You are on page 1of 80

 

 
-AdXj NH@A@FKNQ C@JNZXEZ@EQ

Nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk 
Aep`tec`sof y sear`l`a`fs bfccywffhnksns 
]nhrf Justeoektn
 

]nhrf Justeoektn ns `kvnst`dehfr `khnpnkh`nktn, erqu`tnatf y ert`ste. Qu fjre be fjtnk`hf h`vnrsfs prno`fs y be s`hf
pujc`aehe y nxpunste, nktrn ftrfs, nk nc Aïraucf hn Jncces Ertns nk Oehr`h, ce Lnr`e @ktnrkea`fkec hn Ertn Afktnopfråknf -
EZAF nk Oehr`h, ce Znec Eaehno`e hn Nspeõe nk Zfoe f cfs @kst`tutfs
@ kst`tutfs Anrvektns hn Kunve Pfrg y Ab`aedf. Nktrn sus fjres
erqu`tnatñk`aes hnsteae nc AZNEE - Anktrf hn Arnea`ñk hn ces Ertns hn Ecafrañk. Nk ce eatuec`heh rns`hn nk Jnrcïk hfkhn
hnserrfcce uke `kvnst`dea`ñk sfjrn nc treslfkhf rnc`d`fsf y sear`l`a`ec hnc aep`tec`sof,
ae p`tec`sof, hn ce qun nste fjre lfroe pertn.
Oås `klfroea`ñk nk 
nk hnc`r`fusbntnrftfp`es.jcfdspft.hn/
 

Nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk Aep`tec`sof y sear`l`a`fs bfccywffhnksns


bfccywffhnksns 
]nhrf Justeoektn
 

su 
a9 
E9 rn9 uk rn ce
hn 
 
]nhrf Justeoektn

Nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk 
Aep`tec`sof y sear`l`a`fs bfccywffhnksns 
8£aXj NH@A@FKNQ C@JNZXEZ@EQ
 

]rfb`j`he ce rnprfhuaa`ñk tftec f pera`ec nk auecqu`nr sfpfrtn, `kacu`hf @ktnrknt


Xfhfs cfs hnrnabfs rnsnrvehfs
H`snõf hn auj`nrte9 Ekhrn` Oertïknz Hurek
]r`onre nh`a`ñk9 kfv`nojrn hn :=5>
© ]nhrf Justeoektn
© Nh`a`fkns C`jnrter`es, ]rfhbuï`, Q.E.
Aerp`ktnrfs, >. Kevn 51. ]fc. @kh. Oeteaunrvfs.
:2:== Qek Cfrnkzf hn Nc Nsafr`ec. Oehr`h 
www.c`jnrter`es.afo 
www.c`jnrter`es.afo 
@QJK9 042-28-40>8-4>:-1
Hnpñs`tf cndec9 O-1:.150-:=5>
@oprnsf nk Ehvekt`e Afouk`aea`ñk Drål`ae
@oprnsf nk Nspeõe / ]r`ktnh `k Qpe`k
 E ces vïat`oes hnc
hnc `opnr`f
 

ïkh`an 
]rnlea`f.............................................................................
]rnlea`f............................................................................. 55
Nc `opnr`f y nc kf-`opnr`f............................................. 50
Ce v`fcnka`e sear`l`a`ec..................................................... :1
Ce l`aa`ñk hnc c`jnrec`sof................................................ 15
Nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk................................................... 85
Ce l`aa`ñk hnc h`knrf....................................................... 8>
Dnfpfcït`ae hnc `opnr`f.................................................. >0
Nc
Cfstnetrf hn cetfhf
fifs qun pfcït`ae.....................................................
cf vnk................................................ 40 <4
Ces ar`s`s l`at`a`es............................................................. 21
Ce ednkhe dcfjec`ste........................................................ 00
Nc s`stnoe hn dunrre.........................,.............................. 5=0
Ce dunrre tftec................................................................. 550
Ces dunrres prfxy............................................................ 5:>
Ce l`aa`ñk hn ce «Dunrre afktre nc tnrrfr·..................... 515
Nc s`fk`sof...................................................................... 514
Nc ^Q y ces jekhnres lecses............................................. 585
Ce dunrre j`fcñd`ae y quïo`ae........................................ 58>
Ces pekhno`es.................................................................. 580
Ce dunrre oàh`ae............................................................. 5>>
Ce keturecnze l`at`a`e....................................................... 5>0
Cfs onh`fs sear`l`a`ecns................................................... 5<1
Nc rntfrkf hn ce @kqu`s`a`ñk............................................ 544
 

Ce `ktnc`dnka`e nkoesaerehe........................................... 52>


Ce oåsaere onh`feoj`nktec........................................... 504
Ce oåsaere buoek`ter`e.................................................. :=5
Ce hfjcn ofrec................................................................. :=>
Ce l`aa`ñk supnre e ce rnec`heh........................................ :55
Znlnrnka`es :54 
]rnlea`f 
Nk nste fjre veofs e ofvnrkfs nktre ce rnec`heh y ce l`aa`ñk. \eofs e `ktnkter afoprnkhnr
kunstrf t`nopf
rnec`heh prna`seonktn
y ce l`aa`ñk hnshn
`ktnreatùek nste pnrspnat`ve.
hn lfroes Hnshne ce
ouy h`lnrnktns afkstetea`ñk
añof hn qun
cf bek bnabf bfy ce
nk ftrfs
t`nopfs, y qun ns prna`seonktn e trevàs hn nste afopcnie rncea`ñk afof pfhnofs
afoprnkhnr nc pfhnr afktnopfråknf. Qn nktnkhnrå nktfkans pfr quà, s` veofs e ofvnrkfs
nktrn ce rnec`heh y ce l`aa`ñk, kf pfheofs s`tuerkfs ùk`aeonktn nk nc tnrrnkf hn ce rnec`heh.
Hn oeknre qun hnjnofs nopnzer pfr hnacerer qun q un nstn trejeif kf sn `ksar`jn sfceonktn nk
nc dàknrf hnc nkseyf f hn ce arït`ae, s`kf teoj`àk nk nc hn ce l`aa`ñk. Qn punhn hnl`k`r pfr cf
tektf afof uk nkseyf-l`aa`ñk. ^k nkseyf, pfrqun nstå jesehf nk `klfroea`ñk vnrez. ^ke
l`aa`ñk, pfrqun nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, nk cf qun t`nkn hn oås prflukhf, hn oås `ktndrec, ns
lrutf hn kunstre `oed`kea`ñk. E lecte hn afkter afk tfhfs cfs hetfs, bnofs afks`hnrehf
knanser`f afopcnter ce `oednk, «afknater cfs puktfs·, afof h`an Hev`h @agn, eter aejfs. Hn
oeknre qun kf sn punhn el`roer nk snkt`hf r`durfsf qun tfhf cf qun equï sn h`an ns vnrheh.
K` 
4
 

s`qu`nre arnnofs qun nste kfa`ñk tnkde ouabf snkt`hf. Q`k nojerdf tfhf cf qun sn el`roe ns
pfs`jcn. Uun sne, nk pertn, uke l`aa`ñk, kf s`dk`l`ae qun kunstre `ktnka`ñk sne arner uke
rnec`heh qun kf nx`stn, s`kf oås j`nk nxtrepfcer, e pert`r hn cf qun sn ounstre, uke pfs`jcn
rnec`heh nkoesaerehe. Nk tfhf aesf, qun ecdf sne afoprfjejcn, qun ecdf sn punhn prnsnkter
afof uke «vnrheh·, kf `opc`ae qun nste cf c f sne. Afof vnrnofs, uke hn ces nstretnd`es hnc
`opnr`f ns lejr`aer vnrhehns l`at`a`es. Nk ftres pecejres, kunstre `ktnka`ñk ns snr vnreans, pnrf
ce prfp`e tnoåt`ae y nc prfp`f aeråatnr hnc tnoe qun kfs faupe kfs `op`hn snrcf pfr
afopcntf. ]frqun, `ks`st`ofs, kf afkteofs afk tfhfs cfs hetfs, 9 y pfrqun hehe ce urdnka`e
hn ce s`tuea`ñk kfs vnofs fjc`dehfs e seaer afkacus`fkns, e eh`v`ker, e `ktnrprnter ces
`ktnka`fkns qun bey hntrås hn cf qun vnofs. Hn bnabf arnnofs qun uk trejeif hn nstes
aereatnrïst`aes, qun sn faupe hn nstn tnoe, kf ns pfs`jcn kf sfcf s`k uke a`nrte hfs`s hn
`oed`kea`ñk, hn l`aa`ñk, s`kf `kacusf hn perekf`e.
\nrnofs qun nc `opnr`f fpnre sndùk uke nstretnd`e hn afblus`ñk hn ce rnec`heh y hn ce l`aa`ñk. Uun
nk nc  i lfkhf, e pnser hn ce afktukhnka`e hn ce rnec`heh, nste kf ns e onkuhf oås qun
[.prfhuatf hn uke l`aa`ñk. \nrnofs qun bfy uke hn ces lfroes afof sn trekslfroe ce rnec`heh
ns arnekhf prnv`eonktn su l`aa`ñk. ]unhn snr nktfkans oås rnvncehfr afoprnkhnr nste
h`kåo`ae 5 qun anõ`rsn nxacus`veonktn e ce «vnrheh· y e ce «rnec`heh·, sfjrn tfhf sej`nkhf
añof nstes vnrhehns y rne- ) c`hehns
c` hehns sfk lejr`aehes. Afoprnkhnr nc `opnr`f supfkn pfr cf
tektf `ktnrprnter ce rnec`heh y ce vnrheh e pert`r @ 

hn ce oeknre nk qun nstes sfk afkanj`hes, ns hna`r, nk ouabfs aesfs, e pert`r hn ce l`aa`ñk,
rnafrr`nkhf nc aeo`kf `kvnrsf. ]nrf teoj`àk e pert`r hn ce oeknre nk qun nstes sfk
ofstrehes, punstes nk nsanke.
nsanke. Uun bfy tektfs nstuh`fsfs sn `ktnrnsnk pfr ce aucture afof vn-
vn -
bïaucf hn afoprnks`ñk hn ce rnec`heh ns uk sïktfoe hn qun ce l`aa`ñk t`nkn ouabf qun
hna`rkfs sfjrn ncce, hn qun nste ns nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e l`aa`fkec. Kunstre afkv`aa`ñk ns qun ce
l`aa`ñk punhn hna`rkfs ouabf hn ce rnec`heh, pfrqun ce rnec`heh ns nk sï l`aa`fkec, pfrqun ce
l`aa`ñk ns su aetec`zehfr. Nk ce onh`he nk qun nktrn l`aa`ñk y rnec`heh kf nx`stn uke
h`st`ka`ñk tek knte afof sn kfs suncn beanr arnnr. Nk ce onh`he nk qun tfhf ns uk drek
tnetrf.
]fr ftrf cehf ce keturecnze hnc `opnr`f ns ce onkt`re, nc h`s`oucf, nc snarntf, nc
nkoesaereo`nktf. Hn oeknre qun `ktnkter afoprnkhnrcf supfkn tnknr qun hnsvncer,
eh`v`ker, hnsnkoesaerer, equnccf qun pfr su prfp`e nsnka`e kf sn punhn vnr`l`aer. Hnjnofs
eacerer qun kf tnknofs eaansf e k`kduke lunktn hn `klfroea`ñk snarnte, afkl`hnka`ec,
aces`l`aehe, nkauj`nrte, pr`v`cnd`ehe, s`kf tek sfcf e `klfroea`ñk pùjc`ae hn c`jrn eaansf. Q`
eaesf afksndu`ofs
kunstre `oed`kea`ñk,eanrter nk equnccf qun kf ns afoprfjejcn, nstf hnjnrå snr eabeaehf e
e kunstre `ktu`a`ñk, e ce afbnrnka`e hn kunstre tnfrïe. Nk tfhf aesf,
afof veofs e `ktnkter ofstrer, kf ns tek h`lïa`c ec onkfs eanraersn e cf qun kfs fauctek,
pfrqun ce rnec`heh, `kacusf ce rnec`heh l`at`a`e afktnopfråkne, kf hnie hn snr uk tfhf
afbnrnktn. P pfrqun bey ouabfs lcnafs sunctfs nk cf qun sï ns afoprfjejcn. 
51
 

Qn punhn nktnkhnr nktfkans pfr quà ouabfs hn cfs oàtfhfs eaehào`afs leccek e ce bfre hn
afoprnkhnr nc pfhnr. Cf bej`tuec ns qun nstfs oàtfhfs qun sn eu-tfhnkfo`kek «r`durfsfs·
kf cf punhek ejeraer pfr afopcntf, pfrqun pertnk hn ce jesn hn lredonkter nc sejnr nk årnes
pera`ecns, `khnpnkh`nktns, `kafknxes7 ketureconktn, oås låa`conktn afktrfcejcns. H`v`hn nt
`opnre. Uu`nrnk afoprnkhnr nc pfhnr pnrf nståk etrepehfs nk ces prfp`es rnhns hnc pfhnr.
Kf sn punhn knder qun tfhes nstes epfrtea`fkns sfk vec`fses, pnrf kf pfhnofs hnier hn
snõecer nste aernka`e lukheonktec. Kf pfhnofs hnier hn sfspnaber qun nk nc lfkhf tfhe ce
perel nrkec`e hnc sejnr eaehào`af n `kst`tua`fkec ‘ce nspna`ec`zea`ñk, nc oàtfhf, nc r`dfr, ce
vnrheh‘ ` kf sfk oås qun ces afkh`a`fkns hnc sfont`o`nktf hn nstn sejnr ec pfhnr.
Nk tfhf aesf nx`stnk teoj`àk kuonrfsfs ekec`stes qun trejeiek nk jesn e ce ontfhfcfdïe
eaehào`ae y hn cfs qun kf sn punhn huher hn quà cehf nståk. Nstn trejeif sn jese nk junke
onh`he nk nstn t`pf
t`p f hn `kvnst`dea`fkns, e ces qun ftfrdeofs uk nkfron vecfr y afk ces qun
nsteofs nk hnuhe. ]nrf kunstrf fjint`vf ns ftrf. Ns, `ks`st`ofs,
` ks`st`ofs, eter cfs aejfs qun v`kaucek
ukfs lnkñonkfs afk ftrfs, ukes h`sa`pc`kes afk ftres, treter hn 3 arner uke `oednk hn
afkiuktf, uke pekfråo`ae afoprnks`ve. Nste v`s`ñk pekfråo`ae kfs pnro`t`rå afo- ¡
prnkhnr qun ce o`soe cñd`ae fpnre hntrås hn lnkñonkfs epernktnonktn h`lnrnktns. Ce
keturecnze ‘e uk t`nopf v`fcnkte y nkoesaerehfre‘ hnc `opnr`f rnvnce i cf qun tfhfs nccfs
t`nknk nk afoùk. Qndu`r nc b`cf rfif hn ce v`fcnka`e, ehnktrersn nk su cejnr`ktf, ns ce acevn 

pere afoprnkhnr añof luka`fke nc `opnr`f. @opnh`r qun afoprnkheofs nstes
v`kaucea`fkns, qun arneofs qun ces h`st`ktes nxprns`fkns hn ce v`fcnka`e sfk lnkñonkfs
e`scehfs,
prfpedekheafkvnkanrkfs hn qun ce aucpe
`opnr`ec. Afoprnkhnr nstfnsnshn
ce ftrfs, ns ce nstretnd`e
jesn lukheonktec lukheonktec
pere hn cfs
nktnkhnr qun ce
h`st`ktfs punjcfs hn ce X`nrre tnknofs ouabf oås nk afoùk nktrn kfsftrfs qun cf qun aehe
ukf hn nccfs t`nkn afk sus hfo`kehfrns7 qun ns, nk hnl`k`t`ve, rns`st`r ce v`fcnka`e ``opnr`ec.
opnr`ec.
]fr nste rezñk, pfrqun kunstrf `ktnràs kf ns tektf nc hnteccn afof nc treslfkhf, sn bek
fo`t`hf ces a`tes afkarntes. ]frqun kf kfs `ktnrnse tektf nc r`dfr hn ces rnlnrnka`es afof ce
prflukh`heh, ce `ktndr`heh, ce afbnrnka`e, nc aeråatnr treksvnrsec hnc ekåc`s`s. Nk cuder hn ces
a`tes puktuecns sn be `kacu`hf ec l`kec
l `kec hnc nsar`tf uke sncnaa`ñk hn rnlnrnka`es dnknrecns nk ces
qun sn pfhrå prflukh`zer y afoprfjer ce vnrea`heh hn ce `klfroea`ñk. Xeopfaf sn bek
a`tehf fjres tnñr`aes hn aeråatnr dnknrec, qun nc cnatfr auctf sejrå rnafkfanr s`k oås pnrf qun
berïek ce cnature oås åspnre pere nc pùjc`af dnknrec, ec qun nste fjre sfjrn tfhf sn h`r`dn. Nk
suoe, pfrqun sn trete hn rnlcnx`fkns urdnktns qun eafksniek prnsa`kh`r hn tfhf cf c f eaansfr`f.
Eukqun bnofs nstruaturehf oïk`oeonktn nstes rnlcnx`fkns, cf a`nrtf ns qun kf kfs be
prnfaupehf qun ouabfs hn cfs b`cfs etrev`nsnk tfhes ces snaa`fkns, qun sn bejcn uk pfaf hn
tfhf e ce vnz. P ns qun, afof hna`ofs, kunstre `ktnka`ñk ns prna`seonktn afoprnkhnr ces
v`kaucea`fkns nktrn cfs h`st`ktfs lnkñonkfs, cf qun t`nknk nk afoùk s`tuea`fkns f nvnktfs
epernktnonktn 
5>
 

`kafknxfs. Nste nstruature, nk a`nrtf ofhf frhnkehe pnrf teoj`àk cejnrïkt`ae, levfrnan ce
afoprnks`ñk treksvnrsec, ouct`h`onks`fkec, prfdrns`ve, s`ouctåkne, qun afof vnrnofs ns ce
lfroe nk qun fpnrek ces ednkhes nkauj`nrtes hnc `opnr`f. Hn bnabf, uk a`nrtf aefs ns
teoj`àk uke hn ces nstretnd`es hnc `opnr`f. Hn oeknre qun, pnro`t`r qun nstn aefs pert`a`pn
nk uke a`nrte onh`he nk nc ekåc`s`s, punhn afktr`ju`r e afoprnkhnr h`abf aefs `opnr`ec.
Bfy aehe vnz oås nc ofhus fpnrekh` hnc `opnr`f ns vnkhnrkfs onkt`res afk nc nkvfctfr`f hn
«vnrhehns· fl`a`ecns. Nste ns, afof vnrnofs, uke hn sus ouabes l`aa`fkns. Nstes onkt`res sn
lejr`aek nk junke onh`he 3 hn oeknre nkauj`nrte, y nk ouabfs aesfs kf ns pf- ! s`jcn
afoprfjer s` kfs nståk o`kt`nkhf, puns tfhf sn rnhuan e ce cñd`ae hnc «nstf ns esï pfrqun cf
h`df i yf· (qun sfy nc qun oekhe, nc qun faucte f hnsvnce ( ce `klfroea`ñk). Hn ebï qun
beyeofs nopnzehf pfk`nkhf nk aunst`ñk nc vecfr hn ce vnrheh afof oàtfhf hn
`kvnst`dea`ñk. ]uns hn bnabf ouabes hn nstes «vnrhehns· sfk lejr`aehes. Hn ebï qun
hnsvncer cfs oàtfhfs añof fpnre nc `opnr`f,
` opnr`f, `kacusf eukqun sne epncekhf e uk a`nrtf drehf
hn `oed`kea`ñk, punhn snr oås anrtnrf qun nc supunstf r`dfr eaehào`af. Hnspuàs hn tfhf,
¶quà snkt`hf t`nkn nspnrer e qun sn hnsaces`l`qun hntnro`kehe `klfroea`ñk, s` nste pfr
pr`ka`p`f sfcf sn hnsaces`l`ae nk nc ofonktf nk qun nc esuktf ye kf t`nkn rncnveka`e6 Qn
nktnkhnrå nktfkans pfr quà nc «r`durfsf· oàtfhf eaehào`af punhn tnro`ker s`nkhf, hn
oeknre oås f onkfs `ktnka`fkehe, añopc`an pfr eat`ve f pfr pes`ve hn nste nstretnd`e hn
nkaujr`o`nktf ¡ 
5= i 
`kbnrnktn e ce `ktnc`dnka`e hnc `opnr`f. Nk ftres pecejres, ouabes hn nstes «snr`es·
`kvnst`dea`fkns, sfk `kflnks`ves
cfs qun sfk prna`seon ktn pere qun pfrqun
 prna`seonktn kf kfelnater
kf punhek punhnk
elnater ec elnater
prnsnktn.ec  prnsnktn. P sus oàtfhfs sfk
prnsnktn.
]fr nc afktrer`f nste cñd`ae pnrvnrse hnc nkoesaereo`nktf, hn ce fauctea`ñk, fjc`de e tfhf
equnc qun prntnkhe afoprnkhnr nc `opnr`f bfy, e ut`c`zer, eukqun sne nk uk oïk`of drehf,
ce cñd`ae perekf`ae, afksp`rea`fk`ste f afksp`rekf`ae. Ieaquns Ceaek kfs be ofstrehf beste
quà puktf ce perekf`e ns uke bnrreo`nkte ccnkecc nke hn pfs`j`c`hehns np`stnofcñd`aes y hn
afoprfo`sf sfa`ec. Nsteofs bejcekhf ketureconktn hn perekf`e fpnret`ve, ontñh`ae.
]erekf`e ontñh`ae, puns, afof ce «huhe ontñh`ae· aertns`eke.
Qn nktnkhnrå ebfre pfrqun sfk iusteonktn nstfs oàtfhfs cfs qun nc `opnr`f nstå
hnsearnh`tekhf, hnof-k`zekhf, anksurekhf, ar`o`kec`zekhf.
ar`o`kec`zekhf. Nk nstn afktnxtf bey qun
`ksar`j`r ce rna`nktn fpnrea`ñk nkauj`nrte «Ce j`jc`ftnae hn Fseoe j`k Cehnk· (oeyf hn
:=5>), qun v`kauce ec cïhnr tnrrfr`ste y ednktn nkauj`nrtf hn ce A@E afk eutfrns qun,
prna`seonktn, hnsofktek ces «vnrhehns· fl`a`ecns, hnshn Kfeo Abfosgy e O`abnc
Abfssuhfvsgy. Bea`àkhfkfs arnnr qun ces tnfrïes afksp`ret`ves afktr`juynk ec tnrrfr`sof,
auekhf prna`seonktn cf qun beank ns ofstrer qun nc tnrrfr`sof ns, nk nsnka`e, tnrrfr`sof hn
Nstehf nkauj`nrtf, f onifr, tnrrfr`sof hn `opnr`f nkauj`nrtf. P ns qun sfk nstfs nklfquns
afksp`rea`fk`stes cfs qun, pfr ce prfp`e keturecnze nkauj`nrte hnc `opnr`f, onifr punhnk
eanraersn e afoprnkhnrcf. Ec l`k y ec aejf ce ps`qu`etrïe be s`hf 
54
 

s`noprn ukf hn cfs lrnktns hn jetecce afktre ce `oed`kea`ñk, ce arnet`v`heh y ce c`jnrteh.


Ce perehfie ns qun nc s`stnoe hnofk`an
h nofk`an cf perekf`af ec o`sof t`nopf qun àc o`sof ns aehe
vnz oås perekf`af, ec o`sof t`nopf qun lfonkte ce perekf`e dnknrec`zehe afof
onaek`sof hn afktrfc sfa`ec. Nk rnec`heh kf sn trete hn uke perehfie s`kf hn ce s`opcn cuabe
hn lunrzes afktrer`es. Nc s`stnoe aunst`fke cfs oàtfhfs perekf`afs prna`seonktn pfrqun nc
s`stnoe ns perekf`af y pfrqun nstn oàtfhf punhn aecercf onifr qun cfs oàtfhfs eaehào`afs
hn ce cñd`ae f hnc «r`dfr·. Esï, aes` sn pfhrïe el`roer qun sfcf afk uke a`nrte hfs`s hn nste
ontñh`ae sn punhn bfy afoprnkhnr añof luka`fke nc `opnr`f. Afoprnkhnr añof
 perekf`e ontñh`ae
«sn· p`nkse, añof «ukf· «sn· afopfrte, añof «sn· eatùe nk nc `opnr`f (X`qquk-Afo`tà
@kv`s`jcn). ]nrf ec o`sof t`nopf bey qun snr afksa`nktns hn qun 7 nste perekf`e ns uke hnr`ve
`kseke. Bey qun oektnknr 3 uke a`nrte h`steka`e secuhejcn afk rnspnatf e ncce. ]uns ce
nstretnd`e hnc `opnr`f ns teoj`àk
teoj` àk etreperkfs nk nste hnr`ve perekf`ae suye.
Nk rnsuonk, nstn nsar`tf ns, `ks`st`ofs, uk nkseyf- 7 l`aa`ñk. Xfhf cf qun sn el`roe nk àc ns
pfs`jcn, `kacusf 9 pfhnofs hna`r qun ns ouy pfs`jcn, pnrf kf ns, nk nc snkt`hf r`durfsf hnc
tàro`kf, vnrheh. Nk ùct`oe `ks- 3 teka`e, teoj`àk nstf ns uk tnetrf. Ns terne hnc cnatfr ( hna`h`r
quà fjre, quà `ktnrprnte a`ñk ns onifr, ce `o- i pnr`ec f ce kunstre. Afof sn vn, oås eaå hn
` ktnrprntea`ñk
auecqu`nr prntnkh`he fjint`v`heh, kfs hnacereofs hnshn ye nc kf-`opnr`f. ¡Uuà nop`nan nc
nspnatåaucf! 
55 
Nc `opnr`f y nc kf-`opnr`f 
Lfroucnofs ukes kfa`fkns jås`aes pere nopnzer. Nk nste fjre veofs e treter hn
afoprnkhnr nc `opnr`f.
Xektf nc `opnr`f afof nc]nrf ¶quà ns ncnk`opnr`f6
kf-`opnr`f, Nc `opnr`fkfnssfk
snkt`hf r`durfsf, cf afktrer`f
cuderns, k`hnc kf-`opnr`f.
Nstehfs, k`
drupfs hn Nstehfs, k` frdek`sofs, k` dfj`nrkfs, k` drupfs hn pnrsfkes, k` pnrsfkes. Nc
`opnr`f ns tfhf equnccf qun hfo`ke y qun ninran h`abf hfo`k`f e trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e y hn su
eonkeze. Nc kf-`opnr`f ns tfhf equnccf qun rns`stn nstn hfo`k`f, qun rns`stn nste v`fcnka`e y
nste eonkeze. Q` nc `opnr`f ninran su hfo`k`f e trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e y ce eonkeze, nc kf-
`opnr`f t`nkhn e ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, qun ns uk nstehf `hnec nxnktf pfr afopcntf hn v`fcnka`e y hn su
eonkeze. 
@opnr`f y kf-`opnr`f, hfo`k`f y afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn sfk, pfr cf tektf, pr`ka`p`fs fpunstfs. Qu
fpfs`a`ñk ns hn frhnk afkanptuec. ]nrf kf sfk s`oàtr`afs. Nc `opnr`f y nc hfo`k`f sfk rnecns.
Nc kf-`opnr`f y ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn sfk, afof bnofs h`abf, `hnecns. Qn punhn nster oås f
onkfs anrae hn h`abfs nstehfs, sn t`nkhn e nccfs. @opnr`f y kf-`opnr`f, hfo`k`f y
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, kf sn nxacuynk s`kf qun sn hek ec o`sof t`nopf, 
50
 

sn afopcnonktek, sn afklrfktek. Qfk hfs lunrzes qun eatùek nk snkt`hf fpunstf, qun
epuktek e pfcfs afktrer`fs, qun afklfroek uke j`pfcer`heh. Qn trete hn kfa`fkns
afkanptuecns pnrf qun s`rvnk pere afoprnkhnr tfhfs cfs lnkñonkfs sfa`ecns, hn h`st`ktes
auctures, e h`st`ktes nsaeces, nk h`st`ktfs pcekfs. Nk pr`ka`p`f nk tfhfs cfs lnkñonkfs
pfcït`afs, nafkño`afs, sfa`ecns, sn punhnk rnafkfanr nstes lunrzes fpunstes.
Uun nc hfo`k`f sn ninran e trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e y hn su eonkeze ns tektf afof hna`r qun nc
onaek`sof hn hfo`k`f lukheonktec ns nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec (Znkà D`rerh). Nstf be s`hf
esï y s`dun s`nkhf esï bfy, eukqun e trevàs hn kunvfs onaek`sofs, hn kunves lfroes. Bn-
ofs afonkzehf h`a`nkhf qun bfy nc `opnr`f fpnre hn uke oeknre pert`aucer, kfvnhfse, s`
cf afopereofs afk ces lfroes afof fpnreje bean tek sfcf ukes hàaehes. ]nrf cf a`nrtf ns
qun nste lfroe epernktnonktn kfvnhfse kf ns oås qun nc rntfrkf hn cf sear`l`a`ec. Afk kun-
ves ofhec`hehns, afk kunvfs treins, afk kunves oåsaeres, pnrf cf sear`l`a`ec ec l`k y ec aejf.
Nk hnl`k`t`ve nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec afks`stn nk ce eho`k`strea`ñk hn ce ounrtn (Edustïk
Deraïe Aecvf) afof h`spfs`t`vf hn pfhnr, afof lukheonktf hnc frhnk sfa`ec, pfcït`af, rn-
c`d`fsf, ofrec. Ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn pfr nc afktrer`f sn jese nk ce eusnka`e tftec hn ce
v`fcnka`e y hn su eonkeze afof ncnonktfs
nc nonktfs ert`aucehfrns hn cf sfa`ec. Nk ftres pecejres, nk ce
rnkuka`e tftec e cf sear`l`a`ec. Nk cuder 5 hn nccf, ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn afks`stn nk nc nqu`c`jr`f
nktrn ce v`he `kh`v`huec ‘jïfs‘ y ce v`he afouk`ter`e ‘zfà ‘ , nktrn ce c`jnrteh `kh`v`huec y
ce c`jnrteh afouk`ter`e, nktrn ce keturecnze y ce aucture. 
5: 
Ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn kf hnjn afklukh`rsn afk ce c`jnrteh nk dnknrec, y onkfs eùk afk ccee
c`jnrteh
ce `kh`v`huec, qun
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn ns eckf ns oås
o`sof qun uke
t`nopf hn ces ouabes
`kh`v`huec l`aa`fkns
y sfa`ec, keturechnc `opnr`f.uk@ks`st`ofs,
y aucturec, nqu`c`jr`f
qun hnpnkhn hn ces a`rauksteka`es, qun kf ns rnhua`jcn e lñrouces f e hnacerea`fkns
uk`vnrsecns hn hnrnabfs. Kf nstå nxnkte hn afktreh`aa`fkns, puns nk hnl`k`t`ve ns nc
rnsuctehf hn ce afopnksea`ñk hn lunrzes afktrer`es, `kh`v`huecns y afcnat`ves, keturecns y
aucturecns. ]nrf cf qun ce h`lnrnka`e lukheonkteconktn hnc hfo`k`f ns qun nk ce
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn h`abfs nqu`c`jr`fs t`nkhnk e prfhua`rsn s`k qun sne knanser`f nc rnaursf e ce
v`fcnka`e y e su eonkeze. Nk ftres pecejres, ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn sn afrrnspfkhn afk cfs
nqu`c`jr`fs hn ce jecekze, o`nktres qun nc hfo`k`f cf bean afk ce eaa`ñk v`fcnkte hn ce
nspehe. Cf bej`tuec ns qun ce c e jecekze y ce nspehe fpnrnk hn oeknre afkiukte nk ce rnec`heh.
Hn ebï qun ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, ns hna`r, ce jecekze s`k ce nspehe, sne uk `hnec, uke sfa`nheh
s`k v`fcnka`e y s`k sear`l`a`fs.
Afof sn vn, ce c`jnrteh qun `ktndre ce kfa`ñk hn afkv`vnka`e-/z£r36 kf ns ejstreate, k`
`kh`v`huec, s`kf nc rnsuctehf hn h`abf nqu`c`jr`f, e uk t`nopf `kh`v`huec y sfa`ec, keturec y
aucturec. Hn ebï qun nk nc tàro`kf afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn afkvnriek afk-, v`he y c`jnrteh. Ce c`jnrteh
`kh`v`huec ns uke l`aa`ñk hnc `opnr`f, uke hn ces oås pfhnrfses, uke hn ces oås leceans, uke
hn ces oås heõ`kes. Ns uke l`aa`ñk pfrqun sfcf uke o`kfrïe ns aepez hn ecaekzer nste
c`jnrteh `kh`v`huec, f ce `cus`ñk hn ce c`jnrteh `kh`v`huec, ec prna`f hn qun  
:5
 

ce oeyfrïe tnkde qun rnkuka`er e ncce. Ns uke l`aa`ñk pfrqun faucte ce vnrhehnre suo`s`ñk
hnc `kh`v`huf ec ràd`onk hfo`kektn, sne afof hfo`kehfr f afof hfo`kehf, puns snr
hfo`kehfr ns ftre lfroe hn suo`s`ñk. Ns uke l`aa`ñk, l`keconktn, pfrqun kf t`nkn snkt`hf
bejcer hn c`jnrteh `kh`v`huec, ec snr ce vnrhehnre c`jnrteh, afof bnofs ofstrehf, sfcf uk
afopfknktn ▭ hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. 
51 
Ce v`fcnka`e sear`l`a`ec 
Ce h`ecàat`ae nktrn hfo`k`f y afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn ns uke nxtnks`ñk hn ce h`ecàat`ae aep`tec`ste.
Nk nlnatf nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste sn jese nk nc hfo`k`f hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. Nc ràd`onk
aep`tec`ste sn `ksteure, nk uk pr`onr t`nopf, hnstruynkhf ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, snperekhf e
`kh`v`hufs y afouk`hehns, e eojfs hn su keturecnze y hn su aucture, snperekhf ce aucture
hn ce keturecnze7 nk hnl`k`t`ve, hnsnqu`c`jrekhf f ectnrekhf cfs nqu`c`jr`fs hn ce afkv`vnka`e-
c`jrn. Nk uk sndukhf t`nopf vfcv`nkhf e rncea`fker nstfs ncnonktfs ye snperehfs, pnrf
ebfre e trevàs hn cfs onaek`sofs hnc onraehf y hn cfs `ktnraeoj`fs y ce eauoucea`ñk aep`-
tec`stes. Nc `ktnraeoj`f onraekt`c kean v`a`ehf pfr nste cñd`ae hnsnqu`c`jrehfre y hnstruat`ve
hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn qun cn ns `kbnrnktn. Nste ns ce cñd`ae hn ce «eauoucea`ñk pr`o`t`ve· hn
Oerx. Nste ns ce «drek trekslfroea`ñk· hn ce qun kfs be bejcehf Gerc ]fceky`. Nk ftres
pecejres, nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste ns nsnka`econktn hnstruat`vf, v`fcnktf. Qu fjint`vf ùct`of hn
hnstruaa`ñk ‘pnrf teoj`àk pr`onrf, puns t`nkn qun nopnzer pfr ncce, pere sust`tu`rce pfr
rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes‘ ns ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. 
:1
 

Cfs onaek`sofs aep`tec`stes kf sfk oås qun ce ùct`oe vnrs`ñk hn ftres lfroes b`stñr`aes hn
hfo`k`f. Xfhes ncces sn bek jesehf nk ce v`fcnka`e y nk ce eonkeze hn ce v`fcnka`e7 ns hna`r,
nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, nk nc onaek`sof
ona ek`sof sear`l`a`ec. Xfhes ncces t`nknk afof treslfkhf ce
eho`k`strea`ñk hn ce ounrtn. Nc hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste kf sn h`st`kdun nk nstf hn ftres
ofhec`hehns hn hfo`kea`ñk, sfcf sn h`lnrnka`e nk ces lfroes. ]fr nsf bean lecte bfy uke
drek eopc`tuh hn o`res pere nktnkhnr añof ce kfvnheh knfc`jnrec ns, nk rnec`heh, uk
rntfrkf sear`l`a`ec.
Nk nstn afktnxtf hn hnsnqu`c`jr`f, hn oerd`ke-a`ñk, hn hnk`drea`ñk, hn hnstruaa`ñk, y nk
hnl`k`t`ve, hn sust`tua`ñk, hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn pfr rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes, bey qun
nktnkhnr ce rntñr`ae hnc aeoj`f y hnc prfdrnsf `ktnro`kejcn qun hfo`ke nk nc `opnr`f. ]ure
rntñr`ae, pure `hnfcfdïe, pure rnc`d`ñk, `kaucaehe nk cesc es afksa`nka`es pere qun nc prfansf
nsnka`econktn hnstruat`vf nk qun sn jese nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste kf sne pnra`j`hf afof tec.
«Ce rntñr`ae hnc aeoj`f s`rvn pere hnsoektncer tfhe afstuojrn, pere hnstrfzer tfhfs cfs
vïkaucfs, pere hnsafkanrter tfhe anrtnze, pere h`sueh`r tfhe sfc`her`heh, pere oektnknr uke
`ksndur`heh nx`s- i tnka`ec arñk`ae· (X`qquk-Afo`tà @kv`s`jcn).
Nk ftres pecejres, nc `opnr`f ns s`noprn pfr hnl`k`a`ñk nc qun ninran ce v`fcnka`e, o`nktres qun nc kf-
`opnr`f ce rns`stn. Hn ebï qun teoj`àk pfheofs hns`dker ec kf-`opnr`f afof rns`stnka`e.
Eukqun nk ce pråat`ae, nk ces `hes y vnk`hes hn ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec y hn ce rns`stnka`e hnc
kf-`opnr`f, ce v`fcnka`e afkarnte ns `oputejcn e eojes pertns. Afoprnkhnr nstn iundf hn ce 
58

v`fcnka`e ns ce acevn pere afoprnkhnr añof luka`fke nc `opnr`f. Afoprnkhnr añof ce
v`fcnka`e ns uk pr`ka`p`f nsnka`ec, añof nste sn nkaerke nk cfs h`spfs`t`vfs, nk ces
`kst`tua`fkns, nk cfs lnkñonkfs hnc s`stnoe. Afoprnkhnr añof teoj`àk ouabfs hn cfs c fs
lnkñonkfs qun ehsar`j`ofs e ce `ktnc`dnka`e, e ce aucture f e ce a`nka`e, sfk, nk ùct`oe
`ksteka`e, lfroes sujc`oehes hn v`fcnka`e. Nc sejnr afof afkt`kuea`ñk hnc pfhnr  pfr ftrfs
onh`fs. ]nrf pere afoprnkhnr vnrhehnreonktn ce v`fcnka`e teoj`àk ns knanser`f, afof h`if
Kfeo Abfosgy, rns`st`rce, snr pertn hn ce rns`stnka`e. Ns hna`r, kf sn punhn bejcer hn
v`fcnka`e s`k tfoer pertn nk ce cuabe, eukqun sne nk ce cuabe `ktncnatuec, afof cf ns nstn
nkseyf, pfrqun teoj`àk nc `ktncnatf pert`a`pe
pert`a`p e hn nste v`fcnka`e. Xfhf nstf kfs tren
t ren hn kunvf
e ce aunst`ñk hn ce vnrheh y hn ce onkt`re, hn ce afklrfktea`ñk hn l`aa`fkns.
Ce v`fcnka`e kf sn nkt`nkhn s`k su eonkeze. Ce h`ecàat`ae nktrn v`fcnka`e y eonkeze hn ce
v`fcnka`e ns lukheonktec, afof Tectnr Jnkieoïk be ofstrehf afk cua`hnz. Nste h`ecàat`ae ns
ce qun nstå nk ce jesn hnc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec. Cfs sear`l`a`fs kf sfk sfcf nc ninra`a`f hn ce
v`fcnka`e s`kf, sfjrn tfhf, su nsank`l`aea`ñk, su r`tuec`zea`ñk, su s`ojfc`zea`ñk. Ce v`fcnka`e
eatùe pfr pert`he hfjcn, afof hnofstrea`ñk hn cf qun nc pfhnr punhn y afof eonkeze hn cf
qun nvnktueconktn pfhrïe. Auektf oås nl`aez sne nstn onaek`sof, onkfs v`fcnka`e rnec snrå
knanser`f ninranr, nk ce onh`he nk qun ce eonkeze rnprnsnktehe, nsank`l`aehe, r`tuec`zehe,
s`ojfc`zehe, sujc`oehe, sne aepez pfr sï sfce hn oektnknr nc frhnk sfa`ec. P nste lfroe
nsank`l`aehe, r`tuec`zehe, 
:>
 

nta., hn v`fcnka`e punhn snr hns`dkehe afof uke l`aa`ñk. Nk ftres pecejres, ce  l`aa`ñk hn ce
v`fcnka`e punhn tnknr ` uk nlnatf tek pfhnrfsf afof su rnec`heh. Nk ce pråat`ae eojes eatùek
hn oeknre afopcnonkter`e, ectnrke, @ aïac`ae.
aïac` ae. Cf qun kfs `ktnrnse ns ofstrer beste quà puktf
nste h`onks`ñk l`at`a`e hn ce v`fcnka`e ns nl`aez bfy.
]fr ftrf cehf sn punhn hna`r qun ce v`fcnka`e sear`l`a`ec ns l`at`a`e nk nc snkt`hf nk qun ces
«vnrhehns· e ces qun sn esfa`e sfk teoj`àk l`at`a`es. Kfs rnlnr`ofs e ce vnrheh hn ce aucpe qun,
nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, ns teoj`àk uke l`aa`ñk. Nc sear`l`a`f nk sï sn afkv`nrtn nk uk onrf prntnxtf
pere ninranr nc pfhnr. P pere nccf nc rnqu`s`tf lukheonktec ns afkter afk uk nkno`df, afk uk
aucpejcn, n `opfknr nste l`aa`ñk afof «vnrheh·. Esï fpnre bfy e drekhns resdfs nc
tnrrfr`sof. ]nrf nstn lnkñonkf afkl`dure kunstre pfcït`ae, kunstre ofrec, kunstre iust`a`e hn
uke oeknre ouabf oås prflukhe. Afof Lrekz Gelge supf vnr onifr qun keh`n, ce iust`a`e
ns ektns uk r`tuec nsaàk`af qun uk prfanh`o`nktf iustf. Nk ftres pecejres9 uke l`aa`ñk bnabe
rnec`heh.
Hn ebï qun ce afopc`a`heh nktrn hfo`k`f y l`aa`ñk, nktrn `opnr`f y nspnatåaucf, sne tek
nstrnabe. Nste ns ce rezñk pfr ce qun, afof vnrnofs, bfy kf sn punhn h`st`kdu`r nktrn pfhnr
y onh`fs. ^kf y ftrfs sfk hfs aeres hn h n ce o`soe ofknhe. P tfhf nccf nk nc afktnxtf hnc
onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec, hn ce nsank`l`aea`ñk, hn ce r`tuec`zea`ñk, hn ce l`aa`fkec`zea`ñk hn
hn ce
v`fcnka`e hn ce qun vnk`ofs bejcekhf.
Ce v`fcnka`e ns ce acevn pere nktnkhnr nc pfhnr. ]fr nsf, eukqun sn vn y sn bejce tektf hn
v`fcnka`e, nste sn nkt`nkhn tek pfaf. ]fr nsf ce prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe,  
5> 

hnshn cfs epernan


v`fcnka`e onh`fss`noprn
e ces uk`vnrs`hehns,
rfhnehe hn ukce afklukhnk, ce nspnateaucer,
eure sedrehe, oec`ktnrprntek, ce anksurek.
afof Ce
uk lnkñonkf
`kafoprnks`jcn, `kiust`l`aejcn, `rrea`fkec. ]nrf teoj`àk sn prnsnkte afof uk lnkñonkf
puktuec, cfaec, e`scehf hn ce nstruature hn hfo`kea`ñk7 ns hna`r, sn prnsnkte afof v`fcnka`e
snperehe hn ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec (Qcevfi :`zng). Nc `opnr`f kf sfcf t`nkn nc ofkfpfc`f hn
ce v`fcnka`e «junke·, s`kf teoj`àk nc hn ce h`st`ka`ñk nktrn v`fcnka`e «junke· y v`fcnka`e
«oece·. P ns qun ce afoprnks`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e ns, afof nc frf, ukf hn cfs tejùns lukhe-
onktecns qun sfst`nkn ce rnc`d`ñk hnc pfhnr. ]uns nk nc lfkhf tfhf sn rnhuan pere nc `opnr`f
e uke cñd`ae ouy s`opcn9 ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec ns «junke· y ce v`fcnka`e kf-`opnr`ec ns
«oece·. Nk ftres pecejres, tfhe ce v`fcnka`e qun nc `opnr`f ninran nk su levfr ns aec`l`aehe
`opcïa`teonktn afof «junke·, afof hnlnkse, afof prftnaa`ñk, afof sndur`heh, afof
frhnk. ]fr nc afktrer`f ces lunrzes qun rns`stnk e ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec sfk, sndùk ce
prfpedekhe `opnr`ec, v`fcnka`e «oece·. P nk ce onh`he hn cf pfs`jcn, ce ùk`ae v`fcnka`e.
]ere nktnkhnr nstn iundf hn ce v`fcnka`e
v `fcnka`e bey qun sejnr qun nste h`st`ka`ñk nktrn ce v`fcnka`e
«junke· y ce v`fcnka`e «oece· ns nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e uke l`aa`ñk. E pert`r hn nste onaåk`ae
lukheonktec sn punhnk nktnkhnr ouabfs lnkñonkfs bfy. Nste h`st`ka`ñk pese pfr faucter,
nkoesaerer, nxtnrkec`zer, ce prfp`e v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec7 trekslnr`rce e ftrfs ednktns, qun
punhnk snr esï `hnkt`l`aehfs afk nste v`fcnka`e,
v` fcnka`e, qun nktfkans ns hns`dkehe afof «oece·. F
j`nk, auekhf nc `opnr`f kf 
:4
 

t`nkn oås rnonh`f qun ninranr pfr sï o`sof ce v`fcnka`e, nktfkans ce nstretnd`e lukheonktec
ns prnsnkterce afof «junke·, pere cf qun knans`te afktrepfknrce e ftre v`fcnka`e «oece·.
]uns cf qun nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e cnd`t`oe ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec y pnro`tn hns`dkerce afof
«junke· ns tfhe nste l`aa`ñk, tfhe nste nsank`l`aea`ñk. Nstf kf s`dk`l`ae qun nste
nsank`l`aea`ñk sne uke pure l`aa`ñk. Hn bnabf pertn hn nste l`aa`ñk ns uke  l`aa`ñk rnec`zehe.
rnec`zehe.
Afof vnrnofs tfhe nste cñd`ae hn ce fauctea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec, hn su `hnkt`l`aea`ñk
afof «junke· f «oece·, ns ce acevn pere nktnkhnr ces oek`pucea`fkns hnc nspnatåaucf, hn cfs
onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk, hn ces rnhns sfa`ecns, nk suoe, hn ce prfpedekhe `opnr`ec. Kf ns
oås qun ce onaåk`ae sear`l`a`ec nk ce qun sn be jesehf nc pfhnr hnshn qun nc bfojrn ns
bfojrn.
Ce v`fcnka`e `kbnrnktn ec hfo`k`f kfs ccnve e ce aunst`ñk hn ce cndec`heh y ce ar`o`kec`heh. Nc
`opnr`f ns pfr hnl`k`a`ñk ar`o`kec, pnrf knans`te nkaujr`r nste ar`o`kec`heh pere cnd`t`oersn.
cnd`t` oersn.
Ec o`sof t`nopf qun ns nste v`fcnka`e, f onifr, su bej`c`heh pere eho`k`strerce, cf qun
vnrhehnreonktn cf cnd`t`oe, ec oerdnk hn ces rntñr`aes hn ce tnfrïe hnc hnrnabf. Ce
afopc`a`heh hnc `opnr`f afk ce ar`o`kec`heh, ce lfroe nkauj`nrte afof nste afopc`a`heh sn
prfhuan, sfk afoukns e ce pfcït`ae y e ce rnc`d`ñk. Cfs cïhnrns, cfs bàrfns, cfs h`fsns, cf sfk
prna`seonktn pfrqun sfk treksdrnsfrns hn cfs tejùns f hn ces cnyns, pnrf treksdrnsfrns
«junkfs·. Ec bejcer hnc `opnr`f bfy bejceofs ec o`sof t`nopf hn uk lnkñonkf pfcït`af y
rnc`d`fsf, ehnoås hn ofrec. Ce ar`o`kec`heh `opnr`ec bfy kf nstå nkaerkehe tektf 
5< 
nk l`dures bnrf`aes f ofkårqu`aes f h`v`kes afof nk cfs prfp`fs onaek`sofs hnc aep`tec.

