Falacias Significancia en Los Sistemas Argumentativos

7$t$h{st{$s I jsR Psjs{$sR t jBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR
G
*$B ] s?
t9 Vj`stIB ps{?
s
pZ}B I yt%R$s{$?
Bt t ytj$t{$s V$h{$sj
*}ss8tB I ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?

Bt
=t$%R$IsI Ws{$Btsj Ij 7Z
V% Vj8 d1xn T wM(((D sY?

s jst{s T ie_= Ny]V VipeWqyWV
qj\3s-U wLx;Dw1dD;xxdnx\xdnE T eT8s$jU \I8s$t{{s{$sio{$AsIZs
VARs{
et jBR }BAj8sR JZ t{ss js ytj$t{$s V$h{$sj wyVD R t{Zts js }T
Rts{$?
Bt PB8sj I I8$tsIBR sR}{BR Ij 8ZtIB sj {B8B js }Rts{$?
Bt I
{BtB{$8$tB k j s9Bts8$tB et j 8ZtIB sj js sZ8ts{$?

Bt R Z$j$9sIs }ss
I$PtR }B}?
BR$BR k t yV Yst R$IB }B}ZRBR %s$BR 8BIjBR PB8sjR 7$t 8AsB
t js sZ8ts{$?
Bt R }BR$Aj Z$j$9s sZ8tBR JZ }s{t %?
sj$IBR }B t jBR {ZsjR
Zt st?
sj$R$R IsjjsIB %js {$sR PsjjsR j?
B${sR eRBR sZ8tBR RBt ItB8$tsIBR PsjsT
{$sR Z{YBR I jBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR }B}ZRBR t js {B8Zt$IsI I js ytj$t{$s
V$h{$sj tB {BtBjst j ZRB I sZ8tBR Psjs{R VjZtsR I RsR Psjs{$sR R?

st jsT
{$BtsIsR {Bt sR}{BR RZA`$%BR Ij IAs 8$tsR JZ BsR RBt $t?
tR{sR I js sZT
8ts{$?
Bt }B jB JZ jBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR IA?
st s}j${s Zt ss8$tB R}{$sj
s RsR Z
? j$8sR et R sAs`B R RZI$s js }BR${$?
Bt JZ sIB}st I$%RBR R$R8sR I
sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$Aj }ss RBj% R }BAj8s
d ytBIZ{{$?
Bt
*tB I jsR ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?

Bt js ytj$t{$s V$h{$sj ss{s t BBR j }BAj8s
I js }Rts{$?
Bt PB8sj I I8$tsIBR sR}{BR }RtR t j 8ZtIB sj =tB I RBR
sR}{BR R h sj s9Bts8$tB k js }Rts{$?

Bt I {BtB{$8$tB }ss jB {Zsj I$%RBR
3$tst{$sIB }s{$sj8t }B js 7{s?

s I ]$t{$s k q?
{t${s =t$%R$IsI Ws{$Btsj Ij 7Z }B js 3ZtT
Is{$? Bt I yt%R$s{$BtR ]$t?

Bt !7*y] k js ]B8$R$? $h{sR I js _{$s I ZtBR V$R
G
{s$B I js ]B8$R$?
Bt I yt%R$s{$BtR ]$t?
h{sR w]y]D
8BIjBR PB8sjR Yst R$IB }B}ZRBR =t 8BIjB Ij s9Bts8$tB Ij Rt$IB {B8?
Zt JZ$
js PB8sj$9s{$?
Bt I }B{I$8$tBR k }$t{$}$BR JZ {ss{$9st }sBtR %?
sj$IBR I $tPt{$s
Ns sZ8ts{$?
Bt Ys R$IB Z$j$9sIs t j 8ZtIB sj }ss I$PtR }B}?
BR$BR t I$PtR
s
?sR k %s$BR 8BIjBR I sZ8ts{$?
Bt Yst R$IB IRsBjjsIBR ItB Ij s
?s I ytj$t{$s
V$h{$sj =tB I RBR 8BIjBR js sZ8ts{$?

Bt As$Aj R h s Zt Z}B }s${Zjs
I }sBtR I s9Bts8$tB IBtI sZ8tBR s Ps%B k t {Bts I Zts }B}BR${$?

Bt RBt
}BIZ{$IBR k %sjZsIBR }ss %$h{s js s{}sA$j$IsI I I${Ys }B}BR${$?

Bt
]ZstIB R $tts {s}Zs sR}{BR I Zt s

?s Ij 8ZtIB sj t Zt R$R8s PB8sj R
IRsAj JZ j PB8sj$R8B tB {s}Z s8A$?

t sJZjjBR }BAj8sR $tYtR s ?
R s
?s VjZtBR
}BAj8sR RBt %$sAjR B P?

s{$jR I IR{ss 8$tsR JZ BBR RBt }s s{$%s Ij 8ZtIB
sj }B jB {Zsj j 8BIjB IA ssjBR {Z$IsIBRs8t
et j {sRB I js sZ8ts{$?
Bt R }BR$Aj JZ R Z$j${t sZ8tBR s}st8t %?
sj$IBR
}B JZ Zts $tR}{{$?

Bt 8sR {{sts %j sjZts Psjjs t RZ {BtRZ{{$?
Bt j?
B${s eRBR sT
Z8tBR R ItB8$tst Psjs{R ej ?

8$tB Psjs{$s R Z$j$9s s8A$?
t }ss P$R s PsjjsR
t j }B{RB JZ BA$ts js -}BR${$?

Bt I sZ8tBR k {BtssZ8tBR IZst Zts sZT
8ts{$?
Bt
*$%RBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

Bt As$Aj Yst R$IB }B}ZRBR *Zt >*=WpnH }B}ZRB
Zt R$R8s sZ8ts$%B tsj IBtI R sARs I jBR {Bt{}BR I sZ8tB k IBs
_s,,t k 7sB >_iVH IRsBjjsBt Zt R$R8s JZ Z$j$9s j jtZs` I js }Bs8s{$?

Bt t
j?
B${s -tI$Is sj $Zsj JZ ps{?
s k 7$8s$ >VpH ?
R Z
? j$8B Ys{$tIB Zts {jss I$R$t{$?
Bt
t jsR Z$j$9sIsR }ss }Rts j {BtB{$8$tB R${B k ts$%B !BR IRsBjjBR
RBA sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$Aj }ZIt t{BtsR t zRb$`, >zieeH BtIst,BqBt$
k BbsjR,$ > !W*n !W*H 3st{R{s qBt$ >!GVEH s zY$` > ViqH k iBtsjI
NBZ$ >N!=yH ej j{B $tRsIB }ZI I$$$R s jBR R$Z$tR RZ%kR t sZ8ts{$?
Bt
As$AjU _s,,t k zRb$`, >_zieeH k ]YRK

t%s sZ$8st k NBZ$ >]NMH
ej RZI$B I jsR Psjs{$sR t js sZ8ts{$?

Bt As$Aj }8$$?
s %$s }B{RBR I s9BtT
s8$tB $t{B{BR JZ tB $t{Zst t jsR 8$R8sR Psjs{$sR Ij 8ZtIB sj * Rs PB8s
sJZjjBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

Bt As$Aj JZ $t{B}Bt Zt ss8$tB I jsR Psjs{$sR
}8$$?
st 8BIjs Zt }B{RB I sZ8ts{$?
Bt R$t BR
ej BA`$%B I R sAs`B R RZI$s j ss8$tB JZ jBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

Bt
As$Aj IAt Is s jsR Psjs{$sR _ss jjB R }Rts?

st I$%RsR Psjs{$sR JZ Yst R$IB {BtBT
{$IsR k RZI$sIsR PZs Ij s

?8A$B I js ytj$t{$s V$h{$sj k jZB R 8BRs?
s j ss8$tB
JZ R IsIB }B sjZtBR I jBR R$R8sR I sZ8s{$?

