Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Building The Hyksos Vassals Some Thought
Building The Hyksos Vassals Some Thought
K.
=J$B$
M$$*$`
$B%.
KB@K$
B<
K.
(.j<KB<
Bj
K.
=J$B$
$B(<KB<
9?K?.$
Roxana Flammini1
!
-
'
vassals;
+
+'
+
+
+
&
'
"!
'
'
"'
!
.
"
&
''
'
+
'
>6
"'";
"
'
!>
.!"6
'
'
-
>
+
+'
'
Introduction +'!
'
'>
'
+
!
'
'
'65
+'
'
"
'
"'
+
"
"
-
'
+'!
+
'
'
"
'
Modernity changed religious beliefs about the
"''
'
+
''
'
'
+'
+
!
'
+
¬"
6
K ;
''
'
unfolded to the degree that the state and its prog
"§
"
+
+
'
'!
'
+
!
'
"
'!
' '
+
"
+
'
'
+
'
'
'";
-
'
"
'
'
'
'
62 '
"'
66
K ;
+
"''
+;
!
"
'
'
J
>
'
'
'
Modernity as
such matters here, but to point out the relevance of
"!
+
+'
'
"
'
-
'
"
+
"
!
"
'
'
+
'
'
'>
of Middle Ages6S The related concept of feudalism
6
B
'
'
as a concept of universal history enhanced the pre
ed to the analyses of these matters, historical theo vious thousand years and “coincided to a large
'
J
>;
'
]Qth century
+
"
dark
%
1
9
-'
'
?''
';
% 6
KOSELLECK
\\^;
]S6
"'
'
!
?'
'';
?B<?.K6 S
KOSELLECK \\;
]
'
'
]Sth century
2
B
¬"
!!
";
6
MOTZKIN
]QQ;
^^
6
"
+
+'
static, but the concept of
[
WHITE
\\§
6
'
KOSELLECK
\\;
_6 Modernity (Neuzeit)
]Qth
!
+';
^
KOSELLECK
\\^';
^^6 revealed an additive "
6
5
WHITE
\\;
6 Z
KOSELLECK \\;
]^6
%!
" '6
!"
*'7.!"
'
*'
_;
\]_;
[[&^_
© 2015 by Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien
[^
''
j'
unique and clear meaning, thus it is important to centres in Egyptology located in Europe (mainly
'+'
+ '
'
+
'""
@'!;
.'
'
j'
'
6Q
$'
66
B'
;
;
%
ancient Egypt as a feudal '6
K
'
'
'
'6
'
'
';
'
-
!
';
"'
"
'
'
of the most relevant French Egyptologists, Gaston
practices, but its meaning varied through time: %'"
;
Histoire ancienne des peoples de
from describing practices performed by people l’Orient +
+'
"
¬
+
'
''7
]ZS_
+'6
"'
!
"
"
¬
'
''7 the possession of land: “The most favoured of the
Qth
!
(6 10 At that princes married an heiress rich in U, settled on
;
"'
+
!
'!
'
her domain, and founded a race of feudal lords. 12
'
!'!
'
'
+
'
¬6
K
'
;
+
'
'
-
'
'
"'
bonds, he stated that:
;
'''
4
'
¬.!
.!"';
J
";
+'
.
"
]Qth
!
'
+'!
'
'6
The feudal lord was proud to recognize
increase in the number of disciplines dedicated to Pharaoh as his master, and he himself was master
"'
"'
'>6
+'
of the soldiers and priests in his own petty state.
.!"
!;
'
"
"''
+
From the top to the bottom of the social scale eve
' '
'
-
<'"
' !
'
'>
+
'
';
+
"'
<
'6
!
4
'
"
'
!
.!"
!
¬"
'
-
!
'
'
'!6
K
'
.!"'
''
+
>;
'
"'!
+ '+
4
;
;
'
''
;
'
'
"'
+'
'
'
§
'
'
'
'
''
'
%6
+
'
';
'
+
'
*
'
'
611
$
'
'
" '
"
6][
'
'
"''
;
'
+
'
' K
'
+
"
less reinterpretation of the Egyptian history, had to tion is related to the fact that the Egyptian Weltan-
'
&
'
'
6
schauung
'
>
+'
+
< ;
.!"
'
+
'
'
'
"
"
6
feu-
'
"
+'!
dalism +'
'
"
'
!;
'
]Qth
!
+'6
'
+
'
'
'
+
]Z_\
'
]Q_\
'!
.!"
'
6
%'"
+;
feudalism
+
>
+
" ;
'4
pervaded all the Egyptian society, from gods to
Q
KÓTHAY
\]];
]]
'!
'
'
' !;
"'!
]Q\6
?6
'
'" !
`
¬j'
'
-
'!
+'!;
6
';
'
'
+
'
'
+
'!
''6
" sion on feudalism in Ancient Egypt sustained by K. JANS-
'"
+"'
'
+
-
;
±'
EN-WINKELN ]QQQ6
K
'
-
'
''';
"!
9
;
'
"!
*!'
'
'
¬'
'!
;
'
'
"
+
""
'
''
'
-
!
O.
'
'
#
.
