I

III
-
A

1. -

1.1.

, 1565. ,
6.000 , - .
. 1570.
, ,
1650. ,

.
empa (1697-1726)
(
). ,
. 1731.
1762. ( Kamapuue ). 1811.
, 1821. .
1825. Tpee (
I), ,
. 1880. ,
, 1881.
- , e 36
, , . ,
, unocmpancmeo,
.
1917.
,
().
. ,
1917. ,
,

npomu .1
:
;
,
. 2
,
1

, , : ,
1917, 1922. , : , 1988, .31,3741.
2
: 1) ; 2) 3)
. , . 48-49.
2

 (
). 3 1918.
, ( ),
.4 1921.

. 5 1922.
,
.
1923.
[ - ),
.

(, , , .),

. , 1934. , 1921.
(
- - ),

-
. 1934.

( - ), ,
,
,
.
1941.
( HKTb). 1943.
.
,
,
, .
, ,

- 6.
. ,
1946.
, Muucmapcmo .

,
. 1953.

- .
,
3

, . 63-64.
, . 65;
() .
5
: , , , , , , .at.
6
, . 264; - : Deacon, Rjchirc.A History of the
YLussian Secret Service, New York: Taplinger Publishing Co., 1972.229
4

 -
( - ). 1954. ( )
1991. -
: 1/ ; 2/ 3/ .
( ),

( ),
.
.
, 1978. ,
, ,
. , .7
,
14 .8
, . ,
.
.
, , .

, .
,
.
.

.
,
- .
,
. ,
.
,
.
, ,
. npeceaajyu,
, a y ,
4-6 .
, 8
(, ,
).
,
7

1977. , :
, . , ,

. ,
.
; Internet 26/02/2002, www.fas.org/irp/world/russia/ kgb.
8

,
, .
4

,
. ,
.
.
:
;
; .

. ,
,

.9
.
,
() . 1988.
( )
,
, .10
,
, : , ,
, , ,
.
. , ,
.
,
.
, ,
. ,
.
, 1981. ,
, .
.
, 1991.
(),
( )
.
1.2. -
21. 1991.
,
( ), ,
.
,
9

490.000 1973. . He
. ,
,
.
10
: , , , , , , cit. 231)

 je, , -
(, , ).
XX ,
, ,
, ., -
.
- ,
, ,
. ,
- ,
.
,
, ,
, . 11
,
,
, ,
,
,

.
-
.
, , ,

, .
(
, ,
, , -
)
.
.

: 1/
; 2/ ... 3/ ,

.12
, ,
,
.
:
, OSCE; -
; ,
11

:
, , , : , 1999, cip. 83-116.
12

, . 95.
6

 ; .
.13 ,
,
.
1991. 2005.
.
, , ,
.

,
,
.
- ,
, . -
: , ,
,
1997. 14, ,
, ,
.
-
( ), 3. 1992. ,
, .15
: 1/
; 2/ ,
, ,
, ; 3/
,

; 4/ ,
,

5/
,
,
, .
: , ,
. .
opy , a :
, ,
13

, oope 2005. .
14
: Kegli, Carls V. , Vitkof, Judhin R., Svetsk politika - trendi tmnsformacija, op. at., ST686.
15
j ,
:


.

 , .
: , , , ,
, , , , ,

.
, .
, a ,
. ,
,
, , .
,
,
, ( )
.

, 1996. .

.
: , , ,
, ,

(, , .).
(
- /), , 1999.
( ), .
, : 1/

; 2/
( )
; 3/
4/

.
: ()
; ()

, ()

.16 :
, ,
.
() .17
1998.
,
16
17

Ibid, II. (
7).
Ibid, III. (
8

8,9).


.
n , (,
, ) ()
.
,
.
- :

);
2.
caeem a

(

)
3.
caeema

(>

) ,18
1.

: 1/
; 2/ ; 3/
4/
.19
y
.
: ()
( n
); ()
; ()
() ,

( .) . 20 : 1/

; 2/
; 3/ ; 4/


; 5/ ; 6/
, , ,

; 7/
18

:
21 1992 r. N 2398-1
)

.
19
Ibid, 1
20

, N 8 or 10 2 23,02.01 (
34); 23.11.01 ( 54), 2. .
9


( , ,
.) 8/
, .21
, ,
. ,

( ).
,
. a
. .

- ,
.22
:
( ),
,
, ( )
,
. ()
( .),
.
, , -
, ,

. To cy : 1/
2/ 3/ (BP); 4/
(); 5/
(); 6/ (); 7/
(); 8/
(); 9/ () 10/ ,
- .23
1.3.
-
8. 1992.
1993. ,
1995., 10.
1995.. , -
:
-

;
;

21

lbid, 3. OcHOBHtie .
: Ibid, 4. ,
23
: , , . cit., . 266-267; www.fas.org/irp/world/russia/indc\.hi:r .
;
.
22

10

 ,
, ( 5);
;

, ;



.24
-

1992.
,
() , . 293 18. 1991.
25, ().
1996. ,

,
, ,

. , ,
, .26
,
.
, : 1/
; 2/
; 3/ ; 4/
5
.27
. ,

. ,
: ,

, , , ;

.28
, :
1.

24

,
8 1995 , . , , KpeMAb, 10 1996
, N 5-.
25


,
. , , ,
18 1991 1, N 293; ,
, (),
. ,
- , nociao ,
1991.
26
,
, cif.
27
Ibid, Oraxibfl 4.:
28
Ibid, 5.
11

 ( );
2. ( -
) , ,
, .;
3. ,
;
4.
;
5. ,
, .;
6. ,
,
7.
.29

,
, . 30
,

. (
) .
(. 24),
,
,
, .
,
,
,
. ,

.