]nrf ce cñd`ae
Q`k nstes årneshn ce ar`o`kec`heh
fpeaes, `kbnrnktnececoerdnk
snarntes, `opukns, pfhnr ns
hnceceo`soe.
cndec`heh, kf sn punhn nktnkhnr nc
`opnr`f bfy. Ce nstruature hn ce ar`o`kec`heh `opnr`ec kf ns c`knec. Kf afks`stn nk uke cïkne
nk ce qun nc oec f nc ar`onk sn s`tùek nk uk nxtrnof y nc j`nk f ce cny sn s`tùek nk nc ftrf. Qn
trete hn uke nstruature oås afopcnie, tec qun ce ar`o`kec`heh etrev`nse eojes rnd`fkns, y sn
punhn suj-h`v`h`r e vfcukteh nk uke ar`o`kec`heh
ar` o`kec`heh «oece· y uke ar`o`kec`heh «junke·. Ces
ectes nslnres hnc pfhnr sfk nk nsnka`e tek ar`o`kecns afof cfs ar`o`kecns «oecfs·, afk ce
h`lnrnka`e hn qun punhnk ofvnr e vfcukteh ce cïkne rfie qun snpere nc «j`nk· y nc «oec·, y
prnsnktersn hn nste oeknre afof ar`o`kecns «junkfs·, e trevàs hn h`vnrses lfroes hn
snarnt`sof, nkaujr`o`nktf n `opuk`heh qun sn nkaunktrek oås eccå hn ce cndec`heh.
Qn trete nk hnl`k`t`ve hn ce nstruature sear`l`a`ec, puns ns prna`seonktn nc onaek`sof
sear`l`a`ec nc qun, eho`k`strehf pfr nc `opnr`f, treze ce cïkne qun snpere ec treksdrnsfr «oecf·
hnc treksdrnsfr «junkf·, ec v`ccekf hnc bàrfn, ec bnrnin hnc sektf, e ce vïat`oe sear`l`a`ec hn ce
h`v`k`heh. ]nrf kf ns sfcf nc `opnr`f, nk nc snkt`hf afkarntf hnc tàro`kf, nc qun prfhuan nste
snperea`ñk, s`kf nc `opnr`f nk nc snkt`hf uj`auf hnc tàro`kf9 nc `opnr`f nk aehe ukf hn
kfsftrfs. ]frqun cf qun aereatnr`ze e ce h`kåo`ae sear`l`a`ec ns qun pert`a`peofs tfhfs nk
ncce.
Nk suoe, nstn `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk uj`auf ns lukheonktec pfrqun t`nkn nc pfhnr hn
h n ofvnr nstes
cïknes, 
:0
 

hn oek`pucer ce. pnranpa`ñk hnc «j`nk· y hnc «oec·, hn nsank`l`aer sear`l`a`fs onh`åt`afs, hn
hns`dker e ces vïat`oes y e cfs vnrhudfs fl`a`ecns. @ks`st`ofs, nste h`onks`ñk sear`l`a`ec ns
arua`ec pere nktnkhnr nc pfhe nk dnknrec, pnrf nspna`econktn nc pfhnr `opnr`ec bfy nk uk
afktnxtf nk nc qun cf nspnateaucer y cf onh`åt`ah sfk ofonktfs lukheonktecns hnc pfhnr, nk
uk afki tnxtf nk nc qun ce l`aa`fkec`zea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e ns uk7 hn ces lfroes lukheonktecns hn
su ninra`a`f. Nk ftre9 pecejres, jfy Bfccywffh nkaerke ce rnc`d`ñk sear`l`a`e aep`tec`ste afk tekte
t ekte
l` kecns f cfs eutfs hn ln.  
nl`aea`e afof nk ftrfs t`nopfs c b`a`nrfk cfs iu`a`fs l`kecns
54  

`
  l`aa`ñk hnc c`jnrec`sof 
Ce
Ce tnkhnka`e `opnr`ec hnc aep`tec`sof ns afkvnrt`r ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn nk rncea`fkns hn
hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste. Nk ftres pecejres, afkvnrt`r aehe vnz oås tfhf nk onraekaïes y nk
`ktnraeoj`fs onraekt`cns y beanr hn nccf nc ràd`onk hn hfo`kea`ñk pr`ka`pec. Hn oeknre qun
uke hn ces acevns hn nstn hfo`k`f ns prnsnkter cfs `ktnraeoj`fs onraekt`cns afof c`jrns, qun
àstfs cf pernzaek. Nste ns uke hn ces l`aa`fkns lukheonktecns hnc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste. Nste ns
ce l`aa`ñk hnc c`jnrec`sof. 
Hn cf qun sn trete ns hn faucter qun ce c`jnrteh hn ces onraekaïes sn fjt`nkn ec prna`f hn ce
pàrh`he hn ce c`jnrteh hn ces pnrsfkes, f pere snr oås nxeatf, qun cf qun sn deke nk ces
rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes sn p`nrhn nk ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. Pe bnofs ofstrehf añof ce c`jnrteh
`kh`v`huec ns nk nsnka`e uke l`aa`ñk aep`tec`ste. Nc s`stnoe knans`te `kh`v`hufs cf oås
«c`jrns·, cf oås «c`jnrehfs· qun sne pfs`jcn afk rnspnatf e sus afouk`hehns, e sus auctures,
e sus treh`a`fkns, e su keturecnze, pere qun punhnk afkvnrt`rsn nk trejeiehfrns oås
c`jrnonktn nxpcftejcns y nk afksuo`hfrns afk oås c`jnrteh pere afksuo`r, nk arnynktns oås
vfcukter`fsfs nk nc s`stnoe. Ce «c`jnrteh· qun prfaceoe ce prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe 
15
 

ns uke c`jnrteh l`at`a`e, uk suanhåknf hn ce vnrhehnr7 c`jnrteh qun knanser`eonktn ns uk


afopfknktn hn 5 afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. Nk nstn afktnxtf bey qun nktnkhn ce epernktn c`jnrea`ñk,
qun nk rnec`heh ns ce c`jnrec`ze a`ñk, hn ces afstuojrns, ce ofrec y ce snxuec`heh. Hn e` qun ce
bfofsnxuec`heh sne bfy, kf sfcf ecdf e rnspnte s`kf teoj`àk e ecejer, pfrqun ns ce
vekduerh`e hn uk tnkhnka`e e ce hnsketurec`zea`ñk hn ce v`he nk ce qun s jese nc s`stnoe, e ce
hnsv`kaucea`ñk hn ce snxuec`heh hn ce c e lnrt`c`heh y su snkt`hf prflukhf.
Nste «c`jnrteh· ns uke lecse c`jnrteh
c` jnrteh pfrqun nstå sn ont`he ec s`stnoe, pfrqun kf aunst`fke nk
prflukh9 heh su cñd`ae hn hfo`kea`ñk. Hn tfhf nccf be bejceh Inek Jeuhr`ccerh afk drek
cua`hnz. Q` nc `opnr`f afr anhn epernktnonktn c`jnrtehns ns pfrqun sn jnknl`a` hn nccf. Nk
ftres pecejres, tres ce epernktn c`jnrteh
c`j nrteh 7 nsafkhnk onaek`sofs sn suo`s`ñk ec s`stnoe oås
pra lukhfs. Ce vnrhehnre c`jnrteh suncn vnk`r eafopeõea hnc hnsaràh`tf, ce hnofk`zea`ñk f
ce ar`o`kec`zea`ñ pfr pertn hnc `opnr`f, qun prntnkhn esï afktnknr 3 afkted`f hn h`abe
c`jnrteh nk ftrfs.
]nrf teoj`àk ce c`jnrteh hn ofv`o`nktf hn ces on9 aekaïes y hn cfs aep`tecns ns uke l`aa`ñk,
tek lecez afre ce hn ce c`jnrteh hn cfs `kh`v`hufs. Nc ràd`onk aep`tec`s te afks`stn nk afkvnrt`r
e ces pnrsfkes nk onraekaïe sne afof prfhuatfrns f afof afksuo`hfrns, puns n hnl`k`t`ve
ns nc `ktnraeoj`f onraekt`c y su ràd`onk a eauoucea`ñk nc qun hfo`ke ces rncea` rncea`fkns
fkns nk
dnknri `kacu`hes ces sfa`ecns. Ns hna`r, ces vnrhehnres rncea`a kns sfa`ecns nk nc ràd`onk
aep`tec`ste sfk ces hn ces on aekaïes7 ces rncea`fkns nktrn ces pnrsfkes sn jesek y 9 
1: 
supnh`tek e nstes rncea`fkns nktrn afses. Uun nstf sne esï pnrf pn rf qun kf cf pernzae ns ftre hn

ces l`aa`fkns
oeknre hncsn
nk qun s`stnoe.
ninran ncNshfo`k`f
`opfrtektn
nk ncnktnkhnr nste sut`cnze,
aep`tec`sof, pfrqun
tektf ec k`vnc hn ns prna`seonktn
ce prfhuaa`ñk ce ec
afof
hnc afksuof. Ns ce rndce hn frf pere afoprnkhnr beste quà puktf ce nafkfoïe aep`tec`ste ns
pfcït`ae.
]ere nktnkhnr nstn hfo`k`f hn ces onraekaïes sfjrn ces pnrsfkes ‘nk hnl`k`t`ve, hn ces
rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes sfjrn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn‘ ns knanser`f afoprnkhnr ce kfa`ñk hn
afopnksea`ñk. ]fhnofs h`v`h`r nc afkiuktf hn s`tuea`fkns qun sn hek nk nc snkf hnc
k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk.
ràd`onk aep`tec`ste nk hfs t`pfs9 equncces qun sn s`tùek pfr nka`oe hnc k`vnc hn
afopnksea`ñk, y equncces qun sn s`tùek pfr hnjeif.
hnjeif. Nc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk ns equnc nk nc
qun sn prfhuan nc nqu`c`jr`f nktrn nc hfo`k`f y ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. Equnc pfr nka`oe hnc
auec afopnkse, y pfr hnjeif hnc auec kf afopnkse, cf qun ces rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes epfrtek afk
rnspnatf e cf qun rnstek hn afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn.
Kf bejceofs hn afopnksea`ñk nk uk snkt`hf nafkño`af nstr`atf s`kf nk uk snkt`hf kf
auekt`l`aejcn, sujint`vf, ps`afcñd`af, puns nk hnl`k`t`ve sn trete hn pfknr nk cfs hfs pcetfs hn
ce jecekze ncnonktfs `kafkonksurejcns. Ns ftre lfroe hn `kafrpfrer, afof prfpusf
TÓbnco Zn`ab, nc leatfr sujint`vf ec oetnr`ec`sof fjint`vf oerx`ste. Nk ftres pecejres, pfr
hnjeif hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk nc hfo`k`f prnvecnan sfjrn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, nc prfansf
hn eauoucea`ñk hnstruyn oås afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn qun ces lfroes hn rncea`ñk aep`tec`ste
aep`tec `ste qun
afkstruyn. ]fr nc afktrer`f, pfr nka`oe 
52
 

hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk nc ràd`onk afkstruyn oå lfroes hn rncea`ñk aep`tec`ste qun ces
lfroes hn afkv` vnka`e-c`jrn qun hnstruyn. F j`nk kf rnqu`nrn hnstruï_ f punhn afksnrver
oås lfroes hn afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. N hna`r, pfr
 pfr nka`oe hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk sn nkaunk
trek cfs hfo`kehfrns, y pfr hnjeif cfs hfo`kehfs7 pf nka`oe cfs qun ninrank ce v`fcnka`e
nstruaturec, eukqu sne hn oeknre `kafksa`nktn, y pfr hnjeif cfs qun ce pe hnank. Nk ftres
pecejres, e cfs qun nståk pfr hnjei hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk, kf cns afopnkse nc prfans hn
trekslfroea`ñk aep`tec`ste7 o`nktres qun e cfs qu nståk s`tuehfs  pfr nka`oe, afopnkse. 
nka`oe, s`cns afopnkse.
Nste afopnksea`ñk ns nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, afo hna`ofs, sujint`ve, `opfs`jcn hn onh`r nk
tàro`ka fjint`vfs, puns nk hnl`k`t`ve afks`stn nk afoperer hn nsteh`fs afksnaut`vfs hnc
prfansf hn trekslfroea`ñ aep`tec`ste, hfs nsteh`fs nk cfs qun ces prfpfra`fkns nc
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn y rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes verïek. Nc hnl`k`t`ve sn trete hn afoperer ce
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn af nc hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste, nk tektf qun prfansf, y nk h`st`ï V tfs åoj`tfs hnc
s`stnoe. Afof bnofs v`stf ce nsnka` hnc prfansf `opnr`ec aep`tec`ste afks`stn nk hnstru`r lf`
oes hn afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn e aeoj`f hn arner lfroes h rncea`ñk onraekt`c. Nk ftres pecejres,
nk sust`tu`r v`h y c`jnrteh ‘`kh`v`huecns y sfa`ecns, keturecns y aucture cns ‘ oås
nqu`c`jrehes, pfr ftres lfroes hn rncea`ñk n ces qun prnvecnan ce hfo`kea`ñk, y ce v`he y ce
c`jnrte pesek e snr suanhåknfs. Lfroes hn rncea`ñk aep`tec`s
aep`tec` s nk ces qun cfs hnsnqu`c`jr`fs kf
sfcf kf sn afopnksï s`kf qun t`nkhnk e `karnonktersn afof onaek`sofs a hfo`kea`ñk
s`stào`afs. Nk hnl`k`t`ve, sn trete hn afr 
18 
vnrt`r v`he y c`jnrteh
c `jnrteh oås eutàkt`aes, oås `ktndrecns, oås sfstnk`jcns, oås hurehnres, nk
suanhåknfs
ns ftre hn cesoås l`at`a`fs,nktrn
h`lnrnka`es oås pera`ecns,
nc hfo`k`foås
y ce`ksfstnk`jcns, oås prfv`s`fkecns.
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn9 Nk nlnatf,
nc hfo`k`f t`nkhn nste
e dnknrer
oås y oås hnsnqu`c`jr`fs, oås y oås es`ontrïes, e cf cerdf hn nspnatrfs s`stào`afs oås
eopc`fs7 o`nktres qun ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn t`nkhn ec oåx`of hn nqu`c`jr`f e k`vnc cfaec. Qfcf
bey qun afoperer auåktf bek nvfcua`fkehf ces a`v`c`zea`fkns prnaep`tec`stes, e tfhfs cfs
k`vncns, e cf cerdf hn
h n o`cnk`fs, y auåktf cf bek bnabf ces aep`tec`stes,
aep` tec`stes, nk tek sfcf hfs f trns
s`dcfs, pere nktnkhnr hn quà nsteofs bejcekhf.
Nc `]bfkn f nc `]eh
` ]eh sfk ninopcfs ouy afkarntfs hn nste cñd`ae hn sust`tua`ñk hn ce rnec`heh
hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn pfr ce psnuhfrnec`heh hn cfs `ktnraeoj`fs aep`tec`stes. Nstfs
h`spfs`t`vfs ‘nsteh`fs prnv`fs bea`e ce `opcektea`ñk dnknrec`zehe hn o`arfab`ps f kekf-
ab`ps nk nc dekehf buoekf
buoekf‘ epernktek afknaterkfs afk tfhf7 pnrf cf qun beank nk rnec`heh
ns snpererkfs hnc oukhf rnec qun kfs rfhne.
Qn punhn fjsnrver equï ftre hn ces h`onks`fkns l`at`a`es hnc s`stnoe, fjintf lukheonktec hn
ce prfpedekhe. Nk nlnatf, nc eperetf hn prfpedekhe t`nkn afof ftrf hn sus afont`hfs
lukheonktecns beanrkfs arnnr nste l`aa`ñk. Afkvnkanrkfs hn qun afopnkse, hn qun onrnan ce
pnke tfhf cf qun pnrhnofs hn afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn e aeoj`f hn tfhf cf qun dekeof dekeofss afk ces rnce-
a`fkns aep`tec`stes. Nk hnl`k`t`ve9 qun nc h`knrf punhn afoprercf tfhf. Ce prfpedekhe hnjn
beanrkfs arnnr qun nsteofs pfr nka`oe hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk, 
50
 

afk `khnpnkhnka`e hn auåc sne kunstre s`tuea`ñk rnec hnjn oek`pucer kunstre pnranpa`ñk. Ce
oek`pucea`ñ` hn nste pnranpa`ñk sn afkv`nrtn nk uk tnrrnkf hn jete c`e lukheonktec nk nc qun
nc s`stnoe hnjn cnd`t`oers` pere ce oeyfrïe. Qn trete hn beanrkfs arnnr qun nc s`s tnoe nk su
afkiuktf kfs ccnve f kfs ccnverå e tfhf7 o`cedrfseonktn e nstn pereïsf. Nc pereïsf hn ces rnc`
d`fkns treh`a`fkecns, pnrf nste vnz pereïsf nk ce X`nrre Nstn ns nc sunõf eonr`aekf. Ec t`nopf
qun kfs hnj ofstrer, pnrf sfcf sncnat`veonktn, r`tueconktn ‘pun nk hnl`k`t`ve s`dun s`nkhf
ce cñd`ae hn ce l`aa`ñk sear` l`a`ec‘ nc `kl`nrkf pere uke o`kfrïe. Xeoj`àk `kl`nrk nk ce X`nrre.
Qn afoprnkhnrå ebfre pfr quà nstn k` vnc hn afopnksea`ñk y su oek`pucea`ñk sujint`ve pf
pertn hn ce prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe ns acevn pere nktnk hnr añof sn vnkhn ce l`aa`ñk hnc àx`tf
y ce l`aa`ñk h` prfdrnsf.
Nc s`stnoe aep`tec`ste afks`stn nk uke nkfron lud bea`e hncektn qun trete hn nsafkhnr su
nsnka`e hnstruh t`ve y nkoesaerer nste hnstruaa`ñk afk su afkstrua a`ñk l`at`a`e, ert`l`a`ec.
Nste hnstruaa`ñk dnknre `kku onrejcns prfjcnoes qun nc s`stnoe prntnkhn rnsfcvnr trevàs hn
onaek`sofs aep`tec`stes, cf qun kukae afks` dun pfr afopcntf. ]frqun ce vnrhehnre nsnka`e
hnc s`s tnoe ns ce hnstruaa`ñk y nc hnsnqu`c`jr`f, ce l`aa`ñk
l`a a`ñk h qun nstfs prfjcnoes punhnk snr
rnsunctfs afk cfs `ks truk`nktfs hnc onraehf. Cfs prfjcnoes sfcf sn sfb a`fkek hn oeknre
epernktn, nkoesaeråkhfcfs oås qu rnsfcv`àkhfcfs, prfvfaekhf e su vnz kunvfs prfjcn oes,
nk uk aïraucf v`a`fsf `ktnro`kejcn qun kfs etrepet rep e tfhfs. Beste qun ce lerse kf punhn hurer
oås... 
1< 
Xfhf nccf, `ks`st`ofs, nk jesn e uke cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec qun treksl`nrn f nxtnrkec`ze cfs
prfjcnoes hnc pfcf
kfs vnkhn afof hnc hfo`k`f
sfcua`fkns ec nk
cf qun pfcf hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn.
rnec`heh sfk onaek`sofs hn Ce trekslnrnka`e
prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe
hn prfjcn-
oes, e ftrfs prfjcnoes, f e ftres s`tuea`fkns onkfs pr`v`cnd`ehes
pr`v`c nd`ehes hnc s`stnoe. Nstf cf
nxacuyn `ktnka`fkeheonktn hn su pepnc afkabà
afkabà pere qun kf pnra`jeofs ce vnrhehnre nsnka`e
hn h`abfs onaek`sofs. Nk ftres pecejres, nc s`stnoe nxtren
nx tren r`qunze ‘v`he y c`jnrteh vnr-
hehnres‘ hnc pfcf `klnr`fr, qun
q un trekslfroe nk h`knrf ‘qun punhn afoprer v`he y c`jnrteh,
pnrvnrt`hes nk nc prfp`f prfansf hn ce afopre‘, h`knrf qun a`rauce bea`e nc pfcf supnr`fr,
beste eauoucersn hn oeknre ejnrrektn. Esï, nk cuder hn sear`l`aer nste r`qunze l`at`a`e nk
lfroe hn «destf `oprfhuat`vf· (Dnfrdns Jete`ccn), afof tektes a`v`c`zea`fkns bek sej`hf
beanr, ce andunre aep`tec`ste ces rn`kv`nrtn prfhuat`veonktn nk ce vfråd`kn hnc s`stnoe, nk
uke nsp`rec `ktnro`kejcn y hnc`rektn qun kf bean oås qun euonkter ce v`fcnka`e y ce aucpe
`kafksa`nktns (Tectnr Jnkieoïk).
]nrf vfcveofs e ce l`aa`ñk hnc c`jnrec`sof. Nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste supfkn afkh`a`fkns
es`oàtr`aes hn pert`he ‘ces hn ce eauoucea`ñk pr`o`t`ve‘ qun sn rnprfhuank n `karnonktek
prfdrns`veonktn, y qun hn cnabf beank aehe vnz oås `opfs`jcn nc «c`jrn· onraehf. Cf
o`sof e tfhfs cfs k`vncns9 nktrn nc noprnser`f y nc trejeiehfr, nktrn nc vnkhnhfr y nc
afoprehfr, nktrn nc earnnhfr y nc hnuhfr. Nc c`jrn afonra`f, afof ù prna`f iustf, kf ns oås
qun uke ejstreaa`ñk, uke s`tuea`ñk `hnec qun kukae sn ecaekze pfr afopcntf nk 
:=
 

ce onh`he nk qun ces


c es afkh`a`fkns hn hfo`k`f sfk es` oàtr`aes, nk ce onh`he nk qun nx`stn uk
`opnr`f y ur kf-`opnr`f. Qfcf bey qun fjsnrver auecqu`nre hn ce7 cïknes hn lr`aa`ñk hnc
`opnr`f y hnc kf-`opnr`f, e auec qu`nr k`vnc, pere nktnkhnr beste quà puktf nc afonr a`ñ kf
sfcf kukae ns «c`jrn·, s`kf qun ns hn bnabf b dunrre pfr ftrfs onh`fs. ]fr nc afktrer`f, nk ces
zfke9 oås pea`l`aehes, nk cfs anktrfs, eccï hfkhn hfo`ke n `opnr`f hnshn bean tektf t`nopf
qun ye sn be pnrh`ha ce afksa`nka`e hn nstn hfo`k`f, ce arnnka`e dnknrec`ze he ns qun cfs
`ktnraeoj`fs onraekt`cns sfk c`jrns, qu nx`stn ecdf tec afof nc prna`f iustf. ]nrf s` nstf ns es9
`ks`st`ofs, ns pfrqun nk nstes s`tuea`fkns hfo`ke a- a-`opnr`f, pfrqun kfs nkafktreofs pfr
nka`oe hnc k`va hn afopnksea`ñk, pfrqun ce prfpedekhe aep`tec`ste n aepez hn nkoesaerer
su hfo`k`f. Nstf sn afks`dun, n junke onh`he, fauctekhf y nxtnrkec`zekhf nste v`f cnka`e
bea`e s`tuea`fkns oås hnslevfrna`hes, equncce qun nståk pfr hnjeif
hnjeif hnc k`vnc hn
afopnksea`ñk.
Xfhf `ktnraeoj`f onraekt`c fsa`ce nktrn hfs pfcf7 nc c`jrn `ktnraeoj`f y nc sequnf. Xfhf
afonra`f ns, nc hnl`k`t`ve, nk uk drehf oeyfr f onkfr, uke lfroe h pea`l`aea`ñk, uke
s`tuea`ñk afyukturec nk ce qun nc se qunf kf cn afopnkse e ce pertn oås pfhnrfse, pnrf n ce
qun sn s`dun s`rv`nkhf hn nstn afof
a fof eonkeze per `opfknr afkh`a`fkns hn kndfa`ea`ñk y hn
`ktnraeoj` hnsnqu`c`jrehes e su levfr. Ns hna`r, tfhf `ktnraeoj` onraekt`c supfkn, nk oeyfr f
onkfr drehf, uke afea a`ñk. Auekhf bejceofs hn afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn nsteoa teoj`àk t eoj`àk
bejcekhf hn `ktnraeoj`f c`jrn, pnrf nk nc vn` hehnrf snkt`hf hnc tàro`kf9 `ktnraeoj`f c`jrn
nk nc snr 
12 

t`hf nk qun
snkt`hf nstnhnsnonraekaïes
bejcer `ksar`jn nkpfr
ukequncñd`ae
cfs hn `ktnraeoj`f
j`nkns oåsnk
sn `ksar`jnk dnknrec y nk nc qun
uk afopcnif kf t`nkn
hn rncea`fkns
oås eopc`f qun kf punhn rnhua`rsn e ce nqu`vecnka`e hnc vecfr hn aeoj`f. Ns cf qun Inek
Jeuhr`ccerh be cceoehf «`ktnraeoj`f s`ojñc`af·.
\fcv`nkhf e ce kfa`ñk hn k`vnc
k `vnc hn afopnksea`ñk, ces s`tuea`fkns pfr nka`oe hn h`abf k`vnc
sfk equncces qun ninrank su hfo`k`f sfjrn ces s`tuea`fkns pfr hnjeif hnc k`vnc, y nk
afksnaunka`e punhnk `opfknr afkh`a`fkns hn `ktnraeoj`f qun cns sfk levfrejcns. Esï, nk
dnknrec, ces s`tuea`fkns pfr hnjeif
hnjeif hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk sfk equncces sfont`hes ec
hfo`k`f hn ces pr`onres, y pfr cf c f tektf e afkh`a`fkns hn `ktnraeoj`f hnslevfrejcns. Nstes
h`st`ka`fkns sn hek nk tfhf nc s`stnoe y nk h`st`ktes nsaeces. Hn kunvf bey qun nktnkhnr cfs
tàro`kfs levfrejcn y hnslevfrejcn
hnslevfrejcn nk nc snkt`hf oås eopc`f, afof afopnksea`ñk hn ncnonktfs
`kafkonksurejcns. ]uns nk hnl`k`t`ve hn cf qun nsteofs bejcekhf ns hn pfknr nk cfs pcetfs
hn ce jecekze ncnonktfs hn h`st`ktf frhnk. Afktrepnser, uke vnz oås, vnrhehnres c`jnrtehns,
vnrhehnre v`he, afk sus suanhåknfs, afk sus l`aa`fkns. \nofs equï ftre vnz beste quà puktf
nc aep`tec`sof kf sn punhn rnhua`r e lfroucea`fkns auekt`tet`ves, añof nk àc ns arua`ec nste
kfa`ñk hn l`aa`ñk.
Nc o`tf hnc c`jnrec`sof y hnc knfc`jnrec`sof sn `ksar`jn nk nste cñd`ae. Nc c`jnrec`sof y nc
knfc`jnrec`sof sfk nk hnl`k`t`ve nulno`sofs qun nsafkhnk qun nk nc oeraf dnknrec hn ce
«c`jnrteh· hn ofv`o`nktfs aep`tec`stes, cfs pfhnrfsfs punhek `opfknr tfhe uke snr`n hn
onh`hes qun cns sfk jnknl`a`fses, 
:5
 

tecns afof cnd`scea`fkns, rnducea`fkns, sujvnka`fkns, `ktnrvnka`fkns, oek`pucea`fkns,


ofkfpfc`fs, nta. Nstf ns cf qun sn nsafkhn hntrås hn ce oåsaere hnc c`jrn `ktnraeoj`f. Nstf ns
cf qun nstå nk nc treslfkhf hn cfs cceoehfs tretehfs hn «c`jrn· afonra`f qun nc `opnr`f nstå
bfy `opfk`nkhf hn lfroe afeat`ve y nkauj`nrte pere qun snek eprfjehfs pfr ces oer`fkntes
pfcït`aes.
Cf `opfrtektn ns nktnkhnr qun nktrn nc pfcf hnc c`jrn afonra`f y nc hnc sequnf kf bey
h`safkt`ku`heh, qun eojfs sn hek nk ecduke onh`he nk tfhf `ktnraeoj`f. Qn trete hn ce
o`soe h`kåo`ae afk h`st`ktfs drehfs hn `ktnks`heh oås anrae hn uk pfcf f hn ftrf. Esï bey
qun nktnkhnr ce afkfa`he nxprns`ñk hn Aer` vfk Aceusnw`tz9 «ce dunrre ns ce afkt`kuea`ñk hn
ce pfcït`ae pfr ftrfs onh`fs·, qun hn bnabf sn punhn `kvnrt`r, afof be bnabf O`abnc
Lfuaeuct, nk ce pfcït`ae ns ce afkt`kuea`ñk hn ce dunrre pfr ftrfs onh`fs. ]nrf teoj`àk nxtnkhnr e
ce nafkfoïe9 nc afonra`f ns ce afkt`kuea`ñk hn ce dunrre pfr ftrfs onh`fs. 
Xfhf nstf kfs pnro`tn afoprnkhnr qun nc aep`tec`sof, nk su prfp`e nsnka`e, kf sfcf ns uk
ràd`onk pfcït`af-nafkño`af, s`kf qun ns oås pfcït`af qun nafkño`af. Uun nk nc aep`tec`sof ce
nafkfoïe nstå supnh`tehe e ce dnfpfcït`ae y e ce pfcït`ae. P nstf e tfhfs cfs k`vncns. H`abf hn
ftre oeknre, cfs onaek`sofs nafkño`afs sfk s`noprn `kstruonktfs hn pfhnr. Q` e vnans vna ns kfs
pernan qun nstf kf ns esï, ns, afof bnofs ofstrehf, pfrqun sn trete hn s`tuea`fkns
nxanpa`fkecns nk ces qun ces afkh`a`fkns sn eanraek e ces hnc c`jrn onraehf. P pfrqun nste
pnranpa`ñk, nste arnnka`e, ns oek`pucehe pfr ce prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe. Nstn ns, hn kunvf, nc
l`aa`ñk. 
 pfhnr hn ce l`aa`ñk.
:: 

Nc `opnr`f hn
Znsuo`nkhf, ukecehnl`aa`ñk   pere nktnkhnr ce kf-7`ñk hn l`aa`ñk nk nstn trejeif, pere
ces acevns
nktnkhnr beste quà puktf nc hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste sn ninran e trevàs hn ce l`aa`ñk, ns añof ces
lfroes hn rncea`ñk aep`tec`ste h`l`nrnk pfr afopcntf hn ces lfroes hn afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn.
O`nktres qun ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, afof bnofs ofstrehf, ns nc rnsuctehf hn uk nqu`c`jr`f
v`tec, sfa`ec, aucturec, ofrec, ces rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes sn rnhuank e ce pure onraekt`c`zea`ñk
hn ce v`he, e ce sust`tua`ñk hn ce v`he y ce c`jnrteh vnrhehnres pfr sus suanhåknfs. Nste ns ce
jesn hn ce hfjcn ofrec, qun ns ce ofrec hfo`kektn nk nc `opnr`f, hn ce qun kfs faupernofs
oås ehncektn. Nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste supnrpfkn uke leabehe l`at`a`e e su nstruature hn
rncea`fkns onraekt`cns, afk ce `ktnka`ñk hn epernkter rncea`fkns
rnc ea`fkns ofrecns nktrn pnrsfkes qun
nk rnec`heh sn r`dnk sndùk ce kf-ofrec hn cfs `ktnraeoj`fs onraekt`cns, jesehfs nk ce rn`l`aea`ñk hn
ce v`he. Q` nc `opnr`f ns `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk ns pfrqun sn `opfkn nk junke onh`he bea`nkhf
peser nsfs suanhåknfs hn v`he y hn c`jnrteh pfr vnrhehnre afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. Hnc àx`tf qun
tnkde ce afkstruaa`ñk hn nste l`aa`ñk hnpnkhn nk junke onh`he su pfhnr. Cfs nafkfo`stes
qun cf 
85
 

rnhuank tfhf e kùonrfs fcv`hek qun nste h`onks`ñk pureonktn sujint`ve, qun sn ninran nk nc
åoj`tf hn ce aucture, hnc nspnatåaucf, hn cfs onh`fs, ns acevn pere ce hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec. Ns
cf qun kfs be nksnõehf, nktrn ftrfs, Duy Hnjfrh. Nk ftres pecejres, nc aep`tec`sof bfy kf sn
punhn nktnkhnr s`k Bfccywffh.
]nrf ce nxprns`ñk `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk hnjn nktnkhnrsn teoj`àk nk uk snkt`hf oås prflukhf.
Bnofs h`abf qun ce oeknre nk qun nc `opnr`f hfo`ke ns e trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e y hn su
eonkeze, y qun nstf kf ns ftre afse qun nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec. Nk nlnatf, hnshn cfs
frïdnkns hnc bfojrn nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec ns cec e jesn hnc afktrfc sfa`f-pfcït`af, ehnoås hn
rnc`d`fsf-ofrec, nc h`spfs`t`vf qun hnl`kn cfs cïo`tns hn ce c`jnrteh y hn ce v`he hn cfs
`kh`v`hufs nk nc snkf hn ces sfa`nhehns, nc qun rnduce cfs nqu`c`jr`fs nktrn treksdrns`fkns y
prfb`j`a`fkns, nktrn keturecnze y aucture, nktrn jïfs y zfà. Nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste kf bean
oås[ qun `kafrpfrer nk sus prfp`fs onaek`sofs nste h`kåo`ae sear`l`a`ec hn oeknre qun nc
s`stnoe, hn lfroe `opcïa`te, sear`l`qun sus ncnonktfs nxanhnkter`fs, h`sluka`fkecns,
h` sluka`fkecns, fjsfcntfs7
equnccfs qun sn rns`stnk f h`l`auctek ce rnprfhuaa`ñk hnc s`stnoe. Nstfs ncnonktfs `kacuynk
tektf pnrsfkes afof afses, pfrqun nc sear`l`a`f hn ces pnrsfkes afo`nkze prna`seonktn pfr
su rn`l`aea`ñk.
Nc s`stnoe cndec y pnkec, afof nc afkiuktf hnc Nstehf, kf ns oås qun uk onaek`sof
supnh`tehf ec frhnk aep`tec`ste. Afof bek ofstrehf Tectnr Jnkieo`k y D`frd`f Edeojnk nc
Nstehf hn hnrnabf s`noprn aunkte afk ce pfs`j`c`heh hn snr suspnkh`hf y rnhua`hf e ns 
:1 
tehf hn nxanpa`ñk. Qn punhn hna`r qun nc Nstehf hn hnrnabf ns ce nxanpa`ñk qun, nk
afkh`a`fknsns
`opfrtektn levfrejcns, sn he
hnsteaer qun ce nk nc snkf
pfcït`ae nstå ce rndce qunenscencnafkfoïe,
hnsupnh`tehe nstehf hnqun
nxanpa`ñk. Cf hn
ces kfa`fkns
Nstehf hn hnrnabf y nstehf hn nxanpa`ñk, esï afof tfhf nc eperetf hnc Nstehf, nståk
supnh`tehes, nk nc afktnxtf hnc ràd`onk
ràd` onk aep`tec`ste, ec frhnk nafkño`af, l`keka`nrf y of-
knter`f. Q` cfs onraehfs bek nx`st`hf hnshn h nshn bean o`cnk`fs pnrf kf nc aep`tec`sof ns pfrqun
nktfkans tfhevïe nx`stïek lunrzes hn frhnk pfcït`af, rnc`d`fsf, ofrec, qun `opnhïek qun nstn n stn
hfo`kere. ]fr nc afktrer`f, uke vnz `ksteurehf nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste, cf nafkño`af supnh`te
nc rnstf hn ñrhnkns, y nk pert`aucer nc pfcït`af, qun pese esï e nster e su snrv`a`f. Nc Nstehf
jurduàs, hnshn sus frïdnkns, nstå ec snrv`a`f hnc frhnk aep`tec`ste.
aep`tec` ste. Qn punhn el`roer, nk nstn
snkt`hf, qun ce pfcït`ae ns ftre hn ces
c es l`aa`fkns hnc aep`tec`sof. 
Nc hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste, sne e trevàs hn sus onaek`sofs f hnc eux`c`f afyukturec hn ce pfcït`ae
y nc hnrnabf, sn `opfkn nk jesn e ce v`fcnka`e y su eonkeze7 nk ftres pecejres, e trevàs hn
onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec. Nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec ns `ksnperejcn hn ce l`aa`ñk, puns nk ùct`oe
`ksteka`e sn jese nk ce afkstruaa`ñk l`at`a`e hn ce h`st`ka`ñk y ce snperea`ñk nktrn «junkfs· y
«oecfs·, nk ce v`kaucea`ñk hnc «oec· y ce aucpe, nk ce trekslnrnka`e hnc oec y ce aucpe
sfa`ecns uj`aufs e ab`vfs nxp`etfr`fs afkarntfs nspna`econktn hns`dkehfs pere tec l`k. Nk
nstn snkt`hf bey qun nktnkhnr, teoj`àk, ce nxprns`ñk `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk, nk ce onh`he nk qun
su hfo`k`f ns ninra`hf e trevàs hn
h n l`aa`fkns sear`l`a`ecns. 
81
 

Ce l`aa`ñk hnc h`knrf  


^ke hn ces l`aa`fkns lukheonktecns hnc s`stnoe ns nc h`knrf. Afof bnofs ofstrehf, nc
ràd`onk hn hfo`kea`ñk aep`tec`ste sn jese nk nxtrenr r`qunze hnc pfcf hfo`kehf y
trekslfroerce nk h`knrf nxankhnkter`f qun a`rauce bea`e y sn eauouce nk nc pfcf hfo`kehfr.
Nc h`knrf ns ut`c`zehf pere afoprer suanhåknfs hn v`he y hn c`jnrteh ‘vnrs`fkns l`at`a`es hn
ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, qun nc prfp`f s`stnoe hnstruyn‘7 pnrf su vnrhehnrf afont`hf ns, e
trevàs hn cfs onaek`sofs nafkño`afs, snr vnbïaucf hn ce hfo`kea`ñk. Hn oeknre qun nc

h`knrf hnsnopnõe
hnl`k`t`ve ukafklukh`r
afks`stn nk pepnc anktrec, e tfhfs
ce r`qunze afk cfs k`vncns,
nc h`knrf. nk ns
Nstf beanr arnnr
cf qun kfsnste
n ste l`aa`ñk,
nksnõñ cf qunnknk
Cnss`kd
Ketbek nc Qej`f. Hn eaunrhf afk kunstrf pcektneo`nktf, pfr cf tektf, ce vnrhehnre r`qunze ns
nsn afopcnif nqu`c`jrehf hn c`jnrteh y v`he ‘`kh`v`huec y afcnat`ve, keturec y aucturec ‘. Nc
h`knrf, pfr nc afktrer`f, kf punhn afoprer oås qun ncnonktfs snperehfs y lredonkter`fs hn
nse rnec`heh afopcnie y v`tec, puns sfcf punhn beanrcf trekslfroåkhfcfs nk ncnonktfs
`khnpnkh`nktns, h`v`s`jcns, auekt`l`aejcns, nkeinkejcns, nk hnl`k`t`ve, nk onraekaïes y vecfrns
v ecfrns
hn 
:8
 

aeoj`f. Nk uk sndukhf t`nopf nstfs ncnonktfs nkeinkehfs punhnk vfcvnr e lfroer pertn hn
kunvfs nktns, qun kf sfk ftre afse qun ofkstrufs qun ce prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe prntnkhn
vnkhnrkfs afof ecdf v`vf, pnrf qun sfcf sfk suanhåknfs hn v`he. Nc h`knrf iunde uk pepnc
lukheonktec nk nste trekslfroea`ñk, nk nste lecs`l`aea`ñk, puns eatùe afof `ktnronh`er`f
arnekhf ce `cus`ñk hn qun ces onraekaïes vecnk cf qun aunstek, bea`àkhfkfs arnnr ‘nste ns ce
rnc`d`fs`heh aep`tec`ste‘ qun nc h`knrf punhn afoprercf tfhf (Dnfrd Q`oonc).
Ce l`aa`ñk hnc h`knrf sn rncea`fke afk ce lerse hnc c`jrn afonra`f hn ce qun bnofs bejcehf.
@ks`st`ofs, nc prna`f hn ces onraekaïes afktr`juyn e arner ce `cus`ñk hn qun nstes vecnk cf qun aunstek.
]nrf nc s`stnoe hn nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze qun nstå nk ce jesn hn ce dekeka`e aep`tec`ste kf sn
sfstnkhrïe s` kf lunsn pedekhf ec trejeiehfr onkfs hn cf qun aunste su trejeif y vnkh`nkhf
ces onraekaïes oås aeres hn su vnrhehnrf vecfr. Cf qun nstå nk nc treslfkhf hn tfhe nste
l`aa`ñk hnc c`jrn onraehf y hnc prna`f iustf ns qun cfs `ktnraeoj`fs onraekt`cns nkoesaerek
ce afeaa`ñk qun, nk oeyfr f onkfr drehf, cfs eafopeõe. Nstn nkoesaereo`nktf ns nc qun
prfhuan nc lnkñonkf hnc lnt`ab`sof hn ce c e onraekaïe. Ns seh`sof sujc`oehf.
Ce l`aa`ñk hnc h`knrf sn punhn tnkser tektf afof ce sfa`nheh punhe eduekter nste afeaa`ñk.
Nste s`tuea`ñk cïo`tn ns ce qun nsteofs v`v`nkhf bfy. Xek `opfrtektns hn aere e ce rnvfcua`ñk
qun v`nkn sfk ces acesns oås jeies qun t`nknk h`l`auctehns hn sujs`stnka`e afof ces acesns
onh`es `kh`dkehes ektn nc lreuhn s`stào`af hnc qun sfk aehe vnz oås afksa`nktns. 
:> 
Ce arnea`ñk hn h`knrf l`at`a`f nk nc pfcf supnr`fr kf bean oås qun `ktnks`l`aer ce prns`ñk qun
cfs onaek`sofs hnc s`stnoe ninrank nk nc pfcf `klnr`fr, sne pfr vïe secer`ec, l`saec,
`klcea`fker`e,
o`soe oeknrearnh`t`a`e, f pfrpunhn
qun nc h`knrf nc rnstfafoprercf
hn onaek`sofs hn cfs qun
tfhf, teoj`àk veofs
punhn e treter. ]frqun
oek`pucercf hn ce
tfhf, beanr
rnec`heh auecqu`nr l`aa`ñk. Nc h`knrf pfr su prfp`e nsnka`e `kafrpfre nstn aeråatnr l`at`a`f,
qun sn `ktnks`l`ae e onh`he qun cfs s`stnoes ofknter`fs sfk oås nstejcns y oås `kst`-
tua`fkec`zehfs. Nste ns ce perehfie9 auektf oås nstejcn ns nc s`stnoe, oås pfhnrfsf ns su
o`tf. @dueconktn, auektf oås l`hua`er`f ns uk s`stnoe ofknter`f, oeyfr ns su rnc`d`fs`heh,
oås arnnk cfs l`ncns aep`tec`stes nk tfhe ce lerse qun sfst`nkn nc s`stnoe, oås afktr`juynk,
eukqun sne hn oeknre `kafksa`nktn, e su v`fcnka`e. \`fcnka`e, rnc`d`ñk y h`knrf lfroek esï
uk afopcnif `knxtr`aejcn.
]nrf ehnoås hn su prfp`e nsnka`e l`at`a`e
l`at`a` e nc h`knrf iunde uk pepnc lukheonktec pfrqun
elnate ec rnstf hn cfs
c fs onaek`sofs hn hfo`kea`ñk hnc s`stnoe, nkoesaerehfs nk lfroe hn
ftres tektes l`aa`fkns. Nc h`knrf ns nc ncnonktf acevn pere sfontnr e ce pfcït`ae y ec hnrnabf ec
ràd`onk aep`tec`ste, pere afkvnrt`r e ce pfcït`ae nk nc tnetrf qun ns bfy, y e cfs pfcït`afs nk
oer`fkntes, pfr eat`ve f pfr pes`ve. Hnc o`sof ofhf, nc sfl`st`aehf eperetf hn prfpedekhe
qun nc `opnr`f bfy knans`te kf snrïe pfs`jcn s`k nc h`knrf l`at`a`f. Nk l`k, nc h`knrf lcuyn
`opuknonktn ‘ pnauk`e kfk kfk fcnt‘ nktrn cfs snatfrns lfroecns n `klfroecns hn ce nafkfoïe,
nktrn cfs aårtncns hn ce hrfde y Tecc Qtrnnt, nktrn ces acfeaes 
84
 

hn cfs Nstehfs, ces FKDs «buoek`ter`es· y cfs niàra`tfs prfxy, pfk`nkhf hn oek`l`nstf uke
vnz oås beste quà puktf ce cndec`heh
c ndec`heh ns uke lerse ec snrv`a`f hnc s`stnoe aep`tec`ste y afof
nstn sn lukheonkte nk ce ar`o`kec`heh.
Esï, bfy ce hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec sn ninran nk junke onh`he e trevàs hnc s`stnoe ofknter`f
l`hua`er`f y nc afktrfc hn ce arnea`ñk hn h`knrf pfr pertn hnc aårtnc jekaer`f. Nste arnea`ñk hn
h`knrf ns lukheonktec puns cn pnro`tn e ces àc`tns h`spfknr pnroeknktnonktn hn c` c`qu`hnz
qu`hnz
pere beanr rnec`heh sus ednkhes. Nk ftres pecejres, nc s`stnoe bfy hnpnkhn hn ce trekslnrnka`e
hn h`abf h`knrf l`at`a`f, ‘arnehf nx k`b`cf nk cfs pfcfs supnr`frns hnc s`stnoe‘, e auecqu`nr
puktf s`tuehf oås anrae hn cfs pfcfs `klnr`frns. Qectåkhfsn, pfr esï hna`rcf, tfhe ce aehnke
prfhuat`ve, cf qun supfkn uk ectf drehf hn ert`l`a`ec`heh, y qun nxpc`ae ouabfs hn cfs
lnkñonkfs hn bfy. Ns hna`r, nste h`spfk`j`c`heh hn h`knrf l`at`a`f cn ftfrde e ces àc`tns uke
drek aepea`heh pere ectnrer nc aursf keturec y frdåk`af hn ce rnec`heh, pere, lejr`aer
lejr`aer kunves
rnec`hehns e pert`r hn l`aa`fkns, snek rnvfcua`fkns hn afcfrns, drupfs tnrrfr`stes f pekhno`es.
Qn trete nk hnl`k`t`ve hn uk onaek`sof cndec hn lecs`l`aea`ñk hn h`knrf, hn uk pr`v`cnd`f qun
nc aårtnc jekaer`f be fjtnk`hf pfk`nkhf ces cnyns pùjc`aes ec snrv`a`f
snrv`a` f hn sus `ktnrnsns
pr`vehfs, cf qun cns pnro`tn qun nstn h`knrf l`at`a`f kf sn hnst`kn ec j`nk afoùk s`kf e sus
`ktnrnsns pert`aucerns. Hn ce o`soe oeknre nc s`stnoe hn rnsnrve lreaa`fker`e kf ns oås qun
uk onaek`sof qun cn pnro`tn e cfs jekafs prnster cndeconktn h`knrf qun kf t`nknk. Nk a`nrte
oeknre sn punhn hna`r 
82 
qun cfs jekafs prnstek h`knrf l`at`a`f y e aeoj`f fjt`nknk h`knrf rnec, lrutf hnc trejeif y hnc
nslunrzf rneccfs
aerde sfjrn hnbfojrfs
cfs hnuhfrns.
hn cfsNk hnl`k`t`ve,ncncpnsf
a`uhehekfs h`knrf
hn l`at`a`f
tfhe ce bean nc s`stnoe
nafkfoïe, punsoås
sfk `knstejcn,
cfs
vnrhehnrfs arnehfrns hn r`qunze, cfs rnsaetehfrns hn ùct`of rnaursf hn ce drek jurjuie hn
vecfrns l`at`a`fs qun bfy cf pnrv`nrtn tfhf.
P e pnser hn qun nc `opnr`f aunkte bfy afk uke drek aepea`heh pere arner h`knrf, ec o`sof
t`nopf sus àc`tns kf sfk afksa`nktns hn ce knans`heh hn `kvnrt`rcf afkvnk`nktnonktn pere
dnknrer trejeif y afksuof, hn oeknre qun tfhf nc a`acf a` acf sn a`nrrn y sne sfstnk`-jcn.
]rfjejcnonktn kukae nk ce b`stfr`e be nx`st`hf uk s`stnoe tek pnrvnrsf qun sne aepez hn
dnknrer tektfs nxanhnktns pnrf ec o`sof t`nopf nstfs nxanhnktns kf snek `kvnrt`hfs hn
kunvf nk nc a`acf nafkño`af prfhuat`vf nk ce onh`he sul`a`nktn pere nv`ter ce oerd`-kea`ñk
y ce pfjrnze hn drekhns snatfrns hn ce pfjcea`ñk. Nc `opnr`f sn be vunctf tek ar`o`kec qun
rnsucte oås rnktejcn hnstru`r Nstehfs nktnrfs pere vfcvnrcfs e afkstru`r, vnkhnr eroeonktf,
epfyer drupfs tnrrfr`stes, sequner rnaursfs nknrdàt`afs, qun `kvnrt`r nk eat`v`hehns
prfhuat`ves afkvnka`fkecns. P s`k nojerdf nc s`stnoe punhn pnro`t`rsn nc cuif hn
hnspnrh`a`er `kdnktns rnaursfs hn oekf hn fjre. Xfhf nccf
nc cf nk nc afktnxtf hn su pnrvnrs`ñk
ofrec n `hnfcñd`ae, pert`auceronktn hn ces àc`tns, qun bek pnrh`hf ce aepea`heh hn h`st`kdu`r
nktrn r`qunze y h`knrf.
Nc h`knrf l`hua`er`f, iuktf ec nkfron k`vnc hn nkhnuheo`nktf y hn vecfrns l`keka`nrfs
lreuhucnktfs, 
:<
 

kf bean oås qun `ktnks`l`aer ce v`fcnka`e qun cfs onaek`sofs ofknter`fs, l`keka`nrfs y
nafkño`afs trekso`tnk e tfhf nc s`stnoe. Hnshn 5045, nk qun sn hnrfdñ nc petrñk frf, nc
hñcer sfcf be pfh`hf sfstnknrsn nk nc oeraf hn ce hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec etcekt`ste, y nk per-
t`aucer, hnc afktrfc hnc pntrñcnf y su afonra`ec`zea`ñk.
]ere afoprnkhnr nc pepnc qun nc pntrñcnf iunde nk nc s`stnoe ofknter`f bey qun sejnr qun nc
h`knrf ns, nk nsnka`e, afrpfrec y nsp`r`tuec. Ns ec o`sof t`nopf uke onraekaïe oås y uke
afkvnka`ñk sfa`ec. Ns, lrnktn ec rnstf hn onraekaïes prflekes, uke onraekaïe sedrehe. Ns nc
ùct`of sust`tutf sear`l`a`ec hn uke cerde snr`n qun afkl`dure ce b`stfr`e hn cfs `ktnraeoj`fs
sfa`ecns t (Bfrst Gurk`tzgy). Kf t`nkn snkt`hf hna`r, afof ns bej`tuec, qun nc h`knrf
l`hua`er`f kf t`nkn rnspechf7 pfrqun hn bnabf tfhe lfroe hn ofknhe rnqu`nrn hn nste hfjcn
h`onks`ñk afrpfrec y nsp`r`tuec, `koeknktn y tresankhnktn. Cf qun faurrn nk nc aesf hn ces
ofknhes l`hua`er`es ns qun ce prfp`e nafkfoïe, y pert`auceronktn cfs c fs rnaursfs keturecns f
nknrdàt`afs hn hnoekhe uk`vnrsec, afof ns nc aesf a esf hnc pntrñcnf, pesek e hnsnopnõer hn
leatf nc pepnc hn rnspechf oetnr`ec hn ce ofknhe. Qn nktnkhnrå nktfkans pfr quà nc s`stnoe
l`hua`er`f eatuec `opc`ae knanser`eonktn nc afktrfc hn nstfs rnaursfs y cf qun nstf `opc`ae
hnshn nc puktf hn v`ste hn ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec. Kf sfcf sn trete hn afktrfcer cfs rnaursfs,
pert`auceronktn cfs nknrdàt`afs, s`kf teoj`àk hn esndurer qun nstfs sn afonra`ec`ank nk ce
h`v`se qun, hn leatf, rnspechek, qun sn afktrfcn su h`str`jua`ñk e trevàs hn rutes oerït`oes,
fcnfhuatfs, nta., qun sn punhe oek`pucer su prna`f afof lfroe  
:4 
`kh`rnate hn elnater ec rnstf hn h`v`ses. Kf ns aesuec`heh qun ce oeyfr pertn hn ces dunrres
c`jrehes
rnaursfs pfr nc `opnr`f nk ces
‘pert`auceronktn ùct`oes hàaehes
nknrdàt`afs ‘ y su sn `ksar`jek nk nsteNccñd`ae
afonra`ec`zea`ñk. hñcer hn
ns,afktrfc hn cfsnc
nk rnec`heh,
pntrfhñcer. F qu`zås sne oås eanrtehf hna`r nc pntrf-hñce
 pntrf-hñcer-]nktådf kf, pfrqun nstå rnspechehf
r-]nktådfkf,
tektf pfr nc pntrñcnf
p ntrñcnf afof pfr ce lunrze o`c`ter qun bean pfs`jcn su sequnf.
Lrnktn ec s`stnoe l`hua`er`f ces ofknhes rnspechehes pfr frf supfknk nafkfoïes oås
nstejcns, onkfs nxpunstes e ces jurjuies y e ces ar`s`s, afk pfs`j`c`hehns hn arna`o`nktf oås
afktnk`hf y sfstnk`jcn7 nk hnl`k`t`ve, s`stnoes oås nqu`c`jrehfs, oås eutñkfofs, onkfs
v`fcnktfs, afk onkfs aepea`heh pere nxtnrkec`zer su v`fcnka`e f pere sulr`r ce v`fcnka`e
nxtnrke. Nc frf supfkn pere uke ofknhe «pfknr cfs p`ns nk ce t`nrre·, y pere ces rncea`fkns
nktrn ces h`st`ktes h`v`ses, uk ncnonktf hn rnec`heh afoùk, afof ns nc snkt`hf afoùk nktrn
ces pnrsfkes. Nk a`nrtf snkt`hf, nc frf ns afof nc trejeif sfa`ec ejstreatf hnc qun kfs bejcñ
Oerx, uk ncnonktf rnec hn v`kaucea`ñk sfa`ec hn tfhf nc s`stnoe,
s`stn oe, prna`seonktn pfrqun
rno`tn, nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, e ecdf oetnr`ec, afkarntf, fjint`vf, rnec. 
Hn ebï qun ce prfpedekhe hnc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk anksurn bfy s`stnoåt`aeonktn tfhe
`klfroea`ñk qun pnro`te nktnkhnr añof luka`fke nc s`stnoe l`hua`er`f y nc pepnc anktrec qun
nc frf y ftrfs ontecns bek hnsnopnõehf, e cf cerdf hn ce b`stfr`e, afof ncnonktfs
nstej`c`zehfrns. ]nrf kf bey qun o`st`l`aer nc frf. Xeoj`àk ns a`nrtf qun ouabes dunrres y
afkqu`stes e 
>5
 

cf cerdf hn ce b`stfr`e ‘ y tfhevïe bfy‘ pnrsnduïek eprfp`ersn hnc frf einkf, hn ce o`soe o` soe
oeknre qun ces hn bfy jusaek eprfp`ersn hnc pntrñcnf y hnc des. P ns qun uke vnz qun nc frf
sn afkv`nrtn nk uke lfroe hn h`knrf,
h `knrf, pese e snr uke onraekaïe sedrehe. F nk ftres pecejres,
pese e snr uke lfroe hn sust`tua`ñk sear`l`a`ec y pfr cf tektf aekec`ze ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec.
Bnofs ofstrehf añof ce hnsv`kaucea`ñk hn uke ofknhe hnc frf `opc`ae `opc `ae ce `ktnks`l`aea`ñk
hnc aeråatnr `opnr`ec hn uke nafkfoïe, hn ce v`fcnka`e qun nste ninran sfjrn ftres nafkfoïes,
sfjrn ftres ofknhes, sfjrn nc kf-`opnr`f. Nk nlnatf, nk nc aesf hnc rnspechf afk frf ces
ofknhes sn v`kaucek `kh`rnateonktn e trevàs hn nstn rnspechf afoùk, cf qun hfte ec
afkiuktf hn oeyfr nstej`c`heh, hn oeyfr rnec`heh, rns`st`àkhfsn esï e ce l`aa`fkec`zea`ñk hn ce
nafkfoïe qun bfy pehnanofs. Ec afktrer`f, nc s`stnoe l`hua`er`f s`nkte ces c es jesns pere tfhfs
cfs nxansfs l`keka`nrfs, puns ncuhn rnlnrnka`es rnecns afk ces qun pfhnr afoperer cfs vecfrns,
lfonkte nafkfoïes l`at`a`es jesehes nk ce nspnaucea`ñk, sfontn e ce nafkfoïe prfhuat`ve e
oeyfr prns`ñk.
Ehnoås, ce h`v`se l`hua`er`e hn rnlnrnka`e errestre ec rnstf hn h`v`ses qun nståk supnh`tehes
e ncce, ces fjc`de e nktrer nk ce o`soe h`kåo`ae hn l`aa`fkec`zea`ñk hn sus nafkfoïes, s` kf
qu`nrnk qunhersn rnzedehes. Xfhf nccf nk nc oeraf hn ce h`kåo`ae sear`l`a`ec nk ce qun ces
h`v`ses qun oås afkl`ekze etrenk sfk equncces oås hfo`kektns, ns hna`r, ces qun aunktek afk
oås onaek`sofs hn hfo`kea`ñk. Qn fjsnrve equï nc pepnc qun ce v`fcnka`e hnsnopnõe nk ce
afkl`ekze ofknter`e, afof faurrn nk nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec qun nstå nk 
:2 
ce jesn hn su luka`fkeo`nktf, tec afof bek ofstrehf O`abnc Edc`ntte y Ekhrà Frcàek. Nk
nlnatf,
hnc hñcerafkl`ekze
y ce nk ce ofknhe
c e bndnofkïe o`c`tery hnc
ukek`o`heh hn ce v`fcnka`e
`opnr`f etcekt`ste. vek hncfcequn
Iusteonktn oekf,
bfyafof nc vïes
nstå nk vecfrhn
hnsepernanr.
Ce `oprns`ñk `operejcn hn h`knrf l`at`a`f
l` at`a`f y nc `konksf nkhnuheo`nktf sfcf punhnk
sfstnknrsn nk ce onh`he nk qun nc `opnr`f ns `opnr`f y qun kf bey ftres lunrzes qun punhek
hnsel`ercf, nk ce onh`he nk qun ce h`v`se hn rnlnrnka`e hnc `opnr`f supfkn nc sear`l`a`f oås
arnïjcn, nk ce onh`he nk qun nste v`fcnka`e sear`l`a`ec ns oås nl`aezonktn r`tuec`zehe, nk ce
onh`he nk qun nc `opnr`f onifr lejr`ae su l`aa`ñk. ]nrf nc pepnc bndnoñk`af hnc hñcer nstå
bfy rntrfanh`nkhf s`dk`l`aet`veonktn, nk ce onh`he nk qun ftres nafkfoïes y ofknhes nståk
afktrerrnstekhf aehe vnz oås nstn pepnc ‘afof ns nc aesf, sfjrn tfhf, hn Ab`ke‘, nk ce
onh`he nk qun nstes nafkfoïes nståk `karnonktekhf nc afonra`f nktrn ncces nk sus prfp`es
h`v`ses ‘ hnshf-cer`zea`ñk‘, nk ce onh`he nk qun nståk ecoeankekhf drekhns aekt`hehns
hn frf. Esï, nsteofs v`v`nkhf bfy ce treks`a`ñk hnshn uk oukhf nk nc qun hfo`keje nc
`opnr`f hnc hñcer e ftrf nk nc qun nstn sn ve e vnr fjc`dehf e afopert`r su bndnofkïe afk
ftres nafkfoïes y ftres h`v`ses. Nk nste treks`a`ñk vek e `klcu`r tnoes ouy ver`ehfs afof nc
drehf hn l`keka`er`zea`ñk hn ces nafkfoïes, nc afktrfc hn ces l`kekzes, cfs rnaursfs y nc
afonra`f, ce aepea`heh hn `klcunka`e e k`vnc aucturec y onh`åt`af, nc k`vnc tnakfcñd`af, ce
aepea`heh hn hfo`k`f, kf sfcf nk nc pcekf pureonktn o`c`ter, s`kf 
>1
 

teoj`àk nk nc hn ftres ofhec`hehns hn dunrre hn jeie `ktnks`heh, nta. Nk hnl`k`t`ve, sn punhn


rnsuo`r tfhf nstf h`a`nkhf qun ce tnkhnka`e lukheonktec hnc `opnr`f etcekt`ste, su puktf
lunrtn, ns nc hn ce l`aa`ñk, nk nc snkt`hf oås eopc`f hnc tàro`kf7 o`nktres qun nc jcfqun
nurfes`åt`af sn jese nk pfcït`aes, nafkfoïes y auctures oås rnecns. 
Nk nlnatf, nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste afktrfce ces l`kekzes, sus ofknhes l`hua`er`es sfk tfhevïe
hfo`kektns, pnrf sus nafkfoïes nståk ouy nkhnuhehes7 afof afktrepert`he, Ab`ke, Zus`e
y ftrfs peïsns nonrdnktns aunktek afk kuonrfsfs rnaursfs keturecns, aepea`heh prfhuat`ve,
nafkfoïes onkfs nkhnuhehes, rnsnrves hn frf. Nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste aunkte tfhevïe afk nc
c`hnrez-df a`nktïl`af, tnakfcñd`af, aucturec y onh`åt`af. P nstn c`hnrezdf ns lukheonktec pere
nc hfo`k`f, elnate s`dk`l`aet`veonktn ec ofhncf nafkño`af, t`nkn uke afopfknktn jàc`ae
qun, afof vnrnofs, aehe vnz ns oås h`lïa`c h`lnrnka`er hn cf nafkño`af. Kfs rnlnr`ofs e
tfhf uk afkiuktf hn lnkñonkfs, hnshn nc snatfr edrf`khustr`ec ec leroeaàut`af, hn ce
`khustr`e aucturec e ce hnc nspnatåaucf, qun afof vnrnofs kf sn punhnk nktnkhnr s`k su
afopfknktn `opnr`ec, jàc`ae, ec o`sof t`nopf qun l`at`a`e, qun sfk cfs vnbïaucfs hn ce
hfo`kea`ñk hnc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk. Nk ftres pecejres, s`du`nkhf kunstrf pcektneo`nktf
`k`a`ec, nc hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste `kafrpfre uke h`onks`ñk, ec o`sof t`nopf hnstruat`ve y
l`at`a`e, pert`auceronktn e trevàs hn cfs aejeccfs hn Xrfye hn ce a`nka`e, ce tnakfcfdïe, ce
aucture f nc nktrntnk`o`nktf. Nste hfo`kea`ñk e trevàs hn ce l`aa`ñk ns hn cf qun veofs e
fauperkfs afk oås hnteccn nk nstn trejeif.  
:0 
Hehe nste es`ontrïe nktrn uk `opnr`f etcekt`ste oås l`at`a`f y kunves pftnka`es nonrdnktns
oås rnecns, hehf
sndukhes, hehf nc
nc bnabf
oeyfrhn qun nc pr`onrf
hfo`k`f pfr pertnnshnc
nc qun nstå hn
pr`onrf pnrh`nkhf
tfhe ukepnsf afk rnspnatf
ver`nheh e ces
hn tàak`aes
hn hfo`kea`ñk ouy sfl`st`aehes, pernan cñd`af pnkser qun nste treks`a`ñk kf sn prfhuzae hn
oeknre peaïl`ae, s`kf prna`seonktn bea`nkhf usf hn nstes tàak`aes `opnr`ecns jàc`aes,
j àc`aes, nk nc
snkt`hf oås eopc`f hnc tàro`kf. Nsteofs bejcekhf tektf hn dunrres afkvnka`fkecns afof
hn dunrres hn auerte dnknrea`ñk f afklc`atfs hn jeie `ktnks`heh. Cf qun ns prnv`s`jcn ns qun
ar`s`s y afklc`atfs hn h`st`ktf frhnk snek prfvfaehfs y ut`c`zehfs l`at`a`eonktn afof
afertehes pere afktrfcer y knutrec`zer e ce pfjcea`ñk, nk ce treks`a`ñk bea`e ftrf frhnk
l`keka`nrf y ofknter`f, hehf qun sn rnqunr`rïek onh`hes hn nxanpa`ñk y hn afktrfc pfjce-
a`fkec, nk perecncf e aekancea`fkns hn hnuhe, afkl`saea`fkns hn lfkhfs, rnsntnfs ofknter`fs,
nta. Nk ftres pecejres, ns ouy pfs`jcn qun nk cfs prñx`ofs t`nopfs vneofs ecdùk t` t`pf
pf hn
afcepsf afktrfcehf hnc s`stnoe l`keka`nrf y ofknter`f, y nstf sn bede nk nc afktnxtf hn ar`s`s
f afklc`atfs prfvfaehfs hn oeknre ert`l`a`ec pnrf prnsnktehfs ektn ce fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae afof
keturecns, afof nspfktåknfs, afof prfvfaehfs pfr ftrfs. 
a rua`ec bfy afoprnkhnr añof luka`fke nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk, hn ebï qun
Hn ebï qun sne tek arua`ec
sne tek urdnktn, pfrqun nstn ve e snr uk leatfr acevn ‘eh`v`keofs‘ nk cf qun sn evna`ke.
Xfhf nstf punhn faurr`r hn h`st`ktes oeknres, afk oeyfr f onkfr affrh`kea`ñk nktrn ukes
nafkfoïes y ftres, afk oeyfr f onkfr 
>>
 