"'
!6
+
HINZE and C. CAHEN (JANSEN-WINKELN
]QQQ;
]_£\
6
;
'
"
'
''
+
SCHNEIDER
\]\;
]_6
'
!§
%'
;
10
A summary on the evolution of the concept in PÉCOUT
is perceived as a mode of production or social formation ]QQS;
]_S\£]_S]6
'
"
'
"'"'
'
'
" 11
LICHTHEIM ]Q[;
[]6
6
K
'
'
"''
"
12
MASPERO;
66;
;
^[6
%!
" '6
'
'
.
"'
!6
'
;
][
MASPERO;
66;
;
Q^£Q_6
%!
" '6
"
'
'
4
!>
M''`
$
K
(-
!>
$
'
9' [_
'>
<6]^
K
¬'
+
¬economic structures usu
'
'
vassals of the king, the '!
'
'
+
'
'
'
¬
'
'
+;
+
'
'
ideology of feudalism as a political system.20
!
'
'
615 The struggles,
+
>!
';
¬'
>
+
"'
'
²
of feudalism and its related concepts in Ancient
'
!
'
'
";
<'
.'
6
B
';
+'
+
+'
' 6
*>
j
'""
;
school of Egyptology, the German school consid such as the European manorial system of depend
ered nomes as U and nomarchs as inde-
'
+
'
¬
'
'
.'
%!
'
+
'
';
+'
"
!
'
'
"
Geschichte des Altertums ]ZZ^&
'
' 621 Homage and the
]Q\6
K
.
"'
'
"
+
'
"'
>
'
'
'
'
"
+;
vassalage.
+
+'
-
"'
#
'
.!"
!;
J6
J '!
'
20th
!6]S recently described the historiographical develop
As mentioned above, Egyptology as a special ment and variations in the use of the concept of
-
'
'!
"' feudalism
"6
$
"
adigms and does not escape from the use of con her analysis encompass the recognition of the
"6
j
;
'
'
>
'
employment of analogies in Egyptological histori
"
';
;
+
ography, and the fact that although concepts like
"
'""'
'
' capitalist and capitalism are not frequently used,
6]Z
#
'
¬'
feudal "
'
+
!
'
'
";
+
>
'>
through capitalist '622 As a matter of fact,
'
'!
"
+
(6
$
''!
the idea of progress from one stage to another is
"
!
#'
patrimonialism in
'
'
''
!
+
#
"''6
'
feudalism
+'
'
.!"
'
'" !
'
+
'
'
"'
6
;
.
"'
'
<'
.'
60s,]Q
'!
'
''
'6[
+
'
"
vassal
+'
"'";
+
>
"'
"'
"'
"
"
'
';
emphasis on the natural usage the concept of vas-
'+
'
'
'
<'
.'
" sal acquired in current Egyptological approaches
'
'
-
"
!
-
'
!>
"
'
]^
M ASPERO;
66;
6
;
_6 lection of studies edited by MORENO GARCÍA
\]['
'
15
MASPERO;
66;
;
_6
"''
.!"'
16
?6
'
BRUGSCH
]ZSS
'
WIEDEMANN
]ZZ^6 '
'
'6
]S
PETRIE
]ZQ^£]Q\_§
BREASTED
]Q[S
¡]st
]Q\Q¢§
K EES ]Z
66
¬! ;
6
BAINES
]QQ]§
¬'
'""
"'
]Q[§
PIRENNE
]Q[Z§
STOCK
]Q^Q§
SCHENKEL
]Q^6
j
'
;
6
SCHNEIDER
\\[6
'!;
6
DANERI DE RODRIGO
]QQ6
!+'!;
]Q
SCHLOEN
\\];
]ZS6
'""
'
+'
!
6
B
+
20
SCHLOEN
\\];
]ZQ6
%!
" '6
'""
"'
6
j
';
+
21
SCHLOEN
\\];
]ZQ6
%'
!
$
22
KÓTHAY
\]];
]S6
B
'!
"
'
6
DIAKONOFF
]QZ\;
%
"
''
!
'
]Qth century, on the myth of the “eternal
'
B6
BERLEV
]QS];
.!"'
%
J
6
.!";
'
"''
''
'""
'
!+'!;
"'
!
.!"
'
!
'
.!";
6
MORENO GARCÍA
\\Q6
'""
'
'6
B
'""
'
>
#6
[
DANERI DE RODRIGO
]QQ;
^6
HELCK
]QZ;
6
K EMP
]QS
'
!
[
''
j'
"'6 feudalism
'
'
"
+
'
6[\ As mentioned
Building the Hyksos’ vassals above, in a feudal
''
vassals +
;
'
''
';
"
'
"''
+
'
time, other topics lost their centrality, such as the J'
'';[] description of Hyksos subordina
"
!>
'
'
"'
+'
'
'!
'
;
'
>
.
'625 such as the Quarrel of Apophis and Seqenenre
As in all those topics, in the analysis of the subor ]Qth
(!'!
'
"
8
" ;
dination practices held by the Hyksos, many layers '
'
.
'
%'
]Qth and 20th centuries, the subordina
.!";
<'
'
*'
+
'
tion practices did not occupy a relevant place in and titles linked to the Hyksos also contributed to
''
-6
'
;
'
+
the description of the subordination practices as
interested in other features, many of them men vassalage6
B
"
'!
'
+
'
;
K
J*;
+
'
'
+'
!'
'
6
626
B
'
"
+
'
The Quarrel of Apophis and Seqenenre
9'"6
'
¬!>
;
$'
;
.
]\]Z_
+'
'
'!
"
¬"
'
'
"
+
'
'' '
%"'
]Qth
(!'!
