Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a
School of Nursing, Columbia University, 630 W. 168th Street, Mailbox 6,
New York, NY 10032, USA
b
Department of Biomedical Informatics, Columbia University, 630 W. 168th Street, Mailbox 6,
New York, NY 10032, USA
c
Center for New Media Teaching and Learning, Columbia University, 630 W. 168th Street,
Mailbox 6, New York, NY 10032, USA
KEYWORDS Summary The Institute of Medicine (IOM) Committee on Quality of Health Care in
Patient safety; America identified the critical role of information technology in designing safe and ef-
Education; fective health care. In addition to technical aspects such as regional or national health
information infrastructures, to achieve this goal, healthcare professionals must re-
Nursing;
ceive the requisite training during basic and advanced educational programs. In this
Evidence-based
article, we describe a two-pronged strategy to promote patient safety through an
practice;
informatics-based approach to nursing education at the Columbia University School
Informatics of Nursing: (1) use of a personal digital assistant (PDA) to document clinical encoun-
ters and to retrieve patient safety-related information at the point of care, and (2)
enhancement of informatics competencies of students and faculty. These approaches
may be useful to others wishing to promote patient safety through using informatics
methods and technologies in healthcare curricula.
© 2004 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
demographics (e.g., age, gender, race/ethnicity) Log, we used the Physician’s Current Procedural
as well as student information such as clinical Terminology codes for procedures including those
site and level of independence in performing related to diagnostic tests [11]. We also created
interventions. custom terminologies for local concepts such as
For the MS students, we needed to select a frame- student names, clinical sites, and rotations.
work consistent with NP practice and expand the
data elements to include medical diagnoses and
3.1.3. User interface
treatments. The framework for the NP application is
The user interface was designed and implemented
the SOAP (subjective, objective, assessment, plan)
in Satellite Forms for the Palm OS. We tailored the
note augmented by categories of NP assessment and
values for clinical encounter-related data elements
plan as taught in our curriculum. Following selec-
(e.g., only relevant nursing diagnoses, medical di-
tion of the framework, we initiated a process to
agnoses, teaching interventions, and medications)
ascertain which data elements should be collected
for each ETP rotation (e.g., community, childbear-
across NP specialties and to determine which stan-
ing family) or NP program (e.g., women’s health,
dardized terminologies should be used for defining
pediatrics) in order to minimize searching through
structured data elements. We first interviewed pro-
irrelevant information. This is illustrated in the
gram directors and analyzed the content of the cur-
data entry screen shown in Fig. 2. The strategy
rent clinical logs. Second, we created a superset of
for managing the tailoring of user interface items
the data elements from the clinical logs. Next, we
in the knowledge base is described in detail in
asked each program director to identify which data
[12].
elements were currently collected and which data
elements should be collected.
A variety of media was used by the program
directors to collect clinical log data from NP stu-
dents including paper, excel spreadsheets, and
audiotapes. A total of 57 unique data elements re-
sulted from the analysis of the clinical logs. In all
instances but one, the number of desired data el-
ements (range = 19—48, mean = 27) exceeded the
number currently collected. Sixteen data elements
met our pre-set criterion of selection by five of
seven program directors for inclusion in the NP log
(Table 1).
After selection of the data elements, we gen-
erated a list of criteria for selection of the stan-
dardized terminologies for the structured data
elements:
• included in the Unified Medical Language System
(UMLS) [6];
• recognized by American Nurses Association (ANA)
[7];
• registered with Health Level 7 (HL7) for vocabu-
lary domain specification [8];
• priority given to systems in the public domain.