afktrfc hn ce s`tuea`ñk, afk oeyfr f onkfr v`fcnka`e. ]nrf hn cf qun kf aejn huhe ‘
`ks`st`ofs, cf eh`v`keofs, k` cf hnsneofs k` afktr`ju`ofs e nccf‘ ns hn qun pfhrïe faurr`r
nk uk luturf prñx`of, y qun nk nstfs nvnktfs ve e iuder uk pepnc anktrec nc `opnr`f hn ce l`a-
a`ñk. H`abf hn uke oeknre s`opcn9 cf prnv`s`jcn ns qun ce lerse hnc 55Q kf sne oås qun uk
epnr`t`vf afoperehe afk cf qun nc `opnr`f hnjn hn nster prfjejcnonktn pceknekhf nk nstfs
ofonktfs.
]nrf o`nktres ce treks`a`ñk e uk kunvf frhnk ofknter`f ‘pfs`jcnonktn ouct`pfcer‘ sn
prfhuan, nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste s`dun
s` dun `opfk`nkhf su hfo`k`f nk drek pertn hnc frjn. Bnofs
ofstrehf añof nc afktrfc hn cfs rnaursfs nknrdàt`afs y su afonra`ec`zea`ñk sfk ncnonktfs
`ktndrecns hnc s`stnoe ofknter`f hnc pntrf-hñcer. Nk afksnaunka`e, tfhfs cfs Nstehfs qun
pfknk nk aunst`ñk nste h`atehure hn leatf, tnro`kek pehna`nkhf ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec, hn uke
oeknre u ftre. Esï, ec oerdnk hn ces lerses qun cfs eperetfs hn `ktnc`dnka`e y cfs onh`fs hn
prfpedekhe nsank`l`aek, e onkuhf afk ce afopc`a`heh hn drekhns FKDs, cf a`nrtf ns qun nk
tfhfs cfs afklc`atfs hn ces ùct`oes hàaehes ces aunst`fkns anktrecns nrek nc afktrfc hn cfs
c fs
rnaursfs, ces h`v`ses qun cfs afonra`ec`zek y ces r`vec`hehns
r`vec` hehns `ktnr`opnr`ecns.
Nc s`stnoe hn ce hnuhe ve hn ce oekf hnc s`stnoe l`hua`er`f. Nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e rno`tnk e cf
o`sof9 beanr pfs`jcn nafkfoïes oås l`at`a`es e trevàs hn ce afeaa`ñk hn nafkfoïes oås rnecns.
Nstf ns cf qun nstå nk nc tres-lfkhf hn ce rncea`ñk afonra`ec y l`keka`nre nktrn Nstehfs ^k`hfs
y Ab`ke9 cfs eonr`aekfs afoprek cfs prfhuatfs ab`kfs s`noprn y auekhf cfs ab`kfs
afoprnk 
1= 

ce hnuheafk
ounstre eonr`aeke, eukqun sejnk
ouabe acer`heh qun puktf
beste quà nste aehe
cfs vnz vecn onkfs.
`ktnraeoj`fs Nc tnoe hnluka`fkek
nafkño`afs ce hnuhe hn
bnabf afof uke eper`nka`e, afof uke oåsaere hn ces afeaa`fkns qun cns sujyeank. ¶Añof
ns pfs`jcn qun ce hnuhe sne ut`c`zehe afof uk onaek`sof hn hfo`k`f, s` cfs earnnhfrns
nståk hn bnabf oås nkhnuhehfs qun cfs hnuhfrns6 Ce rnspunste ns ce o`soe qun ce qun
vnk`ofs prfpfk`nkhf hnshn nc pr`ka`p`f9 pfrqun cfs onaek`sofs nafkño`afs, he `duec qun
snek nk pfs`t`vf qun nk kndet`vf, nk lfroe hn nxanhnktns f hn hàl`a`ts, v`nknk eafopeõehfs
s`noprn hn ce afrrnspfkh`nktn afeaa`ñk. Nstf ns cf qun nc tnñr`af ‘kf nc pfcït`af‘ Pek`s
\erfuleg`s kfs be ofstrehf afk rnspnatf ec hfo`k`f hn Nstehfs ^k`hfs sfjrn sus ec`ehfs.
]fr nsf nc vecfr nxeatf hn ce hnuhe kf t`nkn `opfrteka`e, pfr nsf ce hnuhe sn punhn, pfr
s`stnoe, rnkndfa`er. ]frqun nc afont`hf hn ce hnuhe ns nk hnl`k`t`ve rnprfhua`r y earnankter
ces rncea`fkns hn pfhnr, sus es`ontrïes. Es`ontrïes hn pfhnr qun, afof vnk`ofs h`a`nkhf,
sfk afksusteka`ecns ec ràd`onk aep`tec`ste y e su `opnr`f. NcN c `opnr`f afks`stn prna`seonktn
nk prfvfaer nstfs hnsnqu`c`jr`fs hn oeknre sfstnk`he, hn oeknre qun rn`kn uke a`nrte pez y
nstej`c`heh, hn oeknre qun sn arnn uke eper`nka`e hn nqu`c`jr`f. Ce perehfie ns qun nc
nqu`c`jrf afks`stn nk rnprfhua`r uk hnsnqu`c`jr`f, nk rnprfhua`r y nk cf pfs`jcn `karnonkter
ce trekslnrnka`e hn r`qunze hnshn ukf hn cfs pfcfs bea`e nc ftrf.
Nk suoe, bfy ofknhe y hnuhe sfk pråat`aeonktn cf o`sof. Q` nc `opnr`f sn punhn
nkhnuher, s` nkaunktre earnnhfrns h`spunstfs
h` spunstfs ‘ u fjc`dehfs‘ e afoprer 
>4
 

su hnuhe, ns pfrqun nc `opnr`f ns nc `opnr`f, y,ec onkfs pfr nc ofonktf, hfo`ke. ]frqun punhn
rnspecher su ofknhe y su hnuhe afk ce v`fcnka`e
v `fcnka`e hn su niàra`tf, afk ce sfl`st`aea`ñk hn sus
oàtfhfs hn hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk, afk ce aepea`heh hn su `ktnc`dnka`e pere prfvfaer dfcpns hn
Nstehf nkauj`nrtfs, pfrqun punhn `opr`o`r h`knrf l`at`a`f
l`at`a` f pere pfknr e sus ñrhnkns niàra`tfs
prfxy hn tfhf t`pf y afkh`a`ñk, pfrqun aunkte afk ce tnakfcfdïe aepez hn aetec aetec`zer
`zer
pekhno`es, oek`pucer nc ac`oe f prfvfaer tnrrnoftfs.
Oås ehncektn kfs faupernofs hn ce ednkhe dcfje-c`ste. ]nrf pfhnofs ehncekter qun nc
h`knrf ns ukf hn cfs ouabfs aejeccfs hn Xrfye e trevàs hn cfs auecns nste sn nstå
`opfk`nkhf. Nk nlnatf, afktrfcer nc h`knrf ns afktrfcercf tfhf nk nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste.
Auekhf nc `opnr`f hnc aep`tec nstà tek afksfc`hehf qun tfhf cf qun nx`ste sn rnhuzae e
onraekaïes, nktfkans afktrfcer nc h`knrf s`dk`l`aerå hnl`k`t`veonktn afktrfcercf tfhf. Esï,
afktrfcer nc h`knrf hn uke pnrsfke, lïs`ae f iurïh`ae, nqu`vechrå nk ce pråat`ae e sfontnrce f
knutrec`zerce s` ns knanser`f. Nstf ns cf qun sn nsafkhn nk nc prfansf qun bfy nsteofs
etrevnsekhf hn hnseper`a`ñk hnc h`knrf nk ontåc`af y su sust`tua`ñk pfr nc h`knrf
ncnatrñk`af. Hntrås hn cfs ruj`fs y sfkr`nktns heknsns pedekhf afk sus soertpbfkns cf qun sn
nsafkhn ns nc soert-tftec`ter`sof dcfjec. Qn trete nk nlnatf hnc nstehf pfc`a`ec h`slrezehf hn
afktrfc ofknter`f, hn ce o`soe oeknre qun, afof vnrnofs,
v nrnofs, ftrfs tektfs aejeccfs hn Xrfye
hnc Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec sn prnsnktek afk cfs h`slreans hn ce a`nka`e, ce tnakfcfdïe, ce
onh`a`ke, nc buoek`ter`sof f ce nafcfdïe. 
15 
Dnfpfcït`ae hnc `opnr`f 
Beste ebfre afkanptuecns,
nk tàro`kfs bnofs bejcehf hn hfo`k`f
tfoekhf afofy jesn
hn afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn,
a fkv`vnka`e-c`jrn, hn `opnr`f
ce treh`a`ñk oerx`ste y hn kf-`opnr`f,
pnrf nxtnkh`àkhfce
beste ejeraer espnatfs kf nstr`ateonktn nafkño`afs afof sfk ce v`he, ce c`jnrteh, ce
v`fcnka`e, tfhf nccf nk nc oeraf hnc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec. @ks`st`ofs, tfhf nstf nstå `opcïa`tf
nk auecqu`nr `ktnraeoj`f nafkño`af7 ce nqu`vecnka`e hn vecfrns
v ecfrns hn aeoj`f kf ns oås qun ccee
 lfroe nk qun nstfs ftrfs espnatfs qun r`dnk ces rncea`fkns buoekes sn nkoesaerek. Hn ebï
qun Oerx hnje snr `ktnrprntehf, afof bek snõecehf Lrnhr`a Ieonsfk f Ecnxekhnr Gcudn, nk
tàro`kfs hn rnprnsnktea`ñk.
Kunstre afkanptuec`zea`ñk kfs flrnan uk oeraf hn `ktnrprntea`ñk hn ce rnec`heh ouy
fpnret`vf, puns kfs pnro`tn afoprnkhnr ouabfs hn cfs lnkñonkfs qun sn prnsnktek nk nc
ràd`onk aep`tec`ste e ce cuz hn ce h`kåo`ae j`pfcer hn ce qun bnofs bejcehf. Xfae ebfre tre-
ter hn `hnkt`l`aer nstfs ncnonktfs afkanptuecns, nstes tnks`fkns nktrn pfcfs, nk kunstrf
oukhf rnec. Afof bnofs h`abf, nk snkt`hf nstr`atf ces kfa`fkns hn hfo`k`f y afkv`vnka`e-
c`jrn, hn `opnr`f y kf-`opnr`f, kf 
>0
 

sfk cuderns, Nstehfs, frdek`sofs, drupfs, pnrsfkes. ]nrf ec o`sof t`nopf afkv`nkn
`hnkt`l`aer beste quà puktf nstfs pfcfs sn afkanktrek oeyfronktn nk ukfs cuderns u ftrfs,
nk ukfs Nstehfs u ftrfs, nk hntnro`kehfs drupfs f `kst`tua`fkns f nk ftres. Q`k pnrhnr hn
v`ste qun ec rnlnr`r kunstres kfa`fkns afkanptuecns e nktns afkarntfs nsteofs bea`nkhf uke
dnknrec`zea`ñk.
Hn oeknre qun s` qunrnofs snr r`durfsfs pnrf ec o`sof t`nopf kf k f pnrhnrkfs nk nc àtnr hn
ce tnfrïe nstnofs fjc`dehfs e secter pnroeknktnonktn nktrn ukf y ftrf rnd`strf, nktrn nc
afkanptf y ce rnec`heh. Nk tfhf aesf kunstre `ktnka`ñk pr`ka`pec kf ns ccnder e `hnkt`l`aer
hntnro`kehfs lnkñonkfs afk hntnro`kehfs ednktns f eperetfs hn Nstehf f Nstehfs qun cfs
prfhuank. ]ere nsf nx`stnk pnr`fh`stes hn `kvnst`dea`ñk qun sn faupek nspnaïl`aeonktn hn
nste cejfr. Kunstre `ktnka`ñk ns, pfr nc afktrer`f, nsacernanr hn oeknre dnkàr`ae a`nrtfs
lnkñonkfs, treter hn afoprnkhnr beste quà puktf nstfs rnspfkhnk e ce cñd`ae hnc `opnr`f, y
pfr cf tektf punhnk snr ut`c`zehfs pfr ukfs u ftrfs ednktns nk h`st`ktfs cuderns f ofonktfs.
Qectekhf pnroeknktnonktn nktrn ce tnfrïe y ce rnec`heh pfhnofs nktnkhnr nc `opnr`f bfy y
ec o`sof t`nopf nstejcnanr uk oeraf tnñr`af qun punhe snr ut`c`zehf hn oeknre oås
dnkàr`ae.
Nc bnabf hn qun cfs
c fs o`sofs lnkñonkfs punhek snr fjsnrvehfs nk h`st`ktfs cuderns y e
h`st`ktes nsaeces ns hn uke drek `opfrteka`e puns kfs pnro`tn nstejcnanr ec`ekzes
nstretàd`aes. Ec`ekzes qun sfcf sfk prfv`s`fkecns nk ce onh`he nk qun uke tnkhnka`e kf-
`opnr`ec punhn afkvnrt`rsn nk `opnr`ec, pnrf qun nk 
1: 

tfhf aesf
Zus`e sfk fpnret`ves.
punhnk tnknr lrnktn]fr ninopcf,etcekt`ste,
ec `opnr`f rnafkfa`nkhf nc vecfr
s`k qun qun ncqun
nsf `op`he afktrepnsf hn Ab`kee fsu
nstes pftnka`es,
vnz, hnspc`ndunk pfcït`aes `opnr`ecns nk ftrfs åoj`tfs y bedek usf hn cfs h`spfs`t`vfs hn
hfo`k`f `opnr`ecns qun ekec`zeofs. @hnkt`l`aer nstes s`tuea`fkns afoukns kfs punhn
pnro`t`r, pfr ninopcf, nstejcnanr ec`ekzes `ktnrkea`fkecns pere beanr lrnktn ec dcfjec`sof. ]nrf
ehnoås, kf pnrhnr hn v`ste qun nc `opnr`f y nc kf-`opnr`f cf etrev`nsek tfhf, e tfhfs cfs
k`vncns, kfs pnro`t`rå nktnkhnr ec o`sof t`nopf lnkñonkfs hn frhnk dcfjec, kea`fkec, cfaec,
afouk`ter`f f `kh`v`huec, y vecfrer beste quà puktf sn punhn trejeier e ukf u ftrf k`vnc, afk
uke a`nrte afbnrnka`e, s`k qun cfs onh`fs nstàk nk afktreh`aa`ñk afk cfs l`kns.
Afkarntekhf, bfy sn punhn rnafkfanr nk nc oukhf ce suprnoeaïe hnc `opnr`f etcekt`ste,
c`hnrehf pfr Nstehfs ^k`hfs n `ktndrehf pfr Nurfpe, Iepñk, y ftrfs peïsns ec`ehfs afof
Aekehå, Eustrec`e, @srenc, Erej`e Qeuhï, nta. Iuktf e nstn `opnr`f, nx`stnk uke snr`n hn
pftnka`es nonrdnktns, edrupehes jeif nc earñ-k`of JZ@AQ (Jres`c, Zus`e, @kh`e, Ab`ke,
Quhålr`ae) esï afof ftrfs Nstehfs el`kns afof @råk y \nknzunce, qun, eukqun nk dnknrec sfk
ouy hnpnkh`nktns hnc `opnr`f etcekt`ste, nståk dekekhf prfdrns`veonktn `khnpnkhnka`e y
afktr`juynkhf e lfroer cf qun pfhrïe snr uk oukhf ouct`pfcer. Ns, sfjrn tfhf, nc aesf hn
Ab`ke y hn Zus`e. @ks`st`ofs, nk dnknrec nstfs Nstehfs punhnk snr `hnkt`l`aehfs afof nc kf-
`opnr`f nk cf qun sn rnl`nrn e su pepnc afof afktrepnsfs hnc 
<5 

`opnr`f etcekt`ste, pnrf nstfs Nstehfs oekt`nknk e su vnz rncea`fkns `opnr`ecns afk rnspnatf e
sus zfkes hn `klcunka`e.
]fr hnl`k`a`ñk
hnl`k`a`ñk nc aep`tec`sof ns uk ràd`onk qun sn be afkvnrt`hf nk hfo`kektn lrnktn lrnktn e ftres
lfroes hn rncea`ñk y hn frdek`zea`ñk sfa`ecns. Bejcer hn ràd`onk aep`tec`ste `opc`ae esuo`r qun
nstn ns nc qun hfo`ke ftrfs ñrhnkns sfa`ecns, y nk afkarntf
afkarntf,, nc frhnk pfcït`af
pfcït`af,, nc rnc`d`fsf y nc
ofrec. Nc aep`tec`sof supfkn ce suo`s`ñk hn ce pfcït`ae, ce rnc`d`ñk y ce ofrec, qun t`nkhnk e peser
e fpnrer afof onres leabehes veaïes hn afktnk`hf,
afktnk`hf, afof lnkñonkfs afcetnrecns qun nc ràd`onk
aep`tec`ste t`nkhn e pfknr e su snrv`a`f, pfr eat`ve f pfr pes`ve. F nk tfhf aesf afof lnkñonkfs
o`kfr`ter`fs.. Ec o`sof t`nopf
o`kfr`ter`fs t`nopf,, nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste `kafrpfre hn ecduke oeknre nstes
h`onks`fkns nk su prfp`e cñd`ae, s`k hnier hn snrv`rsn hn ces ekt`dues lfroes afof oåsaeres qun
 

nsafkhnk nc vnrhehnrf rfstrf hnc aep`tec. Esï, tektf ce pfcït`ae, afof ce rnc`d`ñk y ce ofrec
luka`fkek bfy, sfjrn tfhf, afof oåsaeres hnc `opnr`f. Bey qun cnnrces s`noprn nk afkiuka`ñk
afk nc rnstf hn lnkñonkfs s` sn qu`nrn nktnkhnr añof afktr`juynk ec hfo`k`f `opnr`ec, e ce
oeknre hnc «pfc` junkf· y nc «pfc` oecf·. Nktnkhnr, pfr ninopcf, ce afopc`a`heh qun punhn
nx`st`r nktrn nc \et`aekf y ce ednkhe hnc Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec.
Nste h`onks`ñk nkoesaerehfre sn fjsnrve nk nc aesf hn cfs Nstehfs-kea`ñk,
Nstehfs -kea`ñk, aehe vnz oås
sfont`hfs e ces h`kåo`aes aep`tec`stes n `opnr`ecns, beste nc puktf hn qun bfy nståk nk n k prfansf hn
hnseper`a`ñk. Ce cñd`ae `opcïa`te hnc aep`tec`sof ns afcfk`ec`ste, `opnr`ec`ste. 
<: 
Hn bnabf, afof sn sejn, ce eauoucea`ñk pr`o`t`ve afcfk`ec iudñ uk pepnc lukheonktec nk cfs
frïdnkns hnc aep`tec`sof. Ce cñd`ae `koeknktn hnc aep`tec`sof ns ce hnc arna`o`nktf y ce afkqu`ste
`operejcn hn tfhf cf qun tfhevïe kf be `kafrpfrehf e su s`stnoe.
s`s tnoe. Afof bnofs ofstrehf,
ofstrehf, su
cñd`ae `ktnrke ns ce hn ce trekslfroea`ñk hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jr
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrnn nk hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste, y nstn
prfansf,, hnstruat`vf y afkstruat`vf ec o`sof t`nopf, dnknre oås prfjcnoes hn cfs qun rnsuncvn,
prfansf
prfhuan `knv`tejcnonktn heõfs afcetnrecns,
afcetnrecns, eanktùe ce es`ontrïe s`stào`ae, nta. Hn oeknre qun nc
`opnr`f sfcf punhn sfstnknrsn y secver ces eper`nka`es e trevàs hn uke h`kåo`ae `operejcn n
`ksfstnk`jcn hn arna`o`nktf y hn afkqu`ste
a fkqu`ste `opnr`ec, hn bu`he `kseke bea`e hncektn.
Afof lesn eatuec hn nste h`kåo`ae hn hnstruaa`ñk y afkstruaa`ñk, cf qun bfy nsteofs
prnsnka`ekhf ns, e trevàs hn kuonrfsfs onaek`sofs, ce hns`ktndrea`ñk hn cfs Nstehfs-kea`ñk y
su rn`ktndrea`ñk nk nc frhnk knfc`jnrec dcfjec, qun t`nkn afof fjint`vf l`kec, rncet`veonktn
rncet`veonktn
nkauj`nrtf,
afouk`sof,,cepernaïe
afouk`sof `ksteurea`ñk hnprfynatf
qun nstn uk Kunvfdcfjec`zehfr
Frhnk Oukh`ec tftec`ter`f
tftec`ter`f.
hnc `opnr`f . Hnshnnre.`operejcn
etcekt`ste ce aeïhe hnc y qun
k`kduke lunrze nre aepez hn fpfknrsn e àc. ]nrf nk cfs ùct`ofs eõfs bnofs v`stf rnsurd`r
elfrtukeheonktn h`st`ktes `k`a`et`ves
`k`a`et`ves e h`st`ktfs k`vn
k`vncns
cns qun sn rns`stnk e nste hfo`kea`ñk dcfjec.
 Xektf hn Nstehfs nk su afkiu
afkiuktf
ktf f esfa`ea`fkns hhnn Nstehfs afof hn drekhns
drekhns snatfrns hn ce
pfjcea`ñk, tektf nk cfs peïsns anktrecns afof pnr`làr`afs.
pnr`làr`afs. Nk perecncf e nste fpfs`a`ñk e ce
hfo`kea`ñk etcekt`ste sn nstå prfhua`nkhf
prfhua`nkhf,, afof bnofs ehncektehf
ehncektehf,, ce hnshfcer`zea`ñk 
11
 

hn Ab`ke, Zus`e y ftrfs peïsns hn su nktfrkf


nktfrkf,, y ce arnea`ñk hn h`vnrsfs frdek`sofs
`ktnrkea`fkecns ectnrket`vfs
ectnrket`vfs e cfs nx`stnktns ‘ afktrfcehfs
afktrfcehfs oeyfr`ter`eonktn pfr nc `opnr`f
etcekt`ste ‘ , afof ns nc aesf hnc Jekaf Es`åt`af hn @kvnr@kvnrs`fkns
s`fkns nk @klrenstruature (lukhehf nk
fatujrn hn :=58).
Hn oeknre qun nsteofs etrevnsekhf uke àpfae hn `klcnx`ñk b`stñr`ae nk ce qun cfs nqu`c`jr`fs
dcfjecns sn nståk rnhnl`k`nkhf, cf qun nxpc`ae ce s`tuea`ñk hn ar`s`s n `kanrt`huojr
`kanrt`huojrnn dnknrec`zehes y
cfs rneafofhfs nk ce dnfpfcït`ae dcfjec. Ec o`sof t`nopf drekhns snatfrns hn ce pfjcea`ñk qun
bek `hf s`nkhf aehe vnz oås oerd`kehfs,
oerd`kehfs, nk h`st`ktfs ddrehfs,
rehfs, pfr ces pfcït`aes knfc`jnrecns
dcfjecns hn ces ùct`oes hàaehes, sn s`nktnk aehe vnz onkfs `hnkt`l`aehfs afk ces pfcït`aes
`opnr`ecns, sfk aehe vnz oås vïat`oes hn nstes, pesek e nkdrfser ces l`ces hn ce rns`stnka`e, hn uke
lfroe u ftre. Nc rntf nk nstn ofonktf ns afoprnkhnr cf qun ukfs lnkñonkfs y ftrfs, nk
h`st`ktfs cuderns y e h`st`ktes nsaeces, t`nknk nk afoùk7 nk quà onh`he nstes lunrzes punhnk
`hnkt`l`aersn afof uk kf-`opnr`f y ec`ersn pere rns`st`r ec `opnr`f.
`opnr`f. Nstn trejeif prntnkhn snr uke
afktr`jua`ñk e nste v`s`ñk treksvnrsec, afoprnks`ve,
afoprnks`ve, `ktndrehfre, rns`stnktn. @ks`st`ofs,
`ktnrkea`fkec`ste pnrf kf dcfjec`ste.
Nste afyukture dcfjec pnro`tn nktnkhnr ouabesouabes hn ces ar`s`s y hn cfs afklc`atfs qun nsteofs
etrevnsekhf bfy.
bfy. Ces dunrres nk Fr`nktn ]rñx`of sn `ksar`jnk nk nste cñd`ae `ktnr`opnr`ec`ste
`ktnr`opnr`ec`ste nk
ce qun ces ofkerquïes hnc Dfclf n @srenc sfk ec`ehfs hnc `opnr`f etcekt`ste, o`nktres @råk y sus
årnes hn `klcunka`e, sn fr`nktek 
18 
bea`e Ab`ke y Zus`e. Nc rna`nktn eaunrhf afk @råk (iuc`f hn :=5>) ns pertn hn nste `klcnx`ñk
pceknter`e nk ce qun nsteofs `konrsfs. Ec o`sof t`nopf cfs afklc`atfs qun rfhnek e Zus`e, hnshn
 Eldek`ståk beste ^arek`e, rnspfkhnk ec `ktnràs
`ktnràs hnc `opnr`f etcekt`ste pfr e`scer
e`scerce,
ce, y nk pert`aucer
hn Nstehfs ^k`hfs pfr nv`ter uke oeyfr v`kaucea`ñk
v`kaucea`ñk nktrn Nurfpe y nc d`dektn nu nu-rfes`åt`af
-rfes`åt`af.. Hn
ce o`soe oeknre nk h`vnrsf
h`vnrsfss puktfs hnc dcfjf nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste pnrs`dun ce afktnka`ñk hn
Ab`ke.
Nk tfhes nstes årnes hn afklc`atf f hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk nstå iudekhf uk pepnc lukheonktec
lukheonktec nc leatfr
sfa`ec, ce nx`stnka`e hn snatfrns hn ce pfjcea`ñk hnsafktnktfs
hnsafktnktfs.. ]uns nstes s`tuea`fkns cfaecns rnecns
sfk, afof vnrnofs,
vnrnofs, ce jesn nk ce qun ces h`kåo`aes l`at`a`es hnc `opnr`f sn `ksar`jnk. Q` e nstf cn
uk`ofs ce nkfron aepea`heh qun t`nkn tfhevïe nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste pere arner h`knrf, ce
sfl`st`aea`ñk hn sus oàtfhfs pere `kl`ctrersn nk ftrfs Nstehfs ‘ e trevàs hn cfs onh`fs hn
afouk`aea`ñk, ces rnhns sfa`ecns, lukhea`fkns y FKDs, epfyf e drupfs `ksurdnktns y tnrrfr`stes,
ce aetec`zea`ñk hn aetåstrflns «keturecns·, nta. ‘  , , tnknofs ye ecdukfs hn cfs `kdrnh`nktns
knanser`fs pere afoprnkhnr nk quà snkt`hf nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk-eatùe bfy sfjrn
ce rnec`heh. Hn kunvf, cf qun nsteofs `ktnktekhf beanr afk kunstrf oeraf tnñr`af ns
afoprnkhnr ce epernktn afopcni`heh y ver`nheh hn cfs lnkñonkfs qun bfy sn nståk prfhua`nkhf. prfhua`nkhf.
 Xfhfs
 Xfhfs nstfs afklc`atfs,
afklc`atfs, ar`s`s, hhnsnstej`c`zea`fkns
nsnstej`c`zea`fkns,, rnvunctes
rnvunctes,, aetåstrflns,
aetåstrflns, nta., sfk cf qun sn be
hehf nk cceoer afklc`atfs hn jeie `ktnks`heh f dunrres hn auerte dnknrea`ñk.
 P  
<>
 

ns qun bfy kehe ns cf qun pernan. Eukqun ouabfs kf sn beyek hehf aunkte, nsteofs ye nk pcnke
tnranre dunrre oukh`ec, qun ec o`sof t`nopf ns uke dunrre a`v`c pceknter`e hn ces àc`tns aep`tec`stes
afktre tfhfs. Ce acevn ns nktnkhnr qun tfhfs nstfs lnkñonkfs hn h`vnrsf t`pf, qun kf pernank
dunrres afof cf nrek ces dunrres treh`a`fkecns,
treh`a`fkecns, teoj`àk cf sfk. Nstf ns cf qun nc `opnr`f hn ce
l`aa`ñk kf qu`nrn qun nktnkheofs, y ouabf onkfs qun cuabnofs nk su afktre nk nste dunrre
tftec aep`tec`ste. 
1> 
Ce vnrhehnre  pfcït`ae sn ninran bfy aehe vnz onkfs nk cfs perceonktfs f nk cfs dfj`nrkfs y
Nc tnetrf hn ce pfcït`ae

aehe vnz oås e trevàs hn cfs onaek`sofs hn hfo`kea`ñk hnc aep`tec `opnr`ec, qun kf afkfank
lrfktnres hnktrf hnc `opnr`f,
`opnr`f, y qun sn eafopeõek s`stnoåt`aeonktn hn ce afeaa`ñk. Ces
 vnrhehnres lrfktnres
lrfktnres kf sfk ces qun epernank nk cf cfss oepes s`kf ces qun sn rns`stnk e ces h`kåo`aes
h`kåo`aes
`opnr`ecns. Ces lrfktnres
lrfktnres hnc aep`tec kf sfk cïknes hnc`knehes nk uk oepe s`kf årnes hn `klcunka`e,
hn prns`ñk, hn `kl`ctrea`ñk, hn hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk. Eccï hfkhn vnofs prfjcnoes, prftnstes,
`ksurdnka`es, ns hfkhn nståk ces lrfktnres hnc aep`tec. ]rfjejcnonktn
]rfjejcnonktn kukae nk ce b`stfr`e nc pfhnr
be s`hf tek lcu`hf, tek ntàrnf, tek onteoñrl`aj.
onteoñrl`aj. Lcuyn afof cfs nspïr`tus hn cfs h`fsns ekt`dufs
e kt`dufs,,
eccï hfkhn ces rnc`d`fkns kf sn bejïek epnkes `kst`tua`fkec`zehf
`kst`tua`fkec`zehf,, pere nkaerkersn eequï
quï f eccå sndùk
ces a`rauksteka`es, nk lnkñonkfs tek ver`ehfs afof uke ar`s`s hn hnuhe sfjnreke, nc afcepsf hn
uke h`v`se, uke rnvfcua`ñk hn afcfr, uke snquïe f uk tnojcfr hn t`nrre. Hfkhn nc aep`tec kf
nkaunktre sec`he nk eat`v`hehns prfhuat`ves
prfhuat`ves ‘ afkstruat`ves
afkstruat`ves ‘  , , cf bean nk eat`v`hehns
hnstruat`ves, qun afof bnofs ofstrehf 
<4
 

rnspfkhnk e ce cñd`ae `opcïa`te hn ce afkqu`ste aep`tec`ste. Xfhe afkstruaa`ñk rnqu`nrn uk oïk`of


hn hnstruaa`ñk, cf qun s`dk`l`ae qun ces drekhns
d rekhns aetåstrflns y dunrres sfk pfhnrfses lunktns hn
ofv`c`zea`ñk hn aep`tec y hn fjtnka`ñk hn jnknl`a`f
jnknl`a`f,, tektf nk sus lesns hnstruat`ves afof
afkstruat`ves.
Nktrn nc `opnr`f y kf-`opnr
kf-`opnr`f `f kf sn punhnk nstejcnanr cïknes hn hnoeraea`ñk aceres. @kacusf nk
Nstehfs qun sn fpfknk nk oeyfr drehf e ce hfo`kea`ñk etcekt`ste (Z (Zus`e,
us`e, Ab`ke, @råk, \nknzunce)
nc `opnr`f sn `kl`ctre hn uke oeknre u ftre e trevàs hn qu`ktes afcuokes, epfyf e fpfs`tfrns,
fpfs`tfrns,
lukhea`fkns y FKDs, fc`deraes, aeopeões onh`åt`aes, rnvfcua`fkns hn afcfrns, drupfs
`ksurdnktns, tnrrfr`stes, etnktehfs.
etnktehfs. Nstes tàak`aes hn hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk bek ehqu`r`hf bfy uke drek
sfl`st`aea`ñk. Afoj`kek ce eaa`ñk nkauj`nrte hn ces ednka`es hn `ktnc`dnka`e, ce oek`pucea`ñk hn
oeses, su pert`a`pea`ñk afksa`nktn f `kafksa`nktn, ce oek`pucea`ñk hnc ac`oe, uk pfhnrfsf
eperetf hn prfpedekhe qun ces nkoesaere y cnd`t`oe, nta. Nstn ns nc vnrhehnrf tnrrnkf hn ce
dnfpfcït`ae bfy,
bfy, pnrf teoj`àk hn ce pfcït`ae, puns nc `opnr`f ut`c`ze nstes eroes tektf afktre
kea`fkns nkno`des afof afktre su prfp`e pfjcea`ñk. Nk r`dfr nste h`st`ka`ñk ye kf t`nkn snkt`hf. snkt`hf.
Ns uke oåsaere oås.
 Esï, bfy sfcf sn punhn bejcer hn pfcït`ae, nk nc snkt`
snkt`hf
hf acås`af hnc tàro`kf
tàro`kf,, eccï hfkhn sn fpfknk
fpfknk
rns`stnka`es s`dk`l`aet`ves
s`dk`l`aet`ves e ce kf-pfcït`ae `opnr`ec9 nk ce \nknzu
\nknzunce
nce hn Budf Abåvnz f K`afcås
Oehurf,, nk ce C`j`e hn Oueoer nc Dehel`, nk ce Q`r`e hn Jesber ec-Eseh. Nk ftres pecejres, nc
Oehurf
`opnr`f hnc aep`tec kf 
<2 
punhn pnro`t`r qun nx`ste ce vnrhehnre pfcït`ae nk nc snkt`hf treh`a`fkec, s`kf tek sfcf su l`aa`ñk,
nc tnetrf hn ce pfcït`ae.  Eccï hfkhn bey vnrhehnre ppfcït`ae fcït`ae ce afojetn.
afojetn. Cf o`sof
pfhrïeofs hna`r hnc Nstehf hn hnrnabf, hn ce hnofarea`e.
Ces hnofarea`es nurfpnes hn pfsdunrre kf sfk ce rndce s`kf ce nxanpa`ñk. Nk ncces teopfaf be
nx`st`hf ce prnhfo`keka`e hnc Nstehf hn hnrnabf sfjrn nc hfo`k`f hnc aep`tec. Qfcf qun ce
afyukture b`zf knanser`f qun nc aep`tec anh`nsn ektn nc Nstehf hnc j`nknster y ce sfa`echnofarea`e.
]nrf sfcf pfrqun ces àc`tns `opnr`ecns y cfaecns afoprnkh`
afoprnkh`nrfk
nrfk ce `opfrteka`e hnc afktrfc hn
Nurfpe y ce eonkeze qun supfkïe nc ninopcf afouk`ste. Ehnoås sn h`f ce a`rauksteka`e hn qun
nre knanser`f rnafkstru`r nstfs peïsns hnspuàs hn ce Qndukhe Dunrre Oukh`ec, y hn qun Nstehfs
^k`hfs afkteje afk nxanhnktns pere prfp`a`er nstn o`cedrf. Nurfpe ns acevn nk ce hfo`kea`ñk
dcfjec, afof nsteofs v`nkhf bfy, bfy, y nc aep`tec etcekt`ste afoprnkh`ñ qun tnkïe qun anhnr nk
hnrnabfs sfa`ecns s` kf qunrïe qun nstes kea`fkns sn v`kaucesnk e ce ^k`ñk Qfv`àt`ae. Nk suoe, cfs
cceoehfs Nstehfs hnc j`nknster nurfpnfs lunrfk oås ce nxanpa`ñk qun ce rndce. Lunrfk uke
l`aa`ñk nk nc snkt`hf nk qun nrek nc prfhuatf hn uk ncnonktf nxtnrkf ec ràd`onk aep`tec`ste, pnrf
qun e uk t`nopf snrvïe pere cnd`t`oer nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste `opnr`ec. Q`rv`nrfk pere rnlfrzerrnlfrzer nc
o`tf hn qun nre pfs`jcn, ec o`sof t`nopf, nc aep`tec`sof y nc Nstehf hn hnrnabf. hnrnabf. ]nrf nse lerse ye
tnro`kñ.
Ces eyuhes nstehfuk`hnksns e ce rnaupnrea`ñk hn Nurfpe Faa`hnktec hnvfcv`nrfk hnvfcv`nrfk nk pertn e nstes
kea`fkns 
1<
 

e ce pfs`a`ñk hn hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste afcfk`ec, eukqun lunsn sfont`hes e ce bndnofkïe hn Nstehfs


^k`hfs. Nk nstn afktnxtf teoj`àk bey qun nktnkhnr ce l`aa`ñk hn cfs Nstehfs hn hnrnabf
faa`hnktecns, qun nrek nk nc lfkhf s`tuea`fkns hn pr`v`cnd`f aep`tec`ste y afcfk`ec fjtnk`hes e
trevàs hnc hfo`k`f nk ces pnr`lnr`es. Qn trete ftre vnz hn uke lfroe hn l`aa`ñk, f hn b`pfarnsïe, f
afof sn cf qu`nre cceoer, puns kf punhnk pnro`t`rsn snr Nstehfs hn hnrnabf oås qun nk ce
onh`he nk qun ninrank ce hfo`kea`ñk aep`tec`ste afcfk`ec, nk ce onh`he nk qun ec aep`tec cn `ktnrnse
cnd`t`oersn «vnkh`nkhf· nste l`aa`ñk. Ce perehfie ns qun ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec ns cf qun
 vnrhehnreonktn
 vnrhehnreonk tn cnd`t`oe, pnr
pnrff hn oeknre nkau
nkauj`nrte,
j`nrte, sujc`oehe, rnpr`o`he,
rnpr`o`he, s`ojñc`ae, ec Nsteh
Nstehff
hn hnrnabf, eatuekhf ces tnfrïes hn ce sfjnrekïe hnc Nstehf
Ns tehf afof oåsaeres hn ce hfjcn ofrec
`opnrektn.
Ns a`nrtf qun cfs Nstehfs bek iudehf
iud ehf y iundek tfhevïe bfy uk pepnc `opfrtektn afof
onaek`sofs hn `ktnrvnka`ñk nk ces h`kåo`aes aep`tec`stes, afof bnrreo`nktes hn afktnka`ñk,
afktrfc, aekec`zea`ñk, nta., hn cfs lcuifs hn aep`tec. Q`dunk hnsnopnõekhf uke luka`ñk arua`ec pere
nc luka`fkeo`nktf hnc s`stnoe aep`tec`ste dcfjec. ]nrf sn trete hn uk pepnc eux`c`er, snaukher`f,
snaukher`f,
treks`tfr`f,, supnh`tehf nk tfhf ofonktf ec aep`tec dcfjec. Nk nstn snkt`hf bey qun nktnkhnr ce
treks`tfr`f
kfa`ñk hn rnprnsnktea`ñk pfcït`ae. Cf qun vnrhehnreonktn rnprnsnktek cfs Nstehfs bfy, cf
vnrhehnreonktn nkoesaerek, kf ns ec punjcf sfjnrekf
qun vnrhehnreonktn sfjnrekf,, s`kf e ces lunrzes hnc aep`tec. Ce
rnprnsnktea`ñk bey qun nktnkhnrce nk nc snkt`hf oås tnetrec hnc tàro`kf, afof je`cn hn oåsaeres.
Ce vnrhehnre rnprnsnktea`ñk 
14 
pfcït`ae
sfk ftrenk nc `opnr`f
afse ns ce hnc
qun oåsaeres hncaep`tec,
aep`tec,nsnkceuk
l`aa`ñk
je`cn hnc aep`tec. Ouabfs
hn h`slreans hn cfs lnkñonkfs
`k`ktnrruop`hf
`k`ktnrruop`hf, , pnrf qun bfy kf
teoj`àk
t`nkn ofonktfs hn nspna`ec `ktnks`heh, afof veofs e ofstrer. Bey qun cnnr ce rnec`heh pfcït`ae y
nafkño`ae afof uk drek tnetrf, afof uk drek aerkevec, nk faes`fkns afof uk oeaejrf r`tuec
sear`l`a`ec.
Nk nlnatf, nc aep`tec dfj`nrke afk su prfp`e rnprnsnktea`ñk, afk su prfp`f tnetrf tnetrf.. Ce pfcït`ae
treh`a`fkec, nc Nstehf hn hnrnabf, ce hnofarea`e, ce cnd`t`o`heh, nta., sfk sfcf ecdukfs hn cfs
pnrsfkeins hn ce luka`ñk. Cfs aeoj`fs `opfrtektns e k`vnc pfcït`af f cnd`scet`vf kf faurrnk
pfrqun beye uke oeyfrïe hnofaråt`ae qun cf hna`he f pfrqun h`abfs aeoj`fs jnknl`a`nk e ce
oeyfrïe, s`kf pfrqun uke o`kfrïe hn `ktnrnsehfs t`nkn sul`a`nktn pfhnr pere oek`pucer e ce
fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae, f j`nk pere ccnver e aejf h`abfs aeoj`fs hn oeknre `rrnducer, nkauj`nrte, s`k qun
sn pnra`je hnoes`ehf.
hnoes`ehf.
Hn oeknre qun ce pfcït`ae treh`a`fkec sn be afkvnrt`hf nk uk purf tnetrf. Cfs dfj`nrkfs hn turkf
hn cfs rndïonkns j`pert`h`stes hn turkf cnd`scek e dfcpn hn hnarntf, afeaa`fkehfs,
afeaa`fkehfs, sfjfrkehfs f
eonkezehfs pfr nc aep`tec, qun knans`te onh`hes råp`hes qun kf punhnk nspnrer e qun ces cnyns
snek hnjet`hes nk cfs perceonktfs
perceonktfs,, y qun aunkte afk eroes hn hnstruaa`ñk oes`ve l`keka`nres f
ofknter`es f arnh`t`a`es sul`a`nktnonktn pfhnrfses pere qun k`kdùk pfhnr pfcït`af sn etrnve e
hnsfjnhnanr sus h`atehfs. Nk nc afrezñk hnc `opnr`f, nc j`pert`h`sof ns uke lerse tek drftnsae
j`ofkerquïe bnrnh`ter`e, afof 
qun nstå hekhf pesf e ce j`ofkerquïe
45
 

faurrn afk cfs Jusb y cfs Ac`ktfk, tec afof Ehr`åk Qecjuab` be afonktehf `rñk`aeonktn.
Nk cfs perceonktfs hnc `opnr`f cfs pfcït`afs ye kf bejcek nktrn sï s`kf qun pfsek ektn ces
aåoeres y aecaucek nc lfroetf hn sus lecea`es hn eaunrhf afk cfs añh`dfs onh`åt`afs.
Znduceronktn sn frdek`zek nk-lrnkteo`nktfs h`ecàat`afs l`at`a`fs nktrn cfs pert`hfs hnc
frde k`zek nk-lrnkteo`nktfs
ràd`onk pere qun ce lerse hn ce pfcït`ae s`de s`nkhf arnïjcn pfr cfs a`uhehekfs,
a`uhehekfs, ec o`sof t`nopf
qun sn s`cnka`ek f oek`pucek ces pfs`a`fkns hn drupfs
d rupfs pfcït`afs oerd`kecns qun pfhrïek
`ktrfhua`r ecdf hn vnrheh nk nc hnjetn. ]fr nsf kf ns nxtreõf qun nc petrñk aehe vnz oås
bej`tuec hn ces oer`fkntes pfcït`aes hn kunstrf t`nopf snek cfs pnrsfkeins onh`åt`afs, afk junke
eper`nka`e, ontrfsnxuecns,
ontrfsnxuecns, afk treins y afrjetes hn eutfr. «Esï suanhn afk ce nstnt`zea`ñk hn ce
pfcït`ae qun prfpudke nc lesa`sof· (Tectnr Jnkieoïk).
Jnkieoïk). Ces hna`s`fkns oås rncnvektns qun bfy sn
tfoek nk cfs perceonktfs f nk cfs dfj`nrkfs, sn bek hna`h`hf prnv`eonktn e punrte anrrehe,
afof ns nc aesf hn cfs tretehfs hn c`jrn afonra`f (XX]
(XX],, XX@] f X@QE), f ce eprfjea`ñk hn
lfkhfs hnst`kehfs ec tnrrfr`sof nk nc perceonktf nstehfuk`hnksn (l`kecns hn :=58). Ces cnyns oås
`opfrtektns sn hna`hnk bfy nk rnuk`fkns snarntes afk cfj`stes, s`nkhf ce eprfjea`ñk pfr cfs
perceonktfs f cfs dfj`nrkfs uk onrf tråo`tn lfroec. Ce h`sa`pc`ke hn vftf hn cfs pert`hfs ns
ftrf hn cfs nkdrekeins qun bean pfs`jcn ce h`atehure hnc aep`tec afk ce oåsaere hn ce hnofarea`e.
Cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk hnkuka`ek ce «rnjnchïe· hn cfs h`putehfs qun sn rns`stnk e nstfs
h`atehfs. Nste ns ce h`atehure hn bnabf hnc aep` 
12 
tec qun pfaf e pfaf sn nstå afkv`rt`nkhf nk h`atehure hn hnrnabf
hnrnabf..
Nk cfs Nstehfs hnc `opnr`f ye kf t`nkn snkt`hf bejcer hn snperea`ñk hn pfhnrns. Nc ùk`af pfhnr
ns nc hnc aep`tec qun sfontn y ec`kne e cfs pfhnrns ninaut`vf
ninaut`vf,, cnd`scet`vf y iiuh`a`ec.
uh`a`ec. Nstfs kf sfcf
kf sn nqu`c`jrek ye nktrn sï, s`kf qun k` s`qu`nre
s `qu`nre nqu`c`jrek ec aep`tec, qun rnprnsnkterïe ce
knans`heh hn afopnksea`ñk oås `opfrtektn. Nc tnetrf hnc Nstehf hn hnrnabf t`nkn trns
pnrsfkeins pr`ka`pecns9 nc pnrsfkein hnc dfjnrkektn, nc pnrsfkein hnc h`putehf y nc pnrsfkein hnc
iunz, qun rnprnsnktek uke afonh`e `ksucse pfrqun epnkes nx`stn afklc`atf nktrn nccfs, ec oerdnk
hn ces cuabes hn pfhnr hn ces àc`tns cfaecns y cfs
c fs aeoj`fs hn arfofs nktrn pert`hfs oeyfr`t oeyfr`ter`fs.
er`fs.
]nrf teopfaf bey nqu`c`jr`f bfy bfy hnc auertf
auer tf pfhnr. Nc pfhnr hn cfs onh`fs ns iusteonktn nc qun
pfkn nk nsanke ce l`aa`ñk hn cfs trns pfhnrns acås`afs
acås`afs.. Nc tnetrf o`sof hnc Nstehf sn nsank`l`ae
sfjrn tfhf nk cfs onh`fs, hn oeknre qun nc auertf pfhnr afktr`juyn hn oeknre s`dk`l`aet`ve s`dk`l`aet`ve e
 vea`er hn afktnk`hf
afktnk`hf e nstfs y e pr
prnsnkter
nsnkter nste lerse aafof
fof uke rnec`heh. Cfs perceonkter`fs
perceonkter`fs cn
bejcek oås e ces aåoeres qun e sus afcndes7 cfs iunans sejnk qun cfs iu`a`fs oås `opfrtektns sn
hnserrfccek ektns nk cfs onh`fs qun nk cfs iuzdehfs7 cfs dfjnrkektns hnarntek afk ce urdnka`e
qunftrfs
cfs rnqu`nrnk cfs onraehfs.
trns. ]ere Hnhnoeknre
oeyfr lecte qun hn
nqu`c`jr`f nk pfhnrns
ce pråat`ae pncfrqun
auertfhnpfhnr
 ‘ pfrqun cf qunt`nkn oåsnspfhnr
sn trete qun
hn qun
beye uk hnsnqu`c`jr`f pnroeknktn hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn y hnc hfo`k`f hnc aep`tec ‘   ‘ , teopfaf
nx`stn snperea`ñk 
41
 

nktrn nc pfhnr hnc aep`tec y nc auertf pfhnr


pfhnr.. Nste af`ka`hnka`e hnc pfhnr hnc aep`tec y nc pfhnr hn
cfs onh`fs ns, hn bnabf, uke oek`lnstea`ñk oås hnc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk. Aep`tec y
onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk ‘ f afof vnrnofs
vnrnofs,, «`kqu`s`tfr`ecns· ‘  sfk
 sfk hfs ofonktfs hn uk
o`sof pfhnr.
Qn suncn bejcer hn «punrtes d`retfr`es· pere rnlnr`rsn e ce `he y vnk`he hn aerdfs nktrn nc snatfr
pr`vehf y nc pùjc`af. ]nrf
]nrf bey ftrf t`pf hn punrtes d`retfr`es qun sfk, s` kkff tek lrnaunktns, sï oås
nxprns`ves hnc pepnc qun iunde bfy ce pfcït`ae nk nc `opnr`f.
`opnr`f. Qfk ces punrtes d`retfr`es nktrn ce
pfcït`ae
pfcït`af ypere
nc nspnatåaucf.
nspnatåaucf . Nc vnrhehnrf
ehqu`r`r cnd`t`o`heh. pfhnr nsqun
Hn oeknre nc nk
hncces
aep`tec, pnrf
punrtes nstn hnjn
d`retfr`es h`slrezersn
pfcït`aes nståkhn pfhnr
`opcïa`tes ces punrtes d`retfr`es onh`åt`aes, ce pfcït`ae afof tnetrf. ]fr nsf ns tek bej`tuec bfy vnr
e pnrsfkeins hnc nspnatåaucf
ns pnatåaucf aeoj`er cfs pcetfs a`knoetfdrål`afs pfr cfs pcetfs pfcït`afs. ]nrf
qu`zås ces punrtes d`retfr`es oås `opfrtektns bfy snek ces qun afouk`aek ces ednka`es hn
`ktnc`dnka`e y ce pfcït`ae. Dnfrdn B. T.T. Jusb, \ceh`o`r ]ut`k, sfk sfcf hfs ninopcfs `ks`dkns.
 \eofs
 \eo fs e fauperkfs hn nnstn stn tnoe oås ehncekt
ehncektn.
n.
Bfy ouabfs
ouabfs sn sfrprnkhnk hn qun ces `zqu`nrhes y ces hnrnabes «reh`aecns· afopertek ecdukfs
puktfs hn sus prfdreoes y ccndunk `kacusf e lfroer afec`a`fkns hn dfj`nrkf. ]nrf ]nrf nstes ec`ekzes
nstretàd`aes kf sfk tek «reh`aecns· afof pernan, s` tnknofs nk aunkte beste quà puktf nc
j`pert`h`sof afkv`nrtn ce pfcït`ae nk uke lerse. Esï, uk s`dkf pere rnafkfanr beste quà puktf sn
afoprnkhn ce suo`s`ñk hn ce pfcït`ae ec rà 
10 
d`onk aep`tec`ste ns prna`seonktn nstn. Cf bej`tuec ns qun cfs qun oås sn nsaekhec`ank pfr nstes
ec`ekzes nktrn hnrnabe n `zqu`nrhe «reh`aecns· snek
s nek prna`seonktn equnccfs qun tfhevïe arnnk qun
cfs pfcït`afs hna`hnk ecdf (ec oerdnk hn ces cnyns sfa`ecns hn turkf). ]nrf cf vnrhehnreo
vnrhehnreonktnnktn
reh`aec bfy ns ce oeknre nk qun nc s`stnoe pfcït`af be s`hf snaunstrehf pfr nc aep`tec. Cf
 vnrhehnreonktn
 vnrhehnreonk tn reh`aec ns ce oek
oeknre
nre nk qun cfs o onh`fs
nh`fs nståk oek`pu
oek`pucekhf
cekhf y anksurekhf
anksurekhf ce
`klfroea`ñk, eopc`l`aekhf ces onkt`res fl`a`ecns, afkteo`kekhf
afkteo`kekhf tfhe ce ssfa`nheh
fa`nheh afk ce `hnfcfdïe
afopnt`t`ve,
afopnt`t`v e, ndfïste, oetnr`ec`ste y jàc`ae aep`tec`ste. Cf reh`aec bfy ns qun uke s`tuea`ñk hn
h`atehure nkauj`nrte y hn leatf hnc aep`tec, s`de perna`àkhfcn e ce oeyfrïe hnofarea`e. Cf `keuh`tf
ns qun uke s`tuea`ñk hn nxanpa`ñk afof ce qun v`v`ofs punhe sndu`r perna`nkhf kfroec. Nc
cevehf hn anrnjrf hn ce pfjcea`ñk ns nstrnonanhfr
nstrnonanhfr..
Ce o`soe lerse hnc c`jrn afonra`f sn rnprfhuan hn ecduke oeknre nk ce lerse hnofaråt`ae. Q` nk
nc onraehf ce prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe prntnkhn beanrkfs arnnr qun tnknofs c`jnrteh pere
afksuo`r, pere ncnd`r ce onifr fpa`ñk nk kunstres afopres, ce onifr rncea`ñk aec`heh-prna`f, hn ce
o`soe oeknre kfs qu`nrn beanr arnnr qun tnknofs c`jnrteh hnofaråt`ae pere ncnd`r nc prfdreoe
pfcït`af qun
oås, ce hn ce oås kfs `kh`v`huec
c`jnrteh afkv`nkn.
afkv`nkn. Nk
pereeojfs
hna`h`r.aesfs
hna`h`r . ]nrfcecel`aa`ñk qun nc s`stnoe
ùk`ae c`jnrteh ns ce hncprfaceoe ns, uke
aep`tec pere vnz
afoprer
cfs prfdreoes y ces hna`s`fkns pfcït`aes. Hn oeknre qun kf sfcf sn kfs o`nktn s`kf qun ehnoås
sn kfs bean `opcïa`teonktn rnspfksejcns hn tfhfs cfs oecns7 puns nk 
4>
 