"'
*'
'
+
.!";Z con '
''
¬''
&
'
'
'
+
J'6Q Unsurprising !
&
'
'
'>6[[
^
K
'
'""
'
"6
'
+
'!
!>
'
+
'
'
'
`
OREN
]QQS§
RYHOLT .!"6
8 7
U>
]QQS§
SCHNEIDER 2010, A RNOLD 2010; BIETAK 2010a; erected by the new conquerors is to be explained by the
SHIRLEY
\][6 feudal organization of the Hyksos Empire in Asia, inde
25
PETRIE
]Q\;
S\6 "!
!
9
'
+6
?6
26
?6
MEYER
]ZZ^;
[;
;
[\^§
GUNN and GARDINER
]Q]Z;
[S§
ALBRIGHT
]Q;
]\6
%!
" '6
ENGBERG
]Q[Q;
^£^S§
ALT
]Q_^§
'
'!;
6
BER- []
K
?''
K'
+'
]Q\Z
'
"
!
NAL
]QQ]6 6
GARDINER
]Q]§
'
j
$'
S
LUCKENBILL
]Q]\;
][^£][Q§
WATERMAN
]Q];
Z£Q6 J'
+
]Q[
'
]Q[_;
6
LACAU
]Q[Q;
Z
SAYCE
]Q\[6 ^_£S]§
$
$'
J'
+'
]Q_^
Q
SÄVESÖDERBERGH
]Q_];
__6 and published by L. HABACHI
]QS§
'
-'!
[\
j
';
"
'
'
!
-
'
K
$'
Albright asserted that: “It is becoming more and more evi ?6
GABOLDE 2005, VAN SICLEN III
\\_;
\]\6
dent, as a result of a comparison of the data from different [
'
'
;
6
editio
9';
'
+'
'
'
'''
"
princeps GARDINER
]Q[§
'
R EDFORD
]QS\§
GOEDICKE
!
6?6;
]QZ§
SPALINGER
\]\6
+
'!
9'
+
[[
SPALINGER
\]\;
][\£][]6
!6
K
'
+
!>
M''`
$
K
(-
!>
$
'
9' [S
In the Quarrel;
"
"
'
6^\
K
"
'
+'
'
¬>
nsw
+
'
'
'
+'>
.!"
'
;
'
'
'-
+
!>
;
'
'
%'
"
<_
'
$
$'
J'
J
''
!>
.!"6^]
+';
+
'
'-
.!"'
K
-
'
\th century,
+
B^Q6
J
nsw
$
'!
J'
;
""
'
''
'
'
¬
heqa
'
¬
wr
+6
';
(6
9
'
'
+
$
?!
K 6
< ;
'
ferent ideological levels can be discerned about the
feature in the source is the portrait of the Hyksos '
'""
'
¬!>
"
6
>
'
'
+
""
$ ;
'
'
'
+
'
¬.!"'
6[^ The source parallels the actions of Apophis !
"
!
J'
-
'
+
'
$
' '!
'
!
'
"'
!
&
'
+'!
.!"'
6[_
+'
''
!>
+'
'
'
th
!
+
'
'
+'
Hyksos by means of declaring that “they ruled against the Hyksos led to the establishment of the
+
$;[
+
'
<+
J
'
+'
'
6^
positive actions of the female king supported by With slight and subtle differences, both types of
6 sources reinforced the negative image of the
The Turin King-List, dated to the reign of !>
'
'
+'>
.!"6^[
'
]Qth
(!'!;
!>
6
'
!'
+
'
'
The fragment preserves the nomen ¬$
'
K
('c'
+'
'
;
'
+
!
'
4
;
J '6
K
!>
+'
"
!
86
M'
$;
The
"
!
+
'
'`
¬
Hyksos. A New Investigation ]Q6
'
+
¡¢
]\Z
!';[S the number '""
'
4;
'
'
"
>
'
!
%'
6[Z '"
¬K
<'
!>
to
K
"
'
!
%'
explain
!>
'
"'6
K
delineates a violent assault of the Egyptian territo author connected the Hyksos political tradition
ry from peoples of the East, “invaders of obscure +
'
B
'!
'
+
;
'
'
+
.!";
'
'
!'
%';
+
'
+
'
!
K '6[Q ''
+
!
86
%'>
'
'
'
"'"
"
]Q_6^^
%'>
'
!>
+
¬
'
!
'
'
+'
' ;
'
"
vassal started to '
'
'
'
+
6
86
'
'
'
'6
K
"
'
+
'
!
+
'
]th Dynasty and the end “small vassal
>
+
'
'>
+
!>
;
'
K
J edged the “leading king as suzerain6
$
*;
'!
'
$
'
vassals of the
+
!'
'
'!'
!>
;
'
$>;
+
>'
'
"
'
"
makes the Theban vassal of one of the Apophis
> "
''!6
#
!'
[^
B
"''
'";
6
GOLDWASSER
\\6 ;
+'
'
>6
'
'"'
'
%" ;
[_
SPALINGER
\]\;
]£][6 +
+
!;
""
'
[
ALLEN
\\;
_6 *
+
.!";
'
'
''
'
[S
RYHOLT ]QQS;
]]Z§
MÁLEK
]QZ;
]\]6
"
'
'+
6
'
-
[Z
WADDELL
]Q^;
Z[6 eastern frontier of his kingdom, through fear of the Assyri
[Q
WADDELL
]Q^;
SS£Q[6 '
+
+
+
"
+6
SAYCE
]Q\[;
[^Q
^\
BREASTED
]Q[S;
]6
%!