. ,
. , (
)
.
,
.
, ,
,
.
, .
, .31
29

Ibid, 6.
Bennett, Gordon, The SlU: Russias Intelligence Service,
UK: The Conflict Studies Research
Centre, March 2000, Internet, www.ppc.pims.org/csrc
31
2,4,5,6,10,12 14;
1996. ,
; Foreign Intelligence Service, Internet 18/04/2002, www.fas.org/irp/ world/russia/svr/
index.html.
30

12

 , ()
, .

: 1/ ; 2/
; 3/ ; 4/ ;
5/ - ; 6/ (
); 7/ ; 8/ ; 9/ ; 10/
- .32
.
,
(, .) .

.

. : 1
,
,
2/ ,
, ( ),
napmuja ,
.
,
. ,
:
( ) ;
; , ,
; ; -
; ;
;
.
:

.
, ,
;

, . He
,

.

32

22 35 . pepa
.
. .
: ; ; ; ; ;
; ; ,
; ; ;
.
13

 .33
,
,

.
-
,
, : 1/

; 2/
,
; 3/

(
, ) 4/
.


.
.
, ,
.


(). ,
,
, -
.
,
, .
- : 1/
2/ .
: /
\ /
/
.34
,
,
. ,
, ,
, .
, .
.
, ,
33

,
.
34
: , , , , , , . cit.
14

 .

.
, , , .
- , , : 1 / 2/
.
.
, .
- :

,
,

, (. -
, .).

;
. .
, - ,
, .
, , ,
) .
,
.
, .

.

, -
,
, .
,
. ,
, .
. To je j
.
, . ,
, .

,
.
. :
, ,

.
,
.

15

 ,
.

. ,
.
",
,

() 1987. 500 .
(),
. 1993.
().
, .
-
c.35.
1995.

, .

,
- ( , .).
, a
.
,
,
.
- ,

,
.36
1.4.
() ,
.
(),
1993.
( - ),
.37 1995.
() , ,
35

( - ), Internet, 20/05/3. wwwfas.org/

irp/world/russia/svr.
36
Ibid
37
: or 21 1993 r. N 2233

; . 91 1994. : ;
; ;
po; .; , , op. at., . 267-268
16

 1995. .38 -
,
. , ,
,
: ; ;
; ,
.39 1995.
1999. ,
, .40
: ;
; 14
; (
,
);

.

,
, ,
.41 , : ,
,

( ,

);
; capayjy
; ,
; ,
,

.42
, ,
- : ,
, -, ,
, ;

(
),
38

,
03.04.95, . 40- ( . 15-95 . . 1296 01/12/99. ,); :
13 15
, ,
1
1999 , , , Kpe, N226-;
. ,
.
39
Ibid ,
( , ,
,
()

; : .
6.
40
Ibid, II
41
8.
42
: ....
17


; ()
( ).
- ,
- 12.
1995. .

.

. 12 III , ,
, :
,
, ;
,

, ,
;
-

,
;

, , ;
, ;
, ,
, ,
, , ,
;
, ,
- ,
, .;

,
, ,
, ,

;

;


,
, , , , , , ;
, , ;
-

18

 , ,
;
,

-,

-
,
, , - ,
;

,

, ;

,
.
, 13 1995.
. , :
-

,
,

,
.
, ,
, ,
; , ,
,
43;

, ;

, ,
;
,



, , ,
( );
a , , a y , ,

43

19 , ;
,
.
19

 ;
, ,

(
),
.

;
,
, ,

;
;

.
, 24 ;

,
, ,
,

.
;

,
()
, , , - ;


;

,
;

,
;
,
, ;
;
;
, ,

;

,
-

20

 , ,
;

, , .;

,
.

,
. 44
17. 2000. ,
,
.45 1997.
,
.46
, :
1. ,

.
,
.
, , (),
, .
, .

. ,
.

.
, ,

.
44

13.

6 1998. . N 806
,
. , , , 17 2000 , N 1109.
46

6 1998 . N 806
1 , ,
. , , , N 1109; ,
LBP. ( ); ,
Internet 17/05/2002, u ww.fas.org/irp/world/russia/fsb/ organizatit)
45

21

 , ,
.

;
Amumepopucmu
. ,
1995. ,

47;
2) , ;
3) ;
4) ;
5)
6)
,
,

;
7) ;
8) ;
9) ;
10) e;
11)
48
12)
1)

1995.
, 250
, .



,
. ,
300 ,

.
,
. (
), ,
.
,
. , 75.000 .
, 45.000
1997. ( 30.000
poy ).49
47

1996. 402 ,
35
.

200 .Ibid.
48
N 515, . , , ,
Kpc.MAb, 22.05. 1997.;
Internet 20/05/2002, wuw.agentura.ru/text/documents/.
49
: : ( .
24.12.1993. N 2288, . , ,
22

1.5.
(),
1921. .