Bt As$Aj -$RtR s RsR Psjs{$sR
qs8A$?
t R 8BRs?
s sJZjjsR Psjs{$sR JZ tB RBt ssIsR $tI${?
stIBR jBR }BAj8sR JZ jjB
s{ss Bt R$Z$t R tZ8st jsR {ss{?

et js R{{$? $R${sR {B8ZtR s BIBR jBR R$R8sR
I sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$Aj et js R{{$?
Bt n R }Rtst jsR Psjs{$sR k R RsAj{t sJZjjsR
JZ RBt j%stR }ss RBR R$R8sR 3$tsj8t R RZI$st R {sRBR sjR k RZ }BR${$?
Bt
Pt s jsR sZ8ts{$BtR Psjs{R
1 ej8tBR I Zt R$R8s I sZ8ts{$?Bt As$Aj
]B8B PZ?
-}RsIB }B _s,,t t >_zieeH jBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$Aj {Ztst
t tsj {Bt jBR R$Z$tR {$t{B j8tBR sZtJZ sjZtsR %{R $8}j?
{$BRU
T =t jtZs ` j?
B${B RZAks{t Z$j$9sIB }ss }Rts j {BtB{$8$tB
T =ts tB{$?
Bt I sZ8tB
T *ht${$BtR I {Bt4${BR t sZ8tBR
T =t 8{st$R8B I $tPt{$s JZ }8$s RsAj{ R$ Zt sZ8tB R s{}sIB
NBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR RBt tBt{R {BtRZ?

IBR t AsR s Zt jtZs ` j?
B${B k Zts
tB{$?
Bt I {BtR{Zt{$s j?
B${s Iht$tIB sR?
j {Bt{}B I sZ8tB
_B `8}jB }BI?

s Z$j$9sR Zt jtZs` I }$8 BIt B Zt jtZs` 8?
sR R${$%B
{B8B jsR {j?

sZRZjsR I <Bt I js }Bs8s{$?
Bt t j?
B${s Z$j$9stIB j B}sIB I {BtR{Zt{$s
R}{$%B s ht I BAt Zts I$%s{$?

Bt JZ }8$s js {BtRZ{{$?
Bt I sZ8tBR VZtJZ
RBR {Bt{}BR R t{ZsIst {Bt jsR {ss{?

R${sR {Bt%t{$BtsjR I Zt R$R8s j?
B${B jBR
RstR R j8tBR RBt $tYtR s js sZ8ts{$?

Bt As$Aj
Ns tB{$?
Bt I {Bt4${B t sZ8tBR IA RsAj{ {Z?
stIB Zt sZ8tB ss{s B {BtT
sI${ s BB _B `8}jB IBR sZ8tBR Rs?

st t {Bt4${B R$ RZRtst R}{$%s8t
{Bt{jZR$BtR {BtsI${B$sR ej {Bt{}B I {Bt4${B t sZ8tBR tB $t%BjZ{s js {B8T
}ss{$?
Bt t sZ8tBR 7$t 8AsB R$ R }B% sj {$$B I {B8}ss{$?
Bt }ZI tBt{R
Iht$R Zts js{$?

Bt A$ts$s I IBs * Rs PB8s Zt sZ8tB IBs?
s s BB R$ R?
st
t {Bt4${B k j }$8B R 8`B JZ j RZtIB I s{ZIB sj {$$B I {B8}ss{$?

Bt Z$j$9sIB
eR $8}Bst IRs{s JZ js js{$?

Bt I IBs R?
BjB RsAj{ Zts js{$?
Bt I PZ9s t IBR
sZ8tBR t {Bt4${B 7$t 8AsB t j }B{RB I sZ8ts{$?

Bt }ZIt Rs $t%BjZ{sT
IBR 8?
sR I IBR sZ8tBR k js js{$?
Bt I IBs tB sj{st9s?
s }ss I{$I$ js s{}sA$j$IsI
I Zt sZ8tB
Ns s{}sA$j$IsI I jBR sZ8tBR I}tI I js $ts{{$?

Bt I BIBR jBR sZ8tBR
I$R}Bt$AjR sj 8B8tB I js sZ8ts{$?

Bt eR }B R 8B$%B JZ j }B{RB I sZ8ts{$?
Bt
R PB8sj$9sIB t sjZtBR R$R8sR 8I$st Zt st?

sj$R$R I$sj?
{${B 8$tsR JZ t BBR {B8B
Zts I$R}Zs t j }B}Btt I Zts {Bt{jZR$?

Bt k RZ B}Btt
n 3sjs{$sR t js sZ8ts{$?Bt
=t sZ8tB }ZI R Psjs9 }B I$PtR 8B$%BR et Rs R{{$?

Bt R }Rts?
st %s$BR
$}BR I Psjs{$sR NsR }$8sR R ht s sR}{BR RZA`$%BR NsR RZtIsR s}s{t {B8B
{BtR{Zt{$s I Zts 8sjs {BtRZ{{$?

Bt I jBR sZ8tBR
nd 3sjs{$sR I ij%st{$s
e-$Rt Psjs{$sR >VqGe O!N*ei eieV7H JZ R ht s sR}{BR RZA`$%BR Ij IT
As B I js PB8s t JZ jBR sZ8tBR RBt tZt{$sIBR VjZtsR I jjsR R?
st PZ8t
js{$BtsIBR {Bt j {Bt-B I Zts I$R{ZR$?

Bt sj k tB RBt 8skB$s$s8t I tZRB $t?
R
NBR R$Z$tR $}BR I sZ8tBR ItB8$tsIBR Psjs{$sR I j%st{$s $ttst RZRts Zts
{Bt{jZR$?
Bt {Bt sjB 8?
sR JZ js %$It{$s sj
T VZ8tZ8 sI YB8$t8 U sZ8tB IBtI R ss{s j {s?

s{ B js }RBtsj$IsI Ij
B}Btt t jZs I RZ R$R wFZst R j jsI?

Bt }BJZ ks Ys BAsIB {Bt st$B$IsI D
T VZ8tZ8 sI 8$R${BI$s8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s}jstIB s js
}$IsI Ij B}Btt wWB 8 {Zj}t I BAB RZPB 8Z{YB }BJZ t 8$ {sRs tB Ysk
I$tBD
T VZ8tZ8 sI %{ZtI$s8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s}jstIB s Zts
sZB$IsI w*$BR -$R }BJZ yRss{ WbBt {? ? D

s t ej
T VZ8tZ8 sI As{ZjZ8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s s%?

R Ij 8$IB B
js s8ts9s I PZ9swz$% As`B jsR jsR I *$BR B JZ8s?

sR t j $thtBD
T WBt {sZRs }B {sZRs U IBtI R sh8s JZ sjB R js {sZRs I Zt %tB s?
Zt {ZstIB tB
R?
s PYs{$t8t I8BRsIB
T _jZ$Z8 $tBs$BtZ8 U IBtI R }tI Zts R$8}j R}ZRs s Zts }Zts t
sj$IsI {B8}j`s
T i$h{s$Bt U IBtI R {B8 j B I ss Zt {Bt{}B sARs{B {B8B sjB {Bt{B
qBIBR jjBR s}stst R sZ8tBR %?

sj$IBR }B Zts $tR}{{$?
Bt 8?
sR {{sts %js RZR
PsjjsR j?
B${sR et sjZtBR I jjBR js Psjs{$s sI${s t JZ RZjt }Rts }8$RsR JZ sj8t
tB RBt {B{sR t j Rt$IB I JZ tB $tt js{$?

Bt I${s {Bt js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt B A$t s}jst
s sR}{BR JZ R{s}st Ij 8s }$t{$}sj Ij IAs _B `8}jB j R$Z$t sZ8tB
XOB 89{B j sAs`B }BJZ RBk {sj$h{sIBU tB -}$t{$s k sj8t t{T
R$B j I$tB"
R Zt sZ8tB sI 8$R${BI$s8 NsR s9BtR -}ZRsR t ?

j tB RBt s9BtR %?
sj$IsR }ss js
{Bt{jZR$?
BtU t jjsR -$R Zts s}js{$?
Bt s js }$IsI Ij 8}jsIB
ej }BAj8s {Bt Rs {jsR I sZ8tBR R JZ jsR {Bt{jZR$BtR AsRsIsR t jjBR tB R?
st
AsRsIsR t js %IsI Rt$IB {B8?