3.1.4. Database and knowledge base transformations, clean data are moved into a set
The database for the project is currently imple- of staging tables, which are linked to the repos-
mented in Microsoft Access, but care has been taken itory. The repository contains tables for the final
in the design to permit migration to higher capac- resting place of the main clinical data model and
ity database engines, such as Microsoft SQL Server the data analysis queries and reports. The knowl-
or Oracle, when needed. The logical database is edge base is embedded within the repository and
implemented as a set of linked Access databases im- is implemented in a simple two-table structure of
plementing a synchronization database (function- concepts and relationships. This structure provides
ing as the input buffer), the scrubbing database, functions such as version control of standardized
the repository, and the knowledge base. The de- terminologies for structured data elements, sort
sign of the synchronization database is dictated by order of items in the user interface by specialty
the tooling used to implement the palm user in- or program, control of which value lists belongs
terface and is a collection of Access database files to which specialty (e.g., dementia in gerontology
generated from the satellite forms development nurse practitioner (GNP), but not pediatric nurse
environment. The scrubbing database is a single practitioner (PNP)), and linking of nursing inter-
database file implementing the main clinical data ventions to nursing diagnoses (ETP only).
model, links to the synchronization database files,
and links to the knowledge base. It also contains 3.1.5. Reports
a collection of tables used in auditing, data trans- We extract a wide variety of knowledge from the
formation, and scrubbing processes. All processing collected data using simple SQL queries. We gen-
and transformation of the data are performed in erate individual student and aggregate reports ev-
the scrubbing database. The same data model ery 2 weeks for distribution to students, faculty,
is implemented in both the scrubbing database preceptors, and program directors. ETP reports fo-
and the repository. Upon completion of the data cus on aspects of the nursing process, e.g., which
Promoting patient safety through informatics-based nursing education 585
interventions are done for a particular nursing di- tivities to enhance the informatics competencies
agnosis. A typical cumulative report for the NP stu- of students and faculty.
dents includes frequencies for items such as gender,
race, medical diagnoses, diagnostic tests ordered, 4.1. Student informatics competencies
nursing diagnoses, nursing interventions, classes of
medications prescribed, and referrals (Table 2). For students, we derived an initial list of infor-
matics competencies from three sources: Amer-
ican Nurses Association [18], Staggers et al.’s
3.2. Patient safety resources
Delphi study of nursing informatics competencies
[19]; and Bakken’s informatics competencies for
The second aspect of PDA use that we have imple-
evidence-based practice (EBP) [2]. For ETP stu-
mented is retrieval of patient safety-related infor-
dents, we selected the set of beginning nurse in-
mation at the point of care. Selection of resources
formatics competencies from Staggers et al. as the
is at the discretion of the program director. For
basis of the curriculum development and compe-
the ETP students, only Micromedex, a pharmacy
tency assessment.
database that includes drug—drug and drug—food
At the Master’s level, NP program directors par-
interactions, is required. At the Master’s level,
ticipated in a series of meetings and e-mail dis-
the faculty for each program selected a set of re-
cussions to: (1) rate which competencies should
quired and recommended references. For example,
be included in the NP curriculum, (2) indicate if a
Micromedex, Growth 2, Kidometer, National Insti-
particular competency was currently included in a
tutes of Health asthma guidelines, and Journals
course in their program, and (3) indicate whether
to Go are required for pediatric nurse practitioner
each competency on the final list should be inte-
students. PNP students also purchase Isilo, a doc-
grated into a specialty course, taught in a core
ument reader, so that they can use pediatric and
course (e.g., research), or taught in an ‘‘intensive’’
cardiology databases. Resources required for acute
that program directors could elect for students in
care nurse practitioners (ACNPs) include: Pocket
a particular NP program. See [20] for details of this
Guide to Diagnostic Tests [13], Principles of Critical
process.
Care Companion Handbook [14], Harrison’s Man-
Nursing informatics competency assessment sur-
ual for the PDA [15], Essentials of Diagnosis and
veys were developed based upon the competencies
Treatment for PDA [16], and Major Incident Medical
that the program directors selected [21]. Our data
Management and Support [17]. The ACNP students
show that significant changes in informatics compe-
also select a PDA pharmacy knowledge base such
tencies occur during the course of our educational
as Epocrates or Micromedex to assist in prevention
program and that at program completion, ETP stu-
of medication errors (Table 3).
dents meet the Staggers et al. competencies for
beginning nurse in all but one area [21]. We subse-
quently augmented the curriculum to address that
4. Enhancing informatics competencies area.
of students and faculty Based upon the input of the ETP and NP program
directors, we also created two intensives to support
Provision of informatics tools and resources in development of the competencies: (1) decision
the curriculum is insufficient to influence patient making and decision support, and (2) web-based in-
safety. Students and faculty must also possess the formation for consumer education. The intensives
necessary competencies to appropriately use the are required of ETP students and available to MS
tools and resources. Consequently, we initiated ac- students as well. Examples of competencies with
586 S. Bakken et al.
Software
NIH website http://emall.nhlbihin.net/hp2010/Default.asp?