" '6
!
'!
\th centu in his book The Burden of Egypt;
"
]Q_];
866
!
>
+
'
"
"
+'
WILSON
'
'"
$
'
'6 9
¬K
@'
'
6
^]
SAYCE
]Q\[;
[^Q6
$'!
'
'
'
'
“%'
^
POLZ
]QQZ;
]6
'
!>
$ "
>
'
.!"
^[
?6
'
SPALINGER
\]\6
from the east, overrunning the land, burning the cities, and ^^
VAN SETERS ]Q;
]£][6
!
"6
'
;
'
$''
[Z
''
j'
'
+
'
'
¬
;
'!
!'!6
'
'
'
'
"
+
''
!
+
'
'
'
'
'
'
¬
¬'
'
+
*'
'
.!"
$
¬
6
K ;
+ '
+
'
political
- '
9
'6
]Z\\&]_[\;51 and applied
tion of the concept of vassal;
" '
"
¬'''
&
+
!
'
> "6 '!'
&
"'
'
"
'
%'>
+
M6
J
³
"
"
'
';
K
'
J'6
K ;
-
"
'
""
>
'
!"
+
'
¬'''
+'
'
'!
+
!>
'
!
>
'6^_ The same argu 9
652 He also suggested that the Hyksos con
;
"'
'
"
+
&
$
'
'
'
'
;
+'
"
"
!
@6
"
"
vassal_[
&
'
'
+
vas-
% '
-
'
$;
sals
"
"
'
'
.!";
through the concept of covenant.^
'
!>
'!;
< ;
%'>
+
¬
"
%'
'6_^
'
"
+
'""!
"
¬' K
!
"
"
J ;
''`
'
+
¬
J;
+
!>
'
'
!'
'
'
+
J'
¬!
+'
-
'
¬'
¬'
'
'!'
+'
'
'
!
+
'!
6^S
K
+
'
'
'
>
"
'
';
+
'"
+
;
'!'
!
%'>
+
'
!'
!'
'
"6^Z
$
"
'
%'655
';
M'
$
'
'
'
'
'
+
'
!
Hyksos shared the same political and diplomatic
'
¬
+
'!
>
"
'
'
%'>
%'
'
!
6^Q Finally, she also '
'
¬
' 656 Even though
"!
'
'
'!
+
!>
+
'
*'
'
'
'
]Zth
!
?6 50
;
'
'
²
9
'!;
¬"
' both the
%'
'!
"''
!
'
"!
'
'
+
'
.!"
$
'
"'
'
'
"-
"
'
9
6
;
'"
-
'
6
'
%
J
'
'
'
'
;
M'
$
'
"
'
!
"
'
''
'
'
"''
'
'"
!
%'>
diversity,_S framed by the emergence of a dynasty
'
'""
!>
;
+
+
"'
^_
KOROŠEC 1931. 52
VAN SETERS (]Q;
]S
'
'
¬K
;
^
MENDENHALL
]Q_^6 "
J'
?K
_£S;
" '
'
!
'
^S
MUNN-R ANKIN 1956, 79. right to pasture cattle in the Delta and hold land in agricul
^Z
MUNN-R ANKIN
]Q_;
S£SS
'
"
'
'6
K
must have been guaran-
+
$ ' '
'
. '
teed by treaty arrangements6
%!
" '6
'
'6
_[
VAN SETERS ]Q;
]S6
^Q
MUNN-R ANKIN
]Q_;
Z]£Z6
_^
VAN SETERS ]Q;
]S\6
50
MUNN-R ANKIN
]Q_;
ZQ;
Q6
%6
LIVERANI
\\]
'
'
55
VAN SETERS ]Q;
]Z£]Q6
!"
J
+
"
"''
¬K
HELCK
]QZ[;
Q]£QS;
6
]]Q§
6
'
H ABACHI
]QS6
!
6
56
''!
'
+
'
'
'
"
'
51
#
'
!
$
'
practices held by the Hyksos can be related to Levantine
9
;
+
"
"
'
RYHOLT
]QQS;
^£^[
traditional practices (FLAMMINI
\]]£]6
'
'6
]Z\\
?6
j
_S
?6 BOURRIAU
\]\6
"
;
+
'
!
BIETAK
\]\';
][Q;
'6
]_[\
?6
!>
M''`
$
K
(-
!>
$
'
9' [Q
!;
'
"
<
+''!;
'
"'
'
+
!>
other sites in Egypt is being continuously incorpo
subordinates and not to discuss the concept of vas- '
;
'
-
sal6_Z
'
'
"
'
'
.660 The information on the
of vassals
$
''
>
!>
"
!
"
''
(';
]Sth
(!'!
'
J
+'
;
!'
"
;
"
conceived due to a “reminiscence of the earlier
'
66
';
';
';
+'"
'
j
(!'!
+'
'
¬Welt-
;
"'
;
!'
>
K
K
reich
+
'!
'
'
¬'
'" J*
'
''
'6
< ;
6
_Q '
'
+
"'
(6
$
'
-
'
"';
'
'
-
!
!;
'
+
'
economic
"
"''
"'6
-
"
vassal and a political '
'>
'
'
"'
'
'
.!"