,
, 1995. ,
(
.).50
, ,
.
: 1

; 2/
(
-TECHINT/SIGINT ELINT)
, -
, ; 3/
4/
,
-
(IMINT) .
,
HUMINT ,
, (
- :
( - , Inurnet
20/05/2002, www.fas.org/irp/russia/fsb/index.html. ,
.
,
.
,
, , ,
.
, . V

, (
),
.
, ,
.
, -
- .
1992 , 3531-1.
50
1994. ; , , . cit.,
. 272.
23


()

, . 51
- -
( NSA GCHQ),

24. 1991. ,
1993. 52,
1994. ,
- .
: 1/

; 2/ -
; 3/
,
-
(ELINT, COMINT) 4/
,
.53
,
. 1996. ,
.54

, : 1
; 2/ ; 3/
,
; 4/ ,
(
)
; 5/ ,
, ; 6/ ,
() 7/ -
;
51

, .,
(SIGINT).
52




, ,
. , , 24 1991 , N 313;
: .1
.
, ( .
24.12.93 N 2288),
B.EAbUMH, , , 19 1993 , N 4524-1.
53

, (
, ,

.
54
,
3.

24

 , ,
,
.). ,
,

.

,
.
,

.
(), ()
().
() : 1/

, .
- .
,
, ,
; 2/
(,
); 3/ ,
4/ .
.55
, , ,
.
: ,
, ,
,
,

, ,
, - .

,
e- .56
1.6.
() ,
, a
(
) 1996. . 57
55

Ibid, 9. Ibid.
: Ibid, 4.
57
: ,
, 24 1996 , 15 1996 ( .
56

25

 .
()
9. 1996. . : 1/
,

; 2/
(
,
; 3/ ,
; 4/

; 5/
; 6/
; 7/
-
,
8/
,
.58 ,

.
,
. , ,
.

.
. 250 .59

()
() 1993. ,
. .


,
() . 1996.

. ,
, .

18.07.1997 N 101-, 07-11.2000 N 135-).

58
,
. : 9 1996 r. N 349.
59
,
. : or 9 Niapra 1996 . N 349.
26

2. -


2000 ,
.60 1766.
60

.
27

.. , , .
1122. .. ,
.61
, V ..
By - , ,
,
. 62
By
.

. ., ,
; ,
, .63
( ,
, ) ,
,
.

2.1.

. , ,
,
. , XVI,
, ,
, ,
-
,
.

,
.
20. ,
1911. , ,
, ,
. ,
, ()

.
, (,
, )
,
. To 1. 1949.
, ,
61

By, , 1952, : , . 91
, . 89.
63
, . 67-70.
62

28

 . , ,
, .

- ,
.
(
1948. )
. ,
, - ,

.
, ,
.
, ,
.
.64 (,
).65 , ,
.
.
, , ,
,
,
. -
, ,
. ,

.
: ,
. ,
.
: , ,
. , , ,
: , , , .


.
.

,

, . .


.66

64
65

66

.
He !
, , . cit., . 48.
29

 , a .
,
XX , ,
,
, .67
, HP
- . , ,
( )
( ) (,
, ), ,
.
( 1999. 1,246,871.951)
( ) 55
91,9%. , .
, , , , , .,
, , ,
,
. je
,
.68 ,
, ,
, .
. ,
,

. , ,
10,1% 15 ,
43 1.000, 69 je
HP .69
2.2. -
, HP
, ,
,
, , .70 ,
, ,
-
. , (Jeffrey
Richelson) - : 1/
; 2/
; 3/
67

: , , , , , , . cit.
5 23 (23. ), 5 ( )
, je y
69
6 China, Internet 22/05/2002, www.cia.gov/world/factbook/china.
70
qingbao intelligence
information, ziliao - , .
68

30

 ; 4/
5/
.
, : l/ () 2/
: ()
; ()
; ()
; ()
; ()
78 () .71
,
- , , MI5, MI6 ,
BBC .
,
. ,
, ,
,
., ,
.
, : 1/ ; 2/
3/ -
.

1983. , a
,
,
.
1983.
,
,
. ( ,
)
,
.

.
1985.
( )
. ,

.

.
71

Ibid, 277.
31

 19%. ,
,
, .72
120 , , , , ,
.
, ,
.

.

(, , .).

.
,
, . Amnesti International

. ,
, ,
.73
.

.
, ,
, .
- ,
. To

- .
-
.
Tpe ,
HP
. .
,
: 1/

,
; 2/

3/
. 74 ,
,
.
72

China, Internet 22/05/2002, www.fas.org/irp/world/china/mss/liistory.html

Peoples Republics of China, Internet 22/05/2002, www.amnesty.org/People; Republic: China/State secret - a
pretext for represion.html.
74
Third Bureay, Hong Kong, Macao and Tainjan Bureay; Ministry of State Security (MSS), Guoija Anguan
Bu (Guoanbu), Internet 23/05/2005, www.globalsecurity, org/inteil/world/ china/mss-ops.htm.
73

32


. ,
, ,
.
emu
.
,
, ,

.

.75
,
,
.

, .
- ,
.
.


.
( , .)
500
( , )
( , , , , .
). , ,
:

(Diaocha
Ziiiao)

, ,
,
(GUOJI GUANXI YANJIU).
,
, ;

([Shu Bao Jianxun)

,
,
,

(XIANDAI GUOJI GUANXI),
.76
-

75

f?2 Sixt Bureay, Counterintelligence Bureay.

76

Ministry of State Security (MSS), Guoija Anguan Bu (Guoanbu), Internet 23, 5 } www.global
security, org/inteli/\vorld/china/mss-ops.htm.
33


,
.
.
,
.
, ,
.

P3
.
, ,
.


, Lumiciang.

