RESEARCH
Lee
INORGANIC CHEMISTRY
Beyond fossil fuel-driven
nitrogen transformations
ingguang.G. Chen,” Richard M. Crooks,” Lance C. Seefelat,” Kara I. Bren,
1. Morris Bullock, Marcetta Y. Darensbourg, Patrick L. Holland, Brian Hoffman,
‘Michael J. Janik, Anne K. Jones, Mercouri G. Kanatvidis, Paul King, Kyle M. Laneaster,
Sergei V. Lymar, Peter Pfromm, William F. Schneider, Richard K. Schrock
BACKGROUND: The invention ofthe Haber-
Bosch (H-B) process in the early 1900s to
produce ammonia industrially from nitrogen.
and hydrogen revolutionized the manufacture
of fertilizer and led to fundamental changes
In the way food is produced. Its impact is
‘underscored by the fact that about 50% of
‘the nitrogen atoms in humans today originate
rom this single industrial process. In the cen-
‘tury after the H-B process was invented, the
chemistry of earbon moved to center stage,
resulting in remarkable discoveries and a vast
array of products ineluding plastis and phar-
macenticals. In contrast, ite has ehangea in
Industrial nitrogen chemistry. This scenario,
reflects both the inherent efficiency of the H-B.
process and the particular challenge of breaking
the strong dinitrogen bond. Nonetheless, the
rellance ofthe H-B process on fosi fuels and
its associated high CO, emissions have spurred
recent interest in finding more sustainable and
environmentally benign alternatives, Nitrogen
ints more oxidized forms i also industrially,
biologically, and environmentally important,
Possible routes for nitrogen
‘transformations that eliminate
‘oF minimize the need for fossil
fuels. A more thorough
understanding of nitrogenase
may lead to more efficient
homogeneous catalysts for
reduction of No to NH
Coupling of theory and
‘experiment wil ead to
‘more effective and stable
heterogeneous and
lactrocatalysts. Innovative
energy sources, such as
plasmas, which involve
roneuilrium chemistry.
may lead to new nitrogen
= conversion mechanisms,
ey
Nirogenase ymes
‘and synergies in new combinations of oxi-
dative and reduetive transformations across
the nitrogen cycle could lead to improved
efficiencies.
ADVANCES: Major effort has been devoted to
{developing alternative and environmentally
{endl processes that would allow NH pro-
duction at distributed sources under more
benign conditions, rather than through the
large-scale centralized H-B process, Hydro-
carbons (particularly methane) and water are
‘the only two sourees of hydrogen atoms that
‘ean sustain longterm, large-scale NH produe-
ton, The use of water as the hydrogen source
for NH production requires substantially more
‘energy than using methane, but its also more
‘environmentally benign, does not contribute to
the accumulation of greenhouse gases, and does
not compete for valuable and limited hydro-
carbon resources, Microbes living in all major
‘ecosystems are able to reduce N, to NH, by
using the enzyme nitrogenase. A deeper under-
standing of this enzyme could lead to more
@
%8 gm,
‘ead
Heterogeneous catasts
serous
ficient catalysts for nitrogen reduction under
ambient conditions. Model molecular catalysts
have been designed that mimic some of the
functions of the ative site of nitrogenase. Some
modest sucess has also been achieved in design-
ingeleetroeaalysts for dinitrogen reduetion.
leetrochemistry avoids the expense and envi-
ronmental damage of steam reforming of me-
‘thane (whieh aecounts for most ofthe cost of
the H-B proces) and it may provide a means
for distributed production of ammonia. On
‘the oxidative side, nitric acid isthe principal
‘commodity chemical containing oxidized nitro
sen. Neary all nitric acid is manufactured by
cidation of Ny throush
‘the Ostwald process, but
Read the ful article Amore direct reaction of
EthitayaedouNewith Op mightbe prac-
org/1026/ tically feasible through
seleneeax0ll_— further development of
nonthermal plasma tech-
nology. Heterogeneous NH oxidation with Os
is at the heart of the Ostwald process and is
practiced in a variety of environmental pro-
‘ection applications as well. Precious metals,
remain the workhorse catalysts, and oppor-
tunities therefore exist to develop lower-cost
materials with equivalent or beter activity and
selectivity. Nitrogen oxides are also environ-
mentally hazardous pollutants generated by
industrial and transportation activities, and
‘extensive research has gone into developing and
applying reduction eialyst. Three-way catalytic
‘omvestersare operating on hundreds of milion
‘of icles worldwide. However, increasingly
stringent emissions regulations coupled with
‘the low exhaust temperatures of high-efficiency
‘engines, present challenges for future combus-
tion emissions control Bacterial denititcation
is the natural analog of this chemistry and
another source of study and inspiration for
catalyst design.