Zt B j?
B${s R$tB t 8B{$BtR JZ Ps%B{t s sJZjjBR JZ
tZt{$st jBR 8`BR sZ8tBR
et j $ttB I {BtRZ$ Zt 8BIjB PB8sj I Zt sR}{B I js sj$IsI R $8}Bst
t t {Zts tB sRjsIs s I${YB 8BIjB sJZjjBR }BAj8sR w{B8B jsR Psjs{$sRD }RtR t
j 8ZtIB sj
NBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

Bt As$Aj tB IA?
st }Rts sZ8ts{$BtR Psjs{R
]B8B jsR Psjs{$sR 8t{$BtsIsR st$B8t sst {Bt sR}{BR 8B{$BtsjR ?

RsR tB s}sT
{t t js 8skB?
s I jsR PB8sj$9s{$BtR I js sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$Aj }ZR tB }ZIt R
{s}ZsIsR }B j 8BIjB PB8sj
et j {sRB t JZ P{$%s8t j R$R8s {Bt8}jss {B{s8t RBR sR}{BR t js
}Rts{$?
Bt I {BtB{$8$tB AsRs?
s JZ j R$R8s {BtB9{s k %$ js Psjs{$s
n1 3sjs{$sR t js {BtRZ{{$?Bt I Zt sZ8tB
_B BB jsIB sjZtsR Psjs{$sR RBt %IsIs8t $tRstR k tB $tt js{$?
Bt {Bt sR}{BR
RZA`$%BR I js I$R{ZR$?
Bt R$tB {Bt js RZ{Zs k j 4Z`B I js 8$R8s _B `8}jBU
T VZ8tZ8 sI ytBst$s8 U R {ZsjJZ$ sZ8tB JZ ZRs js jsU X 7$ sjB tB }ZI
R }BAsIB $t{B{B tBt{R IA R {$B" B X7$ sjB tB }ZI R }BAsIB {$B
tBt{R IA R $t{B{B"
eR 8BIB I s9Bts8$tB Z$j$9s js sZRt{$s I %$It{$s I js %IsI wB PsjRIsID I Zts
Bt {B8B }ZAs I jB B}ZRB _B `8}jB R$ tB Ysk %$It{$s I %$Is -sR

}B}BR${$?
tBt{R tB -$R eRB R ssIB {B8B Psjs{$s }B 8Z{YBR hj?

BRBPBR }B R 8BIB I s9BtT
s8$tB R j t?
Z{jB I 8Z{YBR R$R8sR I s9Bts8$tB tB 8BtB?
Bt${B *RI R }ZtB I
%$Rs js ts{$?
Bt }B Psjjs t js }Bs8s{$?
Bt t j?
B${s R?
s Zts Psjs{$s I js 8$R8s PB8s JZ
js `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt I sZ8tBR }ZR jBR sZ8tBR R %Zj%t `ZR$h{s{$BtR st js sZRt{$s
I $tPB8s{$?
Bt {BtsI${B$s w8`BR {BtssZ8tBRD
7$t 8AsB tB Ysk tsIs $t{B{B t RBR R$R8sR ks JZ I}tI Ij t$%j I Isjj
{Bt j JZ R ss t j 8ZtIB sj k I jsR Ys8$tsR Z$j$9sIsR t ?

RBR 8BIjBR et jBR
R$R8sR tB 8BtB?
Bt${BR R {B{B s{}s Zts {Bt{jZR$?
Bt {ZsjJZ$s AsRsIs t Zt sZ8tB
sI $tBst$s8 IA$IB s JZ RZ AsR I {BtB{$8$tB tZt{s R {B8}js
NsR Psjs{$sR }$$B }$t{$}$$ wXJZ %sIt jBR Y{YBR"D }Rtst 8skB $t?
R }ss j
st?
sj$R$R I jBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$Aj _ZIt }RtsR I I$PtR PB8sRU
d !P{$tIB {B8B }8$Rs Zts R$8}j Iht${$?

Bt I js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt IRsIs
1 =t sZ8tB {${Zjs 8?
sR {B8}j`B JZ wdD }B JZ %tZsj8t }tI `ZR$h{s
js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt {Bt js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt 8$R8s
=t sZ8tB I R $}B R {BtR$Is {${Zjs ks JZ js {Bt{jZR$?

Bt s R }BAsIs R
Z$j$9s {B8B Zts }8$Rs }ss {BtRZ$ j sZ8tB _B `8}jBU X*$BR -$R }ZR *$BR
Y$9B JZ js $Aj$s PZs R{$s k js $Aj$s sh8s JZ *$BR -$R" VjZtBR sZBR s8A$?
t
{BtB{t Rs Psjs{$s As`B j tB8A I {${ZjZR $t I8BtRstIB Ns sZ8ts{$?

Bt {${Zjs
R RB}tIt8t {B8?
Zt
!sR Psjs{$sR $tRstR RBt jBR VZ8tZ8 tBt RJZ$Z et Rs {jsR I sZ8tBR
js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt R$8}j8t Psjjs {B8B {BtR{Zt{$s I jsR }8$RsR _ZIt s8A$?
t }RtsR
I I$PtR PB8sRU
T V^8$t Y {BtR{Zt U {ZsjJZ$ sZ8tB I js PB8sU 7$ V tBt{R }B jB
stB V
T *tk$t Y st{It U {ZsjJZ$ sZ8tB I js PB8sU 7$ V tBt{R WB V }B jB
stB WB
T yt{BtR$Rt{k U RZRts JZ sh8s{$BtR {Bts$sR B {BtsI${B$sR RBt s8AsR %T
IsIsR
T 7Bjt ]Bt{} U ZRs Zt {Bt{}B }ss ss{s Zt {Bt{}B Ij {Zsj j?

B${s8t I}tI
eR $}B I Psjs{$sR R st {B8? 8$tB Psjs{$s }ss P$R R?

Zt JZ Z$j$9st j ? BjB s ?
RsR
{ZsB PB8sR
ej }$8B R R$8}j8t Zt ZRB $t{B{B I js j?

B${s Ws j st{It RZj R
ZRsIB {B8B `ZR$h{s{$?

Bt I jB {Bts$B I Zts }B}BR${$?
Bt I8$tsIs {ZstIB t sj$IsI
j P{B I I${Ys s{{$?

Bt R R$8}j8t js tB `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt I Rs {Bt{jZR$?
Bt _B `8}jB j
sZ8tB
7$ s?
s 8 s8s tBt{R s?
s R {sRs?
s {Bt8$B
R IBsIB }B j sZ8tB
s?
s tB 8 s8s
}B jB JZ js {Bt{jZR$?

Bt Xs?
s R {sRss {Bt8$B" tB R?
s `ZR$h{sIs eRB tB R$t$h{s JZ
s tB R {sRs?
P{$%s8t s? s {Bt8$B _ZI YsA BsR s9BtR }B jsR {ZsjR s?
s R
{sR {Bt8$B
et jBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR t jBR {ZsjR js IBs I jBR sZ8tBR R s{$%sIs }B
$t{BtR$Rt{$s jBR sZ8tBR JZ R IBst s R$ 8$R8BR RBt sZ8tBR tBtTRJZ$Z }ZR
RBt sZ8tBR JZ }Rtst $t{BtR$Rt{$sR t RZ RZ{Zs qs8A$?

t jBR R$R8sR I sZT
Bt As$Aj RZjt $t{Z$ t Zts sZ8ts{$?

8ts{$? Bt {BtsI${B$s IBtI Zt sZ8tB
R ZRsIB }ss IPtI k ss{s js 8$R8s {Bt{jZR$?