,
( ),
.
: 1/ ;
2/ ; 3/ ; 4/
, , .
170 . . ,
50 ,
.77

HP ,
.
1.500
70 , 15.000
2.700 . ,
.
,
. , 1979.
, 1989.
, ,
.
1991. , ,

, FBI.

.
(
77

Budget and Personel, Internet 23/05/2005, wmv.fas.org/irp/world/china/mss/budget.htm

34

 ).
,
, .78
1999.

,

, , .
1983. 1995. (
)
",
.79

, FBI je
HP . ,
,
. ,
, CIA (
) , .80

,
HP .
. , 4
HP ,
22. 1993. ,
HP
. 23

HP , ,
,

, ,
.

. To cy : / ,
; /

; /
; / ,
/
.81
78

Sources and Techniques of Obtaining National Defense Science and Technology

Intelligence, Prefeace, Internet 22/05/2002, www.fas.org/irp/world/china/
79
Loeb, Walter, Pincus, Walter, Official Confirms Security Breach.
- In: Washington Pt-u, Arr29,1999
80
Kamen, Al, Wrong Lee Accused. - In: Washington Post, April 26, 1999, p. A P.
81

Excerpts of State Security Law of Peoples Republic of China, Internet 22/05/2002,www.fas.org/irp/

world/china/docs.htm.O : , , , , ,
, .

35

 .
,
, .
(, ,
, .) ,
, ,
.

. , (
)
.

. . 1986.
(John F. Burns), New York Times,
.
,
.
15 .
10 -
.
.

.82
,
, .
:
, , , ,
.
, ,
.

.

, ,
, ,
. ,
(),
, .
,
- ,
. . ,

. ,
-
.
, ,

82

Second and Third department PLA General Staff Headquarters, Internet 22/05/2002, www.fas.org/
irp/world/china/facilities/pla.htm
36

 1980.
.
.
, .
,
- ,
,
.


. , ,
, .
opoi
. ,
,
.
,
, 1980. ,
,
.

, - ,
V , , .
-

,
, , .
,
,
,
. HP
: , ,
, , , ,
, .
, ,
, .
-
, .

, .
, . 21 .90
. , ,

.
,
.
,
,
37

 je
.
.

.
,
,
- .

, ,
.
.
793 ,
.

,
1964. .
.
,
. ,
, -
.


.
,
, .
. ;
; .


.

3. -
,
.
1868.
.
38

 (1803-1868).
. . (
), .
()
. (
), () .
, .
( )
,
.
.

3.1.
, .
, .
- oakafa,
XII . ,
.
(Tojotomi Hidejoshi)
. 83
,
, . 1558.
,
, .
,
1582. .
. ,
. ,
.
, ,
, -
. Kokuriukai HAH
, 1901. , Gemjosha.
.
, Genijoshi .
,
. ,
-
, 1901.
.

.
Motujiro Akashi .
. ,
83

, , , Tembuna
no , .
39

 ^

.
1904. .
(
.),
.


, . 84

.
,

,
. To ce, , :
,
,
. To .
. ,

,
.

.
, ,
1914. .
. 1915.
, - ,
.
,
.
,
- .
- , 1921.
, , .
- , .
1922.
. , 1925.
,
.

.
,
.
, 13,00 , 30
84

: , ., , , :
, 1938, . 492-500.
40

.
.
, ,
.
, ,
. , ,
300 , .
.

3.2. -

- ,
, ,
.
- -
,

,
. -
1976. , 2005.
National Defeise Program Guideline . ,
, 2003.
: 1/
; 2/
3/
.85
, - ,
,

.
-
. , : 1/
; 2/ ae (Nakbo - Naikaht
Chosashitsu Betsusbitsu); 3/ Breichrf; 4/
DIO (Jouhou Honbu); 5/ DIH; 6/
(Chobetsii); 7/
: () (Nibon Rikujyo Jieitai), ()
(Nibon Kaijyo Jieitai) ()
Nibon Koku Jieitaiy,
(NBA Keisatsucbf) a
(NPSC); 9/
MOFA Gaimusbo; 10/
{Koancho) 11/
- ( METI .).86
85

Przystup, James J., U.S. - apan Rilatiotu: Progres Toward Mature Partnership, Institute tor Strategic
Studies Washington D.C.: National Defense University Press., June 2005, p. ~
86
Japan Intelligence and Security Agencies, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.oiig/irp/world/ japan/
41


1986.
,
; ,

;
. ,
, , ,
,
. ,
,
(
).87
(Naicho)
Naicbo
, ,
. ,


.
: 1/
2/ .

, , World-Politico-Hconomk Research Council {WpERG),
Kyodo News Service, Radio Press njiji Press.88
; ,
. ,
,
, , .

.
.
,
HP , ,
, ,
.
( Bfeichf )
(Bfeicbf )

, Maritime Self-Defense Force - MSDF -Nibon Kaijyo Jieitai
Air Self-Defense Force - ASDF - Nibon Koku Jieitai,
Self-Defense Force - DSF. To
87

Security Council of Japan, Internet 18/08/2005, wwwias.oig/irp/world/japan/sc.htm

1967. (Massatomi Uchikanti), WPERC . ,
1987.
.
88

42

 DSF ,
.
1954.
.89

. ,
DSF , DSF
.
DSF
.90

,
DSF .
, . ,

, . ,
,

(Diet). : 1/ (Internal Bureau), y
, , ,
; 2/ Defense rac'dities
Administration Agency; 3/ DSF: (a) ,
(Joint Staff Council and Chairman), () , ()
4/
: () National Defense Academy, (6)
(National Defense Medical College), ()
(National Institute for Defense Studies), ()
(Technical Research & DevelopmentInstitute) ()
(CentralProcurementOffice)91.
, (Bureau of Defense
Policy), (Bureau of Finance) (Bureau of Equipmenty,
DSF.