ùct`oe `ksteka`e tektf ce hnofarea`e afof nc onraehf hnpnkhnk ‘ nsf nsf kfs h`ank ‘  hn
 hn kunstres
hna`s`fkns. Qn trete hn uk d`dektnsaf onaek`sof hn `kaucpea`ñk, qun sn afrrnspfkhn afk ce
`opuk`heh hn ce qun h`slrutek ces àc`tns ar`o`kecns. Ce rnec`heh ns qun, tektf nk nc åoj`tf
hnofaråt`af afof nk nc onraekt`c ‘ qun qun nk rnec`heh sfk nc o`sof ‘  , , ces hna`s`fkns nståk ye
tfoehes auekhf e cfs a`uhehekfs cns tfae «hna`h`r·.
Nk nlnatf, ces kndfa`ea`fkns, cfs eaunrhfs y ce vnrhehnre tfoe hn hna`s`fkns nk nc `opnr`f sn
Bnofs v`stf qun auektf oås pfr nka`oe sn nstå ‘ 
r`dnk pfr ce cñd`ae hn ce nxacus`ñk. Bnofs
rncet`veonktn ‘  hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk, oås fpa`fkns hn kndfa`ea`ñk sn t`nknk, hn oås
aepea`heh hn afeaa`ñk sn h`slrute. ]fr nc afktrer`f auektf oås pfr hnjeif sn nstå ‘ hhnn
kunvf, rncet`veonktn ‘  hnc hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk, onkfs fpa`fkns hn hna`s`ñk sn t`nknk, oeyfr
ns nc drehf
d rehf hn afeaa`ñk ec qun sn nstå sfont`hf. ]uns j`nk, ces hna`s`fkns `opfrtektns nk nc
`opnr`f sn tfoek s`noprn pfr nka`oe hnc k`vnc hn afopnksea`ñk, nktrn h`st`ktfs ednktns qun
nståk, tfhfs nccfs, pfr nka`oe hn h`abf k`vnc. ]nrf nstes hna`s`fkns elnatek teoj`àk e equnccfs
qun nståk pfr hnjeif hnc k`vnc y qun kf t`nknk kehe qun hna`r nk ce kndfa`ea`ñk
knd fa`ea`ñk pfrqun
pfrqun bek s`hf
nxacu`hfs hn pert`he hn ce onse hn hnjetn. Nste ns ce cñd`ae bej`tuec nk ces cceoehes
«hnofarea`es·, nk ces qun nc j`pert`h`sof f ces afec`a`fkns hn dfj`nrkf hniek c`tnreconktn lunre
hn ce onse hn kndfa`ea`ñk
knd fa`ea`ñk e ces o`kfrïes. Xeoj`àk
Xeoj`àk ns ce cñd`ae, afof sn sejn, hn ces
kndfa`ea`fkns hn cfs tretehfs hn «c`jrn· afonra`f, e ces qun kf t`nknk eaansf oås qun ecdukfs
pfcït`afs.. Nste ns ce cñd`ae lukheonktec qun r`dn 
pfcït`afs
8= 
nk nc s`stnoe bfy, sne nk nc åoj`tf pfcït`af f nk nc nafkño`af, qun ye kf t`nkn snkt`hf snperer. Ce
cñd`ae qun hnl`kn ces drekhns hna`s`fkns, ces drekhns rnuk`fkns hn ces àc`tns, nk ces qun, ec oerdnk
hn sus r`vec`hehns,
r`vec`hehns, tfhfs sejnk pfknrsn hn eaunrhf nk cf lukheonktec, qun ns cf qun jnknl`a`e e
tfhfs y pnriuh`ae e cfs a`uhehekfs qun kf nståk afkvafkvfaehfs
faehfs e ce rnuk`ñk.
O`nktres qun cfs tretehfs hn «c`jrn· afonra`f sn kndfa`ek nk snarntf y sfcf t`nknk eaansf e nstes
kndfa`ea`fkns uk rnhua`hf kùonrf hn perceonkter`fs, cfs lecsfs nklrnkteo`nktfs nktrn nc pert`hf
prf-`opnr`ec`ste
prf-`opnr` ec`ste afk afrjete ezuc y nc pert`hf prf-`opnr`ec`ste afk afrjete rfie afks`stnk
prna`seonktn nk hnier lunre hnc hnjetn tfhf cf qun `opfrte y sust`tu`rcf pfr pure rntñr`ae. P P,, pfr
supunstf,, kf bejcer hn ces kndfa`ea`fkns hn cfs tretehfs hn c`jrn afonra`f.
supunstf afonra`f. Hn ce o`soe oeknre,
k`kdùk pfcït`af hnc ràd`onk j`pert`h`ste bejcerå hnc afktrfc hn ce arnea`ñk hn h`knrf pfr nc aårtnc
jekaer`f,, hnc s`stnoe hn rnsnrve lreaa`fker`e, hn ce hnseper`a`ñk hnc frf hn ces jñvnhes hn cfs
jekaer`f
jekafs anktrecns, hn cfs ofkfpfc`fs nkauj`nrtfs, hn cfs pereïsfs l`saecns, hn cfs tretfs hn levfr e
ces drekhns afrpfrea`fkns,
afrpfrea`fkns, hn ce afopc`a`heh afk nc tnrrfr`sof y nc ar`onk frdek`zehf,
frdek`zehf, hn ces
oel`es leroeaàut`ae y j`ftnakñcfd`ae, hn cfs ab`ps `opcektejcns, hn ces veaukes ekt`lnrt`c`heh, hn
cfs abnotre`cs, nta. Nk suoe, bfy ce pfcït`ae kf ns ftre afse qun uk tnetrf. Kf ns ce sfcua`ñk e
k`kdùk prfjcnoe s`kf pertn hnc prfjcnoe.
Nc `opnr`f bfy ns tek tftec`ter`f f oås qun cfs tftec`ter`sofs hn ftres àpfaes, sfcf qun bfy nc
ecaekan ns pråat`aeonktn dcfjec, cfs oàtfhfs sfk oås sfl`st`aehfs 
44
 

y oås nkauj`nrtfs, y ce prfpedekhe ns oås nl`aez pere hns`klfroer e ce oeyfrïe. Nk 5011 cfs
kez`s qunoerfk nc Zn`absted y eauserfk hn nccf e cfs afouk`stes7 nk :==5 cfs kez`aep`tec`stes qun
afktrfcek nc oukhf hnrr`jerfk ces Xfrrns Dnonces y eauserfk hn nccf e tnrrfr`stes y`beh`stes. Nc
kez`sof ecnoåk tnkïe sus aeopfs hn afkanktrea`ñk7 nc kez`aep`tec`sof dcfjec t`nkn bfy ouct`tuh
hn aårancns snarntes nk ces qun sn preat`ae ce tfrture s`stnoåt`ae. Nc pr`onrf pfhïe knutrec`zer
knutrec`zer
auecqu`nr eonkeze ec ràd`onk onh`ektn su pfc`aïe snarnte7 nc sndukhf bean cf prfp`f afk hrfkns
tncnh`r`d`hfs.. Nc pr`onrf preat`aeje ce nudnkns`e7 nc sndukhf ce be `kafrpfrehf y nkoesaerehf nk
tncnh`r`d`hfs
sus v`rus,
v`r us, veaukes y frdek`sofs ddnkàt`aeonktn
nkàt`aeonktn ofh`l`aehfs
ofh`l`aehfs..
42   
Cfs fifs qun tfhf cf vnk 
¶]nrf nktfkans qu`àk oekhe6 Afof h`an Hek`nc Nstuc`k, nc oukhf kf cf afktrfcek ukfs sej`fs
s`k`nstrfs hnshn ecduke sece snarnte
s narnte ecrnhnhfr hn uke jfce hn ar`stec. ]nrf ecdf hn nsf bey
bey.. Nc
dfj`nrkf hnc `opnr`f ns uk afopcnif nktreoehf hn pfhnr, lfroehf pfr frdek`zea`fkns snarntes
y ssno`snarntes afrpfrea`fkns,, tb`kg tekgs, frdek`sofs `ktnrkea`fkecns
no`snarntes,, jekafs anktrecns, afrpfrea`fkns `ktnrkea`fkecns,,
aeses rnecns, «Nstehfs prflukhfs·, ectfs aerdfs pfcït`afs, o`c`terns y hn `ktnc`dnka`e, cfjj`ns,
lukhea`fkns,, anktrfs hn `kvnst`dea`ñk, onh`fs hn prfpedekhe, FKDs, nta. Nktrn tfhfs nstfs
lukhea`fkns
ednktns nx`stn uke a`nrte inrerquïe, pnrf, auektf oås kfs eanraeofs e ce aùsp`hn, onkfs nx`stn
uke inrerquïe lfroec f `kst`tu`he afof cf sfk cfs Nstehfs, s`kf uke inrerquïe rncet`v
rncet`vee hn bnabf
qun sn afrrnspfkhn afk nc pfhnr rnec, afk su s`tuea`ñk nk ncn c nktreoehf
nktreoehf,, afk su aepea`heh hn
`klcunka`er nk nc rnstf hn ednktns, afk cfs onh`fs afk cfs qun aunkte pere ninranr tec pfhnr, afk ce
afkl`ekze afk ce qun aunkte nktrn nc rnstf hn ednktns. Nk ce aùsp`hn hnc pfhnr sn nkaunktrek
frdek`zea`fkns snarntes y sno`snarntes ‘ hn ecdukes kf sn afkfan k` s`qu`nre ce nx`stnka`e f nc
kfojrn ‘ , esï afof frdek`zea`fkns 
85
 

qun tresa`nkhnk pera`econktn e ce fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae tecns afof nc Acuj J`chnrjnrd, ce Afo`s`ñk
 Xr`cåtnre!,
 Xr`cåtnre!, nc Afksnif hn Zncea`fkns Nxtnr`frns
Nxtnr`frns y ftres,
ftres, qun sn rnùknk hhnn tektf nk tekt
tektff pere
hnl`k`r ces drekhns cïknes hn ce dnfpfcït`ae,
d nfpfcït`ae, ce nafkfoïe y ces nstretnd`es dnknrecns nk ces h`vnrses
oetnr`es.
Cf `opfrtektn ns nktnkhnr qun nstes frdek`zea`fkns snarntes y sno`snarntes kf beank oås qun
rnlcnier nc pfhnr nafkño`af y l`keka`nrf rnec hn ces oeyfrns afrpfrea`fkns hnc `opnr`f, `opnr`f, y qun su
fjint`vf ns afksnrver n `karnonkter nstn pfhnr pfr tfhfs cfs onh`fs onh`fs.. Uun nc pfhnr pfcït`af nstå,
nk sus l`dures oås hnsteaehes, sfont`hf e nstn pfhnr nafkño`af, l`keka`nrf y ofknter`f. Afof
bek ofstrehf Hev`h @agn f Ehr`åk Qecjuab`, nstes frdek`zea`fkns trejeiek e cerdf pcezf, afk
ednkhes hn ouabe oeyfr hurea`ñk y afkt`ku`heh qun ces qun punhnk eafontnrsn nk cfs a`acfs
pfcït`afs.. Esï, ec oerdnk hn ces r`vec`heh
pfcït`afs r`vec`hehnsns qun nx`stnk nktrn tfhfs nstfs ednktns, nc `ktnràs afoùk
ns nstejcnanr onh`hes afoukns qun cfs jnknl`a`nk e tfhfs, qun kf sfk ftres qun ces hnc
`opnr`ec`sof aep`tec`ste, ces hnc sfont`o`nktf
sfont`o`nktf hn ces kea`fkns y cfs punjcfs qun sn s n rns`stnk ec
`opnr`f,, ces hn ce anktrec`zea`ñk hnc afktrfc y nc hfo`k`f
`opnr`f hfo`k`f,, ces hn ce nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze hnshn nc
pfcf `klnr`fr hnc s`stnoe bea`e nc supnr`fr.
supnr`fr. ]fr nsf nk nc lfkhf kf ns `oprnsa`kh`jcn afkfanr nk
hnteccn nstes frdek`zea`fkns, nk ce onh`he nk qun sejnofs qun su cñd`ae kf hnie hn snr ce hnc
hfo`k`f `opnr`ec`ste aep`tec`ste, ces hnc tftec`ter`sof ofknter`f, a`nktïl`af, tnakfcñd`af,
tnakfcñd`af, oàh`af
oàh`af,,
onh`åt`af,, nta. ]fr hnjeif hn nstn k`vnc hn frdek`zea`fkns snarntes y sno`snarntes sn 
onh`åt`af
2= 
nkaunktrek ftres frdek`zea`fkns `ktnrkea`fkecns y cfs eperetfs hn Nstehf Nstehf,, auyfs aerdfs
pr`ka`pecns sfk hna`h`hfs, eanptehfs, afktrfcehfs,
afktrfcehfs, afoprfont`hfs
afoprfont`hfs,, hn uke oeknre u ftre, hnshn
nstn k`vnc supnr`fr.
Ns `opfrtektn sujreyer ce h`onks`ñk snarnte hn nstes ns tes frdek`zea`fkns. Qfk «fifs qun tfhf cf vnk·
afof nc s`tuehf nk ce aùsp`hn hn ce p`råo`hn oesñk`ae. Afof nc punstf hn v`d`ceka`e anktrec hnc
]ekñpt`af
]ekñpt `af hn Inrnoy Jnktbeo, hnshn nc qun sn punhn vnr tfhf s`k snr v`stf, afof kfs be
ofstrehf O`abnc Lfuaeuct.
Lfuaeuct. Esï, ce pfcït`ae, afkvnrt`he aehe vnz oås nk `kdnk`nrïe sfa`ec,
s fa`ec, nk ce qun
tnro`kerå trekslfroåkhfsn e cerdf pcezf, afks`stn nk «afkstru`r y oektnknr uk s`stnoe hns`duec
nk nc qun ukfs vnk s`k snr v`stfs, y ftrfs sfk v`stfs s`k vnr· (Dfuvnrknrper cn Abefs9
 @kdàk`nr`n Qfa`ecn nt Ofkhe-c`set`fk). Kf sfcf sn trete hn vnrcf tfhf, s`kf
teoj`àk hn qun tfhfs cfs qun nståk jeif su afktrfc snpek qun ns nståk
tåk s`nkhf v`d`cehfs. Nk
nlnatf, ces acevns
acevns hnc dfj`nrkf hnc `opnr`f sfk nc snarnt`sof y ce fok`sa`nka`e. Hn ebï qun nc
afktrfc hn cfs eperetfs hn `ktnc`dnka`e sne lukheonktec, puns luka`fkek sndùk nste o`soe cñd`ae,
snek ces prfp`es ednka`es hn `ktnc`dnka`e dujnrkeonktecns f snrv`a`fs
snr v`a`fs perecncfs
perecncfs.. Nstn s`stnoe hn
dfj`nrkf supfkn ce ar`o`kec`heh nkauj`nrte y ce `opuk`heh hn cfs oàtfhfs oàtfhfs,, esï afof nc afktrfc
hn cfs ednktns oås `opfrtektns hn ce pfcït`ae, ce iust`a`e, ce a`nka`e, ce aucture y cfs onh`fs, e
trevàs hn tfhfs cfs oàtfhfs qun snek knanser`fs, `kacu`hfs nc sfjfrkf, ce nxtfrs`ñk, ce rnvncea`ñk
hn snarntfs, ce eonkeze f nc esns`ketf
esns`ketf..
]nrf ces afses sfk ouabf oås afopc`aehes, tnk`nkhf nk aunkte qun ces inrerquïes hn pfhnr kf
sfk nstejcns 
8:
 

y ces r`vec`hehns kf ansek, qun cfs h`st`ktfs snrv`a`fs hn `ktnc`dnka`e punhnk trejeier hn oeknre
oås f onkfs affrh`kehe f afopnt`r y v`d`cersn nktrn nccfs, sfcepersn afk ftrfs snrv`a`fs
perecncfs, nta. Nstes r`vec`hehns
r`vec`hehns sn pfknk hn oek`l`nstf pert`auceronktn auekhf ecdukf hn nstfs
«fifs qun tfhf cf vnk· h`lukhn `klfroea`ñk pr`vehe
pr`vehe hn ecdùk h`r`dnktn, f hnsvnce pertn hn
fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes, pere prns`fker, pere hnofstrer cf qun punhn, afof ev`sfs pere
kevndektns. 
 
Ces ar`s`s l`at`a`es 
81
Bnofs v`stf qun ce jesn hn ce afkqu`ste `opnr`ec aep`tec`ste, qun sn nstå hnserrfccekhf ec o`sof
t`nopf nk ouabfs lrnktns,
lrnktns, hnshn ce `kdnk`nrïe sfa`ec e cfs tnetrfs hn dunrre, sn punhn rnhua`r e ce
cñd`ae hn trekslfroer ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn nk rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes. «]ere quà ofcnster e kunstrf
pr`of p`h`àkhfcn qun kfs prnstn su tecehrehfre, s` ns oås låa`c `r ec anktrf afonra`ec y afoprer
uke.· Nste `hne, qun pernan eknahñt`ae, nxprnse ce cñd`ae hnc evekan aep`tec`ste, qun ns nk junke
onh`he pure `hnfcfdïe. «]ere quà ofcnstersn nk prnperer uk du`sf aesnrf aesnrf,, s` ns oås låa`c `r ec
OaHfkech's.. ]ere quà ofcnstersn nk rnuk`rsn afk cfs eo`dfs, s` ns oås låa`c afoprer uke pnc` hn
OaHfkech's
Bfccywffh y vnrce nk aese...· Uun ftfrdunofs oås vecfr e ces l`aa`fkns aep`tec`stes qun e ce
rnec`heh hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn ns nc ddrek
rek lrnktn hn jetecce hnc s`stnoe y hn su prfpedekhe. Nstf
ns cf qun bek fjv`ehf cfs nafkfo`stes9 qun nk ce o`soe kfa`ñk hn vecfr aep`tec`ste nståk
afktnk`hfs ncnonktfs ofrecns, `hnfcñd`afs, sujint`vfs,
sujint`vfs, rnc`d`fsfs, qun ns `opfs`jcn nc`o`ker e
pnser hn qun kf punhek snr auekt`l`aehfs, qun hn bnabf lfroek pertn hn ce lñrouce auekt`tet`ve
hnc vecfr, eukqun kf sn punhek 
21
 

snperer hn ce ut`c`heh f nc trejeif ejstreatf. Hn bnabf ce nstretnd`e hnc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste afks`stn
nk rnhua`r h`abfs vecfrns `kafkonksurejc
`kafkonksurejcns ns e vecfrns hn aeoj`f
aeoj`f.. Qn bejce hn «pàrh`he hn
 vecfrns·, pnrf hn
hn cf qun bejrïe qun bejcer oås j`nk ns hn ce sust`tua`ñk hn cf cfss vecfrns
treh`a`fkecns, ofrecns, keturecns, aucturecns, v`tecns, nta., pfr vecfrns hn aeoj`f.
Nste trekslfroea`ñk hn ce afkv`v
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
nka`e-c`jrn nk rncea`fkns aep`tec`stes punhn prfhua`rsn hn
h`st`ktes lfroes9 hnshn ce c`jrn ncnaa`ñk beste ce dunrre, afk tfhes ces s`tuea`fkns `ktnronh`es.
Auektf oås pfhnr eauouce y afkanktre nc `opnr`f
`opnr`f,, auektf onkfr sne su pnkntrea`ñk nk nc kf-
`opnr`f
`opnr`f,
s`tuea`ñk, auektf oås arït`ae
nk ces årnes sne su knans`heh
e afkqu`ster, hn afkqu`ste,
oås v`fcnktf auektf
tnkhnrå e snr nstn oås hnsprftnd`he
prfansf sne ce
hn afkqu`ste.
@ks`st`ofs, ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn sn aereatnr`ze pfr su tnkhnka`e ec nqu`c`jr`f. Nstn hnjnrïe snr nc
 vnrhehnrf s`dk`l`aehf
s`dk`l`aehf hnc tàro`kf «sf
«sfstnk`j`c`heh·.
stnk`j`c`heh·. ]fr
]fr nc afktrer
afktrer`f
`f nc `opnr`f sn je
jese
se nk nc
hnsnqu`c`jr`f,, nk ce es`ontrïe7 puns cf qun pnrs`dun ns ce hfo`kea`ñk hn uk pfcf sfjrn ftrf, ce
hnsnqu`c`jr`f
nxpcftea`ñk y ce nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze hnshn nc pfcf `klnr`fr bea`e nc pfcf supnr`fr hnc s`stnoe.
Hn oeknre qun ce nstretnd`e jås`ae hnc `opnr`f ns, pfr uk cehf, eprfvnabersn
eprfvnabersn hn cfs hnsnqu`c`jr`fs
ye nx`stnktns, y pfr ftrf, `ktnks`l`aercfs, aetec`zercfs, prfvfaercfs. Nk suoe, lfonkter ces ar`s`s.
«Kf v`v`ofs uke ar`s`s hnc aep`tec`sof s`kf, ec afktrer`f, nc tr`uklf hnc aep`tec`sof hn ar`s`s·
(X`qquk-Afo`tà @kv`s`jcn).
@kv`s`jcn). Auecqu`nr ar`s`s ns uke fpfrtuk`heh pere nc `opnr`f pere euonkter su
årne hn `klcunka`e. 
28 
Nstf ns cf qun Kefo` Gcn`k be hnkfo`kehf «aep`tec`sof hnc hnsestrn·. ]nrf cf qun nste ekec`ste
kf be
hn, h`abf
s`kf ns qunnstes
prfvfaer ce tnkhnka`e `opcïa`te
ar`s`s. Ehnoås nnk
stfncns`opnr`ec`sof
 ‘ nstf aep`tec`ste
cf qun nste fjre ns, kf
prntnkhn sfcf ‘ 
epfrter eprfvnabersn
eprfvnab
 ‘ , nste ersn
tnkhnka`e `kbnrnktn e aetec`zer f prfvfaer ar`s`s rnspfkhn iusteonktn e uke cñd`ae ånl`aa`fke-
c`zea`ñk hn ce rnec`heh, f s` sn prnl`nrn, e trekslfroer ce rnec`heh sndùk
 l`aa`fkns prnafkanj`hes. Nk ftres pecejres, e `ktnks`l`aer pfr onh`fs
ert`l`a`ecns ar`s`s nx`stnktns y prnsnkterces nk cfs onh`fs
on h`fs hn
hns`klfroea`ñk afof ar`s`s einkes e ce eaa`ñk hnc `opnr`f, sne nk lfroe hn
aetåstrflns «keturecns·, pekhno`es hn «kunvfs· v`rus, «rnvfcua`fkns· sfa`ecns, afklc`atfs rnc`d`fsfs
f rea`ecns, eaa`fkns hn drupfs
d rupfs `ksurdnktns, etnktehfs tnrrfr`stes, nta.
 X`nkn rezñk nc Afo`tà
Afo`tà @kv`s`jcn auekhf
auekhf h`an qun nc pfh pfhnr
nr ye kf rns`hn nk ces
ces `kst`tua`fkns
`kst`tua`fkns.. Aehe
 vnz ns onkfs rnprnsnktet`v
rnprnsnktet`vff nk nc snkt`hf hn cf
cfss v`nifs sïojfcf
sïojfcfss hnc pfhnr
pfhnr.. P s`k nojerdf
nojerdf s`dun
rnprnsnktet`vf nk nc snkt`hf nk nc qun ces ar`s`s e trevàs hn ces qun fpnre, nkaerkek,
s`nkhf rnprnsnktet`vf
eukqun sne treks`tfr`eonktn, nc pfhnr. Nc onifr ninopcf hn nste lfroe lfr oe cïqu`he, lcu`he, nsp`r`tuec,
hn pfhnr, qun sn sfc`h`l`ae nk a`nrtfs ofonktfs y a`nrtfs lnkñonkfs, ns ce lfroe hn pfhnr pfr
ektfkfoes`e nk nc aep`tec`sof9 nc h`knrf. Uun afof bnofs ofstrehf ns e uk t`nopf afrpfrec
y nsp`r`tuec. Hn oeknre qun kf ns qun nc pfhnr beye rnkuka`ehf e su tnetrec`heh aereatnrïst`ae
y sn beye trekslfroehf nk «eketfofpfcït`ae· f «j`fpfcït`ae·. A`nrteonktn uke junke pertn hnc
pfhnr fpnre bfy sndùk ce cñd`ae ««eketfof/j`fp
eketfof/j`fpfcït`ae·,
fcït`ae·, 
88
 

afof kfs ofstrñ Lfuaeuct7 pnrf ftre pertn ‘ hn hn bnabf ce oås `opfrtektn ‘  cf  cf s`dun bea`nkhf
sndùk ce cñd`ae rnprnsnktet`ve, tnetrec, s`ojñc`ae. Qfcf qun ebfre nc tnetrf hnc pfhnr be sec`hf e ce
aeccn. Ce rnprnsnktea`ñk hnc pfhnr treh`a`fkec,
treh`a`fkec, ce hn cfs lestfs hn ce afrtn y cfs pecaf
pecafss rnecns, be
hehf pesf e ftre lfroe hn rnprnsnktea`ñk oås `klfroec9 cfs etnktehfs tnrrfr`stes tnrrfr`stes,, ces pekhno`es
f cfs hnsestrns «keturecns·. Ce Aese Jcekae be hehf pesf e ces Xf Xfrrns
rrns Dnonces «aeynkhf
`kfcv`hejcnonktn·
`kfcv`hejcnonkt n· nk sus oùct`pcns rnprnsnktea`fkns.
rnprnsnktea`fkns.
Nktrn nc pfhnr lfuaeuct`ekf, nc qun sn ninran e trevàs hn cfs aunrpfs, hn ces pfjcea`fkns
pfjcea`fkns,, hn cfs
h`spfs`t`vfs,
h`spfs`t`vf s, hn ces `kst`tua`fkns
`kst`tua`fkns,, y nstn pfhnr qun s`dun s`nkhf rnprnsnktet`vf
rnprnsnktet`vf,, tnetrec,
nspnateaucer, bey uke h`lnrnka`e lukheonktec9
lukheonktec9 nc pr`onrf sn afrrnspfkhn, e ddrekhns
rekhns resdfs, afk nc
pfhnr nstejcna`hf,
nstejcna`hf, `kst`tua`fkec`zehf7 o`nktres qun nc sndukhf ns uk pfhnr qun nstå pfr
nstejcnanrsn, qun `opfkn aeoj`fs s`dk`l`aet`vfs
s`dk`l`aet`vfs nk ce nstruature sfa`ec, pfcït`ae, nafkño`ae.
Q` ce afkv`v
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
nka`e-c`jrn t`nkhn ec nqu`c`jr`f, nc aep`tec`sof hn ar`s`s eprfvnabe n `ktnks`l`ae cfs
hnsnqu`c`jr`fs hn auecqu`nr t`pf.
t`pf. Cf qun h`lnrnka`e e kunstrf `opnr`f hn cfs hn ftrfs t`nopfs ns
qun be ecaekzehf uke nkfron aepea`heh, sfl`st`aea`ñk y sut`cnze pere aetec`zer h`abfs
hnsnqu`c`jr`fs,, pere lfonkter f prfvfaer nstes ar`s`s, e trevàs hn oàtfhfs epernktnonktn kf
hnsnqu`c`jr`fs
edrns`vfs, onh`ektn
onh`ektn ce a`nka`e, ce tnakfcfdïe, ce onh`a`ke, ce j`fcfdïe, ce dnf`kdnk`nrïe, ce `kdnk`nrïe
sfa`ec, nta. Nste trekslnrnka`e e åoj`tfs a`nktïl`af-tnakfcñd`afs hn ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec ns uke hn
ces oåsaeres hn ces qun sn s`rvn nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk. Cf  
2< 
qun kf bejïe faurr`hf kukae ektns nk ce b`stfr`e ns qun sn puh`nre `klcunka`er tektf tektf,, y hn uke
oeknre tek `opnranpt`jcn, nk cfs lnkñonkfs keturecns f rnecns. Nv`hnktnonktn bey uk nkfron
trejeif hn `kvnst`dea`ñk hntrås hn nstes oekfs `kv`s`jcns, drekhns rnaursfs nafkño`afs, nafkño`afs,
pfhnrfsfs `ktnrnsns, pnrf tfhf nstf qunhe fauctf hntrås hn sus aetestrñl`afs nlnatfs. nlnatfs. Nstf ns cf
qun h`st`kdun ec `opnr`f hn bfy hn ftrfs `opnr`fs
`opnr`fs.. Xeoj`àk cf qun h`st`kdun ‘ rncet`veonktn
rncet`veonktn ‘  
ec `opnr`f etcekt`ste hn ftrfs `opnr`fs nonrdnktns9 su hfo`k`f hn ces ar`s`s oekuleaturehes
oekuleaturehes afof
oàtfhfs hn afkqu`ste.
Ces ar`s`s l`at`a`es sn jesek nk nc oàtfhf prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfc
 prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfcut`fk. ut`fk. Qn trete hn arner f
lfonkter prfjcnoes l`at`a`fs pere, eprfvnabekhf ce rneaa`ñk a`uheheke e h`abfs
prfjcnoes, ehfpter sfcua`fkns qun kf bejrïek s`hf eanptehes nk afkh`a`fkns kfroecns, y qun
ns cf qun sn prntnkhïe hnshn uk pr`ka`p`f, pere cf qun sn s n ofkte tfhe ce fpnrea`ñk. Nc «sbfag· ‘ 
ce rneaa`ñk ‘ qun nc prfjcnoe prfvfa prfvfaee nk ce a`uhehekïe bean pfs`jcn qun sn ehfptnk
sfcua`fkns hn nxanpa`ñk, qun kf bejrïek s`hf pfs`jcns nk uk Nstehf hn hnrnabf. Hn oeknre
qun nstn oàtfhf prfjcno-rneat`fk-sf
 prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfcut`fk, cut`fk, f s` sn prnl`nrn, ce arnea`ñk hn ar`s`s
l`at`a`es, pfkn hn oek`l`nstf beste quà puktf nc `opnr`f bfy fpnre sndùk uke cñd`ae tftec`ter`e.
Uunoe hnc Zn`abted ? hnrr`jf hn ces Xfrrns Dnonces. Qfjrn tfhf s` tnknofs nk aunkte qun nstes
ar`s`s sfk tektf oås nl`aeans ‘ «abfaektns·
«abfaektns· ‘ 
 ‘  auektf
 auektf oås hreoåt`aes, auektes oås vïat`oes
prfhuank. Q` ekec`zeofs nstes ar`s`s y jekhnres lecses afk pnrspnat`ve, s` kfs prndukteofs qu`àk
sn jnknl`a`e ‘au` jfkf, au` 
8>
 

 prfhnst ‘ hn ncces, kf snrå h`lïa`c eh`v`ker, e pnser hn ce afopcnie treoe hn snarnt`sof y


afopc`a`hehns, e pnser hn ce eecderejïe
afopc`a`hehns, cderejïe onh`åt`ae, qun cfs qun sn jnknl`a`ek hn ncces sfk
prfjejcnonktn cfs o`sofs qun ces prfvf aek. @ks`st`ofs, ces sfcua`fkns sfk cf pr`onrf, cf
prfvfaek.
afksndu`r.. ]ere nccf ns knanser`f prfvfaer uk prfjcnoe hn sul`a`nktn
qun sn prntnkhn afksndu`r
oedk`tuh qun prfvfqun tec rneaa`ñk nk nc pùjc`af, qun pnro`te fjv`er auecqu`nr hnjetn f
auecqu`nr rnlcnx`ñk snrnke sfjrn ce aunst`ñk. Uun nc pùjc`af kf sfcf eanptn s`kf qun hnoekhn ces

onh`hes hn nxanpa`ñk
hreoet`zer nstes afrrnspfkh`nktns.
afrrnspfkh`nktns
ar`s`s, y eprfvnabersn . Nkhnc
hnc «sbfag· hnl`k`t`v
hnl`k`t`ve
e snnspnatehfr
pùjc`af trete hn eprfvnaber, `ktnks`l`aer
pere evekzer nk ce y
ednkhe hn ce afkqu`ste `opnr`ec. Xfhf nstf pfkn hn oek`l`nstf, afof bnofs evekzehf, beste quà
puktf bfy cf pfcït`af y cf onh`åt`af vek hn ce oekf7 pnrf teoj`àk, añof sn trete nk ùct`oe
`ksteka`e hnc v`nif h`spfs`t`vf sear`l`a`ec ut`c`zehf nk tektes rnc`d`fkns y ebfre rntfoehf pfr ce
rnc`d`ñk aep`tec`ste dcfjec.
Bnofs h`abf qun nc hfo`k`f sn jese nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e nk nc h`spfs`t`vf sear`l`a`ec, qun nc
aep`tec`sof kf bean oås qun `kafrpfrer h`abf h`spfs`t`vh`spfs`t`vff sear`l`a`ec nk cfs prfp`fs onaek`sofs
hnc s`stnoe. Nc «aep`tec`sof hnc hnsestrn· ns uke vuncte hn tunrae oås nk nc prfansf hn
`kafrpfrea`ñk hn cf sear`l`a`ec
s ear`l`a`ec nk cfs prfansfs nafkño`afs
nafkño`afs,, a`nktïl`afs, tnakfcñd`afs, onh`åt`afs
onh`åt`afs,,
nta. Nste cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec kfs pnro`tn
pnr o`tn nktnkhnr cf qun ouabfs hn nstfs lnkñonkfs
epernktnonktn `kafknxfs
`kafknxfs t`nknk nk afoùk, añof nk tfhfs nccfs fpnre ce o`soe h`kåo`ae
trekslnrnka`ee hn aucpes, 
sear`l`a`ec9 ce trekslnrnka`
 
22aeters`s sfa`ec, ce `hnkt`l`aea`ñk l`at`a`e hn aucpejcns n `kfanktns, hn «junkfs· y «oecfs·, nta.
ce
Ce cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec ns nk nc lfkhf ce o`soe hn s`noprn. Qfcf qun ebfre sn bean oås sfl`st`aehe,
oås pnroeknktn, oås afopcnie, oås faucte f `kafksa`nktn. Ebfre nstes ar`s`s sn prfhuank afk
oås lrnaunka`e, nk h`st`ktfs åoj`tfs, e h`st`ktes nsaeces, sfcepåkhfsn ukes afk ftres,
`ksar`j`àkhfsn nk uke cñd`ae hn afkt`ku`h
afkt`ku`heheh hn h`st`ktfs nvnktfs, qun vek rnsfkekhf ukfs afk
ftrfs, qun vek rnlfrzekhf cfs o`tfs fl`a`ecns. Ces h`kåo`aes sear`l`a`ecns treh`a`fkecns teoj`àk sn
jesejek nk ce rnpnt`a`ñk, nk ce inrerquïe, nk rnonofrea`fkns y rneatuec`zea`fkns pnroeknktns. Hn
oeknre s`o`cer, ces ar`s`s bfy kf sn hek hn oeknre `khnpnkh`nktn, s`kf qun tfhes ncces sn
`ksar`jnk nk uke h`kåo`ae ùk`ae, sndùk uke ednkhe afoùk qun sn s n ve `opcektekhf
prfdrns`veonktn,
prfdrns`veonkt n, afk a`nrtes ver`ea`fkns
ver`ea`fkns.. Esï, kf ns aesuec`heh qun nktrn ukes ar`s`s y ftres sn
punhek fjsnrver petrfkns afoukns qun sud`nrnk, kf sfcf qun nx`stnk oekfs `kv`s`jcns qun
ces frqunstek, s`kf ehnoås qun kf sfk oås qun ver`ea`fkns hn uk o`sof du`ñk oås f onkfs
prnnstejcna`hf.. Equï y eccå ces o`soes aer`aetures hn Oebfoe, ce o`soe hnlnkse hn ce c`jnrteh hn
prnnstejcna`hf
nxprns`ñk, ces o`soes vïat`oes iuhïes, cfs o`sofs tnrrfr`stes ye l`abehfs l`abehfs pfr ce pfc`aïe, ces
o`soes hnstruaa`fkns hn prunjes...
pr unjes...
Hn cf qun sn trete nk hnl`k`t`ve ns hn qun ce v`fcnka`e hn uk nvnktf y ce hn ftrf snek pnra`j`hes
afof ce o`soe v`fcnka`e, qun nste s`de eatuekhf hn oeknre `opcïa`te afof eonkeze nktrn ukf y
ftrf,, nk nc ïktnr`k. Nk nlnatf ce eonkeze ns arua`ec perte nktnkhnr añof 
ftrf
8<
 

luka`fkek nstes ar`s`s. Cf qun afopertnk tfhes ncces ns qun hnjnk snr pnra`j`hes, kf sfcf afof
 v`fcnka`e nk eatf,
eatf, s`kf teoj`àk nk pftnka`e, afof eeonkezes.
onkezes. ]
]fr
fr ftrf ceh
cehff ns bej`tuec qun nstes
ar`s`s snek aehe vnz oås hn frhnk «dcfjec·. «Nstf f equnccf supfkn uke eonkeze dcfjec·, rnp`tnk
afof aeaetùes ces oer`fkntes pfcït`aes y cfs hns`klfroehfrns hn turkf. ]ere qun bedek pfs`jcn,
sndùk nc oàtfhf prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfc
 prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfcut`fk, ut`fk, ce ehfpa`ñk hn «sfcua`fkns dcfjecns·. Cfs
onh`fs hn prfpedekhe pfknk pert`aucer àkles`s nk ce v`kaucea`ñk nktrn ukes ar`s`s y ftres, kfs
rnaunrhek ektnanhnktns y aesfs s`o`cerns, `ks`stnk nk qun cfs o`sofs v`rus f cfs o`sofs
tnrrfr`stes f cfs o`sofs
kunves onkt`res fl`a`ecnseaa`hnktns eàrnfs afkaurr`nrfk
ces v`nies onkt`res fl`a`ecns, qunnktnro`kek
ar`s`s ektnr`frns, rnlfrzekhf
afkv`rt`àkhfsn esï afk
nk «vnrhehns·,
afof prfaceoeje nc v`nif Dfnjjncs, e lunrze hn rnpnt`a`ñk, hns`klfroea`ñk y anksure. Quanhnk
teoj`àk e onkuhf eafktna`o`nktfs epernktnonktn `ktresankhnktns
`ktresankhnktns ‘ afofafof nc `opeatf hn uk
hrfk nk cfs ierh`kns hn ce Aese Jcekae
J cekae (nknrf hn :=5>) ‘ 
 ‘ , qun luka`fkek sndùk ce o`soe cñd`ae
hn ce eonkeze cetnktn, y qun punhnk snr afkvnk`nktnonktn
afkvnk`nktnonktn prnsnktehfs nk uk luturf afof
«prunjes prn-afkst`tu`hes·, qun rnlunrzek nc afkiuktf hnc du`ñk, qun hek uk e`rn hn eutnkt`a`heh
e tfhe ce l`aa`ñk. Uun s`rvnk teoj`àk afof ev`sf e kevndektns qun cfs oås pfhnrfsfs hnst`kek e
cfs onkfs pfhnrfsfs
pfhnrfsfs,, f ss`opcnonktn
`opcnonktn ukfs pfhnrfsfs nkvïek e ftrfs pfhnrfsfs...
pfhnrfsfs... Hnspuàs hn
tfhf ce ùk`ae rndce ns qun kehe ns cf qun pernan.
Uun tfhes ces ar`s`s kf sfk oås qun lredonktfs
lredonktfs,, ver`ea`fkns, hnserrfccfs
hnserrfccfs,, hn uke o`soe ar`s`s
dcfjec, qun 
0= 
tfhes ces tàak`aes
h`st`ktes ar`s`s lfroek pertn
hn ar`s`s sn hn ce o`soe
ut`c`zek nstretnd`e,
hn oeknre pernan nv`hnktn
afoj`kehe. nk equnccfs
Qndùk h`vnrsfs aesfsnk
ekec`stes, nkncqun
^Q
(snpt`nojrn hn :==5) sn ut`c`zerfk hn oeknre s`ouctåkne nc afktrfc rnoftf hn ev`fkns (cfs qun
`opeaterfk nk ces Xfrrns Dnonces), ces eroes kuacnerns hn jeie `ktnks`heh (hnofc`a`ñk hn ces
tfrrns), ces eroes
er oes j`fcñd`aes (åktrex), ce dnf`kdnk`nrïe (bureaekns pere ejsfrjn
ejsfrjnrr ce reh`ea`ñk y
hnspcezerce bea`e nc Etcåkt`af), nta. Nc usf afoj`kehf hn h`st`ktes tàak`aes hn ar`s`s teoj`àk ns
uke pfhnrfse eroe hn perekf`h`zea`ñk hn ce sfa`nheh, rnlfrzekhf y ouct`pc`aekhf su nlnatf
eonkezektn. ]`àksnsn s`opcnonktn nk nc nlnatf qun prfvfae h`lukh`r qun drupfs tnrrfr`stes
«`kafktrfcehfs· punhnk beanr usf hn eroes er oes kuacnerns f j`fcñd`aes. Nste afoj`kea`ñk hn h`st`ktes
tàak`aes hn ar`s`s, iuktf e su ofhucea`ñk, pnro`tn ehepter su k`vnc hn `opeatf e ces a`rauksteka`es
y e cfs terdnts nspnaïl`afs
nspnaïl`afs.. Cf qun ns `opfrtektn nktnkhnr ns qun ce v`fcnka`e y su eonkeze, ces
eaa`fkns afkarntes y cfs nvnktfs «nv`tehfs· eatùek hn oeknre afoj`kehe y affrh`kehe. Nste ns
ftre hn ces rezfkns pfr ces qun t`nkn snkt`hf bejcer hn `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk9 ns tek
nlnat`vf cf qun faurrn afof cf qun pfhrïe faurr`r, cf qun sn nv`te afof cf qun sn `oed`ke.
 \`fcnka`e y eonkeze afofafof ces hfs aeres hn ccee o`soe ofknhe hnc hnc pfhnr
pfhnr..
Hn oeknre qun ces ar`s`s l`at`a`es kf sfk nk nc lfkhf tek h`lïa`cns hn rnafkfanr
rnafkfanr.. Xfhf equnc qun
hnh`ae ecdùk t`nopf ec tnoe tnr tnro`ke
o`ke `hnkt`l`aekhf petrfkns afoukns, du`fkns s`o`cerns,
nstretnd`es el`kns, qun pnro`tnk 
84
 

sfspnaber qun sn trete hn ftrf np`sfh`f hn ce o`soe l`aa`ñk nk aursf.  Esï, cfs
o`sofs lnkñonkfs bfccywff-hnksns
bfccywff-hnksns sn vuncvnk e her uke y ftre vnz, cfs o`sofs pesepfrtns
`kteatfs hn tnrrfr`stes vuncvnk e epernank nk nc cuder hnc ar`onk, o`cedrfseonktn rnaupnrehfs
nktrn ces ru`kes hn ces X
Xfrrns
frrns Dnonces u «fcv`hehfs· pfr cfs tnrrfr`stes nk nc cuder hnc ar`onk hn
Aberc`n Bnjhf (nknrf hn :=5>). Ns bej`tuec qun beye lcnafs sunctfs, qun sn afontek nrrfrns, qun
beye `kafbnrnka`es,
`kafbnrnka`es, qun ce `klfroea`ñk oås rncnvektn kf tresa`nkhe e ce fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae, qun ces
prunjes oås afkacuynktns hnsepernzaek, qun tnst`dfs pr`v`cnd`ehfs f supunstfs eutfrns snek
esns`kehfs
hnsepernzaek ektns hn qun nk
f ounrek punhek bejcer,
nxtreões qun `ktncnatuecns
a`rauksteka`es... quncehnl`nkhnk
@kacusf vnrs`fkns
lecse jekhnre ectnrket`v
ectnrket`ves
oås `opfrtektn eshn
ces ùct`oes hàaehes ‘ nc nc ^Q ‘ , t`nkn ontnhures hn pete tek oeyùsauces afof qun ce Xfrrn 4 sn
hnrruojn s`k qun k`kdùk ev`ñk ce beye `opeatehf, f qun ce JJA `klfron hn nstn afcepsf
o`nktres ce tfrrn sn punhn vnr nk p`n nk pektecce. Qfjrn tfhf nstf, cfs onh`fs afktrfcehfs pfr nc
aep`tec aeccek.
Nstf kfs ccnve e ukf hn cfs espnatfs `opfrtektns hn nstes ar`s`s l`at`a`es. Nstes kf knans`tek ce
«afklfro`heh· hnc 5==% hn ce fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae. Ns sul`a`nktn afk qun ce oeyfrïe arne nk ces
 vnrs`fkns fl`a`ecns,
fl`a`ecns, cf qu
qunn sn punhn afksndu`r onh`ektn nc afktr
afktrfc
fc hn cfs onh`fs
onh`fs pr`ka`pecns, qqun
un
kf t`nknk kehe oås qun beanr qun h`lukh`r y rnpnt`r s`k sec`rsn hnc du`ñk cf qun cfs eperetfs hn
`ktnc`dnka`e y o`c`terns, ces nojeiehes f cfs onh`fs hn rnlnrnka`e hnc `opnr`f cns prfpfra`fkek.
prfpfra`fkek. Nc
s`stnoe 
82 
punhn tfcnrer ukcea`nrtf
Abfssuhfvsgy, punhndrehf
dlfonkter,
rehf hn «h`safklfro`heh·,
nk cfs aesfs nk qun n `kacusf, afof hn
ce h`vnrs`heh be pfs`a`fkns
ofstrehf O`abnc
punhe
`ktnks`l`aer nc afklc`atf sfa`ec f snrv`r afof afertehe pere ce rnprns`ñk. Nk nlnatf bfy nsteofs
 v`nkhf añof nc `opnr`f
`opnr`f nstå tretek
tretekhf
hf hn v`kaucer nc tnrrfr`sof afk equncces
equncces pfs`a`fkns qun
hnsvncek nstfs ofkteins, hn oeknre qun ces o`soes onh`hes hn nxanpa`ñk qun supunsteonktn
s`rvnk pere cuaber afktre nc tnrrfr`sof punhek snr ut`c`zehes afktre `ktncnatuecns, ekec`stes f
pnr`fh`stes qun hnkuka`ek ce lerse, y nk dnknrec afktre ce h`s`hnka`e.
Nste aunst`ñk hn ce «afklfro`heh· ‘ nc nc bnabf hn qun ce oek`pucea`ñk hn ce fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae kf
knans`te snr tftec pere snr nl`aez ‘ , ns nk nc lfkhf ce o`soe cñd`ae qun r`dn ce h`atehure aep`tec`ste
hn bnabf qun bfy pehnanofs. Nk nlnatf, nlnatf, ce h`atehure hn cfs onraehfs kf knans`te snr hn
hnrnabf pere snr nlnat`ve, nk ce onh`he nk qun s`de evekzekhf hn bnabf. Nste ns uke sut`cnze
qun sn cn nsaepe bfy e ce oeyfrïe y qun ns anktrec pere afoprnkhnr nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk. ] ]esf
esf
`opfk`nkhf,, s`k qun epnkes sn kftn. Ns cf qun Hev`h @agn hnkfo`ke «tbn
e pesf sn ve `opfk`nkhf
tftec`ter`ek t`ptfn· («nc evekan hn pukt`cces tftec`ter`f·). Afof be ofstrehf Xb`nrry
Onyssek ce h`atehure oås nl`aez ns equncce qun kf knans`te snr hnacerehe, nc dfcpn hn Nstehf oås
nlnat`vf ns equnc qun sfcf ns afkfa`hf pfr ukfs pfafs. Nc 55Q ns nc onifr ninopcf. Equï vnofs
ftre vnz nc vnrhehnrf pfhnr qun t`nkn bfy
bfy ce l`aa`ñk, puns sn punhn ccnder e nsank`l`aer ce
hnofarea`e o`nktres nc tftec`ter`sof eatùe afk tfhe su nl`aea`e. Kf `opfrte tektf qun ces  
01
 

onkt`res fl`a`ecns snek f kf vnrhehns, cf qun `opfrte ns qun ce oeyfrïe ces arne, y qun cfs kf
arnynktns, cfs bnrnins, snek teabehfs hn cfafs, hnofk`zehfs f knutrec`zehfs.
Oås ehncektn veofs e fauperkfs hnc pepnc anktrec qun ce dunrre hnsnopnõe nk nc `opnr`f
`opnr`f.. ]nrf
afkv`nkn ebfre ehncekter qun nstes ar`s`s rnspfkhnk e ce o`soe cñd`ae jàc`ae, e ce hn ce knans`heh
pùjc`af.. Nc @klfron
hn tfhf frhnk jesehf nk ce hfo`kea`ñk hn hns`dker y lejr`aer uk nkno`df pùjc`af
hn @rfk Ofukte`k ofstrñ qun nc s`stnoe hn dunrre ns uk onaek`sof lukheonk lukheonktec tec nk

kunstres
sfa`nheh sfa`nhehns,
s`de nstekhfqun auopcn uk
frdek`zehe afont`hf
sndùk nstruaturec
ce cñd`ae `oprnsa`kh`jcn
hn ce hfo`kea`ñk, nk cehnconh`he
ns hna`r, afktrfcnksfa`ec
afktrfc qun cee
trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e y su eonkeze. Ces ar`s`s kf sfk s fk oås qun lfroes hnr`vehes hn ces dunrres
treh`a`fkecns,, edrns`fkns pfr ftrfs onh`fs. Ces dunrres ps`afcñd`aes y ces dunrres
treh`a`fkecns
afkvnka`fkecns
afkvnka`fk ecns kf sfk oås qun uk o`sof lnkñonkf7 sfcf ces h`st`kdun ce `ktnks`heh. Nk nlnatf,
afof bnofs ofstrehf,
ofstrehf, ce v`fcnka`e rnec y su eonkeze
e onkeze kf sfk oås qun hfs pfcfs hn uke o`soe
cñd`ae, qun ns ce hn ce rnprnsnktea`ñk sear`l`a`ec. Nk nstn snkt`hf bey qun nktnkhnr qun ce nl`aea`e
qun t`nknk ces ar`s`s pere nc `opnr`f rns`hn prna`seonktn nk ce h`onks`ñk s`ojñc`ae, y qun t`nkn
ouabe oås `klcunka`e sfjrn ce rnec`heh hn cf qun sn suncn arnnr. Cf s`ojñc`af t`nkn ouabf oås
qun vnr afk ce v`fcnka`e y nc pfhnr qun afk nc ertner tn y ce nstàt`ae.
 Xfhf
 Xfhf nstf sn `ksar`jn
`ksar`jn nk ce cñd`ae hn ce dcfjec`ze-a`ñk y ce `ktnrrncea`ñk
`ktnrrncea`ñk hn ces nafkfoï
nafkfoïeses e k`vnc
dcfjec. Afof be ofstrehf Aceuh`f Getz, cfs afklc`atfs 
08 
`ktnr`opnr`ec`stes
hn oåsEhnoås,
ce dcf-jec`zea`ñk. oeraehfs ces qun sn h`nrfk
dunrres nk nchnacerehes,
lfroecns, pesehf sfkpunhnk
oås h`lïa`cns bfy nk nc afktnxtf
snr hnoes`ehf
hnvestehfres,, tnknr afksnaunka`es `kafktrfcejcns, hnj`hf ec usf hn er
hnvestehfres eroes
oes hn hnstruaa`ñk oes`ve.
Hn ebï qun nc `opnr`f rnaurre s`stnoåt`aeonktn e tfhf uk rnpnrtfr`f hn tàak`aes hn edrns`ñk oås
«jcekhes·, afof sfk cfs afklc`atfs hn jeie `ktnks`heh f ces dunrres hn auerte dnknrea`ñk, qun
hnsnopnõek uk pepnc s`o`cer ec hn ces dunrres acås`aes, qun auopcnk perna`hfs rfcns dnfpfcït`afs,
nafkño`afs, sfa`ecns, ofrecns, s`ojñc`afs, pnrf pfr ftrfs onh`fs. 
@ks`st`ofs nk ce cñd`ae hnc hnsnqu`c`jr`f qun nstå nk ce jesn hn ces ar`s`s. Afof bnofs h`abf,
h`abf, cf
qun h`st`kdun ec `opnr`f etcekt`ste hn ftrfs `opnr`fs ns nc usf nspnaïl`af hn su `ktnc`dnka`e hn
aere e hnseter h`abes ar`s`s, e `ktnks`l`aer f prfvfaer h`abfs hnsnqu`c`jr`fs
hnsnqu`c`jr`fs.. Nc `opnr`f sejn ouy
j`nk qun ce v`fcnka`e sn punhn prfvfaer
prfvfaer,, kf sfcf epc`aekhf v`fcnka`e, s`kf teoj`àk pfr onh`f hn
onaek`sofs ouabf oås sfl`st`aehfs,
sfl`st`aehfs, qun kf sfk nk hnl`k`t`ve oås qun lfroes hn v`fcnka`e nk
pftnka`e, cetnktn, sujc`oehe, pnrf v`fcnka`e ec l`k y ec aejf, hnshn ces aer`aetures hn Oebfoe e cfs
 v`rus hn cejfretfr`f.
cejfretfr`f. Ce v`fcnka`e, afof
afof ce nknrdïe, «kf sn arne k` sn hnstruyn, sfcf sn
trekslfroe·. Auekhf nc `opnr`f knans`te qun ce v`fcnka`e sn hnsetn nk n k ecdùk åoj`tf afkarntf, kf
t`nkn oås qun `kfaucer nc v`rus hnc fh`f rnc`d`fsf f rea`ec, aekec`zer lunrzes pfcït`aes y
sfa`ecns fpfs`tfres hn uk t`pf f hn ftrf, tfaer ces tnaces afrrnates nk nc frhnk afrrnatf, hn oeknre
qun «sn· eat`vn nc iundf hn ce v`fcnka`e rnaïprfae (Znkà D`rerh)
D`rerh),, qun 
80
 