Bt jB {Zsj }ZI %R {B8B Zts PB8s I
Psjs{$s RBjt {Bt{}
; 7$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR k Psjs{$sR
et Rs R{{$?
Bt R RZI$st I$PtR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR -$RtR t PZt{$?
Bt I jsR
Psjs{$sR sZ8ts$%sR s$As 8t{$BtsIsR et j R$Z$t s}ssIB -}stI$8BR j s

?8A$B I
jsR Psjs{$sR tB RBjB s sZ8tBR $tI$%$IZsjR R$tB s8A$?

t sj st?
sj$R$R I$sj?
{${B JZ$IB }ss
`ZR$h{s Zt sZ8tB
Ns 8skB?
s I jsR R$Zs{$BtR Psjs{R Iht$IsR t js R{{$Bt st$B R?
st AsRsIsR t js
RZ{Zs I jBR sZ8tBR 7$t 8AsB RBR {Bt{}BR }ZIt R s}j${sIBR s {ZsjJZ$
IAs {B8}jB tB R?
BjB s sZ8tBR $tI$%$IZsjR ]ZsjJZ$ }B{RB I `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt $t%BjZ{s
js {B8}ss{$?
Bt I sZ8tBR k {BtssZ8tBR *${YB }B{RB }ZI R %$RB {B8B Zts
I$R{ZR$?
Bt t Zt }B}Btt I Zts {Bt{jZR$?
Bt g k RZ B}Btt NBR sZ8tBR Ij }B}BT
tt RBt js }BR$Aj -}j${s{$?

Bt }ss js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt g 8$tsR JZ jBR sZ8tBR I B}Btt
RBt js }BR$Aj -}j${s{$?

Bt }ss js ts{$?
Bt I g * Rs PB8s sjZtsR Psjs{$sR }ZIt R
{${B sjR {B8B }$$B }$t{$}$$ k 7Bjt {Bt{}

t{BtsIsR t j }B{RB I$sj?
;d *Zt
VZ8ts$Bt 3s8bB,R
_Yst $tY *Zt Iht Zt R$R8s sZ8ts$%B sARs{B >*=WpnH IBtI I`s js RZ{Zs
I jBR sZ8tBR {B8}js8t R$t R}{$h{s {t?

stIBR t jBR {Bt4${BR -$RtR t
jjBR VRZ8 js -$Rt{$s I Zt {Bt`ZtB I sZ8tBR BItsIBR }B Zts js{$?
Bt A$ts$s
I IBs *ht Zt sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB , {B8B Zt }s \p, y00y>XX IBtI Vi R Zt
{Bt`ZtB I sZ8tBR k y00y>X R Zts js{$Bt A$ts$s RBA \p JZ $tI${s jBR {Bt4${BR
t jBR sZ8tBR _B `8}jB
e`8}jB ;d V3)\p, y00y>XX R Zt sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, sj JZ
\p ) \\, 4, g i
y00y>X ) \w\, 4 D, w4, g D, wg, \Di
*sIs js R$8}j${$IsI Ij sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, R }ZI ZRs Zt sPB I$$$IB }ss
Z$j$9s Zts PB8s ?

sh{s }ss ItBs j RsIB I jBR {Bt4${BR
ej {Bt{}B }$t{$}sj R j I s{}sA$j$IsI I sZ8tBR =t sZ8tB \ R s{}sAj
{Bt R}{B s Zt {Bt`ZtB C I sZ8tBR R$ BIB sZ8tB JZ IBs s \ R IBsIB
}B sj?
Zt sZ8tB I C et AsR s ?
RB Iht js R8?
st${s Ij sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB,
s s%?
R Ij }ZtB h`B I Zts PZt{$?
Bt 8Bt?
BBts *sIB JZ t R R$R8s tB R?
s Iht$IB
Zt jtZs` }ss js }Rts{$?

Bt I {BtB{$8$tB tB -$R t ?
j Zts tB{$?
Bt {Bt{s I
sZ8tB k IBs *A$IB s R sjB t$%j I sARs{{$?

Bt jsR Z
? t${sR Psjs{$sR JZ }ZIt
}RtsR RBt sJZjjsR JZ RZt I js $ts{{$?

Bt I jBR sZ8tBR {B8B js sZ8ts{$?
Bt
{${Zjs k {BtsI${B$s NsR Psjs{$sR {B8B jBR sZ8tBR WBt RJZ$Z R?

BjB $tt Rt$IB
{ZstIB YsAjs8BR I js RZ{Zs I jBR sZ8tBR sZtJZ *Zt sI8$s js }BR$A$j$IsI I
sZ8tBR JZ R IBst s R?

8$R8BR
ej sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, Ij `8}jB ;d }Rts Zt {sRB I sZ8ts{$?

Bt {BtsI${T
B$s >*]H IBtI jBR sZ8tBR ss{st k IhtIt $tI${s8t s jBR RstR eR
sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, tB R A$t PZtIsIB k R {BtB%R$sj >*=WpnH ej Y{YB I JZ
}B `8}jB j sZ8tB 4 Rs ss{sIB $tI${s8t }B 4 $8}j${s JZ 4 R Zt sZ8tB
RBjt {Bt{} }ZR IhtI Zt {Bt{}B 8$tsR IZst js I$R{ZR$?

Bt jB ss{s Ns R8?
st${s
R{?
}${s I jBR sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB,R Iht s jBR sZ8tBR I R $}B {B8B sZ8tT
BR tB `ZR$h{sIBR jB {Zsj R $8Bj?

B${s8t {B{B Ns sZ8ts{$?
Bt {${Zjs s8A$?
t
R?
s }Rt t R R$R8s jB JZ }B%B{s Zts Psjs{$s sZ8ts$%s X }$$B }$t{$}$$ "
e`8}jB ;1 7s V3)\p, y00y>XX Zt sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, sj JZ
\p ) \\, 4, g, ;i
y00y>X ) \w\, 4 D, w4, g D, wg, ;D, w;, \Di
et R {sRB Zt sZ8tB }B `8}jB \ R Z$j$9sIB t js I$R{ZR$?

Bt I$sj?
{${s }ss
IPtI s \ eRB }ZI %R {B8B JZ t jsR -}j${s{$BtR }ss `ZR$h{s \ tZt{$s8BR
j sZ8tB \ WZ%s8t js R8?
st${s I jBR sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, {jsR$h{s s RBR
sZ8tBR Psjs{R {B8B tB `ZR$h{sIBR
=ts {ss{?
R${s $8}Bst t R R$R8s R JZ js 8$R8s R8?
st${s R{}${s Iht$Is
}B *Zt $t{Z t Zts {jsR }s${Zjs I Psjs{$sR ItB8$tsIs X VZ8tZ8 sI jB${s8 "
IBtI R RsAj{ JZ Zts }B}BR${$?
Bt R PsjRs }BJZ Ys R$IB }RtsIs {B8B js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt
I Zt sZ8tB Psjs9 et >*]H R 8ZRs JZ t j R$Z$t `8}jB
e`8}jB ;n j sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, V3)\p, y00y>XX IBtI
\p ) \\, 4, g, ;i
y00y>X ) \w\, 4 D, w4, g D, wg, ;D, w;, 4Di
j sZ8tB \ JZ tB }s${$}s t j {${jB I sZ8ts{$?

Bt {BtsI${B$s R {jsR$h{sIB
s8A$?
t {B8B sZ8tB tB `ZR$h{sIB d
_Bs8sR N?
B${BR -tI$IBR {Bt ts{$?
Bt -}j?
{$s
_BR$B8t *Zt Iht$?

B Zts -tR$?
Bt s js }Bs8s{$?
Bt t j?
B${s {Bt%t{$Btsj t js
{Zsj R }8$ js Z$j$9s{$?

Bt I ts{$?
Bt -}j?
{$s >*=WpN_H eRsAj{ JZ }B {sIs }Bs8s
-tI$IB R }ZI {BtRZ$ Zt sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB, {Zks R8?

st${s Iht js R8?
st${s
Ij }Bs8s
NBR j$sjR I jBR }Bs8sR -tI$IBR }ZIt R j$sjR LKi078LX B j$sjR X`Ki078LX
=t j$sj LKi078L R Zt sB8B \ B js ts{$Bt -}j${$s \ I Zt sB8B \ =t j$sj
X`Ki078L R Zt j$sj I js PB8s XtB N" IBtI N R Zt j$sj BA`$%B =ts {j?
sZRZjs I
}Bs8s -tI$IB R I js PB8s U(

Ud , 333, Uz , zL0UELd , 333, zL0UELz " IBtI jBR U7 RBt
j$sjR BA`$%BR NBR j$sjR RZA`$%BR JZ s}s{t t js }ZAs RBt jsR Y$}?
BR$R RBA jsR
{ZsjR js }ZAs R {BtRZ?