, ,
DSF.
DSF, DSF.
.
1998. ,
, (Jouhou Honbu).

.


.

89

1954. Self-Defense torn- luiu Japan Defense Agency

Bfeicbf, Japan Self-Defense Force, Internet ISwww.fas./iro/world/japan/ da.htm
90
: Defense Agency ( lijekbf ), op. at.
91
Ibid, p. 7
43



Icbigaya, (Shinjukii).
, v 7.000 ,
24\3 .92

1996.
, (Defence Intelligence
Headquarters- DIH).93 ,DIH ,
(TECHINT),
:
, , .

, ,
. DIH
,
, ,
, ,
(GSDF, MSDF ASDF).

(DlA),
.
, ( ) DIH
-
, . To cy
:

;
2.

(Human Intelligence - HUM INT).

1.

40

33 .

. ,

;
3. {Im
a g e ry In tellig en ce I A U N T)
,

.
,

92

Defense Agency (//), op. r//.p. 6.

Defence Intelligence Headquarters
- DIH,
world/japan/dih.ht
93

Internet

44

18/08/2005,

www.as.ori ; :rr

 (GSDF);

pad
[Sig nal In telligence SIGINT) je y 350 (
,
,
, ,

.).

GSDF,
.
;
5. ()

DIH .
, 120

(finshed intelligence)
.94
4.

(Chosa Besshitsu Chobetsu) je
, 1958..
.

NSA, :
,
. (SDF), Chobetsu
. ,
, a y
.
, ,
.95
(Jchigaya), .
, Chobetsu je
Naicho,
.
(GSDF),
NationalPolice Agency. O
( ), Chobetsu
Cabinet's Office of Intelligence.96
Chobetsu
,
.
, , Chobetsu je
. Chobetsu
, -
. 97
94

Ibid.
,
,
; :
Chobetsu (Chosa
Besshitsu), Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/world/ japan/chobetsu.htm
96
Ibid, p. 1
97
je
\ ;. ;
Ibid, p. 2.
95

45

 ,
( ,
.) ,
Chobetsu. , Chobetsu
, CDAA
Circulary Disposed Antenna Array, ,
,98
,
, .
, Chobetsu je o Nakho,
1.000 .

- Nihon Rikujyo
Jieitai (Nibetsu), 101.
(101st Survey Battalion).100
Nibetsu,
.
,

.

.
99

101.
(TECHINT and imagery intelligence)
, ,
LandSat.
,

.

(ASDF)101
.

, imagery
intelligent. ,
.102
98

3e x, ,
.
To : Shirano hhigaki, Ryuku ,
Cbitose Wakkanai , Rebunto, Higashi Nemurou u Nemura $
99
Japan Ground Self Defence Force Intelligence, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/
world/japan/jgsdf-i. htm.
100
: Japan Ground Self Defence
Force, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/world/japanjgsdf.htm
101
O , cnara : Japan
Air Self Defence Force, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/world/japan/jasdf.htm.
102
Intelligence Division, Internet 18/08/2005, www.gas.org/irp/world/japan/trg.htm
46


, 501.
501 Hikotai jSquadron Teisatsu Kokutai Hyakuri).
(reconnaissance operation)
Fantom RF-4. USAFs F-4C
- .103
, ,
., U-125 Peace Krypton
Hawker 800.104


,
(Yokosuka).105
, .

.

,
.
,
- ,
MOS-1 {Martime Qpservation Satellite) 18. 199106. .
, ,
, ( .).
,

.

, (
- Orion, Kawasaki -2 - ), ,
ASW MAD ,
, , (APS-80J, APS-80N .) .

,
.
, White Beach, y ,
.
(Gaimusho)
Gaimusho
,

,
103

Ibid
: RF-4, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/program/collect/.htm
105
U-125 Peace Krypton, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/program/collect/u-125.htrr
106
; Japan Maritime Self Defence Force (Nihon Kaijyo Jietai), ln:crr.c:18/08/2005, www.
fas.org/irp/world/japan/jmsdf.htm
104

47

 . , Gaimusho
, ,
,
, .
, Gaimusho , ,
pad u {Intelligence and
Analysis Bureau).107 ,
-
Gaimusho, ,
,
,
/ Gaimusho y
. : 1 /
{General Management Division); 2/
(First Analysis Division) 3/ {Second Analysis
Division).108

{Koancho)
(Homusho)m
.

.109 Koancho 1952.

1.800 . ,
.
, Koancho je ,
-
, , , .
,
, a y
- Sbinrikyo.
Koancho je , ,
. : 1/ 2/
.
, 43 ( ).

,
.110
Koancho ()
107

, .
, Gaimusho : ,
, , , .; : Ministry
of Foreig Affairs {Gaimusbo), Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/world/japan/mpfa. htm.
108
Intelligence and Analysis Buteau, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/uorld japan/iab.htm
109
O : Ministry of Justice (Homusho), Internet
18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/world/japan/homusho.htm
110
: Public Security Investigation Agency (Koancho), Internet 18/0S/2iA5.www.fas.org/irp/world/
japan/koancho.htm.
48

( , .),

. ,

, Koancho . ,
Koancho ce

. ,

, ( ) .