'
6
"''
!
'
''!
'
;
'
+
'
'
-6
-
-
"
'6
As a matter of fact, contemporary sources
mer, the vassal +'
'
'
>
¬' reveal that the Hyksos effectively controlled part
'
-!;
'
.!"6
K
j
$'
J'
J]
+'
vassal +'
'
+
'
>
'
the
K '
+'
'
!
'
'!
'§
;
+'
'
"
!
'
'
?';
+
J
'
'!
!
"'
6
VAN Hermopolis as the southern limit of the territory
SETERS
'
6
!>
6
86
'
'
<
+''!;
'
feudalism-related concepts ''
+
'
'
'
'
"
'
''
'6 %
'';
'
''
'
'
"
+
"
¬+
'
+
'>
<;
+'
>
!>
+
"!
;
' "''
'
way those rulers attempted
!
"
'"
-
''
"'
'
6
'""
'
46
K
'
'
!>
As mentioned above, late Egyptian and Classi
'
'
"
'
.!"
'
+
'
"
'
'
'
+'
.!" lishment of vassalage relationships under the
'
"
+
]Qth and Hyksos rule during most part of the 20th
!6
\th
6
#
"
Nevertheless, late Egyptian sources reveal an
+`
;
'
'"
'!
'
+
!>
'
+
' time, focusing on their religious differences and
"
'!
'
'
''6 "
'!
"
'';
+
?'
_Z
RYHOLT
]QQS;
[[£[S6 61
ALLEN
\\;
]S6
_Q
RYHOLT
]QQS;
[[6 62
BOURRIAU
\]\;
[6
60
MOELLER and M AROUARD \]6
^\
''
j'
'
'
'
"
'
' political changes that resulted from the disputes
6
.
;
among the rulers of the three political entities
pletely discarded because some information on "
" ;
J'
'
<'
+
"
'
"'
'
'6 '
!
'
$
On the contrary, the Egyptian contemporary '
9
;
'
'
'
"
J]
'
?K6
+'
'
!
'
The stelae had been probably on display in the
;
"
"'
'
'
"
J''>;
+
!
+
"
'
'
'
.!"'
+
+§
6
J;
"
'
+
and although the information it provides is scarce, over the possession of the title Heqa class. “rul-
'
+'!
' er (of Upper Egypt”.65
';
'
+'!
'
"'
'
'
6 ing the impact that the Hyksos rule had on the
A point to be highlighted is that possibly the Egyptian tradition is through the importance that
Hyksos rulers had built their control over the the title heqa
$
.!"'
!
&
!
.'
('
£
'
9
+'666 Although the title heqa khas-
not through a military conquest over the land, but ut (“ruler of the foreign lands”) had been in use
"
'
'
"
+
'
"
'
'
B
J
"6
K
"
'
'
"
'
'
+';
'
%
J
'
adopted different patterns depending on factors foreign rulers mainly from Nubia and the Levant,
that are not possible to be reconstructed complete 66
.'
K;
+'
!
!6
+'
'
"
'
'
economic $
'
9
'
+'
''
'
"
;
'
adopted by a particular line of rulers to name
J]
'
'
''
66
The Quarrel of 6
';
]^
'
?K
][
'
'"
$
'6S At that time, the title
'
"''
6
K
"
!
<
'""'
heqa '
'
"!
+
-'
+
'-
!
B^Q;
'
'-
.!"'
used by both the foreign independent rulers locat
+6
'
'
+'
'
"'
ed in Avaris and the Egyptian rulers located at
.!"'
!6
.!"'
'
K;
K 6
¬
9";
'
J'
The mention of this title in the source indicates
'
+
¬a nest of Asiat-
"
'
'
'
!`
ics.[ No more personal information on Teti is the three rulers are mentioned as heqa of Avaris,
!
6
K ;
K
'
'
heqa of Kush and Heqa (of Upper Egypt).Z These
"'
+'
'
!>
'6
;
rulers did not argue about Egyptian royalty but
'
'
.!"'
'
"
'
+
+'
'
Heqa (of Upper
!
!>
'
!'
'6^ Finally, the Egypt)§
+
;
+
+'
'
'
'
<
+'
''>
'
'
!
""
.!"6
!
J'
6 ;
'
.!"'
"
'
J
'
!
>
"'
.!";
'
+
establishment of personal relationships of subordi deserved to be ruled under maat. They also sus
'
'
'
+'!
"'
!>
"
'
'
'
+
!>
;
²6
'
"
'
+
'
-
[
SMITH and SMITH
]QS;
\§
R EDFORD
]QQS;
]^6
K
S
BIETAK
]QQ;
_
'
"6
_6
6_!"#;
6
]]Q;
ZQ6 Z
'
'
+
heqa received differ
^
?6
VAN SETERS
]Q;
]Q
"
"
'
K
"
'!
'-
6
#
'
+'
¬
'
'
'
'
'
'
J
¬"'"!
=]
""
.!"6 '-;
"
'!
'!;
+
+
65
For an analysis of the title Heqa
J;
6
FLAMMINI
""
.!"
¬J
""
\]]£]6 .!"
^[
'-6
?6
FLAMMINI
\]]£]6
66
HARVEY
\\S;
[^S£[^Z6
!>
M''`
$
K
(-
!>
$
'
9' ^]
and challenge later the Upper Egyptian ruler, After reproaching the attitude of the ruler of
'
K ;
J'
6Q Then, the source J ;
'
'
!