Is Ns s{}s{$?
Bt I js }ZAs I}tI tBt{R I js s{}s{$?
Bt
I jsR Y$}?
BR$R *Zt Iht }ss Zt }Bs8s _ Zt y/`Ez0L {Bt R}{B s _ {B8B Zt
{Bt`ZtB I j$sjR RZA`$%BR =t j$sj BA`$%B U R XLL0yQL }B Zt sZ8tB \ R$ -$R

Zts }ZAs }ss U {ZksR Y$}?
BR$R R?
st {Btt$IsR t \
et RBR }Bs8sR }ZIt -$R$ sZ8tBR JZ R IBt s R?

8$R8BR et Zt }Bs8s
_ Zt sZ8tB \ R IBs s R? 8$R8B R$ -$R Zt j$sj U sj JZ \ RB}Bs s U k U et R
{sRB j sZ8tB \ R Zt sZ8tB XtBt RJZ$Z " sj R $t{BtR$Rt }ZRB JZ RB}Bs IBR
{Bt{jZR$BtR {BtsI${B$sR 7$t 8AsB RBR sZ8tBR RBt -{jZ?
IBR Ij sZ8ts$Bt
Ps8bB, }ss j }Bs8s _ k t$t?

Zt sZ8tB tBt RJZ$Z R Zt sZ8tB `ZR$h{sIB
d
<sk JZ t t {Zts JZ j 8B$%B I js I$R{ZR$?
Bt sJZ?
R js `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt B tB Ij sZ8tB
;1 _s,,t k 7sB
B$%sIBR }B j s9Bts8$tB jsj <tk _s,,t k p$B%stt$ 7sB >_iVH Ihtt Zts
-tR$?
Bt I js }Bs8s{$?
Bt t j?
B${s {Bt }$B$IsIR As$AjR AsRsIs t sZ8tBR
et R R$R8s Zt j$sj PZ R Zt s \ B Zt s?B8B tsIB \ 7 ItBs s \ sj

?B8B
{B8}j8tB Ij j$sj \ =t j$sj I?

A$j R Zt j$sj I js PB8s U IBtI U R Zt j$sj
PZ ytPB8sj8t U R$t$h{s XtB -$R %$It{$s }ss U" =ts js R Zts -}R$? Bt
I js PB8s
U U( + 333 + Ud + U> + 333 + UE )p Uz
IBtI js {Bt`Zt{$?
Bt s js $9JZ$Is I js 4{Ys R j st{It k Uz R j {BtR{Zt e-$Rt
IBR $}BR I jsRU jsR jsR As$AjR k jsR jsR R${sR 7BjB jsR jsR As$AjR }ZIt
{Btt j$sjR I?
A$jR ej {Bt`ZtB I RsR jsR sI8?
sR Rs BItsIB }B Zt BIt
}s{$sj
et R R$R8s Zt sZ8tB R Zt {Bt`ZtB BItsIB I jsR sj JZ BIB j$sj PZ
t j st{It I Zts js R s8A$?

t j {BtR{Zt I sjZts js st$B =t j$sj U
R Zts {Bt{jZR$?
Bt I Zt sZ8tB \ R$ U R j {BtR{Zt I sjZts js I \ =t j$sj
U R Zts Y$}?
BR$R I Zt sZ8tB \ R$ U B{Z t sjZts js I \ e-$Rt IBR PB8sR
I {Bt4${BR t sZ8tBRU K`0 IBtI IBR sZ8tBR }8$t sj{st9s {Bt{jZR$BtR
{BtsI${B$sR k `zQ`0 IBtI Zt sZ8tB $t {B8B {Bt{jZR$?

Bt j {B8}j8tB I js
Y$}?
BR$R I BB 7s g5] g w\D j {Bt`ZtB I {Bt{jZR$BtR I Zt sZ8tB \ \CC w\D j
{Bt`ZtB I Y$}?
BR$R I Zt sZ8tB \ k Rs 7 j {Bt`ZtB I jsR R${sR =t sZ8tB
\ ss{s s 4 R$
T g5]g w\D g5] g w4 D C m wiAZRD

T g5]g w\D C m }ss {ZsjJZ$ ; \CC w4 D w=tI{ZRD
3$tsj8t Zt sZ8tB \ IBs s Zt sZ8tB 4 R$
T V XZtI{ZR" B
T V XAZ" }B tB XZtI{Z" V
Ns R8?
st${s I R R$R8s R?
s AsRsIs t js R8?
st${s }ss sZ8ts$Bt Ps8bB,R I
*Zt k }B jB stB }sI{ jBR 8$R8BR }BAj8sR t {ZstB s sZ8ts{$?

Bt XRBjt {Bt{}"
k sZ8ts{$?
Bt X}$$B }$t{$}$$" et R R$R8s }ZIt t{BtsR s8A$?
t sZ8tBR
Psjs{R Ij $}B XtBt RJZ$Z"U jBR sZ8tBR }ZIt t {Bt{jZR$BtR {BtsI${B$sR }B
jB JZ Zt sZ8tB JZ }BR {B8B {Bt{jZR$BtR s \k \ R IBs s R$ 8$R8B WZ%s8t
j }B{RB I `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt s8A$?
t {Z t Zts Psjs{$s " VZ8tZ8 sI jB${s8 " sj {jsR$h{s
{B8B tB `ZR$h{sIBR s sZ8tBR JZ tB }t{t s sjZt {${jB sZ8ts$%B }B JZ R$t
8AsB RBt IBsIBR }B Zt sZ8tB XtBt RJZ$Z" B Zt sZ8tB X}$$B }$t{$}$$"
sj $Zsj JZ t *Zt
;n _Bs8sR N?B${BR iAs$AjR
*ht$Is {B8B Zts -tR$?

Bt I js }Bs8s{$?
Bt t j?
B${s {Bt%t{$Btsj js _Bs8s{$?
Bt t
N?
B${s iAs$Aj >7y1 VpH }8$ {s}Zs sR}{BR Ij s9Bts8$tB Ij Rt$IB {B8?
Zt
I$P?
{$jR I {s}Zs t BsR -tR$BtR NBR }Bs8sR j?
B${BR As$AjR w }jD }8$t
}Rts $tPB8s{$?
Bt As$Aj k tB As$Aj sR$ {B8B s8A$?
t $tPB8s{$?
Bt $t{B8}js k
}Bt{$sj8t $t{BtR$Rt eR?

st PB8sIBR }B IBR $}BR I jsR jsR jsR PZR wI js
PB8s X]sA
]Z}B"D Z$j$9sIsR }ss }Rts {BtB{$8$tB R${B k jsR jsR As$AjR
wI js PB8s X]sA v] ]Z}B"D Z$j$9sIsR }ss js }Rts{$?
Bt I {BtB{$8$tB ts$%B ej
{Bt`ZtB I jsR PZR ItBsIB C IA R {BtR$Rt 8$tsR JZ j {Bt`ZtB I jsR
As$AjR ItBsIB ; }ZI R $t{BtR$Rt
*A$IB s JZ R }BR$Aj I$%s j$sjR {B8}j8ts$BR jBR }j Z$j$9st s js sZ8ts{$?Bt
As$Aj }ss }BI I{$I$ t 8sR {BtsI${B$sR =t sZ8tB }ss Zt j$sj R R
BA$t I Zts I$%s{$?