,
. ,
, ,
.111

,
.112
Koancho ,
.
- 1996. ,
ce Koancho ,
,
.
1.800
1.100.
,
, CIA, FBI, MI6, Mossad .
, ,
.113

(Keisatsttchcfi)
.
,
,
.114 Keisatsuch
(National Public Safety
111

1983. ,

.

. , 1987.
, 1986. ,


.
112
, 1987.

113
: Public Security Investigation Agency (Koancho),
op. at. National Police Agency
(Keisatsuchcb), Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/worid
114
National Police Agency (Keisatsuchcb), Internet
18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/worid japan/npa.htm
49

Commission - NPSC).115

. , ,
, , ,
, ;
: (Administration Bureau),
(Criminal Investigation Bureau),
(Communications Bureau), (Security Bureau)
(Traffic Bureau). ,
.
, .
{Safety
, ,
.
,
.
Keisatsuchc.
ie
,

,
, ,
,
a y
.116
, KeisatsuchcJ)
: (Shikoku), (Kyushu), (Hokkaido),
(Tohoku), (Kanto), (hubu), (Kinki), (Chugoku)
(Tokyo Metro-polian Police).
Keisatsuch(|).
47
,
. , KeisatsuchA
(The National Police Academy),
(National Research Institute of Police
Science), (Imperial Guard Headquarters).117

Keisatsuch ,
.
,
,

115

{National Police Safety Commission - NPSO }


, ,
,
. ;
National Police safety Commission
(NPSC), Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/worid japan/npsc.htm
116
National Police Agencyrs Security Bureau, Internet 18/08/2005, www.fas.org/irp/world/
japan/sb.htm
117
Ibid, p. 2.
50

 .
Keisatsuch^ .
(METI)
(METI) 1949.
(MITI),
. 129
,

. ,

, ,
, , ,
, , . , je
,
.118
METI ,
, ,
, ,
,

JETRO.
METI ca -
.
(Japanese External Trade Research Organisation -JEiRO 119). , JETRO
METI, je 1958.
, . ,
JETRO je ,
( )
.
,
. ,
, ,
, . (
) , , , ,
, .,
.
, JETRO 84
51

33

. 48 28
. 600 600 (300 300 JETRO
).
-

118

2001. MITI METI,

: Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI),
Internet 18/06. 2* 5.www.fas.org/irp/
world/japan/miti.htm
119

51

 , JETRO
(lsusbo Koho) ] ( Daily)

4. -

4.1.
-
. 1200. ...
,
,
.
, .120

,
. 121
,
, . ,
1909.
(HASHOMER),
. HASHOMER 1925. .
HAGANA, 1920. ,
( ).
Hagana Hagana
Irgun Zmi Leumi,
. ,
,
.134
Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI)
Hagana 1929.
(Sherut YediotB) 1934. SHAI.
1948. :

;
;
;
; - ;



, . SHAI, Hagana
120

, : , 2001, . 24-25.
: , , , , ,
( ), .343-345.
121

52

 REKNESH, ,
.122
Shai
(, .),
. Shai
1937. - ( Mossad
le Aliyah Be/ Allya 5),
.
,
,
. , Mossad y (,
, , , )
, , ,
.
, 30. 1948. , .
, , 1. . 1951.
Mossad (
xepejc ), .123

.
- Aman [Agaf
-din) -
.


liekem. , , Lekem je
, ,
,
. Lekem je

, a v
, , ,
. ( 1969.
) je y , a
,
- .
, Mossad, A'man
( )124
- . , , , - , (Reuven
Shiioab), ,
.
122

, , op. at., . 27-28. , . 29. 300

Kahana, Ephraim, Reorganizing Isracl?s Intelligence Community - In: InternationalIntelligence and
Counterinteliigence, Vol. 15, No. 3 (2002), p. 417-418.
124
: Richelson, Jeffrey T, op. cit
123

53

4.2. -
Knesset, , ,

- . ,

.
, 29 :
,
.125

, .
,
-
( ).
/ : ) , ) , )
) .
,
- , .
Mossada ( ),
Shin Bet A'man, ,
,
. 126
Mossada, , .
, , a o
, . , Mossada,
A man,
, ,
.
-
()
, Knesseta.

. ,
, .
ad hoc
.127
-
: 1/
(Mossad); 2/ (Shin Bet
Shabak); 3/ (Aman); 4/
5/
.
(Ha-Mossad Le-Modiin ou-le Tafkidim Meyuh'adim - Mossad)
(Mossad)
125

: , , . r/L, . 66. 139 Richelson, Jeffrey T, op. cit.p. 229.

Richelson, Jeffrey T, op. cit.p. 229.
127
: , , . cit., . 71-73.
126

54

 1. 1951.
()
. (
), 1.500 2.000
.128

(
,
, , a
, .).
, , Mossad
,
, , .
Mossada ,
v , (, ,
, .) .129
Mossad ,
,
(
) (, , .)
- , , .
1951. Mossad

, .
Mossada ,

, : ,
, ,
, ,
, Mossad .130
- Mossada ,
: 1/ , ,
2/ (
1967. ) ; 3/
1968. ; 4/
- ; 5/
1960. , 6/

( -
, - ,
, -
).
Mossad,
. 131
128
129

Sandy Times, 09 August 1987; Grizold, Anton, Tatalovi, Sinia, op. cit., str. 237
267. , .

130

, , :
/ , , 2 (1971), . 80
131
Mossad
55

 1996. ,
Mossada no .132
Mossada ,
.
, , ,
.133 Mossada
, : ) ; ) ) .134
Mossad y .135 :

TSOMET
(Melucha),

Mossada y .
() , ()
Mossada . 136 Mossad .