Asthma guidelines http://hin.nhlbi.nih.gov/as palm.htm
Blood chemistry http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/bloodchemistry.shtml
Stat cholesterol 1.02 http://www.statcoder.com/cholesterol.htm
COPD guidelines http://hin.nhlbi.nih.gov/as frameset.htm
Ebmcal http://www.cebm.utoronto.ca/palm/ebmcalc
Patient tracker http://www.handheldmed.com/prodmore.php?PRID=100
Blood pressure manager http://www.palmgear.com
Dxsaurus http://books.mcgraw-hill.com/medical/diagnosaurus/index.html
Growth 2 http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/statgrowthcharts.shtml
STAT NCD lab coverage http://www.statcoder.com/ncd.htm
STAT cardiac clearance http://www.statcoder.com/cardiac1.htm
Epocrates RX 6.0 http://www.epocrates.com
Math library http://www.radiks.net/∼rhuebner/mathlib.html
Medrules (requires Math library) http://pbrain.hypermart.net/medrules.html
Micromedex http://www.micromedex.com
Kidsshots http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/kidsshots.shtml
Pediatric cardiology (requires Isilo) http://pages.sprint.ca/Spiros/general3.html
Medmath http://pda.rcp.net.pe/palm/preview/45487.html
Date due calculator http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/duedatecalculator.shtml
GRACE ACS Risk Model. 25 http://www.eurocool.com/author/?author=8799
Acid base balance http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/basicsofacidbasebalance.shtml
Cancer staging and treatment v1.7 http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/cancerstagingandtreatment.shtml
CBC 1.0 http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/completebloodcount.shtml
Diabetes guidelines 2.0 http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/diabetesada2002diagnosisguides.shtml
Chest X-ray guidelines for NP/medical http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/basicsofchestx-rayinterpretation.shtml
students
Drips http://www.palmblvd.com/software/pc/Drips-2001-2-19-palm-pc.html
ABG pro 2.2 http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/abgpro.shtml
ICU math zip for adult patient http://www.freewarepalm.com/medical/icumath.shtml
Statcoder http://www.statcoder.com
related objectives and courses for teaching the technical aspects during the initial 2 years of the
competencies are shown in Table 4. project. These include the following:
data generated can assist them to monitor and Resources and Services Administration, Depart-
evaluate the student. ment of Health and Human Services, USA. Michael
• Each new application and the associated changes Soupios’ participation was supported by Columbia
in the database and knowledge base require Center for New Media Teaching and Learning. The
extensive testing to determine usability and to authors thank Christine Curran, RN, Ph.D., for her
maintain consistency of structure and perfor- contributions during the first year of the project,
mance across various rotations and specialties. especially her leadership of the work related to
This remains challenging because each applica- student and faculty competencies.
tion is tailored to the rotation or specialty, and
we currently have six ETP applications and eight
NP applications in use (GNP, PNP, ACNP, Adult
NP, Neonatal NP, Women’s Health NP, Family NP, References
and Oncology NP). We are in the process of de-
veloping standardized policies and procedures to [1] Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the
21st Century, Committee on Quality of Health Care in
assist us in project management.
America, Institute of Medicine, Washington, DC, 2001.
• A sophisticated knowledge base is required to [2] S. Bakken, An informatics infrastructure is essential for
manage the data collection and analysis over evidence-based practice, J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 8
time. We made the decision early on to manage (2001) 199—201.
complexity in the knowledge base rather than in [3] Palm Inc., Milpitas, CA, http://www.palm.com.
the user interface. When we add new content, [4] Satellite Forms MobileApp Designer, Pumatech, San Jose,
CA, http://www.pumatech.com.
the concepts and relationships in the knowledge [5] Extended Systems, Boise, ID, http://www.
base are updated and the new content is ex- extendedsystems.com.
tracted through queries from the knowledge base [6] B.L. Humphreys, D.A.B. Lindberg, H.M. Schoolman, G.O.
into tables suitable for export into the interface Barnett, The unified medical language system: an infor-
development environment. matics research collaboration, J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc.