Bt I R JZ Rs {BtR$Rt k 8$t$8sj NBR sZ8tBR R ItBst {Bt
Zt }s VY X IBtI \ R j {Bt`ZtB I jsR As$AjR Z$j$9sIsR }ss I$%s js {Bt{jZR$?
Bt _
=t sZ8tB Vs X IBs s Zt sZ8tB A X {ZstIB -$R Zt RZAsZ8tB 4d Kd X
I A X sj JZ Vs X R?

t IRs{ZIB {Bt 4d Kd X RB R C \y, Kd i m =ts {BtRZjs
R tI?
s ?
-$B {ZstIB j sZ8tB \ JZ js RZRt Rs Zts `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt
_ss RsAj{ JZ \ R Zt sZ8tB IBsIB R IAt {BtRZ$ {BtssZ8tBR JZ
R?
st RZR }BR$AjR IBsIBR ]B8B jBR IBsIBR RBt s RZ %9 sZ8tBR }ZIt -$R$
IBsIBR }ss jBR IBsIBR k sR?

RZ{R$%s8t jB JZ JZ$ Zt st?
sj$R$R I$sj?
{${B
{B8}jB =ts j?
ts I sZ8ts{$? Bt I sZ8tBR >\( , \d , 333, \z H IBtI
Bt R Zts RZ{R$?
hZst sjtsIs8t sZ8tBR s Ps%B k t {Bts Ij }$8B I js R{Zt{$s w\( D NBR
sZ8tBR \1>Ld RBt ItB8$tsIBR sZ8tBR I $tPt{$s }ss \( k jBR sZ8tBR \1>
RBt ItB8$tsIBR sZ8tBR I RB}B }ss \(
et jBR }Bs8sR j?
B${BR As$AjR jBR sZ8tBR RBt I$%s{$BtR {BtR$RtR R I{$
IsIB Zt sZ8tB \ R {Z8}j JZ C \ Wm _B jB stB t R R$R8s tB R t{ZtT
st sZ8ts{$BtR Psjs{R X tBt RJZ$Z " Ij $}B $t{BtR$Rt et jBR }j tB -$Rt jBR
sZ8tBR JZ R IBst s R?

8$R8BR
NB $tRst I R R$R8s R JZ t j }B{RB I$sj?
{${B I `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt I sZ8tBR
}ZIt t{BtsR sj $Zsj JZ jBR R$R8sR st$BR Psjs{$sR X }$$B }$t{$}$$ " k X RBjt
{Bt{} " }B R$t 8AsB -$R Zt ss8$tB JZ }8$ {jsR$h{s s jBR sZ8tBR Psjs{R
{B8B tB `ZR$h{sIBR
et jBR }Bs8sR j?
B${BR As$AjR R JZ$ JZ BIsR jsR j?
tsR I sZ8ts{$?
Bt -$RT
tR }ss {ZsjJZ$ sZ8tB {Z8}jst jsR R$Z$tR {BtI${$BtRU
d NBR {Bt`ZtBR I sZ8tBR I RB}B k I $tPt{$s IAt R {sIs ZtB Zt {Bt`ZtB
\\d , \1 , 333, \z i
) \ C Wm
{Bt{BIst I sZ8tBR =t {Bt`ZtB I sZ8tBR R {Bt{BIst
R$ 7
7
1 W$t?
Zt \7 R RZAsZ8tB I sj?
Zt \> w> 7D
* Rs PB8s jBR sZ8tBR $t%BjZ{sIBR t Zts Psjs{$s }$$B }$t{$}$$ B RBjt {Bt{}
}BRt Zts j?
ts I sZ8ts{$?
Bt ht$s s }Rs Ij {${jB k RBt {jsR$h{sIBR {B8B sZ8tBR
tB `ZR$h{sIBR
sR s?
Zt R ss8$tB %$s {s t Zts Psjs{$s " VZ8tZ8 sI jB${s8 " =t sZT
8tB JZ tB PB8s }s I Zts Psjs{$s RBjt {Bt{} B }$$B }$t{$}$ }B JZ R$t 8AsB
R IBsIB }B Zt sZ8tB Psjs9 tB t{Rs$s8t R Zt sZ8tB tB `ZR$h{sIB jB JZ
R?
B{Z t jBR R$R8sR I ;`z/ k _s,,t k 7sB et jBR }j st Zts R$Zs{$?
Bt {B8B js
Ij `8}jB ;n j sZ8tB \ R?

s `ZR$h{sIB }ZR Rs IBsIB }B Zt sZ8tB Psjs9 k
?
Rs R js s9?
Bt I RZ `ZR$h{s{$?
Bt jB {Zsj R j?
B${s8t {B{B
x ]Bt{jZR$BtR
et R sAs`B R %$RsBt sjZtsR I jsR Psjs{$sR sZ8ts$%sR 8?

sR $8}BstR VjZtsR
I jjsR I {s?
s{ RZA`$%B {B8B sZ8tZ8 sI YB8$t8 B sZ8tZ8 sI 8$R${BI$s8
RBt $t%$sAjR t jBR 8BIjBR PB8sjR k }ZIt t{BtsR t }?
s{${s8t BIBR jBR R$RT
8sR sZ8ts$%BR WB {BtR$Zkt Zt IP{B t R?

}ZR I}tIt I js 8?
s${s k tB
t{Rs$s8t Ij }B{RB I I$R{ZR$?

Bt
!sR Psjs{$sR {B8B tBt RJZ$Z RBt P{ZtR t sjZtBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?
Bt
As$Aj JZ }8$t js {BtRZ{{$?

Bt I sZ8tBR {s}s{R I IBsR s R?
8$R8BR eRs R
Zts {ss{?
R${s tB IRsAj VjZtBR R$R8sR >VpH %$st $t{jZ$ Rs {jsR I sZ8tBR
k BBR sst {Bt jjBR I 8sts sj JZ s}jstIB sj Rt$IB {B8?
Zt tB Rst sZ8tBR
`ZR$h{sIBR >*=Wpn *=WpN_ _iVH
NsR Psjs{$sR -$RtR t }?

s{${s8t BIBR jBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$Aj RBt
jsR Ij $}B }$$B }$t{$}$ IBtI R }BIZ{ Zt {${jB t js sZ8ts{$?

Bt k RBjt {Bt{}
IBtI R $t{Z t Zts {BtsI${{$?
Bt t j }B{RB I$sj?
{${B eRsR Psjs{$sR RBt $t?
tR{sR I
js sZ8ts{$?
Bt k }B jB stB YIsIsR }B jBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR NBR sZ8tBR
Psjs{R I R $}B tB IAt R `ZR$h{s{$BtR NBR R$R8sR I *Zt >*=Wpn *=WpN_H
_s,,t k 7sB >_iVH k ps{?

s k 7$8s$ >VpH {BtBjst R $}B I Psjs{$sR 3$tsj8t k
{B8B P{B {Bjssj I RsR Psjs{$sR 8Z{YBR R$R8sR $t{Zt t Zts VZ8tZ8 sI jB${s8
sj {jsR$h{s {B8B sZ8tB tB `ZR$h{sIB s sJZjjBR JZ RBt ss{sIBR }B sjZts Psjs{$s }$$B
}$t{$}$$ B RBjt {Bt{} eR }BAj8s tB R t$IB t {Zts t 8Z{YBR R$R8sR et js
_Bs8s{$?
Bt t N?
B${s iAs$Aj >Vp 7y1H RB tB RZ{I }{$Rs8t }BJZ -$R s
I$Pt{$s I jBR I8?

sR Zt ss8$tB R}{?
h{B }ss Rs {jsR I Psjs{$sR >p]7; *]H
$Aj$BsP?
s
>VpH Vj`stIB ps{?

