Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org
OBSTETRICS
Candy twists as an alternative to the
glucola beverage in gestational diabetes
mellitus screening
Diana A. Racusin, MD; Kathleen Antony, MD; Lori Showalter, MSc; Susan Sharma, PhD;
Morey Haymond, MD; Kjersti M. Aagaard, MD, PhD
OBJECTIVE: Screening for gestational diabetes mellitus commonly with a 1-hour venous blood glucose assessment. All subjects subse-
uses an oral glucose challenge test with a 50-g glucola beverage and quently completed the confirmatory 3-hour glucose tolerance test.
subsequent venous puncture. However, up to 30% of pregnant women Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive values, negative predictive
report significant side-effects, and the beverage is costly. We hy- values, false-referral rates, and detection rates were calculated.
pothesized that equivalent glucose loads could be achieved from a
RESULTS: At 130 mg/dL, the sensitivity (100%) was the same
popular candy twist (Twizzlers; The Hershey Company, Hershey, PA)
for candy twists and glucola. However, the false-referral rate (82%
and tested it as cost-effective, tolerable alternative with a test of
vs 90%), positive predictive value (18% vs 10%), and detection rate
equivalency.
(18% vs 10%) were improved for candy twists when compared with
STUDY DESIGN: The glucose equivalent of the 50-g glucola was the 50-g glucola beverage.
calculated as 10 candy twists. We initially used a triple crossover
CONCLUSION: Our results indicate that strawberry-flavored candy
design in nonpregnant patients whereby each subject served as her
twists are potentially an equally effective screening test, compared
own control; this ensured the safety and equivalency of this load before
with the gold standard glucola beverage but lead to fewer false-
using it among pregnant subjects. We then recruited pregnant women
positive screens and therefore could be a cost-effective alternative.
with an abnormal screening at 1 hour (glucose challenge test) in a
double crossover design study. Subjects consumed 10 candy twists Key words: diabetes mellitus, gestational diabetes mellitus, screening
Cite this article as: Racusin DA, Antony K, Showalter L, et al. Candy twists as an alternative to the glucola beverage in gestational diabetes mellitus screening. Am J
Obstet Gynecol 2014;212:.
abdominal pain, diarrhea, sweating, and berry twists would demonstrate equi-
<25 3
headache. Given this side-effect profile, poise in screening for GDM when
pregnant women may be unwilling or compared with the glucola beverage in 25-29.9 3
unable to complete screening for GDM pregnant women but at a fraction of the 30 14
with the glucola beverage.8-10 There are cost.
Parity
limited reports (PubMed, 1990-present)
that provide viable alternatives to M ATERIALS AND M ETHODS Nulliparous 3
the glucola beverage.8-11 For example, Study cohort Parous 17
studies that have investigated jelly beans After institutional review board approval Race/ethnicity
demonstrated lower sensitivity than the (Institutional Review Board Project# H-
glucola (80% sensitivity when the ‘screen 26324, renewal approved on June 24, White 1
positive’ cutoff is a blood glucose value of 2013), recruitment for the study was Black 2
140 mg/dL, 90% sensitivity when the open to all pregnant women seen at the Asian 1
‘screen positive’ cutoff is a blood glucose high-risk obstetrics clinic at Ben Taub
Hispanic 16
value of 130 mg/dL). However, subjects General Hospital between July and
documented that jelly beans were better October of 2013 who underwent either Most of our cohort was Hispanic and multiparous. The
mean age of our population was 30.3, and the mean
tolerated by the study participants than universal or risk-based screening with body mass index was 33.83 kg/m2. The median interval
the glucola drink.8,9,11 the 50-g 1-hour GCT and screened pos- between the glucose challenge test and the candy twists
challenge was 2 weeks. The median gestational age at
The effects of hyperglycemia/GDM itive, thus requiring a confirmatory 3- glucola testing was 24.6 weeks and at candy twists
are well-known in obstetric populations. hour GTT. Written informed consent testing was 28.2 weeks.
Infants of mothers with diabetes mellitus was obtained, and subjects were reim- Racusin. Candy twists as an alternative to glucola.
Am J Obstet Gynecol 2014.
are at higher risk of macrosomia, fetal bursed for their participation. Mean
malformations, shoulder dystocia, hy- gestational age at the time of testing was
poglycemia, hypocalcemia, respiratory 24.6 weeks n for glucola and 28.2 weeks html). Ten strawberry-flavored candy
distress syndrome, and thus neonatal for candy twists. In our institution, a twists yielded 47.408 g of sugars, mostly
intensive care unit admissions. As adults, positive screen is defined as 140 mg/dL. comprised of sucrose. Other major sugars
children of mothers with diabetes mel- Demographics of our study cohort are in the composition were fructose, maltose,
litus are at higher risk of obesity and presented in Table 1. We did not exclude and glucose; 91.968% of the calories were
the development of type II diabetes women with a history of GDM. derived from carbohydrates; 4.527% of
mellitus.5,12-16 This is thought to be the calories were derived from fat,
secondary to “metabolic memory” from Choice and amount of candy and 3.515% of the calories were derived
an intrauterine diabetic milieu.15,17 The To calculate the oral intake necessary from protein.23 In the pilot study popu-
mothers, themselves, are at higher risk to achieve a 50-g load, nutritionists lation, there was no significant difference
for hypertension, preeclampsia, future who specialized in diabetes mellitus in the mean serum glucose after con-
type II diabetes mellitus, shoulder consulted product information re- sumption. Initially, a nonpregnant cohort
dystocia, and operative/cesarean de- garding calories, total and saturated fat, was assembled to investigate this hypoth-
livery. Furthermore, maternal obesity is carbohydrates, sugars (including sugar esis. We found that candy twists provide
associated independently with adverse alcohols), and protein in candy twists an equivalent screening alternative to
pregnancy outcomes and greater sever- in a per piece calculation. This yielded the glucola beverage in nonpregnant
ity of outcomes,15-19 and treatment of 50-g calculated consumption of 10 women.22 In this study, we set out to test
even mild GDM results in improved strawberry-flavored candy twists in 5 these findings in a pregnant population.
maternal and fetal morbidity.4,20,21 Ergo, minutes. Nutritional calculations were
it is imperative that the cost-effective confirmed with the University of Minne- Study protocol
and well-tolerated means of screening sota Nutrition Data System for Research Subject recruitment was limited to those
are used. (http://www.ncc.umn.edu/products/ndsr. who had already ‘screened positive’ for