«sn· `ktnks`l`qunk cfs hnsnqu`c`jr`fs


hnsnqu`c`jr`fs,, qun «sn· prfvfqunk lreatures, nk hnl`k`t`ve, qun «sn· arnnk
fpfrtuk`hehns pere ce `kves`ñk hnc aep`tec `opnr`ec. Nk nlnatf, nc «sn· hn X`qquk-Afo`tà @kv`s`jcn
sn afrrnspfkhn e ce pnrlnaa`ñk afk nste h`onks`ñk `opnrsfkec, uj`aue, s`stào`ae, hnc `opnr`f
`opnr`f..
Nk nc lfkhf ce cñd`ae qun nstå hntrås hn ces rnvfcua`fkns hn afcfrns f cfs afklc`atfs nktrn
rnc`d`fkns, snates f rezes ns ce o`soe qun ce qun nstå hntrås hn ces oek`pucea`fkns ac`oåt`aes f
sïso`aes. Ce nknrdïe nstå ye cetnktn7 sfcf
s fcf bean lecte c`jnrerce, hnsnkaehnkerce, hn oeknre qun punhe
snrv`r e cfs `ktnrnsns hnc `opnr`f. Ce -`kdnk`nrïe y ce -`kdnk`nrïe sfk hfs ver`ektns hn
a`ñert`l`a`ec hn dnf
ce o`soe cñd`ae hn oek`pucea`ñk >= ce rnec`heh. Hnspuàs hn tfhf,
¶quà onifr qun snrv`rsn hn uke nknrdïe ye nx`stnktn, cetnktn, eauoucehe,
eauoucehe, nspnrekhf e snr c`jnrehe,
pere afksndu`r nc oåx`of nlnatf afk ce onkfr eaa`ñk, pere pfhnr beanr arnnr qun sn trete hn uk
lnkñonkf afopcnteonktn
afopcnteonktn einkf e ce `ktnrvnka`ñk `opnr`ec6
Nste nstretnd`e hn «t`rer ce p`nhre y nsafkhnr ce oekf·, hn eprfvnab
eprfvnaberer cfs lnkñonkfs nx`stnktns y
oek`pucercfs,, nk hnl`k`t`ve, hn afklukh`r ce rnec`heh afk ce l`aa`ñk, bean qun ce cñd`ae hnc hfo`k`f
oek`pucercfs
`opnr`ec bfy kf nstà nxnkte hn uk a`nrtf aefs. Nc frhnk aep`tec`ste sn jnknl`a`e hnc aefs, cf
lfonkte, nk ce onh`he nk qun nstn cn pnro`tn
pnr o`tn afksndu`r cfs oåx`ofs nlnatfs afk nc oïk`of
nslunrzf.. Hnshn nc s`opcn
nslunrzf s `opcn hnsnqu`c`jr`f beste ce hnstruaa`ñk hn equncces årnes kf sfont`hes ec
`opnr`f,, auecqu`nr ectnrea`ñk hn ce afkv`v
`opnr`f afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
nka`e-c`jrn ns jnknl`a`fse. Xerhn f tnoprekf, nk luka`ñk
hn ce afyukture, 
>= 
nstes årnes hnsnstej`c`zehes
hnsnstej`c`zehes,, afkvucs`fkehes f hnstru`hes eaejek s`nkhf kunves fpfrtuk`hehns
pere ce afkqu`ste `opnr`ec. ]nrf cf qun bey qun nklet`zer, pfrqun
pfrqun pese hnsepnra`j`hf e ce oeyfrïe,
ns qun nstn hnsnqu`c`jr`f f hnstruaa`ñk hn ces rncea`fkns nx`stnktns, qun bean pfs`jcn ce afkqu`ste
aep`tec`ste, sn ninran teoj`àk bfy nk åoj`tfs epernktnonktn tek pfaf jàc`afs afof ce a`nka`e, ce
aucture, ce tnakfcfdïe f cfs onh`fs hn afouk`aea`ñk.
]`àksnsn nk nc aesf hn C`j`e. Afk `kdnk`nrïe sfa`ec, rnvfcua`fkns hn afcfrns, suo`k`strf hn eroes
e drupfs `ksurdnktns, nta., sn punhn snojrer nc aefs nk uk peïs prñspnrf y eanptejcnonktn
hnserrfccehf.. Ce `ktnrvnka`ñk nxpcïa`te hnc `opnr`f sfcf ns knanser`e ec l`kec hn uk cerdf y
hnserrfccehf
ontñh`af prfansf hn hns`ktndrea`ñk hn ces nstruatures pfcït`aes y sfa`ecns, afk uke aeopeõe hn
jfojerhnfs qun epnkes aeusn jeies faa`hnktecns, afkvnk
afkvnk`nktnonktn
`nktnonktn iust`l`aehe prnv`eonktn pfr
cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk. Hnspuàs hn nstf ce nstretnd`e hnc aefs s`dun hekhf sus lrutfs
afof lunktn hn hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk rnd`fkec. Nc aefs dnknre ràh`tfs ec `opnr`f nk ce onh`he nk qun
punhn nxtnkhnrsn e ftrfs nsanker`fs hn afklc`atf, dnknre o`cns hn iñvnkns perehfs, hnsafktnktfs
hnsafktnktfs,,
oerd`kehfs,, qun punhnk snr oek`pucehfs pere nkdrfser ces c`stes hn niàra`tfs prfxy7 bean qun
oerd`kehfs
a`nktfs hn o`cns hn `ko`drektns sn vnek fjc`dehfs e ejekhfker nc peïs y esï afktr`ju`r e ce
hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk hnc sur hn Nurfpe, nta. Kehe ns cf qun pernan, pnrf tfhf nstå rncea`fkehf. Nc
aefs pfr sï o`sof
o`sof,, `kacusf auekhf kf ve sndu`hf hn ce rnafkstruaa`ñk, ns jnknl`a`fsf pere nc
`opnr`f. Ns ouabf oås låa`c prfvfaer nc aefs qun  
04
 

arner uk kunvf frhnk. Esï, nc `opnr`f bfy ns nspna`ec`ste nk prfvfaer nc aefs pfr tfhfs cfs
onh`fs pfs`jcns.
Nk nstn afktnxtf bey qun `ktnrprnter cfs prfansfs hn jecaek`zea`ñk qun nsteofs v`nkhf bfy nk
h`st`ktfs nsanker`fs. Qn trete hn nste cñd`ae hnc aefs, hn ce `ktnr
`ktnrvnka`ñk
vnka`ñk hn h`st`ktfs ednktns kf
afopcnteonktn affrh`kehfs,
affrh`kehfs, hn ce `kst`dea`ñk hn afklc`atfs rea`ecns y rnc`d`fsfs, hn ce hfatr`ke hn
ce pncne hn pnrrfs, hnc h`v`hn nt `opnre. Nk hnl`k`t`ve, hn hnsnkaehnker hn oeknre ert`l`a`ec
ce v`fcnka`e cetnktn cfaeconktn y fr`nkterce nk nc snkt`hf nk qun cn ns ùt`c ec `opnr`f
`opnr`f.. Afof pertn
hn nstn prfansf
afont`hfs nc `opnr`f
pfr ukes `kst`de
leaa`fkns hn oeknre
afktre ftres, f nkauj`nrte
dr upfsces`ksurdnktns
pfr drupfs c`op`nzes àtk`aes
cfaecns, ypuns
cfs dnkfa`h`fs
nk hnl`k`t`ve
afktr`juynk e ce cñd`ae hn ce pert`a`ñk hn cfs Nstehfs pfsafcfk`ecns nk nkt`hehns oås
bfofdàknes auctureconktn,
auctureconktn, qun punhnk snr oås låa`conktn sfont`hes e ce hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec.
 Ec o`sof t`nopf qun s`rvnk pere prnsnkter
prnsnkter ektn ce fp`k`ñk
fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae uke kkerret`ve
erret`ve s`opcn y
nlnat`ve hn «junkfs· y «oecfs· qun iust`l`ae ces `ktnrvnka`fkns hn cfs niàra`tfs `opnr`ecns
`opnr`ecns.. 
>5 
Ce ednkhe dcfjec`ste 
Cfs pcekns pere `opcekter uk Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec kf sfk sfcf cfs hn uke àc`tn pfhnrfse qun
sn jnknl`a`erïe nkfrononktn hn nstn afktrfc pceknter`f.
pceknter`f. Cf qun ns `opfrtektn nktnkhnr ns qun
nstn ns uk prfansf `opcïa`tf nk cfs onaek`sofs hn eauoucea`ñk y afkanktrea`ñk aep`tec`stes
aep`tec`stes.. ]fr
`ks`st`ofs, nk nc lfkhf kf ns `oprnsa`kh`jcn sejnr s` cfs qun oås oekhek sfk cfs
nsf, `ks`st`ofs,
Zftbsab`ch f cfs Zfagnlnccnr
Zfagnlnccnr f cfs Ofrdek f cfs Jusb, s` sfk iuhïfs esqunkezïns u frdek`zea`fkns
oesñk`aes.
oekhek, Xfhf
Xfhf
pnrf nstf punhn
cf hna`s`vf afktr`ju`r
ns qun, e afoprnkhnr
nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, suce hfo`k`f
ofrec y cesn`hnfcfdïe hn cfshn
ninran e trevàs qun oås
onaek`sofs aep`tec`stes knfc`jnrecns dcfjecns.
dcfjecns.
Ce tnkhnka`e `koeknktn hnc aep`tec ns sndu`r hnstruynkhf tfhes ces nstruatures qun sn s n cn fpfknk,
nspna`econktn equncces qun oås sn eanraek e ce kfa`ñk hn afkv`vnk afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn,
a`e-c`jrn, n `r sust`tuyàkhfces
pfr uke nstruature ùk`ae, anktrec`zehe y tftec`ter`e. ]nrf `dueconktn
`dueconktn bey qun nktnkhnr qun, s` j`nk
nk uke pr`onre lesn nste nstruature sn pfhrïe pernanr e ce hn cfs dfj`nrkfs
d fj`nrkfs tftec`ter`fs
vnrhehnree tnkhnka`e hnc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste ns qun snek cfs prfp`fs onaek`sofs 
treh`a`fkecns,, ce vnrhehnr
treh`a`fkecns
00
 

hnc s`stnoe cfs qun ninrzek nc hfo`k`f y nc afktrfc hn oeknre `opcïa`te. Nk ftres pecejres, bea`e
cf qun veofs ns bea`e uk oukhf nk nc qun nc hfo`k`f sn ninranrå aehe vnz oås e trevàs hnc
h`knrf,, nc secer`f, cfs `opunstfs, ce hnuhe, ce a`nka`e, ce tnakfcfdïe, ce onh`a`ke, ce ac`oetfcfdïe,
h`knrf
nta. Nk nc qun cfs oàh`afs bedek ces vnans hn pfc`aïes, nk nc qun cfs h`spfs`t`vfs soert
`opcektehfs nk kunstrfs aunrpfs bedek ces vnans hn `ktnrrfdetfr`fs. «Nc jrezf eroehf hnc pfhnr
qun v`nkn ns ce onh`a`ke· (X`qquk-Afo`tà @kv`s`jcn). Bea`e cf qun veofs ns bea`e uk
oukhf h`stñp`af pnrf rnec, pfrqun nk nstn prfansf iunde uk pepnc anktrec
ce eaa`ñk `ktnka`fkehe y affrh`kehe hn ce l`aa`ñk y su trekslfroea`ñk
nk rnec`heh. Nc ùct`of Bfccywffh, nc hn ces aetåstrflns y cfs zfoj`s, afkvnrt`hf
afkvnrt`hf nk rnec`heh.
^k oukhf nk nc qun l`keconktn ce fjc`dea`ñk hn prfhua`r y ce c`jnrteh hn afksuo`r af`ka`h`råk.
^k oukhf nk nc qun nc hfo`k`f snrå tek pnrlnatf qun kf knans`terå rnaurr`r e ce v`fcnka`e, nk nc
qun kf sn h`st`kdu`råk ce v`fcnka`e y su eonkeze cetnktn y afkstektn. ^k oukhf nk nc qun ce
l`aa`ñk ecaekzerå su auconk, af`ka`h`nkhf afk ce rnec`heh.
r nec`heh. ^ke s`tuea`ñk tek ecniehe hn ce
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
afkv`v nka`e-c`jrn qun berå qun nste pernzae e tfhfs uke ofkstrufs`heh.
Nc Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec kf sfcf t`nkhn e hnspcnder y nkoesaerer cfs onaek`sofs hn hfo`k`f y
afktrfc nk uk eopc`f nspnatrf hn h`spfs`t`vfs. Ehnoås nste o`soe eaa`ñk afoj`kehe nstå s`nkhf
uke hn ces nstretnd`es pere su `opcektea`ñk. Hn ebï qun, afof vnk`ofs h`a`nkhf,
h`a`nkhf, pere
afoprnkhnr bfy nc `opnr`f y su tnkhnka`e bea`e ce h`atehure dcfjec sne knanser`e uke  
>: 
 v`s`ñk
nktnkhnrpekfråo`a
pekfråo`ae, e, `ktndrehfre,
nc treslfkhf ouct`
ouct`h`onks`fkec.
hn uke ouct`tuhh`onks`fkec.
hn lnkñonkfs Qfcf
Qfcf nste v`s`ñk dcfj
epernktnonktn dcfjec
ec punhncfaecns,
pera`ecns, pnro`t`rkfs
snatfr`ecns.
 \`s`ñk dcfjec, pfr cf tektf, pnrf sfcf pere rns`st`r nc dcfjec`sof. 
Ce tnkhnka`e `koeknktn hnc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste ns nxtnrkec`zer su v`fcnka`e, `kafrpfrerce aehe vnz
oås nk cfs h`spfs`t`v
h`spfs`t`vfs
fs qun cf hnl`knk, euonkter aehe vnz oås su ecaekan. Ec o`sof t`nopf qun
`ktnrkec`zerce nk nc suintf, e trevàs hnc afksuof afopucs`v
afopucs`vff, hn ssuu trekslfroea`ñk nk onraekaïe.
Nste nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e bean qun aep`tec`sof n `opnr`ec`sof snek, nk ce pråat`ae, cf
o`sof.. Qn trete hn uk prfansf `operejcn qun afoj`ke nste h`kåo`ae hn nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn ce
o`sof
 v`fcnka`e afk su nkoesaereo`nktf
nkoesaereo`nktf.. ]rfynater ce v`fcnka`e sfa`ec nk cfs prfp`fs h`spfs`t`vfs
h`spfs`t`vfs hnc
s`stnoe pnro`tn, eukqun sne prfv`s`fkeconktn,
prfv`s`fkeconktn, hnsbeanrsn hn ncce, kf rnafkfanrce, nxpucserce, nk
uke d`dektnsae aeters`s qun cf ejerae tfhf. ]rfansf hn trekslnrnka`e y hn kndea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e
nstruaturec prfp`e hnc s`stnoe, nk nc qun iunde uk pepnc lukheonktec ce prfpedekhe, pnrf qun kf
punhn prfhua`rsn s`k ce pert`a`pea`ñk hn cfs suintfs. Hn ebï qun ce rns`stnka`e sn prfhuzae e tfhfs
cfs k`vncns, qun ce prfpedekhe sne ukf hn cfs ncnonktfs hn pfhnr anktrecns nk nc `opnr`f hn
ce l`aa`ñk. 
^ke hn ces aereatnrïst`aes lukheonkt
lukheonktecns,
ecns, pfr cf tektf, hn cfs onaek`sofs aep`tec`stes, ns qun
Q`rvnk hn vnbïaucfs e ce nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e. Qfk ce dunrre pfr ftrfs onh`fs.
Afks`dunk pea`l`aer a`nrtes årnes hnc `opnr`f e afste hn trekslnr`r su v`fcnka`e e ftres årnes oås
lråd`cns, oås prnaer`es, oås hàj`cns. Ns 
5=5
 

pfs`jcn qun, afof be ofstrehf Gerc ]fceky`, afks`dek nv`ter nk a`nrtfs pnrïfhfs dunrres
oukh`ecns,, pnrf cf beank e afste hn afkanktrer ce `ktnks`heh hn cfs afklc`atfs nk ftres årnes qun
oukh`ecns
t`nknk onkfs `ka`hnka`e nk nc luka`fkeo`nktf hnc afkiuktf.
afkiuktf. C`j`e hnstrfzehe e sñcf ukfs
g`cñontrfs hn Nurfpe7 Pudfscev`e,
Pudfscev`e, ^arek`e... Nk ftres pecejres, cf qun sn ve rnl`kekhf aehe vnz
oås ns, kf tektf ce hnseper`a`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e, s`kf su hnsvïf, su aekec`zea`ñk, hn oeknre qun
sne lunktn hn jnknl`a`f. ]nrf sfcf hn jnknl`a`f nk nc snkt`hf oås nstrnabf hnc tàro`kf. Nste ns ce
h`st`ka`ñk lukheonktec nktrn cfs sear`l`a`fs treh`a`fkecns y cfs sear`l`a`fs aep`tec`stes. Nk cfs
ùct`ofs
Cf lectelekåt`afs
qun cfs nc «destf
«d estfhnc
`oprfhuat`vf·.
`oprfhuat`v f·. Nstf
«c`jrn· onraehf kfnskfs
cf aunktek,
qun supfkf
vnrnsafk
sfcfcua`hnz
qun nkDnfrdns
rnec`hehJete`ccn.
sn nståk
rnl`r`nkhf e uk s`stnoe hn `ktnrvnka`ñk qun pr`v`cnd`e ec drek aep`tec trekskea`fkec pfr nka`oe hn
auecqu`nr ftre afse, s`kf sfjrn tfhf, qun supnh`ter ce sfjnrekïe, ce pfcït`ae, nc hnrnabf
hnrnabf,, cfs onh`fs
hn afouk`aea`ñk, nta., e cfs onaek`sofs hnc aep`tec supfkn `ktnks`l`aer su pepnc nxtnrkec`zehfr
hn ce v`fcnka`e. ]uns àstfs qunhek c`jrns hn tfhe etehure pere snr vnbïaucfs nxacus`vfs hn ce
 v`fcnka`e sfa`ec y pere
pere hnsnkaehnkerce eccï hhfkhn
fkhn cfs jnknl`a`f
jnknl`a`fss hnc aep`tec sfk ooeyfrns
eyfrns y oås
råp`hfs, c`jrns pere hnspcezersn hn uk cuder e ftrf uke vnz qun bek sequnehf y nsqu`coehf ns qu`coehf uke
rnd`ñk tres ftre.
Hn oeknre qun ce hnr`ve dcfjec`ste afkhu afkhuan
an h`rnateonktn e oås y oås v`fcnka`e. Auekte oås
dcfjec`-zea`ñk, auekte oås hnpnkhnka`e hn rnaursfs einkfs, auekte oås nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn årnes
hn ce prfhuaa`ñk, 
>1 
auektf
k`vncns,, oås
k`vncns oås trekspfrtn
v`fcnka`e. P`ktnrkea`fkec
ehnoås, oåshnlred`c`heh,
onraekaïes,
oåsauekte
låa`c nsoåsqunpàrh`he hn s`stào`ae
uke ar`s`s sfjnrekïefe uke
tfhfs cfs
dunrre
oukh`ec tnkde afksnaunka`es tråd`aes pere ce oeyfrïe.
oeyfrïe. Nstf ns cf qun nståk ut`c`zekhf ces àc`tns
pere `opfknr su Kunvf Frhnk dcfjec. Nc oukhf nstå tek `ktnrrncea`fke-hf qun auecqu`nr
ofh`l`aea`ñk nk auecqu`nre hn cfs peråontrfs qun `ktnreatùek e k`vnc dcfjec ‘ prna`fs prna`fs hn ce
nknrdïe, oetnr`es pr`oes, afktrfc hn ces rutes hn trekspfrtn, nta. ‘  , , elnate e tfhf nc afkiuktf y
prfhuan dekehfrns y pnrhnhfrns hn oeknre `opcïa`te. Nstf s`dk`l`aes `dk`l`ae qun, `kv`rt`nkhf cfs
tàro`kfs, sn punhn afksndu`r elnater uk åoj`tf hnc `opnr`f eatuekhf sfjrn ftrf. ftrf. Nstf ns cf qun
nkaujrn ce ednkhe dcfjec`ste9 uk oeyfr afktrfc dcfjec, uk oeyfr pfhnr hn oek`pucea`ñk hnc
afkiuktf nk jesn ec afktrfc hn a`nrtfs peråontrfs dnfnstretàd`afs. Nc oukhf dcfjec`zehf sfcf
afkhuan e oås v`fcnka`e. ^k peïs punhn snr vïat`oe hn ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec pfr nc sfcf bnabf hn
nster nk uk årne nstretàd`ae pere nc trekspfrtn f nc eaansf e ce nknrdïe, pfr c`kher afk ces edues hn
uk nstrnabf oerït`of.
oerït`of. Nstf ns cf qun kf kfs aunktek cfs prfsnc`t`stes hn ce dcfjec`zea`ñk.
dcfjec`zea`ñk.
]nrf ce dcfjec`zea`ñk kf sfcf afks`stn nk ce nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec nk ces
pnr`lnr`es, teoj`àk afkv`nrtn
afkv`nrtn pertn hn cfs anktrfs nk pnr`lnr`es. Ce o`c`ter`zea`ñk hn ces pfc`aïes
kea`fkecns y cfaecns kf ns oås qun ce afksnaunka`e hn nste h`kåo`ae `opcïa`te nk ce dcfjec`zea`ñk.
Ns nv`hnktn qun, s` ces àc`tns aep`tec`stes sn `ktnrnsek oås pfr sus kndfa`fs qun 
5=1
 

pfr sus afka`uhehekfs, hnscfaec`zekhf ce prfhuaa`ñk y afkhnkekhf e sus vna`kfs e ce


oerd`kec`heh, knans`tek ec o`sof t`nopf `ktnks`l`aer ce v`fcnka`e afktre sus vna`kfs. Nk nstn
afktnxtf bey qun nktnkhnr qun, nk ce s`tuea`ñk hn ar`s`s y hn treks`a`ñk hn cfs anktrfs hn pfhnr e
k`vnc oukh`ec qun nsteofs etrevnsekhf,
etrevnsekhf, ces rnspunstes e ces ar`s`s sfk prna`seonktn ce
fpfrtuk`heh hn `opcnonkter onh`hes nxanpa`fkecns qun afktr`juyek e ce `ksteurea`ñk hnc
Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec. Nk ftres pecejres, nc aefs y ce v`fcnka`e nk ces pnr`lnr`es hn cfs anktrfs kf
sfk tektf uk prfjcnoe pere ces àc`tns oås pfhnrfses s`kf uke fpfrtuk`heh pere evekzer nk ce
h`atehure dcfjec. Nk nstn snkt`hf bey qun cnnr cfs arna`nktns lcuifs hn `ko`drea`ñk
«hnsafktrfcehe· qun nstå s`nkhf ut`c`zehe ert`l`a`econktn afof ednktn hnsnstej`c`zehfr, esï
afof ce nv`hnktn `kst`dea`ñk e ce v`fcnka`e rea`ec y ec hnsaràh`tf hn ces pfc`aïes cfaecns qun
nsteofs fjsnrvekhf nk Nstehfs ^k`hfs.
Ftre aereatnrïst`ae prfp`e hn ce ednkhe
ed nkhe dcfjec`ste y hn su sujh`v`s`ñk nk h`vnrses ednkhes
pera`ecns, snatfr`ecns,
snatfr`ecns, prfdrns`ves, ns qun kf nx`stn uke af`ka`hnka`e tftec nktrn aehe uke hn ncces y
ces h`st`ktes ar`s`s f nvnktfs
nvnktfs,, oås f onkfs l`at`a`fs, qun pnro`tnk su `o-pcnonktea`ñk. Esï, uke
aetåstrfln «keturec·, uke pekhno`e f uk «eaa`hnktn· eàrnf punhnk snrv`r s nrv`r ec o`sof t`nopf pere
evekzer nk cfs o`sofs åoj`tfs, afof pfr ninopcf,
ninopcf, ce c`jnrec`zea`ñk hnc ssnarntf
narntf oàh`af f nc
afktrfc j`foàtr`af hn cfs suintfs. ^k lcuif `kus`tehf hn `ko`drea`ñk f uke eonkeze tnrrfr`ste
trekskea`fkec punhnk snrv`r eojfs e ce arnea`ñk hn uke lunrze eroehe hn aeråatnr trekskea`fkec.
Nk ftres pecejres, 
5=8 
nc
qun`opnr`f t`nknnuke
sn sfcepek ednkhe dcfjec`ste
`ktnrrncea`fkek. qun cehf,
]fr ftrf sn h`v`hn
cehf e sutfhe
, nx`stnk vnz uke
nk uksnr`n
afkiuktf hnyednkhes
hn ar`s`s nvnktfspera`ecns
qun e su
 vnz sn sfcepek n `ktnrrncea`fkek.
`ktnrrncea`fkek. ]
]fr ùct`of,, ce nstretnd`e prfjcno-rneat`
fr ùct`of  prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfcut`fk
fk-sfcut`fk
nstejcnan l`at`a`eonktn rncea`fkns hn aeuse-nlnatf nktrn h`abfs prfjcnoes y sus
sfcua`fkns. ]nrf hehfs nstfs sfcepns nx`stnktns tektf ec k`vnc hn ces ednkhes afof ec hn ces
ar`s`s, h`vnrses ar`s`s punhnk afktr`ju`r e uke o`soe ednkhe7 hn ce o`soe oeknre qun uke o`soe
ar`s`s punhn afktr`ju`r e h`vnrses ednkhes. Nk suoe, ce vnrhehnre afbnrnka`e, ce vnrhehnre
el`k`heh, kf ns ce qun v`kauce cfs prfjcnoes y ces sfcua`fkns, afof ce prfpedekhe
prntnkhn beanrkfs arnnr, s`kf ce qun v`kauce e tfhes ces ar`s`s y nvnktfs l`at`a`fs nktrn sï, pfr uk
cehf, y e tfhes ces ednkhes pera`ecns nktrn sï, nk uke ednkhe dcfjec, pfr nc ftrf.
Nk ftres pecejres, afof vnk`ofs h`a`nkhf,
h`a`nkhf, bey uke drek afbnrnka`e nk tfhf nstn afkiuktf hn
lnkñonkfs qun hnkfo`keofs ar`s`s f nvnktfs lejr`aehfs f l`at`a`fs. Q`k hnsaerter qun ecdukfs hn
nccfs sï snek keturecns f nspfktåknfs, puns, afof bnofs v`stf, v`stf, cfs nvnktfs l`at`a`fs kf sfk oås
qun ce aetec`zea`ñk ert`l`a`ec hn cfs pr`onrfs. @dueconk
@dueconktn, tn, bey uke ddrek
rek afbnrnka`e, uk treslfkhf
a fkiuktf hn onh`hes qun sn prntnkhnk tfoer pere her sfcua`ñk e nstes
afoùk, nk tfhf nc afkiuktf
ar`s`s. Nste drek afbnrnka`e hn lfkhf hn eojes snr`ns ns, `ks`st`ofs, oås s`dk`l`aet`ve qun ce qun
nx`stn nktrn cfs prfjcnoes y ces sfcua`fkns, rnlfrzekhf tfhf nccf ce tns`s hn qun ce
nstretnd`e prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfcu
 prfjcno-rneat`fk-sfcut`fk t`fk nstå pnroeknktnonktn nk nsanke. 
>8
 

 Esï, s` fjsnrveofs hntnk`heonktn, qun aereatnr`ze e tfhes nstes sfcua`fkns ns cf qun nstå
hntnk`heonktn, cf qun
nk ce jesn hn ce afkqu`ste aep`tec`ste9 sust`tu`r ces rncea`fkns jesehes nk ce afkv`v
afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
nka`e-c`jrn pfr
rncea`fkns hn hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste, trekslnr`r ce sfjnrekïe hn cfs punjcfs e tfhf uk ejek`af hn
h`spfs`t`vfs, aehe vnz oås anktrec`zehfs, afktrfcejcns, auekt`l`aejcns, h`d`tec`zejcns, oek`pucejcns,
es`oàtr`afs, nk cfs åoj`tfs ofknter`f, jekaer`f, l`saec, a`nktïl`af, tnakfcñd`af, oàh`af, sek`ter`f,
nta.
Ces `ktnka`fkns dcfjecns hnc `opnr`f sn punhnk fjsnrver teoj`àk nk nc bnabf hn qun ouabes hn
nstes ar`s`shn
pert`aucer y nvnktfs lejr`aehfs
cfs peïsns anktrecns.elnatek,
Hn kunvfkf, pfr
kunvf, aesuec`heh,
fjsnrveofs ukeo`sof
vïat`oes `ktnrkea`fkecns,
lnkñonkf nk hn
nk nvnktfs
h`st`ktf t`pf, hnshn uk «eaa`hnktn· eàrnf e uk etnktehf nk uk årne turïst`ae f uk nvnktf hnpfrt`vf
`ktnrkea`fkec. Kf `opfrte cf cnifs hn aese qun sn prfhuzaek nstes ar`s`s, nk ncces ns bej`tuec
qun beye `opc`aehfs kea`fkecns hn cfs qun sn fauperåk pr`fr`ter`eonktn cfs onh`fs hn
hns`klfroea`ñk cfaecns, qun snråk rnpetr`ehfs afk tfhfs cfs bfkfrns y ce perelnrkec`e pfr ces
eutfr`hehns hn turkf. Xfhf nccf kf sfcf hfte hn oeyfr rnec`heh ec afkiuktf hn bl`a-a`ñk,
dnknrekhf uke oeyfr nopet`e n `hnkt`l`aea`ñk nk nc nspnatehfr
ns pnatehfr,, s`kf qun ehnoås afktr`juyn e
arner ce `oprns`ñk hn qun h`abes «eonkezes· sfk nlnat`veonktn «dcfjecns·, y pfr cf tektf
knans`tek «sfcua`fkns dcfjecns·. Esï, sn trete hn qun ces ar`s`s snek,
sne k, pfr hnl`k`a`ñk,
trekskea`fkecns,, eat`vekhf hn oeknre `opcïa`te nste cñd`ae hn rnspunste dcfjec qun afktr`juyn e
trekskea`fkecns
cfs 
5=< 
pcekns dcfjec`stes. Nc «sbfag· afof oàtfhf hn afbns`ñk hn tfhfs cfs c fs punjcfs nk nc Kunvf
n xtnro`k`f hn cfs `kl`ncns. Ce rnc`d`ñk hn cfs sear`l`a`fs
Frhnk Oukh`ec, y hn nxtnro`k`f sear`l`a`fs
 dcfjecns. 
Uun nc Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec sn nstå `opcektekhf prfdrns`veonktn, snatfr`econktn,
snatfr`econktn, e trevàs hn
tfhe uke snr`n hn evekans y nxpnr`onktfs cfaecns, oerd`kecns, pnr`làr`afs, eprfvnabekhf
s`tuea`fkns levfrejcns
levfrejcns f nxanpa`fkecns, kf ns h`lïa`c hn afoprfjer pere tfhf equnc qun snpe cnnr
nktrn cïknes. Ce oeyfrïe hn nstfs
n stfs nxpnr`onktfs nståk s`nkhf afkvnk`nktnonktn anksurehfs,
anksurehfs,
l`ctrehfs f oek`pucehfs pfr cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk, nk ce onh`he nk qun nståk nk lesn hn
prunje y punhek dnknrer rnabezf f eceroe sfa`ec,
s fa`ec, nk ce onh`he nk qun nståk nk prfansf hn
`opcektea`ñk. Nstfs nxpnr`onktfs punhnk afks`hnrersn afk tfhe prfp`nheh afof cejfretfr`fs
rnecns nk cfs qun ces l`aa`fkns hn ce ednkhe nkauj`nrte sfk tnstehes, sne nk nc åoj`tf hn cfs
h`spfs`t`vfs soert, hn ce ejfc`a`ñk hnc h`knrf nk ontåc`af, hn cfs v`rus y ces veaukes, hn cfs
treksdàk`afs
hfkhn f hnc treksbuoek`sof.
treksbuoek`sof
rn nstå oås. hnsprftnd`he,
ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn
afkv`vnka`e-c`j Esï, cf bej`tuec
nknsårnes nstfs evekans
qun sfont`hes e su vnzsneprfhuzaek eccï
«sbfags·, nk
rndïonkns pfcït`afs afktrfcehfs pfr nc `opnr`f,
`opnr`f, nk pnr`lnr`es ecniehes hn cfs anktrfs nk ces qun cfs
nlnatfs hn cfs nxpnr`onkt
nxpnr`onktfsfs punhnk snr fauctehfs y oek`pucehfs pfr cfs onh`fs. ] ]nrf
nrf teoj`àk
sfk ut`c`zehfs afof afjeyes buoekes a`nrtfs snatfrns oerd`kecns hn ces pfjcea`fkns hn cfs
anktrfs, qun sn vnk fjc`dehfs e sfontnrsn e nstfs prfdreoes nxpnr`onktecns jeif ce afeaa`ñk hn
pnrhnr sus hnrnabfs, pnks`fkns f eyuhes 
>>
 

sfa`ecns. Esï nstå evekzekhf, nktrn ftrfs prfansfs, ce `opcektea`ñk hn o`arfab`ps nk


buoekfs, nk h`vnrsfs åoj`tfs.
Nk nstn snkt`hf teoj`àk sn punhn hna`r qun ce cñd`ae hnc s`stnoe
s `stnoe ns sear`l`a`ec y qun nste
h`onks`ñk sear`l`a`ec be s`hf trekslnr`he nk pertn e cfs prfansfs a`nktïl`afs, tnakfcñd`afs,
tnakfcñd`afs,
oàh`afs. Nc sejnr, ce a`nka`e, ce onh`a`ke, ce tnakfcfdï tnakfcfdïe e kf sfk k` «junkfs·
k` «oecfs·7 teopfaf sfk knutrecns7 sfk sear`l`a`ecns. Q` punhnk ccnder e snr

jnknl`a`fsfs pere ukesear`l`a`ec


o`kfrïe. P nste h`kåo`ae oeyfrïe ns sn pfrqun
fjsnrveechno`sof t`nopf
oeknre sfk pnriuh`a`ecns
ouy nv`hnktn pere
nk nc åoj`tf hn ce uke
`kvnst`dea`ñk y nc hnserrfccf. Nc snarnt`sof qun elnate e ce `kvnst`dea`ñk hn pukte kf ns sñcf uke
aunst`ñk hn afopnt`t`v`heh. Ces `kvnst`dea`fkns oås evekzehes sfk snarntes pfrqun, afof
 vnrnofs,, nståk `ktrïksnaeonktn
 vnrnofs `ktrïksnaeonktn esfa`ehes e nste h`h`onks`ñk
onks`ñk sear`l`a`ec, nk pert`aucer e ce dunrre. Nk
nstn snkt`hf hna`ofs qun cfs onaek`sofs a`nktïl`afs, tnakfcñd`afs, oàh`afs, nta., hn bfy sfk
`kstruonktfs hn cf sear`l`a`ec. Ce a`nka`e y ce tnakfcfdïe rnqu`nrnk rnqu`nrnk `kofcer
vïat`oes nk cfs ecterns hnc prfdrnsf. Nc leket`sof qun bfy fjsnrveofs nk tfrkf e ce
`kkfvea`ñk a`nktïl`ae,
a`nktïl`ae, sne ec ehfrer cfs eancnrehfrns hn pertïauces, f ec beanr afces pere fjtnknr nc
ùct`of `]eh, kf ns ftre afse qun uke lfroe hn pert`a`pea`ñk sear`l`a`ec
sujc`oehe, qun sfst`nkn ce rnc`d`ñk aep`tec`ste. 
>< 
Nc s`stnoe hn dunrre 
Beste equï bnofs `ktnktehf ofstrer qun nc aep`tec`sof kf ns oås qun ce ùct`oe lfroe hn
hfo`k`f qun nc bfojrn be hnserrfccehf, qun nstn sn punhn es`o`cer e uk d`dektnsaf h`spfs`t`vf hn
eho`k`strea`ñk hn v`fcnka`e, ninra`he aehe vnz oås pfr cfs prfp`fs onaek`sofs ofknter`fs,
nafkño`afs,, a`nktïl`afs, tnakfcñd`afs, oàh`afs,
nafkño`afs oàh`afs, nta. Nk cf qun supnre nc aep`tec`sof e ftrfs
rndïonkns hn pfhnr ektnr`frns ns nk `kafrpfrer uk ectf drehf hn v`fcnka`e sfa`ec nk cfs prfp`fs
onaek`sofs aep`tec`stes,
aep`tec`stes, esï afof nk snr aepez hn nxtnr-kec`zer cfs nxanhnktns hn v`fcnka`e e
trevàs hn nstfs o`sofs onaek`sofs f hn ftrfs eux`c`erns. ^kf hn nstfs onaek`sofs hn
nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e, kf nxacus`vf
nxacus`vf hnc s`stnoe aaep`tec`ste,
ep`tec`ste, pnrf qun nk àc ehqu`nrn uk
pepnc tfhevïe oås nstruaturec, ns nc s`stnoe hn dunrre.
]fr ftrf cehf, bnofs ofstrehf qun nktrn nc c`jrn afonra`f y nc sequnf kf bey sfcua`ñk hn
afkt`ku`heh, qun eojfs sfk pfcfs nktrn cfs qun sn s`tùek tfhes ces pfs`jcns s`tuea`fkns
`ktnronh`es. Ehnoås, qun nc s`stnoe afks`stn nk ce onraekt`c`zea`ñk hn ce v`he. ]fr cf tektf tektf,, nk
nc pfcf hnc sequnf hnjnofs `kacu`r kf sfcf 
5=0
 

ce hnstruaa`ñk f ehqu`s`a`ñk v`fcnkte hn j`nkns, s`kf teoj`àk ce hn ce v`he buoeke. Nk rnsuonk,


ce dunrre kf ns uk nstehf nxanpa`fkec f a`rauksteka`
a`rauksteka`ec
ec qun sn fpfkn ec ns
nstehf
tehf kfroec hn pez, s`kf
uke h`onks`ñk `ktndrektn hnc s`stnoe aep`tec`ste qun etrev`nse tfhf su nspnatrf, tfhfs sus nstehfs.
Ce nxprns`ñk «s` v`s peano, pere jnccuo· («s` qu`nrns ce pez, prnpåretn pere ce dunrre·)
hnjn nktnkhnrsn nk nstn snkt`hf j`pfcer, aïac`af. Cfs pnrïfhfs hn dunrre y hn pez kf sfcf sn
ectnrkek. Ce pez afkt`nkn ce dunrre y ce dunrre ce pez. Kukae sn nstå nk dunrre f nk pez pfr
afopcntf.. Nste cñd`ae teoj`àk r`dn e k`vnc nspea`ec, nk jesn e ce nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e e ce
afopcntf
qun kfs bnofs rnlnr`hf. Ces dunrres cfaecns nståk kutr`nkhf ec `opnr`f nk tfhf ofonktf.
Nc `opnr`f sn jese nk ce eho`k`strea`ñk hn nste v`fcnka`e, nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e jàc`ae, nk su rnpertf
nspea`ec y tnopfrec, nk nster prnperåkhfsn pnroeknktnonktn pere ce dunrre, nk hfs`l`aerce
hn oeknre qun cn sne jnknl`a`fse, nk oektnknr y earnankter uke pfs`a`ñk hn c`hnrezdf lrnktn e sus
afopnt`hfrns,, nk tfhfs cfs tnrrnkfs, pnrf
afopnt`hfrns pnrf,, pfr nka`oe hn tfhf
tfhf,, nk nc hn ce dunrre, nk sejnr
aekec`zer tfhf nstn nslunrzf jàc`af nk ftrfs snatfrns nk s`tuea`fkns hn pez rncet`v
rncet`ve.
e.
Hn oeknre qun, e l`k hn aunktes, ce dunrre ns uke hn ces acevns hn jñvnhe hnc `opnr`f
`opnr`f.. Kf ns qun
ce dunrre sn supnh`tn e ce nafkfoïe f e ce pfcït`ae, s`kf ec afktrer`f9 ns nc ncnonktf pr`ka`pec hnc
qun hnpnkhn tfhf cf hnoås. «Cfs s`stnoes nafkño`afs,
nafkño`afs, ces l`cfsflïes pfcït`aes y cfs aunrpfs
iurïh`afs s`rvnk y eopcïek ec s`stnoe hn dunrre y kf e ce `kvnrse· (@klfron...). Ce ftre acevn hn
jñvnhe ns, afof bnofs v`stf, ce bndnofkïe ofknter`e y l`keka`nre, y nc afktrfc hn ce arnea`ñk hn
h`knrf l`hua`er`f,
l`hua`er`f, qun kf ns oås qun nc pfcf afopcnonk
afopcnonkter`f
ter`f hnc hn ce dunrre, puns ukf y ftrf sn
rnlunrzek. Ce l`aa`ñk hnc pntrfhñcer kf snrïe sfstnk`jcn s`k nc rnspechf rnec hnc ]nktådfkf.
Nc h`knrf l`at`a`f ns pfr cf tektf `ksnperejcn hn ce v`fcnka`e qun cf sfst`nkn. Nstf ns cf qun kf kfs
h`ank ce oeyfrïe hn cfs nafkfo`stes eaehào`afs
eaehào`afs,, f pfr `dkfreka`e f pfr afopc`a`heh.
Nste tnks`ñk nktrn nc h`knrf arnehf nx k`b`cf nk nc pfcf ofknter`f y l`keka`nrf hnc s`stnoe, y
ce v`fcnka`e hn ces dunrres qun cf rnspechek ns, pfr ftrf cehf, uke hn ces oek`lnstea`fkns oås
nv`hnktns hn ce cñd`ae rnc`d`fse hnc aep`tec`sof, f pere snr oås prna`sfs, sear`l`a`ec. Nk uk pfcf,
pfcf, nc
sulr`o`nktf hn cfs aunrpfs7 nk nc ftrf, ce rnsurrnaa`ñk hnc nspïr`tu, nc o`cedrf
o`ced rf.. Nk nc lfkhf tfhf nc
nspnatåaucf hnc s`stnoe sn rnhuan e nste nsank`l`aea`ñk sear`l`a`ec, e ce sujc`oea`ñk hn su v`fcnka`e.
Nc drek afont`hf hn ce prfpedekhe ns, afof nk uk d`dektnsaf eutf hn ln, nsank`l`aer nc pfhnr hnc
`opnr`f,, cnd`t`oer su pepnc hn iunz uk`vnrsec nk ce h`st`ka`ñk hnc «j`nk· y hnc «oec·, aest`de
`opnr`f aest`derr e cfs
bnrnins hn ce rnc`d`ñk aep`tec`ste, e cfs `kl`ncns hn ce arnnka`e nk nc h`knrf l`hua`er`f
l`hua`er`f.. Afof cn
faurr`ñ ec bnrnin Oueoer nc n c Dehel`, qun sn etrnv`ñ e prfpfknr uke ofknhe rnd`fkec rnspechehe
pfr frf.
frf. Ces dunrres hn rnc`d`ñk hn bfy nsafkhnk ce dunrre hn ce rnc`d`ñk aep`tec`ste afktre
a fktre cfs
`kl`ncns. Nc lukheonktec`sof aep`tec`ste sn trete hn nkaujr`r afk ftrfs lukheonktec`sof
lukheonktec`sofss oås
onh`åt`afs.
Hn oeknre qun ce dunrre kf ns sfcf pere nc `opnr`f nc ùct`of rnaursf, s`kf teoj`àk su
 pr`ka`p`f. «Ces dunrres 
>4
 

kf sfk "faes`fkehes" pfr afklc`atfs hn `ktnrnsns `ktnrkea`fkecns


`ktnrkea`fkecns.. ^ke snaunka`e cñd`ae afrrnate
`kh`ae qun oås e onkuhf rnsucte prna`sf hna`r qun ces sfa`nhehns dunrrnres rnqu`nrnk ‘ y pfr
nkhn hnjnk dnknrer ‘   tecns afklc`atfs· (@klfron...). Nk ftres pecejres, nc pereh`doe hn ce
 ‘  tecns
hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec ns, nk nsnka`e, jàc`af. Hfkhn onifr sn punhn eprna`er nstf ns nk nc snatfr
tnakfcñd`af.. Qfcf nc s`stnoe hn dunrre cn pnro`tn ec `opnr`f, drea`es e ce nxtreaa`ñk afkt`kuehe hn
tnakfcñd`af
r`qunze hn cfs punjcfs e trevàs hn onaek`sofs ofknter`fs, l`saecns, `klceaa`fke-r`fs, hnserrfccer
pnroeknktnonktn su tnakfcfdïe jàc`ae hn pukte, qun e su vnz derekt`ze nc hfo`k`f `opnr`ec. Qfcf

ye trevàs
evekzerhnpnroeknktnonktn
ce nkfron l`keka`ea`ñk
nk nstepùjc`ae punhn
tnakfcfdïe hnncpukte.
snatfr
s natfr]fr
`khustr`ec-o`c`ter
nsf ce acevn hnpnro`t`rsn oektnknr
ce treks`a`ñk bea`e uk
Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec nstå nk ce arnea`ñk hn kunvfs onaek`sofs l`saecns e k`vnc dcfjec, qun
bedek pfs`jcn oektnknr uke bndnofkïe o`c`ter y tnakfcñd`ae. Hns`ktndrer ces nstruatures pfcït`aes
hn Nstehfs ^k`hfs y hn Nurfpe y ec o`sof t`nopf rn`ktndrerces nk uke kunve nstruature dcfjec,
tfhf nccf nk nc oeraf hn ce nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze hn ce pfjcea`ñk pere sfstnknr ce bndnofkïe hnc
s`stnoe hn dunrre. Nste ns ce acevn pere nktnkhnr ce treks`a`ñk bea`
bea`ee nc Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec
Nc s`stnoe hn dunrre ns h`kåo`af, pnroeknktn, afopnt`t`v
afopnt`t`vf,f, `operejcn7 ns ce oequ`ker`e
aep`tec`ste pfr nxancnka`e. Ouabes hn ces kfa`fkns aep`tec`stes sfk, nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, jàc`aes. Nc
«niàra`tf `khustr`ec hn rnsnrve· hn oekf hn fjre hnc qun kfs bejcñ Oerx nkaunktre su nopcnf hn
ùct`of rnaursf prna`seonktn 
55: 
afof niàra`tf o`c`ter. Ce kfa`ñk hn ec`nkea`ñk hnc trejeiehfr pfr ce eutfoet`zea`ñk aep`tec`ste kf
ns oås qun uk aesf pert`aucer hnc sfont`o`nktf hn ce v`he e ce oequ`ker`e hn dunrre. Nc cïo`tn hn
s fchehf nk ce låjr`ae hn ounrtn.
ce ec`nkea`ñk hnc trejeiehfr nk ce låjr`ae ns ce ounrtn hnc sfchehf ounrtn.
Ce prfhuaa`ñk y ce hnstruaa`ñk hn ce dunrre sfk ces hfs aeres hn ce o`soe ofknhe, nc cïo`tn nk nc
qun sn nkaunktrek ce h`onks`ñk hnstruat`ve y afkstruat`ve hnc s`stnoe.
Nc s`stnoe hn dunrre `opnr`ec ns uke oequ`ker`e `operejcn pfrqun su hfo`k`f hnpnkhn hnc
pnroeknktn prfdrnsf hn ce tnakfcfdïe jàc`ae7 pere ehncektersn e sus nkno`dfs, pere oektnknr
ces inrerquïes afk rnspnatf e sus ec`ehfs y ec rnstf hn Nstehfs
Ns tehfs sfont`hfs
sfont`hfs,, pere qun ce dunrre
s`noprn sne `ko`knktn y esï sne nlnat`ve afof eonkeze pnroeknktn. Nste afkh`a`ñk `operejcn hn
ce oequ`ker`e hn dunrre `opc`ae qun nc `opnr`f knans`te her sec`he rnduceronktn e sus nxanhnktns
hn prfhuaa`ñk jàc`afs, prfvfaekhf ert`l`a`econktn afklc`atfs, hn uke oeknre u ftre, snek
prfp`fs f einkfs9 «nk ce reïz hn tfhes ces h`lnrnka`es fstnks`jcns hnc `ktnràs kea`fkec yeank cfs
rnqunr`o`nktfs h`kåo`afs
h`kåo`afs hnc s`stnoe hn dunrre nk sï, qun rnqu`nrn hnc afklc`atf eroehf

pnr`ñh`af· (@klfron.
oequ`ker`e ..). Ec `opnr`f
sfcf punhn oektnknrsn k`kdùk
drea`es afklc`atf
e nccfs, cn ns einkf,
nk ce onh`he nk qunnknc ce onh`hecfsnk`kst`de.
`opnr`f qun nste
 \nofs
 \nofs equï ftre vvnz
nz beste quà pupuktf,
ktf, nk nc s`stnoe aep`tec`st
aep`tec`stee `opnr`ec, `ktnraeoj`f
`ktnraeoj`f onraekt`c y
afeaa`ñk v`fcnkte sfk `ksnperejcns. Nk ùct`oe
ùct`oe `ksteka`e nc s`stnoe hn dunrre ns sfstnk`hf pfr cfs
er oeonktf qun sn vnk fjc`dehfs e nccf. 
afktr`juynktns y pfr cfs afoprehfrns hn eroeonktf
>2
 

]nrf pere nktnkhnr nc pepnc nstruaturec hn ce dunrre teoj`àk hnjnofs l`ierkfs nk añof nste
elnate ec snatfr a`v`c, supunsteonktn
s upunsteonktn peaïl`af.
peaïl`af. Esï, cf qun aereatnr`ze ec `opnr`f bfy ns qun aehe
 vnz t`nkn onkfs
onkfs snkt`hf h`st`kdu`r
h`st`kdu`r nktrn cf a`
a`v`c
v`c y cf o`c`ter
o`c`ter,, nktrn ce pez y ce ddunrre.
unrre. Nc pr`ka`p`f
ns qun ce tnakfcfdïe jàc`ae hn pukte qun ve s`nkhf supnrehe hnjn rna`acersn nk nc snatfr a`v`c, qun
sn vn esï `kveh`hf pfr h`kåo`aes prfp`es hn cfs aeopfs hn jetecce. Nc etequn, ce hnlnkse, ce
prftnaa`ñk, ce sndur`heh, ce v`d`ceka`e, nc afktrfc, nc nsp`fkein, qun sfk aetndfrïes fr`d`keconktn y
pr`ka`peconktn o`c`terns,
o`c`terns, sn vek nxtnkh`nkhf prfdrns`veonkt
prfdrns`veonktnn ec åoj`tf a`v`c. Kunstrfs nh`l`a`fs
sn afkv`nrtnk
h`spfs`t`vfs
h`spfs`t`vf s hnnkv`d`ceka`e,
`kstecea`fkns hn prftnaa`ñk
kunstres y sndur`heh,
rnhns ssfa`ecns
fa`ecns kunstrfshnj`nkns
nk onaek`sofs hn afksuof
nsp`fkein y afktrfc.nkNstf ns
cf qun sn nsafkhn hntrås hn ces a`uhehns `ktnc`dnktns, hn cfs h`spfs`t`vfs
h`spfs`t`vfs `ktnc`dnktns, hn
ces epc`aea`fkns `ktnc`dnktns. X  Xfhf
fhf nccf nk nc afktnxtf
afktnxtf hn ce hnr`ve
hnr`ve dcfjec`ste y tft
tftec`ter`e,
ec`ter`e, qun
afkv`nrtn e auecqu`nr vna`kf nk uke eonkeze,
e onkeze, sne afof pnhnreste, afof v`fcehfr nk snr`n s nr`n f
afof sfspnabfsf hn tnrrfr`sof.
tnrrfr`sof. Cfs nkno`dfs lejr`aehfs pnro`tnk her sec`he e cfs nxanhnktns
nxanhnktns..
 Xektf nxanhnktns
nxanhnktns hn pprfhuaa`ñk
rfhuaa`ñk afo
afoff nxanhnk
nxanhnktns
tns hn v`fcnka`e sf
sfa`ec.
a`ec.
Nc s`stnoe hn dunrre nstå nk ce jesn hn ce a`nka`e, hn ce tnakfcfdïe y hn ce onh`a`ke fl`a`ecns. Nstfs
sfk ftrfs tektfs vnbïaucfs hn ce hfo`kea`ñk aep`tec`ste. «Ce dunrre ns ce lunrze oft`vea`fkec oås
`opfrtektn pere nc hnserrfccf hn ce a`nka`e nk tfhfs cfs k`vncns, hnshn nc k`vnc ejstreateonktn
afkanptuec beste nc 
558 
nstrnabeonktn tnakfcñd`af.
tnakfcñd`af. Ce sfa`nheh ofhnrke cn ftfrde uk ectf vecfr e ce a`nka`e "pure" pnrf
b`stñr`aeonktn rnsucte `knv`tejcn qun tfhfs cfs hnsaujr`o`nk
hnsaujr`o`nktfs
tfs s`dk`l`aet`vfs qun sn bek bnabf
eanrae hnc oukhf keturec sn beyek v`stf `ksp`rehfs pfr ces rnecns f `oed`ker`es knans`hehns
o`c`terns hn ces h`st`ktes àpfaes. Ces afksnaunka`es hn cfs hnsaujr`o`nktfs cundf bek `hf oås eccå
hnc aeopf hn ce dunrre, pnrf lun ce dunrre ce qun s`noprn be prfv`stf nc `kankt`vf `k`a`ec·
(@klfron. ..). Nstf sn pfkn hn oek`l`nstf e tfhfs cfs k`vncns,
k`vncns, pert`auceronktn nk ofonktfs
arït`afs afof bfy.
Nk kunstrfs t`nopfs ce oeyfrïe hn ces uk`vnrs`hehns, hn cfs `kst`tutfs hn `kvnst`dea`ñk, hn ces
FKDs,, hn cfs tb`kg tekgs, hn ces pujc`aea`fkns, nståk ec snrv`a`f hn ce
lukhea`fkns,, hn ces FKDs
lukhea`fkns
hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec, y hnsprnkhnk nstn fcfr e ounrtn pfr cfs auetrf afstehfs. Kf ns qun tfhes
ncces y tfhes ces pnrsfkes qun ces `ktndrek afopertek ces `ktnka`fkns pnrvnrses hnc `opnr`f
`opnr`f.. Nc
esuktf ns oås afopcnif. Ns ce prfp`e oequ`ker`e aep`tec`ste, `ksnperejcn hn ce qun bean luka`fker
nstes `kst`tua`fkns, ce qun nstå etrepehe
e trepehe nk ce h`kåo`ae hn eho`k`strea`ñk hn ounrtn.
ounrtn. @kacusf nk nc
aesf hn ouabfs a`nktïl`afs j`nk`ktnka`fkehfs,
j`nk`ktnka`fkehfs, pfr nc sfcf
s fcf bnabf hn nster nkoeraehfs nk nstes
nstruatures
lfkhfs inrerqu`zehes,pfr
hn `kst`tua`fkns, nkhfdåo`aes,
trejeier nk nspna`ec`zehes,
r`dafopert`onk-tec`zehes,
afopert`onk-tec`zehes
nc oeraf hnc r`dfr , pfr hnpnkhnr
fr y ce ontfhfcfdïe eaehào`aes oec hn
nktnkh`hes, tnro`kek qunhekhf etrepehfs nk ce rnh pnrvnrse
pnr vnrse hnc s`stnoe, y afcejfrekhf, s`k
sejnrcf, afk nc nkno`df. Nk hnl`k`t`ve
hnl`k`t`ve tfhf sn rnhuan e uke cñd`ae ouy s`opcn9 nc aep`tec hna`hn cf
qun 
>0
 

ce a`nka`e hnjn afkl`roer, nc aep`tec hna`hn cf qun sn pujc`ae y cf qun kf. Cf hnoås sn rnsuncvn
pfr ces prfp`es h`kåo`aes buoekes. Nk ftres pecejres, nc aep`tec, nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, hna`hn ces
 l`aa`fkns qun cn `ktnrnse afkvnrt`r nk rnec`heh. 
]fr ftre pertn, nste hnr`ve jàc`ae hnc afkiuktf hn ce sfa`nheh sn nstå prfhua`nkhf bfy nk perecncf
e ce prfdrns`ve pr`v
pr`vet`zea`ñk
et`zea`ñk hn cfs snatfrns o`c`ter
o`c`ter,, tnakfcñd`af y hn sndur`heh, cf qun `ktnks`l`ae
ce h`kåo`ae `operejcn hn ce oequ`ker`e hn dunrre, su `khnpnkhnka`e hnc vnrhehnrf `ktnràs f
hnlnkse hn cfs punjcfs
punjcfs,, ce `kst`dea`ñk hn afklc`atfs pfr nc purf `ktnràs hnc kndfa`f. Hn oeknre
qun ce trekslnrnka`e
 v`fcnka`e ec snatfr
`opnr`ec, s`kf pr`vehf
ehnoås, hnc s`stnoe
`ks`st`ofs
`ks`st`ofs, hn dunrre kf sfcf
, ce l`a-a`fkec`zea`ñk hn cesupfkn
dunrre,ncce`karnonktf hn ce
arnea`ñk ert`l`a`ec
hn su knans`heh.
Nc s`stnoe hn dunrre kf sfcf ns nc lukheonktf nstruaturec hnc `opnr`f s`kf ehnoås nc ùct`of
rnaursf pere rnsfcvnr ces ar`s`s. ]frqun pnro`tn `opfknr pfcït`aes hn nxanpa`ñk pere nxtrenr
r`qunze hn cfs a`uhehekfs y hnst`kerce e ce hnoekhe hn ùct`of rnaursf nk aesf hn drevn d revn
ar`s`s9 nc eroeonktf
er oeonktf.. ]ere nccf, nc `opnr`f sn vn fjc`dehf e dnknrer ert`l`a`econktn afklc`atfs, snek
prfp`fs f einkfs, nk ce onh`he nk qun àstfs hnk sec`he e cfs nxanhnktns o`c`terns f pnro`tek
eat`ver ce `khustr`e o`c`ter.
o`c`ter. Nk eojfs aesfs ce cejfr lukheonktec hn ce prfpedekhe hnc `opnr`f ns
faucter nste cñd`ae jàc`ae nstruaturec y vnkhnrkfs h`abfs afklc`atfs afof eonkezes f
afklc`atfs einkfs, anksurer nk ce oeyfr onh`he pfs`jcn tfhf cf qun t`nkn qun vnr afk eaunrhfs 
<= 
nañof
`ktnrnsns
añof, eroeonktïst`afs.
, nk ùct`oe Afofncsnrnstf
`ksteka`e, auekhf vn nchn
aïraucf hn ce v`fcnka`e
cfs onaek`sofs sn a`nrre, yhn
hn nxtreaa`ñk s n r`qunze
sn afoprunje
sn ed
edftek,
ftek,
sfcf cn qunhe ec s`stnoe ce fpa`ñk hn ce dunrre. Ns hna`r, sfcf e trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec sn
dnknre ce hnoekhe hn ùct`of rnaursf qun rnspfkhn e ce knans`heh hn hnlnkhnrsn ektn uk etequn.
^k ninopcf ouy s`opcn9 uk afksuo`hfr, nk t`nopfs hn ar`s`s, punhn rnkuka`er e afoprersn ukfs
zepetfs, pnrf uke kea`ñk eonkezehe pfr uk nkno`df kf huherå nk afoprer eroeonktf, `kacusf
s` pere nccf t`nkn qun nkhnuhersn. \fcvnofs
\fcvnofs e nkafktrer equï ce v`kaucea`ñk hn dunrre y
nafkfoïe, y ehnoås, hn hnuhe. Qbegnspnern nktnkh`ñ qun cf qun nc earnnhfr prntnkhn nk ùct`oe
`ksteka`e ns afjrersn su «c`jre hn aerkn·. F ec rnvàs, qun eonkezer afk afjrersn
afjrersn ce «c`jre hn
aerkn· ns cf qun fjc`de ec hnuhfr e nkhnuhersn. ¶Kf ns nstf cf qun nstå nk nc treslfkhf hn ce
tre`a`ñk hn Xs`pres
Xs`pres ec punjcf dr`ndf (iuc`f hn :=5>)6
Bnofs h`abf qun ce v`fcnka`e y su eonkeze sfk hfs ofonktfs hn uke o`soe h`kåo`ae. Ce
eonkeze hn ce v`fcnka`e ns nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e uke lfroe hn fpt`o`zer rnaursfs
rnaursfs,, hn afksndu`r e
trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e l`at`a`e cf qun rnsucterïe oås afstfsf afksndu`r e trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e
rnec. Kf bey åoj`tf nk nc qun hnsnopnõnk uk pepnc oås `opfrtektn ce l`aa`ñk, nc
nkoesaereo`nktf,, nc aeoulcein, ce eonkeze, qun nk nc hn ce eonkeze hn ce v`fcnka`e. Xfhf
nkoesaereo`nktf Xfhf nc
s`stnoe hn dunrre sn afkstruyn sfjrn nste cñd`ae l`at`a`e. Ce prfpedekhe nxednre y hreoet`ze ektn
cfs a`uhehekfs ce `opfrteka`e hn ces eonkezes, hn ces qun hnjn prftndnr ce oequ`ker`e hn 
554
 

dunrre. Hn ce o`soe oeknre, prnsnkte afof «hnlnkse· cf qun nk rnec`heh sfk edrns`fkns
`opnr`ecns.
Nc snatfr `khustr`ec-o`c`ter ns ce jesn hn tfhe ce nafkfoïe, ce qun he eaansf e cfs rnaursfs
nknrdàt`afs, ce qun bean pfs`jcn nc trekspfrtn dcfjec`zehf,
dcfjec`zehf, ce qun prfpfra`fk
prfpfra`fkee ce oetnr`e pr`oe
qun ec`onkte tfhe ce aehnke prfhuat`ve, ce qun nstå nk ce jesn hnc edrfkndfa`f, ce `khustr`e
ler oeaàut`ae. Ce dunrre ns, nk rnsuonk, ce acevn hn jñvnhe qun sfst`nkn ec
j`fquïo`ae y ce leroeaàut`ae.
`opnr`f. 
<5  
Ce dunrre tftec 
Qn afoprnkhnrå ebfre pfr quà nc `opnr`f nstå c`jrekhf uke dunrre tftec afktre tfhfs. ]frq ]frqun
un ce
dunrre ns su vnrhehnre nsnka`e. ]frqun
]frqun ce hnr`ve bea`e ce dunrre ns `operejcn nk s`tuea`fkns
s `tuea`fkns hn
ar`s`s prflukhe afof ce qun etrevnseofs bfy. ]frqun su supnr`fr`heh lrnktn e ftrfs `opnr`fs
nonrdnktns ns prna`seonktn ce hn ce dunrre. ]frqun nc s`stnoe hn dunrre ec`onkte tfhe ce aehnke
prfhuat`vee y tfhfs cfs snatfrns. ]frqu
prfhuat`v ]frqunn ce dcfjec`zea`ñk supfkn uk oukhf s`k lrfktnres nk nc qun
ces s`tuea`fkns hn afklc`atf hn acesns sn ouct`pc`aek
ouct`pc`aek.. ]frqu
]frqunn nc s`stnoe sfcf afkfan ce bu`he bea`e
hncektn y nstå bea`nkhf hn ce ar`s`s ce fpfrtuk`heh pere `ksteurer uk Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec.
Bnofs bejcehf hn ces ar`s`s l`at`a`es, pnrf nstes kf sfk oås qun uke lfroe
lfr oe hn dunrre hn jeie
`ktnks`heh. Ce dunrre sn hnspc`nde nk tfhfs cfs lrnktns y afktre tfhfs, beste nc puktf hn qun
ouabfs lnkñonkfs
lnkñonkfs qun bfy v`v`ofs afof aft`h`ekfs, hn cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk e
Bfccywffh, hn cfs treksdàk`afs e ces pekhno`es
pekhno`es,, hn ces aetåstrflns «keturecns· ec aeoj`f
ac`oåt`af,, kf sfk oås qun dunrres, pfr eat`ve f pfr pes`ve, afk h`st`ktfs ddrehfs
ac`oåt`af rehfs hn `ktnks`heh, nk
luka`ñk hn ces 
550
 