s Ns }Bs8s{$?
Bt t j?
B${s As$Aj 7Z Iht${$?
Bt ?
B${s k
{B8}Zs{$Btsj qR$R I s$R t ]R I js ]B8}Zs{$?
Bt =t$%R$IsI Ws{$Btsj Ij 7Z
d
>VqGe H qY VY$R8 GAU NB${ stI 3sjjs{$R
Y}U\\bbb$thIjRB\tbR\sY$R8\jB${Y8j
> ViqH s zY$` iZjR sRBtR stI sZ8tRU PB8sj RZI$R BP sZ8ts$Bt stI IPs
y7 W (T(d((dT
> !W*H V BtIst,B _ *Zt iV BbsjR,$ stI 3 qBt$ Vt sARs{
sZ8ts$BtTYB${ s}}Bs{Y B IPsZj sRBt$t V$h{$sj ytjj$t{ nUEnud(d
d
> !W*nH V BtIst,B 3 qBt$ stI iV BbsjR,$ Vt sRRZ8}$BtTAsRI Ps8bB, PB
tBtT8BtBBt${ sRBt$t _B{ 1tI ytts$Btsj GB,RYB} Bt NB${ _Bs88$t stI
WBtT8BtBBt${ isRBt$t }sR ddudM dn
>]NMH ]sjBR ]YRK

t%s Vts sZ$8st iBtsjI _ NBZ$ NB${sj BIjR BP VZ8tR
7ZA8$I B V] ]B8}Z$t 7Z%kR dM
t9 78?
>*]MH *$B ] s? st${s I _Bs8sR N?
B${BR iAs$AjR qR$R I N${t{$sZs
t ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?
Bt FZt$B I dM
>*]H *$B ] s?

t9 Vjts$%sR }ss %$s Psjs{$sR t js sZ8ts{$?
Bt As$AjU
Zt st?
sj$R$R {B8}ss$%B GB,RYB} I yt%R$sIBR t ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?
Bt 7st
FZst FZt$B I d

>*=WpnH _ *Zt !t Y V{{}sA$j$k BP VZ8tR stI $R 3ZtIs8tsj iBj $t WBtT
8BBt${ sRBt$t stI NB${ _Bs88$t stI WT}RBtR s8R yF]Vy n Mx1TMx dn
>*=WpN_H _ *Zt Vt sZ8ts$Bt 78st${R PB NB${ _Bs8R b$Y -}j${$ ts$Bt
y]N_ n yq _RR
>eieV7H qY eBR $t sRBt$t
Y}U\\1(;nMEx1\
IAs\I{A}B`\RZ}}B\Psjjs{$Y8
>p]7;H Vj`stIB ps{?

s ]sjBR ]YRK
t%s pZ$jj8B 7$8s$ qY iBj BP *$sj{${R $t
*PsR$Aj VZ8ts$Bt _B{I$tR BP Y yz ytts$Btsj ]BtPt{ BP Y ]Y$jst
]B8}Z 7{$t{ 7B{$k ]Bt{}{$?

Bt ]Y$j WB%$8A I d;
>p7H Vj`stIB F ps{?

s stI pZ$jj8B i 7$8s$ *PsR$Aj VZ8ts$Bt PB e-tII
NB${ _Bs88$t 7ZA8$I B Y xY ytts$Btsj ]BtPt{ Bt NB${ _Bs88$t
stI WBt8BtBBt${ isRBt$t wN_Wi:D ej _sRB q *${
>!GVEH iBA V BbsjR,$ stI 3st{R{s qBt$ VARs{ sZ8ts$Bt V$h{$sj ytjT
j$t{ stI Nsb ;wnT;DU1xu1E dE
>N!=yH iBtsjI _ NBZ$ F& WB8st FB Vj} *st _$t,sI *st ]s%t FRR${s N$tIT
Rsk stI s, 3Bj9 _BRR Bt BB8 xU V RAI PB }ZAj${ $ts{$% R8$TPB8sj jsj
sZ8ts$Bt yt _B{ BP Y EY ytts$Btsj ]BtPt{ Bt V$P{$sj ytjj$t{ stI
Nsb FZjk d
>_iVH <tk _s,,t k p$B%stt$ 7sB VZ8tTAsRI -tII jB${ }Bs88$t b$Y
IPsR$Aj }$B$$R FBZtsj BP s}}j$I tBt {jsRR${sj jB${ 1xTx
>_zieeH <tk _s,,t k psI zRb$`, NB${R PB *PsR$Aj VZ8ts$Bt 7Z%k $t
IPsR$Aj sZ8ts$Bt
>7y1H p i 7$8s$ k i _ NBZ$ V sY8s${sj qs8t BP *PsR$Aj isRBt$t stI $R
y8}j8ts$Bt V$h{$sj ytjj$t{ xnU d1xudxd1
>zieeH psI VG zRb$`, VARs{ sZ8ts$Bt RkR8R V$h{$sj ytjj$t{
(U11xu1 d
>O!N*eiH $st OBI qY 3sjjs{k BB
Y}U\\bbb}$8t{B8\ AkBI\Psjjs9BBY8

Falacias Significancia en Los Sistemas Argumentativos

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Falacias Significancia en Los Sistemas Argumentativos

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

7$t$h{st{$s I jsR Psjs{$sR t jBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR

*}ss8tB I ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?

=t$%R$IsI Ws{$Btsj Ij 7Z

V% Vj8 d1xn T wM(((D sY?

qj\3s-U wLx;Dw1dD;xxdnx\xdnE T eT8s$jU \I8s$t{{s{$sio{$AsIZs

{BtB{$8$tB k j s9Bts8$tB et j 8ZtIB sj js sZ8ts{$?

V$h{$sj tB {BtBjst j ZRB I sZ8tBR Psjs{R VjZtsR I RsR Psjs{$sR R?

*tB I jsR ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?

sR}{BR R h sj s9Bts8$tB k js }Rts{$?

3$tst{$sIB }s{$sj8t }B js 7{s?

Is{$? Bt I yt%R$s{$BtR ]$t?

V$h{$sj =tB I RBR 8BIjBR js sZ8ts{$?

I }sBtR I s9Bts8$tB IBtI sZ8tBR s Ps%B k t {Bts I Zts }B}BR${$?

}BIZ{$IBR k %sjZsIBR }ss %$h{s js s{}sA$j$IsI I I${Ys }B}BR${$?

]ZstIB R $tts {s}Zs sR}{BR I Zt s

IRsAj JZ j PB8sj$R8B tB {s}Z s8A$?

}BAj8sR RBt %$sAjR B P?

sj }B jB {Zsj j 8BIjB IA ssjBR {Z$IsIBRs8t

}B JZ Zts $tR}{{$?

Z8tBR R ItB8$tst Psjs{R ej ?

t j }B{RB JZ BA$ts js -}BR${$?

*$%RBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

Zt R$R8s sZ8ts$%B tsj IBtI R sARs I jBR {Bt{}BR I sZ8tB k IBs

_s,,t k 7sB >_iVH IRsBjjsBt Zt R$R8s JZ Z$j$9s j jtZs` I js }Bs8s{$?

As$AjU _s,,t k zRb$`, >_zieeH k ]YRK

ej RZI$B I jsR Psjs{$sR t js sZ8ts{$?

sJZjjBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

ej BA`$%B I R sAs`B R RZI$s j ss8$tB JZ jBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

As$Aj IAt Is s jsR Psjs{$sR _ss jjB R }Rts?

{$IsR k RZI$sIsR PZs Ij s

JZ R IsIB }B sjZtBR I jBR R$R8sR I sZ8s{$?

s{ss Bt R$Z$t R tZ8st jsR {ss{?

Pt s jsR sZ8ts{$BtR Psjs{R

1 ej8tBR I Zt R$R8s I sZ8ts{$?Bt As$Aj

T *ht${$BtR I {Bt4${BR t sZ8tBR

T =t 8{st$R8B I $tPt{$s JZ }8$s RsAj{ R$ Zt sZ8tB R s{}sIB

NBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR RBt tBt{R {BtRZ?

_B `8}jB }BI?

{B8B jsR {j?

R}{$%B s ht I BAt Zts I$%s{$?

RBR {Bt{}BR R t{ZsIst {Bt jsR {ss{?

RstR R j8tBR RBt $tYtR s js sZ8ts{$?

sI${ s BB _B `8}jB IBR sZ8tBR Rs?

{Bt{jZR$BtR {BtsI${B$sR ej {Bt{}B I {Bt4${B t sZ8tBR tB $t%BjZ{s js {B8T

Iht$R Zts js{$?

t {Bt4${B k j }$8B R 8`B JZ j RZtIB I s{ZIB sj {$$B I {B8}ss{$?

eR $8}Bst IRs{s JZ js js{$?

sZ8tBR t {Bt4${B 7$t 8AsB t j }B{RB I sZ8ts{$?

