth with ASD. research and training resources for the sex education of people
with moderate to severe learning disabilities. British Journal of
In sum, the present study documents that parents want Learning Disabilities, 35(1), 30–37.
and require support in addressing sexual behavior with Groce, N. E. (2003). HIV/AIDS and people with disability. The
their children with ASD. Specifically, parents require Lancet, 361, 1401–1402.

123
684 J Autism Dev Disord (2012) 42:676–684

Hellemans, H., Colson, K., Verbraeken, C., Vermeiren, R., & youth: The Reach for Health Study. Family Planning Perspec-
Deboutte, D. (2007). Sexual behavior in high-functioning male tives, 33(6), 268–275.
adolescents and young adults with autism spectrum disorder. O’Donnell, L., Stueve, A., Agronick, G., Wilson-Simmons, R.,
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 37, 260–290. Duran, R., & Jeanbaptiste, V. (2005). Saving sex for later: An
Hellemans, H., Roeyers, H., Leplae, W., Dewaele, T., & Deboutte, D. evaluation of a parent education intervention. Perspectives on
(2010). Sexual behavior in male adolescents and young adults Sexual and Reproductive Health, 37(4), 166–173.
with autism spectrum disorder and borderline/mild mental Padgett, D. K. (1998). Does the glove really fit? Qualitative research
retardation. Sexuality and Disability, 28(2), 93–104. and clinical social work practice. Social Work, 43, 373–381.
Howlin, P. (1997). Autism: Preparing for adulthood. London, Patton, M. Q. (2002). Qualitative research and evaluation methods.
England: Routledge. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Jaccard, J., & Dittus, P. J. (1993). Parent-adolescent communication Prelock, P. A., & Vargas, C. M. (2004). The role of partnerships in
about premarital pregnancy. Families in Society, 74, 329–343. program development for adolescents with autism spectrum
Kaestle, C. E., Halpern, C. T., Miller, W. C., & Ford, C. A. (2005). disorders. In C. M. Vargas & P. A. Prelock (Eds.), Caring for
Young age at first sexual intercourse and sexually transmitted children with neurodevelopmental disabilities and their families
infections in adolescents and young adults. American Journal of (pp. 275–300). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Epidemiology, 161, 774–780. Ray, F., Marks, C., & Bray-Garretson, H. (2004). Challenges to
Kirby, D. B., Baumler, E., Coyle, K. K., Basen-Engquist, K., Parcel, treating adolescents with Asperger’s syndrome who are sexually
G. S., Harrist, R., et al. (2004). The ‘‘Safer Choices’’ interven- abusive. Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity, 11, 265–285.
tion: Its impact on the sexual behaviors of different subgroups of Ruble, L. (1992). Social/sexual awareness of persons with autism: A
high school students. Journal of Adolescent Health, 35(6), parental perspective. Unpublished master’s thesis, Indiana Uni-
442–452. versity, Bloomington, IN.
Konstantareas, M. M., & Lunsky, Y. J. (1997). Sociosexual knowl- SIECUS (2011). Human sexuality position statement. Retrieved from
edge, experience, attitudes, and interests of individuals with http://siecus.org/index.cfm?fuseaction=Page.viewPage&pageId=
autistic disorder and developmental delay. Journal of Autism and 494&parentID=472.
Developmental Disorders, 27(4), 397–413. Stanton, B., Cole, M., Galbraith, J., Li, X., Pendleton, S., Cottrel, L.,
Levy, S. R., Perhats, C., Nash-Johnson, M., & Welter, J. F. (1992). et al. (2004). Randomized trial of a parent intervention: Parents
Reducing the risks in pregnant teens who are very young and can make a difference in long-term adolescent risk behaviors,
those with mild mental retardation. Mental Retardation, 30(4), perceptions, and knowledge. Archives of Pediatrics and Adoles-
195–203. cent Medicine, 158(10), 947–955.
Löfgren-Mårtenson, L. (2004). ‘May I?’ About sexuality and love in Stokes, M., & Kaur, A. (2005). High-functioning autism and
the new generation of intellectual disabilities. Sexuality and sexuality: A parental perspective. Autism, 9(3), 266–289.
Disability, 22(3), 197–207. Stokes, M., & Newton, N. (2004). Autistic spectrum disorders and
Mandell, D. S., Walrath, C. M., Manteufel, B., Sgro, G., & Pinto- stalking. Autism, 8(3), 337–339.
Martin, J. A. (2005). The prevalence and correlates of abuse Tantum, D. (2000). Psychological disorder in adolescents and adults
among children with autism served in comprehensive commu- with Asperger Syndrome. Autism, 40, 47–62.
nity-based mental health settings. Child Abuse and Neglect, 29, United Nations Enable (2011). Convention and optional protocol
1359–1372. signatures and ratifications. Retrieved from http://www.un.org/
Miles, M. B., & Huberman, A. M. (1994). Qualitative data atialysis: disabilities/countries.asp?navid=12&pid=166.
An expanded sourcehook (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Wallis, P. J. (2000). Issues in social sexuality for people with
Publications. disabilities, their families, and professionals. In M. J. Fine & R.
Miller, B. C., Benson, B., & Galbraith, K. A. (2001). Family L. Simpson (Eds.), Collaboration with parents and families of
relationships and adolescent pregnancy risk: A research synthe- children and youth with exceptionalities (pp. 391–407). Austin,
sis. Developmental Review, 21, 1–38. TX: Pro-Ed.
O’Donnell, L., O’Donnell, C., & Stueve, A. (2001). Early sexual
initiation and subsequent sex-related risks among urban minority

123

You might also like