‘OUTLOOK: Demands for greater enerzyeff-
ciency, smaller-scale and mote flexible pro-
‘esses, and environmental protection provide
‘rowing impetus for expanding the scope of
nitrogen chemistry. Nitrogenase, as well as
nitrifying and denitrfying enzymes, will even-
‘tually be understood in suticient detail that
robust molecalareaalytie mimics wil emerge
Hreetrochemical and photochemical methods
also demand more sty. ther intriguing areas
of research that have provided tantalizing
result inelude chemiea! looping and plasma-
driven processes. The grand challenge in the
field of nitrogen chemistry is the development
‘of catalysts and processes that provide simple,
low-energy routes to the manipulation of the
redox states of nitrogen.
*Canespndeg ata: Era erence (0.0)
colscmuas ed (RC) cesta (LC)
‘Ge aca 1G. Chen a, Se 380 eal
(2s) DoE scenes alt
1202 ‘bt fine wo Sie BewooVo.9s o9u9}95/ren WOH popEoLUNOR,RESEARCH
INORGANIC CHEMISTRY
Beyond fossil fuel-driven
nitrogen transformations
‘ingguang G. Chen,'* Richard M. Crooks,"* Lance C. Seefeldt,** Kara L. Bren,”
R. Morris Bullock,” Marcetta Y. Darensbourg,’ Patrick L, Holland,” Brian Hoffinan,”
ichael J. Janik," Anne K. Jones," Mercouri G. Kanatzidis," Paul King,”
Kyle M. Lancaster, Sergei V. Lymar,® Peter Promm,!*
William F. Schneider,” Richard R. Schrock"
Nitrogen is fundamental to al of lfe and many industrial processes. The interchange of
nitrogen oxidation states in the industrial production of ammonia, nitric acid, and other
‘commodity chemical
largely powered by fossil fuels. A key goal of contemporary
‘esearch in the field of nitrogen chemistry is to minimize the use of fossil fuels by
developing more efficient heterogeneous, homogeneous, photo-, and electrocatalytic
processes or by adapting the enzymatic processes underiying the natural nitrogen cycle,
‘These approaches, as well as the challenges involved, are discussed in this Review.
duced forms of nitrogen, partially ame
‘monia (NH,), are vital to life. Before the
arly 19005 all reluced N came from bio-
logical nitrox fixation by microbes, This
landseape changed in the early 1900s with
{he invention by Haber and Bosch ofan indus-
‘rial process to reduce No to NH, (Np + SEs =
NHL). The Haber-Bosch (HB) process has led
‘tw fundamental changes in the way food is pro-
13,this 10 dasron rection sore hee:
‘modynamically favorable than the parasitic four-
ecto water oxidation to O,, Ths, tis possibe
{or NO,” to be the only preauet of an anoxic pro-
‘es particulary in neutral and alkaline solutions,
‘fasufidently active an selective eleetrocatalyst
‘or Ba 6 ean be dscns The eoresponding cell
‘eompletng athodi reaction ean be either water
‘reduction to H oF O, reduction to water. Little
apparent progresshas yet been made in develop-
ingsuet catalysts, but theres no reason to believe
that they eannot eventually be discovered.
By coupling eathodie Nz reduction (Ea. 2)
‘with anodic Nz oxidation (Bq. 6), an eleetro-
‘chemical cell consuming only atmospheric Np
and water as feedstock to yield aqueous NHNOS
(Bq, 7) ean be envisioned.