( , , , , , , (,
, ), , , , , ,
). ,
,
, ;137
KAISARUT
(Tevel)

, ( ) Mossada y
. Mossad (
Shin Bet Amari)
(CIA, FBI, DIA .) SIGINT HUMINT
.

Mossada cy ,
.138
.
,
( )
11. 2001. ,
Mossada cy 17.

(
1972.
) , . : Richelson , Jefrrey T., op. a/., pp 203209.
132
Shahak, Israel, The Israeli Terrorist State and its Mossad Assassins, Intrenet 25/04/2002, u-ww.rense.
com/generall3/mosso.htm
133
, , majm , : , 2001, crp. 55.
134
Kahana, Ephraim, op. cit., p. 417,
135
Mossad - : , , op. at., crp. 78.
136
,. 55.
137
Mossad - The Institute for Intelligence and Special Tasks, Internet 25/04/2002, wwwfas.ort
urpworld/israel/m<>ssad/index.htnil; : Deacon, Richard, The Israeli Secret Service^ New York, 197.
138

Richelson, Jeffrey T., U.S. Inttlhgenu Community (fourth edition), op. at., pp 208-209.
56

CIA FBI
. 139 ,

, .
-
;140
TSAFRIRIM : ,
, - ;
; ;
; , .;
hohama Psichoiogit - LAP

141;
NEVIOT
(Keshet)

(TECHINT)

.

,
( .). - . (
: , )
, , .;
YAHALOLIM () ,

;
Mossada

-
.
Yard ,


142
.
Mossada , ,
-

139

Davis, Douglas, Mossad warned CIA of attacs. - In: TlxJerusalem Post Newspaper, Tuesday, September
18, 2001; , Mossad,
11. . Mossad ca

, , LMxrrf.
aepe
(Jonathan Pollard case); Stern, David, Israeli Mossad Linkg To World Trade Center .Attack,
Interne:25/04/2002, wwwkhilafah. com/1421/ category.php? DocumentlD=29-17-l.
140
(op. cit., p. 196-197)
.
141
MOSSAD - Institut du renseignement et des operations speciales, Internet 25/04/2002,
www.chez . com/boigion/secret/israel/mossad/mossad.htm; : Grizold, Anton,Tatalovi, Sinia,
op. cit., str. 237
142
Richelson, Jeffrey T., op. cit., p. 196-197; Inside Israels Secret Organizations. - In: Janes
Intelligence Review, No. 10 (1996), pp 464/465; Grizold, Anton, Tataiovi, Sinia, op. at., str, 237;
, , op. cit., . 56-57.
57

 , . Mossada

AL. ,
:
2/ (Metsada). 143 Metsada je
, :
. ,
() Mossada y .
KIDON,
( ) .144
Mossada -
, ,
. ,
- : 1/ ,

IGINT ; 2/ ,

( .)
3/
,
.145
, Mossad ,

, . , Mossada
y ,
,
,
, .
.

(Sherut ha-bitachon ha-Klali - Shin Bet)
(Shin Bet) je
, 30. 1948. ,
. Shabak,

(Sherut habitachon ha-Klah).
: 1/
; 2/
143

Mossada je
2001. v
; Mossad Agents Arrested In Attempt To Bomb
Mexican Congres, Internet 25/04/-2002, www.rense.com/gencrall7/mossad agentsarrested.htm; Cienfuegos, Ernesto, Zionist Terrorists Arrested Inside Mexican Congres, Internet
25/04/2002, www.aztlan.net/mex mossad.htm ;
144
1973. , .
1988.. MATICAL METSAD.4.
: Kahana, Ephraim, op. cit., p. 418.
145
Kahana, Ephraim, op. cit., pp. 417-418.
58

 ( )
; 3/
,
- ; 4/

5/
.
Shin Bet
, - , :
1/ ; 2/ ; 3/ ; 4/
; 5/ ; 6/ ; 7/
- 8/ . ,
, .146
,
, , .
Hetia ,

. , :
; ; ;
.
,
.
p (
), ,

,
.
, -
( ),
, ,
, - - .147
Shin Bet, 1977. , ,
, , , .148
,
,
, . Shin Bet ,
.
, ,
.
,

( Shai, je y
),
146

SHIN BET - Service de la Securite Generale,

Internet, 26/04/2002, www.chez.com/
boigien/secret/israel/ shinbet/shinbet.htm;
Richelson, Jeffrey T., op. cit., pp 222-223.
147
Ibid, 222-224; : , , op. at., . 61; Grizold, Anton , Tatalovi.
Sima, op. cit., str. 237;
Shin Bet, Internet 25/04/ 2002, www.fas.org/irp/world/israe
shinbet/index.html
148
Deacon, Richard, The Israeli Secret Service, New York, 1977
59

 .
Shin Bet ce
, , .
Shin Bet je
,
, , , ,
, Aman (
, ). ,
,
, , ,
.149 Shin Bet je -
, ,


.
, . ()
, (
).

( ).
. , 1999. 2000.

