You are on page 1of 5

MilNova: An Approach to the IoT Solution based

on Model-Driven Engineering for the Military


Health Monitoring
Rolando P. Reyes Ch. Manolo Paredes Calderón Luis Montoya
Universidad de las Fuerzas Universidad de las Fuerzas Universidad de las Fuerzas
Armadas ESPE Armadas ESPE Armadas ESPE
Sangolquı́, Ecuador Sangolquı́, Ecuador Sangolquı́, Ecuador
rpreyes1@espe.edu.ec mparedes@espe.edu.ec lhmontoya@espe.edu.ec

Hugo Pérez Vaca Wilbert G. Aguilar


Universidad de las Fuerzas Universidad de las Fuerzas
Armadas ESPE Armadas ESPE
Sangolquı́, Ecuador Sangolquı́, Ecuador
hlperez@espe.edu.ec wgaguilar@espe.edu.ec

Abstract—In 2015, Zheng & Carter warned that the Internet of only considers the virtual approach. A typical example is a
Things (IoT) would have an exponential deployment in all types of shopping site developed with NGN where it is possible to
industry in order to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of its only make purchases in the Internet, while with technologies
operations. In the military sphere, it has not been different. The
Ecuadorian Armed Forces are trying to equip their soldiers with IoT it is possible for thousands of people to make physical
IoT Technology to monitor and visualize in real time the state purchases in an instant, to pay them virtually (e.g., sensors)
of health during combat missions. However, the implementation while analyzing the pattern of purchases. In this sense, it is
and research, at least in Ecuador; has been very complex due to assumed that IoT has had an exponential growth in recent
two problems: (1) organization in the design and the integration years; creating an innumerable and endless list of applications
of the components and applications when participate several
researchers and engineers of multiple disciplines (e.g, control, for commercial and industrial operations (eg, production, lo-
software) and (2) the complex implementation due to the tech- gistics, transport, surveillance, energy, among others) [3]. This
nological fragmentation between the military contexts (e.g., air accelerated growth can be attributed to the decrease in size and
force, army and navy). We propose an approach to the solution cost of sensors, improved power and electronic processing,
to the implementation of real-time military health monitoring in Internet penetration and IPv6 in wireless connectivity (4G
combat missions, using the Model-Driven Engineering (MDE)
paradigm and the research model proposed by Takeuchi & LTE, 5G, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth), and development of software
Nonaka. We were able to obtain a meta-model delineated in in conjunction with analysis of data in the cloud [2].
the 4 domains of the IoT Technology embedded within the 4
contexts of a product line process. The meta-model has solved
the problem associated with implementation as a product line However, IoT technology has not only been boosted in the
while had increasing the comprehensibility between researchers
and engineers. industrial arena, but has also achieved a prominent deployment
Keywords—Models, Model-Driven Engineering, Product Line, in human-oriented services [2]. There are several examples
Internet of Things, Ubiquitous Technology, Military Health in this regard [3]–[5]; for this reason, the Armed Forces in
different countries, are interested in equipping their troops with
I. I NTRODUCTION IoT technologies to monitor and visualize the state of health
Internet of Things (IoT) is considered as a promising in the different combat missions. In Ecuador it has not been
paradigm that joins an ecosystem of sensors, systems and different; its Armed Forces have taken the initiative in this
database to monitor any environment or object in a specific area. Although, its implementation and research, at least in
space of time [1]. Zheng & Carter in 2015 [2], described to Ecuador, has been very complex due to two problems: (1)
the tecnology IoT as a new capability that offers an ecosystem organization in the design and the integration of the com-
of technologies to: (1) extract real data (of daily life), (2) ponents and applications when participate several researchers
analyze them in a virtual environment and (3) give them added and engineers of multiple disciplines (e.g, control, software)
value through analysis and algorithms that allow decision and (2) the complex implementation due to the technological
making and rapid responses. This procedure differs with other fragmentation between the military contexts (e.g., air force,
technologies such as Next Generation Networks (NGN) that army and navy).