Ns s{}sA$j$IsI I jBR sZ8tBR I}tI I js $ts{{$?

I$R}Bt$AjR sj 8B8tB I js sZ8ts{$?

R PB8sj$9sIB t sjZtBR R$R8sR 8I$st Zt st?

Zts I$R}Zs t j }B}Btt I Zts {Bt{jZR$?

=t sZ8tB }ZI R Psjs9 }B I$PtR 8B$%BR et Rs R{{$?

{BtR{Zt{$s I Zts 8sjs {BtRZ{{$?

nd 3sjs{$sR I ij%st{$s

js{$BtsIBR {Bt j {Bt-B I Zts I$R{ZR$?

T VZ8tZ8 sI YB8$t8 U sZ8tB IBtI R ss{s j {s?

B}Btt t jZs I RZ R$R wFZst R j jsI?

T VZ8tZ8 sI 8$R${BI$s8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s}jstIB s js

T VZ8tZ8 sI %{ZtI$s8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s}jstIB s Zts

sZB$IsI w*$BR -$R }BJZ yRss{ WbBt {? ? D

T VZ8tZ8 sI As{ZjZ8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s s%?

js s8ts9s I PZ9swz$% As`B jsR jsR I *$BR B  JZ8s?

7$t$h{st{$s I jsR Psjs{$sR t jBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR

*}ss8tB I ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?

=t$%R$IsI Ws{$Btsj Ij 7Z

V% Vj8 d1xn T wM(((D sY?

qj\3s-U wLx;Dw1dD;xxdnx\xdnE T eT8s$jU \I8s$t{{s{$sio{$AsIZs

{BtB{$8$tB k j s9Bts8$tB et j 8ZtIB sj js sZ8ts{$?

V$h{$sj tB {BtBjst j ZRB I sZ8tBR Psjs{R VjZtsR I RsR Psjs{$sR R?

*tB I jsR ]$t{$sR I js ]B8}Zs{$?

sR}{BR R h sj s9Bts8$tB k js }Rts{$?

3$tst{$sIB }s{$sj8t }B js 7{s?

Is{$? Bt I yt%R$s{$BtR ]$t?

V$h{$sj =tB I RBR 8BIjBR js sZ8ts{$?

I }sBtR I s9Bts8$tB IBtI sZ8tBR s Ps%B k t {Bts I Zts }B}BR${$?

}BIZ{$IBR k %sjZsIBR }ss %$h{s js s{}sA$j$IsI I I${Ys }B}BR${$?

]ZstIB R $tts {s}Zs sR}{BR I Zt s

IRsAj JZ j PB8sj$R8B tB {s}Z s8A$?

}BAj8sR RBt %$sAjR B P?

sj }B jB {Zsj j 8BIjB IA ssjBR {Z$IsIBRs8t

}B JZ Zts $tR}{{$?

Z8tBR R ItB8$tst Psjs{R ej ?

t j }B{RB JZ BA$ts js -}BR${$?

*$%RBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

Zt R$R8s sZ8ts$%B tsj IBtI R sARs I jBR {Bt{}BR I sZ8tB k IBs

_s,,t k 7sB >_iVH IRsBjjsBt Zt R$R8s JZ Z$j$9s j jtZs` I js }Bs8s{$?

As$AjU _s,,t k zRb$`, >_zieeH k ]YRK

ej RZI$B I jsR Psjs{$sR t js sZ8ts{$?

sJZjjBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

ej BA`$%B I R sAs`B R RZI$s j ss8$tB JZ jBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

As$Aj IAt Is s jsR Psjs{$sR _ss jjB R }Rts?

{$IsR k RZI$sIsR PZs Ij s

JZ R IsIB }B sjZtBR I jBR R$R8sR I sZ8s{$?

s{ss Bt R$Z$t R tZ8st jsR {ss{?

Pt s jsR sZ8ts{$BtR Psjs{R

1 ej8tBR I Zt R$R8s I sZ8ts{$?Bt As$Aj

T *ht${$BtR I {Bt4${BR t sZ8tBR

T =t 8{st$R8B I $tPt{$s JZ }8$s RsAj{ R$ Zt sZ8tB R s{}sIB

NBR R$R8sR sZ8ts$%BR RBt tBt{R {BtRZ?

_B `8}jB }BI?

R}{$%B s ht I BAt Zts I$%s{$?

RBR {Bt{}BR R t{ZsIst {Bt jsR {ss{?

RstR R j8tBR RBt $tYtR s js sZ8ts{$?

sI${ s BB _B `8}jB IBR sZ8tBR Rs?

{Bt{jZR$BtR {BtsI${B$sR ej {Bt{}B I {Bt4${B t sZ8tBR tB $t%BjZ{s js {B8T

Iht$R Zts js{$?

t {Bt4${B k j }$8B R 8`B JZ j RZtIB I s{ZIB sj {$$B I {B8}ss{$?

eR $8}Bst IRs{s JZ js js{$?

sZ8tBR t {Bt4${B 7$t 8AsB t j }B{RB I sZ8ts{$?

Ns s{}sA$j$IsI I jBR sZ8tBR I}tI I js $ts{{$?

I$R}Bt$AjR sj 8B8tB I js sZ8ts{$?

R PB8sj$9sIB t sjZtBR R$R8sR 8I$st Zt st?

Zts I$R}Zs t j }B}Btt I Zts {Bt{jZR$?

=t sZ8tB }ZI R Psjs9 }B I$PtR 8B$%BR et Rs R{{$?

{BtR{Zt{$s I Zts 8sjs {BtRZ{{$?

nd 3sjs{$sR I ij%st{$s

js{$BtsIBR {Bt j {Bt-B I Zts I$R{ZR$?

T VZ8tZ8 sI YB8$t8 U sZ8tB IBtI R ss{s j {s?

B}Btt t jZs I RZ R$R wFZst R j jsI?

T VZ8tZ8 sI 8$R${BI$s8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s}jstIB s js

T VZ8tZ8 sI %{ZtI$s8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s}jstIB s Zts

sZB$IsI w*$BR -$R }BJZ yRss{ WbBt {? ? D

T VZ8tZ8 sI As{ZjZ8 U sZ8tB t j JZ R $tts }RZsI$ s s%?

js s8ts9s I PZ9swz$% As`B jsR jsR I *$BR B JZ8s?

T _jZ$Z8 $tBs$BtZ8 U IBtI R }tI Zts R$8}j R}ZRs s Zts }Zts t

qBIBR jjBR s}stst R sZ8tBR %?

tB RBt {B{sR t j Rt$IB I JZ tB $tt js{$?

R Zt sZ8tB sI 8$R${BI$s8 NsR s9BtR -}ZRsR t ?

AsRsIsR t js %IsI Rt$IB {B8?

tZt{$st jBR 8`BR sZ8tBR

et j $ttB I {BtRZ$ Zt 8BIjB PB8sj I Zt sR}{B I js sj$IsI R $8}Bst

NBR R$R8sR I sZ8ts{$?

]B8B jsR Psjs{$sR 8t{$BtsIsR st$B8t sst {Bt sR}{BR 8B{$BtsjR ?

{s}ZsIsR }B j 8BIjB PB8sj

et j {sRB t JZ P{$%s8t j R$R8s {Bt8}jss {B{s8t RBR sR}{BR t js

n1 3sjs{$sR t js {BtRZ{{$?Bt I Zt sZ8tB

T VZ8tZ8 sI ytBst$s8 U R {ZsjJZ$ sZ8tB JZ ZRs js jsU X 7$ sjB tB }ZI

tBt{R IA R $t{B{B"

eR 8BIB I s9Bts8$tB Z$j$9s js sZRt{$s I %$It{$s I js %IsI wB PsjRIsID I Zts

Bt {B8B }ZAs I jB B}ZRB _B `8}jB R$ tB Ysk %$It{$s I %$Is -sR

tBt{R tB -$R eRB R ssIB {B8B Psjs{$s }B 8Z{YBR hj?

{Bt j JZ R ss t j 8ZtIB sj k I jsR Ys8$tsR Z$j$9sIsR t ?