Magna Carta 1 Magna Carta 2. 2000.
Mossad, Shin Bet A'man,


. Shin Bet
, .150

(Agaf ha-Modiin - A'man)
(Aman)
Hagana .151
, A'man ce
- .
, : () (strategic-political intelligence)
- ; () (warning and preventive intelligence) -
() - .152
- ,

, ,
,
149

Richelson, Jeffrey T., op. cit., pp 225-227

Kahana, Ephraim, op. cit., pp. 421-422.
151
, , op. cit., crp. 52
152
: Kahana, E.phraim, op. cit., pp. 420-421.
150

60

, (TECHINT/COMINT - Communication Interception). , ,

, ,
. , 7.000
, ,
, . ,
.
: 1/ {Production); 2/ (Intelligence
Corps); 3/ Foreign Relations) 4)
(Field Security and Military Censorship).153
- .
,
, .154
,
. , 1963. 1968.
, , ,
, .

(
,
-

- ).
,
;

.
pa ,
SIGINT COMINT - ,

.
, ,
( , , ,
, , ).
SIGINT,
.
.155

,
.
,
, .156
153

: Richelson, Jeffrey T., op.

cit, p.
210;

(Sayeret
Maktat),

154
Ibid.
155
Ha Aman 131,
.
Mossad; , , op. tit., . 52.
156

Aman: Military Intelligence - Agaf ha-Modi'in,

Internet 25/04/2002, www.fas.org/irp/
world/israel/aman/ index.htmJ; Richelson, Jeffrey T., op. a/.y pp 213-214
61

 , A'man
: ,
,
, (- ).

:
;
,
, , ;
;

; ;
.
A'man je
, 1973. , je
.
, -
,
. ,
(TECHINT),


(RADINT, SIGINT, ELINT, PHOTINT,
IMINT),
.171
Aman, Mossad-o,
UKUSA
.157
(MAMAD)
(Mamad)
.
Mossada
- , INR. Mamad


.158
,
,
. ,
,
.
, Mamad , 1999. ,

157

: , , o&muat/mne .,., op. at. . 66; Richelson, Jeffrey T., op. at.,
pp 235-236.
158
(op. cit., . 53) )- ^

62

 .
100 ,
.
. ,
( ,
.).
1982. .159

Vaadat
-
. ,
, o ,
- . Shin Bet
, , .

,
{Latam) . Latam
,

Vaadat.
, .
,
.
.160
,

. ,
.
().161

-



,
.
,
159

: Ibid, pp 220-221
: , ( ), ..., op. cit., A1-17/18. 6 Kahana,
Ephraim, op. cit., pp. 419-420.
161
Kahana, Ephraim, op. cit., pp. 419-420.
160

63


.


5. Biycra 1914.
(Teskj/at I Mahsusa).

30. 1918. ,
, a
Karakol .
,

. 16. 1920. ,
.
,
. ( Grubu),
23. 1920. , 21. 1921.
(Felab Grubtt),
. , 18. 1920.
(Askcn Polis Teskilah),

,
po .
,
,
19. 1921. .

, (Tedkik Heyeti Amirlikleri),
1. 1921. 22. 1922. .
,

(Mudafaa-I Milliye), 3. 1921.
MIM.
, MIM MIM
.
,
,

. MIM MIM je
,
5. 1923. , .
, 1926.
,

.162 . 10152 6.
162

; National Intelligence Organization: History of the MIT,

Internet 22/04/2002,
www.fas.org/ irp/world/turkey /mit/history.htm
64

 1927.
- Milli Emniyeti Hi^meti - AiAH), ca
, , ,
. ,
1965. ,
. 644
().
-
-
[Millo Ghvenlik Kurulti
- MGK),
,
- ,
,

, n
. ,
, , ,
. ,

, -
. ,
. 2937 1. 1983.
(Millo stihbarat
Koordinasyon Kuruht ),
,

. , :

,
, ,

(), M3T.163
- : 1/
(); 2/
; 3 ; 4/ 5/ -
164.

(Miilo stihbarat TeiokilBta - )

163

DEVLET 3ST3HBARAT H3ZMETLER3 VE M3LLO 3ST3HBARAT

LBTI KANUNU, Kanun No. 2973, Kabul Karihi 1/11/1983; je cryinu) iia cii.nv 1
1984. .
164
Ibid, B3R3NC3 KISIM, B3R3NC3 BULbM
(11 , I, ^ l: ^ .:
MiiHiiciapcKor ; 5/5).
65

 ( MIT) je
, ,


.
. 644 6. 1965. ,
. . 2937 1983.
, .
, ,
:
,

. ,

.
: 1/
, , , ,
,
, , ,
MGK ; 2/
, ,
MGK
; 3/
MGK
; 4/

TPIX ; 5/
; 6/
MGK . 165
,

,

. ,
,
,
MGK.
Ha () ,
.166
MGK , a
. ()
no .
: 1/ ;
2/ ; 3/
(TECHINT/SIGINT) 4/ .
165

Ibid, MADDE 6 (a,b,c,d,e,f,g).

; : Ibid, MADDE 21.
166

66

 : () ; () ()
. ,

:
167 . ,

Eeja, ,

. ,
: 1/ ; 2/ ; 3/
4/ .
(, ).168
-
,
, .


.
, .
, ,
. ,

. 180.000 50.000 ,
,
.
,
, .
,
,
, .
( ,
, ),
, .
, ,
: (
, , ,
, .); ( ,
) ( ,
).

.
167

Kpa : Fain, Tvru Ci .

op. ci pp 118, 671; Andrew, Christopher, op. cit., p. 395.
168

National
Intelligence
organization:
Organizational
chart,
Internet,
22/n4
\vA\4v.fas.org/irp/\vorId/turkey/intorg.htm; www.mit.gov.tr ( Web MI-)T

67

Z+

2.

68