978-1-5386-3123-2/17/$31.00 2017
c IEEE

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana. Downloaded on March 27,2022 at 03:29:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
In this study we propose to MilNova1 , an approach to the • Morin et al. [6] proposes an IoT health system called
solution and research proposal for the implementation of the Tellu’s E-Health built with a proposal of ThingsML for
monitoring of ”military health” in combat missions through solving IoT complexity problems in different domains.
Internet of Things (IoT). We use the joint experience between The proposal is oriented to the use of ThingsML.
the Model-Based Engineering (MBE) paradigm [6] and the
research model proposed by Takeuchi & Nonaka [7]. III. M IL N OVA : A PPROACH TO THE I OT S OLUTION BASED
Preliminary results are prominent. So far the model of ON M ODEL -D RIVEN E NGINEERING
superior level of abstraction or meta-model has been for- A. Problem and Motivation
mulated that maps to all the domains and abstract contexts The background shows that IoT applications have grown
that makes up the construction and implementation of this within the scope of health services [1], [3], [4]. Due to this
type of IoT solutions. The meta-model contain 4 domains phenomen several Armed Forces are looking for or trying
of building IoT solutions embedded in the 4 contexts of a to monitor and visualize the health status of their troops
product line process. The 4 domains of construction refer to: during several combat missions. In Ecuador it has not been
generation, collection, processing and visualization of data; different. The Ecuadorian Armed Forces have undertaken the
and these in turn are embedded within 4 contexts of product research initiative on IOT technologies for use in military
development: conceptual, technological, implementation and health, both in combat missions and for the physical training
research. The meta-model has solved the problem associated of their troops. However, obtaining a solution according to
with implementation as a product line while increasing the military needs (Army, Navy and Air Force) is complicated
comprehensibility between researchers and engineers. when has two problems: (1) organization in the design and
This article is structured in: Section II details the backgroud. integration of the components and applications with several
The research proposal and approach to the solution is detailed researchers and engineers of multiple disciplines (e.g, control,
in Section III. Section IV describes the conclusions and lessons software, others) and (2) the complex implementation due to
learned and Future Works are explained in Section V. the technological and cultural fragmentation of the military
context. This is compounded by the low budgets for technol-
II. BACKGROUND
ogy research and integration with systems such as C3I22 or
As mentioned earlier, the list of IoT applications is endless C4ISR3 for decision-making during combat missions. Neither
in commercial and industrial operations [3]. In the field of can we exclude accelerated and volatile changes in the policies
health has been no exception. Thanks to the IoT technology and processes of management in military health.
you get the versatility to connect to anyone, anytime, anywhere
[1], with the purpose of get faster diagnostics and predictions. B. Research proposal and approach to the IoT solution
We could say that IoT technology could be redesigning the The above-mentioned problems are summarized in the
modern health care management, at least in civil society complexity in the implementation, development, and research
[4]. In this sense, we can say that military health is even of IoT technology. Therefore, we propose to MilNova, an
more critical and complex, especially when there are soldiers approach to the solution and research proposal for the imple-
involved in high-risk combat operations, where medical care mentation of the ubiquitous monitoring of military health in
is very limited and there is an imperative need to care for real time through the joint experience between Model-Based
each soldier in the mission. We have tried to find literature Engineering (MBE) paradigm [6] and the model of research,
on this subject, especially literature that proposes models for innovation and production lines proposed by Takeuchi &
the implementation, development and research of this type of Nonaka [7].
solutions in the field of military health [2]. We have not been MBE is a software development methodology that allows
able to find more than something related to health care in the us to create and exploit domain models or conceptual models
civil field. Here are some of these jobs we have found: that try to solve a specific problem. The interesting thing about
• Zhao et al. [3] explains the platform called RMMP-II to MBE is the reuse of its models to simplify the design process
help control the physiological and cardiological diseases (e.g., patterns of recurring design patterns). Although this type
of people in rural areas in China. Only the components of methodology has a software orientation, we take its design
of the platform are explained. process in order to maximize the compatibility between the
• Islam et al. [4] points out several practical challenges components or systems that make up a solution based on IoT
that must be addressed in order to apply IoT technology technology while also helping to promote the Communication
in the field of health. A standard platform proposal between individuals and engineers from different disciplines
(topology, network and architecture) is explained without towards a goal within a common domain [8].
any emphasis on implementation aspects. On the other hand, we have the research model and product
• Rohokale et al. [5] mentions the use of IoT technology in line proposed by Takeuchi & Nonaka Model. This model (from
the monitoring of maternity programs in rural areas. The 2 Military systems of Command, Control, Communications, Intelligence and
study is only aimed at communication between sensors. Informatics
3 Military systems of Command, Control, Communications, Computers,
1 Mil that comes from the Latin Militarius and Nova means New in English Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana. Downloaded on March 27,2022 at 03:29:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Fig. 1. Research proposal and approach to the solution: MilNova