a`rauksteka`es y hn cfs `ktnrnsns hnc `opnr`f. Ce dunrre be ccndehf bfy e snr tek tftec, e
hnspcndersn nk tektfs pcekfs,
pcekfs, e nkoesaerersn onh`ektn afertehes tek sfl`st`aehes, qun e onkuhf
ns h`lïa`c rnafkfanrce. ^ke hn ces afkh`a`fkns hn nste dunrre tftec y ouct`h`onks`fkec ns qun k`
s`qu`nre ns pfs`jcn h`st`kdu`r nktrn eo`dfs y nkno`dfs. Nste ns pertn hn ce nstretnd`e hn afklus`ñk
hnc `opnr`f.
Uun sn trete hn uke dunrre tftec, dcfjec, ouct`h`o
ouct`h`onks`fkec,
nks`fkec, sn punhn fjsnr
fjsnrver
ver afk oeyfr k`t`hnz
nk nc aesf hnc tnrrfr`sof
tnrrfr`sof.. Cfs o`sofs tnrrfr`stes qun cuabek nk tnetrfs hn dunrre nk Fr`nktn
Onh`f,
hfs Es`e
aeres hn fceÅlr`ae,
o`soe afontnk
ofknhe. etnktehfs nk cfs
Ces jekhnres Nstehfs
lecses anktrecns.
nk aese beank]nrf
]nrf cf ukf
arnnr tfhey cf ftrf sfkhncesce
ce l`aa`ñk
«Dunrre afktre nc tnrrfr·, iust`l`aek ces dunrres hn afkqu`ste nk ces pnr`lnr`es y ce `ksteurea`ñk hn
nstehfs pfc`a`ecns nk cfs anktrfs.
anktrfs. Ce o`soe v`kaucea`ñk hn anktrfs y pnr`lnr`es ce nkafktreofs nk
nc aesf hn ces pekhno`es
pekhno`es.. Auekhf nstes sn hek nk ces pnr`lnr`es, ns knanser`f qun pertn hn ce ar`s`s
sn afkted`n e cfs anktrfs, hn oeknre qun tfhe ce l`aa`ñk sne pnra`j`he afof uke rnec`heh
dcfjec. P tfhf nccf afk
a fk ce afopc`a`heh, pfr eat`ve f pfr pes`ve, hn oeknre afksa`nktn f
`kafksa`nktn, hn frdek`zea`fkns `ktnrkea`fkecns, drekhns FKDs, y nc pepnc `kh`spnksejcn hn cfs
onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk. ^ke pekhno`e, pfr pfknr uk ninopcf, ns nk afkiuktf,afkiuktf, kf sñcf uke
dunrre j`fcñd`ae afktre cfs elnatehfs7 teoj`àk ns uke dunrre afktre tfhe ce rnd`ñk, dunrre
sek`ter`e, buoek`ter`e, onh`åt`ae7 uke dunrre nktrn leroeaàut`aes7 uke dunrre afktre tfhfs 
5:= 
nk cfs åoj`tfs hn ce cnd`scea`ñk, hn ces rnducea`fkns
rnducea`fkns,, hn cfs prftfafcfs7 uke dunrre ps`afcñd`ae
pere ce `opfs`a`ñk
kunstrfs hn veaukea`fkns fjc`detfr`es7 uke dunrre bea`e ce afkqu`ste j`foàtr`ae hn
aunrpfs, nta.
Nc `opnr`f hnc aep`tec sfcf afkfan ce cñd`ae hnc hfo`k`f y hn ce nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze. Nstf
s`dk`l`ae qun nc pr`v`cnd`f hn ce pez y hn ce nstej`c`heh sfcf sn punhn afksndu`r ec prna`f hn ce
suo`s`ñk ec `opnr`f y e sus onaek`sofs hn nxpcftea`ñk. Q` cfs punjcfs f ces kea`fkns cn sfk ùt`cns
ec `opnr`f, s` punhnk snr fjintf hn nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze, nk lfroe hn hnuhe, `opunstfs,
afksuof,, jnknl`a`fs, nc `opnr`f cns derekt`ze uke rncet`ve pez. ]nrf
afksuof ]nrf nk ce onh`he nk qun nstf kf
ns pfs`jcn nc `opnr`f ces sfontn e uk du`ñk prnhntnro`kehf y prfdrns`vf hn hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk,
`ksurdnka`e, dunrre a`v`c... beste ccnder e ce dunrre hnacerehe. Q` sn punhn bejcer hn dunrre tftec ns
teoj`àk pfrqun cf qun hnl`kn bfy e ce afkqu`ste `opnr`ec ns nste prfdrns`v`-heh. ]frqun nc
`opnr`f aunkte afk uk du`ñk sfl`st`aehf, prfdrns`vf, ofhucer, qun sn ve pnrlnaa`fkekhf hn
fpnrea`ñk nk fpnrea`ñk, qun pnro`tn `r euonktekhf prfdrns`v
prfdrns`veonktn
eonktn ce `ktnks`heh hn ce edrns`ñk
a`rauksteka`es.. Q`noprn ce o`soe cñd`ae hn ce eaa`ñk ert`l`a`ec y nkauj`nrte,
nk luka`ñk hn ces a`rauksteka`es

nk equncces pecekaes
`opcnonktekhf qun pnro`tnknk
prfdrns`veonktn
prfdrns`veonktn hnsnkaehnker ce v`fcnka`e
nc aesf hn qun rnec,
ce s`tuea`ñk pfr cetnktn.
sï sfce, fNstes eaa`fkns
afk ce sn ces
eyuhe hn vek
eaa`fkns ektnr`frns, kf afkhuzae e cfs fjint`vfs `opnr`ecns
`opnr`ecns.. ^ke cñd`ae prfdrns`ve qun teoj`àk
rnspfkhn e su aeråatnr nkauj`nrtf.
nkauj`nrtf. Esï, nk luka`ñk hn cfs aesfs, sn suanhnk f sfcepek ce dunrre hn 
<:
 

hnuhe, nafkño`ae, hn h`v`ses, hn seka`fkns, ce dunrre treksdàk`ae, ces rnvfcua`fkns


rnvfcua`fkns hn afcfrns, ces
aetåstrflns, ce dunrre ac`oåt`ae, ces pekhno`es, cfs etnktehfs,
etnktehfs, cfs hrfkns
hrfkns,, ces dunrres prfxy,
prfxy, ce
dunrre a`v`c, ce dunrre a`jnrkàt`ae, cfs jfojerhnfs,
jfojerhnfs, ce `kves`ñk...
Nste prfdrns`v`heh, nste snaunka`ec`heh hn cfs drehfs hn `ktnks`heh hn ce dunrre tftec, sn s n prfhuan
nk luka`ñk hnc afktnxtf hn aehe s`tuea`ñk y su drehf hn `ktnreaa`ñk afk s`tuea`fkns afkt`dues f
affrh`kehes.. ]fr ninopcf ut`c`zekhf nk h`lnrnktns afklc`atfs rnaursfs afoukns,
affrh`kehes afoukns, afof ddrupfsrupfs
`ksurdnktns, auye rnktej`c`heh punhn esï fpt`o`zersn. Nk nstn afktnxtf bey qun nktnkhnr nc lcuif
hn tnrrfr`stes
aeoj`fs y onranker`fs
hn kfojrn nktrn
(Ec Uenhe, Eldek`ståk,
No`retf Abnabnk`e,
@scåo`af, Pudfscev`e,
Pudfscev`e,
nktrn ftrfs) C`j`e, @reg,e Q`r`e,
qun afktr`juynk nta., y sus
nkoesaerer qun
nk nsnka`e sn trete hn uke o`soe h`kåo`ae eatuekhf nk h`st`ktfs cuderns.
Ce dunrre ns tftec pfr eat`ve f pfr pes`ve, afof rnec`heh f afof eonkeze. Nk nstn snkt`hf bey
qun nktnkhnr qun sn bejcn tektf bfy hn «eonkezes·, qun ce dunrre rnec qun sn c`jre nk uk
hntnro`kehf puktf hnc dcfjf, sne nl`aez ec o`sof t`nopf nk ftrf puktf,
puktf, nk tektf nk auektf
eatùe afof «eonkeze·. «E junk nktnkhnhfr,
nktnkhnhfr, pfaes pecejres jestek.· ]fr nsf Auje nkvïe
pnrsfkec oàh`af e Ålr`ae Faa`hnktec, pfrqun sejn qun ce ar`s`s hnc Àjfce (vnrekf hn :=58)
teoj`àk ns uke eonkeze afktre ncce. Nk nste h`onks`ñk eonkezektn iunde uk pepnc anktrec ce
prfpedekhe hn dunrre, kf sfcf hn aere e ftres kea`fkns s`kf teoj`àk e ftrfs nsanker`fs hn ce
o`soe dunrre. Xb`nrry Onyssek be  
<1 
ofstrehf añof nk ces dunrres rna`nktns nc `opnr`f be afkstru`hf nsanker`fs hn afklc`atf

 l`at`a`fs,
cfs onh`fs hny cfs be h`lukh`hf afktr`juynk
hns`klfroea`ñk nk cfs onh`fsnkafof
tfhf cf pfs`jcnvnrhehnrfs.
s` lunsnk Nkcenste
e ce afklus`ñk hn h`kåo`ae,
rnec`heh y ce
l`aa`ñk, afk tàak`aes onh`åt`aes nspnaïl`aes afof nc afccedn y nc ofktein hn h`lnrnktns rnd`strfs
pere arner ecdf qun ns e onh`es rnec y e onh`es l`at`a`f.
]nrf nstn usf hn ce eonkeze sn nxt`nkhn e ftrf t`pf hn s`tuea`fkns qun nk pr`ka`p`f pfhrïek
pernanr kf jàc`aes. Esï, ce Xrf`ge nstå ut`c`zekhf Nstehfs nurfpnfs afof Ab`prn f Drna`e afof
 vnrhehnrfs aeopfs
aeopfs hn jetecce pere sus nxpnr`onktfs knfc`jnrecns
knfc`jnrecns.. O`cnk`fs hn a`
a`v`c`zea`ñk
v`c`zea`ñk kfs
bek nksnõehf ce `kofrec`heh hn prnster h`knrf e equnccfs qun kf cf punhnk hnvfcvnr.
hnvfcvnr. ]nrf nstes
cnaa`fkns hn ofrec jås`aes bek s`hf fcv`hehes bfy pfr ce kf-ofrec aep`tec`ste qun ounvn cfs b`cfs
hn ces oer`fkntes pfcït`aes nurfpnes
nurfpnes.. P hn bnabf cf qun nstå suanh`nkhf nk Drna`e bey qun cnnrcf
nk acevn nurfpne, `kacusf dcfjec. Cf qun nstå nk nc treslfkhf hn ce trednh`e dr`nde ns, ftre vnz,
nste cñd`ae hn ce eonkeze. Drna`e afof sear`l`a`f ninopcer`zektn pere nc rnstf hn Nurfpe. Drna`e
afof flrnkhe r`tuec pere secver ces rndces knfc`jnrecns y prfp`a`er ce eauoucea`ñk nk nc
rnstf
cehfs.hnc afkt`knktn.
Qndùk ecdukfs Ce o`soeceh`kåo`ae
ekec`stes snquïe hneonkezektn, sear`l`a`ec,
Aec`lfrk`e nstå s`nkhf punhn fjsnrversnpere
dnf`kdnk`nr`zehe pfr tfhfs
rnlfrzer ce
lerse hnc aeoj`f ac`oåt`af nk tfhf nc pceknte. Ec l`k y ec aejf, ¶kf ns prna`seonktn Bfccywffh nc
« aep`tec`sof 
cuder oås `kh`aehf pere nstn aep`tec`sof hn ce l`aa`ñk, pere nstn «aep`tec`sof
5:1
 

hnc hnsestrn·6 Nk nc afcof hn ce l`aa`fkec`zea`ñk hn 5 ce rnec`heh, kf sñcf Bfccywff


Bfccywffhh nsank`l`ae cfs
hnsestrns aep`tec`stes, s`kf qun nc aep`tec`sof `kafrpfre nk sus
s us prfp`fs onaek`sofs ces tàak`aes
bfccywffhnksns
bfccywffh nksns y nsank`l`ae uke snquïe rnec nk nc o`sof Bfccywff
Bfccywffh, h, qun s`r
s`rve
ve pere vnkhnr ce
supnrprfhuaa`ñk hnc aecnkteo`nktf dcfjec.
 E pnser hn qun sn nkoesaern
nkoesaern afk tfhf t`pf hn nvnk- | tfs, ar`s`
ar`s`ss f afklc`atfs `khnpnkh
`khnpnkh`nktns,
`nktns, ce
dunrre hnc ¡ `opnr`f ns tftec, dcfjec, uke y ce o`soe. Nc fjsnrvehfr ` etnktf pfhrå nkafktrer cfs
b`cfs qun rncea`fkek ukfs ` y ftrfs nsanker`fs e pfaf qun nstuh`n nstfs lnkñon- § kfs afk
au`hehf y sfrtnn
prfpedek- ces treopes hn cfs onh`fs hn l hns`klfroea`ñk. Esï, pere qun ce dunrre hn
5 he punhe hns`klfroer sfjrn ce dunrre afkvnka`fkec ns ¡ knanser`f qun nc `opnr`f
knutrec`an e cfs pnr`fh`stes hn dunrre `khnpnkh`nktns, equnccfs qun kf eaetek ce suo`s`ñk
s uo`s`ñk hn cfs
onh`fs fl`a`ecns. Nstn aruan hn `klfroe- 6 a`ñk kfs pnro`tn
pnr o`tn nktnkhnr qun ce dunrre afkvnka`fkec
` y ce dunrre onh`åt`ae sfk hfs ofonktfs hn ce o`soe | dunrre. ▭ 
Ces dunrres prfxy 
Hnspuàs hn tfhf cf qun vnk`ofs h`a`nkhf sn nktnkhnrå pfr quà ce oeyfrïe hn ces dunrres qun
c`jre nc `opnr`f bfy sfk dunrres prfxy.
prfxy. Xnk`nkhf nk aunkte qun ces àc`tns `opnr`ecns t`nknk nc
afktrfc hn ce oåqu`ke hn `opr`o`r h`knrf,
h`knrf, tnk`nkhf nk aunkte qun nc `opnr`f afktrfce n `opfkn
ces pfcït`aes hn ouabfs Nstehfs, tnk`nkhf nk aunkte ce sfl`st`aea`ñk
s fl`st`aea`ñk hn cfs oàtfhfs hn
`kl`ctrea`ñk nk h`st`ktfs k`vncns hn ftrfs Nstehfs, tnk`nkhf nk aunkte ce afkvnk`nka`e
afkvnk`nka`e hn prnsnkter
nstes dunrres ektn ce fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae afof dunrres cfaecns, rea`ecns f rnc`d`fses, sn afoprnkhnrå
qun ec `opnr`f cn rnsuctn oås `ktnrnsektn epfyer hn h`st`ktes oeknres e drupfs hn `ksurdnktns,
onranker`fs,, tnrrfr`stes, keraftrel`aektns, f afktreter e niàra`tfs pr`vehfs, qun cuaber afk sus
onranker`fs
prfp`fs niàra`tfs. Nk nc lfkhf sn trete hn ce cñd`ae aep`tec`ste ccnvehe ec nxtrnof9 tfhf cf qun nc
ac`nktn nx`dn sfk rnsuctehfs y hnie nk oekfs hn cfs
c fs afktret`stes tfhf nc trejeif sua`f qun sne
knanser`f, hnc qun sn hnsnkt`nkhn pfr afopcntf.
Nk nc lfkhf cfs niàra`tfs prfxy sn afrrnspfkhnk hn ce oeknre oås afbnrnktn afk ce cñd`ae hn ce
`ktnrvnka`ñk ert`l`a`ec nk s`tuea`fkns rnecns nx`stnktns, hn 
<8
 

ce qun vnk`ofs bejcekhf. Ektn ar`s`s y afklc`atfs cetnktns, quà onifr qun snr v`rsn hn ncnonktfs cfaecns f rnd`fkecns per peree hnsnkaehnkercfs. Nc `opnr`f
s`noprn nstå ebï pere prfpfra`fker nc epfyf nafkño`af, nc eroeonktf, nc nktrnkeo`nktf,
nktrnkeo`nktf, ce cfdïst`ae, ce h`rnaa`ñk, ce prfpedekhe,
prfpede khe, nta., hn oeknre
nkauj`nrte, e trevàs hn eperetfs hn `ktnc`dnka`e, hn lukhea`fkns u FKDs, hn peïsns ec`ehfs `ktnronh`er`fs.
Ces h`st`ktes leantes hn ce ar`o`kec`heh frdek`zehe sn afopcnonktek y rnec`onktek. Nc trål`af hn hrfdes, hn ftres onraekaïes
onrae kaïes `cndecns f hn pnrsfkes
pnro`tn l`keka`er h`rnateonktn e drupfs
dr upfs cfaecns, hn oeknre qun sus snrv`a`fs cns rnsuctnk oås jeretfs ec `opnr`f, hn oeknre qun punhek prfpfra`fker
h`knrf nk nlnat`vf pere fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes, f pere rnsaeter e cfs jekafs `opnr`ecns nk s`tuea`fkns hn ar`s`s. Ce o`soe cñd`ae sn epc`ae ec afonra`f
`cndec hn ftrfs rnaursfs. Esï, nk ce dunrre nk aursf nk Q`r`e nsteofs v`nkhf añof drupfs tnrrfr`stes sn beank afk nc afktrfc hn rnaursfs pntrfcïlnrfs
cfaecns, afk ce afkk`vnka`e hnc `opnr`f qun sejn qun nstn trål`af `cndec afktr`juyn e su l`keka`ea`ñk y pfr cf tektf ec`dnre ce aerde nafkño`ae `opnr`ec.
 Ehnoås ns teoj`àk nc `opnr`f nc qun qun eaeje afoprekhf nstn pntrñcnf `cndec, tres nc afrrnspfkh`nktn nt`q
nt`quntehf
untehf lreuhucnktf.
lreuhucnktf. Hn oeknre qun nc pntrñcnf
luka`fke, nk ce pråat`ae, hn ce o`soe oeknre qun nc trål`af hn hrfdes. Cf auec kf ns uke s`opcn ontålfre s` tnknofs nk aunkte qun nc `opnr`f ns
eh`atf ec pntrñcnf, nstå knans`tehf hn àc, beste tec puktf qun nstå h`spunstf e afontnr auecqu`nr ar`onk pere afksndu`r su hfs`s. 
5:< 
 Esï, pfhnofs nkdcfjer nc keraftrål`af nk nc npïdreln hn ces dunrres
dunrres prfxy, tnk`nkhf
tnk`nkhf nk aunkte qun nc trål`af hn on
onraekaïes
raekaïes `cndecns kf ns oås qun uke
lunktn hn l`keka`ea`ñk, pnrf qun su vnrhehnrf afont`hf ns nc hn ce hnstruaa`ñk
hnstr uaa`ñk hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn y nc epfyf e ce hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec. Nk ouabfs
peïsns cet`kfeonr`aekfs pfhnofs fjsnrver nste v`kaucea`ñk hn trål`af `cndec y hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec, s`nkhf nc ar`onk frdek`zehf uke sunrtn hn jrezf
eroehf nkauj`nrtf hn ce afcfk`zea`ñk aep`tec`ste. \neofs afk oås hnteccn nstes v`kaucea`fkns. Ec `opnr`f cn `ktnrnse qun sus ouct`kea`fkecns sequnk
cfs oeyfrns jnknl`a`fs pfs`jcns nk ce pnr`lnr`e. ]ere nccf ns afkvnk`nktn
afkvnk`nktn oektnknr e reye ce prftnste sfa`ec y afkter afk ce afopc`a`heh hn ces àc`tns
cfaecns. Nc ar`onk frdek`zehf sn faupe hn beanr nc trejeif sua`f qun, tektf ces afrpfrea`fkns hnc `opnr`f afof ces eutfr`hehns cfaecns, kf punhnk
rnafkfanr. Esï, ns uk `kdrnh`nktn lukheonktec hn ce hfo`kea`ñk aep`tec`ste nk ces pnr`lnr`es. Nk hnl`k`t`ve su terne ns rnpr`o`r hn oeknre v`fcnkte tfhf
equnccf qun sn fpfkn e ce hfo`kea`ñk afcfk`ec aep`tec`ste, nk tfhfs cfs snatfrns, e tfhfs cfs k`vncns9 nstuh`ektns, eat`v`stes, s`kh`aetfs,
s`kh`aetfs, pnr`fh`stes,
`ktncnatuecns, prflnsfrns, pfcït`afs, iunans, nta.
Nc trål`af hn hrfdes y ftres onraekaïes `cndecns ‘ ̀
 ‘ `kacu`he
kacu`he ce onraekaïe buoeke, afks`hnrehe afof tec pfr ce kf-ofrec aep`tec`ste  ‘ ‘  supfkn
 supfkn ce lunktn
hn l`keka`ea`ñk lukheonktec hn tfhe ce fpnrea`ñk. Afk nc ebfrrf s`dk`l`aet`vf hn rnaursfs qun nstf supfkn pere nc `opnr`f. Ce oeyfr pertn hn ce hrfde
`cndec ve e perer e afksuo`hfrns hn cfs anktrfs, pere cf qun 
<>

ns knanser`f afkter afk ce afopc`a`heh hn sus eutfr`hehns. ]ere nccf cfs keraftrel`aektns hnjnk trejeier ec snrv`a`f hn ces afrpfrea`fkns
a frpfrea`fkns `opnr`ecns. Uun
ce hrfde sne `cndec ns uk ncnonktf acevn pere qun tfhe ce nstruature sn sfstnkde. Uun ce hrfde sne `cndec ns lukheonktec pere qun nste hnsnopnõn su
pepnc afof onh`f hn l`keka`ea`ñk hn tfhe ce nstruature, pere qun ces eutfr`hehns hnc `opnr`f tnkdek oås ed`c`heh hn eaa`ñk, hn aere e qun cfs
keraftrel`aektns eatùnk e su snrv`a`f nk nc hfo`k`f afcfk`ec aep`tec`ste. ]ere r`zer nc r`zf cfs aårtncns
aår tncns hn ce hrfde cn afop
afoprek
rek ces eroes ec `opnr`f. P
prfpfra`fkek h`knrf kndrf e cfs jekafs hn Tecc Qtrnnt pere auehrer jecekans.
Nc `ktnraeoj`f aep`tec`ste sn eafopeõe hn oås afeaa`ñk e onh`he qun ces s`tuea`fkns hn pfhnr sfk oås es`oàtr`aes. Hn ce o`soe oeknre, nk equncces
årnes pnr`làr`aes nk ces qun ces es`ontrïes afk cfs anktrfs sfk oås eausehes, ce tnkhnka`e ns qun sn fpnrn afk uk oeyfr drehf hn ar`o`kec`heh y hn
`opuk`heh. ]fr nc afktrer`f, eccï hfkhn ce hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec nstå oås afksfc`hehe, nc s`stnoe sn punhn pnro`t`r oeyfrns drehfs hn cndec`heh. ]nrf nc
`opnr`f ns nc o`sof equï y eccå. Nste afktreh`aa`ñk pfkn hn h n oek`l`nstf, uke vnz oås, beste quà puktf ce ofrec lukheonktec hnc `opnr`f ns ce kf-ofrec,
y nk cfs anktrfs pr`v`cnd`ehfs, qun hn bnabf nkaerkek su hfo`k`f, nste kf-ofrec s`opcnonktn sn nkoesaere tres ce aernte hn uke ofrec treh`a`fkec
l`at`a`e. Nstf ns cf qun aereatnr`zñ e ces jurdunsïes nk nc pr`onr aep`tec`sof, pnrf qun ebfre sn be nxtnkh`hf e ce oeyfrïe hn ce a`uhehekïe afof lfroe
hfo`kektn hn hfjcn ofrec. 
5:2 
Ftre oeknre nk qun nc `opnr`f c`jre sus dunrres prfxy ns e trevàs hn Nstehfs ec`ehfs f sfont`hfs qun flrnank ce afertehe pnrlnate pere nsafkhnr ce
oekf hnc `opnr`f. Qn trete hn Nstehfs-cïo`tn, tnkhnktns ec tftec`ter`sof, qun eatùek ec snrv`a`f hnc `opnr`f afk ces vnkteies hn beanrcf nk tektf qun
Nstehfs `khnpnkh`nktns, afk eperetfs hn Nstehf n `ktnc`dnka`e hftehfs hn drek aepea`heh hn eaa`ñk. Ns N s nc aesf hn peïsns afof @srenc, Erej`e Qeuhï f
 Xurquïe, qun
qun e onkuhf sn nkaerdek hn ces fpnrea`fkns oås turj`es, hnc epfy
epfyff e drupfs tnrrfr`stes, hn ce frdek`zea`ñk hn jekhnres lecses7 nk hnl`k`t`ve,
hn rnprnsnkter nc pepnc hn «pfc` oecf· nk ce l`aa`ñk. Hn oeknre qun kf sfcf nstfs Nstehfs eatùek afof prfx`ns hnc `opnr`f s`kf qun ehnoås s`rvnk nk
ouabfs aesfs afof `ktnronh`er`fs nktrn nc `opnr`f y drupfs `ksurdnktns f tnrrfr`stes.
tnrrfr `stes. Hn ebï qun sne `opfrtektn qun nstàk s`tuehfs nk rnd`fkns nk
afklc`atf, hnshn ces qun punhnk prfpfra`fker epfyf h`rnatf e nstfs drupfs, nk lfroe hn nktrnkeo`nktf, trekspfrtn, aruan hn lrfktnres, rnlud`f,
es`stnka`e oàh`ae, nta.
^k ninopcf
Qeuhï, ns ce qun
pnrf nk dunrre prfxy^k`hfs
Nstehfs qun nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste
prfpfra`fke nstå c`jrekhf
cfdïst`ae, bfyeroeonktf,
tnakfcfdïe, (hnshn oerzf nta.hn@ks`st`ofs
:=58) afktre
nk cePnonk, c`hnrehe
cñd`ae hn pfr su Nstehf
ce oequ`ker`e veseccf Erej`e
hn dunrre
pnroeknktn. Nc snatfr `khustr`ec-o`c`ter hnc `opnr`f knans`te her sec`he rrnducer
nducer e sus nxanhnktns, knans`te `kst`der afklc`atfs qun cfs rnqu`nrek. Cf
`opfrtektn pere àc kf ns qu`àk c`jre ces dunrres
dunrr es s`kf qun ce prfhuaa`ñk o`c`ter tnkde sec`he. P o`nktres ces jfojes aenk sfjrn ces a`uhehns y  
<<
 

ce pfjcea`ñk a`v`c, afk ce `opc`aea`ñk nkauj`nrte hnc `opnr`f, o`nktres cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk epnkes hek aunkte hn nst
nstes
es dunrres prfxy,
prna`seonktn pfrqun pernank kf tnknr kehe qun vnr afk cfs Nstehfs anktrecns, ces eaehno`es prnst`d`fses hnc `opnr`f ftfrdek prno`fs Kfjnc hn ce ]ez
e ces oer`fkntes pfcït`aes f buoek`ter`es qun hnsnopnõek cfs pepncns prftedfk`stes nk tfhe ce l`aa`ñk. Ces dunrres prfxy sfk pnrlnates pere oektnknr
ce eper`nka`e hn ce cndec`heh y ce hnlnkse hn ce pez, pere aerdercn nc ounrtf e ftrf.  
51= 
Ce l`aa`ñk hn ce «Dunrre afktre nc tnrrfr·  
Bnofs ofstrehf añof bfy ces dunrres hnc `opnr`f sfk c`jrehes nk junke onh`he pfr niàra`tfs prfxy. P nktrn nccfs, nc tnrrfr`sof iunde uk pepnc
anktrec. Xeoj`àk bnofs h`abf qun, iuktf e ce arnea`ñk hn h`knrf l`hua`er`f, ce ftre acevn hn jñvnhe hnc s`stnoe ns ce dunrre. Hn oeknre qun nc h`knrf
l`at`a`f arnehf pfr nc s`stnoe y su epfyf nkauj`nrtf ec tnrrfr`sof `ktnrkea`fkec sfk hfs aeres hn ce o`soe ofknhe, hfs ncnonktfs anktrecns hnc
hfo`k`f e trevàs hn ce l`aa`ñk. 
Nc s`stnoe hn hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec knans`te, pfr hnl`k`a`ñk, hns`dker f lejr`aer uk nkno`df pùjc`af, «uk nkno`df sfa`ec dnku`keonktn eonkezektn·
qun iust`l`qun «tfoer y peder uk "prna`f nk sekdrn"· (@klfron. .. ).  ). Q`k nstn nkno`df tfhe ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec hnc s`stnoe
s`stnoe qun, afof bnofs
ofstrehf, sn aekec`ze y afkt`nkn e trevàs hn ce nsank`l`aea`ñk sear`l`a`ec, kf snrïe afktrfcejcn. Nc nkno`df hns`dkehf/lejr`aehf pfr nc s`stnoe sn
afrrnspfkhn afk ce v`fcnka`e «oece·, knanser`e pere pfhnr prnsnkter ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec afof «junke·. Q`k nstn nkno`df nc s`stnoe kf fjtnkhrïe nc
afksnksf qun knans`te pere `opfknr su frhnk,
fr hnk, 
<4

@ks`st`ofs,, nc `opnr`f hn ce
kf afksndu`rïe ce tnks`ñk knanser`e qun sfst`nkn ec `opnr`f, rnsurd`rïek ftrfs ñrhnkns e k`vnc cfaec, rnd`fkec, kea`fkec. @ks`st`ofs
 l`aa`ñk afks`stn nk lejr`aer uk uk nkno`df l`at`a`f,
l`at`a`f, pnrf pere nccf nccf sn tfoe afof jesn jesn uk nkno`df rnec. rnec. Q` kf lunsn pfr
tfhe nste oequ`ker`e
ecaekzehf hn oek`pucea`ñk,
ce `opfrteka`e qunnc t`nkn
tnrrfr`sof
bfy`ktnrkea`fkec bfy kf snrïe
ns, jås`aeonktn, oås qunnsuktnrrfr`sof
pfrqun lnkñonkf eknahñt`af.
lejr`aehf,Q` nctnrrfr`
tnrrfr`sof
sof hnbeNstehf
tnrrfr`sof N stehf
nkauj`nrtf, f, onifr h`abf, tnrrfr`sof hn `opnr`f nkauj`nrtf. nkauj`nrtf. ¶Añof pfhrïe s`kf uke pekh`cce hn rnjnchns trfdcfh`tes eldekfs
frdek`zer y ninauter uke fpnrea`ñk tek afopcnie afof nc ^Q, ec o`sof t`nopf nk nc afrezñk l`keka`nrf y nk nc afrezñk o`c`ter hnc `opnr`f6 ]nrf, pfr
supunstf, uke prndukte tek nv`hnktn kukae sn cn faurr`rå e k`kdukf hn cfs «nxpnrtfs· hn cfs onh`fs.
 Xres ce aeïhe hnc afouk`sof,
afouk`sof, nc `opnr`f
`opnr`f etcekt`ste knans`teje arner uk kunv
kunvff nkno`df. Nsn nkno`df
nkno`df lejr`aehf ns nc y`beh`sof `ktnrkea`fkec. Nc oft`vf
ns qun ces zfkes hn afkqu`ste `opnr`ec qun nc `opnr`f t`nkn nk su ednkhe sfk, sfjrn tfhf, peïsns ousucoekns.
ousucoekns. ]frqun aunktek afk drekhns rnsnr ves hn
pntrñcnf y des, pfrqun faupek årnes
år nes `opfrtektns hnshn nc puktf hn v`ste dnfnstretàd`af, pfrqun sn rns`stnk nk dnknrec e ce `kves`ñk aep`tec`ste. Xeoj`àk
pfrqun nx`stnk o`kfrïes ousucoekes nk ouabfs peïsns, cf qun pnro`tn hnsnstej`c`zercfs e trevàs hnc tnrrfr`sof
tnr rfr`sof y`beh`ste. Ns nc aesf hn Zus`e, hn
dunr re a`v`c sfk cfs hfs pfcfs hn ce o`soe h`kåo`ae. Arnnofs 
Ab`ke y hn ftrfs peïsns hnc årne. ]nrf teoj`àk hn Faa`hnktn. Dunrre dcfjec y dunrre
51: 
qun ce hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk hn cfs peïsns anktrecns e trevàs hnc y`beh`sof lejr`aehf ve e snr uk ncnonktf anktrec nk ce treks`a`ñk bea`e nc dfj`nrkf
dfj`nr kf oukh`ec.
Ns cf qun ye sn nstå pnra`j`nkhf nk Lreka`e. Esï, nc y`beh`sof ns sfcf ce pukte hnc `anjnrd hn uke ednkhe ouct`h`-onks`fkec y ofhucer qun `kacuyn,
hnshn ce afkqu`ste aep`tec`ste hn Nstehfs pnr`làr`afs, beste ce `ksteurea`ñk hn nstehfs pfc`a`ecns, h`atehures f ce `kst`dea`ñk hn dunrr
dunrres
es a`v`cns nk peïsns
anktrecns. Xfhf
Xfhf nccf nk nc afktnxtf hn ce treks`a`ñk bea`e nc Kunvf Fr Frhnk
hnk Oukh`ec. Hn ebï qun nktrn nc y`beh`sof y nc `sceo`sof beye uke cïkne ouy
h`luse, pfrqun hn bnabf ces `ktnka`fkns kf hnacerehes hnc `opnr`f sfk `kst`der afklc`atfs nktrn ar`st`ekfs f iuhïfs y ousucoekns, esï afof nktrn ukes
snates ousucoekes y ftres.
ftres. Nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, nc y`beh`sof ns ftre hn ces «eonkezes dcfjecns· qun nståk s`rv`nkhf afof prntnxtf pere ce
`opcnonktea`ñk hnc Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec.
Hn oeknre qun nc y`beh`sof ns ce nxause pnrlnate pere ce dunrre tftec, dcfjec, prfxy,
prfxy, hnc `opnr`f. Kf sfcf s`rvn pere nkoesaerer ces dunrres `opnr`ecns
s`kf teoj`àk pere iust`l`aerces. Nk nlnatf, ce onkt`re fl`a`ec hn qun nc y`beh`sof ns nc nkno`df pùjc`af pnro`tn, ec o`sof t`t`nopf,
nopf, iust`l`aer ces
`ktnrvnka`fkns puktuecns h`rnates hn cfs Nstehfs `opnr`ecns, y snrv`rsn hn àc hn oeknre nkauj`nrte afof ec`ehf. Esï, ce rnec`heh ns qun, afk aeråatnraerå atnr
dnknrec, cfs tnrrfr`stes
tnrr fr`stes trejeiek ec snrv`a`f
snr v`a`f hnc `opnr`f, qun cns prfpfra`fke h`knrf, er
eroes,
oes, nktrnkeo`nktf
nktrnkeo`nktf,, cfdïst`ae, epfyf eàrnf, rnlud`f, trekspfrtn,
nstupnlea`nktns,, `opuk`heh, nta. Xfhf nccf, ces oås hn ces vnans, hn oeknre nkauj`nrte, e trevàs hn Nstehfs  
nstupnlea`nktns
<2
 

ec`ehfs, hn eperetfs hn `ktnc`dnka`e y o`c`terns snarntfs, hn lukhea`fkns y FKDs qun trejeiek hn oeknre sno`acekhnst`ke.
Nk ces dunrres acås`aes, cfs Nstehfs afktejek afk niàra`tfs rnducerns qun `ktnrvnkïek hn oeknre frhnkehe, afk fjint`vfs afkarntfs, ec snrv`a`f hn cfs
`ktnrnsns hnc Nstehf. Nc aep`tec, kf aejn huhe, iudeje uk pepnc lukheonktec afof l`keka`ste, y e onkuhf `kst`dehfr, hn nstes dunrres, pnrf nsteje
rncet`veonktn sujfrh`kehf e cfs `ktnrnsns hnc Nstehf. Bfy ce s`tuea`ñk sn be `kvnrt`hf afopcnteonktn nk uk afktnxtf nk nc qun nc drek aep`tec kf t`nkn
petr`e, nk nc qun nc `opnr`f nstå afktrfcehf pfr nc drek aep`tec y cfs pfcït`afs sfk onres oer`fkntes. Cfs Nstehfs eatùek afof rnprnsnktektns, pnrf cfs
 vnrhehnrfs `ktnrnsns sfk cfs hn ces afrpfrea`fkns
afrpfrea`fkns aep`tec`stes qun, ec oerdnk hn ququnn punhek tnknr su snhn equï f eccå, sfk nnkk ce pråat`ae ce suoe hn cfs
`ktnrnsns hnc aep`tec `ktnrkea`fkec. Nk nstn afktnxtf hn afkqu`ste hn kunvfs onraehfs, hn nxtnrkec`zea`ñk hn ce prfhuaa`ñk, hn sujafktretea`ñk hn
årnes hn kndfa`f, nta., nc tnrrfr`sof `ktnrkea`fkec nkaeie e ce pnrlnaa`ñk. Nstn afktnxtf hn aep`tec`sof dcfjec ns `opfrtektn pere nktnkhnr nc
tnrrfr`sof. Nk r`dfr kf sn punhn hna`r qun uk drupf
d rupf tnrrfr`ste trejein per
peree uk Nstehf f uk eperetf hn Nstehf afkarntf hn oeknre fl`a`ec, h`rnate,
pnroeknktn. Nc tnrrfr`sof kf hnie hn snr uk ednktn rncet`veonktn `khnpnkh`nktn afk nc qun nc rnstf hn ednktns `opc`aehfs, y nk afkarntf cfs eperetfs
nstretàd`aes. Nk nstn snkt`hf nc tàro`kf oås eprfp`ehf pere hns`dker ce rncea`ñk 
hn Nstehf, o`c`terns f hn `ktnc`dnka`e hnc `opnr`f, nstejcnank ec`ekzes nstretàd`aes.
518 
hnc tnrrfr`sof `ktnrkea`fkec afk nc `opnr`f snrïe nc hn ec`ehf nstretàd`af.
 Esï, aes` sn pfhrïe bejcer hn P`beh`sof Q.E.
Q.E. Nc ofhncf sn pernan ouabf ec hn ces lrekqu`a`es. Q`noprn be nx`st`hf uk a`nrtf tnrrfr`sof, pnrf bfy nc
lnkñonkf hnc P`beh`sof Q.E. sn ouct`pc`ae afk ce lea`c`heh afk ce qun sn nxt`nkhnk ces ouct`kea`fkecns nk nc aep`tec`sof dcfjec. Nk nlnatf, ec `opnr`f
cn `ktnrnse qun nc tnrrfr`sof sne dcfjec. Ec l`k y ec aejf hn cf qun sn trete ns, kf sfcf hn qun r`khe uk snrv`a`f, s`kf teoj`àk hn vnkhnrcf. Esï, uke
junke pertn hn ce fpnrea`ñk ns h`snõer tfhf nc rnpnrtfr`f hn `oådnkns, cfdfs, jekhes sfkfres, afk qun v`nkn nkvunctf nc prfhuatf. Nk
hnl`k`t`ve, prfofvnr uke oerae. ^ke vnz qun nste be ehqu`r`hf pfpucer`heh, uke vnz qun be tnk`hf àx`tf nk nc onraehf, sn punhn nxtnkhnr nc kndfa`f e
ftrfs onraehfs, jusaekhf noprnkhnhfrns cfaecns qun afktr`juyek e ce `kvnrs`ñk, s`rv`àkhfsn hn tfhf nc oergnt`kd prnv`f pere esndurer su àx`tf. Esï,
tfhe ce rntñr`ae hnc `sceo`sof reh`aec y ce P`beh, qun cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk kfs vnkhnk afof cfs oft`vfs qun ounvnk e nstfs «reh`aecns· e
ec`stersn, kf ns oås qun pertn hn ce lerse, pertn
per tn hn ce afertehe onh`åt`ae pere vnkhnrkfs nc prfhuatf. Nk rnec`heh, ce oeyfrïe hn cfs tnrrfr`stes kf sfk
tektf lekåt`afs rnc`d`fsfs afof oerd`kehfs nafkño`afs, onranker`fs, nxafojet`nktns hn ftrfs afklc`atfs, qun cuabek cf o`sof jeif uke jekhnre qun
jeif ftre. P ns qun nc tnrrfr`sof ns prfvfaehf, nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, pfr nc `opnr`f, kf sfcf nk nc snkt`hf onraehftàak`af, s`kf teoj`àk nk nc oås rnec.
 Xfhe ce hnstruaa`ñk y nc aefs qun nc `opnr`f prfvfae
prfvfae nk ukfs 
<0

nsanker`fs hn afklc`atf, prfpfra`fke nc aechf hn auct`vf pere kunvfs «lukheonktec`stes·. Ce pfjcea`ñk oerd`kec, cfs iñvnkns hnsnkaektehfs qun bek
 v`stf sus v`hes hnstrfzehes pfr ce v`fcnka`e `opnr`ec,
`opnr`ec, cfs tfrturehfs, punhnk rnsera`rsn hn nccf nkdrfsekhf ces l`ces hnc y`beh`sof
y`beh`sof,, qun nc `opnr`f sn
nkaerde hn aekec`zer nk su prfp`f `ktnràs. Esï, nc tnrrfr`sof ns nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e uke lfroe
lfr oe hn rnaupnrea`ñk hn ces `ksurdnk-a`es ekt``opnr`ec`stes, uke
lfroe hn fpfs`a`ñk afktrfcehe. Hn ce o`soe oeknre qun, afof vnrnofs, luka`fkek nc buoek`ter`sof y nc nafcfd`sof e ftrfs k`vncns y nk ftrfs
nktfrkfs. 
51< 
Nc s`fk`sof 
Bey qun nktnkhnr nc s`fk`sof nk nc afktnxtf hn tfhf cf qun vnk`ofs h`a`nkhf. Nc s`fk`sof y nc y`beh`sof, afof h`an Ehr`åk Qecjuab`, sfk hfs h fs aeres
hn ce o`soe ofknhe, hfs lejr`aea`fkns `opnr`ecns qun nkoesaerek y s`rvnk e uk pcek hn hfo`k`f dcfjec.
]ere nopnzer bey qun rnafkfanr nc pepnc prnhfo`kektn qun bek hnsnopeõehf cfs iuhïfs iuhï fs nk ce b`stfr`e hnc aep`tec`sof
aep`tec`sof,, tec afof kfs be ofstrehf
 Tnrknr Qfojert. Ce nstruature hn afopc`a`heh nktrn nc aep`tec
aep`tec iuhïf y cfs eperetfs hn pfhnr nurfpnfs,
nurfpnfs, nk cfs s`dcfs nk cfs qun nc aep`tec`s
aep`tec`sof
of sn `opusf
afof ràd`onk pfcït`af-nafkño`af, t`nkn ouabf qun hna`rkfs sfjrn ce lfroe lfr oe nk qun fpnre nc `opnr`f bfy. Nk nlnatf, cf qun cfs iuhïfs hnserrfccerfk e
cf cerdf hn s`dcfs ns uke nstruature nk rnh
r nh e k`vnc dcfjec ‘ rnh
rnh hn `klfroea`ñk, rnh hn `klcunka`e, rnh hn `kl`ctrea`ñk, rnh hn `kvnrs`fkns y aràh`tfs ‘  , ,
qun trekslnrïe nxanhnktns y cfs hnst`keje e aràh`tfs nk h`st`ktfs puktfs hn ce rnh nk luka`ñk hn ces a`rauksteka`es. ^k nktreoehf `ktnksf ‘ lfroehf lfroehf
pfr leo`c`es iuhïes nk h`st`ktes a`uhehns y peïsns  ‘ 
‘  qun
 qun sn sfcepeje e cfs åoj`tfs tnrr`tfr`ecns nxtnksfs nk cfs qun sn `kstecejek ‘ afouk`hehns
afouk`hehns 
4=
 

ar`st`ekes f ousucoekes ‘ . Nktreoehf perecncf ec e c hn cfs anktrfs hn pfhnr pfcït`af, afk cfs qun nstejcnaïek rncea`fkns hn afopc`a`heh, bfy h`rïeofs
hn sfont`o`nktf y afktrfc. Cf `opfrtektn ns nktnkhnr qun nste rnh `ktnkse iuhïe be s`hf e cf cerdf hn ce b`stfr`e hn ftrf frhnk, supnrpunste e cfs
åoj`tfs tnrr`tfr`ecns, kea`fkecns, cfaecns, afrrnspfkh`nktns, pnrf s`k onzacersn afk nccfs, afksnrvekhf su s`kducer`heh. Hn oeknre
o eknre qun luka`fkeje
afof uke nspna`n hn `kstecea`ñk hn r`ndf y hrnkein afk rnspnatf e cfs sustretfs nk cfs qun sn `ksteceje, afof espnrsfrns y suo`hnrfs hn
c`qu`hnz, afof puktfs hn `rr`dea`ñk y hn ejsfra`ñk hn aep`tec. Nk cfs ofonktfs hn snquïe nafkño`ae, prfpfra`fkejek ce c`qu`hnz
knanser`e e cfs dfjnrkektns7 nk cfs ofonktfs hn nxansf hn c`qu`hnz, ce hrnkejek bea`e sus suo`hnrfs.
Ns fpfrtukf `hnkt`l`aer nste h`onks`ñk
h `onks`ñk iuhïe hnc aep`tec`sof b`stñr`af ‘ uke
uke hn ces pr`ka`pecns, pnrf kf ce ùk`ae ‘  pere
 pere afoprnkhnr nc pepnc hnc
s`fk`sof bfy.
bfy. Ce nstruature hn nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze y hn suo`k`strf hn h`knrf l`at`a`f, tektf ofknter`f afof arnh`t`a`f, qun bfy r`dn nk nc `opnr`f
dcfjec cn hnjn ouabf e ce nstruature iuhïe aep`tec`ste hn ce qun bejceofs. Kf ns qun ce treh`a`ñk iuhïe sne ce ùk`ae lunktn hn ce aucture, ce `hnfcfdïe y ce
ofrec aep`tec`stes. Qejnofs qun ce aucture prftnstektn teoj`àk be hnsnopnõehf uk pepnc prnpfkhnrektn, tec afof kfs ofstrñ Oex Tnjnr. Hn bnabf
ce ec`ekze nktrn a`nrtfs snatfrns prftnstektns y iuhïfs ns, afof be ofstrehf ]`nrrn B`ccerh, lukheonktec pere nktnkhnr añof fpnrek ces àc`tns
bfy.. 
aep`tec`stes dcfjecns bfy
512 
Hn ebï qun @srenc iundun uk pepnc anktrec bfy nk nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste. Afof aejnze hn punktn hn ce afkqu`ste nk Fr`nktn Fr `nktn Onh`f. ]nrf teoj`àk,
hnshn nc puktf hn v`ste prfpedekhïst`af, afof nc pfcf afopcnonkter`f hn ce l`aa`ñk hnc y`beh`sof y cfs afklc`atfs rnc`d`fsfs nktrn iuhïfs f ar`st`ekfs y
ousucoekns.. ]fr nsf nc s`fk`sof ns ukf hn cfs pr`ka`pecns `ktnrnsehfs nk qun nx`ste nc y`beh`sof, pfrqun nc s`fk`sof y nc y`beh`sof sn knans`tek nc
ousucoekns
ukf ec ftrf, sfk hfs hn cfs pnrsfkeins pr`ka`pecns hnc tnetrf hn ce «Dunrre afktre nc tnrrfr·.
tnrr fr·. ]fr nsf nc s`fk`sof ns uke h`onks`ñk acevn hn ce
prfpedekhe `opnr`ec`ste etcekt`ste. ]fr nsf, afof be ofstrehf Ieafj Afbàk, afof faurrïe nk ces afrtns b`stñr`aes nurfpnes, ednktns s`fk`stes,
seyek`o y ftrfs s`opet`zektns hnc s`fk`sof nståk bfy `kl`ctrehfs nk kuonrfsfs eperetfs hn Nstehf, nk ces uk`vnrs`hehns, nk cfs onh`fs hn
hns`klfroea`ñk, nk ce `khustr`e hnc nspnatåaucf, nk Bfccywffh. Nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk ns, teoj`àk, s`fk`ste.
Nk nste cñd`ae prfpedekhïst`ae `opnr`ec, tec afof be bnabf vnr Kfroek L`kgncstn`k, sn `ksar`jn ce `ks-truonktec`zea`ñk hnc Bfcfaeustf kez` y ce
 v`at`o`ze-a`ñk hn cfs iuhïfs.
iuhïfs. Esï afof ces oek`pucea`
oek`pucea`fkns
fkns b`stñr`aes hn qun ns fjintf
fjintf,, tec afof bek ofstrehf Zfjnrt Leur`ssfk,
Leur`ssfk, ^rsuce Bevnrjnag y
ftrfs. ¶]fr quà ns knanser`f ar`o`kec`zer ces `kvnst`dea`fkns qun pfknk nk aunst`ñk ces vnrs`fkns fl`a`ecns sfjrn nc Bfcfaeustf, s` kf ns pfrqun nstes
 vnrs`fkns fl`a`ecns sfk
sfk afkstruaa`fkns l`at`a`es qun sn prntnkhnk beanr
beanr peser pfr vnrhehns, qun pfhrïek snr hnsofktehes
hnsofktehes pfr nstes vnrs`fkns
ectnrket`ves6 
45

Nk ce o`soe cñd`ae hn afopc`a`heh hnc s`fk`sof afk nc prfynatf `opnr`ec sn `ksar`jn nc cceoehf ekt`sno`t`sof,
ekt`sno`t`sof, qun ns nk rnec`heh uke afer tehe pere
tnrd`vnrser ce rnec`heh y afojet`r hn oeknre pnrvnrse
pnr vnrse e equnccfs qun hnkuka`ek nc s`fk`sof y ce h`onks`ñk s`fk`ste hnc `opnr`f, pere nv`ter qun sn bejcn
nk prflukh`heh hnc pepnc anktrec qun bek tnk`hf y s`dunk tnk`nkhf cfs iuhïfs nk nc aep`tec`sof, pere cnd`t`oer ce arnea`ñk hnc Nstehf hn @srenc y cfs
dnkfa`h`fs qun afontn afk `opuk`heh.
Uun beye vïat`oes iuhïes nk ouabes hn ces jekhnres lecses hn bfy, e onkuhf frqunstehes nk afopc`a`heh afk nc s`fk`sof, rnspfkhn e ce o`soe cñd`ae
hn v`at`o`zea`ñk. Nc ekt`sno`t`sof cn s`rvn hn afertehe ec `opnr`f pere ontnr nk uk o`sof seaf nc ekt`s`fk`sof y nc ekt``opnr`ec`sof, qun nk ce
pråat`ae sfk h`lïa`cns hn h`lnrnka`er. Nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e cfs pnrsfkeins ektedfk`stes qun ce l`aa`ñk `opnr`ec kfs prnsnkte nk nsanke sfk nc iuhïf «junkf·
y nc y`beh`ste «oecf·. Nste l`aa`ñk nstå h`snõehe pere faucter qun nc s`fk`sof ns uke h`onks`ñk anktrec hnc prfynatf `opnr`ec`ste etcekt`ste y qun nstn
prfynatf `kacuyn ce lejr`aea`ñk l`at`a`e hnc y`beh`sof. 
Nc 5 5 Q y ces jekhnres lecses 
jekhnres lecses
Bnofs tretehf hn ofstrer nc pepnc qun nc tnrrfr`sof `ktnrkea`fkec
`ktnr kea`fkec hnsnopnõe afof niàra`tf prfxy nk ce dunrre dcfjec hnc `opnr`f. Ces jekhnres lecses
kf sfk oås qun uke hn ces petes hn tfhe ce afkstruaa`ñk, ce qun afkv`nrtn tfhe ce l`aa`ñk nk rnec`heh, per pert`auceronktn
t`auceronktn hn aere e ce a`uhehekïe hn cfs
Nstehfs anktrecns. @ks`st`ofs, ce «Dunrre afktre nc tnrrfr· ns uke fpnrea`ñk nkauj`nrte hnc `opnr`f etcekt`ste jesehe nk ce cñd`ae hn afkvnrt`r nk
rnec`heh uke l`aa`ñk, y nsank`l`aer y hreoet`zer h`abe rnec`heh beste vfcvnr e beanr hn ncce ftre l`aa`ñk, nk uke nsp`rec s`k l`k. Cf qun e su vnz pnro`tn
trekslfroer ce rnec`heh nk nc snkt`hf nk nc qun cn `ktnrnse e ces àc`tns `opnr`ecns, nk nc snkt`hf hn ce ednkhe nkauj`nrte hn
hncc `opnr`f pere `opcekter uk
Kunvf Frhnk Oukh`ec tftec`ter`f. Cfs etnktehfs hn jekhnre lecse kf sfk oås qun uk np`lnkñonkf hn nste cñd`ae qun sn jese nk afkvnrt`r uke l`aa`ñk
nk rnec`heh, fauctekhf qun sn trete nk nlnatf hn uke l`aa`ñk pcek`l`aehe hn oeknre nkauj`nrte. Hn ebï qun sne acevn pere nc `opnr`f hnsearnh`ter,
hnofk`zer y nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e ar`o`kec`zer ces pfs`a`fkns qun prna`seonktn hnsvncek nste nstruature nkauj`nrte. 
4:
585
 

