Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The History
The Ages of The Trees
"No one knew whence they (Ents) came or first appeared. The High Elves said that the Valar did not
mention them in the 'Music'." (L248) Also, their own traditions sharply distinguish the Ents (and
Entwives) from the other Speaking Peoples by that they attributed their origin not to the design of the
gods but to another species.
"Elves began it, of course, waking trees up and teaching them to speak, and learning their tree-talk.
They always wished to talk to everything, the old Elves did." (TT) So Treebeard recalls the earliest
history of the Shepherds of the Trees. Later records say that "they were known to the Eldar in ancient
days, and to the Eldar indeed the Ents ascribed not their own language but the desire for speech. " (LP)
However, very probably we should rather read "Quendi" here than "Eldar", for the memory of the Ents
seems to begin only in the time when Morgoth, known to them as "the Great Darkness", was
imprisoned and then "came in the North" (TT), i. e. established himself in Angband. Of his earlier
dwelling in Utumno even their oldest member, Treebeard, does not reveal knowledge.
But during this period there were no Eldar in Middle-earth. If the Ents awoke in the Ages of the Trees
and during Morgoth’s imprisonment, the "Elves that cured us of dumbness long ago" (TT) would have
been Umanyar, those who stayed behind. Then the most likely candidates are probably the Nandor, the
Green-Elves. They were reported to have gained deeper knowledge of trees than any other of their
kind (S). Their activity may not even have been restricted to trees: perhaps those Elves "who always
wished to talk to everything" were also responsible for the "awakening" of various beasts which
became capable of rational speech.
The Ents, however, were distinct from these: together with Elves, Dwarves, and Men, they were
afterwards reckoned as species of rational creatures. An old poem which Treebeard had learned in his
youth – by whom he does not tell: the Nandor most likely - lists the Free Peoples, maybe in their
apparent order of appearance:
"Learn now the lore of Living Creatures!
First name the four, the Free Peoples:
Eldest of all, the elf-children;
Dwarf the delver, dark are his houses;
Ent the earthborn, old as mountains;
Man the mortal, master of horses." (TT)
This would further limit their awakening to the period before Man’s awakening in the East.
Their place of origin, however, was not in far Rhun but seems to have been West of Anduin. This was
the region where the Entwives first "made gardens to live in" (TT). We may perhaps expect the
awakening to have occurred in the precise region which later was called Fangorn Forest – which in
that time, however, "was all one wood ... to the Mountains of Lune." (TT)
The Origin
The Eldest and the Firstborn
The statements about origin and age of the Ents are mysterious. Of course, no one would doubt that
the Elves are indeed Iluvatar‘s "Firstborn", and they would have to be so to "cure" the Ents from
dumbness. But why then are the Ents notoriously called "the most ancient people surviving in the
Third Age" (LP) and "oldest of living creatures" (L131)?
This can only interpreted that way that there were Ents before there were talking Ents. The first
specimen probably were but mute and "dumb" or yet "unawakened" beings, looking and behaving just
like another kind of tree. But of course, they were not ordinary trees.
It cannot be doubted that Elves cannot just pass along and teach a tree at the wayside to talk and move,
not to mention turning a forest into another Free People! There must have been an inherent potential of
rational thought to the proto-Ents which only Iluvatar could have given to them and which was but
waiting for the outside impulse to get active.
Lothlórien recorded a unique hypothesis of their origin: "Some (Galadriel) were [of the] opinion that
when Yavanna discovered the mercy of Eru to Aulë in the matter of the Dwarves, she besought Eru
(through Manwë) asking him to give life to things made of living things not stone, and that the Ents
were either souls sent to inhabit trees, or else that slowly took the likeness of trees owing to their
inborn love of trees. ... The males were devoted to Oromë, but the Wives to Yavanna." (L248)
If this was true, it would set real Ents far apart from "talking beasts", animate but soulless. No doubt,
those spirits were sent before the Elves awoke but had to lie dormant till their proper time, so not to
turn down the intended order in which the Children of Iluvatar would appear. This had not been
allowed even to Aule’s Dwarves!
The Olog-hai
However, "there are other sorts of Trolls beside these rather ridiculous, if brutal, Stone-trolls, for
which other origins are suggested." (L153) This probably refers to the Olog-hai, a ferocious kind that
was first time met in the War of the Ring (LP). But kind of origin may that have been? Was Sauron
even that late still powerful enough to attract other Maiar to his service? Did he, being the
Necromancer, manage to imprison fëar into stone which Morgoth never achieved, thus turning it
finally resistant against the sunlight?
Or – there is left one terrifying possibility that perhaps has the highest probability of all, but, if true,
would pose one of the Dark Lord’s worst crimes in the history of Arda. Were the Olog-hai like the
orcs twisted out of other creatures?
The Olog-hai appeared 3000 years after the mysterious vanishing of the Entwives.
Could an Olog be what becomes of an Entwive after millenia of twisting?