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana. Downloaded on March 27,2022 at 03:29:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
which the agile methodologies was born) has taught to develop to Segura A. (2016) [11] considers that in IoT solutions are of
products through the use of Concurrent Engineering from paramount importance to consider the perspectives of the user,
a scalable perspective and with stable and highly cohesive technical personnel and researcher. Therefore, the importance
equipment. Although the model is oriented to a proposal of of applying the aforementioned phases transversally to the
the 90’s, this model has allowed in the past to propose models domains. In this way the conceptual phase helps conceptually
or methods capable of controlling processes in an empirical define the system in such a way that any member can un-
way, under an iterative context, to substantially improve the derstand it; the technological phase explains the technology
development of complex products accepting changes during to apply with concepts; the implementation phase explains
the Process without these changes would have an impact on the methodologies to be applied for each technology and
the project [7]. finally the research phase explains an empirical method for
The solutions with IoT are complex systems of systems evaluation.
(SoS) that use electronic control (e.g., sensors), communi-
IV. C ONCLUSIONS AND LESSONS LEARNED
cations and interconnectivity, information systems, storage,
data analysis, others. This has meant that the implementation The integration and orchestration of several domains and
requires models capable of directing several engineers and re- phases in MilNova, have allowed an adequate deployment
searchers from different disciplines towards a solution. Textit of research, development, and implementation with some au-
MilNova, is a research project of the University of the Armed tonomy in the multidisciplinary working groups (Electronics,
Forces ESPE that seeks an approach to the solution applying Systems, Telecommunications.), but everyone with the same
the MBE paradigm and the model of Takeuchi Nonaka. We goal in common. The deployment of our meta-model in its
know that modeling, deploying and developing solutions with inception has not been easy, due to the problems related to
IoT is still a challenge and our contribution could be part of the Ecuadorian military culture and the warnings mentioned
the discussion, validation, and verification of proposals for IoT by Zheng Carter [2]. However, after coordination between the
solutions that are currently underway. members have been able to create 2 undergraduate theses
To explain our proposal, we have created a meta-model related to control systems and information systems and 2
shown in Figure 1. The abstraction of the meta-model pro- postgraduate theses concerning the encryption of connectivity
motes simple models that allow solving in smaller parts our and prediction algorithms. The creation of increasing the
problem. We consider IOT systems as columns of our meta- number of postgraduate theses is not ruled out. We believe
model, because of their importance in the processing and that the meta-model could be begining of IoT-based technolo-
conversion of data into information (eg, generation, collection, gies within the Ecuadorian Armed Forces, transforming the
processing, and visualization). To the conversion phases we doctrine of military health into their theaters of operations
have called domains, so we have created the domain of data V. F UTURE W ORKS
generation where we apply the electronics, data collection
domain where it encompasses the connectivity, information Currently we are initiating the implementation of MilNova,
processing domain where it contains the information systems our tesists work in conjunction with engineers and researchers.
and finally the knowledge visualization domain with the anal- All have understood the conceptual, technological and imple-
ysis and algorithms (e.g., BI, data mining, machine learning). mentation aspect of each domain and are working as a product
In other words, the generation and collection domains will line. Our future work is oriented to research and definitive
be responsible for the generation and capture of biomedical results of the application of our meta-model with artifacts
signals until they are transformed into meaningful data, which based on ThingML proposed by Morin et al. [6].
will be sent by a secure communication medium (encryption) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
to an information system [9]; processing and visualization
Our acknowledgment to SENESCYT, Universidad de las
domains are responsible for receiving and processing data into
Fuerzas Armadas ESPE, Armada del Ecuador y Ejército
useful information through dynamic information systems to
Ecuatoriano
generate new knowledge [1].
The domains presented allow concurrent engineering with R EFERENCES
the overlapping of several of their activities. It is for this [1] A.-M. Rahmani, N. K. Thanigaivelan, and T. N. Gia, “Smart e-health
reason that it is possible to organize engineers, experimenters gateway: Bringing intelligence to internet-of-things based ubiquitous
and researchers, so that engineers can create the right designs healthcare systems,” in CCNC, 2015, 2015, pp. 826–834.
[2] D. Zheng and W. A. Carter, Leveraging the internet of things for a more
for each domain, students carry the development during the efficient and effective military. Rowman & Littlefield, 2015.
implementation process, and then pass the researchers to the [3] W. Zhao, C. Wang, and Y. Nakahira, “Medical application on internet of
empirical evaluation [10]. There appears the need for the do- things,” in Communication Technology and Application (ICCTA 2011),
IET International Conference on. IET, 2011, pp. 660–665.
mains to resemble the phases to a manofacturation line. Phases [4] S. R. Islam, D. Kwak, M. H. Kabir, and M. Hossain, “The internet of
are created in the domains as rows of the meta-model: concep- things for health care: a comprehensive survey,” IEEE Access, vol. 3,
tual, technological, implementation and research. The idea is pp. 678–708, 2015.
[5] V. M. Rohokale, N. R. Prasad, and R. Prasad, “A cooperative internet
to obtain synergy and coordination between multidisciplinary of things (iot) for rural healthcare monitoring and control,” in Wireless
groups from beginning to end in implementation. According VITAE, 2011 2nd International Conference. IEEE, 2011, pp. 1–6.

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana. Downloaded on March 27,2022 at 03:29:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
[6] B. Morin, N. Harrand, and F. Fleurey, “Model-based software engineer- Applications and technologies,” Procedia Computer Science, vol. 83,
ing to tame the iot jungle,” IEEE Software, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 30–36, pp. 1274–1281, 2016.
2017. [10] I. Nonaka and H. Takeuchi, “Organizational knowledge creation,” Cre-
[7] H. Takeuchi and I. Nonaka, “The new new product development game,” ative Management, SAGE, London,, pp. 64–82, 2001.
Japanese Business, vol. 64, no. 1, p. 321, 1998. [11] A. A. Segura, “Arquitectura de software de referencia para objetos
[8] D. C. Schmidt, “Model-driven engineering,” IEEE Computer Society, inteligentes en internet de las cosas,” Revista Latinoamericana de
vol. 39, no. 2, p. 25, 2006. Ingenieria de Software, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 73–110, 2016.
[9] R. Negra, I. Jemili, and A. Belghith, “Wireless body area networks:

Authorized licensed use limited to: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana. Downloaded on March 27,2022 at 03:29:29 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like