5 (1998) 1—11.
• It is challenging to keep up with the rapidly evolv-
[7] A. Coenen, B. McNeil, S. Bakken, C. Bickford, J.J. Warren,
ing changes in parts of the system architecture. Toward comparable nursing data: American Nurses Associ-
For example, the release of a new PDA OS ver- ation Criteria for Data Sets, Classification Systems, J. Am.
sion is likely to precede the availability of the Med. Inform. Assoc. 19 (2001) 240—246.
development software and the synchronization [8] S. Bakken, K.E. Campbell, J.J. Cimino, S.M. Huff, W.E.
Hammond, Toward vocabulary domain specification for HL7
software. Consequently, students may have a PDA
coded data elements, J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 7 (2000)
that is incompatible with the rest of the architec- 333—342.
ture. We are moving toward a strategy that would [9] International Classification of Disease-Clinical Modification,
allow us to support various versions of Palm OS 9th Revision, Med-Index, Salt Lake City, UT, 1992.
and Windows CE devices. [10] V. Saba, Home Health Care Classification (HHCC) System,
http://www.sabacare.com, 2002.
[11] American Medical Association, Physician’s Current Proce-
dural Terminology, Chicago, 2000.
6. Conclusions [12] W.T. Klein, S. Bakken, Design and Implementation of a Stu-
dent Clinical Log Database and Knowledge Base, NI 2003,
Patient safety is a vital concern and informatics- Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2003.
based approaches have a significant role to play in [13] D. Nicoll, S.J. McPhee, M. Pignone, W.M. Detmer, T. Chou,
Pocket Guide to Diagnostic Tests, McGraw-Hill, New York,
prevention of errors of commission and omission. 2000.
An informatics-competent workforce is a signifi- [14] J. Hall, G. Schmidt, D. Wood, Principles of Critical Care
cant component of a safer healthcare environment Companion Handbook, 1999.
for all patients including those from traditionally [15] E. Braunwald, A. Fauci, D. Kasper, K. Hauser, D. Longo,
underserved populations. We believe that through L. Jameson, Harrison’s Manual of Medicine, McGraw-Hill,
New York, 2001.
the types of educational activities described in this
[16] L. Tierney, S. Saint, M. Whooley, Essentials of Diagnosis
paper, we are preparing advanced practice nurses and Treatment, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2001.
competent in the use of information technologies to [17] Advanced Life Support Group, Major Incident Medical Man-
promote safe and evidence-based nursing practice. agement and Support, BMJ Books, 2001.
[18] American Nurses Association, The Scope of Practice of
Nursing Informatics and the Standards of Practice and Pro-
fessional Performance for the Informatics Nurse Specialist,
Acknowledgements American Nurses Association, Washington, DC, 2001.
[19] N. Staggers, C.A. Gassert, C. Curran, Informatics compe-
This project was funded by grant 1 D09HP00261 tencies for nurses at four levels of practice, J. Nurs. Educ.
(S. Bakken, principal investigator) from the Health 40 (2001) 303—316.
Promoting patient safety through informatics-based nursing education 589
[20] C. Curran, Informatics competencies for nurse practition- [22] G.O. Barnett, J.J. Cimino, J.A. Hupp, E.P. Hoffer, DXplain.
ers, AACN Clin. Issues 14 (2003) 320—330. An evolving diagnostic decision-support system, JAMA 258
[21] S. Bakken, S.S. Cook, L. Curtis, M. Soupios, C. Curran, (1987) 67—74.
Informatics competences pre- and post-implementation [23] C. Ruland, Decision support for patient preference-based
of a palm-based student clinical log and informatics for care planning: effects on nursing care and patient
evidence-based practice curriculum, Proc. Am. Med. In- outcomes, J. Am. Med. Inform. Assoc. 6 (1999) 304—
form. Assoc. Symp. (2003) 41—45. 312.