Cfs etnktehfs tnrrfr`stes nk cfs peïsns anktrecns hnc `opnr`f y ce dunrre


dunr re tnrrfr`ste nk ces pnr`lnr`es kf sfk oås qun ces hfs ae
aeres
res hn uke o`soe ofknhe.
Hfs lnkñonkfs qun pfhrïek ouy låa`conktn tnkhnr e afkvnrdnr nk ce onh`he nk qun ce h`st`ka`ñk nktrn anktrfs y pnr`lnr`es aehe vnz t`nkn onkfs
snkt`hf y nc `opnr`f punhn nsaecer cfs afklc`atfs sfa`ecns nk cfs anktrfs beste afkvnrt`rcfs nk dunrres a`v`cns. Ecdf hn nstf veofs e vnr nk cfs prñx`ofs
eõfs nk nc prfansf hn trekslnrnka`e hn sfjnrekïe hn cfs Nstehfs anktrecns ‘ sfjrn sfjrn tfhf nk Nstehfs ^k`hfs y Nurfpe ‘  ec  ec dfj`nrkf oukh`ec.
Hn tfhfs cfs etnktehfs hn jekhnre lecse, nc oås `opfrtektn hn ces hfs ùct`oes hàaehes be s`hf s`k cuder e huhes nc hnc 55 hn Qnpt`nojrn hn :==5, qun
ecdukfs ekec`stes afof T`cc`eo Nkdhebc f Xb`nrry Onyssek afks`hnrek uk dfcpn hn Nstehf nkauj`nrtf. Nstn nvnktf pnro`tn nktnkhnr beste quà puktf
 v`v`ofs bfy jeif uk ràd`onk
ràd`onk `opnr`ec tftec`ter`f, jeif uke h`atehure nkauj`nrte hnc aep`tec. Qfcf bey qun af afoperer
operer nste jekhnre lecse afk ce qunoe hnc
]erceonktf ecnoåk pfr cfs kez`s nk 5011 pere nktnkhnr nk quà s`tuea`ñk nsteofs. Ces ekecfdïes sfk kuonrfses9 ce o`soe ar`s`s hnc s`stnoe, ce o`soe
hnr`ve tftec`ter`e, nc o`sof tnrrfr`sof hn Nstehf nkauj`nrtf. Qfcf aeoj`ek ces lfroes, cfs oàtfhfs, ce sfl`st`aea`ñk hn ce prfpedekhe, nc ecaekan
pceknter`f hnc ràd`onk, cfs ab`vfs nxp`etfr`fs,
nxp`etfr`fs, pnrf ce h`kåo`ae hn lfkhf ns ce o`soe. Qejnofs e cf qun afkhuif nc hnc`r`f kez`, hnc qun ce qunoe hnc
`keudurecns. Nc hnc`r`f hnc 55Q punhn, hn ce o`soe oeknre, afks`hnrersn nc eatf `keudurec hn ce hnr`ve tftec`ter`e 
Zn`absted lun ukf hn cfs eatfs `keudurecns.
58: 
qun
Bnofsbfyv`stf
pehnanofs
añof cey eho`k`strea`ñk
qun j`nk pfhrïehnccnverkfs e uke`opnr`ec
ce v`fcnka`e XnranresnDunrre
rnhuanOukh`ec.
e uke cñd`ae ouy s`opcn hn h`st`ka`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e «oece· hn ce v`fcnka`e
«junke·, qun nste h`st`ka`ñk sn prfhuan e trevàs hn su r`tuec`-zea`ñk sear`l`a`ec. Nk nlnatf, cfs etnktehfs hn jekhnre lecse kf sfk ftre afse qun
sear`l`a`fs r`tuecns hnc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste. Nk nccfs sn vn hn ce lfroe oås acere añof ces àc`tns sear`l`aek e sus prf p`fs a`uhehekfs pere afksndu`r sus
fjint`vfs.. Qfk uke afkstetea`ñk hn beste quà puktf nc ràd`onk aep`tec`ste fpnre afof uke rnc`d`ñk. Cfs etnktehfs pfknk nk nsanke
fjint`vfs nsanke uke
v`fcnka`e l`at`a`e bnabe rnec`heh, qun ns `hnkt`l`aehe `konh`eteonktn afof v`fcnka`e «oece· y prfvfae ce afksnaunktn rneaa`ñk pfr pertn
hnc pùjc`af oek`pucehf9 nc aest`df hn cfs «aucpejcns·. «Ces "eonkezes" nk afktre hnc "`ktnràs kea`fkec" usueconktn sfk dnknrehes f eancnrehes pere
dunrr e· (@klfron...). Ce eonkeze l`at`a`e y ce v`fcnka`e rnec vek hn ce oekf. Nc prfjcnoe
set`sleanr ces knans`hehns aeoj`ektns hnc s`stnoe hn dunrre·
hnoekhe uke sfcua`ñk9 ce «Dunrre afktre nc tnrrfr·. «Eonr`ae ^khnr Etteag·, t`tucejek ouabfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk tres nc ^Q. Cf
qun kf hnaïek ns qun qu`nk nsteje rneconktn eteaekhf Eoàr`ae nre nc `opnr`f etcekt`ste o`sof.
Ces jekhnres lecses sfk uke oek`lnstea`ñk ouy nv`hnktn hnc pfhnr qun t`nkn bfy ce l`aa`ñk. Nstfs eu-tfetnktehfs sn pcek`l`aek afof uke l`aa`ñk. Ns
pfs`jcn qun cfs qun pceknerek nc ^Q sn `ksp`rerek nk nc iundf @ccuo`ket` hn Qtnvn Ieagsfk, qun ye nk 502: ofstreje 
41

hfs tfrrns dnonces eteaehes y nc nh`l`a`f hnc ]nktådfkf nk cceoes. Hn cf qun sn trete ns hn afkvnrt`r uke l`aa`ñk nk rnec`heh. ]nrf s`dun
luka`fkekhf afof l`aa`ñk nk nc snkt`hf nk qun cfs rnspfksejcns kf sfk oås qun `ktnronh`er`fs, y nk qun nste l`aa`ñk pnro`tn trekslfroer nc oukhf
rnec beste afkvnrt`rcf nk ftre afse, qun e su vnz be s`hf afkanj`he afof l`aa`ñk nk cfs hnspeabfs snarntfs hn ces àc`tns hnc`rektns qun bfy afktrfcek nc
oukhf. Nk suoe, ce o`soe cñd`ae hn afkvnrt`r ce l`aa`ñk nk rnec`heh ce nkafktreofs e hfs nsaeces. P cf qun rncea`fke eojes, ce treope qun bean
pfs`jcn qun ces ednkhes nkauj`nrtes sn bedek rnec`heh, ns ftre l`aa`ñk9 ce qun `hnkt`l`ae e cfs tnrrfr`stes afk cfs aucpejcns, hniekhf lunre hn nsanke
nsanke
e  cfs vnrhehnrfs aucpejcns.
X   
Ce dunrre j`fcñd`ae y quïo`ae 
Bnofs v`stf beste quà puktf ce dunrre ns nc pereh`doe hn tfhes ces lfroes hn hfo`k`f `opnr`ec, bnofs ofstrehf qun ouabfs lnkñonkfs kf sfk oås
qun h`st`ktes ver`nhehns n `ktnks`hehns hn ce o`soe dunrre, qun ce prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe t`nkn afof pr`ka`pec afont`hf nkoesaerer ce vnrhehnre
vnrh ehnre
nsnka`e jàc`ae hn ouabfs lnkñonkfs afktnopfråknfs. ]uns j`nk, veofs e sndu`r tretekhf hn `ktnrprnter ecdukfs hn nstfs lnkñonkfs hnshn ce o`soe
cñd`ae, nspna`econktn equnccfs nk cfs qun nste afknx`ñk ns oås h`lïa`c hn rnafkfanr.
^ke hn ces dunrres qun nc `opnr`f nstå c`jrekhf bfy afktre tfhfs ns ce dunrre j`fcñd`ae y quïo`ae. Ecdukes hn ces eroes hn ns te dunrre sfk cfs
frdek`sofs dnkàt`aeonktn ofh`l`aehfs f treksdàk`afs, cfs bnrj`a`hes, cfs pnst`a`hes, cfs lnrt`c`zektns, cfs v`rus ‘ teoj`àk
teoj`àk treksdàk`afs ‘  , , ces
 veaukes, cfs låroeafs nk dnknrec. Nk nstn snatfr
snatfr sn punhn fjsnrver cf qun bnofs h`abf sfjrn nc s`stnoe hn dunrre, añof ns ce tnakfcfdïe hn dunrre ce
 vekduerh`e qun sfst`nkn y nk ce qun
qun sn jese tfhe ce `khustr`e. Nk nlnatf
nlnatf,, kf ns aesuec`heh qun ces afrpfrea`fkns oås `opfrtektns hnc snatfr prfvnkdek 
oås
588 
48
 

iusteonktn hnc åoj`tf jàc`af. Nk rnec`heh kukae cf bek ejekhfkehf. Ns nc aesf hn Ofksektf, qun lejr`añ nc Ednktn Kerekie ut`c`zehf nk ce Dunrre hn
 \`ntkeo. Xfhe
Xfhe ce `khustr`e j`fquïo`ae y leroeaàut`ae rnspfkhn nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e e uk pereh`doe hn du dunrre,
nrre, nk uk drehf u ftrf, afk oeyfr f onkfr
`ktnks`heh. Ce cñd`ae lukheonktec qun sfst`nkn tfhf nstn snatfr ns ce hn ce eho`k`strea`ñk afktrfcehe hn ounrtn. Ces cnd`scea`fkns y ces
rnducea`fkns kf vncek pfrqun cfs prfhuatfs snek secuhejcns, afof kfs tretek hn beanr arnnr, s`kf pfr qun kf snek hnoes`ehf tñx`afs, pfr qun kf
prfhuzaek hnoes`ehfs heõfs afcetnrecns, pfr qun kf oetnk hnoes`ehf. Cfs bnrj`a`hes, cfs pnst`a`hes, cfs ekt`j`ñt`afs, cfs ektïdnkfs, sfk,
afof `kh`ae su kfojrn, y pfr hnl`k`a`ñk, cntecns. Ce aunst`ñk ns rnducer auåkhf, hñkhn, añof, e qu`àk f quà hnjnk oeter.
 \neofss nc aesf hn cfs auct`vfs
 \neof auct`vfs treksdàk`afs
treksdàk`afs.. Nstfs sn afonra`ec`zek fjc`detfr`eonktn nk uukk peag afopcntf iuktf afk bnrj`a`hes,
bnrj`a`hes, pnst`a`hes y
lnrt`c`zektns. Nc pepnc hn tfhf nc peag ns nc o`sof qun nc hn ces eroes j`fcñd`aes y quïo`aes ‘   ‘ ̀`ks`st`ofs,
ks`st`ofs, teoj`àk cf sfk ‘ 9 eaejer afk tfhe ce v`he
 vndntec, ek`oec y buoeke qun sn rns`stn
rns`stn e ce pure cñd`ae hn ce prfhuat`v`heh aep`tec`
aep`tec`ste.
ste. Qn afoprnkhnrå qun ektn nste dunrre nkauj`nrte, ce nspna`n
treksdàk`ae qun sfjrnv`vn kf punhn snr oås qun uk nkdnkhrf, uk ofkstruf, sfcf e onh`es keturec. P nc fjint`vf ùct`of ns qun cfs qun afonk
ofkstrufs sn afkv`nrtek teoj`àk nk ofkstrufs...
Nk nc lfkhf sn trete hn ce o`soe cñd`ae dnkàr`ae
d nkàr`ae qun, afof bnofs ofstrehf, nstå nk ce jesn hn ce trekslfroea`ñk aep`tec`ste9 hnstru`r ce afkv`vnka`e-
c`jrn y  
58< 
sust`tu`rce pfr rncea`fkns onraekt`cns. Hn ce o`soe oeknre qun nc s`stnoe trete hn e`scer ec suintf hn su nktfrkf v`tec y aucturec, hn su afouk`heh, y
beanr hn àc uk fjintf afonra`ec`zejcn, uk rfjft prfhuat`vf y afksuo`hfr, nc edrfkndfa`f trekslfroe e ces nspna`ns vndntecns nk ayjfrds e`scehfs hn
su nktfrkf, ek`qu`cekhf nc rnstf hn ce v`he qun afklfroe su afouk`heh, afkv`rt`àkhfcfs nk oåqu`kes hn prfhua`r. Kf pernan uke aesuec`heh qun ce
lnrt`c`heh nk ces sfa`nhehns ofhnrkes t`nkhe e hnsankhnr y qun ec o`sof t`nopf ces nspna`ns treksdàk`aes snek `klàrt`cns. Xeopfaf pernan uke
aesuec`heh qun punhek snrv`r ec afktrfc hn ce lnrt`c`heh buoeke. Kf sn trete hn ontålfres s`kf hn ce o`soe cñd`ae eatuekhf e h`st`ktfs k`vncns.
Qn nktnkhnrå nk qun afks`stn ce `khustr`e hn cfs treksdàk`afs afk ftre afoperea`ñk, qun hn kunvf kf ns uk sïo`c s`kf nc o`sof lnkñonkf epc`aehf nk
hfs åoj`tfs h`st`ktfs. Ns afof uke dunrre reh`feat`ve, j`fcñd`ae f quïo`ae qun eaeje afk tfhe ce v`he, nxanptf equncce qun sn beye prftnd`hf afk uk
trein nspna`ec hn sndur`heh f nk uk jùkgnr. Cfs treksdàk`afs sfk cf o`sof9 nspna`ns prftnd`hes afk treins y oesaer`cces, qun afks`dunk sfjrnv`v`r e uke
dunrre qun sn c`jre e su ecrnhnhfr, hn ce qun nccf's sfk cfs ùk`afs sfjrnv`v`nktns. Nstf ns cf qun nsteofs afo afo`nkhf9
`nkhf9 sfjrnv`v`nktns hn dunrres
j`fcñd`aes, quïo`aes y reh`feat`ves. Xeopfaf ns uke aesuec`heh qun ces afkteo`kea`fkns reh`feat`ves prfhuzaek outea`fkns dnkà dnkàt`aes.
t`aes. ]frqun cfs
ofkstrufs treksdàk`afs qun nsteofs afo`nkhf sfk teoj`àk sfont`hfs e reh`ea`fkns nk cejfretfr`f pere ofh`l`aer sus ddnkns. nkns. Hn ebï qun ces
oer`fkntes 
4>

pfcït`aes kndfa`nk nk snarntf afk nc aårtnc j`ftnakf-cñd`af cfs tre


tretehfs
tehfs hn «c`jrn· afonra`f. Afof sn vn, uk`nkhf cfs puktfs afo`nkze e rnvncersn nc
 vnrhehnrf rfstrf hnc `opnr`f.
`opnr`f.
Ce edr`aucture `khustr`ec afks`stn jås`aeonktn nk `r sust`tuynkhf ce edr`aucture cfaec hn sujs`stnka`e y hn pnqunõe nsaece pfr drekhns pcektea`fkns hn
ofkfauct`vfs treksdàk`afs.
treksdàk`afs. Ce dunrr
dunrree j`fcñd`ae quïo`ae y reh`feat`ve hn jeie `ktnks`heh qun, nk hnl`k`t`ve, ns nste `khustr`e, afktr`juyn e nste afkqu`ste
prfdrns`ve, pfrqun elnate, kf sfcf e ces b`nrjes f ces pnstns afktre ces qun supunsteonktn sn afojetn, s`kf nk dnknrec e tfhe ce v`he qun rfhne nstfs
auct`vfs, `kacu`he ce buoeke. Nk ftres pecejres, cfs auct`vfs treksdàk`afs y sus prfhuatfs eux`c`erns prfvfaek heõfs afcetnrecns nk auct`vfs
afc`khektns kf treksdàk`afs y nk sus pfjcea`fkns buoekes, y esï, `kh`rnateonktn, afktr`juynk e ce nxtnks`ñk hnc ofhncf edrf`khustr`ec.
edr f`khustr`ec. Dunrre y
afkqu`ste hn onraehfs, hn kunvf, sn hek ce oekf.
 Xfhf nccf
nccf sn `ksar`jn nk ce cñd`ae pnrvnrse hnc hfo`k`f hnc drek aep`tec sfjrn ce sfjnrekïe
sfjnrekïe hn cfs punjcfs, e trevàs
trevàs hn ecdf tek ncnonktec afof ns ce
ec`onktea`ñk. Ftre vnz ce o`soe h`kåo`ae hnstruatfre hn ces lfr oes hn v`he y rncea`ñk nx`stnktns y su sust`tua`ñk pfr rncea`fkns hnpnkh`nktns hn ce
nafkfoïe dcfjec, y pfr cf tektf sfont`hes e ces es`ontrïes hn pfhnr hnc `opnr`f, e su afktrfc, oek`pucea`ñk, nspnaucea`ñk, nta. Qn trete, teoj`àk, hn
pfhnr elnater e nkfrons
nkfr ons snatfrns hn ce pfjcea`ñk e trevàs hn ce oek`pucea`ñk hn cfs prna`fs hn cfs ec`onktfs, y ut`c`zer nstf afof eonkeze, afof eroe
pfcït`ae. 
582 
Ces pekhno`es 
Ces pekhno`es sn punhnk `kacu`r teoj`àk nk ce aetndfrïe hn dunrre j`fcñd`ae hn jeie `ktnks`heh, pnrf cf qun onifr ces aereatnr`ze ns qun punhnk snr v`r
e dnknrer f aetec`zer ar`s`s hn t`pf oàh`af, sek`ter`f
sek`ter`f,, buoek`ter`f, qun nkoesaerek ce afkqu`ste aep`tec`ste.
Ce cñd`ae hn ces pekhno`es ns afopcnie, ver`ejcn, ofhucer, ouct`h`onks`fkec, nk pnroeknktn nvfcua`ñk. Cfs v`r us jàc`afs sfk frdek`sofs
v`r us nx`stnktns. Qfk, ftre vnz, ofkstrufs afopunstfs hn lredonktfs hn
dnkàt`aeonktn ofh`l`aehfs h`snõehfs nk cejfretfr`fs o`c`terns e per t`r hn v`rus
ftrfs v`rus, hn ce o`soe oeknre qun cfs Ekt`dufs arnejek sus qu`onres. Nsteofs ftre vnz nk ce cñd`ae hn ce oek`pucea`ñk hn ce rnec`heh e pert`r hn
l`aa`fkns, qun e su vnz sfk afkvnrt`hes nk rnec`heh
rne c`heh y prnsnktehes ektn nc pùjc`af afof lnkñonkfs keturecns f nspfktåknfs, kf nxnktfs hn uke a`nrte

h`onks`ñk oec`dke,
`kvnst`hes nk nc snkt`hf
hn tfhf nc pfhnroåsafkted`fsf,
sfjrnketurec y oås rnc`d`fsf epfaecïpt`af
oecàl`af, hnc tàro`kf. ]unsqun
nk nlnatf nstes qu`onres
ce treh`a`ñk o`arfsañp`aes
rnc`d`fse nståk
vnïe nk cfs ofkstrufs y
nk ces pcedes. Ftre vnz cfs sear`l`a`fs y su afkiurea`ñk afof vnbïaucfs hn hfo`k`f aep`tec`ste. 
4<
 

Cf bej`tuec ns qun cfs v`rus treksdàk`afs snek ofh`l`aea`fkns f afoj`kea`fkns hn v`r us afoukns nx`stnktns
nx`stnktns.. ]frqun uke hn ces nstretnd`es pnrvnrses
ut`c`zehes, afof be ofstrehf Ifk Zeppfpfrt, ns qun cfs v`rus jàc`afs sn afklukhek afk cfs v`rus hn cfs qun sn afopfknk, hn oeknre qun punhek snr
ut`c`zehfs lreuhucnkteonktn pere hnarnter ce pekhno`e hnc v`rus treksdàk`af. Esï, punhnk arnersn e pert`r hn v`rus hn nklnronhehns ouy nxtnkh`hes
nktrn ces pfjcea`fkns pnr`làr`aes, sfjrn tfhf hn ces oås hnslevfrna`hes, y qun hn bnabf sfk v`r us qun ye aeusek nstrednstredfs
fs s`dk`l`aet`vfs ektns hn ce
fpnrea`ñk. Ns nc aesf hn ces hnkfo`kehes nklnronhehns hn ce pfjrnze, afof ce tujnraucfs`s, ce oecer`e, nc añcnre, nc hnkdun y ftres, esfa`ehes e ce
nxpcftea`ñk `khustr`ec, e ce afkteo`kea`ñk, e ce hnskutr`a`ñk, e ce lecte hn b`d`nkn, nta. Ce acevn ns qun cfs sïktfoes hn cfs v`rus jàc`afs snek ouy
perna`hfs e cfs hn nstes nklnronhehns, cf qun pnro`tn,
pnr o`tn, drea`es e ce ut`c`zea`ñk hn oàtfhfs hn h`edkñst`af ouy cexfs f lreuhucnktfs, beanr peser pfr nc
 v`rus jàc`af nk aunst`ñk tfhf uk afkiuktf hn sïktfoes s`o`cerns.
s`o`cerns. Nk ftres pecejres, pfhnr dnknrer ert`l`a`econktn uke pekhno`e, afoj`kekhf y
ofhucekhf h`lnrnktns leatfrns, nk luka`ñk hn ces a`rauksteka`es.
a`rauksteka`es. Nk nc cïo`tn, afof `kh`ae Zeppfpfrt, s`k qun k` s`qu`nre sne knanser`f nc v`r us nk
aunst`ñk.
Ces pekhno`es sn afkv`nrtnk esï nk uke fpfrtuk`heh pere dnknrer uke ar`s`s cfaec, hnarnter nstehfs hn nonrdnka`e, nkv`er pnrsfkec sek`ter`f, oàh`af,
buoek`ter`f f o`c`ter7 nk hnl`k`t`ve, prfvfaer uk nstehf hn «sbfag· dnknrec`zehf qun lea`c`tn cfs pcekns hn hfo` 

5>=  
kea`ñk `opnr`ecns. ]nrf teoj`àk punhnk snrv`r hn fpfrtuk`heh f hn afrt`ke hn buof pere nxpnr`onktfs hn ce `khustr`e leroeaàut`ae f hnc
edrfkndfa`f, f pere nkoesaerer cfs heõfs afcetnrecns prfvfaehfs pfr ces afrpfrea`fkns `opnr`ecns.
Ces veaukes sfk pertn `ktndrektn hn nstes dunrres j`fcñd`aes hn jeie `ktnks`heh. Ces veaukes nk dnknrec prfhuank kuonrfsfs heõfs afcetnrecns, `kacusf
nk ce pfjcea`ñk seke hn cfs peïsns anktrecns. Ce cñd`ae hn ce veauke kfs ccnve hn kunvf e cf qun bnofs h`abf sfjrn cfs treksdàk`afs y sfjrn nc s`stnoe
hn dunrre nk dnknrec. Qfk, pfr hnl`k`a`ñk, uke edrns`ñk pere ce j`fcfdïe buoeke, qun punhnk afktnknr, kf sfcf cfs v`rus etnkuehfs f ounrtfs afktre
cfs qun sn prntnkhn `kouk`zer, s`kf ehnoås tfhe uke snr`n hn ehyuvektns tñx`afs y afkteo`kektns, ontecns, ftrfs v`rus f jeatnr`es, lredonktfs
frdåk`afs, nta., nk ouabes faes`fkns `kafktrfcehfs f hnsafkfa`hfs. Hn ebï qun, e onkuhf, `kacusf nktrn ce pfjcea`ñk seke, ces veaukes prfhuzaek
nlnatfs snaukher`fs hn tfhf t`pf, `kacu`he ce ounrtn7 aesfs qun sfk fpfrtukeonktn s`cnka`ehfs pfr nc eperetf hn hns`klfroea`ñk
hns`klfroea`ñ k hnc `opnr`f.
Nk nc aesf hn
h n ces pfjcea`fkns nopfjrna`hes y hnskutr`hes, nk nktfrkfs afkteo`kehfs pfr ce `khustr`e, bej`-tueconktn nk peïsns pnr`làr`afs, nc s`stnoe
`kouk`ter`f kf rns`stn cfs nlnatfs hn nstes veaukes y sus heõfs afcetnrecns sn ouct`pc`aek. Hn oeknre qun, ehnoås hn nstfs nlnatfs afcetnrecns, ce
 veauke punhn prfvfaer prna`seonktn
prna`seonktn ce nklnronheh afktre ce qun prntnkhn `kouk`zer.
`kouk`zer. Esï, ces veaukes sn suoek
suoek e cfs nlnatfs hnstruat`vfs hn cfs v`rus
jàc`afs7 lfroek afk nccfs uk s`stnoe ùk`af. 
44

 Ehnoås, cfs v`rus jàc`afs y cfs prfdreoes


prfdreoes hn veaukea`ñk nståk s`nkhf ut`c
ut`c`zehfs,
`zehfs, hn oeknre oås f onkfs
onkfs `ktnka`fkehe, nk prfdreoes nudnkàs`afs
nkauj`nrtfs9 ekt`-lnrt`c`zektns, nspnro`a`hes, ejfrt`vfs, `kacusf afk afopfknktns qun h`sar`o`kek rea`econktn e ces vïat`oes. Ns nc onaek`sof
sear`l`a`ec fpnrekhf e k`vnc o`arfsañp`af, cfs ektïdnkfs afkvnrt`hfs nk lekåt`afs hn ce purnze rea`ec y rnc`d`fse afof nk ftres àpfaes cf lunrfk cfs
bfojrns. Zea`sof
 Zea`sof j`ftnakfcñd`af leroeaàut`af. 
j`ftnakfcñd`af y leroeaàut`af.
]nrf `ks`st`ofs,
`ks`st`ofs, ces pekhno`es sn `ksar`jnk nk ce cñd`ae ofhucer hn ce dunr
dunrrere tftec. Cf qun beank ns `opcnonkter uk s`stnoe hn afktrfc pfjcea`fkec
qun, ektn hntnro`kehes a`rauksteka`es, punhn `ktnks`l`aersn beste afkvnrt`rsn nk uk s`stnoe hn knutrec`zea`ñk tftec hn ce pfjcea`ñk, s`o`cer e uk nstehf
hn nxanpa`ñk, pnrf ut`c`zekhf pnrsfkec oàh`af y sek`ter`f nk cuder hn pfc`a`ec, bfsp`tecns nk cuder hn aårancns y aeopfs hn afkanktrea`ñk, `kynaa`fkns
nk cuder hn eroes. ^k tftec`ter`sof hn afrtn a`nktïl`af-oàh`af,
a`nktïl`af-oàh`af, ouabf oås nlnat`vf y esàpt`af qun nc hn ces pfc`aïes
snarntes y ces tfrtures. 
Nc ac`oe hn nxanpa`fkec`heh qun rfhne e ces ar`s`s pekhào`aes jnknl`a`e nk dnknrec e ces leroeaàut`aes, ec levfrnanr ce cex`tuh hn cfs prftfafcfs hn
eprfjea`ñk hn onh`aeonktfs, ec her sec`he e sus nxanhnktns, afof suanhn nk nc aesf hnc eroeonktf, puns nk hnl`k`t`ve sn trete teoj`àk hn eroes.
Drea`es e ces s`tuea`fkns hn nonrdnka`e, ec «sbfag· sfa`ec, cfs prftfafcfs hn sndur`heh hn ces veaukes sn rnceiek, ces afopeõïes sn c`jnrek hn su
rnspfksej`c`heh, sn evekze nk ce `opcnonktea`ñk hn onaek`sofs hn afktrfc oås jnknl`a`fsfs pere ces 
5>: 
afrpfrea`fkns y onkfs sndurfs pere cfs a`uhehekfs, sn s`nktek ces jesns hnc afktrfc pfjcea`fkec tftec e trevàs hn ce l`aa`ñk oàh`ae.
Nk ces pekhno`es sn fjsnrve teoj`àk añof nstn t`pf nspnaïl`af hn ar`s`s s`rvn e ednkhes
ed nkhes h`lnrnktns y e h`st`ktfs k`vncns.
k`vncns. Nk nstn aesf, ce perekf`e hnc
afkted`f, qun cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk sn nkaerdek hn hreoet`zer, afktr`juyn e ce hnofk`zea`ñk hn ce `ko`drea`ñk, e cfs afklc`atfs
a fklc`atfs rea`ecns, e uk
oeyfr afktrfc hn lrfktnres, ec nkhurna`o`nktf hn ces cnyns hn nxtrekinrïe, e ce fjc`detfr`nheh hn ces veaukes, nta. @ks`st`ofs
@ks`st`ofs nk ce h`onks`ñk
ouct`h`onks`fkec, ofhucer, prfdrns`ve, afopcnonkter`e, hn nstes ar`s`s. Afof nk ftrfs t`pfs hn ar`s`s, ces pekhno`es sn `ksar`jnk nk uke cñd`ae hn
afkt`ku`heh qun sn ve eheptekhf e ces a`rauksteka`es pert`aucerns, e ces rnspunstes hn cfs a`uhehekfs, qun sn ve nkseyekhf nk h`st`ktfs nsanker`fs, qun
 ve `opcnonktåkhfsn nk cfs åoj`tfs
åoj`tfs cnd`scet`vf
cnd`scet`vf,, rnduce-tfr`f, hn prftfafcfs oàh`afs
oàh`afs y sek`ter`fs, hn eprfjea`ñk hn onh`aeonktfs,
onh`aeonktfs, nta.
nta. Qn trete nk
hnl`k`t`ve hn uke tnakfcfdïe jàc`ae, qun, afof sejnofs, hnjn snr pnroeknktnonktn hnserrfccehe, tnstehe, onifrehe, auyfs nxanhnktns hnjnk nkafktrer
sec`he pere l`keka`er kunvfs evekans, auyf pnrsfkec hnjn nktrnkersn afk rnducer`heh, qun hnjn nster s`noprn prnperehe pere nklrnkter f prfvfaer
kunves ar`s`s, qun hnjn snrv`r afof eonkeze `ko`knktn nk tfhf ofonktf.
^ke pekhno`e afkarnte punhn, pfr ninopcf, lea`c`ter ce `opcektea`ñk hn jesns o`c`terns hnc `opnr`f nk uk årne afkarnte. ]nrf ehnoås afktr`juyn, iuktf
afk ftres ar`s`s hn uk t`pf f hn ftrf, e evekzer nk ce afksnaua`ñk 
42
 

hn ftres ednkhes hn onh`f y cerdf pcezf, hn ecaekan oås dcfjec. Esï, ces pekhno`es afktr`juynk nk dnknrec ec ehfatr`keo`nktf hn ce pfjcea`ñk nk cf
qun rnspnate e ces veaukes y e prfdreoes hn veaukea`ñk fjc`detfr`fs, cf qun e su vnz ejrn ce pfs`j`c`heh hnc afktrfc oes`vf hn ce pfjcea`ñk, hn ce
`opcektea`ñk fjc`detfr`e hn h`spfs`t`vfs j`foàtr`afs, nta.
]fr ùct`of, teoj`àk ces pekhno`es, afof bnofs evekzehf, sn `ksar`jnk nk uke cñd`ae `kbnrnktnonktn sear`l`a`ec y rnc`d`fse. Xfhe ce np`hno`e v`nkn
rfhnehe hnc eure hn ce oech`a`ñk h`v`ke. Znafrhnofs
Znafrhnofs,, s`k `r oås cnifs, ces pnstns jïjc`aes. Nc ac`oe sfa`ec hn o`nhf e snr afkted`ehf pfr nstn oec
uj`auf ejfke nc tnrrnkf pere qun kunvfs seanrhftns-sek`ter`fs, vnst`hfs afk kunvfs treins anrnofk`ecns hn sndur`heh, ancnjrnk ce c`turd`e hn ce
snperea`ñk y ce hns`dkea`ñk hn ces vïat`oes, e ces qun keh`n fserå eanraersn sf pnke hn bnrniïe. 
5>8 
Ce dunrre oàh`ae 
Afof vnk`ofs h`a`nkhf, ce a`nka`e, ce tnakfcfdïe y ce onh`a`ke fl`a`ecns, sn `ksar`jnk nk ce cñd`ae jàc`ae. Cfs v`rus y ces veaukes jàc`afs kf sfk oås qun
ce vekduerh`e hnc snatfr, nc tnrrnkf
tnr rnkf pr`v`cnd`ehf hn nxpnr`onktea`ñk nk nc qun ces afkh`a`fkns hn nxanpa`ñk beank pfs`jcns nkseyfs qun ces cnd`scea`fkns
afoukns prfb`jnk. @ks`st`ofs nk qun ce a`nka`e, ce tnakfcfdïe, ce onh`a`ke kf sfk k` junkes k` oeces k` knutrecns, s`kf
sear`l`a`ecns, y qun ce `kvnst`dea`ñk hn pukte ns iusteonktn uke sunrtn hn r`tuec sear`l`a`ec auyes vïat`oes
 prfp`a`ek nc «prfdrnsf·
«prfdrnsf· hnc sejnr.
sejnr. 
Ce onh`a`ke faa`hnktec fl`a`ec sn jese nk nc pereh`doe hn ce dunrre. Nk afktre hnc snkt`hf afoùk hn o`cnk`fs hn a`v`c`zea`ñk, nc s`stnoe aep`tec`ste
lfonkte ce nklnronheh y ce hnpnkhnka`e
hn pnkhnka`e hn cfs pea`nktns hn cfs oàh`afs, pfrqun ce onh`a`ke kf hnie hn snr uk s`stnoe hn afktrfc sfa`ec y hn
eho`k`strea`ñk afktrfcehe hn ounrtn. Jeif ce eper`nka`e hn ce aurea`ñk, cf qun nc s`stnoe oàh`af y leroeaàut`af
ler oeaàut`af aep`tec`ste pnrs`dunk ns beanr e cfs
pea`nktns hnpnkh`nktns hn ces hrfdes y suo`sfs ec s`stnoe eutfr`ter`f oàh`af, esï afof, hn oeknre nkauj`nrte, prfvfaer nlnatfs snaukher`fs 
40

 nulno`sof pere heõfs afcetnrecns hn dunrre ‘  qun


 ‘  nulno`sof  qun bedek, hn cfs a`uhehekfs, nklnrofs e pnrpntu`heh hnc s`stnoe y lunktn hn `kdrnsfs
pnroeknktn. Nc treslfk-hf jàc`af hn ce onh`a`ke fl`a`ec sn punhn eprna`er s` afks`hnreofs qun nste sn jese nk nc eetequn,
tequn, nc afrtn, ce nxt`rpea`ñk, ce
qunoe, ce tfx`a`heh, ce reh`ea`ñk. ^k pfhnrfsf eperetf hn prfpedekhe y hn sfjfrkf oås f onkfs nxpcïa`tf e cfs `kvnst`dehfrns, e cfs oàh`afs y e ces
eutfr`hehns, esï afof uk sut`c nktreoehf hn afeaa`fkns afoùk e ftrfs snatfrns, sn nkaerde hn cnd`t`oer nste ofhec`heh edrns`ve hn onh`a`ke y hn
hnsearnh`ter, oerd`kec`zer, hnofk`zer, anksurer, y nk cfs aesfs oås nxtrnofs, nc`o`ker, lfroes hn onh`a`ke ectnrket`ves. Afof bnofs v`stf nk nc aesf
hn cfs treksdàk`afs, ce ekecfdïe nktrn ce dunrre y ce onh`a`ke kf ns uke ontålfre. Ce onh`a`ke faa`hnktec aep`tec`ste ns uke dunrre hn jeie `ktnks`heh qun
nc `opnr`f c`jre afktre tfhfs. Xeopfaf ns uke aesuec`heh qun sne prna`seonktn
prna`seonktn nk nc afktnxtf hn s`tuea`fkns hn dunrre nk ces qun ce onh`a`ke hnc
`opnr`f punhn beanr sus oeyfrns evekans7 nk nstes s`tuea`fkns h`spfkn hn pfjcea`fkns oås hnsprftnd`hes pere ut`c`zerces afof afjeyes buoekes.
Afof nk ftrfs snatfrns, cfs nxpnr`onktfs hn Ifsnl Onkdncn nk cfs aeopfs hn afkanktrea`ñk kez`s kfs flrnank nc pereh`doe hn añof luka`fke ce
onh`a`ke nk nc kez`aep`tec`sof hn bfy.
Nk nstn afktnxtf pernan afbnrnktn qun ce nutekes`e t`nkhe e nxtnkhnrsn y cndec`zersn prfdrns`veonktn. Kf pernan uke aesuec`heh qun ce eanptea`ñk
sfa`ec hn ce nutekes`e sn prfhuzae ec o`sof t`nopf qun nc aep`tec sn eprfp`e aehe vnz oås hn ce secuh pùjc`ae, y  
2= 
cfs sndurfs oàh`afs sn jnknl`a`ek hn aetec`zer ert`l`a`econktn ce ounrtn. Nk nc lfkhf sn trete hn ce o`soe cñd`ae qun r`dn nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk9
hnsnkaehnker `ktnka`fkeheonktn uke ar`s`s cetnktn, jnknl`a`åkhfsn hn nccf, y bea`nkhf rnspfksejcn ec `kh`v`huf, qun nk nstn aesf ns, ec o`sof t`nopf,
 vïat`oe y vnrhudf.
Q`, afof bnofs v`stf, uke hn ces l`aa`fkns oås pfhnrfses hnc s`stnoe ns ce hn ce c`jnrteh `kh`v`huec, pernan cñd`af qun nste t`nkhe e ce c`jnrteh pfr
nxancnka`e hnc `kh`v`huf9 ce hn hersn ce ounrtn. ]nrf, nk nc afcof hn ce hnpnkhnka`e hnc pfhnr, nc suintf sfcf punhn beanrcf s` ns nc s`stnoe oàh`af
qu`nk sn ce eho`k`stre. Ce auco`kea`ñk hn ce c`jnrteh hnc `kh`v`huf, qun ns hersn ce ounrtn, af`ka`hn esï afk nc ofonktf nk qun nc s`stnoe oàh`af
aep`tec`ste sn qu`te ce aernte y ounstre su vnrhehnrf rfstrf afof h`spfs`t`vf hn eho`k`strea`ñk hn ounrtn. ]nrf nc s`stnoe kfs vnkhnrå ce nutekes`e
afof uk «evekan· nk ces «c`jnrtehns·. Afof tfhes ces «c`jnrtehns· hnc Nstehf jurduàs aep`tec`ste9 tn afkanhnofs «c`jnrteh· pere h`slruter s` beans
sulr`r cf qun hnjns, tn afkanhnofs «c`jnrteh· pere afksuo`r s` tn sear`l`aes cf qun hnjns, tn afkanhnofs «c`jnrteh· pere oeter s` tn hnies oeter tec
afof hnjns. P afof prno`f l`kec e ce suo`s`ñk ec s`stnoe hn ounrtn, tn afkanhnofs uk oetnofs, c`jnrekhf esï
ukee ùct`oe c`jnrteh9 pnh`rkfs qun tn oetnofs,
hn tfhe aucpe ec s`stnoe. Ce c`jnrteh hn pnro`t`r qun nc s`stnoe kfs hn ounrtn nkaujrn ce afjerhïe qun knans`te nc s`stnoe hn sus sfont`hfs, ce lecte hn
 vecnktïe pere her ce v`he pfr ecdf. ]fr nsf ce afktrel`dure hn ce nutekes`e afktnopfråkne ns ce l`dure hnc tnrrfr`ste. 
5>4
 

Nc prfansf hn eanptea`ñk sfa`ec, ofrec y cndec hn ce nutekes`e sn afrrnspfkhn afk nc hn ce prfdrns`ve hnstruaa`ñk hn cfs vecfrns prnaep`tec`stes y su
sust`tua`ñk pfr vecfrns aep`tec`stes, qun hn bnabf sn rnhuank ec vecfr hn aeoj`f. F s` sn prnl`nrn, nc prfansf nk nc auec ces sfa`nhehns sn qu`tek ce
oåsaere hn ce ofrec ar`st`eke, buoek`ste, treh`a`fkec, y ounstrek nc rfstrf hn ce kf-ofrec aep`tec`ste. 
5>2 
Ce keturecnze l`at`a`e 
Hnspuàs hn tfhf cf qun bnofs h`abf ns nv`hnktn pfr quà pere pe re nc `opnr`f ces ar`s`s `hnecns sfk ces ar`s`s «keturecns·. Ces snquïes, cfs h`cuv`fs, ces
`kukhea`fkns, cfs bureaekns, cfs tnrrnoftfs, cfs tsukeo`s, prfhuank hn lfroe `opnrsfkec, ekñk`oe, iusteonktn cf qun nc s`stnoe aep`tec`ste knans`te
pere nxtnkhnr sus rnhns hn hfo`k`f y afktrfc9 ce hnstruaa`ñk
hnstr uaa`ñk hn ce afkv`vnka`e-c`jrn. Xektf onifr
onifr s` kf sn punhn beanr rnspfksejcn hn ncces oås qun e
ce keturecnze. Nk nlnatf, ce o`soe cñd`ae hn `ktnrvnka`ñk ert`l`a`ec nk s`tuea`fkns hn ar`s`s cetnktns f cervehes qun sn he nk nc aesf hn hnsnstej`c`zea`fkns,
rnvfcua`fkns hn afcfrns f afklc`atfs nk dnknrec, sn epc`ae e ces ar`s`s «keturecns·. Nc `opnr`f h`spfkn bfy hn tnakfcfdïe aepez hn aetec`zer ar`s`s y
aetåstrflns keturecns, hnshn ce ofh`l`aea`ñk hnc ac`oe e cfs tnrrnoftfs. Xfhf nccf sn nkdcfje nk ce hnkfo`kehe ddnf`kdnk`nrïe,
nf`kdnk`nrïe, qun afoprnkhn tàak`aes
afof cfs abnotre`cs («nstnces quïo`aes·7 kf afklukh`r afk afktre`cs f «nstnces hn afkhnksea`ñk·), fkhes y pucsfs ncnatrfoedkàt`afs, s`stnoes
t`pf BEEZ], nta. Hn oeknre qun nc `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk afks`dun afkvnrt`r uke l`aa`ñk nk rnec`heh, pnrf vnkhnrce afof
keturec. 
25

Q`k huhe, nc eroe pnrlnate. Nste ns ce rezñk pfr ce q ^n


^n cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk epnkes bejcek hn nstfs tnoes. Pe sejnofs qun ns prna`seonktn
tfhf cf `opfrtektn, tfhf cf qun nstå pesekhf, tfhf cf qun nstå nk prfansf hn nstejcnanrsn y cndec`zersn cf qun cfs onh`fs anksurek. Cf o`sof sn punhn
hna`r hn ce a`nka`e fl`a`ec.
Hn kunvf ce dunrre ac`oåt`ae y sïso`ae ns ouct`h`-onks`fkec, prfdrns`ve, ofhucejcn. Ejerae tfhfs cfs drehfs hn ce hfo`kea`ñk `opnr`ec, hnshn nc
etequn nkauj`nrtf e lfroes hn prfhuaa`ñk edrïafce y dekehnre treh`a`fkecns pere su afkqu`ste pfr cfs ofkfauct`vfs treksdàk`afs, pesekhf pfr ce
hnsnstej`c`zea`ñk hn drekhns årnes e trevàs hn ce `klcunka`e nk nc onh`f keturec y cfs onh`fs hn sujs`stnka`e, beste ccnder e su ut`c`zea`ñk afoj`kehe nk
nsanker`fs hn dunrre afkvnka`fkec. Esï, ce dunrre ac`oåt`ae-sïso`ae eteae ecdf tek ncnonktec pere ce v`he y ce sujs`stnka`e buoekes afof ns ce
ec`onktea`ñk, ec ectnrer cfs rndïonkns keturecns hn ccuv`es, sfcneo`nktf y tnopnreture, beste ce aetebzea`ñk hn aetåstrflns «keturecns· snvnres afof
snquïes, fces hn aecfr, drek`zehes, bncehes, `kukhea`fkns, tnrrnoftfs, tsukeo`s, nta.
Ces dunrres ac`oåt`aes supfknk pfr cf tektf ce hnstruaa`ñk hn ces lfr oes hn v`he y cfs s`stnoes hn sujs`stnka`e nx`stnktns, cf qun s`nkte ces jesns pere
su trekslfroea`ñk nk drekhns nxpcftea`fkns edrfpnauer`es afktrfcehes pfr nc aep`tec trekskea`fkec. Hn ebï qun hnjnk snr v`kaucehes e ces dunrres
j`fcñd`aes-treksdàk`aes.. Nk nlnatf, cfs frdek`sofs dnkàt`aeonktn ofh`l`aehfs sn h`snõek pere snr rns`stnktns e cfs `kdrnh`nktns tñx`afs 
j`fcñd`aes-treksdàk`aes
5<= 
afktnk`hfs nk cfs abnotre`cs. Nstf s`dk`l`ae, `ks`st`ofs, cfs abnotre`cs nståk s`nkhf teoj`àk ut`c`zehfs, hn ce o`soe oeknre qun suanhn afk cfs
bnrj`a`hes y cfs st`a`hes, afof uke lfroe hn etequn e ces lfroes hn v`he keturecns kf treksdàk`aes. Bea`nkhf pfs`jcn qun cfs auct`vfs treksdàk`afs punhek
`opcektersn eccï hfkhn nste dunrre ac`oåt`ae y j`fcñd`ae be nxtnro`kehf ftres lfroes hn v`he, y afkv`v`r afk nste ccuv`e bfst`c o`nktres nstfs
prfdreoes hn luo`dea`ñk e drek nsaece afkt`kùek.
]fr ftrf cehf ce dunrre ac`oåt`ae prfpfra`fke uke afertehe pnrlnate pere vnkhnr ce lerse hnc aeoj`f
ae oj`f ac`oåt`af, ec o`sof t`nopf qun, nk pertn, cf
prfvfae. Nk nlnatf, ces ofh`l`aea`fkns hnc ac`oe supfknk prfvfaer `ktnka`fkeheonktn fces hn aecfr y snquïes nk a`nrtes zfkes, cf qun ns
oek`pucehf, nsank`l`aehf y hreoet`zehf nk cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk pere beanr arnnr ce l`aa`ñk hnc aeoj`f
afkvnk`nktnonktn oek`pucehf,

ac`oåt`af. ]nrf,
abnotre`cs.  Esï, ec
ceso`sof t`nopf
t`nopf,
oùct`pcns , nc aeoj`f
ectnrea`fkns
ectnrea`fkns hncac`oåt`af
ac`oe quno`sof s`rvn hn nxause
ce dnf`kdnk`nrïe nstå pere iust`l`aer
nstå prfvfaekhf sn ncpunhnk
usf hneabeaer
ce dnf`kdnk`n-rïe, y nkfl`a`ec
e ce kerret`ve pert`aucer,
fl`a` nc hn cfs
ec hnc aeoj`f
ac`oåt`af. Qfjrn tfhf equncces qun supfknk nc «aecnkteo`nktf·. Hn oeknre qun nc aeoj`f ac`oåt`af, ehnoås hn snr uke drek nsank`l`aea`ñk hn cerdf
ecaekan s`rvn afof afrt`ke hn buof pere cfs abnotre`cs. 
 E l`k hn aunktes kf sfcf sn arne ce l`aa`ñk hn qun nc aeoj`f ac`oåt`af nstå aeusehf pfr nc bfojrn7 ehnoås, nste l`aa`ñk sn afkv`nrtn ‘ 
pera`econktn ‘  nkrnec`heh, y ns ut`c`zehe afof eroe onh`åt`ae pere rnlfrzer
r nlfrzer su 
2:
 

l`aa`ñk y evekzer nk ce ednkhe hn ce hfo`kea`ñk dcfjec. Ce cñd`ae ns ce o`soe qun ce qun nsteofs `hnkt`l`aekhf nk ftrfs lrnktns hn dunrre9 uke ednkhe
nkauj`nrte hn hfo`kea`ñk, e trevàs hn tàak`aes trnonkheonktn sfl`st`aehes, afks`dun afkvnrt`r ce l`aa`ñk nk rnec`heh y  vnkhnrkfs nste
rnec`heh afof uke «eonkeze· qun hnoekhe sfcua`fkns qun, e su vnz, pnro`tnk rnec`onkter pnroeknktnonktn nc a`raucf v`a`fsf hn ce eho`k`strea`ñk hn
ounrtn aep`tec`ste.
 P afof bnofs afonktehf pere nc aesf hn ces pekhno`es,
pekhno`es, nste lecse keturec`heh hn o
ouabfs
uabfs hn cfs hnsestrns ««keturecns·
keturecns· afktr`juyn e hfter e nstn
lnkñonkf hn uke pert`aucer h`onks`ñk epfaecïpt`ae, ofrec, pert`auceronktn aere e ce treh`a`ñk iuhnfar`st`eke, afk tfhf nc eperetf hn ce aucpej`c`heh, ce
rnspfksej`c`heh, ce rntr`jua`ñk, ce vnkdekze, nta., qun tek sut`conktn eprfvnabek cfs lersektns hnc aecnkteo`nktf dcfjec. \nrnofs añof tfhf nstf ns
ut`c`zehf nk ftre hn ces l`aa`fkns hnc `opnr`f9 ce oåsaere onh`feoj`nktec. 
5<: 
Cfs onh`fs sear`l`a`ecns 
Ce luka`ñk lukheonktec hn cfs onh`fs hn oeses bfy ns hns`klfroer, anksurer cf `opfrtektn, oek`pucer ce `klfroea`ñk, pnrf teoj`àk prnsnkter
Qndùk O`abnc Abfssuhfvsgy
Abfssuhfvsgy ce prfpedekhe kf sn r`dn ye pfr ce hfatr`ke hn ce hns`klfroea`ñk, s`kf
afof
pfr vnrhehns
cf qun hnkfo`keces onkt`res
«hfatr`ke fl`a`ecns.
`kqu`s`tfr`ec·, qun afks`stn nk ofstrer ej`nrteonktn cfs nxansfs hnc pfhnr, hn Duektåkeof e Eju Dbre`j, hnc
rnafkfa`o`nktf fl`a`ec hn ce tfrture e cfs heõfs afcetnrecns afktre ce pfjcea`ñk a`v`c. Nlnat`veonktn
Nlnat`veonktn uke afse ns faucter ce `klfroea`ñk hnsedrehejcn
hnsedrehe jcn
qun kf sn qu`nrn rnafkfanr pùjc`aeonktn, y ftre ouy h`st`kte ns, kf sfcf rnafkfanrce, s`kf nxb`j`rce nxpcïa`teonktn y afk tfhf cuif hn hnteccns. ^ke ns
uke eat`tuh b`pñar`te y ftre aïk`ae. ^ke hnie lunre hn nsanke
nsanke ecdukfs hn cfs ncnonktfs qun pfhrïek bnr`r ce snks`j`c`heh hnc pùjc`af, y ftre ns
fjsanke. Nk auektf e ce h`st`ka`ñk nktrn ce hfatr`ke hn ce hns`klfroea`ñk
hns`klfr oea`ñk y ce `kqu`s`tfr`ec, arnnofs qun ce hfatr`ke qun bfy r`dn nk ce prfpedekhe
`opnr`ec nstå e aejeccf nktrn eojes, afopertn ecdf hn eojes. Ns hns`klfroehfre n `kqu`s`tfr`ec ec o`sof t`nopf, b`pñar`te y aïk`ae, nsankfdrål`ae y
fjsanke. 
21

Nk nc lfkhf nc onifr aec`l`aet`vf pere cfs onh`fs hn oeses hn bfy ns nc hn onh`fs sear`l`a`ecns. Bnofs tretehf hn ofstrer qun nc hfo`k`f sn
ninran e trevàs hn ce v`fcnka`e y hn su eonkeze, y qun nstf sn nkauehre nk nc hnkfo`kehf onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec f «onaek`sof hnc ab`vf nxp`etfr`f·
(Znkà D`rerh). Ouabes rnc`d`fkns bek d`rehf nk tfrkf e cfs sear`l`a`fs y bek ncejfrehf sfl`st`aehfs r`tuecns sear`l`a`ecns afof h`spfs`t`vfs pfcït`af-
rnc`d`fsfs hn afktrfc sfa`ec y ofrec. ]uns j`nk, cfs onh`fs hn oeses bfy sfk ukf hn cfs åoj`tfs nk cfs qun sn nsank`l`aek cfs r`tuecns sear`l`a`ecns hn ce
rnc`d`ñk aep`tec`ste. P nstfs r`tuecns sfk uk vnbïaucf hn pfhnr lukheonktec, `kh`sfa`ejcn hn ce pfcït`ae, tec afof bfy sn preat`ae, kf hn ce pfcït`ae nk nc
snkt`hf acås`af hnc tàro`kf, qun afof bnofs v`stf ns uk purf tnetrf. Ce hfatr`ke hn ce hns`klfroea`ñk y ce `kqu`s`tfr`ec sn lukhnk nk uk o`sof
onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec qun pfkn nk nsanke hntnro`kehfs ncnonktfs, ec t`nopf qun faucte ftrfs, ftrfs, tfhf nccf hn aere e ce r`tuec`zea`ñk hn ce v`fcnka`e y hn
su eonkeze. Nc rnsuctehf ns qun cfs r`tuecns sear`l`a`ecns qun jfy sn ancnjrek nk cfs onh`fs hn oeses sfk ce vnrs`ñk
afktnopfråkne hn cfs eutfs hn ln hn ekteõf. Hn ebï qun nc tàr o`kf «`kqu`s`tfr`ec· sne tek eanrtehf.
 Eukqun ce cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec
sear`l`a`ec qun sujyean e nstfs r`tuecns onh`åt`afs ns afop
afopcnie,
cnie, sn punhn rnhua`r e uk pr`ka`p`f ouy s`o s`opcn9
pcn9 faucter ce v`fcnka`e
nstruaturec hnc s`stnoe y nkoesaererce onh`ektn ftre v`fcnka`e l`at`a`e, `hnkt`l`aejcn, cfaec`zejcn, e`scejcn, hns`dkejcn afof v`fcnka`e «oece· y/f afof
nsqunoe 
 v`fcnka`e «junke·. Esï, cfs sear`l`a`fs sn punhnk rnhua`r e uk nsqunoe
5<8 
jås`af, afopunstf pfr trns ncnonktfs9 vïat`oes, vnrhudfs y pùjc`af, afk h`st`ktes pfs`j`c`hehns hn `hnkt`l`aea`ñk hnc pùjc`af afk cfs hfs pr`onrfs. E
pert`r hn nstn nsqunoe jås`af sn punhnk her ver`fs t`pfs9
 X`pf E. Nc pùjc`af sn `hnkt`l`ae
`hnkt`l`ae afk ces vïat`oes. Ns nncc aesf hnc 55Q. Cfs tnrrfr`stes sfk hns`dkehf
hns`dkehfss afof «oecfs· y ces vïat`
vïat`oes
oes hn cfs etnktehfs ‘ 
iuktf ec pùjc`af qun sn `hnkt`l`ae afk ncces ‘  afof
 afof «junkfs·. Ce ehvnrtnka`e hn Dnfrdn T T.. Jusb, hïes hnspuàs hn ce drek nsank`l`aea`ñk, hnjn
`ktnrprntersn nk nstn snkt`hf9 «F nstås afk kfsftrfs f nstås afk cfs tnrrfr`stes.· Ehnoås hn snr uk ekuka`f hnc ràd`onk pfc`a`ec qun sn evna`keje.
 X`pf J. Nc pùjc`af
pùjc`af sn `hnkt`l`ae afk cfs vvnrhudfs.
nrhudfs. Ns nc aesf hnc supunst
supunstff esns`ketf hn J`k Cehnk. Ce vïat`oe ns hns`dk
hns`dkehe
ehe afof «oece· y cfs vnrhudfs
 ‘ iuktf
iuktf ec pùjc`af qun afk nccfs sn `hnkt`l`ae ‘  afof
 afof «junkfs·.
 X`pf E + J. Nc pùjc`af
pùjc`af sn h`v`hn nk su `hnkt`l
`hnkt`l`aea`ñk
`aea`ñk nktrn ces vïat`oes y cfs vvnrhudfs.
nrhudfs. Ns nc aesf hn ces supunstes
supunstes hnaep`tea`fkns bfccywffh
bfccywffhnksns
nksns hn
faa`hnktecns pfr y`beh`stes (hnshn edfstf hn :=58). ]ere ukfs sn epc`ae ce lñrouce hnc t`pf E y pere ftrfs ce hnc t`pf J. ]nrf sn trete nk rnec`hehrne c`heh hnc t`pf
dnkàr`af, qun punhn `kac`kersn bea`e cfs hfs t`pfs ektnr`frns. ]nrs`dun
]nrs`dun,, pfr hnl`k`a`ñk, nc afklc`atf sfa`ec, ce reh`aec`zea`ñk hn ces pfstures, nk nc cïo`tn, ce
dunrre a`v`c.
Hn cf qun sn trete ns, afof ye ehncekteofs, hn h`st`kdu`r nktrn uke v`fcnka`e «oece· y uke v`fcnka`e «junke·, pere cnd`t`oer esï ces eaa`fkns v`fcnktes
«junkes· hnc `opnr`f. Bnofs ofstrehf añof ce nstretnd`e 
28
 

hnc pfhnr afks`stn nk hns`dker uk nkno`df y hn nste lfroe


lfr oe iust`l`aer su v`fcnka`e «junke· afof uke rnspunste e ce v`fcnka`e «oece· hn h`abf nkno`df.
]uns j`nk, nste fpnrea`ñk ns nk nsnka`e uke r`tuec`zea`ñk sear`l`a`ec, uke nsank`l`aea`ñk, uke l`aa`ñk afkvnrt`he nk rnec`heh. Nk nc aesf hnc
tnrrfr`sof nste l`aa`ñk ns nv`hnktn, tnk`nkhf nk aunkte qun, nk ce oeyfr pertn hn cfs aesfs, y s`k huhe nk ces drekhns fpnrea `fkns t`pf 55Q, cfs
tnrrfr`stes sfk ec`ehfs nkauj`nrtfs
nkauj`nrtfs hnc pfhnr pere hnsnopnõer nc pepnc hn «oecfs· nk ce l`aa`ñk. ]fhnofs nktnkhnr
nktfkans beste quà puktf nc vnrhehnrf pfhnr, ce vnrhehnre pfcït`ae hnc `opnr`f bfy, bfy, sn sfst`nkn nk nste cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec y l`at`a`e. ]fhnofs nktnkhnr
beste quà puktf iundek cfs onh`fs bfy uk pepnc `ktrïksnaeonktn pfcït`af. Nk nstn snkt`hf bejceofs, teoj`àk, hn `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk. 
]nrf nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec ns ouabf oås afopcnif. Qn jese nk ce trekslnrnka`e hn ce v`fcnka`e sfa`ec, hn ce aucpe, nk ce `hnkt`l`aea`ñk hn cfs
nspnatehfrns afk vïat`oes f afk vnrhudfs, nk ce prfynaa`ñk sfjrn nccfs hn nste v`fcnka`e y nste aucpe, y nk nc onifr hn cfs aesfs, nk uke vnrhehnre
aeters`s sfa`ec. Nc onaek`sof ns tek pfhnrfsf qun eatùe `kacusf s`k qun sneofs afksa`nktns hn nccf, afof be ofstrehf Znkà D`rerh afk drek cua`hnz.
Hn oeknre qun nc r`tuec sear`l`a`ec, ce v`fcnka`e nsank`l`aehe nk cfs onh`fs, hnc etnktehf f hn ce pekhno`e «keturec· hn turkf, luka`fkek nk a`nrte
oeknre afof oåsaeres. ]nrf e uk o`sof t`nopf afof uk afopcnif hn sïojfcfs qun aekec`zek, lfaec`zek, afkanktrek, hnsvïek, sust`tuynk,
nkoesaerek, ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec hnc s`stnoe9 cfs afklc`atfs nktrn
5<<   
r`afs y pfjrns, nktrn earnnhfrns y hnuhfrns, nktrn aep`tec`stes y trejeiehfrns, nktrn jekqunrfs y hnsebua`ehfs, nktrn noprnser`fs y perehfs, nktrn
anktrfs y pnr`lnr`es, nta. Hnspuàs hn tfhf,
tfhf, afof sejnofs, nste v`fcnka`e nstruaturec, e pnser hn snr rnec y etrevnser tfhf nc s`stnoe, nstå beste tec puktf
`kafrpfrehe nk sus onaek`sofs qun kf ns låa`conktn pnranpt`jcn. Afof bnofs ofstrehf, s` nc aep`tec`sof ns nl`aez ns pfrqun sus prfp`fs
onaek`sofs ofknter`fs, l`keka`nrfs, onraekt`cns, l`saecns,
l`saecns, esï afof nc afkiuktf hn h`spfs`t`vfs a`nktïl`afs,
a`nktïl`afs, tnakfcñd`afs, oàh`afs, qun cns hek lfroe,
aekec`zek nk junke onh`he ce v`fcnka`e sfa`ec. Ns hna`r, fpnrek teoj`àk afof onaek`sofs sear`l`a`ecns. ]nrf nc s`stnoe kf ns pnrlnatf y knans`te
rnaurr`r e onaek`sofs eux`c`erns qun aekec`ank cfs nxanhnktns hn v`fcnka`e. Nste ns ce luka`ñk hn cfs r`tuecns sear`l`a`ecns onh`åt`afs, ehnoås hn
nkoesaerer ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec `opcïa`te nk cfs pr`onrfs. Q` nsteofs fjsnrvekhf uk euonktf s`dk`l`aet`vf hn nstn t`pf hn nsank`l`aea`fkns
nsank`l`aea`fkns,, hn
jekhnres lecses, hn snaunstrfs y hnaep`tea`fkns, hn pekhno`es, hn aetåstrflns «keturecns·, ns pfrqun ns iusteonktn nk nc afktnxtf hn ce ar`s`s qun
etrevnseofs auekhf nc s`stnoe oås knans`heh t`nkn hn rnaurr`r e ncces.
Hn oeknre qun cfs onh`fs hn oeses luka`fkek, nk a`nrte oeknre, afof uk afcabñk eofrt`duehfr hn ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec hnc s`stnoe, hnc o`sof
ofhf qun afktr`juynk e aekec`zerce nk ftrfs åoj`tfs oås jnknl`a`fsfs pere ces àc`tns. Cfs onh`fs nkoesaerek y aekec`zek ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec e
trevàs hn cfs r`tuecns sear`l`a`ecns hn cfs qun vnk`ofs bejcekhf. Qn trete, afof 
2>

hna`ofs, hn uk h`spfs`t`vf afk hfs afont`hfs pr`ka`pecns9 nkoesaerer uk t`pf hn v`fcnka`e ‘ ce ce v`fcnka`e rnec, nstruaturec  ‘ 
‘  y
 y nsank`l`aer ftrf t`pf
 ce v`fcnka`e l`at`a`e7 ce v`fcnka`e «junke· y ce v`fcnka`e «oece· ‘  , , pnrf qun ec o`sof t`nopf hnjn snr nk pertn afkvnrt`he nk
hn v`fcnka`e ‘  ce
rnec`heh. Auektf onifr luka`fke nstn onaek`sof, oås v`fcnka`e puhn pnro`t`rsn `klc`d`r nc `opnr`f nk ftrfs peïsns, nk ftrfs punjcfs, nk ftrfs
a`uhehekfs. Nk ce onh`he nk qun ce l`aa`ñk hn qun kfsftrfs sfofs cfs «junkfs· y cfs ftrfs sfk cfs «oecfs· ns arnïhe pfr ce oeyfrïe. Nk ce onh`he
nk qun ces o`kfrïes qun kf sn arnnk ce l`aa`ñk, sfk es`o`cehes e cfs «oecfs·. Nk nstn snkt`hf nc `opnr`f luka`fke bfy afof uke oequ`ker`e tftec`ter`e
trnonkheonktn sfl`st`aehe, nk ce qun ukf hn cfs ncnonktfs acevns ns ce nopet`e hnc nspnatehfr. Afof bek bnabf ftrfs tftec`ter`sofs, pnrf onh`ektn
oàtfhfs ouabf oås ncejfrehfs n uj`aufs. ^t`c`zekhf nc o`sof petbfs hn ce cerde treh`a`ñk sear`l`a`ec, nc o`sof hn ce trednh`e dr`nde, pnrf ebfre
`kafrpfrehf nk nc nspnatåaucf, nk cfs onh`fs, nk ces snr`ns hn tncnv`s`ñk, nk Bfccywffh.
Ce onkt`re ns afksusteka`ec ec s`stnoe. P nste onkt`re ns nk hnl`k`t`ve ce qun sn hnr`ve hnc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec, ce qun faucte ce v`fcnka`e nstruaturec
rnec y nk su cuder nsank`l`ae ces v`fcnka`es sear`l`a`ecns l`at`a`es. Nc 55Q ns bfy ce oehrn hn tfhes ces onkt`res. Ce onkt`re lukhehfre sfjrn ce qun sn
afkstruynk nc rnstf hn onkt`res `opnr`ecns, ce qun hnjn snr rnkfvehe rnduceronktn afof ns bej`tuec nk tfhf ràd`onk sear`l`a`ec y r`tuec. Nc 55Q ns ce
l`aa`ñk lukhea`fkec hn kunstrf t`nopf, ce qun hnl`kn ces «vnrhehns· fl`a`ecns sfjrn ce  
5<2 
qun sn afkstruynk nk cf suans`vf nc rnstf hn l`aa`fkns hn sndukhf frhnk, ce qun iust`l`ae tfhes ces eaa`fkns v`fcnktes «junkes· hnc `opnr`f, ce qun
`opfkn nc afksnksf hfo`kektn qun ns knanser`f esuo`r nk tfhfs cfs åoj`tfs hn ce v`he sfa`ec, ce qun h`st`kdun nktrn eo`dfs y nkno`dfs, nta. Nste
treoe hn l`aa`fkns etrev`nse hn tec oeknre tfhf nc s`stnoe bfy qun ns h`lïa`c kf vnrsn etrepehf pfr ncce. Qfjrn tfhf nk nc aesf hn tnknr ecdùk dreh
drehff hn
rnspfksej`c`heh f hn pfhnr nk nc `opnr`f. Nstn c`jrf ns uk `ktnktf hn rfopnr nse treoe pnr vnrse hn afopc`a`heh afk ces onkt`res hnc pfhnr y hn
dnknrer uke treoe hn rns`stnka`e ectnrket`ve.
Ce `ktnka`ñk ns nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e esfa`er afk nc tnrrfr`sof tfhf cf qun sn fpfkde e ce cñd`ae hfo`kehfre hnc aep`tec. ]ert`auceronktn equncces
pfs`a`fkns, `hnes, `ktncnatuecns,
`ktncnatuecns, onh`fs, qun sn hnh`aek prna`seonktn e hnsofkter nstes onkt`res fl`a`ecns. ]
]ere
ere nccf ce prfpedekhe hhnc
nc `opnr`f sn hnh`ae
e hnsearnh`ter y e hnofk`zer, y aehe vnz oås, e anksurer y e ar`o`kec`zer nstes pfs`a`fkns ectnrket`ves, jeif cfs aec`l`aet`vfs hn kndea`fk`sof, tnfrïes
afksp`ret`ves, afopcf-t`stes,
afopcf-t`stes, afksp`rekf`aes, nta. Ehnoås hn esfa`erces afk nc tnrrfr`sof, ftre hn sus nstretnd`es ns ontnr nk uk o`sof seaf e ekec`stes
n `ktncnatuecns snr`fs, afk tfhf t`pf hn jcfdunrfs, nxtrevedektns, abercetekns n `cuo`kehfs. Xeoj`àk, `kl`ctrer ednktns nkauj`nrtfs hns`klfroehfrns, hn
oeknre qun nc pùjc`af hnsprnvnk`hf tnro`kn pnrh`àkhfsn nk nste iukdce hn `klfroea`ñk y hns`klfroea`ñk, `hnkt`l`qun e ukfs afk ftrfs, y rndrnsn
l`keconktn ec rnh`c hn cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk fl`a`ecns. 
2<
 