+
"
"
'>
';
him through persuasion, asking for his help to
';
'"
'
J'
;
'
J'
'
"
'
+
'
+
'
6
<''!;
.!"'
'
'
'
'6
J'
4
"
"
'6S\
K
There are further indications that Apophis con
maintains the idea of Apophis claiming the ruler
'
"
'>
+
;
'
!;
'
¬
4
w r
""
.!"
'
+6
K
'"
n RTnw, J;
^;
'
¬
'
#
!
J'
;
+
]
J
-
'
4
'
'
.!"'
6
¬
'
;
<_6
K ;
"
K
"''
+'!
"
'
the fact that Apophis claimed his right to rule over "
+
'
'
""
.!";
+'
'
¬
';
J
+
"'
'
²
'
"
+
"
"
'
< ;
-
vassal –
J ;
'
'
"
'
'
the one, related to the possession of land and the
6
K
+'
"
'
'!
&
+
"
"
'
not seem to be supported by the information provid
“the son of the ruler of Kush
'
!
6
.
J
"
"
J
¬my son.” A closer look at the classi '
'
''
+
J
+
-
+
¬
"''
'
"
+
+
+
';
+
'
J'
;
'!
>
'
+
"'''" 6
"
"
of formal procedure and at present no formal agree
'
+'
position the ruler of
'!
>
'
"
6
J
'
.S]
j
+
' The information provided by other sources also
ments, Apophis proposed a sort of alliance to the
'
'
'
6
K
''
J
'
J'
'
''
!>
'
!
+
;
!
'!
'
.!"'6
$6
¤>
'
towns of this Egypt and Khenet-henty-nefer (or structure to cover areas of authority, notably mili
“both our lands)”' shall be in joy.”S[ '!
6S_
$ !;
"
Q
Another contemporary source is the inscription of Why did you raise yourself as ruler [of Upper Egypt] with-
;
'';
'
.>'6
"
' out letting me know? Have you seen what Egypt has done
bly served under kings Ahmose I, Amenhotep I and against me? The Ruler [of Upper Egypt] who is there,
K
+
'
J'
'
<Kamose, the victorious> given life, is attacking me in my
"
;
$6
LICHTHEIM
]QS;
]£]_6 territory (…)” (FLAMMINI
\]]£];
_Q6
S\
When he states “your mouth is narrowed when you make S
Alternative translation proposed by SMITH and SMITH
]QS;
'
'
"
'
]^th and ¬
+
;
'
"
'
15th Dynasty administration (she considers both lation of gifts reinforce the description of the pos
!'
!
"
;
'
'
"
'
"''
'
+
¤>
"
"
'
6
K
'
''
'
+
'
''
+
'
ent from the Egyptian one, also points out to a dif
¬'
'
¬>
6S
$
"
"
'
'
cludes that the Hyksos adopted certain aspects of "6
';
!
'
!
.!"'
''
+
!
"
"
J
'
'
'';
+
'
'
!
J
'
"
+'!
'
"
'
6
';
!>
'
"
+
'';
'
The Quarrel between
certain features of the Egyptian culture, such as Apophis and Seqenenre mentions the dispatch of
";
'';
'
6
!
'
'6
K
-
'
"
+
'
'
fragmentary letter in cuneiform at Tell el Dabca
Levantine origin that led them to build an identity "
"
'
"
as
+;
+
+
%
"
''6Z\
'
'
.!"'
> "6SS Thus, the evidence reveals that by the late
K
"
'
!>
"
"
"
'
among the Hyksos rulers and other local chiefs +
>
"
'
'
"
!
'
'6
';
'
'
'
;
'
"
> "
$''' ;
?'
8.
[S[_
¡?@
_SZ¢
'
¬
'
;
'
"
"
'
-
;
!
'
"
'
+'!
'
!>
'
;
'
'
'
'
'
"'6Z]
+'!
!>
'
!'!6SZ
+'
''
'
"
"'!
+;
'
'
< ;
'
"
'
.!"'
!6
inscription on one of its sides reveals: “Good god, Even though the evidence is scarce, to make
Lord of the Two Lands, Nebkhepeshre, Son of Re, the concept vassal
4
'
!
!
socio-politi-
Apophis, given life6
B
;
'
cal subordinate
'
+
'
'
'
"
+
"
!
!
!>
"'
-
+
+'"
'
¬the follower of
!
"6
$'
"
"
'
'
'
4
'
"
"
"§
"
''
§
'
"
'
'
"
'
lishment of hierarchies; dispatch of messengers;
+
+'
'
'
'
6
''!
''
'
+
>§
'
'!
4;
(
6
!'
'6
K
"
'!
+
remarked that
'
'
-';
'
"'
" ;
+'!
'
'
+'
¬4
"
<
'"
' 6
'
&
!
'
!>
nate;
'
"
'
-
'
+;
'
;
'
'
"''
+'!
'
'
'
scribal palette by the same king to a man called
"6
''
'
'
"
!
4;
a picture of mutual loyalty emerges that
!
"'
together6 ”SQ
'
'6Z
Thus, the language related to kinship bonds
;
.!"
!
+'
!
¬
;
¬
¬
'
"
"
"''
'
"
]Qth century,
S
SHIRLEY
\][;
_[];
_^6 Z
66
patronage;
'!
-
'
'
"
'
'
!'