Nap + 31100) # NU a)
4 NOs i) * Ha
o
‘The additional H, produetion is necessary
{for matching eathodie and anodic currents and
maintaining the electrolyte pH constant. Such
cell would require a minimum of 108 V to
‘operate in neutral or alkaline eletrolte, which
{is slightly lower than the minimum water elec-
‘woljsis voluge of 123 V. Advanees relating to
‘lectrochemical N, oxidation wil require devel-
‘opment of catalysts that are sufiiently active
(capable of good current densities at low over-
Potentials, sleetive (with respeet to water oxt-
dation), and stable (toward deactivation under
harsh redax and pH operating conditions).
NO, reduction and NH; oxidation
Overview
‘The redox chemistry of forms of nitrogen other
‘han Nis immense and rich, and it is extensively
incorporated into biological systems. Both NO,,
and NH, are environmentally hazardous pollu-
tants generated by industrial and transportation
activity, and thus much research has gone into
‘developing and applying NO, reduction andl NT,
‘oxidation eatalysts As soften the case the under
standing of these catalysts lags their applications
“Ammonia oxidation and NO, reduction are
tal to environmental protetion and are much
less well understood or optimized than the syn
thesis of Ny. There are appealing opportunities
‘twapply the experimental and eomputational tools
‘of modern heterogeneous catalysis to these re-
actions, both to develop a fundamental under
standing of the processes and o identify superior
materials and catalytic transformations—for ex.
ample, catalysts that can selectively reduce NO,
‘to N, using hytrocarbon reductant, Environ-
‘mental applications generally demand high lon-
sevity, durability, and tolerance to poisons. Key
‘gaps in understanding indlude how activity and
selectivity can be acheved in relatively e001 gas
streams how catalyst structure evolves overlong
periods of time, how sulfur and other common
Doisons interfere with reactions, and especially
how these effects can be mitigated.
NO, reduction
[NO decomposition, the reverse of a, 3s ther=
‘morlynamically dovnhil but dieu to eatalyze
under the oxygen-rich conditions of interest or
‘environmental protection (00). Nevertheless, NO
‘decompastion has een demonstrated using both
homogeneous and heterogencons catalysts. De-
‘composition appears to involve a two-electron
redliction of two NO molecules to ahyponitrite
(E48).
2NO + €° + NOs wn
NOs +e + N02 wn
NOP 42H NO+1,0 60
Coordination complexes of hyponitrtes are
not uncommon, and a tr+Cu hyponitite coved
nation complex has been isolated as an inter-
mediate in the catalytic decomposition of NO
to Nz (0). A Ga dimer has similarly been m=
plicated as the active site fa Cx-exehangedre0-
lite catalyst for NO decomposition (63).
NO, can be catalytically reduced to N, via
several routes Precious metals are active fr NO,
reduetion by CO and hydrocarbons, but only
‘under conditions in which O, concentrations are
low (10). Vanadiatitania catalysts and metal-
‘exchanged zeolites catalyze selective reduction
‘ofNO, by NH, (69) Nitrsamine appears to be
the key Na forming intermediate inthe catalytic
Pathway (Eq, 9.
NH, +NO—HANNO+H' +e A)
HLNNO +N, + 1.0 on)
“This Nforming reaction is exothermic, imply-
Ing substantial, but perhaps not insurmountab
kinetic eallengs to reversing the chemistry
NO, can also be catalytically reduce with Hy
‘over Pd. and Pt catalysts (13), and Ny is typically
the desired product (66). By suitable selection
‘of promoters and control of the NO/H, ratio,
however, NH, can be produced over P catalysts
(70), Likewise, NHy competes with Nz as the
product ofthe catalytic reduction of NO, and
NOs” by Hy over Pd eatalysts (12).
Certain bacteria analogously reduce NO,” and
NO, through a series of gaseous interme
ates, leading ultimately to Ny in a process called
1202 “bt Kine wo soso Bewsaouores eou9}9s/-ery WOH papeqLUMEA,RESEARCH | REVIEW