 E pert`r hn tfhf cf qun vnk`ofs h`a`nkhf sn punhn


punhn nktnkhnr beste quà puktf cfs onh`fs eatùek bfy afof h`spfs` h`spfs`t`vfs
t`vfs hn ehfatr`keo`nktf.
ehfatr`keo`nktf. Afof
bnofs v`stf, tfhf sn jese nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e nk uk cnoe frwncc`ekf hnc t`pf «Ce eutfr`heh h`an ce vnrheh. Cfs onkt`rfsfs sfk tnrrfr`stes·. Nstf punhn
pernanr nxednrehf pnrf nk rnec`heh nstå `opcïa`tf nk auecqu`nr hnjetn, afkvnrsea`ñk, fp`k`ñk, pfs`a`ñk `ktncnatuec, afopfrteo`nktf,
afopfrteo`nktf, nk tfhfs cfs
åoj`tfs fl`a`ecns hnc s`stnoe.
Q` j`nk ces epfrtea`fkns
epfr tea`fkns hn O`abnc Lfuaeuct sfjrn ce «eketfofpfcït`ae· y ce «j`fpfcït`ae· sfk lukheonktecns, bey qun snõecer qun bfy nc pfhnr
nxpnr`onkte uk rntfrkf e cf sear`l`a`ec. Hn oeknre qun bejrïe qun v`kaucer ce eketfof/j`fpfcït`ae y nc nspnatåaucf sear`l`a`ec, cfs aunrpfs rnecns y su
prfynaa`ñk nk cfs onh`fs, ce kuhe v`he (D`frd`f Edeojnk) y su r`tuec`zea`ñk nk ces pektecces hn j`ts. Nste nstruature es`oàtr`ae ns ce o`soe qun ce
qun sn he nk nc s`stnoe nk su afkiuktf, nktrn nc aep`tec l`keka`nrf y nc prfhuat`vf, nktrn nc aep`tec`ste y nc trejeiehfr, nktrn nc earnnhfr y nc hnuhfr, nktrn
nc h`knrf l`hua`er`f y ce nxtreaa`ñk hn r`qunze rnec. Nk nc snkf hn nste nstruature nc nspnatåaucf sear`l`a`ec prfpfra`fke cfs rfcns hn rnlnrnka`e qun hnjnk
snr noucehfs o`oàt`aeonktn. Nk nstn snkt`hf bey qun nktnkhnr nc ehfatr`keo`nktf hn cfs onh`fs. Kf sñcf ns ehfatr`keo`nktf nk nc h`saursf, teoj`àk
cf ns nk nc afopfrteo`nktf
afopfrteo`nktf.. Nk nstn snkt`hf sn punhn `ktnrprnter nc h`spfs`t`vf sear`l`a`ec onh`åt`af
onh`åt`af,, teoj`àk, nk a`nrtf ofhf, afof uk h`spfs`t`vf
eketfof/j`fpfcït`af,, s` tnknofs nk aunkte beste quà puktf nstn kfs `opfkn, kf sfcf ces «vnrhehns· nk ces qun sn hnjn arnnr, s`kf 
eketfof/j`fpfcït`af
24 
teoj`àk cfs afopfrteo`nktfs kfr oet`vfs, cfs kf sfspnabfsfs.
Nk nc h`spfs`t`vf sear`l`a`ec sn aruzek eojfs rnd`strfs9 nc hnc h`saursf y nc hnc afopfrteo`nktf. Hn oeknre qun, `ks`st`ofs, equï ns hfkhn nstå bfy ce
 vnrhehnre pfcït`ae y kf nk cfs perceonktfs.
perceonktfs. Nk nc h`spfs`t`vf oonh`åt`af
nh`åt`af sear`l`a`ec ns hfkhn sn kfs h`an
h`an añof bey qun afopfrtersn, añof bey ququnn
ofvnrsn, añof bey qun o`rer7 pnrf teoj`àk añof bey qun pnkser, añof bey qun bejcer, quà bey qun hna`r, quà bey qun aeccer, añof sn hnjn hna`r. Nk
hnl`k`t`ve, añof bey qun sfontnrsn e ce nstruature hn hfo`kea`ñk. Cf qun qu`nrn hna`r, ec o`sof t`nopf, añof bey qun `ktndrer nste nstruature, añof
nste hnjn etrevnserkfs, añof hnjnofs sfontnrkfs y añof hnjnofs sfontnr. Hn ce o`soe oeknre qun bey «junkfs· y «oecfs· hnjn
bejnr hfo`kehfrns e hfo`kehfs, pere qun tfhf luka`fkn afof ns hnj`hf. Kf hnjn nx`st`r k`kduke eoj`dónheh. Nk nstf afks`stn, pfr pfknr uk
ninopcf, OestnrAbnl.
Nstn pepnc hn cfs onh`fs afof h`spfs`t`vfs hn ehfatr`keo`nktf hnjn afoprnkhnrsn nk rncea`ñk afk ces ar`s`s. Nk nlnatf, nc `opnr`f bfy nstå bea`nkhf
uk nkfron nslunrzf pere ehfatr`kerkfs nk tàak`aes hn dnst`ñk hn ar`s`s, hn aetåstrflns, hn pekhno`es,
pekhno`es, nta. Nk cfs l`cons hn Bfccywffh, nk ces snr`ns hn
tncnv`s`ñk, nk cfs tncnh`er`fs, kf hnieofs hn vnr pfc`aïes o`c`ter`zehfs nktrekhf pfr ce lunrze nk v`v`nkhes, pnrsfkec oàh`af afk treins hn sndur`heh,
afktrfcns enrfpfrtue-r`fs afk h`spfs`t`vfs hn nsaeknehf, nta. P nk tfhfs cfs aesfs sn kfs hh`an `an cf qun hnjnofs beanr y kf beanr, cf qun hnjnofs
pnkser y kf pnkser, e qu`àk hnjnofs 
545

fjnhnanr y hn qu`àk hnjnofs sfspnaber. Nk hnl`k`t`ve sn trete hn uk nkfr on h`spfs`t`vf hn ehfatr`keo`nktf nk nc qun ce afks`dke lukheonktec ns, hn
kunvf, qun tfhf cf qun ce eutfr`heh h`an ns vnrheh y qun nc qun kf fjnhnzae ns uk nkno`df. Afof vnrnofs ce rnec`heh y ce l`aa`ñk kf sn h`st`kdunk nk
nstn snkt`hf. Ce ar`s`s qun kfs ounstrek nk nc `klfroet`vf hn ce tncnv`s`ñk y ce ar`s`s hn qun vnofs nk nc a`kn t`nkhnk e afklukh`rsn y e
rnec  l`aa`ñk
snrv`r nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e e cf o`sof9 nc ehfatr`keo`nktf nk ces tàak`aes hn dnst`ñk hnc aefs, e prnperer kfs pere ce prñx`oe ar`s`s, e esuo`r qun nc qun
hnselïe ces vnrhehns fl`a`ecns cf pederå
ped erå ouy aerf.
Nk nstn snkt`hf punhn hna`rsn qun cfs onh`fs c`jrek bfy uke dunrre onh`åt`ae y ps`afcñd`ae afktre tfhfs. Kf ns aesuec`heh qun uke junke pertn hn ce
`klfroea`ñk prfvnkde h`rnateonktn hn cfs eperetfs o`c`terns y hn `ktnc`dnka`e hnc `opnr`f, hn sus nojeiehes, hn pnr`fh`stes-ednktns `kl`ctrehfs nk cfs
prfp`fs onh`fs, hn seyek`o, nta., qun ce cñd`ae hn ces fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes, afof vnrnofs, etrev`nsn tfhe ce prfpedekhe. Cfs onh`fs c`jrek uke
dunrre afktre tfhfs pfrqun, afof ^kncn Qeo, hnshn uk pr`ka`p`f tretek hn qun kfs ec`stnofs nk nc jekhf hn ce v`fcnka`e «junke· `opnr`ec, `kacusf
ektns hn qun kfs hnofs aunkte hn qun sn trete hn uke dunrre y nsteofs `opc`aehfs nk ncce. Nstf nstå pesekhf bfy teoj`àk nk ces sfa`nhehns oås
nstejcns, oås evekzehes hn cfs anktrfs. Xek `opfrtektn pere nc `opnr`f ns afkfanr e sus nkno`dfs afof rnacuter e sus ec`ehfs. ]nrf e onh`he qun oås
arït`ae sn vuncvn ce s`tuea`ñk oås sn hnl`knk ces pfstures y oås sn `ktnks`l`ae nste dunrre ps`afcñd`ae qun trete hn knutrec`zer kunstre 
22 
`ktnc`dnka`e, kunstre `ktu`a`ñk, kunstre afoprnks`ñk, kunstre aepea`heh hn h`åcfdf y afkv`vnka`e, kunstre c`jnrteh, y afkvnrt`rkfs nk o`c`tektns
lekåt`afs hn ukf u ftrf jekhf, hn oeknre qun nc `opnr`f sn punhe jnknl`a`er hn h`abf afklc`atf.
Ce dunrre sn c`jre ec
e c o`sof t`nopf nk h`st`ktfs pcekfs y nk h`st`ktfs lrnktns y ukf hn nccfs ns nc onh`åt`af.
onh`åt`af. Ce `ktnrprntea`ñk sear`l`a`ec qun bnofs
hnserrfccehf ounstre beste quà puktf nstfs pcekfs kf sfk oås qun h`lnrnktns h`onks`fkns hn uke o`soe rnec`heh. Afoprnkhnr añof sn v`kaucek
nstfs pcekfs ns ce acevn hn ce rns`stnka`e ec `opnr`f, hn ce afoprnks`ñk hn ftres s`tuea`fkns epernktnonktn einkes, hn ce nopet`e afk nc sulr`o`nktf hn
ftres vïat`oes. Ns nste nopet`e ce qun nc s`stnoe, y nk per
pert`aucer
t`aucer sus r`tuecns onh`åt`afs sear`l`a`ecns, trete hn oek`pucer. Ns nste nopet`e ce qun kfs
pnro`tn rns`st`r, y beanrcf nk afouk`heh, eukqun sne e o`cns hn g`cñontrfs f e s`dcfs hn h`steka`e. Ns nste oek`pucea`ñk hn ce nopet`e ce qun pfkn hn
oek`l`nstf beste quà puktf bfy nc `opnr`f ns `opnr`f hn ce l`aa`ñk.
Afof
qun nståpertn hn nstecfcñd`ae
pesekhf, sear`l`a`ec,
hna`s`vf, uke hnnscesanksurehf.
pfr pr`ka`p`f nstretnd`esEc
ncnonktecns
afktrer`f, hn cfs onh`fs
cf qun ns s`opcnonktn
kfs aunktek cfs onh`fsanksurer ce `klfroea`ñk.
hn oeknre Cf oås `opfrtektn,
nxpcïa`te ns `ksusteka`ec, `r cf
`rrncnvektn,
rncnvektn,
eknahñt`af. Nktrn cf ukf y cf ftrf, nkafktreofs tfhf t`pf hn nstretnd`es hn oek`pucea`ñk, hn `klfroea`ñk sujc`o`kec, hn rnlfrzeo`nktf
rnlfr zeo`nktf `opcïa`tf hn
ces kerret`ves fl`a`ecns, nta. Cfs onh`fs sfk afof ecdukes pnrsfkes9 o`nktnk pfr hnl`k`a`ñk y sfcf sn ces punhn afkfanr tretekhf hn 
541
 

afoprnkhnr cf qun sn nsafkhn hntrås hn sus onkt`res. Afof faurrn afk cfs onkt`rfsfs, arnnr cf qun kfs h`ank cfs onh`fs s`dk`l`ae afkvnrt`rsn nk sus
 vïat`oes. ]frqun
]frqun s` kfs o`nktnk ns pfrqun
pfrqun qu`nrnk ecdf hn kfsftrfs
kfsftrfs..
Ftre nstretnd`e bej`tuec hn cfs onh`fs pere oektnknr ce eper`nka`e hn qun `klfroek ns afkvnrt`r ce prnkse snr`e nk prnkse rfs
rfse.e. Esï, e onkuhf cfs
pnr`ñh`afs prnsnktek e iñvnkns dceourfsfs, `ktnc`dnktns y ouct`o`ccfker`fs, qun bek bnabf su lfrtuke drea`es ec nslunrzf, nc sear`l`a`f y nc nspïr`tu
noprnkhnhfr. Ouabfs hn nccfs nk nc snatfr hn ces tnakfcfdïes h`d`tecns, hn ce rfjñt`ae, hn ce j`ftnakfcfdïe. Cf qun kf kfs aunktek ns qun s` nstfs
iñvnkns bek afksndu`hf tektf àx`tf, s` sus noprnses bek afksndu`hf aft`zer o`ccfkns nk jfcse hn ce kfabn e ce oeõeke, ns e onkuhf pfrqun lfroek
pertn hnc snatfr `khustr`ec-o`c`ter hnc `opnr`f, pfrqun nståk esfa`ehes e prfdreoes nkauj`nrtfs hn ectf k`vnc, pfrqun nståk ec snrv`a`f hn `ktnrnsns qun
kf afkv`nkn hnsvncer pere qun kf sn p`nrhe nc e`rn hn dce-ofur.
dce -ofur. Hn oeknre qun kfs nkafktreofs afk ce o`soe cñd`ae hn ce afrt`ke hn buof onh`åt`ae,
qun nsafkhn ce pnrvnrs`ñk
pnr vnrs`ñk hnc s`stnoe qun seae jnknl`a`f hn ce dunrre. ]nrf nstf kf ns uk s`opcn ninopcf.
ninopcf. H`an ouabf, kf sfcf hn añof luka`fke ce
prfpedekhe hnc s`stnoe bfy, s`kf hn su hfjcn ofrec. Nc onksein hn lfkhf qun hnjn ccnder e ftrfs noprnkhnhfrns ns nc qun nstå nk ce jesn hn ce kf-
ofrec aep`tec`ste9 «Yepetnrf e tus zepetfs. Kf prntnkhes errndcer nc oukhf s`kf hnh`aertn e ecdf
ecd f afkarntf y deker ouabf h`knrf afk nccf. Nc usf qun
ftrfs bedek hn tus `kvnktfs kf ns tu prfjcnoe.· 

20  
Ftrf hn cfs ncnonktfs lukheonktecns hnc `opnr`f bfy ns ce pert`a`pea`ñk. Uun kf ns nk nc lfkhf ftre afse qun per t`a`pea`ñk sear`l`a`ec. Ce
pert`a`pea`ñk ns uke hn ces afertehes lukheonktecns hnc `opnr`f pere su hfo`kea`ñk, pfrqun nk rnec`heh ns uke lecse pert`a`pea`ñk, uke lfroe hhnn
aepter ce nknrdïe pfpucer qun pfhrïe fpfknrsn ec s`stnoe y rnaupnrerce pere qun nc s`stnoe punhe eprfvnabersn hn ncce. Bejcernofs hn ecdukes hn nstes
lfroes hn rnaupnrea`ñk, hn ces qun nc nafcfd`sof ns bfy uke hn ces pr`ka`pecns. ]nrf `kacusf uk lnkñonkf afof ce hnofarea`e punhn snr `ktnrprntehf
bfy nk nstn snkt`hf. Esï, ce hnofarea`e ns ukf hn nstfs h`spfs`t`vfs hn aepture, hn eofrt`duea`ñk, hn rnprns`ñk, hn rnaupnrea`ñk hn ce fpfs`a`ñk ec
s`stnoe. Ftrf ninopcf cf tnknofs nk ces rnhns sfa`ecns. Ce arnnka`e dnknrec ns qun nstes kfs flrnank, hn oeknre dretu`te, uk oukhf hn rncea`fkns,
r nhns sfa`ecns sfk rnhns y sfa`ecns. Cf qun ce oeyfrïe kf afoprnkhn ns qun kf sfk oås qun
hn nxpnr`nka`es, hn nofa`fkns. Ce arnnka`e ns qun ces rnhns
onaek`sofs hn aepture, afkoutehfrns nk cfs qun ce v`he y ces rncea`fkns vnrhehnreonktn sfa`ecns sfk trekslfroehes nk `klfroea`ñk, nk aekt`hehns,
nk hetfs. P ecoeankehes pfr uke `ksteka`e anktrec ‘ f pfr uke snr`n hn `ksteka`es qun fpnrek hn oeknre anktrec`zehe ‘  qun
 qun rno`tn oås e ce nstruature
hn ce p`råo`hn oesñk`ae qun e ce rnh. Esï, kf ns nxtreõf qun rnhns epernktnonktn sfa`ecns afof ce T`g`pnh`e snek hn bnabf onh`fs hn
prfpedekhe anktrec`zehfs nk cfs qun sn oek`puce y anksure ce `klfroea`ñk oås snks`jcn.
Cf qun bey qun nktnkhnr hn ces rnhns sfa`ecns, cf oås `opfrtektn, kf ns tektf qun snek uke `konkse 
54>

lunktn hn jnknl`a`f pere cfs qun ces dnst`fkek, s`kf sfjrn tfhf qun sfk `kstruonktfs hn afktrfc sfa`ec, qun eatùek afof vnbïaucfs hn rnaupnrea`ñk, hn
knutrec`zea`ñk, hn ekucea`ñk hn ce v`he rnec kf aep`tec`ste. Hn ce o`soe oeknre qun nc aep`tec`sof lfrh`ste b`zf hnc trejeif ce lunktn lukheonktec hnc
 vecfr, ebfre nstfs h`spfs`t`vfs
h`spfs`t`vfs trekslfroek ce r`qunze rnec hn ces afo
afouk`hehns,
uk`hehns, kunstre v`he,
v`he, kunstre arnet`v`heh, kunstre `kt`o`heh, ku
kunstrfs
nstrfs hnsnfs, nk
fjintf hn kndfa`f y afktrfc pfcït`af. P ns iusteonktn nk nstn prfansf hn trekslfroea`ñk hfkhn ninrank su pfhnr. P s` punhnk beanrcf ns pfrqun, nk
ùct`oe `ksteka`e, sfk lfroes hn pert`a`pea`ñk sear`l`a`ec. 
0= 
Nc rntfrkf hn ce @kqu`s`a`ñk 
 Pe nk 50<4 nk nc @klfron hn @rfk @rfk Ofukte`k sn sudnrïe qun hnjïek snr cfs «prfhuatfrns hn pncïauces afonra`ecns· qu`nkns hnserrfccerek uk
ofhncf ectnrket`vf ec hn ce dunrre «hn ce o`soe oeknre nk qun cf b`zf ce @kqu`s`a`ñk Nspeõfce y cfs onkfs lfroecns iu`a`fs hn jruies hn ftrfs
t`nopfs, afk nc prfpñs`tf hn cfdrer ce "pur`l`aea`ñk sfa`ec", ce "sndur`heh hnc Nstehf" u ftrfs fjint`vfs qun snek tektf eanptejcns afof arnïjcns pere
ces sfa`nhehns hn ce pfsdunrre·. Bfy nsteofs hn ccnkf nk nstn nsanker`f. Hn ebï qun pfheofs bejcer hn sear`l`a`fs bfccywffhnksns afk
tfhf r`dfr. ]nrf bey qun hnsteaer nc usf hnc tàro`kf «arnïjcn·. Nk ftrf puktf hnc @klfron sn rnafonkheje «ce hntnr o`kea`ñk hn cfs k`vncns oïk`ofs
y ñpt`ofs hn hnstruaa`ñk hn v`he, prfp`nheh y rnaursfs keturecns afof rnqu`s`tf pere cfdrer ce arnh`j`c`heh hn uke eonkeze nxtnrke, cf qun rnsucte
nsnka`ec pere luka`fkns pfcït`aes y oft`vea`fkecns·. Nste ns ce cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec hn ce qun vnk`ofs bejcekhf, e uk t`nopf l`at`a`e y rnec, nk nc snkt`hf nk
qun sn pcekne afof uke l`aa`ñk bfccywffhnksn, pnrf knans`te ninautersn rneconktn pere qun sne «arnïjcn·. 
544
 

Ce cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec kfs pnro`tn nktnkhnr añof fpnre bfy nc `opnr`f, añof nsafkhn su v`fcnka`e nstruaturec y ce nkoesaere onh`ektn uke v`fcnka`e
l`at`a`e qun h`st`kdun knteonktn nktrn «junkfs· y «oecfs·, qun `opfkn afof vnrhehns fl`a`ecns onkt`res lejr`aehes pfr cfs eperetfs hn `ktnc`dnka`e,
hreoet`zehes pfr cfs onh`fs hn prfpedekhe y ce `khustr`e hnc nspnatåaucf.
nspnatåaucf. Xfhes ces jekhnres lecses sn punhnk nktnkhnr hnshn nste cñd`ae. Nk tfhes
ncces pfhnofs rnafkfanr nstfs petrfkns afoukns. Ce o`soe afks`dke hnc ^Q, «f nstås afk kfsftrfs f nstås afk cfs tnrrfr`stes·, nstå teoj`àk prnsnktn
nk ce snr`n hn supunstes hnaep`tea`fkns oeraeheonktn bfccywffhnksns
bfccywffhnksns qun nc drupf tnrrfr`ste
tnr rfr`ste Nstehf @scåo`af be ninautehf rna`nktnonktn (hnshn
 h`st`kdu`r afk tfhe acer`heh ec «junkf· y ec «oecf·. Ce o`soe cñd`ae qun nk nc nscfdek «In su`s
edfstf hn :=58). Nk ncces sn punhn  ‘ y sn hnjn ‘  h`st`kdu`r
Aberc`n·. ^ke vnz oås cf qun sn pnrs`dun ns nc afksnksf hn tfhe ce pfjcea`ñk nk tfrkf e nstes onkt`res lejr`aehes, es`o`cer `opcïa`teonktn afk cfs
tnrrfr`stes e tfhes equncces pfs`a`fkns qun kf eanptek ce kerret`ve fl`a`ec (pnrsnaua`ñk hn Ece`k Qfrec y ftrfs «In kn su`spes Aberc`n·). @kacusf
sn punhn fjsnrver ce o`soe cñd`ae `opcïa`te e k`vnc s`ojñc`af nk nc 55-Q (5 + 5, tfrrn + tfrrn), qun vuncvn e hersn nk nc 55-O nk Oehr`h (:==8), nk
nc 4-4 nk Cfkhrns (:==>), y nk nc 55-O-cc nk Lugusb`oe. Kf pernan uke af`ka`hnka`e qun ces jekhnres lecses oås `opfrtektns hn ces ùct`oes hfs
hàaehes tnkdek tfhes ncces ce ecus`ñk s`ojñc`ae ec «hfjcn ofkstrufsf·, e ce «v`fcnka`e rnaïprfae·, hn cf qun kfs be bejcehf Znkà D`rerh.
D`rerh . ]nrf kf ns
`oprnsa`kh` jcn 
05 
rnaurr`r e ce aåjece pere afoprnkhnr ce cñd`ae `kqu`s`tfr`ec `opnr`ec.
@ks`st`ofs nk qun sn trete hn uke nstretnd`e ouy sfl`st`aehe y ncejfrehe, qun jusae oek`pucer ps`afcñd`aeonktn e ce a`uhehekïe y cnd`t`oer ce ar`o`kec`-
zea`ñk hn auecqu`nr pfs`a`ñk h`s`hnktn, y qun nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e ns uke lfroe hn dunrre onh`åt`ae afktre tfhfs. tf hfs. Esï afof ce `ktnks`l`aea`ñk hn cfs
afklc`atfs sfa`ecns, rea`ecns, rnc`d`fsfs.
rnc`d`fsfs. P pfr supunstf rnlfrzer y cnd`t`oer ce hfo`kea`ñk ae aep`tec`ste
p`tec`ste dcfjec. Nk rnsuonk, afkanj`r uke l`aa`ñk,
afkvnrt`rce nk rnec`heh, y drea`es e ncce, trekslfroer uk nstehf hn afses rrnec
nec nk ce sfa`nheh nk ce h`rnaa`ñk qun cn `ktnrnsn ec `opnr`f, cf qun e su vnz ns
r nec`heh. Xfhf nccf nsafkh`nkhf ce oekf hnc `opnr`f hntrås hn ce nsanke.
afkvnrt`r uke l`aa`ñk nk rnec`heh.
Afof hnaïeofs, ce o`soe nstretnd`e sear`l`a`ec sn punhn fjsnrver nk ce snr`n hn supunstes hnaep`tea`fkns hn a`uhehekfs faa`hnktecns, f hn sus ec`ehfs,
e oekfs hn tnrrfr`stes y`beh`stes. Hn kunvf ce `ktnc`dnka`e hnc `opnr`f sn s`rvn hn uk lnkñonkf nx`stnktn y cf oek`puce afk ttàak`aes àak`aes bfccywffhnksns
nlnat`vf. Esï, afof rnec`heh hn pert`he sn tfoek sear`l`a`fs rnecns, afof cfs qun nståk tnk`nkhf cuder nk nc oeraf hn ces dunrres
pere beanrcf oås nlnat`vf. dunr res
nk @reg y nk Q`r`e, afont`hfs nk pcezes pùjc`aes, drejehfs afk oàtfhfs aesnrfs, afcdehfs nk @ktnrknt, qun ejeraek hnshn cep`he cep`hea`fkns,
a`fkns, c`kabeo`nktfs,
c`kabeo`nktfs,
arua`l`x`fkns, hnsauert`zeo`nktfs, hnaep`tea`fkns,
hnaep`tea`fkns, beste `kd
`kdnstes `ks`st`ofs,, rnecns, ninautehfs pfr cfs prfp`fs
nstes aekïjecns. Qn trete hn sear`l`a`fs, `ks`st`ofs
drupfs tnrrfr`stes, afk uk ectf drehf hn `oprfv`sea`ñk, 
540

nk onh`f hn tuouctfs kuonrfsfs y nxa`tehfs. Kf hnjnofs fcv`her qun ouabfs hn nstfs drupfs d rupfs tnrrfr`stes sfk ec`ehfs nkauj`nrtfs hnc `opnr`f, y qun
nstn t`pf hn eatfs pere etnrrfr`zer e ce pfjcea`ñk cfaec sfk, hn oeknre `opcïa`te f nxpcïa`te, eprfjehfs pfr àc. Qn `ksar`jnk nk ce h`kåo`ae oås dnknrec
hn ce c`op`nze àtk`ae qun, afof bnofs ofstrehf, lfroe pertn hn ce ednkhe nkauj`nrte hnc `opnr`f pere jecaek`zer nstehfs nstretàd`afs. ]nrf cf qun
qunrnofs sujreyer equï ns qun nstfs sear`l`a`fs sfk rnecns,
r necns, nspfktåknfs,
nspfktåknfs, oïk`oeonktn pcek`l`aehfs. Nc prfjcnoe ns qun su nl`aea`e hn aere ec pùjc`af
tncnv`s`vf ns c`o`tehe, nspna`econktn pere uk nspnatehfr qun kf nstà leo`c`er`zehf afk cfs añh`dfs cfaecns, afof ns nc aesf hnc a`uhehekf faa`hnktec.
H`abf hn uke oeknre s`opcn9 kf ns låa`c h`st`kdu`r nktrn nc «junkf· y nc «oecf·, kf ns låa`c `hnkt`l`aersn afk ukf u ftrf, s`kf s`opcnonktn snkt`r uke
snksea`ñk hn rnpudkeka`e dnknrec. Kf ns aesuec`heh qun nstfs sear`l`a`fs kf snek ofstrehfs nk cfs onh`fs hn hns`klfroea`ñk
hns`klfr oea`ñk faa`hnktecns.
Afopårnksn ebfre nstfs sear`l`a`fs rnecns afk ces supunstes hnaep`tea`fkns hn faa`hnktecns pfr y`beh`s-tes qun sï bek tresankh`hf e cfs onh`fs
faa`hnktecns. E pnser hn qun nk nsnka`e sn trete hn cf o`sof, nktrn ukfs y ftrfs bey uke h`lnrnka`e ej`soec e tfhfs cfs k`vncns. Esï, nk nstes ùct`oes
hnaep`tea`fkns sn h`st`kdun afk tfhe acer`heh ec «junkf· hnc «oecf·. Epernank nk nsanke sfcf nstfs hfs pnrsfkeins9 nc supunstf tnrrfr`ste, h`slrezehf
aår ancns 
hn tnrrfr`ste, nkaepuabehf, hn kndrf, eroehf, hn p`n7 y nc supunstf rnbàk faa`hnktec, h`slrezehf hn pr`s`fknrf, afk nc trein kerekie hn ces aårancns
52= 
nstehfuk`hnksns, afk nc pncf repehf, errfh`ccehf.
errfh`ccehf. Nk ftrfs aesfs cfs tnrrfr`stes sfk eatfrns d`dektns y ces vïat`oes eatfrns nkekfs, pere esndurer ce
h`st`ka`ñk y ce nl`aea`e s`ojñc`ae. Nstes supunstes hnaep`tea`fkns suncnk vnk`r prnanh`hes hn onkseins nk cfs qun eojfs pnrsfkeins o`rek e ce aåoere y
sn h`r`dnk h`rnateonktn e Faa`hnktn ‘  «^k «^k onksein e Eoàr`ae·, «^k onksein e cfs ec`ehfs hn Nstehfs ^k`hfs·, nta. ‘  , , nk uk `kdcàs f lrekaàs
pnrlnatfs. Ces pertns oås fjsankes, s` ns qun bek tnk`hf cuder, kf lfroek pertn hnc ofktein pere kf bnr`r ce snks`j`c`heh hnc nspnatehfr. Xf Xfhf
hf nccf sn
ncejfre afk uk drek rnl`keo`nktf hn onh`fs, sn dreje afk ver`es aåoeres, drek aec`heh hn vïhnf y euh`f, ofktein ncejfrehf, afrtns, aeoj`fs hn
aåoere, iundfs hn zffo, nta. Nk suoe9 afk uk nst`cf pnrlnateonktn bfccywffhnksn. Afof kf pfhïe snr hn ftre oeknre, e nstes hnaep`tea`fkns cns
s`dunk `opfrtektns eaa`fkns f `ktnrvnka`fkns
`ktnr vnka`fkns hnc `opnr`f, j`nk sfjrn nc tnrrnkf, f j`nk e k`vnc kea`fkec, onh`hes hn rnprns`ñk pfc`a`ec, lrfktnr`ze, nta.
 Nk iuc`f hn :=5> ukfs
ukfs beagnrs uarek`ekfs
uarek`ekfs pujc`aerfk
pujc`aerfk uke drejea`ñk
drejea`ñk nk ce qun sn vnïe qun ec onkfs
onkfs uke hn nstes
supunstes hnaep`tea`fkns
hnaep`tea`fkns nre uke l`aa`ñk drejehe nk nstuh`f afk tfhe ce sfl`st`aea`ñk hn ces prfhuaa`fkns
bfccywffhnksns. 
Ftrfs petrfkns afoukns kfs flrnank oås `kh`a`fs hn qun sn trete hn jekhnres lecses lejr`aehes pfr nc `opnr`f. Qn ekuka`ek afk ektncea`ñk, pere
oektnknr nk v`cf ec pùjc`af
pùjc`af.. Ces supunstes vïat`oes sfk a`uhehekfs faa`hnktecns f ec`ehfs, hn peïsns `opc`aehfs nk nc afklc`atf, f e cfs qun nc `opnr`f
qu`nrn `opc`aer. Qn prnsnktek afof prflns`fkecns s`k rncea`ñk h`rnate afk 
0:
 

ce dunrre, afof ns ce affpnrea`ñk, nc eat`v`sof, nc pnr`fh`sof lrnncekan, afk cfs qun nc nspnatehfr faa`hnktec onh`f punhn nopet`zer, e cfs qun
punhn `hnkt`l`aer afof «`kfanktns·, afk nc pnrsfkein «junkf·, pfr fpfs`a`ñk ec pnrsfkein «oecf·. Nstå nk iundf equï ce cñd`ae sear`l`a`ec hn ce qun
bnofs bejcehf, ce `hnkt`l`aea`ñk afk nc «junkf·, ce hnofk`zea`ñk hnc «oecf·, ce trekslnrnka`e hn ce aucpe. Nk suoe, ce s`opc`l`aea`ñk l`at`a`e hn tfhe
ce afopcni`heh hnc afklc`atf e ce nsank`l`aea`ñk hn uke v`fcnka`e «oece· ninra`he pfr cfs tnrrfr`stes, qun rnqu`nrn hn ce `ktnr vnka`ñk hn uke v`fcnka`e
«junke· `opnr`ec. Ec o`sof t`nopf qun sn nkoesaere ce v`fcnka`e rnec y nstruaturec hnc s`stnoe, hn sus dunrres hn afkqu`ste y hn ce `ksteurea`ñk hn
nstehfs pfc`a`ecns nk cfs anktrfs.
 Ektnr`fronktn bnofs ofstrehf qun ces ednkhes hnc `opnr`f sfk sfk prfdrns`ves, ofhucerns,
ofhucerns, ouct`h`onk-s`fkecns,
ouct`h`onk-s`fkecns, pera`ecns, snatfr`ecns,
snatfr`ecns, sfcepehes,
ej`nrtes, nta. Nk ftres pecejres, eukqun uke hntnro`kehe jekhnre lecse f uke hntnro`kehe
hntnr o`kehe pekhno`e punhn tnknr uk fjint`vf oås afkarntf, nstes, iuktf
ec rnstf hn nvnktfs, ar`s`s,
ar`s`s, jekhnres lecses u fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes, teoj`àk afktr`juynk e ftre snr`n hn fjint`vfs hn onh`f y cerdf pcezf. Hn ce
o`soe oeknre nc pùjc`af terdnt hn nstes eaa`fkns kf ns ùk`af y e vnans uk o`sof nvnktf punhn nster h`r`d`hf e ver`fs hn nccfs. ]fr ftrf cehf bnofs
 v`stf qun ce h`kåo`ae sear`l`a`ec ns,
ns, pfr su prfp`e nsnka`e, eoj`
eoj`vecnktn.
vecnktn. P esï, nk faes`fkns
faes`fkns cf qun sn jusae prna`seonktn
prna`seonktn ns ce h`v`s`ñk, ce afklrfktea`ñk
sfa`ec. Nk nc aesf hn nstes hnaep`tea`fkns bfccywffhnksns vnofs ecdf hn nste afopcni`heh. Q`rvnk ec o`sof 
01 
t`nopf pere cnd`t`oer ces eaa`fkns `opnr`ecns jàc`aes y pfc`a`ecns ektn nc a`uhehekf faa`hnktec onh`f, pnrf teoj`àk, ec o`sof t`nopf, pere reh`aec`zer e
a`nrtes o`kfrïes, e rnacuter o`nojrfs pere cfs drupfs tnr
tnrrfr`stes.
rfr`stes. Ehnoås, nc o`sof oetnr`ec ns, e su vnz, l`ctrehf, ofktehf, hreoet`zehf, hn h`st`ktes
oeknres pfr cfs onh`fs hn prfpedekhe, sndùk cfs aesfs. Qn suo`k`stre, afof ce afo`he prnperehe, prnafa`kehf, pere qun aehe ukf hn cfs onh`fs hn
turkf cn hà nc tfqun l`kec afk su nst`cf prfp`f.
Nk rnsuonk, nstes fpnrea`fkns kf nståk nxnktes hn uk a`nrtf drehf hn aefs, afof nc afkiuktf hn ce afkqu`ste `opnr`ec, cf qun afktr`juyn nk tfhf aesf
e ce nstretnd`e hn nkoesaereo`nktf qun cf r`dn tfhf. Nk nlnatf, tfhf t`nkn qun pernanr aeñt`af, nspfktåknf, `oprfv`sehf, eutàkt`af,
eutàkt`af, rnec... P sfjrn tfhf
kf t`nkn qun pernanr qun be s`hf au`hehfseonktn h`snõehf nk ce cess ednka`es hn `ktnc`dnka`e hnc `opnr`f, afk fjint`vfs afkarntfs, l`coehf nk nstuh`f afk
bfccywffhnksns. 
cfs ùct`ofs truafs bfccywffhnksns.
521

Ce `ktnc`dnka`e nkoesaerehe 
Nk ce Drna`e Ekt`due, ce ]`tfk`se nre uke hn ces lunktns hn ce «vnrheh·. ]nrf cf a`nrtf ns qun sus rnvncea`fkns hnjïek snr hnsa`lrehes pfr ce aeste
seanrhftec hn Epfcf, nk ces seces sedrehes ‘ snarntes
snarntes  ‘ 
‘  hnc
 hnc sektuer`f hn Hnclfs. Bfy ce «vnrheh· fl`a`ec rnspfkhn e ce o`soe cñd`ae hn
snarnt`sof, e ce o`soe onh`ea`ñk seanrhftec. Cfs eperetfs o`c`ter y hn `ktnc`dnka`e hnc `opnr`f, esï afof tfhe uke afbfrtn acnr`aec hn
a`nktïl`afs, `kvnst`dehfrns,
`kvnst`dehfrns, oàh`afs, `kdnk`nrfs sfa`ecns, ncejfrek afk uk ectf drehf
d rehf hn afkl`hnka`ec`heh ces «vnrhehns· fl`a`ecns qun bek hn rnd`r nk nc
`opnr`f, qun `opfknk sus cnyns, qun `opucsek sus dunrres, qun hns`dkek nc «j`nk· y nc «oec· fl`a`ecns. Ec o`sof t`nopf qun fauctek ancfseonktn tfhf
equnccf qun sn fpfkn e nste l`aa`ñk.
Ns lukheonktec h`st`kdu`r nktrn equnccfs tnoes qun nståk v`vfs y equnccfs qun nståk ounrtfs, nktrn equnccf qun nstå nk prfansf hn ncejfrea`ñk,
hn hna`s`ñk, hn rnec`zea`ñk ‘ l`aa`fkns
l`aa`fkns rnec`zehes ‘   ,, y equnccf qun be pnrh`hf tfhe rncnveka`e, f qun ye nstå sul`a`nktnonktn nstejcna`hf.
nstejcna`hf. Nk ftres
pecejres, nktrn equnccfs tnoes arua`ecns hn ces ednkhes nkauj`nrtes hnc `opnr`f qun 
08
 

nståk nk prfansf hn snr `opunstfs e ce a`uhehekïe, y pfr cf tektf nståk nk nc treslfkhf hn sus fpnrea`fkns hn nkoesaereo`nktf, y equnccfs ftrfs tnoes
qun kf t`nknk k`kduke `opfrteka`e y pfr cf tektf punhnk snr ar`t`aehfs s`k oeyfr tresankhnka`e. P ns qun prna`seonktn pfr kf snr ye rncnvektns, uke
hn ces nstretnd`es hnc `opnr`f ns ut`c`zer nstfs tnoes afof afrt`kes hn buof pere evekzer, hn oeknre nkauj`nrte, `opcïa`te, `kh`rnate, sujc`o`kec, nk cfs
tnoes qun sï sfk rncnvektns. Ar`t`aer pfr ninopcf nc aep`tec`sof nk dnknrec, f ce `khustr`e hnc pntrñcnf, afof afertehe pere dekersn e ce fp`k`ñk pùjc`ae,
pere epernkter prfdrns`sof, y esï vnkhnr ednkhes nkauj`nrtes qun pnrs`dunk ce h`atehure dcfjec. Nstf ns cf qun beank bfy cfs prfpedekh`stes hnc
aeoj`f ac`oåt`af afof nc Acuj hn Zfoe.
]fr ftrf cehf bey qun h`st`kdu`r nktrn ces fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes hn pr`onr frhnk y ces hn sndukhf, tnranr, auertf frhnk. F nk ftres pecejres, nktrn ces
«vnrhehns· ‘ onkt`res
onkt`res  ‘ 
‘   lukheonktecns,
lukheonktecns, qun sfst`nknk tfhe ce kerret`ve fl`a`ec, y ces «vnrhehns· ‘ onkt`res
onkt`res  ‘ 
‘  snaukher`es
 snaukher`es qun ces rfhnek, s`dunk,
rnlunrzek, rnaujrnk, nta. Nste sndukhe h`st`ka`ñk sn sfcepe afk ce pr`onre, hn oeknre qun ces «vnrhehns·-onkt`res hn sndukhf frhnk punhnk snr
ut`c`zehes afof afertehes pere rnlfrzer ces pr`ka`pecns. Nstf cf nsteofs v`nkhf e h`er`f e tfhfs cfs k`vncns
k`vncns.. Nc a`k`sof, pnrf sfjrn tfhf ce b`pfarnsïe,
ns dnknrec`zehe eccï hfkhn bey nc oïk`of hn pfhnr.
Nste nstretnd`e dnknrec punhn snr ut`c`zehe nk h`vnrses ver`ektns, pnrf nk nc lfkhf sn trete hn ce afoj`kea`ñk hn cfs hfs ncnonktfs ektnr`frns9 ce
rncnveka`e hnc 
0> 
tnoe hn aere e ces ednkhes
ed nkhes nk aursf, y nc drehf hn `opfrteka`e hn ces «vnrhehns·-onkt`res nk rncea`ñk afk nc afkiuktf hn ce kerret`ve l`at`a`e. Esï,
 vnofs epernanr nk cfs onh`fs h`lnrnktns
h`lnrnktns nsaåkhecfs y pfcào`aes
pfcào`aes,, rnvncea`fkns hn nx ectfs aerdfs, nx ednktns hn `ktnc`dnka`e f sfpcfkns, hfauonktfs
hfauonktfs
hnsaces`l`aehfs «afoprfontnhfrns·, pujc`aea`fkns
pujc`aea`fkns hn prnst`d`fsfs pnr`fh`stes qun afktreh`ank ces vnrs`fkns fl`a`ecns, nrrfrns f nxansfs hn cfs eper
eperetfs
etfs
hn `ktnc`dnka`e, hnacerea`fkns fl`a`ecns hn lecsf errnpnkt`o`nktf, lecse buo`cheh, lecses h`saucpes, cådr`oes hn afafhr`cf, nta. ]nrf sn trete aes` s`noprn
hn fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes au`hehfseonktn pcek`l`aehes pere, afof hnaïeofs, tnkhnr afrt`kes hn buof qun afk ce eper`nka`e hn pfknr nk aunst`ñk
a`nrtfs ncnonktfs hn ces eaa`fkns `opnr`ecns, nk rnec`heh
r nec`heh rnlunrzek cfs esuktfs oås rncnvektns, cfs oås hna`s`vfs, ces onkt`res lukheonktecns. H`abf hn
uke oeknre ouy s`opcn, hn cf qun sn trete ns hn `opfknr ce cñd`ae hn «ebfre hn cf qun tfae bejcer ns hn nstf·, y her esï pfr eanptehf equnccf qun nstå
`opcïa`tf y hn cf qun kf t`nkn snkt`hf h`saut`r pfrqun hnjn bejnr afklfro`heh dnknrec, pfrqun ns ce jesn sfjrn ce qun sn es`nkte cf qun ns ebfre
pfcào`af u fjintf hn h`saus`ñk. Esï bey qun `ktnrprnter lnkñonkfs epernktnonktn h`vnrsfs afof Duektåkeof, Eju Dbre`j, ce aepture hn J`k Cehnk,
 T`g`cnegs, nc aesf Qkfwhnk,
Qkfwhnk, nta.
Nste cñd`ae rno`tn teoj`àk ec onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec qun bnofs ofstrehf,
ofstrehf, y ns cf qun pnro`tn aec`l`aer e nste hfatr`ke hn prfpedekhe «`kqu`s`tfr`ec·,
Abfssuhfvsgy. Nk nlnatf, nstes fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes kf sfcf s`rvnk pere rnlfrzer 
afof bean O`abnc Abfssuhfvsgy.
524

nc du`ñk l`at`a`f pr`ka`pec, s`kf teoj`àk pere


per e eanpter `opcïa`teonktn cfs oàtfhfs tftec`ter`fs nopcnehfs9 ces hntnka`fkns nxt
nxtrefrh`ker`es,
refrh`ker`es, ces aårancns
snarntes, ce tfrture, cfs hrfkns,
hr fkns, cfs heõfs afcetnrecns, nta. Afof vnrnofs, kf ns uke aesuec`heh qun ces tfrtures hn Eju Dbre`j (pr`ka`p`fs hn :==1)
snek nxtrefrh`ker`eonktn sfl`st`aehes hnshn nc puktf hn v`ste nstàt`af. Nk suoe, s`du`nkhf uke cñd`ae ouy perna`he e ce hn ce @kqu`s`a`ñk f e ce hn ftrfs
rndïonkns tftec`ter`fs b`stñr`afs j`nk afkfa`hfs, nc `opnr`f hn bfy nstå ofstråkhfkfs afk tfhe acer`heh qun v`v`ofs nk tec ràd`onk tftec`ter`f dcfjec,
qun equnccfs qun kf fjnhnank, f qun s`opcnonktn t`nknk ce oece sunrtn hn snr hns`dkehfs «sfspnabfsfs hn tnrrfr`sof· pfr nc Drek @kqu`s`hfr, snråk
epcestehfs s`k p`nheh pfr nc ràd`onk ec oerdnk hn auecqu`nr cndec`heh. Kf sñcf ns esï, s`kf qun kfs cf nståk hniekhf acerf.
Hn kunvf cf sear`l`a`ec y cf l`at`a`f afklcuynk, pfrqun hn bnabf nc onaek`sof sear`l`a`ec, afof bnofs `ktnktehf ofstrer, ns ce jesn hn ce afkstruaa`ñk
hn ce l`aa`ñk7 nk afkarntf hn ce l`aa`ñk ofrec qun sfst`nkn tfhf nc nktreoehf hnc s`stnoe9 ce h`st`ka`ñk nktrn nc «j`nk· y nc «oec·. Xfhes nstes
fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes sfk l`aa`fkns oås f onkfs rnec`zehes. Nc esns`ketf hn J`k Cehnk sn kfs h`an qun ns rnec, pnrf hn bnabf kf tnknofs oås
prunjes qun ce lftf hn leo`c`e hn ces oer`fkntes pfcït`aes pr`ka`pecns y ftrfs ninautfrns nk ce sece hn fpnrea`fkns. ]fr ftrf cehf nc afoekhf
nspna`ec qun supunsteonktn sn nkaerdñ hnc esns`ketf sulr`ñ aesueconktn uk eaa`hnktn eàrnf hn oeknre qun sus `ktndrektns kf punhnk afktrehna`r
ce vnrs`ñk fl`a`ec. Nk suoe, sn trete hn uke l`aa`ñk qun nståk prnsnktåkhfkfs afof uke vnrheh.
 E tfhf nccf bey qun suoer ce vnrs`ñk
vnrs`ñk bfccywffhnk-sn hnc aesfaesf,, Ynrf Herg Xj`rty (:=5:), qun nk nc lfkhf kf hnie hn rnspfkhnr e ce o`soe cñd`ae
l`at`a`e. Lrnktn e ce h`st`ka`ñk acås`ae nktrn rnec`heh y l`aa`ñk vnofs equï, nk nc afkiuktf hn ce fpnrea`ñk supunsteonktn rnec ‘ 
 ‘ ̀`ktndrehe
ktndrehe pfr ce vnrs`ñk
fl`a`ec, h`st`ktes vnrs`fkns y pfcào`aes pnr`fhïst`aes, y ce vnrs`ñk bfccywffhnk-sn ‘ 
 ‘ , uk afopcnif nktreoehf hn rnec`heh y l`aa`ñk, hn vnrheh y onkt`re.
]nrf ns qun nste afklus`ñk ns pertn hn ce nstretnd`e prfpedekhïst`ae, hn ce fpnrea`ñk nkauj`nrte, pfr eat`ve f pfr pes`ve. Cf qun pnrs`dun ns qun,
eukqun tnkdeofs huhes sfjrn ce vnrea`heh hn cfs bnabfs, eukqun, nk ùct`oe `ksteka`e, ce ùk`ae oetnr`ec`zea`ñk sne uke l`aa`ñk bfccywffhnksn, ce
arneofs afof ce «vnrheh· fl`a`ec. ]nrf sfjrn tfhf hn cf qun sn trete, eprfvnabekhf tfhe ce afklus`ñk, ns hn rnlfrzer ces onkt`res pr`ka`pecns9 nc ^Q,
ce rnspfksej`c`heh hn J`k Cehnk (ednktn nkauj`nrtf hn ce A@E) nk cfs etnktehfs, y nk dnknrec ce «Dunrre afktre nc tnrrfr·. Bea`nkhf hn cf
a`rauksteka`ec uke pfcào`ae, sn rnlunrze cf pr`ka`pec, pere cf qun kf sn eho`tn tec pfcào`ae. P ftrf hn cfs afont`hfs hn nstes fpnrea`fkns nkauj`nrtes
ns qun, hnsp`stehfs pfr ce afklus`ñk nsank`l`aehe y ce hreoet`-zea`ñk hn ce `klfroea`ñk, eho`teofs afof knanser`fs cfs oàtfhfs tftec`ter`fs hnc
`opnr`f9 ce `kinrnka`e nk Nstehfs sfjnrekfs, ce tfrture, ces aårancns snarntes, cfs heõfs afcetnrecns hn cfs hrfkns, ces eatuea`fkns ec oerdnk hn ce
cndec`heh `ktnrkea`fkec, ce nxanpa`fkec`heh, ce nauea`ñk sfspnabfsf ? tnrrfr`ste. 
0<

You might also like