'
SS
FLAMMINI
\][;
]S^6 '
"
'
+
+
'
;
SZ
DARESSY
]Q\;
]]_£]\6 +
"
'
"-
'
SQ
A RNOLD
\]\;
][6
%!
" '6
'
"6
'
'"
Z\
BIETAK
\]\;
"6
]^6 FLAMMINI
\]]£];
S^6
B
"'
'
'
<'
Z]
FLAMMINI
\]]£];
S]&S6 .';
6
WESTBROOK 2005; for an approach to patronage
"'
.!"'
!;
6
MORENO GARCÍA
\][6
!>
M''`
$
K
(-
!>
$
'
9' ^[
+
'
'
-
"6
j
+ ural usage). I consider that this particular applica
ing the common statements of the time, ancient tion of the concept “vassal;
+"'!
"
.!"
+'
-
'
'
'
'
'
!
+'!
'
.!"'
>
+
'
6
'';
+
'
'
6
+'!;
'
"
'
Acknowledgements
'
!>
+
'
ered their vassals6
!
\th I am grateful to Alicia Daneri Rodrigo and Gra
!;
-
''
!>
'
@
$
'
'
'
'
'
+
'
'!'
"'"6
'
'
8'
?'
'
"
'
+
!
'
' %
@'Ï';
K
'
$
"
"
;
'
'!
'
!
'
'6
<
+''!;
'
'
+
'
'
!
!>
'
'
'-
'
''
+
"
!
4
'6
B
;
+
"
' '
"
'
!
"
!6
Bibliography
ALBRIGHT, W.F. BOURRIAU, J.
]Q
K
.''
'
K
%;
BASOR
[;
2010 The Relative Chronology of the Second Intermediate
&]^6
K <
#
7 7
>7
>
ALLEN, J.P. Sequences, ]]&[S;
%6
%';
The Second Interme-
diate Period (Thirteenth-Seventeenth Dynasties). Cur-
\\
K
$"
"
' ";
rent Research, Future Prospects, B*
]Q6
*6
BES
];
]&]S;
"6]¹6
BREASTED, J. H.
ALT, M.
]Q[S
History of Egypt. From the Earliest Times to the Per-
]Q_^
Die Herkunft der Hyksos in Neuer Sicht, 6 sian Conquest, 2nd
6
<+
=
>6
A RNOLD, DO. BRUGSCH, H.
2010 7
8K6789Q6 Z
7<N6 ]ZSS
Geschichte Ägyptens unter den Pharaonen nach den
Delta People and the Hyksos, ]Z[&];
`
M. M ARÉE Denkmälern, *"6
6
The Second Intermediate Period (Thirteenth-
DANERI DE RODRIGO, A.
Seventeenth Dynasties). Current Research, Future
Prospects,
B*
]Q6
*6 ]QQ
J
8>9
67
9<> N>>
¥
¥
>
BAINES, J. una época de crisis.
REE;
?
.
]QQ]
.!"'
%!
'
(
`
%! ;
@
'
[;
6
Early Written and Iconographical Record, JNES _\7;
DARESSY, G6
Z]£]\_6
]Q\
"
'
"
"';
ASAE S;
BERLEV, O. ]]_£]\6
]QS]
*
"
ô
'
õ
'
%
!
.";
RdE [;
DIAKONOFF, I.
[£^Z6
]QZ\
K
$
<'
.'
$
!
BERNAL, M. %
nd
%
?;
Oikumene [;
S£]\\6
]QQ]
@># K
>$
>$
- ENGBERG, R6
ilization, M
6
`
K
'
'
'
(
'
]Q[Q
The Hyksos Reconsidered. $B? ]Z6
? '
6
!
.;
<+
+>;
<686
FLAMMINI, R.
BIETAK, M.
\]]£]
("
"
""
.!"`
]QQ
Avaris, The Capital of the Hyksos. Recent Excava-
$
$'
J'
J;
JSSEA [Z;
__£S_6
][Q&]Z;
M. M ARÉE
6
The Second Intermediate
6
]^\£]_[\
'6?6;
][&]ZQ;
` C. DI BEN-
Period (Thirteenth-Seventeenth Dynasties). Current
+and E. R AVENNA
6;
Diversidad
Research, Future Prospects,
B*
]Q;
*6 de formaciones políticas en Mesopotamia y el Cerca-
\]\
*
!>ö
J '!';
"''
:
:7
?>
¥
8 >
!
forme, CRAI ;
QS[£QQ\6 regionales en la Edad del Bronce, %B
];
'
'6
^^
''
j'
GABOLDE, L. \\^
Futures Past. On the Semantics of Historical Time,
\\_
$
J'
ª
Khypi ^;
[_£^6 <+
=
>6
]Q]
K
('
!>
!
J'è`
K
?''
\]]
j'
.!"
!;
]]£][_;
`
E. BECHTOLD,
K';
<
6
;
JEA [;
Q_£]]\6
A. GULYÁS and A. HASZNOS
6;
From Illahun to
Djeme. Papers presented in honour of Ulrich Luft,
]Q[
Late Egyptian Stories,
6
6
'
'
$
[]]6
B
6
GOEDICKE, H.
LACAU, P.,
]QZ
The Quarrel of Apophis and Seqenenre,
$'
6
]Q[Q
±J'
;
ASAE [Q;
^_£S]6
GOLDWASSER, O.
LICHTHEIM, M.
2006 King Apophis and the Emergence of Monotheism,
]Q£][[;
`
E. CZERNY, I. HEIN, H. HUNGER, D. MEL- ]Q[
.!"`
$!
?
'" !;
of Manfred Bietak,
B*
]^Q;
6
]6
*6 ]QS
>
6789
J
N 'K Z
7-
GUNN, B. and GARDINER, A. dom, >!6
]Q]Z
<+
.!"'
K`
6
K
."
LIVERANI, M.
of the Hyksos, JEA
_7];
[£_6 2001 International Relations in the Ancient Near East
HABACHI, L. +**++**<+
=
>6
]QS
The Second Stela of Kamose and his Struggle against LUCKENBILL, D.D.
the Hyksos Ruler and his Capital, (J
Z;
@>
]Q]\
¬K
.
`
"!
'
+
!
(6
'6
(6(6
*>`
4
; The Biblical World
HARVEY, S. [_7;
][^£[Q6
2007 J
''+!`
<
'
j
.
MÁLEK, J.
(!'!
!'
<';
[^[£[_;
`
)6
HAWASS
'
86
]QZ
K
B'
M
!'
?'
K;
R ICHARDS
6
The Archaeology and Art of Ancient
JEA
Z;
Q[£]\6
6789K68
@:Q$ $.
?'
[;
?'
6 M ASPERO, G.,
HELCK, W. 66
History of Egypt, Chaldæa, Syria, Babylonia, and
Assyria, 66
SAYCE
6;
6
;
<+
=
>6
]QZ
Geschichte des Alten Ägypten, HdO _6
*6
]QZ[
²'6
#'6 East, BA ]S7;
£^^
'
]S7[;
^Q£S6
JANSEN-WINKELN, K. MEYER, E.
]QQQ
]Q[
KOROŠEC, V. .
!
'!
.!"
!;
]S_£]QZ;
`
]Q[]
Hethitische Staatsverträge. Ein Beitrag zu ihrer juri- M. FITZENREITER
6;
6
7
K >
>!
stischen Wertung,
*"
+ '
schreibung zwischen Vorfall und Befund, .$ X,
$
\6
*"6 *
6
Ayer _[7];
S£^_6 \]['
Ancient Egyptian Administration,
*
6
!>
M''`
$
K
(-
!>
$
'
9' ^_
?;
Iraq
]Z7];
Z£]]\6 Egyptian Archaeology;
B
6
OREN, E. (ed.) SHIRLEY, J.J.
]QQS
8#KZ
> >7
>- \][
$
N>N
7 "K ">-
spectives;
!
%
%
'"
Q;
ond Intermediate Period to the Advent of the Rames-
!
$!"
$
Z6
9 '" '6
sides;
_]£\;
` J.C. MORENO GARCÍA
6
\]['6
PÉCOUT, T. SMITH, H. and SMITH, A6
]QQS
M'';
]_S\£]_S];
`
A. VAUCHEZ
6
Diction- ]QS
'
J'
K; ZAS
]\[;
A History of Egypt, [
6;
*
6
\]\
K+
$
9'!`
±J'
'
±"
"
'
]Q\
Hyksos and Israelite Cities. *
6 $;
JEH [;
]]_£][_6
PIRENNE, H. STOCK, H.
]Q[Z
Introduction a l’histoire du droit egyptien. Les trois ]Q^Q
]Q£[];
`
H. GUKSCH and D. POLZ (eds.) Stationen.
9 ';
BASOR ]ZZ;
]£[6
Beiträge zur Kulturgeschichte Ägyptens,
%'6
\]\
K
K
$'
J'
;
[__£[_;
`
M. M ARÉE
QUIRKE, S.
6
The Second Intermediate Period (Thirteenth-
\\S
K
!>
.!"
]\\
?.6
<+
+
Seventeenth Dynasties). Current Research, Future
'
'
;
][£][Q;
`
H. CRAWFORD
6 Prospects,
B*
]Q6
*6
The Ancient Near East and Egypt. From Sargon of
WADDELL, W.G.
Agade to Saddam Hussein;
B
6
]Q^
Manetho.
?';
%*
6
R EDFORD;
(66
WATERMAN, L.
]QS\
K
!>
'
!
'
K'
;
Orien-
talia [Q;
]£_]6 ]Q]
'?!
'
'
$
'
;
AJSL
[7^;
Z£Q6
]QQS
Textual Sources for the Hyksos Period,
]£^^;
`
.6
OREN
6
]QQS6
WESTBROOK, R6
]\£[[6
]QQS
SÄVE-SÖDERBERGH, T. \\
j
+
;
£;
`
R. KOSELLECK, The Practice of
Conceptual History. Timing History, Spacing Con-
]Q_]
K
!>
.!";
JEA [;
_[£S]6
cepts.
$'
6
SAYCE, A.H.
WIEDEMANN, A.
]Q\[
K
!>
.!";
The Biblical World
]7_;
]ZZ^
Ägyptische Geschichte. M
6
`
Von den ältesten Zeiten
[^S£[__6
bis zum Tode Tutmes III. Handbücher der alten
SCHENKEL, W. @ ;
]6
@
'6
]Q^
Zum Feudalismus der ersten Zwischenzeit Ägyptens, WILSON;
866
Orientalia
[[;
[£6
]Q_]
The Burden of Egypt, ? '
6